Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Analysis Level-II
by
Centre for Vibration Analysis & Machine Condition
Monitoring (CVCM)
szafar_kazmi@yahoo.com
Ph:051-9246021
Fax:051-9218114
Cell:0300-8561060
OVERVIEW
What is your present and future budget for equipment & training?
Environment?
INSTRUMENT TYPES
Data Acquisition
Principles
&
Signal Processing
Raw Signal
Amp
Integrator
1x, 2x
Accelerometer
High Pass
Filter
Amp
Low Pass
Filter
Detector
P-P or RMS
AC
Output
Display
Reading
DC
Output
that
from
Data
Selection of Transducers
What is Transducer?
A transducer is a device which transforms a nonelectrical physical quantity (i.e. temperature,
sound or light) into an electrical signal (i.e.
voltage, current, capacity)
In other word it is a device that is capable of
converting the physical quantity into a
proportional electrical quantity such as voltage
or current.
Selection of Transducer
Vibration Transducers
SensorsTransducersProbesWhat is it?
.It basically converts mechanical
vibration to an electrical signal
Accelerometer
Charge Type &
Line Drive
Constant Voltage &
Constant Current
Velocity Probe
Displacement
Shaft Riders
Proximity Probes
(Eddy Current Probes)
Velocity Sensors
Accelerometers
Seismic Transducer
VELOCITY PICKUP
Velocity Pickups
ADVANTAGES
The
output
of
the
accelerometer
has
been
integrated to velocity and has
a 900 phase change
100
mV/inch/sec
mV/mm/sec)
500
mV/inch/sec
mV/mm/sec)
(4
(20
SESMIC TRANSDUCERS
ACCELEROMETER
S
IEPE
Internal
Amplifier
Industrial
AMP
AMP
Charge Mode
External Amplifier
High Temperature
Accelerometers - advantages
Rugged.
High stability.
Integrate to Velocity
Easy to mount
Accelerometer Types
The three most common are :
Compression Type
Shear Type
Acoustic Shield
Preload Stud
Seismic Mass
Piezoelectric Material
Electric connector
Base
Mounting Stud
Receptacle
ICP Amplifier
ICP Circuit
Piezoelectric Material
Seismic Mass
Preload Sleeve
Acoustic Shield
Piezoelectric Material
Seismic Mass
Electric connector
Post
Base
Mounting Stud
Receptacle
ICP Circuit
Typical Accelerometer
Parameters/Specifications
Sensitivity
1.5KHz
10KHz
32KHz
Freq.
Instrument
freq. = 80
KHz
Frequency Range
Relative Sensitivity
30
dB
20
10
Frequency Response of Sensor
0
-10
-20
-30
-40
2Hz
10KHz
Frequency [xf0]
Non-contact Pickups
MAGNETIC
FIELD
NON-CONTACT PICKUP
PICKUP
COIL
SHAFT
OSCILLATOR
DETECTOR
DC
GAP
METER
AMPLIFIER
SIGNAL SENSOR
DISPLACEMENT
SIGNAL - TO
ANALYSER OR
MONITOR
Shaft Sticks
Hardwood,
fish-tail,
fixed
to
accelerometer or velocity pickup
Shaft Riders
Shaft Rider
MACHINE HOUSING
NON-METALLIC TIP
SHAFT SURFACE
safety issue
Radial Shaft
Vibration & Position
Radial Casing
Vibration
Axial Shaft
Vibration & Position
Measurement Parameter
Find
the
flattest
spectrum
Normally
velocity is used.
Always
acceleration
Acceleration
Velocity
Displacement
use
for
Monitoring Techniques
Vib.
Acceleration
accentuatesAcceleration
HIGH frequencies,
and attenuates LOW frequencies.
Velocity
flat treats all frequencies equally.
Velocity
Displacement
accentuates LOW frequencies,
and attenuates
HIGH frequencies.
Displacement
Freq.
Comparison of Transducers
Proximity Probes
Accelerometers
Advantages
Disadvantages
Easy to install
No moving parts
Good
range
Small/light weight
Withstands
temperatures
Measures
motion
high
shaft
Measures
position)
DC
No moving parts
Needs
source
external
power
Provides
information
on
dynamic motion
limited
shaft
high
dynamic/frequency
directly
Installation
Limited
freq.
range.
No
detection of rolling element
bearing faults
Temperature restrictions
in
(shaft
Run-out problems
Vibration Pickups
Journal
Bearings
instability
Shaft
Rotating
Speed
Blades
2x
Rolling Element
Bearings
Gear
3x
1 KHz
3KHz
Velocity Probe
Accelerometer
25KHz
Monitoring Techniques
Types of Bearings
Journal
JournalBearings
Bearings
Stationary
StationarySignals
Signals
Relative
RelativeLow
LowFrequency
Frequency
Modulated
ModulatedRandom
RandomNoise
Noise
Pulsating
Pulsatingsignals
signals
High
HighFrequency
Frequency
Use Accelerometers
Although there are many different types of transducers available, the most common
type used for day to day data collection are Accelerometers.
Data Quality
Whether it is your job to collect the data and/or analyse the data it is important to
understand that the technologies will not give you the answer to a machines
problem unless you have collected meaningful, quality data
There are certain considerations that must be taken prior to any data being
collected, these are:
Variable speed machines - it is very important to collect data with the correct
running speed enter into the analyser
Transmission Path
In many cases the further you are away from the initial event the weaker the signal
will become, resulting in the data appearing to be lower in value.
In more extreme cases the impact can be lost amongst other machine noise by the
time it has reached your transducer, resulting in no detection of a machine problem.
Usually the best place to acquire data from a machine, is at the bearings.
This is because the bearings are the only part of the machine that connect
the internal rotating components to the stationary components (Casing)
Repeatable Data
This consistency will allow you to trend the machinery condition and properly judge the
progression of faults
In order to aid with repeatable data the analyser requests for data to be collected in
certain locations on the machine.
Measurement Points
A measurement point is defined as three alpha numeric digits along with their
respective definition
Orientation and location on each component
The
measurement
point
identifier can be seen in the top
right while the point description
is shown just below
Measurement Points
The first letter of the Point Identifier refers to the type of machine being monitored
M = MotorP = PumpF = Fan
The second character represented by a number indicates the location on the machine
Inboard (Drive End) or Outboard (Non Drive End)
The third letter refers to the orientation of the sensor or the type of processing being
done by the analyser
H = Horizontal V = Vertical
Measurement Points
The following example shows how the numbering system changes as you cross from
one component to the next
This changes when the next component is required for data collection
2
1
2
Turning Speed
When the turning speed has been located, the software will re-calculate all the
frequencies to this exact speed.
Once the turning speed has been set, it is now possible to determine what is
Synchronous/Non-synchronous and Sub-synchronous energy.
Turning Speed
The spectrum is showing numerous
impacts
appearing
at
different
frequencies.
Ex6
12
BFI - Example 6
-P2V PUMP OUTBOARD VERTICAL
Route Spectrum
30-Jan-96 15:14:51
OVRALL= 13.52 V-DG
RMS = 13.46
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 2987.
RPS = 49.78
10
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Frequency in kCPM
120
140
160
Freq:
Ordr:
Spec:
2.987
1.000
.115
EX3
1.0
What type
present?
of
energy
Los - Example 3
-P2V Pump Outboard Vertical
Analyze Spectrum
15-Nov -95 10:00:16
RMS = 1.27
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 737.
RPS = 12.28
0.8
0.6
P2V
Synchronous Energy
0.4
0.2
0
0
6000
12000
18000
Frequency in CPM
24000
30000
Freq: 736.86
Ordr: 1.000
Spec: .245
is
point IDs and definitions / speeds. For this reason the route does
not recognise points if their IDs are altered in the database
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
2X
3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1
9-30X RPM
BEARING BAND 2
30-50X RPM
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
Imbalance
2X
3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1
9-30X RPM
BEARING BAND 2
30-50X RPM
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
Imbalance
2X
Misalignment
3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1
9-30X RPM
BEARING BAND 2
30-50X RPM
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
Imbalance
2X
Misalignment
3X- 6X
Looseness
BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM
30-50X RPM
Bearing Band 2
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
Imbalance
2X
Misalignment
3X- 6X
Looseness
BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM
30-50X RPM
Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
Imbalance
2X
Misalignment
3X- 6X
Looseness
BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM
30-50X RPM
Bearing Band 2
Digital Signal
Processing
Analog Signals
Analog signals:
Examples:
Thermometer mercury height rises as temperature
rises.
Car Speedometer Needle moves farther right as you
accelerate.
Stereo Volume increases as you turn the knob.
Digital Signals
Digital Signals:
varying
pressure waves in the air and convert them into
varying electrical signals.
Voltmeters
Digital Multi-meters
Absolute Vibration
with Free-Space
AC Signal
DC
Signal
Bandpass Measurement
Peak
RMS
Avg
Peak
to
Peak
Freq. = 1/Time
Freq. = Hz
= rev. per second
Machine Freq. are function of RPM
i.e. rev. per minute
Always ask....
Are you measuring RMS or Peak , etc ??
What is the frequency range ??
How much averaging?
Detector
Apeak peak
T
ARMS
A peak
RMS
Apeak
T = averaging period
1
2
a
(t )dt
T 0
A peak
Apeak peak
RMS
2 * ARMS
Quantizing-1
Example:
Output
States
Discrete Voltage
Ranges (V)
0.00-1.25
1.25-2.50
2.50-3.75
of
3.75-5.00
discrete
states
5.00-6.25
with
1.25V
6.25-7.50
7.50-8.75
8.75-10.0
You have
signals.
0-10V
Separate
into
them
set
increments.
Quantizing-2
The number of possible states that the
converter can output is:
N=2n
where n is the number of bits in the AD converter
Example: For a 3 bit A/D converter, N = 23 = 8
Analog quantization size:
Q = (Vmax - Vmin)/N = (10V 0V)/8 = 1.25V
Encoding
Here
the
we
assign
digital
value
(binary number) to
each state for the
computer to read.
Output
States
000
001
010
011
100
101
110
111
Resolution
Sampling Rate
Sampling Rate: The sampling rate (SR) is the rate at which amplitude values are
digitized from the original waveform or Frequency at which ADC evaluates
analog signal.
Sampling Rate: the sampling rate (SR) is the rate at which amplitude
values are digitized from the original waveform or Frequency at
which ADC evaluates analog signal.
Aliasing
Aliasing
Occurs
when
the
input
signal
is
Frequency Filtering
Filters
Frequency Filtering
ypes of filters:
High-Pass filters
As the name imply, a high pass filter allows high
frequencies to pass. (lower frequency limit)
Low-Pass filters
Allow low frequencies to pass through
(upper limit)
Bandpass filters
Allows only frequencies within the band
Anti-aliasing filters
Low pass filter at half the sampling frequencies
High-Pass filters
Low-Pass filters
Bandpass filters
L.O.R
Fmax
Length of Waveform
1. Aliasing
2. Leakage
Solution:
-ve
..give discontinuities
when ends joined
2nd Sample
Use Hanning Window
+ve
-ve
Actual
Spectrum
Measured
Spectrum
Lines of Resolution
The
better
the
resolution
the
more
accurate
the
frequency displayed
BW = Fmax/LOR
Resolution
BW = Fmax / LOR
Energy is summed up
within a Bin and plotted
Centre Frequency
Bandwidth
Lines of Resolution
0.20
0.5
L2 - TA 16
-M1H Motor Outboard Horizontal
Analyze Spectrum
13-Mar-01 09:14:16
09:13:53
PK = .3852
.7078
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 1497.
1496.
RPS = 24.95
24.94
PK Acceleration in G-s
PK Acceleration in G-s
0.16
0.4
0.12
0.3
0.08
0.2
0.04
0.1
0
0
400
800
Frequency in Hz
1200
1600
Frequency
Frequency
Uniform
Hamming
Blackman-Harris
Hanning Window: best compromise between frequency
resolution and amplitude accuracy for steady-state
machinery analysis
Uniform or Flat-Top:
machinery analysis.
Averaging
Overlap Averaging
This works well since the first part and last part of the
sample have their amplitudes reduced in normal averaging,
while the overlapping sample takes full readings at these
positions.
Display/Storage (1)
Display/Storage (2)
Measurements
transferred
to
the
vibration
analysis
Waveforms
Waveforms (1)
Waveforms (2)
e.g:
Waveforms (3)
The analysis of time waveform data is not a new technique. In the early days of vibration
analysis time waveform data was viewed on oscilloscopes and frequency components
calculated by hand. The relationship between frequency and time is as follows:
f = 1/p where:
f is the frequency in Hz
Knowledge
of
this
relationship permits the
determination
of
frequency components
from the raw waveform
data.
Waveforms(4)
For example:
Waveforms(5)
In most situations the time waveform pattern is very complex as illustrated below and
therefore the determination of frequency components is extremely difficult using this
method and is not recommended.
In most situations time waveform data is best utilized by applying the principles of
pattern recognition and if necessary calculating the frequency components of the
major events in the waveform pattern.
Unit of measurement
Resolution
Averaging
Windows
Units of Measurement(1)
Units of Measurement(2)
The same data is now displayed using velocity note
how the 300Hz component is more apparent.
The same data is now displayed using acceleration
note how the large lower frequency component is
diminished and the higher frequency component
accentuated.
The unit of measurement displayed in time
waveform data should be the natural unit of the
transducer used. For example if a displacement
reading is required, then a displacement transducer
should be used. In most cases where modern data
collectors are employed this means that acceleration
will be the unit of choice. If data is gathered from
non-contact probes on sleeve bearing machines
displacement is usually used.
The classic sine wave illustrated below is rarely seen in acceleration time waveform.
This is because acceleration emphasizes the higher frequency components that are
almost always present in the vibration signal. This de-emphasizes the underlying lower
frequency signal.
Unbalance
Although the classic symptoms of misalignment are M and W shapes in the time
waveform, these symptoms cannot be relied upon. The relative phase angle between
the 1 x RPM and 2 x RPM components determines the shape or pattern of the plot.
In the pattern below the relative phase between 1 x RPM and 2 x RPM was changed 90
degrees resulting in a very different pattern.
The pattern below originates when the 1 x, & 2 x, vibrations are 0 degrees apart.
When observing time waveform data symmetry above and below the centerline
axis is important. Symmetrical data indicates that the machine motion is even on
each side of the center position. Non-symmetrical time waveform data indicates
the motion is constrained possibly by misalignment, or rubs.
This waveform pattern is symmetrical above and below the zero line.
The following waveform pattern is non-symmetrical above and below the zero line. The
amplitudes below the line are significantly higher than those above the line. In this case
a misalignment condition was the source. The markers on the plot indicate 1 x RPM.
When the previous time waveform is observed with 1 x RPM markers present it can be
noted that the waveform pattern although complex is repetitive with 1 x RPM. This
indicates that the vibration is synchronous to RPM.
The waveform pattern below indicates a non-repetitive pattern characteristic of nonsynchronous vibration.
This example, is of two frequency sources that are not harmonically related. (58 Hz and
120 Hz) This is the kind of signal that could be created when a 2-pole motor has an
electrical hum problem.
It can be seen that the higher frequency wave does not always start at the same part of
the lower frequency cycle and therefore appears to ride on the other wave causing
symmetry to be lost. Care must be exercised when determining symmetry of the time
axis. 1 x RPM markers are available in most software programs and should be used to
avoid confusion.
At first glance this waveform appears to have large impacts occurring with somewhat
similar spacing. The horizontal axis is scaled in time units.
By using RPM as the horizontal axis and applying 1 x RPM markers the major impacts
can be seen to be occurring at approximately the same part of the revolution. However
closer inspection reveals that the spacing is not exactly synchronous In this case the
problem was a single large defect on the inner race of a bearing. The change in
amplitude of the defect was due to the defect coming in and out of the load zone.
This is the FFT taken from the above machine note the highest amplitude at BPFI is
< 0.05 ips! (15g pk @ BPFI = 2.13 ips).
Another excellent application for time waveform is the observation of beat frequencies
and modulation effects. Often these phenomena are audible. The time span for data
collection should be set to capture 4-5 cycles of the beat.
The time period between the beats on the above waveform is 0.5 s. From this information
the frequency of the beat is calculated at 120 CPM.
difference between the two source frequencies In this case the beat was caused by
interaction between a 2 X RPM vibration source and a 2 x fL vibration source on an
induction motor.
When the FFT process is applied to a signal that contains impacts the true
amplitude of the vibration is often greatly diminished. The following time waveform
was taken from an 1800 RPM machine. It shows several random impacts with
magnitudes over 6 g pk. The cause of this signal was a failed rolling element
bearing. The shape of the waveform often appears to be a large spike followed by a
ring down.
The plot below was a velocity spectrum taken from the same bearing note the
amplitude of vibration is less than 0.04 ips.
scale
indicates
above
amplitude
machine
of
the
the
impacts
Waveform Analysis(1)
Time waveform analysis is an analysis tool. It would not recommend that it be taken on
all measurement locations on a regular basis. This would add significantly to the time
required and data storage requirements.
Use Time waveform for the following selected analysis situations to enhance FFT
information.
Gears.
Looseness.
Rubs.
Beats
Impacts
Waveform Analysis(2)
Amplitude
Amplitude Symmetry
Beats / Modulation
Crest Factor
Introduction
The Crest Factor is equal to the peak amplitude of a waveform divided by the RMS value. The
purpose of the crest factor calculation is to give an analyst a quick idea of how much impacting
is occurring in a waveform. Impacting is often associated with roller bearing wear, Cavitation and
gear tooth wear.
In a perfect sine wave, with an amplitude of 1, the RMS value is equal to .707, and the crest factor
is then equal to 1.41. A perfect sine wave contains no impacting and therefore crest factors with a
value higher than 1.41 imply that there is some degree of impacting.
Crest Factor
The Problem with the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)
The definition of the Fast Fourier Transform implies that any signal can be approximated by
the sum of a set of sine waves. Unfortunately, this doesnt work so well when one has a signal
that consists of non-periodic events, impacts or random noise . Both impacts and random
noise appear the same in the spectrum although they mean different things in the context of
machinery vibration analysis. The crest factor is therefore useful in giving the analyst a quick
idea of what is occurring in the time waveform.
Crest Factor
Comparison of 2 Waveforms
In below figures we can see an example of the use of the Crest Factor. The waveform in figure
on left has a crest factor of 3.01. The waveform in figure on right has a crest factor of 1.61.
The data in figure on left represents a machine with serious rolling element bearing wear, and
the crest factor is relatively high due to the amount of impacting occurring within the bearing.
The data in figure on right represents a machine with an unbalance, but no impacting related to
bearing wear.
Crest Factor
Conclusion
The Crest Factor is a quick and useful calculation that gives the analyst an idea of how
much impacting is occurring in a time waveform. This is useful information that is lost if
one is only viewing a spectrum as the FFT cannot differentiate between impacting and
random noise. Impacting in a time waveform may indicate rolling element bearing wear,
gear tooth wear or Cavitation. Quite often, the Crest Factor is trended over time in order
to see if the amount of impacting is increasing or not.