Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
to the patient, and likely to make the hair oily, even TABLE I.-PITYRIASIS CAPITIS (DANDRUFF)-
when not used excessively. CLASSIFICATION OF RESULTS OF TREATMENr
Although satisfactory results had been obtained Mild Moderate Severe
degree degree degree
with the foregoing, it seemed that each had dis-
,
advantages rendering it unacceptable for continual Rapid improvement...... 4 days 8 days 12 days
use. What I sought was a product cosmetically
Moderate improvement. . . 6 days 12 days 18 days
Slow improvement........ 10 days 20 days 30 days
acceptable, non-greasy and non-irritant to the +
+ +
scalp which would rapidly control the condition.
Volume 2 of "New Products Index"4 covering for 30 days or longer before being brought under
pharmaceutical specialties marketed in Canada up control was evaluated as "slow improvement".
to July 15, 1956, listed details of Sabol, a product In connection with the foregoing Tables IIA,
which appeared to fulfil all criteria. Subsequently IIB and IIC, it should be noted that:
I wrote to the company to request trial samples. 1. No particular remedy was reserved for any
In the evaluation that followed, patients were particular type of case. Patients as they attended
divided into three groups of 34 patients per group, were allotted remedies in sequence. For example,
treated with: (a) the salicylic acid lotion; (b) a the first patient in this survey of 102 cases was
proprietary preparation containing selenium sul-
fide; (c) Sabol. treated with salicylic acid lotion, the second with
The results of investigations of these 102 patients selenium sulfide, and the third with Sabol, whilst
the fourth patient in the series reverted to salicylic
are summarized in Tables IIA, IIB and IIC, whilst
Table I represents a yardstick for evaluating these acid lotion.
tables. For example, dandruff of moderate degree, 2. Each of the Tables IIA, IIB and IIC elaborates
brought under control within eight days, was re- principally results on males. This was unavoidable
corded in Table I as showing "rapid improvement". as the whole assessment was carried out at a
Conversely, severe dandruff requiring treatment Royal Canadian Air Force Station.
TABLE IIA.-SALICYLIc ACID LOTION
Improvement Degree of
Total No. pityriasis
of patients Patients None Slow Mod. Rapid capitis Side effects Comments
34 Male 1 x Severe Male
2 x Moderate One man complained of
3 x Severe stinging of scalp.
28 4 x Mild
men 5 x Moderate
6 x Severe
7 x Severe Stinging of scalp
8 x Moderate
9 x Moderate
10 x Moderate
11 x Mild
12 x Moderate
13 x Mild
14 x Moderate
15 x Mild
16 x Moderate
17 x Moderate
18 x Severe
19 x Severe
20 x Moderate
21 x Mild
22 x Moderate
23 x Severe
24 x Moderate
25 x Mild
26 x Mild
27 x Mild
28 x Severe
0 6 12 10
6 Female 1 x Severe Stinging of scalp Female
women 2 x Severe All women improved
3 x Severe rapidly. Two women
4 x Severe patients complained of
5 x Severe Stinging of scalp stinging of scalp.
6 x Severe
0 0 0 6
ASSBSSMENT-Good.
A rather crude but effective preparation; effective in all cases surveyed.
Liable to cause stingingoof the female scalp.
116 CASPERS: PITYRIASIS CAPITIS (DANDRUFF) Ca n.Ad. M. J.
Jtuly 15, 1958, vol. 79
S1
TABILE 11B. SELENIUM1 SUFIDE
I 10 piovemnllod. Deqree of
10otal N\o. pityrisuis
of patieWN11 I'a1ieot.t N'one Slow JI10(d. Rapid capitis Side effects Cotitnenits
34 Male 1 x Sever e
2 x Moderate
28 3 x Moderate
litlel 4 x Moderate
5 x Sever e IEX(e*.live oiliness 'Thrllee ien (omllp)lainIed
6 x Moderate of excessive oiliness.
7 Moderate
8 x ModeIrate
9 x Moderate
10 Moderate
11 x Moderate Elxcessive oiliness
12 x Mild
13
14
x x Mild
Moderate
15 x Moderate
16 x Sever e
17 x Moderate
18 x Moderate
19 x Severe
20 x Moderate Excessive oiliness
21 x Moderate
22 x Mild
23 x Moderate
24 x Moderate
25 x Moderate
26 x Moderate
27 x Sever e
28 x Moderate
0 6 20 2
6 Femiiale 1 x Severe
wN omen 2 x Sever e Clonsidered by
3 Moder ate patient to be
4 x Moder ate "messy". Onie womnan consi(lered
5 x Moderate it n;iessv.
6 x Mild
1 3 2 0
Ass1.;,s.S1ENT- Fair/.
The least effective of the three p)el)alationls surveyed. Liable to cause excessive oiliniess of the scalp) duriing treatment.
tion is more effective in women than men. Un- the patient is also advised to avoid activities which
fortunately it is liable to cause stinging and increase perspiration and sebaceous activity.
irritation to the female scalp. The better results
obtained with women may in part have been SUMMARY
attributable to higher standards of personal hygiene
and their more conscientious carrying out of The problem of pityriasis capitis is surveyed. A
instructions. discussion of the etiology of the condition is followed
C. Proprietary product containing selenium sul- by an account of the pathology, clinical features, diag-
nosis, and complications of this annoying complaint.
fide.-This preparation appeared to be the least Local and general treatment are considered, and the
effective of the three. Although all men responded scope and value of the latter are considered in rela-
to treatment, only two responded rapidly and the tion to the former. Mention is made of the effectiveness
majority improved only moderately rapidly, or of benzalkonium chloride in local treatment, and results
slowly. Three patients (two with a moderate of personal investigations are elaborated.
degree and one with a severe degree of pityriasis
capitis) complained of excessive oiliness of the The opinions expressed in this paper are those of the
author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the
scalp during treatment. One of the six women R.C.A.F. I acknowledge gratefully the ready co-operation
failed to respond at all, and no woman responded received from Frank W. Homer Ltd. and their kindness
rapidly to treatment. One patient complained of in forwarding me samples for clinical appraisal. My grati-
tude is also extended to Squadron Leader P. Laird Gibbs,
the messiness of the preparation. M.D., Senior Medical Officer, R.C.A.F. Station, Goose Bay,
Local treatment.-This has been dealt with to Labrador, for his encouragement and advice in the com-
some extent in the evaluation of the three fore- piling of this work.
going remedies. From time to time the disease REFERENCES
may take on a more acute phase (seborrhaeic
1. ANDREWS, G. C.: Diseases of the skin, 4th ed., W. B.
dermatitis) with areas of erythema and even Saunders Company, Philadelphia, 1954, p. 168.
weeping. It is possible that these acute outbreaks 2. HODGES, J. P. S.: Lancet, 2: 225, 1951.
are due to secondary infection. It has been noted 3. MARTIN-SCOTr, I.: Brit. J. Dermat., 64: 257, 1952.
4. HUGHES, F. M., editor: New Products Index, Vol. 2,
for some years2-5 that cetrimide appears to be an Canadian -Pharmaceutical Association, Toronto, 1956,
effective application in cases of seborrhzea and p. 68.
5. NEVILLE-SMITH, C. H.: Lancet, 2: 314, 1951.
recently, within the United Kingdom, the Pharma- Idem: Ibid., 1: 1016, 1952.
ceuticals Division of Imperial Chemical Industries 6. ROXBURGH, A. C.: Common skin diseases, 10th ed., H.
K. Lewis & Co. Ltd., London, 1955, p. 158.
Ltd. have introduced under the trade name Cetav- 7. SPEIRs, R. J. 0. AND BROTHERWOOD, R. W.: Practitioner,
lon P.C. (P.C. = pro capite), a lotion concentrate 179: 78, 1957.
8. YATER, W. M.: Fundamentals of internal medicine, 3rd
containing 17.5%o cetrimide as an active principle. ed., Appleton-Century-Crofts Company Inc., New
Speirs and Brotherwood7 reported the effect of this York, 1949, p. 1113.
preparation on 26 cases taken from their practice
in south-east London, and concluded that Cetavlon R.SUMEJ
P.C. was an effective, safe and pleasant preparation Les pellicules sont composees de cellules de la couche
for use against seborrhceic dermatitis. cornee qui se detachent de l'epiderme par l'action d'un
It is well known that seborrhoeic dermatitis as a processus infectieux 'a bas bruit contracte le plus souvent
dans les salons de coiffure. Le pityriasis sec et le st6atoide
complication of pityriasis capitis often benefits envahissent peu a peu le cuir chevelu et menent a la
from ultraviolet light. In such instances it is ad- calvitie precoce. Le diagnostic differentiel de cette affection
comporte le psoriasis et le tinea capitis. Les complications
vantageous to wash the scalp on the day before qu'elle peut entrainer comportent la furonculose, l'impetigo,
application, with mild erythema exposures given les fissures des plis post-auriculaires, des coins du nez et
thereafter at intervals of five to seven days to the des levres.
top and sides of the scalp. Dans sa recherche d'un traitement satisfaisant l'auteur
General treatment.-Within recent years the fit l'essai d'une formule 'a base d'acide salicylique, de
value of constitutional measures in the treatment perchlorure de mercure, d'huiles de ricin et de lavande, le
tout dissous dans l'alcool 'a friction. Cette preparation
of pityriasis capitis has been questioned, and fre- demande un usage prolong6 et produit une sensation de
quently it is held that such measures are of no brculure sur une peau irritee. II passa ensuite a l'emploi
value whatsoever. It is my own impression that d'une solution de sulfure de sel6nium dont les propriet6s the-
general measures have a very definite place in the rapeutiques n'etaient pas suffisantes a faire accepter l'odeur
over-all treatment of this troublesome condition. caracteristique et la tendance 'a rendre la chevelure huileuse.
Une solution de chlorure de benzalkonium vendue dans le
Many patients with pityriasis capitis or frank commerce sous le nom de Sabol (marque deposee) donna
seborrhaeic dermatitis have low basal metabolic les meilleurs resultats avec le moins d'inconvenieRt. Les cas
rates, or on questioning admit to consuming an les plus rebels s'ameliorerent rapidement. L'auteur met les
excess of carbohydrates, fats or alcohol. In some malades en garde contre la conjonctivite qui peut resulter
du contact de ce produit avec les yeux. II fait aussi mention
instances a deficiency of vitamin B has also been de l'emploi d'une lotion 'a base de cetrimide (17.5%)
noted. It is therefore my practice to supplement vendue sous le nom de Cetavlon (marque deposeee). En
local treatment with general measures. Alcohol, plus du traitement topique, l'amelioration de l'etat general,
chocolate and large amounts of cream, butter, milk la correction d'un metabolisme basal insuffisant et l'obser-
vance d'un regime approprie enrichi de vitamin B peuvent
and sweets are forbidden, and any suspected contribuer au bien-etre du sujet et ne doivent pas etre
vitamin B deficiency is rectified. In severe cases neg lges.