Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
premises, buildings, or parts thereof in which there exists the hazard of fire or
explosion due to following:
a)
b)
Premises or locations
Alcohols (production by distillation)
Batteries (charging workshops)
Acetylene (storage or use of)
Acetylene (manufacture of)
Use or storage of toxic substances
or preparation
Acids (use or storage of)
Flammable amines, storage
Workshops for repair and servicing
of motor vehicles
Wood or similar combustible
materials
(workshops where these are
worked on) Wood, paper,
cardboard or similar combustible
materials (deposits of) Candles or
other wax objects, etc.
(moulding of)
For an explosion to take place, all three sides of the triangle,satisfying the
following conditions, must be present:
There must be a supply of oxygen present. In most situations this is
applicable as a result of the oxygen content in the air (21%).
There must be sufficient fuel present in the air to form an ignitable mixture.
The fuel may be in the form of a gas, vapor, mist or dust.
There must be a source of ignition with sufficient energy to ignite the fuelair mixture. For electrical equipment this may be from an arcing or sparking
device or from a hot surface. There may be sources of ignition other than
electrical equipment, such as hot exhaust surfaces from internal
combustion engines. These devices do not fall within the scope of the North
American electrical codes and are normally covered by other codes and
standards such as Occupational Health and Safety.
The mixture of gas and air must be between the Upper and Lower
Flammable Limits for a fire or explosion to occur.
Flash Point
Group
Substance
IIB
Acetaldehyde
-38
-39
IIA
Acetic Acid
103
39
IIA
Acetic Anhydride
120
49
IIA
Acetone
-4
-20
Auto-Ignition Temp.
Group
Substance
IIB
Acetaldehyde
347
75
IIA
Acetic Acid
867
464
IIA
Acetic Anhydride
600
316
IIA
Acetone
869
465
IIA
Acetone Cyanohydrin
1270
688
Class I
Group
Vapor Density
Substance
IIB
Acetaldehyde
1.5
IIA
Acetic Acid
2.1
IIA
Acetic Anhydride
3.5
IIA
Acetone
2.0
The gases are divided into groups with similar characteristics based on
two main factors:
The requirements for constructing an explosion proof or flameproof
enclosure to contain an explosion of the gas or vapor, and
The minimum current (amperage) required to ignite the gas or vapor. This
is the basis for gas grouping relative to intrinsically safe circuits.
The North American Division system groups gases into four Groups;
A, B, C and D, where A is the most critical group.
The IEC system groups the gases into only three Groups; A, B and C, with
C as the most critical group.
NORTH AMERICAN VS IEC PRACTICES The North American Division system groups
gases into four groups while the IEC system groups the gases into only three groups. Table
2.4.1 shows a comparison of the two systems, a typical gas for each group and the MESG
and MIC for each of the gases.
Table 2.4.1
Comparison of North American and IEC Gas Groupings
MESG
Typical
Gas
Acetylene
Hydrogen
Ethylene
Propane
NA
(mm)
IEC
0.25
<0.5
0.28
<0.5
0.65
0.5-0.9
0.97
>0.9
MIC
(mm)
IEC*
60
>0.8
75
>0.8
108 0.45-0.8
146
<0.45
Grouping
NA
A
B
C
D
IEC
IIC
IIC
IIB
IIA
* For the IEC gases and vapors are subdivided according to the ratio of their minimum
igniting currents (MIC) to that of laboratory methane
REPRESENTATIVE GAS
II A
PROPANE
II B
ETHYLENE
II C
HYDROGEN
The selection of electrical equipment for use in hazardous areas must ensure that the
maximum surface temperature of any part of the apparatus exposed to the potentially
explosive atmosphere, does not exceed the auto ignition temperature
(i.e., the temperature at which the substance when heated will ignite spontaneously).
Temperature classifications according to the North American and IEC 79-0 standards are
detailed in Table A.
The reference ambient temperature of 40C will be assumed unless otherwise stated on
the apparatus labeling .
The T-Classification allocated to Certified Electrical Apparatus is based on normal
temperature at the most difficult operating conditions. For example, the most onerous
condition for an increased safety, Ex-e, terminal box would be an enclosure fitted with the
maximum permitted number of terminals with every terminal carrying its maximum
rated current and maximum cable lengths connected to each terminal .
Table A
T-numbers for North America and IEC
Maximum
Temperature
Classification
T1
T2
T2A
T2B
T2C
T3
T3A
T3B
T3C
T4
T4A
T5
T6
Surface Temperature
North America
IEC
450C
450C
300C
300C
280C
260C
230C
200C
200C
180C
165C
160C
135C
135C
20C
100C
100C
85C
85C
CLASS I
DIVISION
DESCRIPTION
SYSTEM
ZONE
SYSTEM
ZONE 0
DIVISION 1
Hazardous under
normal operation
GASES &
VAPORS
DIVISION 2
Not normally
Hazardous
ZONE 1
ZONE 2
COMMENTS
Division 1 is split into
Zone 0 and 1. Zone 0 is a
small % of locations
usually confined to inside
vented tanks.
Zone 2 and Division 2 are
essentially the same
CLASSIFIED
AREA
Zone 0
Div. 2
ESTIMATED %
OF DIVISION
AREAS IN
EUROPE
<2%
<5%
Occasionally in normal opeartions
Zone 1
Zone 2
ESTIMATED %
OF DIVISION
AREAS IN
NORTH
AMERICA
> 60 %
> 95 %
< 40 %
DEFINITION OF DIVISIONS:
North American Hazardous Locations are divided into Class and Divisions:
Class I, Division 1 :
A Class I, Division 1 location is one where an explosive atmosphere is presumed to be
present in normal operation either all or part of the time. These are typically
manufacturing areas such as a pharmaceutical plant where volatile gases escape from
vessels during fermentation. In theory, Division 1 locations encompass both Zones 0
and 1 as designated in IEC Standards.
Class I, Division 2 :
A Class I, Division 2 location is one where volatile flammable liquids or flammable gases
are handled, processed or used, but which are normally enclosed in containers from
which they can only escape in the case of accidental rupturing or abnormal operation of
equipment. This classification approximates Zone 2 in IEC Standards
DEFINITION OF ZONES:
The Zones are divided in three types based upon frequency of occurrence
and duration of an explosive gas atmosphere as follows:
ZONE 0:
Zone 0, locations in which explosive gas atmospheres are present
continuously or are present for long periods;
Zone 0 locations are those where there is a flammable mixture exists
typically more than 1,000 hours per year.
Zone 0 locations typically do not exist outside of enclosed spaces except for
the area immediately around vents which are venting from a Zone 0
location.
ZONE 1
Zone 1, comprising locations in which:
Explosive gas atmospheres are likely to occur in normal operation; or
Zone 1 locations are those where there is a flammable mixture more than 10
hours per year and less than 1,000 hours per year.
Zone 1 locations normally occur around vents or in enclosed areas where
there are intermittent or continuously open processes
The areas where Explosive gas atmospheres may exist frequently because of
repair or maintenance operations or because of leakage;
The area where location is adjacent to a class I, Zone 0 location, from which
explosive gas atmospheres could be communicated .
ZONE 2
Zone 2, comprising Class I locations in which, Explosive gas atmospheres are
not likely to occur in normal operation and, if they do occur, they will exist for a
short time only; or
Explosive gas atmospheres will not occur in the air except as the result of an
abnormal situation such as a failed pump packing, flange leak, etc. Also when
an abnormal situation does occur it will be corrected within a short time .
Zone 2 locations are those where explosive gas atmospheres will exist for less
than 10 hours per year
ZONE 2
Method of
Protection
Symbol
Flameproof
Increased
Protection Principle
Zone
Standards
CENELEC
IEC
EN 50 018
60079-1
EN 50 019
60079-7
Safety
Intrinsic Safety
ia
ib
Pressurization
0
1
EN 50 020
EN 50 020
1
60079-11
60079-11
EN 50 016
60079-2
Non-Sparking
Powder Filled
EN 50 021
60079-15
EN 50 017
60079-5
EN 50 015
60079-6
Oil Immersion
Encapsulation
----A
Special
Encapsulation
EN 50 028
standards
----- Protection
National
Flameproof enclosures contain the explosion and allow gases to cool as they escape
across the joints.
Flameproof protection is often used for motors and switchgear. Since very little heat is
generated in switchgear, the surface temperature of the enclosure is only slightly higher
than the surrounding atmosphere. In most cases the switchgear satisfies the temperature
classes T5 and T6.
Motors dissipate more heat. In order not to exceed the permissible limiting
temperature, it may be necessary to lower the rated output of a flameproof motor as
compared to a standard motor.
Examples of components requiring flameproof protection:
Motors with slip rings and commutators
Three-phased squirrel cage motors
Switchgear with opening and closing contacts such as motor protection switches, circuit
breakers and air break contactors
Fuses
Transformers
Lighting fixtures
Communication equipment measuring instruments
( IS : 8289 1976)
The Oil Immersion Ex-o concept has historically been used for heavy duty
switchgear, motor starters and transformers.
The standard for design and testing of Ex-o type electrical apparatus is IEC
60079-6. (IS : 7693-1975)
The basic principle is to immerse the electrical parts in mineral oil, which will
prevent any exposure of the arcing or sparking to the an explosive atmosphere. It
will also quench arcs and limit the temperature rise on electrical parts.
Standards for oil immersion protection, Ex-o, require that all parts capable of
producing arcs or sparks must be immersed in the oil at a depth not be than 25
mm. A method to check the oil level must be provided, e.g., by a sight glass or by
some other reliable method.
Some mineral oils used in switchgear apparatus produce acetylene and
hydrogen gas when arcing occurs. Because of the risk of fire or an explosion with
oil immersion, this application for apparatus in hazardous areas has been
generally restricted. In the Petro-Chemical industries there are very few examples
of Ex-o certified products installed in hazardous areas even though the
standards permit its use in Zones 1 and 2.
FIRST NUMERAL
Protecting against solid bodies
0 - No Protection
1 - Objects equal to or greater than 50 mm
2 - Objects equal to or greater than 12.5 mm
3 - Objects equal to or greater than 2.5 mm
4 - Objects equal to or greater than 1.0 mm
5 - Dust Protected
6 - Dust-tight
A commonly asked question is what IP number is equivalent to NEMA. While there may be
differences in the intricacies of the testing program such as nozzle size and water velocity, following
Table provides conversion of the NEMA type numbers to IP ratings.
NEMA
Type Number
1
2
3
3R
3S
4 and 4X
5
6 and 6P
12 and 12K
13
vs.
IP Ratings
IP Designation
IP10
IP11
IP54
IP14
IP54
IP56
IP52
IP67
IP52
IP54
MOTORS
ZONE 0
ZONE 1
ZONE 2
Transformers &
Capacitors
a)
All
power
and
No
Transformer
or
distribution transformer Transformers and capacitors suitable for
capacitor shall be used
and capacitors with type Zone 1 areas
in this area
'd' protection
Transformers and capacitors that are dry
b) For control
and
type or containing liquids that need not
instrumentation purpose,
have any special enclosure provided and
type of protection 'i'
the following requirements are satisfied:
a) Cable boxes shall be suitable for
specified level of current and fault clearing
time.
ZONE 0
ZONE 1
ZONE 2
b) Only off-circuit manually operated tap
changers shall be allowed with provision for
locking the opearting handle in position.
c) Auxiliary devices shall be intrinsically
safe or if they have sparking contacts,
these shall are
1) type 'd' or hermatically sealed
2) under adequate head of oil
3) of enclosed break type
Or alternatively , auxiliary devices may be
deleted or installed in a safe zone rendered
safe by pressurisation.
d) Any other sparking accessories or
swutch shall comply with the requirements
for Zone 1 area
Where oil-filled transformers are used,
necessary precaustions against spread of
fire shall be complied with (IS 1646 -1961)
Lighting fittings
Switchgear
Controlgear