Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 26

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW

,(-"&"(-,("'& & & .


!"#$%&"'(%')'*"+',")-'%.'!"#$%&
!#'$%(''&)(*$(+/'0'1'#"2"-'.-%&'(3"
"45(%-/

/-0(%,-"& & & & 1


67&8'9()-(',%7-'$)-""-':,'$3"$;5*<
%7('(3"9"'"="*(9')##'&%*(3'#%*</

%(*'&23&45(&*((6' ' 7
>:)&)')**%7*$"9',"(')*%(3"-
3%795*<':)5#%7(

%(*'&!"$(3'& ' ' 8


$%)('49(%4&!-%6$%:& & ;
1*'%="-=5"+'%.'(3"'5*="9(&"*(
:)*;5*</

/2%'#04$%:&& &&&&&&& &&&&&&&&& <=


1*'%="-=5"+'%.'$%*97#?*</

-//2#%4$%:& &&& &&&&&&&&& <+


1*'%="-=5"+'%.')$$%7*?*</

'/5220&>"23$0(& &
@")(7-5*<'ABC'D)-93)##'B$3%%#'%.
E795*"99/

/-"(("&4$>''' '
&&&&&&&&

''''''''
<1

<8
INSIDE
F")$35*<'(3"':)95$9/ &&45(&3$%-%/$-0&/"$'$'&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&<?
$%4(")$(*& & & &&&&&&&& <; ''''K")4'(3"'<"*"-)#'%="-=5"+'%*'(3"'L*)*$5)#'$-5959M
''''5(N9'<#%:)#'5&8)$(M')*4'3%+'5('&),')O"$(',%7M'(3"
F3"'35<3#,')*?$58)("4'GH1'+5(3 ''''9(74"*(/
I-%."99%-'D$J"=52/

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&+
0(44("&3"29&45(
(,$42"
,(-"&"(-,("'@
!"#$%&"'(%')'*"+',")-'%.'E-75*'E795*"99'K"=5"+/'P'+%7#4'#5;"'(%'();"'(359'?&"'(%'+)-&#,'(3)*;')##'%7-'-"(7-*5*<'-")4"-9'.%-',%7-'
$%*?*7"4'9788%-(')9'+"##')9'%8"*#,'<-""('%7-'*"+'-")4"-9'+3%'3)="'Q79('Q%5*"4'%7-'87:#5$)?%*/'B5*$"'%7-'5*$"8?%*M'E-75*'
E795*"99'K"=5"+'3)9'9(-5="4'(%'8-%=54"',%7'+5(3'78'(%'4)("'5*.%-&)?%*'(3)('59'8"-?*"*('(%',%7-'.7(7-"/

E-75*'E795*"99'K"=5"+'3)9'"9():#593"4'5(9"#.')9'(3"'8-"&5"-'.-""':795*"99'&)<)R5*"')('ACS1/'!5(3'"="-,'=%#7&"')*4'"="-,'5997"M'
+"'9"";'(%'+%-;'+5(3'(3"'9(74"*(':%4,'(%'87:#593'$%*("*('(3)('59')5&"4')('8-%=545*<'9(74"*(9'+5(3'(3"'5*.%-&)?%*'*""4"4'(%'87('
(3"&'%*"'9("8')3")4/'F359'&),'()$;#"')*,'5997"'.-%&'-"$-75(&"*('4")4#5*"9'(%'-"97&"'?89'%-'.-%&'(3"'L*)*$5)#'5*479(-,'(%'(3"'
$%*97#?*<'5*479(-,/'!3)("="-',%7-'*""49M'E-75*'E795*"99'K"=5"+'3)9':""*'(3"-"'(%'8-%=54"'(3"&/

19'+"':"<5*')'*"+'=%#7&"M'+"'3%8"'(%'$%*?*7"'(%'&""(',%7-'"T8"$()?%*9')*4'&%-"/'F%'$%*?*7"'(%'8-%=54"'(3"'ACS1'9(74"*('
:%4,'+5(3'U7)#5(,'5*.%-&)?%*M'+"'+5##':"'&);5*<')'."+'$3)*<"9'(3)('+"'.""#'+5##'5&8-%="'%7-'%="-)##'$%*("*(/'P*')*'"O%-('(%';""8'
")$3'5997"'"="*'&%-"'-"#"=)*('(%'9(74"*(9M'+"'+5##':"'"9():#5935*<'*"+'9"$?%*9'4"45$)("4'(%'5*="9(&"*(':)*;5*<M'$%*97#?*<M')*4'
)$$%7*?*</'P*')445?%*M'+"'+5##'8-%=54"',%7'+5(3'5*479(-,')*4'$)-""-'8-%L#"9'+5(3'")$3'5997"'(%';""8',%7'5*.%-&"4'%.'+3)('
%88%-(7*5?"9')-"'%7('(3"-"/

F3"9"'$3)*<"9'$%&"')9'E-75*'E795*"99'K"=5"+N9'&)5*'<%)#'59'(%'9"-="',%7/'F%'3"#8'79'4%'(359M'P'+%7#4'#5;"'(%'"*$%7-)<"',%7'(%'
$%*?*7"'9"*45*<'5*'-"$%&&"*4)?%*9')9'(%'3%+'+"'$)*'5&8-%="'%7-'87:#5$)?%*/'P('59',%7-'.""4:)$;'(3)('3)9'3"#8"4';""8'79')'
97$$"99/

1<)5*'P'+%7#4'#5;"'(%'.%-&)##,'(3)*;'"="-,%*"'.%-'(3"5-'$%*?*7)#'9788%-(/'!5(3%7(')*,'.7-(3"-'4"#),M'P'+%7#4'#5;"'(%'8-"9"*('(%',%7'
%7-'L-9('5997"'.%-'(3"'VWWX0VWYW'9$3%%#',")-/'P'95*$"-"#,'3%8"'(3)(',%7'$%*?*7"'(%'<"(')9'&7$3'%7('%.'E-75*'E795*"99'K"=5"+')9'
+"'4%/

!)-&#,M

E"*Q)&5*'S%
Z45(%-05*0C35".

!!"&'4-33
>"('$,(%4 )$/(&>"('$,(%4@&3$%-%/( 3$%-%/( -,)$'2"'
B7**,'!%*< Z-5$'I)-; B("83"*'D%%$; @-"4'^5&
65*'B7* J&5(-,'B379("-
(,$42"&$%&/5$(3 -''2/$-4(&(,$42"
E"*Q)&5*'S% C-59?*)'C)-5##% 9-"6(4$%:
B(".)*5"'67
)$/(&>"('$,(%4@& /2>A&(,$42" K%:"-('C3)*< &&>BCDC&/EFGHDI
2>("-4$2%' 6"979'["-"45) C3-59']%7*< ''C%="-'83%(%'$%7-("9,'%.'S%*)'_3)%
67#5"'C3"* 6)*"'^5& ''1-?$#"'83%(%9'$%7-("9,'%.'
2>("-4$2%' '''+++/9T$/37
)$/(&>"('$,(%4@& J)=54'\),R*"- /"(-4$)(& ''P*("-=5"+'83%(%'$%7-("9,'%.'ACS1
9-"6(4$%: ,()(02>9(%4 'B$3%%#'8-%L#"'83%(%'$%7-("9,'%.'
C3-59?*"'S57 1&%-"2"'6"*< 'ABC
S%*)'_3)%
!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&.
45(&/-0(%,-"
2/4J%2)&+==?
2KDCLFE&+M %CNFOLFE&.
6%-4)*'E"#.%-('`'F3"'!%#.'%.'!)##'B(-""( !)-*"-'E-%9/'B8");"-'B"-5"9a'K"97&"9lP*("-=5"+5*<
[%9(a'1#83)'^)88)'I95'E795*"99'@-)("-*5(, [%9(a'E"()'1#83)'I95'1$$%7*?*<'[%*%-9'B%$5"(,
F5&"a'b8& F5&"a'i0j8&
S%$)?%*a'[)5*"9'cX S%$)?%*a'E7*$3"'VYiW'
J"9$-58?%*a' I-"=5%79' &7#?&5##5%*)5-"' )*4' )7(3%-' %-'
dF3"'!%#.'%.'!)##'B(-""(e')*4'dC)($35*<'(3"'!%#.'%.'!)##' %CNFOLFE&?
B(-""(eM' 6%-4)*' E"#.%-(M' +5##' <5="' ) '&%?=)?%*)#' 98""$3' 1PFC'!%-;93%8a'B"$-"(9'(%'188#,5*<'(%'k-)47)("'B$3%%#
):%7(':795*"99'"(35$9')*4'97$$"99/ F5&"a'f8&
S%$)?%*'VWc'C%="#
2KDCLFE&+M J"9$-58?%*a'1445?%*)#'+%-;93%8'%*'g%=/'Vc')('iacW8&
1PFC'!%-;93%8a'C)-""-9'5*'E795*"99'C%*97#?*<
F5&"a'f8&
S%$)?%*a'VWc'C%="#'
%CNFOLFE&<=
J"9$-58?%*a' 1445?%*)#' +%-;93%89' %O"-"4' g%=/' YV' )('
E-75*'P*("-*9358')*4'B7&&"-'6%:'@)5-M'@)##'VWWX
f8&')*4'g%=/'Vh')('i8&
F5&"a'F7"94),'YY0c8&
S%$)?%*a'B"$%*4'@#%%-'S%7*<"M'1$;"-&)*
2KDCLFE&+M
J"9$-58?%*a'k"('(3"'$3)*$"'(%' &""('78'+5(3'"&8#%,"-9'
6%:'B")-$3'67&89()-(a'DE1
98"$5L$)##,' ()-<"?*<' ACS1' 9(74"*(9/' @%-' $7--"*(#,'
F5&"a'F7"94),'h0j8&
-"<59("-"4'ACS1'9(74"*(9'%*#,/'E-75*'PJ'-"U75-"4/
S%$)?%*a'B(-)(3&%-"'E#4</
Y9('@#%%-M'K%%&'YYb
%CNFOLFE&<+
6%:'B")-$3'67&89()-(a'@%-'1##'D)Q%-9
2KDCLFE&+;
F5&"a'F37-94),'Y0h8&
ACS1'k-)47)("')*4'I-%."995%*)#'B$3%%#'@)5-'VWWX
S%$)?%*a'C)-""-'C"*("-M
F5&"a'!"4*"94),'YY0c8&M
c-4'@#%%-M'C%*."-"*$"'K%%&
S%$)?%*a'1$;"-&)*'k-)*4'E)##-%%&
J"9$-58?%*a' C7--"*(#,' -"<59("-"4' ACS1' B(74"*(9' %*#,/'
E-75*'PJ'-"U75-"4/ %CNFOLFE&<1
E-75*'C%*97#?*<'k-""*'F"$3*%#%<,'C)9"'C%&8"??%*
F5&"a'j)&0j8&
%CNFOLFE&+
S%$)?%*a'[7&)*5?"9'1fY
1PFC'!%-;93%8'E795*"99'YWYa'P*="9(&"*('E)*;5*<
J"9$-58?%*a' ' E-75*'C%*97#?*<N9'h(3' 1**7)#'B(-)("<,' )*4'
F5&"a'f8&
>8"-)?%*9' C)9"' C%&8"??%*/' C%&8"("' +5(3' (%8'
S%$)?%*a'VWc'C%="#
7*4"-<-)49' 5*' )' ci' 3%7-' $%&8"??%*' (%' 4"="#%8' )'
J"9$-58?%*a'1445?%*)#'+%-;93%8'%O"-"4'g%=/'YX')('f8&
8-"9"*()?%*' )*4' -"$%&&"*4)?%*9' -"<)-45*<' $#")*'
"*"-<,/'
%CNFOLFE&.
1PFC'!%-;93%8a'[%+'(%'k"('P*(%')'k-")('DE1'I-%<-)&
,FKFOLFE&1
F5&"a'f8&
6%:'B")-$3'67&89()-(a'S)9('C3)*$"'.%-'@)##M'1##'D)Q%-9
S%$)?%*a'VWc'C%="#
F5&"a'@-54),'Y0h8&
J"9$-58?%*a'1445?%*)#'+%-;93%8'%O"-"4'g%=/'Vh')('f8&
S%$)?%*a'C)-""-'C"*("-M
c-4'@#%%-M'C%*./'K&/

,-$.%& #/& 01"& 233& 4567& 8492:(;$9'& $%& <=(& 71;;1%'>& ?1"@'=1/'& 1%&
ABC7D4&2%:&93$9@&1%&E?1"@'=1/'FG
!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&1
%(*'&23&45(&*((6
2LPOP&-QQCRQKFI&AFD
-QCDBFE&5CRIHQS&!PHTCRD
!A&'#%%A&*2%:
4BF& 2LPOP& PGOHQHIDEPUCQ' '(%$2"&'4-33&*"$4("
-"$"*(#,' )**%7*$"4' )' *"+' 3%795*<'
:)5#%7(' 8-%<-)&' (%' :%#9("-' (3"' )5#5*<' !
3%795*<' &)-;"(/' 1#(3%7<3' (3"-"' 3)="'
:""*' 9#5<3(' 5&8-%="&"*(9M' .%-"$#%97-"'
-)("9' )-"' 9?##' 5*$-")95*<' )*4' %="-)##'
3%795*<' 8-5$"9' )-"' )88-%T5&)("#,' cW'
8"-$"*(' #%+"-' (3)*'5*' VWWb/'F3"5-' 8#)*'
)5&9' (%' )9959(' #%$)#' )*4' 9()("' 3%795*<'
)<"*$5"9'(%'8-%=54"'$3")8"-'&%-(<)<"9'
( %' L - 9 ( 0 ? & "' % -' # % + 0 5 * $ % & "'
3%&":7,"-9/'F3"')4&5*59(-)?%*' 3%8"9'
(3)(' (359' 8-%<-)&' +5##' 3"#8' #%+"-'
5*$%&"'.)&5#5"9'87-$3)9"'3%&"9'5*'(3"'
&549('%.'(359'(%7<3'"$%*%&5$'9(%-&/'

F%' 8-%=54"' .7*45*<' (%' (3"9"' 3%795*<'


L*)*$"' )<"*$5"9M' (3"' <%="-*&"*('
8 # ) * 9' ( %' 3 ) = "' ( 3 "' F - " ) 9 7 - ,'
J"8)-(&"*(M' @)**5"' D)"M' )*4' @-"445"'
D)$' 87-$3)9"'3%795*<':%*49/'F359'+5##'
3"#8' 3%795*<' L*)*$"' )<"*$5"9' &);"'
*"+' #%)*9' (%' 8%("*?)#' 3%&":7,"-9/' ()T8),"-9' +5##' *%(' 3)="' (%' 93%7#4"-' (3"' 5*5?)?="9' (3)(' 45-"$(#,' ()-<"(9' #%+"-0'
F3"'<%="-*&"*(' )#9%'8#)*9'(%'5*9?(7("' :7-4"*' 5*' 8),5*<' .%-' (359' 8-%<-)&M' (3",' 5*$%&"'3%&":7,"-9/
)' ("&8%-)-,' $-"45(' 8-%<-)&' 9%' (3)(' 3)="'*%(',"('-"#")9"4'5*.%-&)?%*'%*'3%+'
(3"9"' )<"*$5"9' $)*' -"L*)*$"' (3"5-' (359'8-%<-)&'+5##':"'.7*4"4/'[%+"="-M'(3"' F3"' )4&5*59(-)?%*N9'#)9(' 3%795*<':)5#%7(M'
"T59?*<' :%*49M' +35$3' +5##' 5&8-%="' F-")97-,' J"8)-(&"*(' 59' -"98%*95:#"' 5.' )' -"#")9"4' 5*' @":-7)-,M' 9""&"4' (%' 3)="'
#5U7545(,' )$$"99' .%-' (3"' %7(9()*45*<' 3%795*<')<"*$,'3)88"*9' (%'4".)7#(' %*' 5(9' +%-;"4' -)(3"-' +"##' 9%' .)-/' 1$$%-45*<' (%'
:%*49/' ' F3"' )4&5*59(-)?%*' "9?&)("9' $-"45('8),&"*(9/' (3"'@"4"-)#' [%795*<' @5*)*$"' 1<"*$,' )*4'
(359' 8-%<-)&' +5##' )##%+' 3%795*<' (3"' J"8)-(&"*(' %.' [%795*<' )*4' A-:)*'
J"="#%8&"*(M'&5##5%*9'%.'1&"-5$)*9'3)="'
)<"*$5"9'(%'#"*4'&%*",'(%'37*4-"49'%.'
(3%79)*49'' %.' 1&"-5$)*9/' F3"'
V#TUOPDFTZ@&DBHI& :""*' ):#"'(%'();"')4=)*()<"'%.' (3"'#%+"-'
95R"' %.' (3"' 8-%<-)&' +5##' 4"8"*4' %*' BCRIHQS&LPHTCRD&PHOI& &%-(<)<"' -)("9M'-"97#?*<' 5*' )*' 5*$-")9"4'
)<"*$,'4"&)*4/' DC&FQPLTF&DBFIF& * 7 & : " - 9' % .' 3 % 7 9 5 * <' 8 7 - $ 3 ) 9 " 9 /''
BCOFCYQFEI&DC&[FFX& A#?&)("#,M' (359' 3%795*<' :)5#%7(' )5&9' (%'

V(WXFEDI&LFTHFNF&DBPD& DBFHE&BCOFI\] "*):#"' (3"9"' 3%&"%+*"-9' (%' ;""8' (3"5-'


3%&"9/' F3"' *"+' 8-%<-)&' 59' "T8"$("4' (%'
DBHI&QFY&HQHUPUNF& ZT8"-(9' :"#5"="'(359' *"+'5*5?)?="' 93%7#4' #)7*$3' )-%7*4' g%="&:"-M' +35$3' 59' )#9%'

IBCRTG&CQTZ&ITHSBDTZ& %*#,'9#5<3(#,'5&8-%="' (3"' 3%795*<'&)-;"('


:"$)79"' [%795*<' @5*)*$"' 1<"*$,0-"#)("4'
+3"*' )' qjMWWW' ()T' $-"45(' .%-' L-9(0?&"'
3%&":7,"-9'"T85-"9/'
HOXECNF&DBF&BCRIHQS& #%)*9' $%*9?(7("' )' ="-,' 9&)##' 8%-?%*' %.'
OPE[FD\] (3"' &%-(<)<"' &)-;"(/' noY' 8"-$"*(p''
[%+"="-M' (3"' 8-%<-)&' 59' 9?##' -)(3"-' 7=(9@& 1#<& ;1"(& H(+'& 10& <=(& ?((@& 1%&
1 # ( 3 % 7 < 3' % m $ 5 ) # 9' 3 )= "' 9 ( ) ( " 4' 95<*5L$)*('$%*954"-5*<'5('59'%*"'%.'(3"'."+' !"#$%!#'$%('')(*$(+G91;

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&7
%(*'&!"$(3' !A&-92"(44(&^(%:

*HQQFEI&C_&DBF&%CLFT& E"-;"#",' )44-"99"4' 45O"-"*$"9' 5*'


&)*)<5*<'$%*s5$(9':"(+""*'$%&8)*5"9'
(3",' %:()5*"4' )' hf' &5##5%*' 4%##)-'
:)5#%7(' )*4' )-"' $7--"*(#,' 8),5*<' #)-<"'
(KCQCOHKI&>EH`F&+==? )*4' &)-;"(9')9' +"##' )9'+3"*' )*4' +3,' 45=54"*49':)$;'(%'(3"'<%="-*&"*(/'
"m$5"*$,'%$$7-9'5*'"$%*%&5$'-"#)?%*9/
>*' >$(%:"-' YVM' VWWXM' F3"' B="-5<"9'
K5;9:)*;' I-5R"' 5*' Z$%*%&5$' B$5"*$"9' 5*'
D"&%-,'%.'1#.-"4'g%:"#'+)9'8-"9"*("4' 9PaCE&0CIIFI&_CE&
(%' (+%' 1&"-5$)*9a' Z#5*%-' >9(-%&' )*4' !PQ[&C_&-OFEHKP
>#5="-' !5##5)&9%*/' E%(3' +5**"-9' &)4"'
$%*(-5:7?%*9' (%' (3"' )*)#,959' %.' >*' @-54),' >$(%:"-' Yi(3M' 1&"-5$)N9'
#)-<"9(' :)*;M' E)*;' %.' 1&"-5$)M' 3)9'
" $ % * % & 5 $' < % = " - * ) * $ " M' % -' ( 3 "' -"8%-("4' )' 9(""8' #%99' %.' V/Vh' :5##5%*'
-"<7#)?%*9'(3)(')7(3%-5(,'L<7-"9'79"'(%' 4%##)-9' +5(35*' (3"' (35-4' U7)-("-/' F359'
98")-3")4' $%&8)*5"9' )*4' L*)*$5)#' #%99' $%5*$54"9' +5(3' (3"' :)*;' CZ>M' ^"*'
S"+59NM'#)9(' ,")-' %.' "&8#%,&"*(' :".%-"'
9,9("&9/' >9(-%&M' )' 8%#5?$)#' 9$5"*?9('
.-%&' P*45)*)' A*5="-95(,M' 59' (3"' L-9('
-"?-"&"*(/'19'%.'*%+M'(3"'$%&8)*,'3)9' 'CKHPT&%FDYCE[HQS&
,"(' (%' -"=")#' +3%' (3"' 97$$""45*<' CZ>'
+%&)*' "="-' (%' +5*' (3"' g%:"#' +5##' :"' (%' 7*4"-();"' (359' "*%-&%79' (bFKDI&CQ&'OPTT&
Z$%*%&5$9'I-5R"')*4'(3"'Lr3'+%&)*'(%' L*)*$5)#' :7-4"*/' F3"' &%-(<)<"' )*4'
$-"45(' $)-4' 45=595%*9' %.' (3"' :)*;' +"-"'
!RIHQFII&
+5*')'g%:"#'(359',")-/'["-' +%-;'.%$79"4'
35('(3"'3)-4"9(' )9'#"*4"-9')-"'L*45*<'5(' 1' -"$"*(' 9(74,' .-%&' P*("-*"(Vk%' )*4'
%*' 3%+' $%&&%*' *)(7-)#' -"9%7-$"9'#5;"' 5*$-")95*<#,' 45m$7#(' (%' 8),'(3"5-' #%)*9'
<-)R5*<' #)*4' )*4' .%-"9(9' $)*' :"' 79"4' :)$;/' [%+"="-M' :)4' #%)*9' 3)="' D"-$3)*(' C5-$#"' 5*45$)("9' (3)(' )#&%9('
97$$"99.7##,' :,' (3"' 8"%8#"' (3)(' ("*4' 4"$-")9"4' 5*' 9"="-5(,' $%&8)-"4' (%' 3)#.' (3"' 9&)##' :795*"99"9' 97-=","4' 79"'
( 3 " &' + 5 ( 3 % 7 (' < % = " - * & " * (' 8-"=5%79' #%99"9/' !3)(' -"&)5*9' 5*' 9%$5)#' *"(+%-;5*<' 95("9' .%-' #5;"' F+52"-'
U7"9?%*' 59'+3"*'(3"':)*;'+5##':"' ):#"' )*4' @)$":%%;M' (%' 5*$-")9"' (3"5-'
5*("-="*?%*/'!5##5)&9%*M')*' "$%*%&59(' ( %' 8 7 # #' 5 ( 9 " # .' % 7 (' % .' L * ) * $ 5 ) #'
.-%&' (3"' A*5="-95(,' %.' C)#5.%-*5)M' 4"8"*4"*$"' %*' (3"' <%="-*&"*(' 95*$"' 87:#5$5(,/'F359'.%-&'%.')4="-?95*<'59'*%('
%*#,' .-""M' :7(' )#9%' 5*$-"45:#,' "O"$?="'
47"'(%' (3"' 98""4' )*4' =)9(#,'5*$-")9"4'
-)*<"'%.'8%("*?)#'$%*97&"-9/'[%+"="-M'
4 " 9 8 5 ( "' ( 3 "' 5 * s 7 T' 5 *' 8 % 9 5 ? = "'
8-%&%?%*M'(3"-"')-"'8%("*?)#' 4)*<"-9'
5*' 7?#5R5*<'9%$5)#'*"(+%-;5*<'95("9/'B7$3'
4)*<"-9' 5*$#74"' )4="-?95*<' (%' 97$3' )*'
"T("*(' (3)(' $%*97&"-9' :"$%&"'
)**%,"4' %-' (3"' .)$(' (3)(' $-5?$59&9' %.'
(3"' L-&' )-"' .%-' 87:#5$' =5"+5*</''
[%+"="-M' +5(3' 97$3' 79"-0.-5"*4#,'
("$3*%#%<,M':795*"99"9')-"'*%+'):#"'(%'
:-54<"' (3"' <)8' :"(+""*' (3"&9"#="9'
)*4'(3"5-'$%*97&"-9/'

'HW&3PKF&/BPESFI&CQ&
$QIHGFE&4EPGHQS
E5##5%*)5-"' K)Q' K)Q)-)(*)&M' .%7*4"-' %.'
(3"' k)##"%*' k-%78M' )*4' L="' %(3"-9M'
5*$#745*<' "T"$7?="9' .-%&' P*("#' )*4'
D$^5*9",' H' C%/M' +"-"' )--"9("4' .%-'

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&8
$%**"$?%*9' (%' +3)(' A/B/'
12%-*",'I-""('E3)-)-)'9()("4'59'
(3"' #)-<"9(' 3"4<"' .7*4' 5*954"-'
(-)45*<'"="-/'F3",'+"-"'$3)-<"4'
.%-' 8%$;"?*<' %="-' VW' &5##5%*'
4%##)-9' 5*' 5##"<)#' 8-%L(9' :,'
%:()5*5*<' 5*.%-&)?%*' ):%7('
:795*"99"9' #5;"' k%%<#"' P*$/' )*4'
[5#(%*' [%("#9/' F3"' 5##"<)#'
)$?=5?"9' +"-"' 9788%9"4#,'
$%*47$("4' 47-5*<' 67#,' %.' VWWb'
)*4' +"-"' 459$%="-"4' (3-%7<3'
L-9(' ?&"' "="-' $%7-(0)7(3%-5R"4'
+5-"()89/'

-IHPQ&/CRQDEHFI&
,COHQPDF&
!ECPGLPQG&
'FENHKFI
1' -"$"*(' 9(74,' %.' :-%)4:)*4'
9"-=5$"9':,'A*5="-95(,'%.'>T.%-4M'
Z*<#)*4')*4'A*5="-95(,'%.'>=5"4%M'
B8)5*')*4'9788%-("4':,'C59$%'"=)#7)("4' ,CY&5HDI&<==== -59"*' fW' 8"-$"*(/' J"985("' (359' 8%95?="'
(7-*'%.'"="*(9M'(3"'U7"9?%*'-"&)5*9')9'
ii'$%7*(-5"9')*4' VhW'$5?"9'(%' L*4' (3)(' (%' 3%+' #%*<' (359' -59"' +5##' #)9(/' E)9"4'
B%7(3' ^%-")' 3)9' $%&"' %7(' %*' (%8M' S)9(' +"";M' J%+' 6%*"9' P*479(-5)#' 9(-5$(#,' %*' 9(%$;9M' 5(' )88")-9' (3)(' (3"'
:")?*<'%7(' 6)8)*M'(3"' 8-"=5%79' #")4"-M' 14=)*()<"' -")$3"4' ):%="' YWMWWW' .%-' "$%*%&,' &),' :"' 9#%+#,' -"$%="-5*</'
)9'(3"' &)5*' :-%)4:)*4' 9"-=5$"' *)?%*/' (3"'L-9(' ?&"' (359' ,")-/'F359' $)&"' )9')' [%+"="-M'%(3"-9')-<7"'(3)('(359'-59"'+5##'
B%7(3' ^%-")M'+5(3')'(%()#'%.' Xbt'+5-"4' 93%$;' (%' 5*="9(%-9' 5*' (3"' &549(' %.' )' :"' :-5".' +5(3' 9%&"' 8-%L(9' :)9"4' %*'
3%79"3%#49M' 3)9' 3)4' )' &)995="' 4""8' -"$"995%*/' B5*$"' D)-$3M'J%+' 3)9' $7u*<'$%9(9M'*%('5*$-")95*<'")-*5*<9/'P('
5&8-%="&"*(' 5*' (3"'U7)#5(,' )*4' 98""4' $ ) *' ) # 9 %' : "' * % ( " 4' ( 3 ) (' ( 3 "'
%.' 5*("-*"(' 9"-=5$"9/'@%##%+5*<'6)8)*' 5*' 7*"&8#%,&"*(' -)("' 59' 9?##' )(' -"$%-4'
(35-4' 8#)$"' 59' [%*<' ^%*<' )*4' (3"*' 35<39M' +35$3' <%"9' )<)5*9(' 5*45$)(%-9' %.'
B + " 4 " * M' B + 5 ( R" - # ) * 4 M' ) * 4' ( 3 "' "$%*%&5$'5&8-%="&"*(/'
g"(3"-#)*49/'F3"' A*5("4'B()("9' 3)9'*%('
&)4"'5(' 5*(%' (3"'(%8'YW')*4'59'5*$#74"4'
5*' (3"'9"$%*4035<3"9('$)("<%-,'+35$3'59' 61&"(2:&/2'<&H(+'&!"$(0'I&9=(9@&1#<&
4"L*"4' )9' 3)=5*<' )' d$%&.%-():#"e' !"#$%!#'$%('')(*$(+G91;
)="-)<"' 5*("-*"(' $%**"$?%*/' F359' +)9'
)*' 5&8-%="&"*(' $%&8)-"4' (%' (3"'
8-"=5%79' ,")-' 5*' +35$3' (3"' 97-=",'
9()("4' (3)(' (3"' A*5("4' B()("9' 3)4'
9"-=5$"9'(3)('+"-"':)-"#,'97m$5"*(/

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&M
!"#$%$&!'"()$&)*$+"(,
$%)('49(%4&!-%6$%: !A&("$6-&6\&'20-%6$
P*="9(&"*(' :)*;5*<' 59' %*"' %.' (3"' &%9(' )2-)$?="'
)*4' ,"(' "#795="' $)-""-' %8?%*9' .%-' 9(74"*(9'
5*("-"9("4' 5*' :795*"990-"#)("4' 8-%."995%*9/'
P*="9(&"*(' :)*;"-9' )-"' ;*%+*' (%' :"' 35<3#,' "FIFPEKB
$%&8"*9)("4')*4' (%' +%-;' #%*<'3%7-9M':7(' 3%+'4%'
:)*;"-9'-);"' 5*' 9%' &7$3' $)85()#' )*4' +3)(' 4%' (3",' 'PTFI&c&4EPGHQS
4%'47-5*<'(3%9"'#%*<'3%7-9v'D)*,'%.'79'3)="'3")-4' ZU75(,M'@5T"4'
):%7(' 4):)<5-#9/$%&M'J)?*<')'E)*;"-' 1*%*,&%79M'
)' !":' 95("' 4"45$)("4' (%' $%*9%#5*<' (3"' 95<*5L$)*(' /CEXCEPDF&3HQPQKHQS
%(3"-9' %.' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;"-9' +3%' 3)="' :""*' DH1M'C)85()#'K)595*<M'
)O"$("4' :,' (3"' "$%*%&5$' -"$"995%*/' D)*,' %.' 79' A*4"-+-5?*<
3)="' )#9%' 9""*' (3"' C)-#%9' B%#59' $3)-)$("-' %*' (3"'
("#"=595%*'93%+'J"98"-)("'[%79"+5="9'+%%'359'+5."' !
+5(3' "T8"*95="' <"()+),9' %*' 8-5=)("' Q"(9')*4' qcWW' k"*"-)##,M' )*' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;N9' -"9")-$3' 4"8)-(&"*('
8"-.7&"9M' +35$3' 3"' .7*49' +5(3' 359' Q%:' 5*' :)*;5*</'[%+"="-M' (3%-%7<3#,'-"9")-$3"9'98"$5L$' $%&8)*5"9M'5*479(-5"9M')*4' (3"'
+35#"' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;5*<' &),' 9""&' (%' :"' %*"' %.' (3"' &%9(' "$%*%&,')*4'(3"*'&);"9'-"$%&&"*4)?%*9'):%7(' (3"':7,5*<'
#7$-)?="':795*"990-"#)("4' $)-""-' %8?%*9M'&)*,'9(74"*(9' +3%' )*4'9"##5*<'%.'=)-5%79'L*)*$5)#'8-%47$(9/'F3"'9)#"9')*4'(-)45*<'
)-"'$%*954"-5*<'87-975*<'5*("-*93589')*4'$)-""-9'5*'5*="9(&"*(' 4"8)-(&"*(M')9' (3"' *)&"' 5&8#5"9M' 5*$#74"9' 9)#"9' 8"%8#"' )*4'
:)*;5*<' 5*("-*93589' 4%' *%(' 3)="' $%&8-"3"*95="' 5*479(-,' (-)4"-9'+3%'4")#'+5(3'(3"'9"##5*<')*4':7,5*<'%.'"U75(,'n9(%$;9p'
;*%+#"4<"M' )*4' +5(3%7(' (3)(' ;*%+#"4<"' (3",' $)*N(' :"' #5;"' )*4' LT"4' 5*$%&"' n:%*49p/' B)#"9' )*4' (-)45*<' 9"-=5$"9' )-"'
C)-#%9' B%#59/' C)*454)("9' &79(' 3)="' )' (3%-%7<3' )*4' <"*"-)##,' .%-' 5*9?(7?%*)#' %-' 5*="9(%-9' +5(3' )' 35<3' *"(' +%-(3/'
$%&8-"3"*95="' 7*4"-9()*45*<' %.' (3"' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;5*<' F3"' $%-8%-)("' L*)*$"' 4"8)-(&"*(' 59' )#9%' ;*%+*' )9' (3"'
5*479(-,'(%'5&8-"99'"&8#%,"-9'47-5*<'5*("-=5"+9/ 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;5*<' 45=595%*M' +35$3' 59' .7-(3"-' 45=54"4' 5*(%'
8-%47$(' <-%789' )*4' 5*479(-,' <-%789/' F3"' 8-%47$(' <-%78'
V$QNFIDOFQD&LPQ[FEI&PEF&[QCYQ& 5*$#74"9' &"-<"-9' )*4' )$U7595?%*9M' L*)*$5)#' 98%*9%-9M' )*4'
DC&LF&BHSBTZ&KCOXFQIPDFG&PQG&DC& #"="-)<"4' L*)*$"/' F3"' $%="-)<"' <-%78' 9"-="9' $#5"*(9' .-%&'

YCE[&TCQS&BCREI\\\] =)-,5*<' 5*479(-5"9M' 5*$#745*<'L*)*$5)#' 5*9?(7?%*9M' 3")#(3$)-"M'


)*4'("$3*%#%<,M'(%'*)&"')'."+/'
P*' 95&8#"9(' ("-&9M' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;9' )-"' L*)*$5)#'
5*("-&"45)-5"9/'P*="9(&"*(':)*;"-9'9"-="' )9')':-54<"':"(+""*' F3"' 9)#"9' )*4' (-)45*<' 4"8)-(&"*(M' )9' (3"' *)&"' 5&8#5"9M'
(+%' 8)-?"9' (%' 3"#8' $%&8)*5"9M' )*4' 8%995:#,' <%="-*&"*(9M' 5*$#74"9'9)#"9'8"%8#"')*4'(-)4"-9'+3%'4")#'+5(3'(3"'9"##5*<')*4'
-)59"' $)85()#' (3-%7<3' &7#?8#"'&")*9/'P*="9(&"*(' :)*;"-9'$)*' :7,5*<'%.'"U75(,'n9(%$;9p')*4' LT"4' 5*$%&"' n:%*49p/'F3"-"')-"'
5997"' n%-' 7*4"-+-5("p' )*4' 9"##' 9"$7-5?"9M' +35$3' 5*$#74"' (,85$)##,'(3-""'(,8"9'%.' 9)#"98"-9%*9/'F3"-"'59'(3"'$#)995$'-"()5#'
8-5&)-5#,' "U75(,' n9(%$;9p' )*4' 4":(' n:%*49p/' P*' )445?%*M' :-%;"-M'+3%' 9"##9' 9(%$;9' )*4' 9(%$;')4=5$"' (%' (3"' )="-)<"'6%"M'
5*="9(&"*(' :)*;9' 8-%=54"' <754)*$"' (%' $%&8)*5"9' -"<)-45*<' (3"' 5*9?(7?%*)#' 9)#"98"-9%*M' +3%' +%-;9' +5(3' #)-<"'
&"-<"-9' )*4' )$U7595?%*9' )*4' +5(3' (-)45*<' 45O"-"*(' L*)*$5)#' 5*9?(7?%*)#' 5*="9(%-9M' )*4' (3"' 8-5=)("' $#5"*(' 9"-=5$"'
5*9(-7&"*(9M'97$3')9'$%&&%45(,0(%0"U75(,'9"$7-5?"9/ -"8-"9"*()?="M' +3%' +%-;9' +5(3' 7#(-)035<3' *"(' +%-(3'
5*45=547)#9/'[%+"="-M'9)#"9' )*4'(-)45*<'9"-=5$"9'5*' 5*="9(&"*('
F3"'9(-7$(7-"9'%.'5*="9(&"*(' :)*;9'=)-,'9#5<3(#,'4"8"*45*<'%*' :)*;9')-"'<"*"-)##,'.%-'5*9?(7?%*)#'%-'5*="9(%-9'+5(3')'35<3'*"('
(3"'5*45=547)#'L-&w'3%+"="-M'<"*"-)#'5*="9(&"*(':)*;9'5*$#74"' +%-(3/
(3-""' :)95$' 4"8)-(&"*(9a' -"9")-$3M' 9)#"9' )*4' (-)45*<M' )*4'
$%-8%-)("'L*)*$"/'' F-)4"-9M'%*' (3"' %(3"-' 3)*4M' 3"#8' .)$5#5()("' (3"' 87-$3)9"' )*4'
9"##5*<'%.'9"$7-5?"9':,'"T"$7?*<'(-)4"9'%*':"3)#.'%.')'$#5"*('%-'
3%#45*<' )*' 5*="*(%-,' %.' 9"$7-5?"9' (%' 9"##/' F3"-"' )-"' (+%'
8-5&)-,' -%#"9' (-)4"-9' 8#),' 5*' )' :)*;/' @5-9(M' (3",' 3"#8' $#5"*(9'
!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&;
8-%=54"'#5U7545(,'(%'$#5"*(9':,'"T"$7?*<'87-$3)9"9')*4'9)#"9'%.'9"$7-5?"9/'F-)4"-9'&);"'&%*",'.%-'(3"'$#5"*(':,'9"##5*<'9"$7-5?"9')(')'
35<3"-'8-5$"'.-%&'+3"*'(3",'87-$3)9"4'(3"&/'E"954"9'9"-=5*<')'$#5"*(M'(-)4"-9')#9%'"T"$7("'(-)4"9'%*':"3)#.'%.'(3"'5*="9(&"*(':)*;M'
+35$3'59';*%+*')9'8-%8-5"()-,'(-)45*</'F-)4"-9')5&'(%'&);"')'8-%L('795*<'(3"'L-&N9'%+*'$)85()#/
F3"'$%-8%-)("'L*)*$"'4"8)-(&"*('59')#9%';*%+*')9'(3"'5*="9(&"*(':)*;5*<'45=595%*M'+35$3'59'+3)('&%9('7*4"-<-)47)("9')5&'(%'<"('
5*(%/'F3"' 45=595%*' &)5*#,'9"-="9' (3"' .%##%+5*<' (+%' .7*$?%*9a'Yp' &"-<"-9' )*4' )$U7595?%*9' )*4' Vp' 7*4"-+-5?*</' F3"' &"-<"-9' )*4'

Classification of Investment Banks


Bulge Bracket Middle Market Boutique
• The largest and most • Firms dealing with clients • Specialized firms with
profitable firms with revenues of less than relatively smaller clients
• Examples: Goldman Sachs $1 billion • Example: Mercanti Group
and JPMorgan • Example: Jefferies & Co

)$U7595?%*9'7*5(' )4=59"9'$%&8)*5"9'%*' &"-<"-9':"(+""*' $%&8)*5"9/'@%-' "T)&8#"M'5.'$%&8)*,'1'+)*("4'(%' 87-$3)9"'C%&8)*,'EM'


(3"' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;' +5##' 3"#8' L<7-"' %7(' (3"' L*)#' 8-5$"' %.' (3"' 4")#' )*4' &);"' 97-"' (3"' (-)*9)$?%*' 59' "T"$7("4' 9&%%(3#,/' F3"'
7*4"-+-5?*<'7*5(' %.'(3"'5*="9(&"*(' :)*;'&)5*#,'9"-="9'(%' -)59"' $)85()#' .%-' )' $#5"*(' $%&8)*,'"5(3"-' (3-%7<3' "U75(,'n9(%$;9pM'4":('
n:%*49pM' %-' #%)*9/'1*' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;' 59' .7-(3"-' 45=54"4' 5*(%' 8-%47$(' <-%789' )*4' 5*479(-,'<-%789/'F3"' 8-%47$(' <-%78' 5*$#74"9'
&"-<"-9' )*4' )$U7595?%*9M' L*)*$5)#' 98%*9%-9M')*4' #"="-)<"4' L*)*$"/'F3"' $%="-)<"' <-%78' 9"-="9' $#5"*(9' .-%&' =)-,5*<' 5*479(-5"9M'
5*$#745*<'L*)*$5)#'5*9?(7?%*9M'3")#(3$)-"M')*4'("$3*%#%<,M'(%'*)&"')'."+/'

1#&%9(')##'5*="9(&"*(':)*;9'93)-"'(3"'9)&"'35"-)-$35$)#'9(-7$(7-"/'

!
Analyst Associate Vice President Managing Director

S5."9(,#"')9')*'5*="9(&"*(':)*;"-'59'"98"$5)##,'45m$7#(' 47"'(%'(3"'.)9(08)$"4' +%-;'"*=5-%*&"*(')*4'#%*<'3%7-9/'P*="9(&"*(' :)*;"-9'


+%-;5*<' 5*' $%-8%-)("' L*)*$"' )*4' -"9")-$3' 797)##,' +%-;' &%-"' (3)*' YWW' 3%7-9' )' +"";/' E)*;"-9' 5*' 9)#"9' )*4' (-)45*<' 3)="' &%-"'
-")9%*):#"'+%-;'3%7-9M':7('(3",')-"'$%*9()*(#,')-"'7*4"-')'35<3')&%7*('%.'8-"997-"/'!35#"'9%&"':"#5"="'(3"'$%*9()*('8-"997-"')*4'
.)9(08)$"4'+%-;5*<'"*=5-%*&"*('<5="'5*="9(&"*(' :)*;"-9')*'"4<"M'%(3"-9':"#5"="'(3"'8-"997-"'59'(%%'&7$3'(%'979()5*')'8"-&)*"*('
#5."9(,#"M'-"<)-4#"99'%.'(3"'3"r,'U7)-("-#,':%*79/'C%*9"U7"*(#,M'&)*,':)*;"-9'&%="'%*'(%'%(3"-' L"#49'97$3')9'8-5=)("'"U75(,M'3"4<"'
.7*49M')*4':795*"99'4"="#%8&"*(')r"-'(3"5-'(+%0,")-'9?*(/

DZKkZKB'H'1CGAPBPFP>gB
PRODUCT @Pg1gCP1S'BI>gB>KB
SZ\ZK1kZJ'@Pg1gCZ
GROUP
SERVES CLIENTS THAT ARE IN
DIFFERENT INDUSTRIES INCLUDING COVERAGE
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS,
HEALTHCARE, AND TECHNOLOGY, GROUP
AMONG MANY OTHERS.

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&?
PgJABFK]'>\ZK\PZ!a E,a'Z-5$'I)-;

& CONSULTING B()O'!-5("r

B(-)("<5$'$%*97#?*<'.%$79"9 '%*') '$%&8)*,N9 '"T("-*)#'


*5-4&$'&/2%'#04$%:d .)$(%-9')*4'"*=5-%*&"*('+5(35*'(3"'$#5"*(N9'5*479(-,/''
C%*97#?*<' 59 ' ) ' 35<3' 8-%L#"' 5*479(-,' +5(3' F3"' .)$(%-9 ' )*4' "*=5-%*&"*(' -"#)("4' (%' 9(-)("<5$'
8-%."995%*)#9'.-%&'45="-9"'"47$)?%*)#':)$;<-%7*49/' $%*97#?*<' 5*$#74" '$%&8"?*<'$%&8)*5"9M' 9788#5"-9M'
P*' (359' L"#4M' 8-%."995%*)#9' ;*%+*' )9 ' $%*97#()*(9' $79(%&"-9M' )9' +"## ' )9' <%="-*&"*(' -"<7#)?%*9/''
8-%=54"'(3"5-' "T8"-?9" ')*4'-"$%&&"*4)?%*9 '5*' )' B(-)("<,' $%*97#()*(9' +5## ' 79" ' (3"5-' "T8"-?9" ' (%'
=)-5"(,' %.' L"#49' 97$3' )9 ' -"9%7-$"' &)*)<"&"*(M' -"$%&&"*4')*4'5&8#"&"*(') '8#)*'%.')$?%*'(%'3"#8'
#5?<)?%*M')*4'("$3*%#%<,/ ) ' $%&8)*,' -")$3' 5(9 ' <%)#9 ' +3"*' %*"' %.' &%-"' %.'
(3"9"'.)$(%-9'$3)*<"9/
1*' "T)&8#"' %.' )' -"#)?%*9358' )*)#%<%79 ' (%'
$%*97#?*<' L-&9' )*4' $%&8)*5"9' (3)(' 79"' (3"5-' > ( 3 " -' $% * 9 7 # ? * <' 9 8 " $ 5 ) # 5 R) ? % * 9' 5 * $ # 7 4 " a'
9"-=5$"9'+%7#4':" '(3)(' %.' )'4%$(%-' )*4'8)?"*(/' ' 1' &)*)<"&"*(M' L*)*$5)#' 9"-=5$"9M' #5?<)?%*M' 37&)*'
8 ) ?"*(' + 5 # # ' 7 9 7) ## ,' =595(' (3"' 4%$(%-' .%-' -"9%7-$"9M')*4'3")#(3$)-"/
8-"4%&5*)*(#,'(+%'-")9%*9M')'45)<*%959 '%*')*'5##*"99'
%-' .%-')'$3"$;78/' 'B5&5#)-#,'$%*97#?*<'L-&9'+5## '79"'
(3"5-' "T8"-?9"' (%' -"$%&&"*4' 54")9 ' (%' 3"#8' 3(-4#"('&23&45(&/2%'#04$%:&
$%&8)*5"9 '(3)(' &),' :"' )(' -59;' .%-' #)-<"' #%99"9 '%-' >"23(''$2%
"="*' .)5#7-" ' %-' (%' 8-%&%(" ' <-")("-' "m$5"*$,' 5*' )'
9():#" ' %-' "="*' (3-5=5*<' $%&8)*,/' k%="-*&"*(' C%*97#?*<' 8-%=54"9 ' )' +")#(3' %.' "T8"-5"*$"' 5*'
:%45"9 ')*4'$%&8)*5"9 '+5## '9"";' $%*97#?*<' 9"-=5$"9' 45O"-"*(' :795*"99' L"#49 ' :"$)79"' %.' (3"' =)-5%79'
(%' -"$"5=" ' )4=5$"' )*4' -"$%&&"*4)?%*9' .%-' :795*"99 ')98"$(9 ')*4'-)*<" '%.'$#5"*(9')*4'5*479(-5"9'
8-%:#"&9'(3)('(3",'$)**%('-"9%#="'(3"&9"#="9/ (3)(' $%*97#()*(9'+%-;'+5(3/' 'Z&8#%,""9 ')-"';*%+*'
(%' +%-;' #%*<' 3%7-9'+3"*'+%-;5*<' 5*'(3"'5*479(-,/'
C%*97#()*(9 ' 8-5&)-5#,' %O"-' (3"5-' 9"-=5$"9 ' 5*' (3-""' F359 ' .-"U7"*(#,' %$$7-9 ' 47-5*<' :79,' 9")9%*9' +3"*'
)-")9' %.' :795*"99a' P*.%-&)?%*' F"$3*%#%<5"9M' (3"-"')-"'*7&"-%79'$#5"*(9 ')*4'8-%Q"$(9 '(%'&)*)<"'
%8"-)?%*9M')*4'9(-)("<,/' 47" ' (%' 5*$-")9"4' 4"&)*4' .%-' $%*97#?*<' 9"-=5$"9'
)$-%99'$#5"*('5*479(-5"9/
P*.%-&)?%*' F"$3*%#%<5"9 ' $%*97#?*<' 59' $%*$"-*"4'
+5(3' 3"#85*<' $#5"*(9 ' )4%8(' *"+' ("$3*%#%<5"9 ' (%' F359 '8-%."995%*'-"U75-"9 '&%4"-)("'(%'#)-<" ')&%7*(9'
5&8-%="':795*"99 '"m$5"*$,/''C%*97#()*(9 '5*'(359 'L"#4' %.'(-)="# ')9 '(")&9'%.'$%*97#()*(9 ')-"'9%&"?&"9 '9"*('
797)##,' 3)=" ' 4"<-""9 ' +5(3' ) ' ("$3*%#%<,' -"#)("4' %7(' (%' &)*)<"' )*4' $%##):%-)("' +5(3' )' $#5"*(' .%-'
$%*$"*(-)?%*' 97$3' )9' $%&87("-' 9$5"*$"/' ' PF' =)-,5*<' #"*<(39 '%.' ?&"/' ' P(' 59 ')#9%' ) '*"$"995(,' .%-'
$%*97#()*(9'3)=" '"T8"-5"*$" '+5(3' 9%r+)-" '79"4' 5*' 8-%."995%*)#9'5*'(359 'L"#4'(%'8%99"99 '9(-%*<')*)#,?$)#'
:795*"99'97$3')9'(3%9"'8-%47$"4':,'>-)$#"')*4'B1I/ )*4'8-%:#"&'9%#=5*<'9;5##9/
>8"-)?%*9' $%*97#?*<' 3"#8' $#5"*(9 ' 5&8-%=" ' (3"5-'
5*("-*)# '+%-;5*<9 '5*')-")9 '97$3')9 '37&)*'-"9%7-$"9/''
B7$3' $%*97#()*(9' 5*' (359 ' L"#4' 5&8-%="' )' $#5"*(N9'
%-<)*5R)?%*M'8-%$"995*<M')*4'8-%47$?%*/' ' F3",' +5##'
*%(' %*#,' &);"' -"$%&&"*4)?%*9 ' (%' 5&8-%="'
%8"-)?%*9 ':7(')#9%'&);" '97-" '(3)('(3%9"'54")9 ')-"'
$%--"$(#,'"T"$7("4/
!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<=
(%4("$%:&/2%'#04$%:
C%*97#?*<' 3)9' (-)45?%*)##,' :""*' ) '$%&8"??="' 5*479(-,' (%' "*("-' :"$)79" '%.' 5(9' 8%87#)-5(,' )*4' U7)#5(,' %.'
$)*454)("9/' ' @5-&9'#%%;' .%-' $)*454)("9 '(3)('8%99"99 ')'9(-%*<' #"="#'%.' )$)4"&5$' 97$$"99 '97$3')9w' )'35<3'kI1M'
"T8"-5"*$"'(3)('4598#),9'(")&+%-;M'5*("-8"-9%*)#'9;5##9M')*4'8-%:#"&'9%#=5*</

S5;"' &)*,' %(3"-' 8-%."995%*9 ' $%*97#?*<' L-&9 ' 79"' (-)45?%*)# ' :"3)=5%-)#' 5*("-=5"+' U7"9?%*9 ' (%' <)7<"' )'
$)*454)("9N'8"-9%*)#5(,/''1'$%&&%*'5*("-=5"+'(,8"'59 ') '$)9"'9(74,/''1*'5*("-=5"+"-'+5## '<5="'(3"'5*("-=5"+""')'
:795*"99 '8-%:#"&'(%'9%#="'3")=5#,'795*<')'$)*454)("N9'9;5##9 '5*')*)#,959/''F3"9"'(,8"9 '%.'8-%:#"&9'5*$#74"':7(')-"'
*%(' #5&5("4' (%' )*)#,959 '%.' 4"$#5*5*<' $%&8)*,' 8"-.%-&)*$"' 5*' )98"$(9 '5*$#745*<' 8-%L(9' )*4' 8-%47$?%*' )*4'
$-")?*<'9%#7?%*9'(%';""8')':795*"99'97$$"99.7#'+5(3'5*$-")9"4'&)-;"('$%&8"??%*/

@%-' 8%("*?)#' $)*454)("9' (%' 3)="' 97$$"99' 5*' $)9"' 5*("-=5"+9M' 5*45=547)#9' 93%7#4' )*)#,R" ')*4' 8-)$?$"' $)9"'
5*("-=5"+9/'D)*,'$%&8)*5"9 '3)="'9)&8#"'$)9" '9(745"9')=)5#):#"'%*'(3"5-'+":95("')9 '+"## ')9'8-)$?$" '+%-;93%89'
.%-'(3%9"'5*("-"9("4/''F3"-"')-"')#9%'$)9"'9(74,'<754"9 ')*4'%*#5*"'-"9%7-$"9 '.-%&'$%&8)*5"9 '97$3')9 '\)7#(')*4'
!"(@""(/

)PRTD&/CQIRTUQS&:RHGF&
"PQ[HQSI
2)("-00 ''''''''''''''&!('4&42&*2"6&32"

Y/'D$^5*9",'H'C%&8)*, Y/'E)5*'H'C%&8)*,

V/'F3"'E%9(%*'C%*97#?*<'k-%78M'P*$/ V/'F-5*5(,'I)-(*"-9'SSC

c/'E)5*'H'C%&8)*, .\&k)##78'C%*97#?*<

h/'E%%R'H'C%&8)*, h/'F-5)<"'C%*97#?*<'k-%78

f/'J"#%52"'C%*97#?*<'SSI f/'[")#(3'14=)*$"9'SSC

i/'D%*5(%-'k-%78 i/'C%-*"-9(%*"'K"9")-$3

b/'I-5$"+)("-3%79"C%%8"-9'SSI' b/'>CHC'B(-)("<,'C%*97#()*(9
nC%*97#?*<'I-)$?$"p
j/'B(-)("<5$'J"$595%*9'k-%78
j/&D"-$"-'SSC
X/'F3"'E%9(%*'C%*97#?*<'k-%78M'
X/&Z-*9('H']%7*<'SSI'nC%*97#?*<' P*$/
I-)$?$"p
YW/'D5##5&)*'P*$/
YW/'>#5="-'!,&)*

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<<
AN INTRODUCTION TO

ACCOUNTING
E,'J)=54'\),R*"-
$'&-//2#%4$%:&"$:54&
V$Q&DBF&YP[F&C_&
!"9(' S1' $%&&7*5(,/' P(' )#9%' 8-%=54"9'
5*("-)$?%*' +5(3' &)Q%-' )$$%7*?*<'
32"&9(d L-&9/' \%#7*(""-5*<' 5*' (3"5-' 8-%<-)&'
EFKFQD&eQPQKHPT& 1$$%7*?*<' 59' )' $3)##"*<5*<' 8-%."995%*'
+5##' 8-%=54"' ,%7' +5(3' )' 8-)$?$)#'
;*%+#"4<"' %.' )$$%7*?*<' 8-%$"47-"9'
IKPQGPTI@& +35$3' -"U75-"9' 7*5U7"' 9;5##9' )*4'
)2-5:7("9/' 1' 8"-9%*' +3%' 59' 5*("-"9("4'
)*4' 3"#8' ,%7' 4"("-&5*"' +3"(3"-'
)$$%7*?*<' 59' (3"' -5<3(' 8-%."995%*' .%-'

CXXCEDRQHUFI&HQ& 5*' 87-975*<')*' )$$%7*?*<'$)-""-' &79('


3)="' )*' )8?(74"' .%-' &)(3/' ["' %-' 93"'
,%7/'F3"'B(74"*(' 1$$%7*?*<' B%$5"(,'59'
)' ACS1' )$$%7*?*<' $#7:/' F3",' 3%9('
&79(' )#9%' 3)="' <%%4' $-5?$)#' -")45*<'
PKKCRQUQS&YHTT& "="*(9'+5(3'&)Q%-' )$$%7*?*<'L-&9')*4'
) * 4' ) * ) # , ? $) #' 9 ; 5 # # 9 /' 1 r " -' ) # # M' 3%#4' +"";#,' &""?*<9/' F3"' B(74"*('
)$$%7*?*<'-"U75-"9'%*"'*%(' %*#,'(%' :"' 1$$%7*?*<' B%$5"(,' 59' )*' "T$"##"*('
SC&RXf] ):#"'(%'8"-.%-&'&)(3'%*'"$%*%&5$'4)()'
:7(')#9%'(%' )*)#,R"'4)()')*4':"'):#"'(%'
-"9%7-$"' (3)(' 8-%=54"9' ACS1' 9(74"*(9'
+5(3' )' 8)(3+),' (%' (3"' 8-%."995%*)#'
459$"-*' 8)2"-*9'(3)('&),':"'79".7#' .%-' +%-#4'%.')$$%7*?*</''
&)*)<"&"*(' %-' 5*45=547)#9/' I-"$595%*'
1*' )$$%7*?*<' $)-""-' 59' ="-,' "T$5?*<' (%' 4"()5#' )*4' 87*$(7)#5(,' )-"' )#9%'
) * 4' $ ) *' % O " -' ( - " & " * 4 % 7 9' -"U75-"4/'F3"'&%9(' 5&8%-()*(' )2-5:7("'
52*&,2&$&:(4&45("(d&
%88%-(7*5?"9/' 1$$%7*?*<' 59' (3"' 59' 3)=5*<' )' $%&&5(&"*(' (%' "(35$)#'
8-%$"99' %.' 9(-7$(7-5*<' )*4' )*)#,R5*<' F3"' -"U75-"&"*(9' .%-' )*' )$$%7*?*<'
5*("<-5(,/' !3"*' -"8%-?*<' %*' 9"*95?="'
"$%*%&5$' L<7-"9' )*4' 4)()' .%-' (3"' $)-""-' )-"' -5<%-%79/' 1' 4"<-""' 5*'
L*)*$5)#' 5*.%-&)?%*M' 5(' 59' =5()#' (%' :"'
5*("-*)#' 79"' %.' L-&9' )*4' (3"' "T("-*)#' )$$%7*?*<' %-' )' -"#)("4' L"#4' 59' %r"*'
3%*"9(')*4'(%'*%('%:9$7-"'5*.%-&)?%*/
79"' %.' (3"'87:#5$/'>-<)*5R"4' "$%*%&5$' -"U75-"4/' ACS1' %O"-9' )*' )$$%7*?*<'
4)()' 8-%=54"9' 5*95<3(9' .%-' &)*)<"-9' %*' &5*%-' 5*' (3"' 1*4"-9%*' B$3%%#' %.'
3%+' (%' &%="' .%-+)-4' +5(3' (3"' V4BF&OCID&HOXCEDPQD& E795*"99' +35$3' 8-%=54"9' 9(74"*(9' +5(3'
)' =" - ,' 4 "() 5 # " 4' : ) $ ; < -% 7 * 4' 5 *'
$%&8)*,' )*4' &);"9' 5(' ")9,' .%-' (3"'
87:#5$' (%' 9""'3%+' +"##' (3"' $%&8)*,'59'
PgEHLRDF&HI&BPNHQS&P& )$$%7*?*<'8-%$"47-"9/'>*$"',%7'"*("-'
4%5*</' D%9(' 5&8%-()*(#,' )$$%7*?*<' 59' KCOOHDOFQD&DC& 5*(%' (3"' L"#4' %.' )$$%7*?*<M' F3"' CI1'
n C " - ? L " 4' I 7 : # 5 $' 1 $ $ % 7 * ( ) * ( p'
( 3 "' 8 - % $ " 9 9' % .' " 9 ( ) : # 5 9 3 5 * <'
)$$%7*():5#5(,' +5(35*' )' :795*"99' %-' FDBHKPT&HQDFSEHDZ\] $"-?L$)?%*' +5##' :"' =5()#' )9' 5(' )##%+9'
< % = " - * & " * (' % -' ) * ,' 8 ) - ? $ 7 # ) -' )$$%7*()*(9' (%' L#"' -"8%-(9' +5(3' (3"'
5*9?(7?%*' .%-' (3)(' &)2"-' (3)(' 4")#9' B"$7-5?"9' )*4' ZT$3)*<"' C%&&5995%*/'
+5(3' &%*",/' P*' (3"' +);"' %.' -"$"*(' !5(3' )' CI1' ,%7' +5##' :"' ):#"' (%' -59"' 5*'
ACS1' 3)9' &)*,' 45O"-"*(' )$$%7*?*<'
L*)*$5)#' &"#(4%+*9' )*4' 9$)*4)#9M' (3"' L"#4' %.' )$$%7*?*<' )*4' &%-"'
-"9%7-$"9' (3)(' +5##' 3"#8' <754"' ,%7'
%88%-(7*5?"9' 5*' )$$%7*?*<' +5##' <%' 78' %88%-(7*5?"9'+5##':"' %8"*'.%-' ,%7/'P(' 59'
(%+)-4' )' 975():#"' $)-""-' 8)(3/' ' ACS1'
47"' (%' 9(-5$("-' 5*("-*)#' -"<7#)(%-,' )' ;*%+*' .)$(' (3)(' )$$%7*()*(9' +5(3'
\PF1'n\%#7*(""-' P*$%&"' F)T' 19959()*$"p'
9 ( ) * 4 ) - 4 9' ) * 4' & % - "' - 5 < % - % 7 9' CI1N9' 3)="' )*' )4=)*()<"' %="-' (3%9"'
59' )' *%*8-%L(' %-<)*5R)?%*' (3)('
)$$%7*?*<'8-%$"47-"9/ +3%'4%*N('5*'(3"'Q%:'&)-;"(/''F3"-"')-"'
8-%=54"9'()T' )9959()*$"'(%'8"%8#"'5*' (3"' (+%'&)Q%-'8)(3+),9'(%'<"(',%7-'CI1/

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<+
>PDBYPZ&< >PDBYPZ&+

! 3CE&DBCIF&YBC&YPQD&DC&XEPKUKF&HQ&/PTH_CEQHP !&3CE&DBCIF&YBC&YPQD&DC&XEPKUKF&HQ&CDBFE&IDPDFI&PI&
YFTT\
x ci'U7)-("-'7*5(9'%.')$$%7*?*<'-"#)("4'
97:Q"$(9 x ci'U7)-("-'7*5(9'%.')$$%7*?*<'-"#)("4'97:Q"$(9
x ci'U7)-("-'7*5(9'%.'E795*"99'-"#)("4'97:Q"$(9 x ci'U7)-("-'7*5(9'%.':795*"99'-"#)("4'97:Q"$(9
x V',")-9'%.'+%-;'"T8"-5"*$" x Y',")-'%.'+%-;'"T8"-5"*$"
x 8)995*<')##'.%7-'8)-(9'%.'(3"'CI1'"T)& x VVf'U7)-("-'7*5(9'5*'<"*"-)#
x I)995*<')*'"(35$9'$%7-9"/ x 8)995*<')##'.%7-'8)-(9'%.'(3"'CI1'"T)&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
x 8)995*<')*'"(35$9'$%7-9"

-KKCRQUQS&eEOI&TCC[&_CE&DBF&_CTTCYHQS&I[HTTI&PQG&PgEHLRDFIh

&i&-QPTZUKPT&PLHTHDZ &&i&-LHTHDZ&DC&YCE[&HQGFXFQGFQDTZ
&&i&0FPGFEIBHX&I[HTTI &&i&4FPO&I[HTTI
&&i&*EHgFQ&PQG&CEPT&KCOORQHKPUCQ& &&i&9RTUDPI[HQS&PLHTHDZ
I[HTTI &&i&5HSB&FDBHKPT&IDPQGPEGI
&&i&-gFQUCQ&DC&GFDPHT &&i&/COXRDFE&THDFEPKZ&&
&&

4991#%J%.&72"(("'
''''''''''''''1$$%7*?*<'$)*':" '97:0$)("<%-5R"4'5*(%'(3-""'45O"-"*('8)-(9/'g%(')## ')$$%7*()*(9 '4%'(3"'9)&"'Q%:')*4'
5('59')4=)*()<"%79 '(%';*%+'(3" '(3-"" '45O"-"*('(,8"9 '%.')$$%7*?*<'$)-""-9 ':".%-"',%7'4"$54" '(%'87-97"') '$)-""-'
8)(3'5*')$$%7*?*</'E"#%+'59')'U75$;'97&&)-,'%.'(3"'45O"-"*(')$$%7*?*<'$)-""-9/

& &
'''''
&&&&4#:$<K5%<("%23&&&&&& &62L &&&&&&4:*$'1"B

P.' ,%7' )-" ' 5*' (3"' )745?*<' ["-"' ,%7' 3"#8' :795*"99"9 ' )*4' 14=59%-,' 1$$%7*()*(9 ' )9959('
8-%."995%*M' ,%7' )*)#,R"' (3"' 5*45=547)#9'+5(3'(3"5-' ()T' .%-&9' $%&8)*5"9 '5*')99"(9'"=)#7)?%*9'
L * ) * $ 5 ) # ' 9 ( ) ( " & " * ( 9 ' % .' ) * 4' 8 - % = 5 4 " ' ( 3 " &' ( ) T' )*4' 3"#8' .)$5#5()(" ' &"-<"-9'
$%&8)*5"9 ')*4'4"("-&5*"'(3"5-' $%*97#()?%*' )4=5$"/' ]%7' $)*' :"(+""*'$%&8)*5"9 ')9 '&"-<"-9'
.)5-*"99 ' )*4' -"#5):5#5(,' )*4' )#9%' )4=59"' $%&8)*5"9' %.' (3"' $)*' :"$%&" ' ="-,' ("$3*5$)#'
+3"(3"-' (3",' )-"' )*' )$$7-)("' ()T' 5&8#5$)?%*9 ' %.' $"-()5*' % - 4 " ) # 9 /' F 3 " ,' ) # 9 %' 3 " # 8'
-"8-"9"*()?%*' %.' ) ' L-&N9' )$?%*9' )*4' 98"$5)#5R"' 5*' ()T' $%&8)*5"9 '+5(3':74<"?*<M')*4'
L*)*$5)#'3")#(3/'1'&)Q%-'8)-('%.' 8%#5$,' %.' 9()("' )*4' #%$)#' ;""85*<' (-)$;' %.'(3"5-' L*)*$"9/'
)745?*<' 59 ' &);5*<' 97-" ' (3)(' <%="-*&"*(9/' I"%8#" '5*'(3"'()T' >(3"-' 9"-=5$"9 '&),' 5*$#74" '-59;'
$%&8)*5"9 ' "9():#593' 9(-%*<' :795*"99 ' $)*' )#9%' 98"$5)#5R"' 5*' ) 9 9 " 9 9 & " * ( 9' ) * 4' . - ) 7 4'
5*("-*)#' $%*(-%#' 9,9("&9 ' (%' 5*("-*)?%*)#'()T/ 5*="9?<)?%*9/'
8-%("$(' (3"&9"#="9 ' )<)5*9('
.-)747#"*('-"$%-49/

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<.
'''''''''''''

)
!
E,'C3-59?*"'S57'''''''B()O'!-5("-
'
'" ' '
' ' ' ' )*;"4' (3"' (%8' VW''
' ''' ''''9$3%%#':,'!#'$%(''?((@& !
EStudents explore business
)*4'CG-G& &H(+'&M&?1"3:&)(/1"<M' (3"' $<7=>?@7"-3!
problems through a
ABC' D)-93)##'B$3%%# '%.'E795*"99 '5*' multidisciplinary approach ' ' ' ' ' S5;"' (3"' DE1' I/D/' 8-%<-)&M' (3"'
S%9' 1*<"#"9' 59' )' 8-5=)(" ' -"9")-$3' that teaches interpersonal ZT"$7?="' DE1' 59' 4"95<*"4' .%-' (3%9"'
)*4' )$)4"&5$' 5*9?(7?%*' -)*;"4' skills/teamwork, leadership +3%' +593' (%' -"&)5*' .7##,' "&8#%,"4'
35<3#,' .%-' 5(9' )$$%7*?*<ML*)*$"M' and entrepreneurial talents, +35#"' 87-975*<' )*' DE1' 4"<-""/'
"*(-"8-"*"7-9358' )*4' 5*("-*)?%*)#' global awareness and [%+"="-M' (359' 8-%<-)&' 59' .%-' 9"*5%-'
:795*"99 ' 9(745"9 ' 8-%<-)&9/' F3"' technological knowledge.”! &)*)<"-9' )*4' 9")9%*"4' 8-%."995%*)#9/'
D)-93)##' $7--5$7#7&' "&83)95R"9' B(74"*(9' $)*' )2"*4' $#)99"9' 5*' "5(3"-'
5*("-)$?=" '#")-*5*<M' :"5*<' (3"' L-9(' -3!"45/"6/54700859.20".9:"-.9.;7/0 S%9' 1*<"#"9' %-' B)*' J5"<%' %*' @-54),9'
9$3%%# '+5(3'5*("-*)?%*)#'(-)="#')*4' )*4' B)(7-4),9' .-%&' jahf' )&' (%' hacW'
9(74,' 8-%Q"$(9')9 '-"U75-"&"*(9' .%-' ' ' ' ' ' F3"' D)-93)##' DE1' I-%<-)&' .%-' 8&/' F3"' $7--5$7#7&' 59' .%$79"4' %*'
"="-,' DE1' 4"<-""/' \)-5%79 ' DE19' I-%."995%*)#9' )*4' D)*)<"-9' 59' %O"-"4' )$(7)#' :795*"99' +%-#4' 95(7)?%*9' (3)('
)*4' 98"$5)#5R"4' 4"<-""9' %O"-"4' 5*' (3"'"="*5*<'.%-' 9(74"*(9'+3%'+%7#4' 9"*5%-'&)*)<"-9'%r"*'"*$%7*("-/'
5*$#74"a #5;"' (%' :"' .7##,' "&8#%,"4' +35#"'
87-975*<' )*' DE1' 4"<-""/' P(' 59' )' cc' *3$!&"-3!"6/5;/.A
&%*(3' 8-%<-)&M'5*' +35$3' (3"' Y9(' ,")-'
F3"' PEZ1K' DE1' 8-%<-)&' 59' )*'
-./01.22"-3! $%*959(9' %.' $%-"' $#)99"9/' 1r"-'
) $ $ " # " - ) ( " 4' < # % : ) #' D E 1' . % -'
$%&8#"?%*'%.' (3"' Y9( ',")-M'(3"'9(74"*('
"T8"-5"*$"4'8-%."995%*)#9/'F359'7*5U7"'
' " " " ""1'(+%' ,")-M'.7##'?&"'8-%<-)&M'(3"' $)*' 9"(' (3"' 8)$"' .%-' (3"' -"9(' %.' (3"'
8-%<-)&' 59' %*"' ,")-' 5*("*95="' )(' ABCM'
D)-93)##'DE1'8-%<-)&'%8"-)("9'+5(3')' 8-%<-)&' n)9' #%*<' )9' 5(' 59' +5(35*' L="'
+5(3' )' $#)99' 95R"' %.' %*#,' ff' 9(74"*(9/'
#%+' 9(74"*(' (%' .)$7#(,'-)?%' )*4' 9&)##' ,")-9' (%()#p/' F3"' "="*5*<' $#)99' &""('
@-%&' 17<79(' (%' J"$"&:"-M' 9(74"*(9'
$#)99' 95R"9/' B(74"*(9' "T8#%-"' :795*"99' (+5$"')'+"";'.-%&'i'8&'(%'XahW'8&/'P.'
$%&8#"("' (3"' DE1' .7*4)&"*()#9M' )*4'
8-%:#"&9' (3-%7<3' )' &7#?459$58#5*)-,' (3"' $%&&7("' (%' S/1/' 59' 5*$%*="*5"*(M'
.-%&' 6)*7)-,' (%' 67#,M' (")&9' %.' h0f'
)88-%)$3' (3)(' (")$3"9' 5*("-8"-9%*)#' (3"'L-9(',")-'%.'$%-"'$#)99"9'$)*')#9%':"'
9(74"*(9' 8)-?$58)("' 5*' )' L="0&%*(3'
9;5##9l(")&+%-;M' #")4"-9358' )*4' $%&8#"("4' )(' (3"' *"+' >-)*<"' C%7*(,'
#%*<' 5*("-*)?%*)#' $%*97#?*<' 8-%Q"$('
"*(-"8-"*"7-5)#' () # "*(9 M' <#%:)#' C"*("-'5*'P-=5*"/
.%-' )' A/B/' %-' .%-"5<*' $%-8%-)("' $#5"*(/'
) + ) - " * " 9 9' ) * 4' ( " $ 3 * % # % < 5 $ ) #'
F359' 8-%<-)&' 9(-"99"9' :795*"99'
;*%+#"4<"/' B5*$"' D)-93)##' 59' #%$)("4'
-"#)?%*93589' :"(+""*' g%-(3' 1&"-5$)M'
$#%9"' (%' &)Q%-' :795*"99' )*4' L*)*$5)#'
$"*("-9' 5*' S/1/M' (3"' 9$3%%#' %O"-9' )' 195)')*4'S)?*'1&"-5$)/'
9(-%*<' )#7&*5' *"(+%-;' (3)(' %8"*9'
) 4 4 5 ? % * ) #' % 8 8 % - ( 7 * 5 ? " 9' ) * 4'
"T8"-5"*$"/ !"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<1
!
'-.0B7/"54"!==5>9?9;
9!-&-GOHIIHCQI&>ECeTF
' ' ' ' ' 1' .7##0?&"M' %*"0,")-' 8-%<-)&M' (3"'
S"="*(3)#' D)9("-' %.'1$$%7*?*<'59'-)*;"4' )9' VWWX VWYW VWYY
%*' %.' (3"' (%8' <-)47)("' )$$%7*?*<' 8-%<-)&9' 188#5$)*('I%%#
5*'(3"'*)?%*/'F%'8-"8)-"'.%-w'$)-""-9'5*'87:#5$' 188#5$)(5%*9'K"$"5="4 YifY VWbi VVVh
)$$%7*?*<M'L*)*$5)#'9"-=5$"9')*4' 5*="9(&"*('
t'1$$"8("4 VXt Vct VVt
:)*;5*<M' <%="-*&"*(' )*4' *%*08-%L(M' )*4'
$%-8%-)("' L*)*$"M' (3"' 8-%<-)&' 79"9' $)9"' C#)99'B5R" VYX VVV
9(74,'&"(3%49')*4'(")&+%-;'5*')##'$%7-9"9/
1$)4"&5$'I-%.5#"
-.0B7/"54"3>089700"C.<.?59
1="-)<"'kI1 c/c c/c c/c
'''''F3"'D)9("-'%.'E795*"99'F)T)?%*M'%O"-"4' D"45)*'kD1F iXW bWW iXW
:%(3'.7##0?&"')*4'8)-(0?&"M'59')5&"4'(%'
kD1F'jWt'K)*<" ihW0bcW ihW0bhW ihW0bhW
4"="#%8'9;5##9l"T8"-?9"'8-%."995%*)#9'*""4'
+35#"'+%-;5*<'+5(3'5*45=547)#9')*4'L-&9'+5(3'
()T'#"<59#)?%*')*4'-"<7#)?%*')(')##' k"*"-)#
<%="-*&"*('#"="#9/'F)T)?%*'5*$#74"9'#)+M' 1="-)<"'1<" Vj Vj Vj
"$%*%&5$9M')$$%7*?*<')*4'8%#5?$9M')*4'(379'
-"U75-"9'(3"'()T')4=59%-'(%'7*4"-9()*4')##' 1="-)<"']")-9'!"";' f f f
ZT8"$()*$,
)98"$(9'%.'()T'#)+')*4'5(9')4&5*59(-)?%*/'
D)--5"4'B(74"*(9 Yit Yht Yct
-.0B7/"54"-7:8=.2"-.9.;7A79B

'''''F359'4"<-""'8-%=54"9'83,95$5)*9'+5(3'(3"' A*4"-<-)4'D)Q%-9
.%-&)#':795*"99'"47$)?%*'*""4"4'(%'3"#8' [7&)*5(5"9')*4' Vbt Vft Vbt
(3"&'-")#5R"'(3"5-'8-%."995%*)#'<%)#9/'P('59' B%$5%#%<,
&%4"#"4')r"-'(3"'ZT"$7?="'DE1'8-%<-)&'
B$5"*$"
)*4')##%+9'83,95$5)*9'(%'")-*')'4"<-""'5*'%*#,'
%*"',")-M'+5(3%7('5*("--78?*<'(3"5-'$)-""-9/'' B$5"*$"'H'Z*<5*""-5*< Vit Vbt VYt
E795*"99 Vct Vit cWt
5*.%-&)?%*'):%7('(3"'ABC'D)-93)##'B$3%%#'%.'
Z$%*%&5$9 YXt Yht Yft
E795*"99'8-%<-)&9M'=595(a
C%&87("-'B$5"*$" ft jt bt
'+++/&)-93)##/79$/"47'''

!:A8008590
'''''Z)$3'8-%<-)&'3)9'5(9'%+*')4&5995%*'
-"U75-"&"*(9/'F%'L*4')88#5$)?%*'&)("-5)#'
)*4'.%-'&%-"'5*.%-&)?%*'):%7('(3"'ABC'
D)-93)##'B$3%%#'%.'E795*"99'8-%<-)&9M'=595(a

'+++/&)-93)##/79$/"47'''

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<7
/-"(("&4$>'
"*%7<3' (%' <"(' )' Q%:/' F3"' Q%:' &)-;"(' 59' :"$%&5*<' &%-"' )*4' &%-"' $%&8"??="/'
F[Z'E1BPCB
Z="*' +5(3%7(' (359' L*)*$5)#' $-5959M' :"5*<' 5*' $%##"<"' )*4' -"$"5=5*<' ,%7-' 4"<-""' 59' *%('

!A&02%-&j5-2
K"<)-4#"99M')'Q%:' +5##' *"="-' .)##'5*(%',%7-' #)800'+3"(3"-'5('59')'8)-(0?&"'Q%:'%-' )'$)-""-M'
,%7' *""4' (%' :"' )<<-"995="' )*4' ' 8-"8)-"4' 5*' ,%7-' Q%:' 9")-$3/' E7(' '4-33&*"$4("
4%*N('.")-w'+"'
!
3$%,$%:&-&^2!h
Z="*'5.',%7')-"'*%('$7--"*(#,'#%%;5*<'.%-')'Q%:M'5('59'"99"*?)#' (%'
;""8' $%**"$?%*9' +5(3' )##' 8-%."995%*)#9' ,%7' 3)="' &"(' 9%' .)-/''
@%-'5*9()*$"M'5.',%7'3)="'4%*"'=%#7*(""-'+%-;'5*'(3"'8)9(M'(35*;'
):%7(' *"(+%-;5*<' +5(3' (3"' =%#7*(""-' $%%-45*)(%-/']%7' *"="-'
;*%+'+3%'+5##':"'#%%;5*<'.%-')*'"&8#%,""'5*'(3"'.7(7-"/

P.' ,%7' )-"' )$?="#,' #%%;5*<' .%-' )' Q%:M')' ="-,' 3"#8.7#' -"9%7-$"'
(3"9"' 4),9')-"'%*#5*"'Q%:' 9")-$3'"*<5*"9'97$3')9'D%*9("-' )*4'
C)-""-' E75#4"-/' 1*' 5*=)#7):#"' -"9%7-$"' .%-' ACS1' 9(74"*(9' 59'
E-75*\5"+/' !3"-"' "&8#%,"-9' 8%9(' Q%:' #59?*<' 98"$5L$)##,' .%-'
E-75*9/'!3"*'#%%;5*<'.%-' )'Q%:'%*#5*"',%7'+5##'+)*('(%'8-"8)-"'
)' #%*<"-M'&%-"' 4"()5#"4' -"97&"' 9%' (3)(' ,%7' $)*' &%-"' ")95#,'
45O"-"*?)("',%7-9"#.'.-%&'%(3"-'8%("*?)#'$)*454)("9/

]%7' 4%'*%(' +)*(' (%'-"#,'%*#,'%*'5*("-*"(' Q%:'9")-$3' "*<5*"9/'P('


59' 5&8%-()*(' (%' :"' )<<-"995="' +5(3' ,%7-' Q%:' 9")-$3' 9%' #%%;'
)-%7*4'5*' (3"'$#)995L"49M')9;'.-5"*49')*4'8-%."99%-9M')*4' "="*'
$)##' $%&8)*5"9')9;5*<'5.'(3"-"')-"' )*,')=)5#):#"'8%95?%*9/']%7'
4%'*%('*""4'(%':"'3)-)995*<'8"%8#"'.%-')'Q%:M':7(',%7'4"L*5("#,'
+)*('(%'"T3)79(',%7-'"="-,'-"9%7-$"/

d///,%7'4"L*5("#,'+)*('(%'
"T3)79(',%7-'"="-,'
-"9%7-$"/e (3"5-' -"97&"9' .%-' "="-,' Q%:' (3",' )88#,/' F359' 59' )' <%%4' 54")'
:"$)79"' ,%7' &),' )88#,'.%-' 9"="-)#' 45O"-"*(' Q%:9')(' (3"' 9)&"'
?&"/' P.' ,%7' 79"' Q79(' %*"' -"97&"M' ,%7' 3)="' (%' ;""8' ,%7-'
*"$4$%:&A2#"&3$"'4&"('#9(h -"97&"'<"*"-)#'9%')9'(%'*%(' #5&5(' ,%7-9"#.M':7('(359'$)*')#9%':"'
1'-"97&"'59')'$%*$59"'4%$7&"*('93%+5*<'"&8#%,"-9'+3)(',%7' :%-5*<'.%-' (3"' "&8#%,"-' (%' -")4' )*4' ,%7-' -"97&"' &),'.)4"'
)-"'$)8):#"'%.')*4'3%+',%7'+5##':"'=)#7):#"'(%'(3"5-'$%&8)*,/' 5*(%' (3"' :)$;<-%7*4/' C79(%&5R5*<' ,%7-' -"97&"' .%-' ")$3' Q%:'
P('59'(3"'L-9(' 9("8' (%'<"u*<',%7-' .%%(' 5*'(3"'4%%-/'F-,'(%' (35*;' +5##' 93%+' ,%7-' "&8#%,"-' 3%+' ,%7' &5<3(' :"' 8"-."$(' .%-' (3"5-'
%.' )' -"97&"')9',%7' +%7#4' )*'5*("-=5"+')*4' &);"')'$%*9$5%79' $%&8)*,/
"O%-(' (%' 79"' ,%7-' -"97&"' (%' 459?*<7593' ,%7-9"#.' .-%&' %(3"-'
)88#5$)*(9/'F359'+5##'<"(',%7'$#%9"-'(%'<"u*<',%7-'*"+'Q%:/ B()-?*<' +5(3' )' :#)*;' 9#)("' &5<3(' :"' 5*?&54)?*<M' :7('
-"&"&:"-M' ,%7' 4%' *%(' 3)="' (%' :"' 8-"=5%79#,' "&8#%,"4' (%'
!3"*' +-5?*<' ,%7-' L-9(' -"97&"M' (3"' :"9(' -"9%7-$"' 59' 8"%8#"' +-5("')'-"97&"/'P*9(")4',%7'$)*'#59(',%7-'=%#7*(""-'"T8"-5"*$"9'
+3%' 3)="' )#-")4,' +-52"*' %*"/' 1' <-")(' 8#)$"' (%' 9()-(' 59' (%' )*4' )$?=5?"9',%7' 3)="'8)-?$58)("4' 5*/']%7' &),')#9%' +)*(' (%'
9")-$3'.%-'.-""'-"97&"'("&8#)("9'%*#5*"/'F359'+5##'3"#8',%7'L*4' #59(' 98"$5)#' 9;5##9')*4' ()#"*(9',%7'3)="')$U75-"4' (3)('&),'&);"'
(3"' 8"-."$(' .%-&)(' .%-' ,%7-' -"97&"/' F3"-"' )-"' 95("9' (3)(' ,%7'=)#7):#"'5*'(3"'8%95?%*' ,%7N-"'(-,5*<'(%'L##/'F3"'5&8%-()*('
8-%=54"'$)-""-098"$5L$'-"97&"9'(%'$)("-'(%')*'5*479(-,',%7')-"' (35*<'3"-"'59'*%('(%' #5"' %*',%7-' -"97&"M'5.',%7' )-"' $)7<3(',%7'
)88#,5*<'5*(%/'B5&5#)-#,M'&)*,'8"%8#"')#9%' $3%%9"'(%'$79(%&5R"' +5##'%*#,'"*4'78'#%95*<'$-"45:5#5(,'+5(3'.7(7-"'"&8#%,"-9/

!"#$%&!#'$%(''&"()$(*&<8
g%+'(3)(',%7'3)="'L*593"4'+-5?*<',%7-'L-9('-"97&"',%7'&79(' -%:%?$')*4' -"3")-9"4/'P*9(")4M'&);"')'#59('%.' 8%5*(9'(3)(' ,%7'
8-%%.-")4/'C3"$;',%7-'3")4"-')*4'&);"'97-"'(3)(')##',%7-' +)*('(%'
$%*()$('5*.%-&)?%*'59'$%--"$(')*4',%7'3)="'*%('&5998"##"4' $%="-' +3"*' )*9+"-5*<'45O"-"*(' U7"9?%*9/'^""8'5*' &5*4' (3)('
)*,(35*</'[)="'9%&"%*"'"#9"'-")4',%7-'-"97&"')*4')9;'5.',%7-' +3"*' ,%7' )*9+"-' (3"9"' U7"9?%*9',%7' +)*(' (3"' "&8#%,"-' (%'
%:Q"$?="9')-"'$#")-/'@5*)##,M'8-5*(',%7-'-"97&"'%*'$#")*'+35("' ;*%+'+3,'(3",'93%7#4'35-"',%7'%="-'%(3"-')88#5$)*(9/!
8)8"-'+5(3'8#)5*':#)$;'5*;/
[)="' )' #59(' %.' -"."-"*$"9' )*4' )*' "T(-)' $%8,' %.' ,%7-' -"97&"'

dy5.',%7')-"'$)7<3('#,5*<' 8-5*("4' %7(' .%-' (3"' 5*("-=5"+' 5*' $)9"' (3"' 5*("-=5"+"-' +5##' *%('
3)="' 5(' 5*' .-%*(' %.' (3"&/' nK"&"&:"-M' ,%7' 4%' *%(' *""4' )'
%*',%7-'-"97&"',%7'+5##' 8-"=5%79'Q%:' .%-' -"."-"*$"9M'85$;')'."+' 5&8%-()*(' 8"%8#"' .-%&'

%*#,'"*4'78'#%95*<' ,%7-'8)9(')$?=5?"9'%-'"="*')'*"5<3:%-z)*,%*"'(3)('$)*'=%7$3'
.%-',%7p/
$-"45:5#5(,'+5(3'.7(7-"'
"&8#%,"-9/e J-"99' )88-%8-5)("#,' .%-' ,%7-' 5*("-=5"+/' !")-' $#")*' 5-%*"4'
$#%(3"9' )*4' $#")*' $#%9"0(%"4' 93%"9/' ]%7' 93%7#4' :"' +"##'
<-%%&"4M')*4'(-,'*%('(%' %="-+3"#&'(3"'5*("-=5"+"-' +5(3',%7-'
$%#%<*"'%-'8"-.7&"/'!3"*'5*'4%7:('):%7('+3)('(%'+")-M'(35*;'
-/$%:&A2#"&3$"'4&$%4(")$(*h &%-"'$%*9"-=)?="#,/'F359' &")*9' (-,'(%' $%*$")#' )*,'()2%%9'%-'
@5-9(')*4'.%-"&%9(M'5('59':"*"L$5)#'(%'-"9")-$3'(3"'$%&8)*,',%7' :%4,' 85"-$5*<9/' S%%;5*<' +"##' -"9("4' )*4' -"#)T"4' .%-' ,%7-'
)-"' )88#,5*<'(%' +%-;'.%-/'D)*,'"&8#%,"-9'3)="' )'#%(' %.' 8-54"' 5*("-=5"+'59'"99"*?)#/
.%-' (3"5-' $%&8)*,' )*4' &),' #%%;' .%-' "&8#%,""9' +3%' )-"' )9'
"*(3795)9?$')9'(3",')-"/'J%5*<',%7-'3%&"+%-;')#9%'&);"9',%7' F-,'(%' :"' ")-#,' .%-' ,%7-' 5*("-=5"+z+"')-"' *%(' 9),5*<'%*"'%-'
&%-"' 8-"8)-"4' .%-' (3"' 5*("-=5"+/' ]%7' $)*' (3"*' $)("-' ,%7-' (+%' 3%7-9' ")-#,M':7(' )(' #")9(' Yf' &5*7("9' 9%' (3)(' ,%7' $)*'L*4'
)*9+"-9' (%+)-4' +3,' (3"5-' $%&8)*,'*""49',%7' %*' (3"5-' 9()O/' +3"-"',%7N-"'9788%9"4'(%' :"/'F359' 59')#9%' )'<%%4' ?&"'(%' 79"'
]%7' +5##' )#9%' L*4' (3)(' "&8#%,"-9' +5##' )9;' 5.' ,%7' 3)="' )*,' (3"'-"9(-%%&':".%-"3)*4'9%'(3)(',%7'4%'*%('9(-"99',%7-9"#.'%7('
47-5*<'(3"'5*("-=5"+/

! !3"*' ,%7-' 5*("-=5"+"-' 5*(-%47$"9' 35&9"#.l3"-9"#.M' +)5(' .%-' )'


3)*493);"' )*4' 4%' *%(' 95(' 7*?#' (3"' 5*("-=5"+"-' 95(9' 4%+*' %-'
5*=5("9',%7'(%'95('4%+*/'D)5*()5*'","'$%*()$('.%-'(3"'5*("-=5"+M'
:7('4%'*%('9()-"',%7-'5*("-=5"+"-' 4%+*M',%7' +)*(' (%'#"(' (3"&'
;*%+',%7')-"'"*<)<"4'5*'(3"'$%*="-9)?%*':7('*%('(3-")("*5*<'
(3"&/']%7' 93%7#4')#9%' ;""8' <%%4' 8%9(7-"' :7(' (-,' *%(' (%' #%%;'
(%%'9?O/'J%'*%('L4<"('47-5*<',%7-'5*("-=5"+'%-'$-%99',%7-')-&9'
%-'87(',%7-' 3)*49'5*',%7-'8%$;"(z(3"9"')-"'$#")-'95<*9'%.'3%+'
7*$%&.%-():#"' ,%7' )-"' )*4' $)*' &);"' (3"' 5*("-=5"+"-'
7*$%&.%-():#"/

1' #%(' %.' "&8#%,"-9' +5##' )9;' +3"*' ,%7' )-"' )=)5#):#"' (%' +%-;'
)r"-' (3"'5*("-=5"+/'J%' *%('3"95()("'(%'&"*?%*' 5.',%7' 3)="')*'
%:#5<)?%*' (3)(' &5<3('3%#4' ,%7' :)$;/'>*$"' )<)5*M',%7' +)*(' (%'
:"'3%*"9(/'P.')*4'+3"*' ,%7'<"(' 35-"4'.%-' (3"'8%95?%*M',%7'4%*'
*%('+)*('(%'98-5*<',%7-'9$3"47#"'%*'(3"&/
U7"9?%*9' .%-' (3"&M' 3)=5*<'U7"9?%*9' 8-"8)-"4' +5##' 3"#8' ,%7'
$%*=",',%7-'5*("-"9('5*'(3"5-'$%&8)*,/ 1('(3"'"*4'%.'(3"'5*("-=5"+'-"&"&:"-'(%'(3)*;'(3"'5*("-=5"+"-'
)*4')*,%*"'"#9"'+3%' 3)9'3"#8"4',%7'n5/"/'(3"'-"$"8?%*59(M')*,'
I-"8)-"' ,%7-' )*9+"-9' :".%-"3)*4' :,' 9")-$35*<' $%&&%*' Q%:' )99%$5)("9M'9"$-"()-,M'"($/p/']%7' &),')#9%' +)*(' (%')9;'+3)(' (3"'
5*("-=5"+'U7"9?%*9')*4'8-)$?$5*<'(3"&'"5(3"-'+5(3')'.-5"*4'%-' 9"#"$?%*' 8-%$"99' 59' #5;"' )*4' 3%+' #%*<' 5(' &5<3(' :"' .%-' ,%7' (%'
5*'.-%*('%.')'&5--%-/']%7'+5##'+)*(',%7-')*9+"-9'(%':"'$#")-')*4' L*4'%7(' 5.',%7' <%(' (3"'Q%:/''K")##,'(-,'(%'#")="'(3"'5*("-=5"+"-'
,%7'+)*('"*97-"',%7' )-"')*9+"-5*<'(3"'U7"9?%*'(3)(' 59':"5*<' +5(3' )' #)9?*<'5&8-"995%*M'"="*' 5.' ,%7'4%' *%(' <"(' (3"' Q%:'(359'
)9;"4' )*4' *%(' .)##' %O' (%85$/' F359' 4%"9' *%(' &")*' (3)(' ,%7' ?&"M'(3",'&5<3('-"&"&:"-',%7'.%-')*%(3"-'8%95?%*'#)("-/
93%7#4' &"&%-5R"' ,%7-' )*9+"-9w' ,%7' 4%' *%(' +)*(' (%' 9%7*4'

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 17


PM4'+5(3///' E,'67#5"'C3"*
N:+2":&A9Q(*$R B"*5%-'B()O'!-5("-

D"GO'*BZ&GHG&ZCR&KBCCIF&DC& D"JO&*BPD&GC&ZCR&GC&YHDB&ZCRE&
LFKCOF&P&XEC_FIICEd UOF&PYPZ&_ECO&#/0-d

NAO'P'&79(')4&5('P'454'*%('%-5<5*)##,' NAO'!3"*'P'3)="'(3"'?&"0')*4'(3)('59'
8#)*'(%'<%'5*(%'(")$35*</'P'+"*( *%('="-,'%r"*0'P'#5;"'(%'(-)="#/'P')&')#9%'
5*(%'(3"'L"#4'%.'"$%*%&5$9':"$)79"'P' )'37<"'98%-(9'.)*M'"98"$5)##,'$%##"<"'
.%7*4'5('.)9$5*)?*</'D,'5*5?)#'8#)*' .%%(:)##/
)9')*'7*4"-<-)47)("'+)9'(%'<%'5*(%'(3"'

D"KO'5PNF&ZCR&LFFQ&[FFXHQS&RX&
:795*"99'L"#4M':7(')r"-')'."+'"$%*
$#)99"9M''P'+)9'3%%;"4/'''B%'+3"*'P'<"('
(%'(")$3'9%&"(35*<'(3)('P'L*4' YHDB&#/0-&_CCDLPTT&SPOFI&PI&YFTTd
"*%-&%79#,'
"*Q%,):#"M'(3)('&);"9'(")$35*<'="-,' NAO'>3M'%.'$%7-9"M'P'+)($3'"="-,'95*<#"'
")9,')*4'="-,'9)?9.,5*</' <)&"M'"="*'5.'+"')-"')(')'9%7-'8%5*(/

$:N./:" -=O7@8PQ" ." 27=B>/7/" 45/" RS'!T0"


O7U./BA79B" 54"$=595A8=0"1.0"V779"B7.=189;"
D"HO'$_&ZCR&KCRTG&BPNF&KBCIFQ& D"LO&%CY&CQ&DC&ICOF&OCEF&
7@7/" 089=7" ;7W9;"180"61XOX" .B" B17" R98@7/08BY" PQZ&CDBFE&XEC_FIIHCQ@&YBPD&YCRTG& GHkKRTD&lRFIUCQI\&&5CY&YCRTG&ZCR&
54" S.2845/98.Q" '50" !9;7270" 89" EMMHX" Z7" 80" HD&LFd GFIKEHLF&DBF&KREEFQD&IDPDF&C_&DBF&
=>//79B2Y B 7 . = 1 8 9 ;" ." = 2 . 0 0" 5 9" STCLPT&FKCQCOZd
-.=/57=595A8=0"C175/YX NAO'P'4%*N(';*%+'5.'(359'$%7*(9':"$)79"'

D"Ea'4C&IDPED&Cb@&YBPD&GC&ZCR& 5('59'9?##'5*')$)4"&5)M':7('P'(35*;'P'+%7#4'
)#9%'3)="'"*Q%,"4'359(%-,')9')'
NAO'1('#")9('.%-'(3"'A/B/'"$%*%&,M')9'
(3"'@"4'3)9'-"$"*(#,'9)54M'(3"-"')-"'
FQaCZ&OCID&PLCRD&DFPKBHQSd 8-%."995%*/'P'3)="')#+),9':""*'="-,' 4"L*5("#,'95<*9'(3)('5('59'9():5#5R5*</'>.'
.%*4'%.'359(%-,')*4M'5*'.)$(M'%*"'%.'&,' $%7-9"M'&%9('98"$5)#59(9'5*'(359'L"#4'
NAO'P'="-,'&7$3'"*Q%,'(3"'5*("-)$?%*' .)=%-5("'L"#49')9')'<-)47)("'9(74"*(' 8-"45$(')'="-,'9#%+'-"$%="-,M'9%'+"'+5##'
+5(3'9(74"*(9M'"98"$5)##,'47-5*<'%m$"' +)9'"$%*%&5$'359(%-,/'E7('P'"*Q%,'%(3"-' 8-%:):#,'3)="'(3"'35<3'7*"&8#%,&"*('
3%7-9/'P('59')'$3)##"*<"'(%'(")$3' :-)*$3"9'%.'359(%-,'Q79(')9'&7$3/' -)("9'.%-')'."+',")-9/
"$%*%&5$9')*4'P'"*Q%,'(3)('$3)##"*<"/

D"IO&-&TCD&C_&IDRGFQDI&KCQIHGFE& D"MO'0PID&lRFIUCQh&9PQZ&
D"FO'*BPD&YCRTG&LF&ZCRE& ZCR&DC&LF&CQF&C_&DBF&BPEGFID& LFTHFNF&DBPD&DBF&eQPQKHPT&KEHIHI&BPI&
LHSSFID&_ERIDEPUCQ&PLCRD&DFPKBHQSd (KCQCOHKI&XEC_FIICEI\&,C&ZCR&BPNF& OPGF&FKCQCOHKI&OCEF&EFTFNPQD&
PQZ&PGNHKF&_CE&IDRGFQDI&DBPD&eQG& PQG&HOOFGHPDF&DC&KCTTFSF&IDRGFQDI\&
NAO'F3)('+%7#4'3)="'(%':"'(3"'#)-<"' ZCRE&KTPIIFI&GHkKRTDd 0CC[HQS&PD&ZCRE&KTPIIFI@&BCY&
$#)99'95R"9/''F3"'#)-<"'$#)99'95R"9'&);"'5(' PKKREPDF&GC&ZCR&DBHQ[&DBHI&
="-,'45m$7#('(%'5*("-)$('+5(3'%*#,':7(')' NAO'!%-;/'!%-;/'!%-;/''19;'U7"9?%*9/' IDPDFOFQD&HId
3)*4.7#'%.'9(74"*(9/'>(3"-+59"M'P'4%*N(' Z$%*%&5$9'59'{)|'45m$7#('97:Q"$(M'9%')'
3)="'&)*,'$%&8#)5*(9/'F3"'9(74"*(9')(' 9(74"*('*""49')'#%('%.'8"-9"="-)*$"'(%' NAO'!"'+%7#4'#5;"'(%'(35*;'(3)('
ACS1')-"':,')*4'#)-<"'="-,'3)-40 97$$""4'5*'(359'L"#4/'F3"-"'59' "$%*%&5$9'59')#+),9'="-,'-"#"=)*(/'[)9'
+%-;5*<')*4'5*("##5<"*(/'F3)('59'%*"'%.' 7*.%-(7*)("#,'*%'98"$5)#'d(-5$;e'(%' 5(':"$%&"'&%-"'-"#"=)*('(%'$%##"<"'
(3"'(35*<9'(3)('&);"'(")$35*<'3"-"'9%' 4%5*<'+"##'5*'"$%*%&5$9'%-')#&%9(')*,' 9(74"*(9v'P'+%7#4'9),'(3)('5('3)9a'
"*Q%,):#"/ %(3"-'-5<%-%79'L"#4'%.'9(74,/'P('3"#89'5.' Z98"$5)##,'(3%9"'):%7('(%'<-)47)("')*4'
,%7'"*Q%,'(3"'97:Q"$('&)2"-/ "*("-'(3"'Q%:'&)-;"(/'K"$"*('"="*(9'
3)="'85U7"4'&)*,'9(74"*(9N'5*("-"9('5*'
:795*"99's7$(7)?%*9')*4'(3"'9%7-$"9'
%.'97$3's7$(7)?%*9/'
BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 18
F[Z'3$%-%/$-0&CKPBPB
&4BF&:TCLPT&$OXPKD&C_&DBF&3HQPQKHPT&/EHIHI& +=
&5CY&DBF&3HQPQKHPT&/EHIHI&/PQ&-bFKD&ACR& ++
&m4BF&'DRGFQDn

&4BF&3HQPQKHPT&/EHIHIh&-Q&2NFENHFY& & +.

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 19


3$%-%/$-0&/"$'$'
45(&$9>-/4&2%&45(&:02!-0&(/2%29A
!A&'4(>5(%&922/6
'DPb&*EHDFE&

P
D& BPI& LFFQ& P& THgTF& CNFE& P& ZFPE& QCY& IHQKF& DBF& KCTTPXIF& C_& DBF& *PTT& 'DEFFD& SHPQD& 0FBOPQ& !ECDBFEI& PQG& DBF&
QPUCQYHGF&EFPTH`PUCQ&DBPD&DBF&eQPQKHPT&IFKDCE&YCRTG&LF&HQ&_CE&P&IDCOPKBJKBREQHQS&EHGF\&&-pFE&DBF&HQNFIDOFQD&
LPQ[& eTFG& /BPXDFE& <<& LPQ[ERXDKZ& XECDFKUCQ& CQ& 'FXDFOLFE& <7@& +==;@& OPE[FDI& FWXFEHFQKFG& RQXEFKFGFQDFG&
GECXI&DBPD&KPRIFG&XFCXTF&PECRQG&DBF&QPUCQ&DC&KEHQSF&PI&DBFHE&1=<[oI&GHIPXXFPEFG&LF_CEF&DBFHE&FZFI\&&!FSHQQHQS&
2KDCLFE&8@&HQ&YBPD&LFKPOF&[QCYQ&PI&V!TPK[&*FF[@]&DBF&,CY&^CQFI&HQGRIDEHPT&PNFEPSF&_FTT&<@;M1&XCHQDI&CE&<;q\&&
4BHI& LFKPOF& DBF&HQGFWoI& YCEID& YFF[TZ& GFKTHQF& CQ& LCDB& P& XCHQD& PQG& XFEKFQDPSF&LPIHI& FNFE\& & *HDB& -OFEHKPQI& LFHQS&
YCEEHFG&PLCRDr&XPZHQS& DBFHE&OCEDSPSF@&eQGHQS& PQCDBFE& aCL&PpFE& LFHQS&TPHG& Cb@&CE& DBF&XCIIHLHTHDZ&C_& EFUEFOFQD@& & HD& HI&
FPIZ& DC& RQGFEIDPQG& YBZ& XFCXTF& BPNF& LFFQ& OCEF& KCQKFEQFG& YHDB& DBFHE& CYQ& YFTT& LFHQS& HQIDFPG& C_& DBF& STCLPT&
EPOHeKPUCQI&C_& DBF&eQPQKHPT&OFTDGCYQ\&&4BF&CEHSHQPT&XPQHK&HI&CNFE&QCY& PQG&HD&HI&HOXCEDPQD&DBPD&YF&TCC[&YHDB&P&LECPG&
NHFY& PD& BCY& QPUCQI& CDBFE& DBPQ& DBF&#QHDFG& 'DPDFI& BPNF& LFFQ& PbFKDFG& LZ& DBHI& DREOCHT\& & $Q& DBHI& PEUKTF& HD& YCRTG& LF&
HOXCIIHLTF&DC&KCNFE&PTT&PEFPI& C_&DBF&YCETG&PQG&BCY&DBFZ&BPNF&LFFQ&PbFKDFG\&$QIDFPG&DBF&_CKRI&YHTT&LF&CQ&DYC&EFTFNPQD&
DCXHKIh& &/BHQPoI& ECTF&HQ& DBF&EFKCNFEHQS& STCLPT&FKCQCOZ& PQG&DBF&EFIDERKDREHQS& C_& STCLPT&eQPQKF&DBPD&YHTT&BFTX& BFPT&DBF&

/5$%-o'&"20(&$%&45(& *%(' :)$;' (%' 5(9' 8-"0$-5959' 9()("/''


K"()5#"-9' 5*' *)?%*9' +%-#4+54"'
:02!-0&(/2%29A )-"' :"5*<' &%-"' $)7?%79' ):%7('
>="-' (3"' 8)9(' ,")-' (3"-"' 3)9' :""*' )' (3"5-'87-$3)9"9/'F3",')#9%'4%'*%('
$%*954"-):#"' )&%7*(' %.' :7RR' -"=%#=5*<' 3)="' (3"' "T$"99' #5U754' $)85()#'
)-%7*4' (3"' C35*"9"' "$%*%&,' +5(3' (3)(' +)9' %*$"' 3)4' (%' 87-$3)9"'
-"98"$(' (%' (3"' <#%:)#' L*)*$5)#' $-5959/'' "T$"99' <%%49' )*4' L*4' +),9' (%'
I"%8#"' 3)="' :""*' (3-%+5*<' )-%7*4' <"('8"%8#"'(%':7,'(3"&/
97$3' 9()("&"*(9' )9' dC35*)' %+*9' )##' %.'
1&"-5$)N9' 4":(Me' )*4' dC35*)' 3)9' *%(' F3"' 95R"' %.' C35*)N9' "$%*%&,' 59'
:""*' )O"$("4' :,' (3"' +%7*4"4' <-%+5*<':7('9?##'#"99'(3)*')'(35-4'
5*("-*)?%*)#' "$%*%&5$' 9()("/e' ' F3"9"' %.' (3)('%.' (3"'A*5("4' B()("9'+5(3'
$#)5&9' 3)="' =)#545(,M' :7(' (3",' $)*' )#9%' )' kJI' %.' Yc/j' (-5##5%*/' ' E"5*<' )'
:"' &595*("-8-"("4' +5(3%7(' )' 4""8"-' $%7*(-,'+3"-"'5('3)9'8-%="*'3)-4' !
#%%;' 5*(%' (3"' $7--"*(' 9()("' %.' C35*)/'' (%' :%--%+M' :%(3' $%-8%-)?%*9' )*4' 3%79"'8-5$"9/''P('59'(%%'")-#,'(%'$)##'(359')'
F3"' L-9(' ;",'85"$"' %.' 5*.%-&)?%*' (3)(' 3%79"3%#49' 5*' C35*)' 3)="' -"9%-("4' (%' :7::#"M' :7(' (3"' <%="-*&"*(' *""49' (%'
&79(' :"' 7*4"-9(%%4' 59' (3)(' C35*)M'#5;"' 35<3"-' 9)=5*<9' -)("9' 5*' (3"' 8)9(' ,")-9/'' :"' -")4,' (%' 5*(-%47$"' #"<59#)?%*' 5*'
&%9(' %.' (3"' %(3"-' 4"="#%8"4' +%-#4' F3"9"' 9)=5*<9' 87(' C35*)' 5*' )' 8-"&5"-' %-4"-' (%' ?<3("*' #5U7545(,' 5.' (359' (-"*4'
*)?%*9' 454' -"$"5="' )' <%="-*&"*(' 9()("'(%'#"*4'+3"*'(3"'-"9('%.'(3"'+%-#4' $%*?*7"9/''F3"'B3)*<3)5'1093)-"'5*4"T'
9?&7#79' 8)$;)<"' 5*' %-4"-' (%' 8-"="*(' -")##,' *""4"4' 5(/' ' [%+"="-' (3)(' 59' 78' )' 9%#54' iWt' .-%&' #)9(' g%="&:"-M'
5(N9'#)-<"#,'"T8%-(' :)9"4'"$%*%&,'.-%&' "T$"995="'9)=5*<'4%"9'*%(' 9?&7#)("'(3"' )*4' (3"' )="-)<"' C35*"9"' 3%&"' 8-5$"'59'
$%##)895*</' ' F3"' "*4' %.' VWWj' +)9' )' "$%*%&,'%-'*"+':795*"99'<-%+(3/ *5*"' ?&"9' (3)(' %.' (3"' 3%79"3%#4'
( " - - 5 : # "' ? & "' . % -' - " ( ) 5 # /' B 7 $ 3' 5*$%&"/''F3"9"'L<7-"9'+3"*' $%&:5*"4'
"9():#593&"*(9' 9(%88"4' 8#)$5*<' %-4"-9'
.%-'&%-"'&"-$3)*459"/''F359'+)9')';5##"-' V\\\DBF&PNFEPSF&/BHQFIF& +5(3' (3"' #)-<"' 5*$-")9"' 5*' (-)45*<' )*4'

.%-' C35*)N9' &)*7.)$(7-5*<' 5*479(-,' BCOF&XEHKF&HI&QHQF&UOFI& 3%&"' 9)#"9' +%7#4' #")4' )*,%*"' (%'
DBPD&C_&DBF&BCRIFBCTG& :"#5"="' (3)(' (359' 59' (3"' :"<5**5*<' %.' )'
+35$3' (3-5="9' %*' $%*9()*(' +%-#4+54"' HQKCOF\] :7::#"' (3)(' +5##' 7*4%7:("4#,'#")4'(%')'
"T8%-(9/' ' C35*)' &)*)<"4' (%' 87##' $)()9(-%835$':7-9(/
(3-%7<3' (3"' :-5".' #7##' 5*' (-)4"/' E".%-"' C35*)N9'-"$"*('<-%+(3'59'9%&"(35*<'(3)('
)*%(3"-' !)##' B(-""(' <5)*(' $%7#4' .)##M' 93%7#4':"'8)54'$#%9"')2"*?%*'(%/''1r"-'
C35*)N9' 8-%47$?%*' +)9' :)$;' 78' )*4' (3"' 4"8#%,&"*(' %.' (3"' 9?&7#79M'(3"-"'
-7**5*</' ' [%+"="-M' 8-%47$?%*' 59' 9?##' 3)9' :""*' )' -)854' Q7&8' 5*' 93)-"' )*4'

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 20


)*4' 1&"-5$)' 9?##' #")*' (%+)-49' (3"'
-%7("'%.' ."+"-' -"9(-5$?%*9M' 3%#45*<'
9 ( - % * <' ( %' ( 3 "' . - " "' & ) - ; " ('
835#%9%83,' )*4':"#5"=5*<' (3)('L-&9'
93%7#4' &);"'(3"'4"$595%*9' %*' 3%+'
&7$3' (%'8),' (3"5-' "&8#%,""9/' 'F3"'
kVW' 5997"4' )' 9()("&"*(' 5*45$)?*<'
(3)(' -"<7#)?%*9' +%7#4' :"' &)4"'
-"U75-5*<' )' 95<*5L$)*(' 8%-?%*' %.'
=)-5):#"' $%&8"*9)?%*' (%' :"'
4"."--"4' n?"4' (%' 8"-.%-&)*$"' )*4'
(%' :"' 5997"4' 5*' (3"'.%-&' %.' 9(%$;p/''
F3",' )#9%' )9;"4' )##' L-&9' (%'
5 & 8 # " & " * (' 5 * 4 " 8 " * 4 " * ('
$%&8"*9)?%*' $%&&52""9' +3%'
-"=5"+' (3"' L-&N9' 9(-7$(7-"' )*4'
9,9("&)?$' -59;M')4Q79?*<' "&8#%,""'
$%&8"*9)?%*')88-%8-5)("#,/

1*%(3"-' 5&8%-()*(' )98"$(' %.'


L*)*$"' (3)(' (3"' kVW' 5*="9?<)("4'
+)9' -)595*<' -"U75-"4' 8"-$"*()<"'
! "U75(,' $%*(-%##"4' :,' #)-<"' :)*;9/''
"('4"#/4#"$%:&23& (3"'A^M'3)="':""*' 95<*5L$)*(#,')O"$("4'
:,' (359' <#%:)#' 3)-49358' #")=5*<' !3"*' &)*,' #%)*9' :)$;"4' :,' #52#"'
:02!-0&3$%-%/(& "="-,%*"' 5*' )' 8%95?%*' -")4,' (%' "U75(,' n(3"' =)#7"' %.' (3"' 8-%8"-(,'
D)*,' "$%*%&59(9' )-"' .)5-#,' $%*L4"*(' 3"#4' )<)5*9(' (3"' #%)*p' )-"' 8-"9"*(M'
*"<%?)("/
(3)(' +"' 3)="' 9""*' (3"' +%-9(' %.' (3"' 7*9():#"' "$%*%&5$' $%*45?%*9' +5##'
-"$"995%*' )*4'(3"'"$%*%&,'59'-")4,'(%' #5;"#,':"'(3"'-"97#(/''P('&),'9""&'#5;"'
1'<-%78'%.'(+"*(,'L*)*$"'&5*59("-9'
:"<5*'&);5*<')'-"$%="-,/''g%+M'8%#5$5"9' (359' 8-%:#"&' +%7#4' :"' ")95#,' LT"4'
)*4' $"*(-)#' :)*;"-9' &);5*<' 78' (3"'
*""4' (%' :"' 5&8#"&"*("4' 9%' (3)(' )' :,' 5&8#"&"*?*<' )'<#%:)#' 9()*4)-4'
kVW'&"('5*'I529:7-<3'.%-'(3"5-'&%9('
9(")4,'-"$%="-,'59' 8%995:#"/'' F3"' +%-#4' &5*5&7&'"U75(,'-"U75-"4'(%':%--%+'
-"$"*(' 97&&5(' (%' 459$799' .7(7-"'
8%+"-9' )*4' $"*(-)#' :)*;"-9' &79(' Q%5*' %*/' ' [%+"="-M' (3"'8-%:#"&' #),9' 5*'
- " < 7 # ) ? % * 9' ( 3 ) (' & 7 9 (' : "'
(%<"(3"-' (%' &);"' 97-"' (3)(' (3"' +3"*' )$$%7*?*<' -7#"9' (3)(' )-"' *%('
5&8#"&"*("4' 5*(%' (3"' L*)*$5)#'
(3"' "$%*%&,' -"$%="-9M' 5(' 59' :,' 7*5.%-&' 5*' "="-,' $%7*(-,/' D")*5*<'
5*479(-,/' ' Z9():#593"4' 5*' YXXXM' (3"'
979()5*):#"' &")*9/' ' 1#%*<' +5(3' (3"' (3)(' (3"' +),' )99"(9' )-"' "=)#7)("4'
kVW' <)(3"-9' (%' $%*="-9"' )*4'
A*5("4' B()("9M' %(3"-' 5*("-*)?%*)#' $)*'=)-,'"*%-&%79#,'.-%&' 8#)$"' (%'
: - ) 5 * 9 ( % - &' ) : % 7 (' 3 % +' ( 3 "'
8%+"-9M' 6)8)*M' @-)*$"M' k"-&)*,M' )*4' 8#)$"/' ' 1&"-5$)*' 9()*4)-49' 797)##,'
5*479(-5)#5R"4' )*4' 4"="#%85*<'
*)?%*9' %.' (3"' +%-#4' $)*' +%-;' 5*=%#="' 8-5$5*<' )99"(9' (%' &)-;"(M'
(%<"(3"-' .%-' (3"':"*"L(' %.' (3"' +3"-"'Z7-%8")*'8%#5$5"9')-"')5&5*<'
<#%:)#'"$%*%&,/''>*"'%.'(3"'3%(' (%' -"="-(' (%' d9&%%(3"4e' :)#)*$"0
(%85$9' 459$799"4' +)9' (3"' 93""(9'(3)(')-"':"2"-'.%-'-"<7#)(%-9'
$ % * ( - % = " - 9 5 ) #' 5 9 9 7 "' % .' (3)*'5*="9(%-9/' ' F3"'kVW')<-""4' (%'
" T ( - ) = ) < ) * (' : % * 7 9 " 9' . % -' +%-;' %*' <"u*<' (3"9"' 8-)$?$"9'
L*)*$5)#' 9"$(%-' "&8#%,""9/'' 9()*4)-45R"4' 5*("-*)?%*)##,' 9%' (3)('
k"-&)*,' )*4' @-)*$"' ("*4' (%' #"99'+5##':"'#%9('5*'(-)*9#)?%*/
#")*' (%+)-49' )' 9(-5$("-' 9()*$"'
%*'(3"'95R"')*4'(,8"'%.':%*79"9M'
+)*?*<' (%' #5&5(' (3"&' (%' )'
9&)##"-' 8"-$"*()<"' %.' )*'
5*45=547)#N9 '*%*0=)-5):#"'5*$%&"'
)9' +"##' )9' 8),5*<' 8)-?)##,' 5*'
93)-"9 '-)(3"-' (3)*'$)93/' E-5()5*'
!
BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 21
5CY&DBF&(KCQCOZ&HI&
-bFKUQS&ACR BY CHRIS YOUNG
'DPb&*EHDFE

A*#"99',%7'3)="':""*' #5=5*<' 7*4"-' )'-%$;M',%7' ;*%+' (3)('$7--"*(#,M'1&"-5$)'


)*4'&%9('%.' (3"'+%-#4' 3)9':""*' #%$;"4'4%+*' 5*' )*'"$%*%&5$'-"$"995%*/'F3"'
*"+9'3)9':""*'5*7*4)("4'+5(3'4%%&')*4'<#%%&/'[%+"="-M'(3"-"'59')'9(%-,'%7('
(3"-"'(3)('3)9*N(':""*'(%#4/'!"'3)="')##'3")-4'(3"'9()?9?$9')*4'L<7-"9/'F3"'
Q%:' #%99' L<7-"9M' (3"' $%*97&"-' 8-5$"'5*4"TM' )*4' %.' $%7-9"M' )##' (3"' 98""$3"9'
&)4"':,')##'(3"'()#;5*<'3")49'+"'9""'-"<7#)-#,'%*'("#"=595%*/'E7('3%+')-"'+"M'
)9'$%##"<"' 9(74"*(9M' )O"$("4v' ]"9M' "="*'5*'%7-'+%-#4' %.' :%%;9')*4' :""-M'(3"'
5*("-*)?%*)#'"$%*%&,'3)9')O"$("4'79'8-%.%7*4#,/

@5-9(M'9%&"(35*<'(3)(' 45-"$(#,')O"$(9' 79/' * 7 & " - % 7 9' 5 * ( " - * 9 3 5 8 9' . % -'


P*' (3"' 8)9(' ,")-M' (3"' AC' 9,9("&' 3)9' 7*4"-<-)47)("9' 3)="' :""*' $7u*<'
-)59"4' (75?%*' :,'X/ct/'@%-' (3"' )="-)<"' 4%+*'%*' (3"5-'%O"-5*<9/'1*' 5*="9(&"*('
9(74"*(' +5(3' *%' L*)*$5)#' )54' %-' <-%78' 5*' B)*' @-)*$59$%' +35$3' 5*' VWWb' %.' Q%:9M'9(74"*(9')-"':-)*$35*<'%7(' )*4'
9$3%#)-93589M'(3)(' 59' *5*"' 37*4-"4' Lr,' (%%;'%*' (3-""' 7*4"-<-)47)("'5*("-*9' 5*' 4"="#%85*<' &%-"' 9;5##9/' B(74"*(9' )-"'
Q79(' .%-' (75?%*/' F359' 59' *%(' "="*' (3"5-' &%-(<)<"' 4"8)-(&"*(' 5*$#745*<' 98"*45*<' &%-"' ?&"' )2"*45*<' 9(74"*('
5*$#745*<'3%795*<M'&")#'8#)*9M'%-' )*,'%.' %*"' .-%&' ACS1' $%7#4' *%(' ();"' %*' )*,' -7*'+%-;93%89'97$3' )9'-"97&"':75#4"-9'
(3"' %(3"-' )&"*5?"9' +"' 8),' .%-/' @%-' 5*("-*9' 5*' (3"' 97&&"-' %.' VWWX' 95&8#,' )*4' &%$;'5*("-=5"+9/'B(74"*(9' )-"')#9%'
(3%9"' %.' ,%7' +3%' +"-"' )'#52#"' 9#%+' 5*' :"$)79"' (3"-"' +)9'*%('"*%7<3'+%-;'(%' :"<5**5*<' (%' &)8' %7(' (3"5-' %8?%*9/'
&)(3' $#)99M')' (3%79)*4' 4%##)-9'59' *%(' )' <5="'(%')*'7*8)54'5*("-*/'B(%8' )*4' (35*;' k-)47)("' 9$3%%#' 59' :"$%&5*<' )' &7$3'
#)7<35*<' &)2"-/' F3)(N9' (+%' ACS1' ):%7(' (359' .%-' )' 9"$%*4/' F3"-"' +)9' *%' &%-"')2-)$?="' %8?%*')9'Q%:9':"$%&"'
@-"*$3' ("T(:%%;9M'(+%'C5=5#'Z*<5*""-5*<' 4"&)*4' .%-' )*& #%/2$:' 5*("-*/'1#(3%7<3' )'-)-"' $%&&%45(,/'F3"')="-)<"'9(74"*('
("T(:%%;9M' .%7-' &5$-%"$%*%&5$9' (359' 59' (3"' "T$"8?%*' -)(3"-' (3)*' (3"' 59' *%+' &7$3' &%-"' )+)-"' %.' +3)(' 3"'
("T(:%%;9M' )*4' )' 97:9$-58?%*' (%' (3"' -7#"M' $%&8"??%*' )*4' 9788#,' %.' (35*<9' $)*'4%' (%'&);"'35&9"#.'&%-"')2-)$?="'
&)<)R5*"' %.' ,%7-' $3%5$"' +5(3' $3)*<"' 97$3' )9'Q%:9' )*4' 5*("-*93589'.%-' $%##"<"' .%-' (3"'"="*(7)#5(,'%.'"*("-5*<'(3"'+%-;'
#"r'%="-'.%-'#7*$3')('1$;"-&)*/' 9(74"*(9'3)="':""*' $%&5*<'.7-(3"-' )*4' .%-$"/'P*')'+),M'(359'-"$"995%*'59'3"#85*<'
.7-(3"-':"(+""*/' :,' 4-5=5*<' 9(74"*(9' (%' #")-*' "99"*?)#'
E"954"9' (3"' (35**5*<' %.' %7-' +)##"(9M'
:795*"99' 9;5##9' (3)(' +5##' 3"#8' (3"&' 5*'
$%&8"??%*'.%-' 5*("-*93589'59':"$%&5*<' F3"' "*?-"' 85$(7-"' 59' *%(' )##' <-",' 9;5"9'
:%(3' -"$"995%*9' )*4' *%-&)#' "$%*%&5$'
L"-$"/' @5-&9' +35$3' 79"4' (%' %O"-' )*4' -)5*4-%89/'!5(3' .""' 35;"9')*4' #)$;'
?&"9/' P*' )' -"$%="-5*<' "$%*%&,M' (3"9"'
9;5##9'+5##' :"'"="*'&%-"'79".7#/'F3"'J%+'
6%*"9' P*479(-5)#' 1="-)<"M' %*"' %.' (3"'
:5<<"9(' 5*45$)(%-9' .%-' (3"' 9()("' %.' (3"'
1&"-5$)*'"$%*%&,M':-%;"'YWMWWW'8%5*(9'
5*' &540>$(%:"-' .%-' (3"' L-9(' ?&"' 5*' )'
,")-/'C%&:5*"4' +5(3' (3"' 8%95?="' *"+9'
$%&5*<' .-%&' E"*' E"-*)*;"' )*4' (3"'
(-")97-,' 4"8)-(&"*(M' 5(' #%%;9' #5;"' %7-'
"T("*4"4' "$%*%&5$' .%-"$)9(' 5*$#74"9'
9%&"' 97*935*"' .%-' $7--"*(' $%##"<"'
9(74"*(9/

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 22


45(&:"(-4&
/"(,$4&/"$'$'h&
-&02%:&!#9>A&"2-,
BY ROBERT CHANG

4
STAFF WRITER
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&BF&:EFPD&/EFGHD&&/EHIHI&&BPI&IKPEEFG&DBF&THNFI&C_&OPQZ !5(3' )##' (3"' "T(-)' &%*",M' :)*;9' +"-"' +5##5*<' (%' L*)*$"'
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&-OFEHKPQI\&4BFZ&PEF&&BREUQS&IHQKF&DBFZ&BPNF&aCHQFG &%-(<)<"9'+5(3' &7$3'#%+"-' 5*("-"9(' -)("9M'&);5*<'5(' ")95"-' .%-'
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&DBF&&HQKEFPIHQS&&QROLFE&&C_&&RQFOXTCZFG&&XFCXTF&&CE 1&"-5$)*9':7,'3%&"9/' '["*$"M'(3"' 1&"-5$)*' 4-")&' 3)4'Q79('
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&BPNF&&&YHDQFIIFG&&&NPTRF&&&C_&&&DBFHE&&&IDCK[&&XCEsCTHCI :"$%&"')'+3%#"'#%('$3")8"-'(%')2)5*/'
ITPIBFG& HQ& BPT_& $D& BPI&LFFQ& OCEF& DBPQ& P& ZFPE&IHQKF&DBF& KEHIHI&
LECRSBD& DBF& eQPQKHPT& UDPQ& 0FBOPQ& !ECDBFEI& DC& HDI& [QFFI@& I"%8#"'+3%'*%-&)##,'$%7#4'%*#,')O%-4'(%'-"*('(%%;')4=)*()<"'
XECOXUQS&DBF&SCNFEQOFQD& DC&HIIRF&PQ&RQXEFKFGFQDFG&ORTUJ %.' #%+' 5*("-"9(' -)("9' (%' :7,' 3%&"9/' F3"' <-%+(3' 5*' 4"&)*4'
DEHTTHCQtGCTTPE&LPHTCRD\&AFD& FNFQ&HQ&BHQGIHSBD@&OPQZ&XFCXTF&GC& $)79"4'3%79"'8-5$"9'(%'9;,-%$;"(M')*4'9%&"'3%&"%+*"-9'(%%;'
QCD&RQGFEIDPQG&DBF&FKCQCOHK&KEHIHIo&ECCD\& )4=)*()<"'%.'(3"'&)-;"(':,'-"L*)*$5*<'(3"5-'3%&"9')(')'35<3"-'
,CFI& DBF& _PRTD& THF& YHDB& _CEOFE& XEFIHGFQD& !RIBd& 3CEOFE& 8-5$"/' D)*,' 1&"-5$)*9' $%7#4' *%+' &);"' )' #5=5*<' :7,5*<' )*4'
3FGFEPT& "FIFENF& KBPHEOPQ& -TPQ& :EFFQIXPQd& 2E& *PTT& 'DEFFD& 9"##5*<'3%79"9'.%-'8-%L(M')#9%';*%+*')9'ds5885*</e
/(2Id& 'BCRTG& DBF& LTPOF& _PTT& CQ& HQNFIDCEI@& OCEDSPSF&
KCOXPQHFI@& CE& FNFQ& DBF& PNFEPSF& -OFEHKPQd& 4C& SFD& DC& DBF& 1#%*"M':)*;9'454'*%('3)="'$)85()#'(%'L*)*$"')##'%.'(3"5-' $#5"*(9N'
LCgCO&C_&DBHI&KEHIHI@&YF&DEPKF&HDI&ECCDI&DC&DBF&LFSHQQHQS&C_&DBF& 3%&"9/' F3",' 9%#4' 9%&"' %.' (3"' &%-(<)<"9' (%' <%="-*&"*(0
BCRIHQS&LCCO\ 98%*9%-"4' "*("-8-59"9' #5;"' @)**5"' D)"')*4' @-"445"'D)$M'+3%'
$%*9"U7"*(#,':%7<3('fW'8"-$"*('%.'-"954"*?)#'&%-(<)<"9'.-%&'

45(&-9("$/-%&,"(-9 (3"':)*;9/'g%-&)##,M'@)**5"'D)"' )*4' @-"445"'D)$' +%7#4' %*#,'


:7,' &%-(<)<"9' (3)(' 3"#4' 78' (%' $"-()5*' 9()*4)-49M' :7(' (3"'
&m%2*&1=q&233un 9()*4)-49'+"-"' #%+"-"4' 47"'(%' <%="-*&"*(' 8-"997-"' (%' ;""8'
9788#,'%*'8)-' +5(3'-595*<'4"&)*4/'F359'+)9'(3"'L-9('%.')'9"-5"9'
%.'-59;,'&%="9'(3)('+%7#4'"="*(7)##,'#")4'(%'(3"'3%795*<':79(/'
! F%' ();"' )' $7"' .-%&' %7-' S)("-M' )9' !)##' B(-""(' 5*="9(%-9' :"<)*' 9("885*<' 78' (3"5-'
.%-&"-' 8-"954"*(M'+"' $)*' 87-$3)9"' %.' -59;,' 4":(M' @)**5"' D)"' )*4' @-"445"' D)$' ."#('
:#)&"' (3"' 3%795*<' :%%&' 5*$-")9"4'8-"997-"'(%'$%&8"("/
)*4' 5(9' 97:9"U7"*(' :79('
%*' >9)&)' E5*' S)4"*' )*4' F3"' 3%795*<' :%%&' $)79"4' ."-=%-' 5*' (3"' :)*;5*<' 5*479(-,/'
(3"' 5*.)&%79' B"8("&:"-' E)*;"-9' +"-"' U75$;' (%' ();"' )4=)*()<"' %.' (3"' %88%-(7*5(,M'
YYM' VWWYM' )2)$;9/' P*' #"*45*<'&%*",'(%'8"%8#"'+3%'454' *%('3)="')4"U7)("'$-"45(' (%'
) 4 4 5 ? % *' ( %' # % 9 9' % .' :7,')'3%&"' :)9"4' %*'8-"=5%79'
1&"-5$)*N9' #5="9M' (3"' 9()*4)-49/' F3"9"' 97:8-5&"'
1&"-5$)*' "$%*%&,'(%%;')' &%-(<)<"9' +"-"' &%9(' 8%87#)-'
!
3")=,' :#%+' (3)(' 4),/' A*4"-' (3"*0$3)5-&)*' k-""*98)*M' (3"' 5*' *%*"' %(3"-' (3)*' %7-' %+*'
@"4"-)#' K"9"-="' #%)*"4' %7(' :5##5%*9' %.' 4%##)-9' (%' L*)*$"' B()("' %.' C)#5.%-*5)/' B%%*M'
$%&8)*5"9' )*4' $7(' (3"' 5*("-"9(' -)("' .-%&' c/f' 8"-$"*(' (%' Y' "*?-"' $%&8)*5"9' 98-7*<' 78'
8"-$"*('%="-'(3"'-"&)5*4"-'%.'VWWY/'F359'5*s7T'%.'&%*",' %="-*5<3(' 4"=%("4' (%' #"*45*<'
5*(%' (3"' L*)*$5)#' 9,9("&' 454' 5(9 ' Q%:' 5*' 9)=5*<' (3"' (3"9"' 97:8-5&"' &%-(<)<"9/'E,'
"$%*%&,' .-%&' )' -"$"995%*' 5*47$"4' :,' (3"' "="*(9' %.' #"*45*<' &%*",' (%' )985-5*<'
B"8("&:"-' YY/'F3"'#%+'5*("-"9('-)("9')*4'"T$"99'$)85()#' 3%&"%+*"-9' +5(3' :)4' $-"45(M'
&)4"':%--%+5*<')'#52#"'<11'")9,/' :)*;9' -59;"4' )' $3)*$"' (3)(''
#%)*9' +%7#4' 4".)7#(/' F359'
+%7#4' -"*4"-' (3"5-' &%-(<)<"9'

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 23


+%-(3#"99/'>*"'%.'(3"'&%9('*%(%-5%79'8-)$?$"9'+)9'(3"'9()("4' 97:8-5&"' &%-(<)<"9' 3)4' :""*' 5997"4' )4Q79():#"0-)("' #%)*9'
5*$%&"'#%)*/'!3"-"'5*("-"9(' -)("')*4' $-"45('+"-"' 4"("-&5*"4' +35$3' &")*(' :)*;9' $%7#4' $3)*<"' (3"' &%-(<)<"' 5*("-"9(' -)("'
:,' (3"' 5*$%&"' $#)5&"4' :,' (3"' :%--%+"-/' B%&"' 8"%8#"' :)9"4'%*' "$%*%&5$'$%*45?%*9/'F359' 3)4' +%-;"4'%7('="-,'+"##'
"T8#%5("4' (359' 8-)$?$"':,'"T)<<"-)?*<'(3"5-' 5*$%&"9'(%' <"(')'
:"2"-'5*("-"9('-)("/

45(&/2""#>4$2%&'>"(-,'
P*' )*%(3"-' +%-#4' (359' +%7#4' 3)="' :""*' (3"' "T("*(' %.' (3"'
8-%:#"&')*4'%*#,'(3"'3%795*<'&)-;"('+%7#4'97O"-'5*'(3"'#%*<'
-7*/'K"47$5*<'9"="-5(,'%.' (3"'-"$"995%*/' A*.%-(7*)("#,M' (359' 59'
*%(' 3%+' :795*"99' 59' 4%*"' 5*' (%4),N9' <#%:)#' "$%*%&,/' !)##'
B(-""('5*="9(&"*(':)*;9':%7<3('&%-(<)<"9'.-%&':)*;'#"*4"-9M'
(3"'5*="9(&"*(' :)*;9' (3"*' 9#5$"4' (3"&' 78M'-"8)$;)<"4' (3"&M'
)*4' 9%#4'(3"&')9'9"$7-5?"9M'(3"'&%9('$%&&%*'%.' +35$3' +"-"'
$%##)("-)#5R"4'4":('%:#5<)?%*9'nCJ>9p/'F359'8-)$?$"'(7-*"4'%7('
(%' :"' )' 37<"' &59();"'
95*$"' 5*="9(%-9' +"-"'
7*)+)-"' (3)(' (3"9"'
87-8%-("4#,' d9)."e' .%-' :%--%+"-9'+3"*' &)-;"(' $%*45?%*9'+"-"'.)=%-):#"M':7(' )9'
9"$7-5?"9' (3",' +"-"' (3"'&)-;"(' 9#%+"4' (3"5-' &%-(<)<"' -)("9' 5*$-")9"4' (%' :",%*4'
: 7 , 5 * <' $ % * () 5 * " 4' +3)(' (3",'$%7#4' )O%-4/'1&"-5$)*9'85#"4'+5(3' 4":('.%7*4'(3",'
8)-(9' %.' (3"' 35<30-59;' 3)4'*%'%(3"-'$3%5$"':7('(%'4".)7#('%*'(3"5-'&%-(<)<"'#%)*9/
97:8-5&"' &%-(<)<"9/' F3"' "*?-"' 95(7)?%*' +)9' )' &"99' %.' 3544"*' #)*4&5*"9' +5(35*'
P*="9(%-9'+"-"' +5##5*<' (3"' L*)*$5)#' 9"$(%-/' E)*;9' #%)*"4' (3"5-' &%-(<)<"9' (%'
(%' :7,' (3"9"' CJ>9' 5*="9(&"*(' :)*;9' )*4' @)**5"' D)"' )*4' @-"445"' D)$/' F3"9"'
: " $ ) 7 9 "' ( 3 "' $%&8)*5"9'$7('(3"&'78')*4'9%#4'(3"&')9'9"$7-5?"9M'3545*<'(3"'
$%&8)*5"9' 5*' $3)-<"' 4)*<"-%79' 97:8-5&"' &%-(<)<"9' 5*' ")$3' 9"$7-5(,' #5;"' )'
%.' &%*5(%-5*<' (3"' -59;' #)*4&5*"/' P*="9(%-9' )*4' 3"4<"' .7*49' (3"*' :%7<3(' 78' (3"'
%.' 9"$7-5?"9' 3)4' <5="*' (3"&' 111' -)?*<9n>*"' %.' (3"' 9)."9(' 9"$7-5?"9M':"#5"=5*<'(3)(' (3",'+"-"'-"#)?="#,'9)."'(3)*;9' (%')'
-)?*<9' 8%995:#"p/' F3"' -)?*<' $%&8)*5"9' #)("-' )4&52"4' (3"5-' &59$)#$7#)?%*' :,'(3"'-)?*<')<"*$5"9/'F3"*'1Pk'5*97-"4' (3"9"'
&59();"M':7('(3"'4)&)<"'3)4':""*'4%*"/ 9"$7-5?"9M' :)9"4' %*' (3"' 9)&"' )997&8?%*' (3)(' (3",' +"-"'
d9)."/e'19'(3"'3%795*<'&)-;"('9()-("4'(%'.)5#M'5(':"<)*'(%'(-5<<"-'
F%' $%="-' (3"5-' :)9"9M' 5*="9(%-9' :%7<3(' $-"45(' 4".)7#(' 9+)89' (3"'L*)*$5)#'#)*4'&5*"9/
.-%&' 5*97-)*$"' $%&8)*5"9/' F3"9"' 5*97-)*$"' 8#)*9' $%="-"4'
&%-(<)<"' 9"$7-5?"9' 5*' $)9"' (3",' 4".)7#("4' )*4' (3",' 1('L-9(M'(3"'"O"$(9' +"-"'97:(#"a'F+%' E")-' B("-*9'3"4<"' .7*49'
-"5&:7-9"4' 5*="9(%-9' .%-' (3"5-' #%99"9/' 1Pk' +)9' %*"' %.' (3"' $%##)89"4'5*'67*"'VWWbM')*4'5*' ' 17<79(M'VWWb' (3"'#"*45*<'L-&'
$%&8)*5"9'(3)('5997"4'&)*,'%.'(3"9"'$-"45('4".)7#('9+)89/'S5;"' C%7*(-,+54"' 3)4' (%' :"' -"9$7"4' :,'E)*;'%.' 1&"-5$)' .-%&' (3"'
"="-,%*"'"#9"M'1Pk':"#5"="4'(3"'3%795*<':%%&'+%7#4' $%*?*7"' $-7935*<' +"5<3(' %.' 5(9' &%-(<)<"9' 5*' 4".)7#(/' C%*<-"99'
5*4"L*5("#,')*4'$%*954"-"4'5*97-5*<'CJ>9'(%':"')'9)."':"(/' )44-"99"4' (3"'5997"' :-5"s,/'>="-)##M'(3"-"'454' *%(' 9""&'(%' :"'
&7$3' $)79"' .%-' )#)-&`,"(/' P*' VWWjM' 5*="9(%-9' :"<)*' 9"##5*<'
P*' ")-#,' VWWiM' (3"' 3%795*<' :7::#"' 93%+"4' 9%&"' 95<*9' %.' 9(%$;' 5*' E")-' B(")-*9/' @%##%+5*<' -7&%-9' (3)(' (3"' L-&' +)9'
4"s)?%*M' )<)5*9(' "T8"-(' 4-%+*5*<'5*' (%T5$' 9"$7-5?"9w' 5(9' 9(%$;' 8-5$"'4-%88"4' (%' qcW')'
8-"45$?%*9' (3)(' 3%&"' 93)-"'.-%&'qYbY')',")-'")-#5"-/'1('(3"'5*959("*$"'%.'(3"'@"4"-)#'
!
8-5$"9' +%7#4' $%*?*7"' (%' K"9"-="M'6I'D%-<)*'C3)9"':%7<3('E")-' B(")-*9'.%-' qV')'93)-"/'
-59"/' !5(3' #"99' 4"&)*4' 5*' F3"' <%="-*&"*(' +)9' .%-$"4' (%' :7,' %7(' @-"445"' D)$' )*4'
(3"'&)-;"(M':)*;9':"<)*'(%' @)**5"'D)"'5*'%-4"-'(%';""8'(3"&')s%)(/'
-"47$"' 9788#,' %.' #%)*9'
(3"-".%-"' "*45*<' 9%&"'
#%%9"' #"*45*<' 8-)$?$"9/'
D ) * ,' - " $ 5 8 5 " * ( 9' % .' P*' ' B"8("&:"-' VWWbM' S"3&)*' E-%(3"-9M' )*%(3"-' !)##' B(-""('

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 24


! 8%5*('4-%8'5*'A/B/'J>!'6%*"9'359(%-,/'19')*'5*$-")95*<'*7&:"-'
%.' :)*;9' :7$;#"4M')'*"+'8-%<-)&'+)9'8-"9"*("4'(%' C%*<-"99/'
F3"'F-%7:#"4'199"('K"#5".'I-%<-)&' nF1KIpM'+35$3' -"U75-"4' (3"'
9)&"' qbWW' :5##5%*' %.' .7*45*<' :7(' 5*("<-)("4' (3"' %="-95<3('
-"U75-"&"*(9' C%*<-"99' 9%7<3(/' C%*<-"99' )88-%="4' (3"'
8-%<-)&M')*4'5('9""&"4'(%')997)<"'(3"'L*)*$5)#'#)*4&5*"9/

,2%o4&0(4&45(&3$%-%/$-0&
'(/42"&5-)(&45(&-00&3#%
679(' +3"*' (3"' "$%*%&,' 9""&"4' (%' 3)="' :%2%&"4' %7(M' (3"'
1&"-5$)*' )7(%' 5*479(-,' $%##)89"4/' 1#-")4,' +");"*"4' :,'
.%-"5<*' $%&8"??%*M'1&"-5$)*' $)-' $%&8)*5"9'+"-"'93)2"-"4'
45(%&45(&/,2I&5$4&45(&3-% :,' (3"' &)995="' 4-%8' 5*' $%*97&"-' 98"*45*<'8-%&8("4' :,' (3"'
-"$"995%*/' C3-,9#"-' )*4' k"*"-)#' D%(%-9' nkDp' CZ>9' 9(%%4'
:".%-"' C%*<-"99' )*4' 7-<"*(#,' -"U7"9("4' 3"#8/' I-"954"*('
P*' ' B"8("&:"-' VWWbM' S"3&)*' E-%(3"-9M' )*%(3"-' !)##' B(-""('
>:)&)' .%-$"4' kD' )*4' C3-,9#"-' (%' 4"$#)-"' $3)8("-' YY'
<5)*(M' 4"$#)-"4' 5(9"#.' :)*;-78(/' F3"' @"4"-)#' K"9"-="' 3)4'
:)*;-78($,' 5.' (3"' (3",' +"-"' (%' -"$%*9(-7$(' (3"&9"#="9/'
$%*954"-"4' )' :)5#%7(' :7(' 4"$#5*"4' :"$)79"' 5(' .")-"4' 8%#5?$)#'
C%*9"U7"*(#,M':%(3' $%&8)*5"9'&)4"'&)995="' $7(9' )(' (3"' $%9('
-"8"-$7995%*9/' F3"' .)##' %.' S"3&)*' E-%(3"-9' 93%$;"4' !)##'
%.'&5##5%*9'%.'1&"-5$)*'Q%:9/
B(-""(/'P*' %*#,' (+%' 4),9' #)("-M'(3"' <#%:)#' 5*97-)*$"' <5)*(' 1Pk'
+)9' %*' (3"' ="-<"' %.' :)*;-78($,/' P*' #5<3(' %.' (3"9"' &)995="'
.)5#7-"9M' )*4' (3"' .-)<5#"' 9()("' %.' 1PkM' (3"' @"4"-)#' K"9"-="' -"(&*(&45("(&A(4d
:"#5"="4' 5(' $%7#4' *%' #%*<"-' )O%-4' 5*)$?%*/'C%*9"U7"*(#,M'1Pk'
-"$"5="4' qjf' :5##5%*' 5*' ."4"-)#' :)5#%7(' &%*",M' +35$3' (3"' F3-%7<3%7(' VWWXM'(3"' A/B/'<%="-*&"*(' 98"*(' &%-"' (3)*' qYW'
>:)&)'14&5*59(-)?%*')99"-("4'+%7#4')=%54')'<#%:)#'"$%*%&5$' (-5##5%*' 4%##)-9' %*' "$%*%&5$' -"$%="-,/'Z)-#5"-' (359' ,")-M'359(%-,'
$%##)89"/'B%%*' )r"-'(3"'1Pk'4":)$#"M':)*;9':"<)*' $-)935*<':,' +)9'&)4"'(+5$"')9'E)-)$;'>:)&)'(%%;'%m$"')*4' (3"'@"4"-)#'
(3"'4%R"*/ K"9"-="' $7(' 5*("-"9(' -)("9' (%' #"99' (3)*' %*"' 8"-$"*()<"' 8%5*('
' ):%="'R"-%/'F3"'>:)&)'14&5*59(-)?%*')2"&8("4' &)*,'?&"9'
(%' -"9$7"' (3"' "$%*%&,M' %*"' %.' 5(9' &%9(' 8-%*%7*$"4' "O%-(9'
! :"5*<' (3"' 1&"-5$)*' K"$%="-,' )*4' P*="9(&"*(' 1$(' %.' VWWXM'
+35$3')7(3%-5R"4'5*$-")9"4'98"*45*<'%*'-"9$75*<''&%9(#,'#)-<"'
L*)*$5)#' L-&9/' E7(' (3"' 5*$-")95*<' *7&:"-' %})*;9' 4""&"4'
d(-%7:#"4e'%-'*")-' :)*;-78($,':,'(3"'A/B/'(-")97-,'9""&"4' (%'
5*$-")9"' "="-,'4),a' VfV' (3"' .%7-(3' U7)-("-' %.' VWWj' )*4' cWf'
)*4'hYi' 5*'(3"'L-9(')*4'9"$%*4'U7)-("-9'%.'VWWXM'-"98"$?="#,/''
1&"-5$)*9'+"-"' .7-(3"-' 9;"8?$)#' (3"5-' ()T' 4%##)-9' +"-"' :"5*<'
79"4' "O"$?="#,' )*4' "m$5"*(#,' +3"*' -"8%-(9' +"-"' -"#")9"4'
-"=")#5*<' (3)(' 1Pk' 3)4' 8)54' qYif' &5##5%*' 5*' :%*79"9' (%'
"T"$7?="9' ' n5*$#745*<' (3%9"' (3)(' 3)4' $%*(-5:7("4' (%' (3"'
$%&8)*,N9'4%+*.)##p/'E)*;'d9(-"99'("9(9e'$%*47$("4':,'(3"'A/B/'
F-")97-,' -"=")#"4' (3)(' (3"' &)Q%-5(,' %.' :)*;9' 9?##' *""4"4'
<%="-*&"*(')54'(%'97-=5="'(3"'-"$"995%*/'

J7-5*<' 97&&"-' VWWXM' (35*<9':"<)*' (%' 5&8-%="/' F3"' ):,9&)#'


3%795*<' &)-;"(' :%2%&"4' %7(' )*4' :"<)*' (%' 93%+' 95<*9' %.'
-"$%="-,/'F3"'J%+' 6%*"9'P*479(-5)#' 1="-)<"'35(' YWMWWW' 8%5*(9'
@%-&"-' F-")97-,'9"$-"()-,'["*-,'I)7#9%*')*4'@"4"-)#'K"9"-="' %*' >$(%:"-' YhM' VWWXM' )*4' 5(' $%*?*7"9' (%' &%="' 78+)-4/'
$3)5-&)*' E"*' E"-*)*;"' 8-%8%9"4' )' qbWW' :5##5%*' :)5#%7(' @7-(3"-&%-"M'!)##' B(-""(' $%&8)*5"9' (3)(' +"-"' :)5#"4' %7(' :,'
8-%<-)&' :".%-"' C%*<-"99/' !3"*' C%*<-"99' -"Q"$("4' (3"' (3"'<%="-*&"*(':"#5"="'(3)('(3",'+5##'9%%*':"'):#"'(%'8),'(3"5-'
8-%8%9)#' 47"' (%' (3"' #)$;' %.' %="-95<3(' 9?87#)?%*9M' (3"' J%+' 4":(/'
6%*"9' P*479(-5)#' 1="-)<"' 8#7&&"("4' bbj' 8%5*(9M' (3"' #)-<"9('

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 25


4("9'&A2#&'52#0,&6%2*h
!(&-%&(v>("4&2%&45(&"(/(''$2%
'RLXEHOF&OCEDSPSFh&#%)*9'&)4"'(%'8-%98"$?="'3%&"%+*"-9'+5(3'5*)4"U7)("'$-"45(w'35<3'-59;'%.'
4".)7#(

-GaRIDPLTFJEPDF&OCEDSPSFh&3%&"'#%)*'+3%9"'5*("-"9('-)("'$)*'$3)*<"')('(3"':)*;N9'459$-"?%*

9CEDSPSFJLPK[FG&IFKREHUFIh'9"$7-5?"9'+3%9"'=)#7"'$)&"'.-%&'&%-(<)<"'8),&"*(9w'(3"'&%9('
$%&&%*'(,8"'+"-"'$%##)("-)#5R"4'4":('%:#5<)?%*9

/CTTPDFEPTH`FG&GFLD&CLTHSPUCQI&m/,2Ina'9"$7-5?"9'(3)('+"-"'&)4"'78'%.'45O"-"*('85"$"9'%.'
&%-(<)<"9M'9%&"'%.'+35$3'+"-"'97:8-5&"

4EHXTF&-&"PUQSh&-)?*<&<5="*'(%'9"$7-5?"9'(3)(')-"'$%*954"-"4'(%':"'9)."w'(359'-)?*<'+)9'&59();"*#,'<5="*'
(%'&%-(<)<"0:)$;"4'9"$7-5?"9

-$:h')*'1&"-5$)*'5*97-)*$"'<5)*('+5(3'<#%:)#'?"9w'(3"'>:)&)'14&5*59(-)?%*'.")-"4')'+%-#4+54"'"$%*%&5$'
&"#(4%+*'3)4'5(':""*')##%+"4'(%'.)5#

3PQQHF&9PF&PQG&3EFGGHF&9PKh&<%="-*&"*(098%*9%-"4'"*("-8-59"9'(3)(':7,'&%-(<)<"9'.-%&':)*;9w'
:"$)&"'5*$-")95*<#,'-59;05*$#5*"4'47-5*<'(3"'E793')4&5*59(-)?%*

!FPE&'DFPEQIh'!)##'B(-""('5*="9(&"*(':)*;'(3)('8#),"4'3")=5#,'5*'(3"'&%-(<)<"0:)$;"4'9"$7-5(,'"T$3)*<"w'
5(9'9(%$;'=)#7"'8#7&&"("4')r"-'(+%'%.'5(9'3"4<"'.7*49'$%##)89"4w'"="*(7)##,':%7<3(':,'6I'D%-<)*'C3)9"'E)*;

*PIBHQSDCQ&9RDRPTh'35<3#,'97$$"99.7#'$%&&"-$5)#':)*;'(3)('8)-?$58)("4'5*'(3"'97:8-5&"'&%-(<)<"'
L)9$%w':"$)&"'(3"':5<<"9(':)*;'.)5#7-"'5*'A/B/'359(%-,'47"'(%'4".)7#("4'&%-(<)<"'#%)*9w'+)9':%7<3(':,'6I'
D%-<)*'C3)9"'E)*;

-TPQ&:EFFQIXPQh'$3)5-&)*'%.'(3"'@"4"-)#'K"9"-="'.-%&'17<79('YXjb'(%'6)*7)-,'VWWi'+3%'#%+"-"4'
5*("-"9('-)("9')r"-'B"8("&:"-'YYM'VWWYM')*4'+)-*"4'):%7('3%#"9'5*'(3"'3%795*<':7::#"

!FQ&!FEQPQ[Fh'k-""*98)*N9'-"8#)$"&"*(')*4'$7--"*('$3)5-&)*'%.'(3"'@"4"-)#'K"9"-="w'(%%;'3)*490%*'
)88-%)$3'(%'&)*)<5*<'(3"'$-5959')*4'&)4"'&)*,':)5#%7(9'+5(3'(3"'@"4"-)#'K"9"-="'(3)('+"-"'*%('5*$#74"4'5*'
(3"'C%*<-"995%*)#'.7*4

BRUIN BUSINESS REVIEW 26

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi