IAN ROBERTSON, AN ATLAS OF PENINSULE WAR, YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS, 2010

Peter Hicks et Franois Houdecek La Fondation Napolon | Napoleonica. La Revue

2010/3 - N9 pages 155 156

ISSN 2100.0123

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------http://www.cairn.info/revue-napoleonica-la-revue-2010-3-page-155.htm

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Pour citer cet article :

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Hicks Peter et Houdecek Franois , Ian Robertson, An Atlas of Peninsule War, Yale University Press, 2010 , Napoleonica. La Revue, 2010/3 N9, p. 155-156.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Distribution lectronique Cairn.info pour La Fondation Napolon. La Fondation Napolon. Tous droits rservs pour tous pays.

La reproduction ou reprsentation de cet article, notamment par photocopie, n'est autorise que dans les limites des conditions gnrales d'utilisation du site ou, le cas chant, des conditions gnrales de la licence souscrite par votre tablissement. Toute autre reproduction ou reprsentation, en tout ou partie, sous quelque forme et de quelque manire que ce soit, est interdite sauf accord pralable et crit de l'diteur, en dehors des cas prvus par la lgislation en vigueur en France. Il est prcis que son stockage dans une base de donnes est galement interdit.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon

Article disponible en ligne l'adresse:

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon

Ian Robertson, An Atlas of the Peninsular War Yale University Press, 2010
Reviewed by Peter Hicks & Franois Houdecek
This book of maps is fascinating and infuriating in equal measure. The title claims that it is an atlas of the Peninsular War, and yet the work only includes engagements involving the British Army, plans of battles and sieges in which the Spanish fought alone against the French [being] not included! The maps are on the other hand beautifully clear and modern, compiled by someone who claims to have personally seen many of the places recorded. As a result they are for the most part easy to use and (so the book would have us believe) the best available (although no comment is made on the very recent Spanish publication which would appear to be in direct competition, namely Cartografia de la Guerra de la Independencia (Ministero de Defensa e Ollero y Ramos Editores, 2008)). The compiler/author Ian Robertson is furthermore an experienced military historian so the accompanying text ought to be of high quality. And yet, the tone of the historical accounts is quite jingoistic; everyone except Wellington is treated with avuncular condescension: the Spanish soldiers are all pathetic in pitched battles but plucky foreigners when it comes to sieges (p.6); the Portuguese Royal family is feckless; the French are treacherous Junot enters Portugal gratuitously (p.17). It ought to be possible to tell this story in a more sophisticated way? Even French historiography is brushed off as lying via a startlingly nationalistic quotation from a travel book to Spain published in 1845! (p.7). Modern authors accounts of the war in Spain (Ren Aymes, Charles Esdaile, Jean-Marc Lafon, etc.) seem not to have penetrated. Furthermore, despite the exemplary clarity of most of the maps, some of them reveal the same one-sided approach too for example, some charts only give the movements for one army (pp.77, 95, 97, 123). In its format, Robertsons book is quite similar to the exceedingly useful book produced by Colonel John Elting and Brigadier Vincent Esposito, A Military History and Atlas of the Napoleonic Wars (first edition, Praeger Inc., 1964, second, revised edition, Greenhill Books, 1999) with its combination of detailed maps and a somewhat enthusiastic text. And whilst the book here would appear to be superior to its ancestor in that it provides a greater number of maps, Robertsons maps are occasionally inferior in that they occasionally do not give precise details concerning commanders and corps in the map itself
Peter Hicks & Franois Houdecek, Review: Ian Robertson, An Atlas of the Peninsular War , Napoleonica.La Revue, n9, dcembre 2010 155

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon

and the reader is expected to glean them from the accompanying text. In fact, unlike in the Esposito/ Elting volume, the maps are almost never understandable on their own, and one strongly gets the feeling that they were drawn more with the specialist in mind than the general reader. There is also an annoying unevenness in the way the different maps are treated, for example, on p.15 only the British units are identified not the French, and on p.65 only the names of commanders are given. Whilst this volume has much to offer, English readers are still waiting for the definitive, complete Peninsular War atlas.

Peter Hicks & Franois Houdecek, Review: Ian Robertson, An Atlas of the Peninsular War , Napoleonica.La Revue, n9, dcembre 2010

156

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - regina_univ - - 142.3.217.121 - 28/11/2011 16h26. La Fondation Napolon