Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 138

Training Course on Vibration

Analysis Level-II
by
Centre for Vibration Analysis & Machine Condition
Monitoring (CVCM)
szafar_kazmi@yahoo.com

Ph:051-9246021
Fax:051-9218114
Cell:0300-8561060

VIBRATION MEASURING INSTRUMENTS

OVERVIEW

Choosing Your Instrumentation

What do you want to achieve?

What is your present and future budget for equipment & training?

Person power? Knowledge level?

Number of machines to be monitored?

Type of machines to be monitored?

Environment?

INSTRUMENT TYPES

Overall Level Meters

Quick Check Analyzers

FFT Data Collector/ Analyzers

Full Feature Analyzers

Real Time Spectrum Analyzers

Instrument Quality Tape Recorders

Dedicated Balancing instruments

Data Acquisition
Principles
&
Signal Processing

Data Acquisition System

Raw Signal

Amp

Integrator
1x, 2x

Accelerometer

High Pass
Filter

Amp

Low Pass
Filter

Detector
P-P or RMS

AC
Output

Display
Reading

DC
Output

Data Acquisition System


Sensor/transducer for measurement of physical
variables.
Signal-Conditioner/transmission
circuitry,
enables conversion of signal outputs
transducers to a readable form for
Acquisition/interface modules.

that
from
Data

The Data Acquisition Hardware comprising


Multiplexer, Amplifier, A/D Converter, Buffer
Memory, etc. to digitize the analog signals for CPU.
Computer/CPU to process the digital data for data
processing, display, outputs (control), storage,
transmission, etc.

Selection of Transducers

What is Transducer?
A transducer is a device which transforms a nonelectrical physical quantity (i.e. temperature,
sound or light) into an electrical signal (i.e.
voltage, current, capacity)
In other word it is a device that is capable of
converting the physical quantity into a
proportional electrical quantity such as voltage
or current.

Selection of Transducer

Sensitivity: The transducer must be sensitive enough to


produce detectable output.
Operating Range: The transducer should maintain the
range requirement and have a good resolution over the
entire range.
Accuracy: it is defined as how close the output of the
transducer is to the expected value. High accuracy is
required.
Size: Depending on the application of the transducer, the
size may be of primary importance
Environmental Compatibility: the transducer is
selected based on the various environmental conditions it
can work.
Insensitivity to unwanted signals: The transducer
should be minimally sensitive to unwanted signals and
highly sensitive to desired signals.
Cost: The cost of a transducer is an important
consideration, especially when many sensors are needed

Table: Transducer Characteristics

Vibration Transducers
SensorsTransducersProbesWhat is it?
.It basically converts mechanical
vibration to an electrical signal

Accelerometer
Charge Type &
Line Drive
Constant Voltage &
Constant Current

Velocity Probe

Displacement
Shaft Riders
Proximity Probes
(Eddy Current Probes)

Vibration Transducer Types


Seismic:- Bearing relative to space.
Velocity Pickups
Accelerometers
Piezoelectric velocity pickups

Relative:- Shaft relative to bearing.


Non-contact Eddy Current Displacement Probes

Absolute:- Shaft relative to space.


Shaft Contact Displacement Probes (including Shaft
Sticks and Shaft Riders)

Velocity Sensors

Accelerometers

Displacement Probes (non-contact, eddy


current probes)

Seismic Transducer

VELOCITY PICKUP

Velocity Pickups
ADVANTAGES

Self Generating no power supply required


Magnet inside coil generates velocity
proportional to vibration
Spring mass system
10 Hz. to 1000 Hz.
Phase change 900
Directional mounting
Large & Heavy
Output = mV/inch/sec
Wide range of available outputs
Note :- There are two types of velocity pickups the above
advantages do not apply to piezoelectric velocity
transducers.

Piezoelectric Velocity Pickup


ADVANTAGES

Remember everything that


you just learned about an
accelerometer.

The
output
of
the
accelerometer
has
been
integrated to velocity and has
a 900 phase change

100
mV/inch/sec
mV/mm/sec)

500
mV/inch/sec
mV/mm/sec)

(4

(20

SESMIC TRANSDUCERS
ACCELEROMETER
S
IEPE

Internal
Amplifier

Industrial

AMP

AMP

Charge Mode
External Amplifier
High Temperature

Accelerometers - advantages

No moving parts, no wear.

Rugged.

Very large dynamic range.

Wide frequency range.

Compact, often low weight.

High stability.

Can be mounted in any orientation.

Measures casing vibration

Measures absolute vibration

Integrate to Velocity

Easy to mount

Large range of frequency response

Available in many configurations

Accelerometer Types
The three most common are :

Compression Type

Inverted Compression Type

Shear Type

Compression type accelerometer

Acoustic Shield

Preload Stud

Seismic Mass

Piezoelectric Material
Electric connector

Base

Mounting Stud
Receptacle

ICP Amplifier

Compression Type Accelerometers


Advantages
Relatively low cost
Disadvantages
Sensitive to base strain
Sensitive to Thermal transients
Can cause over-saturation and
transducer settling problems
Widely used

Inverted compression type

ICP Circuit

Piezoelectric Material

Seismic Mass
Preload Sleeve

Mounting stud receptacle

Shear Type Accelerometer

Acoustic Shield

Piezoelectric Material

Seismic Mass
Electric connector
Post

Base

Mounting Stud
Receptacle

ICP Circuit

Advantages - Shear Type


Advantages
Lower sensitivity to base strain
Large dynamic range
Much less sensitive to temperature transients
Stabilizes quickly when taking measurements at low
frequencies.
Disadvantage: Generally higher cost due to added components

Typical Accelerometer
Parameters/Specifications

Typical Accelerometer Frequency


Response

Frequency Response & Mounting


Technique-1

Sensitivity

Frequency Response & Mounting


Technique (2)
Stud
Mounting Mount
Pad
Flat
Magnet
Dual Rail
Magnet
Hand
Probe

1.5KHz

10KHz

32KHz

Freq.

Frequency Response & Mounting


Technique (3)

Frequency Range, Sensitivity &


Application
What is the frequency range of your
InstrumentCables
Sensor Sensor Coupling
Cable
length ?
Sensor freq. =
12 KHz
Sensor
coupling ?

Instrument
freq. = 80
KHz

What is the fault frequency you are looking


for ?

Frequency Range

Relative Sensitivity

30
dB
20

Useful Frequency Range


10% limit 0.3f0 3dB limit 0.5f0

10
Frequency Response of Sensor

0
-10
-20
-30
-40

2Hz

10KHz
Frequency [xf0]

Non-contact Eddy Current Probe (Relative)

Non-contact Pickups

MAGNETIC
FIELD

NON-CONTACT PICKUP
PICKUP
COIL

SHAFT

OSCILLATOR

DETECTOR

DC
GAP
METER

AMPLIFIER

SIGNAL SENSOR

DISPLACEMENT
SIGNAL - TO
ANALYSER OR
MONITOR

Non-contact Eddy Current Displacement


Probes
USED FOR:

Relative Shaft Vibration.

Radial & axial shaft position.

Differential expansion between case and rotor.

Especially effective on machinery with high mass rigid casings


and relatively low mass
rotors supported in journal type bearings.

N.C.P Problems & precautions

Only Measures Displacement - Sensitive


Only to low frequency defects.

Subject to Mechanical and Electrical Runout .

Units must be pre calibrated for specific


shaft materials.

Shaft Contact Displacement Probes


(Absolute)

Shaft Sticks

Hardwood,
fish-tail,
fixed
to
accelerometer or velocity pickup

Measures vibration amplitude &


phase

Shaft Riders

Shaft Rider

PICKUP MOUNTING STUD

SHAFT RIDER ASSEMBLY

MACHINE HOUSING

NON-METALLIC TIP

SHAFT SURFACE

Direct Contact : Absolute Measurements

Shaft Riders (permanently installed)

Shaft Sticks or Fishtails

safety issue

very useful below coupling of vertical pumps

Typical Uses of Vibration Transducers

Radial Shaft
Vibration & Position

Radial Casing
Vibration

Axial Shaft
Vibration & Position

Measurement Parameter
Find
the
flattest
spectrum
Normally
velocity is used.

For very slow running


machine (< 600 RPM)
displacement
is
preferred.

For High frequency


diagnostics
use
acceleration

Always
acceleration

Acceleration

Velocity

Displacement

use
for

Monitoring Techniques
Vib.

Acceleration
accentuatesAcceleration
HIGH frequencies,
and attenuates LOW frequencies.

Velocity
flat treats all frequencies equally.
Velocity

Displacement
accentuates LOW frequencies,
and attenuates
HIGH frequencies.
Displacement
Freq.

Comparison of Transducers

Proximity Probes

Accelerometers

Advantages

Disadvantages

Easy to install

Good for detecting


frequency faults

No moving parts

Good
range

Small/light weight

Withstands
temperatures

Measures
motion

high
shaft

Same transducers for axial


thrust, speed and radial
vibration
Measures
directly
displacements units

Measures
position)

DC

No moving parts

Needs double integration


to displacement

Needs
source

external

power

Provides
information
on
dynamic motion

limited
shaft

Not good for slow speed


machines

high

dynamic/frequency

directly

Sensitive to shaft materials

Installation

Limited
freq.
range.
No
detection of rolling element
bearing faults

Temperature restrictions

External proximitor needed

in
(shaft

Run-out problems

Vibration Pickups

Journal
Bearings
instability

Shaft
Rotating
Speed

Blades

2x

Rolling Element
Bearings

Gear
3x

1 KHz

Non Contact Displacement

3KHz

Velocity Probe
Accelerometer

25KHz

Monitoring Techniques
Types of Bearings
Journal
JournalBearings
Bearings

Stationary
StationarySignals
Signals
Relative
RelativeLow
LowFrequency
Frequency

Use Proximity probes


Rolling
RollingElement
ElementBearings
Bearings

Modulated
ModulatedRandom
RandomNoise
Noise
Pulsating
Pulsatingsignals
signals
High
HighFrequency
Frequency

Use Accelerometers

Transducers and Mounting Techniques

Although there are many different types of transducers available, the most common
type used for day to day data collection are Accelerometers.

These transducers provide an electrical charge proportional to acceleration by


stressing piezoelectric crystals typically 100mV/g sensors are used.

Data Quality

Whether it is your job to collect the data and/or analyse the data it is important to
understand that the technologies will not give you the answer to a machines
problem unless you have collected meaningful, quality data

There are certain considerations that must be taken prior to any data being
collected, these are:

A good understanding of the internal make up of the machine, in order to


understand the best transmission path for data collection - bearing locations,
load zones etc.

Ensure data is collected in a repeatable manner so we can compare two or more


readings to each other - trending purposes

Variable speed machines - it is very important to collect data with the correct
running speed enter into the analyser

Transmission Path

Damaged caused to a machine component will cause a certain amount of


vibration/sound or heat to propagate away from the initial impact.

It is the effect of the impact/force that we are trying to detect

In many cases the further you are away from the initial event the weaker the signal
will become, resulting in the data appearing to be lower in value.

In more extreme cases the impact can be lost amongst other machine noise by the
time it has reached your transducer, resulting in no detection of a machine problem.

Usually the best place to acquire data from a machine, is at the bearings.

This is because the bearings are the only part of the machine that connect
the internal rotating components to the stationary components (Casing)

Repeatable Data

Collect data in the same manner each time.

This consistency will allow you to trend the machinery condition and properly judge the
progression of faults

In order to aid with repeatable data the analyser requests for data to be collected in
certain locations on the machine.

These are called Measurement Points

A measurement point is determined by three characters and a description.


Each character refers to a particular place on the machine being monitored

E.g. M1H is a typical measurement point

Measurement Points

A measurement point is defined as three alpha numeric digits along with their
respective definition
Orientation and location on each component

The image on the right is taken


from the screen of the 2130
analyser during a collection
route

The
measurement
point
identifier can be seen in the top
right while the point description
is shown just below

Measurement Points

The first letter of the Point Identifier refers to the type of machine being monitored
M = MotorP = PumpF = Fan

The second character represented by a number indicates the location on the machine
Inboard (Drive End) or Outboard (Non Drive End)

The third letter refers to the orientation of the sensor or the type of processing being
done by the analyser
H = Horizontal V = Vertical

P = Peakvue Change in DSP of Analyser

Measurement Points

The following example shows how the numbering system changes as you cross from
one component to the next

M1H Motor Outboard Horizontal

M1P Motor Outboard Horizontal Peakvue

P1H Pump Inboard Horizontal

P1P Pump Inboard Horizontal Peakvue

Notice how the 1 is not always the Outboard

This changes when the next component is required for data collection

The numbering system starts from 1 again

2
1
2

Locating Turning Speed

Turning Speed

When performing analysis on spectrums and waveforms, it is of utmost


importance to set the turning speed (running speed) correctly

When the turning speed has been located, the software will re-calculate all the
frequencies to this exact speed.

Once the turning speed has been set, it is now possible to determine what is
Synchronous/Non-synchronous and Sub-synchronous energy.

Turning Speed
The spectrum is showing numerous
impacts
appearing
at
different
frequencies.
Ex6

12

By locating the turning speed, it is very


clear that the impacts are Nonsynchronous

BFI - Example 6
-P2V PUMP OUTBOARD VERTICAL
Route Spectrum
30-Jan-96 15:14:51
OVRALL= 13.52 V-DG
RMS = 13.46
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 2987.
RPS = 49.78

10

RMS Velocity in mm/Sec

0
0

20

40

60

80

100

Frequency in kCPM

120

140

160

Freq:
Ordr:
Spec:

2.987
1.000
.115

Analysis Techniques Test


Have a look at the spectrum below.

Where was the data taken?

When the turning speed has been


located

EX3

1.0

What type
present?

of

energy

Los - Example 3
-P2V Pump Outboard Vertical
Analyze Spectrum
15-Nov -95 10:00:16
RMS = 1.27
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 737.
RPS = 12.28

0.8

RMS Velocity in mm/Sec

0.6

P2V

Synchronous Energy

0.4

0.2

0
0

6000

12000

18000

Frequency in CPM

24000

30000

Freq: 736.86
Ordr: 1.000
Spec: .245

is

Things to Remember about a Route

A route includes information from one area only


A route does not have to include all the equipment defined in that area
The order of the equipment in the route can differ from that of the database
Equipment can appear in more than one route BUT can not appear in the same route
twice
Route measurement points may not include all the points configured on the
equipment
Route measurement points do not have to be in the same order as they appear in the
database
Data is not stored at the route level but in the database with the measurement points,
there for routes can be deleted but will not loose data from the database
A maximum of 50 routes can be stored to each area
Each equipment has a maximum of 144 points
And one route can only contain 1044 measurement points

Important: A route file contains the equipment and measurement

point IDs and definitions / speeds. For this reason the route does
not recognise points if their IDs are altered in the database

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X
2X

3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1

9-30X RPM

BEARING BAND 2

30-50X RPM

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X

Imbalance

2X

3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1

9-30X RPM

BEARING BAND 2

30-50X RPM

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X

Imbalance

2X

Misalignment

3X- 6X
BEARING BAND 1

9-30X RPM

BEARING BAND 2

30-50X RPM

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X

Imbalance

2X

Misalignment

3X- 6X

Looseness

BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM

30-50X RPM

Bearing Band 2

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X

Imbalance

2X

Misalignment

3X- 6X

Looseness

BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM

30-50X RPM

Frequency Bands
Divide spectrum in frequency bands based on the
types of mechanical faults that might appear on the
machine
1X

Imbalance

2X

Misalignment

3X- 6X

Looseness

BEARING BANDBearing
1
Band 1 BAND 2
BEARING
9-30X RPM

30-50X RPM

Bearing Band 2

Digital Signal
Processing

Analog Signals
Analog signals:

Directly measurable quantities in terms of


some other quantity.

Examples:
Thermometer mercury height rises as temperature
rises.
Car Speedometer Needle moves farther right as you
accelerate.
Stereo Volume increases as you turn the knob.

Digital Signals
Digital Signals:

Have only two states.


For digital computers, we refer to binary states,
0 and 1. 1 can be on, 0 can be off.
Examples:

Light switch can be either on or off.

Door to a room is either open or closed.

Examples of Analog to Digital


Applications
Microphones - take your voice

varying
pressure waves in the air and convert them into
varying electrical signals.

Strain Gages - determines the amount of


strain (change in dimensions) when a stress is
applied.
Thermocouple temperature measuring
device converts thermal energy to electric
energy.

Voltmeters

Digital Multi-meters

Machine Vibration Signal


Time Signal

Absolute Vibration
with Free-Space

Machine Vibration Signal


Relative Vibration with
mounting position of Prox. Probe

AC Signal

DC
Signal

Bandpass Measurement
Peak
RMS
Avg
Peak
to
Peak

Freq. = 1/Time

Freq. = Hz
= rev. per second
Machine Freq. are function of RPM
i.e. rev. per minute

Always ask....
Are you measuring RMS or Peak , etc ??
What is the frequency range ??
How much averaging?

Detector
Apeak peak
T

ARMS

A peak

RMS

For Sine waves only:

Apeak

T = averaging period

True peak - peak

1
2
a
(t )dt
T 0

A peak
Apeak peak
RMS

2 * ARMS

Machine Signal Types


Stationary Signals

Vibration from rotating machines

Non - Stationary Signals

Vibration from reciprocating machines (short term)

Vibration from run-ups and coast-down

Analog to Digital Converter


Converts analog signals into binary words

Quantizing: breaking down analog value is a


set of finite states.

Encoding: assigning a digital word or number


to each state and matching it to the input
signal.

Quantizing-1
Example:

Output
States

Discrete Voltage
Ranges (V)

0.00-1.25

1.25-2.50

2.50-3.75

of

3.75-5.00

discrete

states

5.00-6.25

with

1.25V

6.25-7.50

7.50-8.75

8.75-10.0

You have
signals.

0-10V

Separate
into

them
set

increments.

(How did we get


1.25V?

See next slide

Quantizing-2
The number of possible states that the
converter can output is:

N=2n
where n is the number of bits in the AD converter
Example: For a 3 bit A/D converter, N = 23 = 8
Analog quantization size:
Q = (Vmax - Vmin)/N = (10V 0V)/8 = 1.25V

Encoding

Here
the

we

assign

digital

value

(binary number) to
each state for the
computer to read.

Output
States

Output Binary Equivalent

000

001

010

011

100

101

110

111

Accuracy of A/D Conversion

There are two ways to best improve


accuracy of A/D conversion:

increasing the resolution which improves the


accuracy in measuring the amplitude of the
analog signal.

increasing the sampling rate which increases


the maximum frequency that can be
measured.

Resolution

Resolution (number of discrete values the converter can


produce) = Analog Quantization size (Q).

(Q) = Vrange / 2n, where Vrange is the range of analog voltages


which can be represented.

limited by signal-to-noise ratio (should be around 6dB).

In our previous example: Q = 1.25V, this is a high


resolution.

A lower resolution would be if we used a 2-bit converter,


then the resolution would be 10/22 = 2.50V.

Sampling Rate
Sampling Rate: The sampling rate (SR) is the rate at which amplitude values are
digitized from the original waveform or Frequency at which ADC evaluates
analog signal.

Continuous analog signal from a sensor

Analog signal sampled at discrete intervals

Sampling Rate (contd)

Sampling Rate: the sampling rate (SR) is the rate at which amplitude
values are digitized from the original waveform or Frequency at
which ADC evaluates analog signal.

As we see in the second picture, evaluating the signal more


often more accurately depicts the ADC signal.

Aliasing

Aliasing

Occurs

when

the

input

signal

is

changing much faster than the sample rate.

For example, a 2 kHz sine wave being sampled


at 1.5 kHz would be reconstructed as a 500 Hz

(the aliased signal) sine wave.


Nyquist Rule:

Use a sampling frequency at least twice as high


as the maximum frequency in the signal to
avoid aliasing.

Frequency Filtering
Filters

A filter is a function that in the frequency domain has a


value close to 1 in the range of frequencies that the analyst
wishes to retain and close to zero in the range of
frequencies that the analyst wishes to eliminate.

The filter can be applied in the time domain or in the


frequency domain but their function is best understood in
the frequency domain

If the filter is a mechanical or electrical device which


operates on the continuous time physical signal it is called
an analogue filter.

If the filter is a numerical algorithm or mechanical device


which operates on sampled data it is called a digital filter.

Frequency Filtering

ypes of filters:
High-Pass filters
As the name imply, a high pass filter allows high
frequencies to pass. (lower frequency limit)

Low-Pass filters
Allow low frequencies to pass through
(upper limit)
Bandpass filters
Allows only frequencies within the band
Anti-aliasing filters
Low pass filter at half the sampling frequencies

Frequency Filtering (contd)


Typical spectrum of a machine without
any filter applied

High-Pass filters

Low-Pass filters

Bandpass filters

Discrete Fourier Transform

The signal that comes to the analyzer is analog signal. It


must be digitally sampled by the analyzer. This process is a
variation of FFT and is known as DFT.

For DFT the waveform is re-created in the analyzer by


digitally sampling and then transformed into the frequency
domain.

To under stand the FFT digital sampling process ,we must


have the under standing of:

L.O.R

Fmax

Length of Waveform

Digital Sample Size

FFT (DFT) - Pitfalls

Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) - Pitfalls

FFT - Fast Fourier Transform is an efficient means of


calculating a DFT (Discrete

Fourier Transform). Basically, it transform a time signal


into a frequency spectrum.

1. Aliasing

High frequencies appearing as low frequencies.

2. Leakage

Memory contents forced to be periodic.

Can give discontinuities when ends joined.

3. Picket fence effect

Actual spectrum sampled at discrete frequencies.

Peaks may be missing.

FFT pitfalls - Aliasing Effect

Sampling rate too slow


High frequency analysis results in false low frequency
signal

Solution:

Use Anti-aliasing filter.


Typically a 1K (1024 point) transform, 512 frequency components are
calculated.

and 400 lines displayed. Similarly a 2K transform 800 lines are


displayed.

FFT pitfalls - Leakage


+ve
1st Sample

-ve

..give discontinuities
when ends joined

2nd Sample
Use Hanning Window
+ve

-ve

FFT - Picket Fence Effect

Actual
Spectrum

Measured
Spectrum

Lines of Resolution

Lines of resolution determine the clarity of the spectral


data.

The

better

the

resolution

the

more

accurate

the

frequency displayed

The number of lines of resolution selected are divided


into the maximum frequency scale (Fmax) to arrive at the
bin width (BW).

BW = Fmax/LOR

The lines are actually centre frequencies of bins of energy

All the energy within the bin is summed up to give a


single amplitude frequency

Resolution

BW = Fmax / LOR

Energy is summed up
within a Bin and plotted

Centre Frequency

at the centre frequency.

Bandwidth

Lines of Resolution

Lines of Resolution (contd)


TA16

0.20
0.5

L2 - TA 16
-M1H Motor Outboard Horizontal
Analyze Spectrum
13-Mar-01 09:14:16
09:13:53
PK = .3852
.7078
LOAD = 100.0
RPM = 1497.
1496.
RPS = 24.95
24.94

PK Acceleration in G-s
PK Acceleration in G-s

0.16
0.4

The spectrum shown displays


data at 800 L.O.R with an Fmax
of 1600 Hz

0.12
0.3

0.08
0.2

0.04
0.1

0
0

400

800
Frequency in Hz

1200

1600

The second spectrum


displays the same data but
with 3200 L.O.R over the
same Fmax

Windowing and Leakage

FFT based measurements are subject to errors from an


effect known as leakage.

This effect occurs when the FFT is computed from of a block


of data which is not periodic.

To correct this problem appropriate windowing functions


must be applied.

The user must choose the appropriate window function for


the specific application.

When windowing is not applied correctly, then errors may be


introduced in the FFT amplitude, frequency or overall shape
of the spectrum.

Windowing and Leakage

Leakage: Leakage is caused when the time waveform signal


does NOT begin and end at the same point, introducing
spurious frequencies.

The Window or weighting function attenuates the signal


towards the edge of the window minimizing leakage.

Frequency

Frequency

Windowing and Leakage


Required to solve Leakage
Several Types:

Hanning Most Commonly used

Uniform

Hamming

Blackman-Harris
Hanning Window: best compromise between frequency
resolution and amplitude accuracy for steady-state
machinery analysis

Uniform or Flat-Top:
machinery analysis.

is the best choice for transient

Windowing and Leakage

The most common windows and their features are given


below.

This table can be used to choose the best windowing


function for each application.

Averaging

Linear Averaging: In linear averaging, each instantaneous spectrum is


added to the next and the sum is divided by the total number of
spectra. This method is useful in obtaining repeatable data for fault
trending, as used in most predictive maintenance programs.

Peak-hold Averaging: Peak hold is not a true averaging method. During


sampling time, the peak value registered in each analysis cell is
captured and

displayed. This method is very useful in viewing

transients or for stress analysis calculations.

Exponential Averaging: This technique takes the most recent spectrum


collected and weighs it more heavily than the past data. It is useful in
observing conditions that are changing slowly with respect to sampling
time i.e., a steady-state process.

Synchronous Averaging: This method utilizes a synchronizing signal


from the machine being analyzed. The synchronizing signal is usually
derived from a photocell, electromagnetic pickup, or some other form
of tachometer input The vibration input is sampled at precisely the

Overlap Averaging

When more than 1 average is used to calculate the FFT, it is


possible to use overlapping samples, as shown in Figure
below:

This works well since the first part and last part of the
sample have their amplitudes reduced in normal averaging,
while the overlapping sample takes full readings at these
positions.

The reduction in accuracy is very small, and for FFTs with a


low Fmax and a lot of averages, collection times can be
reduced considerably.

For example, an FFT with 400 lines, an Fmax of 6000 CPM,


and 8 averages without overlapping takes 32 seconds to
gather the samples. With 50% overlap averaging, sampling
requires only 18 seconds.

Display/Storage (1)

The data collector/analyzer can collect and store only a


limited amount of data.

Therefore, the data must be downloaded to the computer


to form a history and long-term machinery information
database for comparison and trending.

To perform the above tasks, management and analysis of


machinery data, database management software are
required.

These database management programme for machinery


maintenance store vibration data and make comparison
between current measurements, past measurements and
predefined alarm limits.

Display/Storage (2)

Measurements

transferred

to

the

vibration

analysis

software are rapidly investigated for deviations from


normal conditions.

Overall vibration levels, FFTS, time waveforms.


reports can be generated showing machines whose
vibration level cross alarm thresholds.

Current data are compared to baseline data for analysis


and also trended to show vibration changes over a period
of time.

Trend plots give early warnings of possible defects and are


used to schedule the best time to repair.

Digital Signal Processing (Important


Formulae)

Waveforms

Waveforms (1)

The time waveform is the electrical signal from the sensor.

It is a trace of the voltage changes as the instantaneous


vibration changes from moment to moment.

This voltage is graphed with time. Thus the name Time


waveform. The waveform provides a view into exactly how
that point is moving or vibrating over time.

Waveforms (2)

Just like the spectral there are certain patterns and


characteristics to look for when conducting waveform
analysis.

Once the characteristics have been identified, the


analyst can rule out certain faults

e.g:

if the waveform is periodic faults like


Looseness,
Bearing defects, Cracks could
be ruled out.

Data from the time plot will indicate what type of


vibration is present. The five types of vibration are
harmonic, periodic, beating, impulsive, or random

Waveforms (3)
The analysis of time waveform data is not a new technique. In the early days of vibration

analysis time waveform data was viewed on oscilloscopes and frequency components
calculated by hand. The relationship between frequency and time is as follows:
f = 1/p where:

f is the frequency in Hz

p is the period in seconds (the amount of time required to complete 1 cycle)

Knowledge
of
this
relationship permits the
determination
of
frequency components
from the raw waveform
data.

Waveforms(4)

For example:

This waveform was acquired


from a 1785 RPM pump. The
time spacing between the impacts
is 0.0337 seconds. From this
information the frequency can be
determined.
f = 1/p = 1 / 0.0337 = 29.67
Hz = 1780 CPM
This indicates that the impact is
occurring at a frequency of 1 x
RPM.

Waveforms(5)

In most situations the time waveform pattern is very complex as illustrated below and
therefore the determination of frequency components is extremely difficult using this
method and is not recommended.

In most situations time waveform data is best utilized by applying the principles of
pattern recognition and if necessary calculating the frequency components of the
major events in the waveform pattern.

When to Use Time Waveform

Time waveform can be used effectively to enhance spectral information in the


following applications:
Low speed applications (less than 100 RPM).
Indication of true amplitude in situations where impacts occur such as assessment of
rolling element bearing defect severity.
Gears.
Sleeve bearing machines with X-Y probes (2 channel orbit analysis)
Looseness.
Rubs.
Beats

When NOT to Use Time Waveform

Time waveform can be applied to any vibration problem. In some situations


normal spectral and phase data provide better indications as to the source of
the problem without the added complexity of time waveform data. Examples
include
Unbalance on normal speed machines
Misalignment on normal speed machines

Instrument Setup for Time Waveform


The key to successful analysis of time waveform data is in the set up of the

instrument. The following items have to be considered when setting up the


instrument.

Unit of measurement

Time period sampled

Resolution

Averaging

Windows

Units of Measurement(1)

Amplitude measurement units should be generally selected based upon the


frequencies of interest. The plots below illustrate how measurement unit selection
affects the data displayed. Each plot contains 3 separate frequency components of
60Hz, 300Hz, and 950 Hz.

This data was taken using displacement


note how the lower frequency at 60 Hz is
accentuated.

Units of Measurement(2)
The same data is now displayed using velocity note
how the 300Hz component is more apparent.
The same data is now displayed using acceleration
note how the large lower frequency component is
diminished and the higher frequency component
accentuated.
The unit of measurement displayed in time
waveform data should be the natural unit of the
transducer used. For example if a displacement
reading is required, then a displacement transducer
should be used. In most cases where modern data
collectors are employed this means that acceleration
will be the unit of choice. If data is gathered from
non-contact probes on sleeve bearing machines
displacement is usually used.

Time Period Sampled(1)

The appropriate FMAX and Total Sample Period can be calculated


by the following formula:

FMAX [CPM] = Lines of Resolution x RPM


# Of Revolutions desired

Total sample period [seconds] = 60 x # of revolutions desired


RPM

Time Period Sampled(2)

Resolution: For time waveform analysis it is recommended that 1600 lines


(4096 samples are used).

Averaging: In most data collectors averaging is performed during the FFT


process. Unless synchronous time averaging is invoked the time waveform
presented on the screen will be the last average taken even if multiple
averages are selected in the instrument setup. It is normal therefore to take a
single average.

Windows: Various windows can be applied to the time waveform prior to


performing the FFT. The purpose of these windows is to shape the spectrum
and minimize leakage errors. Some instruments can apply these windows to
time waveform data as well. This would force the data to zero at the start and
end of the time sample potentially losing data. To eliminate this effect a uniform
or rectangular window should be applied.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(1)

The classic sine wave illustrated below is rarely seen in acceleration time waveform.
This is because acceleration emphasizes the higher frequency components that are
almost always present in the vibration signal. This de-emphasizes the underlying lower
frequency signal.
Unbalance

Interpretation of Waveform Data(2)

The waveform below is more representative of sinusoidal vibration when viewed in


acceleration. Note the high frequency components superimposed on the lower
frequency.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(3)


Misalignment

Although the classic symptoms of misalignment are M and W shapes in the time
waveform, these symptoms cannot be relied upon. The relative phase angle between
the 1 x RPM and 2 x RPM components determines the shape or pattern of the plot.

The pattern above illustrates the classic pattern of misalignment.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(4)

In the pattern below the relative phase between 1 x RPM and 2 x RPM was changed 90
degrees resulting in a very different pattern.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(5)

The pattern below originates when the 1 x, & 2 x, vibrations are 0 degrees apart.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(6)


Amplitude Symmetry

When observing time waveform data symmetry above and below the centerline
axis is important. Symmetrical data indicates that the machine motion is even on
each side of the center position. Non-symmetrical time waveform data indicates
the motion is constrained possibly by misalignment, or rubs.

This waveform pattern is symmetrical above and below the zero line.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(7)

The following waveform pattern is non-symmetrical above and below the zero line. The
amplitudes below the line are significantly higher than those above the line. In this case
a misalignment condition was the source. The markers on the plot indicate 1 x RPM.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(8)


Symmetry of the Time Axis

When the previous time waveform is observed with 1 x RPM markers present it can be
noted that the waveform pattern although complex is repetitive with 1 x RPM. This
indicates that the vibration is synchronous to RPM.

The waveform pattern below indicates a non-repetitive pattern characteristic of nonsynchronous vibration.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(9)

This example, is of two frequency sources that are not harmonically related. (58 Hz and
120 Hz) This is the kind of signal that could be created when a 2-pole motor has an
electrical hum problem.

It can be seen that the higher frequency wave does not always start at the same part of
the lower frequency cycle and therefore appears to ride on the other wave causing
symmetry to be lost. Care must be exercised when determining symmetry of the time
axis. 1 x RPM markers are available in most software programs and should be used to
avoid confusion.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(10)

At first glance this waveform appears to have large impacts occurring with somewhat
similar spacing. The horizontal axis is scaled in time units.

By using RPM as the horizontal axis and applying 1 x RPM markers the major impacts
can be seen to be occurring at approximately the same part of the revolution. However
closer inspection reveals that the spacing is not exactly synchronous In this case the
problem was a single large defect on the inner race of a bearing. The change in
amplitude of the defect was due to the defect coming in and out of the load zone.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(11)

This is the FFT taken from the above machine note the highest amplitude at BPFI is
< 0.05 ips! (15g pk @ BPFI = 2.13 ips).

Interpretation of Waveform Data(12)


Beats & Modulation effects

Another excellent application for time waveform is the observation of beat frequencies
and modulation effects. Often these phenomena are audible. The time span for data
collection should be set to capture 4-5 cycles of the beat.

The time period between the beats on the above waveform is 0.5 s. From this information
the frequency of the beat is calculated at 120 CPM.

This represents the frequency

difference between the two source frequencies In this case the beat was caused by
interaction between a 2 X RPM vibration source and a 2 x fL vibration source on an
induction motor.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(13)


Impacts

When the FFT process is applied to a signal that contains impacts the true
amplitude of the vibration is often greatly diminished. The following time waveform
was taken from an 1800 RPM machine. It shows several random impacts with
magnitudes over 6 g pk. The cause of this signal was a failed rolling element
bearing. The shape of the waveform often appears to be a large spike followed by a
ring down.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(14)

The plot below was a velocity spectrum taken from the same bearing note the
amplitude of vibration is less than 0.04 ips.

Interpretation of Waveform Data(15)

Care must be exercised when


assessing the amplitude severity of
1 x RPM impact vibration using
spectrum. This is the spectrum of a
machine with where the key is
impacting the coupling guard. The
amplitude

scale

indicates

amplitudes of less than 0.02 ips.

This is the time waveform from


the

above

amplitude

machine

of

the

the

impacts

exceeds 0.15 ips.

In this case severe damage had


occurred to the key and shaft of
the machine in question.

Waveform Analysis(1)

In conclusion, how is this information practically applied in a condition based


maintenance program.

Time waveform analysis is an analysis tool. It would not recommend that it be taken on
all measurement locations on a regular basis. This would add significantly to the time
required and data storage requirements.

Use Time waveform for the following selected analysis situations to enhance FFT
information.

Low speed applications (less than 100 RPM).

Indication of true amplitude in situations where impacts occur such as


assessment of rolling element bearing defect severity.

Gears.

Sleeve bearing machines with X-Y probes (2 channel orbit analysis).

Looseness.

Rubs.

Beats

Impacts

Waveform Analysis(2)

Use an appropriate measurement unit

Rolling element bearings, gears, looseness, rubs, impacts acceleration

Sleeve bearing machine with x-y probesdisplacement

Initially set up to observe 6 10 revolutions of the shaft in question

Study the following symptoms in the waveform

Amplitude

Amplitude Symmetry

Time Symmetry (use RPM markers)

Beats / Modulation

Impacts (shape and amplitude)

Remember use time waveform to ENHANCE not REPLACE spectral data.

Crest Factor
Introduction
The Crest Factor is equal to the peak amplitude of a waveform divided by the RMS value. The
purpose of the crest factor calculation is to give an analyst a quick idea of how much impacting
is occurring in a waveform. Impacting is often associated with roller bearing wear, Cavitation and
gear tooth wear.

In a perfect sine wave, with an amplitude of 1, the RMS value is equal to .707, and the crest factor
is then equal to 1.41. A perfect sine wave contains no impacting and therefore crest factors with a
value higher than 1.41 imply that there is some degree of impacting.

Crest Factor
The Problem with the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)
The definition of the Fast Fourier Transform implies that any signal can be approximated by
the sum of a set of sine waves. Unfortunately, this doesnt work so well when one has a signal
that consists of non-periodic events, impacts or random noise . Both impacts and random
noise appear the same in the spectrum although they mean different things in the context of
machinery vibration analysis. The crest factor is therefore useful in giving the analyst a quick
idea of what is occurring in the time waveform.

Crest Factor
Comparison of 2 Waveforms
In below figures we can see an example of the use of the Crest Factor. The waveform in figure
on left has a crest factor of 3.01. The waveform in figure on right has a crest factor of 1.61.
The data in figure on left represents a machine with serious rolling element bearing wear, and
the crest factor is relatively high due to the amount of impacting occurring within the bearing.
The data in figure on right represents a machine with an unbalance, but no impacting related to
bearing wear.

Crest Factor
Conclusion
The Crest Factor is a quick and useful calculation that gives the analyst an idea of how
much impacting is occurring in a time waveform. This is useful information that is lost if
one is only viewing a spectrum as the FFT cannot differentiate between impacting and
random noise. Impacting in a time waveform may indicate rolling element bearing wear,
gear tooth wear or Cavitation. Quite often, the Crest Factor is trended over time in order
to see if the amount of impacting is increasing or not.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi