Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 93

HOW TO WRITE COURSE

OUTCOMES
&
HOW TO MEASURE COURSE
OUTCOMES

G. Varaprasad
Department of Computer Science & Engineering
B.M.S.College of Engineering
Bangalore 560 019.
Outline
 Introduction
 Common Mistakes
 How to Write Course Outcomes
 How to Mapping CO-PO
 Direct Assessment Tools
 Indirect Assessment Tools
 CO Attainment
 Reference

1
Introduction
 Course.
 Ex: Computer network subject(code: 12SCS12)
 Ex: Computer network lab(code: 12SCS18).
 Ex: Project work(code: 12SCS83).
 Ex: Seminar(code: 12SCS88).
 Ex: Database management system (16CS5DCDBS)
 Course outcome describes skills/competencies.
 COs are gained by students at the end of the course
 COs are student learning outcomes.
 Ex: Apply skill
 Ex: Analysing skill
 Ex: Design skill.
 Ex: Communication skill
 Ex: Usage of modern tools/new software 2
3
Introduction(Cont…)
 Every course/subject will have COs
 All course outcomes(COs) are must be relevant to particular
course(DBMS).

3
3
Introduction(Cont…)
 Don’t mix with multiple Bloom’s levels(2-6) for a writing a
single CO.
 Write CO for each Bloom’s.
 Except Bloom’s level 1 and level 2.
 Ex:CO: Analyse and apply normalization concept for
relational schema.
 Analyse comes under Bloom’s level 4(PO2).
 Apply comes under Bloom’s level 3(PO1).
 Ex:COa: Ability to apply SQL as well as relational algebra to
find solutions to a broad range of queries. Apply level
 Apply comes under Bloom’s level 3(PO1).
 Ex:COb: Ability to analyse various database design
techniques for a given scenario. Analyse level.
 Analyse comes under Bloom’s level 4(PO2). 64
Introduction(Cont…)
 To avoid writing multiple COs, which are not mapping to any
PO.
 CO1 is written based on Bloom level 1&/level 2, but not
mapped to any PO.

CO1: Remerging/Understanding
CO2: Apply
CO3: Analyse
CO4: Design & Communication
CO5: Investigation

CO6: Usage of modern tool


65
Introduction(Cont…)
 Every course/subject will have to map 2 or more POs.

 Weightage, I will talk later. No.of POs mapped: 6 6


3
Common Mistakes
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept 1/2 COs in a course: Yes/No

Not Acceptable

 Needs around Six Course Outcomes per course

7
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below COs: Yes/No

Not Acceptable

8
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall
CO2,we CO6
acceptare
below COsComputer
from in a DBMSnetworks
course: Yes/No
course

Not Acceptable

9
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below CO in a DBMS course: Yes/No
 Ex:CO: Analyse and apply normalization concepts for
relational schema.
Not Advisable

Analyse comes under Bloom’s level 4 (PO2).


Apply comes under Bloom’s level 3 (PO1)
Write separate CO for Bloom’s level 3
 Ex: CO: Ability to apply NF technique for a given
scenario
Write separate CO for Bloom’s level 4
 Ex: CO: Ability to analyse various normalization
techniques for a given scenario 13
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below COs in a DBMS course: Yes/No

Not Advisable

CO: Write general statement for all COs(Apply)


11
3
for Unit1/Unit2, ……
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below COs in a DBMS course: Yes/No

Not Advisable

CO: Write general statement for all COs(Design


12
3
for Unit1/Unit2, ……
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below COs in a DBMS course: Yes/No

Acceptable

13
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept 1CO (DBMS has 1 CO) is mapping multiple
POs: Yes/No.
 CO1: Ability to define, understand and explain concepts of
database management system

Not Acceptable

14
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below CO-PO mapping(DBMS has 6 COs):
Yes/No

This type of COs-POs


mapping is not
acceptable

15
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept below CO-PO mapping(DBMS has 6 COs):
Yes/No

This type of COs-POs


mapping is not
acceptable

16
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of Database management systems
 Shall we accept 6COs are mapping with single PO: Yes/No

Not Acceptable

17
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
CO2: Apply skill CO3: Analysis skill CO4:Design skill
 Course outcomes of
CO5: Investigation skill
Database
CO6: management
Usage of systems
modern tool skill
 Avoid writing COs based on Units.
 CO attainment issues be avoided if you write based on
entire syllabus
 CO1, CO2 are from unit 1 and unit 2 &mapped to test 1
 CO3, CO4 are from unit 3 and unit 4 &mapped to test 2
 CO5, CO6 are from unit 5 and unit 6 &mapped to test 3
 If students not taken test 3, CO5,CO6 attainment...?
 Write CO based on entire syllabus rather units.
Acceptable
 It is good

1
38
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Course outcomes of X Course/Subject
 Shall we accept below CO-PO mapping: Yes/No

CO1: Apply skill

CO2: Analysis skill


Acceptable
CO3:Design skill

CO4: Investigation skill CO4:Commu

CO5: Usage of modern tool skill

CO6: Engineer and society CO6: Communic

19
3
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Database management systems
 Shall we accept following question paper: Yes/No

Not Acceptable

2
30
Common Mistakes(cont…)
 Internal question paper(CIE) of DBMS
Apply computing skill Analyse skill
 Shall we accept below question paper: Yes/No

Acceptable

21
3
How to Write Course Outcomes
 Course: Database management system(Integrated course)
 DBMS is core: CSE/IT; DBMS is elective: ECE/EEE

2
32
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 DBMS syllabus is divided into units or modules
 At VTU, we call units and Anna Univ, it called modules.

2
33
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Let us assume that DBMS course has CIE and SEE marks.
 You must know what are tools you want to use in assessing
the students.
 It helps identifying skill and measuring COs/POs/PSOs.

 Continuous Internal Evaluation (CIE)-Internal exam


 Semester End Examination [SEE]-University exam 2
34
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Look at Bloom’s before writing COs

2
35
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Look at NBA GA(POs) before writing COs

2
36
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Look at NBA GA(POs) before writing COs

 Remembering(1) and understanding(2) are not addressed


directly with any NBA Graduate Attributes.
 NBA does not emphasize development of remembering(1)
and understanding(2).
 UG-NBA starts with Apply level(PO3) 2
37
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Syllabus is divided into units or modules and then sub-
unit/modules

2
38
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out Unit 1 in the syllabus and then
 Write COs for each sub-unit/module

2
39
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 If students study unit 1a, then what skills(PO/Blooms)
he/she acquires.
U1a: CO1: Ability to list various characteristics of database approach
U1a: CO2: Ability to explain various advantage of database

 First write possible/expected questions from theskill


Q1,3:Remember unit 1a,
then write CO, we are doing reverse engineering
Q1: List various characteristics of Database.
Q2: Explain various advantages of DBMS. Q2,4,5,6:Understand skill
Q3: Define database management system
Q4: Describe database with an example.
Q5: Discuss scenarios, where you cannot use database
Q6: Explain various roles in DBMS

303
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 If students study unit 1b, then what skills(PO/Blooms)
he/she
U1b: acquires.
CO1:Ability to define schemas, data model instances, data
independence.
U1b: CO2:Ability to explain three schema architecture.
U1b: CO3:Ability to analyse various data models for a given scenario
(PO2)
 First write possible/expected questions from the unit 1b,
then write CO Q1,3:Remember skill
Q1: Define schema.
Q2,3,4,5:Understand skill
Q2: Explain three level architecture.
Q3: List various data models used in database. Q6:Anlyse skill
Q4: Classify various data languages
Q5: Discuss about database languages
Q6: Analyse various data models for a given scenario

3
31
U1c:
How CO2:
toAbility
Write to explain
Course various operations in SQL
Outcomes(cont...)
U1c: CO3: Ability to apply SQL to solve problem for given scenario (PO1
 IfCO4:
U1c: students study
Ability to unit
design 1c, then
database what scenario(PO3)
for a given skills(PO/Blooms)
U1c:he/she acquires.
CO5: Ability to Analyse queries operations for a given(PO2)
U1c: CO6: Ability to conduct experiments of database using mode
tools: Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL(PO5) Q1: Remember skill
Q2: Understand skill
 First write possible/expected questions from the unit 1c,
then write CO: Q3:Apply skill
Q1: List various operations of SQL. Q4:Desing skill
Q2: Explain virtual tables.
Q5: Analyse skill
Q3: Apply SQL query to retrieve list of employee work are working
in Bangalore(PO2) Q6: Usage od moder
Q4: Design database for a given scenario(PO3)
Q5: Analyse queries operations for a given scenario(PO3)
Q6: Conduct experiments of database using MySQL(PO5)

32
3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 If CO:
U2a: students
Abilitystudy
to listunit 2a, then
various what skills he/she acquires.
constraints.
U2a: CO: Ability to explain relational database schemas
U2a: CO: Ability to investigate various model for given scenario(PO4)

 First write possible/expected questionsQ1:Remember


for this unitskill
2a, then
write CO:
Q1: List various constraints. Q2,3:Understand skill
Q2: Explain relational database schemas.
Q3: Discuss update operations
Q4: Investigate various model for a given scenario
Q4: Investigation skill

3
33
How
U2b: CO:toAbility
Write Course
to list Outcomes(cont...)
Binary Relational Operations
 If CO:
U2b: students
Abilitystudy unit 2b,
to describe thenRelational
unary what skills he/she acquires.
Operation
U2b: CO: Ability to apply relational algebra to solve problem for given
scenario (PO1)
U2b: CO: Ability to investigate operations for a given scenario (PO4)

 First write possible/expected questions for this unit 2b, then


write CO, reverse engineering Q1: Remember skill
Q1: List binary relational operations Q2: Understand skill
Q2: Explain unary relational operations.
Q3: Apply relational algebra to solve problem for a Q3:Apply
given scenario
skill
(PO1)
Q4: Investigate operations for a given scenario (PO4)
Q4:Investigate ski

3
34
How toAbility
U2c: CO: Write Course
to list Outcomes(cont...)
entity types
 If CO:
U2c: students
Abilitystudy unit 2c,
to explain then
entity what
sets, skills he/she
attributes acquires.
and keys,
U2c: CO: Ability to analyse weak entity and strong entity for a given
scenario(PO2).
U2c: CO: Ability to design ER diagram for a given scenario(PO3)
 First write possible/expected questions for
Q1:the
Remember
unit 2c,skill
then
write CO: Q2: Understand skill
Q1: List entity types
Q2: Explain Entity Sets, Attributes and Keys, Q3: Analyse skil
Q3: Analyse weak entity and strong entity for a given scenario.
Q4: Ability to design ER model for a given scenario Q4:Desing skill

335
How
U3: CO:toAbility
Write to listCourse Outcomes(cont...)
various functional dependencies.
U3:IfCO:
students
Abilitystudy unit 33,Normal
to explain then what skills he/she acquires.
Form.
U3: CO: Ability to analyse various techniques for given scenario(PO2)
U3: CO: Ability to Investigate various normalization techniques for giv
scenario (PO4).

 First write possible/expected questions from the unit 3, then


Q1: Remember skill
write CO:
Q1: List various functional dependencies. Q2: Understand skill
Q2: Explain 3 Normal Form. Q3:Analyse skill
Q3: Validating data in normal form. Q4:Investigate skill
Q4: Investigate various normalization techniques for given scenario

3
36
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
U4:If CO:
students
Abilitystudy
to listunit 4, then
desirable what skills
properties he/she acquires.
of transactions
U4: CO: Ability to describe recovery concepts
U4: CO: Ability to analyse serial schedule and a serializable schedule
(PO2)

 First write possible/expected questions from the unit 4,skill


Q1: Remember then
write CO, reverse engineering :
Q1: List desirable properties of transactions Q2: Understand skill
Q2: Describe recovery concepts Q3:Analyse skill
Q3: Analyse serial schedule and a serializable schedule for a given
scenario

3
37
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 1
Unit 1a: Unit 1a: No.of COs:02
 CO: Ability to list various characteristics of database approach
 CO: Ability to explain various advantage of database
Unit 1b: Unit 1b: No.of COs:03
 CO: Ability to define schemas, data model instances, data independence.
 CO: Ability to explain three schema architecture.
 CO: Ability to analyse various data models for given scenario (PO2)
Unit 1c: Unit 1c: No.of COs:06
 CO: Ability to list various operations in SQL.
 CO: Ability to explain various operations in SQL
 CO: Ability to apply SQL to solve problem for given scenario(PO1).
 CO: Ability to design database for a given scenario(PO3)
 CO: Ability to analyse queries operations for a given(PO2)
 CO: Ability to conduct experiments of database using modern tools:
38
Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL(PO5) 3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 2
Unit 2a: Unit 2a: No.of COs:03
 CO: Ability to list various constraints.
 CO: Ability to explain relational database schemas
 CO: Ability to investigate various model for given scenario (PO4)
Unit 2b:
Unit 2b: No.of COs:04
 CO: Ability to list Binary Relational Operations
 CO: Ability to describe unary Relational Operation
 CO: Ability to apply relational algebra to solve problem for given scenario
(PO1)
 CO: Ability to investigate operations for a given scenario (PO4)
Unit 2c: Unit 2c: No.of COs:04
 CO: Ability to list entity types
 CO: Ability to explain entity sets, attributes and keys,
 CO: Ability to analyse weak entity and strong entity for a given scenario(PO2).
 CO: Ability to design ER diagram for a given scenario(PO3) 39
3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 3

Unit 3: Unit 3: No.of COs:04


 CO: Ability to list various functional dependencies.
 CO: Ability to explain 3 Normal Form.
 CO: Ability to analyse various techniques for given scenario(PO2).
 CO: Ability to Investigate various normalization techniques for given
scenario (PO4).

4
30
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 4

Unit 4: Unit 4: No.of COs:03

 CO: Ability to list desirable properties of transactions


 CO: Ability to describe recovery concepts
 CO: Ability to analyse serial schedule and a serializable schedule (PO2)

4
31
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 1
Unit 1a: Unit 1a: No.of COs:02
 CO: Ability to list various characteristics of database approach
 CO: Ability to explain various advantage of database
Unit 1b: Unit 1b: No.of COs:03
 CO: Ability to define schemas, data model instances, data independence.
 CO: Ability to explain three schema architecture.
 CO: Ability to analyse various data models for given scenario (PO2)
Unit 1c: Total No.of COs:11 in Unit 1:
 CO: Ability to list various operations in SQL.
 CO: Ability to explain various operations in SQL Unit 1c: No.of COs:06
 CO: Ability to apply SQL to solve problem for given scenario(PO1).
 CO: Ability to design database for a given scenario(PO3)
 CO: Ability to analyse queries operations for a given(PO2)
 CO: Ability to conduct experiments of database using modern tools:
Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL(PO5) 42
3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Merging all Course Outcomes(COs) in Unit I
Unit 1: Unit 1: No.of COs:11
 CO: Ability to list various characteristics of database approach
 CO: Ability to explain various advantage of database
 CO:Ability to define schemas, data model instances, data independence.
 CO: Ability to explain three schema architecture.
 CO: Ability to analyse various data models for given scenario (PO2)
 CO: Ability to list various operations in SQL.
 CO: Ability to explain various operations in SQL
 CO: Ability to apply SQL to solve problem for given scenario(PO1).
 CO: Ability to analyse queries operations for a given(PO2)
 CO: Ability to design database for a given scenario(PO3)
 CO: Ability to conduct experiments of database using modern tools:
Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL(PO5)
43
3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) in Unit 2
Unit 2a: Unit 2a: No.of COs:03
 CO: Ability to list various constraints.
 CO: Ability to explain relational database schemas
 CO: Ability to investigate various model for given scenario (PO4)
Unit 2b: Total No.of COs:11 in Unit 2:
 CO: Ability to list Binary Relational Operations
Unit 2b: No.of COs:04
 CO: Ability to describe unary Relational Operation
 CO: Ability to apply relational algebra to solve problem for given scenario
(PO1)
 CO: Ability to investigate operations for a given scenario (PO4)
Unit 2c: Unit 2c: No.of COs:04
 CO: Ability to list entity types
 CO: Ability to explain entity sets, attributes and keys,
 CO: Ability to analyse weak entity and strong entity for a given scenario(PO2).
 CO: Ability to design ER diagram for a given scenario(PO3) 434
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Merging All Course Outcomes(COs) in Unit 2
Unit 2: Unit 2: Total No.of COs:11
 CO: Ability to list various constraints.
 CO: Ability to explain relational database schemas
 CO: Ability to investigate various model for given scenario (PO4)
 CO: Ability to list Binary Relational Operations
 CO: Ability to describe unary Relational Operation
 CO: Ability to apply relational algebra to solve problem for given
scenario (PO1)
 CO: Ability to investigate operations for a given scenario (PO4)
 CO: Ability to list entity types
 CO: Ability to explain entity sets, attributes and keys,
 CO: Ability to analyse weak entity and strong entity for a given
scenario(PO2).
 CO: Ability to design ER diagram for a given scenario(PO3) 45
3
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(CO) of Unit 3

Unit 3: Unit 3: No.of COs:4

 CO: Ability to list various functional dependencies.


 CO: Ability to explain 3 Normal Form.
 CO: Ability to analyse various techniques for given scenario(PO2).
 CO: Ability to Investigate various normalization techniques for given
scenario (PO4).

4
36
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 List out all course outcomes(COs) of Unit 4

Unit 4: Unit 2: No.of COs:3

 CO: Ability to list desirable properties of transactions


 CO: Ability to describe recovery concepts
 CO: Ability to analyse serial schedule and a serializable schedule (PO2)

4
37
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out all COs from all Units, which are not mapped to any PO
 CO: Ability to list various characteristics of database approach
 CO: Ability to explain various advantage of database Unit 1:
 CO: Ability to define schemas, data model instances, data independence.
COs:6
 CO: Ability to explain three schema architecture.
 CO: Ability to list various operations in SQL.
 CO: Ability to explain various operations in SQL
 CO: Ability to list various constraints. Total No.of COs:16
 CO: Ability to explain relational database schemas Unit 2:
 CO: Ability to list Binary Relational Operations Understand skill
COs:5
 CO: Ability to describe unary Relational Operation
Remember skill
 CO: Ability to list entity types
 CO: Ability to explain entity sets, attributes and keys,
 CO: Ability to list various functional dependencies. Unit 3:
 CO: Ability to explain 3 Normal Form. COs:3
 CO: Ability to list desirable properties of transactions
 CO: Ability to describe recovery concepts
Unit 4:
4
38
COs:2
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Then write general course outcome(CO1) for previous said
course outcomes(16 COs)
 CO1: Ability to define, understand and explain concepts of
database management system.

 Note: 1, CO1 may come from Unit 1 or Unit 2 or Unit 3 or


Unit 4, …etc.

CO1 is written based on Remerging/Understand skill

4
39
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out all COs from all Units, which are mapped to PO1
 COX: Ability to apply SQL to solve problem for given
scenario(PO1).
 COY: Ability to apply relational algebra to solve problem
for given scenario (PO1)
 Then write general course outcome(CO2) for above said 2
course outcomes(2 COs)
 CO2: Ability to apply SQL as well as relational algebra to
find solutions to a broad range of queries
 Note:, CO2 may come Unit 1 or Unit 2 or Unit 3 or Unit 4,
…etc. COX, COY are from Unit 2.

CO2 is written based on Apply level


5
30
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out all COs from all Units, which are mapped to PO2
 COX: Ability to analyse various data models for given
scenario (PO2)
 COY: Ability to analyse queries operations for a given(PO2)
 COZ: Ability to analyse weak entity and strong entity for a
given scenario(PO2).
 COW: Ability to analyse serial schedule and a serializable
schedule (PO2)
 Then write general course outcome(CO3) for above said 4
course outcomes(4 COs)
 CO3: Ability to analyse various database design techniques
for a given scenario. CO3 is written based on Analyse level
 Note:, CO3 may come unit 1/unit 2/ unit 3 or unit 4, …etc.
COX, COY, COZ, COW are from Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4. 5
31
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out all COs from all Units, which are mapped to PO3
 COX: Ability to design database for a given scenario(PO3)
 COY: Ability to design ER diagram for a given scenario(PO3)
 Then write general course outcome(CO4) for above said
course outcomes(2 COs)
 CO4: Design ER diagram or database for given scenario.
 Note: CO4 may come unit 1 or unit 2 or unit 3 or unit 4,
…etc.

COX, COY are from Unit 1, Unit 2.

CO4 is written based on Design level

5
32
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take out all COs from all Units, which are mapped to PO4
 COX: Ability to investigate various model for a given
scenario (PO4)
 COY: Ability to investigate operations for a given scenario
(PO4)
 COZ: Ability to Investigate various normalization techniques
for a given scenario (PO4).
 Then write general course outcome(CO5) for above said
course outcomes(3 COs)
 CO5: Ability to investigate various models for given scenario.
 Note: CO5 may come unit 1 or unit 2 or unit 3 or unit 4,
…etc.
COX, COY, COZ are from Unit 2, Unit 3.

CO5 is written based on Investigate level 5


33
How to Write Course Outcomes(cont...)
 Take all COs in all Units, which are mapped to PO5
 COX: Ability to conduct experiments of database using
modern tools: Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL(PO5)
 Then write general course outcome(CO6) for above said
course outcome(1 CO)
 CO6: Ability to conduct experiments of database using
modern tools: Oracle, Mongo DB, MySQL.
 Note: CO6 may come unit 1 or unit 2 or unit 3 or unit 4,
…etc. COX is from Unit 1.

CO6 has written based on usage of modern tool

5
34
How to Write Course Outcomes (cont..)
 All 6 COs are derived from skill sets.

655
How to Write Course Outcomes (cont..)
 DBMS course has 6 COs with POs

656
How to Write Course Outcomes (cont..)
 CO assessment tools used in DBMS course

657
How to Mapping CO-PO
 Mapping mechanism
 Level should be 1/2/3.

5
38
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Mapping level should be 1/2/3.
 How to assign weight for PO(GA).
 Ex: Total marks: 50 & marks focussed on particular PO(GA)

 Note: College/Dept should have a police on marks


distribution for POs
5
39
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Mapping mechanism
 Level should be 1/2/3.
 How to assign weight for PO(GA).
 Ex:Total marks: 50 & marks focussed on particular PO(GA

6
30
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Mapping mechanism

613
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment Tools (80%) for DBMS Subject
1. Exam +
2. Laboratory +
CIE+SEE
3. Assignment +
4. Project work
 Indirect Assessment Tool (20%) for DBMS Subject
1. Course end survey.
 Total marks is 50 for CIE
1. Theory exam is 25 marks
2. Laboratory exam is 10 marks
3. Project work is 10 marks
4. Assignment is 5 marks
 Total marks is 100 for SEE
6
32
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Theory
 Toal marks: 25.
 No.of COs focused is 3 (CO1,CO2, CO3)
 No.of POs mapped : 2 (PO1, PO2)
 No.of PSOs mapped : 2 (PSO1, PSO2)
 PO1Apply level
 PO2Analyze level

 Note: CO1 not mapped with any POs. Since those questions
6
33
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 CIE Question Paper(CIE-I) for DBMS

6
34
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 CIE Question Paper(CIE-II) for DBMS

6
35
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Laboratory
 No.of COs focused : 1 (CO6)
 No.of POs mapped : 2 (PO5, PO10)
 No.of PSOs mapped : 1 (PSO2)
 PO5Usage of modern tools
 PO10Documentation

 Note: CO6 is more focussed on usage of modern tool by


considering conduction of programs 6
36
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Assignment
 No.of COs focused : 1 (CO5).
 No.of POs mapped : 1 (PO4).
 No.of PSOs mapped : 2 (PSO1, PSO2)
 PO5Investigation

Note: CO5 is more focussed on investigation by considering


research paper

6
37
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Assignment

6
38
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Project
 No.of COs focused : 1 (CO4).
 No.of POs mapped : 2 (PO5, PO10).
 No.of PSOs mapped : 2 (PSO1, PSO2)
 PO5Design
 PO10Documentation

Note: CO4 is more focussed on design skill

6
39
How to Mapping CO-PO(Cont…)
 Project
 No.of COs focused : 1 (CO4).
 No.of POs mapped : 2 (PO5, PO10).
 No.of PSOs mapped : 2 (PSO1, PSO2)
 PO5Design
 PO10Documentation

Note: CO5 is more focussed on design skill

7
30
Direct Assessment Tools
 DBMS course has CIE and SEE marks.
 Marks distributions for CIE and SEE exams

7
31
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 List of assessment tools used for CIE

7
32
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 CIE marks for DBMS course
 No.of students is 60.

7
33
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 SEE marks for DBMS course
 No.of students is 60.

7
34
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment

7
35
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for test 1(CIE-I) & test 2 (CIE-II)
 Questions are mapping to COs.

7
36
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for lab
 Lab components are mapping to COs.

7
37
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for Assignment
 Questions are mapping to COs.

7
38
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for mini-project
 Questions are mapping to COs.

7
39
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for SEE
 We don’t know student which questions he/she answered.
 Att=Total marks secured by all students/number of students
 Ex: 5239/60=97.3;CO(1,2,3,4,5,6) attainment is 97.3% (in %)
 Ex: CO(1,2,3,4,5,6) attainment is 3 (in the scale of 3)

8
30
Direct Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 Direct Assessment for CIE & SEE

 CO2=Test1(Q1b+Q2b)+Test 2(Q1b+Q2b)+SEE/5
 CO2=Test1(3+3)+Test2(3+3)+SEE(3))/5=15/5=3 or 100%
8
31
Indirect Assessment Tools
 Course end survey collected through google forms
 Questions are written based on course outcomes(COs)
 DBMS course has 6COs

682
Indirect Assessment Tools(Cont…)
 List of questions in course end survey

8
33
Indirect Assessment Tools(Cont…)

8
34
Indirect Assessment Tools(Cont…)

8
35
CO Attainment
 Direct Assessment for CIE &SEE

 CO1 attainment is 2.6 (in the scale of 3).


 CO1 attainment is 100 (in the scale of percentage).
8
36
CO Attainment(Cont…)
 Indirect Assessment for course end survey
 In DBMS course, no.of students are 60, but 55 students
submitted course-end-survey forms.

 CO1=((42*3) +(10*2)+(3*1)) /55 =2.71 or 2.71/3=90.3%


 CO1 attainment is 2.71 (in the scale of 3).
 CO1 attainment is 90.3 (in the scale of percentage). 8
37
CO Attainment(Cont…)
 Final attainment of CO
 80% weightage is given for direct assessment tools
 20% weightage is given for indirect assessment tools

 CO1 attainment is 2.6X0.8+2.71X0.2=2.622(in scale of 3)


 CO1 attainment is 2.622/3=87.4 (in percentage). 8
38
CO Attainment(Cont…)
 Final attainment of CO
 CO attainment level for past year(CAYm1)-To know value
 CO attainment level for present year(CAY)

8
39
CO Attainment(Cont…)
 Final attainment of PO with respect to DBMS subject
 We used average weightage to measure POs/PSOs

 Ex: PO1 attainment is CO2= 2.974 or 99.13%


 Ex: PSO1 attainment is (CO3+CO4+CO5+CO6)/4
 =(((CO3X3)/2.5)+((CO4X2)/2.5)+((CO5X3)/2.5)+((CO6X
2))/2.5)/4=2.913 or 97.12

9
30
References
1. NBA website: http://www.nbaind.org
2. Wikipedia website: https:// wikipedia.org
3. AICTE website: https:// aicte-india.org
4. BMSCE: website: https:// www.bmsce.in

91
92p

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi