Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract Analyses of environmental isotopes (18O, 2H, et la composition minéralogique des formations des bas-
and 87Sr/86Sr) are applied to groundwater studies with sins d’alimentation et des zones de recharge. Les compo-
emphasis on saline groundwater in aquifers in the Keta sitions isotopiques en 18O et en 2H des eaux souterraines
Basin, Ghana. The 87Sr/86Sr ratios of groundwater and profondes présentent de faibles variations et se placent
surface water of the Keta Basin primarily reflect the ge- près de la droite des eaux météoriques mondiales. Les
ology and the mineralogical composition of the forma- eaux des nappes peu profondes et les eaux de surface su-
tions in the catchments and recharge areas. The isotopic bissent des variations beaucoup plus fortes de leurs com-
compositions of 18O and 2H of deep groundwater have positions isotopiques, dues à l’évaporation et aux fluc-
small variations and plot close to the global meteoric wa- tuations saisonnières. Un excès significatif en chlorures
ter line. Shallow groundwater and surface water have dans les eaux souterraines peu profondes, compte tenu
considerably larger variations in isotopic compositions, de l’évaporation calculée, résulte à la fois de l’évapora-
which reflect evaporation and preservation of seasonal tion et d’apports marins. Les eaux souterraines de fora-
fluctuations. A significant excess of chloride in shallow ges profonds et de puits dans les aquifères proches de la
groundwater in comparison to the calculated evaporation côte sont caractérisées par des concentrations relative-
loss is the result of a combination of evaporation and ment élevées en chlorure; une influence marine signifi-
marine sources. Groundwaters from deep wells and dug cative est mise en évidence par des droites de mélange
wells in near-coastal aquifers are characterized by rela- bien définies pour les isotopes du strontium et les isoto-
tively high chloride contents, and the significance of ma- pes stables de l’oxygène et de l’hydrogène, avec les
rine influence is evidenced by well-defined mixing lines compositions de l’eau de mer pour l’un des termes du
for strontium isotopes, and hydrogen and oxygen stable mélange. Les résultats fournis par les isotopes du milieu
isotopes, with isotopic compositions of seawater as one dans cette étude montrent qu’une approche multi-isotopi-
end member. The results derived from environmental que est un outil pertinent pour identifier l’origine et les
isotopes in this study demonstrate that a multi-isotope sources d’eaux souterraines salées.
approach is a useful tool to identify the origin and sourc-
es of saline groundwater. Resumen Se ha aplicado el análisis de los isótopos am-
bientales (18O, 2H y 87Sr/86Sr) al estudio de las aguas
Résumé L’analyse des isotopes du milieu (18O, 2H, et subterráneas en la Cuenca de Keta (Ghana), haciendo én-
87Sr/86Sr)a été mise en œuvre pour des études hydrogéo- fasis en acuíferos salinizados. Las proporciones de
logiques portant sur des eaux souterraines salées des 87Sr/86Sr en las aguas subterráneas y superficiales de la
aquifères du bassin de Keta (Ghana). Les rapports isoto- Cuenca de Keta reflejan, fundamentalmente, la geología
piques 87Sr/86Sr de l’eau souterraine et de l’eau de surfa- y la composición mineralógica de las formaciones domi-
ce du bassin de Keta reflètent principalement la géologie nantes en las zonas de captación y de recarga. La compo-
sición isotópica de las aguas subterráneas profundas pre-
senta variaciones pequeñas en 18O y 2H y se acerca a la
Received: 16 March 2000 / Accepted: 29 November 2000 línea meteórica mundial. Las aguas subterráneas someras
Published online: 9 March 2001
y las superficiales presentan variaciones considerable-
© Springer-Verlag 2001 mente mayores en la composición isotópica, hecho que
refleja la evaporación y las fluctuaciones estacionales.
Como resultado de la combinación entre evaporación e
N.O. Jørgensen (✉) influencia marina, se observa un exceso significativo de
Geological Institute, University of Copenhagen,
Øster Voldgade 10, DK-1350 Copenhagen, Denmark cloruros en las aguas subterráneas someras en compara-
e-mail: nielsoj@geo.geol.ku.dk ción con las pérdidas por evaporación. Las aguas subte-
Fax: +45-33-148322 rráneas de pozos profundos y de pozos excavados en
B.K. Banoeng-Yakubo acuíferos cercanos a la costa se caracterizan por sus con-
Department of Geology, University of Ghana, tenidos relativamente altos de cloruros. La influencia
P.O. Box 58, Legon, Ghana marina se evidencia por las líneas de mezcla bien defini-
das por los isótopos del estroncio y los isótopos estables study is to analyse four major aquifers in the Keta Basin
del hidrógeno y oxígeno, mientras que la composición by means of environmental isotopes (18O, 2H, and
isotópica del agua marina se comporta como punto extre- 87Sr/86Sr) in order to identify the source of salinization of
mo de dichas líneas. Los resultados obtenidos en este deep and shallow groundwater.
trabajo a partir de los isótopos ambientales demuestran
que el enfoque multi-isotópico es una herramienta útil
para identificar el origen y las fuentes de aguas subterrá-
Geologic and Hydrogeologic Setting
neas salinas.
The Keta Basin is a fault-controlled Mesozoic/Tertiary
sedimentary basin along the coast of the Gulf of Guinea.
Keywords stable isotopes · radioactive isotopes ·
The basement complex consists of early Precambrian
salinization · salt-water/fresh-water relations · Ghana
Dahomeyan gneisses, migmatites, and schists. These
rocks were affected by the Pan-African orogeny and crop
out along fringes of the basin to the north (Fig. 1b). The
Introduction basal sedimentary sequence in the basin is known from
borehole data and comprises Lower to Middle Devonian
The Keta Basin is one of several fault-controlled sedi-
marine shale, sandstone, and siltstone, which are over-
mentary basins in West Africa along the southeastern
lain by Jurassic dolerites and sills (Akpati 1978). A se-
coast of Ghana and dominated by the Volta River estu-
ries of Cretaceous-Eocene marine sediments, composed
ary. The sedimentary sequence in the Keta Basin consti-
of limestone, shale, and glauconitic sandstone, crops out
tutes one of the most prolific aquifer systems in Ghana
on the eastern edge of the basin close to the Togo–Ghana
(Nerquaye-Tetteh 1993; Bannerman 1994; Frempong
boundary. The sandstones and limestones are highly con-
and Kortatsi 1994; Dapaah-Siakwan and Gyau-Boakye
solidated and dip and thicken toward the coast in the
2000). Therefore, groundwater plays a vital role in the
southwest. In the northeastern part of the basin occur
domestic water supply and in farming economies and,
scattered surficial deposits of Neogene continental sedi-
furthermore, supplies the fairly large communities living
ments that unconformably overlie the Cretaceous-Eoc-
along the coastal strip between the outlet of the Volta
ene limestones and sandstones; these sediments are
River and the Ghanaian-Togo border. Locations are
mainly made up of unconsolidated to semi-consolidated
shown in Fig. 1.
limonitic argillaceous sands with gravelly beds at the
Many dug wells (<10 m deep) in Quaternary to Neo-
base. The central part of the basin, occupied by the Keta
gene clastic sediments are used for domestic water sup-
Lagoon, is dominated by Quaternary unconsolidated
ply, watering of livestock, and for dry-season irrigation
coastal sediments, marine sands, and gravels, which are
purposes. Furthermore, extensive drilling activities in the
on average 30 m thick around Keta, though they thicken
1950s confirmed the existence of deeper aquifers in Cre-
toward the Volta River estuary.
taceous-Eocene limestones, which have since been ex-
Four major aquifers in the Keta Basin are distin-
ploited for urban water supply. Hydrochemical analyses
guished according to the geography and the geological
of this deep groundwater indicate that the groundwater
setting (Nerquaye-Tetteh 1993):
quality in the Keta Basin is generally considered to be
usable for drinking water and agricultural purposes. 1. Weathered Dahomeyan gneisses along the northeast-
However, a major problem in drinking-water quality ern rim of the basin. They crop out around Akatsi and
and management of domestic water supply in the Keta are locally overlain by Neogene to Recent continental
Basin is salinization of groundwater in dug wells and in sedimentary deposits of sands and gravels. Ground-
deep boreholes (Gill 1969; Bannerman 1994). Many water occurs in both the weathered gneisses and surfi-
prospected well sites have not been completed due to sa- cial sediments.
linity problems in the aquifers, and existing deep wells 2. Surficial Neogene continental deposits of unconsoli-
and dug wells have been abandoned due to increasing sa- dated to semi-consolidated limonitic argillaceous
linity over time. In the absence of surface-water sources sands in the northeastern and central parts of the ba-
in close proximity of the communities, several attempts sin.
have been made to find sufficient groundwater resources 3. Cretaceous-Eocene marine limestones and sandstone
on which to base the public water supply. Infiltration of beds that are exploited for drinking water in the cen-
seawater into the groundwater has been observed in tral and southeastern parts of the basin; these units
some deep boreholes drilled along the coastal strip and constitute the major and most important deeper aqui-
saline groundwater exists in aquifers at shallow depths a fer in the Keta Basin.
few kilometres inland. 4. Quaternary coastal marine sands and gravels in the
Three major sources of chloride contamination are to Volta River estuary and Keta Lagoon area. These
be considered in this area: (1) seawater and brackish- surficial deposits of unconsolidated sand and gravel
water intrusion from the nearby Gulf of Guinea and the are generally associated with high groundwater re-
Keta Lagoon (Fig. 1b); (2) dissolved Cl originating from charge. However, areas below sea level may periodi-
sea-spray and marine aerosols deposited in the topsoil; cally undergo salinization due to seawater intrusion
and (3) evaporative enrichment. The objective of this (Gill 1969; Nerquaye-Tetteh 1993).
Seawater from the Gulf of Guinea and Surface water from the Volta River and Keta Lagoon
Seawater:
Ada Foah 48,800 19,000 8.10 0.12 0.709261
Keta 48,900 19,000 8.10 0.12 0.709248
Volta River:
Al Ada Foah 42,800 13,100 6.9 0.15 0.709244
A2 Ada Foah 731 190 0.19 5.26 0.711142
785 215 0.23 4.22 0.710860
Boreholes Rainy season 1996 Dry season 1998 Dug wells Rainy season 1996 Dry season 1998
Deep groundwater in weathered Dahomeyan gneiss Shallow groundwater in Quaternary marine sand and gravel
B1 Akatsi –13.2 –2.97 –14.2 –3.20 B20 Srogboe –19.1 –3.66 –18.3 –3.46
B2 Akatsi –10.9 –2.90 –13.3 –3.08 B21 Whuti –15.8 –3.14 –14.6 –2.86
B3 Akatsi –13.6 –2.83 –13.4 –2.76 B23 Anloga –15.5 –2.75 –13.8 –2.42
B25 Keta –22.1 –3.96 –16.9 –3.22
Dug wells Rainy season 1996 Dry season 1998 1326 Tegbi –17.3 –3.18 –15.4 –2.81
B27 Tegbi –17.8 –3.36 –14.9 –2.85
δ 2H δ18O δ 2H δ18O C2 Ada Foah –15.6 –2.86 –15.2 –2.75
C3 Ada Foah –12.0 –2.28 –12.4 –2.11
Shallow groundwater in Neogene continental sediments C4 Anyakor –15.8 –2.91 –14.9 –2.75
B6 Atsiame –16.8 –3.29 –15.1 –3.23
B11 Klikor –19.3 –3.57 –16.4 –3.03 Locations Rainy season 1996 Dry season 1998
B12 Klikor –16.1 –3.50 –15.3 –3.38
B13 Klikor –17.5 –3.85 –17.1 –3.55 δ 2H δ18O δ 2H δ18O
B18 Dabala –16.4 –3.13 –10.7 –2.04
B19 Dadala –15.0 –3.48 –13.7 –3.24 Seawater from the Gulf of Guinea and Surface water from the Vol-
C5 Badeku –14.3 –2.61 –12.6 –2.41 ta River and Keta Lagoon
C6 Badeku –15.2 –3.21 –14.4 –3.12
C7 Kasseh –14.5 –2.78 –12.9 –2.55 Seawater:
Ada Foah 0.2 –0.04
Boreholes Rainy season 1996 Dry season 1998 Keta 0.1 –0.02
However, highly saline deep groundwater observed in Majoube 1971). The overall enrichment for evaporation
Cretaceous-Eocene aquifers demonstrates that precau- under these conditions is εtotal=εv-l+∆εv-bl=−9.1+(−4.3)=
tions must be taken in near-coastal aquifers. The oxygen- −12.7‰ The initial δ18O composition is estimated to be
and hydrogen-isotope compositions of saline groundwa- –5‰ on the basis of the intersection between the LMWL
ter correlate with the local groundwater–seawater line, and the regression line, and the evaporative enrichment
and the distribution of 87Sr/86Sr ratios suggests that the is therefore approximately 3‰ (see Fig. 5).
major source of saline groundwater is the result of a sig- The loss from evaporation can be modelled according
nificant modern marine influence. to Rayleigh distillation:
The quality of shallow groundwater is of much more
ε18Ototal*lnƒ=δ18Ogw−δ18Oprec=3.00‰ (6)
concern. Many water wells and dug wells have been
abandoned due to increasing salinity problems over time. yielding a residual water fraction ƒ of 0.79 and thus an
However, all the listed dug wells are presently in use for average evaporation loss of approximately 21%. Howev-
domestic water supply, though these groundwaters have er, this value indicates that evaporation loss alone cannot
a wide range of Cl contents, with concentrations of as account for the excess of Cl of more than ×4 in compari-
much as ~500 mg/L, which exceeds the limit for a satis- son to the initial composition of 50–100 mg/L estimated
factory potable water supply. for shallow groundwaters. Furthermore, the scatter in the
The oxygen- and hydrogen-isotope compositions of Cl and δ18O distributions shown in Fig. 6 indicates mul-
shallow groundwater samples have larger variations than tiple sources of Cl.
do the compositions of deep groundwater, which is to A source that can contribute to the Cl budget in sur-
some extent also reflected in fluctuations between wet face water and shallow groundwaters is sea-spray and
and dry seasons (Figs. 4 and 5, Table 2 ). These varia- aerosols in coastal regions exposed to onshore winds
tions are probably the result of local recharge events and (Berner and Berner 1987; Herut et al. 1993). The prox-
evaporation from the unsaturated zone, which mean that imity of the sea and the occurrence of large open sand
seasonal fluctuations are preserved in shallow groundwa- flats, typically associated with brackish-water lagoon en-
ter reservoirs. However, some dug wells are constantly vironments, could lead to wind- and rain-borne marine-
open, which means that evaporation also takes place derived salts deposited in the topsoils, which could be
from the free water surfaces. the cause of the relatively high Cl and Sr contents ob-
Most groundwater samples from shallow aquifers served in many dug wells. The presence of dissolved
have isotopic compositions that are below the GMWL modern marine Sr in shallow groundwaters is comple-
and plot along a straight mixing line that is close to the mented by the Sr-isotope data obtained from the Quater-
local seawater–groundwater mixing line. However, the nary aquifers on the coastal strip. A significant correla-
Cl contents observed in shallow groundwaters are sub- tion exists between 87Sr/86Sr ratios and reciprocal Sr, in-
stantially below the concentrations expected according to dicating a mixing line with the isotopic composition of
seawater intrusion and, consequently, evaporative en- modern marine Sr as one end member (Fig. 7).
richment has to be considered. The maximum average The Cl and δ18O distributions, currently observed in
evaporation loss expressed by the present data can be shallow groundwaters (group 1), have no appreciable
calculated according to a method demonstrated by Clark difference with regard to aquifer type, suggesting that
and Fritz (1997). To calculate the evaporative loss, the some sort of marine influence, e.g., brackish water from
local evaporation slope, the initial isotopic composition, the lagoons and/or seaspray, is most likely also responsi-
and the annual mean temperature for the area need to be ble for the enhanced Cl contents recorded in Neogene
known. The slope of the local evaporation line reflects aquifers. However, the strontium isotope compositions
the influence of varying local conditions but depends of shallow groundwater from Neogene aquifers do not
largely on relative humidity. The slope of the regression explicitly indicate a modern marine influence but rather
line is calculated from equation (4) to be ~5, which cor- multiple sources of dissolved Sr. The relatively high
responds to a relative humidity (h) of approximately 87Sr/86Sr ratios and the scatter of the values indicate that
70% (Gonfiantini 1986). This figure is in accordance most of the dissolved Sr includes a variety of highly ra-
with the reported humidity of 65–75% (Dickson and diogenic weathering products from the Proterozoic crys-
Benneh 1995). The kinetic effect (∆ε), in terms of hu- talline basement rocks. The shallow Neogene aquifers
midity between the boundary layer (bl) and water vapour are located farther inland in the lagoonal environments
(v), can be described with respect to δ18O by the follow- of the Keta Basin. Furthermore, surface water from the
ing relationship: Volta River and brackish water from the Keta Lagoon are
characterized by variable but relatively high 87Sr/86Sr ra-
∆ε18Obl-v=14.2(1-h)‰ (5)
tios, which may also contribute to the strontium-isotope
(Gonfiantini 1986), i.e., for shallow groundwater in the signature of the shallow groundwater in Neogene aqui-
Keta Basin, ∆ε18O=14.2(1−0.70)=4.3‰. The mean an- fers.
nual temperature for the Keta Basin is 27 °C. The frac-
tionation factor α for 18O between water and vapour at
this temperature corresponds to 103lnα18Ow-v~9.1‰
(Notations are: ln, natural logarithm; w,water; v, vapour;
Summary and Conclusions Bannerman RR (1994) Appraisal of the limestone aquifer of the
Keta Basin, Ghana. In: Soveri J, Suokko T (eds) Future
groundwater resources at risk. Publ 222. International
Strontium-isotope compositions in groundwater and sur- Association for Hydrological Sciences, Wallingford, pp 315–
face water in the Keta Basin primarily reflect the litho- 321
logical characteristics of aquifers and catchments as a re- Berner EK, Berner RA (1987) The global water cycle, geochemis-
sult of weathering processes and water–rock interactions. try and environment. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Bison PL, Normand M, Piovesana F, Zuppi GM (1989) Contri-
In addition, however, strontium-isotopes are sensitive in- bution des isotopes des l’environnement á l’étude de la
dicators of modern marine influence. Thus, strontium- recharge naturelle des aquiféres fissurés du bouclier sou-
isotope distributions as well as oxygen- and hydrogen- danien au Burkina-Faso [Contribution of environmental iso-
isotope compositions demonstrate the mixing of fresh topes to the study of the natural recharge of fissured aquifers
of the Sudan shield in Burkina Faso]. Hydrogéologie 3:201–
water and seawater in the Keta Lagoon and the Volta 214
River estuary. Burke WH, Denison RE, Hetherington EA, Koepnik RB, Nelson
The oxygen- and hydrogen-isotope compositions of HF, Otto J (1982) Variation of sea water 87Sr/86Sr throughout
samples collected from shallow and deep groundwater the Phanerozoic time. Geology 10:516–519
plot along a seawater mixing line or evaporation line. Clark ID, Fritz P (1997) Environmental isotopes in hydrogeology.
Lewis Publishers, New York
High Cl contents (>1,500 mg/L) in deep groundwater Coleman ML, Shepherd TJ, Durham JJ, Rouse JE, Moore GR
suggest seawater intrusion as the major reason for saline (1982) Reduction of water with zinc for hydrogen isotope
groundwater in these wells, and this evidence is comple- analysis. Anal Chem 54:993–995
mented by a well-defined mixing line for strontium iso- Craig H (1961) Isotopic variations in meteoric water. Science 133:
1702–1703
topes with seawater as one end member. Dansgaard WF (1964) Stable isotopes in precipitation. Tellus 16:
The salinity of shallow groundwater generally does 436–439
not exceed 500 mg/L Cl. Evaporative loss alone cannot Dapaah-Siakwan S, Gyau-Boakye P (2000) Hydrogeologic
explain the excess of Cl in these aquifers. A marine in- framework and borehole yields in Ghana. Hydrogeol J 8(4):
405–416
fluence is significant in the Quaternary near-coastal Dickson KB, Benneh G (1995) A new geography of Ghana, 3rd
aquifers, as indicated by a well-defined mixing line for revised edn. Longman, Malaysia
strontium isotopes with modern seawater as one end Faure G (1986) Stable isotope geochemistry, 2nd edn. Springer,
member. A similar straightforward relationship with re- Berlin Heidelberg New York
spect to the strontium-isotope distributions cannot be Frempong DG, Kortatsi BK (1994) Some problems associated
with the development of groundwater resources in Ghana. In:
demonstrated in groundwater collected from Neogene Suokko T, Soveri J (eds) Future groundwater resources at risk.
aquifers, which are located in the lagoonal environment Publ 222. International Association for Hydrological Sciences,
in the central part of the Keta Basin, probably because of Wallingford, pp 389–398
multiple sources of dissolved strontium in these aquifers Gill HE (1969) A ground-water reconnaissance of the Republic of
Ghana, with a description of geohydrologic provinces. US
as well as in the brackish water of the lagoons. However, Geological Survey, Water-Supply Paper 1757-K. Washington,
brackish lagoon water and/or seaspray and aerosols are DC, 37 pp
probably the sources of the enhanced Cl contents in shal- Gonfiantini R (1986) Environmental isotopes in lake studies. In:
low Neogene aquifers. Fritz P, Fontes J-Ch (eds) Handbook of environmental isotope
geochemistry, The terrestrial environment, part B, vol 2. Else-
The interpretations derived from environmental iso- vier, Amsterdam, pp 113–168
topes of shallow and deep groundwaters and surface wa- Herut B, Starinsky A, Katz A (1993) Strontium in rainwater from
ters from the Keta Basin demonstrate that the multi-iso- Israel: Sources, isotopes and chemistry. Earth Planet Sci Lett
tope approach provides a useful supplement to tradition- 120:77–84
al hydrochemical analyses in order to identify the origin Hodell DA, Mueller PA, Garrido JR (1991) Variations in the stron-
tium isotopic composition of seawater during the Neogene.
and sources of saline groundwaters. Geology 19:24–27
Jørgensen NO, Holm PM (1994) Isotope studies (18O/16O, D/H
Acknowledgements This project was supported by DANIDA, the and 87Sr/86Sr) of saline groundwater in Denmark. In: Soveri J,
Danish International Development Authority, grant no. 104.Dan. Suokko T (eds) Future groundwater resources at risk. Publ
8L/300. The mass-spectrometer facilities were funded by the 222. International Association for Hydrological Sciences, Wal-
Danish Natural Science Foundation. Reviews by F.J. Pearson and lingford, pp 231–238
H.N. Waber greatly improved the manuscript. Jørgensen NO, Holm PM (1995) Strontium-isotope studies of
chloride-contaminated groundwater, Denmark. Hydrogeol J
3(2):52–57
References Joseph A, Aranyossy J-F (1989) Mise en evidence d’un gradient
de continentalité inverse en Afrique de l’Ouest en relation
Acheampong SY, Hess JM (2000) Origin of the shallow ground- avec les lignes de grain [Discovery of reversed continentality
water system in the southern Voltaian Sedimentary Basin of gradient in West Africa associated with lines of storm rainfall].
Ghana: an isotopic approach. J Hydrol 233(1–4):37–53 Hydrogéologie 3:215–218
Akiti TT (1987) Environmental isotope study of groundwater in Kortatsi BK, Sekpey NK (1993) Chemical and isotope evidence
crystalline rocks of the Accra Plains (Ghana). In: Wand U, for the origin of groundwater in the crystalline basement com-
Strauch G (eds) Isotopes in nature. Academy of Sciences of plex of the upper regions of Ghana. In: Proc African Geologi-
the GDR, Central Institute of Isotope and Radiation Research, cal Conf, Accra, Ghana, pp 221–242
Leipzig, pp 107–121 Loehnert EP (1988) Major chemical and isotope variations in sur-
Akpati BN (1978) Geological structure and evolution of the Keta face and subsurface waters of West Africa. J Afr Earth Sci
Basin, Ghana, West Africa. Geol Soc Am Bull 89:129–132 7(3):579–588