5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1

DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3
300.00 300.00 -
1 1/1/1985 31 91.85 246.01 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 377.56 377.56 -
2 2/1/1985 28 85.82 207.62 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 366.70 366.70 -
3 3/1/1985 31 109.60 293.54 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 516.28 516.28 -
4 4/1/1985 30 104.60 271.12 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 698.62 698.62 -
5 5/1/1985 31 47.83 128.10 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 666.43 666.43 -
6 6/1/1985 30 70.77 183.44 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 683.71 683.71 -
7 7/1/1985 31 29.44 78.84 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 618.58 618.58 -
8 8/1/1985 31 18.34 49.12 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 559.64 559.64 -
9 9/1/1985 30 15.52 40.22 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 449.49 449.49 -
10 10/1/1985 31 56.57 151.52 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 432.56 432.56 -
11 11/1/1985 30 51.07 132.36 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 330.84 330.84 -
12 12/1/1985 31 87.89 235.41 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 317.83 317.83 -
13 1/1/1986 31 98.65 264.22 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 413.61 413.61 -
14 2/1/1986 28 124.90 302.17 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 497.29 497.29 -
15 3/1/1986 31 106.51 285.27 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 638.60 638.60 -
16 4/1/1986 30 71.93 186.45 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 736.27 736.27 -
17 5/1/1986 31 30.30 81.15 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 657.13 657.13 -
18 6/1/1986 30 19.50 50.54 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 541.51 541.51 -
19 7/1/1986 31 17.59 47.11 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 444.66 444.66 -
20 8/1/1986 31 16.41 43.96 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 380.55 380.55 -
21 9/1/1986 30 9.42 24.42 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 254.60 254.60 -
22 10/1/1986 31 26.86 71.95 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - 41.90 126.55 158.10 200.00 1.00
23 11/1/1986 30 127.69 330.98 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 296.89 296.89 1.00
24 12/1/1986 31 83.01 222.32 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 270.79 270.79 1.00
25 1/1/1987 31 129.70 347.38 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 449.73 449.73 1.00
 5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1
DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3
26 2/1/1987 28 148.37 358.94 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 590.18 590.18 1.00
27 3/1/1987 31 136.63 365.96 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 812.18 812.18 1.00
28 4/1/1987 30 71.76 186.01 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 909.41 909.41 1.00
29 5/1/1987 31 59.80 160.16 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 909.28 909.28 1.00
30 6/1/1987 30 31.34 81.23 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 824.35 824.35 1.00
31 7/1/1987 31 17.13 45.87 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 726.25 726.25 1.00
32 8/1/1987 31 10.47 28.05 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 646.25 646.25 1.00
33 9/1/1987 30 13.28 34.42 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 530.29 530.29 1.00
34 10/1/1987 31 9.19 24.61 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 386.45 386.45 1.00
35 11/1/1987 30 23.27 60.31 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 212.67 212.67 1.00
36 12/1/1987 31 74.31 199.03 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - 36.72 211.70 163.28 200.00 2.00
37 1/1/1988 31 52.38 140.30 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - 28.15 140.30 171.85 200.00 3.00
38 2/1/1988 29 154.20 386.38 12.53 85.31 213.76 226.29 - - 226.29 360.09 360.09 3.00
39 3/1/1988 31 185.76 497.54 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 713.67 713.67 3.00
40 4/1/1988 30 85.42 221.42 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 846.31 846.31 3.00
41 5/1/1988 31 17.45 46.73 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 732.75 732.75 3.00
42 6/1/1988 30 25.18 65.26 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 631.85 631.85 3.00
43 7/1/1988 31 14.48 38.77 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 526.66 526.66 3.00
44 8/1/1988 31 13.03 34.90 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 453.50 453.50 3.00
45 9/1/1988 30 12.12 31.41 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 334.53 334.53 3.00
46 10/1/1988 31 10.55 28.27 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - 5.65 162.79 194.35 200.00 4.00
47 11/1/1988 30 174.72 452.86 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 418.77 418.77 4.00
48 12/1/1988 31 116.60 312.29 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 482.64 482.64 4.00
49 1/1/1989 31 125.71 336.69 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 650.88 650.88 4.00
50 2/1/1989 28 153.18 370.58 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 802.98 802.98 4.00
51 3/1/1989 31 124.86 334.41 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 993.43 993.43 4.00
 5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1
DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3
52 4/1/1989 30 106.54 276.15 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 180.80 - 269.58 1,180.80 1,000.00 4.00
53 5/1/1989 31 90.96 243.64 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 83.35 - 243.64 1,083.35 1,000.00 4.00
54 6/1/1989 30 79.47 205.98 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 39.81 - 205.98 1,039.81 1,000.00 4.00
55 7/1/1989 31 42.17 112.94 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 968.97 968.97 4.00
56 8/1/1989 31 20.39 54.61 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 915.53 915.53 4.00
57 9/1/1989 30 11.49 29.78 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 794.94 794.94 4.00
58 10/1/1989 31 11.29 30.24 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 656.73 656.73 4.00
59 11/1/1989 30 31.75 82.30 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 504.94 504.94 4.00
60 12/1/1989 31 79.47 212.86 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 469.39 469.39 4.00
61 1/1/1990 31 65.51 175.46 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 476.40 476.40 4.00
62 2/1/1990 28 111.09 268.74 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 526.66 526.66 4.00
63 3/1/1990 31 86.40 231.41 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 614.10 614.10 4.00
64 4/1/1990 30 73.39 190.23 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 715.55 715.55 4.00
65 5/1/1990 31 65.97 176.70 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 731.96 731.96 4.00
66 6/1/1990 30 47.32 122.65 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 688.45 688.45 4.00
67 7/1/1990 31 21.42 57.38 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 601.86 601.86 4.00
68 8/1/1990 31 44.45 119.06 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 612.86 612.86 4.00
69 9/1/1990 30 15.48 40.12 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 502.60 502.60 4.00
70 10/1/1990 31 13.48 36.10 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 370.25 370.25 4.00
71 11/1/1990 30 11.57 29.99 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - 33.85 200.24 166.15 200.00 5.00
72 12/1/1990 31 78.42 210.03 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - 38.39 210.03 161.61 200.00 6.00
73 1/1/1991 31 196.79 527.07 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 558.62 558.62 6.00
74 2/1/1991 28 106.33 257.24 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 597.38 597.38 6.00
75 3/1/1991 31 92.62 248.06 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 701.48 701.48 6.00
76 4/1/1991 30 78.68 203.95 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 - - 88.78 816.65 816.65 6.00
77 5/1/1991 31 20.91 56.00 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 712.36 712.36 6.00
 5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1
DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3
78 6/1/1991 30 19.45 50.40 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 596.59 596.59 6.00
79 7/1/1991 31 16.94 45.36 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 497.99 497.99 6.00
80 8/1/1991 31 15.24 40.83 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 430.76 430.76 6.00
81 9/1/1991 30 14.18 36.74 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 317.13 317.13 6.00
82 10/1/1991 31 12.35 33.07 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - 18.25 150.19 181.75 200.00 7.00
83 11/1/1991 30 129.58 335.87 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 301.78 301.78 7.00
84 12/1/1991 31 102.12 273.53 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 326.88 326.88 7.00
85 1/1/1992 31 114.74 307.33 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 465.76 465.76 7.00
86 2/1/1992 29 135.04 338.36 12.53 85.31 213.76 226.29 - - 226.29 577.84 577.84 7.00
87 3/1/1992 31 156.29 418.61 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 852.49 852.49 7.00
88 4/1/1992 30 138.45 358.87 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 122.59 - 211.36 1,122.59 1,000.00 7.00
89 5/1/1992 31 55.28 148.06 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 987.78 987.78 7.00
90 6/1/1992 30 33.31 86.35 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 907.95 907.95 7.00
91 7/1/1992 31 19.65 52.63 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 816.62 816.62 7.00
92 8/1/1992 31 40.78 109.23 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 817.79 817.79 7.00
93 9/1/1992 30 30.85 79.97 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 747.39 747.39 7.00
94 10/1/1992 31 53.51 143.33 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 722.27 722.27 7.00
95 11/1/1992 30 60.02 155.58 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 643.77 643.77 7.00
96 12/1/1992 31 110.00 294.61 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 689.96 689.96 7.00
97 1/1/1993 31 126.34 338.39 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 859.90 859.90 7.00
98 2/1/1993 28 98.95 239.38 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 880.80 880.80 7.00
99 3/1/1993 31 138.57 371.15 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 107.99 - 251.95 1,107.99 1,000.00 7.00
100 4/1/1993 30 123.16 319.22 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 230.45 - 319.22 1,230.45 1,000.00 7.00
101 5/1/1993 31 57.97 155.27 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 994.98 994.98 7.00
102 6/1/1993 30 41.30 107.04 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 935.85 935.85 7.00
103 7/1/1993 31 17.20 46.06 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 837.95 837.95 7.00
 5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1
DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3
104 8/1/1993 31 28.45 76.21 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 806.10 806.10 7.00
105 9/1/1993 30 12.63 32.73 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 688.45 688.45 7.00
106 10/1/1993 31 12.29 32.90 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 552.91 552.91 7.00
107 11/1/1993 30 30.71 79.60 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - - 234.09 398.42 398.42 7.00
108 12/1/1993 31 99.27 265.88 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - - 248.42 415.88 415.88 7.00
109 1/1/1994 31 156.07 418.00 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 665.44 665.44 7.00
110 2/1/1994 28 188.99 457.21 12.10 85.31 206.39 218.48 - - 218.48 904.16 904.16 7.00
111 3/1/1994 31 147.72 395.66 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 155.86 - 299.82 1,155.86 1,000.00 7.00
112 4/1/1994 30 103.85 269.18 12.96 29.25 75.82 88.78 180.40 - 269.18 1,180.40 1,000.00 7.00
113 5/1/1994 31 29.43 78.81 13.39 54.84 146.89 160.29 - - 160.29 918.53 918.53 7.00
114 6/1/1994 30 14.92 38.67 12.96 59.11 153.21 166.17 - - 166.17 791.03 791.03 7.00
115 7/1/1994 31 10.32 27.64 13.39 48.75 130.57 143.96 - - 143.96 674.71 674.71 7.00
116 8/1/1994 31 8.70 23.29 13.39 35.34 94.66 108.06 - - 108.06 589.95 589.95 7.00
117 9/1/1994 30 7.64 19.81 12.96 53.02 137.42 150.38 - - 150.38 459.38 459.38 7.00
118 10/1/1994 31 8.84 23.66 13.39 57.89 155.05 168.45 - - 168.45 314.60 314.60 7.00
119 11/1/1994 30 29.44 76.30 12.96 85.31 221.13 234.09 - 43.19 190.90 156.81 200.00 8.00
120 12/1/1994 31 37.80 101.25 13.39 87.75 235.03 248.42 - 147.17 101.25 52.83 200.00 9.00
AVERAGE 65.71 171.82 13.15 58.60 153.61 166.75 9.18 3.28 172.65 612.76 606.86 4.03

KEHANDALAN OPERASI WADUK : 92.50%

TAHUN TERJADI SPILL : 1989, 1992, 1993, 1994 (4 TAHUN)
TAHUN TERJADI SHORTAGE : 1986, 1987, 1988, 1990, 1991, 1994 (6 TAHUN)
KOMENTAR : Operasi Waduk cukup handal
 5 SOAL & JAWABAN GRUP 1
DAVID NELSON LUMBANTOBING

Vmax 1000 Mcm

12 10 120 DMI 5 m/s Vmin 200 Mcm

65.71 171.82 58.60 153.61 Max : 1230.45 1000.00 N= 120

Min : 52.83 200.00 N gagal = 9
200.00 92.50%
Total Tanda
Jumlah Inflow DMI Keb. Air IRR PLTA Spillout Shortage Tamp Bruto Tamp Netto
Date Outflow Gagal
hari
m3/s juta m3 juta m3 m3/s juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3 juta m3

Chart Title
1,200.00

1,000.00

800.00

600.00

400.00

200.00

-
1/1/1985 5/16/1986 9/28/1987 2/9/1989 6/24/1990 11/6/1991 3/20/1993 8/2/1994

Inflow Total Outflow VOLUME