1

droit du commerce lectronique:

un droit diffrent ?
vincent gautrais
professeur titulaire
directeur CRDP
titulaire de la chaire L.R. Wilson
facult de droit CRDP universit de montral
www.twitter.com/gautrais
www.gautrais.com
 faits

Michel Serres
Les nouvelles technologies :
rvolution culturelle et cognitive

2
 faits

ds le moment o change le couplage support

/ message, cest--dire le moment de
linvention de lcriture, alors dans nos
civilisations, tout change !

3
 faits

Aujourdhui nous navons peut tre pas

conscience de la nouveaut extraordinaire des
temps dans lesquels nous vivons.

4
 faits

rvolution des faits

5
 faits

rvolution de lconomie

6
 faits

rvolution des technologies

7
 faits

rvolution de la culture

8
immigrants v. natives
(Mark Prensky, Digital natives, Digital faits
immigrants, 2001)

9
immigrants v. natives
(Mark Prensky, Digital natives, Digital faits
immigrants, 2001)

10
immigrants v. natives
(Mark Prensky, Digital natives, Digital faits
immigrants, 2001)

11
 John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know
1. Take the long view
2. The web isnt the Net
3. Disruption is a feature, not as bug
4. Think cology, not Economics
5. Complexity is the New Reality
6. The Network is not the computer
7. The Web is changing
8. Huxley and Orwell are the Bookends of our Future
9. Our Intellectual Property Regime is no Longer Fit for
Purpose

12
 1. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Take the long view

Rapport au temps diffrent: trop bas sur le court terme
Ex: long tail; FB and control;
Leffet de limprimerie 17 ans aprs?

13
 2. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know
The web isnt the Net
Chris Anderson Web is dead! Long Live the Internet
Over the past few years, one of the most important shifts in the
digital world has been the move from the wide-open Web to
semiclosed platforms that use the Internet for transport but not
the browser for display.

14
 3. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Disruption is a feature, not as bug

Difficile contrler par nature
Doit rester neutre

15
 4. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Think Ecology, not Economics

Ne plus se baser sur la raret

16
 5. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Complexity is the New Reality

Nombre de participants
Nombre des interactions

17
 6. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

The Network is not the computer

Extriorisation de linformation
Concurrence de lordinateur (tlphone, iPad, etc.)

18
 7. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

The Web is changing

Web 1.0
Web 2.0
Web 3.0 (assez de mtadonnes pour permettre une
comprhension au pralable)

19
 8. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Huxley and Orwell are the Bookends of our Future

Aldous Huxley believed that we would be destroyed by the

things we love, while George Orwell thought we would be
destroyed by the things we fear.

Beaucoup de passions

20
 9. John Naughton, The Internet:
Everything you ever need to know

Our Intellectual Property Regime is no Longer Fit for

Purpose
This is a disagreeable but inescapable fact as inescapable in
its way as the fact that young adults tend to drink too much
alcohol. The only way to stop copying is to shut down the net.
There's nothing wrong with intellectual property (or alcohol), per
se, but our copyright laws are now so laughably out of touch with
reality that they are falling into disrepute.

21
 droit

rvolution du droit ?

22
easterbrook vs lessig
 easterbrook

...the best way to learn the law applicable to

specialized endeavors is to study general rules. Lots
of cases deal with sales of horses; others deal with
people kicked by horses; still more deal with the
licensing and racing of horses, or with the care
veterinarians give to horses, or with prizes at horse
shows. Any effort to collect these strands into a
course on 'The Law of the Horse' is doomed to be
shallow and to miss unifying principles.
 lessig
My claim is to the contrary. I agree that our
aim should be courses that illuminate the entire
law, but unlike Easterbrook, I believe that there
is an important general point that comes from
thinking in particular about how law and
cyberspace connect.

This general point is about the limits on law as a

regulator and about the techniques for escaping
those limits .
dialogue dautistes
neutralit technologique est lillustration de
cette volont malheureuse dautonomie
0 tat de la neutralit technologique

1 la neutralit technologique est indfinissable

2 la neutralit technologique ne sert rien

30
 1
droit du commerce lectronique:
un droit diffrent ?
vincent gautrais
professeur titulaire
directeur CRDP
titulaire de la chaire L.R. Wilson
facult de droit CRDP universit de montral
www.twitter.com/gautrais
www.gautrais.com