Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 60

Contract Act

Contracts Act 1872


Modified in 1930
Portion pertaining to purchase and sale of

various Goods was taken out and made a


separate Act in 1930- The Sale of Goods Act
Portion pertaining to association of persons
for setting up of business was carved out and
made a separate Act- The partnership Act
1932

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

What is an Agreement ?
A offers to host a party, to 10 of his class

mates ,if Sun Risers Hydrabad win IPL 2016


Social

X offers to get a Diamond NecklaceDomestic


to his wife
T offers to provide a water motor set to a local

temple and informs Trustee S

Social

M offers to sell his house to N for Rs.40


lacs
Commercial

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Essential elements of
There needs to be an OFFER
contract
The offer needs to be ACCEPTED by the other
party
Only when an Offer is accepted ,it becomes
an AGREEMENT
Not all agreements are same
In the earlier slide we saw 2 agreements
which are SOCIAL in nature , 1 which is
DOMESTIC and 1 which is COMMERCIAL in
Valid Offer + Valid Acceptance =
nature
Agreement

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

For an Agreement to be legally binding and

enforeable, apart from an OFFER &


AGREEMENT ,the third one that is needed is
called CONSIDERATION (Quid Pro Quo )
Consideration is Something in return FOR BOTH
Consideration can be Positive or Negative i.e to
stop / abstain from doing an act.
In the absence of Consideration a Contract is not
enforceable
In the 4 examples we saw earlier, does the party
who makes an offer get anything in return ?
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Creating a Legal
Intention to create a Legal Relationship is a MUST
Relationship
to have the contract legally enforceable. Otherwse
not
This Intention is IMPLIED (presumed )in a
Commercial Contract
VIOLATION OF THE SAME CAN RESULT IN THE
PARTY BEING SUED
But is NOT implied in other contracts like
personal, social or domestic
Even a personal /social / domestic can become
legally enforceable if Intention to create a Legal
relationship
is desired by+both
the parties by
Contract = Agreement
Enforceability
Law
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Agreement

Legally enforceable
CONTRACT

Voidable
Agree
LEB Contract
Act 2 Venkataraman

Legally not
enforceable
Void Agree.
7

Agreement or Contract
Which is wider in Concept ?
Agreement as it includes non commercial ones
like social and domestic as well. On the contrary,
only Commercials ones come under contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

ESSENTIALS OF A VALID CONTRACT


1. Intention to create a Legal Obligation (Offer
2.
3.
4.
5.

& acceptance )
Free consent of Parties
Competency / capacity of parties
Lawful consideration& Lawful object
Should not have been declared to be void

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Types
of
contract

Contracts are divided into 3 types based on


criteria
validity

Formation

Performance

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

10

Validity
Void Agreement

Voidable Contract

Void Contract

Illegal Agreement

Unenforceable Contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

11

Void Agreement
An agreement not

enforceable by Law
A Void agreement does
not create any legal right
or obligation
Such agreements are
void from the beginning
known as void-ab-initio
It never became a
Contract

Voidable
Contract

An agreement is
enforceable by Law at
the option of one or more
of the parties thereto,
but not at the option of
thretended
B to (sec
the Aother
or others
2(1) sell to him his th

An Agreement
with a Minor
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

property at 1/10
its cost to A. B
accepted. Later, it
is voidable for B
,as it was
obtained under
coercion

12

Void Contract

Illegal Agreement

A contract which ceases to

An agreement which is

be enforceable by LAW
becomes void and so
ceases to be enforceable
This contract was
originally valid as per
Law when entered
into ,but it becomes
promised to sell his
voidA later

against basic rule of public


policy,or is criminal or
immoral in nature ,is Illegal
Such an agreement is not
only void but all other
transactions emanating
form this are also illegal

house to B for Rs.50


lacs.
But later it was
destroyed in an
earthquake. A is not
responsible

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

A agreed to buy a car


stolen by B. This is
illegal, Further B sells
it to C ,WHO IS NOT
AWARE .C cannot get
clear title
13

Unenforceable Contract

Example

This is a Contract which cannot

A did not repay an

be enforced in a Court of Law


because of an inherent defect
at a particular time ,say
inadequate stamp duty etc.
They become enforceable once
the technical defect is removed
Here as long as it is
unenforceable Courts will not
intervene.
The parties themselves may
overlook and perform

installment for 38
months to Axix
Bank.Bank filed a suit
after 38 months.
This is not enforceable as
it has crossed the period
of Limitation which 36
months in India.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

14

Formation
Express Contract

Implied Contract

Quasi Contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

15

Express Contract
An Express Contract is

one in which the terms of


the contract are
EXPRESSELY AGREED
UPON (whether in writing
or spoken) at the time of
entering into contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

A property Sale
Deed is an Express
Contract
A Stock Exchange
Listing Agreement is
an EC

16

Implied Contract
An Implied contract is

one in which the contract


comes into existence by
the ACT OR CONDUCT of
the party

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

A passenger in a
train is supposed to
have boarded for
travel and hence
should fulfill all
conditions of Rail
travel namely buying
a ticket

17

Based on Performance
Executed Contract

Executory Contract

Unilateral

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Bilateral

18

Executed contract
A contract in which

both the parties to


the contract have
Performed their

portion of obligation
And nothing is
pending fulfillment

The contracted
Rickshaw puller
carried the
passenger
And the passenger
paid the contracted
amount
Both have fulfilled
their Obligations

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

19

Based on Performance
Executory Contract
A contract in which

either both parties or any


one of the parties has to
perform their contract .
It is pending execution at
the time of entering into
contract

Unilateral
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

A passenger agrees to
pay a Rickshaw puller
Rs.25 for taking to a
place .So ,at this point
neither of them has
performed their part of
contract

Bilateral
20

Executory Contract
Bilateral

Unilateral
Where one party has to

Where both the parties

perform his portion of


obligation
In this, only one party
makes a promise that is
open & available to
anyone who performs
the required
action
A promised
a

have to perform their


respective portion of the
obligation
It has all components of
a contract namely: An
offer, Acceptance,
Consideration, free will
The rickshaw puller
and Lawful
example in previous

reward of Rs.10000
to anyone who
finds his property
documents .
Costa coffee offers
50% discount after
7 PM

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

page
A signs an
Agreement to sell
his car to B for Rs.5
lacs.
21

Quasi Contracts (QC)


QC are Obligations which the Law creates in the absence of an
agreement between the parties

On Occasions, a person may receive a benefit for which the


law considers that he should pay to another person even
though there is no contract between the parties

These contracts do create certain Obligations similar to


Regular contracts

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

22

Types of Quasi Contracts


Claim for
necessaries
supplied to
persons
incapable of
contracting
Sec 68

Right to recover
money paid for
another person
Sec.69

Responsibility
of finder of
Goods
Sec 71
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

Obligation of
person
enjoying
benefits of
non
gratuitous act
Sec 70

Liability of
money paid or
thing delivered
by mistake or
by coercion
Sec 72
23

Sec 68
If a person,

Example:

Is incapable of entering

A supported a minor B

into a contract
Anyone whom he is
legally bound to support
Is supplied by another
person with necessaries
suited to his condition in
life
The person who has
furnished such supplies
is entitled to be
reimbursed from the
property of such person

(who cant contract) and


has given eductaion to
B. A is entitled to be
reimbursed form
property of B (if any )
A took care of B and
spent on Bs medication
when B went into a
coma (mentally ill ). A
is entitled to be
reimbursed from Bs
property

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

24

Sec 69

A person
Who is interested in
the payment of
money
Which another is
bound to pay by Law
And who pays it
Is entitled to be
reimbursed by the
other

Example: 1
A has hired a car from B.
while driving ,Car was

stopped by Traffic and found


not having been insured &not
paid Pollution.
Traffic orders seizure of Car or
pay up.
A pays .He is entitled to
recover from B
Ex:2
A is a tenant in Bs House
B has not paid Prop.Tax &
MCD orders attachment of
property
A pays
A can recover from B

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

25

Sec 70
When a person
Lawfully does anything

for another, or delivers


anbything to him and
He does not intend to
do so gratuitously &
The other person enjoys
the benefit of that
The latter is bound to
compensate the former
in regard to the thing so
done or delivered

Example: 1
A delivers a large size Pizza

to B, instead of medium ,by


mistake. B has consumed it.
B is bound to pay for the
same
Example 2:
A saves Bs property from
being washed away by flood.
B is bound to pay A for
expenses incurred
If it is established A was on
military duty for this purpose
and hence has acted
gratuitously. No
compensation.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

26

Sec 71

A person who finds goods

Example:

of another, & takes it into


his custody,is subject to
the same
responresponsibilty as
Bailee
So a finder of Goods has
to
take proper care of the
goods as a man of
normal prudence would
do
And Has no reight
appropriate the Goods to
himself

A finds the stolen car of B

,who is travelling out of


country.
A informs B about his
locating Bs car and takes
to his house.
But keeps the car on the
road and with the keys
inside.It is stolen now
A is liable to compensate
B for his negligence, as
he has not taken proper
care like a normal person
would do

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

27

Sec 72
A person to whom

money /anything has


been paid/ delivered
by mistake or under
coercion
Should repay the
same or return it

Example 1:
Alleging A has not paid his

fees,notice is sent
A pays the same under
protest.
Later proves that he has
already paid
Is entitled to be repaid
Example 2:
A collects money as donation
from B ,by coercing him into
paying or else..
B proves that he was
compelled.He is entitled to
be repaid.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

28

Quasi Contract

Sec 68 to 72 covers these


Right of lien over goods

This is a Contract which

Perishable goods ?
Cost of locating owner

IS IMPLIED BY LAW
It is an OBLIGATION created
by Law and there need not
be an agreement
NO INTENTION TO ENTER
INTO CONTRACT
ONE PARTY GETS BENEFOT
AT THE COST OF THE OTHER
VIOLATES PRINCIPLE OF
EQUITY
NO ONE SHOULD ENRICHED
AT THE EXPENSE OF THE
OTHER

high ?
Any accretion to goods got
to be also returned-Cow
,Calf.
Finder of

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

While buying a
Parker Pen ,the
shop keeper by
mistake had given
a Mont Blanc pen
and you have
strated using
it.You need to pay
for Mont Blanc

lost
goods

29

Breach of Contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

30

Meaning of Breach
A breach of contract occurs when a party
,without a lawful excuse

Does not fulfill his


contractual obligation

By his own act, makes it


impossible for him to perform
obligation

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

31

Types of Breach
Actual Breach

Anticipatory Breach

Breach that happens on

Breach that happens

the date it is due or to be


performed
The other party gets a
RIGHT OF ACTION
,against the party which
breached the contract

when one of the parties


declares his intention of
not performing the
contract
In such a case the other party
can put an end to the contract
immediately
Or may wait for the breach to
occur on the date of
performance for putting an end
to the contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

32

Remedies for Breach


Rescind the contract

File suit for Damages

File suit for specific performance

File suit for Quantum Meriut

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

33

Rescission:
when a party to a contract breaks it
unilaterally, the other party can treat the
contract as RESCINDED
2. In such a scnerio , the rescinding party is
ABSOLVED of his obligations
3. And is also entitled to COMPENSATION for
damage which he suffered
1.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

34

Remedies
Suit for Damages:
1. Damages are the monitory compensation for
breaching the contract and is allowed to the
aggrieved party for LOSS SUFFERED
2. Loss suffered has to be established
3. The reason for compensation is not
PUNISHING but to make good the loss suffered
by the aggrieved party ,on account of breach
by one

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

35

Remedies
Suit for specific Performance:
1. The aggrieved seeks the order of the court
that the promise made by the party in the
contract be carried out
2. This happens actual damages arising out of
breach are not measurable and when monitory
compensation is not an adequate remedy

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

36

Remedies
Suit for quantum Meriut(Reasonable sum of

money )
When a party PREVENTS the other party form
completing his obligation, the aggrived party
may claim compensation
For the part of the contract already performed
by him
Under quantum Meriut ,where quantum of
compensation
due
ishad
notto mentioned
in
Where one
party
stop performance
his portion of the contract owing to
contract of default
of the other - after having
completed a portion of it ,has a right to
seek compensation based on quantum
merit
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

37

Liability & Payment of


Damage:
Damages
Compensation in money imposed by law for loss
or injury
1.Payable by the person who has breached the
contract
2.To the other party to the contract
3.For damages suffered by the other because of
the breach

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

38

Types of Damages
Ordinary Damages

Special Damages

Exemplary Damages

Nominal Damages

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

39

Ordinary Damages

Special Damages

Damages that generally

They are specific type of

arise on account of
breach of contract by
one
This could be non
economic in nature ,like
pain and suffering under
gone etc.

damage ,awarded to
reimburse the non
breaching party for
ECONOMIC damages that
arise INDIRECTLY from or
FLOW FROM the breach
It covers losses besides
contractual losses and may
include losses such as Loss
of profits or damage to
business or reputation
The onus is on the
aggrieved to prove this

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

40

Exemplary Damages
These are damages

allowed in special cases


of Loss of reputation
suffered by aggrieved
party
Generally awarded in
wrongful dishonor of
cheque or breach of
promise to marry etc.
Ex:Supreme court asked
Sterlite Industries to pay
Rs.100 crores for
polluting environment

Nominal Damages
Awarded in cases where

damage incurred to
aggrieved party is very
nominal or almost Nil
Just to acknowledge the
fact aggrieved party has
proved his case and has
won

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

41

Calculation of Damages
It is basically the difference between

contracted Price and Market price on the date


of breach in case of Sale of Goods
Seller has to deliver ,in the event of breach by
buyer, if he has to claim compensation of the
difference
If seller chooses to retain, he cannot claim
damages even if market goes down further
Neither can he get the damages reduced if
market goes up again

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

42

Liquidated Damages & Penalty


While drawing a contract , the parties , in the

contract itself stipulate ,a particular sum of


money as damages payable to the other aprty
,in the event of breach
This amount could be either 1) Liquidated
Damage
or 2) Penalty
Liquidated Damage
Penalty

This is an estimate of
compensation for damages
for certain anticipated
breach
This estimate is jointly
arrived at and accppeted
by both parties so as to
avoid calculations &
complications in future

This is an amount stipulated in


the contract ,as a deterrent
against breach
And generally is not
commensurate with the actual
loss suffered
But agreed to by both

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

43

Difference between the two


Liquidated Damages

Penalty

This is a Compensation
Based on actual

This is a sort of

quantum of Loss

punishment
No connection with
actual Loss, but an
exaggerated amount to
deter the other from
breach

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

44

Absolute & Contingency Contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

45

Contingent Contract
A contract may be

An absolute
Contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

A contingent
contract

46

Absolute contract

Contingent contract

This is one in which the

This is one contract to do

promisor binds himself to


perform the contract in
any event

or not to do something ,if


some event collateral to
that does or does not
happen (Sec.31)
A promises to
give Rs.10000,
to B,if he comes
first in Class.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

47

Some Typical Contingent


contracts
Contract of Insurance
Contracts of Indemnity

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

48

Essentials of a contingent contract


Its performance depends upon happening or not happening of an
event

The event must be uncertain

The event must be collateral to the main contract

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

49

performance of a

contingent contract
depends upon
happening or not
happening of an
event

Example:

A promises ICICI Bank


that ,in the event of B
not paying a Loan ,A will
pay.
This means As liability
arises only if B does not
pay & so long as B keeps
paying ,A has no
obligation
All guarantees are

contingent contracts
LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

50

The event must be

Example;

uncertain .
If the event based on
which contract has
been made is certain
to happen ,then it is
not a contingent
contract

A promises to pay B

a bonus of
Rs.10000 , if he
completes the work
in 3 months.
In this there is a
possibility of B
completing in 3
months or not.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

51

The event to occur

should not be part of


contract but should
be collateral
(incidental ) to
contract
The event should be
neither a
performance
promised nor a
consideration for a
promise

Example:

A promises to pay a Taxi


driver Rs.150 if he
takes him metro
station and would pay
him after he reaches
This is not a contingent
contract but only a
Conditional contract
,as taking him to
metro is part of
contract and there is
no uncertainity

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

52

Contingent Event & will of Promisor


Performance

Example:

depends
on
happening or not
happening
of
an
uncertain event.
But event should not
be based on will or
desire
of
the
promisor

A promises to give
Rs.10000 to B ,if he
scores 1st Rank in
class, provided A
wants to give
This is not
contingent

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

53

Rules of contingent
contracts
Sec
32

Contingency is the Happening of an Event

Sec
33

Contingency is the Non happening of an Event

Sec
34

Contingency is the future conduct of a living person

Sec
35

Contingency is the happening or non happening of an


event within a fixed time

Sec
36

Contingency is an impossible event

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

54

Sec 32 : Happening of an
event

Contract cannot be

enforced until &


unless the event has
happened
If the event becomes
impossible ,such
contracts become
void

A promises to sell his


House to B, at the
particular price ,if C, to
whom it has been
originally offered, refuses
to buy it. This contract
cannot be enforced until
C refuses.
A promises to give Rs.1
lac to B, if B marries C.But
C marries someone else.
The contract becomes
void

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

55

Sec 33- Non happening of an event


This contract can be

enforced only when


happening of the
event becomes
impossible

A promises to B that

he would pay
Rs.10000 to A, if C
does not clear Final
exams that year. C
does not sit for the
exam .Contract now
becomes enforceable

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

56

Sec 34- Future conduct of a Living


person
In this case the

contract becomes
void when such
person does
anything that makes
the event impossible

A promises to pay B

Rs.10000 if B marries
C.But, C marries D.
contract becomes
void even though
later it is possible D
dies or C divorces D

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

57

Sec 35-Happening of an event


within a fixed time
Contract becomes

A promises to pay B

void
If at the expiration of
the stipulated time,
event has not
happened
If, before the time
given ,the event
becomes impossible

Rs.10000, if B gets
Mika for a function
on 25th of June.
If he arranges Mika
by that date,contract
may be enforced.
If he does not get
contract becomes
void

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

58

Sec 35- Non happening within


stipulated time
Contract may be

enforced when time


fixed has expired and
the event has not
happened
When before expiry
of time fixed,it
becomes certain
such event will nit
happen

A promises to B, that

he would let out his


house to him if no
one occupies by 31st
May.
No tenant comes to
the house till 31st
May & so the
contract is
enforceable

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

59

A agrees to pay B Rs. 1


Sec 36- Impossible
event
lac, if he can move a hill

In such a case

contract becomes
void
It is void ,even if
neither of the parties
knew about the
impossibility of
performance when
the contract was
made

by 2 inches. As this is
impossible , the
agreement is Void
A agrees to sell all
mangoes in his Orchard
to B by an agreement on
15th June. But later learns
that the entire orchard
had been destroyed on
10th June itself. The
agreement is void.

LEB Contract Act 2 Venkataraman

60

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi