Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Regional Trial
Court
NO. First level courts (MTC,
Filing is only done in RTC?
MCTC) may also be assigned.
1. When the lot is not the
subject of any controversy or
opposition;
When?
2. When the lot is contested but
the value thereof doesn’t
exceed Php 100,000
Lopez vs. De Castro
G.R. No. 112905 February 3, 2000
Ruling
The court held that a land registration is an in rem
proceeding which involves a constructive notice
against all persons including the state which is
effective through the publication of the application
for land registration. The court held that when
more than one certificate of title is issued over the
land, the person holding the prior certificate of
title is entitled to a better right against the person
who relies on the subsequent certificate.
Lopez vs. De Castro
Ruling
To begin with, the original tracing cloth
plan of the land applied for, which must be
approved by the Director of Lands, was not
submitted in evidence. The submission of
such plan is a statutory requirement of
mandatory character. Unless a plan and its
technical description are duly approved by
the Director of Lands, the same are not of
much value.
Director of Lands vs. Reyes
G.R No. L-27594
November 28, 1975
Ruling
Obviously, the superimposition of the copy
of the survey plan of land as surveyed for
applicant in the military map of the area
under Proclamation No. 237 was for the
sole purpose of showing that the land
applied for is situated within the area
covered by the military reservation of Fort
Magsaysay appropriately indicated in the
perimeter map of said reservation.
Director of Lands vs. Reyes
G.R No. L-27594
November 28, 1975
Ruling
But the applicant is not relieved
from the original tracing cloth plan
approved by the Director of Lands
as required by law. One of the
distinguishing marks of the Torrens
System is the absolute certainty of
the identity of a registered land.
Director of Lands vs. Reyes
G.R No. L-27594
November 28, 1975
Ruling
Consequently the primary purpose of the
aforesaid requirement is to fix the exact or
definite identity of the land as shown in
the plan and technical descriptions. Hence,
the applicant is not relieved of his duty of
submitting the original tracing cloth of the
survey plan of the land duly approved by
the Director of Lands.
Section 18
Ruling
The settled rule, further, is that once the
registration court had acquired jurisdiction
over a certain parcel, or parcels, of land in
the registration proceedings in virtue of
the publication of the application, that
jurisdiction attaches to the land or lands
mentioned and described in the
application.
If it is later shown that the decree of
registration had included land or lands
not included in the original application
as published, then the registration
proceedings and the decree of
registration must be declared null and
void in so far — but only in so far — as
the land not included in the
publication is concerned.
This is so, because the court did not
acquire jurisdiction over the land
not included in the publication-the
publication being the basis: of the
jurisdiction of the court. But the
proceedings and the decree of
registration, relating to the lands
that were included in the
publication, are valid.
Thus, if it is shown that a certificate
of title had been issued covering
lands where the registration court
had no jurisdiction, the certificate of
title is null and void insofar as it
concerns the land or lands over
which the registration court had not
acquired jurisdiction.
Section 20
If the person
obtains title to land
which cannot be
registered under
the Torrens system,
he does not
become owner of
the land by virtue
of said title.
Sections 21
The court may require applicants
to present additional facts and
other corroborative evidence as
may be relevant in the
determination and resolution of
the case.
Sections 22
Ruling
“The law does not require that the application
for registration be amended by substituting the
"buyer" or the person to whom the property
has been conveyed" for the applicant. Neither
does it require that the "buyer" or the "person
to whom the property has been conveyed" be
a party to the case. He may thus be a total
stranger to the land registration proceedings.”
Mendoza vs Court of Appeals
G.R. No. L-36637
July 14, 1978
Ruling
“The only requirements of the law are: (1) that the
instrument be presented to the court by the
interested party together with a motion that the
same be considered in relation with the
application; and (2) that prior notice be given to
the parties to the case. And the peculiar facts and
circumstances obtaining in this case show that
these requirements have been complied with.”
PUBLICATION, OPPOSITION AND DEFAULT
PP -- M-
M- PP
P
Publication
ublication
What are the three (3) modes of land
M ailing
Mailing
registration?
Posting
Section 23
Notice of Initial Hearing
The court must WITHIN 5 DAYS
from the filing of application,
shall issue an order setting the
date and hour of the initial
hearing which shall not be earlier
than 45 days nor later than 90
days from the date of order.
Notice of Initial Hearing
Ruling
The facts reveal that Manna Properties was not at
fault why the hearing date was set beyond the 90-
day maximum period. The records show that the
Docket Division of the LRA repeatedly requested
the trial court to reset the initial hearing date
because of printing problems with the National
Printing Office, which could affect the timely
publication of the notice of hearing in the Official
Gazette.
Republic vs. Manna Properties
G.R. No. 146527
January 31, 2005
Ruling
Indeed, nothing in the records indicates that
Manna Properties failed to perform the acts
required of it by law. We have held that ‘a party to
an action has no control over the Administrator or
the Clerk of Court acting as a land court; he has no
right to meddle unduly with the business of such
official in the performance of his duties.’ A party
cannot intervene in matters within the exclusive
power of the trial court.
Republic vs. Manna Properties
G.R. No. 146527
January 31, 2005
Ruling
An application (or petition) having been filed in the above-entitled case by (full name
and address) praying for the registration and confirmation (or for the settlement and
adjudication, in case of petition in cadastral proceedings) of title to the following
described lands:
(Insert description)
You are hereby served this notice to appear before this Court at its session to be held at
_________________ on the ______________ day of _______________, 19 ______, at
_____________ o'clock in the _________ then and there to present such claims as you may
have to said lands or any portion thereof, and to submit evidence in support of such claim; and
unless you appear at said Court at the time and place aforesaid, your default will be recorded
and the title to the lands will be adjudicated and determined in accordance with law and the
evidence before the Court, and thereafter you will forever be barred from contesting said
application (or petition) or any decree entered thereon.
Witness, the Hon. ________________________ Judge of the Court of First Instance of _______
this _______ day of _________________, in the year 19______.
Attest:
Commissioner of Land Registration
1. To confer jurisdiction;
2. To apprise the whole world of
the pending registration case so
thatis they
What may assert
the purpose their rights
of publication?
or interests in the land, if any,
and oppose the application if so
minded
PUBLICATION OF NOTICE OF INITIAL
HEARING
Upon receipt of the order of the
Publication
court
Thesetting in a newspaper
the case
publication forOG
in the of
initial
is
general
hearing,
ENOUGH circulation
the
toLRA remains an
shalljurisdiction
confer cause the
indispensible
notice toupon procedural
be published
the court.once in
requirement.
the Official Gazette and once in
the OG is enough to confer
jurisdiction upon the court.
…because it is a component of
procedural due process and aimed
at giving “as wide publicity as
possible” so that all persons having
Why?
an adverse interest in the land
subject of the registration
proceedings may be notified
thereof.
Within 7 days after publication in
the OG of the notice of initial
hearing, the LRA administrator
MAILING
shall TOaPERSONS
cause copy of NAMED IN to
the notice
APPLICATION
be mailed to every person named
in the notice whose address is
known
Mandatory requirement
The requirement that personal
notice shall be a prerequisite to the
Lack of personal
validity notice
of registration does
would
not vitiate
absolutely the proceedings
prohibit the foreclosure
of unknown claims, for the reason
that personal notice could never be
given to “unknown claimants.”
The purpose of the law in requiring
the giving of notice by all
What is the purpose of notice three
modes is to strengthen the Torrens
by all three modes?
system through safeguards to
prevent anomalous titling of real
property.
…a step
New to the protection
publication
essential necessaryofto
persons
includeinterested in the
additional area
property which is intended to be
included.
If the land borders on a river, navigable
stream or shore, an arm of the sea, or lake,
or if it otherwise appears that a tenant-
farmer or the national government may
MAILING
have an TO THE
adverse SECRETARY
claim to that of OF
the
If the applicant requests to have the
PUBLICthe
applicant, WORKS ANDalso
notice shall HIGHWAYS,
be mailed to
line of
the Secretary a public
of way
Agrarian or
Reform,road
Solicitor
GOVERNOR, AND MAYOR
determined
General, Director of Lands, Director of
Public Works and Communications,
Director of Forest Development, Director of
Fisheries and Aquatic Resources, as may be
appropriate
Solicitor General represents the
What is the Role of the Solicitor General?
Government in all land registration
and related proceedings.
Within 14 days before the initial
hearing, the LRA administrator shall
cause a duly attested copy of the
notice to be posted by the sheriff in
a conspicuousPosting
place on the land
applied for and also in a
conspicuous place on the bulletin
board of the municipality or city in
which the land is situated;
Mandatory requirement.
Sections 25
1. The oppositor must have an interest
in the land applied for
2. He should state the grounds for his
a. Based on the right of
objection as well as the nature of
dominion or some other real
hisREQUISITES
claimed interest
FOR OPPOSING
right opposed to the adjudication
APPLICATION:
or recognition of the ownership
3. The relief being prayed for
of the applicant, whether it be
limited or absolute
All the allegations contained in the
application shall be held as confessed
by reason of the absence of denial on
the part of the opponent;
What
The isperson
the effect
whoofhas
failing
nottochallenged
oppose?
cannot allege damage or error against
the judgment ordering the registration
inasmuch as he didn't allege or pretend
to have right over the land.
H-P-A-P
H-P-A-P
H-P-A-P
H A
3. An wardee in a sales
PP
1. A omesteader who hasn't
A4.Who maywho,
2.application
A urchaser
erson file
of opposition?
claiming
friar
by land
to be
virtue
been issued his title but has
who
of in is
the
deemed
possession
award,toishave
authorized
of the
an land
equitable
to
andtake
has
title
fulfilled all the conditions required
possession
applied
to the land
with
of even
the
theland
LMB
before
tofor
enable
the
its
by law for the issuance of the
him toissuance
complypurchase
of
withtherequirements
patent
patent;
for the issuance of the patents
Private person may NOT file opposition on
behalf of the Government.
The provision which allows the
court at once upon the motion
FAILURE TO APPEAR ON THE DAY OF of
the applicant, no reason to
INITIAL HEARING IS NOT A GROUND the
contrary appearing, to order
FOR DEFAULT WHERE OPPOSITION OR a
general default to be recorded,
ANSWER HAS BEEN FILED
cannot be interpreted to mean
that the court can just disregard
the answer before it.
Section 26
Order of Default, when entered
1. Order of general default—if no
person appears and answers within
the time allowed; by description in
the notice “to whom it may
concern”, all the world are made
parties defendant and shall be
concluded by the default order
2. Order of special default—when
an appearance has been entered
and answer filed, default order shall
be entered upon against persons
who didn't appear and answer
Section 26
Motion to lift order of General Default
An order of default is interlocutory
in character, subject to the control
of the court, and may be modified
and amended as the court may
deem proper at any time prior to
the rendition of the final judgment.
Party declared in default loses his
standing
What in court;
is the effect of Order of Default?
He cannot appear in court, be
heard or be entitled to notice
Section 27