Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 14

Std.

Deviatio
N Mean n
tpc1 10.5 3 81.3509 14.05727 84.4590 11.36747 82.5564 1.42117
10.10 3 81.7895 13.37137 82.0000 8.73211 108.9949 .20386
15.5 3 103.6316 49.75896 83.3934 8.66025 107.4564
15.10 3 103.1345 50.80283 105.7158 46.82691 125.7615
20.5 3 105.4737 48.72142 83.9945 1.01829 130.6077
20.10 3 114.7135 42.44176 114.2404 39.44542 116.0949
Total 18 98.3489 35.98552

tpc2 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 92.3005 25.42828
tpc3 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 111.9120 22.52481
tpc4 10.5 3 111.9302 1.45233 96.0863 18.92778 139.4286 22.01319 146.3497 3.21384
10.10 3 145.069 2.26968 93.4588 11.83976 134.6667 16.90979 169.9563 32.46785
8
15.5 3 146.5426 1.66215 126.7922 67.31225 137.3651 16.77065 161.5410
15.10 3 175.5736 36.89719 127.5765 67.44820 180.5926 90.68068 194.5464
20.5 3 184.9922 29.83965 130.7922 67.58527 138.5291 1.97192 195.1202
20.10 3 162.0736 52.54359 112.5569 91.89014 197.1005 76.38638 212.9126
Total 18 154.363 34.49808
7
tpc5 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 114.543 53.85147
8
tpc6 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 154.613 49.24206
8
tpc7 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 180.071 59.82528
0
tfc1 10.5 3 49.9748 8.08340 72.7712 4.65695 66.1119 1.08495
10.10 3 49.7227 3.97364 80.2222 8.97974 80.7204 2.51954
15.5 3 57.8459 3.45391 82.7386 6.38786 93.8076
15.10 3 56.4454 3.19328 93.0654 6.22710 99.9150
20.5 3 67.8179 4.23210 105.8431 5.00672 96.1678
20.10 3 77.7339 5.42283
Total 18 59.9234 11.10932
tfc2 10.5 3 66.7908 1.33827

10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 83.5719 14.15553 104.4139 33.41061
tfc3 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 90.1894 26.28132
tfc4 10.5 3 79.7463 12.94319 78.6323 3.84404 87.0958 11.79846 95.6000 3.96159
10.10 3 89.6443 14.32505 77.7045 1.09265 92.8429 6.20512 111.6909 15.29787
15.5 3 96.4925 1.50273 82.4124 6.75789 95.0268 1.13400 120.7818
15.10 3 111.9378 25.71300 85.9519 2.63307 100.7739 4.37738 139.6000
20.5 3 116.4627 20.61823 94.9210 6.94201 146.9808 56.85245 148.6000
20.10 3 112.2338 30.11195 107.0515 8.11491 154.4559 54.37587 144.7727
Total 18 101.086 21.68438
2
tfc5 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 87.7789 11.59219
tfc6 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 112.862 39.14022
7
tfc7 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 126.840 27.72379
9
dpph1 10.5 3 37.0954 3.09734 37.5479 3.03258
10.10 3 39.3914 .19165 38.6700 .56882
15.5 3 39.8893 .25353 41.0235
15.10 3 40.5809 .21956 39.7373
20.5 3 42.5450 .19165 41.8446
20.10 3 47.5519 2.75113 44.9918
Total 18 41.1757 3.66068
dpph2 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 40.6358 3.32707
dpph3 10.5 3 36.5208 3.55580 39.9798 5.42982 36.8992 1.47287 37.2741 1.10926 3
10.10 3 37.3312 4.44771 43.2146 .40118 35.8398 2.61314 38.8052 .95348 3
15.5 3 39.8703 .64321 42.5322 3.46517 36.3307 1.41318 38.5291 2.13161
15.10 3 38.6548 1.16874 44.4023 1.74923 39.6382 2.35936 39.5331 4.71701
20.5 3 42.3015 2.16083 42.3048 1.44447 39.6124 3.85966 40.2359 3.70229
20.10 3 44.7326 4.75227 51.1751 2.01873 48.7080 2.64173 49.6486 3.28259
Total 18 39.9019 3.97779
dpph4 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 43.9348 4.35231
dpph5 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 39.5047 4.98201
dpph6 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 40.6710 4.92233
dpph7 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 39.0951 4.78916
frap1 10.5 3 79.1682 10.64449 110.0877 28.94511 152.3944 17.48677
10.10 3 90.9399 25.00780 112.4269 35.91463 142.5056 8.39574
15.5 3 141.3303 23.32939 153.5380 .55709 153.5889
15.10 3 171.2703 15.01994 156.8421 4.28749 152.5333
20.5 3 173.4324 12.76993 149.7076 1.47914 155.7556
20.10 3 174.5135 12.46764 168.0994 7.62014 174.7028
Total 18 138.442 43.24907
4
frap2 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 141.783 28.04754
6
frap3 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 155.246 12.23183
8
frap4 10.5 3 169.268 6.78137 186.6993 .66414 204.2574 4.24066 223.7048 2.00170
1
10.10 3 178.326 7.43831 196.3370 8.97842 214.5105 5.19502 229.6095 2.73426
1
15.5 3 181.9130 8.68750 211.8442 3.10750 232.6118 10.99616 236.5619
15.10 3 180.5725 5.89601 215.4312 .92445 239.1519 .98864 240.1810
20.5 3 185.7536 6.74030 217.0978 .39191 239.6160 2.68323 249.0381
20.10 3 205.3442 17.89081 271.6630 11.03140 276.7890 13.25452 283.2667
Total 18 183.529 13.97912
6
frap5 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 216.512 28.18961
1
frap6 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 234.489 24.44838
5
frap7 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 243.727 20.27801
0
hmf1 10.5 3 3.6037 .31987
10.10 3 5.4196 .61892
15.5 3 5.8598
15.10 3 5.8483
20.5 3 5.8598
20.10 3 6.0640
Total 18 5.4425 .92346
hmf2 10.5 3 3.6522 .37483 3.8269 .51812 3.9177 .46687 4.3160 .1
10.10 3 5.6297 .27529 5.5454 .43304 5.8029 .31481 5.9781 .2
15.5 3 5.9597 .25039 6.0091 .21148 6.0645 .23770 6.0889 .2
15.10 3 5.9472 .19954 6.0779 .25971 6.1593 .22527 6.2237 .1
20.5 3 5.9287 .36606 6.0440 .30859 6.0705 .18934 5.5054 1.4
20.10 3 6.1319 .25060 6.1893 .18256 6.2746 .14308 6.0645 .2
Total 18 5.5415 .91642

hmf3 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 5.6154 .89609

hmf4 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 5.7149 .87288
hmf5 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 5.6961 .85379
hmf6 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 5.8847 .72054
hmf7 10.5 3
10.10 3
15.5 3
15.10 3
20.5 3
20.10 3
Total 18 5.9399 .72577

Test of Homogeneity of Variances


Levene Statistic df1 df2 Sig.
tpc1 Based on Mean 3.171 5 12 .047
Based on Median .218 5 12 .948
Based on Median and with .218 5 8.485 .945
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.526 5 12 .088
tpc2 Based on Mean 8.480 5 12 .001
Based on Median .539 5 12 .744
Based on Median and with .539 5 4.396 .743
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 6.701 5 12 .003
tpc3 Based on Mean 7.638 5 12 .002
Based on Median .982 5 12 .468
Based on Median and with .982 5 4.667 .512
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 6.575 5 12 .004
tpc4 Based on Mean 6.806 5 12 .003
Based on Median .963 5 12 .478
Based on Median and with .963 5 3.780 .533
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 5.954 5 12 .005
tpc5 Based on Mean 2.198 5 12 .122
Based on Median .452 5 12 .804
Based on Median and with .452 5 8.199 .802
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.990 5 12 .153
tpc6 Based on Mean 8.480 5 12 .001
Based on Median .539 5 12 .744
Based on Median and with .539 5 4.396 .743
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 6.701 5 12 .003
tpc7 Based on Mean 5.097 5 12 .010
Based on Median .460 5 12 .798
Based on Median and with .460 5 6.817 .795
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 4.208 5 12 .019
tfc1 Based on Mean 1.984 5 12 .154
Based on Median .152 5 12 .975
Based on Median and with .152 5 6.603 .972
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.630 5 12 .226
tfc2 Based on Mean 2.145 5 12 .129
Based on Median .325 5 12 .888
Based on Median and with .325 5 8.389 .885
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.883 5 12 .171
tfc3 Based on Mean 6.769 5 12 .003
Based on Median .513 5 12 .762
Based on Median and with .513 5 6.028 .760
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 5.478 5 12 .007
tfc4 Based on Mean 2.016 5 12 .148
Based on Median .469 5 12 .793
Based on Median and with .469 5 8.046 .790
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.847 5 12 .178
tfc5 Based on Mean 2.224 5 12 .119
Based on Median .563 5 12 .726
Based on Median and with .563 5 5.970 .727
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.057 5 12 .142
tfc6 Based on Mean 9.677 5 12 .001
Based on Median .738 5 12 .609
Based on Median and with .738 5 4.133 .632
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 7.846 5 12 .002
tfc7 Based on Mean 3.112 5 12 .050
Based on Median .774 5 12 .587
Based on Median and with .774 5 6.363 .600
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.873 5 12 .062
dpph1 Based on Mean 8.447 5 12 .001
Based on Median 1.113 5 12 .404
Based on Median and with 1.113 5 3.632 .480
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 7.308 5 12 .002
dpph2 Based on Mean 3.644 5 12 .031
Based on Median .357 5 12 .868
Based on Median and with .357 5 6.966 .863
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 3.029 5 12 .054
dpph3 Based on Mean 3.138 5 12 .049
Based on Median .521 5 12 .756
Based on Median and with .521 5 6.686 .755
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.784 5 12 .068
dpph4 Based on Mean 4.006 5 12 .023
Based on Median .542 5 12 .741
Based on Median and with .542 5 3.580 .742
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 3.517 5 12 .034
dpph5 Based on Mean 1.204 5 12 .365
Based on Median .281 5 12 .915
Based on Median and with .281 5 8.013 .911
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.104 5 12 .408
dpph6 Based on Mean 3.874 5 12 .025
Based on Median .310 5 12 .897
Based on Median and with .310 5 7.002 .892
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 3.175 5 12 .047
dpph7 Based on Mean 4.751 5 12 .013
Based on Median .376 5 12 .856
Based on Median and with .376 5 4.357 .845
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 3.925 5 12 .024
frap1 Based on Mean .681 5 12 .647
Based on Median .409 5 12 .834
Based on Median and with .409 5 10.341 .833
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean .663 5 12 .659
frap2 Based on Mean 9.946 5 12 .001
Based on Median .708 5 12 .628
Based on Median and with .708 5 4.036 .648
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 7.991 5 12 .002
frap3 Based on Mean 5.410 5 12 .008
Based on Median .902 5 12 .511
Based on Median and with .902 5 4.292 .552
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 4.782 5 12 .012
frap4 Based on Mean 1.871 5 12 .173
Based on Median .524 5 12 .754
Based on Median and with .524 5 6.902 .752
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.728 5 12 .203
frap5 Based on Mean 5.341 5 12 .008
Based on Median 1.512 5 12 .258
Based on Median and with 1.512 5 4.388 .345
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 4.954 5 12 .011
frap6 Based on Mean 3.868 5 12 .025
Based on Median .942 5 12 .488
Based on Median and with .942 5 6.190 .514
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 3.538 5 12 .034
frap7 Based on Mean 2.137 5 12 .131
Based on Median 1.185 5 12 .372
Based on Median and with 1.185 5 5.770 .417
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.074 5 12 .139
hmf1 Based on Mean 2.473 5 12 .092
Based on Median .302 5 12 .902
Based on Median and with .302 5 7.471 .898
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 2.110 5 12 .134
hmf2 Based on Mean .801 5 12 .570
Based on Median .068 5 12 .996
Based on Median and with .068 5 8.761 .996
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean .670 5 12 .654
hmf3 Based on Mean 1.337 5 12 .314
Based on Median .348 5 12 .874
Based on Median and with .348 5 9.779 .872
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.223 5 12 .357
hmf4 Based on Mean 1.684 5 12 .213
Based on Median .332 5 12 .884
Based on Median and with .332 5 5.594 .876
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 1.526 5 12 .254
hmf5 Based on Mean 10.135 5 12 .001
Based on Median .864 5 12 .532
Based on Median and with .864 5 2.298 .604
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean 8.339 5 12 .001
hmf6 Based on Mean .390 5 12 .847
Based on Median .090 5 12 .992
Based on Median and with .090 5 9.907 .992
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean .354 5 12 .870
hmf7 Based on Mean .481 5 12 .784
Based on Median .126 5 12 .984
Based on Median and with .126 5 9.576 .983
adjusted df
Based on trimmed mean .442 5 12 .811

ANOVA
Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
tpc1 Between Groups 2797.551 5 559.510 .349 .873
Within Groups 19216.723 12 1601.394
Total 22014.274 17
tpc2 Between Groups 2931.739 5 586.348 .873 .527
Within Groups 8060.414 12 671.701
Total 10992.153 17
tpc3 Between Groups 4346.843 5 869.369 2.438 .096
Within Groups 4278.399 12 356.533
Total 8625.242 17
tpc4 Between Groups 10186.675 5 2037.335 2.434 .096
Within Groups 10045.318 12 837.110
Total 20231.993 17
tpc5 Between Groups 4119.259 5 823.852 .219 .948
Within Groups 45180.411 12 3765.034
Total 49299.669 17
tpc6 Between Groups 10994.205 5 2198.841 .873 .527
Within Groups 30227.060 12 2518.922
Total 41221.265 17
tpc7 Between Groups 9292.138 5 1858.428 .433 .817
Within Groups 51551.942 12 4295.995
Total 60844.081 17
tfc1 Between Groups 1796.937 5 359.387 14.321 .000
Within Groups 301.151 12 25.096
Total 2098.088 17
tfc2 Between Groups 2988.919 5 597.784 17.181 .000
Within Groups 417.525 12 34.794
Total 3406.445 17
tfc3 Between Groups 3045.438 5 609.088 .840 .546
Within Groups 8696.594 12 724.716
Total 11742.032 17
tfc4 Between Groups 3257.626 5 651.525 1.651 .221
Within Groups 4735.982 12 394.665
Total 7993.608 17
tfc5 Between Groups 1919.208 5 383.842 12.611 .000
Within Groups 365.232 12 30.436
Total 2284.440 17
tfc6 Between Groups 13269.083 5 2653.817 2.493 .090
Within Groups 12774.183 12 1064.515
Total 26043.266 17
tfc7 Between Groups 6600.096 5 1320.019 2.450 .095
Within Groups 6466.248 12 538.854
Total 13066.345 17
dpph1 Between Groups 193.113 5 38.623 13.358 .000
Within Groups 34.696 12 2.891
Total 227.809 17
dpph2 Between Groups 104.379 5 20.876 2.989 .056
Within Groups 83.800 12 6.983
Total 188.180 17
dpph3 Between Groups 146.070 5 29.214 2.852 .064
Within Groups 122.917 12 10.243
Total 268.988 17
dpph4 Between Groups 220.278 5 44.056 5.196 .009
Within Groups 101.746 12 8.479
Total 322.024 17
dpph5 Between Groups 345.073 5 69.015 10.773 .000
Within Groups 76.874 12 6.406
Total 421.947 17
dpph6 Between Groups 305.067 5 61.013 6.853 .003
Within Groups 106.832 12 8.903
Total 411.899 17
dpph7 Between Groups 283.198 5 56.640 6.369 .004
Within Groups 106.716 12 8.893
Total 389.914 17
frap1 Between Groups 28144.065 5 5628.813 18.485 .000
Within Groups 3654.135 12 304.511
Total 31798.200 17
frap2 Between Groups 8960.044 5 1792.009 4.873 .012
Within Groups 4413.255 12 367.771
Total 13373.299 17
frap3 Between Groups 1678.142 5 335.628 4.654 .014
Within Groups 865.357 12 72.113
Total 2543.500 17
frap4 Between Groups 2167.943 5 433.589 4.508 .015
Within Groups 1154.127 12 96.177
Total 3322.070 17
frap5 Between Groups 13082.305 5 2616.461 73.562 .000
Within Groups 426.819 12 35.568
Total 13509.124 17
frap6 Between Groups 9461.804 5 1892.361 32.464 .000
Within Groups 699.493 12 58.291
Total 10161.296 17
frap7 Between Groups 6767.098 5 1353.420 72.743 .000
Within Groups 223.267 12 18.606
Total 6990.364 17
hmf1 Between Groups 12.842 5 2.568 18.626 .000
Within Groups 1.655 12 .138
Total 14.497 17
hmf2 Between Groups 13.246 5 2.649 30.828 .000
Within Groups 1.031 12 .086
Total 14.277 17
hmf3 Between Groups 12.257 5 2.451 21.112 .000
Within Groups 1.393 12 .116
Total 13.651 17
hmf4 Between Groups 11.991 5 2.398 29.938 .000
Within Groups .961 12 .080
Total 12.953 17
hmf5 Between Groups 7.767 5 1.553 4.030 .022
Within Groups 4.626 12 .385
Total 12.392 17
hmf6 Between Groups 8.588 5 1.718 86.638 .000
Within Groups .238 12 .020
Total 8.826 17
hmf7 Between Groups 8.645 5 1.729 67.072 .000
Within Groups .309 12 .026
Total 8.955 17

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi