+

. - , * & )( ' & % $ #" !

/ 0 1
. 4 5" 6#78 2(3

=
. ' ? >8 $#" <,;: 79

/ 0 1
. @79 6#78 2(3
 - 5 A
.E F ,( G ,( G B E &8 C &5 D&1B 78#

5,

- IIIIA 2 : J 6KIII % , 5 ! H> ( - 7

-* O '(: !; A N I I, @ IIL III : M

.E 2/S N@ : M D?>; 2/P @ @ D5 # P B 2? P Q R

T(KU , V : 2LW X 2? P T ?U , Y( , Z( P *[ Q\

0@ X -

c9 d ef D&5 C Af C 5 C g, D&5 E- ? &8 b# B V]^ T_ S ` >8a

. C ( > h '>; C@ i?j # k7_7M # >l h C& T m ZnL

T? c9 2, 7L Q !> 6 7M 2, M 2 U A: -: D ;: G ?

. i_ 7>M

. T? c9 p lf m I : o( I CI> N 'j 9 I8 T A:

. h KU ql K% r s# L

. 2(@ ; u#@ 2L t
 h 9f

. &> & o ! S; m F v uc f

... 07S> w g 2Lv#

;75 8C m-

K5 2 x C7y !; :

V M c9 m !; ( -: &z - uc f

V ql f C

C #Eq| w7 :B { H S !% d f

h KU ql ! 5 N K% C - K m 'U c9 6 } T%

. C n> ( C T9: 79 ~ h ,( y 2 U m N<

. 2(@ ; u#@ 2L t
 ! " # $ % & ' '( ) * +
, % - '( - .# /0 # /% 12 '
44 5+ 64" 4 ' 3 12 '
/ 0 ) !" 0 3 !& 7 4 5 -' 5+ 8
$ 9+ : ; & 7 97 '( 0

< & 8 !& %7 = '4 &

8 > ;: '" * 8 .# =
; 6 = % 2' * /0 !" ' 3 % 4 4

? & 54 4 % 3 ' ) ' 3 $ 44

44 & 3 )' ) ' 4 % , <#$ 44
? 5+

$ 4 % 0 " @ 4 5 6 <#$ /A
0 $ & )' ) ' 5 4 5 -6 >2 0
& 3 ' = ' .# .4
= = 7 4 $ % $0
? 97 = % ;: '( 54
% ' $0 0 !& 0 / $ #
@ 9 , / 2% % + % # *
= #" 6 4; 7 5 3 5 $0
 ? % 5+
4% # 14 4@ $ : & , 5+ 9 , 4
? 2 & , ' 6 & ,
9 , ' 4 B C ' #
. 2+ . % % 4 % & , /$ 4 .#
? / $ 0

D '' , 5+ 9 , . 2+ 9 4 B
= - 1 7 4 ' /'% # 4 % / ,E
C G 4 % 54 !" 54 F4 )' "

? # 5+ / H
/ C 4( 4 @/ , , 8 E
/'% 44 G. % /'% F B 1 7 $4& @ 5+

6 I# 1 ) ) # 6
( @ G 54 !" 54 F4 # 2 ,@
? 4( 4

! "9 ;6 5+ 9 , !& , - ' ' 4 <#$ '

=- 44 % $ 4 ( @ . 2+ 4 % /
? % B 5+ ' 4
J @K . 2+ % /0 % ' 4 # 44

? 2 ,@ 4 %

B ' 4 0 % &' & , 5+ 9 , 0

 % # 4 % ' 7 % . % % %

* ' 4 B <#$ ! " 9 ' 4 =- *' * 8L

4+ 8 1 B /46 4@ / ' 2 ,@ 4 % J 8 ,
?8 42

9 , 9 , ' 4 6 #
? 4 M ' 4 %'
D 4 0 9 , #$ B $
,( % 5+ 5 -6 5 1N E
K - ' ! % = % )' = - % -
? /4 % ' = - C ' @ &

$ +2 % C "B 3= % 1" 2 ' ' '

5+ /1 3 1 ! 5+ !& = )
1" )& !7 5+ !& &+ 1 + + +2

? 5+ 8&+ !& %1 ) # !% 8%
= @O %% L !& @ 5+
?5 A % -

D ;6 + 9 , $
M' 1 ' !& - 544 5 -6 ( E
# : > - 5 4 &( 4, 5+ %
? /$ A > - ; / '7 7
/ 9 # ) ' 5+ &+ 4 + *@ 4 B
 P , 5+ ;7 , 5+ = ' % 5+
+ &+ <#$ 54 5 -6 >& , 4 4 H %
4> 6 / ' ,B 3 4; $4 %% '
&+ = @ 1 8 =' / ,% 44 5 6 N
4 - " ' 4@ ; +2 4 5+
? 5+ % 54 7 '; 5 +
% 6 % 5+ C )' ) & 54 + E
) = - & A & 2' / 46 ' # 4
! & ) : 5 % 5+ )' 5 $0 ' 4 !" Q

? 5+ #
2, % I ' !& + ( C !" ,( E
*@ C ! & 5+ 6 K = - =

? 6 @ 54 / C '7 M-6 $ 0 )'

? 8' 4 0 0 B #$ $ 0
D9 , #$ ' 4 4 ) '

. % % = 6 4 % & , K6 $" E
? #$ B A
/ /0 %1 % 2' / -6 ) - 5+ E
2% % + 5 $0 @ 9, 8 #3*
%' ) ' !& 9 8 ) %% 0 $ &
?* /0

4
 / / 0 5 7 / &4 $ ) : 5 % 5+ ! & *% 4& 94
8'7 @ # ! 4 *, ! & .4 ' 8
4 7 K @ / 0 54 !& 4 H * !, 7 & " #
? ,%
/2 &4 #3 4 @ 2' = 1 5+ 9 , E
% ' = % $ . @4 @ / % ''

? % 6 ;
% @- 5+ 9 , ( + 8 /4% ;6
D & ( @ ' 4 >4

!" ! # " " $ % &'

( )*! +, - )." # $ " * *" !.) &$/) # !"
( . )* 0 1 # " ! % "2 "# " 34'

D & 7 O' !& , ( : ( <#$ ! & R

?S % - 5+ %% $
?S % - S $#6 $ $ S 5+ $

8 / 3 5+ /0 !& 2 ,% /0 2+ #"
?S 8 4 !%
' = - S9 5 4 5+ $
? S 5+ I &4
I &4 * + /4& 54& % 9 % 542 7 $
S 5+ I &4

'
 ? S 8+ +2 @ 6 2' $
I &4 <#$ 3 5+ @5 % N $ 5+ I &4 #"
S @ I &4 / & , I &4 $
@ & ( # - ( & ( ! " ' ' ' 4 >4
? & 7 O'
D > 4$ =% ' 4 <#$ !6
? K6 % % ' 4 5 24 *' E
54 /A $ & , 8 /A 8 0 .# 5+ 9 , C E
' 5 4 4 2+ 8 " % 8 B ' 4
?9 , #$ 4 ' 4
6 / # % - 7 !& > 5+ $ + " E

? ' = - /$ 4 $ & + % '

+2 $ % 5+ 1N $ !& > @ E
? 8% 5+ I &4 '
8 ' 8 8 @ / 0 5+ / + ' 4 E
+2 4& C *% ! /0 /
? '4 = ) $ .#
#$ B ' 4 !& 4 & > 4$ <#$ T
6 1) 7O . 8%7 8 4 $ 9 ,
) , 4 4 G F) $ B #$ '' *
!" ,( . U 7 4 & . 4@ 4 G #$" *$ ,* " ,*$ F
4 &> O , 3 5+ 9 , 4 6 4& 4 7O
6!! !" 5 / * FD . ' 4 =+
* @ 0 " % 6 * 54 /A
9 , ' 4 %% #$ 3 2 + 9 , #$
? . 2+ % /0 ,
" ! " % ' B ' 4 <#$ ! & 4 &(

) - ( A 3 & & 7 O' & ( B

? 9 4 B
4 9 , - # V$ V 1 !& 4 & E

? 4 @ 8% 4 % 8% 44 9 , # ,%
$ U 4 & # 5+ ' 4 7 M 6 E
?9 - C & % - 5+

W & 5+ / 7 - & B4 4& 6 V !& 4 & E

? $ - 7 5+ I &4 6 & B4 4& ,
'M % =2 % C %' 2 %' V !& 4 & E

5+ I &4 - K2 6 4& 24 5+ %
? I4 ! & I &4
% K C @ 4& , % ' E
? 2 ,% / C %7 @ C !& =
( ;6 % @ - 5+ 9 , 5 $ , !&
# $ ' 4 /'% M 80 - O' B " !&
? 2 1 '% B
 / !" 7 , 3 '' !" ' 4 '@ B
B @ - 1 ! " < 4 < '@ .# . 2+ % 5+
)' / ! " 1 B @ - /1 3 & 5+ !"
? + % 5+
'' 1 ! " < '@ 3 5+ , 1 7
! " , 1 B 3 5+ / -( 4 4 B
? 5+ I &4

/ 7 6 - & B4 8 .4 7 #$ = '
? B 5+
0 & $+ % - 5+ $ 1 B @ - /1

? %
@( V2 /$ , 6 B #$ ' 4
? "

= X

5
/% 12 ' !" #$ % " & ' '( ) * +
' 3 12 ' ,% - '( - .# /0 #
4 5 -' 5+ 8 44 5+ 64" 4
? !& 7
.4 ! & +2 $ 5 -' 4 % 0 5+ / 7 4
4 !& = ' 5+ # 3 8 & !&
7 5+ 4 5 7 <#$ : & ' % - + *
B 5+ =- # *' 3 + = % = &
?+2 % + B 5+ -
/$ ' 5+ 9 , M % 8 " , #6
? @ 0 *, % ,% 8%7
4 $ " $0 & $ 5+ B
' ' = % ;: ' 5 4 0 = = 7
? 97
# 3 14 4@ $ : & , 5+ 9 , 4
&) 0 3 2 ( & , ' 6 & ,
? 1( ; ' % - )' ) ' 4 4 B $ -6 & V2
& 5+ / 7 - !& , - ' .4 7 #$ ;6 ' #
@ & ;- . : < ;6 5+ $ B /1 W
% 4 P % + % % - !& > #
# 38 % 0 < A & 5+ /0 !" ,(
8 " !& # 4 4 *, ; ' & 5+ +
?9 , #$ ,% % 8%7
 4 @ 5+ / 8 4 % U /@ 14 B
/ 0 2@ .# 64 * # 3 -, & 0
5+ 5 0 64 #$ + & ' 3 /0 5+
? .4 !& = '" !&
&" # % 4 5 4 5+ 5 8
% 6 - * 3 % = - Q 6 *% - ' @ & 5 & 5+
8 !' & 3= % /0 % + /0 =
?G= % 5+ F 5+
I4 # 3 5+ / 7 6 - !& > B #$ ' #
? 5+ K6 / % 8 " 14 1M

!
& ! & .4 ! & +2 $ 5 -' 4 & 5+ 4
? -' 8 & 4 + " <+ # 8
G F
? .4 !& = ' 5+ #
! & K6 , 4 - 'F D M 5+ > & 4%
G F
? G > :' ' > +2 > B 4

?. 1 .4 $4 & 4 & 5+

4 3 *' + 3 6# $ " *$ ,* 7 ! ! !" 5 / * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& YG F

? K3 3 54 4 1 1 - 3 3 @ % 3 1
&% $ ## !" Y
 1 3+ !& 4 5 -' GCorpusF .4 1 B
?+ +2 GAnimusF .
% %& ' ' 4 !& 5 @ 5+ 4 #
!& = -6 3 5+ 8+
! "* , #$ I4 8'7 ! & *% 5+ 4% 8 #
* $ - 6 1 3 $0 4 *, Z
? 5+ . % *@
!& - ' +2 3 $ M 5+ =- #
8 ,K B ' 5+ % 3
A Z ) ' .M )' 2 /' F D !&
4 # 4 8L 3 8 4% / ' < " 8, @ 4 &
@ % ' , 3 % < " 8+ ! & 54 ' ,
?G F
$ % ' /4& = @ .4 7 $ # >4 3G
> $ 5+ 5 ' 4
/ ' #/ 3 ' % - : +2 !" %% 8
% "8 " & % <#$ 8 ">
#$ 3 & !" 5 6 <#$ 54 , * 3 + 8 "
?G F
@ 5+ !" , 5+ , @ 8
% > &B 3 - 5+ 4 5 7 #6 + *

) 3 &8 9 1! 9 1! , :" !1 !1 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 Y

? 'K 3 3 4 ' 3B4
&% $ ##% -. / 012, 3+, - 1" ! " ) * + , (

#
=7 = $ 5+ 6J 9 H 4 5+ ) !"
G ' !& 97 = =7 = 'F ! 97
G F
8 & .# 3 5+ 8 = 5+ 5+ 9 #$ ! '
? = !& & 7 = % ! & 5+ 4 8 !&
"
$ #
4 !& , 4 5 -' % 4 5+ &
= % = &9 7 , 5 7 <#$ - /1 3 ' '
?= % 5+ &
4 $' B 1M 1 - 4 & 5+ / 7 #6
! & 5+ 0 =- *' B 3 5+ 4& @ -
7 5+ <4 Z % + B +
? +2
5+ / %' ' 4 8 @ .# 4 !76
<# $ 5+ B /0 & %' % / 0 * - $ -&"
? 6 ,6 * % % 9 * 5 7
% 5+ B , ' % 4&
8 )' / ; % 3G ' B;1 F 54 8 & 4 *, 8 4O

& $ :; </ 6 => 4 15 6 7 89 3 (

$
)' @ ' 4 *, / 4 2: G ' &F , G ' &F "
G F
Z
6 % - 8 "! / 4% ' 7 4 % #6
! & 54 5+ 8 4 ! & 54 5+ + M'
? = & & 7 = %
B G F @ 4 4 5+ 8 5+ + + & '
5+ # 3 5+ $ ! 7 ;
= A 6J & = ! & / % 5+ 8 3 = $ = ! & / % .4
?+ #$ / % & 4 ; = ! & *% $; #" 3
' 7 4 % & , , $ ' 5+ 9 , Z #$
+ " $ 5+ FD ! & 5+ 8 G % F54 &B
8 ' <+ 6J K6 -' '7 M 8 ' <+ = '
? G 8&
- ' " 8' 8 * = ' ' # 5+ % &
6J &= . = = #$ ' 3 < A -' +2 K6
4@ ' = - * =7 &M / % ' #$ 8 , %
G F
8 "4 @ ' #$ =
= % " *,6 5+ M 2% 4 ' 7 % I4 % '" # $

@ , / 3A 4 + , - ./ 0 + 1 123" ( ) 0 * &' ( ) 4. 3 ? 3 (
& $ # % B@ 3A
& %# C % $ :; </ 6 => ) * + , (

5
 & ' 7 4 % 8 )A #6 4%
/ /0 4 ' .# . 2 + 4 % ' ' 6
? ' 7 % 6
5+ G ' '3 F 8 >;6 ! &
? 6 = % !
+; % 5+ / /0 / $ @ Z
* / %' $0 0
) = % ' ;: ' ' 38 ) = 0
?
/ 0 & %' @ / 0 5+ 5 B #$ ;6 &
%& .4 ! & +2 ' 5 -' 4 3M 4@
; @ 0 Z - 3 > 8 > %
.# 3 @ 8 8 3= % 5+
7O ) > N @ # 0 %7 / $
? 0 *, # / 5+
:F > ;6 5+ $ !& > /4 % B ' #
? @ 0 8 & $+ % - /1 G ;-
 "
$
B #$ ' 5+ & 6 -&" = ' B
;- 7 /1 3 . : 7 ;6 5+ / 7 !" C
! " , 9 , 8%7 ;'( 8%7 %7 J !" 9
! &> B #$ ' 3 5+ > % C
? % % 0 $ A & $+ % -

$ %& '#
5+ > @ 3 % 8%7 / $ 5+ 4%
? 5+ . : ! !& > ' % 8%7 ,
$ )* %& '# (
8 8 ! 3 5+ + <+ + 3+ 7 5# 6M 5+
? 8'7 ! " 8 ,
8 " <+ % 3 8'7 ! " 8 , 8 + " + " 38 % +
G F
? 8 8,
/ % <4 4 8'7 ' ( <+ C + 3 $+
G F
? 8 = 4 ; 8% ' + 8 &
? % 4 ! " /, " G F + + 3* ! + , %

& C $ # @ @ 3A G H @ DIJ 6 7 8 9 :; 9 D :9 )/ E F )/ 7 (
##% S .* 3A -. / + PQ R L.* DIJ -2 1K )/ , )/ ) L > MNO / (
& ' $

<
 G F
8 5+ 3* $ G5+ F
8 + $ 9 + 5+ 3 %& 8+ $ 5+
G F
! + % 3 & +C
54& ! & : = - 5+ 07 : 7 4 ;6 Z,
D $
4% 4+ 38 % !" 8 , 8 4% + D :" 2 ?
8 & 4 *, 5 , /+ ' +2 !" 4 /, 8'7 ! " ,
M 3 7 8 > <4 M %%
?) ' )' < A 4 8 8
8 8' 7 ' ( <+ C 8 #" + % D ;" ?
?8 = 4 ; 8 &+ / % <4 4
? 8 4 ' 8, @ #" <+ + % D ! !,)*< =, ?%
8 C ! " 8, /, : 5+ V ' #
? <+2 !" 8 ' 8
% 8%7 4 !& > : : 5+ ! !& 4
? * > 4 " % >
$ +, - %& '# "(
4 3 5+ > *, % , 8%7 ;'( 8%7 / $"
7 <# / ( ' # 3 7 4; C @
D! " ' 4 / '%

& %$ ## @ @ 3A -. / 8 " R L.* DIJ =. :; 2 6 :; 9 (

& ## $ # B@ 3A U2 VQ R R1 , ? 7 3 < 2,W >? @ ./ 4 "T I (

%
 ,01 2 ! %& '# . /
$0 > ' %7 V & 4%
I &4 ) O$ 7 3 4 *, 5+ 9 , , (
? 4 )
%- : !& ; ' !& 4 G4 F 07 / 46 ' ! & %7 4%
#L ' 3 / = ' 3 ; ' #$ '
+2 $ ! & 4 *, 5+ /$4 & 4 3 / % 9
8 &4 .#
4 0 7 46 ' 5+ 07 46 ' / 7 )$# %7
G F
?8 .# !& ; ' ! ! & /$4 & = - 4% + 5+
4 7" # 3 , ( C 4& " ;'( 8%7 5+ 07 # /
! & $ !& > B # ' ' 4 5+ ' 4 8%7
? 0 # @M &) 1N & -
* , $ 5+ FD ! & 5+ 4 4 ; 8 %7 >
' F> 4 8 > 8 & ; ' !& 4
G F
G??? * *-@ /4 39 + : 3 '(
D G.4 &F W 8 %7 &
8 > + > 4 *, $ 5+ F
?G%F G > < $ A /4 :

& $ % J - 13A R 9?.B C 3 DE ) 8 - ",A (

?% K :; </ 6 => (
& $ :; </ 6 => 9?.B C 3 DE ) 8 - ",A (%

&
F
/$4 & 4 *, B 4 *, 5+ 07 @ 7 4 #$
3 .4 ' ! & @O 24 7 : ! & 4 *, 8 4 %
B 4 *, K6 5+ 3 8 #" : #L
?8 4 % : ! & 4 *,
8 %- 4 *, !& 4 9 /$ # # !& 4
?
5+ 9 , !& 4 *, $ ;'( 8%7 5+ % 5 7
4 ' 38 > 8 > 8 &4" 8 & ; '
?G F 8 2 8 81 8'7 +2 <#$
5+ % @4 > ;'( 8%7 8 < # =' ;6
? , % 8 % ' 4 5 4
2 ! %& '# 3
/ $ 4 $ & 5+ ! 544 7 *, %7 1 4 4%
? 4 % 54 & ,
D % U;- 5+
6 7 8 ' >4 8 & ; ' 4 *, = - & ; F
* $ B ( % = - #" & 5+
G F
? G = - # 1 #" " % % +2
! & +2 $ @ - 'F D !& %7 C &
6J &= = + +2 4 @ $ 0 B

& #$ :; </ 6 => 9?.B C 3 DE ) 8 - ",A YG F

3! - 3 3) 3# #>? 8" ." 3 Y G F
? '' K 3 ##
+2 # % 8 > = ! " 54 ' 4@ 7 - ' <#$
G F
? G = ! " 54 ' 4@ 8 & 6J &= )
7 5 -' = )' 4O 5+ 4 % F D 6N C &
, % 4 &M / % = - &8 Z ! & +2 )
?G F G $ -' * = = )' " 3= #$ ,
K6 > ! 4 & @ 5+ FD !& &
' > '( ;: 'R 4 & #8 &
#" 8& + + #" 8 ' 38 > 8:' ' 3
5 -' 38 'L 8 + 6J & % 5+ #" 3 ,
! " 54 ' 4@ % 8 > = ! " 54 ' 4@ K6 '
? G% F
G?=
D !& ' 8%7 &
G' F
G 7 8M 0 K6 ' 3= 12'( $ 5+ F
-' K6 - 4 @ $F !& &
8 9 7 ( < A -' 8'7 #$ ! & 5 - ' K6 #$
GX F
? G / 8 & 8 = !" # 4 ' ' 8 ;: '"

?'# K 3 \- ? ? 4[ 3 3 , 4 3 # 8% # . 3 54 Q / 4 & YG F
!" I 4 C 1 123" ( ) 0 GH * &' ( ) Y 7 3 01Z , 7 (
& '$ %
D , 0 ? # K 3 # X3 5 $ % 3 7 43# $ " 3 4 & .4 Y G%F
? X K 3 ##% 3 1 1 - 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 3 4 Y
(4) - Michel de juglart., Et autres, cours de droit civil, tome 1, éditions Montchrestien ,
paris ,treizième édition , 1997, p . 63.
(5) - A lex weill , Droit civil , les biens, éditions dalloz , paris , deuxieme édition ,1974,P317 .
 D M G CAPITANT F G COLIN F &
G F
G= ) 0 < 0 ! & K6 ' -' F
/ A 4 @ 5+ 9 , ' 4 44& 0 ; 2+
D ' & # 'H > #$ 4 8 A9 , $
4 M 8 &/ % 8 1M ' ! & K6 ' - ' $ 5+ F
G F
?G8 & &= ) 0 < 0
=7 4 3 8%7 $4 7 <#$ % 6
8' 7 +2 ' 4 5 -' .4 *, & 5 & $ 5+
= 1 = ! " - ' <#$ 4 '" ' G 8 & )2 F < A -'
? = !" 4 ' / 3 6J &= .
$ 0 * , = - 3 4% +2 = 4 5+ /+; 1 8 #
? % *,
.4 ;1 &/ % & 5+ !& =7
5+ % - 44 / , &> 6 3.
?
7 '& 4 5'6 ! %& '# " 3
8 & ): 7 )' 8 /A
5+ 7 4 " 4 4; C " %7 :
? $4 4 5+ 5 -, # 3 4 % K ,

G F - Colin et Capitant , traité de Droit Civil français , tome 2 , par juliot la morandiere , 1959 , p
372 .
. K3 3 2+ 3 & - 43 ! ) 3G. + F 54 .4 YG F
8 > , 44 . 4 % .4 9 4%
5 - ' K6 - ' 8 .4 *, 5+ F % G #F% F54 , 3 5+
? G F G= % % 7 ' 8 + !&
, <4 " /4& @ 38 4 K #$ @ @ & '
* , 4 " 8 " 8%7 # 4 % K
? 5+ >
! & 5+ @ 4 % G $$F F 54 ! 5 %7 &
5 - ' < A -' 8'7 K6 8 - ' .4 *, & 5 & 5+ F
?G= % % 7 ' 8 + !&
? @ % 4 > 7 4 % G < F 54 &
5+ FD GF 5F 54 / , & 4% 4 % /
0 8 & $ 0 .4 ! & < A -' 8'7 K6 5 - '
G F
?G = ) 54 & $ & 8 & M 3 6J &= )
8 ,3 2 64 / 5+ > / . 2+ 9
* % ! 3. ' . % # ' 3 ,% 8%7 <#$
6 ; ") # &@")" ." 8. 1A! " ' B7 7 <#$ )
4 G @ % F U;- ( : 5+ > % ;6
@4 : U #6M 3 C , * %
? 8%7 4 " %
-, B % A 8 * ' 5+ 2 " 7 *, #
? % - G. .4 F 0L 5+ 5
? 'K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F
3 4 3 %1 4 3 1 + 3 6# $ " *$ ,* 7 # 8% # . 3 ' 4 4 4 YG F
K 3 ### 3 ! -
#
! & 5 - ' < A -' 8'7 K6 - ' 8 .4 *, 5+ F
% ' 38 + .4 !& 6 3Z ' '
* 3 ' 97 ( =7 ( = 3 = % 5+ + 3= %
& * 5 3 #$ ! & = ) 0 0
) $ +2 ' 3 8 & - ' .# = , * =7 4
?G / =
( % - $ 44 ) 5+ > !& 4
"
) )'
? %7 ' 4 44 + - 5+ % - "
= 5+ C I B 3 - <#$ 4 4 , ; 6" 8%7 4
GEF
- 6 - # 5+ C % 3= 7 1
8 %7 ) #$ #6 " 3 4 @ 7 5 = 7 5 #6M
' 54 ' / #L F +2 I4 5+ '" I4 1 - 44 +
? G= ! " ) % 1M ' '" #" 4 @
! &> ) # 3 4 @ 5+ I 8%7 )
? 8%7 8 " )$# = 5+ % -
8+ (
1 5+ = / )' 4 3 = 5+ !" . # 2 % )$#
( Blandeau) 4 8 %7 % 5+ = 3 97 " = =7 " = 4
= - = 7 8 = #$ 3 !& 5 -' = ; 1
G F
? = 7 5+ ! ! #
6C7
? 7 6 -4 8 4% $ . # # @ @
? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

$
 .4 & &= % 8M = /7 @;- "
5+ ! & #$ %- / 3 % $ & $
? !& 8 V =- = 7 8 = #$ = %
! & +2 4 ! & 5 - ' = +2 @;- "
Q ( +2 3 I &4 <4, ,@ #" " $ 8+ & 6
G F
? 4, 5+
D V C !" . #$ 4 '
<# $ Z B;1 5+ I &4 = - & % % 9 Y
! 4@ 9 - 8+ : 8 & *% 4 &" . 4 +2 I &4
# # / #" 3 4 @ ' = !& > L # 5+
? S+ +2 - @; >
/ "= 5+ &" ! & %7 . #$ ) =7 " " 8 4
3 = &9 7 &= M C @B 3 8& 7 6"
. 8+ 4 4 ' +2 Z' & .4 %
? 1 5+ % L Z' % 3 76 5 &8 ' K6
L + 8 4 4 '" %% = 7: . #$
& % 5+ . #$ I # = / > , 5+
G F
? , & 7 ,
4 & 6 = % , % 5+ I 6N C
= #8 B #. , # = /$4 & 5+ = 3 % 8 M
, 3 5+ ! & 4 &( 4, +2 = , &
?/ 8 - .# 5 $0 + 4 % '(

G1FY Jeana louis bergel , et autres , traite de droit civie , les biens,edition delta , paris,2000, p142-143.
? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 Y G27
5
5+ 8 #6O !" ' +2 ! % '( #$ 47' )
G F
? & % -
9 :1 ;< =
#" 3 ) 7 6 4@ 8 2% ' ! & 4 4 4% . #$ 4%
= % $ ; Z = % = 5+ %
% "+ " 5+ 3 6N K6 % ( % / % 3
? / %
% ' 5+ 3 6 = & = !" = '@ / # !" >,
I 6 = % 2' 8& 9 7 = $= #$ ' 3 &
9 7 <#$ 4 ' $ G ' 3 =7 ( 3 3 '( 3 9 7 ( = F
! & % 54 = % <#$ &= ' 3 %
? )' ) ' %' )' $ 3 '
# $ 4 /+ " . $4 # 3 6 = 5+ %
4 ) # 3 !& 4 5 -' '' 5+ - * =7
< ( #$ 8 4% ) ' = % B 1 9 =6
)&? )'> "(
? ) ' )' $ " % ' 5+ 8%7 ) *
G F
? @ 1J % &) -' 4 @
=- * 4 C .4 *, @ ! & 5+ >
* =7 G4 C ' F 5+ 4 6 0
?I 6 . 2+ 4 % $ 4 5+

' K3 # = ' * 3 &4 D , ? 'K3 # = ' * 3 4 & .4 YG F

? X K3 3 1 - 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 #$" 3 4 !7- YG F
-Jean-louis bergel et autres , op. cit , p 142 .
 ' 1 0 F G 8' . 4 F %7 % B
! & 5 1 @ % +2 - @ = 4 @ 5+ M @ #"
!& ' 7 % $4 &" # G $ @ V2 % &= <+ .#
G F
? #$
' !& 5 - ' 5+ F. ' 4 %
= )' )' $ "; % $ 6 = $ =
7 5+ 3 @ &> 6 7 7 $
G F
? G @ 1J B4 -' 4 @ %
)' " = - 1 7 5+ . 2+ 9 V & 4%
? = K6 )
5+ 2% > #6 !" 2+ % ,% 8%7
G % < F 54 K %- )' $ 1 % &) 4 @
* =7 # $ = 1( ' ," 4 %
? 14
%' @ /0 + : 5+ % - !& 4
? % 0 $ A
"
) > CD E 4& => @6 A B
2 '8 & & 7 /1 3 4 7 $ % ! & 4 *, 4%
4 @ & 5 & 5+ 3 # 5+ /0 3 9
8 8 $ 3 0 8 & 0 !& 7 5 -'

? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

? XK3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 = + 4 &YG F

<
4 B 3 5+ * ; '( / 0 8 4@ 38 5+ $0
# 3 4 *, * 5+ 8 4@ 38 ! & 4 *, ;
? 0 8 & 5+ /0 )
$) F @6 A B (
. A #" 3 % 5+ + $
! #$+ "5 & ' ( 44 1 3: -6
?8
8 &" ! & .4 ! & +2 $ 5 -' 4 5+ /A
5+ # 3 -' 8 & 4 + " <+ 3 #
@ 7 0 & '8 "3 .4 !& = '"
8 #= $ = '" 5+ 3 % 5+
4 @ 5+ 3 @ -' . = 3 < 0 4 *,
4 # 3 5+ /0 /0 0 8 4 * #$
? + !& 4 5 -' 4 ; B %1
4 @ 1 $0 0 4 *, = - & 5+
5+ F 0 # $ ) % /4% # 24 %7 # 3 - 6
4 B 3 = ' 4 !& / % H - *, #G
' 7 * 1 0 #$ 3 %% 5+
54 B F %1 # 5+ B . 2+ .
D !& . 2+ 4 % G% #F

G # >;6 ! = # ) 8 C 7 = +2 F
? = 7 ) 8 #$ 4 0
/ 5 -' 8 & 5 -' ! & 4 *, $D & 5+
%
54 & / % 4 & * 5 *@ 5 - ' <#$
1J B4 4 @ 5+ #$ ! & 3 = #$ - 8 , % .# !&
? @
D8 G <$ F 54 K . 2+ 4 % &
8 '" ' - > * = $ F
?G 0 %
- '= !& 8 6 .# = FD ! & 8%7 &
G F
? G> ;: ' '
D 7 % Z,
! " .4O 4 @ @ 1J B4 4 @ ! " :2 &5 & $
! # % > - $ # )' ! 3= )' "
?= &B 4 % - -
!& 8 - ' .# :2 # 3= &5 & D #$" "
' 4 4 8 > 8 ;: '" 8 'L 1M ' @ 5 -'
? G F
%
+2 B 3 % *, * .4 *, =7 4 * #$
#" % *, #$ > 6 4@ 3 8 & &= )
G% F
? 5+ = !& = . !" 4 ' +2
D 5+ @ 7 / 0 #
? '' K 3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F
3 1 4 3 6 #$" 7!! !" 5 / * E. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F
? '#% K 3 3 54 4 1 1 - 3 3 @ %
3> 5M 6 >,*$ ,* E > 1 #1 ?)" # $ " 7 # 8% # . 3 ' 4 Y G%F
?' K3 '3 4 '(

F
 $ )& B GH 0 +E . /
3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 3 C * I &4 F $ I &4 B;1 5+ !
? % C / ' G 54 4 & >@ I &4
C * I &4 3 = % '( I &4 F B;1 I &4 !
?G 54 4 & >@ I &4 3
5+ - -% 1 &4 # 3 -' ' 1 5+ I &4
? 1" 4 /+ ' 4% % 1 I &4
7 31 I J +E 3
D 1( = - B & 5+ > 6
@ @ /@ 9 3. .4 & 1 5+ 1 Y
5+ 1" 3 . !& @ .4 $4 7
$ A 4 54 1( = - 4 @
? 5+ K;6 '" Z' (
&4 Q B 5+ * % ) 1L K6
?G ' 4' AF) 4 !"
@& K= @6 LBM =K " 3
* + /4 2 % 54& % M 5+ + / /$
3 &4 24 6 % # G 5+ I &4 = I &4 F &4
? 8% - 6 &4
$ N, 01 @6 A B "(
5+ 5 4 G % %& F ! & ; '(
4 ; '( #" 3 % 7 6 * - 6 1
A )' 2 % - )' ) '
?8 4 % 8+ 4 4
 G F
? G8 8 .4 ! & 4 *, F 8 ! & ; '( >
4 *, 1 8 38 .# % 2 ' ; '( 4 #
@" * 4 A 5+ . 3 4 *, ' !& / % ; '(
8 &! ' )' ! " ; '( .4O 3 # #
?G F
+ 54 5+ '" ! " 4
; F 8 ! & ; '( 4 % G <<# F 54 & 4%
# K6 # 3 5 A 4
?G/ # B A
6 )' % 8 &" ; '( / 0 L #$ ! &
? 6 +2 A 8 & ; '( M % 54 K 3 %
.4 ( 4 5+ & - 6" - 6 4 @ ; '(
? ' 1
B 6 @ @ $ 3 4% K 6 @> $;
? G% F
= (
D 4 % 8%7 4 ;6
8 1 8 & !6 3B 8 %& ! & 4 *, $D F) *
? 6 4 ; M 8@ " C : 8 8 $
3 )' 2' ' 5+ * ; '(
1 . ! & 4 *, 1 .4 !& %
D $ 7 6 "
? ' ' K 3 ##X 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 !" $ " 3< ' YG F
? # K3 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 6 >" $ 7 # 8% # . 34 '/$ " YG F
?' %K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 & Y G%F
4 * , !& + 54 $ 1J = % )- %% 5+ Y
5+ I &4 ! - )- , 4 5+ #
! &4 *, 4 +. ; '( ) -
?8 4 Z, )'
.# 8 & &= ) " *% 5+ Y
3 - #" 5+ I &4 ! 0 8 & 0
8 & 4 *, / .# % F3 8 4 8 ; '(
G8

4@ & % $ 5+ & 2 " Y%

? % ' & 54 4 $ ; '( & 2
$= LO @6 A B "(
: ! & ; '( $ 4 *, 4 / 7 !& % 8%7 =7
' 3 / / = ' 3 ; '( #$ ' 3 %-
B 1 % 8 &) B 3 % #L
G F
? 8 4& ,
38 " " .# $ 5+ / 7 /& 4 *, / 7 #$ ! &
=% 4@ #" 5+ # 3 %- ! & ; '( 4 *,
5+ ] &4 ! 3 5+ .4 6 0 $ 3! # 4 *,
$ . 0 #$ ! & % 5+ 4+ - #"
? 5+ I &4 I 6 $! 3

? %'K 3 # = ' * 3! :2 , . ; ") 3 4 6 4& YG F

*2 4 F* 4% 4 % 4%& ) ' !& & , 4 4 *,
4@ + +2 $ *2 ' ; G8 ' @* !&
M' 4 # 4% 7 <#$ . 3* 4% " 4 "
; 5+ $ 3 8 4 94 3 ' 4 3 O !&
4 *, .4 +2 $ " @ +2 O$ !'
) ' A 6J ) ' : !& & , 4 4 *, 5 2 4 *'
<#$ ) : = ' 4 1 B 4% &
5 /, $ . : ! " 5+
? 4 *,
* " $ 5+ 3 5+ /& 4 *, I #
4 @ &4L % & 2 8 L 4 *, 3 4
?) : @ ' .4 4% @> & 2
? <4 4 4 *, 9 9 5+ V ' #
= 6 - ' $ 5+ !" K6 =' ;6
= '" ! & < A -' 8'7 4 5 -'
? = ) 0 8 & 0 * = %
4 ' > #$ 5+ > !& % 8%7 =7 " 8
? : $
1J % &) -' 4 @ &5 & $! # 5+
8 @ / 0 5+ & 3 14 * 42 ' < ( $
0 < A &> 6 ; 0 8 8 8 2 6
?8

#
 !" # $ %&

-' 8 .4 * , @ & 5 & 5+ ='

= % = ! & 4 5 - ' < A -' 8'7 K6
= ) 0 8 & 0
= , * =7 4 &M K6 / @ = - & !M 4 5 - ' <#$
? # / = ) $ K6 #$ ' 8 & - ' .#
.4 ) = 4 6 0 $ 5+
? +2 8 0 .# = 8 &4
= % ; Z 4 !& 4 5+ 4 #
? % = % !& 4 G F
8 + 5+ ; Z .# -
? /4 % 8 )' + 6 8 &4 Z
4 # 5+ % 5 24 = % 6 = % Q 6
?= % $ A 4 = % !& % 5+
? S 5+ $
$ '' !& / % 4 5+ = ' > !" 9
= ) 54 & $ 4 & & 1 .# .4
+2 1 .# . 8 , 64 5+ 9 ,
? 8'7 ) ' & <#$ + <4 @
5 #6 5+ 44 9 4 5+ / @ #$
+2 I4 . .4 9 =% % 5+
5+ 5 ' 0 & 4$ % - - *
, 4 5+ 4 # . >6 ,

$
 !" # $ %&

? 4 .4
?S & 5+ $
4; W $8 8 & ; ' ! & +2 5 -' 4 W 4
' +2 ' ' % + 44 @ ## 5+
?+
% 4 +2 4 0 4@ 5 - ' <#$ 4 4 )' 5+
? >;6 ' = - & < A !"
? + M $4 /4 5+ ' - B4 4@
?S + > S % > S 5+ )' >
9 5+ / & -% <#$
GEF
& , / $ G% G % %F 4 , 4 % . 2+
B 7 #$ ;6 M # ' 4 = ' $ A
5+ & B4 , + Z = % & 5+
7 #$ B & 5+ # /0
? 1 B + % 5+ )' = - & B 4 /1

6 O ' 54 3/ 4 4 % , # X^ #^ _ O X ^ X /@ Y GEF
? 44 3 # X^ #^%

5
 !" # $ %&

$ K / QR / GP
) 3 &= 4 6 0 $ 5+
!& 4 5+ +2 8 0 .# = 8 &4 .4
<# $ - G F = % ; Z
? /4 % 8 )' + , ?8 +
S 5+ ; Z = % $
.4 F 5+ % $ 1J ) 5+ / % - #"
? 5+ !& > ) G.
9 $ 3 9 " 3 54 5 #6 5+
? S 5+

GP
-' & -' $ $4 3 $4 4 ! & 5+ 4
? 4 A ' ' 4 !" & 7 /'% 3 4
4 3 = % ; Z $ D .4
5+ = 3 = % = ;
/ - 5 24 & 6 $ F8 +
?G % /
)' + 3 6 8 &4 Z )
G F
? ? /4 % 8

? '%X K 3 # = ' * E ' 4 YG F

 !" # $ %&

% 5+ 3 % %& !" & /'%

/+ ' = % !& , =- = % !&
? 5+
/' % 7 6 2' % 8 5+ ; Z B
D !" ' 4
$ +E GP (
? 5+ ; % $ 3 5+ @ $
$ )6 ./
! &= % = 4 /+ ' 5+ !" 4 5 ( :
; @ 5+ $ 24 - $ 3 5+
5+ #$ ! & ? /4 % 8' + , 3 &= 8 &4
+2 ' 5+2 + % %
G F
? !& &= ) @ ' :
2 % %& . ' 3 .4 !& 4 5+ #L
? + 7
%& - %& ' & * % !& 4 5+
? /4 % )' Z 38 + / 3K 6
% '" B 2 !& 4 , 3 5+ 7 ! & 5+ 4
!& ' @ + Z + 7 ) 2 ! & ,% 8%7
K6 1 5+ $9 5+ 3 2
!& , K6 1 + Z 3 2' * 2 = + /
? K 3 ## 3 4 '( 3 7 4E # " 9 1! $ 3 54 / 4 & YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

# - 5+ &M / % +2 K6 + 9
? & <# @ / @ 4
% $ 1J * / 1 5+ L # !& Y
8 82 64" : 3 - #" 5+ . &4 * /
2 5+ - L /4 % + = 3 82 @ 8
) 5+ 8M 3 < A 4 - 6 +2 4
! @ = ,$ ) #$ K6 ) # C :
G F
? Z ' 0 C :
$ ) 6 > ST 3
D 5+ +
) = )'6 ) ' U
; 5+ + /4& ! & ,% % 8%7 =7 " 4%
7 6 G 4 F &( K 6 4
% 3 3= - 1 3 @) @ !, % 7
5+ 4 % % * L #$ ! & 3 $ A
+ 5+ *,6 3 7 6 4 4 *,
G F
?/ *7 8 6 * =7 .# 4% = 7 " = % / %
3 5+ 4 9 ,6 / !& / %7 " 4%
? /4 % )' &+ > + /4&
> + F . 2+ 4 % G %F F 54 44 #$

K 3 \-? ?4 [ 3 4 '( 3 & - 4E 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& YG F

? #
? % Y % K 3 8'7 * YG F

%
 !" # $ %&

? G /4 % $+ 4
54 G $F 54 G+ /4 % > % /4& F 4 #$ ! &
G F
FF H H _ O - ; , F H# % G F

! + + 6 @ A #$
! + 8 !" 5 ( : 3 7 K 6 7 & +
! & 5+ I &4 35+ . &4 * <#$
4( 4 , : 4, # / ' K6
G F
? K6
)- V ) F ) = )R B U
6 &( 6 4 %
A $ /4 % & = . )' + + K6 4 /'
> 34 4 "3/ *7 6
)' ) ' 7 $ ' ) ' 6 / 4 >
?4 H 6
5+ + ' 7 . * % C 4%
& & ' 3 )' /4 % = - & 4 6
70 * O- ; <#$ 8 , .# P: ) )' # 5 7 <#$
= - 4 '" K , 4% 3 $ ' ! & 4(
G% F
? & .4 8 * ; 9 #$ ! & /4 % 5+ /0

? X 44 ## ^ ^ 6 O ' 54 0 YG F
3 # = ' * E 6 #$" *$ ,* 7 ! ! !" 5 / * E. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F
? K
/'@ 3 1 + 3 3# . # I 2 ! >) # " 3 G *$" ! ) 73 &Y G%F
? ## K 3 '3 4 ' =2 1

F
 !" # $ %&

! "4 4 >;6 $ M' <#$ K 6 % >;6 0 4% 2+

? % K C C A
> $O 6 4 ; 8%7 ) I B
# ^F % 4 # # /4 % & ,6 + Z 3= -
? # > ' - ; =
> @ A - ; FD ! & 8 54 B
; H % % = % ; 5 4" *,6 + /4 %
G F
? G8 * / % # > 6 -
# 7 ' G $F 54 K 7 6 / 7 K6' '7 Z'
5+ 9 ,6 % + /4& 54& % A 6 - ;
? /4 %
K :" 54 K ' #" 6U 0 A $
3 ( 0 ` .# 3 4 % G %F F 54
+7 = ' 4 @" * / 4 A <#$ ! & 82 %
<4 O / 4% K6 K #8 8 . #$ 3 6
G F
? @ + ! 5# ' 3 & .4 # ' #$ 6
G%F
? !' > # '
' 4 ; 5+ + /4& 1 # > 6 . $Z .

5 4 ' 54 3 - ; @ , ## ^ ^ _ O % ^# /@ % YG F
? X 44 3 ## ^ ^
K3 '3 2+ 3* + & - $ 43# . 1 " 3 & .4 3 @ + ! YG F
? #
3 * ' 44 3 =2 1 /'@ 3 # ! J " # " 3 G # . 1 " ! 2 !F3> !' Y G%F
?% K3

#
 !" # $ %&

# $ 4 % 6 %F 7 54 K ! & 4 &" 6 &

D.
! & 6 5+ 6 4 ; 9 ,6 + ' "
? 4 6 % - "
5+ ; <#$ 1 9 ,6 + 4 8 54 K " /1
$ 44 3 # 7 ' 6 %F 7 54 , * = -
? > 6 ; 5 4" ' 7 6K
5+ ! "9 , 6 = 6 4 < > = L 8 &
? $ 1J * )
G F
? 4 2 ,% 4 ( / * #$
D $ "5 ( : $ A M' $
?S )' /4 % + 5+ P , 9 ,6 $
4 & 4" / # # 6 4 ; , P ,
/ 4 FF5H FH 5 _ O HF5 ) . % 8 @ 4
% . % 8 % = FF H H % _ O 5^F H
D 54& %
G F
? 4 + ' + /4& . 3 5+ & ,6 + /4& $
L 4; * &5 6 4 #" 8 % ;6
& .4 ) : 4, +; 7 4 9
4 /4& * 3 54 , 5+ & 6/ # 34 > -

? ^ '^ ' _ O 4 4( : & 4 #' %% /@ % YG F

? % : & 4 ^ ^ _ O # /@ %
? # K3 # = ' * 3 & 4 3 @ + ! YG F

#
 !" # $ %&

# ) : <#$ ! & .4 *@ #" 4& % % *

$4 4 '( 5+ . &4 * ,% = - ' + 4(
? C *
)W > 7 ' U#
%7 ! & 7 =4 4 M 8 !& & ' ; $
? K 6 >@ / & >@ & $ 3 6 < 8 !&
)' # /4 % )' + + & 7@ ;
G F
? 6 /4 " & = +
E ( BX U$
<# $ '3 & !& 4 Z %% 5+
<# $ 1 3. @ & @ &
? 5+ ; Z &
I4 ! & & + + 9 #$ 4 & "
G F
)' ? 5+ ; 4 7" !& .4 Z 8 !
? - #" 5+ . &4 ! )' /4 %
$I +E GP "(
# 5+ ; 4 Z = % 5+ &4 = % $
D '
$Y + AH M I ./
4 ' 3 5+ ; $4 3 = % ! & 5+ 4
? 5+ 9 ,6 6 = %

? %X K 3 # = ' * 3 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& YG F

? 'K3 # = ' * 3 54 / 4 &Y G F

#
 !" # $ %&

<#$ 2 ' 38 & & 7 = % = = % 5+ +

!& I 6 = % = . = '" 6 = %
4 & / % '( #$ 8 , % '" .4
= % # = #$ '" ! " 4 % * 3 &= - * =7
G F
?= % 5+ 5+ <#$ ! ' 3 =7 ( ' '( 9 7 (
= 2 4 5+ /+ ' = % 5+
8+ = ) C 7 8 5+ @ .+ $ # 1
?8 & &= '" 4 %
$ $ % !& $ = )' * - ' 5+ $ 24
A % #" )' # 3 % - /4 % +
A #" 5+ $ $ % ' # 3 $ @ $
4 8 & $ = )' 8L ' 24 $
G F
? G +2 4' % 5+ F 8+
= 2 4 5+ /+ ' = % K6
24 3K 6( = 3 ' $ + ( = 1 3 + Z ;
5+ / K 6( = # 24 ' $ +
? 4
D 5+ + Y + :.Z I 3
) [\4 I U
@ @;& & 5 & # 3 5+ ; 6 = % &(
8 !, % 8 : ' 8 ' !& -' 4 24

? K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F

?X K3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & YG F

##
 !" # $ %&

# 3 4@ .# ! %% +2 ' M' 6 =
> #$ 8 & 7 !& = ) 8 .# 4% -
5 O &= . ' M' 3 , & +2
M' 5+ # 3 O @ 6 = 8 "+
%% 5+ , 4 5+ + 5 O '
? ' M' 8& 8 'L $ O
GEF C 5+ I &4 ' , +2 6 % #"
= " 3 6 = !& 4 Z %% 5+ #
6 = )' , +2 4 # 3 4 &( * 4 @O
; 8 ' .# K6 , +2 9+ /@ 3 /4 %
4@ @; ' !& 9+ " 3 5+ I &4 * +2 +
G F

Z 5+ 6 = 5+ & % !" 5 ( :
24 $8 / 0 $0 24 + & .+ $ "
? 5+ 4& @ 8 & = - 8 &4 .# 6 = +2 1
4 V4 B F 4' 8 1 4' 6 = 4' #"
6 = Z -% 424 & G 8 1 4 +2 4 ' +2 4'
G F
? 8+ Z %

?5+ . &4 * M' 5+ !& . 2+ 4 % ^' 54 Y GEF

?X #K3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F

#$
 !" # $ %&

)& ]' I U
Z ; 3 = % ; 4 ( !& " 4 5+
!& 4 # 3 > = % !& 4
4 8 7 = 34 6 7 5 1 " $ 4 A
8 & 6 9 6 = 8 7O >O 8 .
? ; . /'( = &
; Z 4 * !& 4 5+ & 4
3 = % = &4 @ M
? /4 % 8 )' +
Z 8 L 6 & ' 4 ; *
6 = % 3 9 5+ Z # +
. % /0 4 % 8 &K 5+ /0 $ 0
? /0 /1 /0 B 5+ !& > )

#5
 !" # $ %&

^ ' 4 D +E GP "(
5+ / 0 & I4 . % /0 B 5+ 4 %
4 2+ 8 .# /0 0 4 % 8 &K
? ;% '
% !& %- G 4' % 5+ F 54& @ #"
5+ = - & % <#$ ! & @ : /;&" $ 4 .4O
5 , L %' 1+ -/ % ' 8 "
/; &" ! " / 0 #$ >4 3 - <#$ * / ; K 6 @ /0 4 ,%
% '; % % 3 & @ % <# %% ; :
% 4 ! ' .# . % $ /0 #$ %
/0 @ ' -B .4 @ 44 @ 4& @ = - &
? 7
D^ ' 4 %& '# . /
%& 1 ! =4 4& % & $. %
4 & % <#$ M : < K6 K6 %& = %
! & 54 I 6 % = % = /0
<# $ ) : /; & =% & 9;- 54 ; ' %
G F
? %- 15 @ = )' $ %
D. % 0 4
/ 0 / ' > '' = % ) ' !& 4 /0 _
# X ' @ 2+ 8 .# 6

? XK 3 3 2+ 3 46 43 : /) # . 8) >/ 3 YG F

#
 !" # $ %&

/0 $ '' % !& 4 /0 _
# M 54 ; %1 B % %' =%
_ O <$H<5 ) /0 2+ . % 2 /&4
G F
? F<5H H

D ' !, % = - #7 + #$ 64
?/ , Z' 4 4&" , F< H #H 5 _ O H< /@ / ' _
G F
?. % ' 'M , F< H #H 5 _ O #H< /@ / ' _
$ 5 4 * . 4" > 0 !" . % ' ' 4 ' 4%
# . % - =% ! / 0 >4 3. % 0
! &4 $ @ ' 44 % K6 4
D $ ''
% 4 : &5 & $ , Z' & 1 .4 '_
- -6 ' , ' =2 1 ' % 44 C :
. % ' 4 54& %
=2 1 & @ ! >4 .# . % ' 1 @ ' _
<#$ M &+ % = % 1 % * - #
G% F
? 5 6

? # 44 3 # X^ ^ 6 O ' 54 0 YG F
? % 44 3 # ^ '^ % 6 O ' 54 0 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 YG%F

#<
 !" # $ %&

' B %- 1 5 @ 4 / 0 a4 /$
-@ @ " 3 %- 5 % 4 !& 4 & 1 '
<#$3 ' 4% 8 > = % !& 4
%1 B ) 6
8 /4 % 5 = % )' " + /4& 4 !" , 3. % '
?5 4 = % ,
D_' 4 D! )F 3
+ /4& 4 %- 1 5 @ 4 6 / 0 a4 1 4%
0 5+ /0 4 * 6 % % /4 % 5 = % )' "
' ! & / % .# )' /4 % / 0 4 % > @
? )' ) ' 4 5+
,6 % /4 % 5+ /0 &" "D 1 U - .# O'
DI 6 5 /0
/4 % / 0 ' ' 5+ /0 !& 2 ,% /0 $
% 8 4 /0 #$ / % )'
?S )' ) ' ,8 &K + 4
# /0 0 /4 % 5+ 8 ! & 8%7 ) A =7
.# =- 4 % 4 ! & ' ' / % .# / 0 #$ a4 * C
B 4& ) ' $ ' 4 % = % !&
G F
?
)' + + ' 5 % #!
G5 % 5+ 1 F ' 1 >;6 ! & /4 %

3 % : 2 ,% 4 3G . & * *$" ! ) F3 G . + F .4 54 YG F
? K3 '3 4 ' =2 1 /'@ 3 1 + 3

#%
 !" # $ %&

2@ = % 4 $" # /4 % = )' 4 #"

? %' /4 *
0 = )' /4 % 5+ / 0 #6 /4 % "
4 % 54 6 K = - /4&
A , *, 6 8 #3 % 4 .#
? 5+ <#$ ! & 54 , )' , 5+ '
1" 4) )' ) ' 4 $ & 5+ 4 $
9 4 &" /0 $ <#$ ! & 4 .# 3 %
1 Z' & 4 C &
/ / A 4 4' 2+ % %^
?G F 4 ' ; % <#$ ! & +2
3 $4 % K6 &* ' -" 9 *4 #$
- ) 4 & , H / Z' & / 0
, /4 % 5+ /0 !& 4 & !" ) ' , 1 4
4' <# $ = 6 # 4' ' A
4 1 4' C C ' # . % ' $
D $ ! 4 5+ !&
4 = K_
Z' 4 4 &" , <$H<5 !, % /0 2+ #
54 $ &8 % - /' 8 . % ' 'M / ,
0 - I ' !& 4 & Z' ! &
+ 4 5 , /1 6 -( 44& K% <#$
? XK 3 ' 3 2+ 3*+ $ 4 3 #8 B # . #$" # " 3 & .4 YG F

#F
 !" # $ %&

@ J =6 !& 5 4( & , <# 4 "

44& 4 C 4 8 )'F . % - & 7 !&
1 /$ ' G @ 4 ' =2 1 4 544 % 4
@ ' " =% 3 4 ' ; 5+ ' # %
#5 H%# / ' ' !" 9 4 # 3 % !& 5 ' 4
5 4 %& 4 4&" )' /4 % 1" " , F%#H 5H #
G F
? > & ,
&5 & )' /4 % % ) ' " 54 !' 5 4%&
8 6 8-' 4 4 % H % - =1 @ 4 '
3 4% ) -Z !& )' /4 % ' !& " ,
?G F Z' &4 / / =- % - 8 4$ /$
0 $ & $ 4% #$ 5+ !& 9 4 & 4@
#5 H%# / ' ! 54 K , # = %%
B4 R N ! *,6 / 4 ) + K6 F
-% A5 ' 5+ 9 %& F<5H H _ O <$H<5 /@

_ O 5%H<5 / %- ' ;& & 9+

= 1 ) & O' )- 8 4 % , F<5H FH

?G > &( , 5 4%& @" K 6

' " $ 1 V )' /4 % 5+ 4& @ 4 M 54 <#$ ;6
4 4&" 4 / / 4 @ I 6 % = % %
?. % ' 'M , Z'

? 44 3 # %^ X^ ' 6 O ' 54 0 YG F
?% K3 # =' ' * 3 #8 B # . #$" # " 3 & .4 YG F
$
 !" # $ %&

54 7 '; $ ) - # > ' #5 H%# / ' / 44 #$

?8 & ( # 5 4%&
8 4 4 54& 4$ Z ! & 4 & =1 5 4%&
% 0 % 5+ $ 1 4 @ 4 !&
@ 544 % - : /& !" % %_% < 4 / , 4
? $
5 7 54 5+ $ 4 @ ! & / % .# )' /4 % 5 4%&
' 1 @ ' 5+ <#$ +
.# 8 % 8 & +2 L # 3 ' 4 ) - .#
?5 4%& 4 4&( =1 !" /4 % 8'
+2 > - 8 4% ) 4%& 4% #$ #
? GEF 4 Z' / %
B 5+ @ ! & 8' ' 4 5 4%& /4% K6'
G ' 4 3 ; 3U , F - G. .4 F
544 8 . % 4%& 5 4% 3 !& @4
4' < : *,6 % 1 4' 4' $ 4
?G F
'
4 % ' !& 5 4%& - 5 ; 0
54 = - & )' /4 % 1" ! & <4 & 6 8 " 5 1
8 4% ) - % =% /4 K% 54 & 4
& /0 5+ 54 $ 6J .+ 4' B4 ' !" 9 4 # 3< A
?. %

? /0 0 1 4 4 ' 4 .# . % 4 / ' Z' &/ "4 GEF

? %%K 3 # =' ' * 3 & .4 G F
$
 !" # $ %&

D ? `_
% - 9 ' 9 /@ 5 4%& ) !"
.# . # : ' ' -" 1 ' B4 ' 6
FF H H % _ O 5HF /@ % ;6 # , ; % /0
?G F . % 8 ,
/ 13. % Z' &4 '' / ;7 , @ 9' 0
=% & 1 % K6 4 & 1 ' 5 ,
54 # > ' 5HF % G #FF 54 K B4 ' 3 ;7
+ 1 8 + 54& +2 Z .+ 4 ' 5+
;7 , C A # 3
? 1 '; C % @ 3 7 U +
! & % 5+ !& . % 8 @ - 9 4 &
D ! & 6 #F 7 54 K B 5+ 54
F<5H FH _ O 5%H<5 % # 54 / 7 )' K6 F
-% A 5 ' $4 %& / 6 ,
3 5+ 54 ! ' .+ 4' !& 3 ;& 24 $
4 4& / / =- # . % ' *,6 $
? GEF G , Z' '
5$HF / @ .# 7 / ' 4 ' 5+ 54 4 4&" 7
?G F
' 5+ 54 4 4& 7 , .# FF H <H < _ O

? '# 44 3 ## ^ ^ 6 O ' 54 0 G F
? 5+ $ $4 % 5 & 1 54 <#$ K M-6 $ GEF
? % 44 3 ## ^ ^% 6 O ' 54 0 G F

$
 !" # $ %&

! &> @ $ 4' #$ B 4 ' ! 9 * 4 .# '' >4

, ; ;% ;: ' =% ! -' '' :
+2 C % Z # 3 46 1' * !& ;7
$ 7 U + 5 $ 0 ! & ,% # &* ! ,
? ;7 ,
& + & /1 3 % <#$ ! & 1 4' ) A 8
. %& / 0 -" / / 7 1" 8 M 4' %1 / 4%
!& / , <#$ Q 6 , <#$ .+2 54& '
48 % 38 > ' 4" % 1 5+ 54
- M 5+ M +2 %' !& <
, *, 6 .# = ' 48 @ % .+ 4' M
?G F
' (
' 54 , + # K6 # > ' 5$HF / ' B #$
@ 4' !& Z' &4 / =- @ !&
*@ .4 2 > - / /' , ! & /$4 *,
A 7 $' 5 -6 5+ 54 4 )- % 8 6 5 24
5+ ! &4 & % @- & . % ' 5
? , ; / Z' &/ 0 )' ) ' /$ 4

? #K 3 ' 3 2+ 3*+ $ 43 >/ "3 & .4 YG F

$#
 !" # $ %&

$ % ' 9 @O 2 1' 5+ 54 /A
5 1" * - ' 4 ' !, % C ! & 4 *, Z " 4' 4
?G F
4' 4 5+ 54 4 ' 54 % )' /4 % Q
/ =- # . % ' # 5+ /$ '
? Z' &4
^ '8 7 BK Ja ! = ) F =]0_#
C 4 = 65 4 %& "
8 4 @ 4' !& =1 / # 4( K 6
$ A 5$HF / ' 5#H%# / ' K ' / 7 /1 3 =
5#H%# / ' / : ! 9 5 4 '
= % & - /' 4' /0 8 4 ' 5 4%& 4 4& =
, .# <H H < _ O H < /@ % !, % # . %
= % = - & 4' / ' % = 'M
?G F . %&
2+ , )A # 5+ !& , 9 4 & % #$
. % / % 4 9 4 4 * 4 -&" 3 4' 4 +2
+2 ; = % * , /4& , / ' @ ' !&
4 '! & Z' / 2' !& H < % K
? . %& = % = - & = 4

? ' 5+ 54 4 4&" 7 , X'^# / ' ' 54 YG F

? X 44 3 ^ ^ 6 O ' 54 0 YG F

$$
 !" # $ %&

*,6 / % -% 8 !& % #$ 1 54
8 #3 4' + , ; / Z'
, = 1 4 4' $. % 4 C 7
? '
5+ . - K6 F D !& 8 54
$ 4' + 6J K6 -' 5 8'7 '3 %& ! &
4' 8 ' 8 = . %& = % Z )- <;& 1 54
?
K6 2 . % 07 Z O' ! " . % =% Z -8
?G @"
/ ' !, % 4 .# /0 !& H < % 4 /0 4%
. % =% = I# %H 5H F _ O $<H % /@ .# 7

?G F
4' / '
4 $<H % / ' # > ' H < % K % '" ;6
. % =% / % M # 4' !& % : 7, 4 9
/ % %' # 5 4%& % ' =1 4
@O , : = % ) - = 1( %%
G *' *,6 F 8, =% V2 , @ )'
+2 ; > - 5 1 , & U 7 K6 ' !%
". % =% 3 % !& &= 94
? Z /4 , # !" / #L &+ > - Z

? 44 3 ^ X X 6 O ' 54 0 G F

$5
 !" # $ %&

I &4 * C Z /4& , /; ' ;6

4 A !" >@ 6 2 ,% / 5 2 ,@
? I &4 /
8 U ' M 5+ ; =% Z )- ) 1 #"
/' . % /@ # / )' /4 % = - & = !&
4 $4 . % ' . % =% 1 = % # %
? 4'
% 0 1 $ A !" $
% %% " - % 4 4 ' 4 4&L @ 6
4 54 & .# =1 4 #$ 2 ,% ! & &+ > - "
8 6" Q 4 $4 % <# / %
0 7 5+ = % 9 >4$ 0 & >0
/ 4% + 4 5+ 1" -' / -, 3 : = %
? %& + !" ! " * # A

$ . .4 $ '' ! & / % 5+
D 5+ %% !& >

$
 !" # $ %&

"
$ R /
8' 7 K6 5 -' & 5 & F $ 5+ / 7 % ' ' 4 ;6
&= ) 87 ! & 4 5 - ' < A -'
?G #$ ! &

.4 $ '' 5+ !& % 8%7 * 4%

+2 $ 7 5 - ' =% / #L 3 4 5+ / @ 3.
5+ 9 , = + * 6 $ 0 =7 + !&
; " ! " +2 4& 4 % / #" 3 .4 8& $

= ) 0 0 * 8'7 ) ' 5+ !" 8 > "

G F
? /4 % )' $ % 1N * ) 5+ ;

5+ @ 7 3 5+ =% #$ $ 0

? 5+ %% B ) , %
6 élement material 7 ^? ER (

" .4 / 7 K;6 '( . 2 + % 5+ > 4 8 /A

? .4 7 54& 4 B 3 8%7 8 !" 9 8

G F YPhilipe bihr, droit civil géneral , éditions dalloz , paris, treiziéme édition , 2000, p 187 .

$<
 !" # $ %&

$ ^? ER ./
8 12 '( <+ L 3 !& = ) $ & & $
G F
? -8 Z' %- 8 97 ( 8 '" 4
<#$ + +2 - - F D 8M C 8 &
5 -' 8 & -' 8 !& - ' 8 +2 4 -@ -
.4 !& 5 <4 , +2 ) 8 #$
G F
?G % 8 > 8 L 7
5 -' = - &= !& ! & 4 *, D 8 ! & C 8 &
G% F
? 8 > 8 '" 8 & 7
+2 4 5+ - 8 #!
5 #L 3 5+ 9 , = , > 6 "
) 3= ) 4 *, ,% = 6 -'
= % 2' ' $ +2 4 .4
/+ ' = % <#$ + G ' 3 '( 3 9 7 ( 3 = F
B > 6 L =7 ( = 3= ) 4 4
, % #$ =7 % 542 7 ) 8 =7 % !& = #$ . -
7 # 3 =7 ( = 4 8 =7 %
% * =7 ( = &5 4 & 5 +2 / @ .4
8 4 %

G F YPhilipe bihr , op . cit , p 187 ?

? XK3 3 4 '( 3 7 43 *" *$" ! ) 3 4 &4 4 YG F
G3F Y Michel de juglart , op . cit , p 63.

$%
 !" # $ %&

$ ^? []' ) F BK 3
7 5 -' = % 4 & " 5+ .4 =% 8 !" 5 ( 4
= , 64 4 & 8 % # 3+ ! & +2
+2 ) = = #$ #L 3 8 0 +2 0 .#
+2 / % 6J & % " 3 $ 4 &
?= #$ ) / % 4 &
D +2 4 .4 & -
B 5+ !& 4 B $ 5 1 Y
?+ !& = ) $ & <#$ M :
C $4 7 G ( $ * F % "Y
3 5+ 8 K6 4 4@ 3 5+ .4
#$ 3 % !& 7 -' $ 5+ ) - @ -' &
+2 ' 54 7 % <#$ I 4 /4&
G F
? @ ' " 5+ !& 0
.# = % - .4 4 & - Y%
= % 7 # & 7 3 +2 8 &4
=% 87 % + 3 , >; 6L > 6 3 ' +2 4
54 & / % = , 64 & * 8 % 8+
? 8 97 ( % ;: '" /4$
4 & * / % 8 3 =7 " = ) 87 % +
: ! & .4 ! = #$ , ! 64
?= % ' #$ +2 %& Z 2 1 '" 2 & 8 =7 %
D , 0 ? X% K 3 # = ' * 3 4&4 @ 4 YG F
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 G. + F .4 54 Y

$F
 !" # $ %&

0 +2 $ 4 & - Y
> 0 @ 544 4 *, ! & 4 7 " 3 % @4
? 0 % '' B 3 '
! & 4 5 - ' K6 / % 4 & #" 4%
4 % *,6 & , M' 8 4& .4 8 / % .# !&
? I &4 > 0 *2 @ )' 9 , ,@
+2 ! " % 4 4 "G 4 5 - ' F .4 =% 4@
$G4 A < : % %& #$ 'F?< A
= % 4 @ 4 5 - ' <#$ 4 ' 4 8 & -' + +2
* F +2 ! " % /1 .# : % " 4 5 -'
?5 4 5 -' & $ G ;1
- ' $ 4@ 3 $ #$ 8'7 4 5 - ' K6 4@
! & 4 5 -' + 3 -' 4 5 -' =% #$ 3 :
D 5+ 4 5 -' C ' # 39
$ )&? b - "3
D <#$ ! & , % ' # 3 5+ 4 5 - ' =%
D N = 6a AH 8& J EK ` )&? b U
C 7 4 5+ 5 <#$ 3 7 5 -' , !'
% # '4 5+ 4 ' / 4 " % ! & +2 5 -'
G F
?G ;1 = ' 5+ F8 < : +2
+ M 5 4 8 - ' =% 3< A 5+ +2 = / <#$

G FY Braaudry lacantinerie, traité de droit civil ( de la prescription ) , tome 28 , edition daloz , p 175 ?

5
 !" # $ %&

8 4 & 8 & 4 + " <4 %

G F
? 54 &
! & +2 8 # ' " .4 &4 5 <#$ 4 #
4 @ @> 4 ' 8 & 4 5 -' $5 3+
# '( 4+ ( # '( 4 3 %% = - = -
G F
? 4 5+ / @ /4& 5 - ' <#$ / % 7 7
S* E . a ` )&? bU
! 5 4 " 8'7 4 5+ K6 5 <#$
/ 1 5+ % .4 +2 $ K6 % " $%
.# $ = ' +2 5+ % ! 38 " % 5+ <#$ & ! 6
8' 7 % ! & +2 -' $ 3 : !" % / @ /1 !& 4 -'
B ( & 76 #" 3 5+ 8 " % L : 5 - ' <#$ 4 '" 4@ 8
% % K6 * # 1 3 6 76 "
?8 "* / ' / . $ 6J K6 8+
/1 A ' *2 !& 4 5 -' C 7 #$ 7
% & B4 44 ' 5 <#$ F* 8 ' . !" %
?G % !& 4 5 -' =% &B
! ;6 4 5+ 5 -' 4 <#$ 7
4 : % " 5+ )' " .4 =% $ 7 B
G% F
?+ % !& # '( +2

3> 5M 3 " 8" : /) #$" *$ ,* " ,*$ 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ YG F

? 'K3 %3 4 '(
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 G. + F .4 54 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 &4 Y G%F

5
 !" # $ %&

S* ) 0 6 )&? b U#
* ,6 = 8'7 ' M 3 8'7 4 5 -' +2
? '" 6J & % = ' 8 -'
8 'L $ B4 35 4 5 -' B 4 4> 0 4@
? 5 - ' <# = < M M 9 * "8 ; -'
54 , 4 5 -' 5 <#$ 1 4 % C 4%
? 4 % G% F

"8 ; +2 /'L $ -' ! -' 5+ Z F

/0 K #$ % 4 G ??? 5+ # = < M 2( 8 +
%
+ : #$ ! : -' 5+ =% +2 8 8 47'
? 8& +2 )'
#3. 4 5+ .4 !" > 54 /
K6 -' .4 4 & * +2 + 54& %
8'7 +2 I4 . &/ % ) 38 ' 6J
? G <4 @ : 54 L 8 /& A ! & K6 + ; F
8 4 & 4 4 / .4
#" -' 8 ' 8 'L $ 5+ # 3 +2
? 5+ <4 & *
38 ( + /4 4 % 1 . 07
38 ( + < A= - &< .4 '
4 5 -' 81 !" +2 !" > 5+ % 1N
/ 'L 54 4 5 -' -' 8 I4 < 4
?8 '
5
 !" # $ %&

9 /4 6 - ' 4 5+ 5 <#$ ! & 1

?/ !& 46 '
M 3/& / 46 /'L 4 5 -' , 64 & 4O O
5 -' & * / @ - <#$ , % 3 +2 / -
& 4 5+ 4@ 3 . 07 .# / 46 /'L 4
< M O /' .# #$ <+ 3 = -
G F
? 4 4 - 3 5+ 64 5+ =
F 6 #" - ' 4 5 -' , +2
, 7 K6 4 /$ 8 1 -' G $ A ''O
? /4 % . K6 O + #
5 -' .# - ' I ' / 4 G% F 54 / !" 9
8 46 +2 * 1 3< M M 8 .# +2 /'L 4
8 A % 4 5+ -' #$ 1 38 & 4
*' *' = - -' 5+ ,% 8%7 =7
? W "???? ' M' * > / & =4 4@ #
4 8+ -' 54 / ' . ' B
$ 5+ <#$ 8 3 ' M' ' $
?* '
O $ %% +2 )' , & +2 -' ; #"
G F
?9

= % / 4 F , 8" # 8< # . 34 ' , YG F

?% K 3 ##' 3 5 $ % 3 4 3G
?X XK3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4&Y G F

5#
 !" # $ %&

> * +2 #" 8 I 8%7

! - ' 8L 97 ( = ) M' 3 5+
= = , & +2 &5 &8 G / ?= % F 54 K 4
) )' = + # ! & 3 $ 8% = +2
G F
G 6 M' = . F 9 7 ( = 8'7 ) ' + 3 O @
G% F 54 K 5 6 5 ># = 8L #
2( 8 + " +2 ; -' /+ ' 4 %
+ - -' +2 8L / # '8 < M
? +2 )'
0 $4 0 6 44 -' 5+ 8 !" 5 ( 4
%% 8 3 5+ !& 7 4 *, 8 +2
.# %% +2 1 K6 3 @O , & 5+ 8+ +2
%% +2 - .# 4 ' 4% A4 # 4 *, ) '
$, % % - 44 .# $ G .4 +2 FC +2
&Q 6 ) 4 4 4% #$ 44 $ 0 +2 !" 4 *,
G F
? 8& 7 " $ 0 +2
54 K 9 $4 @ $ 5+ $ 5+ 4
? # 7 ' 4 % G% F

' 3+ A K6 ) ' #" 5+ <#$ =% B

< @ $ /4 3+ / 4& 6 + A F
/% $ 8& % )2 / % <#$ G8 &

?% K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G F
?% K3 # = ' * E 4 ' , YG F

5$
 !" # $ %&

64 38 0 0 .# = !& 4 4 & *
3 % F %% +2 )' % !& 4 5 -' 1J > 8 ,
? 5+ & $ % )2 4& * 3G $ / 4&
? -' 5+ 1L % $ A M' C %
4 & 4 5 -' 4 L 3C 7 : -' 4 5 -' %%
* #" +2 $ 3 < A )' 8'7 ) ' $ 8 C " K6
?. .4 ) ! " <4 &
! 3 < A )' 8'7 ) ' 4 5 - ' K6 #
&4 !& , 84 . C 7 4 5+ 84
! & 4 5 -' . 84 &4 !& . 3 # 1"
G F
? # 1 -' 8 'L $ "

!& @ 5 $0 4 5+ C 7 #24 & 5+ > 1 #L

? 1 ! % % 5+
!% 8 L < A -' 4 5 -' 6 1 #" 8
: *-' ; > # ' 8 8 C 7 7 <#
87 : / # 3 4 5 -' 8 8 & / % .# 8'7 8'7
4 5 -' Z 8 !& U , 4 8 7 " 3 : 7 "
G F
? 8'7 ) '
@; / @ 1 3 4 5 -' &M - ' / @ 1 -' 5+ 1
4 / 4% 1( = - # 38 ' -'
?5 6 % 4

? '' K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 YG F

? # K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & YG F

55
 !" # $ %&

( 4 c K )&? b U$
+2 * : L 5+ !& , 4 5 - ' =%
/ % 5+ <# $ =% 39 ! & 5+ 8 & =- #$ 3 5 - ' <#$
4 % '" G % %& F 2 2 + " 5+ 1 6
4 & * / % / K6 + B 39 !& = %
<# 8 @ - = , 64 5+ !&
$ & 8 / % / = 9 !& @ / @ 4 &
/$4 & 9 !& +2 # 3/ + &I 6
? 5+
8 A. .4 9 ! & +2 4 & =% B
.4 3 8'7 6 < A* 2 = '" 4 % .
- 5+ 4 & * / % 3< A* 2 4 5 -'
G F
? , 9 !& +2 % / @ 4 & <# 8 @
8 O < ' %& 1 6 + D9 ! & 5+ 1
? & <#$ / % $4 %' 4 < '%
=7 4 4 "V - ; !" > <#$ 5+ 1J
?9 6 - *
9 ! & 5+ ' !& " 4 5+ 5+ I &4
#" G 2 % F ' #$ ! & " /4 % = )' , 8
5+ 7 : 4 / @ 4 1 3 , % -
Z " #$ ! & @4 U , 4 & .M 8 % # 9 !&
* 6 8+ * - ' -% @ # 3 8'7 8 = +

?% K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G F
5
 !" # $ %&

5+ - 3 8- ! /4 % 8 = )' 5+ . &4
; 9 !& 8+ ' !& " 4 %& 6 + * 2
!& % + <4 #$ ! & + 7 + K6 + +
+ 9 7 ( = $4 ;1 + M F 6N K6 <+ .# = A
?G @ = 6N
5+ ) AL 4 / % $ %7 <4 .# 4 1 '(
5+ 4 % + @ 7 3 7 +2 $Z 6N K6
; -% <#$ 3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ' ;6 $4 4 '" ) -
GEF
4 # +2 G 8+ 4% .# +2 7 +2 F +2
G F
? 9 !& +2
?5 5+ M # M % 1( = - 9 ! & 5+ 1
5 -' 5+ !& 4 5 - ' =% 44 / 6
9 , / % 9 !& 5 -' -' 5 -' !" 5
,% 4' 3 6J 4. I &4 = 5+ 9 !& 4'
?+ ! & 4 *, 9 ! & & , 4 '"
$ ^ ]' []' "(
# 3= , 64 4 5 -' 4 5+
? 5 - ' <#$ &M / % ;6 = )' " # &4 /+;
! "8 4 "8 M +2 I4 4 % 5 , 8%7 >;6 #
/ @ 8 > 8 > 5+ )' "
? @ 5+

? 4 $4%7 / &" $4 '" #L ' ;6 $4% 5+ 4 4 '" " 1 8+ Y GEF

? K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

5<
 !" # $ %&

D -% . ' 4 ;6 B ' #
( élement moral ) D ^ ]' []' ./
D 8 M 5+ . %7 C 44
= ) 0 + !& 0 +2 > "F
? G ??? = 7 " 97 " = 3= #$ 38 & &
G F
?G = % = '" +2 &5 &F $
G F
?G8 5+ F D 8 !& C <44
= ) 0 0 = )' " +2 I4 F $
= + 4 4 & 5 4& # +
G%F
? G 6J K6 ) ' +2 )' # 8 -* %7 5+ 9 ,
8 ," + +2 &4" ) F 8 !& ;'( 8%7 8
G' F
?G8 !"
D 7 <#$ ;6 V '
8 %7 >;6 ; 3 +2 8 $ 5+ . / @ Y
+ )' " ! " +2 54 " 8 M <#$ 5 ,
&H 8 0 38 > 8 >
?+ 3= ) 0 4
.# K6 3= , 64 4 5 -' 4 5+ ;
# +2 % 0 4 % & % 4 & / %

?X K3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & YG F
?% K3 # = ' * 3 >/ "3 & .4 Y G F
G%F Y Alex weill , op . cit , p325-326 .
? X K3 # = ' * 3 4&4 @ 4 D ,
? %# K 3 # = ' * 3 "F* +? ,# . #$" *)$K 3 4 6 4& YG'F

5%
 !" # $ %&

=% 4= )' " !" 84 " 8 .# K6 +2

? #$ ! & 7 5 -'
12 '( ,% = 5+ 3 8' 4 .# = +2 44 Y
12 '( ,% 8 & & = )' " 5+ 3= #$ + *
? # = #$ 6 #$ + *
! &= % 44 8 3 +2 44 * #$
? #$ 97 ( = 6N @ ;1 K6 #
? 5+ 8 & / % .# = 4
4 $0 +2 5 / . / @ $0 4 YQ
? < A )' 8'7 ) ' 5+
< &L 8'7 ) ' $ 4 % / 8 4 & 4 *, #L
Y 6J K6 = 8 &" $ " &= )
8 4 4 % & % " L Y 8 4 &4 : & 2 M' '
@ 5+ <#$ 4 % 7 6 8+
? .4 & 4@ /A $ 1N
/ @ 7 $ 87 6 5+ . #
G F
? , 5+ % 5+ .4
4 7 $ #" @; 6" = 6 . / @ $ Y4
84 &4 ; M' 7 + L # 3
8 & $ <#$ 8 ( 4%& 0 0
? : )' +2 + 9, % ' #

3 ##X 3 - 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3G ' ! 8" >" $ F # 8% # . 3< ' YG F

? ''% K
 !" # $ %&

6 F 6 +2 4& 4 % & 5 ,b $
$ -' . 5 + $ G +2 A $
? < A 4& % K6 + Z ; 3 .4 ' M
7 $ +2 4 % & -
@ ' 4 @ 5+ #* 3 + $ K@
A 8 7' + $ @ 4 ` 5+ + #
. $ & 7 ( 8'7 5+ 8 + ; % $& : +
G F
8& ) = - &+ 8 + $
1 '" * , 9 "3. ( + 8 Y
A +2 #" . ( + $ #$ ! & 4
?+
% + 4% 3 + A 4 0
8& ) = - & 5+ )' < + A
D !& . 2+ 4 % 6 7 54 4% 3 @
?G @ 8& ) = - & 5+ )' + : + F
1 3 4 + A K6 54 " 1 '( #$ 9 *, 4%
3 @ 8& ) < A 4& 5 , ,%
5+ 1J G. .4 F =% )2 / % $ 3 /%
G F
? )2 !" + A +2 !" >
/ *7 8 3 % 81 -' . K6 5+ *%
# 8 % 1 #" 3 )' /4 %

! - 3 4 '( 3 B 4 ) 3 &B 1 + 3 !" 5 / & " 3 - YG F

? K3
? #K3 # = ' * 3G. + F 54 .4 YG F
 !" # $ %&

8 'L 38 % 1 $= )' " 84 " & .#

<# $ % 81 I4 * 4 & % *
?= )' " 3 4 5 -'
^ ]' []' ? d 7 3a 3
? . .4 $ % 5+
5 -' 4 1L 5+ .4 4 1" ' #"
64 4 & !& ( ;6 3 5+ ! & +2 > -
?= ,
' 7 . $ S. 4 1" >
? 80 ; 8 & 9;-(
GEF
-' @ @ % /@ . 1" & '
/ % . 4 C " F .4 8 1 Z
!& @ @ .4 #$ G 4 5 -'
5+ 8'7 ) ' + " 5+ .4 &" # 3.
+2 " +2 M ' &4 !& % 3 , &
1( )& < A ) ' + , &
/ 1 .# 3 $0 ) : & % <#$ / % $ 9
= , 64 4 & / % , % ) : *, B
= #$ ) 0 0 <4 & 5 -' # 8 & -'
@ K6 5+ .4 8 9 K 6 '"
G F
?. !& ' & 1( @ -' @
44 C " $ @ @ 44 ' % $ @ @ $ 7O $ YGEF
? 1( )& < ,
''X K 3 # = ' * 3< ' D , 3 %K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
Y Philipe bihr,op.cit , p 187
 !" # $ %&

D !& 4 % 6% 7 54 K . 2+ 9 K 4%
$ <+2 @O 7 & 4 = 5+ 44 K6 9+ #" F
?G 4 = - & 5+ <#$ )' " 4@ #" " 4 5+ 8
" 5+ 5 C 7 4 & ??? F !& 6 % 7 54

? G 8'7 +
. 4 C " " . 2+ 9 #$ ;6 Z,
! & 4 5 -' 8 +2 1 ! 3 .4 4 5+
* @ 5+ 8+ &" 3 8'7 ) ' + 8 C "+
8' 7 ) ' + 8 1L +2 > 3 1!
? &4 = & !& 1( )& *% " 3 < A )'
)' 8 + 1" )& 8 & -' + % ! & <4 *,
1 M 3 ' 4 @" 5 - ' <#$ !, % 8&+ + 3 8'7
! & 2@ 8+ ;1 M < A )' + " 4 5+ <4
-' 5+ & " 4%& '
% <#$ &" , C 7 G8 1 8 & 1 '( &4 "F
% - & 4@ $ #L 3 ) 2 4 5+
G F
?8 @ "38 % / % ;
D $8 & ( : .# O'
?S -@ A % % <#$ #"
54 ! & 5+ #" " 8 . C " %%
? ;% '"
? XX# K 3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4&D , %K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
 !" # $ %&

+2 5+ !% 4@ +2 ! F % ' 5+ '" 5+ #"

a4 = ' +2 )' + " = ; +2 C "G ' = '
: 1L . !& 4 @L % <#$ C% , + 3 5+
5+ ) '
9 , # 3 *@ 2' $ 4 % &
&> B 3 I &4 &* <#$ ! & > -'
3 I &4 &/ % 4 %% , 6 $0
& @ 4 8 4& 1 K6' 4% -' 4 4
?
G F
? 4 2' * . 5+ 1" L #
8 , 8 7 %7 4 1 4 % & 1J 4%
? % 8%7 ' 4 8 %7 0 + 8%% 7
ML 'K c 8 %7 &+ 4 0 c * c 8 %7 &+ 6 0
? 0 <#$ , !& > ' #
$ ^ ]' ER !) 7 & D] "3
( théorie subjective ) ) [\4 )& D] U
G saviyny F 8 %7 / I4 3 5+ 4 % 0 $
D $4 7 G *F

/4 % = )' ' % $ 1J V 5+ "

7 3. .4 ) 5+ . &4
#$ ) !" ) 3= !& 4 5 - ' =% <4 .4

G F - Philipe bihr ,op.cit , p 187.

#
 !" # $ %&

K 6 +2 !" ," . $ .
G F
? 8'7 ) ' 8 '"
/ 4 " #" 8 & 5+ . $ $4 % & ' 4&
? K6 4 % &= 0 6 0 8 0 ' 3 5+ /%
= ' 4 @ +2 . =% 0 <#$ -
= - 3 2' ' +2 7 3 8'7 ) '
) = $= #L 3 6J & % = '+
> = > M 8 ' = '" +2 4&
? 54 & 7 ' :' '
% = #$ ) +2 > ) 6J & % #"
? 8'7 ) ' 8 '( * 8 -
<4 & 94 M' < A )' +2 M <#$ 4% #"
44 " 84 /4 %% 5+ ! =% '
G F
? : )' + "
5+ !" 4 5 -' )@ 8 $ 5+ / % 4 % & - "
/ / 4% ' 7 % #- "B /4% # $ 1N
8 %7 G Domat F G " !F8 %7 8 !L 3 0 <# I4 <4 '
6 + ) , 7 ( pothier )

* #6 4% , !& " ' 0 4%

4; / 0 d /0 #6 3 ' 7
?

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
G F Y Jean-louis bergel , et autres , op.cit , p 136-137 .
?% K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D ,

$
 !" # $ %&

( théorie objetive ) )&? )& D] U

4 0 < ' G ihering F G L 'K F / 8 %7 C & 4%
? 6 0 4 %
" 4 5 -' & & ;% ' & 4 % & V $" I
?. 5 , , .4
! & K6 .4 -' 4 1 3 # 5+ $ 4 5 -'
.4 - ' #$ # /7 ) 5+ > &( ) 8L
& $ +2 & 3 4 5 -' 4 54 ( 3 54 ( &4
G F
?4 @ !& " 4 &M +2 / % ; 4 @ 4 "
B 6 0 7 >;6 ! & 0 <#$ !
3 4 @ 84 " & 4 5 -' 4 & M =%
+ ' +2 4 @ & = - & 4 5 -' !& -'
? : )' 8'7 ) '
-' 8 +2 ' M' 0 <#$ !, %
+ 8 +2 87 * 5 - ' <#$ *7 !& 5 -'
? O )' + 8'7 ) '
+2 4 / % G , % F 5+ M V $" / ' $
? & 54 7 -' !&
! & 8 - ' +2 5+ 5+ =- &Q 6
?* /4 6 ' $ 5+ <#$ 47 4 < A )'
+2 4 $ + ( 5+ + .# V $" I #
<#$ 4 3 6 0 % $ 8'7 ) ' +

? K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&D , ?% # K E # = ' * E4 ' , YG F

5
 !" # $ %&

! +2 #* < A )' K6 + 4% 5+ / % ,
+ : 4 54 4 <+ " 2 K6 + 4@ 3 Z
5+ / % 4 5 -' ' 6 0 4 B 38 ' 8 'L
' # # 5+ $ 4 5 -' 3I 6 $ /4 /4 B
G F
? 4 0 0 <#$
< A )' +2 @ % " 0 <# #6 !& )
B 6 0 % $ >;6 ! & 3 M' 5+ I &4
? <#$ 8 %
!, % % #" 0 >;6 -% #"
?S / , 5+ 5+ . &4
<4 8 .# % %% +2 !& % 6 0
? # , +2 *-' 3 5+ . &4 *
% ' 3 5+ I &4 5 , +2 6 4 0
? >;6 ; 1N
G. ' ' * F 0 <# #6 4%
@ & D] E ^ H AM ( 4 %> '6
4( 4 ( @ . 2+ 4 % K % 'L
0 # 6 4 @ . 2+ 9 4 5+ %
. 5+ / % ) 3. 6
? , +2 % Z / 8 3= % = '"
M' & 4 % G $%< F 54 K 4 K 6

D , %# K 3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
- Jean-louis bergol et autres , op.cit , p 138 ?
 !" # $ %&

1 '" " $ <#, 4 .4 AC B 4 5+ . &4 *

G F
? 54& %
<=]K # . Z 7. b V
B $ A 5+ . =%
? 4 % 6 % % 7 54 ,
' !& 8 & 6 4 8 !& : 8 M & ! & 5+ / % F
GEF
? GZ '
Z ' K6 & F ' 7 4 % G # F 54

? G 4% 5+ 'O
D $ 5+ / % & 54 + #
?Z ' ' !& : 8 &Y
? 6 8 ! & K6 8 M &Y
' !& 2@ 4 5 - ' 5+ 5+ / @ /4& &
#" 3 '' Z $ = , .4 ) :
= % % U & 6 !& 4 5 -' & +2
?Z ' & ( & K = 4% 3 & > 6 5+ 8
( Acte de pure faculté ) D 7 + E )[V #a ) + e
5+ & >6 0 # 6 " 4& / % 5+ "
?G. .4 F
? K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
: 8 M & $ 6 M D9 @ 1 & , M-6 54 <#$ K 4 YGEF
: Z ' & #" 3 4 & $ Z ' & 38'7 +2 8 / % #$ Z
D Z # 3
G?Z ' ' !& : 8 & !& 6 4 8 ! & K6 8 M & ! & 5+ / % F

<
 !" # $ %&

( /4& ( K6 $ &
G F
? % K6
K 7 6 8 3 < A = !& 4 &" , K6 / @ #L
U ! 4@ 3G8 % = 4 4 K6 8 M &F %
?4 = ! & I4 8 8 4 *-' 3 + !,% " % 8'
/ % # 1 3 % )' 5+ 8 / % 6 <# (
& -2 #$ Z7 < 8 7 4 ! & -2 @L
% 8 )' : ! & 4 &" Z L 3 % -
5+ #38 4 4 -2 @" * + -
! & +2 8 : = !& , 4 , ) /4 %
4O / #L 3 8 9 7 ( 8 '" 8 8 !& % 8% = )
G F
? % - % )' 4 A * #$ ! " 5+
5+ /4& $ K6 " 5+ / @ /4& &
5+ 4 4 % +2 $ / % .# K6 G . .4 F
G% F
?4 = '" 4 % & <4 & $ 3 4
6 Acte de simple tolerance 7 f b BK/U
4 8 -6 ` 4 !& < & Z ' &M 4
8 .# ' I# /A ! & Z7 7 8 % ) : .4
G' F
' '

? K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 D , ? %'K 3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

G F Y Braaudry lacantinerie , op, cit , p 164 e
?' K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G%F
?X YX K3 # = ' * 3 - Y G'F

%
 !" # $ %&

4 8 & I4 = ) 3 4 &( 4& Z '

8 @; 5 & 3Z ' ' !& 8 & % 8% K% , 4 &( #$
? +2
0 $ $0 +2 $ & !& Z ' & . -
L <#$ #L 3 : ) 4 &" 1 4Z ' 7
, Z K6 4 &H 8 3 8+ +2 ! & 4'7
G F
?
: = !& 4 K6 / % 4 & &5 & $Z ' & #"
K6 3 4& ' !& & <#$ 38 Z ' : #$
* 8 + 3 /+ A Z , K6 $= ) 4
G F
? @ . 8&
5+ 8 / % ; K6 & * & <#$
3 . .4 ! " 4% 7 K6 & 7 6
= 4 5+ , 3 <4 . >6 Z ' &
4 5+ <#$ = ) = #$ ! & 4 &" : = %
?Z ' ' !& 4 &( !&
= )' " 84 . 4 5+ <# / %
G% F
?Z ' ' !& 8 8 8 K6 .4 / %
8 ' 8 3< C K6 Z ' & 1
/4 % +; 54 *, #$ ! & !, /1 3 ' @;& ! & 0 7

? K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F
?% K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y G%F

F
 !" # $ %&

? = 7 ( = )' &4 K6 # ;
#24 & * - ' 3 @ . 8 = 0
+2 ; = ) 0 0 4 % 8 &4 G &F
? % 8
!& : 8 % 3< A K6 8 / % & % #$ ! & )
# 8 + % ! 4 *, 8 &) 3Z ' '
? 5+ . &4 /4 % 8 & % )'
! % 4 9 !& 4 . 2+ 4 % 6 % % 7 54 K
/ $ '" /A 4 # 7 07 Z ' !& &
? # & !& 4 /%
/ % & #" % ; 4% -' 9 , ,%
# % 4 *, ! 64 & / 3Z ' !&
7 *2 @ > 0 ,% ' *@ 2'
G F
?9 ,
!& 2% & $D $ & ( : (
07 2 4 !% / 3 5+ & !" Z ' !& K6
?S> #
6 K6 M & )% +2 8 %%
? 5+ & !" Z ' ' !& / %

? ' K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

" 8M < = , .4 K6 M M # =%
@ 8+ Z 0 8 0 8'7 8 '" 4 % 8 % +
/ % = , 4 & 1 3 $ 1 V
= - 4 F 4& A &M Z ' ' !& < C M .# K6
G F
G K6 & & $ A Q ' 8- " 8 ,"
= Z ' 4 !& 8+ / % .# +2 Z !" ' 7 ,% )$# 4%
D < ( #$ 5+ . &4 * '
6J K6 5+ K6 8 U ' $ Y
?8 & : 4 &" +2
/4$ 5+ !& @ $ .4 Z ' & "Y)
! &4 *, * - ' #$ ! & 3< A 4Z ' ' " % <#$
G F
? 1 'L : 5+ . &4 * '" Z ' '
? .4 . 5+ / % - 8 % ;6
# , 5+ % 5+ +
? 5+ 9 C '
"
( /
$ & >; 6L 544 9 " 54 5 5+ #6
? $ 1J > 6
* 4 % 80 % 5+ 9 !& > ' #
? I4 ! & < 1J 9 K2 6

? K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
? X'' K 3 # = ' * 34 ' , YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

$) (
'= % = !& 5 - ' K6 8 - ' .4 *, 5+
/ @= - & 7 5 - ' <#$ M 3 / = ) $ K6 #$
? 8 & - ' .# = , * =7 4 &M K6
0 & 0 5+ +2 & <#$ % 4@
5+ +2 I4 ! 7 3 # % 4@ = )
4 $ 5+ <#$ 3 @ 5+ 8+ # Z . .4
? $ 1J &) %
?S % 5+ $
?S 9 5 4 $ ) -
) %& '# . /
8 & 5 -' = % = ! & 4 *, @ 5+ 4
8 & 0 * % 4 < 8 ;: '" 8 9 7 ( 5 -'
G F
? 8 & = ) 0
+ 3 5+ 8 &4 + 5+ -
?8 + 3 /4 % 8 )' "
54 ' 5 - ' <#$ '+ !& 7 5 - ' +2 %% #L
0 0 - ' <#$ +2 #" 3 8 " 54 ' / / = !"
5+ +2 I4 * #" % 5+ %% = ) 0
? 8'7 ) ' +2 + 8 4 % .# . .4
% #$ ! & 3 % % 5+ /'" % 5+ !& =-

# K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

5+ !& 7 5 -' 5+ $ % 5+
+2 4 @ !" ,( 3 4 *, > - 8 & 4 & 5 ;6
* 8 & = ) 0 8+ 0 8
5+ 9 #$ ! & % ) 38 > 8 >
D $ 54 4& 1J
# = ! " 54 ' / ! & 4 &( * # % "Y
* I &4 5+ 4 4 '" 5 &4 F 4 % 0 B;1 5+ I &4
? G 54 4 & >@ I &4 C
)' ! " - ' !& 5 % 5+ .4O Y
? )' /4 % =
# - /4 % 8 )' ' %& ! & @ #" 5+
4 !& G * F % /4 % 5+ 4 W G ' 5F

?Z )' ' *
5+ 4 # 1 ! !& @ 5+ 1( Y#
= % !& &+ 1 + + +2 %
1 ! $0 #6J $ +2 % C 7 #" 3 5+
) # !% 8% 1" )& +2 7 5+ 8 &4
G Q?/?= %# F 54 # 5+ ! & 8@ % 8&+ !& %1
?G # >;6 ! = # ) 8 C 7 = +2 F
+2 % # G 5+ 1F 1 ) ' 5+ Y'
?8 8 = 8 #4 3 <+ 1 8, % = '
# 44 C 4, % 8+ = +2 % Z YX
3 A= - 5+ # 5+ I &4 5

<#
 !" # $ %&

9 4 - 6 $ 5+ = @ # A $ +2 C 7 %
? &
) g ` 3
' = 0 1 5+ !& % 5 -6 1d 0
" $ 0 #$ * =7 ! & 5+ <#$ ) 3 8' 7
? % 5 4 4 1 . &) 5+
5+ = ) / 4 /0 4%
? $ 1J - '
D !& 4 % G% %F 54 / !" 9
1 ; " 76 < L 5+ @" #" ????F
.# @ " $ 8 & 5+ 8& 76 < ( 8 & *@ <
?G) <#$ 8 +
<# $ 1 3 % $ 1J ) & - 5+ = 4@ & $ 4
?C : 76 < ( )
% $ 1J V L . .4 5+ @ #"
= - & % 5 4 3 /4 % = )' '
- <#$ 1 7 - & !& ) 5+ I &4
- # 7A 4@ . 2 + 9 /A 3U , 3 4
@ 65 $7 54 K 8 " 4 % , 5+ '"
5+ '" 5 , $ - #$ ! " = - 4@ 4( 4 (
% 1M # 8 % '" $ % '" =% ! @
? ' 7

<$
 !" # $ %&

D- <#
6 paisible 7 D )H? < F# / h
> !" 4 8 97 ( '" +2 $ 4 4 %
G F
: 5+ !" 8+ ! 5 %
# ' 44 5 % & $ 24 A 5+
?> #$ & *-% 4
! 5+ - 3 : > - &+ C &" $
) % A #! 24 $ % 5 4
?< (
9 R1 K c]' h U
3 @ 8$ !& 8 K6 54 " 8 1M 0:, & 5 & < (
0 +2 0* ! 5 5+ )' -:, > / 46 '" $
G F
?= )
5 % 4 " & #" 4 /4& < ( ) 5+
G% F
8 "= - 'L # O- P: = - & & 44
?8 & .# O- P: 44 5 % *-% 4 0% !%
9 & -' 8'7 5 % 'L +2 / % # . '
% %% 4, 44 5 % & . ' 38
? 8+ 9+ ( 8 A = ' +2 4, +
G 4 < ( F> 5 % 'L . 4 < ( , . '
? X# K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
3 4 3 ) ! 8" 3 ! ! !" 5 / * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 &Y G F
? '' K 3 3 54 4 1 1 - 3 3 @ %
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 , 3' K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 & Y G%F

<5
 !" # $ %&

5+ F %% 8 & I4 !& < 1 /4 34 4 = - &.

> 6 3 G 8+ 2 ,% ( # 6 L +2 ;1 44$ #" < (
G F
? 44 9 K6 >; 6L . < ( 1
+2 4 4 5 % +2 &+ " ' 5+ ) < (
? $ 5+ /' 44 5 % <# &# 4@ = '
)' ! " K 6 !' 8 5+ ) & )& < ( '
) 9 A & $ 3< ( ) : = - $4 - 5+
?= % 6 = & ," = )' % 8 &
2 ' / 46 '" , P: #3C P: &< ( > 6
? 5+ 9+ 44 >& 2' , < ( 3 5+ )' "
4 & < ( 3+2 4, : 4 & $C
? 5+ !& : 4, +2
" 4O 5+ 4 8& @ @ .# $8 4 .# < (
G F
? 44 >& & !" & 0 +2 24 $ 5+ 4 #"

4 % ! 3< ( 2' $ 5+ !& ' #" 4%

9 , ,@ %' * @ 2' 5+ 4 -
?4 54 4 ' I &4 *2 @ ;6 'L
5+ 4 > 7 C !" 5 ( : 8 A
?
& # 5 % = - &8 +2 /@ 24 $ 4 5+ ! & .4 *@ #" Y

3 7 4 3 # .)*" "% 2 3) = 4 3 4 4 3) &4 YG F

?X #K3\-? ? 4 [ 3 '4 ' - 3 4 '(
? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 < ' YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

8&+ # " +2 8 #" < ( 3 5+ 4$ ! & 1O

4 3 5+ 4 4 '( +2 ! & I &4 * 2 ,@ &+
G F
? < ( )& 6 24 $ $ % '" /1 < ( 5+
'" ! " #4 -," /1 24 $ 8 + 4 4@ +2 1 #" 8 L #
24 $ 5+ 3 <#$ 7 & 0 & .4 *4 44 5 %
$ 3 ' 8%7 ) < #$ 3 < ( )&
5+ ! & +2 8 .# < ( *-% 7 8 I ' 8%7
24 $ 5+ ' #= ) 3< ( )& 6 ! 4 "
? !% 54 -
5 % & 0 & 9 4 +2 -," 544 5+ #L #$ ! &
G F
?< ( )& 24 $ A L @ .
8 4 % 54 > 76 ! " < *4 4 4 4% . #$ 4%
/ @ 5+ 4$ 8 % !" 4 38 & 1 '" 07 *, / "
&M 3 &9 4 > 4 5+ % 'L ' < ( &M +2
24 $ 4 8+ !& 0 44 5 % 'L ( < (
G% F
? & , ,% I4 " ' 7 C% 8 ,@ #$
9 R1 K iH [V h U
D 8M < ( )& +
jb K 9 R1 K U/
3 8 47' <4 < ( 8 & *@ ") < 1J #

$ K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
? X% K 3 # = ' * 3G )' ) ' F ! ! !" 5 / * E. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
G%F - Braudry lacantinerie , op.cit . p. 200 .

<<
 !" # $ %&

24 $ / ' 5+ 3) # Q ( / ; K6 < A
< ( 8 & *@ .# K6 ") # ' *-' 8L $
) ' . 5+ 4 4 'L ) - < A 6 K6 + ; 38 5+
G F
? 8 & *% / < ( ) # ' ) '
8 + 8 A .# * < ) : + $
< ( 8 + 3 4 +2 8 I &4 $4 4 '"
) : C 3 5 & 5+ 8 &+ .# %% #$
@8 6 2' 8+ &* 4 8 B 1 K6 G 4 4 +2 F
/ < ( # 24 $ A 5+ I &4 # !& V C +
G F
? 8 & *%
l>m K 9 R1 K Uk
+ 8 @O ) & 8 M 5+ . .# < ( )& +
8 +# % $ 1J Q ( 5+ Z
D % . 2+ 4 % G% %F 54 8 & #$
G) #$ 8 + .# @ " ??F
? 44 < ( 9 -% L < ( )& +
) 8 + 44 5 % & 5+ K6 9+ " #" # !&
8 + % ' +2 /4 2@ < ( /4 # 0 3< (
+ ) # $ L &+ 5+ % '" < ( *-% " #L 3 < (
G% F
? /4 % : 4, ' 5+ I &4 8 + 5+ 9+

&4 D , ?X #K3 # = ' * 3 # .)*" "% 2 3 6J 3) &4 YG F

? KE # = ' * E
3> 5M 3 2 +? 2 # >) " # !" 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G F
? X K 3 \- ? ?4 [ 3 4 '(
? #3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G%F
<%
 !" # $ %&

6 # $I B % 8 &I 7 6 / #$ 4
5+ & % 3 4 < 1 + /2 4 = - ) & < ( )&
? 5+ % )' 5 % ) : & #6 $ < ( 4
! 8 " 0 =- !" ) @ % . "
, B 5 1" /4& ' 8 - 3 5 -*
&+ # M 3 4 7 5+ M &
' 9 8-' & 9 4 8+ !& 8 3
&+ " .# K6 # !& 3 5+ I &4 = - & 5+ 6
44 '" I &4 8 &+ " @ / & ;6 $4 ' 8 < ( 8+ 8
8 & *@ B #$ ! & @O < ( )& #" 3 5+
1d ' : $ 8 @ 87 /A 8 "38 +4 8 ' < (
< A 5+ ) A .# 4 7 ' B 3 ' ! & 5+
G F
? ' Z 1J 5+ 8 4@ < ( )& 8& +
( Nom équivoque ) ) O F# / h
8+ '7 !& % +2 5+ ; 4 5+ U , 4 %
G F
? 6J '7
?C : )& $ , 5+
n B* o K c]' h U
? 8+ 4 % 8 &V I4 5+ 814 $
4 % = $ 8 #" C : ) 5+
<#$ 8 < A )' / 8'7 ) ' + +2 $ : Z, B
?Z ' & & ' ! & 5+
? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F
? 'X' K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 YG F
<F
 !" # $ %&

I4 5 4 5+ 4@ 8 3 5+ . ) #$ )
+2 4 + & <#$ 3 , A 8+ #* +2
? ' 7 AI 6 7
! 1 <#$ " +2 ) .# C : M
)' + +2 $/ ; 3 5+ <#$ M C A : *@
G F
? < A )' / 8'7
K6' : 4& +2 4& 8& B ( % #
G F
? +2 4 @ : 4& B 5+ .4 *2 @
+2 1 > 0 - #" C : ) 5+
) # $ 6 8+ 3 8'7 ) ' % !& 8-'
!& 4 -@ > 0 #" % $ 1J Q ( Q R 8
? 8'7 ) ' 5+ ! " +2 > "
)p * ) B' 7 5'6 h U
D , A 5+ 4 1
1 @ )' 8'7 ) ' 8+ 4@ #" D A G
? 1 @ 4 8'7 K6 8 ' 4@ 3 8
4% ! 1 *2 % 9 5+ 4@ D #. / G
% + 8 !& 8+ 4@ 3 8 @ 8'7 ) ' % +
? 4 4 8'7 8 K6 8 '
4% / 46 Q + % C + /4 6 D :, ) G

?X K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& YG F

?X K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 & YG F

%
 !" # $ %&

@ 5+ 4@ 3 )' , & 5+ % 8+
G F
? 7 )'
% 54 K 6 % M' I " #" D N)*" G!
8+ $ 1 3 , ! & $ % /1 8 ;: '" 8 46 54
<# V *-' 8 3 K6 8 ' + / % )' $+ $
"4 -3 % <#$ 8 $ .# % 2 4 ! & 5+
G F
? +2 84
?9 , ,@ %' *@ 2' , : 5+ 4% 4
< A & ;% ' 6 & C : )& #" 44 % P% 1 4%
0 4 $ 5+ - / % .# $/ 3)
? '"
8 5+ ) & @ &; 7 ;% ' C : )& C I #
@) #$ # ! & 3 5+ 7 I4 " ) .# &5 &
1" 4 ) 5+ 6 -6 8 . #$ ! & #6O 1( ! &
? $ 6
,L 7 ( 5+ ) & ,C : # /4& ! . # #6 #L
G% F
? 1 1) 5+ 6 ) 8 $-
) 5+ 6 % - " #" 8 4 4 8 4% . #$
/ 6 8 ' 6J . M # 8M 1 1 6 #$
G' F
? 8 1" )& 8 &
?' K3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F
?' K 3 8'7 * YG F
? % K 3 ## 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G%F
?' K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 & Y G'F

%
 !" # $ %&

. /4 8 3 5+ 4 /4& !" 6 . )$#

+2 I4 8 @ C 7 . * C 8 . #$ ! & #6O
4 .# &5 & /4 3 8 1" ! " +2 B
5+ . >6 !& 4 $ ; 3+2 !" '
G F
? 2 @ 5+ $
3. 4 M /4& ! " -% .4O C : $Z
5+ .4 4 . % C "
<#$ ! 4@ 5+ 3 % 8 4 . 7 L %
G F
? 5+ I &4 4 5+ $ &L
5+ ) K6 )& C : )& ! " )$# % Z .
G% F
? G F4 % & !& ) 3) @ & %' $
n B* o K iH [V h #U
5+ 8 & @ " 1 8 ' )& C : )& Y
G% %F 54 K %- . 2+ 9 8 #6 $ 34 % &B
8 =- )& C : M % 8%7 4 8 A . 2+ 4
G' F
? 5+ . % ( < 1
@ 3C : 7 L + @O ) & C : )& Y
? % $ 1J Q ( 5+ Z 7 ( #$
5+ 2 5+ B 5+ +2 4 & #" 7

? X'' K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4& Y G F

?' K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4&Y G F
? %K3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " E4 6 4& Y G%F
?D , 0 ?% K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 Y G'F
- Colin et capitant , op . cit , p 217 .

%
 !" # $ %&

A ; 0 > !" 8+ ) .# *
5 $0 & 8 4 M 3 6 8'7 ) ' + "8 C A
* C & <#$ 3 K 6 8 ' <+ 8M -@ 4 4
G F
? 8+ - 6 I 6 5+
V $ 8 & " @ 1 5+ ; C : + @
) #$ 8 + .# @ " 5+ I &4 % $ 1J
? . 2+ 4 % G% %F 54
( visible ) <q F# / #
I 4 !& 8+ & +2 5 5+ 0 4 %
G F
?8 ' .# = ) 4 !& @ !&
$8 + 1 M +2 $ $ 5 $ 0 4 %
G% F
? 9+ 8 8&+ #" # ' < A 48
& 5 $0 % $ 1J V ! 5+ % -
& 8% ' = ) 38 $ 8 ' ) = +
? /
5+ 0 M +2 $ & #"
76 ) 5+ / #24 & 3 / / 6
6 la clandestinité 7

N r K c]' h U#
& ' +2 / @ #" =% 5+ .4 ) ) & 76 ) &

? K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

D , K3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G F
? X # K 3 ##X 3 3 , 43 , 8" # 8% # . 3 4 ' /$ " Y
? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 Y G%F

%#
 !" # $ %&

? < A 5+ 8% % - = , 64 4
4 % 4 @ 8+ 76" +2 4 ! 4 " 76 )& A
G F
? 2' ' 5+ !76 4 / $ $ 76" +2
B4 4% 3+2 8 ' .# = $0 = - 5+ #"
$ 4 & 8 > M * =7 A +2 '
* 8 ' 8% 8 '" 4 & 4 8 & 76 .# 54 & = )
?+ % !& 8 -'
76 ) 5+ / 76 ' 8% +2 '" #" $
? /4 % ' 5+ I &4 ! % $ 1J V /1
+ +2 '" #L $ 76 4 5+ 0 ;
4 38 6> 04 3) ' ) ' 5+ / / 3 $0
G F
? )' # 76 5+ ; 7' C )' 8 A ! "
76 ) 4 % # 3 % / * # L 5 $ 0 5+ / / #L
/+ # !& G 7 / F8 #/ 5+ / " /4& $
B 0 5+ 7 3 % ' ! & +2 5+ /
G% F
? / *-'
& + 76" 4 ' 8 % 5+ 76 ) & *%
5+ 76" 3 & $ B <+ $ +2 76L &
C 8 ' + 8+ 76" +2 !& ) #" ' %

- 3* + 3G ' ) ' 3 = % F 8" !" 5 /3 ' 4 YG F

? K 3 #X 1
= ' * 3. 4 / 4&D , ? X K3 # = ' * 3 4&4 @ 4 YG F
?' %K3 #
? K3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G%F

%$
 !" # $ %&

? 5 $0 8+ / 8 - & +
+2 3 % 76 5+ B 4 5 4 1 8%7 ) ,
! 76 $ 8 + 3 ; ' 8 O @ < C
'" - /4 % = 7 ( = )' .4O 5+ I &4 4
G1 F
? % - <# +2
0 $ '" /4& 4 76 Z L 5 $0 4 #" 5+
? # ,% -
; 76 /1 5 $ 0 5+ 4 ;& '( ,% & #"
G F
? /4 % *-% $ 76L 4 4 5 $0 8 Z .# @ " 4
/ 9 , ,@ %' *@ 2' 0 - 4%
? @ 4 ' =% I &4 *2 @ ;6 '"
N r K iH [V h U#
jb KN r K U/
4 8 L # !& 3 = - ) & 76 ) & !" %7 C )$#
C 4 C & 76 #L * / 5 $0 #" " 5+
G% F
? 8'7 = ) / 5 $0 ! 76 ) 6N
7 6 2' ! 5+ M % !" . #$ , 4 '
) 5 0 <# $ A3 / 5 $0 ) % $ @
76 3 0 7 8 + 1 *, #" & % -
? 97 ( ;: '" = - - >; 6L > 6 ' $
?' K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4&YG F
D , ?X K3 # = ' * 34 ' , YG F
- Braudry lacantinerie , op.cit , p 199 ?
? X K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & Y G%F

%5
 !" # $ %&

76 @ " 1 8 ' ) & 76 I 8%7 : .

G F
/ 8 !& " 8 ' + B 5+ 8&
< A !& 5 $0 ) ! & 76 5+ #L 3 5+
? 5+ L
/ & 76 # . # ' $ 1N A 5+ 76
G F
* !& 6 5+ . , 8 /$ A 4 5+
? 4 % G% %F 54 K )' . # . 2+ 9 #6 4%
l>m KN r K Uk
@ % $ 1J Q ( 5+ Z + 8 #
?) #$ 8 + .#
G% F
? / = ) 9 - '" 5+ 0 #" 76 ) & +
54 4 ; 0 /1 # 54 % 76 5+ 4 #" # !&
? /4 % *-% 76 8
/ ;6 9 , ,@ %' 2' 0 - 4%
? I &4 *2 @
? ( continue ) Bb F# / '6
% G% %F 54 / ,- #$ ! & . 2+ 9 K /
4 ( @ G5 $F 54 / ,- #$ ! " 8 " 4
5 ' & 24 $ 8 + ??? F D ! & 54 B 4(
G ??? 9 -% "

G F YAlex weill , op.cit , p 322 ?

? #K3 # = ' * 3 4 D , ? X K3 # = ' * 3 4& 4 @ 4 YG F

? Y XK3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G%F

%
 !" # $ %&

+ % ! & +2 @ 4 5 -' & 5+ 'L 4 %

G F
? 0 %
% +2 ' + -5 6 !, #L
/4& ) & 5+ L 3 # !& ; & 7 " 8 *7
? *-% '(
B 01 =K / L K c]' h U$
> 0 >; 6L > 6 54 ;6 +2 / @ /4& 5+ '" /4 4 %
? 5+ = '" % 5+
M + % " ! & +2 ) ' '( -
4 5 -' & ! # &4 6N @ 8 '
?+ % +2 97 " !& 4 -@ 0
: @ + % +2 ' . , # !&
G F
? 54 & 8 ' 8 ' 7 5 ' 5+ ! 9 -% "

G .+ $ 3 =7 " 3 97 " 3 F & % + .# +2 !& )

& *-% > 8 > #$ ! & = ) 0 0
4% 8 '" ! " 4% . F M # 8M 8 '"
?G8 - * =7
G% F
8 - , % 4% 3 + = - ! & >@ 5+ '" / 0 " L #
8 '" , % G ' = +2 F 4 % !& / 8 '"
?G & !& C +2 ' /'

? %% K 3 # = ' * 3 >/ "3 & .4 Y G1F

? XK3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
G%F Y Colin et capitant , op . cit , p 217 ?

%<
 !" # $ %&

G ++ ,7 F 5 $@ 5 @ )' + % '" & >

G F
? 5+ 'L 6 & -% "
? 5+ .4 8'7 $ '( - %7 C I
'( &M 5+ 4 " # +2 / @ /4& # !&
5+ ; 3 5+ 8' 8M 5+ .4
>6 '( - > 6 #" 8 # !& ) 3 =;-( ! & 5+ $
G F
? 5+ .4
'L +2 /% / #L @ 4 " 5+ = ) #"
? 5+ .4 4% 8 - * =7 @ M '" < %&
V %- &8 3 5+ '" - # % K 7AL #$ / 4O
G%F
? < 8
Z I # 3 & 5+ & -6 = ' . #6 "
.4 ! &5 5+ / % + - 4 '(
I &4 I &4 @ " - #$ $ 4 3 .
? 5+
5 4 5 %' 9 -% " 4 ' ' 5+ 4 #
.M & 4 &( + 3 5+ I &4 = - & %
?
B 01 =K K iH [V U
' I 6 5+ ) & 2 ' >;6 = - ) & '( /4& ) &
A # 5+ 38 ' .# = 8 #!
?'# K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3 . 4 4 +& Y G F
? XK3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G F
? X' K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & Y G%F

%%
 !" # $ %&

5 ' A 8 ' 5 ' A 3 !" ' 5 '

G F
?8 & V # < : '
% $ 1J Q ( ' ' A 5+ *-% )& )
54 , 'Z 5+ I &4 ! /1 3
?8 ' .#
V 35 ' 5+ ! " 5+ #" + @O ) & '( /4& ) &
'( - I4 4% 3) #$ 8 + .# @ $ 1J
?9 , ,@ %' *@ 2'
8 6 5+ M / 6 4 * 4 #" 9 , ! & *%
8 7A " 8 &4 *4 # C ) )
G F
? %
)O ' "(
44 5+ . +2 & > 6 #" , & 5+ >
3 #" 3 = 7" ! & / 4% 3 , 5+ /
# @ 5+ !" , 5+ 4@ 3 ,% % 5+ L
YD -% @ , 5+ C
)O ' ./
#" !, % " ! & K6 $ -' $ , 5+
8 # ,% % K6 !& " = )
G% F
? %% +2 )'

? XX K 3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
? X YXX K 3 8'7 * YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 54 / 4& , 3X %K3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & Y G%F

%F
 !" # $ %&

D !& 1 &
4 4 5 -' . 5+ .4 , 4 5+
G F
? 7 )' '" .
D !" 7 <#$ ;6
! & +2 4 5 -' 4 4 & >% 5+ ! # , 5+ "E
M' " 4%& 4 7 ;1 F 7 5+ 5 + %
?G O % ! & ; '" 4 , & +2 8
.4 $ 5+ . &4 !& 4 % , 5+ / % E
.# G %% F +2 I4 4 0 .# 4 % & 4 <4
%% +2 &) 8 8 38 ' 5+ , +2 '
* 5+ M , 5+ > # 3 8'7 6 #$ < #" 8
? I
4 3 8'7 ) ' < A )' % !& 4 8 - ' /A +2
% 4 /+ " 4 * = ) 0 0 84
?8 +
+2 * = 7" ! & / 4% , 5+ / 44 E
5+ $ ' M' ' $ %
? 97 ( = )
4 ,% / % 5+ " K6 !& 4@
% ' ' $ 3 )' 8 #
? 7 2 ,%
8+ L Z @ 4 ' !, % % + , +2 E

? %# K 3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

F
 !" # $ %&

M' F % * =7 + 4 3 % 7 6 4 ,
, & +2 3 ( 4%& # <4 ' 5 O , &+2
? G ??? % 5 4L 87 .# % K6 $ # <4 ' %
% * =7 + = ! " 54 ' 4@ % 5+ >;6 #$
8@ ' K 5+ 87 6 + 4@ 8 5+
G F
?8 : ) :
1N @ 5+ $ , 5+ $D ' #$
S ? 5+ %
% 5+ ' 7J < # .# ! # , 5+
8' 7 ) ' 5+ 4 I4 4 *, $ @8 4 .# #
?
# $G 7 )' = '" F4 % 4% 7 , 5+
, +2 ' .# G %% +2 F : 4& <4 .#
8' 7 &; 4 % & %% +2 3 8 ' 8 'L =
8 + <+ .# 6 #$ , +2 -' $ 4 5 -'
+ % 4 /+ 8 : )' 8+ 3 , 4 5+ %
G F
? , & 8+ +2 + 44 .# $4 / + ( #$ 3
CK / O ' AH 3
!& 4 5 -' %% +2 8 " % " K6 $ , +2

D , 3 XK3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & -G F

-Alex weill, op.cit , p 314 .
? '# K 3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ?% K3 # = ' * 34 ' , YG F
Y Philipe bihr,op.cit , p 187.

F
 !" # $ %&

G 4 " F 4% Z @ 4' ) # 8 ' 8 'L $

G F
? % K6 ,% /
#8 & 4 5 -' 8 ; +2 , +2 -
? %% = - = - 4@ % 3 7 5+ 5
7 5+ ! & ` ' .# $ +2 4 5 -' 8 / .# % 4'
.# %% +2 = @( ! & 8 , . - 8 3 ,
; 44 8 !" 4 + " , 38 ' 5+
8+ % 4' + % 8M &4( 4 , +2 *-'
? 8 " <4 /+ $ : = &" 1
D $ % . 2+ 4 % , +2
8& U
/ @; % / + 44 # /$ %% +2 , +2 /$
+ < M M 9 * + 8 + / +2
G F
?8
5 4L C 7 4 /46 ' =2 ' /4 6 * D/ 1
W ??? &
= . / < M M : )' 4 5 -' O
? +2 )' 4 & 8 >
D #$ ! & # 7 ' Q?/?= G% F 54 4%
"8 ; +2 /' $ -' ! -' 5+ Z F
? G 5+ <# = < M 2( 8 +
? '# K 3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ?% K3 # = ' * 34 ' , YG F

Y Philipe bihr,op.cit , p 187.

?' K3 # = ' * 3 4 D , 3 K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
?% K3 # = ' * 34 ' , D ,
F
 !" # $ %&

" 8& U
+2 4 / /$ A ) ' +2 /$
G F
?/ + >
M' ' = '( = 97 ( = ) 9 #$ ,Q 4
* %7 / 3 8 4 94 ' 5+ $ 24 9 +
/4 & / 7 6 / /$ A ) ' , & +2 / 9
5+ 5+ <#$ ) !" /$ 3 4 5+ 5+ ! & /$ @"
3 / '7 ) ' 8 + 6J 6 &=
)' = '" 4 @ 4 5 -' F = # ' 5+ &/ 4
I &4 * / + -' = # +2 / G 7
D $ / %- <#$ = 7 3 5+
s ) U
, 5+ 4 5 -' # , +2 ,
4 ' # /$ 3 7 ! & 6J = @ 5+ : 1 &=
G F
% + : / &" * & = ! " /$4 *,
? 4 K6 % 5+ * , 5+
J 6J = ' @ +2 = ' , & +2 K6
, & +2 97 ( = @ +2 D 9 7 ( = +2 # 1 F 34
' , 3 8'7 ) ' )' <+ G @ F =
= ' @ +2 ' , & +2 D 5+ $ 24
? $
K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4& , % K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 4 YG F
?
D , ? % K 3 8'7 * YG F

U Alex weill, op.cit , p 315?

F#
 !" # $ %&

) ") U
) 4 % 4%& ! " /$4 *, 4 ' # +2 %- $
! &5 % / + 3+ 97 ( = / 6 6 = % I '
5+ !& & ' 6 = % ) /$ &L 4 5+
?9 + M'
O $ 4 ' 4 4% 2( 4 %& 4%& ! "
? -' +2 4
, 5+ @ 7 % $ $ $ D 8'7 U - .# O'
, 5+ 1N $ I S % 5+
?S % 5+ & 7 6
? 1" % " 2 6 $ 1J B , 5+ / ' #
)O ' F+/ "3
)O ' 3t U
/4 % + !& % , +2 )' , 5+ G Y
? '" " 5+ , 5+ % # 3 4 -
5+ !& % 1N 1 . V $ #"
? K6 .
. G % %& F + )' , +2 *-' ;
% 8 + # 3 81 $ /4 % 8 &= % =
G F
? 7 )' = 5+ 1 .

K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4& D , ? #K3= ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

X'%

F$
 !" # $ %&

!& = ' 44 &" , 4' !& / % , 5+

= )' ! " + & - .4O 8 " <4 + "
G F
? /4 %
;1 M' 3 , 5+ % 5+ @ 7 V2 /$ #$
# 8 8+ 54 - /4 % O % )' *-'
? ' '
, +2 V .M , 8 % #$ & 9 7
)' ! " 4 .4O , 5+ G +2 4' % 5+ F 54& %
5 % 5+ $ 54& % <# ' ' # 3 /4 % %
A #$ ) 6 - * ' !&
? , 5+
= 8 / 1 / % , +2 4% 8
?G & + C H ' ( 4%&F 8 + 8 & / % .# 4 ' !, %
# 3 5+ I &4 * ! , 5+ G Y
G F
? , 4 %% 5+ ' %
I &4 * , 8+ 8 'L ! 8 , +2 #! Y
% 8 6 2' !" M 4 #$ 3 5+ I &4
<4 ' % 8 9+ " #" * - ' 3 8'7 & 4 &( 4 8+
, +2 *-' 54 I &4 L # 3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
= #$ 1 % !& % K 4@ 3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 $ 8 'L

G F Y Braaudry lacantinerie, op, cit, p 208 ?

? ''# K 3 # = ' * 3 4 D , ?X K3 # = ' * 34 '/$ " YG F
? %X 3 K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 YD ,

F5
 !" # $ %&

9 , % '" ' / !& 8 0 , +2

! & .4 4 *, 8 ) ' / 6 7 + 5 $0
? - 8+
!" 0 49 A 4 &( 4 ! & @ / % 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
! & % ' 54 4 *, - ; 3 4 *, 7
% <4 4 5+ % 7 3C
G F
?) : 9 @ @ " 5+
/ 0 " 5+ I &4 * , 5+ ! #"
' = M' 6 $ 1 'L 54& % <#$ & 6 4@ 4
, 1 '( # . 2 + 9 @ 4% 3 8 + 5+ I &4 *
, M' 5+ 54 & . 2+ 4 % G$%<F 54 K
? /4 % 7 5+ I &4
)O ' ae
! " 5+ % 3= % ' B4 5+ >;6 '( =%
? , 5+ % "/ ' # 3 K6 / >6
/ >6 !" % , 5+ M ,% K 6 #$ 54& % E
?G8 / , +2 1 $/ >6 F 7
% B 3 5+ > : 'B 5+ % " ;
4 B 5+ F 7 81 87 6 ' .# ! " B
? G 81 5+ & %'
0 , )& + >6 !" >' , 5+ % L #$ ! &
G F
? 8 07
? K3 '3 4 '( 3 B 4 ) 3 3 - YG F
? X% K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4& D , % K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

F
 !" # $ %&

Q " 4 5+ ) %7 C 4 & ) & 4 ' 5+ , &

$ 1J 2 ' & >6 $4 7 5+ 4$ 3 $ 1J
5+ - 76 + 5+ ) & M # !& 4
8 1 4 & 7 5+ /+; , 3 $ 1N Z
G F
? + - B '' $ >' & >6
* 81 5+ )' ! F ' B #$ . '
? 2' G 84
/4 % &4R 54 , ' 1 *-' $
? # % - #" 4 / + /
! & <4 4 *, 2 ,% 8 4 94 D 1
8 L B B /1 81 87 6 /1 - 54 8 ' $ 8 4 &4
+ - B '' /4 % / 4 )'
? , & 5+ / 5+
5+ 8 " % $ .# F K6 >6 !" , 5+ % " #"
C & : * C # '3 @ > , +2
? @ 5+ !" : 5+ > L G
@ > K6 >6 !" % , +2 /@
, & @ 5+ K 6 > 6 5+ L G ?? 3* F
' Z 5+ I &4 * + $ 1J *
5+ & 54 4 5+ 4 K6 >6 # 3 /4 %

? X'' K 3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 &YG F

F<
 !" # $ %&

%% / F 2' ' K6 >6 '3 4 5 -'

G F
? G 87 ' 5+ , &
8 + ' K6 >6 - %7 $
5+ 8 87 ' * 4 & 4% 8 ! 3 @
G F
? , & +2
)O ' iH [V U#
D $ $ A & $+ K2 6 , 5+ +
)O ' 8 L6 U#
V ; 3 K6 * # 5+ 1 ,
G% F
? . >6 !" #* 3 K6 . 4, 1
5+ )' )' /4 % ' , +2 + 8 &
8'7 = % = '" % / <4 *, 3 4 . 4,
? <4 *, ) ' : / #$ ' , & <4 0 #
)BH ? ) - ) O ' h U#
&V , 7 / 4 3 + , * , 7 07 5+ 0
# $ ! & . - .# 5+ 4' , %% +2 = , +2 > &"
@ .# ) ' + ! , & 4 , +2 4 0 3> &(
? 5+ 8 &
, +2 : ! G 4 *, '" * ( 4%& ;- ;1 F

3 % 4 R ' 7 + 3B 1 + 3 # # !" # " 3 - 4& YG F

? XX K 3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , 0 ?% K3 3 1 - 3 4 '(
?% #K34 ' , ,
?% K3= ' * 3 4 YG F
?X #K3= ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & Y G%F

F%
 !" # $ %&

?+ % !" 84 " " M

? , 1 = ; , 7 0 >6 !" >' 5+ % L 8L #
A& . K ) O ' h # U#
? G F
) # $ 1 84 " C 8'7 8 = , +2
: 8 + <4 ' >;6 ! & /4 % )' 8 #" 3 8 + . .#
' Z - 6" " 5+ 8 & @ .# 8'7 8'7
? @ 5+ !" , 5+
)O ' 7 3a U$
5 -6 ) !& % 5+ !& % 1N "
8L 1N <#$ 1 ) !& - 5 @ , 5+ 0
S , &/ @ +2 #" /+;
4 4 @ 4 < : . 2+ 9 !" 5 ( % ' 4%
% 2 % & *, /@ # 3 1( I % $
D B 4 % K , 1( & '
2 + - 2/ nu & 8 AH U
# ) 8 C 7 = +2 F ! & Q?/?= 6% #7 54
?G # >;6 ! =
8 C 7 4 5+ 8 $4 7 @ @ *, 9 /@ $
? 8% 1" )& 8 & *% +2 #$ 9+ K6 38 #
D $4 7 I 6 @9 *,
2b k b v AH / n uWa U
C 7 4 & ?? F ! & Q?/?= 6% 7 54 K B

? ''# K 3 # = ' * 3< ' D , ? % K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

FF
 !" # $ %&

# $ C " % ' 5+ '" 5+ L 8'7 + " 5+

G I4 )' $ '(
D K #$ /7
+2 2 4 C 7 .# 3 , 5+ C "+ /4& Y
C 7 F3 <#$ 8 4 8 8'7 ) ' + 8 4 5+
&4 !& @ +2 G 8'7 ) ' + 8 , +2
G F
? # 1 , & +2 8 &4 . # &
? # & !& 4 /% / % ' 5+ '" C 7 5+ Y)
8 L = ' +2 5+ 9 , 4 5+ / ' #" #
8 + , & +2 8 ! 3 6 +2 #$ ) ' + 8 8 C 7
? 87 ' 5+ '"
# $ 1" ) & <4 8 & *@ 8'7 ) ' + 8 +2 !&4" "
G F
? &4(
nu & . ) > + sa ) O ' S *# U%
7 ! & 07 5+ !% F 4 % G% F 54 K 9
?G # >;6 ! & 4 /% / ' @ &
! 7 07 # !% L , & 4 #" 5+ K #$ /7
? % 8,% % : !& 4 / %
0 ! % L , & 5+ 4 8+ 1 K6 / @ #L
1 8 &) % % 5+ !" 4@ 5+ <#$ +2 !&4" L 3 #
? #$ 9 @

#K3 # = ' * 3. + 54 .4 YG F
3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ? X% K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4& YG F
X K
 !" # $ %&

1" , +2 ! & *% C 7 @ 5+ !" , 5+ :

G F
? 1" )& *7 54 4 , 47' ! & *% 8 : #$
D) > + sa w x ) O ' ) - S *# '6
. .4 $ % 5+ =' &
B % ' &> 6 , & 5+ / L . >6 L
? 1N /
+2 !76 3 : $ & @ 7 !76
8 ! @ !" , 8+ 542 ,
6 /4 % )' $ 5 6 <#$ 1N 47'
? 4 *, %
S @ 5+ !" , 5+ : $ D 8'7 U - .# O'
?S : #$ - $ # "
D !& K 4 4 % G %# F 54 K 9
8' 7 : 4 *-' 8 ! & <4 ' >;6 ! & /4 % )' 4 F
GEF
? G 8 & / % .# 8+ ) ' 8'7
+2 ! % , +2 M ,% & 4 54 <#$ !, % 9 %
8 + 7 : 8'7 ; 3 8+ !& + - , &
4 ' Z #+ " 3 @ 5+ !" 8 : 4
? & 4 4 + @ !" , 5+ )@ : 4
+ 8 , 64 : 8'7 8 : , +2
D , ? %K3 # = ' * 3 4&4 @ 4 YG F
YAlex weill , op.cit , p 317
*-' K6 8: K #" G 8 ! &F 07 9 ' & V C A 54 <#$ Y GEF
54 + 9 % 7 6 1 '" 8 & / % .# 8+ ) ' 8'7 8'7 :
?! / % ' G 8 ! & F 5 & ># ' ' # Z A #$ 3 <4 ' >;6 ! & /4 % )' K6
 !" # $ %&

M' ;&L 3 @ 5+ !" , 8+ 8 8'7 ) '

+ !" M' 5 O 5+ 8 A 4@ 8 O ;1
!& 5 % 5 / ' & * " " 3 8+ & , 7 * 7
? 4 1 , & 0 #" 5+ 7 : , # L 4%
? M' 8 + ;6 5 * 4 & 8& L M'
@ !" , 8+ 7 : *-' ; 8 , +2 B #6M
G F
: 4 84 " C
@ 5+ !" , 5+ M 4 /0 @ 4%
4 4 8 <4 @ 4 *, : 4 )
G F
? : 4 = , +2 8 C
D !& G %# F 54 4@
8 7 : 7 " 8+ 7 : #" /4 % )' *-' 8 AF
# $W " /4 % 54 . ' <#$ = ,
?G :
D 8 ! & 8%7 *
4 7 % 5+ !" , 5+ : 9 @
4@ +2 !& 4 $0 7 , +2 54 4 % )
4 ' : " # 3 @ 5+ 44 '8 C 4 *, ) '
G% F
? < 4$" , 5+

K3 # = ' * 3. ' =+ 4&4 D , ?' K3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F

?% K3 # = ' * 3 4 D , ? %X
D , ? X' K 3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4&Y G F
Y Colin et capitant, op.cit , p 215.
K3 # = ' * 3 !& 4 D , ? X% K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4 & Y G%F
? %
 !" # $ %&

D $ G %# F 54 K # N 4 M #$ =%
. : 4 7 = 8 C +2
S* G' 6 U
!& 8' 4 .# = : , +2 !% 4 & #$ B4
G F
? <+ .#
4 ;@ @ A 3 : ! & % - <#$ 4
+2 5+ 4' : !" $0 .4O G , % 3* F8
? @ !" , 8+ 7 % ' 5+ 4' 1 + ,
$ 8 +2 4% . b8 A : #$ '
G F
? Y8 > = ) 5+ 9 ,
+2 4 Z 54 4 7 # 54 4 5+ 4 > W
? < A )' 8'7 ) ' = + 87
# % - ' +2 # ' % 1N 5+ <#$ V 1
/ % /1 A M '" 8 M' 4% D # 1
@ > 4 $ %% 8 4% .# K6
# 8+ 7 : ! & <4 M' 8 *,
3 4 'Z " 4%& 4 3 5+ 4' : @ !" , &
F O /4 % 5 O )' $4 * - '
G% F
? G %%
5 *4 &* 44 <4 ' !, % > #24 & M' !& )
' C : ) 8+ 4 '" O

? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F

? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 D , ? X K3 # = ' * 34 '/$ " YG F
?% K 3 # = ' * 34 ' , , ? %' K 3 # = ' * 3 - 4& Y G%F

#
 !" # $ %&

? /4 %
.# K6 7 , +2 @ > 4 + Y
? 8 'L 8 ' +2 +
#L 3 @ > -
G F
? + - )' 8 1 ; %-
+2 @ 5+ ! " , & 5+ B 4 - $
?S %% * 8 M 4% . ' > 8% @ ,
6 8 $ " ! " 8%7 /'% " ( <#$ ! & R
8 !% 4% ! F ' - 8 8%7 C I
: / 8 #3> % @ , +2 I4 G 54 4 5+
? ' +2 ! @ !" , 5+
8 " 4 > L %% A* 8 / '
G F
? 5+ 7 : #$ ! &
G #% F 54 K . #$ ' 7 4 % U C /&4 4%
- / . 2+ 4 G %# F 54 K * = - ' 4
? 5+ 7 : '
' , +2 ) I : /$ 8%7 6N C A
% =- * ! #$ : % @ > % @
G% F
? G 8+ ) ' 8'7 : +2 8M F ,% % 54& % *
. * M- M 8+ 7 84 L A 4@ +2 *@ '

= ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ? % K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& YG F

? K3 #
? K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G F
? % 3 # = ' * 3 4 D , ? 'X K 3 # = ' * ?< ' Y G%F

$
 !" # $ %&

; '( & ' B 5 -6 #$ 3 8 + 44 4' *- K6

& @ 7 $ @ 4$" # 3 ' = % !&
@ ! " 8+ , & +2 !& 4 ' Z 3 5+
? 8 " 8% = ) 8 /&+ K6 * O-
! " .4O ' C " 2 4 , % .# ' @" ;,
? 4 a4 9 % < % #$ 3 % % ,(
! " , 5+ - 8, 7 44 - '
+2 I4 4 % &" 8 : > 3 : 7 @ 5+
? @ 4 / .# . 5+ 8&4 .# $ ' ,
!% .# , +2 I4 ' )- K 8 ! & 8%7 * #
? @ !" , 5+ : % % ! : =
D AH G' 6 U
.# 8+ 7 : *-' , +2 #"
'7 : 4 7 3 8+ 2@ , 4 8 &/ %
? 7 )' 5+ , +2 64
: = , 4 7 +2 / % + ?Q?/?= G %# F 54 "
5+ 7
% - 5 $0 , +2 8 4& # B4
& 7 8 4 12 '( 8 &+ 8 & " !& -@ 4 4
G F
? 8'7 ) ' @ # # 8+ &4" <4 @
D 5+ 7 : $ 1 , <#$ V ! : #

? %X K 3 # = ' * 3 - 4& D , 3% K3 # = ' * 34 ' , Y G F

5
 !" # $ %&

? !& = ) , <#$ G
*- ' ( = 8 8 $0 " 7 ) G)
+2 !& C : 2 6 + 4 4 ,
9+ # / % 8 & $ " 8'7 $ &4L 9+ ,
D4 # 3
! & #$ 8 ;&" = , +2 "4 7 8 E
? H
! &8 & @" 38 > +2 > 7 E
> & G f @" /4 F .4 > & 5
? G =7 ( 97 ( = % ) $ 3* 3 5 &( 5 ( F %
5+ '" 7' " = 8 , 4 & <#$ L
G F
? 5+ 7 : '4 ,
D # & 1 ) ,
4 O 8 - ( 54 "4 M' , +2
5 % 8 O = L /@ Z 8 4 '" C 5 O
.# 4' 4$" = , , #$ L 3 & '"
? &4( #$ 3 5+ 7 : Z ' 8+ 8 &!
* 4 &9 ( 1 38 + &9 ( 4 !& 8 & @" #"
0 / 8 3 : + - " , & 0 5+ L 8 &5 % 5
)' - 4 = !& . - 8
6 0 8 & % / , & 5+ $ $ 5+ 0 3 :

K3 # = ' * 34 ' , D , ? X%' K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4&Y G F

?X %
 !" # $ %&

7 : 3 84 ) : $ <4 8
?* W' 1 4 4 '" *2 5+
M 3 2 ,@ ; 9+ #6 4% = , 6; % - /
A 4@ 3 8 +2 &4 8 " 4 ;1 ,% / ) -
' #" ) < &4" ;&L , +2 7 B 2 ,@
+2 ! &* % <#$ . 7 -6L ' A ' )
G F
? -6( #$ 1" )& ,
$ +2 C 4 & /
? 8'7 ) ' + Z +2 M I4
+2 , /& @ @ 5+ !" , 5+ 7 :
)' ! " .4O - #" 5+ . &4 5+ <#$ ! 3 8%
, & 5+ 5 7 64 3 84 " #" /4 %
/4 % ' 4 5+ I &4 * - 54 /4 % 54 ) '
G F
? : #$ B 4 W
B ! % - & !& 1 % - 5+ 7 : 0 ;
4 4 4 4 ' ! & +2 4 B4 B 3 5+ 4' : ,
%7 ) A # 3 # /& * 84 " * 3 <4 ' < 4$"
*-' ) A ! " )% = 8, 7 , +2 '
) : 1 % *-' 3 - /4 % = - & "
? '

? K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & D , ?' K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

G F GAlex weill, op . cit , p 319

<
 !" # $ %&

S*# 7 3a U#
+2 4 7 " @ 5+ !" : , 5+ &
7 : ) ' 3 : 4 7 " = ,
2' $ : #$ / G 4' *2 @ F 4 4% L 5+
4% 9 , ,% B 39 , 7 & ,
4 ) ' @ # *,6 ; : / @
G F
? 4%
&4 !& # G Q ? / ?= % F54 K C 7 5+ 7 :
? # !& 4 @" :
4& % 5+ 7 : 4' *2 @ 4 !& . '
54 % 1( = - 4 *2 @ 1" + # 3 1(
? 2 @ 4
4' = - & 1 "3 1" + ; %
? % $ @
/ 6 !& ) 3 8'7 % 5+ 7 : / ,% +
? G F C% ) ' 8 " 8+ 7 : ' )

K3 # = ' * 3 4 D , . %# K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

?X
? ' K 3 8'7 * YG F

%
 !" # $ %&

"
w w a bR
! & < A -' 8'7 K6 5 -' 4 =% 4 @ 5+
?8 & 6J &= ) 0 8 & 0 * +
? 5+ 4; W $ 8 & 82; '" + ! & +2 5 -' W 4
A F +2 ' ' % + 44 @ ##
?G % %& F + ' , G+
3. .4 !& 5+ 4 #"
? 5 % % '" % $ 1J
< A! " % 4 +2 4 0 4@ 3 4 " 5+ )' 4@
4 @ 87 ' 5+ *7 4@ .# 6 76 & 76 : ' >;6 '(
? ,
#" +2 4 + M $4 /4 % 5+ ' - B4 4@
! S % > S 5+ )' > 3 8& A $4% 3 84 L & !6
D -% B #$ C ' # S +

bR
5+ 9 , ! & +2 5 -' 4 " )' 4 @ 5+
? / 8 & = )' " 5 ' 3 8 & 82; '"
4 8 " % 4 3 <4 +2 ) 4 4 " 5+ )'
+ $ +2 B = ' +2 $ / #" # =%
+2 - @ - 4 4& 4 " 5+ =% <+
?G F
= ' +2
? X% K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4&Y G F
F
 !" # $ %&

% " 4 5+ =% $ 3 5+ @ ' A +2 M
! &/ % '" % ' 5+ 54 4 5+ 4
? $ :"
% 5 % " % B 3 6J ! " +2 % " )' 5+
= - & 5+ % " F @ @;& +2 8- = ' +2
+2 ! " = ' +2 4 @> !, % " 3 GB
? ,% /
?G. .4 F $ +2 * " #" 5+ )'
% 4 @ 5+ !& 4 5 - ' =% .4 =%
? @ 5+ / .
" B , 7 $ 5+ )'
? .4
' 4@ +2 4 5+ )' L % 8 0 ;
? 2' 4@ #
? $ ' ' ' 5+ )' ( = - ' #
) ] Eby )u bR (
! & 4@ 8 G 'F 54 4 . 2+ 4 % / !" 9
I4 8 $ % + ' C 7 FD % 5+ '
? G / ' M-6 & 2 #$ #" " : = !&
? 81 . K6 5+ 5 @
? 1 ! 24 ' , "
5+ ' 7 8 + .# @ 8 G% 5F 54 44
? ' Z
 !" # $ %&

@ 4 1 2 @ 0 5+ 4 7 8 G% F 54 @
? # & 1 #" " '
D ' 4 4 <#$ / !" 9
) ] Eb+ . /U
+ 4 % &" 4% 3 : = ! & .4 8 +2 % ' 4 %
$8 "> . 8 = !% 8 8
G F
?> 9 , = )
' +2 /% : = !& 8+ .4 .# +2 % # &"
= 5+ $ = =7 " = + 4% 5+ 9 , 3
8 L 3 : = !& 4 &" 1 = # 8+ 4% /4 97 "
? ' +2
<+ 8 4% &" #" ' +2 $ = +2 D # 1
G / $ 'F
<+ .# = ) 8 <4 % &L ' = A= +2
G F
? / = #$ ) $ '
#L +2 !" 0 76 ' M' B 4 4&
$5 6 #" @ 81 !" 0 + / 4&
? 81
!" 0 B # 6 ' M' . 2+ 9 #6M
?8 K6 = 4 % &" +2 7 / % I4
1 & , $ 6 #$ 9 @ 4@
? / ' M-6 & 2 : = ! & 82 4 &( 8 #" ' +2
?% K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ? '## K 3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F
? 'K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
 !" # $ %&

1 F 6 " .4O a ' ; #$ ,7

G F
? !& $( 4 4 +2 Z
! ) ] Eb+ 7 3a 3
K 4 / 8 ' 1L +2 > + 3 24 C 7 '
' + 8 +2 #3 #) % Z
? # 1 ' &4 .# / 6 )
B 3 Z ) : ! & ! 4@ 8 L +2 I4 ' % C "
?/ + $ ; +2 )A
1( = -* 3 ) : >;6 &4 !" % 1( )&
4 % 9 , ,@ %' @ M' ' 3 *2 @ 1L =
? 8 & @ 4 4
) ] N b6 )u bR "(
)] N 0 ./
? : = ! & I4 <#$ 8 + 8 / $ % + $ ' +2
?) : @ ' = - & 5+
: = ! & .4 8 = 8 8 2 + 8 / $; ) : = '
' +2 $= 8 4 8, + 64L < C !&
$ A8 / *2 & % 3< = ! & 82 4 &(
? ' +2
D $ '/ %
! & 4 &" #$ 8 ' .# = + $ / +2 1 #" Y
? : =

? ' X K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 YG F

 !" # $ %&

8 3 : = ! & 4 &" 8 + M / " +2 1 #" Y

M -6 8 " & 2 : = ! & 82 4 &( 8 3 #/
?G . @ K6 8 $ F /'
' $ B # 5+ )' ! & 8 4@" 4 & +2
? ' < A = ! & .4 8 - #6 " 3 4
8' & . ! & +2 / 4@" 4 & 5 & B . %
! & 4 &" 8+ M 8 &4( 8 8 + 8@ 5+
' / 7 8 & =- / ' M-6 8 4 3 : =
G F
? ' /' M-6 =
! ) ] N 0 7 3a 3
#" 8 , "+ ' 3C 7 ' /
?5 '(
# ' 8 3 8+ ' +2 &4 - ' 1"
? 1( = - !" M
# / 8 L / +2 1" )& *% = ) !
+2 /& 3 : = ! & 4 &" 8 + 4 8#
8 .# 9 , ,@ K 6" # 4 *2 @ = 8 & "
? '; I &4 4 +2 ' K;6 '" %- -'
? 1 ! 07 0 L 7 5+ )' " % -
7 <#$ 0 L ' K6 . @ 4 " 5+ )' " /
?8+ 7 : 1L +2 #$ /% / ' 5+ #" #

% K3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4&Y G F

#
 !" # $ %&

"
a
1 #$ 3 6J ! " +2 % " )' L 3 4 " 5+ )'
5+ % 3 6 K6 % >;6 '( =% = % % 1
8 4 )' )' /4 % - = 1 +2 7 4
4 5+ % " 4 & 54 4& 1 4@ "3 - 5+ 7 #
? 6 & ' 87 6 ! " +2
; -% A 5+ 5 6 ! " +2 5+ % L 4 %
24 5+ 5+ 3 % ; 5+ & % ' 5+ 7
44 " 3 54 4 5+ 4 % ' 5+ ,% " ! " % ( .4O B
?
54 /, + ( % ( #$ M 5+ %
G F
? % ; 5+ 54 ! " % ' 5+
G @/ , & F 5+ 9 % - / ! # 5+ % "
D $
?B !" B 5+ % 3B $ @ @ = - &Y
? 4% G= 7 ( F % > = - &Y
! " 5+ % "/ !& . 2+ 4 G % $G% #G% G% F 4 4%
? K6 >6 / >6

= ' * 3 4 D , X' K 3 # = ' * 3 !" 5 / & " 3 - YG F

? K3 #

$
 !" # $ %&

' % r sa a (
$ ' % r sa a c]' . /
B + 8 # K6 >6 / >6 4 %
G F
?* B1 9 8 !
% $F 54 B / > 6 ! " 5+ % "/ . 2+ 9 /0 4%
D ! & G Q ? / ?=
1 ' >' #" 8 A 7 * / > 6 ! " 5+ % F
G ?? ' ' + ' 8+ 8 >6
% / / 87 6 ! " +2 % 5+ K #$ /7
4 ' / >6 /' !" 4 #$ 3 2 6 7
? # ,% = - 4
5+ % M B !" B % #*
44 "/ > 6 5+ 4 3 5+ *-% # % / * ,
G F
? 87 ' 5+
3 8 76 !" 8+ % " L 8 +2 $ >' #"
S > ' 5+ 7 : % ( #$ M
5+ & & 7 > 6 54 4 5+ $/ > 6 )' $!
?S /4 % 54 " 84 !" , 87 ' 5+ 54 47' 8 $ S 87 '
{ K Y - L Bz ' % r sa a 3
) & 7 > ' 5+ 8 " % 54 4 5+ )' / >6
D % #$ ! &

? % K 3 ## 3 5 $ % 3 , 4 3 #$" *$ ,* 3 4 'YG F
? %% K 3 # = ' * 34 ' , D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

5
 !" # $ %&

5+ L . .4 !& @ > ' 5+ #" 6

1N 7 ) 7 07 0 3 # 87 6
#" 3 % % )' /4 % ' + B 3> ' 5+
+2 6 #$ !% B !" 7 <# % L , & > ' 5+
G F
? % 8 - % " 7 <#$ : *-' 3 < A )' + , &
< ( 76 F 5+ ) & ) > ' 5+ #" 6
% $ 1J V 87 6 ! " ) # % L G , A
?) + 4 & " +2 #$
3 ' % 87 6 ! " 5+ % " 8+ ' >' #" 6 #
8 C 7 / >6 !" > # % #" '* # -
! " 81 ' 0 GC 7 8 /A !& F '
?8 ' 1"
/ > 6 / ?= G % $ F 54 K , . 2+ 9 + 4%
= !& 81 M <4 % &" < $ ' F # 1 #" ' '
? G 8+
5+ & 8+ ;% '" 9 0 8 ' / >6 ' +
8 1 8 ' 1 > ' * - ' #" 3 ' = 87 '
$ 3 : = ! & 4 &" ! & - ' 87 ' 5+
)' F ' 5+ !& % 1N 54 7 '( * - '
G F
? G % /4 %

G F - Braudry la cantinerie , op, cit , p 267 ?

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 YD ,
? #K3 # = ' * 3 &4 Y G2F
 !" # $ %&

5+ 44 " $ 54 4 5+ ' / > 6 5+ &" ! & ) /$ "

, 5+ I &4 9 7 R 87 ' 5+ 54 ! " > 6 5+ 54 /, " 87 '
? /4 % )' - 54 (
'2 V + = sa % b + = CO d "3
)' / % ( /4 / >6 !" >' % L 5+ 54 *-%
?9
87 ' 5+ 54 ! " 5+ 54 /, / >6 % + 4@ #
54 ) ' " /+ L 3 1 5+ $ 3 /, #$ 542 $
> 6 5+ 54 ! " 54 <#$ /, > ' 5+ 4 )' L 5+
/4 % 54 L 5+ I &4 5 = '8 % # /
? )'
| K=6 8 ' & B W U/
G F
/ >6 !" = #$ % 5+ I &4 * > ' 5+ 54 #"
' > 6 5+ / 4 - ;1 C * I &4 * *-' B
?
> 6 /' 3 5+ I &4 A > ' 5+ 54 #"
* I &4 8 + *-' 8L ' & !, 4@ 5+
?I 6 ' 54 8 + '" #" 54 4 & >@ I &4 C
D ? 6 } B 6 8 ' & B W Uk
/4 % 54 "4 #" 87 ' 5+ 54 ! " 8 + 54 /, / >6 *-'
87 6 ! " 5+ % " 8+ ' >' #L 3 )'

G F Y Colin et capitant , op.cit . p420

?' K3 # = ' * 3. +4 54 D ,

<
 !" # $ %&

54 ! "8 + 54 /, - /4 % )' * - ' ' %

? 87 ' 5+
L ' Z ) ' 5+ !& 4@ G > ' F B #"
/4 % 54 'L + = >6 7 <# % % 5+
G F
? %
) '! "8 + 4 ' ' / >6 . 2+ 9 Z ' 4@
! " 87 ' 5+ 54 /, 8 ' 1" 4 8 3 % /4 % )' " Z
? /4 % 54 ( 8+ 54
~ r % r sa a "(
2a a 2J ` ~ r % r . /
% ") ' ) ' 87 ' & # % !% $ K6 >6
? 7 * 4%
? 5+ % " !" 4 @ @;& = ' +2 8 @ +2 $
5+ % 8 +2 # / + " 8- K6 K6 >6 =
< :" 8 ;- > W' 1" ! & 8 + 8 " 4 K6 38 "
G F
?8 9
>; 6 # $ 3 = ' +2 # & 5+ 8 " % K6 >6
? + 8 8 + 9 87 ' > 6 .# / >6
D !& G% F 54 K
8 " % " & - '" # ! & %7 " #" < A ! " +2 5+ % F
?G= #$ 9 , .4 / ' 4 = !& -' 5+

? %K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

%K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G F
%
 !" # $ %&

87 ' 8 =7" !& / K 6 > 6 5+ % " " 54 K /7

. 5+ 9 , ! & 5 - ' > 6 I4 % ( # -
. 4 +2 .4 4 & 5 8 & - '"
? =2 &
8 " 4 ' /' = !& 4 5 - ' <#$ =% #"
? .4 / ' B 4 4 5 - ' =% +
? 7 / ' - " 4 5+ % + $K
5+ 8 " % .# K 6 87 6 +2 =7" $ K % - )
/ 8+ % 4 !& -' 5+ 8 " % " & - '" * # !&
G F
? 4 ' 8 ' /
.4 4 & 5 ! & 5 4% 5 - ' $
/ ' =% 5 -' $4 O 54& % * ! - #$ 3 5+
? / ' / /+; 8 K 4@ 9 A 3 44 +2 4
.+ / ' / ' = - & 5+ % + 8 8 /7
? 7 A/ ' $
D $ .4 A / ' =%
GP N 4 BF C b 3
% 4 7 / ' !" 4 : 4 / ' #$ =%
> = 7" 4 8 7 / ' &+ 3 6J ! " 8 +
D 8 .4 ) A @
K 6 87 6 ) ' 8 ' + % ! & > ' 4 *, '" YG
9 % 0 !& . * =7 /1 8 .# % +2 * M

? '' K 3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F

F
 !" # $ %&

8 , & 8+ # ' M' 87 8+

G F
?. % ( % ( #$ & 44 )' +
8+ % 4 % % % +2 !" , +2 4@ <#$ G
> 6 / % /1 3 , 5+ 7 7 M > 6 5+ 4 #
' <4 & &4 ' M' < &L 8 & <4 *, .# %
O % 4 /+ 3 4 ' % /' !" Q 8 & <4 ,
? 8'7 ) ' @ 5+ <+ Z 8 < A
D % Q?/?= G % F 54 8& & #$
87 6 )' <4 , +2 '" #" .4 / ' 4 5+ % + F
? G 8'7 ) ' <4 , >6 '" 5+
^A Cb "3
8 5+ !" + > 6 / ' = - & / .# $
! & 5 -' 54 +2 /' F 4 8+ !& 5 -'
4 ' 5 ' Z 7 . /' 3 5 5 -' 8+ 4
?G 4 ' 4
G F
? 8+ % 4 - )' / ' #$ /
5 -' =% ' $ &( +2 !" ' 5 4N #" 4%
?9 , ,@ 4% *,6 2' 8+ 4 !& 7
4 & 4@ +6 4 8 & , 94 4@ *2 / ' #$ ! & 1
/ % 4 . ! " & , <#$ *2 * /1 3 % @ !"
? &, 4' / ' / % +6 @ & , /; '

? XK3 # = ' * 3 4 ' D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

? XX K 3 # = ' * 3 54 Q / 4&D , ? XK3 # = ' * 3 4 'YG F
 !" # $ %&

? % / ' #$ ! & G% #F 54 4%
+6 &4 % !" 4 *2 , & 5- 4' / ' F
?G # *2 , / ' / % / %
L ' $; # *2 , 6J / ' 4 ' K6 / ' #" 8 A
? G *2 , / ' ,
/ ' C #" 8 ! 4 $ 8 @ 7 / ' 1 .+ / '
G F
? $ .+ / ' * 7
% ! " 4O $; + / ' 9 8 5 ( 4
8 " % " & - '" 8 - # " / ' !" 4 5+
? 5+ = !& -' 5+
D ~ r %r + ) - '6
7 + >' 5+ & % ' 54 4 5+ K 6 > 6 5+
? @ & 7 & > 6 4@ 6
DB 7 6 4@ + / ' #
K 6 8 7 6 5+ #* , & 5+ > ' 5+ 4@ Y
?Z @
8 7 6 5+ 76 C A < L > ' 5+ Y
G F
? ) <#$ 6
> 6 !& 4 2 ' ' 4 4% 5 Y%
? >' @;& 8 K6

D , 3' K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
(2) - Braudry lacantinerie , op . cit , p 217 .
 !" # $ %&

D 8'7 U - .# O'
4 #" 3 8 + 54 87 ' 5+ 54 /, K6 >6 47' $
? S 5+ I &4 ' /4 %
• r %r + = sa % b + = CO b V
D Q?/?= G% $F 54 K !" 9
G /4 % ` 87 ' 5+ 8+ ! " /, K6 >6 + F
54 / , *-' 87 ' 5+ + 97 ( K6 >6 8 4 $
* - 54 '( /4 % )' 8 + 54 ! " 87 ' 5+
? 5+ I &4
D 8+ ! " 87 ' 5+ 54 /, +2 - 8L / !&
>' 5+ #L 3 /4 % )' > ' 5+ YG
38 + 54 87 ' 5+ 54 /, ; @ > 6 5+ , &
G F
? /4 % )' @ /
/4 % +; 54 '" -% 8 + 54 ! & # 4 8
? 5+ I &4 *
8 @ > ' <+ .# = # !& > 6 5+ ) YG
54 ! " 87 ' 5+ 54 /, K 6 > 6 * - ' # 3 8 !4 = !&
= ) -% 9 7 " = ) 8 @ +2 6 #$ #" 8 +
G F
? +2
! " 87 ' 5+ /, * - ' ; % /4 % ' K6 >6 #" YG%
G% F
? ' * Z ) ' ! " 54 ' > ' 5+ #" " 8 +

G F Y Philipe bihr , op.cit , p 206 ?

?' K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
?X K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4 & Y G%F
 !" # $ %&

"

. + + $ . .4 5+ )'
. 4% " 3 <4 .4 4%7 + 3) ' )'
D ! " 5+ + C ' # 3 <4
]R ? W€6 (
7 8 - ' & +2 ! 6 #" 5+ + F D ! & Q?/?= G% 5 F 54 K
GEF
? G % - M 5 - ' <#$ 4% #" . = !&
5 - ' +2 4%7 # =% . .4 & 4%7 5+ +
? 8 > # + !& 4
D $ 4%7 5+ + 4@
AH ? ] ? 16 ./
!& 4 8 - ' & ! 6 #" 3 54 7 84 L 8+ & +2 !6 $
< A ! " 5+ % 4 3 8'7 ) ' 8 '" 4 @ & #
2 6 <#$ > % %& + '
G F
? ( abandon) ! '
! 6 4@ / 4 8+ 4 ' *-' ; 3 . 1 % 5+ & 6
# 6M B 5+ + $ 3 2 # 4 @ 4 &
3 ; '( I 6 5 + 38 .# U / %
8 & + 4 % 3 % & +2 !6 B4 4 %

Y GEF
! 4' G. F5 &4 " 1 54 <#$ K 4 M-6 ! " $ 5 ( 4
5 6 <#$ * 3 7 5 - ' 4%7 '7 I 6 % - .M 5 - ' 4% B 3 54 4 %
?G F 4 ' G. F ># M-6 #$ Z # 3! & %' I 6

G F Y Alex weill, op.cit , p 330 .

#
 !" # $ %&

% !& 4 5 - ' 4% #" < 6L % & +2 !6 8 A

? + 5+ + <#$ 8 3 7 )' 4 %
• [ 6 3
* '+ +2 @ % > 5+ + =% 4@
?> 9 $ A
4 %7 B 3 K 6 87 6 +2 % - 4 + B4 $
7 )' = '" !& 4 5 -' 4%7 5+ +2
5+ & % ' 54 4 5+ 4 .# K 6 87 6 5+ / ' / %
? 8 & 5 -' 4 + /' 4 !
AH EK BT =W "3
# 8 & A G .4 F 5+ !& 4 5 - ' +2 4%7 4@
D # 1 3 2 - > 0 5 $% 5 %
!& 4 5 -' 4%7 5+ % /4 /- !" + + .4O
? # . +2 4%7 5+
9=+ ^? ]R = 6 "(
0 ! 8 ' .# = !& 4 5 - ' +2 4% #" 5+ +
G F
?. 07
+2 4% #" 2 .4 = '" 1 .# <4 6 #$ B
? 8 & 5 - ' 4% 7 '(
?< 6" : +2 6L 5+ + =%
5 - ' 4%7 4& # B4 3 <4 .4 +2 4% #" 5+ +

? %'' K 3 # = ' * 34 ' , YG F

$
 !" # $ %&

, 54 4 5+ / @ # 8 & < A 5 -' )' !& 7

@ ' +2 5+ ) A # +2 5+
?< (
!& 7 5 -' AZ B .4 +2 4%7
? < A -' 8'7
$ & + 5+ + ,% % ' 54& % ! & 1 '" 4 8 A
? .4
#L . 07 + +2 L .4 + ! 8 B
= !& 7 5 - ' +2 5 4 @ * . 4
G F
? * + #" 4 4 8 -' 9 '" 8 L +2 L
D Q?/?= G% F 54 4%
A= !& 7 5 - ' +2 5 4 @ * #" 5+ + F
/ A @ 54 4 5+ & 2 '* '" #" + 5+
#" 54 4 5+ 8 4 .# @ ' )' 8 & 4 +2 54 "
G 76 4 #" +2 /& / & 4
% % 5+ !& 4 5 - ' 4% + :
4% .4 5 4 @ * / @ = $
D !& ' # #$
] AH =W ./
< A -' 8'7 '8 & 7 5 - ' +2 4% 4 % 5+ +
G F
? 84 . !% '" ! #

? X'X K 3 # = ' * 3 !" 5 / & " E - YG F

G F- Michel de juglartet , et autres , op.cit , p 143 .

5
 !" # $ %&

* @ 4 5 - ' 4% /4 % 5+ 4%7 +2 AY
8 & - '" , /4 3 .4 & 5 4 .# @O
?4 # ! & C &" 4 4 8 - ' -'
07 /4 <4%7 +2 L @ ' % 9 , B4 #" # 1
+2 % + B 9 , @ ' <#$ ! & ' B;1 / .
G %# F 54 K , ' 1;1 ;6 *2 , = ' % 4 4 '"
? 4 %
% !& 4 5 -' 4%7 + 5+ I 8%7 ) $8 A
?M / : 5+ M ' @ ' 9 ,
M / /4 @ ' 9 , 4 + 5+ $ N V A
G F
? : 5+ # &
' AH =W 3
+ #" % 5+ 4% ) ' &B ) $ # ) ' / % 5+ 4%7
? .4 8&
Z> L 6 A# . U
5 -' & +2 ' 4 5 $% 5 % #" 5+ + %
? 5+ ' % !& 4
#" # 1 @O * 5 $% 5 % +4 ; ( /4
& 7 5 -' & ' & + 4 C ,7 A
9 -% R 1 & 5 - ' 54 8 L /4 3 & +2 5+ +
. @O *

?
? X' K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 4 YG F
 !" # $ %&

26 A# . )&? b )0 ‚ EK AH ? '> U
& + & 87 % !& 4 8 -' ' & +2 9 " "
8 4@ /4 8+ + > 0 > 0 . .4
/ /4 5+ .4 <4%7 #$ <4 @ 3 =2 & 4 4 &
5+ % ' 3 I 6 5+ * 8+ C / 8+ 4 8 C
G F
? 8 & ; '( 4 / % 4 =2 & ; +2 > % % $ $
AH ? a S*6 U#
, 4 : > - 8 & 4 5 -' / @ % ! & ; '(
+ ! " .4O #$ 5+ .4 +2 $ 4%7 8 & : +2
% 6 I &4 = - & $4 4 '" ! & 4 @ +2 /4 5+
) : F $4% ) ' 5+ 4%7 ' ;6 %% #$ / 4 8+
? % % 8+ 4 4 '" +2 #L G C
G F
5 7 1O ) : : 4 0 54 L
?Q?/?= G % F 54 @
4 #L 3 4 4 '( I &4 * ' ) ' " 7 54 <#$ 44
' )' " 4 76 4 #" 3 $ 0W 5 $0 5+
?! 5+ 4% /& W
? .4 $ & 4%7 $4%7 8 L ' ;6 8 + 4 4 '" +2 ) - / #"

? K3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ Y G F
? ## K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&YG F

<
 !" # $ %&

9=+ ^ ]' []' = 6 "(

?G F
.4 $ & % * ! 5+ 4%7 <4 7 . 4% "

3 % 5+ 4$ <4 % " 1 B % $ 5+ 4%7 8 + 8 #

5+ 4 %7 9 9 .M <+ .# +2 >

;1 3 4 8 - ' +2 4 # '" " ! .

? # ' M'

%% 5+ 8 " % " )' $ *@ .4 8

5+ & 6 > ;6 4 % +2 3>

? @ 5+ <+ , & +2 0 4 <4 7 %

A 5+ $ 1 '" $ 3 5+ 4% ! " .4O . 4%7

. 8 4% /A 07 % 8+ 6 #$ 4%7 B +
G F
? 8& ) $ #" @ +2

?X K3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4&Y G F

G F Y Alex weill, op.cit , p 331 .

%
 !" # $ %&

G[ )-,V
% K6' - '" 7 #$ 5+ / H ' 4 ;6
? 5+ @ - 44 4@
4 !& 4 B 5+ 3 & ;6
6 8 &4 ; @ 5+ # 3 $4
? /4 % 8 )' + 8 +
% - & * % !& 4 5+ # !&
4 5+ + 8 4 3 # 5+ *,6
+ + - & & = . )' & K6
5+ + 3 7 6 > &+
- # 7@ ; ! 6 4 %
/0 0 5 % 5+ + 3 6
! & 1N /$ 4 6 #$ &L /4 % )' + /4&
? 5+ / @
!& 4 #$ ! 3 = % ! & 5+ %
& ' & !& 6 = %
4 7 " 5+ @ A ; @
? # @
? *2 ) !& 4 L 5+ 7 ! & 5+ 4
.4 $ '' !& / % B 5+
?.
& @ & 5 & 8M 4 % 44 .4

F
 !" # $ %&

54 & 4 + % +2 / % 5 $0 4 &
# $ !& =- # = % % 8 & ' 5+ %
! & 7 5 - ' ! & .4 / % ? 4 *, 54 &
- ' $ 4@ 8'7 +2 $ 4% 5 - ' <#$ 44 5+
?9 = - & $ 3 :
0 ! " +2 > 8 4 % .# . ! & 5+ / %
5+ ! 8 & = ) 0 5+ !&
?8
4 5+ B . 4 1( @ @ % *, 4%
<# $ ! & . 4 !& @ @ $ / @ ! .4
? 4 % 6% % 7 4 %
4 0 $ 0 4 % . 9+ 8
$ & 5+ 6 0 - B 3 6 0
, .4 I 4 0 3 % $ 1J B4 !
4 +2 & ;% ' 1 . 5 ,
? 7 8 -' =% / % &
< A )' +2 + /4& $ 0 = 7 0 ;
+2 4 0 3 6 0 B;1 5+ I &4
? < A )'
?. 6 0 . 2+ 9 #6 4%
- + 7 # 4 @ & 5 & 5+

#
 !" # $ %&

+ / 4& +2 #" . + 1' $

4 5 , , % /1 4 84 " < + A
8&) .# /% 8& % )2 $ < A4&
? % 81 -' . K6 5+ Z 3 G. .4 F
5+ & 4 @ 4 Z ' K6 &
+ 3 M % 4 % $M '
#" 5+ I &4 ! 5+ & !" & <#$ ) %
! & Z ' & & !& 8+ / % .# +2 / % # -
? +2 = , 4 .4 6
- 3 . .4 # " 5+ 9
G< ( ) & 6F 24 $ M > !& $ 5+ <#$
) & 6F , G 76 ) & 6F & , -% A5 '
= )' 1 % $ 1J * ) ! # G C :
#2 1 0K ,% / 5+ I &4 5 /4 %
# % ! 5+ ' $ . 4 <4 .4
!, % "/ % $ < A )' 8'7 ) ' <+ $= +
, % % K6 !& " = ) #"
? %% +2 )' #
! & + - , & +2 !% , +2 M ,% / & 4 $
! " 8 : 4 8+ 7 : 8'7 ; 8+
= - & # @ 5+ !" , 5+ : 8 " @ 5+
D $ 4 % G %# F 54 &
? : 7 (
#
 !" # $ %&

? = 8 C +2 7 (
& " 4 )' 4 @ & 5 & 5+ 7 #$ ;6 &
'8 & 82; ' 5+ 9 , ! & +2 5 -' 4 = -
? # / 8 & = )' 5
4 8 " % 4 <4 +2 ) 4 & 4 5+ )'
6J ! " +2 5+ % 4 % : % 5+ )'
8 - = ' +2 % 5 % " 5+ % -% 7 A
% 4@ 3B = - & 5+ % @ @;& +2
? ,% / @> !, % 5+
#$ 3 + B 4 5+ % " M #
)' /4 % 54 - =% # 5+ 54 ! " % ' 5+ 54 /,
? 5+ I &4 * ' 4 - =%
- + 5+ 8 A $ 1J * 5+ @ #"
4% #" ? . .4 5+ 4% #" # B4 $ '
? <4 . 3 <4 .4

#
 ! ( & '

= ,% 6 @K 9 64 5 5 > 0 , @"
4 !" <#$ .4O #" 3 @O 7 % + = % C
-' N 2' & & 4% 3 9+ - *'
1 N 2 ' <#$ 3 = % <#$ ,% ! "
? I &4
4 7 4% : $ % 5+ 0
4 &" . 5+ I &4 / 0 # !& / $(
? 5+ I &4 $ C
& / 4% 4 !" 4 5M 14 ' 5+ I &4
? 9,
?S 5+ I &4 6 $
&= . % 5+ = 8 ! " ' ' 5+ I &4 >4
/ / 0 !' 3 !& @ 5+ <#$ &L 8 & 6J
5 % <#6M % &4 .# K6 + 8 $ '' 4 !& / %
? 6 4 4 ! & ,% 8'7 8'7 /
? 5+ % 9 A B4 $ , + $
# 4 5+ & < : . 2+ 9
? 24 % '" 1 5+ I &4 = - &
! 8+ ! & .4 &" #" % 7 5+ I &4 * +2 =
? %% $ .4

##
 ! ( & '

#" " @ 5 % 2' -' $4 ' % <#$

<# / -( 4 4 0 a4 / 4& %
?
?S 5+ I &4 / 4& % / <#$ $
)' ) ' ' 4 5+ 5+ /2 % - (
? I &4 5+ I &4 -6 1
! & 1J ) 8% )- = +2 6 4@ 9 #"
!& ) - % ' #" 5+ I &4 = - %' % 38 8 '"
=- #$ 3 = ' + /4& 5+ )- = '"
, 54& @ $ 54 I &4 &4 * + /4& <4 7 '' 4
? ,% > - = % * , /4 , /$M
?S #6N 1J $ S 54& % <#$ , $
2 ( * - ): K 6 !" / 7 #$ '
B4 ! " 5+ / -( & B4 % ( # % -
- I4 ! & 5+ I &4 I &4 & 7
? 6

#$
 ! ( & '

)& B ' J1
/ !& 0 8 A 5+ +; % 7 4%
$ .4 ! 8+ ! & 4 &( * 4 +2 + M '
I 6 = % = !& %& ! & 5+ <#$ @ ' 3 %%
? B;1 5+ I &4 5 = - & # 5+ ; Z
> ) I4 ! & 5+ I &4 I &4 ' 4 !" = - @
$ A & $+ 4& % / & !&
? I &4
#$ ' # 3 5+ / -( 44 $ 4& % / <#$
# 5+ I &4 6 + L 4 -( #$ 4 4 B
<#$ - 3 )- 5+ %' % 9
$ A & $+ - ' &5 & $ 2 6 + " I &4
5+ I &4 % - 44 !" 3 1 )- I &4
I &4 I &4 * + /4& 54& % = - ' 3 B 1 )-
? $ 1J , 5+

Y ƒ )& B G-
% 0 $ : * @ / 0 5+
5 4 + , 4@ 5 -6 1J &) )' 0
97 ( = ' ' $0 & 3 )' ) '
?8
#5
 ! ( & '

& # & 4 &( + @ % 1 4 5+

) ' & B /4% # 5+ J ' 5+ I &4
? &( & !& # 4 '" , > 4$
)& B G- (
/A 3 / 4% % !" * 5+ I &4 !& %7 *
! " 64 #$ I4 3 5+ -6 8 4 % #$
I ' > / .# % -" Q 6 *% - ' @ 5+ &"
? G F
=
I &4 B " /4 4 5+ I &4 0 /
4 @O 97 ( / ,% 34 J 5+
44 '" , 7 % # I &4 7 !" / 6
G F
?8 1
"= - & ! ' 5+ % > &" & '
/ 0 ! " ' 4& % " /1 3 4 /0 ' 6
D -% $ - 5+ I &4 0 C ' # I &4
!< # | K? q ./
&5 & $ ! ' / 0 5+ % ! 4%
!& 9+ - 4" 2 ,@ - ' 8 $ 4
<4 , 5+ 4 9+ * @ 4 *, 5+ % " ,%
'' & ! " 5+ & # !& 3 8 ) A !&

? XK3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F

?% K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F

#
 ! ( & '

! " ! >4 B 3 5+ 4 4 '" 5+ % '" $

!" $ 4 '% 8 1 ! : > - C . 4 *,
? % +2 ! " >4 9 % +2 ! " >4 9 3 &
5 % 5+ 4% 4 *, 54 & >4 5+ 4 4 '"
D $ & !" I 6 $ '% " ' - ' 5 % <#$ '
-' 5 % : 5+ 4 4 ' ! " >4 -' 5 %
) 6 ) - 5+ <#$ 4 -
?) : W ' ;6 ) - *
G F
?G , 7 3 76 3 5 % F $ 4 & 4 *, ) &
' 5 % : 5+ 4 4 '" ! " >4 ' 5 %
! & ) : W ' ) 5+ 6 -
G F
? @ . "M +2
I &4 / 0 ' 4& 7 3 2 2 - <#$ #6
? 5+ 8 >4 .#
I &4 % +2 I &4 ! " @ # 5+ I &4 '% "
? % +2
# 6 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 $ 54 I &4 5+ 4 4 '" 4
D !& 44 '%
?5 % ) : ' #" 5+ 4 4 '" ! " >4 I &4 Y
? +2 , 4 : !" % " 5+ 4 4 '" ! " >4 I &4 Y

? K 3 # = ' * 3 /;& =+ 4&4 YG F

? % K 3 8'7 * YG F

#<
 ! ( & '

G F
? , +2 4 5+ 4 4 '" ! " >4 I &4 Y
5+ ! " >4 2 ,@ AI 6 " I &4 <#$ ) !" @
@ #" <4 *, ) ' 8% ' 87 % *7 "M
8 5 , 8@ % K% % 8& 7 " 1O 4@ 54 4 & 8
? #" +" #7 4 #" & <#$ >@
+2 M A # 3 2 ,@ A I 4 4& "
G F
? I &4 ! " & <#$ > % "
1 5+ , % & 5+ I &4 /
% % # 3 8+ I &4 ( ! " +2 -,
? / 4% ' 7 % 5+ I &4 0 4 1
$ b ! | K? 3
4& +2 ! " >4 4 4 * - + - 5+ I &4 0
* , , !-' ' % 3 8+ 7
&/ % '
' ' % !" '' * I &4 <#$ C % B
5+ I &4 W' = 4 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 6 G droit canonique )

4 # 7@ ' = % !" a4 >4 4@

@/ "/ 4 ;7 @ ,/ @' 4& /
3/ / "4 ! & 76 / /$ ,% 7
G% F
? ' +2 ! 4 $4 4 '" = /

? X K # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
?' K3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F
? X K3 # = ' * 3 &4 Y G%F

#%
 ! ( & '

5 % 8+ ' Z 1 Z ! I &4 <#$ = - *' " /1

#" 3 ! ) : 4 $4 4 '" = 9 A= -
I &4 * 8 &) 8% 4 4 '( ; ' ) : #6
? ,% = - & 8% 4 4 '(
4& 3 5 /& 4 ' * I &4 <#$ A # 4 / 4%
?G F
G # /& F 4 % K , I &4 <#$ 4 & *'
$ &B 1 % 0 GC * I &4 F I &4 <#$ /1
C +2 ! " ' ' >4 4% 4 54 '
! &4 / ' - !& 0 ) : 4&
? 5+
07 - 54 0 G 54 4 & >@ I &4 F #4 0 /1
C * I &4 - 6" /1 * 2 ,@ A* -
' 54 , / #" / "4 Z 3 2 ,% * - #6
G F
? 8& @ ! &
K6 8 @ B / 4% % 8 B4 ' 7 % 4 '" 4%
@ , 5+ B;1 I &4 ! & K B 3 5+ I &4
% / , 4% $ 1J 7 5+ K6 4 (
? 4
4 % % ' , /0 1M 4%
5+ K6 ' 7 * 8 " 4 ( @
? . 2+ * /
? X# K 3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
?# #K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
#F
 ! ( & '

^ H AM ! | K? " 3
)' ) ' '4 . 2+ % $ : 5+
? )' /4 % / 0 '' @
> @ I &4 3 C * I &4 3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 F B;1 5+ I &4
? 5+ <#$ 7 % , I4 " 3 G 54 4 &
? 4 ( @ 4 % 5+ / . 2+ 9 /0
' = 3 5+ & , / 4 % B
? $ 1J + % "
I &4 <#$ 3 = - 5+ I &4 $ 9 4 4%
4 & % <#$ ,9 $4 4% 5+ & , / %1 - "-
@ ' " $ I &4 <#$ &L 5+ K6 +
% 4 6 I &4 5+ / * / # 3 5+
F4 # G )' " = - = 1 7 4 ' /'% F 4
? G Q?/?= %$# F 54 A ! " G % % F 54
6 - I &4 8 " B;1 5+ I &4 - 4 /A
54 I &4 <#$ I &4 K 6B = 4& ' 4@ 9 L #
? @ ! & 54
4 ( @ , %H H 5 _ O F H % /@ %
= ) , 5+ I &4 . 2 + 9 4% 4 4 4(
6 ( 4 1 ) / '@ C 6 (
G. % /'% F B 1 7 6 /'% # 2 ,@
GEF
4( 4 ( @ G5# F 54 ! " G5 $F 54 D 4
54& @ 5+ I &4 / 4& % a4 !& 4 <#$ "B 3
? 7 6 !& + 5+ I &4 I &4 * + /4&
GEF
9 !: / 4% 4 ( @ 44 3 ^ '^ % 5 4 ' 54
54 4 # 64 % ( * ' ) ) , 5+ I &4
G $ F F 54 !" G $ # F
$
 ! ( & '

( @ 4 % '% 5+ / 4 #$
? 4( 4
D $ B;1 . 2 + % 5+ I &4
54 4 & >@ I &4 C * I &4 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
$44 4& . 5+ ! " >4 " K6
)& „ 7 ƒ "(
) A %% = - 4@ 0 #$ = 0 $ 5+
4 @ 3/ - ' / -' *, 6 !& = % ) +2 /0
$ 1J 5+ 4 <#$ ! I 6 %% 0 #$ = -
DB % $ 6
_ ' 8 7 3a ! 3/ U
4@ 4 % % 1L % / . 2+ 9
? 8 6 % # 7 54 ) !& @ 5+
3 # & !& 4 / % = ) +2 % C " $
1" 4 ; 4 !& @) 6 - ' 5+
? *- @ A 48
! & 1 # #" = % 1" 2 ' ' 5+
1 ' 4' 1 4 @" ) ' 1L 8 1"
% 8 $ 3 % 0 I4 . % '
1( @ -' @ !& @ 5+ % &" #
?
D @ @ !, % / 1" 5+ 4 ='
3 !& 4 / % !" % 5+ !& @ 4 5+ !
? 1 !" !& @ % 5+ 1
$
 ! ( & '

8 & &4 + 4 = I &4 07 +2 % <#$

! & @ @ 1 #" B 3 4 5+ ' 1( )& K6
? 5+ 4 I @ ; 4 /4% = &4 ! & % 5+ 4
)]' I bR k 0/ E 0 U
= % 2 ' )' ! " .4O 5+ !& 1N /$ "
54 5+ F - /4 % = - & # 5+ ;
L ' +2 Z ) ' 5+ @" #" 3G ' & '6
9 4% 3 G ' &F % /4 % % )' ! " .4O 5+
GEF
? 4 % G% % % <F4 / , 5+ 1 #$ . 2 +
54 ' / " )' ) ' )' % - ' 5+
8 !& @ #" ' = - C ' 3 =
' : !& @ #" 3 ; '( $ #$ 4
? /4 % $ #$ 54 , 4 +2
AH )& „ U#
# 5+ &" 3 +; 7 5+ 4 %
8 ;6 =% .# - ) ' $ 8 " 4 ' 4@ .# = & 0 >
4 M <#$ 4@ 5 $0 % + % '" 4 ' ,
? B;1 5+ I &4 $ 6 I &4 = - & % +2 + ,
/A 5+ % /4& 3 5+ %
! & 4 &( " ! " .4O $ 0 *@ & 8 ") = 0 1
?/ 6 = %

8 4 %& % & % %& % + FD ! & G F 54 B Y GEF

5+ @ #" F D ! & G F 54 ? G 9 -% 4 ' X 54 8 + ' #" 8 # 8 6
G ' /4 % 54 L Z 4' !" 8 # @ 54 ' ' % . %& &= %& ! &
$
 ! ( & '

> 8 & -' ' 4 % 5+ /A 8 !" 5 ( :

: #$ "3= &B 4 1N <#$ ) 8 #
> 3 # 5+ !& 1N <#$ 1 % ) & #" 6
K6 #" % > 6 *, < = % +2 & 0
< : 2 + !" % ! " .4O 4@ 3 < A +
? % 4 +2 )'
#" & O' 1 #24 & = ) " 6 4 +2 #L
?S 7 A 8'7 =
& , O' 1 #24 & 3 !& 7 = ) /
S : % 8
'. % ' +2 !& , 4%
? / = ) +2
?S "4 ' &( $ S <#$ $
D ! & 5+ % "4 ' &( /'%
' … [ 68 ' & K1 . /
3* /0 @" ! & " # 5+ 8 9 "
5 %' 5 $0 @ 9, / " 4 ,% / Z #
4 ,5 % > '" # $ 4 & .4 C /4&
G F
?* /0 / 44 +2
! & .4 : + 8L 5 -' ! & - ' .# $ +2
<# $ 5 % &+ " 5+ ) : / % 8 Z' 5+ <#$
? 8'7 = ) @ 5 4 &
? K 3 ##X 3 5 $ % 3 * + 4 43 2 )" 2 : "34 ' >'YG F

$#
 ! ( & '

4 5+ 9+ 5 $0 9, > 6 % &4 Z #"

! " .4O 3 8+ 9 + L / 4 ! & 44 +2 Z 5 % 5 & +2
K6 + 8 7 K @( 4 & ! " 54 ) -,( !, 7
G F
)' 4@ .# 4 J 6 " ? 8'7 8% ,%
! " .4O 3 4 !" 4@ +2 &+ )
?* /0 ;6( ' 7
' R % ,% ! " = - & 8% 4 ' 8 &
@= &4 !& : $ = , @( 9 ' %
G F
?5 % A" 4 7 8+ - ,% ! " +2
34 = . * , 8 # # 5+ 5 ( 4
%% 4 4 '" +2 = /4 L @O
? <4
% - 9 , ) A /&4 $ # 5+ 4 % "
<#$ : @ !& 8% 1" ! " # 9+ !" = %
) : !& / % 9, 4 % 3 % 2' 5 $0
? 4 &(
, L 3 K6 % '( , 5+ !" ,(
! &K .# +2 ,7 5 0 % 0 B - 4 @R /&4
? 8 97 R ; @ 8 8 '" G % %& F 8 + ;: '"
? # & 8 ;: '" & &% 8 .#

G F Y Alex weill .op .cit , p.300 .

? X% K 3 3 2+ 3 I4 43 + 3 # !" 5 /3P 'YG F

$$
 ! ( & '

D AH )- r ) [ 6 8 ' & " K1 3

# 0 +2 =% 542 5+ %
D
8 c K )]& > U
) $ : 5 1 = +2
G F
?=
8' 7 8 + 4 @ 38 + 8 +
8 $= +2 ! & 24 , " % *, # < A -'
G F GEF
? '& 1( @ !& @ 5+ #
D % % <#$ ! & . 2 + 4 % G %# F 54 4%
4 I 3 G # >;6 ! = # ) 8 C 7 = +2 F
! &9 ) ' $ % <# 4 4 &( < '
' 5+ 9 #6 " 4% 3 = ) +2 # 5+
4 5+ ! % # !" K6 = 1(
3 !& @ % 5+ 1 % 5+ !& @
% <# $ / @ 4& % 3 5+ &+ ,7 4& @ *,
& !& 4 / % ! = !& @ 5+ 1 -' %
5+ !& &+ 1 + + +2 " #
G% F
? 5+ 8&+ !& %1 ) #$ % 1( )& +2 !7

(1) - Alex weill , op . cit , p 300 .

.4O A 4 3 !& 4 @ ,% 9 8- ' % Y GEF
?/ = - & -' .4O 5 8 1" 4 !"
? X K 3 ## 3 4 '( 3 & - 43 ) ! B &B ! 3 $ .4 !7- YG F

G%F Y Alex weill , op . cit , p 333 ?

$5
 ! ( & '

/ 0 @ # 35 A % - $ 5+ 8 4& %
L # = ) 5 A $ 5+ I &4 9
5+ I &4 &4 )' 5 ' 4 4 / 4% & 8% '
G F
?= I &4 + >@ Z
' & ' " 'B 5+ ! & 4 &( %
= - * " #" ' / .# 8 1" +2 !&
?G5 ' 4' F 1" I 6
% @ # 3= I &4 '" 1 ' , 5+ I &4 'L
G F
? &9 4 -6 1 4 5+
D8 ) 'W )0 ‚ U
8 -' = ) ' ' $ !& 7 5 -' ! 5+ "
? 8% + 8 5+ 8 38 &
4 3 97 ( 8% ' ,5 O M' 5+ #
+ % 9 7 ( =% ! 3 - ' <# /&4 5+
? : 6 +2 '
$ 8 k b R1 ) 0 U#
- ' ! &5 5+ 5 -6 1N
? = = % )' $ %
/ &4 % '( ! " L 3 # / = 54 ' 5+ '
= )' " ) ' ' 5+ !" 9 4 5 $0 % +
?

? # K 3 \ -? ?4 [ 3 2 + 3 & - 4 3 # !" 3 % 4 Y G F
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 4 D , ? ##K 3 # = ' * 3 4 & .4 Y G F

$
 ! ( & '

"
$ [H [V | K? )' J
$ A M' 2 6 5+ I &4 % - B "
$ 3 5+ I &4 -K 6 1 %7 % !" '' #*
- M' ) - #$ C ' # 3 @ I &4 / & , I &4 $
? 2 6 5+ I &4 %
$ | K= ) )' (
6 I &4 ! " 8 & ! .# = -B /'% I &4 !76
%& I &4 ! " ) - -B /'% & I &4
? % I &4
? S / '% #$ ! " 0 5+ I &4 - $
? % I &4 5+ I &4 4
% )- % +2 $ % I &4
G F
? 8 & .4 8 8&+ 8%
? 5+ I &4 = - I &4 ! " & , B /'% $
G F
? % = = 3 %& I &4 $ 5+ I &4
? & = % !" 4 ' & I &4 $

?X K3 3 2+ 3 *+ / 4 3 # !" 3B: 5 &YG F

?X K3 # = ' * 3P 'YG F

$<
 ! ( & '

.# $ A O' + 5+ I &4 % - ' 4 44

& , I &4 5+ I &4 4 $D 1 0 44 U -

#6" !" '' '" @ I &4 / # 5+ 4 %

?S & , = ) @ 4

D -% !" 5 : O' #$ & @

& , I &4 <#$ # $ $ 5+ I &4 - 4 %

' @ I &4 /3 & , ,% / /

,% 0 '( 5 !& '' / % @ / !&

? '

3 2, % 5 $ ' @ ,% /

% .# ' B 7 6 "3 & , ,% ! 4

8 + 1 -6 & , ,% ' 4 B 38 &

48 + ) .# -6 $ ' ,% ' 3 4

G F 6M -6 ! ' $ 3 1 -6 &8

@+ = 4 /4& 4 4 O .# ,% $ & , ,%

3 3C A % + <#$ . +L / %

? 1 -6

<#6 & 4 1 @ !& $ ' ,% A

? K3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F

$%
 ! ( & '

3 8 & 9+ ! & 07 4@ F !& % 0 ( % ,%

+ @ 1 3 2 ,% ' 8 & 9+ % *,
? G F ) - <4 Z = 6M -6 @ G? #
8 = % 7 & ' $ ,% 9 # 9 /0 & L #
/+ ' 8 3 & , < &4 * = ) @ @ ,%
- @ A 2 / & , I &4 7 / ! - @
? - = * , 4@ 5 7 <#$ 3 #7 @
&4 ' 4 @ 5+ &+ & + 4@ 5 5 > 0
@O 5 % + = % C ' ,% 64
5 4 3 9+ - *' 4 % &" ! " <#$ .4O 3
5+ K6 2' ,% C 0 !" ' ,%
,. 4 Z C 9 , @O / 7
; - @ )- 9 , = 7 & #" 6 -
9+ 4 -" ! " .4O + <#$ - 54% , "
? 2 9+ !" 4 9+ 8
?< - = ' .# O' ! & ( $ 0 $
< "3 $ " !" # ' '% " O' #$ ! & ( %7 > 6"
? & , I &4 I < " 3 5+ I &4 @ 2@
$ | K? ) > | & |; 9 :1 . /
# '" @ I &4 & 5 & 5+ I &4 < ( I
D 1

? K3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F

$F
 ! ( & '

D ' ,@ -' 8 5+ I &4 ,% -' G

!& $ 4 % " 9 , B C I &4 <#$
?= 9 , 0 # % '( & " $ 4$ # 5+
+ @O 4 4 / 6 + 44 !& ,% 4 % "
?= C 4 5 $0 @
' 9 8 ' ,@ &8 $ 5+ ,@
3 1" 3 %% 3 I &4 0 1 4 @8 &4 = M
/ 6 !& , I &4 @8 &* 3< 6" /
!" / 6 - "8 &* 3 6J &= . =
G F
? = 1 4 % 6 )4 L = 4 1"
D ' I &4 / 8 5+ I &4 / G
/ M # 8M & , = I &4 ' 8 @ /
? '( I &4 5 4 @
3= !& 9+ 5+ M 4 .# / $
G F
? 8 4 ! 4% / $
8 A 6 - /+ @O # 35 , 8 "+ / 8
?9 , / 8
5+ I &4 = - & / 5+ 4 " G%
/' ! " .4O 3/ 6 % + % '( 4@
@O / !& ' ,% !" / 6 M #" " & ' &+
/4 ; 9 , / 4 ! @O / & , %' 6 - /+
?

? K3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 ?Y G F

XK3 # 3 1 - 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 1 "34' 4 YG F
5
 ! ( & '

0 5 - % /$+ : !" 4@ 4 !" / 9+

G F
?9 ,
$ 0 / #" 5 -6 A 1J + 7 4@ 5+ % &+ YG'
: C 5+ ) : 4@ 8 3 ' 5 ,%
' 3 ' &+ # 4@ 5M @" 4 4 +" % /
&+ 7 - ,4 4 9+ - + 54 = - 6
G F
? 54 4 &+ =6 8+ 9+ % > / 6
@ 4 , 5+ I &4 *, % 8%7 C <#$
? 2@
<# $ : 4 ' ! & / % 5+ I &4 )- - GX
: @ *2 @ ! & / % 5+ I &4 / 3 @ ) - K2 6
> 0 : #" 8 & 4 < 4 + @O / # 3 4
? &/ % *2 @
$ | K? ) K O | & |; " 9 :1 3
4 '" & , I &4 & 5 & $ 5+ I &4 < ( #$ I
D # V &
4@ & , = & %' # 5+ % G
3 87 % + 4 M $ <#$ 3 8'7
? @O 8 #= $ , : @ I &4
5+ ;% '( ,= I &4 5+ I &4 * % * G
G% F
?= & , I &4 @ I &4 * + 3= &

? K 3 \-? ?4 [ 3 4 '( 3 > M 3! :2 , # $ " 3 !7- ' YG F

? 'X K3 ## 3 ! - 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 # !" 1! K # ". !/ 34 6 4&Y G F
? ## K 3 # = ' * 3 % 4 Y G%F
5
 ! ( & '

=4 -6 * 4 - ( $ @ I &4 &/ % '' : "G%

>4 4@ 3 , 9 @ @ 64 6M -6 $
I &4 1 8 & @ 4 5+ ! & 4 &( 4 ! " 2 + 5+ I &4
?8 !" % 4 / )- C * I &4 5+ 4 4 '"
4 &( 9 @ ' 4 5+ I &4 * % Z' G'
#L 3 + #$ - @ I &4 3 5+ C
/4 / 3 ' 4 ' ,% / 5+ I &4 B4
G F
?K 6(
I &4 5+ I &4 = 7 4 % < ( #$ /A !&
? @; - % 4 * #$ " '(
F= 9 , 0 8 @ I &4 8 5+ I &4 E
?= M ' ,% + ; G=
@ $ &L $0 * ! ' " ) - 5+ I &4E
G F
?= !&

% '7 $ ) - 54 5+ / 6 )' @ 9 , 6
G% F
? @ I &4 , ) - $
? 5+ I &4 @ I &4 7 4 9 , I &4 * + E
= ' .# / &* = I &4 7 .# ,% E
I &4 4 / #3 @ I &4 5+ I &4 < 4
< 4 8 + @O 8 @ I &4 4 / 5+
? *2 @ > 0 : #" 8 & 4

? K3 # = ' * 3 # .)*" "% 2 3 6J 3) &4 YG F

? X' K 3 # = ' * 3P ' YG F
? #K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y G%F
5
 ! ( & '

I &4 N Z 4 8 =' / % ;6 / !&

5+ 4 * &( #$ A3 & , I &4 5+
1 8 6" ) ' 4& # ? ' ,% ! " @O
+ % '" % @ / 4 " 3= M ' /4& '(
?9 , 7 !" %
44 '" I &4 C * I &4 &" . % '" /A !&
& >@ I &4 %7 ) A " & , I &4 5+
,% + 8 ! " 4 '" # 3 @ I &4 54 4
'( & 3 @ ,% ' $ 7 /
70 64 $ @ L 6M -6 @ >4 3 24
G F
? @ ,%
^ H AM N p %> "3
% 1 !" 9 ;6 . 2+ ,% >@ !& >
? 5+ 9 , &5 4
K 6" 64 3 & , I &4 5+ I &4 ,@
? '( ,%
DK 6 #$ 5 4 % 1
% : & 4 3 H FH 5 W _ O # <5< /@ %
D 8@ - .# 5+ I &4 0 ,% K 6L =
9 , ,@ 4% *,6 L 3 5+ I &4 I &4 = #" 7
,% 9+ #3 ' ,@ 6" , 64

* 3. ' 4 =+ 4& D , ? %%K 3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F

?# 'K3 # = '

5#
 ! ( & '

3 4 - 5+ & & 9+ -% +2 7
C &" .# &4 #" M' 5 1" K 6 !& )
@;-" M' $ @ &K - 8 ???? 8 +
4 @???8 6L 8 ' ' ,@ 3 '" I &4 -
? G F
6 G /?"?= % F 54 ,% @ 6 #$ =
% : & 4 H H _ O < /@ % ,
I &4 5+ I &4 @ < @ .# 4 4 O .#
? & ,
/ ; 64 C * I &4 ??? F D % #$ , B
7 &B ) ' 7 # '( ,@ K 6" -
= % 2' <#$ 4 *, 54 - 5+ & 4 *,
8 4 4 !" ,( '( ,@ = - = - *' & ,
! & @ 5+ &L 9 + 9 , = M ' % 5+
G F
?G
V2 !" 4 ,@ 4 % #$ % '" ;6
D
I &4 3 C * I &4 3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 F B;1 5+ I &4 Y
%% +2 44 - 9+ ) 4 & G 54 4 & >@
4 % -' !& .# 9 , ,% 4 K 6( L % %
? @5 % =% (= %% +2 44

? K3 ' 3 =2 1 /'@ 3 1 + 3 3 % : 2 ,% 4 ( YG F
?% K 3 8'7 * YG F

5$
 ! ( & '

! & 07 @O L =- '( ,% K 6" >@ Y

& % 4 ( @ G % G %# F 4 ,%
>' @ L 8 ) - = =4 , 8 4 % '(
?= M ' /4& ! " ,( 3 4 ,% "8
& , 5+ I &4 54 4 & >@ I &4 1' Y%
! " >4 5+ I &4 I4 " 3 C #
5+ 14 " % 3= & 4 %' + 5+
4 ! & +2 4& ' 2 @ I &4 $ * #$ 3 %
,% + # 3 6M -6 #" @ ( #6L 8 @C
?= M ' /4& '( & ! 7 0 '
D | K? iH [V "(
D $ $ A $+ - K2 6 5+ I &4 4 7
2 a ? ] 01 / 8 EK y ? Y † ! Bx | K? . /
#" & 0 > # 5+ 5+ I &4 4 % K 6 4%
? A <+ .# = +2
8 <4 4 5+ = % 8+ +2 1 #L
8 + 4 &( 9 @ @ 8 % "
? 5+ I &4
5+ I &4 4 ' *-' = +2 % L # !&
<# 8 8 )- 3 % # 8 1" ! " 4 8%
G F
? '" U , 0 4$ - 5+ 1" I ' I &4

? #K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& D , ? '# K 3 # = ' * 3. 4 / 4& Y G F

55
 ! ( & '

8 .# +2 % $ 5+ I &4 L 8 &
5 6 <#$ 1" #" 3 I &4 4 5+ I &4 *
+2 Z $ 5+ I &4 * 4 5+ 7 = )
? $ *, !& 0
5+ 4 4 '" I &4 76 5 &8 &+ 4@ #" 8 + 4 ' *-'
4 &( #$ * 4 *-' 8L 44 4 &R , 9+ / #"
44 4 &R C / #" 3C * I &4 4 4
& <#$ >@ * - ' 8 L / / 4 4@ & # C
G F
? 54 4 & >@ I &4 = - &
, + 5+ ; I 6 = % % L 3 =
= +2 3 = 7 ( = +2 3 97 ( = +2 1 5+ I &4
43= % <# / + 1 " O$ )- B 3 .+ $
I &4 3; = % <#$ ) / 1
? 1" = - - 54% L
] ? ' + Bx Q/ 3
= % 8 & *% % 5+ I &4 , 4 % K 6
<# $ % #" # 3 ' = '( = 9 7 ( = 5+ 1 3 &
= % <# $ % 4 4 , = 7 ( = % 5+ 3 % = %
? 5 $0 @ 7 ( = % . 3 5+
. % 4 % F = ! & 54 4 % =7 ( = % =
G ;- = >
= ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ?# 'K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& YG F

? %K3 #
5
 ! ( & '

= #" 5+ $ = 5+ # 3 , 5+ I &4 = % <#$ !

G F
%
; @ 5+ I &4 ! % - 8 !" 5 ( 4
8L ; ;6 4 % #$ L # ! & ? 5+ 8 &4
? 5+ I &4 % 5+ ; @
K6 !& I 4@ 3 . 2 + ,% 8 & ,%
3 : )' C & 4, / 4 64 % / +
64 % 97 ( K6 !& 4 ,
4( 4& : 4, 5+ I &4 * % # 8+ / 4
G F
? K6
M # 8 M 5+ I &4 * 6 4 % !
?4 H %
+ 8 ' %' 1 % 8 5+ I &4 % !
* 5+ - 6 /1 4 +2 4 8 - 6 3 % ? & 5+
G% F
? 8 % 5+ I &4 !
+2 L #$ ! & 3 9 , 5+ I &4 !
39 #$ % 8+ ! B 9
G' F
? 5+ % 9 38 # 9 8+

' K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' YG F

? '% K 3 # = ' * 3< ' YG F
? XK 3 # = ' * 3 ) ! B &B ! 3 $ .4 !7- Y G%F
3 # = ' * 3. U 7 4 & . 4@ D , ? 'K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' Y G'F
? 'K
5<
 ! ( & '

D ‡' 01 L6 J GBx ^ K? " 3

% ' I &4 8 # '( * - 5+ I &4
9 , 0 ; 3 C 4 # 5+ 4 !&
?=
C + 8 '( I &4 8 @ " A
4 $ "39 , @O / M " 7 3= 9 ,
" '( ,% K 6" 64 2@ @+
4 5+ !& $ @( - A -' $ 3 6
? 9+ 4 -L , 4 Z C /4 Z ' 3 C
+ = ! " 4 '( 4 5+ I &4 8 & &4 + ; Y
G F
? 87 = 1 ' !& /
/4 & 1 I &4 0 ' ,% K 6" - #"
,@ ! " * 5+ I &4 L 3 '( & = M '
8 &! 6 @ " $ &L " 5+ I &4 $ &L '
? @
5& '# | K? lb | K? '6
C 814 , &C +2 > - 5+ I &4 * 4 %
$ '' "3 % - $ M-6 7 '' # 3) :
)- 3 !& @ 4 .# +2 %' $ 0 *,
C ' 5+ I &4 % - M-6 &C /+ ( #7
G F
?+ % ! & 54 4 &M / % ) :

3 1 1 - 3 4 '( 3 & - 43 # !" # # " 3 ' 4 4 YG F

? % K 3 ##%
? ' K 3 8'7 * YG F
5%
 ! ( & '

"
| K? ) 'g 4
- 8 4 .# +2 8 * .# 2 ( 1 $ 5+ I &4
5 $ 0 9, 5+ I &4 3 & , = 5 % %
& 0 > +2 >4 1 !& @
? %%
&4 !& 3 8'7 8% K6 , @" + /4& $ ' ' 4 ! & / %
? ,% ! " " $ 0 >;6
$ % - 3 B;1 5+ I &4 * &- $
? 5+ +; % @
*, 6 I 6 I &4 $ : 5+ I &4 8
?GEF $ 7 1 I &4 % +; -
4 ( @ , FH % % 6 #7 54 K !" 9
2@ 8 7 8 / , % K6 . + FD 4(
? % $ %
/4 " 2% 1 3 8 & &4 &4 7 /4 " 2% ,% 1
?G % 8- " #" #(
/4 " 2% ,% 1 F D !& % # 6 5 7 54 K
- K6 1 C 7 /4 " 2% 1 8 + 3 $
?G.
D $ I &4 % $ ) &- $ !& %7 =7
? = ! " I &4 * 4 '
? 7 ) I &4 *
? ,% $
5F
 ! ( & '

= ) 4 - I &4 * = 4 % $

4 &( #$ 4 7 4 3 2 ,@ Q 4 &" 4 3 @+

? I &4 * @ M $

V A 5+ I &4 % - - '7 $- <#$

- <# $ ! " ,( 8 3 I &4 <#$ - = )'

! & ( : # 3 8'7 4 - C 7 G $ 3 7 3 F

/ 4 &( @ . 5+ I &4 ' $ D O'

?S + 4 % *,6 #

?S 5+ I &4 0 & K 6( & B4 ) #

4 &( ) @ % 1 3 4 5+ #"

3 5+ I 6 I &4 / 0 ! & # &

- 6 B4 ! I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& @ ,

54 & % <# $ ! & > ) # 38 #= 5+

? 5+ I &4 &/ % .4 I4 L ,

D ' 4 - % <#$ ' #

GEF
D N I &4 @- ! & !: 4 ( @ 65$F F 54
?G # 8 ,% $ 7 +2 / ,% / I &4 * 4 . + F
 ! ( & '

D) [ (
A *4 I &4 ; 3 I &4 @- /$ -
%% 7 $ F !6 >4 I &4 -
I &4 &4 : # 3 G ,% 82 " 2 ,% - )
8 / ,% / I &4 * 8 = ; 3 < &4 5 5+
? #
?5 6 -
= ! " 4 ' I &4 #" # =% % $ % ! @
4 &( 4 @+ = - " C : 3 @+
?8 &
7 8 & .4 & 4@ I &4 * = #" # G F 2@
? ,% ! " ( .# , =% 8 &+ 8 &
4 ( @ , . 2+ 9 # 4@
$ # 3 I &4 * 4 " !& K 44 4(
,% / % #* = !" 4 ' I &4 C
* %' 9+ " 4 'R *2 @ 1" 4 % * I &4 # 1
I &4 3 8'7 = 4 4 %
4 % C : ,% / % 54 4 & >@ I &4
?8 )- $0 = !" 4 ' 8 @ 4 &( 4
?S 2@ > S @ 5+ I &4 !
 ! ( & '

@ 5+ &4 5+ 1 #" @ 5+ I &4

) - > 7 . .4 !& 5
G F
?G '( 3 0 3 3 4 F 1 % 5+ $
/ $G F - 5+ $0 ;
5 % I &4 ' .4& % ' - ,
? 5+
/4 " 4 1 @ ! 3 2@ -
? & 4 &( " 5+ , 9 @ 4& / % 3 *@ $
' 5+ , 9 @ 4& C * I &4 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 *
? 5+ ! & 4 &( ; / 4@ ! 3C 7 C
! & 4 &( " !& / % 2 @ I &4 54 4 & >@ I &4
D - 5+
4 $ 4 ! & / & C% / #" # 54 4 & Y
? I &4 * %
?C * I &4 44 #" 8 4@ & Y
+2 , !" & <#$ .4O % ) ' ! 6 Y%
8 3 &4 %& A 6J %& ! & & <#$ . Y'
G F
?C * I &4 * 8% #

X% K 3 # = ' * 3 P ' YG F
? XK3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
 ! ( & '

$) [ "(
3 8 % - 8 ,% / K6 0 $ 7
) &4 M 3 9+ 9 , &4 - @;& 4 7 C 7
??? ' M' F= ) & 2 8 8 !&4 =
?GW
.# ! & 7 .# 9 4 - )- I &4 * ) $
4 ( @ % 54 K %- % A " 7
? 4(
$ & , = ) #" I &4 * 7 ) &4
? I &4 / 6 + :
= #$ ! & .4 $ #" I &4 * 7 ) 8 & !&4
?= ) * 9+ @; 64 .# / 6 $
I C 3 5 6 $ 7 I 8%7
K6 $,% -' %' - $ # '
= ! % 3 8 !&4 = ) 54 & $ ,% / I &4
G F
? = ) 1 7 Z 3 @ = - .M 8 &
> 7 3 - &; 7 7 - 0 4 8 "
?
? S 5+ I &4 * 7 8 >
? 7 8 - - 5+ .
<#$ ! & .4 ! & < A -' 8'7 +2 @ 5+ I &4 *
' 8 " % " 4, + 3 & .4 5+
?
?#K3 # = ' * 3 'P bG F

#
 ! ( & '

.# $ / <4 % !& ! 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 *

4 * +2 F 6 % F 7 54 K %- # 5+ ) A"
8 ) : 5+ 8 " % " ! & 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 %
?G ' #$
) 8 &4 $4 ' 3 I &4 5 7 - #"
3 # !& 4 4 ' =2 1 / 4% 1 L 3= ) & 2 =
! 7 4 8+ &4 1L 1 5+ I &4 7 A
? 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 " % <4 "
- ' G. .4 F !& % 5+ / %
? 54 4 & >@ I &4 C * I &4
1 $ 4 5+ .# 3 .4 4 1L 24 5+ 1
4 ! & @ 4 5+ <#$ 3 4 @ 1( = -
?6 % 7 = ' % 5+ / @ 3 5+ .
4 5+ I &4 7 - & B4 7@ '" .# O' A
D $8 & ( !"
5+ - ! =- = $ 5+ I &4 * = $
? S 5+ <#$ + @ 4' 4 5 , 4% = 8 /
54 F9 , - 54 4 ( !" '' 4 O' # - "
% - 4 ! & 0 ; 6( /1 3 ' ! & G 5+
? B;1 5+ I &4 ' 5+ 54 @;& M 2 ,%

$
 ! ( & '

_ O 5HF / @ % 6 # 7 54 K !" 4 # )'

G F
? . % 8 @ , FF H H %

4 '8 4 < " A . %& +2 !& ) F

D -% @ 4 G : #$ 5+ <#$ @
? ` ^ =]b FW o& F# . /
, '" ) !& . % 8 , 5HF % 6 # 7 54

? 5+ <#$ @ 4 ' . %& +2

K 4 % .+ 4' 5 F 5 7 <#$ 5+ 54
?G # 7 ' 54
72 - ! " . 4" & 5 & $ 5+ 54
.+ 4' M +2 % '" ! & 4% 4 %
% G #F F 54 & - & *,6
G F
@" K 6 .4 2 5+ 54 /' 3 # > ' 5 HF

3 4 ' 4 *, +2 3 , 5+ 54
# $ ' 5 @+ $ 4' C 8 & B
/0 4% 5+ % &+ 7 4 & 2 ,% & 4'
/ @ .# 7 / ' !, % ' 5+ 54 4 4&" 7 9
5+ 54 4 4 &" 7 , FF H < H < _ O 5$ H F
G% F
? '

44 3 5 4 ' 54 3. % 8 , ## ^ ^ _ O X^# % YG F
? '#
3 2+ 3 $ 43 : /) # . # . # . #$" ,@K 3 54 & 07 4& b G F
? %% K 3 '
? 44 3 ## ^ ^ 6 O ' 54 0 b G%F

5
 ! ( & '

4' !& 8 5+ % I &4 5 +2 - $

? S < &4 % G 5+ 54 F .+
/ . % 8 @ 9 8 , 44 - 5+ 54 $!
I &4 @ 4 ( @ 4 % 8 &
? S 5+
D $ " !" % M' <#$ 44 . /'% "
9 :1
5+ 54 0' 5+ I &4 * 4 8 < ( #$ I
, 5HF % G # F 54 K ! & < ( #$ 4 '" % 8+
4' < ( #$ &" /1 ) : 4 3. % 8
" ,% ! " I &4 * ! & 4 @ 5+ 54 1 .+
G F
82 7 '" 4
- - $ .# 7 - 44 = 5+ 54 I $
/' % @ & 4 / 1 ' !& 4 I &4 @
.# H H _ O FFHF$ /@ .# 3 6 ,@ . %
/ @ /4& 8 3 ;7 -% 8 + 1 /4% / &4 B F8
) 8L 5^F /@ % G# F54 K %- 8 B 9+ 1!" #?8
3 5+ <#$ @ 4' 8 8 A . %& +2 !&
@ /4& 8 3 7 + &4 <#$ 8 B : #$
G F
? G /?"?= $5F F 54 / M ;&; I &4

? K3 # = ' * 3 & .4 G F
? 3 8'7 * YG F
 ! ( & '

" 9 :1
<4 * , 1" 5+ I &4 * 8 < #$ I
& , & 3 4" % 1 4 * # 5+ 54 0 '(
, ;7 5 1 -&" ; 8% % 4; ! ' .# . % -,
G F
? 4 @( 9
4 ( @ 6 # 7 54 K % ' 544 I &4 * -
4 5+ . 3 # 5+ = 44 - ," 4(
4 '4 !" Q " +2 4 % L 1 7
? 1( @
7 8 4 B 3 @ 44 8 .# < ( $ #$
5+ I &4 @ # , % 4 M #L 3 - $ & 5+ 1(
D % <#$ 1 3
% : & 4 <H H $ _ O ' ' /@ > #% % % /@ %
D8 1 .#
!& ) 8 !& 5HF % G% F 54 K 4@ " 9 "F
: #$ 5+ <#$ @ 4' 84 < " A . %& +2
. 8 " % # $ G# F 54 & 5+ 54 # 4 @
/ *, 6 5+ I &4 ' - 54 <#$ / 9
@ $4 G$ #F 4 4 % $4 G % <F 4
? A G 4 (

? Y K3 # = ' * 3 @ + 3 & .4 YG F

<
 ! ( & '

D O ) </ "(
,% $ 3 2 ( 4 $ & ,% $ 4
' 8A # 3 ,% / 8'7 ,% "5 / 6 ;
-% $ 4 3 & 5 1O ) 84 " 6 3 @ 544
# ( 8 "8 / 6 ! $ ) ( / %
? / / 6 4 "
? I &4 @ /4& ! " $ 4% .4O
2% ,% 1 gg 4( 4 ( @ G 5F 54 4%
- K6 1 C 7 /4 " 2% 1 8 + 3 $ /4 "
? hh .
D 1 $ A -% ! " 5 ( : 9 , #$ K 6
5 , !& !: 4 ( @ 6$5F7 54

44 % 6 #7 54 K 9 8 " 3 I &4 * $
- , $ / 4 3 # 7 ' 6$5F7 54 4 % -

S # 9 A & ' 3 ,% / I &4 @

#" & ' 4( 4 ( @ 6 57 54 K , 9

S I &4 C 9 4 $ $ /4& $4 %

@- . $ - $ 5 , !& K 8 7A" 9 !& )

3 8@ % &9 4 4 7 * $ /4& !" #4 " 3 I &4

?8 % 1 -' ,% ! " 8 =

/ / / 6 1 F D !& % # 6 7 54 6

? G C% > 2 '(

/ 0 3 $ 4 /4 * 4 5 1" 8'7 % ,% !& 8 !" ,(

? I &4 . # /

%
 ! ( & '

? ' g ` L6 (
D !& K 4( 4 ( @ 6 5 $ 7 54 !" 9
' ;6 * / #" $4 4 '" I &4 5+ I &4 % ??? F
?GC
D !& 4 % 6 % < 7 54
3 8 " $4 $4%7 ' ;6 ) - 8+ 4% #" % +2 + 8 F
G ?? #> " @ ' ' 4 76 5+ 4% #L
! & 4 &( @ ' 54 ;6 5+ I &4 * ) 8L 8 &
? & 4 &( " 1 & 4 5+
-6 C C 7 54 <#$ - I &4 <#$ * 6 #
G F
? *, # +2 , & ;, 3 / /' 6 B
@ /4 / ,% !& L ' 4 4 I &4 *
6 # L : 54 4 5+ M #" 3 : 54 4 5+ M /
G F
? = ' +2 ! % , *
5 , 1 G4 - F- #$ 44 #$ + :
1 & , - 3 , " I &4 * 4 / "
? 5 4 @ 5+ ! ' 1 5+ '" )
?9 , B I &4 @ /4& ! " 6 - #$ > 6 .4O B
+ 9, %'" ! & 8 07 9 8, + 4@ 4 -
? @8 % = '" 8 & #6 8 %& 3 1 %

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
? K 3 8'7 * YG F

F
 ! ( & '

| K= K ] ˆ ~ [ V1 o r (
ˆ ~ [ V1 . /
6" 5 2 4 *% 5+ I &4 K 6(
? 9+ 9 , %
% +2 4 % % I &4 5+ I &4 #
8 4 '( <+ 4 % * Z ' #" 3 8 & 6J &= .
?
4& % % 4( 4 ( @ 6$ 7 54 K % -
4 4 & ;, F D K B ! % K 6( 6
? $ ' 4 2 ,% / I &4 * % #$ %# 3 % 3%
( I &4 % % : % 4
*% / : % I &4 % %
?G : #7 6" 5 2 4 *% % 6" 5 2 4
&+ @( K 6( "?/?"?= 6 5 % 7 54 K % -
!" @( K 6( O FD % . % /'% 0
?G # >;6 ! & % K / 6" 5 2 4 % 4
+ ; / /0 @( K 6( #"
G F
? 5+ I &4 0 6" /4 '7 % ,%
45 &F # 7 ' 6 $ 7 54 K ! 5 %7 ! " 9 8 "
4 @( K 6( $9 C A #" & 2 ' G $ '
@( K 6( Z 6" 54 <#$ % 5 #
?/ /0 4 <#$

? %K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 YG F

<
 ! ( & '

K ] ~ [ V1 3
9+ 4 % 3 9+ 0 2 ,% ; & K 6( 4 %
2, @ 3/ 2 ,% 4 > 6 K 6( #$ 9
? & 6" 44 B 1 1 4 & 3 1 4
K 6( % 4( 4 ( @4 !" 9
B 3 2 ,% > 6 K 6( 9+ 4@ 9 4 &
D ! & 8 6 # 7 54
? / '@ / K 6( # 2 ,% $ F
& ( 4 ' ,% * 7
?G @" K6 5 ' O ,@ # .
? & K 6( ! & 8 6 #$ 7 54 K 44
; % &+ * 0 .# . % /'% / '@
54 1 5 %7 F /4 % 5+ 6 ,% 3 %
G? ?/?"?= X
D 4 65 7 54 6 # 7 54 %- 8 &
I &4 <#$ 7 24 ( / O 5+ I &4 0 K 6( E
? > 2 'R @/ M
. 2% 8 ,% / /0 & K 6(
? G ?/?"?= # 54 F I &4 &
, % / * 3 & , I &4 5+ I &4 =' & 4%
,% / 4 'L !& &4 Z ' .# & ,
3 ' ,% / 5+ I &4 * * #$ "3 & ,
!& % C '( * - I &4 <#$
? 5+
<
 ! ( & '

,( Y - 5+ I &4 0 ' ,% K 6" % #

3= M ' /4& '( - Y 6 - 4& %
8 3 $ 4M ,% !& # 3/ /0 % - $
" 6 )4 , 4 / 4 " # '
G F
?K 6( 4 % " 1( I &4 $ # >4 -
| K? ) F | K? @6 LBM d =K =K > •? b (
) ' '4 5 6 <#$ 5+ 2@ - " $ 4
I &4 5+ I &4 2% @; - & O' 4- ( #$ 3
S
S 5+ ) @ = - & /1
&4 ; * +2 8 / 1 /1 5+ !" M $

?S 4 J

I &4 4 & @ 54& @ /$M &4 * + /4& 54& % 9 %

4 4 <#$ Z ) #" 5+ =- 44 / 3 5+
D O' - # 3 % $ # M'
?S I &4 ! & # 1 $ 5+ I &4 * / #"
+2 = $ S 5+ I &4 ! & # 1 $ I &4 * / #"
> S 54& % <# ; 4% /1 S = 4 '( 8 +
S 8 & !&4 &4 !" 4 8 / S )' ,@ !" @-

? 'K3 # = ' * 34' 4 YG F

<
 ! ( & '

) F | K? | K? @6 )>,' ./
<# $ 3 +2 !& 4 B 5+ I &4 / %
3 5 A 5+
+2 <4 .# % 4' & % ' .4 *, ! & 5+ / % <#$
= % % !& @ 5+ / ! & 3 8% 1( ' '
G F
? 1 ! & & 7
!& 1J ) 8% 2 ,% )- = +2 9 6 4%
?8 8 '"
4 4 '" I &4 F , I &4 B;1 $ B;1 5+ I &4 % 7
?G 54 4 & >@ I &4 3 C * I &4
& %' # 5+ " 5+ I &4 &4 #$ = 7
.4 *, $ & , B M ; 3=
I &4 3 5+ % ! & &4 8 - ' .#
)' ) ' '5 6 <#$ B " 5+ M = 9 ,
?8 >4 .# = $ I &4 9 , 4 # 3
' % 8+ 1" " &4 &4 ' 5+ I &4 " Y
8 &4 1 /+ ' I &4 3) 6 -
- " )- 8 3 5+ 4 1" % 4 1" $ %
?8 & = ' 8 54%

X# K 3 # = ' * 3 4 &YG F

<#
 ! ( & '

4 &. *4 4 J +2 # Y
4 @ 3 %7 @ 2 & >6 5+ I &4 I4 L : > - C
1( 4 -@ 4 ' 4& # I &4 @& /'
G F
?=
8 .# +2 % $ 5+ I &4 #$ ! &
? I &4 4 5+ I &4 *
* + $ " * + /4& $ I &4
G F
? ( 4 @( 4 ;&/ - "4 #" K6 1 &4
1 '" G 5+ F &4 * + /4& 54& @ % #
3 4@ 5+ 4& @ & 54& @ 3 #$
$ 38 0 9+ 5 4& & 8 & !&4 &4 ,% 4
?S #6 1J $ S 54& % <#$ ,
| K? ) F | K? @6 LBM =K =K > Bp 3
/ 4 @ I &4 5+ I &4 / @ + /4& 54& % <# 4 %
D $ , # 3 7 6 54
3 2, % ) - 7 5+ &4 * + Y
?/ 7 ) 7 6 7 =%
I &4 F I &4 2 7 4 5+ I &4 * + Y
= I &4 +2 )' #" 5+ & : = G=

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 &YG F
? ## K 3 # 3 5 $% 3 7 43 !" 2 O! ," 3 )A .4 YG F

<$
 ! ( & '

G F
? I &4 +2 '6 #" 5+ %'
& 54 %' 5 7 # 5+ '" $ 54& % <#$ %
#" 3 C 5+ I &4 3 8& , M =
#" !" 0 4 4@ C 8+ +2 Z'
4 4 " I &4 8 38 A =
/ ! " .4O 4@ = ,% C #" # !& 3 = %%
=% * ! #$ 3 8 6 ! & 4 &" # 8+ 1 /A +2 !&
! "/ 6 54 &" 4 &( 4 1 5+ I &4 4 % C :
?= 9 + 5 1" @ % ' /$+
7 @ 5+ I &4 7 H %- ) ,% $
I &4 * + = I &4 4 % 38 #= I &4
G F
? % 7 !& 4 & I &4 . " I &4 -% 5+
% I &4 5+ I &4 * /4& 54& % % ' *
& % '" 4" 4 " 6 5# G5 FG5 <G5 74 !" . 2+
? ,% 8%7 #
? 1J &" ! & ) 3 + " 54& % <#$ ) 9 M 4%
D -% ' 4 8 ' #$
@& K= @6 LBM d =K =K > c K ) #u 3‰ 7 A 1 "3
3 I &4 / 6 ' 1N + ( = '@ $
? < 1 54& % <# ,% /+ = 1

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
3 # = ' * 3 3 - D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 ' > ' YG F
4 '( 3 & - 43 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- D , ?X K
? K3 %3
<5
 ! ( & '

@& K= @6 LBM d =K =K > [r

&4 + I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& @ "
! " .4O - 7A" 3 & & # 3 8 & !&4
? 1J )
K= A # =K U
5+ I &4 % FD 4( 4 ( @ 6 5 F 7 54 K
?G I &4 = - '
5+ I &4 &4 * + 8 K #$ K6
$* + /4& & 3 5+ < &4" -%' " = -
I &4 * 8 3 I &4 * 5+ I &4 * 6 &4
8+ 54% - 8 L = ) = - < 6L 8 5+
= - ' & 8 , + 4 = M - 1
' 8% - %' 3 5+ I &4 = - $ 9 8 8 .# '
G F
? < A 5+ 8 &"
5+ I &4 8% & , + +2 4 2 1 '" $
D $ I &4 = - 8& L
C " 3 I &4 * 4 5+ ! & 4 &( *@ #" E
? $4 @ 5+ I &4 & + 4@ +2
+2 U ' /4 % 3 I &4 8 & &4 +2 #" E
<# % 8 & 8+ C ( 5+ I &4 5
G F
? <+ .# % !& % : &4" 4 5+
#X K 3 # = ' * 3 )A .4 YG F
? #K 3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 D , ? %K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F

<
 ! ( & '

I &4 ' 8% - %' / &4 ' * 4 = - -

D $ '' - 5+
.M - 3 ; I &4 $ &4 I &4 G Y
+ = & & 7 = % &=
? 5+ I &4
I &4 0 1 8+ )' 4, 7 I &4 5+ ) -* 4 ;
3 5+ &4( 8% -%' = I &4 5+ I &4 5+
$ i % 4' A )' ) ' " 7
@ 1 &4 .# * 7 4 .# /
G F
?* % 8 % M 8 /
! & 07 @ " #6" 4 ' I &4 ,
G F
? 5+ I &4 ' 4 %
/ ! 3 I &4 , 8 6 &4 & ! 5+ I &4 %
8 & &4 !" = I &4 ;&" 4 3 4 , <#$ 4 %
? 5+ ' & + !
/ I &4 ! 5+ I &4 * &4 = -%'
/ 7 6 @ 4 @ # ' 6 A
G% F
? 7 6 / 54

# K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

? # K3 8'7 * YG F
? X# K 3 # = ' * 3 /;&4 =+ 4&4 Y G%F

<<
 ! ( & '

* &4 + I &4 - %' 6 !,@ #" 8

$ 1J +8 &) - %' 6 / 5+ I &4
? I &4 , & #
G F
? % 5+ I &4 L )- !,@ I &4 #"
&4 * / #" 8 3 I &4 * @ 5+ ! & .4 *% G Y
' & + & 3 I &4 ! " .4 /A 5+ I &4
1 I &4 * 4 .4 #" 38 6 5+ 5+
&4 M <#$ % #" 3 = ' C ( #6O 8L $ '
, 8 .M , 3 5+ ' & +
I &4 ! " <#$ 8 + # 3 I &4 / @ 1 4 &R
I &4 &4 * #" $ 3 ' 4 '" 4 8+ 5+
G F
? < &4 % I &4 8 = C
D $ &4 * &4 9 @ B;1 4
) F | K? LW & C3 | K? K= LW & s ) U
I &4 * 4 7 @ 5+ I &4 * &4 M <#$ 7
I &4 @ /4 ,% 3 5+ I &4 & + I &4 * 4 $
G% F
? 7 I &4 * @ 4@ /A 5+
I 6 / / 5+ I &4 0 / ' #$
? / 4@ * 7 3

? K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 YG F
G F YAlex weill , op . cit , p 341.
3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 D , 0 ? K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y G%F
K

<%
 ! ( & '

$ | K? LW & C3 ) F | K? K= LW & ) " ) U

* 3 5+ I &4 * !" 4 7 @ I &4 &4 * #"
@ /4 & ! " .4O #$ 3! I &4 7 4 5 6 <#$
? & &4 + ! 7 ) I &4 % 3 5+ I &4
I &4 #" 8 B % =- * )' #$
8 / L 3 5+ I &4 &4 * #4 G<4, &4 Z 'F
8 4 ; 8 C% / #" 3 5+ I &4 * &8 : # L
G F
? 5+ I &4 *
8 G- W =] b& | K? K= LW & )" " ) U
= ! & ''O 5+ I &4 * &4 M 5 <#$ =%
% &L ) ' $4 1" 4 ' 5+ I &4 * M3
3 $ 4 %& ) 3 4%& = - & 8 " 4 4 &( <+ .#
?G ' 5 4 5+ F )' /4 % ' 3
$ &4 3 < &4 4 '" 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * #"
? 7 ,% !& ) I &4 5+ I &4 * 4@
I &4 ,% 5+ I &4 @ /4 Z #" !&
? 6
*, 6 @ M' I &4 / 5+ I &4 #" I &4 >
5 3 I &4 / 6 > 4 ; 3 @ ,%
G F
)- T & 0 > ) - %% >

K3 # = ' * 3 ' >' Y G F

? #K 3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 YG F

<F
 ! ( & '

5+ >4 &4 #" - 6 /4& ) 8 $ 0 ; 4

3 5+ - -% =% !& #2 3 #
!& @/ % 1 .4 4 1" I ' &4 )-
+2 #" & 0 > # 5+ ,% !& $ 3 .
? A
#$ ! & ) 3 )' ' $ &L 5+ 4 ' +2 #"
G F
? 7 ) I &4 % 5+ I &4 - %'
& 4 FF H H $ _ O F <<5 /@ % !" 1 ' !& 0
D8 B 4 :
9 , 5, @ / 5+ &- ' 8 - % 18 F
:2 ' ) 'M 8 & 4 8 #$ @ / & / ' $ &L
!& ' 1;1 54 -% <#$ + 4@ &- ; #" 1
G F
? ?? G 8 4& )' ' $ &L 5+ 1J #
- I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& @ / " 7A" "
C % -" 8 6 # *4 = ) / 6
? 54& % <#$ 7A( 1 $ 8 4 /
5 &4 * / @ . 3 &4 @ 54& % = 6 / #L
I &4 % 5+ I &4 - %' # !& ) $ # ='
I &4 - %' * 4 = 8 & &4 M 7 !& )
Z = % $C : 2% 8 U !& ) 5+
? 4 ' ' , /

? K3 # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4& 4 YG F

? K3 ## 3 44 3 3 4 ' /'@ 3 0 % # 2 # " YG F
%
 ! ( & '

2 K K= A # =K Uk
G 5# F 54 / %- # &4 * /4 8 & !&4 , /+
? 4( 4 ( @
2 7 4 " ) - 5+ I &4 8 & !&4 + F
'" 4@ 4 " ) - 8 + ; $ '6 #L 5+ I &4
G <4, 5 4 / #7
I &4 * /4& 54& % 8 & &4 /+ " 1J I 54 <#$ ;6
D $ I &4 5+
8 sa ? ] 01 6 LW? d =K s [ U Uk
# $ = 54 ' 9 4 ' 5+ 8 & !&4 +
%% $ 8 M 5+ I &4 ;1 * 4 M 3 &4 , *4
? %
4 '( & 6N $ &4 /4 = !" 4 ' 8 +
8 7 = 1 ' !& ! + 5+ I &4 / 38 "
& 54 # 5+ 5+ I &4 4 @ % #$ 3
3G F
*4 M '7 5+ 8& 4 4 ' $ 8 & !&4 !& ) " =
4% 7 3 5+ ) &4 M 3 &4 5+ ,
? - -
$ BF+ ; ]# | K? ! G[ G > ) F | K? LW d =K ) " [ U Uk
7 @ &4 !& I &4 * 5+ I &4 8 & &4 +
G F
M 4 / #7 5+ I &4

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F

%
 ! ( & '

I &4 @ /4 / " 3 <# 7 / % / 4 0 8 &)

?=
#3 % L 3 # @ I &4 * 8 & &4 4 #L
4 5+ 5 % %' / @ - 4@ = 9 + 5 1L U '
/ ! 5+ ) : @ $ # 9 4 @ 3 #
? 9, % '" 5+ 4 I &4 % U ' /1 <+2 % 4
5+ I &4 $ 8 & & I &4 #" 8 & !&4 !& . ' / #$
+ B 3> 6 I &4 $ <4, & I &4 #"
&4 > - C 8 *@ #" 5+ I &4 * I &4 8 & &4
<#$ ) ' #" , / I &4 7 @! 3= I &4
? I &4 * !& % % ' I &4
#" " 5+ I &4 * *-' .# I &4 &4 >;6 #$
. &4 &4 # 3 I &4 * !& % '
I &4 8% ! & , + # 4 I &4 <#$ < 6L * .# $
; 3 &4 <4, I &4 * / .# 8 & !&4 >;6 5+
G F
? 5+ I &4 * 8% 8 & !&4 8 7 / 6 # +
/ !" #7 6M * G "?/?"?= 5# F 54 >,
? I &4 <4 % #7 4 44 -' 8 $ ,% 8
&4 > - " /4& &4 * /4& 54& @ = 6 Y
54 ' 8 & &4 9 4 @ /4 *4 ' $ !&4 L 8 &
?=

X K3 # = ' * 3 9 1! $ 3 54 / 4 & Y G%F

%
 ! ( & '

1B @ @ #" 3 9 4 <#$ @ /4 U !&

<#$ = 0 ;- ! " #$ .4O &4 , * *% L
I &4 . ' 8L E / /0 54& %
? '7 % 1"
@& K= @6 LBM =K =K > O
D !& K "?/?"?= G 5 7 54 !" 9
K 6 #$ 8 O .# = % L C 5+ #" F
G= +
D !& % # 6 5 < 7 54 K
G 7 5+ I &4 &U - + F
C 5+ 9 , 7 ,% !& * 8 #$ /7
I &4 5+ I &4 * /4& 54& % 4 % 8 & 5+ =
+2 5+ I &4 4& % 8,% * $ 3
G F
? 8% 1 & 0 > 8+
= ' #" 5+ I &4 @ /4 / *-' ,% !" ,(
,% 4% 1J V2 L 3 # / 6 )- % 7 !& I &4
D $ 0 54& % <#
54 ' ) ' ! & 5+ I &4 8 ,% *-' Ds )Š + ] Y
?= 9 ,
=% + B I &4 1( = % <#$ =
?6 K K 5 !" 7 = M ,% 8 M .#

* 3 4 D # ' , 0 ?# %K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F

? K3 # = '
%#
 ! ( & '

)4 8 + 3 & M 4 *' ;1 ,% +
G F
? 4 ' =% 6
3 9 , B 5+ I &4 8 & , ,% !& *
@ 1( ) 8 #= C 5+ 1" 4 & + B
2 % % 1( = - 1 5+ @ !&
?= 4 1L 5+ 1( $ @;& 3 4 @
= 1 ' ! & 5+ I &4 8 ,% +
? # 5+ 54 ' ) ' ! & 8 ) 3 87
= 9 , $4 '" ) ' ! & 5+ I &4 &4 82 ,@ 4 '" #L
G F
6 '" 8 + 9+ % &4 ! & ' 'M
+2 A #$ 8 !,@ = ' / ! " 4 '" 3 4'
G% F
? 5+ I &4 I &4
8 1 4 ' 8+ 1" ' +2 /4@ #" C * I &4 ;1
8 / ,% + 3 % %% +2 $ 8 !& # 4 %
4 5+ - =% 8 & = ) 8 1" 4 5+
?= !" 0
4 % 4 ' ! " 0 /4 , /+ ,% #$
2 '( ' !& 7 4 ' <#$ B 8 I &4 +2
% 5+ - /4& =% 8 , % .# 4%

? XY 'K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
G F- Alex weill ,op . cit , p 342 .
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y G%F

%$
 ! ( & '

' 8 6 & % #" . - !& > #

G F
? % ( 6 )4 , #
D M #$ 5 4 % 1
% : & 4 H <H _ O /@ %
D 8 1 .#
& 9+ C H > - 4 1" ! " >4 I &4 B ??? F
/ 5 ,% L /1 8+ C > - 5+ !"
. 4 % / 1" / / 8 6 4 ' K 7 =;-( ! & +
G F
? G ??? 9 + > -
9 , 5+ I &4 = - ,% *-' D) " )+] U
D=
< 4 .# / = I &4 5+ I &4 * ,% +
? )' 5+ ; / #$
? 87 = 1 ' ! & 5+ 8 4 ' ) 8 &
, % M 3 ! & 7@ 5+ &4 +2 A
I &4 / 4 ! " 5+ I &4 7 >@
@( ,% !& ) 3 6J K6 5+ 7 #$ K6
* ,% !& ) 3 0 4 ;% '" 5+ !& 8

3 % 7 / & 3 4 3 !" P 8 01 .) : " 3) 4&C YG F

? XK3 # = ' * 3 4 D , ? XK33 '3 ' - 3 5 $%
D , # ' 0 %%# K 3 # = ' * 3 3 % : 2 ,% 4 ( YG F
%' K 3 8'7 * 3 % : & 4 ^ ^ _ O ' /@ % Y
K3* 7 3 % : & 4 ^ ^ _ O # /@ % Y ,
? ##

%5
 ! ( & '

I &4 * !" @O 5+ I &4 * > -

G F
?
1 " 5+ I &4 * M 54& % <#$ 7AL , % / @ #"
) 8L 3 8 = - 8 3 1( 3 =%
# / /0 = ;- $ 8 4 / ;- - # !&
? '7 % 8 / C% - > 2 '( !& )
| K? ! D]# Z )BFˆ / | K? ! ? [ CF ) ‡+ |= '6
$) F
! " '' * I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& @ &" "
I &4 ! " 8% & ' .# / 6 + ,% 4
? 5+
/ &4 * /4& 54& % /+ " 5+ 8% +2 ' L
/ 5+ I &4 4 / I4 3 $ = = -
?S I &4 0
4 % = M % I &4 I &4 0 .# ,%
/ 5+ 9 , 4 / ; 3 5+ I &4 4 /
G F ?
&4 - >; 6 0 9 , 0
I &4 ,% ! " ( * 5+ I &4 4 / 4 #
? I &4 ' 8 ,% 5 @+ 8 3=

? K3 # = ' * 3 .4 . + 54 YG F
? 'K 3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

%
 ! ( & '

I &4 ' 1 5+ I &4 4 / !& ) 4@ 1 '" 8 "

D
8 % 5+ I &4 7 ,% / !& / 6 #" Š3
+ 8 8 5+ 1 8 / #$ L +2 $ &4
/ =% '( I &4 8 6* #L 3 I &4 G 8 & !&4 F 9 4
"G F / 6 !" 1 4 ' #" +2 /+ ; 8
G F
? I &4 * @
A = 9 , I &4 5+ ,@ #" " 3
- U 7 = - $ / 38 - 4/ '" $ 0 K6
G F
2 Z 8 ,% 5 @+ K ; / #$
8@ - # 44 5+ I &4 8 Q 4 .# / -( 4
- # 3 $ A & $+ 2 6 I &4 <#$ -B
? ,% / % $ )
* + /4& 54& @ 1 5+ 4& @ 54& @ /$ ,
# 6 ! & 1N , 5+ I &4 I &4
4 & @ / 7 B K 6 !" / #$ =- '
I 6 & 54 >; 6( I4 ! & 5+ I &4 I &4 -
? 4 / - 6 & , B '

? Y K3 # = ' * 3 .4 . + 54 YG F
? X K3 # = ' * 3 ) ! B &B ! 3 $ .4 !7- YG F

%<
 ! ( & '

"
| K?
, 8 ;6 =% .# - ) ' $ % 5+ 4 "
% + % '( 4 M $ <#$ " 3 4 =%
? ,% = - &
5+ 4 ( @ . 2+ 4 % / $" 4%
D $ &" ! " #* 4
= - & % !& @ 5+ 1
3* ' / !& 0 1 1 3 5+
? %% @ A" 5+ ! & .4 + ;
? 8 97 R ; @ % ,7 8 " * .# +2 4 8
? 8+ ! & 4 &" +2 @5 % ' 5+ I &4
8 & 6 &= % +2 I &4 $ 5+ I &4
5+ ! " >4 # 3 $ 7 8+ -
B 4 *, A +2 #" & 0 > #
?8 & 8' ' &B 4 $
D I &4 B;1 5+ . 2+ 9 *, 4%
? ! ! )*K 9 1! $ '6 5 & 5+ 8 &+ " .# +2 D!
? = .) : " 9 1! $ 4 &( 44 8+ , .# +2 D 1
4 & 4 &R C 8+ .# +2 D 1 1
? !! & "1% - 9 1! $ / /
<+ .# = ) 8 1 I &4 <#$ .# +2 )-

%%
 ! ( & '

?= # 8+ 1L 7 "
1 #$ A 5+ 1 1 <#$ #"
+2 )' / " # 5+ )' > 6 5+
? < A )' + 8'7 + " ,
4 3 5+ I &4 I &4 %% !& B #$ > ' #
$ ) - 3 / 6 44 7
?8 4 / - !" ,% / @

( Action en réintégrande ) D ? ?u0a | K?

0 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 / 5+ 4 . 2+ 9 4
8 + 3 & ( /' / !& 07 7 $ 4 $
? 5+ I &4 $ A &
G% < 4 F 4 % 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 / . 2+ % = 4%
? G5 5G5 $ F 4 4( 4 ( @ G % F

I &4 <#$ M ,% 8%7 8 " * % K <#$ ! " 9

6 & , # % ' ' 3 I &4 <#$ $ ! & > '
/ !" ,( 3 ,% / I &4 <#$ @ $ ) -
?8 4

%F
 ! ( & '

$) ' J 6 ? ?u0a | K? %& '# (

? ?u0a | K? %& '# . /
D % . 2+ 4 % G% <F 54 K ;6
. %& &= % +2 I &4 $ Š ? ?uŠ0a | ŠK?
8 ' & + L / @ .# : 4, 3 5+ <#$ 4 - 8+ 4% .#
G F
?) : 5 %
4 % .# % +2 7 I &4 $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 $
: > - ' 8+ 8 54 &" , % )- 4 8+
?5 %
G F
? ' 5+ 9 '( 5 % I &4
# ' /0 / $ I &4 <#$ ' 4 #
38 & ! '" 4 @ 5+ ) : !& ) 8 &L
/ ' 7M / @ % , @" 4 H + 8 #" % %% $ !
G% F
? ,% ! " 4
. - I &4 <#$ @ - ' ! & ,% 8%7 54 & 4@
?) : 5 % C $ 5+ C -6 4 8 &
C * I &4 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 . $ = $
4 5+ &4 #$ 3I 6 54 4 & >@ I &4

D , ? %K3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G F

? ' K3 # = ' * 3 3 - Y
G F Y Jean-louis bergel ,et eutres, op.cit , p 436 ?
D , ?' K 3 # = ' * 3 ) 4&C Y G%F
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y

F
 ! ( & '

C 4 &( * 4 4 @ ! & ' 54 / 4 4 %'

G F
?5 %' 5+ !&
8+ /4 / , & +2 +2 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
4@ 5+ <#$ 4 # @ 4 / " 8+ ' / 3 '
? 76 $4% 4@ 5 &8 &+ "
" 5+ I &4 . $ = 7 #$ /A
8 - I &4 ,% > & B4 4 #$ # 5+
SC * I &4 / 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 $ $ 5+ ! " >4
I &4 > 4& / 6 8 *% .# M-6 $ O' #$ 1 U - .#
4 4 '" I &4 $ $ F & Z, 4 5+ I &4 &4 * B4 4%
?GC * I &4 / 5+
8 @4 A 5+ I &4 > 6 + M' !" ,(
? 2 <4 % ,%
64 C * I &4 ' 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 M I &4 >
G F
?! I &4 - ! K 6"
C * I &4 M 5+ I &4 > ,% C 4 & 8 54& %
- 4 % %% 5 54 4 & >@ 5+ 4 4 '"
> 54 % A9 , 3 - : 07 4%
7 %% 7 I &4 -&" &) < &4 ! & &4 8: ' .#

?# #K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

F
 ! ( & '

G F
? 6" #$ Z %
- #" 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 I &4 + #
I &4 &/ @ 0 '" 3C * I &4 , & ) -
3 8 /+ $ ,% - > 3 *2 @ ;6 5+ 4 4 '"
C * 5+ 4 4 '" ) - < &4 * &4 +
? 8A ' !&
> - 4 % - 5 $ - ,% !& ) $
G F
? C / 4 " & 4@ 9+
,% 4 & B4 , 3 + 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 & B 4 "
I &4 - %' C 7 38 , I &4 >
5+ 4 4 '" I &4 % - & B4 !" 4
? % 4 1
$ ? ?u0a | K= ) )' 3
& >@ I &4 C * I &4 &" ! & ,% 8%7 9 " /A
B 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ' # "3 & I &4 54 4
/ I &4 $ $! 3 % - % 4
?S I &4
' 6 I &4 $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ' ,% 8%7 ) A I
G% F
! & 4 &( * / !& 0 $ >4 & I &4

? % K3 # = ' * 3 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& Y G F

3 K 6 44& 3 3 4 ' /'@ 3 ! 2 ,% 36 1! 7 E = 4 Q YG F
? K3
G%F Y Colin et capitant , op.cit , p 217 .

F
 ! ( & '

I &4 I &4 ! " ) @ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 L # ! & 5+

5 % 5+ 9+ " $ 9 A & !& + , O'
G F
? #4 5+ , & I &4
U 3 - 6 I &4 & 5 & $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 . 8%7
I &4 3 5+ 9+ " $ 9 A + , I &4
# 5+ , I &4 3 O' I &4
G F
? 5+ I &4 I &4
D8 B O' I &4
)' 8'7 ) ' + .# , +2 @ ! + Y
+2 > - * # 3 % !& 4 5 -' 8 3< A
9 7 ( 4 . 4" K 6 !& Z ' & & !& 8+ / % .#
? 4 8 & 5 -' %
%' / ! . 3 ' 54 8 + /4 / +2 + Y
? $ & " /A % '"
44 '" I &4 # 39 A;& <#$ 5 % &+ " "
5 -' 4 &) 5+ 9+ '" 5 % !& + 5+
? @ 8
D8 B G F 5+ I &4
. 3 ' 4 4@ #" " 4 L 5 % : 5+ &+ " #"Y
? # 5+ / 7 #$ 5 % ' 5+

? % K3 # = ' * 3 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& Y G F

# # !" # " 34 6 4& , ?# XK3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F
? #K3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2

F#
 ! ( & '

.# K6 4 L ' /4 / 5 % : 5+ &+ " #" Y

,7 $ 3 &4 5+ ,7 = 5+ 8 &+ "
? ,7 = 5+ 2@ +
5+ ) : ) : % 5+ 8 " % " 4, , + Y%
- % I &4 1 3 ' 6 #$
/A 44 #$ 3 8 4 '( <+ 4 . % * =
"3 5 % 5+ ) A !& + 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
.4 4, * & I &4 & 5 & $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 Z
8 " % " 4, 3 ,% ! " 4 <4 8% #6M 4 5+ !&
8+ +2 & I &4 3 ' 5+ <#$
. % * +2 Z' %& = % ! & ) %& I &4 $ 3
? 8 4 '( <+ 4
$ ? ?u0a | K? ! [r "(
? 8 & !&4 &4 /$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 K 6 / 6 4 %
? ?u0a | K? ! K= . /
D !& K 4 % 6 % < 7 54 / !" 9
?????? 8 " $4 $4%7 ' ;6 ) - 8+ 4% #" % +2 + F
G?< A & +2 5+ 4 ' , +
4( 4 ( @ 6 5 5 7 54 / !" , 9
. %& &= % 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * + F D !& K
5+ < ( .4 @ 8 < ( .4 5+ 8 A
?G a4 4 *, 4

F$
 ! ( & '

) : % +2 $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 &4 4 $

? 8+ 4 4 '" ) -
/ 1 3) : & +2 & " 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
? 4 5+ G &4 F M $ @
" % <4 I &4 <#$ &4 1 4 !
G F
? 8 %
= - = - 4 @ @ 4 7 5+ $5
? %%
G ' F % U 7 +2 5+ + 5+ 4 7 #$ ! &
? 4 5+ !& -@ ; 4 '
G F
? ) : B 4 @ 2@ ( #$ !
@ 8 &+ " 4@ 5+ &4 1 !
35 ' 35 $ 0 & 5+ . ) 6 5+ $ % +2
G% F
? 24 $
9 ; / /0 !& 0 $ I &4 C : #
+2 3 # 07 " < ( > 5 % 8+ !& +2
8 + /4 / +2 38 V " < 4 76 % 8& 7 "
?G % < @ 1 '" 4 * F ' @ 9 -% " 4 '
!& 4 5+ 8 M b8 =' &4 1 #L

3 3 7 9 ( 3 2 +? 2 # .)*" 1 " # 4 " Q 8 3 54 / 4& Y G F

? %X% K 3 3! -
= ' * 3 4 &4 4 D , 0 ? % K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F
? ' K3 #
? ' K3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- Y G%F

F5
 ! ( & '

3 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 +)?8 1 4@ Y .4 @ %

? 4 @ 5+ 4 54 2 @ 1( 2' #
, $ Y ' ! " I4 .# 8+ ! & *@ 4 , &4 1L
I &4 * +) 8" 1 4@ Y 1( 2' 1" + 4 @
? 5+ 4 4 '"
&4 , 8 $ $ A -% ! " 5 ( :
. G $ A & I &4 <#$ + #$ F @; +2 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
< A )' + .# , +2 + 3 8'7 ) ' +2
G F
? 8 ' 5+ 4 4 'L ) - I &4 <#$ &4
% G % <F 54 K ) , +2 9 6 $
& +2 5+ 4 ' , + ??? F 1 % 4
? 97 ( = ) 3 5+ $ ' M' 1 G ??? < A
% 5+ <#$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 - $
? 7 5+ % 7 3
) +2 3Z ' & & !& 8+ @ .# +2 +
4 4 '" I &4 &4 4 ; 64 % 9 7 ( . 4" K 6
' I &4 <#$ * 8 +2 I4 ' - 3 5+
G F
?
+2 % <4 7 +2 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 &4 , . '
? 6J * . 9 !&

3 # = ' * 3 4 &4 4 D , ? % K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F

? '# K
= ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& D , 0 ? X K3 # = ' * 3 4 &4 4 YG F
?# K3 #
F
 ! ( & '

$ ? ?u0a | K? ! 2 K cK= 3
5 % +2 5+ 9+ " .# K6 $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 8 & !&4
? 76 &) :
4 & / % K6 $ 4 4 '( I &4 8 & &4 #$ !
97 ( 8 &4 5+ ) ' ! " .4O B ) : &
?
+2 3 ' #$ ) " .# 8 & &4 -
4 8 4 &( % ' 4% . '
G F
? 8'7 8% 9+ " ,% ! "
& 6 7 6 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 8 & !&4 + 8
) : % 5+ % " #" # 3 5+ 9+ " .# K6
6 76 B & 76 : #$ ' : !" ) : K6
I &4 8 & &4 4@ 5+ 8 " % " .# > 6 #$ 3 .
/ . ' ! <4, &4 *-' # 3 4 4 '(
? G 87 ' 5+ ) / F 5+ ) A" 4@ 87 '
D % 4 % G% FF 54 8 & #$
5+ 8 " % " ! & 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 % 4 * +2 F
?G ' 6 #$ 8 ) :
- #" 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * &4 + 8 !" 5 ( :
! &) B 4% #$ = - 64 5+ 9+ " 4% 8 & &4 *
# 7 8 +L G 4 % I &4 F 8 & &4 4, I &4 * <#$ &4
G F
? 4% -
? %K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F
? % K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F

F<
 ! ( & '

$ ? ?u0a | K? > g ` "(

C : # 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 % $ : - 9 >76
! " 4= % K @" 4 ! & ,@ 3 / /0
? ,%
G5 $ 7 4 / # 4 % 6 % FG% < 7 4 / !" 9
$ ) - 4( 4 ( @ GX X

D ,% / 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 %
$ ' AH + K= F& / . /
4 5+ % +2 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 &4 )
? 8 8 " % <4 M
8 4 # 3 4 &( @ I &4 * 1 5+
G F
? I &4 <#$ * % - 4 5+ 7
# 3 , & +2 / 8'7 ) ' + %% +2 $ +2 . '
! " 0 49 A 4 &( 4 ! & ' ' / % 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
? 4 *, 7
$5 3 5+ 4 4 '" * G 7 F 4 5+ 4 7 #
?G F
%% = - = - 4@ @> 4 7 5+
0 sa ^?m& c K N = Ka ( > 3
.# % +2 + B 4 % G% <7 54 - #$ ! &
? 8 " $4 ) - 8+ 4%

3. 4 4 +& D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 !" 5 / & " 3 - YG F

? K3 # = ' * 3+ &4
? #K 3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- GG F

F%
 ! ( & '

97 ( 8 +2 &+ " ' $ $ 5+ 4% !

? 76 & : / % ) : 5 % & = - &
1 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * M 4 & +2 !& ) 8 4 $
? 97 ( 8 # !& V 3 ' 4% 4@ % 8+
5 $ 05 5 % = - & 4% 54 4& 5+ ) ' #6
G F
? G 76 = - & F 5 $ 0 A5
= ; 3 @ 5+ * ! " .4O 5+ )' ' 5 % 4
G F
? 4 5 %
+2 = !& 4 #L ' I &4 <#$ % -
GEF
) : & = - & # 3 @ ' 4@ 5+ 7 3< A
94 6 4 P : ) ' "= - '" = - & =%
+2 54 " A @ 5+ ) ' ! " .4O 3 $ A
# 7 = - & M # 39 = - & 5+ )' 4@
38 - +2 / 5+ ,@ 4 % #7 1 3 2 ,%
/ 1 8 4 % - L 8 +2 / 6" A
/ A 8 ' 4@ 5+ &L # 8 A / 4 ! 3
G%F #7 #$ % *-' 8 84 "
* Z ' .# 8 & !&4 ) : 8 / % .# -

? K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 YG F
? % Y %X K 3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F
= - & 5 % 5+ 9+ " " 3 +2 54 " 4 5+ 9+ " !" 4O ) : 5 % GEF
? '6 4 = - & ) : .4 < ( >
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- Y G%F

FF
 ! ( & '

D - 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
5+ 8 C .# # 4 % D 4& Y
? 4 5 % = - & ' +2 @ + !& 4 &"
7 24 #- 2 4 4 &( #$ 4@ #
G F
? 4 9 A
;6( 8 M 3 +2 5+ ! & *% " #$ )
4 # $ !& + 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ! " /
G F
? 8+ +2
3> 5 % !& - /+ +2 5+ ! & *% ";&8
A % ! & .4 ; '" = - & )A B4 .# #$ "
! " .4O 46 P: = - & #$ # 3 @
G% F
?8 4 8 ' !& +2 54 " 4 5+ )'
%& 4 &( *@ #" +2 5+ $ .# % ! & 4 &( *% Y
* I &4 * 7 " 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * 7 8 L .4
? 54 4 & I &4 C
, 5+ 4% ! " G 5+ ! & 4 &( F #$ .4O Y%
%& 8 #$ >% 4 8+ 54 '" +2 *-' B +2 > -
G' F
? # 4

G1F Y Jean-louis bergel ,et eutres, op . cit , p 436 .

?# K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& YG F
? % K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G%F
= ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- D , ? % K 8'7 * Y G'F
? '% K 3 #
 ! ( & '

$ )]0 EK G # . = B b# / " 3
) 8 4 4( 4 ( @ 6 5 $ 7 54 / !" 9
* ! 38 ' @ 9 -% " 4 ' &4 5+ '
) ,% 5+ I &4 54& % %- # 5+ 4 4 '" I &4
F 5+ I &4 5 +2 9 -% " 4 ' 54 5+ '"
? G 5 %' 5+
/ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * +2 Z ' 54& % <#$ & Q 6 4@ 9 "
# 3 4 " /4 / ! 3 ' @ ' 8+ ! & !, 4@
D $
s )
* 8 ,% 8 L 3 > 5 % = - & 8+ 4% 4@ +2 #"
% - 8& + " @ ' 54 % + 4@ / .4 8+ 4 4 'L
? 4 % 6% %F 54 /
= ' / 4 ! 5+ )' > 5 % '" L #
G F
) : )' B 4
) ")
- 6 % % ! " 7 .4 5+ ,7 = &4 5+ #"
? +2 $4 ' 5+ !& '
/ " 3 8+ !& ' @8 ' &4 5+ C 7 <#$
? ,7 = 5+ !" 4 ' 8 & &4 3> 5 % 8 )'
1 9 - '" #L 3 &4 = & !& ,7 = 5+ 1" )& *%

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
 ! ( & '

* - ' / #" 8 " 5+ 4 ,@ ,7 = 5+ ' 8 & !&4 5+

$4 4 '" 4 L 3 &4 5+ 4 !,% 8 & !&4 4 5+ 0 #
G F
? I &4 " 8
D &4 ' ,7 = 5+
8 4 / !, % % +2 M @ 4' !& 2@ #" Y
?8 - .4 4%& !, %
4 ' M 3 8+ ' .4 +2 $#6 4' 4 #" Y
* 4%& ! " , 8 & !&4 4 ' 3 K6 8 4 * 4%& ! " +2
G F
? 6J K6 8 4
?W =' 5+ $ ,7 = 5+ 4' 4 4 /
$ 0 ‹& # E )]0 ,V | K= LW # / '6
#" 3 5+ )' W ' ;6 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * +2 !& )
<# $ & +2 ;& ) : 5 % *@ 4@ ) ' #$
? 8 5+ )' @
3 9+ ( 9 @ @ +2 / 4 76 ' 6 *@ 4@ 5+ 4% #"
+2 > " @ I ' ;6 I &4 * +2 !& ) ' 54 L
G%F
? 8 76 / .# 5+ 9+ (
? 4 % 6 % % 7 54 K %- #
G ' 54 F 544 % N I &4 * 1" )& &4 ! & *%

? XK3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F

K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- , ? %% K 3 3 + & 4 3. 4 4 +& Y G F

G%F Y Colin et capitant , op.cit , p 249

? K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & D , Y
 ! ( & '

G F
? 2 % 1( = - #
3 % ' 5+ 9+ % ' 54 I &4 <#$ * &4 /% / #L
Z F ' '" 5+ I &4 * 8+ ! +2 # Z
G F
?G % 5 4 5+
;6 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * / #L 3 /4 % 54 - %' 54 $ $ ' 54
? #4 + /
@ % 4 4 3 % /4 !,% #"
54 ' 54 &" ! & ) 3 = ,% " ! " .4O I &4 *
@ '3 $ A !& ! . ' /4 % 54 ' - %'
G%F
9 -% ( >@ 54 &. ' , # !& ) 2A 8 &
4 & , , % / 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 @- & B4 "
- $ S I &4 <#$ 0 '( ,% K 6" I4 & O'
?S # -
! & % + % '( 4@ / 6 A "
' ,% ! " M 4 1 - 4 & ' &+ /'
@O / & , %' 6 - /+ 8 " @O " / !&
% /$+ : / 9 + /4 ; 39 , 4 !
G' F
?9 , 0 5 -

? K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 .4 . + 54 YG F
3. . 4@ U 7 4 & D , 0 ? %X K # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G%F
' K3 # = ' *
? K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' Y G'F

#
 ! ( & '

I &4 0 ' ,@ K 6" ! & ,@ % . % '" #

M ' /4& '( $ - $ # " 5+ 4 4 '"
3G F
$ 4M ,% : / /0 % - $ # =
& , - !" ,( 3 I &4 0 K 6( @
? # % '
D N - #" '( ,% K 6( 4% #
‡' 01 g ` . /
- 5+ 44 '" I &4 0 ' ,% K 6( -
4 & 3 @ &! 6 I &4 M $ '(
8 L 3 5+ 9+ " !& ' 1 4 I &4 M - #$ > 6
G F
? I &4 0 @ /4 ,% ,% !&
8 "38 1 *, / '( 4 % . 2+ 9 > /
8 ; 4@ @4 , , -6 4 =% '( M %
? -6 #$ * 4 ' L 64 / / #" 8 ; "
,% ) = - 8 + ' .# @ 6 $ '( %
G% F
? & , ,% /
$ 8 G-Œ6 • b =K 3
% )' $8 ' ' ,% !& * .# = M 4 %
? 6 < - + " = % =% 8 .#
& , 1 , % 5+ 4 4 '" 5 &4 7 '( ,% #L

? 'K 3 \-? ?4 [ 3 2 + 3 & - 43 1 + 3 & .)*" 2 3 $ 4 YG F

? K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& Y G%F

$
 ! ( & '

/4 / ,% ! & 8 L 8 & 9+ = !" 8 = -

?K 6(
4 ' = B 4= $0 / ) '( ,%
?= M 6
/ 3 & , ,% / 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 '8 0 ;
9 , F= M ' /4& , ,% !& 8L '( ,%
?G
$ 2 ‡+ ? ?u0a | K? ! CF L6 (
$ ? ?u0a | K? ! CF ./
3 @ ! &) I &4 <#$ # 7 ' - #"
.# = 4 .4 /+L # 8 - &4 " 1 M 4
4 !& ) 8 !" 5 ( : # @ 3 +2 8 '
#" Z, 3 $ /4& I &4 - K6' *2 @
) ' @ % ! & 4 *, . 3 7 4 5+ 8 4@ &4
3 5+ 4% 4@ &4 M Z, 3 # !& 4 3 5+
/ L 3 5+ )' ' ;6 I &4 /13 ' 7
G F
? -( ) ' % 38 #
# 3 >; 6L 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ,% 4 / > 6
D 44 #$ + :

% K3 # = ' * 3 !" 5 / & " 3 - YG F

5
 ! ( & '

)]0 EK G # . = l ? K= + s ) hU
4 5+ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * C 7 <#$
? G "?/?"?= X X X 'F 4 K %- & 4 &( W @ ' 54
4 8+ C * I &4 * 8 L <#$ &4 L #
/ 8 + ! & 4 &( ( 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 ! " M " ' & % 54
#L 3 ) : 5 % = - &8 & + " ! " I4 C 4 !& %
&L 8 "8 + 4 8 ,@ - ' I &4 <#$ * /@
&4 5+ ! " 9+ % 54 &" ! & ) 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 9 ,
G F
? $4 .4 / + L +2 @ 5+ 4 5 -' # 4
: 8 B4 4@ 8 & !&4 #" 8 !" % 54 &" / , 4@
? /4
)' , 8 ' & &4 C 8 & !&4 !& / ,%
G F
? % O' / %- 8+ ! & .4
8 44 : 8 & !&4 !& / , <#$ ,% *-'
G% F
? 8 8 & !,@ #7 !&
* -% / M 5 ' 2 4 5+ L &4 5+ 4 4& 8 0 ;
5 4 3 ' 1 '" 4@ # 38 & + " 54
? I 6 5 4 &R , #" 5+ I &4 * %

? ' K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F

?# K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' YG F
# K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & Y G%F
 ! ( & '

$ 6 lKA a ) R )]0 B b# • K= + ) ") U

I &4 * = &4 8L 3 5 % &4 &+ " 4@ 5+ -
?G ' /4 / F % '" 5 % ' A 8+ /A 5+ 4 4 '"
: 38 !" % 54 &L &4 5+ 4 ,% ,% <#$
C # 8 ,% 3! &4 M 8M 44
? 5 % 8 5+ 9+ " )' , 8 &
/' 4 @O &4 !" 4 5+ 4 !& % 5+ 4 /
&4 5+ 4 4 8 & &4 + 3 % 5+ = 8 9+
&4 1L / @ 3 544 54 9-' " 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 8 & *
G F ? 5+ 8 9+ " = ' 4@
=] b& • 2 K cK= EF 6 2] (A ]# • ) R )]0 K= + =# • )" " ) U%
$ G p 6 8+/ + sa
/4 / 8 + 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * <#$ &4 + 8
I &4 <#$ * = 8- #* % 35 % 8 9+ / '
6 % % F 54 / , 4% ,7 = 5+ !" 4 ' 8 & &4
+ ,7 4& @
5+ @ 4' !& / % 8+ 1L 8 & !&4 /% / #"
W =' $ 8+ 1 / 3 % 4' !& / % &4
G F
8L 4 ' #$ ! & . / % @ 4' !& / % + ;
C 44 : 8 !" % 54 &" 8 " 5+ 4 &4 !,%
? % ' $

= ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F

? ' K3 #
?# XK3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F

<
 ! ( & '

= I &4 * "8 &4 % 4 ' 8 & !&4 4 #"

? % 8 1" )& *% 8 &
sa =] b& 2 K cK= 6 2] (A ]# • ) R )]0 =# • K= + )'6 ) U$
$ G p 6 8+/ +
@ 4' !& / % M 3 ,7 = $ 8+ 8 & !&4 1 #"
&4 ! " 5+ 4 !,% 8 L 3 &4 5+ W ='
I '8 5+ 4 4 '" &4 4 #" 8 + 8 & &4 '
5+ 4 ,% <#$ ' 7 9 > 3= - I &4
,7 4 '6 5 % : 8 &+ 8+ 1 ! &4 !"
G F
+
44 '" &4 *-' 54 $
?8 &+ " /A 5+
.# + ,7 - = $ A -% ! " 5 ( 4
? 4 % 6 % % 7 54 8 &
6 % % 7 54 K ,7 - - %'" ' ' 8 M 5# ' 1 I
/' / $ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 C : # 4 %
/ % 4 #" 3 6 4 4 *, 5 %' 9, & (
? ,% ! " 4 8'7 8% , @L
3 &4 5+ ,7 = 8+ ) : Z ,% /
#* 76 / '7 M / @ % , @" ! & 4 H ' # L
* 8 & !&4 7 -&" 8 + 4 4 'L &4 / 4 !,

? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F

%
 ! ( & '

G F
? = % '( I &4 C * I &4
5+ 4 ' .# ) : Z =- 8 #" . #$ *
,7 =
!& & 70 3 8'7 8% , @" 6" ,% ! " 6 / .#
I &4 K6 5+ I &4 8 & / % .# 4 * ! #$ /A 8
?G 7 F 4 5 $ 0 5+ 1 $4 4 '"
? ?u0a | K? ! ? [ CF ) ‡+ 3
44 '" I &4 % @5 % 2 ( & , - #"
= ! & &4 $ & #" 3 I &4 <#$ ,% 0 3 5+
&4 !" : 5+ 4 8 & !&4 /+L 8 ,% / < &4
? S I &4 <#$ 4 / I4
.# , % - )' 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 / > 6
D = 7 L # < 4
G‡' b N p / )K W ? ?u0a | K? ) + U
'( ,% / & 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 4 / - 44
G F
? @ / 8 ,% + @O 8 / 8M
4 # 3 @ &! 6 ' 2' 4 8 #"
& ' <O 4 /+ .# 8 & 0 4 = =4 %% -6
4 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 / /A 3 .4 ,%
/ 8 !,@ 4 8 + ; ' ,% 4 % 8 " @O
3 4 *2 @ / 6 % + : B4 /

? Y K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 Y G F
? '% K 3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 D , ? 'K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

F
 ! ( & '

I &4 * + ; G 6 -F> - /+ ' /

' ,% / - 7 1
M ' /4& 54& % % 9 , / 8 ' /
= I &4 8 & C & , ,% 4% # 3=
?8 ,% 8 +
/ K6 4, 8 ' + # 3 : !& ' / 8
G F
? %- ' / / 4 6 1
B 4 + 44 0 @O "+ ' / 0
+2 8L 3 % + 4 *2 @ 4 :
24 + 9+ 9 , / !& & , ,% ! "
?/ 6
D KO Np / )K W ? ?u0a | K? ) + U
* /1 3 6 = - ! " 82 * % - 4 ! " +2 "
& , ,% / ' ,% / 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 *
. + & , 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 5 4 /
= - #7 '" ! 2 Z 3= % 8 8 ,%
?. #7 $4 @ 3 @5 % -
#8 & C & #" B & , , % 4 % #$ & , / 4 #
+ /4 / 8 & G9 , )' 3 / 6 4 "FI 6 5 9+
? 7 = ' I &4 0

? K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F
 ! ( & '

G F
? I &4 7 < 4 = ' / / " # &
!& ) 6J . / /0 " 1 / ( 4 <#$
? = % % '" /4& &+ 4 M $ 4$"
#" " 3 +2 - /4 5+ 5 4 / #7 + #
G F
?/ = - &8 M % 8 &K #7
' 8 ,% 5 @+ 5+ I &4 5 4 / "
D # 0 8 !,@
I &4 ' 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 / Y
I &4 7 ,% 4 # 3 >; 6( G = F
1 = ! 5+ I &4 4 / 4%
G% F
? " ' 7 5+ 4 &
Y
5+ I &4 ' 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 /
/ - >; 6" ) ' # 3 M' "I 6
G' F
? I &4 <#$

? XK3 # = ' * 3 . 01 ! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 4& Y G F

? % K3 # = ' * 3 5+ &+ % + 34 6 4& Y G F
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' Y G%F
? %K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 Y G'F
 ! ( & '

"
( La complainte ) n ' L] | K?
? '2 5+ I &4 5+ I &4 /$ C * I &4
! " >4 0 # !1 5+ I &4 U C & =-
C * % '" % '" 4 # 5+
? - #" 5+ 4, 8
% 6% 7 54 / ,C * I &4 . 2 + 9 /0 4%
? 4( 4 ( @ 6 5 $ 7 54 , " 4
' 54 8 +2 '" %& + F D 8 ! & 6 Q?/?= % 7 54 K
GC * I &4 ' ;6 * 8 + 8+ C 8 *@ /1
3 = / # K6 # 7 C ' I &4 <#$ B
$ ) - !" ,( 3 I &4 <#$ 8 4,
?8 4 / - ,% / I &4 <#$ 5
$ n ' L] | K? %& '# (
: 4, = % +2 I &4 $C * I &4
G F
? < $0 +" C * - 8+ 8 C .#
.# : 4, ' 54 % +2 I &4 C * I &4 #"
? 5+ <#$ 8,
8M @ .4 & $ I &4 <#$ * Z .# C $
? 8+ 8 " , % +2 97 " @

K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YD , 0 ? K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F
?
 ! ( & '

# 5+ '2 5+ I &4 ; $C * I &4 #

6 "* ; I 6 I &4 3 C 4, 8
G F
?C
% +2 & %& & I &4 C * I &4
I &4 8 4 5+ I &4 @ A !& 8+ ) C
?= 9 , 0 8 # @
?SC * I &4 0 '( ,% K6 $D O' 4
' 54 &= %& +2 $ I &4 $C * I &4
1 5+ > &( $ I &4 <#$ 3 5+ <# C 4,
? 8+ ! & *% 4 &" . +2
*, 7 &B 5 , ) ' I &4 9 #$ - 0
S< A ) ' + / S 8'7 ) ' + $! 4
$ 2' <#$ 4 *, 54 , - 5+ & B /1
!& ,@ % '" 4% 9 + 9 , = & , =% 2'
G F
? ' ,% K 6" 64 5 &4 <#$
$ n ' L] | K? ! [r "(
?C * I &4 8 & !&4 &4 / 6 4 %
n ' L] | K? ! K= . /
?) 6 - ' @ 5+ % +2 $
# 4@ 3 - #$ $ % +2 4% #$ ! &
? % *, & % ' .4 *, ! & 5+ / % <#$

D 0 ! #$ , ? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F
Y Alex weill , op . cit , p 352 ?
K3 # = ' * 3 $ 4 YG F
#
 ! ( & '

@. 8+ 1 C * I &4 &4 !& ) #

G F
? < A )' 8'7 ) ' + 8 1 ! , & 5+ '
= 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 % $ >;6 #$
? : )' / 7 )' +2 &4
8 + ; , +2 3 % +2 I ' C * I &4
/4 % % )' 8 + , & @O 4 <4 I &4 <# (
? + -
$ =7 ( = ) 97 ( = ) + # !&
3 = ' , & +2 / I &4 <#$ * ' 5+
* = 8 8'7 ) ' = +2 .# )'
?C * I &4
/ *@ #" # C * I &4 * , +2 O + 8 "
< &L )' / '7 ) ' 8 '" .# = !& C
? @
/ '7 ) ' 4 5+ 8 + = ' +2 /
G F
? 8'7 !& ! C * I &4 * = / 6
= ) + 7 = ) +2 C * I &4 =
4 : 4, <4 C * I &4 * = 8 9 ! & +2 3 *2
4, I &4 <#$ * # 8 3 I &4 8 82 64 ! "
G%F
? 5+ <#$ * C &M 9 !& 8+ , #" / '7 82

? %K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F

' K 3 8'7 * YG F
? %# K 3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G%F

$
 ! ( & '

Z ' & & !& 8+ / % .# +2 . 2+ % Z'

* I &4 * 5 4( 5+ 8 K6 +2 G Q?/?= % % 54 F
: !& K6 5 4( Z ' !& 3C
?C
# Z' ' 7 % . % I 6 % C 4 "
# 3 8+ 8 C .# -% : !& C * I &4 5 +2
5+ 5 4R ' 3/ ' 5+ 8+
G F
? , &
M' "C * I &4 , 5+ L 8 =' Y
% G $%< 7 54 K . 2+ 9 < 1 '" 4% , & +2 8 /A
?C * I &4 ' 8 Z' 4
8 = !& 4 ' .# 4 C M' O , F
8 C = 6 ) - M' * #$ 5 O !&
? G 5+ I &4 <4, C
I &4 <#$ 5 % 8 6 .# 4 , +2 $ M'
? 5+ I &4 * I
# G Q?/?= $%< 7 54 & , M-6 *@ 4@ 9 0 ;
8M C 8 C = 6 ) - M' !& 8 9
%% 3C = ) - M' : <# 5 <#$ 4 %
8 C 8% 8'7 C ) - M' B # >;6
D N % ' 5 : M-6 #$ 9 Z
G ??? C 8% 8 C 6 ) - ??? F
? # #Y# K3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&YG F

5
 ! ( & '

!& #4 G $%< F 54 K M' #+ 4@ % #"

? 6N , +2 8 47' + ; 1 '( '
C 5+ I &4 * 8 'L * M' + "
M' 5+ I &4 @ /4& $ Z 4 .4
3 + " = % 8 ( 4%& ! " 4 ' @; 4,
I &4 @ .# 3 / I &4 ' $ 5+ 4% #$
G F
?= I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& % ' ' 5+
+2 # ' +2 C * I &4 * -
G F
? I &4 <#$ * = '
@ 4 4@ 5 %' % 5+ C * I &4 #"
.4 1L % 5+ / @ 1" )& &4 ! & *% 8 L
2 % 1( = - # . # 5+
$ 6. 0 '" & 4$ - 1" )& 8 & *% 3
?)
$ n ' L] | K? ! 2 K cK= 3
8 + &4 C .# K6 $C * I &4 8 & !&4
? @ 4 C #$ ' %
8 4 .# $ 8'7 8 & &4 4, * C * I &4

_ O X /@ % !" D # ' , 0 ?# K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F

? %' K 3 1 44 3 ## 3 2 ,% # #^ ^ X
? XX K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G F
 ! ( & '

? ' : 4, I &4 <#$ * + C

C 8 & !&4 4, * C * I &4 4 # ; 7
8 "4 ' = . 8 8 /A . 3 +2 8, '
C * I &4 * #$ = #$ 8 ' 4% 3 8,
G F
? ' ' 8 & &4 #" & 0 C: # 5+
G. F K6 >6 G 1 F/ >6 !& C * I &4 *
#" 9 !& * 3 ' > 6 #$ ! C
12 '( 9 @ 5+ #$ C
? 8 :
: )' +2 C /@ < A & ; C 1 #" 8
G F
? 4, I &4 * 6 &4
< A & 5+ 2 C 4, C * I &4 *
I &4 * + 8 ! & % '" ' ,% 3 % M ' 4, ;1
G% F
? +2 4, 5+
F8 M : Z 8 C $ 4@ 8 & !&4
O M M' 4 C #" G < A )'
8 + C #$ $ I &4 <#$ / 6 L 8
64 &4 3 < A )' 8 I &4 8 6" ) -
G' F
? ,< &L O I &4

? #%% K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&YG F

? K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
? K 3 8'7 * Y G%F
? K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G'F

<
 ! ( & '

!" 54 &" % Q 6 $C * I &4 ) - #"

% 8 " % " .# : 4, * I &4 <#$ L 3 C @8 &
8 M ) - #$ 8 " &4 8 3C # ; / '
, &C : #$ )- *-' &4 3C M #
G F
?C / '8 1 #" " 8 .#
$ n ' L] | K? > g ` "(
- & % - ,% / C * I &4 @
4 7 - 4 8 A3I 6 I &4 % * I &4 <#$ 4@
D $ C * I &4
2 G- n ' l> ' AH + K= F& / . /
)' F @ 5+ % +2 &4 C * I &4 * -
5+ % 8+ 1 I &4 <# 8 4 & &4 !& ) # G 8'7
' G F. .4 !& 5
?) 6. 0 '" & 4$ - *
? I &4 <#$ * 7 8 #$ &4 1 #L
' 2# + ! AH n '# L & / 3
&4 5+ !& 4 &( I &4 <#$ * )'
? % C .4 C " 4 &( #$ 4
@ .4 & $DC * I &4 * Z .# .# C $
" A = - , % +2 97 " @ 8M
G F
? 5+ <# ,

? #%# K 3 # = ' * ?. ' 4 =+ 4& YG F

? K3 # = ' * 3 3 - YG F

%
 ! ( & '

* C = &4" ' ! & +2 !" 8 @ .4 " $

G F
? 6 #$ =
/ # +2 5+ , ) I &4 <#$ * Z .# C
#$ / 3C ) ' ,C #$ & V #4
7 / 3 &4 8 / 7 " & $0 C
G F
? &+ 5+
C * I &4 * Z .# 8 & !&4 4 C L / !&
6 : & , 3 @ , 3 4 , "
DC #$ C ' # 3 5 4( 6
^? n ' U
$ 3 8+ +2 &+ , C & .4 & $
G% F
? 2+ ;- 8& 7 " - 5+ +2 / 4 @
D #/
? & + +2 C !& K6 / @ 5 % - " 6
! & .4 38 #" 4 +2 C 8 & /@
64 $+ 4 ' +2 * 3 2@ *-@ 3 $ 1
G'F
? & 97 " = ) M' 8
- 8+ +2 $ 1" ! & ) 5 4 & <#$

? # K3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- YG F

K3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 # ' 0 ? K3 # = ' * 3 3 - YG F
?
? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 Y G%F
? #% K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & Y G'F

F
 ! ( & '

? 2+ &7 " 8& 7 "

+2 * &M C / % M # 5 A % - 4@ G
%& ! " .4O = - 64 4' < %& ! & 8 % =7 ( = '
? +2
=7 ( 8% 5 +2 * < %& ! & &M / % M
6 7
8& 8 * < ;- 8 4' 8, -2 @L ;1 #
* I &4 * 6 # Z 8+ &4 , & <#$
?C
D -% !" 5 ( : 8 "
4@ , 8 #" A G &4 F +2 C 8 & !&4 64 " Y
!% #* + )' C &4 Q 6" 4 ! " C
- 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 = - 64 C * I &4 = -
G F
? 76 &) : 5 % 5+ )' /
, B4 8 4 , 8 & !&4 4 &" /+ Y
?G%F /+; $ #"3 &4
! F8 + 4 &4 , B4 4@ C #" 8 # !& )
?G , 8+ 8 & 4
C I &4 * &4 "C * I &4 * $ ;
G' F
? 8 & !&4 !& % O' 4& % % -

? X K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G F

? #% K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
? X K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G%F
D8 ^ ^ XW X '# /@ % : & 4 % !" 0 Y G'F
@ 6 = M '' 4 5+ " I &4 Q?/?= G ' F 54 ' !& C ,% "F
? G ? /?"?= G ' X F 54 K
 ! ( & '

# 3 ,C ! & B4 +2 % 8' * .# 4
* = 8 Z 3C - = % ) - ,
, ) 5+ I &4 * Z .# C 3C * I &4
G F
? / C )- , 8& V #4 / 3 : 5+
<# $ * % 4% 3 &4 <+ .# % C & *% - Y
G F
! & % #" 8'7 8 & !&4 <+ : <+ %&
% ) & O ) < %& C /@ - =7 " = 6J
? =7
> % 8 & !&4 5 4 C & - Y
&4 & 76 ' 6 B4 + # 3 & " 4@ 5 %
4% M ' ! ' 8 & !&4 /+
G% F
? <4, I &4 * &4 + 8, % 8
#" 8 1= 4 ' ! & 5+ I &4 * 4 C + 8 Y
# 5+ I &4 <#$ 3C 8% .4M ' 8 & !&4 +
8+ 8 " 4 ' = +2 #" B 4 - #"
G' F
?= #$ 8
C $ #" 4% K6 $9 , ,@ 4 6
? / 5+

? XK3 # = ' * 3. + .4 54 YG F
G'F ? K3 # = ' * 3 - 4& YG F
? % K3 # = ' * 3 4 Y G%F
? X K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G'F
 ! ( & '

n ' U
8 & !&4 4 @> ! & /2 % C $ % C "
G F
D $ ? 8+ &4 8, 8 A 8 8
5+ * C &4" , 8 & !&4 4 .# .4 ( > #
? 2 ,% A ( 5 2 ,% ( 5 3 #6 .# +2
D % C #6 #
$ Hp n ' s [U
, % ! " I &4 * #/ 3 ,% / 8 6 C #$
5+ 4 4 '" I &4 * 1 3 $ &4 5+ 8 & !&4 8 C
8 & !&4 &4 /2 @ 9 + = I &4 K6 64 3 +2 > -
3 &4 5+ C - / 4% 9+ C !& = 8 &4
G F
? <4, C * I &4 * + 6H , #$ L
# 6 - / K6 ! & / #7 , 2 ,@ ,
G% F
?/ ' 4 %-
+2 = * , 2 ,% ( - 8 6 5 ( :
f +" 3 % +2 4 - ) - I &4 * # !&
* I &4 &4 * 3 5+ 8 % +2 !& 8 & @
* $ +2 + 8+ @ , # 3 +2 4, C
. B .# $ ,% 38 &4 C * / ) - & I &4
? 5+ = 6

? XX K 3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F
? K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' YG F
? #%X K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & Y G%F
 ! ( & '

; = 8 5+ * C .# 2 ,% C
G F
?C * I &4 * + 3 % ! " 5+
8 & 8 8+ 8 & +2 4, I &4 * # !&
? 8%
4 3+2 4 *, &4 , ' 4 I &4 * #
" !& . - +2 = % @ , '% I &4 ,
? 8%
$ & & 7 = % % &+ L #
'' Z /1 3 5+ ' &) = M &+
G F
? 5+ I &4
H p ST n ' ) " [
2 ,% 6 % C #6 . ,
" 3 ,% / 2@ 6 44 .# $ 3 2 ,@ A "
8 , , +2 8 #( # 6 / % 4
? 8+
4) O 5 * 4 /4 M' #" C 8 # 1
G% F
?8 @ , 8 % +2 ( # 6 8 "
38 Q 6 8 6 3 <+ .# % /4 #" 8 8 M
G'F
? 2 ,@ A @ , < M % * 38 4 . " /4

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
K3 # = ' * 3) 4&C D , ? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- YG F
? %##
G%F Y Alex weill , op .cit , p 338 .
? X K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G'F
#
 ! ( & '

$ ?1 ) d { l[V )- V *`/ EK Cd ] n ' U%

-& 4 @ #" 5 4( 6 6 : C M $
3 5 -6 ; =% , 5 4L K6 6
6 ) K6 8 @ .# 6 ! & K6 #"
<#$ C L 3 +2 , 5 4(
. 4( ,% .4 ,% < 0 K6 4& % 8 & . ' % '
&/ & +" C * ,% 8 +
G F
?8 & !" 54 &" C
( a =6 ) R )]0 = B b# / " 3
54 8 +2 '" %& + ??? F G Q? /?= % F 54 / !" 9
G ??? '
C 9 @ @ 9 -% " 4 ' &4 5+ ' ) 8 4
C * I &4 *
7 ' 4 4@ 8 + 1" )& G &4 F +2 ! & *% $
<+ 8 3 ' C 9 @ @ % + 8 &4 1 # '
54 F + 5 7 8 +2 '" 8 C 7 ! C @ ;
G F
? G /?= %#

' 87 ' 5+ 54 8 + ! " /, ' 54 " &4 + Y

@ - / @- * 6 76 >' # & 7 6 &4
G% F
? +

X K3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G F
?# K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
? #K3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- Y G%F

$
 ! ( & '

@ 4 4@ 5 %' 5+ $- #$ %
? ' 9 < 4@
n ' ‹& # E )]0 ,V | K= LW # / '6
C 9 @ W ' ;6 C * I &4 * +2 !& )
? G /?= % 54 F .4 %
D $ &( ,% / % 4 / 54 <#$ ;6 I &4 * / #L
C 7 ' 54 # '" * 8 + C ! & +2 ' "Y
8 & + 8 3 8, C % M > 8 8
? %
24 $ , % ! & ' 54 C 4 *, . C '" Y
G F
? +2 5+ + 5 4 5+ 8 %
-6 C C 7 ' 54 - I &4 <#$ * 6
? 8 +2 , & ;,
A !& . ' L /1 /4 % 54 - %' 54 $ $ ' 54
G F
? *-% >@ )2 : $
, % 8L /& 1 4 I &4 #" 8 - %' 54 !& )
5+ I &4 &4 = -%' 34 4 % /4
G% F
?= - I &4 * "8 !%

? 'K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F

? #' K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F
? #K3 # = ' * 3 3 - Y G%F

5
 ! ( & '

7 3 @ 4 C 'C 9 @ / ' 54 ) ' " 4

, 8 U , 0 .# C / 54 )' 4 .4 C
? 5+ !& 4 &"
4 4@ / "C +2 /& @ ' )' 4 76 C #"
G F
?8
2, % ( 8 W " ' 54 . ' ; @ , #"
? +2 ! " 2 ,% A
? I &4 , & 94" / ' 54 4 +2 4, I &4 * ;1
8' 7 U - .# O' L 3 & 54 C #"
D $ 44 #$
S ' 54 ) ' 4 !
K6 4 - &4 5+ !& C & 44 #" Y
/ ' 54 ) ' " 4 35 ' 54 C $ 4
* = +2 i .# $ 7 # & <#$ & 9 @
G F
? I &4 <#$
4 C & , % '" 4& C & 44 #"
44 8 # 2@ , & <#$ & 3 7 6 K6
G% F
?/ &5 4 K6 & <#$ 44 C * I &4
<#$ M .# G FC 9 @ W I &4 ' ' 54 )'
G' F
? I &4
? 'K3 # = ' * 3 &4 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- , ?X K3 # = ' * 3P ' YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G%F
? K3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- Y G'F
 ! ( & '

$ 2 ‡+ n ' L] | K? ! ? [ CF )' J L6 (
$ n ' L] | K? ! ? [ CF )' J . /
) 8 L 7 & , ,% / C * I &4 #"
G , & @ F 4 *, - B I &4 <#$ 7 4& ,%
, % =% F< W C $ B ) 8- #
& 9 M I &4 9 , / @ 4@ &4
8 M .# = % + 3G @/ 4 F $ 4 C
8 + ; G "?/?"?= 5 54 F I &4 <#$ < 0 4& = M ,%
4 ' =% 6 )4 8 + 3 & M 4 *'
2 '( '! & : 4 ' <#$ K / " ) '
G F
? 5+ - =% 8 , % .# 4%
< &4 > &4 / % 4@ #" 3 I &4 > Z ) , % ! & *%
/ 1 I &4 U " , & $ # *2 @ !& =- 2- 6 7
7 %% 7 - 8 I &4 / 6 > 4% ,%
?Z
# 7 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 &" ! & < &4 &4 * #L
/+ ' $ # @ 8 ' .# = , $0
G F
?> #$ ' ! & ,% 8 L 5+ C * I &4
8 8 & !&4 C * ,% L < &4 = &4 #"
&4 97 " 4 @ .4 & +" # ,% 3 8+

? 'K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
3 % : & 4 ^ '^ _ O # #' /@ @ !" 0 YG F
? K3 3 44 3 4 ' /'@ 3 2 ,%

<
 ! ( & '

? 9 7 ( #$ @ & 8+
4 , #L C 9 )' I &4 4 / , > 6
/ @ 4@ /4$ /4$ 4@ @L # 38 !" 54 &" 8 +L /
8 & !&4 %& &4 %& 14 4@ C & '
G F
? - 4' .# -2 /4$ 1 : %&
= 7 % &4 5+ 4O % M / L @C #"
G F
? 8 / @ .# ( #6" C
I &4 I &4 * + /4& 54& @ 5 & /+ ,%
9 , C = M ' 5+ I &4 8 + 8 5+
8 7 I ! 3 &4 Z C * I &4 / 8 &
! C * ,% / F I &4 K 6 $ 8 & !&4
44 8 G= I &4 8 !,% ' C M 4 % &R &4 $
* I &4 5+ /A 3 44 5+
G% F
? !& @ $ % 5+ $C
38 & !&4 ' 6 , ) 4@ 5+ I &4 4 /
G5+ 7 , % F 5+ ,@ / % C% + #
+( 4 / #7 + B I &4 * 8 & !&4 Z
? 82 "4 "8 !" 54 &"
G' F
? 7 !" / # 7 /4& I &4 * !&

? ' K3 # = ' * ' 4 4 , ? 'K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 4 !7- Y G%F
? %K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G'F

%
 ! ( & '

/ #7 !& < ( # 44 : C !& / +

G F
? ;6( +( 8 !" 54 &L
&C 8 & !&4 !& / &4 )- !& ,% +
G F
? % O' 4& % % # 8, 8 = .# ,
8 L % +2 $ 8 4' !& & I &4 * 8 & &4 / @
8 & !&4 5+ 8 #L - ; 9 4B ,% !&
8 6N C * 8+ % 'L !,@ &4 5+ * C
G% F
? 8+
8 ,% ,7 ,% ! , + #"
4 #" j 4 % 6% % 7 54 / %- ,7 = 5+
% / ,% + I 6 !& $4 " ,7 8 $ / +
G' F
= I &4 / 6 / 5+
4 / % 8+ ! & 9+ % !& ' <#$ , % / % 4@
G5 % 54 F , @( 4 & 8 A & ' /4% !& % !& ' 6
? 4( 4 ( @
n ' L] | K? ! ? [ CF ) ‡+ 3
#L 3 24 & , / C * I &4 4 / +
,% 5 @+ 8L 4 A 4 - = -* / #$ 47 '"
= % 8 8L 8 ,% 5 @+ ! 38

? #' K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4&Y G F

? % K 3 8'7 * YG F
? XK3 # = ' * 3. . 4@ U 7 4 & Y G%F
? #'% K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4 & Y G'F

F
 ! ( & '

4 "! <#$ C% 4. @+ 3 5+ M' ! & %

, / 6 !& " / #" 3 9 , )' / 6
+ / 6 - /+ I &4 4 / 3 - /
? / 4 1/ !& >4 - # 1 I &4 *
8 & 15 5 &4 8 & , & " .# & , ,% 4% / #$
? 7 = ' I &4 0 + /4 ,%
I &4 0 .# ,% 4% C * I &4 4 /
? I &4 ' 8 ,% 5 @+ 8 #" 3 = I &4
5+ / L I &4 & , ,% #4 ,@ #L Y
?8 8& +
? &5 4 % 44 # ,@ 4%
% : & 4 H FH < W _ O <## /@ % # 1
=' 9+ &" 5 ,@ I &4 ??? F 8 .#
FF5H H $ 4 % 4O FF#H H $ _ O / ) 8 7
I &4 ' )' 5+ I &4 4 / A
5+ I &4 7 % / L ???? &-
G F
?G 6 I &4 <# ' 8 ,% 8

?% K3 # = ' * 3 3 % : 2 ,% 4 ( YG F

#
 ! ( & '

"
=&=M BK %> | K?
% 6 % 7 54 K , 54 4 & >@ I &4 . 2 + 9

? 4( 4 ( @ 6 5 $ 7 54 / , " 4

D !& ! % 4 % 6% 7 54 B

C % ) ' 6 ' 54 8 +2 '" %& + + F

<# $ > @ - ,% !" * 8+ 44 54 4 & 8

.# 4 !& 4 / & C% / 4@ - &

? G ??? , B4 8M

- # 3 / 6 3 I &4 > K6' 54 <#$ ;6

8 4 / - !& > ' /1 ,% / % -

D -% #

#
 ! ( & '

=&=M BK %> | K? %& '# (

&= +2 % +2 I &4 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4
/ " 8 - 5+ , Z / & 9 .# : 4, 8 &
G F
? #$
/ % 54 4 & $44 % 8+ &4 ' I &4 $
G F
& <#$ >@ / - 3 8+ M 8 & &4
% 5+ 54 4 & >@ I &4 7 #$ ;6 0 ;
2 @ I &4 # !& / % . 3 ; *% / $44 -6
G% F
? ;%' 9 @ -6 4 ! " >4
! & = 7 ( = +2 * I &4 54 4 & >@ I &4 1
Z / 8 8 9 .# >%L 8 - %
? =7 ( = '"
4 M + 54 4 & >@ I &4 L 5+ I &4 @ >;6 ! &
%' C @ .4 7 &4 Z ' 3 8 & !&4 &4 542 7
' 4 & +" .4 7 8 & !&4 Z' 3 < -6 *%
?C * I &4 <4, /1 / %
? +2 9+ 5+ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 & + 4
DB , C * I &4 & +
I &4 3 5+ ! & ; *@ .# 4 &( * 4 & C I &4 " Y

? K3 # = ' * 3 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& Y F

? 'Y %3 # * 3 % 4 YG F
G%F Y Colin et capitant , op . cit , p 247 ?

#
 ! ( & '

4 &" ; *@ 4@ 4 &" 5+ 54 4 & >@

G F
? & <#$ *% ' $ G 4 &( & F *%
38 & !&4 %& %" 4 & *% 54 4 & >@ I &4 Y
8 & !&4 &4 %& *% & <#$ L C * I &4
? :
+" 4 & <#$ >@ / , % / % 54 4 & >@ I &4 Y%
? -6 4 4 , #" +L ,% + C * I &4
54 4 & >@ I &4 * =7 C * I &4 " ; 6( <#$ /A
- ' !& 5 % 5+ / + '" B
!& %& ! & $4 B G5 ' 5 $0 3 , 3 24 5+ F
? . %& &=
I &4 4 # 3, ' )- & & >@ I &4 > 6
! " >4 . %& &= %& ! & *% B;1 5+ I &4
% 5+ 1 7 ,% 3 $44 C . 5+
! "* .# ' )- 3 +; -
# $ 64 .# '( -6 8 .# $ '( ,%
! 6 8 4 -6 * 4& 4 8 4 3 @ @ 4 ( ,%
@ L ,% $ $ ,% / 3 @ 8 & #" 8 7 '"
G F
?=

? K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' YG F

*)$K 3 4 6 4& D , ? 'K 3 # = ' * 3 !" 5 / & " 3 - YG F
' %K3 # = ' * 3 ,# . #$"

##
 ! ( & '

C +2 @ 54 4 & >@ I &4

I &4 * - 38 @C 4 ! & +2 4& ' 2 @ I &4
! 6 2' = C + '
? @
I &4 % 1 & , I &4 $ $ 3 - % >;6 1 4% #
* 8 K2 6 8 4 7 0 @ I &4 S 5+
?S '( I &4
24 '( & ' !& @ I &4 I 8%7 .
G F
? , & !& @ ! 6 B
4 3I 6 5+ I &4 $ : & , I &4 I 6N .
G C !& ' @ F 6 +2 8
G F
? @ I &4 '' .# '( & & 7
& , I &4 54 4 & >@ I &4 / !&
?= @ 4 3+2 % + 24 ) -
B '( ,% / 54 4 & >@ I &4 * * #$ A
, @ ! " 54 4 & >@ I &4 * + 8 ! & ,% 8%7 % '"
G% F
?8 6" - #" @ ( / % '
B ,% & , I &4 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 #"
' 24 $ 5 $0 3 % 7 5+

? 'K3 # = ' * % 4 YG F
? ' K 3 8'7 * YG F
K3 # = ' * 3 $ 4 Y G%F

#$
 ! ( & '

#" 3 5+ ' 9+ /' 4 .# / L # 3 '

> @ )- ' I &4 * +2 + 3 I &4 - * '
& "4 " 5+ I &4 I &4 <#$ 54 4 &
? 5+ 9 ,
L 38 & 9+ = 9 , 54 4 & >@ I &4 /A $
,@ 1 @O & <#$ >@ M '( ,%
/ 8 @ C 4) &L #$ 3 9 ,
G F
? '" M " #
- 54 4 & >@ I &4 0 ' ,@ K 6" "
& !" ,( 3 I &4 9 #$ - -
K 6" - % - $ = M ' /4& , '(
? ' ,@
,% M 3 - #$ ! " % 7 I &4 <#$ '( ,% #L
7 3 A @ 8 ! 6 .# '(
= M 4@ % 5+ & & , 1 , % I &4
G F
? I &4 <#$ 0 8 6" /4 ,% 8 & 8 & 9+
2@ $ I &4 <#$ 8 & / % .# ' L / !&
+2 8 8 @C 4 +2
I &4 <#$ K 6 B ' 3 8+ ! & 4 &( / " %
? 4 / # $ ) -

?X K3 # = ' * 3P ' YG F
? ' K3 # = ' * 3 4 YG F

#5
 ! ( & '

=&=M BK %> | K? ! [r "(

=&=M BK %> | K? ! K= . /
8 4& 8 & ) .# % +2 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 &4
G , & 5+ F @ 8+ 1 I &4 <#
) 6 % - ' G. .4 F 8
?6 % !" P 7

3 8' 7 ) ' + % % +2 I &4 <#$ L #

% 8 U .# M' 6 7 #$ 1 ' 3 , & +2
54 4 & >@ I &4 5+ I &4 * O /'L : 4, *
?6 $%< ! " 7

5+ ! "4 ' I &4 <#$ &4 !& ) 8 !" 5 ( :

!&4 &4 - .# 4% !" 4 *, I &4 I4 " $ &L
?8 &
>%" G 8 & !&4 &4 F 9+ - - 4%& $ #L
<#$ &4 !& 8 L 4% #$ = - 64 54 4 &
/ L 8 & !&4 /+" - G 4% I &4 F 4% 8 6 I &4 ! " M
. 54 4 & >@ I &4 * 8 $# 7 4% - 5&
? I 6 5+ I &4
'" 4 M 54 4 &M O / @ #" 3 # !& ' @
5 O O B4 8& 7 " % 5 O M'
,% ! " M M' *-' 3 97 ( # 6 : %

#
 ! ( & '

+ 8 F 5+ I &4 ! " 4 '" 54 4 & >@ O /+(

( 4%& I &4 ! " 4 '" " G O 4, , & +2 $ M'
G F
? M' .4 C &9 ( 8 + .# O 8- .#
I &4 < @ 8 & = - 54 4 & >@ I &4 &4 / !&
?C *
=&=M BK %> | K? ! 2 K K= 3
& 4 / % .# K6 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 8 & !&4
<# $ 3 &4 5+ , 8 Z 4 !" / 8 .# < %&
% ) ' ! & %% 44 #$ 3 &4 5+ 44 &
5+ ; , & <#$ M 4 % &( ! " &4 & ,
G F
? +2 $# *@ /$ 4 !& &4
% - I &4 <#$ * ' 8 & &4 $4 &
$ < %& $ 4 4@ 8 & !&4 G / ?= % F 54 / ,
, # &" &4 %& 4 & 3 : &4 %&
# : %& & <#$ 4 #" 7 3 ;%' , 5+
? 54 4 & >@ I &4 C * I &4 * : &4
=&=M BK %> | K? > g ` "(
I &4 % $ ) - 4 % 6% 7 54 K , 4%
? ,% / 54 4 & >@
B C * I &4 * - * =7 I &4 <#$ * - 4

* 3 4 D , 0 ? #%Y # K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 4 +& Y G F

? '# K 3 # = '
'X K 3 # = ' * 3 4 &4 4 YG F

#<
 ! ( & '

B 5 ' 24 , % 5+ / + '"
& >@ I &4 8 "3 C 4 W ' ;6 5 ,
? - 5+ I &4 $ A & $+ 6 - 54 4
$ n ' l> 2 & „ k ' AH + K= F& / . /
&4 ) # 6 % 7 54 , - #$ ! & K 4%
6 @ 5+ ) - % +2 54 4 & >@ I &4
? 87@ / / #" /$ 4 -6 544 8+ .# C @ )
$ ?=Y =&=d BK/ ! ( 4 )'> 7 3 3
/ & 8 & !&4 9 54 4 & >@ I &4 % -
& >@ I &4 * 4 &4 4 # 3 5+ , 8M
Z #" % ) ' ! 6 : &M 8 & !&4 / @ #" 54 4
? G 5+ !& 9 @ ! & 4 &" F +2 5+ ,
8 ! " 8 !, 8, 4 4 -2 8 & &4 4 D # 1
5+ C # &/ - = 7 " 8 .# < !& 4'
? +2
D 54 4 & >@ * ' & -
; 9 4@ & ! 3/ / 4 4@ & <#$ Y
; C 4@ # 3 / % !&
G1 F
?C * I &4 * /+ '
# +2 ,( ! " & <#$ .4O % ) ' ! 6 Y
,% 4% M' $ 3 5+ !& 4 &" ! " 5 "
? *2 @ M'
X## K 3 # = ' * 3 # .)*" "% 2 3 6J 3) &4 YG F

#%
 ! ( & '

* 7 54 4 & <#$ # I &4 <#$ &4 !&

# ' 8 8+ , !& 4 /4% 3 & # % @4
<# $ +2 1 3 4 *2 @ = 1( 2' 8 '(
% ) ' /4% 3 8+ 97 ( 8 !" 4 &
? & <#$ # 7 8 6
%& $ < %& @ 4@ 8 & !&4 $4 & <#$
C : &4 %& 4 3 : &4
G F
?C I &4 * #2# & ) ;%'
+2 ,( 4 !" # 5+ C !" & <#$ .4O Y'
& > @ I &4 / 4& C I &4 44 <#$
G F
? 54 4
G> c K )]0 = B 0a " 3
8 & !&4 9 @ 9 -% " 4 ' 54 &4 5+ ' )
? 5+ , 54 4 &
&4 ' 3 8+ 54 ! " 87 ' 5+ 54 /, # ' &4
G% F
? >' # 6 76 & 76
)]0 ,V | K= 9;< LW # / '6
<#$ * ) !& K 4 4 % 6% 7 54 K !" 9
5+ 44 , B4 M 4@ & 4 ' ;6 I &4

? #' K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F

? K3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 YG F
? K3 # = ' * 3 1 " # $ " 34 6 4& Y G%F

#F
 ! ( & '

% A " +2
8 3 I &4 <#$ * % 4 /+ &4 !& : $
4 !& ' @ 3 8 & !&4 4 54 4 & ( @
? , B4 " M & <#$
!& 9 @ !& 4 &" 1 & 4 W ' 54 ) ' " 4
? 5+
4 &" L 4 K6 4 - & <#$ #L
? & <#$ & 4 W ' 54 4 3 54
4 L 7 6 K6 4 C & , % '" 4& #"
?8 # 2@ 4 &" & <#$ &
5 4 K6 & <#$ 44 & >@ I &4 44 8 L #$ ! &
G F
? I &4 <#$ M .# 4 / I &4 54 )' " 4 / &
/ 1 3 /4 % 54 - %' 54 $ 2 1 I &4 * ' 54
#L 3 9 -% ( >@ &. ' )2 : $ K@ ! & . '
G F
? @ /4 ,% L ' 1 4 I &4
3 ' ,@ 5 , .4 W ' 54 ,
& + )' # 54 4 & >@ I &4 0 K6 A
? '(
? & , ,% / I &4 0 4& $ ) - - <#$
<#$ =% 8 ' ,@ / I &4 C & / #"
? ' ,% K 6" - !" ,( 3 & , -

?' K3 # = ' * 3 !7- ' YG F

#' K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G F

$
 ! ( & '

8 G-Œ6 • b =K ‡' 01 []K W # U

54 4 & >@ I &4 L ' I &4 M $
M ' /4& 3 '( & 1 #" " ' ,% / %
?=
=% 54 4 & >@ ) - 8 & C & #" ' ,% !& ) -
, % 8 L $ 8 '" L 3 I &4 - 4 ' $0
G F
& >@ &4
#3G @ 6 ! F '( & , =% Y
44 -6 4 4% . 3 '( 4% - ' '( ,% 8
# 8 54 4 & >@ ) - % !" % ( # ' 8 5+
4 = % 3 5+ =4 -6 4 4% &H (
4 , @O 2, % - = +2 6
? 8 & !&4 4 &
6 )4 54 4 & >@ I &4 7 @ '( ,%
) - & $ 3 - 44 54 4 & , 8
G F
? 5+ , #" 7@
? I &4 0 8 6" /4 ,@ '( - /4& , % #L
& , 1 8 ) - I &4 7 ' ,% #" 8
4 M &+ 1 3 8 & 9+ = M ' !" 8 = -

? XK3 # = ' * E 1 " !! ) E $ .4 !7- Y G F

? 'X K 3 # = ' * 3 # !" 9 1! K # ". !/ 34 6 4& Y G F

$
 ! ( & '

4 8 '" 3 8 4& G & , I &4 - F # 7 ' -

B !" 4 ' $0 8 > ' % 4 Z
& >@ 82 ,@ 38 6" /4 ,% 8 & 3 & , =
G F
?= M ' 8 54 4
<# $ "4 54 4 & 4 W ' 4 I &4 #"
? ' ,% K 6" /4 , !,% 8 L 2 " ) @" &
a ? =&=M BK %> 6 c K [ >1 U
K 6" % # 3 & / +" ' ,% )- !
& >@ ! & 54 4 & >@ I &4 ' ,@
3= M # & <#$ +L 8 3 $ 'L #(
$ ,% ,% 3 / +" 54 4 & >@ &4 )- , #L
1 = 8 6" /4 3 8- #" ) - = L
G F
?G= F9 , M 8' ' ) -
2 ‡+ =&=M BK %> | K? ! ? [ CF )' J L6 (
=&=M BK %> | K? ! ? [ CF )' J . /
D 1 % G Q ?/ ?= % F 54 K !" 9
$ '" #M & '" * ,% ????? F
, >@ / 4 ' 7 / 4% M ,% +
'" ! & C &( 2 / #" >@ #$ & i , U; (
<#$ +( , & 'L / ' A !& &
? XK3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- Y G F
3 # = ' * 3 ' 4 4 D , 0 ? K3 # = ' * 3 $ 4 Y G F
? #K

$
 ! ( & '

/ !& #" +2 ) .# , &C , &

?G8 2
D 8 54 <#$ K6'
/ 8 54 4 & >@ M' ! & I &4 <#$ ,% / % Y
# 1 + & 3 & 8 & !&4 8 /@ +L
# ,@ 4@ +( 4 >@ ,% / $ 5+ !& 4 &"
D ! % G / ?= % F 54
? G ??? & <#$ >@ - ,% !" * ???? F
&4 F - 4 ' 7 / 4% 8 * ,%
G F
? G 8 & !&4
D 4 & ,% / Q 6 $
! 6 ) ' $ 4% < &4 = ! & &4 ,% I "G
# 24 & 3 54 4 & <#$ &4 5+ C $
'( /4& & >@ 8 ,% &4 Z ,% 4
&4 M ,% + <#$ 3 7 = I &4 * !"
# $ &i , U; ( , ' 7 / 4% 8 / .#
/ #" 4 & >@ 8 & !&4 ) .# >@
G F
? ' A !& & '" ! & C &( 2
C &" M = I &4 9 , #4 ,@ #L

? XK3 # = ' * 3 % 4 Y G F
? #' K 3 # = ' * 3. ' 4 =+ 4& Y G F

$#
 ! ( & '

= 9 , 4' 8 / 54 4 & '( ! & &4

,% - & , M 8 & !&4 !& 3 5+
G F
? / / & >@ ) ' 8 / .# , )' C 8
# ,Z M 44 &4 4@ 7 L <#$
?8 ,@ .# C
I &4 C ,% < &4 = !& &4 ,% I " G
7 = I &4 * !" $4 & 8 & !&4 ' /1
G F
?
/ .# &4 , ' 7 / 4% , 8 & &4 M ,%
/ ,% + 2 / &4 !,@ #L 3 < &4 C 8 &
4 @ 7 #24 & 3 , & +L 8 & !&4 !&
G% F
? +( <# , 8 & !&4
,@ 4 / ' 7 + 8 !" 5 ( :
?9 , '
D # 4% 1 7 - C 4%
8 2 &4" 1" 4 @ = I &4 * 5+ I &4 * /+ 7 /0
7 8 4* & <#$ >@ 8 / 8 3 54 4 & >@ I &4
?8% 1 2 / 4 '" 4 " 7 <#$ 4 ' 8 +
= 7 I &4 * $4 4 '( 8 + 7 * 4 8 & !&4 !& / #"
4' A & '( ! & C &( 1 +2

? #' K 3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G F

? K3 # = ' * 3 1 " !! ) 3 $ .4 !7- Y G F
K3 # = ' * 3 3 - Y G%F

$$
 ! ( & '

> % = I &4 * 5+ I &4 8 / /+ 8 7 -

C : * 3 1( )& 8 & *% &4 >@ #
I &4 82 7 " % = I &4 * +2 7&" 1 5+
G F
? 5+
5 & 8 !& 2% . !" 0 &4 ' 7 /0 8 4% #$ " k
'" 4 #6" & / , C #6 @ " &
! " @O 7 $ '" & >@ <#$ $ 3 6 ' 1
G F
?= I &4 5+ I &4 2 7
,% K 6" I &4 2@ * - 4 M 54 <#$ ! " 9 8L #
= 1( 9 , ,@ !" - 4 ) * $ 0 '(
" 4 $4 ' B , , 7 # 87 5+
G% F
? 6N @ 8% . % / !& 8 4
L 54 4 & >@ I &4 7 - 8 4% ;' I 0
G / ?= % F54 & 6 <#$ ' & , ,% )
? 7 / 4% /
,% " / G / ?= % F 54 K &K 7 "
G'F
? @ I &4 54 4 & >@ I &4 8%7 C #$ 3 '(
I &4 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 8%7 Z . * I
> 6 @+ 5+ 2 =% ! " >4 # 3 & ,
?= &

? K3 # = ' * 3 % 4 YG F
? K 3 8'7 * YG F
? X# K 3 # = ' * 3P ' Y G%F
? ' KE # = ' * 3 /;& 4 =+ 4&4 G G'F

$5
 ! ( & '

4% .# 7 - !& 8 &( #$ $ 4@ 9 "

!" @ 4 L / ) - I &4 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4
& > @ I &4 < # Y 5+ I &4 9 , 7
# 6 .# . #3 7 /0 #6 ! & 4 &" @ I &4 $ 54 4
" % 54 4 & >@ I &4 $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 @
? 5+ 14
7 6 G % F 54 1 5 %7 ! " /4& = 8 I #
7 /0 38 / /4& 8 / 8 3 , % .+ / /A
& %' & , I &4 $ &L 54 4 & >@ I &4 * !
<# $ 8 & / % .# ' 44 K #$ 1 4 3= I &4
? I &4
$ =&=M BK %> | K? ! ? [ CF ) ‡+ 3
5 @/ + ! + & , 5+ I &4 5 4 / "
?8 ,%
8L & , ,% & 4 54 4 & >@ I &4 / #" #
/ 6 4% <#$ 4 A 4 - = - #7 '" #" " +
? ,% 4%
I &4 5 4 / A 3 -% 5+ M' ! & 5 % <#$
>; 6( I &4 ' 8 ,% 5 @+ 54 4 & >@
? I &4 9 ,
) 54 4 & >@ I &4 & , ,% & 4 /

$
 ! ( & '

/ 4& % % - # ! & 8 K #" " 3 % 5 % #7

? 2
/ ' ,% / 54 4 & >@ I &4 4 /
G F
? % 5 % #7 3 + @O
$ = '( F DK G "?/?"?= # # F 54 K
, @ A8 - = - /A 4 7 #7
G F
G? # 7 ! & C &R
@ + " % 5+ I &4 4 =' ;6
+2 !" 0 4 %' # 5+ 3 5+ $ @
' ' A 8 ' . 3 <+ .# =
"38 &= ) 8 <+ .# % 8 1" 8 ) - 3 2'
*-' ! <+ .# = 8+ 1" - 5+ / @ 1" 8 7
8 & .4 & #" C 8& *4 3 8 9+ #" = # 8+ 4 '
? 8+ 8% 44 & >@ ) -

# K3 # = ' * 3+ &4 3. 4 +& Y G F

$<
 ! ( & '

& /' / / 0 07 2 ' /$ 5+ 4 4 8

8 Z' 3C 4 &" < %& +2 ' B 3*
<#$ ! & 9 3 : > - 8 8& + <4 4 'L
* % '( &+&+ ! " ' # 4 94 >%"
?/@ % , @" ,% ! " 4 ) : .4 & !"
J= - & 4 5+ +; 7 4@ . 2 + 9 /A
* , , 3 C =' B;1 5+ I &4 $ @
D ;6 # 3 *@ C !& <#$ 7 , *
B 4 . 3 8 1 .# = ! " 4 '( 4 # 5+ ! & 4 &( Y
?8 & ' =
$4 5+ ;% '" = % , /$M $ A 54& @ *, Y
I &4 5+ I &4 * + /4& 54& @ $ 3= &
?
! & 4 &( 4 H '2 2 ,@ , 5+ I &4 /A
# $ I4 ' 5+ ! & *@ 4 &( 4 ! & 5 4 @ ' 3/ +
- @ 4 C 3) : 5 % = - & ' ! " 4 &(
4 " 3 5+ '' # A 3 +2 97 "
( ' - )' # 5+ ' 7 I &4 <#$
54 4 @+ = 6 ! " .4O 3 ,% / 8 0 .# @ -

$%
 ! ( & '

34 $ 1J / ) 4@ 3 5 4 I 6 $ 4@
? 2 5+ 1 $ 4 4 !& 5 @
<# $ & #" 6 3 5+ !& @ 4 &( * 4 A
N % $ /0 4 4+ 3 - -6 ' 4 + 5 6
* 4 ' + /@ 7 ! " ,( 3 ' Z B 35 6
( 5 % = - & 5+ ) A )' ) ' !" 1
?8 %' / M %& ! & 4
5+ &+ F &+ 9 #$ M & *@ #$ + 4%
? 2 9+ !" 4 9+ ! " .4O -6 # Z B 3G %
B;1 5+ I &4 = - & 5+ 4 /+ #$
# 5+ 7 =% $4 7 24 % '" 1
!& % @ K # 3 2 :
? 4 4 &( 4, 5+
%^ & % 5+ 2 4 5 , ! " &4
' 4 % ) A 3 4' 2+ %
/ /$4 % &" * -% +2 / % <#$ -'%
? G M-6 & $ F ' ;
= 7 / &4 3 5+ 2 4 % 4 #$
C 5+ / L $ 3 '4% '4 % .#
? *

$F
 ! ( & '

' ' 8 ") = 0 5+ 7 ,

D ! " &4 97 ( = %
T 7 8 ! & 5+ &+ /' M @4 4! @ 6 E
-" 6M 4 4 @" =
' M 4 &( 5+ 2+ 5 24 *' E
? 8+ 97 ( 8% 6 +2 = %
4 ' % 5+ )' 5 $0 !" Q E
'" = - & # ' 34 H & 6
& A '" = - & ) : 5 %
? 5+ )' ) : % - &
, % @4 - , / M 5+ % )' " /0 - ! E
%1 1 ' !& % %' ! 3C A
* % 4 @( '' % 5+ #3
4 7 & 54 =% /0 %' ; % 'L
6 5 ,@ = - & #$ ! M - 4 ) % ,%
/ B4 '" ! " ,( 3 , % 4 > 6 !& . % %
? % = &+ /' 7 6 %& 2 ,@

5
 ! ( & '

" G[ )-,V
% )' ) ' 4 $ & : $ % 5+ 0
! & 4% 8 9 7 = #$ ' 2' '
, % !" -' @ J 2' /0 ;6 #
? 5+ I &4 N <#$ 1
; 6 / /' 4 =% - ) ' 5+ 4
!& 4 & 5 $0 @ 9, 2% % + %' ,
4 & 5 % = - & <4 8% , @ K6 U ' /4& $ ' ' 4
5 5+ ! & *% 4& . *4 ,% ! " 5
> @ I &4 3C * I &4 35+ 4 4 ' I &4F B;1 5+ I &4
? G54 4 &
<# $ 5 5+ 9 , 1 7 ' 4 ;6 4%
.# % !" 4 !& %7 * " 5M 14 '
& /0 = - & ! ' 5+ > &
? 5+ %" 5+ 44 '
<#$ #6 3 ) $ 6 5+ - ,
8 >4 .# 3 I &4 / 0 ' 4& 2 2 -
% +2 I &4 '@ ! " 5+ I &4 / '% / 3 # 5+
? % +2 I &4
? 2 ,% A ( & 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 ! " ,( 0

5
 ! ( & '

1O 4@ 54 4 & 5+ ! " >4

54 4 & >@ I &4 4 & % K6 97
! ' B 5+ I &4 - 4 ' ' % )
? 5+ I &4 8 > & ' * = - & 24 $4& @
5+ I &4 > & / 4% * 8 " B4 ' 7 % #6
> 5 % = - & 4 &; 8 + C .# +2 @ '
-6 54 4 & = - & % .4 C = - &
? 5+ !& ;
, 0 / % 3 I &4 <# $ 4 . 2+ 9 < 4
9 * 4( 4 ( @ 4 % /
Z & = '' & !" $ % 5+ > &
! & 4& 5+ " /4& 5 $ 0 @ 9, / 8" B /
= 1 & 3 & / /' @" % % @
+2 %% 542 7 7 $ 5+ B +2 K6 Z
3 ' & 1 ! !& @ = 4 1" 2 ' '
? 8 97 8' ' = )' ) ' )'
& I &4 & 5 & $ B;1 5+ I &4 = - & 5+ /
!' & , I &4 $ & !& ,% 8%7 % '" 3 %&
? +2 % + # 5+
$ A & $+ - K2 6 & 5+ I &4 +
38 & 8 &B = 4 ' 4 # 5+

5
 ! ( & '

0 ' * - , $ 3 % +2 4 % +2 5 %
= 9 , 7 ! " @O 2@ @+ !'
= 6- / & 5+ I &4
? ,% / @-
% 6 5 24 *% 5+ I &4 0 K 6
& , , % 5+ I &4 & K 6 9+ 5+
= M ' /4& ' $ 8- #" ' ,%
? ' ,% 0 C * I &4 1'
G+2 F ,% ' = % * , /4& 9 ,
5+ I &4 * + /4& 1 $ A 54& @ *,
5 7 # 5+ ' $ 54& % <#$ % 3 I &4
@ /$+ / 6 54 &L 5+ !& 4& 4 = & 54 %'
/ 6 , % /+ 54& % <#$ 3 > - = & 9+ 5 1"
?
+2 % 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 5+ I &4 &
= - & 8+ 8 &+ " , & +2 ! 6J &= %
I &4 <# 38 + ! &8 54 &" )- B ) : 5 %
+2 Z' C * I &4 ! " ,( 3 6 -
'2 5+ I &4 $ 4 4 4& 8+ -% %

5#
 ! ( & '

- ' !& 5 %' 5 %' 5+

)- 3 @ .4 C 4, ) 6 %
! " % 54 &L C /+" 8+ ! & *@ 4& 4 ,% +2
?8
.# % +2 % $ % 54 4 & >@ I &4 6
8 + 3 % - 8+ 8'7 ) ' +
+2 )- / / 4 & 4 &; C
? & <#$ ' >@
/2 @ = !" 4 ' #" & 0 > # 5+ I &4 <#$
= ) 8 1" I &4 <#$ * )- /1 # 4 ' @
?= # 8+ 1L 7 "
' -% 5+ M' 5+ I &4 * 4 /
; 9 , >; 6 8 ,% / #$ ; I &4
? &4

5$
V2 & !" B #$ 8 =' ;6
D @
D V2 D
D $ V2 & ! " ' 4 <#$ ;6 6
8'7 K6 $ 4 5 -' - ' & 5 & 5+ b
' 3= % = ! & < A -'
/ = % = ! " - ' <#$ 4 ' '3 & &= ) 3
?4 '
0 # = % 97 ' $0 & $ 5+
$ 4@ +2 # ) A %% = - 4@ 0 #$ 3 =
%% 0 #$ = - 4@ 3 8 - ' *, 6 !& ; = )
$ L 8 7 6 % *, % - 5+ ' 3I 6
? 5 -6 $ 1J %
4 5 -6 >2 0 % 0 " @ 4 5+ /A
4% & % 1N 5 -6 $ <# 0 3
0 B . 2+ * 3 !& 0 !&
% / , 6 4 5+ 6 &! . 2+ 9
? 4( 4 ( @/ , , 4
/1 5+ & , / & 4 % B
? 5+ I &4 = - & 6 2 ( 4& % 4 ( @
? # " $)" # # . 2+ % /0 5+ 4 #
;6 # 4 % / , 5+ . 2+ 9 > / b
7 4 @ , 4 B 4; C 8 " $#
55
 )' 8 #38 )' #$ 5+
-6 9 *% ! # 3 %7 : & ): 7 %
8 "5 5+ . # $ M <#$ @
5+ 5 -, 7 -&" 4 R ,% 8%7 % 4%
? % A 7 '
4 6 ; 5+ + . 2+ % b
5+ I &4 ' * #$ A 3 )' /4 % +
C ) )' & ; <#$ '
? - % 5 1 !& 0
4 4 % $4 4 ! & " 5+ 4 . 2+ % b
? 5+ @ $ ) - ' 4 <#$ ,
7 6 = % -% = % !& 4 5+
8 " $# >; 6 ! & #$ 5+ ; Z . 2+ %
= ) $ M' / 7 ) #?
8 !& . 2+ 4 % G F 54 K 5+ I &4 * 6
? 6 = % ! & 5+ 4 +
.4 $ '' !& . 2+ % 5+ / % b
+2 / % 5 $0 4 & & .4 3.
' 54 & 4 5+ % !& -' 8
+ 8'7 5+ .4 +2 Z 4@ = % % 8 &
% G 7 54 / ,9 4% 3 - ' < %
? -' = - & 4 5 -' 5 4

5
 4 5 -' .# - ' I ' / 54 <#$ . 2+ 9
= - /A 3 /4 6 * 1 < M M 8 .# +2 /'L
M' . 2+ 9 <44 .# = - 1 *' -' 5+
=4 # 8 'L %% +2 )' +2 / 8 4 94 '
/ /$ A ) ' , & +2 / -' > / &
4 % 6 7 54 K 4 # 4 5+ <#$ 5
/$ O$ 4 9 !& @ -' 5+
?< M M %% +2
5+ 6 0 . . 2+ 9 #6M b
+ # 3 % $ 1J B4 ! $ & 5 ,-
* < A )' .# 84 .# , +2
? 5+ I &4
= % B , 5+ % 5+ . 2+ 9 = 4% b
4 5+ $ G. .4 F 9 !
D B $ A 1J % &) @
)' ) ' )' - ' !& 5 % 5+ Y
? . 2+ % )' /4 % %
= 1( ' # % 5+ % #6 Y
4 / % ! 8 &= ) $ % +2 M % C B 3 %
@ -' @ !& @ 5+ $ 3 # & !&
5+ ! B @= - & # K6 3 ' & 1

5<
! & @ % 5+ 1 3 % 5+ !& @ 4
?
i # $ 1" & 4 5+ % <#$ ,7
C 7 # 3 5+ % !& &+ 1 + + +2
+2 !7 8 &4 # & &4 1 ! $ +2 %
? 5+ 8&+ !& %1 ) # !% 8% 1" )&
0 .# 4 % & 4 <4 .4 !& G , 5+ F 1 / % Y
- ' &5 & $ , 5+ 3 % +2 4& 4
, % % K6 !& #" !, % K6 $
!& 3 % * =7 24 $ % > 6 *, 4 : )'
4@ % * =7 + = ! " 54 ' 4@ % 5+ >;6
? #
8 4 .# #" % 5+ ' , 5+ /A
5 $ $ 0 ; " 4 *, $ @
?
/4 % )' 1 5+ &) 1 % b
>;6 ' = - & 5+ % 9 + +2 7 ,
54 ! " > 6 5+ 54 ," /, " 1 $ A 54& @ 9
? 5+ - +; 54 /4 % 54 T 87 ' 5+
5+ ! & ,% 8%7 % * 4% 5+ $ 0 b
B % 5 4 % 6 8 1 .# = & 0 > #
4 M 4 8 ;6 =% .# - ) ' <#$

5%
= - & 5 $0 9, H ) / % + %'
? ,%
B;1 5+ I &4 $ 6 I &4 % 5+ 2+ %
3C * I &4 3 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 $ 24 %' 1
? 54 4 & >@ I &4
54 4 & >@ I &4 C * I &4 ! 5+ - b
$ 8 4 94 , +2 + # @ 5+
? &4 $ !" 8+ ' M 5+
* * = 8 !-& B M' # . 2+ 9 ! 1 '" 4@
3 2+ ,% # #6 6 EE !" 7 5+ I &4
8 # 5+ I &4 * * = M' 9 !-&
4%& 9 # $ <#$ M' + 4@ 3 , +2 2' 4 K6 &"
? 5 < " (
5+ $ 8& $ % , +2 < A I #
<+ .# !& / ; 3 /$ A 8 4 94
6 5+ I &4 = - & # , % 4 /
? +2 ) A 4&
' % +2 Z ) 8 I 5+ 1 =% '
G, 4 5+ ! F 5+ I &4 * = , &/ @ +2
3 5+ % !& %' -' , +2 # - "
/4 6 8 * < M M 8 ; %% +2 +2 #"
? 5+ I &4 ! " = 8

5F
 # 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 * = , +2 !-& 9 b
/' / ! & 5 -6 1 0& -6 5+ I &4 1
? &
5+ $ @ + " % 5+ I &4 # !&
= +2 !" 0 4 %' # 5+ 3 4 *,
3 2 ' ' ' A ' . 3 <+ .#
/ @ 1L 7 "8 &= ) 8 <+ .# % 8 1" 8 ) -
8& *4 8 9+ #" = # 8+ 4 ' *-' ! - 5+
? 8+ 8% 44 & >@ ) - 8 & .4 & #" C
# Z ' & & !& / % 5+ /A b
A /4 % % )' Z ' & & !& 8+ / % .# +2
I &4 * * = +2 #$ Z )' 8 I
+2 # 8 U ' $ # 5+
> - 4& . +2 # : # 6J K6 5+
I &4 <#$ * *-' 8 " ' 2 ,% 4 8 " )$# #$ 3 :
? 4& %- $ 8 Z ' .# 4, : 4,
% 6 7 54 K 54 + ,7 - "b
1 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 8 " >4 .# C : * C 4
7 !" % + %' 4 M & /' /
> 5 % / @ % #6 ! " 4 6 4 4 *, = 9 ,
= 8+ ) : Z ,% / # 3 ,% ! " 4
/ @ % 4 4 '( 5 % '" ! & 4 H * 8 +2 5+ ,7
 = - &! ,7 = 5+ &B !& : * , 8
? 5+ % !& 4 +
! " G8 & !&4 F ) : # 7 -&" $ , #
5+ ) ' 4 = - I &4 C * I &4 * " ,%
?> 5 %
# 5+ $ 5+ I &4 . $ '2 4 "b
$ !" $ = . = & %'
. # %' 4 @ $ & 5+ $ %
3 '4 8' & % $ & 6 ' .4
/4& 54& @ 9 *, G F= & 5+ ;% ' ,
% 8 & !A . ,- I &4 5+ I &4 * +
?= I &4 & + 35+ I &4 5+ %'
& 5+ ;% '( &4 9 $ @ , /A
5+ 54 @; 1M 4@ 9 I L
4 5+ I &4 = - Q 4 ) 8 # $ 4 *-'
.# 7 /0 $ '' , 1M #$ / 0 /0
7 V2 8 - .# 54 4 & >@ I &4 9 8,
5+ 4% #" ' 54 5+ ' - /1 3 = I &4
*, 4% /& &C / 5 % 5+ 4% B4 #" 5 @ 4 / 4@
4' ' ! & ,7 1 = 54 ' - , 9
? 7 .4 +2 Z # @ ' !& ,7 4 %
5+ I &4 % - & B4 4& 8 , ;6 b
$ %- !" 9 , #$ 4 %7 %
 & , I &4 & 5 & " ' * - 5+ I &4 /A
/0 & % ' 8 # /2 @ @ /0 # 5+ ! " >4
* . #$ "= &> 6 @+ 5+ 2 =%
- 4 & I &4 <# $ 0 ' ,@ K 6"
?= M ' /4& ' 1 8 6"
-6 # $ @ 6M -6 $ ' $4 %
' /4 4 % 3< 1" ) " 5+ I &4 , 7
? 5+ % + ' /4& $ = M
4 a4 4 & ' ' ,% 0 ;
' 5+ &+ ,% K 6 *' # ,%
<#$ 1 Q + * 4 + -6 5+ !& 4& & #" 6
?
#3 2 ' = % 5 % / Y
? 44 = =6 4 9+ 9 , ' / 6 = $/ 70
= % 8 5+ I &4 4 / 4 #
/ 6 !& " 8 / #$ 3 5+ M' ! & %
5+ I &4 4 / 8 "3 - / /+
/ A 8+ I &4 0 ,% 4% I &4 '
I &4 &4 44 &) 5+ I &4 /
? 5+ 2 &) I &4 /
-6 Z K2 % .4 7 A ++ V2 <#$ ! &
D U %
B ' 4 !" Q @ 0 !& . 2+ % . b
B ' 4 % 2 -&" / ( 6
5+ 9 , M ' 4 / O /0 # F %
?G . % /0 8
% 4 % 54 % K 44 0 54 &" b
/0 2+ * ! 5+ 9 ,
' 'M / , Z' 4 4&" , H ) %
/ 0 # $ K2 6* , ! H H _ O . %
? 824
) ' 5+ % 2' * /0 I4 4@ . 2 + 9 /A b
4 % , # )' /4 % /0 'M )' ) '
4 % 5+ I &4 / 4 & 5+ 9 , I4
U % 3) C 7A 9 " 4( 4 @
* I &4 + - / 8 @K 64
! 7 4( 4 ( @ 54 4 & >@ I &4 C
6 G 7 4 5+ 4 4 ' I &4 /0 -% 5 (
2' * V &4 64 4 "U % # % 7
? & & 7
% 54 5+ / M % 4 Q 4" )' 8" b
4 ( @/ ,G !" 0K !" "F 4 4
e 4(
= 2 4& @ , 4 <#$ # @4 1 9 !
? ,% / 5+ I &4 @-
#
 % 4 C 54 & , -6 C Z b
1 & , M-6 8 .# G 7 D 54 K 4
Z : 8 M & 6 ! & / % .# 9
& Z ' & 6 ) 8'7 +2 8 M 6
M -6 Z : # : Z ' & # !& 4
D 6 7 54 K 4
8 & !& 6 4 8 ! & K6 8 M & ! & 5+ / % F
?GZ ' ' !& :
% 6 7 54 K 4 & , M-6 Z !" , Y
= 6 ) - M' * #$ ??????F 5 & 1 4
) - "C = ) - M' # 3GC 8 C
D 5 # 3C $ 8% < &4 ;6 C
GC 8 % 8 C 6 ) - M' * #$ F
6 E 7 4 K -6 Z 5 , !" ,
? ' 4 " 4 %
6 7 54 K 54 + ,7 - :" U % Y
5+ 9 A* C - #$ *, #! %
? $4 4 ' I &4
/ 0 , # 3 / '7 M / @ % ,@ 4 H Z ' 8
= G) : F8 & !&4 5+ ! 8+ 4 4 ' 8 & !&4
I &4 * ,7 = 5+ &4 .# ) : #$ / % + * ,7
* + /4& 54& % = 6 8 - #$ 3 =% ' I &4 C *
!& 2% ,7 = 5+ 8 I &4 5+ I &4
? +2 A #$ &/ 4 ' K ! " , % .4O @ 4'
$
 0 8 " /4 # 54 4 & >@ I &4 = 7 /0 :" b
%' & , I &4 $ &L 54 4 & >@ I &4 * ! 8
? ' 4 1 $ #/ ) 'H = I &4 &
-* ! 1 % 6 7 54 K 4 9 / %
44 $ K #$ 4 5+ I &4 $ &L 54 4 & >@ I &4
? @ " ' 5+ I &4 I &4 <#$ 8 & / % .# '
8 5+ I &4 0 ' ,@ K 6 *' U % b
2' = - &5 ' 54 + $ &+ 4 4)
D 42 7 =% 8 ' 4
# 7 5+2 5 @ 4& 5 6 4 &/ M 4 >'
? .4 ,% 4 A #$ 3 $ 4 4 .
, 5+ 8 @ 4& & , , % /4- 1 B
7 )' # I 6 $ 5 4 54 4 5+ / % 4& )'
#$ Z ' ; - @ ) - - /' & , ,% / 5+ I &4
?8 ! " *, 54 &" $4 ) 9, : I 6 @+ / % @
4 & / ) ' - 5+ % &+ 44& 54 + " b
& *@ + )' 4 9+ 4 4 4& >% / B ' &
? 5+ 9+ /2 ) " 4 !" 5+ !&
! & .4 / % !" 5 4 5 , , % > 0 <#$ I #
!& ' Z K % @ 2 5+
4 ! " 4@ 4 &" 2 5+ 7 ! " .4O 3 2 ,%
? 5+ I &4 = - & 5+ 4 !" ,(

5
 ! "# $!

$ ) 6 ' )* 6 . /

o )* R ŠŠ hI
3 3 B 1 + 3 #I J " ." 3 + 3 4 k
? # 3 1 1 -
3 + 3 . * 3 0 34 4 ,7 k
##% 3 ! - 3 3 ) 4
3) 4 34 / 4& =% 3 #RF, J * 3 . 6+ k #
? # 3 1 - 3 5 $%
3# #>? 8" ." 3 3 k $

? ## 3 ! - 3 3)
3= 43 + E6 * ." F # , . #I ." k 5
? 3 1 1 - 3

II

# 8% # . 3 , 34 ' k
3 4 3G# 8% # . $ ! 8" 7 , 8"
? ##' 3 5 $ %
4 '( 3 > 5M 3 1 "E 4 34' k
? # 3 1 - 3
 ! "# $!

! ! ! " 5 / * 34 =+ 4& 3 . ' k #

3 @ % 3 1 4 3 *' + 3 6 #$" *$ ,* F
3 54 4 1 1 - 3
7!! !" 5 / * 34 =+ 4& 3 . ' k $
3 54 4 1 1 - 3 3 @ % 3 1 4 3 G #$"
?

! ! ! " 5 / * 34 =+ 4& 3 . ' k 5

- 3 3 @ % 3 4 3G ) ! 8" 7
? 3 54 4 1 1

3 , #$" *$" ! ) 3 &4 3 k

? ##% 3 3 @ %
3 1 1 - 3 4 '( 3 > 5 3 34 3 k <

? ##%
# $" * $ ,* " ,*$ 3 U 7 4 & . 4@ 3 . k %
? 3 4 '( 3 > 5 3 " 8" : /)

, #* ! 7 # 8% # . 3Q / 4 & 3 54 k F
? \ - ? ?4 [ 3 3 , 43G 8"
#1 ?)" #$" F # 8% # . 3/ 4& 3 . 4 k
? # %3 1 - 3 3 14 - 3 6 >,*$ ,* >1
& - 43 # !" # # " 34 4 3 ' k
? ##% 3 1 1 - 3 4 '( 3

<
 ! "# $!

- 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 #$" 34 !7- 3 k

? 3 1
# >) " # !" 34 3+ &3 4 +& 3 . 4 k #
?\-? ?4[ 3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 2 +? 2
+ 3 # !" 5 / 3 '3P k $
? 3 2+ 3 & - .4 4
& - 43# !" 3 % 4 3 k 5

?\-? ?4 [ 3 2+ 3
43 : / ) # . 8) >/ 3 3 k
? 3 2+ 3 46

& - 43 1 + 3 & .)*" 2 34 3 $ k <

? \-? ? 4 [ 3 2+ 3
# . # . # . #$" ,@K E 0 7 4 & 3 54 & k %

? ' 3 2+ 3 $ 43 : /)
3 *+ / 4 3 # !" 35 & 3 B: k F
? 3 2+
? ## 3 5 $ % 3 , 4 3 #$" *$ ,* 3 4 ' 3 k
43 1 " !! ) 3 .4 7- 3 $ k
? %3 4 '( 3 & -
& - 43 ) ! B &B ! 3 .4 7- 3 $ k

? ## 3 4 '( 3
%
 ! "# $!

& - $ 43# . 1 " 3 &3 .4 3 3 @ + k #

' 3 2+ 3
3 & - $ 43 >/ "E &3 .4 k $
? ' 3 2+
& - $ 4 3 #8 B # . #$" # " E &3 .4 5
? ' 3 2+

? '3 4 '( 3 B 4 ) 3 3 3 -
) 3 &B 1 + 3 !" 5 / & " 3 3 - <
? ' 3 4 '( 3 B 4

5 3 G ' !8 " >" $ 7 # 8% # . 3 ' 3< %

? ##X 3 - 3 4 '( 3 >
3> 5 E ! " $ " 3 ' 3< F

? ##X 3 4 '(
& - 4 3 *$" ! ) 3 54 3G. + F .4 #
? 3 2+ 3

= $ +? 2 ! :2 , # $ " 3 ' 3 7- #
?\-? ?4[ 3 4 '( 3 > 5 3 F%F 1 0)
#1 ?)" # $ " 7 # 8% # . 3 ' 4 3 #
?\-? ?4[3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 6 >,*$ ,* E > 1
43 2 )" 2 : "3 ' >' 3 4 ##
? ##X 3 5 $ % 3 * + 4
F
 ! "# $!

# 8% # . 7 8" !" 5 /E 4 3 ' #$

#X 3 1 - 3* + E 6 >,*$ ,*
# . 7 ! % !" 5 /3 4 4 4 3 ' #5
4 3 *+ %1 3 1 + 6 #$" *$ ,* E # 8%
? ### 3 - 3
43 . % = % 3 /$ " 34' #

? ##X 3 3 & - ,
3> 5M 3G F = % 3 /$ " 34' #<
? 3 4 '(
1! , :" !1 !1 3 4 =+ 4& 4 3 /;& #%
? 3 4 '( 3 B 4 ) 3 &8 1!
7 43 *" *$" ! ) 34 4 3 4 & #F
? 3 4 '( 3
4 3 "F* +? ,# . #$" *)$ 3 4 6 3 4& $
? %3 4 '( 3 & -
3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 4 :2 , . ; ") E 4 6 3 4& $
? ##
5 3 . 1! :2 # # !" # " 34 6 3 4& $
? ## 3 4 '( 3 >
3 & - 43 1 " # $ " 34 6 3 4& $#
?\-? ?4[3 4 '(

<
 ! "# $!

5 3 # !" 1! K # ". !/ 34 6 3 4& $$

## 3 - 3 4 '( 3 >
+ 3B 1 + 3 # # !" # " 3 3 - 4& $5
? 3 1 - 3 4 '( 3 % 4 R ' 7
3 ! " P 8 1 .) : " 3C 3) 4& $
? '3 ' - 3 % 7 / & 3 4
# $" 7 # 8% # . 34 @ 4 3 4& $<
? '3 4 '( 3 > 5M 3 3 6 + 1 #1 ?)"

35 $ % 3 7 43# $ " 3 .4 3 4& $%

? # X
3 7 43 # " 1! $ 3/ 4 & 3 54 $F

? ## 3 4 '(
+ ? 2 # .)*" 1 " # 4 " Q8 3 / 4 & 3 54 5
? 3! - 3 3 7 9 ( 3 2

"% 2 3) = 4 3 4 4 3 &4 3) 5
?\-? ? 4 [ 3 '4 ' - 3 4 '( 3 7 4 3 # .)*"

? # 3 5 $% 3 7 43 !" 2 9! ," 3 .4 3 )A 5

<
 ! "# $!

D !" GIII
4 . 2+ 4 % , # X^ #^ _ O X ^ X Y
? /@ 44 3 # X^ #^% 6 O ' 54 3/
4 ( @ , # ^ ^ _ O X'^ Y
? ' /@ 44 3 # ^ ^ # 6 O ' 54 3 !: . 2+
'M , Z' 4 4&" , # X^ ^ _ O '^ X Y#
? # 44 3 # X^ ^ 6 O ' 54 3. % '

Z' 4 4&" , # ^ %^ X _ O ^ /@ .# 7 / ' YY$

e % 44 3 # ^ '^ % 6 O ' 54 3/ ,
' 'M , # ^ %^ X _ O %^ /@ .# 7 / ' Y5

? % 44 3 # ^ '^ % 6 O ' 54 3. %
)' /4 % 1" , # %^ X^ _ O %X ^ % /@ / ' Y
6 O ' 54 3 > &( , 5 4%& 4 4&"

? 44 3 # %^ ^ '
3. % 8 @ , ## ^ ^ _ O X^# % Y<
? '# /@ 44 3 ## ^ ^ 6 O ' 54

- ; @ , ## ^ ^ _ O % ^# % Y%
? X /@ 44 3 ## ^ ^ 6 O ' 54
4 4&" 7 , ## ^ ^ _ O X'^# /@ .# 7 / ' YF
? % 44 3 # ^ ^% 6 O ' 54 3 ' 5+ 54
= " 'M , ^ ^ _ O ^ /@ % Y
3 . %& = % = - & 4' / ' %
<
 ! "# $!

? X 44 3 ^ ^ 6 O ' 54
= ^ X^ # _ O ' ^ /@ .# 7 / ' Y
^ X^ X 6 O ' 54 3 4' / ' . % =%
44
4 @ , ^ ^ X _ O #^ /@ % Y
44 3 ^ '^ % 6 O ' 54 3 44 4

# IV
^\+J \+J \ 2 -\ 9 \F 4 R \] 2 .R S 1 1[1/ G
& _ IJ =/ 6 R " . <_ `1 ?60 .

4 ( ' /0 )' /4 % F 3 54 3 G. +F .4 Y
3 3=2 1 4 ' /'@ 3 1 + 3 % : 2 ,%
? ' 3 2+

4 ' /'@ 3 ! 2 ,% 3 G 5+ I &4 F 3 = 4 3Q Y#

? 3 K 6 44& 3 3
3 % : 2 ,% 4 ( G )' /4 % F 3 3 & '

? ' 3 2+ 3 3 =2 1 4 ' /'@ 3 1 +

$% &' V

3 =2 1 /'@ 3 1 + 3 % : 2 ,% 4 (
? ' 3 2+ 3
44 3 2+ 3 3 4 ' /'@ 3 ! 2 ,%
? ## 3
2<#
 ! "# $!

, (! )* +
Les livres :

1 - A lex weill , Droit civil ( les biens) , éditions dalloz , paris , deuxieme
édition , 1974 .

2 - Braudry lacantinerie, traité de droit civil ( de la prescription ) , tome

28 , édition daloz , paris .

3 - Michel de juglart ., Et autres , cours de droit civil , tome 1 , éditions

Montchrestien , paris , treizième édition , 1997 .

4 - Colin et Capitant , traité de Droit Civil français , tome 2 , par juliot la

morandiere , 1959 .

5 - Jeana louis bergel , et autres , traite de droit civie , les biens ,edition delta ,
paris , 2000 .

6 - Philipe bihr , droit civil géneral , éditions dalloz , paris , treiziéme édition ,

2000.

27$
 % &'

) [ (O
/$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$#"! "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ! >") &8
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ / 7 6 - D & % A ,"
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ D& % "
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ / 7 - D @ "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ / 7 D @ A ,"
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ > D& % "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ : 5+ > D& % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ;- 5+ > D @ S ?
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ;'( 8%7 5+ > D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 8%7 5+ > D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C 5+ > D @ @
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ % - D @ "
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = 5+ D& % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 @ 5+ D @ S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ @ /0 4@ 5+ + DA @ "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ + D& % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ; ' 5+ + D @ S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 *, 5+ + DA @ S ?
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . 2 + % 5+ / D & % &8?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ & 5+ D & % A ,"
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ D& % "
<5
 % &'

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ B 5+ D & % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ % D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ @ A D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 U
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 6 4 Y
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ @ % Y%
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 9 Y'
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = % B 5+ D @ S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ + +2 = % D<
%%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ + + = % D @
%%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 6 = % Y
%'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = % Y
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ . % /0 B 5+ DA @ S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . % /0 > D<
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ /0 5+ D @
%# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5 4%& Y
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 54 U
'' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . % =% & -" 4 'U%
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ D @ "
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ .4 D& % S ?
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ .4 / 7 D<
'#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ .4 & D @
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 5 -' D @ @
<
 % &'

X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ 4 " +2 = - &5 4 5 -' U

X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ : % 5 4 5 -' Y
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ : -' 4 5 - ' U%
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 9 !& 4 5 - ' U'
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . D @ S ?
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . / 7 D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . 4 1" D @
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . %7 0 D @ @
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 6 0 Y
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 0 Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 0 . 2+ 9 >@ D .,
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ $4 & / % D *" B
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 6 " b
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ Z ' &Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 9 DA @ "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ D& % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ > D<
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ - D @
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 24 $ 5+ G
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ G
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5 $ 0 5+ G %
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5 ' 5+ G4
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ D @ S ?
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ / 7 D<
<<
 % &'

# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ /& , +2 D @
#'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ / D @ @
#'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ 1J U 1
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ % "e
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ K2 6 U%
##$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , 5+ 1" U'
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ @ 5+ !" , 5+ 7 : D .,
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ : 7 Y
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ +2 7 Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ : 1" Y%
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ + % 5+ )' D @ A ,"
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ )' D & % "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' % 5+ )' D & % S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$ ' / 7 D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ ' 1" D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' % 5+ )' D @ S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ '/ 7 D<
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ ' 1" D @
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ % "D @ "
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ / > 6 ! " 5+ % "D& % S ?
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ / > 6 ! " 5+ % "! D<
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ & 7 * / >6 ! " 5+ % "D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ / 87 6 5+ 54 ! " > ' 5+ 54 /, + D @ @
<%
 % &'

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ K6 >6 ! " 5+ % "D @ S ?

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8 " 5+ % "- K6 >6 D <
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ / ' D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ .+ / ' D @ @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ K 6 > 6 5+ 7 D .,
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ K 6 > 6 5+ 54 ! " > ' 5+ 54 /, D *" B
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ?5+ +DA @ "
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4 % L 5+ +D& % S ?
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ +2 54 7 54 ( D <
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % > D @
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ +2 & A 5+ 4% D @ @
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <4 .4 4%7 5+ +D @ S ?
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ +2 4% D <
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 5+ +2 4% D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <4 . 4%7 5+ +DA @ S ?
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$& % &8? #8FB
%%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ D @ &8?
%X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ / -( D & % A ,"
%X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 6 D& % "
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 6 D& % S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % $ - 5+ I &4 0D<
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' 7 % 5+ I &4 D @
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . 2+ % 5+ I &4 D @ @
<F
 % &'

' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ D @ S ?
'%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$/ Z = &( D <
'X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ +2 6 = 1 &( D @
'X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$= !& @ 5+ Y
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = ' 5+ Y
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = )' ' 5+ Y%
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 2 6 5+ I &4 -D @ "
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 % - D& % S ?
'# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 @ I I# < ( D<
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 & , I I# 1 < ( D @
X%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . 2 + ,% >@ D @ @
XX$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 K2 6D @ S ?
XX $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8 " 4 '( = &B 4 # 5+ 5+ I &4 D <

X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 4 % 5+ D @
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ '( * - 5+ . &4 D @ @
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C I &4 ' 5+ I &4 D .,
X#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ I &4 % - DA @ "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ D& % S ?
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 7 D @ S ?
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 54 .+ 4' 5 D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 5+ 54 D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ,% $ DA @ S ?
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$4 - D :, S ?

%
 % &'

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 & K 6( D J" B S ?

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ K 6( D <
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ & K 6( D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ I &4 I &4 * + /4& 54& @ D J! * S ?
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ I &4 5+ I &4 @; D <
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ I &4 I &4 * /4& 54& @ , D @
X$$$$$$$$$$$$ &4 * + /4& 54& @ ! & 1N + ( D@ @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &4 * + /4& 54& @ / 6 Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &4 /+ 54& % Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8 & &4 /+ 54& % Yk
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &4 * /4& 54& @ ,% Y
I &4 0 / 5+ I &4 4 / I4 D .,
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ I &4 D @ A ,"

# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$5+ 4 4 '" I &4 D & % "
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % - 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 > D& % S ?
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 > D<
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 % - D @
#'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 / 6 D @ S ?
#'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 &4 D<
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 8 & !&4 D @
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 @- DA @ S ?
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % +2 &4 D<
# $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' ! " .4O 5+ ! & 4 &" 9 @ D @
%
 % &'

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' & % 54 5+ ' D @ @

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ )' W ' ;6 I &4 * D .,
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$8 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 / D :, S ?
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$?5+ 4 4 '" I &4 / D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' & % 54 4 &4 5+ D0 % # G
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5 % &+ " ' ' / &4 5+ D# @ # G
!&4 5 % 8 9+ / ' &4 5+ /4 / D #@ @ # G#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ,7 = 5+ !" 4 ' / 8 &
8 & !&4 5 % 8 9+ / ' /4 / &4 5+ D #., # G$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ? ,7 = 5+ !" 4 '
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 4 / D 1
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' ,% / & 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ & , ,% / & 5+ 4 4 '" I &4 Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 D @ "
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 > D& % S ?
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 / 6 D @ S ?
%$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 &4 D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 8 & !&4 D @
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 @- DA @ S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 8 C @ % +2 &4 D<
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % 8+ +2 C *% D @
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$.4 C Y
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ % C Y
%
 % &'

'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 5 4( 6 6 : &/ C Y%
'$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$9 -% " 4 ' 54 5+ ' D @ @
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C W ' ;6 I &4 * D .,
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $8 C * I &4 4 / - D :, S ?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $C * I &4 4 / -D<
#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C * I &4 4 / D @
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 D A @ "
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 > D& % S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 / 6 D @ S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 &4 D<
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 8 & &4 D @
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 54 4 & >@ I &4 @- DA @ S ?
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C @ 8 ) - % +2 &4 D<
% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ 5+ 44 54 4 & 9 @ 1D @
%#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ @ ! & ' 54 5+ '" D @ @
%#$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ' ;6 I &4 <#$ * D .,
' $$$$$$$$8 54 4 & >@ I &4 4 / - D :, S ?
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ?54 4 & >@ I &4 4 / - D<
' $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $ 54 4 & >@ I &4 4 / D @
X $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ @ &8? #8FB
XX$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ #") B
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ! 8" : " #"
X$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ J >?
%#
 )#* + ( ( (,
"# -!) # . "#/ ,

4 ! "5 01 2 ! # # 3
$ "# .67

223 4 5 ( ! )# &* + , - . ) /01

-. / 0 1!2

F% % ! " #$
 )#* + ( ( (,
"# -!) # . "#/ ,

4 ! "5 01 2 ! # # 3
$ "# .67

223 4 5 ( ! )# &* + , - . ) /01

-. / 0 1!2

F% % ! " #$
Y'