Financial Sector Assessment Programme

Workshop On

29th

Hyderabad December, 2010

DVS Ramesh

Objectives

ICP 14 Preventive and Corrective Measures Regulators are adequately backed by comprehensive legal structure with powers to safeguard the public interest. ICP 15 Enforcement or Sanctions Regulators are legally empowered to take action, where necessary, to ensure compliance to the Act and Regulations.
2

Preventive and Corrective Measures

Core Principle: Supervisory authority takes

preventive and corrective measures that are timely, suitable and necessary to achieve the objectives of insurance supervision.

Regulatory intervention to protect policyholders Regulatory Response is based on problem detected

Overall Enabling Tools: Insurance Act, 1938;

IRDA Act, 1999 adequately equipped IRDA.

Section 14 (2) An Omnibus Provision

3

25/04/2012

Essential Criteria
a.

b.

Availability of Adequate Instruments for timely preventive and corrective measures Specified returns within 6 months from the end of FY (Sec 15), Qly Accounts & Investment Returns, Solvency Margin returns, Monthly Business / Other Returns etc. Progressive Escalation of action or remedial measures Call for Information, Inspection, Examine Books / Accounts / Officers on oath Investigation into the affairs of Insurer (Sec 33) and Search and seizure (Sec 34 H); Penalties (Sec 102) , Suspension / Cancellation of License (Sec 3 (4)) Formal Advise to Warning Letters / Letters of Caution Proposed Insurance legislation makes individuals jointly and severally liable to make good the loss for contravening investment provisions Enhances certain penalties to Rs 25 Crores
25/04/2012 4

Contd....
c. d.

e.

Authority shall have capacity and standing to communicate From formal communications to Directions u/s 34, 110 C; Require insurers to develop an acceptable plan for correction of problems, if necessary Financial Plan (Sec 64VA (2A); Modification of rates, terms and conditions of life policies (Sec 3B); requires insurer to take action (Sec 33(6)); directions regarding reinsurance treaties (Sec 34 F) Measures to prevent breach of law and promptly and effectively deals with non compliance with regulation Call for further information (Sec 21); Order the revaluation (Sec 22) Review of Returns, Examination of Grievances Areas to Strengthen Risk Based Supervision Powers to prescribe higher initial capital requirements in specific cases
25/04/2012 5

Enforcement and Sanctions

Core Principle: The Supervisory authority enforces

corrective action and where needed imposes sanctions based on clear and objective criteria that are publicly disclosed. Decision making lines for remedial actions to be structured A range of actions available say from withholding approval for expansion to revoking the license Overall Enabling Tools: Fines and Penalties & Suspension and Cancellation of Licenses
6

Essential Criteria
a.

Issue formal directions and failure to comply has serious consequences

Advices / Formal communications Directions u/s 27 D (3), 33 (6), 34, 14 (1) Sec 34 E (a) empowers IRDA to prohibit Insurers / any Insurer entering a particular transaction / Class of transactions Reg 27 Cease to transact new business 7

b.

Power to prevent issuing new policies

Contd
c.

Compulsory Transfer of obligations from failing insurers

Sec 37 A empowers to prepare a scheme of amalgamation

d.

Requiring Capital levels to increase, restrict or suspend dividend or other payments to shareholders, restrict share transfer

Capital Levels not insurer specific, Prior approval for share transfer beyond a percentage and restriction on dividend (on Par Fund)

Contd
e.

Effective means to address Management Problems and powers to impose conservatorship

Sec 34 A prior approval for appointment of CEOs/whole time directors; Sec 34 B empowers to remove managerial personnel; 34 C additional directors and 34 E (b) call for meeting of directors or depute its officers to watch the proceedings; Approval for Appointed Actuary Sec 52 A Power to recommend appointment of Administrator for Life Insurance Business Sec 52 H Power of Central Government to acquire 9 undertakings of Insurers

Contd
f.

g.

Periodical checks to determine the compliance Regular Reviews, additional returns or a follow up inspection (where necessary) Fines against Individuals and Insurers Fine on individuals for acting as insurance intermediaries and for rebating Rs 500, proposed to be escalated to Rs 10000 and to Rs 500000 respectively Fine on Insurers for accepting business from other than licensed intermediaries Rs 5000, proposed to be increased to 10 Rs 1 Crores

Contd
h.

Sanctions for withholding the information or misleading information

Sec 104 Empowers to penalize for false statements in the investment returns

i.

Barring individuals from responsible positions

acting

in

Part of overall due diligence Scope for strengthening the procedures by disclosures
11

25/04/2012

Contd
j.

k.

l.

Process of Sanctions do not delay preventive and corrective measures Procedures in place to independently review these respective lines Powers to withdraw the license Reg 23 Suspension of Certificate, Section 3 (4) empowers Powers to protect one or more insurers from financial difficulties of other parts of the group

Insurance business is relatively insulated and Policyholders funds are maintained separately Abilities to infuse additional capital / Solvency Margin 12 Review an ongoing process

Contd
m.

Authority enforces the sanctions

Section 110 AA of the proposed Bill classifies the penalty imposed is recoverable as arrears of land revenue Escalation Provisions ensure the compliance to sanctions

n.

Ensuring sanctions

consistency

in

imposing

Procedures are in place

13

Contd
o.

Authority takes action against individuals / entities operating insurance business without a licence.

Section 103 Rs 5 lakhs penalty or with imprisonment up to 3 years Issues Public Statements cautioning the public

In the Proposed Bill the penalty was escalated to Rs 25 Crores with imprisonment up to 10 years 25/04/2012 14

Thank You

25/04/2012

15