Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
Introduction
Subject matter: radiobiology The mechanisms of different types of
biological effects following exposure to ionizing radiation Types of models used to derive risk coefficients for estimating the detriment
IAEA
Topics
Classification of radiation health effects Factors affecting radio sensitivity Dose-effect response curve Whole body response: acute radiation syndrome Effects of antenatal exposure and delayed effects of radiation Epidemiology
IAEA
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 3
Overview
To become familiar with the mechanisms of
different types of biological effects following exposure to ionizing radiation. To be aware of the models used to derive risk coefficients for estimating the detriment.
IAEA
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
CELL TRANSFORMATION
BOTH ANTENATAL
somatic and hereditary expressed
in the foetus, in the live born or descendants
STOCHASTIC
somatic & hereditary
epidemiologically attributable in large populations
IAEA
Stochastic
Cancer, genetic effects.
IAEA
Deterministic effects
Deterministic(Thres
hold/non-stochastic)
Existence of a dose
threshold value (below this dose, the effect is not observable) Severity of the effect increases with dose A large number of cells are involved
IAEA
Severity of effect
Temporary sterility
0.15 Gy 0.6 Gy
dose threshold
IAEA
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 9
Stochastic Effects
Stochastic(Non-Threshold)
No threshold Probability of the effect increases with dose Generally occurs with a single cell e.g. Cancer, genetic effects
IAEA
10
DIRECT ACTION
INDIRECT ACTION
DAMAGE TO DNA
DAMAGE REPAIRED CELL DEATH (APOPTOSIS) TRANSFORMED CELL
IAEA
16
DAMAGE TO DNA
DAMAGE REPAIRED
CELL NECROSIS
OR
TRANSFORMED CELL
APOPTOSIS
IAEA
17
How DNA is
repaired ?
IAEA
20
IAEA
22
chromosomes
uniformly distributed
Apoptotic cell: chromosomes and nucleus fragmented and collapsed into apoptotic bodies
100%
5000
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 25
DAMAGE TO DNA
DAMAGE REPAIRED
TRANSFORMED CELL
IAEA
26
Chromosomal deletions
IAEA
27
Chromosomal translocations
IAEA
28
CANCER INITIATION
TUMOR PROMOTION
MALIGNANT PROGRESSION
STEAM CELL
METASTASIS
DIVISION
NORMAL TISSUE
DYSPLASIA
advantages.
Rapidly dividing cells begin to accumulate
BENIGN TUMOR More changes within the proliferative cell line lead to full tumor development.
MALIGNANT TUMOR
and invasiveness.
METASTASIS
new tumors.
-15 10 -12 10
PHYSICAL INTERACTIONS
-9 10 -6 10
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL INTERACTIONS
TIME (sec)
-3 10 0 10 3
1 ms
10
BIOLOGICAL RESPONSE
6 10
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
IAEA
40
Radiosensitivity (2)
High RS Bone Marrow Spleen Thymus Lymphatic nodes Gonads Eye lens Lymphocytes
(exception to the RS laws)
IAEA
41
Physical Chemical
LET LET
Increase RS: OXYGEN, cytotoxic drugs. Decrease RS: SULFURE (cys, cysteamine)
Biological
Cycle status:
RS: G2, M RS: S
G2
G0
M
G1
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
Systemic effects
Effects may be morphological and/or functional Factors: Which Organ How much Dose Effects Immediate (usually reversible): < 6 months e.g.:
inflammation, bleeding. Delayed (usually irreversible): > 6 months e.g.: atrophy, sclerosis, fibrosis. Categorization of dose < 1 Gy: LOW DOSE 1-10 Gy: MODERATE DOSE > 10 Gy: HIGH DOSE Regeneration means replacement by the original tissue while Repair means replacement by connective tissue.
IAEA
44
Skin effects
Following the RS laws (Bergonie and
Histologic view of the skin
Tribondeau), the most RS cells are those from the basal stratum of the epidermis. Effects are:
Erythema: 1 to 24 hours after irradiation of
about 3-5 Gy Alopecia(*): 5 Gy is reversible; 20 Gy is irreversible. Pigmentation: Reversible, appears 8 days after irradiation. Dry or moist desquamation: traduces epidermal hypoplasia (dose 20 Gy). Delayed effects: teleangiectasia (**), fibrosis.
(*):alopecia: loss or absence of hair (**): ectasia: swelling of part of the body
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 45
Basal stratum cells, highly mitotic, some of them with melanin, responsible of pigmentation.
IAEA
Skin reactions
Threshold Weeks to Dose to Onset Skin (Sv)
2 3 6 7 10 10 11 12 15 15 18 20 <<1 3 1.5 3 4
Injury
Early transient erythema Temporary epilation Main erythema Permanent epilation Dry desquamation Invasive fibrosis Dermal atrophy Telangiectasis Moist desquamation Late erythema Dermal necrosis Secondary ulceration
IAEA
46
Skin injuries
IAEA
47
Skin injuries
IAEA
48
Effects in eye
Histologic view of eye:
5.0
> 0.15
49
IAEA
Eye injuries
IAEA
50
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
Steps:
1. Prodromic
(onset of disease)
2. Latency
GASTRO INTESTINAL
3. Manifestation
CNS
(central nervous system)
Lethal dose 50 / 30
IAEA
Dose
Lethal dose 50 / 30
Dose which would
cause death to 50% of the population in 30 days. Its value is about 2-3 Gy for humans for whole body irradiation.
IAEA
53
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
Pre-implantation
Organogenesis
Foetus
Time
55
IAEA
Lethality
Time
Pre-implantation Organogenesis Foetus
56
IAEA
0.4/Sv
IAEA
0.1/Sv
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 57
IAEA
58
IAEA
International Atomic Energy Agency
Epidemiology I
Irradiated populations can be studied by
following cohorts of exposed and non-exposed
people back-tracing patients suffering from the disease with regard to possible exposure (case controls)
IAEA
60
Epidemiology II
Irradiated populations are
people exposed from the atomic bomb
explosions people exposed during nuclear and other radiation accidents patients exposed for medical reasons people exposed to natural radiation workers in radiation industries
IAEA
61
Epidemiology III
IAEA
62
Epidemiology IV
Information is scanty (not much,less than needed)
on: Consequences of low doses delivered at low dose rates
To detect an increase from a 20% spontaneous cancer
incidence to 25% (corresponding to an exposure to ~1 Sv) > 1300 persons must be studied
Epidemiology V
Modifying influence of cancer background
incidence
does radiation-induced cancer increase at a fixed level
or in proportion to existing cancer additive vs. multiplicative risk model ?
REGION OF DETECTABILITY
EFFECTIVE DOSE (mSv)
10 3
10 2
101
CHERNOBYL DOSES
10 0
REGION OF UNDETECTABILITY
101 10 2 10 3 10 4 105 106 107 108 109 10 10 1011
10-1 10 0
High
Male / Female 23.3 9.5 20.1 8.3 95.5 40.1 35.0 29.6 46.7 11.5 110.8 29.6 33.1 29.8 103.7 53.5
Low
Male /Female 0.2 0.1 0.5 0.2 5.2 2.2 1.8 1.3 0.7 0.3 10.3 2.4 0.2 0.2 14.6 3.0
IAEA
66
IAEA
67
5
2 1 0.5
1950- 1955- 1959- 1963- 1967- 1971- 1975- 19791954 1958 1962 1966 1970 1974 1978 1982 All cancers except leukaemia (+ 4.8%/y)
IAEA
, &
&
& ,
&
Relative risk
miner studies (cohorts) indoor studies (case controls) log-linear fit to indoor studies estimated from correlation study in different regions
100
200
300
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation
400
500
72
,
3 2
, , ,
0
1 0
,
1 2 3 4
,
Thyroid Cancer
Relative risk
,
2
, ,
,
Thyroid benign tumors
,
0 0 0.05
,
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Belarus
" "
$ "
60 40
$ "
" "
$ " "
Ukraine
"
20 0
" $ & " $ & " $ & " $ & &
& &
&
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
75
IAEA
Belarus (1977-1985) 7 (1986-1994) 390 Ukraine (1981-1985) 24 (1986-1995) 220 Russia (Bryansk and Kaluga region only) (1986-1995) 62
The data represent incidences (not mortality) and are preliminary results. Most excess cancers occurred since 1993. Thyroid cancer has a high rate of cure >90%, but many of the cancers found are of the aggressive papillary type. IAEA
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 76
UK National Registry Radiation Workers 0.47 (-0.12-1.20) 4.3 (0.4-13.6) 1,218,000 person years 34 mSv average dose US Workers -1.0 (<0-0.83 <0 (<0-3.4) 705,000 person years 32 mSv average dose Atomic Bomb Survivors 0.33 (0.11-0.6) 6.2 (2.7-13.8) 2,185,000 person years 251 mSv average dose
IAEA
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 77
X Ray Abdomen 2.6 Barium enema 16 Barium meal 2.8 IV urography 3.2 Lumbar spine 3.2 Pelvis 1.7 Computed tomography Abdomen 8.0 Lumbar spine 2.4 Pelvis 25 Nuclear medicine Tc bone scan 3.3 Tc brain scan 4.3 IAEA
45
35
25 15
5 55 60 65 Age Years 70 75
IAEA
79
IAEA
80
probability dose
IAEA
Dose
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 82
probability dose
dose
IAEA
Dose
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 83
wT
0.20 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.01 0.01 0.05
3 : Biological effects of ionizing radiation 84
IAEA
Summary
Effects of ionizing radiation may be
deterministic and stochastic, immediate or delayed, somatic or genetic Some tissues are highly radiosensitive Each tissue has its own risk factor Risk from exposure may be assessed through such factors
IAEA
85