Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Patrick Gros
N˚0238
Février 2000
THÈME 3
apport
technique
ISSN 0249-0803
!"#$%"
&('*),+.-0/21
3453%6798;:=<46>
?@BA%C=DEFHGJILKMDONQPSRTKQUWVSIX@BVSCYC=D%Z[C
PR\@*UWIBDS]
U^C
P`_SDOaO]cbBVIBIBdODOaO]BRVSIBI*P`UeaQaMPI*RD.a
fgNQV`hiD%K"jkUeaiK\P
lmPnBnoVNMKpKQDOR\@BI*U^qLrBDsItSuSv`ESwYFyxd%zcNQUWDONmv`uuSu$F|{2}2?P`~B^D$bDOaC
P`KMU^A%NQDOaQarB~aD.RTKMU^VI E* n*P`_SDOa
cODbVRr*CYDOILKkDOaKkrBIBDUWILKMNQVbr*RKMU^VI
[ PW_SA%~BNQDsKMDOI*aMVNQUWDOW^D$nVSrBNmIBVSIC
P2KM@*d%C
P2KQUZ
R%UWDOI*aORNQUWKMD50 VNQU^_U^IBD
bBP`I*aWD5ROPbNQD
bD
^PzcUeaU^VIn*PN$VN\bUWIP2KMDOrBN.]D%^WD=KQUWNQD5bD5RD
bVSC
P`U^IBD]
D%K(bD^P
_Sd%VSCYd%KMNQUWD$n*NMVhiDORTKQUWzSD$KMNQAOakD%C=nB^V2dOD$D%IzcUeaU^VI]qSr*D%eqSr*DOamD%D%C=nB^DOaOg^^DRVSILKMU^D%ILKkrBIBD
PnBnBNQVR\@BDUWILKQrBUKQUWzSDDKrBIBDU^ILKMNQVbr*RTKQUWVSInBWra5VSNMC=D%^^DbDOaXIBV`KQUWVSI*aXbD~*PaMD¡ pR%V2z2P`NQU^PI*RD¢DK
R%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PI*RDS]cnBNMVbr*UKmKQD%I*aMVNQU^D%[]B~*PaMDOamDK(R\@P`IB_SD%C=D%ILKQa"bBD~*PaMDOaO]R%VILKMN\PRKMU^VIDKkU^Icz2P`NQU^PISK\a%]
ROPa"bD.aDOaMn*PR%DOapD%rR^U^bU^D%Ia%
£¥¤*¦.§\¨©ª«¬PW_SA%~BNQDKMD%IaVSNMU^D%^WD
®^¯±°²´³^µ0¶·³¸`¹`³»ºJ¼
O¦ B¨¦¬?@*U^ambBVcR%rBC=D%ILK"U^a"PIU^ILKMNQVbr*RTKQUWVSIXKQVYKMD%IaVSNMUeP`P`^_DO~BN\PVSNpI*VI¢C
P2KM@*D%C
P2KQU^R%U^PI*a%
´G K Pa *N\aK "NQUWKKMDOIUWI«KM@*D=R%VILKMD%cKsVR%VC=nBrKQD%N$zcUeaU^VIP`I*b«PD DBP`C=nB^DOa$R%VC=DYNMVSC KM@*U^a
D%ebP`I*b«NQVC nBNQV`hiD.RTKQUWzSD
_D%VSC=DKMNQ PSa pD%^[G´KYR%VILKQPUWIaP`I¡U^ILKMrBUWKMU^zDP`nBn*NMVLPR\@¡P`I*b¡PC=VNQD
VSNMC
PUWILKMNQVbr*RKMU^VI=V`~*PaMUeRI*V`KMU^VIa% R%V2z2P`NQU^PI*RDP`I*b=R%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PI*RDS]%KQD%I*aMVNQU^PnBNQVcbBr*RTK.]`~*PaMDOa
PI*bXKMN\P`I*aVNQC
P2KMU^VIa~oDK pD%DOI~PaMDOaO]BRVILKQNQPSRTKMU^VIP`I*bU^ILz2PNMUeP`ILKQaO]R%PSaDsV` gr*R%WUebD.P`IanPRD.a%
§ ¤ KMD%IaVSNMUeP`P`^_DO~BN\P
E
7 98:8
4; \<
=?>@= ACBEDGFHJIKLMD"NOHEBPIQ#RSDTQ#BRQUKVFR
W(P`I*arBID.anPRDzDORKMVSNMU^D%#X Y[Z ]V\]X Y NQD%n*NMd.aDOISKQD
X ^ V`
r _p] WD.akIBVKMU^VI*abD~PaMDaVSILKRDOW^DOa
Bb D$zDORKMDOrBNQaO]qLr VSInoD%rBKP`r*aQaMUP`nBnoD%^D%N"noVU^ILKQaO]BbDRVSISKQNQPUWILKQD^UWI*dOP`U^NQD(D%KkbDaMVr*aD.an*PSRD.a%]bVSISK
VSILKpn*PNKQUWD(^DOap@cLnoD%NQnBeP`I*aOLj±DORTKQD%rBN\apDK@cLnoD%NQnBeP`I*apnoD%rBzSD%ILKJ(KMNQD(NMDOnBNMd.aDOILKMdOan*P`N"bD.apIZ[r*nBWD%KQa
bBDYR%VLVSNQbBVIBIBdODOakVr R%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.abBPI*a(rBIBDY~*PaMDD%K$nDOrBzDOISK.]n*P`NsRDY~BUeP`Uea%a] (KQNMDYC
P`IBU^nBrB^dOasbD
C
PIBUWAONMD$aMD%C~B^P~B^D
GJoD%I5z2PbBDk) C (%C=DkDOI5_dOVC=dKQNMU^D"nBNQV`hiD.RTKMU^zDSb W(P`I*a0 DOaMn*PSRDmnBNQV`hiD.RTKQU' X cdZ]LWD.aDOISKQUKQdOaWD.anB^r*a
aMU^CYn*WD.a±qSr VSInBrBUeaQaDU^ISKQNMVbr*UWNQDpaMVILK WD.a nVSUWILK\a%]2^DOa@ccnDONMnBeP`Ia%],DK±^DOa±R%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMDOa^UWIBd.P`U^NMD.a%,gI
D eoD%KO]2bBPI*Ua X cdZ]2qLr VInoD%rBK PSaMaMUWC=U^WDON X ^fZbgUhjikdl Vm r _nZbgUhjiGkdl].WD.anoVU^ILKQa aMVILK^DOad%^d%C=D%ILK\abD
X cdZ]qLr VI5noD%rBKpNQD%nBNQdOaMD%ILKQD%Ngn*PNpbBDaMUWC=nB^DOazD.RTKMDOrBN\abDsRVcVN\bVSIBIBd%D.a±@BVSCYVS_AOIBDOabBP`I*oa X Y]ZbgUh,
6 U^ILKMNQVcbBr*RTKQUWVSI¢bBD$^P=IBVKMU^VIb UWIbd%noD%I*b*P`I*R%D$WU^IBdOPUWNQDsC=A%IBD
R%D%^WDb @ccnDONMnBeP`I]BDKkPrªPUK
qLrBDWD.a@cLnoD%NQnBeP`I*anDOrBzDOISU K (KMNQDgP`raMaMUSROP`N\PRTKQd%NQU^aMdOaon*PNbD.azD.RTKQD%rBN\abDR%VLVSNQbBVIBIBdODOa@BVSC=V_AOIBDOa
b*P`I*f a X Y]Zpgnh, WkDYeXzcU^D%ILK(^DYnBNMU^I*R%UWnoDYbBDbr*PWUWKMd o^DOa(@ccnDONMn*^PI*amVSNMC=DOISK(rBID.anPRDnBNQV`hiDORKMUW
UeaMVC=VNQnB@Bq D *ªR D.aiKYbUWNQD5bD5) C (OCYD5aKMNQr*RKMrBNQD 2$qLrBD5R%D%^rBUbBDOa$noVU^ILKQaO]DKR%DXqLrBUaO PnBnB^U^qLrBD5Pr
noVU^ILKQanoD%rK(bVI*f R (%KMNQDKQNQPI*aMnVLadsP`r@cLnoD%NQnBeP`I*aO*DOa"bDOrD.anPRD.aaVSISKmbUWKQakbr*P`rB
3IbUeaMnVLaDbVSI*R$bDbBD%r¢IBV`KQUWVSI*amqLrBUaD$C
P`I*UWnBr*WDOISKDKaMD$NMDOnBNQdOaMD%ILKMDOISKkbBD$C=PIBU^A%NQDaU^C=UZ
eP`U^NQDg WD.amzSDORTKQD%rBN\aVr¢^DOaknVSUWILKQaO]BD%KkWD.a"@ccnDONMnBeP`Ia%M 3I¢noD%rKsP`^VN\apUWILKMNQVbrBU^NMDbBDOakR%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMD.a
^U^IBdOPUWNQDOamaMrBN(RDOaD%ILKQUKQdOaO*gI zVUeRUqSr*D%eqSr*DOaDD%C=nB^DOabBP`I*akWDnBeP`r I *ªqLrBU aMD%NQVILKkNQD%nBNQU^akbBP`I*ak^P
aMrBUWKMsD 2
{WDªP`UWKmqLr r*IXnoVU^ISK"P`n*n*P`NMKMU^D%IBI*D(rBIBD$bNQVUWKMDbBVIBIBdODkVSrBNQIBUKrBIBDsRVSIKMN\P`U^ILKMDWU^IBdOPUWNQDaMrBN
RD$noVU^ILK#t
v^PªP`UWK"qSr rBI*DbNQVUWKMDn*PaQaDn*P`NprBInVSUWILK"bVIBI*dmVr*NMIBUWKrBIBDsRVILKQNQPUWILKMDkWU^IBdOPUWNQDaMrBNRD%KKMD
bNQVUWKMD?t
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
s
EB"aU[ VIR%VI*aMUebA%NQD^DsnVSUWILK"DK"ePbBNMVSUKQD(R%VC=C=Dz2P`NQUeP`~B^DOaO]cWD(ªP`UWKmqLrBD^DsnVSUWILKmP`n*n*P`NMKMU^D%IBI*D
^PbNQVUWKMDVrBNQIBUWKsr*IBDYR%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMDY~BU^WU^IBdOPUWNQD=arBNs^DnoVU^ILK$DK$^PbNQVUWKMDS]R` DOaKsbU^NMD=rBIBD
RVSISKQNQPUWILKQDsqLrBUD.aiKm^U^IBdOPUWNQDzcUeamYzcU^a"br¢noVU^ILKO]BD%KmWU^IBdOPUWNQD(zLUeamYzcU^a"bBD$^P=bNQVUWKMD?t
^PRVSISKQNQPUWILKQDd%nBU^noVeP`U^NMDqLrBDY[ VSIUWILKQNMVbrBUWKDOIzcU^aMU^VInoVrBNsbd.RNQUWNQDrBI«aaKMA%C=DYbDbDOr
R%PCYdONQPSa%]VrBNQIBUWKrBIBDNMDO^P`KMU^VI~BU^WU^IBd.P`U^NMD5DOILKMNQDbDOr«noVU^ILKQaYqLrBUaMVILK^DOanBNQV`hiDKQdOab rBI
C (%C=D$nVSUWILKkE W bBP`I*akbD%rUWC
P`_SDO#
) a t
0"n*P`NMKMU^N5bDKQNMVSU^a=VSr qSrP2KMNQD¢UWC
P_DOaO]±VInoD%rKP`r*aQaUkUWILKMNQVbrBU^NMDbD.a5RVSIKMN\P`U^IKQDOaYKMNQUmVSr
qLr*PbNQU^WU^IBdOPUWNQDOapDOISKQNMDs^DOanBNQV`hiD%KMd.a"b r*I)
C (OCYD$noVU^ILKO
?VrKQDOaR%DOaR%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMD.anDOrBzDOISKaO DnBNQUWC=D%N0 P`UebDgbD KQD%I*aMD%rBN\aO mIsKQD%I*aMD%rBNDOaKrBIBD±VSI*RTKQUWVSI
qLrBU[]2mrBID%I*aMD%C~B^DbDpnVSUWILK\aD%K b @ccnDONMnBeP`Ia%],PaQaVR%UWDgr*INQd%D%[]2RD.RUcbDªP VSICrBWKMU^^UWIBd.P`U^NMDS].R D.aiK
YbU^NMD(bDsC
P`IBU^A%NQDk^UWI*dOP`U^NQDn*PNN\P`n*nVSNKR\@*PSRrBIbDsRDOapnoVU^ILKQapDK@cLnoD%NQnBeP`I*aOT 6D.aR%VLD 55RU^D%ILKQa
bBDmRDKMKMDVSI*RTKQUWVSIYnoD%r*zD%ILKaMDCYD%KKQNMDmaMVr*aVSNMC=Dmb rBIYKQP~B^DOP`r=U^I*bUeRdmY{]Lv]`EsV
r ¢bUWC=DOI*aU^VIa%
6PI*V`KMU^VIbDYKMDOI*aMD%rBN$DOI«NQDOR%VrBzcNQD~oDOPr*RVSrBn«b PrKMNQDOaO mU^I*aMU0]bBPI*as[ D%cDOC=nBWD¢{S]WD.a$RVcD»Z
oRU^D%ILKQa
bD¢ePbNMVSUKQDPr*qLrBD%"^D¢nVSUWILK5bVSUK5P`n*n*P`NMKMDOIBUWN
aMVILK
P`r*aQaU"^DOa=R%VLD 55RU^D%ILKQa
br KMDOI*aMD%rBN
rBKMU^WUeadS4 .D%^VI¡rBI¡nBNQVRD.aMaMr*ab PaQaMUWC=U^^P`KMU^VIRVSrBN\P`ILKD%IPW_SA%~BNQD]VSI¡nDOrKYbBUWNQDXqLrBDX^DOabNQVUWKMDOa
*ªVr@ccnDONMnBeP`Ia(b*P`I*a$^D5R%PSas_dOIBd%N\P` 2kaMVILKbD.a(KMDOI*aDOrBN\asn*P`NMKMUeRrB^U^D%N\a%GJgDOIz,P¢bD
) C (OCYD5b*P`I*a
[ DD%C=nB^Dvc]DKYVInoD%rBK=Pr*aMaMUR%VI*R%Wr*NMDXqLrBDWD.anoVU^ILKQaYaVSISKYbDOaKMDOI*aDOrBN\an*PNKQU^R%rBWU^D%N\aOU W(P`I*a
R%DOasbDOrnBNQD%C=UWDONQa(R%PSa%]o^DOaKMDOI*aDOrBN\a(aMVILKsbDOasP`n*nBWUeR%P`KMU^VI*a^UWIBd.P`U^NMD.abB) D X cdZbBP`I*- a X Y¬]oD%K$WDOrBNQa
R%Vc D 55RU^D%ILKQa"aMVILKmbD.azDORKMDOrBNQaO
W(P`I*a[ D%cDOC=nBWD ]LVIXPP eP`U^NMDrBIBDNMDO^P`KMU^VI5~*UW^UWI*dOP`U^NQD]D%Kp^DOapRVcD 5
R%UWDOILKQabBr5KMDOI*aMD%rBNaVSILK
D%nBNMU^C=dOaaVSr*aVNQC=Dpb rBIBDpC
P2KQNMUeRDSs 6PkI*V`KMU^VIYbDKMD%IaDOrBN D%IB_SWVS~DbVIRR%D%^WDbDpC=P`KMNQU^R%D W(P`I*a
[ DD%C=nB^f D 0B]SU^oªP`rK"RVSI*aiKQNMr*UWNQDkbD.agKQD%I*aMD%rBN\ap$KMNQVUeaVrXqLr*P`KMNQDbU^C=D%I*aMUWVSI*aODO^PbD%zcU^D%ILKC=VU^I*a
U^ILKMrBUWKMUWi]R%PNkU^D.aiKbBU 55RU^^DYb dOR%NMU^NQD$rBIKQP~B^DOP`r bDIBVSC~BNQDOak
KMNQVUeakbBUWC=D%IaU^VI*aar*NkrBIBDD%rBU^^WD
qLrBUI DOI¢P=qLrBDbDOr
PU^a"R%D%ePNQDOaQaMD%C~*WDKMVSrKkªP`UWKkr*IBD$C
P2KMNQUeRD
3I
zSVUWKbVI*R"qLrBDk^P$I*V`KMU^VI
bDmKMD%IaDOrBNgNQDORVSrBzcNMDpKQVrKQDOag^DOagIBV`KQUWVSI*aqLrBUBnoD%r*zD%ILKaO DnBNQUWC=D%N
aMVragVSNMC=Dsb r*IXK\P`~B^DOPrbDsIBVSC~BNQDOaO]SzSDORKMD%r*NQaDK"C
P2KQNMUeRD.aDOIn*PNKQU^R%rB^UWDONOcl"U^D%I¢bD(R%VC=nB^U^qLrBd
bBVI*R
W(P`I*am0 P`nBn*NMVR\@BDsC
P2KQ@Bd%C
P2KQU^qLrBDS]VI¢n*PNKmbD$ePYIBV`KQUWVSI_Sd%IBdONQPWDsb DOaMn*PR%DszDORKMVSNMU^D%[ 3IU^IZ
KQNMVbr*UKb P`~oVN\bY^PsI*V`KMU^VI
b DOaMn*PSRDmbr*P0]SqSr*UVrBNQIBUWK[ d.qSr*UWz2P`^D%ILKbD.a±@ccnDONMnBeP`Ia%SDO^PsD.aiKgªPUK
b*P`I*a^D"n*P`N\P`_SNQPnB@BDvBp 6DOaKQD%I*aMD%r*NQa aMVILKgP`^VN\aU^ILKMNQVcbBrBUKR%VC=C=Dd%KQPISK±^DOaVSNMC=DOa CrBWKMU^WU^IBdOPUWNQDOa
aMrBNs^DOasd%^d%C=DOISK\a$bD
[ D.an*PSRDYzD.RTKMVSNMU^D% D%K$bBD5aVSI br*P0U 3I«N\P`nBnoD%^WD
qLr VIP`nBnoD%^^DVSNMC=D=rBIBD
PnBnB^U^ROP2KQUWVSIb rBI¢DOaMn*PSRD(zDORKMVSNMU^D%zSD%N\apaMVI¢RVSNMnapbBD$~*PaMD
D zD.RTKQD%rBN\a$bD5RVcVSNQbVSIBIBdODOas©DK© n 3IP"
! £
] M
a
V W
U K £ # '
" h ' .
c U W
Y
D o
n
V ^
U S
I K - c `
P *
n *
n `
P M
N M
K ^
U %
D L
I
K
0
c
@ c
n O
D M
N B
n e
`
P I $
k o
]
V
I M
a
V *
r *
@ `
P W
U M
K Y
D S
q r*DYR%D%eP
%'& Û %)(
0
aMVUWK
UWIbd%noD%I*b*P`ILKXbD¢^P«~*PSaDS]gR` DOaK5«bBUWNQDqSr*D J© DK J© D%eP U^C=nVLaDbVSI*R±
J© £ "'h D%K i© J© £ "'h2 3I¢D%I¢RVSI*R^rBDg B© J£ ©
W(P`I*a^D R%PSabBr;nVSUWILK.]^D zSDORKMD%r*NbD«RVC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.aXP¡d%KMd KMN\P`I*aVNQC=dn*P`N £ "'h ]
i£ ©U 6D.aDOISKQUKQdOaarB~*U^aQaMPILKWDXR\@P`IB_SD%C=D%ILKRVSC=CYD
D%KO]bBP`I*aWDR%PabD5[ @ccnDONMn*^PI]n*PN©
^DOaRVSCYnoVSaQP`ILKQDOambD.amnoVU^ILKQakaMVILKkbUWKMD.a¨S¤ ¦ ¦ cS]o^DOaP`rKQNMD.akaMVILKkbUWKMD.a¨S¤ ¦ LS
kIKQD%I*aMD%rBNsb VN\bNQDar*ndONMU^D%rBN(Vrd%_SPbD%r]DKsqLrBU±PXbVSI*RnB^r*aMUWDOrBN\aPNM_SrBC=D%ILKQaO]*noD%r- K (KQNMD
R%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PILKknVSrBNRDONK\P`U^I*asbD
aD.asP`NQ_rBC=D%ILK\aD%KRV2z2P`NQU^PILKnoVrBN$^DOasP`rBKMNQDOaO]arBU^z2P`ILK$qSr*D=R%DOa
PNM_SrBC=D%ILKQaaMVILKmbDOadOWdOC=D%ILKQambBD([ DOaMn*PR%D(zSDORKMVNQU^D%VrbD$aMVI¢br*P`[
W(P`I*a^D$R%PSa_Sd%IBdONQP0]cU^z2PbVSI*RªP`^WVSUWN"bUeaKMU^IB_rBDONWD.a"bUWC=DOI*aU^VIapR%V2z2P`NQU^PISKQDOaDK"^DOa"bU^C=D%IZ
aMU^VI*a±R%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PISKQDOabDOa±KMD%IaDOrBNQaOLDO^P$aMDªP`UWKRVSrBN\P`C=C=D%ILK±D%I=nBeP %PILKgWD.a±UWIbU^R%DOagR%VNQNMD.anoVIBZ
b*P`ILK=Pr¬bU^C=D%I*aMUWVSI*aYRVILKQNQP,z2P`NQUeP`ILKMD.a$D%I DnoVSaQP`ILKO]DK5RDOr¬RVSNMNQDOaMnoVI*bBPILKP`rbU^C=D%I*aMU^VI*a
R%V2z2P`NQU^PISKQDOaD%IU^I*bUeRD mU^I*aU[]rBI«KQD%I*aMD%rBNb VSNQbNQDYKMNQVUea%]P,zSDORrBI¡P`NQ_rBC=DOISKR%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PISK.]r*I
PNM_SrBC=D%ILK"RV2z2P`NQU^PILKpD%KmrBIP`NQ_rBC=D%ILK"RVSISKQNQP,z2PNMUeP`ILKO]LnoD%rV
K (%KMNQD(I*V`KMd T
D.aR%VI*R%D%nK\abD(RV2z2P`NQUeP`I*R%DmDKRVILKQNQP,z2P`NQUeP`I*R%D]`qLrBUnDOrBzDOILKpbdONMVSrKMDONbD(nBNQUWC=DP~VSNQb]SRVSNZ
NQDOaMnoVI*bDOILKbVI*RaU^C=nBWDOC=D%ILKrBIBDC=PNQqLrBDgqLrBULaU^_IP`^DgRDqLr UWªP`rKªP`U^NMD±DOIR%PabDR\@*PIB_DOCYDOILK
bBD~*PSaDSDKKQD
bU^aKMU^I*RKMU^VIbU^aMn*PNQP ^K$aU [ VSI«aMDYWU^C=UKQD=bD.a$R\@*P`IB_SD%C=D%ILK\abD=~*PSaD.akVSNKQ@BVI*VNMZ
C=dODOaOG W(P`IapR%D(ROPaO]c^PC
P2KMNQUeRDbBDsR\@P`IB_SD%C=D%ILKpbBD~*PSaD(DOaKVNMKM@BVS_VIP`^D]D%K J£ £ " h,cGJI
PP`^VN\a nBWraqLr rBIBDkaMD%r*WDkaMVNMKMDmbBDR\@*PIB_DOCYDOILKO]`D%KeP$bU^aKMU^I*RKMU^VI5DOISKQNMDRV2z2P`NQU^PI*RDD%KRVSISKQNQP,z2P`Z
NQUeP`I*R%D"I PnB^r*ag^UWDOrXb (KQNMDSGJªP`rKp~BUWDOI5NQD%C
P`N\qLrBD%NgqLrBDkR%D%eP$IBD(aDmnPaQaDkqLrBDkWVSNQaQqLr VSIYKMN\P,z,PUW^^D
r*IBU^qLrBDOC=D%ILKkbBP`Ia"bDOa~*PSaD.aVNMKM@BVSIBVNQC=d%D.a%
d%KMDOI*brBD.a"P`rKMD%IaDOrBNQab VN\bNQD$arBnod%NQU^D%rBN"DOIrKQUW^UeaMPISKm[ Vnod%N\P2KMU^VI¢bD$RVSILKMN\PRTKQUWVSI
f Vr*N IBUWN.] NMDOzDOIBVI*aP`r R%Pa=bDeP_Sd%VC=d%KMNQUWD5n*NMVhiDORTKQUWzSD4 6P«bU eodONMDOI*RDC
P2hiD%r*NMDqSr VSI¬
KQNMVSrBzDsn*PNmN\P`nBnoVNMKkP`rDOaMn*PR%DOa"zSDORKMVNQU^D%ea"RePaQaUeqLrBDOa"D.aiKkqLrBDKMVram^DOa"zSDORTKQD%rBN\a"¢aVSILKkbd *I*U^a
rBI ªPRKMD%r*N(CrBWKMU^nBWUeR%P`KMUWIBVSIIcrB±nBNQAOaOD%ePXD.aiKszcNQPU nVSrBNsWD.anoVU^ILKQaO]WD.a(@LcnoD%NQnBeP`I*aO]C
PU^a
Pr*aQaU ^DOasC
P2KQNMUeRD.a%±KRDO^P[ D.aiKbVSI*RYP`r*aQaU noVrBN$^DOa(KQD%I*aMD%r*NQaO
P`Uea(rBIKQD%I*aMD%r*NO]qLrBU±D.aiK$rBIBD
PnBnB^U^ROP2KQUWVSIz,PWDOrBN\a5bBP`Ia X Y]pbd IBU¡r*IaMROP`eP`U^NMD¢nBNQAOaXIBDnoD%rK¢bVIRnBNQD%I*bNQDqLrBDbDOr
z2PWDOrBNQaO]SuVr{S]LKMVra^DOapP`rKQNMD.aaQR%P^PUWNQDOanVSrBz2P`ILE K (%KMNQDPaQaMUWC=U^Wd.aX{BD%ePDnB^UeqSr*DqLrBDmKQVrKQDOa
^DOa$R%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMD.aNQD%IRVILKQNMdODOa(D%IzcU^aMU^VI«DKD%I_Sd%VC=d%KMNQUWD=nBNQV`hiD.RTKMU^zDS]DKbVSI*RYKMVSr*asWD.asKMDOI*aMD%rBN\a%]
aMVILKmbD.a"RVILKQNQPUWILKMD.abD$IcrBW^UWKMd$Vr¢bD$IBVSIIcrB^^UKQdb r*IBD$DnBNQDOaQaU^VI
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
s
\
DnD%KMUWKn*PNQP_N\P`nB@BD RVSILKMU^D%ILKrBIN\P`n*nDOSaMrBNeP"IBVKMU^VIbDbBr*P`^UKQdgnoVrBNbDOaDOaMn*PR%DOazSDORKMVNQU^D%ea
_Sd%IBdONQPr]TIBV`KQUWVSIqLrBUD.aiKrBKMU^WUeadODbBPI*aePmar*UKQDgnVSrBN^DOaKMD%IaDOrBNQaO$W(P`IarBI~BrBKbDaMUWC=nB^U R%P`KMU^VI]
VSIaMDsWU^C=UKQD%N\P
P`r¢R%PSa"b D.anPRD.abDbU^CYDOI*aMUWVSI *I*UWDS
>@= qR LaQ#R IK Q D
N@IK
6P$IBV`KQUWVSI
bDkbr*PWUWKMdS]I*P`KMrBNQD%^^DmD%I
_Sd%VC=d%KMNQUWD"nBNQV`hiD.RTKQUWzSD]2noD%roK (KMNQDkPr*aMaMUªPSRU^WDOCYDOILKbd IBUWD
*b P`I*a(^DYROPasbDOasD.anPRD.akzSDORKMVNQU^D%ea%aWPI*as^DYROPbNQDYbBDYR%DK$VrBzcN\P`_SD]oVI aMDYWU^C=UKQD%N\PqLrBD%eqLrBDOa
N\P`n*nDO^a"bBPI*a^DsROPa"b rBI¢DOaMn*PSRD$bDbU^C=D%I*aMUWVSI IBUWD
X Y]Z
¦ ª¤
"!$#%'&)(*+!,(-#/.012*34658792;:<85>= i &?>.@6A %BC!$#ED$GFH(*I/JK%LM.N8O!.MI%@&"#>A @
P D9.MIQD>%R!@-SN.H#!>H.T(*U
N.N8O!.MI%VD$ D$!*U X YXWY Z@[F\!$#,.M0QD$^]'(*.MI_?> mi %`ab%BC!$#
]*c#cB('I,.0 W
e gf^ hZ i
MiUh
j rBIzSDORKMD%r*N ] "i PSaMaMVRU^DbVIRaQPmUNkoR%VC=nVLaMPILKMDbBPI*a^Pk~*PaMDld(s.cUL[ VSIRVSI*aUebAONMDgr*Id%^d%C=DOISK
isbDmm
i]VSI¢Pm
}|~ i i
g|
QK D%qLrBD e i f^ i
wl v i x
w i v yx
GibBD%ILKMU *D%Nm DKm
R%VC=CrBKQP2KQUi
ii n*P`N(WDY~BUeP`UeasbDYR%DKsU^aMVC=VSNMnB@*U^aMC=DNQD%zcUWDOILK(NMDOI*bNQD^DYR%NMVR\@BD%KsbD=br*PWUWKMd
%'& Û %)(
}
w i v yx
Z
i n h 0o hZ i i
MiUZ h
MiUh
ian h o hZ i i"
MiUh
NiUh
rBKMU^WUeaMPILKeP=NQD%eP2KMU^VI p Z ]BVIV~BKMU^D%ILK
3IXnDOrKR%VI*R%Wr*NMD(bDR%D(ROP`eRrBqLrBD]cb rBIBD(n*P`NMKO]
i T]cDK.]Lb P`rBKMNQDkn*PNK.] i TcgI
NiUh
Z
i h h Z
inh iUh
6PVNQCrB^D5bD5R\@*PIB_DOCYDOILK$bBD5~*PaMD
bBP`Ia$0 DOaMn*PSRD5br*PgDOaKbVSI*R J£ DKMKMD
VSNMCrB^D
C=VSISKQNMD$bVSI*R(rBIBDbU e d%NQD%I*R%DsbBDRVC=noVNMKMDOCYDOILKI*DKKQD$D%ILKMNQDs0 DOaMn*PSRDm¥D%KkaVSIbBr*P`[
98:8
4; sU;Q
s =
W(P`I*aRD%KKMDn*P`NMKMU^D]*VIaMDWU^C=UKQD%N\P5=rBIBDnBNQdOaMD%ILKQP`KMU^VIaU^C=nB^Dbr¢VNQC
P`^U^aMC=DbD.a"KMDOI*aMD%rBN\a%]
Qa P`IaaMVr*R%UcDBRD.aMaMU*bBDpNQU^_rBDOrBNVSrbD_dOIBd%N\P`^UWKMd mU^I*aMU0],VSII UWILKQNMVbrBU^N\Pmn*PSaePIBV`KQUWVSIbDpnBNQVcbBrBUK
KQD%I*aMVNQU^D%b D.anPRD.agzSDORTKQVNQUWDO^aO"3IXar*UKWD(nBeP`IUWI*bBU^qLrBd(nB^r*ap@*P`rK LVSI5U^ISKQNMVbr*UKWD.aKMD%IaDOrBNQaDK
[ Vnod%N\P2KMU^VIbDs~*PaMD(qLr DOaK"WDsnBNQVbrBUWKKQD%I*aMVNQU^D%[]LVSIU^ILKMNQVbrBUWK"PWVSNQa^DOap~*PaMDOapnoVrBN"bd.RVSCYnoVSaMD%N
^DOaKQD%I*aMD%rBN\abBP`Ia"RDOap~*PSaD.a% 3I¢a% U^ISKQd%NQDOaQaD(P`^VN\aPrR\@*PIB_DOC=D%ILKQapbDs~*PaMD(DKmP`r5U^Icz2P`NQU^PISK\a%
3I¢RVSI*R^rBDsn*PN"WDROPabDOakR\@*P`IB_SD%C=D%ILK\aDOILKMNQD(~PaMDOaVNMKM@*VIBVSNMC=d%D.a%
>@= fBND"NOH B9IVQURSDTQ#BRCQ#KFR
VSCYC=DOIVSI*an*P`NmbBVIBIBDON"^P=bd *IBUWKMU^VIbD.apKMD%IaDOrBNQaO
¦ ª¤
('. %BC!>#%a]''#`B(*I/.0 D$aD .MJK .0(' `Im;#%(*IBC X Y &8'l%('. mi %(' D !* W ^!@-NT
!2 392U<#"%$VFH('. #('S\I%!]!*I,. !8"*& FH('. Z#%( ]!I/.T!*SB(>-B FH(*I/JK J \.NM.N8O!.MI[D$O('--.0 `I Hmi *)Gu
O* !8%%9
855 ";: 55 l7 23 W
,+.- !`-SN.\#%!>\.0('+JK \.NM.N8O@!*.NI%ED> \ i ) u ,+ D!* X Y0/'W $213&K%`l%A 45" :6" 2^DU U%'9I W ${'7&
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
w s
^P_d%VSC=dKMNQU^DpdOnBU^nVS^PUWNQDmaVSILKbDOaDD%C=nB^DOagbBD"KMDOI*aDOrBN\agbDkR%DKiLnoDDOagKMD%IaDOrBNQagnDOrBzDOISK
(KQNMD
aMLC=d%KMNQU^qLrBD.a%]P`ILKQU^aMcCYd%KMNQU^qLrBD.a%]bd *IBUea%]I*VIbd%_Sd%IBdONMd.a%]onVLaUWKMUWªa$VSrIBdO_SP2KQUªaO^W?VrK
WD$zSVR%P`~*rB^PUWNQDsRePaQaUeqLrBD(bBDOapVNQC=DOa~BU^^UWIBd.P`U^NMD.a"a% P`n*nBWUeqLrBD
c ¨¤ ¦ ¦
¤ DOaKsr*IBD=VNQC=DY~*UW^UWI*dOP`U^NQD=aMrB
N miEu;mi`]P`r*qLrBDO±WD
zVR%P~BrBeP`U^NMD"n*NMd.RdObBD%ILKnoD%rK"P`raMaMUaO PnBnB^U^qLrBDONOC 6D.agKQD%I*aMD%rBN\abBD(R%VILKMN\P`U^ILKMD"D%IXCYd.R%PIBU^qLrBD
aVSILK"bBDsKMD%eaKQD%I*aMD%rBN\aO
c ¨¤ ¦ ¦ L¦
¨¤ ¦
¤ D.aiKsrBIBDVNQCYDY~BU^WU^IBd.P`U^NMDYarBN mi
u
i*v | ª i9v j KQVrKzSDORTKQD%rBNbBD5RD=KicnD
VSI noD%rBKPaQaVR%UWDONsbBD
C=PIBU^A%NQDYr*IBU^qLrBD
rBIBDPnBnB^U^ROP2KMU^VI^UWIBd.P`U^NMD$bm
D bBPI*Z a *D%IbVC=VNQnB@BUeaMCYD$bm D +2]n*P`NePYVNQCrB^Dg
e i f^ i
e {fQ ª i v w i v x
6PY^UWIBd.P`NQUKQd$bDD.aiKkPSaMaMrBNQd%D(n*P`N"ePY~BUW^U^IBdOPNMUWKMd$bD
f V rBNaMD5RVSILz2PUWI*R%NMD=bD
[ r*IBU^R%UKQd5bD]VI«noD%rKrBKMU^WUeaDON$^P~*PSaD
bDV i "i"/v (DOaK$^P
U k R%VC=nVLaMPILKMDsbD qLrBUDOaK"bBVI*RsrBI*U^qLrBDS
h
Z
i v
Minh
l dOR%UWn*NMVqLrBD%C=DOISK.]oXKMVSrKsD%I*bVSC=VNQnB@BUeaC=DbDR
]VInDOrKsPSaMaMVRU^D%NrBIKQD%I*aMD%rBNY{=RVILKQNQP`Z
"
z2P`NQU^PISK"D%K{sR%V2z2P`NQU^PISK.
%'& Û %)(
3InoD%rKbVSI*RPSaMaMU^CYU^^D%N(WD.akKQD%I*aMD%r*NQa(bD=RDKicnoD
P,zDORWD.aDOI*bVSCYVSNMn*@BU^aMC=DOaOM .cU VSIIBDYWD
ªP`UWKn*PSagD%I
_Sd%IBdONQP0]`R D.aiKpqSr*Dm^P$aMd%C
PISKQU^qLrBDbDkRD.a±D%ILKQUKQdOagD.aiKhirB_dODkbUeodONMDOISKQDC3I
noD%rBKO]
n*P`NRVILKQNMDS]cKMN\P`I*aMnVLaDONWD$zSVcROP`~Br*^PUWNQD$bDOa"DOI*bVSCYVSNMn*@BU^aMC=DOa
RD.aKMDOI*aMD%rBN\a%]D%Kbd *IBU^NmWD
KMDOI*aDOrBN "'hUWIczSD%N\aDb rBI=KMDOI*aDOrBN RVSCYC=D"d%KQP`ILKg^DpKMD%IaDOrBNPaQaMVcR%UWds[ DOI*bVC=VSNMnB@*U^aMC=D
" h(U^IczD%N\aMD(bDs[ DOI*bVSCYVSNMn*@BU^aMC=D PaQaMVcR%UWds
> [F"H IKNDSDTQ#BRCH?F NOQ"
kIBD5VSU^abd *I*U^DOaKMD%IaDOrBNQaO]VSIbd IBUKYWDnBNQVcbBrBUKKMD%IaVSNMU^D%[]qLrBUDOaK[ VSndONQP`KMU^VI¡bDX~PaMD
Ma rBN"^DOapKQD%I*aMD%rBN\aO"6P=bd IBUKQUWVSI¢D%I¢DOaK"KMNQAOa"aMUWC=nB^Dg U^aMrT5=KkbDRVSI*R%P`KMd%I*D%NWD.amP`NQ_r*CYDOILKQaO]LD%KmWD
NQdOaMrBWKQP`KD.aiK"^D$nBNQVcbBrBUKkbBDOa"bDOrXKQD%I*aMD%rBN\aO
¦ ª¤
('.0S D$'
;B%U*I
\ i ) uz +
| XY
\ i ) uQ + | XY
Z4 "4C:l<#: , 2!3 4 ";: 2*=6D$ ' @ {U%'I &-8($O !>9,/. &Bl?$$
< ih < i ) v 8 h 8 + v < i h < i ) v 8 h 8 +
< i h < i ) v 8 h 8 + < i h < i ) v 8 h 8 +
3I¢NQD%C
P`N\qLrBD%N\P~*UWDOI0 VN\bNQDsbBDOamPNM_SrBC=D%ILKQaODKMKMD$Vnod%N\P2KQUWVSID.aiK(bU^aKMNQU^~BrKMU^zD *0
bNQVUWKMD$DK
_LP`r*R\@BDs2n*P`NgN\P`n*nVSNKg(0 Pb*bUKQUWVSI=DKD.aiKPSaMaMVRUeP2KMU^zDS,gW^D"I DOaKgn*PaRVC=CrKQP`KMU^zD]2C)(OCYDmb*P`I*a
(
^D$R%PSa"bDsKMDOI*aDOrBN\a"bDsC (OC=DsKiLnoD]RDOR%U
R%Pr*aDsbD$[ VSNQbBNMDsbDOakP`NQ_rBC=D%ILK\a%
c © c
s 6D$nBNQVbrBUWKKMD%IaVSNMU^D%bDbBD%rXzSDORKMD%r*NQa"bD
OD aKmrBIBDsVSNMC=Ds~BU^WU^IBd.P`U^NMD$aMrBN \ mi
e i v i fQ i ª i v i w )v i x w v i x
s WkD(C)(%C=D]c^DknBNQVbrBUWKKQD%I*aMVNQU^D%bDbDOr5zD.RTKQD%rBN\abD i DOaKr*IBDkVSNMC=D~BUW^U^IBdOPUWNQDaMrBNr
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
{.u s
tc¤ c
($U U%'9Ir *-l$A O'#/I,.MIL%($ !EFH('I,JK
D A 98 (*JRJV '-U.TaD$EU%'9I, D$O'#%(*Jm(*! T W
\
^ *
c¨'t 2¨'t
r*IBU^aQaMVI*am b rBIBD=~*PSaD (D%KamiYbD
eP~*PaMD
br*P`^D "i T43I
noD%rKPWVSNQasbd.RVSCYnoVSaMD%N
KQVrKmzSDORKMD%r*N bBD VSr isbD
mi$aDOWVSIR%DOa~*PSaD.a% 3IIBV`KQDg
DK i i
DOIrKQUW^U^aQP`ILK(^PRVIczSD%ILKMU^VIbUWKMD=bD.akU^I*bUeRD.akCrBDK\aVSrNQd%nodKMd.a UW PXaMVC=C
P2KQUWVSIn*P`NNQPnBnoVNMK
Pr U^I*bUeRD.aaMD=KMNQVrBz2PISKr*IBD
VUeaDOI@*P`rKDKrBI*D
VUeaDOI¡~*PaO mU^I*aMU
NMDOnBNMd.aDOILKMD
D%IªPUK
p
D K T i Q
N %
D *
n M
N .
d
a O
D S
I Q
K D p T i L
LP`ILKU^ILKMNQVcbBrBUK=bDOa~*PSaD.a%]VI¡z2PD.aMaQP,DONbDbBdORVSC=nVLaDONrBI¡KQD%I*aMD%rBN qLrBDO^R%VI*qLrBDXaMrBN
R%DOa"~PaMDOaO*l"DOaKMNQD%U^_I*VI*aIBVSr*aO]Bn*P`N"D%D%C=nB^D]PrR%PakbDOaKQD%I*aMD%r*NQa${R%V2z2P`NQU^PISK.]{RVSISKQNQP,z2PNMUeP`ILK
D%K{RV2z2PNMUeP`IL
K *ªR%DqLrBUaMrBUWKknVSrBz2P`ILV K (KQNMD_d%I*d%N\P`^U^aMd$aMPI*a"nBNQV~B^A%C=DYKQVr*akWD.amP`rKQNMD.aKicnD.akbD
KQD%I*aMD%r*NQa 2T
%'& Û %)(
{S{
e 6v f^
e i fz i
VSI*aMU^bdONMVSI*apC
P`U^ISKQD%I*PILKr*IKQD%I*aMD%r*NmqSr*D%eRVIqSr*DsbBD(C)(OCYD.a"z2P`NQU^PI*RD.a
M3IIBV`KQDg
e v 9v v i v
3I¢P=P`^VN\a%]cDOIrBKMU^WUeaMPILKm^PKMNQU^WU^IBdOPNMUWKMd$bD$R%DsKMD%IaDOrBN
e lv fz e i fz i 06v i v v i v
KQVr2hiVSrBN\a±D%I=rKQUW^U^aQP`ILKePsC)(%C=DkR%VIczDOISKQUWVSIYaMrBNgeP$aMVC=C
P2KMU^VI=noVrBNWD.a±UWIbU^R%DOaNMdOnd%KMdOaOC3I=noD%rK
DOIR%VI*R%Wr*NMDg
i i DK v i v
6DOaXVNQCrB^DOaRUWZ´bD.aMaMr*abVIBI*D%ILKeP¬bd.RVSCYnoVSaMUWKMU^VI;br KQD%I*aMD%r*N arBN^PªP`C=U^W^D bD.a
KQD%I*aMD%r*NQa "i
"i LD%eP$C=VILKMNQDmqLrBDkR%DKKQD"ªP`C=U^W^DmD.aiKg_Sd%IBdONQP`KMNQU^R%D2f VrBNpqLr DOW^DVNQC=DmrBIBD
~PaMD],UWLªPrKgP`r*aQaUqLrBDpWD.aKMD%IaDOrBNQa qLrBUePR%VC=noVSaMDaMVU^D%ILKU^I*bdOnDOI*bBPISK\a%3InDOrKgaD"R%VIcz2P`U^I*RNQD
bBDsR%D%ePYD%IRVSI*aiK\P2K\P`ILKKMVrBKkb P~VSNQbqLrBDg
i i v i v Z
Z
V\
D.aiK"^DsaMcC~oV^D(bBD &U!'U&
aU =D%K b*P`I*ap^DsROPaU^IczD%N\aMDT.cUVIar*nBnVLaD
qLr rBIBDR%VC~BUWIP`UeaVSIX^UWIBd.P`U^NMDsbDR%DOapKMDOI*aMD%rBN\aDOaK"KMVSr2hiVrBN\aIcrB^WDg
i i
VSIVS~KMU^D%ILKkPWVSNQaaMr*R%R%DOaQaU^zDOCYDOILKp^DOanBNQVn*NMU^dKQdOaar*UWz2P`ILKQDOa"qLrBUnBNQVr*zD%ILK0 U^I*bd%noD%IbBP`I*R%Dg
e v ;v i i v i
v Z
Z
e v ;v
e v ;v Z
3I¢noD%rKkPWVSNQapNQdOaMrBC=D%NpKMVSrKkRDO^P=aMVr*apVSNMC=D$b rBIKM@BdOVNQA%C=D
t c¤ c
% B *I,^2 i 2 2 i #%(' @H.H/;8 9!%+D$Q%A "!$#%+D>%^U%'I^D>g]%!I/.T!*C#%%
#('U/.HD$OIO@ W R#%($ #,.T% SH
#'/B 9!9'&8'6(' !
%('S TR#%(*J
(,!8%a(>g#($('I`D$('-SO@%EDU{U%'I D$!*U
< v 8 i v
_'- D$(*)#L8(>BIZ%A U%J * T
D$ B%U*I #%(' .HD$OIO% mi mi9W
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
{,v s
c © c
GJ^WraiKQNMVSI*a"RD$qLrBUnBNQdOR%AObD$aMrBNmbDOrROPan*PNKQU^R%rBWU^D%N\aO
c 2 ¦
¤ j KMVSrK5KQD%I*aMD%rBNbDR%DKicnDD.aiKPaQaVRU^drBIBD P`nBnB^UeR%P2KQUWVSI
^U^IBdOPUWNQD 3IR\@BDONQR\@BD$bVSI*R$
RVSC=n*P`NQD%N^DOamR%VLD55RU^D%ILKQamb rBI¢KQD%I*aMD%r*NkP,zD.Rk^DOamR%VcD 55RU^D%ILKQakbD$^P
C
P`KMNQU^R%DsbBD([ P`nBnB^UeR%P2KQUWVSI^U^IBdOPUWNQD$PaQaVRU^d%DScf PSa"bDaMrBNMn*NMUeaDS]RDaMVILK"WD.aC (OC=DOaO
.cVSUK f^ i(DK 0 P`nBn*WUeR%P`KMU^VIWU^IBdOPUWNQD$qLrBUWr*UDOaKkPaQaVR%UWdODg
0 i v w i v x
3I5aMrBnBnoVSaMDqLrBD DOaKCrBIBUb rBIBDk~PaMD gDK ikbBDm^P~*PaMDkbrP`^D"3I5IBV`KQDkP`^VN\a
eP=C
P2KQNMUeRD$bD ]Vb\ D.aiKm[ U^I*bUeRDbD$WU^_I*D$DK 50 UWIbU^R%DbDR%V^VIBIBDS 3I¢IBV`KQDb P`rKQNMDsn*PNK
^DOa"R%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.apbBD b*P`I*aePY~*PaMD Ti M3IP
PWVSNQa
i" v w i" v x
6DOaRVcD5
R%UWDOILKQa"bD bBP`I*a "i paMVILKmbVIRk^DOa"R%VLD55RU^D%ILKQa"bDsePC
P`KMNQU^R%DsbBD bBP`I*a T
3InoD%rKPr*aMaMU
WU ILKQNMVbrBU^NQDYr*I KQD%I*aMD%r*NsKMN\P`I*aMnVLadS]bVILK$WD.aRVcD5
R%UWDOILKQa$aMVILKO]aQP`I*asaMrBNQnBNMUeaMD
I*VIn*Wr*aO]WD.aKMN\P`I*aMnVLad.akbD.asRVcD 55RU^D%ILK\a(bBrKMDOI*aMD%rBN$bD=bd%nP`NMKO'3I bd *IBUWK
[ d%^d%C=D%ILKkbDmmi KMDOqLrBDg
R%VC=C=Dd%KQPISK
e i fz i
e {f^ ª i v 6v i
3I¢P=bVIR Gi sD%K ]*R%DqLrBUdK\P`UWKkP`IBIBVSI*RdS
c 2 ¨S¤
¦
¦O¤o ¬¨¤
¦O 3InoD%rK$bd
IBUWN.]nVSrBNR%DOaz2P`NQU^PI*RD.a%]obDOa
KQD%I*aMD%r*NQa$nP`NMKMUeRrB^UWDONQa KMDOI*aMD%rBN\aaMcCYd%KMNQU^qLrBD.aD%KP`ILKMUeaMLC=d%KMNQU^qLrBD.a%n3I¡noD%rBK=PWVSNQa$bd.RVSCYnoVSaMD%N
KQVrKkKMD%IaDOrBNkaMVr*a"eP=VSNMC=DbDeP
aMVC=C=Db r*IKMDOI*aDOrBNkaMcCYd%KMNQU^qLrBD$D%Kb rBIKQD%I*aMD%rBNP`ILKMUeacC=dZ
KQNMUeqLrBD
gIaMDsnBeP %PILK"b*P`I*a^D$R%Pa"b rBIKQD%I*aMD%rBN fzmi mi`] DOaKkaMLC=d%KMNQU^qLrBDsaUS
e 6v yfz ªrv rv
3I¢P=bVIR`]*bBPI*a"RD$ROPaO]
D.aiKkPILKMUeacC=dKQNMUeqLrBD$aUS
e lv yfQ ªrv 6v
3I¢P=bVIR`]*bBPI*a"RD$ROPaO]
1
? VrK(KMDOI*aMD%rBN
noD%rK$bVIRaO d.RNQUWNQDaMVr*ak^P5VNQCYD
P,zSDOR $aMcCYd%KMNQU^qLrBDDK
PILKMUeacC=dKQNMUeqLrBD
%'& Û %)(
{.E
¤o¤o ¦ c
^ ,¤
¦Y¦ O¤
c©
U^Icz2P`NQU^PISKQDOaO*D%ePD.aiK"[ VS~hiDKkbBrnP`N\P`_N\P`n*@BDaMrBU^z,PILKO
GJILKMNQVbrBUeaVSI*a
bVSI*R¢rBIBDIBVSrBzDOW^D¢n*P`U^NQD¢bBD~*PaMDOa
bD 9D%K K mi2]aVSUWDOISK YDK i TJ 3I
U^ILKMNQVbrBUWK"PWVSNQap^DOamR%Vc D 55RU^D%ILKQa"qLrBUnDONMC=DKMKMDOISKkbBD(nPaQaDONb rBI*D$~*PaMD$[ P`rKQNMDg
DK
DOaK"^P=C
P`KMNQU^R%D
bBDOa ]*qLrBUbVSIBIBDs^DOamR%VLD 55RU^D%ILKQa"bD.azD.RTKMDOrBN\a"bDs^P
bDOrUWAOC=D(~PaMDsb*P`I*a
ePnBNMDOC=UWAONMDS]BqSr*UDOaK"PnBnoD%^d%D(KMN\PbUWKMU^VI*IBD%^WDOC=D%ILKpC
P`KMNQU^R%DsbBDsR\@P`IB_SD%C=D%ILK"bDs~*PaMD.cVSIXU^IczD%N\aMD
D.aiK(^PXC
P2KMNQUeRD
~PaMD
bD.a mIzSDORKMD%r*N bB1
PYnVSrBNkR%VC=nVLaMPILKMDOa b*P`I*aePY~*PaMD T
D qLrBU±PXnVSrBN(R%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.amrBI zDORKMDOrBN b*P`I*a^P
krI*UWzSDOP`r¢bD.a"DOaMn*PR%DOabr*Pr]VIP"
i
i i
D%K i
kIzD.RTKMDOrBN isbDa i$bDR%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.a
~PaMD i
¬bBP`Ia"^P5~*PaMD "i "P5nVSrBNkRVSC=nVLaMPISKQDOa
¬bBP`Ia"^P
l"DOnBNQD%IBVSI*aWDKMDOI*aDOrBN b VSNQbNQDKMNQVUeabrYn*PNQP_N\P`nB@BDnBNMd.Rd.bD%ILKOp.cD.aIBVrBzSD%^WD.a RVcVN\bVI*IBd%D.a
aMVILK
v i v
) ) v + i + v
) + ) v i + v
) + ) +
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
{ s
D%KmUWIczSD%N\aDOCYDOILK
) ) +
f Vr*N^DOaVSNMCrB^DOabU^NQDORTKQDOaO]%VSI$nDOrKNQD%C
P`N\qLrBD%NqLrBDR\@*PqLrBDbBUWC=D%IaU^VIR%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PISKQD]\IBVKMd%D
P,zSDOR rBI$U^I*bUeRDpar*ndONMU^D%rBN.]%U^ILKMNQVbrBUWKrBI$ªPSRTKMDOrBN].PWVSNQaqLrBDR\@*PqLrBDbBUWC=D%IaU^VIR%V2z,PNMUeP`ILKQD]TIBVKMd%D
P,zSDORrBI¢UWIbU^R%DsUWIdONMU^D%r*NO]U^ILKMNQVcbBrBUKmr*IªPSRTKQD%rBN o DOaK"R%DKMKMDbUeodONMDOI*RD$bDR%VC=noVNMKMD%C=DOISKmqLrBU
2R%DsqLrBUU^ILKMNQVbrBUWKr*I
ªPSRTKQD%rBN ¡D%Kmz2P`NQUWD$bVSI*RsbVI*R$R%VC=C=DsWD.azDORKMDOrBNQa"bBD$~*PaMD
R%D$qSr*Uz2P`NQUWDsD%I¢aMD%I*aVSnBnVLadsD%KmUWILKMNQVbrBUWKkbVIRr*IªPSRTKQD%rBN g
]DKkqLr DOaKkRVSISKQNQP,z2PNMUeP`ILK
\
W ¦ c
¤ ¦ B¨¦ 0¤
WVIBI*VI*aeP
bd IBUKQUWVSIarBN"r*ID%cDOC=nBWDS
¦ ª¤
('. &9C!*IG U%J
ST'& 9 gU%'I D$ mi
#('JRJK 9!%
DU !*0 W T*( I,
mi &8'(*.H 2 98 9 !% D> !]''# 2 i
e < i f^ i e 8 fz < i v 8 2 v < i v 2 i" v 8
@r.MCD$O )D$!*SLD$m ! 9 !% 2 &"' " 7
%`GXB *I@& D9. 2 392-< + 45 "*587 D$ `IG0%
.N)D9.H#%
' W
pD.aiKmr*IBD$P`rKQNMDs~*PSaD$bD
]*VI¢P"
gIDeoD%KO]*aMU
v i v i v v i v i v
v i v i v
v i v i v
mDOaKkbVIR$bd
*I*UbDC
P`I*UWAONMDsU^IS KQNMU^I*aMAOqLrBD$D%KmDOaKm~BUWDOI¢rBIBD$VSNMC=Ds~BU^WU^IBdOPUWNQDaMrBNL i uQ
]bVI*R
r*IKQD%I*aMD%r*NO 3I¢P"
%'& Û %)(
{s0
GJSªP`rKNMDOC
P`N\qSr*D%NqLrBDgePkR%VILKMN\PRKMU^VIsIBDnDOrKaMDgªPUWNQDqLrBDaMrBNbBDOaUWI*bBU^R%DOa0 rBIR%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PISK.]
[ P`rKQNMD$RV2z2PNMUeP`ILKOGW PrKMNQD$n*P`NMKO]U^ªPrK"KMVSr2hiVrBN\anBNQdOR%U^aMD%N"qLrBD%ea"aMVILK"WD.aUWI*bBU^R%DOa"rKQUW^Uead.a%
j n*P`NMKMU^NsbDYR%DKMKMDYnBNMDOC=UWAONMDbBd *IBUWKMU^VI]oVSInoD%rK$bd *IBU^N(^DYnBNMVbr*UKsRVILKQNQPSRTKMdYbDbBD%rKQD%IZ
aMD%r*NQaO]qLrBUpDOaKWDXNMd.arBWKQP`Kbrn*NMVbrBUWKKQD%I*aMVNQUWDObDbD%r«KMDOI*aMD%rBN\a%]ar*UWzcUnP`Nr*IBDR%VILKMN\PRKMU^VI
aMrBNrBIU^I*bUeRDbrnBNMDOC=UWDONmKMDOI*aMD%rBNDKr*IUWI*bBU^R%DbD0 P`rKQNMDKMD%IaDOrBNO 3IWDIBV`KQ D
W(P`Ia"WDROPa_Sd%IBdONQP0]BR%DKKQDIBVKQP2KQUWVSID.aiKUWI*R%VC=nB^AKQD]BnBr*U^aQqLr DOW^D$IBD$nBNQdOR%U^aMD$n*PSaWD.a"UWIbU^R%DOamaMrBN
^DOaQqLrBD%eaePYR%VILKMN\PRKMU^VIDOaK"ªP`UWKMD
3IIBV`KQD(bD() C (%C=D
rBInBNQVcbBrBUK"bVSrB~B^D%C=D%ILK"RVILKQNQPSRTKMdST 3InDOrK"D%I Ibd *IBU^NO]
^VN\aQqSr*D(R%D%ePD.aiKmnoVSaQaMUW~B^D]r*In*NMVbrBUWKKMVKQP`^D%C=DOISKkR%VILKMN\PRKMdS]cqLrBUbVIBI*DsPWVSNQaprBIaQR%P^PUWNQD
¦.
6P5RVSISKQNQPSRTKQUWVSID.aiKUWI*bBd%noD%I*bBPILKMDbBD^P5~*PaMDo?VSrKaQR%P`eP`U^NQD]V~BKMD%Icrn*PNR%VILKMN\PRKMU^VIRVSCZ
n*WA%KMDb rBIKMD%IaDOrBNO]oVr b r*InBNQVcbBrBUKsbDKQD%I*aMD%r*NO]VrBNQIBUWK(bVSI*Rr*IIBVC~BNQDUWIbd%noD%I*b*P`ILK(bD^P
~PaMD]BR` DOaKm=bUWNQD$rBI¢U^ILz2PNMUeP`ILKO
fgNQD%I*VI*ap^D(ROPapb r*IXKQD%I*aMD%rBN({sRVILKQNQP,z2P`NQUeP`ILKgDKs{(R%V2z2P`NQU^PISK. WDC
PIBUWAONMDsRePaQaMU^qLrBDS]SVSIXaMPUK
qLrBDY^DOasRVc D 55R%UWDOISK\asbr noV^cI C=D=R%PNQPSRTKMdONMUeaKMUeqSr*
D
aMVILKsbDOasU^Icz,PNMUeP`ILK\a%]bVILKsWD
bBdKMDONMC=U^I*P`IL
K DKkeP=KQNQPSRD
aVSILKkbDOaR%Pamn*P`NMKMUeRrB^U^D%N\a%Bl"DOC
P`N\qSr*VI*amb PUW^WDOrBN\amqLrBD$^P
KQNQPSRDkR%VNQNMD.anoVIbY^PR%VILKMN\PRKMU^VI5br5KMD%IaDOrBNOT 3I
nDOrKV~KQD%IBU^NrBI*DP`rBKMNQD"ªP`C=U^W^Db U^ILz2PNMUeP`ILKQa
nP`NmRVSILKMN\PRTKQUWVSI$
Xh
X
X
XZ
)
> Q#BRCQ#KVFR I BR KB Q#R 4LaQ QUKL)@NjIN@Q#B
6PbUeaiKQUWIRTKMU^VID%ILKMNQDR%V2z2P`NQU^PI*RD"D%KR%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PI*RDzcUWDOILKbD^PYbU eodONMDOI*RD(bDsRVC=noVNMKMDOCYDOILK
) + ) +
bBDOa"U^I*bUeRD.akRVSNMNQDOaMnoVI*bBPILKQapD%IROPambDR\@*P`IB_SD%C=D%ILKkbD~*PaMDoDONK\P`U^I*a"U^ILKMNQVcbBrBU^aMD%ILKmrBI¢ªPSRTKQD%rBN
]*b P`rBKMNQDOarBIªPRKMDOrBN g*lmPnBnoD%^VI*a
.cU D.aiK±rBIYDOaMn*PR%DD%r*R%WUebU^D%I]2D%K D.aiK±CrBIBU*b rBIBD~*PSaDVSNKQ@BVIBVSNMC=dOD].DKgaU[ VI=aD^UWC=UWKMD"sbDOa
R\@P`IB_SD%C=D%ILKQaDOILKMNQD(~PaMDOaVNMKM@*VIBVSNMC=d%D.a%]R%DKKQDbUeaiKQUWIRTKMU^VIbUeaMn*P`N\P eKO" W(P`I*akRDR%PSaD%I¢ D eDK.]*^DOa
C
P`KMNQU^R%DOapbDR\@*PIB_DOC=D%ILKpbD(~*PSaD(aVSISKpVNMKM@BVS_VSI*P`^DOaO]`DK^D%rBNpUWIczSD%N\aDmD.aiK"bVSI*Rm^D%rBNKMN\P`IanoVSaMd%Dg
6PbDOrUWAOCYD(n*PNKQU^R%rB^PNMUWKMdb r*ID.an*PSRDmDOr*R^UebUWDOIXD.aiK0 DUeaiKQD%I*R%Db rBInBNMVbr*UK"aMROP`eP`U^NMDS]SqLrBU
D.aiKmr*IBDsVNQC=D(~*UW^UWI*dOP`U^NQD(nP`NMKMUeRrB^UWAONMD *0acC=dKQNMUeqLrBD]*bBd *IBU^D$DKmnoVSaMUWKMU^zD 2 mVKMVIa"^ P a 3InoD%rK
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
{. s
I*V`KMDON
e 6v yf^ ªrv
D.aiKP`r*aQaMUor*I5KMDOI*aMD%rBNP`nBnoD%^dKMD%IaDOrBNCYd%KMNQU^qLrBDSDKMDOI*aMD%rBNnoD%NQCYD%KbBD(bd *IBU^NrBIXUeaVSC=VNMZ
n*@BU^aMC=D$D%ILKMNQDm¥D%KGmi(n*PN
e lv yfz w ª %v yx
aMVUWK 0 DOIR%VILKMN\PRKQP`ILK"ar*Np^DOapU^I*bUeRD.amvD%KkEB*DK"UeaVSCYVSNMn*@BU^aMC=DPYnoVrBNC
P2KQNMUeRD(^P
C
P`KMNQU^R%DsbBD ]*aMVUWK
D%KKMD=P`n*nBWUeR%P`KMU^VI nDONMC=D%Ksb UebD%ILKMU *DON DK i2'.cU bf; P5noVrBN(RVC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.a b*P`I*a
r*IBDs~*PaMD]cVIIBV`KQD WD.apR%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.abD b*P`I*apeP~PaMD(brP`^D(bDmmi`]DK"VSIP"
6DOa5R%VC=noVSaQP`ILKMD.a aVSILKXP`nBnoD%^d%D.aX¨¤o ¤o ¦ c¡¨¤ ¦ c«bD 3I P¡P`^VN\a g
3I¢V~BKMU^D%ILKmbD$) C (%C=D$rBIBDsNQD%eP2KMU^VID%ILKQNMDsU^I*bUeRDOakRV2z2P`NQU^PILKQaDKkRVSILKMN\P,z,PNMUeP`ILK\a
P,zSDOR]LnP`N"DDOCYn*WDg
W(P`I*asr*IBD
~*PaMDYVNMKM@BVSIBVNQC=d%D]oVIP
]DK¢RD=C=VC=D%ILK$ ^*] n3I noD%rBKP`^VN\a
PSaMaMU^CYU^^D%NsWD.a$U^I*bUeRDOa$R%VILKMN\P,z2P`NQU^PILKQaDK^DOasU^I*bUeRDOa$R%V2z2P`NQU^PISK\a
U.D%rB
[ VN\bNMDbBrKMDOI*aMD%rBNUWILKMDONMzcU^D%ILKPWVSNQaO]*D%KnoVrBN(bU^aKMU^IB_SrBD%N(zD.RTKMDOrBN\a%]C=P`KMNQU^R%DDKKMDOI*aDOrBN\akb VN\bNQD
aMrBnod%NQUWDOrBN.]VInDOrKmIBV`KQD%N ]*£ ] W^
%'& Û %)(
{2}
Û"uÌ?v$wxyz
Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,
615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LÈS NANCY
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex
Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN
Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex
Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex
Éditeur
INRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)
ISSN 0249-0803