Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
PrEP for
Men who have Sex with Men
Linda-Gail Bekker
Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation
IAS Vienna 2010
Today….
• Why Prevention?
• Why PrEP?
• Why MSM?
• Why MSM in Africa?
• Where to from here?
• What else?
The War on HIV….
Male
HIV circumcision
PREVENTION
Condoms
Behavioural
Chemoprophylaxis
Counselling and
Testing MTCTp
Vaccines HSV-2 PEP
Test +Treat Suppressive
PrEP
therapy
Reported Prevention Trials
Efficacy of intervention (Padian,et al:AIDS 2010)
Behavioral
Counseling and Chemoprophylaxis
Testing
MTCTp
Intensive not PEP
better than
PrEP
standard
have unknown
efficacy
Partial efficacy
Circumcision (Orange F)
Prep
0% 100%
Low Utilization of Prevention
Methods
Methods Utilization
• AIDS Education
– Primary Schools 50%
– Secondary Schools 48%
• Maternal to Child Prevention 2-40%
• Sex Workers Outreach 16%
• IDU Harm Reduction 4.3%
• MSM Outreach 11%
• Antiretroviral Drugs
– Inhibit HIV directly
– Prevent mother to child transmission
– Are already formulated and mass produced
• Chemoprophylaxis is a proven concept
– EG: Malaria, TB pneumonia, meningitis
– Perioperative prophylaxis
– A mainstay of prevention if no vaccine
Some Chemoprophylactic Agents
Therapy Year Indication Status
DITRAME +1
PETRA
ZDV + NVP
AZT/3TC
1999 2003:
HIVNET 012 DITRAME +1.1
sdNVP ZDV/3TC+ NVP
PACTG 076
USPHS AZT
Recommendations
80%
decline
PrEP: Back to the Basics
75
FTC/TDF (oral, n = 6)
p = 0.0075, [HR = 7.8]
50
FTC (subcut, n = 6)
p = 0.021, [HR = 3.9]
25 TDF (oral, n = 4)*
p = 0.3
Control (n = 18)
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Number of rectal exposures
• Protective in Animals
• Licensed for Human Use
• Excellent Safety Record
• Long Half Life (>48 hours)
• Enriched in Genital Fluids
• No interactions with
tuberculosis treatment or
hormonal contraception
HIV Reverse Transcriptase
Single stranded RNA
Polymerase
Ribonuclease H
Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitor
DNA
RNA
Chain termination
FTC and TDF have Long Intracellular Half Life
Approved Approved Approved Approved Approved Approved Approved
as BID as QD or BID as QD or BID as QD or BID as QD or BID as QD as QD
50 **
>60
45
40
35
T1/2 (hours)
30
25 24 hours
20 ‡ *
15
12 hours
10
* §
5
0
ZDV d4T ABC 3TC ddI TDF FTC
Serum/Plasma half-life Intracellular half-life
†
Data from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. MMWR Recomm Rep. 2002;51(RR-7):1-64 unless otherwise noted
*Anderson et al. AIDS 2003; 17(15):2159-2168. ‡Piliero et al. 43rd ICAAC, Chicago, 2003.
** Hawkins et al. 5th IWCPHT, Rome, 2004 § Wang et al. IAC, 2002, poster #4546.
Drug Exposure in the Male Genital Tract
Percent of Blood Plasma Levels
Kashuba et al. CROI 13 Abstract 569 (Vourvahis), 13th CROI
Abstracts 396 (Stekler), Abstract 618 (Katzenstein)
APV (20%) NVP (70%) ABC (150%) ZDV (200%) TDF (500%) 3TC (600%)
d4T (2%)
EFV (3%)
SQV (3%)
RTV (3%)
LPV (5%)
NFV (5%)
NRTI PI NNRTI FI
Preclinical Evaluation of Tenofovir
(TDF) + Emtricitabine (FTC)
• Either FTC or TDF were protective
– 70% to 100% Effective
• Emtricitabine + Tenofovir
– The combination was 100% effective
• After repeated rectal exposures (14)
• Given once prior to exposure, and once after
• Protection probably reflects
– High concentrations in genital tissues and fluids
– Long intracellular half life
– Activity in Macrophages
Tsai ‘95; Van Rompay ‘99 ‘00 ‘01 ‘04; Subbarao ’05; Heneine’06 ‘07 ‘08
Mitochondrion outer membrane
christae
matrix
ribosomes
DNA polymerase
Mitochondrial dysfunction with NRTI’s
ATP synthase
• FTC
– Skin or nail discoloration (0-8%; blacks>>Latinos>whites)
• Both
– HBV flare in those stopping
– Lactic Acidosis
• All case reports involve other drugs as well (especially D4T or DDI)
• Monitor anion gap and total CO2
2007
35/52 African
countries were unable
to report any
information relating to
MSM indicators
HIV Incidence by modes of
transmission
(76,315) (74,263) (91,546) (118,279) (11,381) (23,269) (N)
100
80
60
40
20
0
Kenya Zambia Uganda Mozambique Swaziland Lesotho
Percent
Casual heterosexual sex Partners (Casual heterosexual sex)
new Clients of female sex workers
Men having sex with men
infections Partners of clients of female sex workers Injecting drug users
Low risk heterosexual
Other
Death
11 yr to life long imprisonment
1 to 10 yr imprisonment
Imprisonment, unstated duration Sources: Ottoman, LGBT 2009
No specific law Pew Global Attitudes Survey 2002
Protective legislation
Studies with HIV-testing & MSM, 2000-2006
Egypt, 2006:
1%
Senegal, 2005: 22%
Sudan, 2006:
9%
Kenya, 2006:
11%
Mali: 37%
12%: Zanzibar
Cote D’Ivoire: 19%
Ghana: 25% 33%: Zambia
Nigeria (2): 13 – 14 %
21%: Malawi
Namibia: 12%
• Namibia
– The Rainbow Project
(TRP)
• Botswana
– Botswana Network on
Ethics, Law and
HIV/AIDS (BONELA)
• South Africa
– DTHF
• Malawi
– Center for
Development of
People (CEDEP)
4 sites : Results
Characteristic Malawi Namibia Botswana RSA
Age 25 24 26 26
Short questionnaire
HIV Prevalence : CT township
40
35 MSM
30
25
% 20 males
15 females
10
5
0
15-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+
AGE
Soweto men’s study: Results
Location
60
50
40
30 township
metro
20
10
0
township metro
MSM Sensitivity Training For
Health Workers
• 120 HIV Counselors,
trainers, and coordinators
trained between Jan –
April 2010
• Measured by
– Quarterly Computer Assisted Survey
Instrument (CASI)
– Monthly Self Report to Counselor
– Pill Count
• Improves After First On-Study Drug Visit
• Individualized Counseling Strategies Used
– People Go From Pharmacy to Counseling
• Periodic Blinded Drug Levels
Timelines for PrEP Trials
PrEP Issues
• Risk Compensation
• Costs
• Drug Resistance
Protect or Disinhibit?
Jon Cohen, The New York Times Magazine, January 22, 2006
“…behavioral disinhibition:
what if fear of HIV declined
in people who took the
drug, and they then
skipped using condoms or
increased their number of
sex partners?”
What Do we see?
Reported
Risk Behavior
Declined
With
Open-Label
Post-Exposure
Prophylaxis
and
Counseling
Good adherence,
high drug
pressure
time
The evolution of HIV resistance
Resistance and Adherence
Concerns For PrEP
• Starting or Restarting PrEP
– during the RNA+/Ab- window
– Expected to select resistance
• Non-adherence to the daily regimen
– Unclear effect on resistance
– Depends on efficacy, drug levels, selection
• Fear of resistance drives a high bar
– People who miss doses may give up
– People who miss doses when highly exposed
may be told to give up (both sex and PrEP)
The Importance of adherence
• Dose Optimization
– Intermittent PrEP Studies Planned
• Long Term Safety
• Efficacy in Adolescents
• Treatability of PREP Failures
• Synergies and Antagonisms
• When to Start? When to Stop?
• How to Recruit? How to Counsel?
MTN 003/VOICE
Global iPrEx in MSM
CDC Thai IDU
CDC US MSM Safety
CDC Botswana Heterosexuals
50 **
>60
45
40
35
T1/2 (hours)
30
25 24 hours
20 ‡ *
15
12 hours
10
* §
5
0
ZDV d4T ABC 3TC ddI TDF FTC
Serum/Plasma half-life Intracellular half-life
†
Data from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. MMWR Recomm Rep. 2002;51(RR-7):1-64 unless otherwise noted
*Anderson et al. AIDS 2003; 17(15):2159-2168. ‡Piliero et al. 43rd ICAAC, Chicago, 2003.
** Hawkins et al. 5th IWCPHT, Rome, 2004 § Wang et al. IAC, 2002, poster #4546.
Design SHIV
exposure
GROUP 1
(n =6)
-22h +2h
GROUP 2
(n = 6)
-3 days +2h
GROUP 3
(n = 6)
-7 days time +2h
GROUP 4
(n = 6) -2h +22h
GROUP 5
(n = 6) *
+2h +26h
CONTROLS
(n = 9)
50
+2h/+26h (PEP) HR = 4, p = 0.03
-2h/+22h HR = 4.1, p = 0.02
25
*
Garcia-Lerma at al., PLoS Med 2008
Absence of drug resistance in macaques failing
iPrEP with oral Truvada (2 weekly doses)
1800 DM91 DM92X
Log10 RNA copies/ml
8 8 8
6 6 6
wt
4 4 wt
4 wt
2 2 2
0 0 0
0 4 8 12 16 20 0 4 8 12 16 20 0 4 8 12 16 20
Weeks Weeks Weeks
8
6 wt 6
6 wt
wt
4 4 4
2 2 2
0 0 0
0 4 8 12 16 20 0 4 8 12 16 20 0 4 8 12 16 20
Weeks Weeks Weeks
• 2400 people
– 1200 MSM
– 1200 Heterosexuals
• 800 women
• 400 men
• Recruited over 72 weeks
• Followed for at least 24 weeks
So-what if something works?
• In well designed and well run studies
• With robust results
• That show sufficient reduction in
acquisition
• To be deemed effective as well as
efficacious
• That can be rolled out to trial participants?
What then?
Future for Prevention Research
• Before we have the “small pox equivalent”
vaccine against HIV
(Padian)
The challenge is an opportunity
• Prevention research will need to move beyond
the silos and cabales
• Vaccine, Microbicide, T+T, behavioural, PrEP,
Circumcision, etc should get into one room when
trials are designed.
• Social Scientists, epidemiologists, modelers,
basic scientists, clinical trialists and clinicians
need to be on the team.
• We should consider a variety of innovative trials
design methodologies that take into account the
need to test more than one modality or
combination.
PREP in Non-Human Primates
Garcia-Lerma et al