Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Submitted By :
Pranav Mishra
11ID60R20
Lets consider
Luna
wants to go on a vacation.
She has 3 options
Hogwarts
Hogsmea
de
Azkaban
How to decide..???
Let us consider
Each
Entertainment
Facilities
Accommodation cost
Travel cost
Similarly
Selecting
These
MCDM
Multiple Criteria Decision Making
Selection
Important terms
Alternatives
Criteria
selection of alternatives.
Example: (for vacation problem) entertainment,
facilities, travel cost, accommodation cost
Completeness: It is important to ensure that all of the important
criteria are included.
Important terms
Weights
criteria
Entertainment
Facilities
Travel cost6
Accomodation
Important terms
Decision
criteria
rating scale
Entertainment
Facilities
Travel cost10
Accomodation
Criteria
entertainm
ent
Decision makers
Harry
Ron
Hermoin
e
Attributes
weights
=4
Important terms
Decision
Criteria
Decision makers
Attributes
weights
Harry
Ron
Hermoin
e
10
=9
Facilities
=7
Travel cost
=6
Acc. Cost
=7
entertainm
ent
Similarly
Decision makers
Attributes
weights
Harry
Ron
Hermoin
e
entertainm
ent
=8
Facilities
=7
=9
Travel cost
7
10
10
for alternate 3 ( azkaban)
Acc. Cost
5
7
6
Criteria
Decision makers
=
=6
Attributes
weights
Harry
Ron
Hermoin
e
entertainm
ent
=7
Facilities
=8
Decision matrix
Criteria
Hogwart hogsmea
s
de
Azkaban
entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Acc. Cost
Hogwarts (Table 1)
Hogsmeade (Table 2)
Azkaban (Table 3)
TOPSIS
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step
de
entertainm
ent
7=
=
13.93
Facilities
8=
=12.7
3
6=
=12.3
7
Travel cost
DECISION MATRIX
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step
de
entertainm
ent
7=
=
13.93
Facilities
8=
=12.7
3
Travel cost
6=
=12.3
7
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step
de
entertainm
ent
7=
=
13.93
Facilities
8=
=12.7
3
Travel cost
6=
=12.3
7
Standardized decision
matrix.
Criteria
Entertainm
ent
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
Azkaban
9/
13.93
Facilities
Travel cost
Criteria
Acc.
Cost
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
0.65
Azkaban
Standardized decision
matrix.
Criteria
Entertainm
ent
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
9/
13.93
Azkaban
8 / 13.93
Facilities
Travel cost
Criteria
Acc.
Cost
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
0.65
0.57
Azkaban
Standardized decision
matrix.
Criteria
Entertainm
ent
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
9/
13.93
Azkaban
8 / 13.93
7 / 13.93
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
Azkaban
Facilities
Travel cost
Criteria
Acc.
Cost
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
0.65
0.57
0.50
Standardized decision
matrix.
Similarly.
Criteria
Hogwarts
Hogsmeade
Azkaban
Entertainment
0.65
0.57
0.50
Facilities
0.55
0.55
0.63
Travel cost
0.49
0.73
0.49
Acc. Cost
0.64
0.55
0.55
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 2 -
Hogwart
s
Hogsmead
e
Entertainme
nt
0.65
0.57
0.50
Facilities
0.55
0.55
0.63
Travel cost
0.49
0.73
0.49
Attributes weights
Criteria
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
2.6
Azkaban
Standardized
decision
0.64
0.55
matrix
Azkaban
Acc. Cost
0.55
Weighted
Standardized
decision matrix
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 2 -
Hogwart
s
Hogsmead
e
Entertainme
nt
0.65
0.57
0.50
Facilities
0.55
0.55
0.63
Travel cost
0.49
0.73
0.49
Attributes weights
Criteria
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
2.6
2.28
Acc. Cost
Azkaban
Azkaban
0.64
0.55
Standardized
decision
matrix
0.55
Weighted
Standardized
decision matrix
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 2 -
Attributes weights
Criteria
Hogwart Hogsmea
s
de
Entertainm
ent
2.6
Facilities
1.1
Travel cost
2.28
Criteria
Hogwart
s
Hogsmead
e
Entertainme
nt X
0.65
0.57
0.50
Facilities
0.55
0.55
0.63
Travel cost
0.49
0.73
0.49
Acc. Cost
Azkaban
Azkaban
0.64
0.55
Standardized
decision
matrix
0.55
Weighted
Standardized
decision matrix
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 2 -
Similarly
Criteria
Hogwart
.
s
Hogsmea
de
Azkaban
Entertainm
ent
2.6
2.28
Facilities
1.1
1.1
1.26
Travel cost
2.94
4.38
2.94
Acc. Cost
5.12
4.4
4.4
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 3
ideal solution.
A set of maximum values for each criteria is Ideal
solution.
Criteria
Hogwart Hogsmea Azkaban
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
Travel cost
Acc. Cost
s
Max
. 2.6
1.1
Max
2.94
.
5.12
de
2.28
Max
1.1
.
4.38
4.4
2
Max
.
1.26
2.94
4.4
2.6
1.26
4.38
5.12
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 3
ideal solution.
A set of minimum values for each criteria is Negative
Ideal solution.
Criteria
Hogwart Hogsmea Azkaban
s
de
Min.
2.0
Entertainm
ent
Facilities
2.6
Min.
1.1
Travel cost
2.94
Acc. Cost
5.12
2.28
Min.
1.1
Min.
4.38
1.26
4.4
2.94
4.4
1.1
2.94
4.4
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 4
solution. Si*
Criteria
Hogwarts
Entertainme
nt
Facilities
Travel cost
Criteria
Acc. Cost
Entertainme
nt
Facilities
Travel cost
Acc. Cost
Hogsmead
e
Azkaban
(2.6-2.6)2
(2.28-2.6) 2
(2.0-2.6) 2
(1.1-1.26) 2
(1.1-1.26) 2
(1.261.26) 2
(2.94-2.94) (4.38-2.94)
(2.94Hogwarts
Hogsmead
Azkaban
2
2
2.94) 2
e
(5.12-4.4) 2 (4.4-4.4) 2 (4.4-4.4) 2
0.0
0.10
0.36
0.02
0.02
0.0
0.0
2.07
0.0
=
=
=
0.51
0.0 1/2
1/2 0.0
(0.+0.02+0+0.51)
(.1+.02+2.07+0)
1/2
(0.36+.0+0+0)
0.74
1.48
0.6
S* =
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 5 Determine separation from
ideal solution.
Criteria
Hogwarts
negative
Hogsmead
e
Azkaban
Entertainme
nt
(2.6-2.0)2
(2.28-2.0) 2
(2.0-2.0) 2
Facilities
(1.1-1.1) 2
(1.1-1.1) 2
(1.26-1.1)
2
Travel
cost
Criteria
(2.94-4.38)
(4.38-4.38) Azkaban
(2.94Hogwarts Hogsmeade
2
2
4.38) 2
Entertainment
0.36
0.07
0.0
2
Acc. Cost
(5.12-5.12) (4.4-5.12)
(4.4-5.12)
Facilities
0.0
0.0
0.02
2
2
Travel cost
Acc. Cost
Si
2.07
0.0
2.07
0.0
0.51
0.51
=
=
=
(0.36+0+2+0)1/2 (.07+0+0+.51)1/2
(0+.02+2+.51)1/2
1.56
0.773
Steps involved in
TOPSIS
Step 6
solution.
Criteria
Hogwart
s
Hogsmea
de
Azkaban
Si*
0.74
1.48
0.6
Si
1.56
0.773
1.618
2.3
2.253
2.218
Si*+Si
Si /(Si*+Si
)
1.56/2.3
0.68
0.77/2.25 Max
1.62/2.21
. 0.729
0.343
BEST
Attribut
es
AVERAGE
D1
D2
D3
D4
Normalized
W
Q
AVERAGE 1
H(.375)
ML(.22
5)
VL(.125
)
.25
AVERAGE
Q2
AVERAGE
M(.275
)
.25/.91 =
0.275
VH(.42
5)
VL(.12
5)
.21/.91 =
0.230
Q3
L(.175)
VL(.12
5)
VVL(.05
)
.17
.17/.91 =
0.187
.28/.91 =
0.308
VH
VVH
WEIGHT
.425
.475
MH(.32
5)
Q4
.05
.125
.175
.225
.275
.325
.375
1.00
Attribut
es
D1
D2
D3
D4
Normalized
W
Q1
H(.375)
M(.275
)
ML(.22
5)
VL(.125
)
.25
.25/.91 =
0.275
Q2
VH(.42
5)
VL(.12
5)
.21/.91 =
0.230
Q3
L(.175)
VL(.12
5)
VVL(.05
)
.17
.17/.91 =
0.187
.28/.91 =
0.308
VH
VVH
WEIGHT
.425
.475
MH(.32
5)
Q4
.05
.125
.175
.225
.275
.325
.375
1.00
Supplier
AVERAGEs
D1
D2
D3
D4
G1
S
AVERAGE 1
AVERAGES2
.03
.03
.03
.03
.03
.05
.05
.05
.05
.05
S3
.01
.01
.01
.01
.01
Supplier
AVERAGEs
D1
D2
D3
D4
G2
S
AVERAGE 1
AVERAGES2
.95
.95
.95
.95
.95
.98
.98
.98
.98
.98
S3
.85
.85
.85
.85
.85
attribute Q3.D1
Supplier
AVERAGEs
S
AVERAGE 1
AVERAGES2
D2
D3
D4
G3
G(9)
P(1)
MP(3)
MP(3)
MP(3)
MP&F(
4)
MP&F(4 MP&F(4
)
)
3.75
AVERAGEs
S
AVERAGE 1
AVERAGES2
S3
G(9)
MP(3)
P(1)
MP(3)
MP(3)
MP&F(
4)
F(5)
F(5)
4.25
G(9)
G(9)
MP&G(
6)
scale of attribute
ratings
RATINGS
MP&G(6
8.5
ATTRIBUTE
SCALE
)
MP
MG
Q1
Q2
Suppliers
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
Q3
Q4
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
(.03+.05+.
01)
(.95+.98+.
85)
= 0.059
= 1.608
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(4+3.75+4. (4+4.25+8
75)
.5)
= 7.254
= 10.31
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(.03+.05+.
01)
= 0.059
Supplie
rs
Q1
S1
.03/.059 = .
508
S2
Q3
Q4
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(.03+.05+.
01)
= 0.059
Supplie
rs
Q1
Q2
Q3
S1
.03/.059 = .
508
S2
Q4
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(.03+.05+.
01)
= 0.059
Supplie
rs
Q1
Q2
Q3
S1
.03/.059 = .
508
.95/1.608= .
591
S2
Q4
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(.03+.05+.
01)
= 0.059
Supplie
rs
Q1
Q2
Q3
S1
.03/.059 = .
508
.95/1.608= .
591
S2
.05/.059 = . STANDARD
.98/1.608=DECISION
.
TABLE
Q4
Attributes
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03
.95
S2
.05
.98
3.75
4.25
S3
.01
.85
4.75
8.5
DECISION
TABLE
Supplie
rs
(.03+.05+.
01)
= 0.059
Supplie
rs
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.03/.059 = .
508
.95/1.608= .
591
4/7.254= .551
4/10.31= .
388
S2
.05/.059 = . STANDARD
.98/1.608=DECISION
.
3.75/7.254=
TABLE.
4.25/10.31= .
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.508
.591
.551
.388
S2
.845
.609
.517
.412
S3
.169
.529
.655
.824
Q1
S1
.508X.275
Q2
Q3
Q4
S2
S3
ATTRIBUTES
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
from Step-1
Q1
S1
.508X.275
S2
.845X.275
Q2
Q3
Q4
S3
ATTRIBUTES
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
from Step-1
Q1
Q2
Q3
S1
.508X.275
.591X.230
S2
.845X.275
Q4
S3
ATTRIBUTES
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
from Step-1
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.508X.275
.591X.230
.551X.187
S2
.845X.275
S3
ATTRIBUTES
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
from Step-1
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
.508X.275
.591X.230
.551X.187
.388X.308
S2
.845X.275
.609X.230
.517X.187
.412X.308
S3
.169X.275
.529X.230
.655X.187
.824X.308
ATTRIBUTES
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
from Step-1
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
0.14
0.135
0.103
0.119
S2
0.232
0.14
0.097
0.126
S3
0.046
0.121
0.122
0.253
IDEAL SOLTION
Minimum value of Cost Attributes are Ideal.
Maximum value of Benefit Attributes are Ideal.
Cost
attribute
Benefit attributes
Supplie
rs
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
0.14
0.135
0.103
0.119
S2
0.232
0.097
0.126
S3
(Max) 0.14
(min.)Ideal
0.046 solution
0.121
=
0.253}
(Max)0.14,
0.122 0.122,
(Max) 0.253
{0.046,
Q1
Q2
Q3
S1
0.14
0.135
0.103
(min.) 0.119
S2
(max.) 0.232
S3
0.046
0.14
Q4
(min.) 0.121
(min.) 0.097
0.122
0.126
0.253
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
(0.14 - .046)2
= 0.009
(0.135 0.14)2 =
0.000
(0.103 0.122)2 =
0.0004
(0.119 0.253)2 =
0.018
S2
0.232
0.14
0.097
0.126
S3
0.046
0.121
0.122
0.253
S1* = (0.009+0.00+0.0004+0.018)1/2 =
0.166
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
(0.14 - .046)2
= 0.009
(0.135 0.14)2 =
0.000
(0.103 0.122)2 =
0.0004
(0.119 0.253)2 =
0.018
S2
(0.232 - .
046)2 =
0.035
(0.14 0.14)2 =
0.000
(0.097 0.122)2 =
0.0006
(0.126 0.253)2 =
0.016
S1* = (0.009+0.00+0.0004+0.018)1/2 =
S3
0.046
0.121
0.122
0.166
S2* = (0.035+0.00+0.0006_0.016)1/2 =
0.253
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
(0.14 - .046)2
= 0.009
(0.135 0.14)2 =
0.000
(0.103 0.122)2 =
0.0004
(0.119 0.253)2 =
0.018
S2
(0.232 - .
046)2 =
0.035
(0.14 0.14)2 =
0.000
(0.097 0.122)2 =
0.0006
(0.126 0.253)2 =
0.016
S1* = (0.009+0.00+0.0004+0.018)1/2 =
S3
(0.046 - .
(0.121(0.122 0.166
046)2 =
0.14)2 =
0.122)2 =
1/2
S2* = (0.035+0.00+0.0006_0.016)
=
0.000
0.0004
0.000
(0.253 0.253)2 =
0.000
Benefit attributes
attribute
Suppli
ers
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
S1
(0.14 - .232)2
= 0.008
(0.135 - .
121)2 =
0.0002
(0.103 - .097)2
= 0.0000
(0.119 - .
119)2 =
0.000
S2
(0.232 - .
232)2 =
0.000
(0.126 - .
119)2 =
0.0001
1/2
S
S31 = (0.008+0.0002+0.000+0.000)
(0.046 - .
(0.121 - .
(0.122=
- .097)2
0.09
232)2 =
121)2 =
= 0.0006
1/2
0.035
0.000
S2 = (0.00+0.0004+0.000+0.0001)
=
(0.253 - .
119)2 =
0.0179
solution.
)
Criteria
S1
S2
S3
Si*
0.166
0.227
0.02
Si
0.09
0.022
0.231
0.256
0.249
0.251
0.09/0.25
6
0.022/0.24
9
0.231/0.2
51
0.351
0.088
0.920
Si*+Si
Si /(Si*+Si
)
C1* = 0.351
C2* = 0.088
C3* = 0.920
STEP 8
C 3* > C 1* > C 2*
THANK YOU