Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ISSUES
David Throsby
DE LA CULTURE
some current issues
David Throsby*
Artistic labour is characterised by features that combine to set artists apart from other
• L’ÉCONOMIE
workers when viewed in terms of their labour market behaviour. Here, the value of a
work of art can be simplified down to two essential elements – the work’s economic
value, and its cultural value, measured in terms of criteria of artistic worth such as
aesthetic, spiritual, symbolic, and other types of value. In regard to the weights on
economic and cultural value in the objective function, the model will allow for a range
of financial and artistic motivations as stimuli to creative work. At one extreme, a
unitary weight attached to cultural value and a zero weight to economic value would
indicate that the artist’s aims relate purely to the quality of the artwork itself, with
complete disregard for its financial prospects. At the other extreme, a unitary weight on
economic value and a zero weight on cultural value would imply that the artist is in the
game solely for the money. The majority of artists in reality probably lie somewhere
between these two polar cases.
L’activité artistique présente des caractéristiques qui peuvent opposer le profil de l’ar-
tiste à celui des autres travailleurs. Son activité s’organise en fait autour de la création
de deux types de valeurs : une valeur économique liée au revenu monétaire qu’il peut
escompter retirer de son activité à des fins de consommation ; et une valeur culturelle
identifiable en termes de critères artistiques ou encore, esthétiques, spirituels ou sym-
boliques. Selon les pondérations accordées à ces deux types de valeurs dans sa
fonction-objectif, on peut expliciter le rôle relatif des motivations économiques et artis-
tiques dans son offre de travail. Il existe alors deux cas extrêmes, celui où le compor-
tement répond exclusivement à des motivations artistiques, et celui où son comporte-
ment s’explique exclusivement par la maximisation de son revenu monétaire. En fait, la
majorité des artistes se situe entre ces deux extrêmes : s’ils sont motivés par une vision
créative, ils savent qu’il leur faut aussi satisfaire des contraintes en termes de revenu
monétaire.
*
Professor of Economics, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia. Email:
david.throsby@mq.edu.au
1. Introduction
2001, Ch. 6], the decision variables can be specified as the amounts of la-
bour the artist chooses to allocate to different tasks or to producing different
types of output. Such a proposition conceals some potentially strong as-
sumptions about the very nature of the creative act. The artist in whatever
artform allocates time to different tasks involving thinking and doing. Some
require imagination, others the application of technical skills, in still others
these ingredients cannot be separated out; all of them come together to
constitute creative activity. For the mediocre artist large amounts of time
spent at these tasks will still yield work judged to be of little economic or
cultural value; for the so-called genius, the reverse obtains. Thus differences
between artists in the location of the relationship between time spent and
value produced are, in this construction, a measure (other things being
equal) of differences in creativity, in much the same way as in microecono-
mic analysis differences between production functions in input/output space
measure differences in technology.
Clearly the objective function in this model would, as in most decision
models, be subject to a set of constraints. In line with our earlier observa-
tions, it is not difficult to see that the most important constraint on the
artist’s time allocation is likely to be a financial one. Like anyone else artists
have to live, and unless they are fortunate enough to have a wealthy spouse,
a substantial inheritance, a beneficent patron, or an arts council grant, they
must earn an income in order to pay for food, clothing and shelter. Thus the
income constraint in this model can be entered as a minimum constraint on
the economic value of the work or works produced.
The income constraint may affect the production of value directly in a
Document téléchargé depuis www.cairn.info - - - 106.51.27.6 - 26/01/2020 15:48 - © Dalloz
the creative process is depicted as one where the artistic impulse is media-
ted by the economic circumstances and aspirations of the artist.
A formal presentation of a more precisely articulated version of this model
has been put forward by Bryant and Throsby [2006] in a study which inclu-
des some empirical estimation. The study raises the issue of the distinction,
if one exists, between creativity and talent. The latter concept is widely
referred to by artists, critics and consumers as a means of differentiating
between good and not-so-good artists. In common usage, talent relates as
much to technical skill and proficiency as to creativity, the latter being a
more complex quality that is correspondingly more difficult to measure.
Artistic labour markets operate within the larger spheres of the demand
for and supply of labour in the economy as a whole. As is well recognised,
labour markets across the board in many countries are undergoing radical
changes with greater casualisation and increased occupational mobility in
the workforce. Markets for artistic labour have been caught up in these
changes; as Menger [2006] argues, long-term employment in the arts has
been replaced by a project-based system of production relying on short-
term hiring, large parts of business risk are transferred downwards onto the
workforce, and artists learn to manage risk and to stay alive through mul-
tiple job-holding, occupational versatility, diversification of job portfolios
and occasional income transfers from social security or other sources. Des-
pite manifold deterrents to an artistic career, an excess supply of artists
persists in many countries, attributable in part to the non-pecuniary attrac-
tion of work as an artist as mentioned above.
Document téléchargé depuis www.cairn.info - - - 106.51.27.6 - 26/01/2020 15:48 - © Dalloz
The areas of research and writing on the economics of artistic work that
are discussed in this paper have a number of implications for cultural policy.
I shall confine myself to three brief points.
First, it can be observed in a number of countries at present that a shift is
underway from a predominantly artistic focus for cultural policy to an em-
phasis on the cultural industries and the economic potential deriving from
the production of cultural goods and services. Such a shift affects artistic
labour in several ways. On the one hand it implies, as noted above, a move
Document téléchargé depuis www.cairn.info - - - 106.51.27.6 - 26/01/2020 15:48 - © Dalloz
where shortage of time and poor remuneration are the chief constraints on
the development of an artist’s career. At the same time, for some artists it is
not so much time or income that are most needed, but the opportunity to
have work seen, performed, or published, indicating a requirement for po-
licy measures that target the dissemination rather than necessarily the pro-
duction of artistic product. Furthermore, demand-side interventions to im-
prove the operation of thin markets for artistic goods and services may also
be recommended. These considerations ramify in turn into the educational
arena, where the careers of most artists begin. It is increasingly recognised
that training in the creative arts does not necessarily have to lead to a
lifetime as a professional practitioner; rather the creative skills that are ac-
quired at art schools, in conservatoria, etc. are applicable in a wide range of
areas, and can prepare students for employment in rewarding occupations
far removed from the core creative arts.
Finally, we return to the fundamental issue of value creation. Democratic
governments have a variety of objectives, and although in the arena of
policy formation the voice of the economist is often heard most loudly, there
are other non-economic outcomes that the public sector is bound to deliver.
In regard to culture and the arts in general, and the role of the individual
creative artist in particular, a balance in policy-making between the genera-
tion of economic and cultural value would seem always to be an appropriate
ideal towards which governments should strive to progress.
References
Document téléchargé depuis www.cairn.info - - - 106.51.27.6 - 26/01/2020 15:48 - © Dalloz