Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 1 of 19

UI I I TBD St Km Vl t
B A S To m m s m c r
xsTixcftemrr
T oirpdii^?AiiiA
ms BOOOSR,
f U d a t t t i ,
" - g a l a a t *
KICBilEL RDTTBR, MAYOR OP tBB OTT
or PHXumPBi A, BT, AL, , sm
C. ALIVBRAp im3160064-5969,
GSRISi mi B J. tOCIANO
i ps<" 2smi - 20t t , mmi ss msn
m206851'-OMO SBAll VALffl iPIt
642-8S87 JOm 0ELAIIEr, ^
JOBS m somvi sos, Jom i n
omen, JORIf DOB poblic bmploybb
c s t m A i i G B n m m
Bsf endi nt a,
O O N P U m
Cl Ti X Ac t l Ot t No.
1 2 4 0 8
JURT TRIAL KMAUmO)
Thi s i s a ci Ti l ri ghta acti os l sd by Mm Bo^esr* cumatl y a Stats ^ri soasr* for
dsBSfss undsr 42 U.S.C. 1983, al^
^Jalm^tvX Arraat* aad Falss Isprlsoi
ig Qolaifful Rastrsintf XUsgal Ssarch aad Ssisttrs.
i n Ti o l s t i o D o f t b s F o u r t h A a s s d a s s t o f t h s t t i i t s d
Ststss Coastitatiott sad olstioas (>f Das Procsss of Rights sadsr ths Fdurtssoth Aasndsst
t o t h s Co a s t i t i i t i o Q*
n . t a r i s i t e f e S s s i
t h s Pl s i a t i f f ' s c l s i B o f o l s t i o s o f F s d s r s l
Case 2:12-cv-00402-Li Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 2 of 19
Coaiitittttiowa Right* tmdr 42 US<C 1331 () asd 1343.
2* Ths llDltad States BiMini District Court of Vmawmim is an appropriata faaiia u&dar
28 O^S.C. Saetioa 1391 (b) (2) baciuaa it ia iiara t\m avaata giTing riaa to thia clala
oec i t r r ad*
n r u z R X f f
3* Tha Plaiatiff, Jolia Bookar aa a raaidant of tha City of Philadalphia prior to tba
claioa aaatioaad haraia thia eoaplalat* Ra ie citrrMtly a priaoaar usdar DOC# JV*1293| at
SCI-*SoMraat Gmaational FlMility* locatad at 1600 WUtara Mil Bd., SoMraat PA 15S10.
4. Dafaadaat Hiehaal Ihtttar* Mafor of tha Citj of Philadalphia, at al. Placa of haaiaaaa
ia locatad at City Rail* Sooa 215 %iladalphia PA* 19107. Ea ia auad ia hia iftdiTidtial
c a p a c i t y .
5. Dafaadaat Saaa C. Alivara CiliTora**) iraa a Philadalphia Fpliea Ofcar dnriag tha
avaata daacribad ia thia eoaiplaint (Badga No. P823160064-S969). Alitrara ia carraatly aa
iaaata ttadar tha priaoi ID. ICB^3S0!I locatad at SCI*-Graaaa Comctioaal Flgcility* 173
Prograaa Driva, Vayttaaburg. PA 1S37). Ha ia aoad ia hia iaditidual capacity.
6. Dafaadaat Chriatophar J. Lac; aao (**Ltt!iaao") waa a PhiladaliM^ Polica Officar duriag
tha araata daacribad ia thia cog9la:At (Badga Ho. PR-239981--2062). Luciaao ia carraatly
aa iaaata oadar tha priaoa ID. ICB-: 901, locatad at SCI-Vaysart* P.O. Boi 255, RT6., UayiBart
PA 18472'-0256. Ha la aoad ia hia inliridoal capacity.
7. Dafaadaat Thonaa Itelah ("Sgt Itelah**) ia a poUca Sgt. (Badga Kb. Pt205851^460)
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LSi Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 3 of 19
J
t 5900 Bast JkifctUm BiTialon* lo:atd at Ou Fraakllii Sq,, Phildlpliia, PA 19106. Ht
is sttttd in his indiTidoal CAiweity.
8 Dafcsdaat Sma Wtloh dish") ia a police dataetiT# (Badga No. PR08642-8S87)
at 5900 - Eaat Datactiva fiTiaiofi l )catad at Ona Pranklia Sq.* Pliiladalpliia PA 19106. Ra
ia aitad in hia ladiTidual capacity*
9, Dafwdant John Ooa Supanriaor ("Soparriaor**) waa tha aoparviaing ofcar on tha acaaa,
Tha r aal nama and addr aaa i a
wi l l Mod coapl ai nt to ahov tha
attad in hia isdiTidital capacity*
t o Pl ai nt i f f at t hi a t i na* Af t ar di acor ar y Pl ai nt i f f
. naaa and addraaa of John Ooa Suparriaor* Ra ia baing
10. Dafandant John Boa Ofcar i[**Joha Doa Ofcar**) %mm an ofcar on tha acana. Tha
raal naaa and addraaa ia ttaknoim to Plaintiff at thia tiaa* Aftar diacovary Plaintiff will
aaand coaplaint to ahev tha raal naiia and addraaa of John Boa Ofcar* 8a ia baing attad
i n hi a i ndi Ti di tal capaci ty*
11* Dafandant John Dalanay C*Da; jway**) ia tha VSirdan of Gurran Fkroohold Gorractional
Facility (*'C*F*C*F.**)* Ra ia lagally raapenaibla for tha oparation of **C*F*C*F.** and for
tha walfara of all tha inaataa in titat priaon* Locatad at 7901 Stata Rd*^ Philadalphia
PA 19136* Ra ia aiiad ia hia indiTidital capacity*
12* Dafandant John Doa Public Bk^loyaa Xnauranca Providar ia and una tha dafandanta
i naur anca car r i ar. Tha r aal naaa aa<l addr aaa i a t t nknoi m t o Pl ai nt i f f at t hi a t i aa* Af t ar
diacovary Plaintiff will aaand coaplAint to ahow tha raal nana and addraaa of John Doa Public
Bapl oyaa Inattranca Provi dar*
i
Case 2:12-cv-00402-L$ Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 4 of 19
13* At all tl antloaad Ia thl cospUiot Mcli MmnUxit acttd itBdr th* color of mtmf
m c x B
14* (te JiiHiarf 29, 2010 t boit 12tOO pa* PloiAtiff VM drlTiag rwtal cor loot to
bin hf hio girlfriwd Mo* Tori Thoioo (ooo ottochod oidiibit
IS. ffhilo hooding Eootboimd in tho City of Philodolphio oo Toraongo St. nointiff orriTod
ot o rod otop light ot tho iatorooction of B St. ond ?omongo St.
16. Upoo tho light tomiog groio Floi&tiff aodo o right tun oo B. St. hooding South-
bound wfaon ?lointiff noticod o Philodolphio potrol cor ooko o V-tttm* procood b^iind
Pl oi nt i ff ond oohod t ho l i ght o oi gnol l ng f or Pl oi nt l ff t o pol l of or, whi ch Pl ai nt i ff
i o o o d i o t o l j d i d .
17. Tho ofeor thon ottnoonood ovor tho potrol cor*o lood opookor for Plointiff to turn
off tho cor ond to ploco tho k^o co tho roof of tho cor ond to otoy in tho v^iiclo until
f or t hor not i c o.
18. Tho offieor thon opproochod tho drivor oido of tho cor ond ditidod thot Plointiff
ot op oot oi do of t ho cor.
19. At thi o poi nt Pl oi nti ff woo obl o to i dnti ff ti i i o ofeor froa hi o noao tog oo
Offieor Prfor^ who io not o porty t thio ooit.
20. Plointiff ookod thio ofeOr why ho voo boing pullod oTor ot which tioo thio ofeor
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 5 of 19
i nf onMd t hat t l m car vh: ch Pl t f t t i f f i mm dr i vi ag f i t t h* dMcr l pt l oB of cmt
that wu tiMd to eoodt a robbarf
21 Thla offiear aakad Plalatlif if ha ha4 may waapona on hla paraoa that ha ahoold
k&ow about bafora co&dttetliig a aaaich of Plaintiff^a parmi* Plaintiff atata4 tiiat ha had
Bo wtapooa and wo aaarchad*
z v m i i K i n s m x i r
22. Aftar Plaintiff waa aaarchal aaid ofcer atatad, "wall* you^ll ba hald hmrm natil
tha vietia ia brought to tha acma** at ihieh point Plaintiff atatad **1 dida^t rob anjroaay
and X don't conaaat to baing iUagitLly dataiaad.**
23. Vhila undar duraaa Plaintif! vaa foread to atand thara in tha eold with no coat*
iftai anothar patrol ear arrirad vitli tao aora ofcara along vith tha allagad victia,
24. Qtm of tha tvo ofcara appioaehad ofear Prfor and ayaalf and atatad* *'tha tictia
thinka thia ia tha ona that tobbad tia**
25* Paur aara patrol eara arrind* oaa of tisa ofcara who 1 idantiad hf hia naaa
tag waa Dafandant Alivwra, vho atati d to Pryor* **aoaabodj ia trying to fraaa hlA,**
26. Of ear Al i vara bagi n qaaat i oai t t g Pl ai nt i ff wi t hout i nf orai ng Pl ai nt i ff of hi a ri ght
to eouaaal and/or right to raagin ailant.
27. Gndar duraaa Plaintiff coaplLad and anawarad Alivara*a quaation of **whara wara you
haadad bafora baing pullad ovar?* Pliintiff anawarad that ha waa haadad to hia girlfriuda
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 6 of 19
Job vhich **la right doim thm strtit at Statsoa Hiddl School.**
V ZUOBIL mUBQB i SKCSU
f
28* Alivora, aloog vlth Jdm Diio Soporrisor bogiii yolllag at Plaintiff. Ntofa'a tiia
fttddiig gtttt at?^ Alirara than dirt(^ta asothar ofear who Plaiatlff idMtiad by hia aaaa
tas aa Oafwdant Luclaao to *'pop tlia hood** Plaintiff atatad to all tiiraa dafasdanta *too
can't aaarchad tha car vitimt a wkTrant.**
29* Dafidaat Luciano, nithout a warrant antarad tha car and poppad tha hoed and tha
trunk of tha car, at which titsa Dal andant Ooa Ofear yalla out, "thara^a probably
aora ihit in tha trunk, 1*11 chack it,** which ha procaadad to do,
30. Prior to illagallj goins uidar tha hood of tha car Dafandant Alivara atatad that
ha waa Tin Gartiad and would chack whathar tha car waa atolw. Plaintiff atatad to Alivara,
**I*va ahowad you tha Rital Car Racaipt (aaa attached Ethibit **B**) ao there ia no need to
check under tha hood unleaa you haia a warrant.**
I
31* Defndant Alivara, diaregaidad Plaintiff and aaerchad under the hood of the car,
while he and the Superriaor were under the hood Alivera held up a gim and then pieced it
back under the hood into tha eir vint (eee attach Bxhibit **C**),
32* Plaintiff waa forced to ataiid in the cold while tha above Mentioned ofcera illegal
detained and aaarchad the Tiriiicle which Plaintiff waa operating, thua depriving Plaintiff
of hi a ci vi l ri ght s and vi ol at i ng Pl ai nt i ff ' s Gonat i t ut i onal prot act i au by depri vi ng
Pl ai nt i f f of hi a Conat i t ut i onal r i ght a.
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Documents Filed 02/02/12 Page 7 of 19
n m a j o m a a n
33, PUl At i f f f pf dl y Ml ui d Df t f cudasi t Ski pt r r i mr i f hm coul d bi cost t hat
ia thm back umt of tte cor, iiiiicli Sitporvioor doniod his ototlnst **it*o port of o criao
ocoso pat tliio ponk in tho potrol
34 Soporrloor poroooolly portieipotod la tho oet of illosol ooorchiag tho cor ol tho
f ol oo or r oot of Pl oi at i f f
33, noitttiff WW hoadeaffod ood plocod lato tho bock of a potrol cor oad troaoportod
to tto 25th Matrict vhoro Plalatifz aa avbjoct to oaothor ooorch of hia porooa*
3 6 P l o i a t l f f v o o t h o a
i m e o o a o f
bookod oad arraigaod* Boil ao aot ot $100000
37. Oa Jaa* 30^ 2010 Plaiatiff waa traaaforrod to CFCP cotiaty priaoa, CFC,P* priaoa
ia aador tho ceatrol of DafoadMt Dilaaoy, aaid dofoadaat participated ia tho folao
i apr i t onmt of Pl oi at i f f by i o^ i ocai as Pl ai at i f f i a hi a j ai l .
v z n o y s i Q i o f m p i o g b u i u w i i x M o f n m n s
38* Oa 1-*29^10 at 12l55 pa
a t t a c h o d B i h i b i t
I
i n n m x M Q P
t
Oof oBdoat Dot llalah iatorvioNod Dofwdoat Luciaao (ooo
I
39. (to 1-29-10 at liOS pa. Dafcs^t Oat. Htldt lacarvlmad IMaiulaBt Allvar*, (sm
t t ael wd Ri hl bl t "B").
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Documents Filed 02/02/12 Page 8 of 19
40, Mt t dnt Al l vr a eenf MM( i di t r i f i g t hi s i i i t r Ti i r wi t h Dat . t bat 1m amr t l t mA
undsr tlM hood of thm ear, vmkriMtd a reara, raplacad tha raani back into it*a original
l oc at i on*
41, On Ju 2011 Dat HUalj naad thia illagally obtainad avidanca aa i^bably catiaa
to aapport an afdavit for a aaar4h varrant* thua dapriving Plaintiff of hia dua proeaaa
and aidittg aad abatting in naintiljf *a ttelawful Arraat and ?alaa Xvriaoaaant* (aaa attachad
Et Mb i t " V)
42 Dat. 1telah onea givaa notiiea and fcnovladga of tha illagal natura in nhieh tha car
naa aaarchad (without a warrant) atHll contimiad to proeaad forward with hia raport and
afforta of aaeuring a aaarch warranjK, (aaa attachad Sghibit
43 Oafandant Sgt. Walaht with ^owladga and notica diractlj participatad in tha
dapriTatioo and raatraiat of Plaintiff's libartiM hj approving tha coa^lalat praparad by
Dat. Ilalah, (aaa attachad Bghibit
44* On Octobar 4 2010, Dafaiidai^ta Alivara aad Luciano both plaad guilty to criainal
chargaa* (aaa attachad Exhibit **1")
4S Xn April of 2011 Both Alivaifa and Laciaiio wara amtancad to aar?a priaon tiaa for
t h a i r c o n f a a a a d c r i a a a .
46* On 5-19-2011 Philadalphia CciNwon Plaaa Judga Earl V. tmat grantad an Ordar to
Suppraaa tha raara (avidanca) thatt waa unlawfully obtainad by Dafandant AliTara* Mm
Ooa Suparriaor* Doa Ofcar and: Luciano, (aaa attachad Eshibita "J** &
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 9 of 19
47* Bm to the Consti tuti onal Hol nti onn by al l dofnadnnf i n thi n noti on Pl ni nti ff
hnn nufforod unjuntly tttm hin fnUo inprieomwt nnd ttnlnvful nmnt ainoo tha data of
nnlavfttl arraat 1*29*10.
g m i J I M L M B B P S
4 8 , P l a i n t i f f b a a l a d w i t h t l i a l U t a d S t a t a a D i a t r i o t C o a r t B a a t a v n l l i a t r i c t o f
Pannaylvaniai Bookar t. C.P.C.F. Daekat Ho. l(>-7389 thia eaaa ia atill pandini,
X . P U T B r a n U B T
49, Granting Plaintiff a daclaritioa that tha acta and ooiaaiona daaeribad harain violata
hia righta undar tha Conatitotion aftd lava of tha Qnitad Stataa# and
50, Qraatins Plaintiff coapanaatory daaagaa in tha aaoant of $30000 (thirty thouaand
dollara) againat aach dafandaatt Jointly and aavarally,
31. Plaintiff aaaka punitiTa dai^agaa in tha aaoaat of $l250t000 (ooa aillion two Imadrmi
fifty thooaand dollara). Plaintiff aaalca thaaa dgaa againat aach dafandaat* jointly and
a a v a r a l l y.
52. Plaintiff alao aatka a Jury trial on all iaauaa triabla hy jury#
53. Plaintiff alao aarta raeovary of hia eoata in thia aoit* and
34. Any additional raliaf thia e^rt daaaa Juat* propar and aqoitahla.
Case 2:12-cv-00402-LS Document 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 10 of 19
m a r t c m m
I dmclMtm mdmf pwaXtj of pujory that tht forttgoiiig is trtw ftiid eorrct, icpt m to
Mttm 4mot#d on ittfoffBOtiOB asd bollof, aad^ m to thoM I boliovt ttuni to bo truo.
Satadt Jbbbtt |t) . 2012
f t oof wet f al l y sabodt t od.
Jobn Bodlcor #JV-1293 Pto so Plaintiff
l eOO Itel tora Mi l l Rd*
Sonaraat, PA 15510
^ V i
1.!
!i i *' t-
%*
: ' H
X
c. .'
! ;
. %
/ c
J > .
w , .
V " ,
< 1
\ t
V
^ u
.../^ -
TJSciimen^ Filed 02/02/12 Pg;ge;Ll^.Qf 19
. . ! o t ' A i s - a s " K ' * / . K : . 5
? O W J i " - , ^ i i I o . i i i * i " K 4 - ^ i C i _ ^ * . . ; - * / > 5 5 r * *
> . . J t
/ "!
r . i c t :
.,..l-...-p
- - , T j
/ n V i
^ ^ i
> *
C J o
t n m
' s?
1 6 '
J? v:
r
7*
:
7^
m 0k
^ F^ d Tage 12 of 19
( P H I L A D E L P H I A (
INVESTIGATION INTEft.-^W RECORD POUCE OEPARTMEKTV.
EASTD&TECnVES (tNTmVlBlt
DET WALSH# 8587
M A U f A Q R A C E / ' 5 E X
L u c i a 2 2 W / M
A R S S A P T i
3 9 0 i W h i t d k e t A v e B u s i n e s s
NAME OF EMPLOYER / SCHOOt
AOOftESS OF EMPLOVER / SCHOOL
DATES Of PLANNED VACATION t 8US!NE9?( TRIPS
NAME OF CLOSE RELATIVE
N.-A
AODReSS OF RELATI VE
. V- A
PLACE OF (NTEVI EW
a < \ s r D E T B c r i v s
BROUGHT N BY
WE ARE QUESTHDNING YOU CONCERNING;
WARMNCS &r VEN 8Y:
Ra AT KWJ SHi P
P H 0 N 6 #
DAT E
1 ( 1 9 / 1 0
DATE
DAT E
l:05pra
T M E
T M E
J i S Wf f R S
( 1)
(3> { * ) ( 0 m
Q. TtfU mc. in >our tm7 wor<b. whar happened todaj'thntbon&fivsTuhercai Fart D<tectiVM Di\i$ioD mwde 3901 F UTjtUker
A i x :
A. (>51 Friiia> 01-29-l05iappfo;t. J2:15 P.M. \Vc responded toFfoniond Wesnnwfland for radio call uf a rohber>' in
pru'tfTrtts. My parUio' & 1 met b>' Ihe cotnp, >)ui(^jv relayed ash uiriHutarion given Oxjuj the cocnp. to nspodiiig
orticcTx. MoTDcnis later iht) \'ehicl \vtk sp<ttd heded S'B ou 3500 "B" St 8y25TI4. Derendant was t^eo lino
cu>iody bAcr beiog poitUivcty itkntiScd by c<anp. Upon ftinher ii)voM on veb, displaying pa tag lxc*^XK)5. Fnund
protiudiu^ from air fihr box in engine area i^ipcared to be a brow-n \\v)oden colra* typ handle of n gwi. HaM n;>tified and
hd JIW svarrani. Wc transported the ccwnplainwit lo cast deicctivc^ for ftmbef iDtfviewii>g.
t,> W a> ;wy $%':ns on location?
A, No
Q W1jf ^xHi ihc firsi ofnccrs i ihe scciic"
A
^ Who invcsiii^aicd liievAicU:'.'
(^Mvself, Olctr Ahvmt
0^ I ell ic alv^u how you tnve8tii>ttied ibc N-thiclc'.'
QA^ ubSiTicJ :JiKhinghack seaiofthecar. \ thw cticck under the hood of ihc vchicle. 1 am trainttL Thac'H nlicn 1
the gun promiding from the airffluir box. Dunns tny iiive^ti^otton the gunTed the air b(v(. Ai uhich tintc
I placc Ktck into the Iccatign. Do to wfety reason*."
U. In there- un> ihin^ else yw tell me can awisi me in this mvesiigaiioii
A. Ni >. nt ^ ai dnx l i me.
XX f W.WI you to read ywur uiment and make sure tl*s coniwt than sign it
Sr ATFMENT CONCL UDED; l : 4 <) PM
RECORO
] Y e s N O
R E V i e v r e o B Y :
amCKEDBr: /^ i
D5?bnf>e '^iied 02/02/12 Page 13 of 19
INVESTIGATION INTERVIEW RECORD
NAME
O n k c r L u d j
AODRESS
3901 Whi l Jkcf Aw
NAME OF EMPUOYB) / SCHOOL
ADDRESS OF eMI>l OYER / SCHOOL
DATES OF PLANNED VACATION / BU$tfiSS TRIPS
NAME Of CLOSE RELATI VE
N / A
ADDRESS OF RELATI VE
N / A
PLACE OF tNTERVIEVV
EAST DCr eCTI VES
BROUGHT IN BY
WE ARE OUESTIOMMG YOU CONCERNtNO;
WARNI NGS or VEN 8Y:
PHI L ADEL PHI A
p o u c E d e p a r t me n t
EAST DETECnVES
AGE
2 2
APT
6u$i ti cs
RACe WEX
W/ M
! 0 1 I 6 0
I N n V ( E W C R :
DET. WALSH # 85i j 7
9 0 ^
R E L A - n O N S H I P
PHONE#
D A T E
\ n 9 f \ { )
DAT E
O A t C
T V ^
U:55pni
TI ME
T W E
m a m i ,
(1)
(a) m m PI
Q TcU nw. in vow own nx)rdK, uHwt happened lodny tJwi bugsyou hcK al East Detect}>'cs Oiviciow inside I'Wl U Wluwkcr
A \ e
A On FntLi) <a-29.n>Bi appfox. 12:\5 P.M police rwpondcd lo From and VVcsliootciaodrora nctiocallord robben^ m
progress, Mv pumtcr I met by ihe coii]>. quickly relayed flosh infonuatioo given from ihc comp w responding
ofHccrs Momenis inter t)e vehicle {handed S/B Si. in'25T14and ddf. taken intocustod)
acf bitmg posiiivcl)' Id^mifted by cowp, Wc fwiisponcd Uw complainatU to chsi dacctKccs for limljcr imcnic\Mng.
0 Wsam ^viucs otUtKanoti '
A N o ,
Q UTietv vuu ilic rir olTiccrs on the sccnc**
A Ye s
0 is llicfc ,in>' clsa you icU i\k cim uwist me in ihjs mveaigalion?
A K'i. ikM 3t this lime
X.\ I vumt Yoo (o read yottr sioictucni nnd tiutke sure ifs conon ilten sign >u
STATF. ; V( ENTC0 NCL L 1 } HD. 1 0 0 PM
R E C O R D
I ! Y E S U NO
Revf EV-/ eO BY:
t- Tv \^s\2\^^0\02 LS
umentS Filed 02/02/12 Page 14 of 19
. . Ci rcumst ari ^e-i nf . i n' j . dwnL: Or. Tri cay, January 25# 20i 0 ac apprax: i . : TdT. <Bl y 12Ji Cgrm
o f s Rd e i a J i f r f b e i n g p c s L t j v e i y I T- b y r . h ^ c c T ^ r l a i n a n t . Wa s a r i e s t e c i f o r t c b b e r y t h a t
o c c u r r e d o n f ' i i d y J a n u a r y 2 9 , 2 - Oi x 5 a t - : 3 0 0 K f r c r t t St . f u f t e x t h e r o b b e r y t h e c f t e n d e r
t hen, f l ed i n a wnl t t i v hl . c l f l . Shor t l y af t er t he of f ender v as s t oppf c <1 l / y uni t oi m ) : ol Lt ; c i n
Cb 3500 ar ea cf 5 St , dr i vi ng 2<' JC' whi l e Chevr ol et ?B* Tag r / I C- OOOf i , Own* r i nf or r ^ i At i i i * .
i a H e r t r V c h i c j f f . s 5 2 0 1 B a r t r a m Av e r h i l ^ ? a 1 9 1 5 3 . D u r i n g t h e a r i t & v e h i c l i
i r . v ^ s t i a a c i n g , o t Mc e r A l i v e t a d b ? e c v e d s h a n d g u n I n t h e a i r ' . r . t r r o f r h c n n f j UK ' ,
licius to be searclKd !br and seized: Based on ihe above Ikcts and circumKiances, rhe afHani believes thai
probable cause exist for ihc issuance of search wjuraiU for described eMdcnce:
/ V. y i n c . t j " . l i s M c * e % ' i i e n c s , l s d i n ^ 3 a f f i Q u n x t i t ? : ! / f i x e d c a r ^ i c ; q e
< i z c ^ p < ^ t t c y , D N A H v i d - s n c e , c l o t h i n g , a n d a n y < r o i - j ; r . : j i i i ' o !
' / i f i . ! T ^ > ? t , h i j > i i n / e j i i .
F CC- c . ^ n t . r - : : ;
i r i g i r u ' . ^ : D C s U M- :
- V i l : > i 3 . S a a r j Wa l r h
S l ' ; K A f t ; S t : CI - Ay n , ^ NT
I 5 C Z
B A D G E H
t i - E A l ;
f f i r m e d ' i i r . r t : u b s c r l b " J d
3?:oKApj KSa r ! ?0 AUTJ?0i r TY
^ / /
^ %
' }
d a y
' * hi \
"JT35Kr
Filed 02/02/12 Page 15 of 19
> Z 5 r o r b i w ^ ^ f e t u f w i i r T O K S C M C M f O h ' # < i i p # f 0 r H . - y p t * i
8 M V r t c o r d i r M l s K r r t i e ( i { c 1 e s L L C , 8 2 0 1 B a r t r * * A P H U F 1 9 1 S 3
CC<ilD6. CC6105. caiOO, CC3701.
' R O t t a i i 1 ^ T H t ; F O t L O M ' i l r C F M l f l A K ) O A c u t l t * r W > C 6 C S M ( ) < .
R I t e r t o 7 S - 5 1
A
0
>W!io 4-u p
I
f\cC
Ar-.*CnAITrO<' (Avo/*P5/^ KftCfiSSAJ^r CCnfCK KFRf r AOO' TlO^Al ^APt:^ USt J
5<6* I A' ' UK( O*
D t S U n R . Wa l i h
8 SS7
I DO
A t t / o r t i ) 9 < n a r M ^ u O ^ O i & C d l ^ t o r _
0 > y o # " . ^ 0
C O . t y : " ' 0 ^
09l COTTT. t Sl ^
PLASf Rf AD AND FOvt OW YHCSf I N^TKUCTI OWS CAMf nt l t ^
1 I f i l o i ma i . n ' ' . f wa s o t j i i t n s c h ' a m a o o l h ^ j p e ^ i c i r < 9 n i f i o f ma o t p t N t c i b > n i wt e
:/foitiB< cn Nv4 r<c*tv^d, eoo how and f^n socn .n' of^siron fiA^ oaiair^d a.&r !r " *V' ' o-' be' <*^A9
.tC> On0< OeiSO<^ to rffttStM#
/ > Su' ^e4!fr"' te *"' T.a<ji s<i^ ^p^ai vj4 et.a<nd by tuci siyvctaancs *ho*>' ' ss o)ijirr%a ^f3 JQI? oa<e
I a n d p i a c ^ c f i u c n i u f v e i t . ^ r c e
j S w e o i f t e r p t n < n i r . f f a c t * i ' t r n ' ; a P i # * * . ;
* i nts'-C.^fe" i09?ch v 'qu5ii (0 10 ^ M Jc b a ts. ^ tatr adtJjf anii rsasO'^tjXe catiso C' vj to
n "i^ftlBPTC
b Sap 6a>ari's' Drt ev J^4^ re H9.ri i tc(d'e<5 a' '^'e p'ew.4 A/idJ9f or fhe t e'so spa- .iry ^dc^e
t 5<aie 0;>0'*5 to< oe vtra 'fts' ?e<^s ufcec' lo Jeiia.'*
' 3y >('oi'si'T.fcjTpatfC'* co^vde^tc SIS'* * 'j>^N
rTwJTkirnfTN*6N7 n> f CF, .vsc.A?"a5 Jj'.'s a-t &een swo-a it cr 6^f 'fHTO */e*ore <" U>?
. W . K 1 ^ ^ . . a r k ^ > . - > ' < ' r . . - . ' . r t * - d ' ( i U J %* ' "
Md 104^ * OiOe > MBVN VWHid
- ' " "" j o i p t t m fSAniO~SIflaN
WTO
]aBXBS9S
f } i i a c a a a n i 8 f q { } f l f l > MM| i O U
(atS^qoH /ftmmtwj sffOfBaqui ^ /l Mi m9>a/P9*Q)>l 3/HQS
S a A t m r t o o o c s m
u u u u n n o
* M 4B( i q
/ A f f K O / m S M X )
t n o
H3S
0B>A3gro
USl Vpal QMl HI wm^vmn
U s m / x ^ m
i f SumvMmv^sm <apM| Mq
<3PWt!
B M W W J J M M d
xsotpsAtaa
wv<p&( *3
!" " 1"
B| l ^3| adi i apt eN
i w / i i M t a / a 8 / y o y
u e u s m i a > a
ft.tj iMMAOSCq
WA| } 3aa{ [ 3 i Bf PCTi i i Li wq
Hi l OO^ SSn 9I ( HVZ/ I i i mMf uvq
Mf p a SMa f Ax ^ m
WOHBWA
m M 3 0 M k f "
0 O I 0 M
o o m i n n o
f q p a o mi i
l o a p m i
M V A
( FOB
J Xbt Q
w w i r o
M0| [ { 96nB
10161 V4l*IfPPBU 2S3
SI(nUNOeS OMWV
0ii9pQH
A W W J i W J
f c R l
NOSVf 'NOSNiaOH * lA momdmoo / aqpfA
H o o x o n J I p t W H a o i ( n o < WA O N a i H a | a ! A . t a a a ( i
p o w i < > m > m S 3 H i p m i d b m } v o
[ m a v m X N ( W I I l | g a p I S W O ) * W ^ a i H - f S O c c p w r i
NnOOMVH AVMH91H AHSff l OH - 000 : wn9a oonnff l Ss^D
C O K K M C * * U p i l ^ p o f S l i q i p q d p 0 1 S v i a a o m h i s u w e t i p a n s
tipnllRfoM tMatnqofSMiosAWAI VMioSpa* ppq mm 9pn/i 'I>Bstii
ijwwq|tflaoo aip 3B|xaAo>y !aqwdtaoa Xq CQ[ XfMfflwd smm iMdm <n 4q9MtotM|a9dhBfavtV9pn*A*do)Sfii3B01SaP
OQS *9 ^ ^n^l afl 0) iptsAqp SSA ouQItta *{{( PQpn pK too^ BM in pjqquS |ai^iFfmo3 iiHioail!) <4 Mpl
sjenm*" leiMV "VlipA aP >ee 1*1 iaW6 D Pq >3e<^ Om oi 00>ll$ P" ""I'8 <n Vpdbagu imnq^oTO apFp*. q> q otai
pq |ct| da M|S 9 fctpanma
ipilM eg Wl eii fapwg'Mil s|iiq pdm qx "iwaii^ P Jegr 01 ibroai taa|4* 1i 4S i'WP F "P"*
'apffaAS^ tt}p9dn$ "ananljp teoao^ A|a s> 'spnMtn 0|ipqXlMf )s!{dB9 pfO) aV pdfli5 ^amgitilp pidsas
aqfiai^f o)8aiofMii|B<qi|dteO'<WM^>J<9lBnf^anP^d<>t*<>lMi3adtatt||iq]pm<ddv *STC|isino^ira8iipi|iM8{nMpain^)anqqdao3
AJwrnttmsuodw^
(99*00/ lS896Ci) KSlVASVWOHliSS
(68S8i/zmoc Hid snvA Nvss''a
M d Z E ^ i r / L O l O l / t l / C W M V
MdSSitpir OIWIVZ pcmpkmo
iVAiuddv viodyHj
wpwOM| 3i a* S[ - 09r Mv i ^ k umwa
(6Saf / ZP9m)U>BSTVMt mSWl
t i f m i a v g Z ' Q o a i m * v * o
J UJ UVl ams / Bepi KK^
Md 9 ! Wi Z l 0 i 0 Z Wt v p n o * v
w v i o mo j n o i o i / 6 i / i ^ P B O
i(!9&0/P99ta)iS vmnv Nvas o/d
(Z90&/ m6sz Ha) OMviDm HmicusraHD o/d
C V S d W K I W S Z
SBf d[ M00C
MOOONVH AVMBDXH AHSaSOX - 000
MOt OONVH AVA1EK>! H AHSnaOH 000
m a o p m n
* i i w w
j ki ao* t i B! t r
M K WJ O P o n i f m a
M M S n O l D O t t d f f t " " "
e a p s a g i mo e v y a y
|Jod9H ao}|88!isAai sd^ }Jodd>{
WaSSJI>:^(OZyi I/r aj eayod;^
r^!95oa-sr-oi or oKuocbH
J d O U m N F " V T
)Joda^ iioi;3i|saAaig9iii|J8dac[93f|oj }ql|9pB|iqd[
6HO-aeEd_ZT/20/Z0 paiH
4f i^alin-^oi^Vo^l^a^
'-LStV)0^i!t 3 Filed 02/02/12 Page 17 of 19
S C U M B U S I H H S
RtOAY.APRILTS, 20lf
- P I L - A D E L - P H I A C ' A I U V N - W S
PAGEi S '
(^(02/12 Page 18 of 19
C OU RT OF C OMMON P L E A S OF P H I L A D E L P H I A C OU N T Y
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
V .
John Booker
Docket Number : CP- 51- CR- 0005235- 2010
CRI MI NAL DOCKET
Co u r t Ca s e
Page 6 of 9
S e o u e n c e N u m b e r C P F i l e d D a t a D o c u m e n t D a t e F i l e d B v
1 0 5 / 0 5 / 2 0 1 1 T r e n t . E a r l W.
Order Granting Motion for Continuance
ADA A. SHVER DEF ATTY B. SHUTTLEWORTH STENO N. MASCIANTONIO CLERK D. TAKAKJY
LISTED 5/11/11 RM 1002 FOR MOTIONS
0 5 / 0 9 / 2 0 11
Court of Common Pleas - Philadelphia
County
Hearing Notice
1 0 5 / 1 1 / 2 0 1 1 T r e n t , E a r i W.
Mc^n for Si ^ressi on
ADA A SHVER DEF ATTY B. SHUTTLEWORTH STENO N. MASCJANTONi O CLERK D. TAKAKJY
MOTI ON TO SUPPRESS HEARD AND HELD UNDER ADVI SEMENT
L I ST ED 5 / 1 9 / 11 RM 1 0 0 2
05/ 11/ 2011
Hearing Notice
Court of CcKnmon Pleas > Philadelphia
County
1 0 5 / 1 9 / 2 0 1 1 T r e n t , E a r i V y / .
Order Granting Motion to Suppress
ADA A. SHVER DEF ATTY B. SHUTTLEWORTH STENO N. MASCIANTONIO CK D. TAKAKJY
MOTI ON TO SUPPRESS FI REARM GRANTED
TRIAL DATE REMAINS - LISTED 8/22/11 RM 1002
1 0 8 / 1 9 / 2 0 1 1
Pre-Tri ^ Conference Hel d
TRI AL DATE REMAI NS
BOTH SIDES READY
Trent. Eart W.
1 0 8 / 2 2 / 2 0 1 1
Couns el At t ac hed f or Tr i al
Atty Brad Shuttlevwrth attached for 3 day jury trial on 11/28/11 Room 1002
Trent, Earl W.
0 8 ^ 2 / 2 0 11
Hearing Notice
Court of Comnnon Pleas - Philadelphia
County
A O P C 2 2 2 0 - I R v 1 Q Q S a 0 1 1 P n K s d . 1 ( V 2 W 2 0 1 1
Rcent entries made in the court fttmQ offices may not be tmmediateiy reflected on these docket sheets. Neither the courts of the Unified JiKfidal
System of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania nor ttw Adrnntstrative Office of Pennsyfy)ia Courts assume any hatMltty for inaccurate or delayed
data, emirsor omissions on these reports. Docket Sheet information ^>ouid not be used in place of a crfmina} history background check which can
only be provided by the Pennsylvania State PoSce. Moreover an employer does not comply with the provisiona of the Criminal History Record
hiformation Act may be subject to dvit iiabiUty as set forth tn 18 Pa.C.S. Sectk>n 9183.
3^^(^92/ 02/ 12 Page 19 of 19
A x v a & A s s o c i a t e s
ATTOHi r ar r s A2a> Couksbi xobs at La. w
DAHiBi>PATn. Ax.vjk.xjcx:
J B B B C T ' B VA K A X . VA
BHAP V. SMUTTJUBWUHTH *
* A X S O M E M B B a M J B A X t
(Via First-Class, U.S. Mail)
S t t X E S i O O l
l e m M a b x k S C S B B T
FmT. 4 i n n r . i n To . Fs mNv r z . v a mx a l e i o o
< e i 8 > e 6 a > i 6 a 8
F a x ( b i o ) a e s o i a a
<lal@alvfina.com
May 24,2011
lohn.Booker
DOC Number. JW1293
SCI ~ Graterford
PO Box 244
Graterford, PA 19426
RE: Commonwealth V. John Booker
CP- 5 1 - CR- 0 0 0 5 2 3 5 < 2 0 1 0
Dear Mr. Booken
Very good news - I write to let you know that Judge Trent granted our motion to
suppress, and suppressed die rearm from evidence. For your case, that means that the
government is not permitted to have the police ofcers testify about the rearm that was
allegedly recovered from the car your were in.
If th^ nd the complaining witness, he would be allowed to te
supposedly saw, however. Again, that is if they ever locate him. Ill see w
Ve i y t r u l y y y
about what he
August
'LEWORTH,ESQ.