Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ChancellorJean
Chancellor JeanleleSauvage
Sauvage/ oannes
IoannesSylvagius
Sylvagius:
Erasmus’ pprinceps
Erasmus’ rinceps christianus
christianus and
and
aa prince
prince of
of Utopia
Utopia for
for Thomas
Thomas More
More
Maarten Vermeir
University College London
* * *
****
1
CWE, vol. 3, Letter 421, 308.
2
James Tracy, The Politics of Erasmus: a Pacifist Intellectual and His Political
Milieu, U of Toronto P, 1978, 57.
272 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
3
the institutio (the education and/or institution) of a Christian Prince.
A greater political-literary honor for a politician, who was already
dead at the time and thus no longer able to arrange services or
payments in exchange for literary honors, cannot be imagined. Jean le
Sauvage is even explicitly present in one of the prefatory letters of
Utopia, in the preface written by Jean Desmarez, or Ioannes
Paludanus, to Pieter Gillis. In this letter, Paludanus calls Sauvage not
only ‘Chancellor of Burgundy’ but also ‘the one and only Maecenas or
patron of every noble pursuit (who) summons us’ (provocat hic unicus
ille rerum bonarum omnium Moecenas Ioannes Sylvagius Borgondiae
4
Cancellarius).
Unfortunately, no edited book or article on the life and
activities of Sauvage has ever been produced. Only in biographical
dictionaries and broader historical studies can we find descriptions of
his life and political achievements; the most substantial of these
5
accounts are by James D. Tracy and Silvana Seidel Menchi. With this
article, I thus intend to fill a historiographical lacuna and lift once and
for all the darkening condemnatio memoriae Sauvage posthumously
fell victim to. This condemnatio had its origin with the Spanish-
Habsburg rulers who kept the Southern part of the Low Countries
under their control after the ‘Dutch Revolt’ (which affected not only
what is now the Netherlands, but also the entire Low Countries) and
the Eighty Years’ War that ripped apart the Low Countries between
1568 and 1648. The effectiveness of the condemnatio memoriae
inflicted on Sauvage by the Spanish rulers is demonstrated most
3
CWE, vol. 6, Letter 853, 54-56.
4
CW 4, 26-27.
5
Bietenholz, Peter G., Contemporaries of Erasmus: a Biographical Register of the
Renaissance and Reformation, U of Toronto P, 1985-1987, vol. 2, 325-326
(biographical note on Jean le Sauvage is written by James D. Tracy); Silvana
Seidel Menchi, ‘Iulius Exclusus‘ in Desiderius Erasmus, Opera Omnia Desiderii
Erasmi, I-8 Ordinis Primi Tomus Octavus: Iulius Exclusus, De Civilitate,
Conflictus Thaliae et Barbariei, edited by Seidel Menchi, S. Bierlaire, F. et
Hoven, R., Brill, Leiden, 2012, 44-46.
Maarten VERMEIR Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 273
clearly by the near silence of historiographers about him for the past
four hundred years.
The Spanish destroyed the funeral monument with a laudatory
epitaph for Jean le Sauvage in the Cathedral of Brussels as well as the
‘Sauvage chapel,’ where his tomb was situated, to make place for a
new chapel in 1649, thus realizing the ‘assumed last wishes’ of Infanta
Isabella, the daughter of Philip II of Spain and current Habsburg ruler
of the Southern Low Countries. The castle of Jean le Sauvage in
Sterrebeek, a village close to Brussels, and one of the lordships
Sauvage had acquired (next to Escobecque near Lille), was destroyed
shortly after the conclusion of the Eighty Years’ War. That this
happened already during peace time is clear from the fact that a
neighboring sixteenth-century castle in this ‘village of castles’ can still
be visited nowadays. Nor is there any extant portrait of Jean le
Sauvage, even though he was at his time one of the most powerful
men in the Burgundian Low Countries and even called Princeps by the
Christian humanists who had also a strong network of painters that
supported them. We can only vaguely conceive Jean le Sauvage’s
image from two miniatures showing him and his wife, Jacqueline de
Boulogne, in a ‘book of hours’ that belonged to them.
If we restore in our minds his tomb, the chapel in the cathedral
of Brussels named after him, his castle in Sterrebeek in the green
countryside around Brussels (at the time the political heart of the
Burgundian Low Countries and also a political center on a broader
European scale), we get somewhat closer to imagining the material
beauty and splendor surrounding the Chancellor and his aura during
his life time and in the later sixteenth century, when his figure
provided a strong inspiration for the political events in the Low
Countries. This material splendor corresponded to the high political
positions Jean le Sauvage filled during his life time, the most powerful
of which he occupied during his last years. The epitaph on his tomb
stone survived the destruction, and in this text Jean le Sauvage is
celebrated as President of Flanders, Chancellor of Brabant, Chancellor
of Burgundy and ‘Spain’ and as Knight of the Order of the Golden
274 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
6
Fleece, ‘integritatis erga omnes’ – ‘with integrity towards all.’ Sauvage
became a Knight of this Order in 1503 and his coat of arms shows
three silver unicorn heads on a field of azure. Among the top pieces of
The Cloisters Museum in New York is a series of tapestries about the
hunt for and capture of a magical unicorn made in the Low Countries
between 1495 and 1505. These contemporary pieces demonstrate the
great prestige and importance of this symbolic animal with strong
7
Christian connotations. ‘La Dame à la licorne’, the series of six
tapestries among the top pieces of the ‘Musée de Cluny’ in Paris, was
likewise produced around the end of the fifteenth century in the
(southern) Low Countries. After all, the Duchy of Brabant was not
only the political key region of the Low Countries, but also home to
the most specialized tapestry workshops, the majority of which could
be found in Brussels, one of the four capitals of this duchy.
However, the immaterial splendor of Jean le Sauvage’s political
achievements is even more dazzling. Archival documents still permit
us to know that Sauvage was born in Lille in January or February 1455,
the son of a family of civil servants. He obtained a license in law at
the University of Leuven in 1478, made an exceptional career as a
public servant, rose continuously into power within the political
institutions of the Burgundian Low Countries and cooperated closely
with Guillaume de Croÿ, Lord of Chièvres. From 1480, he became a
financial clerk; in 1489/1490, he entered the Council of Flanders as
Councillor; in 1492, he became Councillor-Master of the Requests and
between 1497 and 1508, he was President of the Council of Flanders,
until he exchanged this Presidency for the Presidency of the Privy
Council in 1508. In this position, he presided, until 1511, the group of
intimate political advisors of the ruler of the Burgundian Netherlands.
From 1509 until 1511, Jean le Sauvage combined this high function in
the Privy Council with the position of Chancellor of Brabant, a
position he filled from 1509 until 1514, the year before he became
6
Foppens, Jean François: Bibliotheca Belgica, Bruxelles, 1739, T.2, (32).
7
Cavallo, Adolph S., The Unicorn Tapestries at the Metropolitan Museum of Art,
Metropolitan Museum of Art Publications, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1998.
Maarten VERMEIR Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 275
The Lady and the Unicorn (La Dame à la licorne) drawn in Paris around 1500.
Musée national du Moyen Âge (former Musée de Cluny), Paris.
276 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
8
See Bietenholz, Peter G., Contemporaries of Erasmus: a Biographical Register of
the Renaissance and Reformation, U of Toronto P, 1985-1987, vol. 2, 325-326;
with this payment, the Estates of Brabant expressed unmistakably clearly their
approval of Jean le Sauvage and Guillaume de Croÿ as real ‘Governors’ behind
the 15-year-old Prince Charles. It proves a real relation of trust between the
Estates of Brabant and Jean le Sauvage and his respect for the political culture and
constitution of Brabant.
Maarten VERMEIR Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 277
9
Cf. CWE, vol. 3, Letter 436, 333-334.
10
Marcel Nauwelaerts states in the commentary of the French translation of Letter
443 that Erasmus suspected Pierre Barbier of holding back money from his
stipend. Desiderius Erasmus, La Correspondance d’Erasme, traduite et annotée
par M.A. Nauwelaerts d’après le texte latin de l’Opus epistolarum de P.S. Allen,
H.M. Allen et H.W. Garrod, UP Bruxelles, Volume II, 387; CWE, vol. 3, Letter
443, 340-341.
11
Bietenholz, Peter G., Contemporaries of Erasmus: a Biographical Register of the
Renaissance and Reformation, U of Toronto P, 1985-1987, vol. 2, 326.
278 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
12
enormously appreciated by the Chancellor. With a certain pride,
Erasmus wrote to More in March 1517, that Chancellor Sauvage had
13
‘this dialogue of Iulius and Petrus in his hands and took delight in it’.
This latter remark is one of Silvana Seidel Menchi’s key arguments for
attributing the Julius Exclusus to Erasmus, as she does conclusively in
the introduction of her edition of Julius Exclusius e Coelis as part of
the Opera Omnia Desiderii Erasmi from January 2013. In this excellent
introduction, she even states that Sauvage
became an important link in the diffusion of IE because the
codex that Erasmus sent to Brussels was one of the potential
matrices that gave origin to a wider manuscript circulation and
14
later to the first printed edition of the dialogue.
Menchi writes that Jean le Sauvage was a more powerful and more
15
accessible patron than Erasmus had ever known before. I would like
to state that Sauvage was one of the most powerful political figures in
Europe to share in theory and in practice the same Christian humanist
ideals that Erasmus and Thomas More tried to spread and realize. In
that perspective Jean le Sauvage was for Erasmus and Thomas More
what Cesare Borgia was for Machiavelli: a living image of their ideal
Prince.
It is well-known that Sauvage encouraged Erasmus to write his
Institutio Principis Christiani and Querela Pacis. Less well-known is
Sylvagius’ role in the creation and production of Utopia. When
Thomas More came to the city of Bruges for his ‘Utopian embassy’ in
the Low Countries, he was only able to travel on to Antwerp, where he
would conceive the basis for Utopia together with Pieter Gillis, due to
an interruption of the trade negotiations in Bruges between the
12
EE, II, Ep. 532, Guy Morillon to Erasmus, Brussels, 18 February 1517, ll. 21-26.
13
EE II, Ep. 543, Erasmus to Thomas More, Antwerp, 1 March 1517, ll. 9-10.
14
Silvana Seidel Menchi, ‘Iulius Exclusus‘ in Desiderius Erasmus, Opera Omnia
Desiderii Erasmi, I-8 Ordinis Primi Tomus Octavus: Iulius Exclusus, De
Civilitate, Conflictus Thaliae Et Barbariei edited by Seidel Menchi, S. Bierlaire,
F. et Hoven, R., Brill, Leiden, 2012, 45.
15
Silvana Seidel Menchi, ibid., 45.
Maarten VERMEIR Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 279
16
On May 7th 1515, Erasmus wrote from London to Gillis that Chancellor Jean le
Sauvage had held him busy for three days in Ghent while he was on his way to
London. CWE, vol. 3, Letter 332, 84-85.
17
CW 4, 18-19.
280 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
18
CW 4, 50-51.
19
EE, Ep. 524.
20
CWE, vol. 3, Letter 356, 177.
21
CWE, vol. 4, Letter 476, 95-96.
22 CW 4, 42-43.
23
CWE, vol. 4, Letter 476, 96.
Maarten VERMEIR Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 281
laugh; all the same, it is pleasant to know how the prince feels towards
24
me, or rather the chancellor, who in practice is the prince.’
When Prince Charles inherited the reign over the Spanish
kingdoms with the death of his grandfather King Ferdinand of Aragon
in 1516, he travelled to these kingdoms to fulfill his duties as entering
Prince. Jean le Sauvage and other politicians from the court of Brussels
followed Charles to Spain. On this journey, Jerome de Busleyden
would die in Bordeaux, before even reaching the Spanish peninsula.
25
As James D. Tracy has argued, Netherlandish ‘counsellors’
accompanying Charles in Spain ‘helped provoke’ through their
interventions the Revolt of the Comuneros which claimed the right for
the Spanish representative assemblies to elect their own Prince
autonomously, without the interference of foreigners. Whenever this
‘interference’ is discussed, the role of Netherlandish counsellors, and
especially the role of Jean le Sauvage, who had been Chancellor of
26
Castile since 1516, is described as tactically unwise. I would like to
disagree with this view and to present an alternative perspective on
these facts. I believe that the Chancellor willingly tried to sabotage
the enthronement of the ruler of the Burgundian Low Countries as
Prince of Castile and Aragon. After all, it was Sauvage who had
invited Erasmus to write his Institutio Principis Christiani, in which he
expresses the wish that ‘princes would eschew such dynastic unions
27
and marry within their borders.’ It was the very same Sauvage who
had made great efforts to obtain a stable peace in Europe by an
ingenious web of treaties – an arrangement that surely would be put
under great pressure and at risk through Prince Charles’ accumulation
of crowns on the European chessboard (a fear history would prove to
be correct). It was also Sauvage who had been called the one and only
Maecenas of noble pursuits in Thomas More’s Utopia, a text
presenting for the first time, under the guise of fiction, the political
24
CWE, vol. 4, Letter 475, 94.
25
Bietenholz, Peter G., Contemporaries of Erasmus: a Biographical Register of the
Renaissance and Reformation, U of Toronto P, 1985-1987, vol. 2, 326.
26
W. Blockmans, ‘De onderdanen van de keizer’ in H. Soly, Karel V 1500-1558, de
keizer en zijn tijd, Mercatorfonds, Antwerpen, 1999, 260.
27
James Tracy, The Politics of Erasmus: a Pacifist Intellectual and His Political
Milieu, U of Toronto P, 1978, 58.
282 Moreana Vol. 53, 203-204 Maarten VERMEIR
When Charles’ son, Philip II, would swear his oath to respect
the Joyous Entry of Brabant in Leuven in 1549, including the article of
resistance that Emperor Charles V had unsuccessfully tried to erase
from the Brabantine constitution and through which the Estates-
General of the United Provinces would legitimize the abjuration of
Philip II in 1581, he would pledge his oath into the hands of the
current Chancellor of Brabant who first read out the complete text of
the Joyous Entry: Engelbert van den Daele, the son-in-law of Jean le
Sauvage. Regardless of his suspicious death in Spain (already in 1518
29
there were rumors about poisoning), regardless of a cruel
condemnatio memoriae, Jean le Sauvage’s heritage lives on.
Maarten Vermeir
vermeir.arts@gmail.com
28
CWE, vol. 6, Letter 853, 54-56.
29
L’Académie Royale des Sciences, des Lettres et des Beaux-Arts de Belgique,
Biographie Nationale, Etablissements Emile Bruylant, Bruxelles, 1911-1913,
Tome 21, 441-445.