Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Welcomes you
steel makers .
Members:
Facilitator: Jitendra Katre
Pradeep Chotia Saravanan
Sharnabasava
24
STEP 1
SL
DESCRIPTION CATEGORY
NO
1 Auxiliary Power consumption high C
SL
DESCRIPTION CATEGORY
NO
14 Deterioration of Vaccuum in condenser A
15 Mechanical Seal Failure in CW Pumps A
16 Turbine Islanding Mode Problem C
17 Load hunting Problem B
18 Load throw off Problem C
19 Condenser water Box DP High A
20 DCS Signal/Panel Ear thing Problem A
21 Rotor Earth fault Problem C
22 Generator Transformer Oil leakage B
23 DCS Power Supply failure Problem A
24 ESV Oil Leakage Problem A
25 TG Inlet Steam CV jam Problem C
26 Specific Steam Consumption high B
SL
DESCRIPTION CATEGORY
NO
27 Boiler Water Consumption High B
28 Turbine Inlet Steam abnormal Parameters B
29 SWBP Discharge Pressure high A
30 DAVR Power failure Problem A
31 Failure of Y adaptors in DCS Panels A
32 DM Plant Level gauges Indication Problem A
33 Less Availability of CDQ Boilers B
34 Boiler Tube Puncture Problem B
35 AOP/MOP Pump Discharge Pressure Problem A
36 Chiller Unit Compressor Tripping due to HP/LP A
37 I/H convertor Problem A
38 Trip Oil Pressure Drop Problem A
39 DC JOP Discharge Pressure Problem A
SL
DESCRIPTION CATEGORY
NO
40 Dust accumulation on Generator rotor carbon brushes C
41 Unavailability of 2/3 Logic for Boiler Drum level Transmitters B
Non Availability of bulk tank-1 and 2 to AMT and acid dosing tank connection
42 A
piping
43 Fire Fighting System Unavailable A
44 There is no running amps indication of the drive in DCS A
45 EPB cover unavailability A
46 Compressor Tripping in Boilers B
47 Blower Trip in Boilers B
48 Boiler feed pump freq tripping due to DP Transmitters hardware Configuration B
49 Battery charger failure in DG AMF panel A
50 TSP dosing pump discharge line Problem A
51 Increase in Turbine Vibration A
52 NPIT transfer pump recirculation line frequent leakages A
SL
DESCRIPTION CATEGORY
NO
53 Air washer fill packs arrangement problem B
54 CT fan auxiliary power consumption high C
55 Dewatering Motor manual start stop problem A
56 Chemical handling area floor tiles frequent breakdown B
57 DC EOP Starter penal field Under Voltage alarm signal not showing in DCS A
58 DC charger capacitor banks uncovered A
59 Increase in Boiler steam losses A
60 Drier A&B soft controller unavailable A
61 Automatic lighting ON/OFF provision with timer A
62 Reduction in CT Sump continuous blow down A
63 CDQ-3 Control valves passing problem A
64 Steam Traps Failures Problem A
65 5s implementation in stores A
65 45 13 7
TOTAL NO OF PROBLEMS
1/28/2018 14
STEP 2 CLASSIFICATION OF ‘A’ CATEGORY PROBLEM
SL Problem Status
1 Raw Water Consumption high TO BE SOLVED
2 Pipe line leakages in DM plant TO BE SOLVED
3 Cooling Tower Effectiveness/Efficiency less SOLVED
4 Cooling water Inlet temp High SOLVED
5 Lube Oil Temp High SOLVED
6 Formation of Algae around CT Basin SOLVED
7 Generator winding Temp High SOLVED
8 TG Bearing Temp High SOLVED
9 Condenser water box differential pressure high SOLVED
10 Abnormal Alarms in DCS due to module Problem SOLVED
11 TG Inlet Control Valve Hunting Problem TO BE SOLVED
12 Turbine RTD Failures SOLVED
13 Deterioration of Vacuum in condenser SOLVED
14 Mechanical Seal Failure in CW Pumps SOLVED
15 Condenser water Box DP High SOLVED
16 DCS Signal/Panel Ear thing Problem SOLVED
SWBP Discharge Pressure high
17 SOLVED
15
STEP 2 CLASSIFICATION OF ‘A’ CATEGORY PROBLEM
SL Problem Status
18 DAVR Power failure Problem SOLVED
19 Failure of Y adaptors in DCS Panels SOLVED
20 DM Plant Level gauges Indication Problem SOLVED
21 AOP/MOP Pump Discharge Pressure Problem SOLVED
22 Freq Chillers Unit Compressor Tripping due to HP/LP SOLVED
23 I/H convertor Problem SOLVED
24 Trip Oil Pressure Drop Problem SOLVED
25 DC JOP Discharge Pressure Problem SOLVED
26 Non Availability of Bulk tank-1 and 2 to AMT and Acid Dosing tank connection piping SOLVED
27 Fire Fighting System Unavailable SOLVED
28 There is no running amps indication of the drive in DCS SOLVED
29 EPB cover unavailability SOLVED
30 Battery charger failure in DG AMF panel SOLVED
31 TSP dosing pump discharge line Problem SOLVED
32 Increase in Turbine Vibration SOLVED
33 NPIT transfer pump recirculation line frequent leakages SOLVED
Dewatering Motor manual start stop problem
34 SOLVED
16
STEP 2 CLASSIFICATION OF ‘A’ CATEGORY PROBLEM
SL Problem Status
35 DC EOP Starter penal field Under Voltage alarm signal not showing in DCS SOLVED
36 DC charger capacitor banks uncovered SOLVED
37 Increase in Boiler steam losses SOLVED
38 Drier A&B soft controller unavailable SOLVED
39 Automatic lighting ON/OFF provision with timer SOLVED
40 Reduction in CT Sump continuous blow down SOLVED
41 CDQ-3 Control valves passing problem SOLVED
42 Steam Traps Failures Problem TO BE SOLVED
43 5s implementation in stores TO BE SOLVED
ESV Oil Leakage Problem
44 SOLVED
40 5
17
STEP 2
DATA GENERATION FOR RANKING MATRIX
1/28/2018
18
STEP 2
RANKING MATRIX FOR SELECTION OF “A”
CATEGORY PROBLEMS
4 5s implementation in stores 6 4 4 5 19 4
19 1/28/2018
STEP 2
GANTT CHART FOR SCHEDULED ACTIVITIES
MEETINGS
STEP ACTIVITIES REMARKS
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
2 Selection of Problem
SCHEDULED PLAN Start Date
Definition of the Problem and
3 01
Objectives
JANUARY
4 Analysis of the problem 2016
8 Development of Solution
12 Follow up / Review
20 1/28/2018
STEP 3
OVERVIEW OF CDQPP
TG AUX
TURBINE
CONDENSOR O/L
GSC Ejector
CONDENSOR CONDENSOR I/L
atm
DEAERATOR
condensate HW MAKE UP
FEED WATER
Problem DM PLANT
COOLING TOWER
CT MAKEUP
Area
RAW WATER
500
Water
RAW
DM Water
RO WATER
TRANSFER BYPRODUCT
PUMP A
RO PLANT PLANT
COOLING
TOWER
RAIN WATER
TRANSFER
PUMP B
RO LINE
VENT
RO LINE
RO VENT TO COOLING
TOWER SUMP
CDQPP DM
RO WATER TANK PLANT
28 January 2018 VIJAYANAGAR 23
STEP 3
Raw water is natural water found in the environment and has not been treated, nor
have any minerals, ions, particles or living organisms removed. Raw water includes
rainwater, ground water, water from infiltration wells, and water from bodies like
lakes and rivers.
At CDQPP ,Raw water is taken from Utility for DM water generation in DM plant.
During DM Generation ,Raw water is being wasted for Backwash and Regeneration
process in terms of water loss
1/28/2018 24
STEP 4
IMPACT OF THE PROBLEM
1. High Utility water consumption
AVERAGE
15 4
VIJAYANAGAR 27
STEP 4
IMPACT OF THE PROBLEM
VIJAYANAGAR 28
STEP 4
Objectives of Problem
31 VIJAYANAGAR
1/28/2018
STEP 4
PROJECT SOLUTION
CAUSE ANALYSIS IMPLEMENTATION
SELECTION DEVELOPMENT
Identification of causes
Validation of causes
1/28/2018 32
Root cause analysis
STEP 8 4
STEP BRAINSTORMING
Alex F. Osborn
1888 – 1966
33
1/28/2018
STEP 5 Cause Identification
Identification of Causes for Identification of Causes for
S l no Increase in RAW Water Remarks S l no Increase in RAW Water Remarks
Consumption Consumption
1 UNTRAINED OPERATOR ACCEPTABLE
10 RAIN WATER INSIDE SENSOR ACCEPTABLE
2 MANUAL OPERATION ACCEPTABLE
POOR MAINTENANCE PLAN
3 ACCEPTABLE 11 LACK OF COMMUNICATION ACCEPTABLE
PIPELINE LEAKAGES 12 IMPROPER SOP ACCEPTABLE
4 ACCEPTABLE
13 LACK OF KNOWLEDGE ACCEPTABLE
EQUIPMENT MALFUNCTION
5 AND FAILURE ACCEPTABLE 14 POOR TRAINING ACCEPTABLE
1/28/2018
34
STEP 5 Cause Identification
1/28/2018
35
STEP 5
CAUSE AND EFFECT ANALYSIS
METHOD
MAN
LACK OF FAILURE OF AUTO
IMPROPER
KNOWLEDGE OPERATION
SOP
PIPELINE
LEAKAGES
HIGH HARDNESS
MACHINE
MATERIAL
48
STEP 6
EQUIPMENT
MALFUNCTION AND All pumps PM Schedule is up to date and
1 FAILURE no malfunctioning observed This is not a cause
MORE REGENERATION
3 LESS OBR IN MB REGENERATION This is a cause
CYCLE IN MB
Audited electrical and mechanical
maintenance records, checklist and SMP.
4 POOR MAINTENANCE PLAN This is not a cause
Discussed with technicians.
NO OF
SL CUMULATIVE CUMULATIVE
CAUSES July-15 Aug-15 Sept-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 OCCURENCES
NO FREQUENCY %
IN SIX MONTH
TURBIDITY
1 14 12 10 10 13 14 73 73 24.74
TOTAL 295
28 January 2018 VIJAYANAGAR 45
STEP 7
295 100
90
245
80
Vital Few 70
195
60
145 50 FREQUENCY
121
Useful Many 40
CUMULATIVE
PERCENTAGE
95
73 30
56
20
45 33
10
9
3
-5 0
HIGH HARDNESS TURBIDITY CHLORIDES No OF SAC/SBA REG
CONDUCTIVITY No OF MB REG CYCLES
(60 TO 110PPM) (20-40PPM) CYCLES
1 HIGH TURBIDITY 14 12 10 10 13 14 73
2 HIGH HARDNESS 21 18 20 21 19 22 121
3 HIGH CHLORIDES 10 8 11 8 10 9 56
4 HIGH CONDUCTIVITY 6 6 8 4 4 5 33
N REGENERATION
5 3 1 2 0 1 2 9
CYCLE IN SAC/SBA
MORE REGENERATION
6 0 1 0 0 1 1 3
CYCLE IN MB
25
20
15
HIGH HARDNESS
10
HIGH TURBIDITY
5
HIGH CHLORIDES 0
HIGH CONDUCTIVITY 1
2
3
MORE REGENERATION CYCLE IN 4
SAC/SBA 5
MORE REGENERATION CYCLE IN MB 6
33 9
121 HIGH HARDNESS
56 HIGH TURBIDITY
HIGH CHLORIDES
HIGH CONDUCTIVITY
MORE REGENERATION CYCLE IN SAC/SBA
73
MORE REGENERATION CYCLE IN MB
BRAIN STORMING
1/28/2018 50
Improving availability of CDQ loco by reducing
downtime.
STEP 8
1/28/2018 54
Improving availability of CDQ loco by reducing
downtime.
STEP 9
149805 135487
4922 1595
NOVEMBER
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
APRIL
FEBRUARY
MAY
DECEMBER
JANUARY
MARCH
OCTOBER
MARCH 4.6 0.7
VIJAYANAGAR 72
STEP 10
TOTAL HARDNESS(DM PLANT) BEFORE
MONTH TURBIDITY TURBIDITY
PPM BEFORE PPM AFTER
VIJAYANAGAR 73
STEP 10 CHLORIDES DM PLANT (BEFORE & AFTER)
JUNE 38 19 80
JULY 43 26 70
AUGUST 51 22 60
SEPTEMBER 48 24 50
APRIL 55 23
MAY 48 21
AVERAGE 53 24
VIJAYANAGAR 74
STEP 10
NO OF SBA/SAC REGENERATION CYCLES IN DM PLANT (BEFORE)
MONTH No of SBA/SAC No of
REGENERATION SBA/SAC 20
BEFORE REGENERATIO
N/MONTH 18
AFTER
16
JUNE 15 4
14
JULY 16 4
12
AUGUST 15 4
10 No of SBA/SAC
SEPTEMBER 18 5
8 REGENERATION
OCTOBER 17 4 6 BEFORE
NOVEMBER 15 5 4 No of SBA/SAC
REGENERATION/MO
DECEMBER 15 4 2
NTH AFTER
JANUARY 16 4 0
FEBRUARY 17 5
MARCH 16 5
APRIL 16 4
MAY 15 5
AVERAGE 15 5
VIJAYANAGAR 75
STEP 10
NO OF MB REGERATION CYCLES IN DM PLANT (BEFORE & AFTER)
MONTH No of MB No of MB
REGENERATION REGENERATION
BEFORE AFTER
7
JUNE 4 1 6
JULY 4 1
5
AUGUST 5 1
SEPTEMBER 4 1
4
No of MB
3
OCTOBER 4 1 REGENERATIO
NOVEMBER 6 1
2 N BEFORE
1 No of MB
DECEMBER 5 1
REGENERATIO
JANUARY 6 1 0 NS AFTER
NOVEMBER
SEPTEMBER
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
APRIL
FEBRUARY
MAY
DECEMBER
JANUARY
MARCH
OCTOBER
FEBRUARY 6 1
MARCH 4 1
APRIL 4 1
MAY 5 1
AVERAGE 1
4.
VIJAYANAGAR 76
STEP 10
PROJECT COST EVALUATION
TANGIBLE BENEFITS
1. Raw Water consumption for CDQPP is reduced from 149805 cubic metre to 135487cubic
metre
149805
150000
145000
140000 135487
135000
130000
125000
Before QC After QC
73
STEP 11 Improving availability of CDQ Gas analyzer by reducing downtime. ECCHHA
CCQC 2016
TANGIBLE BENEFITS
2. Reduce in Chemical Consumption in DM Plant.
CHEMICAL CONSUMPTION
10540
12000
10000
8000
CHEM NAME BEFORE AFTER 4922
6000
2915
4000
2000 1595
NAOH 10540 2915 0
NAOH
H2SO4
BEFORE AFTER
H2SO4 4922 1595
74
STEP 11
CHEMICAL COST/MONTH
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
BEFORE AFTER
TANGIBLE BENEFITS
SAVINGS PER ANNUM
TANGIBLE BENEFITS
Total ROI Calculation
IF RAW WATER IS CONVERTED INTO DM WATER THERE WILL BE LOSS OF 24% OF RAW WATER
28 January 2018 85
STEP 11
IF RAW WATER IS CONVERTED INTO DM WATER THERE WILL BE LOSS OF 24% OF WATER
28 January 2018 86
STEP 11
2) CHEMICAL CONSUMPTION BEFORE
28 January 2018 87
STEP 11
2) CHEMICAL CONSUMPTION AFTER
28 January 2018 88
STEP 11
2) POWER CONSUMPTION BEFORE
76
STEP 12 ECCHHA
CCQC 2016
78
STEP 12 ECCHHA
CCQC 2016
2 Selection of Problem
8 Development of Solution
11 Regular Implementations
12 Follow up / Review
81
STEP 12 Improving availability of CDQ Gas analyzer by reducing downtime. ECCHHA
CCQC 2016
INTRODUCTION
WAY FORWARD
83
STEP 12 ECCHHA
CCQC 2016
FUTURE PLANS
1. Optimization of Aux power consumption.
84
STEP 12
85
STEP 12
THANK YOU