MCE: Criteria Development and the Boolean Approach

Exercise 2-7

MCE
Multi-criteria Evaluation

a common method for assessing and

aggregating many criteria. Decision will not be based on a single criteria but a combination.

Types of MCE
MCE

Boolean Aggregation Method

WLC (Weighted Linear Combination)

OWC (Ordered Weighted Averaging)

Exercise 2-7

Exercise 2-8

Exercise 2-9

Objective of the Exercises

single hypothetical suitability problem. to find the most suitable areas for residential development in the town of Westborough, Massachusetts, USA. The town is located very near two large metropolitan areas and is a prime location for residential (semi-rural) development.

Considerations and Requirements..

Developers prime location (areas that best suit their needs

allocated for residential development). environmental groups where new development will or will not occur.

The environmentally-mixed landscape of Westborough includes many areas that should be preserved as open space and for wildlife.

The town regulations limit land for development.

All these considerations must be incorporated into the decision

making process Hence MCE

The goal is to explore potential suitable areas for residential development for the town of Westborough: areas that best meet the needs of all groups involved.

Considerations

Constraints

Factors

LANDCON

MCELANDUSE

ROADDIST

WATERCON

TOWNDIST

SLOPES

WATERDIST

DEVELOPDIST

Constraints
YES / NO ? TRUE / FASLE 1 / 0

Constraints are those Boolean criteria that constrain

(i.e., limit) our analysis to particular geographic regions. Constraints are always Boolean images.
In this Example: The constraints differentiate areas

that we can consider suitable for residential development from those that cannot be considered suitable under any conditions.

Factors
Factors are criteria that define some degree

of suitability for all geographic regions. They define areas or alternatives in terms of a continuous measure of suitability. Individual factor scores may either enhance (with high scores) or detract from (with low scores) the overall suitability of an alternative.

MCE: Criteria Development and the Boolean Approach

STEPS OF THE EXERCISE

a) Path Setup
Change the Data Paths (under the file menu)

so the folder Idrisi32 Tutorial / MCE is set as the working folder.

b) Display of the Image

Display the image MCELANDUSE using the

user-defined MCELANDUSE palette. Choose to display the legend and title map components. Use Add Layer to add the streams layer MCESTREAMS with the user-defined BLUE symbol file Add roads layer MCEROADS with the uniform black symbol file.

c) Water
Display the image MCEWATER with the Qualitative palette.

d) Water Constraints
Display the image WATERCON with the Qualitative palette.

e) Land use Contraints

Observe MCELANDUSE.

Clearly some of these categories will be

unavailable for residential development.

Areas that are already developed, water bodies, and large transportation corridors

cannot be considered suitable to any degree.

f)
Display LANDCON, a Boolean image

produced from MCELANDUSE

Areas suitable 1 unsuitable for residential development 0.

Unsuitable Categories
Open Developed Multifamily residential Small Lots Residential Med Lots Residentials Large Lot Residential Commercial Industrial Transportation Open Water

Suitable categories
Cropland Pasture Forest Open Undeveloped

g)
Examine the images ROADDIST,

TOWNDIST, and SLOPES using the IDRISI standard palette. Display MCELANDUSE with the Qualitative palette.

ROADDIST

TOWNDIST

SLOPES

h)
Examine the images WATERDIST and

DEVELOPDIST using the IDRISI standard palette.

WATERDIST

DEVELOPDIST

Boolean Approach for MCE.

All criteria (constraints and factors) will be

standardized to Boolean values (0 and 1). method of aggregation will be Boolean intersection (multiplication of criteria). This is the most common & Simplest GIS method of MCE. Severely limit analysis and constrain resultant land allocation choices.

Boolean Standardization of Factors

"crisp" or "hard" decision

how continuous data (e.g., slopes) can be

effectively reduced to Boolean values. All of the continuous factors developed previously must be reduced to Boolean constraints.

Landuse Factor
Of the four landuse types available for development,

forested and open undeveloped lands are the least expensive and will be considered equally suitable by developers, while all other land will be considered completely unsuitable.
Unsuitable Categories Suitable categories
Cropland Pasture Forest Open Undeveloped Open Developed Multifamily residential Small Lots Residential Med Lots Residentials Large Lot Residential Commercial Industrial Transportation Open Water

Distance from Roads Factor

To keep costs of development down, areas

closer to roads are considered more suitable than those that are distant.

Suitable categories
areas less than 400 meters from any road

Unsuitable Categories
equal to or beyond 400 meters

Distance to Town Center Factor

Homes built close to the town center will yield

higher revenue for developers. Distance from the town center is a function of travel time on area roads.

Suitable categories
less than 10 minutes or 400 GCEs of the town center

Unsuitable Categories
400 GCEs or beyond are not suitable.

Slope Factor
relatively low slopes make housing and road

construction less expensive,

Suitable categories
slope less than 15%

Unsuitable Categories
equal to or greater than 15%

Distance from Water Factor

local groundwater is at risk from septic system

pollution and runoff, environmentalists have pointed out that areas further from water bodies and wetlands are more suitable than those that are nearby. protected by a 50 meter buffer through constraints.
Suitable categories
at least 100 meters from any water body or wetland.

Unsuitable Categories
Within 100m of water body or wetland

IDRISI Steps for Boolean Images

Display a Boolean image called LANDBOOL. j) Display a Boolean image called ROADBOOL. k) Display a Boolean image called TOWNBOOL. l) Display a Boolean image called SLOPEBOOL. m) Display a Boolean image called WATERBOOL. n) Display a Boolean image called DEVELOPBOOL.
i)

Boolean Aggregation of Factors and Constraints

all of our factors have been transformed into

Boolean images (i.e., reduced to constraints). most typical Boolean aggregation procedure. all eight images are multiplied together to produce a single image of suitability. equivalent to a logical AND operation

 In assessing the results of an MCE analysis,

it is very helpful to compare the resultant image to the original criteria images. This is most easily accomplished by identifying the images as parts of a collection

o)
Open the Display Launcher dialog box and invoke the pick list. MCEBOOLGROUP in the list with a small plus sign next to it. This is an image group file that has already been created using

Collection Editor. Click on the plus sign to see a list of the files that are in the group. Choose MCEBOOL and press OK. Note that the file name shown in the Display Launcher input box is MCEBOOLGROUP.MCEBOOL. Choose the Qualitative palette and click OK to display MCEBOOL.

p)
Use the feature properties query tool (from its

toolbar icon or Composer button) and explore the MCEBOOLGROUP collection. Click on the image to check the values in the final image and in the eight criterion images.

Assessing the Boolean Approach

a value of 1 in the final suitability image is only possible where

all eight criteria also have a value of 1, a value of 0 is the result if even one criterion has a value of 0. i.e. the suitable places must have the suitability criteria of all the factors/ constraints. (maximum relationship). If any one of the factor show unsuitability and all other show suitable, the location is still unsuitable. they do not trade off. In terms of risk, it is very conservative. no tradeoff and risk aversion

The result is the best location possible for residential development and no less suitable locations are identified.

MCE: Criteria Development and the Boolean Approach

Thanks . Questions / Queries ? ? ?