Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Development
Gandhian Ideas Model of Development
Gandhian ideas debated for their relevance to
overall development and rural development
Gandhi comes up as a (Post-Development)
staunch critic of modern civilization and
development
Gandhian ideas per se have attracted attention
given their focus on humanistic, ethical and
decentralised approach to development.
Added relevance of Gandhi in the light of many
ills of modern development like growing
violence, alienation, inequality, immorality, and
environmental degradation; and search for an
alternative
Gandhis writings found in various
publications:
- Hind Swaraj (1908),
- Sarvodaya, Gram Swaraj, Constructive
Programme
- Writings in Young India, Navjivan, Harijan
- Autobiography; Satyagraha in South Africa
- Papers/works of Gandhian scholars
Gandhi was influenced by thinkers like
Ruskin, Marx, Tolstoy and various religious
scriptures.
Gandhi followed an interdisciplinary approach
going beyond economic rationality.
Gandhian Critique of Capitalist
Development and Modern Civilization
It is a curse & disease: it is immoral, irreligious
and narrowly focussed on bodily-welfare
The base of capitalist economics is a mere
Gospel of Mammon
Thrives by creating artificial needs and greed
leading to violence, plunder, and exploitation.
Thrust on industrialization led by machines is
crises ridden with a bleak future
Creates illusion of progress and myth of
wealth; and result only in poverty, inequality
unemployment and dehumanization
Lead to centre and periphery dichotomy
Limitations of Marxian system as per Gandhi:
4. Co-operative Approach
- Living Together
- Adoption of co-operative way of life
- Co-operatives for farm and other activities
- Co-operation based on voluntarism and
morality
5. Khadi and Village Industries
- Khadi and Charaka: Symbol of commercial
peace.
- Revive village industries to avoid evils of
industrialization.
- Decentralized production and distribution.
- To ensure employment to millions
6. Education
- For training both mind and body
- Develop of vocational skill (Nai-taleem) for
employment.
7. Trusteeship (for Economic Equality)
- Gandhian idea of equality to transform
capitalism without violence
- Resources belong to god/nature (hence to
everybody); Any owner is only a Trustee
- Change of heart among owners is needed
- Owners share their earnings with society
8. Social Equality
- Gandhi wanted harmonious existence of
communities without hierarchies
- The unjust practices of caste and
untouchability are not acceptable
- Hindus to atone for it and break the barriers
Assessment
Gandhian of Gandhian
ideas have Ideaspolitical
made considerable
and economic impact
Attempted an integrated model which combines
ethics with development
Comes up as a strong critic of capitalist and
industrial development
Emphasized decentralization for overall and rural
development
Has some useful answers to the challenges of
sustainability (permanence) especially based on
limited wants and simple life
Gandhian approach has been criticized by
many for its limitations:
- Critics calls it a model Opposed to Progress
Technology & Machines
- Romanticisation of tradition and village life
- Status-quoist, Idealist and Reformist arguing
for change of heart rather than change of the
system.
- Criticized for supporting caste-system
But Gandhi was not dogmatic and was open
for correction; may have to be read more
holistically.