Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The expression ‘industrial relations’ by itself means relationship that emerges out of day-to-day
working of labour and management. It includes the relation between an employee and
employer in the course of running an industry. It involves the impact or influences of various
forces. It’s a complex task to study the impact various forces, so researchers have taken three
significant factors, viz. trade union, labour lagislation, and industrial democracy and
considered the issues that emerge out of these which pose a problem to industrial relations.
These themes revolve around the three actors of IR system, viz. employees, employers, and the
government.
Industrial relations,at its core, is a discipline, that concerns itself with the study of the
relationship between employers and employees at an organization, industry or a nation level.
BACKGROUND:
IR plays a crucial role in establishing and maintaining industrial democracy. In India a numbers
of factors ----- social economic and political--- have influenced industrial relations in India.
The history of employer-employee relations can be traced back to the early eighteenth
century. The workers of the textile industry took the support of leaders of the independence
movement to revolt against the oppressive practices of British, whose sole aim was to totally
destroy the textile industry in the country and reduce it to a mere supplier of raw material to
the textile industry in Britain.
In the pre independence days, workers were hired and fired, as the principal of demand and
supply governed industrial relations. The employer was in a commanding position and the
condition of employment wages were very poor
Till the end of the first world war, the trade union movement had not emerged.
There were hardly any laws to protect the interest of the workers except the Employers and
Workmen(Dispute) Act, 1980, which was used to settle wage dispute.
After the First World War, the industrial relation concept assumed a new dimension in the sense that
workers now resorted to violence . There were numerous strikes and disturbances during 1928-29.
As a result government enacted the Trade Disputes Act, 1929, to enhance the early settlement of
industrial disputes.
After India attained independence, one of the significant steps taken in the field of industrial relations was
the enactment of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
In December 1947, an industrial conference was held in India, where an appeal was made to labour and
management to maintain industrial harmony.
Another development in the immediate post-Independent period was the setting up of the Indian Labour
Conference(ILC), a tripartite body to look into IR problem in India. It was constituted with the objective of
establishing co-operation between the government, the employers and the trade unions. It met(first
meeting in Aug 1942) once in a year to discuss problems relating to labour-management relations.
An important characteristic feature of IR in the post-independence period was the change in the
Government’s attitude towards labour and their problems. Many labour laws were enacted to protect the
interest of industrial workers during 1947 to 1956.
[ The value of production loss due to strikes and lockouts in 1980 was Rs 12.53 cr, in 1979 was Rs 125.63cr
and in 1978 it was 108.16 cr.
Industrial Relations (IR) is defined as the relationship between the employer and employees. The employer
represented by the management or association of employers and the employees are represented by
trade unions.
1. Employees and Trade Unions: Unions play a crucial role in organizing the employees and mobilising them
through a set of demands and also engaging with employers through collective bargaining. Employees join
trade unions to improve the working environment as well as for better terms and conditions in
employment. The employees also expresses their grievances in respect of working and employment
conditions through unions. Any seven or more employees are permitted to form a trade union in India, as
per the Trade Union Act,1926. In order to limit the number of trade unions in India, the government
amended the act in 2001. Accordingly, trade unions are registered only if 10% or 100 workers(whichever is
less) are members of a trade union, subject to a minimum of 7 workmen in an establishment or industry.
Some Problems of Trade Unionism in India:
One of the major problem is the fragmentation of unions Several unions, associated with different political
parties and groups, have entered the national scene.
The non-existence of legal provisions for the recognition of unions( except BIR Act and the Maharastra
Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices) makes for fragmentation of unions
and consequent inter-union rivalry.
The multi-unionism to industrial harmony in India has posed a serious threat. In its effort to meet this
problem, the government has evolved the Code of Discipline which provides that a union can claim
recognition of its members comprise 25 per cent of the total workers in that industry. But the
controversy here relates as to how the membership of rival unions should be verified, whether it should
be using the method of membership verification or secret ballot.
The only state which has made some headway in this direction is Maharastra. In 1971 it passed the
Maharastra Act for Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices and Compulsory Recognition of Trade Unions,
1971. The Bombay Industrial Relations Act, which has restricted applications, also empowers the
appropriate authority to recognize a representation union in a plant/industry. The Industrial Relations Bill
of 1978 also sought to provide for a sole bargaining agent in a plant.
Employers desire harmonious industrial relations so that the productivity and profit of their organization is
not affected.
Employers desire the right to hire and fire employees, relocate the firm/factory in case of problem, and
also introduce modern technology to reduce their dependence on employees.
Employer preferred unions so that they can hear ‘one voice’ rather than listening to ‘multiple voices’ in the
system. But after technological advancement and emergence of Human Resource Management, they
directly deal with employees and try to avoid unions as far as possible.
The employers are concerned about attracting and retaining talent in the organization to improve the
productivity and profit of the firm.
They also use FDI as a mechanism to influence governmental policies regarding labour.
Use temporary workers, contract workers and out source their work.
GOVERNMENT:
Government plays a mediating role whenever the employer and employee are not able to arrive at a
consensus regarding any employment related issue. The role of government also changes based on the
policies of the political party
The government also plays a direct role in the industrial relations through legislation, rules and
agreements.
In India, labour is in the concurrent list; hence central as well as state governments can enact legislations.
The government also changes its position based on environmental and economic factors.
Prior to liberalisation, government as well as most of the political parties took pro-employees stand on
most of the critical issues. During stedrikes, the pro-employee stance can be clearly discern. After
liberalisation, the stance has changed from pro employee to a pro-employer one. The central government
and most of the state governments are competing to attract FDI. There is an impression that pro-employee
stance and rigid labour laws deter FDI flow to India.
Key Concepts in Industrial Relations(Dominant Aspects):
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING: Collective bargaining comprises negotiations pertaining to working and service
conditions. Collective bargaining may result in collective agreement.
ILO defines collective agreement as “ all agreements in writing regarding working conditions and terms of
employment concluded between an employer, a group of employers or one or more employers’
organizations, on the one hand, and one or more representative workers’ organizations, or, in the absence
of such organizations, the representatives of the workers duly elected and authorised by them in
accordance with national laws and regulations.
The collective agreements are binding in nature. The principle of free and voluntary negotiation and the
principle of good faith help both the parties to arrive at collective agreement.
STRIKE: A strike is a collective suspension of work, agreed upon by a number of workers with the purpose of
reaching a certain end. Strike is the most powerful weapon for trade unions to force the management to
agree to their demands.
LOCK-OUT: As per Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, lock-out has been defined as, “the temporary closing of a place
of employment, or the suspension of work, or the refusal by an employer to continue to employ any
number of persons employed by him”. Lock-out is the powerful weapon for the employer to force the
employees to return to work, in case of employees resorting to strike. Emoloyers resort to lock-out to put
pressure on the trade unions and employees to scale down their demands.
UNION DENSITY: Union Density is defined as, “a measure of the membership of trade unions, calculated as the
number of currently enrolled members as proportion of all those employees potentially eligible to be
members.
RECOGNITION OF TRADE UNION: Recognition of trade union is done by the employer whereas registration of
trade union is done by Registrar of trade union. Since the word recognition of was not provided in the Trade
Union Act, 1926, employer have good reason for not recognizing trade unions in their organizations. An
organization can have many registered trade unions, but the recognition of the union is decided by the
employer. For healthy industrial relations, the employer may recognize trade unions and negotiate with them.
TRADE UNIONS
Trade unions are an important institution in the realm of industrial relations. A trade union is an
organization of workers or employees that is formed mainly to negotiate with the employers on various
employment related issues.
Trade unions are a major component of the modern industrial relations system. A trade union of workers is
an organization formed by workers to protect their interests, improve their working conditions, etc. All
trade unions have their objectives or goals to achieve, which are contained in their constitution and each
has its own strategy to reach those goals.
Trade unions came into being for a variety of purposes. Individual workers found it more advantageous to
band together and seek to establish their terms and conditions of employment. They realize that if they
bargained as individuals, the employer would have a better leverage.
Additionally, the influence of political parties interested in acquiring a foothold in the labour movement
also provided the impetus for the formation of labour unions.
Blue-Collar and White-Collar Workers: All shop floor workers ( part of the production system who operate
machines and related systems ) are termed blue-collar workers and all clerical or office staff, who do not
work on the shop floor are termed white-collar workers.
At present, Ministry of Labour has recognized twelve central trade unions
i. All India Trade Union Congress
ii. Indian National Trade Union Congress
iii. Hind Mazdoor Sabha
iv. Centre of Indian Trade Unions
v. All India Central Council of Trade Unions
vi. All India United Trade Union Centre
vii. Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangha
viii. New Trade Union Initiative
ix. Self Employed Women’s Association in India
x. Labour Progressive Federation
xi. United Trade Union Congress
xii. Trade Union Co-ordination Committee
The Concept of Trade Unionism
The initial days of industrialization resulted in a kind of work organization where the employer, in their effort
to extract maximum from the resource at hand, including labour, developed an exploitative regime as far
as labour was concerned. An individual worker was powerless in the face of the employer and could do
little for amelioration of his/her condition of work. A collective might not be as powerless. Besides an
individual worker may be dispensable for an employer, a collective may not be. The genesis of modern
trade unionism lies here.
At the fundamental level, unionism binds the workers together into a common action with “strike” as their
ultimate weapon. This collectivism was aimed at resorting some kind of a balance in the employer-
employee relationship.
Trade unionism refers to that movement from the labour that has progressively sought to protect job and
real earning, secure better conditions of work life, and fight against exploitation and arbitrariness to
ensure fairness and equity in employment
In a nutshell, the concept of trade unionism emerges from the need for a constant organization or a permanent
association that is engaged in securing economic benefits for employees while protecting their interests
Impact of Trade Unions: Trade unionism owes its influence to Industrialization and capitalism. Trade
unionism from its inception has been assertive in fighting for the rights of workers and securing higher
wages and benefits. Trade unionism has also made a great impact on the social, political, and economic
life. Trade unions have also, sometimes, led the movement for the ameliorating the conditions of the
weaker sections of the society. They have worked towards improving especially the working conditions
for of the women and children, and abolishing child labour. In addition, they have constantly
spearheaded the movements for general economic betterment of the working class, humane working
hours, safety and other welfare measures pertaining to labour and dependence.
Principles of Trade Unionism:
There are few fundamental principles on which trade unionism hinges, The prominent
ones being:
1. Unity: Unity is strength
2. Equality: Workers must not be discriminated against on the basis of caste, creed or
sex. In regard to pay, each worker must get equal pay for equal work.
Lay-Off: Lay-offs have been defined under Clause 2(KKK) of the ID Act. It means the
failure, refusal or the inability of an employer to give employment to a workman
whose name is present on the master rolls of the industrial establishment and who
has not been retrenched. The “failure, refusal or inability” can be for arbitrary
reasons but must be specifically attributed to any of the following:
Shortage of coal/power/raw materials
Accumulation of stocks
Breakdown of machinery
Natural calamity
Any other “connected” reason
Therefore a workman who has not been retrenched can be laid-off, provided the
above described conditions are met.
Retrenchment: Retrenchment has been defined in Section 2(00) of the Act.
Retrenchment means termination of service by an employer, of a workman, for
any reason whatsoever other than:
As punishment inflicted by way of disciplinary action;
Retirement on reaching the age of superannuation if such a stipulation exist in the
contract of employment;
Voluntary retirement
Non-renewal of contract; and
Continued ill health.
In effect, this means that termination for any reason except the above shall construe
to mean “retrenchment”, in which case, it is necessary for the employer to follow
the procedure for retrenchment, as laid down in the Act. If proper procedure is not
followed, the termination will be deemed illegal.
Closure: Closure means the permanent closing down of a business. It has been
defined in Clause 2(CC) of the Act.
CHAPTER VB. Till 1976, the provisions for lay-off, retrenchment and closure were identical for all
industrial establishment. However through an amendment in 1976, Chapter VB was added.
Its provisions were different from the earlier provisions and covered industrial establishment
that were not of a seasonal nature and employed, on average, during the last 12-month
period, 300 or more workmen. This was further amended in 1982 to make these provisions
applicable to establishments with 100 or more workers.
[1. No woekman whose name is borne on the muster rolls of an individual establishment shall be
laid off by his employer except with the permission of the appropriate government unless
such lay-off is due to shortage of power or to natural calamity and in the case mine, such lay-
off is due also to fire, flood, excess of inflammable gas or explosion.]
EXPLANATION: For the purpose of this section, a workmen shall not be deemed to be laid-off by
an employer if such employer offers any alternative employment ( which in the opinion of
the employer does not call for any specific skill or previous experience and can be done by
the workman) in the same establishment from which he has been laid-off or in any other
establishment belonging to the same employer, situated in the same town or village, or
situated within such distance from the establishment to which he belongs that the transfer
will not undue hardship to the workman having regard to the facts and circumstances of his
case, provided that the wage that would normally have been paid to the workman are
offered for the alternative appointment also
Conditions Precedent to Retrenchment of Workmen:
No workman employed in any industry who has been in continuous service for not less than one
year under an employer shall be retrenched by the employer until:
a) The workman has been given one month’s notice in writing indicating the reasons for
retrenchment and the period of notice has expired, or the workman has been paid in lieu of
such notice wages for the period of the notice.
b) The workman has been paid, at the time of retrenchment, compensation that shall be
equivalent to 15 days average pay ( for every completed year of continuous service) or any
part thereof in excess of 6 months.
c) Notice in the prescribed manner is served on the appropriate government( for such authority
as may be specified by the appropriate government by notification in the official gazette).
Closure of Undertaking:
Closure is when the business of an industrial establishment closes down. The Chapter VB
provisions for closure are as below.
EXPLANATION: An undertaking that is closed down for reasons of (i) financial difficulties
(including financial loses); (ii) accumulation of indisposed stocks; (iii) the expiry of the period
of the lease or license granted to it , or (iv) In case where the undertaking is engaged in
mining operations, exhaustions of the minerals in the area in which operations are carried on
, shall not be deemed to be closed down on account of unavoidable circumstances beyond
the control of the employer within the meaning of the provision to the subsection.
Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (1), where an undertaking engaged in
mining operations is closed down by reason merely of exhaustion of the minerals in the area
in which such operations are carried on, no workman referred to in the Subsection shall be
entitled to any notice or compensation in accordance with the provision of …………
Unionisation: Law and Environment
Two factors are relevant to the process of unionisation in India they relate to
Trade union law
Political parties and their labour strategy
The Trade Union Act, 1926, states as follows: any seven or more members of a trade
union may, by subscribing their names to the rules of the trade union and by
otherwise complying with the provision of the Act with respect of registration,
applying for the registration of the trade union under this Act.
The organization pattern of a trade union federation is usually three-tierd. Units exist
at the plant or shop, state and the national level.
NATIONAL LEVEL FEDERATION
Historically, four major federations have been in existence and have established a
national network of federated union.
All India Trade Union Congress (AITUC)
Indian National Trade Union Congress (INTUC)
United Trade Union Congress(UTUC)
Hind Mazdoor Sabha (HMS)
GROWTH OF TRADE UNIONS: With the change of political atmosphere in the country and the
spreading of ideas about democracy, socialism, the right to a living wage, leveling of
inequalities, building of a welfare state and similar thoughts, there is no doubt that a steadily
increasing number of workers, particularly in the large metropolitan centres, have begun to
realise that a trade union organizaion is very essential for the protection and advancement
of the working classes and their interests.
This problem arises because at the moment there is no uniform legislation available in all the
states and union territories with regard to the recognition issue. It is only in states where the
Bombay Industrial Relations Act in force, e.g., Gujarat and Maharastra, that there are
elaborate provisions regarding recognition.
The Trade Unions Act, 1926:
The Trade Union Act, 1926, deals with the registration of trade unions both employers and
workers, cancellation of trade union registration, rights and liabilities of registered trade
unions, constitution of a separate fund for political purposes. It also deals with penalties and
procedure in case of failure to submit returns and supply of false information regarding trade
union.
SCOPE and COVERAGE: The Act extends to the whole of India and applies to all kinds of unions of
workers and association of employers, which aim at regularizing labour-management
relations. A trade union is a combination, whether temporary or permanent, formed for
regulating the relations not only between workmen and employers, but also between
workmen and workmen or between employers and employers.
The Trade Unions Act, 1926 was enacted mainly in deference to the ILO
convention, the recognition of the rights of workers, to organize and also to
strengthen the bargaining power of the workers.
The Act aim to provide for the registration of trade unions and, in certain respects,
to define the law relating to registered trade unions. The objective of the Act is to:
Lay down conditions governing the registration of TUs.
Define obligations of a registered TU.
Prescribe rights and liabilities of a registered TU.
Some provisions of the Trade union Act, 1926 were amended in 2001. Some of the salient
features of the Trade Union (Amendment) Act, 2001 are:
1. No trade union of workmen shall be registered unless at least 10% or 100, whichever is less,
engaged or employed in the establishment or industry with which it is connected, are the
members of such a trade union on the date of making of application for registration.
2. A registered trade union of workmen shall at all times continue to have not less than 10% or
100 of the workmen , whichever is less, subject to a minimum of 7 persons employed in the
establishment or industry with which it is connected, as its members.
3. A provision for filling an appeal before the Industrial Tribunal/Labour Court in case of non
registration/restoration of registration have been provided.
4.
5.
6.
OBJECTIVES:
The beginning of modern legislation lies in factory legislation. The rapid industrialization and
urbanization without any planning resulted in unsanitary, unhygienic, unsafe, and crowded
work and living places. Both quality of work life and quality of life itself were affected by the
capitalist quest for making quick bucks, unmindful of its social consequences. The objectives
of this Act was to protect human beings from being subjected to unduly long hours of
physical strain or manual labour. The main objectives of this Act are:
To protect health, safety, and welfare of the workmen
Regulate hours of work, weekly offs and annual leave
Regulate the employment of women and young persons.
COVERAGE:
This Act is a Central Legislation and extends to the whole of India, including Jammu and Kashmir
The provisions of this Act are applicable to all Factories, including the factories that belong to the
central government or any state government.
The provision of this Act cover persons who are included within the meaning of the ‘term’ worker
as contained in the Act.
WHO IS A WORKER?
The Factories Act, 1948 has defined a worker in section 2(1). A worker means
A person employed
Directly or by or through any agency
With or without the knowledge of the principal employer
He may be employed with or without remuneration
Chapter 2 Chapter 4A
Inspecting Staff Hazardous Process
Chapter 10 Chapter 6
Penalties and Procedure Working Hours
Chapter 11
Chapter 7
Supplimental
Employment of
Young Persons
Chapter 8
Annual Leave with
Wages
MAIN PROVISIONS:
The Factories Act primarily aims at preserving the health, safety and welfare of workers working in a factory.
The Act also provides for regulating the working hours, weekly offs, leave with wages and employment of
young persons and women. For the workers, being the weaker section of the society, the State has made
elaborate provisions and institutional framework to ensure that exploitation of labour by employer does
not take place. The significant provisions of the Act are
HEALTH AND HYGIENE: Section 11 to 20 of the Factories Act, 1948 detail out the health provision that need to
be followed in “factories”. In particular, provisions for health and hygiene comprise the following
SECTION 24: Striking Gear and Devices for Cutting off Power
Section 41 A to 41 H have been added to Chapter 4A dealing with provisions for hazardous
processes.
WELFARE PROVISIONS: The welfare measures are contained in Chapter V of the Act. Welfare
facilities within the factory premises are supposed to provide mental peace to the workers so
that they can devote their attention and energy to work at hand and not on looking for such
facilities.
SECTION 42: Washing Facilities
SECTION 43: Facilities for Storing and Drying Clothing
SECTION 44: Facilities for Sitting
SECTION 45: First Aid Appliances
SECTION 46: Canteens
SECTION 47: Shelters, Rest Rooms, and Lunch Rooms
SECTION 48: Creches
SECTION 49: Welfare Officers
SECTION 50: This section empowers the state government to make rules regarding exemption of
factories from few of the provisions subject to compliance with alternative provisions.