Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
RP-11 Questions Et Réponses VGR
RP-11 Questions Et Réponses VGR
OÄMLKAP AB JLK JFBRU "Q >ILOP M>OCLFP MBRQ ÅQOB NRB GB NRB
MLRO Ã> GB ABSO>F V OÄMLKAOB BK C>FP>KQ OÄCÄOBK@B À RK M>PP>DB
AB I§@OFQROB P>KP MBRQ ÅQOB >SLFO IB QBJMP AB IB SÄOFCFBO ILOP
NR>KA SLRP OBKQOBOBW @EBW SLRP SÄOFCFBW IB BQ SLVBW "Q PF GB I>F
@FQÄ FK@LOOB@QBJBKQ BE ?FBK >ILOP GBǀGB JB PRFP QOLJMÄ 'B KB
C>FP M>P BUMOÇP AB @FQBO NRF NRB @B PLFQ FK@LOOB@QBJBKQ J>FP AB
@FQBO I§@OFQROB FK@LOOB@QBJBKQ J>FP FI MBRQ >OOFSBO NRLK IB C>PPB
,K MBRQ MBRQ ÅQOB AFOB RK JLQ MLRO RK >RQOB 3LRP P>SBW @LJJB
@BPQ C>@FIB AB C>FOB Ã>
*>FP KLRP >SLKP IFKQBKQFLK ǀ KLQOB FKQBKQFLK BPQ AB IBP @FQBO
CFAÇIBJBKQ 0F GB MLRS>FP IBP MOBKAOB AFPLKP @B AFJ>K@EB BQ V
OÄMLKAOB AFJ>K@EB MOL@E>FK >ILOP G>RO>FP IB QBJMP AB OBD>OABO
QLRQ Ã> MBKA>KQ I> PBJ>FKB
*>FP ?B>R@LRM AB J>I>ABP >OOFSBKQ BQ G>F ÄQÄ SO>FJBKQ QOÇP
L@@RMÄ GB K>F M>P OÄRPPF ÀǀÀ C>FOB QLRQBP JBP SFPFQBP "Q GB JB
PRFP AFQ NR>RGLROAERF PBO>FQ IB ?LK JLJBKQ NRLK MLROO>FQ C>FOB
SBKFO @BP J>I>ABP >R 1>?BOK>@IB MLRO NRB KLRP MOFFLKP MLRO BRU
+LRP P>SLKP NRB I> MOFÇOB @E>KDB IBP @ELPBP
)> MOFÇOB C>FQ NRBINRB @ELPB MLRO KLRP "Q @BPQ M>O I> MOFÇOB
NRB GB SFP >RGLROAERF 'B SFP AB I> DO¾@B AB !FBR M>O I> MOFÇOB
"Q @B J>QFK @LJJB GB PRFP RK MBR C>QFDRÄ ÄMRFPÄ GB AÄPFOB SLP
MOFÇOBP MLRO JLF NRB SLRP MOFFBW MLRO JLF
"Q EFBO GÄQ>FP @EBW RK >JF @ÄQ>FQ RK CLVBO @EOÄQFBK LÖ
AB GBRKBP EOÄQFBKP PÄQ>FBKQ O>PPBJ?IÄP 'B IBRO M>OI>FP BQ
IÀ NRBINRB @ELPB PBPQ MOÄPBKQÄ À JLF RKB MBKPÄB BK O>MMLOQ
>SB@ƿ 'B OBD>OA>FP A>KP IBP ?LFP IBP >O?OBP F@F BQ IÀ BQ BK IBP
SLV>KQ BK QO>FK AB JLROFO G>F MBKPÄȑ e LJJB @BP >O?OBP PLKQ
?B>RU JÅJB PFIP PLKQ BK QO>FK AB JLROFO FIP PLKQ NR>KA JÅJB
?B>RU q "Q M>OCLFP RK >O?OB BPQ MIRP ?B>R ILOPNRFI BPQ BK QO>FK
AB JLROFO NRB ILOPNRFI > QLRQB P> SBOABRO BQ QLRQB P> SFDRBRO "Q
GB JB ABJ>KAB PF @B KBPQ M>P IFJ>DB NRB KLQOB -ÇOB ÄIBPQB > AB
KLQOB ÄQ>Q @>O &I > AFQȑ e-OÄ@FBRPB >RU VBRU AB I§QBOKBI BPQ I>
JLOQ AB 0BP P>FKQP q
B ALFQ SO>FJBKQ ÅQOB NRBINRB @ELPB ABǀAB QOÇP ?B>R MLRO
KLQOB -ÇOB AB OBD>OABO 0LK BKC>KQ NRF OBKQOB À I> *>FPLK >RMOÇP
AB )RF BQ NRF J>FKQFBKQ P> MLPFQFLK BK EOFPQ P> CLF BQ P>
@LKCBPPFLK 3LVBWȑ e'B PRFP P>RSÄ M>O I> DO¾@B AB !FBRƮq BQ NRF
PBK QFBKQ À @BI> 3LVBW £ IEBROB ABǀAB I> JLOQ J>IDOÄ QLRQ
KLRP J>FKQBKLKP @B NRB KLRP MOLCBPPLKPȑ KLRP PLJJBP P>RSÄP
"Q GB @OLFP NRB KLQOB -ÇOB BPQ NR&I >FJB KLQOB ?O>SLROBȑ IB
C>FQ NRB KLRP @OLVLKP BQ NRB KLRP J>FKQBKLKP KLQOB QÄJLFDK>DB
"Q FIǀFI KB P>DFQ M>P AB QÄJLFDKBO RKFNRBJBKQ NR>KA LK PB PBKQ
?FBK BK ?LKKB P>KQÄ BQ CLOQ FI P>DFQ AB IB C>FOB NR>KA LK BPQ
>?>QQR C>F?IB BQ MOÄL@@RMÄ BPQ IÀ NRB SLQOB QÄJLFDK>DB MOBKA
QLRQ PLK PBKP
"Q BK V OÄCIÄ@EFPP>KQ GB JB AFP>FP @B@Fȑ NRB I> JLOQ KBPQ M>P
OBIFÄB À I> SFB )> SFB BQ I> JLOQ KB MBRSBKQ M>P BUFPQBO BK JÅJB
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
QBJMP &I C>RQ NRB I> PÇSB NRFQQB IBP >O?OBP >S>KQ NRB I> CBRFIIB
MRFPPB JLROFO PRO I>O?OB FKPF ALK@ I> JLOQ BPQ OBIFÄB À JLK
>SFP MLRO @B NRF @LK@BOKB IÅQOB ERJ>FK I> JLOQ BPQ OBIFÄB >R
MÄ@EÄ "K BCCBQ >S>KQ NRB KLRP >VLKP IB MÄ@EÄ KLRP K>SFLKP
M>P AB JLOQ >R@RKB *>FP IÀ LÖ FI V > I> JLOQ BE ?FBK FI V > IB
MÄ@EÄ BQ IÀ LÖ FI V > IB MÄ@EÄ FI V > I> JLOQ M>O@B NRB I> JLOQ BPQ
I> @LKPÄNRBK@B AR MÄ@EÄ
"Q >ILOP @BIRF NRFƿ )¾JB NRF MÇ@EB @BPQ @BIIB NRF JLROO>
*>FP RKB CLFP NRB KLRP PLJJBP KÄP AB KLRSB>R AB I"PMOFQ AB
!FBR KLRP >SLKP I> 3FB §QBOKBIIB BQ KLRP K>SLKP >R@RK IFBK >SB@
I> JLOQ 3LVBW )> JLOQ KB MBRQ M>P @ÎQLVBO I> 3FB )> 3FB KB MBRQ
M>P @ÎQLVBO I> JLOQ
"K M>OI>KQ À EFBO A>KP I> MFÇ@B LÖ FI V >S>FQ NRBINRBP GBRKBP
EOÄQFBKP G>F AFQȑ e0F SLRP ÄQFBW F@F PRO I> OLRQB BQ NRRKB
SLFQROB ALKQ LK > MBOAR I> J>ÉQOFPB >OOFS>FQ PRO @BQQB OLRQB À
NR>QOB SFKDQȓAFU JFIIBP 8 HJ: À IEBROB SLRP PLOQFOFBW AB
I>RQLOLRQB >RPPF SFQB NRB MLPPF?IB 3LRP P>RQBOFBW PRO IB @ÎQÄ
SLRP SLRP I>FPPBOFBW DIFPPBO SLRP CBOFBW KFJMLOQB NRLF SLRP SLRP
ÎQBOFBW AR @EBJFK AB @BQQB SLFQROB q "Q @BPQ @LJJB Ã> NRRK
EOÄQFBK ABSO>FQ @LKPFAÄOBO IB MÄ@EÄ M>O@B NRB IB MÄ@EÄ BPQ OBIFÄ
À I> JLOQ "Q AÇP NRB SLRP SLVBW IB MÄ@EÄ PLRP NRBINRB CLOJB
NRB @B PLFQ P>RQBW ILFK AB Ã> ÄILFDKBW SLRP AB Ã> -BR JFJMLOQB
@B NRB SLRP ABSBW C>FOB ÄILFDKBW SLRP AB I>MM>OBK@B JÅJB AR
J>I ->O@B NRB PLRSBKBW SLRP AB @ÎQLVBO IB MÄ@EÄ @BPQ I> JLOQ
BPQ I> JÅJB @ELPB NRB AB OBPQBO IÀ BQ AB I>FPPBO @BQQB SLFQROB
SLRP OBKQOBO ABA>KP
+>QQBKABW M>P AB SLFO @B NRF S> PB M>PPBO ÎQBW SLRP AB PLK
@EBJFK )>MM>OBK@B JÅJB AR J>I CRVBW Ã> BK SFQBPPB .R>KA
SLRP SLVBW RKB QBKQ>QFLK NRF PB MLFKQB BQ IB MÄ@EÄƿ 3LRP IB
P>SBW PF @BPQ NRBINRB @ELPB AB J>I NRB I> JLOQ OÎAB >RQLRO AB
SLRP 3LVBW ILOP ÄILFDKBW SLRP AB Ã> >RPPF SFQB NRB SLRP SLRP
ÄILFDKBOFBW ARKBǀARKB SLFQROB NRF >OOFSB À NR>QOB SFKDQȓAFU
JFIIBP 8 HJ: À IEBROB 3LVBW 3LRPǀSLRP SLRAOFBW SLRP BK
ÄILFDKBO >R MIRP SFQBȑ SLRP ÎQBO AR @EBJFK P>RQBO PRO IB @ÎQÄ
SLRP I>FPPBO DIFPPBO CRFO M>O KFJMLOQB NRBI @EBJFK SLRP ÄILFDKBO
AB Ã> @BPQ QLRQ
"Q @B NRF KLRP C>FQ P>SLFO NRB KLRP >SLKP I> 3FB @BPQ
M>O@B NRB KLRP E>ÊPPLKP IB MÄ@EÄ "Q KLRP E>ÊPPLKP QBIIBJBKQ IB
MÄ@EÄ NRB P>@E>KQ NRB I> JLOQ BPQ OBIFÄB À Ã> KLRP BK CRVLKP
JÅJB I>MM>OBK@B +LRP KLRP BK ÄILFDKLKP M>O QLRP IBP JLVBKP
MLPPF?IBPȑ KLRP P>RQLKP PRO IB @ÎQÄ KLRP CRVLKP KLRP C>FPLKP
QLRQ @B NRB KLRP MLRSLKP MLRO KLRP QBKFO ILFK AR MÄ@EÄ M>O@B
NRB A>KP IB MÄ@EÄ FI V > I> JLOQ +LRP KB SLRILKP BK >R@RKB C>ÃLK
@ÎQLVBO I> JLOQ Ã> @BPQ PÔO +LRP SLRILKP KLRP QBKFO ILFK AB Ã>
!LK@ GB JB PRFP AFQ NRB @B PBO>FQ RK ?LK MBQFQ PRGBQ AB
OÄCIBUFLK ¦> JBPQ SBKR À IBPMOFQ EFBO MBKA>KQ NRB GB M>OI>FP
À @BP EOÄQFBKP GB JB PRFP AFQ NRB @B PBO>FQ ?FBK ABK C>FOB M>OQ À
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
"Q #OÇOB +BSFIIB NRF BPQ >PPFP F@F ABOOFÇOB KLQOB MOÄ@FBRU COÇOB
BQ M>PQBRO FI GB PRFP SO>FJBKQ @LKQBKQ AB IB SLFO MOLDOBPPBO A>KP IB
/LV>RJB AB !FBR GB @OLFP NRFI > C>FQ MIRP AB MOLDOÇP >R @LROP ABP
ABRU LR QOLFP ABOKFÇOBP >KKÄBP MIRP NRB QLRQBP IBP >RQOBP >KKÄBP
JFPBP BKPBJ?IB LJJB IB 0BFDKBRO I> ?ÄKFƮ 'BK PRFP SO>FJBKQ
EBROBRU
"Q GB KB IB AFP M>P NRBK C>@B GB IB AFP ABOOFÇOB PLK ALP BQ SLRP
IB P>SBW 'B @LKK>FP #OÇOB +BSFIIB ABMRFP JLK BKC>K@B 3LVBW "Q
GB P>FP NRB PF #OÇOB +BSFIIBƿ 'B @OLFP @B@F &I BPQ PRGBQ À IBOOBRO
@LJJB KLRP QLRP KLRPǀKLRP PLJJBP QLRGLROP PRGBQP À Ã> KLRP
PLJJBP QLRGLROP ABP ÅQOBP ERJ>FKP *>FP Ã> KB SFBKAO>FQ M>P AR
@RO GB KB IB @OLFP M>P &I PBO>FQ PFK@ÇOB BQ FI I> QLRGLROP ÄQÄ
PFK@ÇOB >R MIRP E>RQ MLFKQ
"Q NR>KA FI > >@@BMQÄ @B *BPP>DB GB IRF >F GB I>F C>FQ ÄIFOB M>O
RK SLQB AB IÄDIFPB @LJJB M>PQBRO F@F ILOPNRFI KB @LJMOBK>FQ
JÅJB M>P @BP @ELPBP @LJJB FI IBP @LJMOBKA J>FKQBK>KQ *>FP FI
> ÄQÄ >PPBW PFK@ÇOB MLRO SLRILFO QLRQ AÄMLPBO BU>JFKBO I> @ELPB
BQ I>?LOABO >SB@ OBPMB@Q PF ?FBK NRB GB MBKPB NRFI > RK ?LK
CLKABJBKQ PLIFAB >ILOP NR>KA FI P>S>K@B J>FKQBK>KQ FI P>FQ LÖ
FI BK BPQ IÀ
!LK@ GB PRFPǀGB PRFP QOÇP EBROBRU MLRO IB 1>?BOK>@IB ,K
JB AFQ NRB I>RQOB PLFO À I> FIP LKQ BR RKB OÄRKFLK F@F MLRO
AÄQBOJFKBO PFIP >II>FBKQ @LKPQORFOB RK KLRSB>R Q>?BOK>@IB LR
>DO>KAFO @BIRF @F IB OBKAOB MIRP PM>@FBRU BQ C>FOB ABP IL@>RU
MLRO IÄ@LIB AR AFJ>K@EB BQ IÄDIFPB > SLQÄ À IRK>KFJFQÄ
I>DO>KAFPPBJBKQ NRLK I>DO>KAFPPB AB @B @ÎQÄ NRFI PLFQ MIRP
DO>KA >GLRQBO ABP IL@>RU MLRO IÄ@LIB AR AFJ>K@EB AB J>KFÇOB
NRFI V >FQ ABP P>IIBP MLRO QLRQBP IBP @I>PPBP NRB IBP PLIP PLFBKQ
OB@LRSBOQP AB JLNRBQQB NRFI V >FQ RK OBSÅQBJBKQ BK ?LFP AB
?LRIB>R NRB QLRQ PLFQ ?FBK >OO>KDÄ BQ NRLK JBQQB AB I> MFBOOB
AB BACLOA À IBUQÄOFBRO !LK@ IÄDIFPB > SLQÄ Ã> "Q GB @OLFP NRB
IBP >O@EFQB@QBP BQ IBP >RQOBP PLKQ J>FKQBK>KQ À IRSOB !BJ>FK
FI V >RO> RKB OÄRKFLK MLRO Ã> MLRO C>FOB RKBǀRKB ÄDIFPB MIRP
DO>KAB I>DO>KAFO M>O I>OOFÇOB BQ I>OO>KDBO >RQOBJBKQ ILOP
KLRP PBOLKP OB@LKK>FPP>KQP >R 0BFDKBRO MLRO @BI>
LK BK @B NRF @LK@BOKB @BP NRBPQFLKP GBƿ &I V BK >
NRBINRBP RKBP NRB GB K>F JÅJB M>P BK@LOB OBD>OAÄBP &I S> MBRQ
ÅQOB C>IILFO NRB G>FIIB ALR@BJBKQ MLRO AÄ@EFCCOBO IBP JLQP SLFO
@B NRB @BPQ )B MOL?IÇJB @B KBPQ M>P SLQOB Ä@OFQROB @BPQ JLK
J>KNRB AFKPQOR@QFLK
-NTR BQNXNMR PTHK E@TS ÈSQD A@OSHRÇƿ BSDR L@HR
PTDKKD QÇONMRD ONTUNMR MNTR CNMMDQ @TW FDMR Ã OQNONR CD
K@TSQD A@OSÈLD 2NMS HKR R@TUÇR NT MNM 0TDM DRS HK @TRRH
CD BDTW PTH RNMS CÇBÇCÇR DS PTH MNMS I@L@HR QDÆT K@ KTLHÊQD
LK @BPQ RKBǀRKB ?LKKB NRBPQFLK LK MBOJBQQBW JLF AB
OBAFOB @B@F 3LVBW À MOLMLP AB @BP NRBPQFLKPȑ PF SLRP PF GB
KV OÄMLKAP M>P @LKCLOJÄJBKQ À @B NRB SLRP MBKPBWƿ 'B S>FP
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
!LK@ SLRP KB MLRSBW M>P SLRP P>SBW ?FBK NRB !FBR I>ǀI>
PLRO@B AB QLRQB P>DBPPB KB MLROO>FQ M>P C>FOB RKB @ELPB M>OBFIIB
&I KV > M>Pƿ &I KV > M>P IB JLFKAOB ?LK PBKP IÀ ABA>KP BK@LOB
JLFKP IFKQBIIFDBK@B AB I¨QOB PROK>QROBI &I KV > NRRKB @ELPB NRF
BPQ GRPQB @BPQ I> ->OLIB )> ->OLIB BPQ GRPQBƮ
"Q ALK@ PF IÄDIFPB @>QELIFNRB SBRQ AFOB @B J>QFKȑ e+LRP
>IILKP ÄIFJFKBO @LJMIÇQBJBKQ IB ?>MQÅJB BQ OBJMI>@BO Ã> M>O
RK JLO@B>R AB PR@OB NRB KLRP J>KDBOLKP QLRP IBP J>QFKP BPQ
@B NRB KLRP >IILKP MOBKAOB MLRO I> OÄJFPPFLK ABP MÄ@EÄPƮq >ILOP
@BPQ @B NRF ALFQ L?IFD>QLFOBJBKQ ÅQOB GRPQB MRFPNRB IÀ !FBR >
ALKKÄ @BQQB >RQLOFQÄ À IÄDIFPB
*>FP SLRP SLVBW À JLK >SFP @BPQ I> ->OLIB NRF BPQ GRPQB
M>O@B NRÀ I> CFK AB I> F?IB !FBR > AFQ @B@F A>KP 0> ->OLIBȑ
e.RF@LKNRB OBQO>K@EBO> RK PBRI *LQ AB B@F LR 6 >GLRQBO> RK
PBRI JLQ À @BIRF IÀ PBO> OBQO>K@EÄB P> M>OQ AR )FSOB AB 3FB q
!LK@ À JLK >SFP @BPQ I> ->OLIBƮ
"Q Ã> KB PBPQ G>J>FP SR A>KP I> F?IB Ã> NRBINRRK NRF > ÄQÄ
?>MQFPÄ >R KLJ eAR -ÇOB AR #FIP AR 0>FKQ "PMOFQq M>O@B NRB Ã>
KBUFPQB M>P Ã> /ÊQD KBPQ M>P RK KLJ %HKR KBPQ M>P RK KLJ BQ
2@HMS $ROQHS KBPQ M>P RK KLJ J>FP IB +LJ AR -ÇOB AR #FIP AR
0>FKQ "PMOFQ @BPQ IB 0BFDKBRO 'ÄPRP EOFPQ BPQ BU>@QBJBKQ @B
NRB IBP >MÎQOBP BQ IBP >RQOBP LKQ OB@LKKR QLRQ >R ILKD AB I¾DB
LK I> NRBPQFLK PRFS>KQB @BPQƿ §SFABJJBKQ Ã> @BPQ
?FBK @LKCLOJB À I§@OFQROB BPQ I> 3ÄOFQÄ
"Q A>KP I> F?IB NR>KA LK OBK@LKQO>FQ ABP DBKP NRF >S>FBKQ
ÄQÄ FJJBODÄP >RQOBJBKQ NR>R +LJ AB 'ÄPRP EOFPQ LK IBRO
LOALKK>FQ AB PB C>FOB OB?>MQFPBO >R +LJ AB 'ÄPRP EOFPQ >S>KQ
AB MLRSLFO OB@BSLFO IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQȑ @QBP BPQ SO>FƮ !LK@
@BPQ I> 3ÄOFQÄ @LKCLOJB À I§@OFQROB
ILOP >R@RK ÄSÅNRB >R@RK >O@EBSÅNRB >R@RK JFKFPQOB KF
MBOPLKKB A>RQOB KB MBRQ AFOB RK JLQ @LKQOB Ã> M>O@B NRB @BPQ
I> 3ÄOFQÄ 3LVBW
"Q I>RQOB GLRO À EF@>DL G>F ABJ>KAÄ ABS>KQ QOLFP @BKQP
JFKFPQOBP NRF ÄQ>FBKQ IÀ MLRO BK AÄ?>QQOB BQ MLRO JB NRBPQFLKKBO
IÀ ABPPRP GBƿ "Q IB 0BFDKBRO J>S>FQ AFQ &I J>S>FQ ALKKÄ RKB
SFPFLK BQ J>S>FQ AFQ LÖ KLRP PBOFLKP BQ @B NRFI C>II>FQ C>FOB 'B
JB PRFP QBKR ABS>KQ QOLFP @BKQP JFKFPQOBP QOFKFQ>FOBP BQ G>F AFQȑ
eLK PF @BQQB AL@QOFKB NRB GB MOÄPBKQB BPQ @>OOÄJBKQ BOOLKÄB NRB
NRBINRBP RKP ABKQOB SLRP JBPPFBROP JLKQBKQ F@F JB JLKQOBO
JLK BOOBRO >R JLVBK ABP §@OFQROBP P>KP J>KRBI 0F I> PBJBK@B
AR PBOMBKQ LR A>RQOBP @ELPBP NRB GBKPBFDKB Ã> KB QFBKQ M>P
AB?LRQ SBKBW ALK@ JB IB JLKQOBO >R JLVBK ABP §@OFQROBP q
-BOPLKKB K> OÄ>DF 3LVBW ǀ @BPQ NRB I> @ELPB KBPQ M>P C>FP>?IB
BPQ SO>F B KBPQ M>P M>O BPMOFQ AB @LKQO>AF@QFLK J>FP @BPQ
I> 3ÄOFQÄ QLRQ PFJMIBJBKQ @BPQ I> ->OLIB "Q @BPQ IÀ NRBƿ
-BOPLKKB KB MBRQ @LKQBPQBO Ã> @BPQ I> ->OLIB AB !FBR MBOPLKKB
KB MBRQ IB C>FOB 3LVBW
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
*>FP ?LKȑ e"PQ @B NRB @BRU NRF KLKQ M>Pƿq )>FPPBW JLF
IB IFOB MLRO ÅQOB PÔO NRB @BPQ ?FBK Ã> 3LVBW e£ MOLMLP ABP >RQOBP
?>MQÅJBP PLKQ FIP P>RSÄP LR KLK .RBK BPQ FI >RPPF AB @BRU NRF
PLKQ AÄ@ÄAÄP BQ NRF KLKQ G>J>FP OBÃR I> IRJFÇOBq
"E ?FBK GB @OLFPǀGB @OLFP CBOJBJBKQ NRB !FBR > >MMBIÄ 0LK
MBRMIB BQ NR&I > MOÄABPQFKÄ 0LK §DIFPB BQ QLRP @BRU NRF >II>FBKQ
ÅQOB IÀ ?>P >S>KQ I> CLKA>QFLK AR JLKAB 'B @OLFP NRB I> F?IB
BKPBFDKB @BI> "Q GB @OLFP NRB QLRQ ELJJB NRF >FJB !FBR AB QLRQ
PLK @RO @EBO@EBO> I> 3ÄOFQÄ 'BǀGBǀGB IB @OLFP GB @OLFP NRFI IB
CBO> 1LRQ ELJJB NRF >FJB !FBR IB CBO>
'B @OLFP NRB PF M>O FDKLO>K@B RK ELJJB > ÄQÄ ?>MQFPÄ AB I>
J>RS>FPB J>KFÇOB NRFI KB P>S>FQ M>P NRFI >S>FQ ÄQÄ ?>MQFPÄ AB I>
J>RS>FPB J>KFÇOBƿ LK @B@F GB KB MBRU M>P IB AFOB A>MOÇP
I§@OFQROB J>FP GB IB @OLFP A>KP JLK @RO NRRK ELJJB PFI
KB P>S>FQ M>P NRBIIB BPQ I> ?LKKB @ELPB À C>FOB BQ NRFI >S>FQ
C>FQ NRBINRB @ELPB AB PLK JFBRU GB @OLFP NRB !FBR CBOJBO>FQ IBP
VBRU IÀ ABPPRP BQ IB P>RSBO>FQ NR>KA JÅJB M>O@B NRFI K>S>FQ
M>Pƿ 0LRSBKBW SLRP AR QBJMP AB 4BPIBV AR QBJMP AB )RQEBO
MBKA>KQ I> OÄCLOJB @BP DO>KAP ELJJBP AB !FBR NRB !FBR >
ELKLOÄP BQ &I I> MOLRSÄ NR&I IBP ELKLO>FQ FIP PLKQ JLOQP A>KP I>
CLF 3LVBW >SB@ QLRQB I> )RJFÇOB NRFIP >S>FBKQ OBÃRB
"Q FI PB MBRQ NRFI V >FQ BK@LOB ABP @ELPBP NRB JLF GB @OLFP
@LJJBƿ "PQ @B NRB NRBINRRK > Ä@LRQÄ E>OIBP #RIIBO @B
J>QFK À IÄJFPPFLK e)EBROB AR OÄSBFI À I>K@FBKKB JLABq BPQ
IRK AB JBP AL@QBROP AB I> F?IB C>SLOFP MLROQ>KQ FI BPQ QOÇP QOÇP
¾DÄ BQƿ *>FP GB QOLRSB NRB @BPQ RK DO>KA AL@QBRO AB I> F?IB
"Q @B J>QFK FI > AFQ FI BKPBFDK>FQ PROǀPRO I> MOLMEÄQFB GB @OLFP FI
> AFQ NRBǀNRFI V >S>FQ AB DO>KABP @ELPBP ABS>KQ KLRP ABP @ELPBP
ALKQ IÄDIFPB KB P>S>FQ OFBK NRF PBO>FBKQ AÄSLFIÄBP >RU DBKP '>F
AFQȑ eJBKƮq À Ã> 'B @OLFP NRFI V > BK@LOB RKB DO>KAB NR>KQFQÄ AB
)RJFÇOB NRF >OOFSB J>FKQBK>KQ MLRO KLRP NRB @BIIB @F S> FKLKABO
I> QBOOB RK AB @BP GLROP MBKA>KQ RKB @LROQB MÄOFLAB MBRQ ÅQOB
I>CC>FOB AB NRBINRBP JLFP PBRIBJBKQ *>FP GB @OLFP NRRKB DO>KAB
NR>KQFQÄ AB )RJFÇOB S> >OOFSBO
'B @OLFP SO>FJBKQ NRB QLRQB MBOPLKKB PRO I> ?>PB AB P> CLF BQ
AB P> PFK@ÄOFQÄ BQ AR C>FQ NRBIIB J>O@EB A>KP QLRQB I> )RJFÇOB
NRBIIB > OBÃRB PBO> P>RSÄB
0LRSBKBW SLRP ILOP AB I> SBKRB AR 0BFDKBRO 'ÄPRP SLRP
SLRP PLRSBKBW NR&I > QOLRSÄ ABP DBKP NRF J>O@E>FBKQ A>KP QLRQB
I> )RJFÇOB NRFIP >S>FBKQ OBÃRB NRF V J>O@E>FBKQ 3LRP SLRP
PLRSBKBW AB @B NRF BPQ >OOFSÄ e+BPQ @B M>P RK ELJJB ?LK
RK @BKQBKFBO OLJ>FK JÅJB FI > @LKPQORFQ KLQOB SFIIB LR RKB
PVK>DLDRB MLRO KLQOB MBRMIB BQ FI QLRQBP @BP @ELPBP NRFI >S>FQ
C>FQBP FI JÄOFQB @BQQB ?ÄKÄAF@QFLK NRLK ABJ>KAB MLRO IRF q 3LRP
SLVBW !FBR BPQ RK -ÇOB @LJMOÄEBKPFC &I @LKK>ÉQ SLQOB @RO
PF SLRP SLVBW SO>FJBKQ I> )RJFÇOB LR PF SLRP KB SLVBW M>P I>
)RJFÇOB &I IB P>FQ
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
!FBR FIP PLKQ >IIÄP >R FIP LKQ OBÃR IBP ILFP BQ AB IÀ FIP LKQ @LKQFKRÄ
SBOP IB M>VP MOLJFP
"E ?FBK >SBW SLRP OBJ>ONRÄ NRB GRPQB >S>KQ NRFIP >OOFSBKQ
>R M>VP MOLJFP 3LVBW >S>KQ ABKQOBO A>KP IB M>VP MOLJFP ǀ
BK C>FQ @ÄQ>FQ RKB NRBPQFLK AB NRBINRBP GLROP PBRIBJBKQ AFU
LR LKWB GLROP MBRQ ÅQOB JLFKP M>O@B NRB @ÄQ>FQ RK QO>GBQ AB
PBRIBJBKQ NR>O>KQB BQ NRBINRBP JFIIBP 8 HJ: &IP >RO>FBKQ MR
BKQOBO GRPQB IÀ A>KP IB M>VP MOLJFP FIP >S>FBKQ QO>SBOPÄ I>ǀ
I>KKÄBǀI> @E>NRBǀ@E>NRB ÄQ>MB AR SLV>DB NRB KLRP >SLKP
M>O@LRORB &IP ÄQ>FBKQ SBKRP IÀ ?>P FIP >S>FBKQ QO>SBOPÄ I> JBO
/LRDB )>OJÄB AB -E>O>LK >S>FQ ÄQÄ BKDILRQFB ABOOFÇOB BRU
&IP >S>FBKQ ÄQÄ IF?ÄOÄP AB IBROP BKKBJFP >S>FBKQ BKQOBMOFP IBRO
QO>SBOPÄB AR AÄPBOQ BQ ÄQ>FBKQ >OOFSÄP >R ?LOA AR M>VP MOLJFP
À (>AÇP >OKÄ> BQ IÀ FIP LKQ Ä@ELRÄ -LRONRLF -LRONRLF LKQ
FIP Ä@ELRÄ
LK *LÊPB >S>FQ AFQ >RU AFU QOF?RP FI >S>FQ AFQ eNRFI >II>FQ
BKSLVBO RK ELJJB AB @E>NRB QOF?R OBMOÄPBKQ>KQ @E>NRB QOF?R
MLRO >IIBO BUMILOBO IB M>VP SLFO A>KP NRBI ÄQ>Q FI ÄQ>FQq
,O SLFIÀ ?FBK MOÄ@FPÄJBKQ IB MLFKQ LÖ IÀ LÖ SLRP BK ÅQBP @B
J>QFK LÖ SLRP SLRP BK ÅQBP >OOFSÄP >RGLROAERF 3LRPƿ )ÄDIFPB
BPQ M>PPÄB M>O I> GRPQFCF@>QFLK >SB@ )RQEBO M>O I> P>K@QFCF@>QFLK
>SB@ IBP JÄQELAFPQBP BQ J>FKQBK>KQ BIIB BPQ >OOFSÄB >R QBJMP AB
I> MOLJBPPB )> MOLJBPPB @BPQ IB ?>MQÅJB AB I"PMOFQ NRF BPQ
MOLJFP ARK ?LRQ À I>RQOB AB IK@FBK 1BPQ>JBKQ BQ >RPPF AR
+LRSB>R 3LVBW I> MOLJBPPBȑ e3LF@F 'BKSBOO>F PRO SLRP @B
NRB *LK -ÇOB > MOLJFP q BPQ @B NRB -FBOOB > AFQ IB GLRO AB I>
-BKQB@ÎQB
BPQ Ã> I> MOLJBPPB )B M>VP MOLJFP @BPQ AB SFSOB A>KP @B
M>VP AR 0>FKQ "PMOFQ BPQ Ã> I> MOLJBPPB AB !FBR MLRO IÄDIFPBȑ
SFSOB A>KP I> MRFPP>K@B AB I"PMOFQ BPQ RK >RQOB JLKAB @BPQ RK
>RQOB M>VP &I C>RQ NRB SLRP PLOQFBW AB @BQ ÄQ>Q A>KP IBNRBI SLRP
>SBW ÄQÄ NRB SLRP PLOQFBW MLRO SFSOB A>KP @B M>VP MOLJFP MLRO
OB@BSLFO I> MOLJBPPB 3LRP PLRSBKBW SLRP AB I> MOLJBPPBȑ e3LRP
OB@BSOBW I> MRFPP>K@B ABK E>RQ >MOÇP IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ PROSBK>KQ
PRO SLRPq
-FBOOB > AFQ NRB @BQQB MOLJBPPB NRF >S>FQ ÄQÄ C>FQB ARK ?LRQ
À I>RQOB AR 1BPQ>JBKQ AB IK@FBK BQ AR +LRSB>Rƿ ,KǀLK
SLFQ NRB @BQQB MOLJBPPB > ÄQÄ C>FQB QLRQ >R ILKD QLRQ >R ILKD
GRPNRÀ @B GLRO AB I> -BKQB@ÎQB BQ @BPQ IÀ NRFIP PLKQ BKQOÄP A>KP
I> MOLJBPPB
!LK@ @BP DBKP ÄQ>FBKQ PLOQFP BQ FIP >S>FBKQ SR AB DO>KAP
PFDKBP BQ ABP MOLAFDBP BK &PO>ÆI "Q IÀ FI > BKSLVÄ ABP ELJJBP MLRO
BUMILOBO RK AB @E>NRB QOF?R "Q NRBINRBP RKP ABKQOB BRU PLKQ
OBSBKRPƿ "K C>FQ NRBINRBP RKP ABKQOB BRU KLKQ M>P SLRIR
V >IIBO !BRU V PLKQ >IIÄP .R>KA FIP PLKQ OBSBKRP FIP >S>FBKQ
RKB DO>MMB AB O>FPFK NRLK K>S>FQ MR MLOQBO NRÀ ABRU ELJJBP
,O FIP K>S>FBKQ BK@LOB G>J>FP DLÔQÄ AB O>FPFK &IP ÄQ>FBKQ A>KPǀ
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
ALKKBW )> >RU ?OB?FP -BR FJMLOQB @B NRB KFJMLOQB NRF A>RQOB
MBRQ AFOB e,E FIP LKQ ?BPLFK ARK E>J?RODBOƮq +>IIBW M>P @OLFOB
Ã> 3LF@F AB NRLF FIP LKQ ?BPLFK F@F JÅJBƮ B NRFI IBRO C>RQ
@BPQ B@F 3LVBW !LKKBW IBRO B@FƮ B@F @BPQ I> +LROOFQROB
ABP ?OB?FP BPQ ¦> NRF IBP C>FQ DO>KAFO )B 0>FKQ "PMOFQ 0BP
AFOB@QFSBP 0> ->OLIB @BPQ @B@F )> ->OLIB BPQ RKB 0BJBK@B )>
PBJBK@B MOLARFQ RKB MI>KQB KLRP J>KDBLKP I> MI>KQB ,O SLFIÀ
@B NRF MOLARFQ I> MI>KQB ALKQ PB KLROOFQ IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ @BPQ
I§DIFPB &I PB KLROOFQƿ &Iǀ&Iǀ&I PB KLROOFQ AB I§DIFPB @BPQ @B
NRB IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ C>FQ &I PB OÄGLRFQ A>KP I> MOÄPBK@B AB !FBR
M>O@B NRB IBP DBKP @OLFBKQ 0> ->OLIB BQ )B I>FPPBKQ >DFO À QO>SBOP
BRU >ILOP NR&I IBRO ALKKB AB C>FOB IBP @ELPBP JÅJBP NRB !FBR >
MOLJFP NRFIP CBO>FBKQ !FBR SLFQ 0LK §DIFPB PB AÄSBILMMBO ALK@
IBP ?OB?FP PLKQ KLROOFBP BQ IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ BPQ DILOFCFÄ 3LVBW
BPQ Ã> e->FP *BP ?OB?FPƮq 1OÇP ?FBK
LK PF @B KBPQ M>P QLRQ SLRP K>ROBW NRÀ JB IB C>FOB P>SLFO
RK MBR MIRP Q>OA
%QÊQD !Q@MG@L PT@MC ID RTHR O@RRÇD C@MR K@ KHFMD CD OQHÊQD
CDQMHÊQDLDMS CDR L@HMR NHMSDR NMS ÇSÇ ONRÇDR RTQ LNH DS NM
@ OQHÇ ONTQ LNM L@QH PTH MDRS O@R R@TUÇ )@H ÇSÇ SDQQ@RRÇD
O@Q K@ OTHRR@MBD CT 2DHFMDTQLJ $RS BD TM RHFMD L@MHEDRSD
PTHK RDQ@ R@TUÇ
"E ?FBKƿ BPQ CLO@ÄJBKQ RKB CBJJB 0RO GB KBǀGB KB
MBKPB M>P NRB @ÄQ>FQ RK PFDKB J>KFCBPQB NRFI S> ÅQOB P>RSÄ ?FBK
NRB GB @OLFB NRB PF NRB !FBR Ã>ƿ 'B @OLFP NRFI PBO> P>RSÄ
@BOQ>FKBJBKQ J>FP NR>KQ À AFOBƿ e*>FKQBK>KQ MLROOFBW SLRP
AFOB NRB @BPQ &+0& !&1 )" 0"&$+"2/q &I C>RQ ÅQOB MORABKQ
>SB@ Ã> 3LVBW M>O@B NRB SLRP SLVBW @BPQ MBRQ ÅQOB IB 0>FKQ
"PMOFQ NRF SLRP ?ÄKFQ M>O@B NRB SLRP >SBW MOFP RKB MLPFQFLK
@LJJB @BIIB AB EOFPQ 3LVBW
3LRP ÅQBP SBKRB F@F MOBKAOB IB M>OQF AB SLQOB J>OF MÄ@EBRO
@LJJB EOFPQ BPQ >IIÄ À I> @OLFU MOBKAOB IB M>OQF AB IÄDIFPB
MÄ@EBOBPPB 3LRP SLVBW BPQ DO>KA @B NRB SLRP >SBW C>FQ IÀ *>FP
À SLQOB MI>@B @B NRB GB CBO>FPƿ 0F SLRP ÅQBP MOÄPBKQB @B J>QFK
PF SLRP IÅQBP SLRP NRF >SBW Ä@OFQ @BQQB NRBPQFLKȑ À SLQOB MI>@B @B
NRB GB CBO>FP GB @OLFO>FP AB QLRQ JLK @RO NRB !FBR S> IB C>FOB
3LVBW NRB !FBR S> IB C>FOB M>O@B NRB NR&I SLRP >FQ ALKKÄ
@BQQB ?ÄKÄAF@QFLK LR M>P Ã> @ÄQ>FQ NRBINRB @ELPB NRB !FBR SLRP
> ALKKÄ BK MIRP *>FP GB @OLFP NRB Ã>ǀNRB Ã> ABSO>FQ SLRP OÄGLRFO
IB C>FQ NR&I SLRP > ?ÄKFB
0F M>O BUBJMIB SLRP M>OIFBW BK I>KDRBP BQ NRFI KV >FQ M>P
AFKQBOMOÇQB A>KP IÄDIFPB BE ?FBK FI KB SLRP BPQ M>P MBOJFP
AB M>OIBO A>KP IÄDIFPB À JLFKP NRFI V >FQ IÀ NRBINRRK MLRO
FKQBOMOÄQBO IBP I>KDRBP *>FP PF SLRP M>OIBW BK I>KDRBP BQ NRFI KV
> M>P AFKQBOMOÇQBƿ "E ?FBK RQFIFPBWƿSLRPƿ ,Ö NRB SLRP
PLVBW BK MOFÇOB @EBW SLRP LR >FIIBROP M>OIBW IÀ M>O@B NRB e@BIRF
NRF M>OIB A>KP ABP I>KDRBP FK@LKKRBP PÄAFCFB IRF JÅJBq BPQ
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
MLRO IRF RK OÄ@LKCLOQ 3LVBW &I PB PBKQ ?FBK M>O@B NRFI BPQ IÀ BK
QO>FK AB MOFBO BQ QLRQ À @LRM IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ SFBKQ PRO IRF LR PRO
BIIB BQ FIP PB JBQQBKQ À M>OIBO BK I>KDRBP )BRO ¾JB EBROBRPB PB
OÄGLRFQ M>O@B NRFIPǀNRFIP LKQ M>OIÄ BK I>KDRBP 3LVBW
"E ?FBK @ÄQ>FQǀ@ÄQ>FQ @B KÄQ>FQ M>P PMÄ@F>IBJBKQ RKB
FKAF@>QFLK NRB !FBR >II>FQ BU>R@BO I> MOFÇOB NRB SLRP >SFBW C>FQB
J>FP @ÄQ>FQ RKB FKAF@>QFLK NRB IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ SLRP Ä@LRQB
BPQǀ@BPQƿ &I SLRP @LKK>ÉQ &I BPQ >SB@ SLRP "Q A>KP @B @>P @F
GB AFO>FP NRB @BPQ I> JÅJB @ELPB BPQ IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ NRF SLRP
ALKKB RKBǀRKB ?ÄKÄAF@QFLK
&I V > NRBINRB QBJMP )> ABOKFÇOB CLFP NRB G>F M>OIÄ BK
I>KDRBP PF GB JB O>MMBIIB ?FBK @ÄQ>FQ GÄQ>FPƿ &I V > BKSFOLK
ABRU LR QOLFP >KP 'ÄQ>FP A>KP I&IIFKLFP BQ FIIV BPQ SBKR JB
@EBO@EBO MLROǀMLRO >IIBO À MLRO I> IFDKB AB MOFÇOB À 7FLK FQV
'>S>FP IB @RO ILROA GB JB PRFP >DBKLRFIIÄ BQ JB PRFP JFP À MOFBO
-BKA>KQ NRB GB MOF>FP GBǀG>F BKQBKAR FIIV NRF >OOFS>FQ BQ NRF
CO>MM>FQ À I> MLOQB '>F AFQȑ eFIIV GBǀGB KB MBRU M>P V >IIBO BK
@B JLJBKQ q ILOP FI BPQ >IIÄ P>PPBLFO
"Q GB MOF>FP G>S>FP IB @RO PF ILROA NRB GBǀGB KB MLRS>FP M>P
>IIBO À IÄDIFPB @LJJB Ã> !E>?FQRAB SLRP SLVBW FI )RF >OOFSB AB
JB ALKKBO RKB SFPFLK MLRO JB JLKQOBO NRBINRB @ELPB NRF S> PB
MOLARFOB J>FP IÀ &I KB I> M>P C>FQ LJJB GB MOF>FP FKQBKPÄJBKQ
A>KP I> @E>J?OB G>F BKQBKAR NRBINRRK M>OIBO '>F >OOÅQÄ AB
MOFBO '>F Ä@LRQÄ BQ FI V >S>FQ NRBINRRK MOÇP AB I> MLOQB NRFƿ
¦> OBPPBJ?I>FQ À RKB I>KDRB ÄQO>KDÇOB À AB I>IIBJ>KA LR AR
M>QLFP KÄBOI>KA>FP LR NRBINRB @ELPB @LJJB Ã> IB AÄ?FQ ÄQ>FQ QOÇP
O>MFAB @LJJB RK JLRIFK À M>OLIBP '>F Ä@LRQÄ AB KLRSB>R BQ GB
JB PRFP AFQȑ e"E ?FBK NRBINRRK BPQ >OOFSÄ BQ FI M>OIB BK >IIBJ>KA
>R JLKPFBRO AR JLQBI MBRQ ÅQOB NRFI S> IRF OÄMLKAOB q
"Q G>F >OOÅQÄ AB MOFBO >MMRVÄ @LKQOB RKB @E>FPB @LJJB @B@F
GÄ@LRQ>FP BQ FI > @LKQFKRÄ À M>OIBO 'B JB PRFP AFQȑ e"E ?FBK GB
JB ABJ>KAB MLRONRLF MBOPLKKB KB IRF OÄMLKA q '>F Ä@LRQÄ GB JB
PRFP AFQȑ e¦> >ILOP @BPQ ?FW>OOB q
&I V >S>FQ RKB PQ>QFLK AB MBP>DB MIRP ILFK PRO I> OLRQB BQ
GBKQBKA>FP IB D>OP IÀ ?>P NRF @OF>FQȑ eIIBW VƮq SLRP P>SBW BQȑ
eS>K@BWƮq 'B JB PRFP OBQLROKÄ G>F OBD>OAÄ ABELOP A>KP @BQQB
AFOB@QFLK BQ À @B JLJBKQ IÀ G>F QLR@EÄ J> ?LR@EB '>F @LKPQ>QÄ
NRB @ÄQ>FQ JLF NRF M>OI>FP ÄQ>FQ JLF 'B PRFP OBPQÄ SO>FJBKQ
QO>KNRFIIB GB KB P>S>FP OFBK AR QLRQ 'B K>S>FP >?PLIRJBKQ
>R@RK @LKQOÎIB AB @B NRB GB AFP>FP GB KB @LJMOBK>FP OFBK AB @B
NRB GB AFP>FP OFBK 0FJMIBJBKQ GBƿ *BP IÇSOBP ?LRDB>FBKQ GB
M>OI>FP RKB PLOQB AB I>KDRB 'B PRFP OBPQÄ ?FBK QO>KNRFIIB R
?LRQ ARK JLJBKQ Ã> PBPQ >OOÅQÄ "Q NR>KA Ã> PBPQ >OOÅQÄ
LEƮȑI>ȑI>Ʈ G>RO>FP @OFÄ QBIIBJBKQ GBǀGÄQ>FP EBROBRU 'B KB P>FP M>P
MLRONRLF J>FP QLRQ @B MLFAP ÄQ>FQ M>OQF
ILOP GB PRFP >IIÄ À IÄDIFPB IÀ G>F >MMBIÄ FIIV "Q NR>KA GB
PRFP >OOFSÄ À IÄDIFPBƿ !>KP @B QBJMP IÀ @ÄQ>FQ * >UQBO NRF
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
!LK@ BIIBP IRF LKQ Ä@OFQ ABP IBQQOBP SLRP SLVBW >MOÇP NRBIIBP
PB PLKQ JFPBP À M>OIBO BK I>KDRBP BQ NRB AB DO>KAP ALKP PB
J>KFCBPQ>FBKQ >R JFIFBR ABRU "E ?FBK @BP CBJJBP LKQ MBKPÄ
NRBIIBP ABSO>FBKQ MLROPRFSOB IBRO JFKFPQÇOB
*>FKQBK>KQ PF SLRP OBJ>ONRBW SLRP NRF IFPBW A>KP SLQOB
F?IB >R SBOPBQ FI > AFQȑ
$RS BD CD BGDY UNTR PTD K@ O@QNKD CD #HDT DRS RNQSHD BQ
DRS BD AB @EBW SLRP PBRIP PTDKKD DRS SBKRB
2H PTDKPTTM BQNHS ÈSQD OQNOGÊSD NT ROHQHSTDK
PTHK QDBNMM@HRRD PTD BD PTD ID UNTR ÇBQHR DRS TM
BNLL@MCDLDMS CT 2DHFMDTQ
$S PFIƿKHFMNQD BE ?FBK PTHK KHFMNQD
!LK@ >RQOBJBKQ AFQ IBP CBJJBPƿ *>FKQBK>KQ PF SLRP
MOBKBW IB @LKQBUQB EFPQLOFNRB OBIFÄ À IÄDIFPB 3LVBW NRF
P>MMIFNRB À @BQQB ÄMÉQOBȑ @BP CBJJBP MBKP>FBKQ NRBIIBP ABS>FBKQ
MLROPRFSOB IBRO JFKFPQÇOB MRFPNRBIIBP >S>FBKQ ÄQÄ ABP AR
KLJ?OB ABP MOÅQOBPPBP AB I> AÄBPPB !F>KB !FBR KBPQ M>P RKB
CBJJB !FBR BPQ RK %LJJB "K OÄ>IFQÄ FI KV BK > NR2K PBRI
BQ @BPQ RK %LJJB )> CBJJB BPQ RK MOLARFQ AÄOFSÄ AB IELJJB
)ELJJB K> M>P ÄQÄ @OÄÄ MLRO I> CBJJB J>FP I> CBJJB MLRO
IELJJB 3LVBW 0F PBRIBJBKQ SLRP LRSOFBW I> MLOQB À SLQOB
FKQBIIFDBK@B PMFOFQRBIIB SLRP SLVBW 3LVBW
)ELJJB >R AÄM>OQ NR>KA IELJJB BPQ >MM>OR PRO QBOOB
FI ÄQ>FQ À I> CLFP J¾IB BQ CBJBIIB CÄJFKFK BQ J>P@RIFK >S>KQ
AB ABSBKFO RK ÅQOB PBURÄ 3LVBW 2K BPMOFQ CÄJFKFK IBPMOFQ
FKCÄOFBRO @BPQ @BIRF NRF BPQ QFJFAB "Q MRFP FI ÄQ>FQ >RPPF
J>P@RIFKȑ IELJJB *>FP NR>KA &I > CLOJÄ NR&I I> MI>@Ä A>KP
NRBINRB @ELPB A>RQOBƿ CFK AB MBRMIBO IB JLKAB &I > OBQFOÄ
AB IRF IBPMOFQ CÄJFKFK > MOFP RKB @ÎQB AB PLK @ÎQÄ BQ > CLOJÄ
RKB CBJJB
"IIB KB ABS>FQ M>P ALJFKBOƮ R @LJJBK@BJBKQ ILOPNRBIIB
PBPQ JFPB À C>FOB Ã> BIIB > @>RPÄ IBCCLKAOBJBKQ AB QLRQB I> O>@B
ERJ>FKB 3LVBW !B QLRQ BQ JÅJB NRB @BI> > ÄQÄƿ BPQ BIIB NRF
> @>RPÄ I> @ERQB "KPRFQB !FBR I> OBIBSÄB &I > O>JBKÄ I> 3FB A>KP
IB JLKAB DO¾@B À EOFPQ M>O I> CBJJB *>FP G>J>FP FI K> ÄQÄ
MBOJFP À I> CBJJB KRIIB M>OQ ABǀAÅQOB JFKFPQOB A>KP IÄDIFPB
-IRP ILFK A>KP && 1FJLQEÄB @E>MFQOB FI > AFQȑ e'B KB MBOJBQP
M>P À I> CBJJB ABKPBFDKBO KF AB MOBKAOB AB I>RQLOFQÄ PRO
IELJJB J>FP BIIB ALFQ ABJBROBO A>KP IB PFIBK@B q 3LRP SLVBW &I
KBPQ M>P MBOJFP À I> CBJJB AB MOÅ@EBO @BPQ SO>F
LK GB P>FP G>F SR ABP CBJJBP NRF ÄQ>FBKQ AB SO>FP
MOÄAF@>QBROP ǀ BQ BIIBP MOÅ@E>FBKQ SO>FJBKQ ?FBK >RPPF ǀ
@LJJB FJÄB *@-EBOPLK BQ ?B>R@LRM AB @BP CBJJBP IÀ *>FP
C>FQBP RK MBR >CC>FOB >SB@ BIIBP MLRO SLFO 3LVBW B KBPQ M>Pƿ
'B @LKK>FP ABP DBKP NRF MLROO>FBKQ M>OIBO BK I>KDRBP @B J>QFK
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
F@F JÅJB A>KP @BQQB ÄDIFPB 0FI KV >S>FQ M>P AFKQBOMOÇQB FIP KB
P>SFPBO>FBKQ G>J>FP AB IB C>FOB 3LVBW
&I C>RQ SLRP O>MMBIBO NRB @BP CBJJBP PLKQ KÄBP PLRP IBCCBQ
ARKB @BOQ>FKB >P@BKA>K@B @B NRF C>FQ NRBIIBPƿ 3LQOB K>FPP>K@B
> ?B>R@LRM À SLFO >SB@ Ã> BPQ NRB SLQOB KLJ SLQOB QLRQ @B NRF
SLRP @LK@BOKB SLRP SLVBW > RKB FK@FABK@B PRO SLQOB MBOPLKKB
MBR FJMLOQB @B NRB @BPQ
B J>QFK GB MLROO>FP >IIBO NRBINRB M>OQ >MMRVBO PRO I>
D¾@EBQQB ARKB >OJB À CBR BQ QRBO RK ELJJB J>FP G>J>FP GB KB
J>SFPBO>FP AB IB C>FOB ->O @LKQOB GB PRFP @>M>?IB AB IB C>FOB
>?PLIRJBKQ Ã> @BPQ PÔO 3LRP SLVBW GB MLROO>FP QRBO RK ELJJB
>RQ>KQ NRLK MBRQ QRBO RK Ä@ROBRFI J>FP LKǀLK K> M>P IB AOLFQ
AB C>FOB Ã> 3LVBW "Q IÀ @BPQ I> JÅJB @ELPB ILOP FI C>RQ SBFIIBO
À @BP @ELPBP IÀ À KB M>Pƿ B@F @B PLKQ IBP @LJJ>KABJBKQP AR
0BFDKBRO
.R>KA BIIBP LKQ Ä@OFQ IÀ ?>P BK AFP>KQȑ e"E ?FBK @BPQ IB
0>FKQ "PMOFQ NRF KLRP I> AFQƮq 3LVBW ->RI > AFQȑ e.RLF BPQ @B
AB SLRP NRB I> ->OLIB AB !FBR BPQ PLOQFB "Q BPQ @B AB @EBW SLRP
PBRIBJBKQ NR"IIB BPQ SBKRB 0F NRBINRRK M>OJF SLRP PF SLRP
>SBW ABP MOLMEÇQBP IÀ ?>P FIP OB@LKK>ÉQOLKQ NRB @B NRB JLF GB
AFP @B PLKQ IBP @LJJ>KABJBKQP AR 0BFDKBRO 3LVBW BPQ SO>FƮ
*>FP PF NRBINRRK SBRQ ÄQ>IBO PLKǀPLK PFI SBRQ PLMMLPBO PFI
SBRQ ÅQOB FDKLO>KQ BE ?FBK NRFI PLFQ FDKLO>KQ 3LVBW ILOP
I>FPPBW IB I>FPPBW IB C>FOB 3LVBW +B SLRP LMMLPBW M>P q *>FP
PLRSBKBW SLRP FI KB IRF BPQ M>P MBOJFP AB M>OIBO A>KP IÄDIFPB
"Q ALK@ @BPQ M>O @BI> NRB SLRP MLRSBW GRDBO AB SLQOB
M>PQBRO LR AB KFJMLOQB NRF A>RQOB SLFO PFI BPQ PMFOFQRBI LR
M>P 3LVBW &I > AFQȑ e0F NRBINRRK BPQ PMFOFQRBI LR MOLMEÇQB FI
OB@LKK>ÉQO> NRB @B NRB JLF GB AFP @B PLKQ IBP @LJJ>KABJBKQP
AR 0BFDKBRO q 3LVBW
BPQ MLRO @BQQB O>FPLK NRB GLOALKKB >RU DBKP AB PB C>FOB
OB?>MQFPBO >R +LJ AB 'ÄPRP EOFPQ BPQ @B NRB ->RI > C>FQ
BQ FI > AFQȑ e0F RK >KDB AR FBI SBK>FQ BKPBFDKBO >RQOB @ELPB
NRFI PLFQ >K>QEÇJB q "Q @BPQ @B NRF BPQ AÄGÀ BKPBFDKÄ F@F
>RPPF 0F NRBINRRK SFBKQƿ 0F RK >KDB SBK>FQ AR FBI AFP>KQȑ
e.RB IBP CBJJBP MOÅ@EBKQ BQ PLFBKQ MOÄAF@>QBROP LOALKKBW IBP
@LJJB JFKFPQOBPƮq I> F?IB AFQȑ e.RFI PLFQ >K>QEÇJB q )BP
@LJJ>KABJBKQP AR 0BFDKBRO @BPQ @B@F F@F
$RS BD DM NQCQD ONTQ CDR "GQÇSHDMR DS CDR "GQÇSHDMMDR CD
RDLAQ@RRDQ ,EƮ DM RD R@KT@MS
+LK JLKPFBROƮ ?PLIRJBKQ M>PƮ +LK JLKPFBROƮ "J?O>PPBW
RKB PBRIB CBJJB COÇOBȑ SLQOB CBJJB 3LVBW LR SLQOBǀSLQOB
BKC>KQ LRƿ 3LVBW
e"PQ @B BK LOAOB MLROƿq 3LVLKP PF G>F ?FBK P>FPFƮ e"PQ @B
BK LOAOB MLRO ABP EOÄQFBKP BQ ABP EOÄQFBKKBP AB PBJ?O>PPBO BK
PB P>IR>KQq
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
P>IRBO >ILOP PLVBW RK CFIP AB !FBR PBOOBW IRF I> J>FK BK AFP>KQȑ
eLKGLRO PRO q "Q NRB Ã> P>OOÅQB IÀ 3LVBW
1BKBW SLRP ILFK AB @BP @ELPBP @BPQ OÄMRDK>KQ 3LRP KB
Q>OABOBW M>P À SLRP >QQFOBO ABP BKKRFP À @>RPB AB Ã> 3LRPƿ
,E @BPQ SO>FJBKQƿ BPQ QBIIBJBKQ C>@FIB AB MÄ@EBO BQ @BPQ
QBIIBJBKQ >QQFO>KQ BQ QBIIBJBKQ >DOÄ>?IB BPQ QBIIBJBKQ C>@FIB AB
QLJ?BO IÀ ABA>KP )B JFBRU @BPQ ABS>KQ I>MM>OBK@B JÅJB AR
MÄ@EÄ QBKBW SLRP ILFKƮ /B@RIBWƮ 0LVBW RK SO>F EOÄQFBKƮ
.R>KQ >RU ELJJBP NRF PBJ?O>PPBKQ PF SLRP BJ?O>PPBW SLQOB
COÇOB PRO IB @LR PF SLRP SLRIBW IB C>FOB Ã> Ã> S> +BJ?O>PPBW
>R@RK ELJJB PRO IBP IÇSOBP PRO I> ?LR@EB LR NRBINRB @ELPB
AR DBKOB M>O@B NRB Ã>ǀÃ> @B KBPQ M>P ?FBK 3LVBW +LK Ã>ǀ
Ã> JLKQOB NR>R AÄM>OQ FI V > RK MBQFQ NRBINRB @ELPB NRF KB S>
M>P 3LVBW !LK@ QBKBW SLRP ILFK AB @B DBKOB AB @ELPB CRVBW Ã>
+BǀKB @LJJBK@BW M>P À C>FOB Ã> F@F >R 1>?BOK>@IB +LK KLRP
KB QLIÄOBOLKP M>P Ã> J>FP M>P AR QLRQ 3LVBW
3LRP PF SLRP SLRIBW SLFO SLQOB COÇOB PF SLRP SLRIBW
IBJ?O>PPBO PRO IB @LR BE ?FBK >IIBW V C>FQBP IB J>FP
KBJ?O>PPBW M>P IBP DBKP PRO I> ?LR@EB M>O@B NRB Ã> KB M>PPB
M>P Ã> @B KBPQ M>P ?FBKƮ "Q Ã> @OÄB RKB MBOSBOPFLK @BPQ QLRQ
¦> @OÄB ABP ELJLPBURBIP BQ QLRQ Ã>
"K C>FQ FI V > ABRU PBRIBP @LKPÄNRBK@BP À @B DBKOB AB @ELPB
0F SLRP @LJJBK@BW NRB SLRP I>FPPBW IBP ELJJBPƿ '>F SR LE
PLRSBKQ FIP SLKQ P>S>K@BO M>OJF IBP DBKP '>F SR ABP ÄDIFPBP LÖ
BK BKQO>KQ IB MOÄAF@>QBRO QBKA IBP ?O>P P>FPFQ @E>NRB PRO I>
PBOOB A>KP PBP ?O>P IBJ?O>PPB BQ I> C>FQ O>PPBLFO eLKGLRO PRO
>IIÄIRF>Ʈq &I QBKA IBP ?O>P MOBKA @BIIB IÀ BQ IBJ?O>PPB &I QO>SBOPB
QLRQB IÄDIFPB BK C>FP>KQ Ã> £ JLK >SFP @BPQ J>I Ã>Ʈ
.R>KA GÄQ>FP BK #FKI>KAB NRB KLRP ÄQFLKP QLRP IÀ ?>Pƿ
3LRP ÅQBP MBRQ ÅQOB >R @LRO>KQ KLRP >SFLKP ABP OÄRKFLKP BQ
GÄQ>FP >R 6 * &I KV >S>FQ M>P AB P>SLK M>P AB AÄQBODBKQP
BK #FKI>KAB 0BRIBJBKQƿ '>S>FP AR P>SLK À ?>O?B >ILOP
@E>@RK AB KLRP > AÔ PB @LKQBKQBO AB C>FOB RKB QLFIBQQB AB @E>Q
AB?LRQ SLRP P>SBW >SB@ @B P>SLK À ?>O?B ,K KBK >S>FQ NRRK
PBRI JLO@B>R BQ BK #FKI>KAB FI KV >S>FQ M>P AB P>SLK &IP PB
I>SBKQ >SB@ RKB PLOQB AB JFUQROB NRF SLRP >OO>@EB MO>QFNRBJBKQ
I> MB>R
"Q ALK@ KLRPƿ ,K KLRP > AFQ NRLK >II>FQ KLRP BJJBKBO
MOBKAOB RK P>RK> CFKI>KA>FP "Q KLRP PLJJBP >IIÄP >R 6 *
+LRP V PLJJBP >IIÄP MLRO MOBKAOB RK P>RK> BPQ @B ?>FK
CFKI>KA>FP @B ?>FK CFKI>KA>FP OÄMRQÄ 'BK >S>FP AÄGÀ MOFP BQ
@ÄQ>FQ >DOÄ>?IB *>FP GB JB PRFP AFQȑ e"E ?FBK KLRP >IILKP >Rǀ
>R 6 * >ILOP @B PBO> QOÇP ?FBK q
*>FP @LJJB GB M>OQ>FP IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ J> AFQȑ e+B C>FP
PROQLRQ M>P Ã> q ,E NRFI BPQ ?LK A>SLFO IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ e+B
C>FP PROQLRQ M>P Ã> q
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
"E ?FBK GB >RPPFQÎQ G>F AFQȑ e'B @OLFP NRB GB K>F M>P BKSFB AB
MOBKAOB RK ?>FK @B J>QFK q
)B AL@QBRO *>KKFKBK BQ IBP >RQOBP LKQ AFQȑ e,E #OÇOB
O>KE>J q FIP LKQ AFQ eLE FI V > AB DO>KABP MFÇ@BP SFQOÄBP BQq FIP
LKQ AFQ e@BPQ J>DKFCFNRB q &IP LKQ AFQȑ e B KBPQ M>Pƿq
$ÄKÄO>IBJBKQ >R JLJBKQ AB @B ?>FK LK GBQQB AB IB>R PRO
ABP MFBOOBP ?OÔI>KQBP @B NRF SLRP @LRSOB AB PRBRO BQ LK SLRP
Q>MLQB >SB@ ABP O>JB>RU AB ?LRIB>R @LJJB Ã> BKPRFQBǀBKPRFQB
SLRP @LROBW SLRP MILKDBO A>KP IB>R COLFAB )BP #FKI>KA>FP BRU
SLKQ PB OLRIBO A>KP I> KBFDB BQ A>KP I> DI>@B BQ QLRQ Ã> *>FP
?FBK PÔO FIP LKQ IE>?FQRAB @B PLKQ AB DO>KAP ELJJBP @LPQ>RAP
BQ ?>O>NRÄP "KPRFQB FIP OBSFBKKBKQ BQǀBQ BKQOBKQ AB KLRSB>R
A>KP @B ?>FK @E>RA FIP M>PPBKQ @LJJB Ã> O>MFABJBKQ AR @E>RA
>R COLFA *>FP JLF FIP JLKQ MBOJFP AB GRPQB JB QBKFO À I>FO
CO>FP >S>KQ ABKQOBO AB KLRSB>R M>O@B NRB Ã> GB KB MLRS>FP M>P
'B @O>FDK>FP NRBK IB C>FP>KQ JLK @RO P>OOÅQB GB K>S>FP M>P
IE>?FQRAB
!LK@ GBǀG>FJ>FP ?FBK Ã> J>FP .RBINRB ELPB J> AFQ AB KB
M>P MOBKAOB @BIRF AB IÀ ?>P "E ?FBK %LT>OA JLK COÇOB BQ #OÇOB
>UQBO BQ IBP >RQOBP NRF V >II>FBKQ IBP COÇOBP BQ QLRP IBP >RQOBP
SLRP P>SBW FIP @>RP>FBKQ QLRP SLRP P>SBW BK >II>KQ IÀ ?>P ILOP
IÀ GB JB PBKQ>FP ABSBKFO RK MBR KBOSBRU SLRP P>SBW M>O@B NRB IB
0>FKQ "PMOFQ >S>FQ AFQȑ e+B IB C>FP M>P q
!LK@ KLRP PLJJBP >IIÄP >R 6 * BQ BK BKQO>KQ QLRP @BP
ELJJBP NRF ÄQ>FBKQ IÀ JLKQ P>IRÄ ,E Ã> C>FP>FQ IBPǀIBP DOLP
QFQOBP A>KP IB GLROK>I I> MOBJFÇOB BQ I> ABRUFÇJB M>DBP QLRP IBP
GLROP IBP OÄRKFLKP ILOP FIP ÄQ>FBKQ IÀ
'B PRFP >IIÄ J>PPBLFO A>KP RKB MBQFQB MFÇ@B BQ BRU PLKQ QLRP
>IIÄP >R SBPQF>FOB MLRO PB AÄPE>?FIIBO "Q MBKA>KQ NRFIP ÄQ>FBKQ
IÀ BK QO>FK AB PB AÄȓƿNRFIP >II>FBKQ PB AÄPE>?FIIBO RKB GLIFB
MBQFQB #FKI>KA>FPB ?ILKAB BPQ >OOFSÄB BQ @B PLKQ AB ?O>SBP DBKP
ABP DBKP NRF PLKQ LK KB MBRQ MIRP MROP BQ AB I> MIRP E>RQB JLO>IFQÄ
)> SLFIÀ NRF >OOFSB IBP PBOSFBQQBP PRO IÄM>RIB BQ BIIB P>MMOÅQB À
BKQOBO A>KP I> MFÇ@B '>F AFQȑ e%BM EBM EBMƮ OOÅQBWƮ -PFQQƮq '>F
BPP>VÄ AB I>OOÅQBO "IIB > OBD>OAÄ SBOP JLF BQ > OF BIIB BPQ BKQOÄB
IÀ BQ BIIB > ALKKÄ À @E>@RK ABRU BQ @BP ELJJBP ÄQ>FBKQ AÄSÅQRP
RKB PBOSFBQQB BP CBJJBP @E>@RKB BPQ >OOFSÄB > MOFP RK ELJJB
I> BJJBKÄ IÀ ABA>KP BQ I> COF@QFLKKÄ @LJJB Ã> '>F SR @B NRB
IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ SLRI>FQ AFOB
"Q ALK@ NR>KA GB PRFP OBPPLOQF G>F AFQȑ e!L@QBRO *>KKFKBK q
G>F AFQ e@LJJBKQ BPQ @B MLPPF?IB 3LRP NRF ÅQBP ABP EOÄQFBKP
SLRP >IIBW IÀ MOBKAOB @BP P>RK>P >SB@ BIIBP q
e,E q FI > AFQ e@B PLKQ ABP COF@QFLKKBRPBP #OÇOB O>KE>J q
'>F AFQȑ e-BR JFJMLOQB @B NRBIIBP PLKQ BPQ J>I Ã> B
KBPQ M>P ?FBK q '>F AFQȑ e)> K>QROB BIIB JÅJB SLRP IBKPBFDKB q
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
&I > AFQȑ e*>FP #OÇOB O>KE>J AÇP IBRO BKC>K@B LK IBRO
>MMOBKA À COF@QFLKKBO BPQ @LJJB SLP FKCFOJFÇOBP BK JÄOFNRB
BQ QLRQ Ã> BIIBP @BPQ Ã> NRLK IBRO >MMOBKA q
'>F AFQȑ e-BR JFJMLOQB @B NRBIIBP PLKQ @BPQ NR>KA JÅJB
J>I ?PLIRJBKQ BPQ IÀ RK ELJJB BQ RKB CBJJB BQ FIP ALFSBKQ
ÅQOB PÄM>OÄP SÅQRP IRK ABS>KQ I>RQOB q JBK
'B KB SBRU M>P JB I>K@BO IÀ ABA>KP M>O@B NRB GB CFKFO>FP M>O
MOÅ@EBO IÀ ABPPRP KBPQ @B M>P 1OÇP ?FBK
A 2HK UNTR OK@ÌS DWOKHPTDQ BD PTDRS K@ %NH @ONRSNKHPTD
3LFIÀ RKB NRBPQFLK FI V > RKB ABRU QOLFP NRBPQFLKP +@ %NH
@ONRSNKHPTD Ã> SBRQ AFOB eI> #LF ABP >MÎQOBPq 3LFIÀ @B NRB SBRQ
AFOB I> CLF >MLPQLIFNRBȑ @BPQ NRB SLRP SLRP BK QBKBW À I> F?IB
*>FKQBK>KQ @B NRLK >MMBIIB I> CLF >MLPQLIFNRB >RGLROAERF ǀ
?B>R@LRM KB PBK QFBKKBKQ M>P À I> F?IB *>FP >MLPQLIFNRB Ã>
SBRQ AFOB I>ǀI> #LF >MLPQLIFNRB I> #LF >MLPQLIFNRB AB I> F?IB
1OÇP ?FBK
B ƿDS KD FQNTOD CD FDMR PTH RD CHRDMS
ENMC@LDMS@KHRSDR DRS BD PTD BDR CDTW FQNTODR RNMS R@TUÇR
"E ?FBK GB KB P>FP M>P 3LRP SLVBW GB KB P>RO>FP OÄMLKAOB À
Ã> ILOPȑ e"PQ @B NRB @BP DOLRMBP PLKQ P>RSÄPq 'B KB P>FP M>P
$WOKHPTDQ K@ CHEEÇQDMBD DMSQD KDROQHS DSƿ
LK IÀ @BPQ RKB >RQOB NRBPQFLK
!LK@ȑ e"PQ @B NRB @BP ABRU DOLRMBP PLKQ P>RSÄPq 'B S>FP
BPP>VBO AB SLRP MOÄPBKQBO Ã> AB C>ÃLK RK MBR MIRP O>QFLKKBIIB
QLRQ BK AFP>KQȑ e'B KB P>FP M>P 'B KBK P>FP OFBK q
*>FKQBK>KQ PLRSBKBW SLRP @B PLKQ IÀ JBP MBKPÄBP FI PB MBRQ
NRBIIBP PLFBKQ C>RPPBP *BP MBKPÄBP @BPQ NRB PF RK @>QELIFNRB
OLJ>FK LR NRF NRB @B PLFQ NRBINRRK NRF BPQ JÄQELAFPQB
MOBP?VQÄOFBK AB IÄDIFPB AR EOFPQ IRQEÄOFBK NRBI NRB PLFQ
IBKAOLFQ LÖ FI PB QOLRSB PFI @OLFQ >R 0BFDKBRO 'ÄPRP EOFPQ BQ
NRFI PB @LKCFB PQOF@QBJBKQ BK )RF MLRO PLK P>IRQ GB @OLFP NRFI
BPQ P>RSÄ
*>FP SLRP SLVBW IÄDIFPB @>QELIFNRB OLJ>FKB KB C>FQ M>P Ã>
"RU FIP @OLFBKQ NRB @BPQ IÄDIFPB NRF IBP P>RSB 3LVBW )BROǀIBRO
P>IRQ BPQ A>KP IÄDIFPB BPQ @LJJB IB MOÅQOB À NRF LK > OBQFOÄ IB
QBJMP A>KQBKKB F@F FI V > NRBINRB QBJMP MLRO >SLFO AFQȑ e&I KV >
M>P AB P>IRQ PF @B KBPQ A>KP IÄDIFPB SLRP SLVBW IÄDIFPB OLJ>FKB q
,O Ã> @BPQ C>RU )B P>IRQ PB C>FQ M>O 'ÄPRP EOFPQ BPQ SO>F ->P
M>O IÄDIFPB J>FP M>O EOFPQ
!LK@ PFI BPQ >MLPQLIFNRB LR LRF >MLPQLIFNRBP BQ
CLKA>JBKQ>IFPQBP IÀ @BPQ @B NRFIP AFPBKQ ÅQOB
LK @BPQ @LJJB @B CLKA>JBKQ>IFPQB NRF BPQ SBKR À JLF FI V
> NRBINRB QBJMP BQ NRF J> AFQ FI > AFQȑ e3LRP MBK@EBW RK MBR
MLRO IB @>ISFKFPJB KBPQ @B M>Pq
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
'>F AFQȑ e"E ?FBK Q>KQ NRB >ISFK BPQ A>KP I> F?IB GB PRFP AB
PLK >SFP q '>F AFQȑ e*LF GB PRFP AR JÅJB >SFP NRB I> F?IB @BPQ
QLRQ >ILOP MLROSR NRB >ISFK PBK QFBKKB À I> F?IB *>FP PFI
PÄ@>OQB AB I> F?IB JLF GB @LKQFKRB À >S>K@BO À @OLFOB I> F?IB q
&I > AFQȑ e"E ?FBK q FI > AFQ eGB SBRU SLRP AFOB NRBINRB @ELPB
3LRP >SBW AÄ@I>OÄ GB SLRP >F BKQBKAR AFOB NRRK ELJJB RKB CLFP
P>RSÄ KB MLRS>FQ G>J>FP ÅQOB MBOAR q
'>F AFQȑ e BPQ BU>@QBJBKQ @B NRB AFQ I§@OFQROB =&I > I> 3FB
§QBOKBIIB BQ KB SFBKAO> G>J>FP BK GRDBJBKQ LR KB PBO> G>J>FP
@LKA>JKÄ J>FP FI BPQ AÄGÀ M>PPÄ AB I> JLOQ À I> 3FB q '>F AFQȑ
e B KBPQ M>P JLF NRF I>F AFQ BPQ 'ÄPRP EOFPQ NRF I> AFQ q
&I > AFQȑ eILOP GB SBRU SLRP ABJ>KABO NRBINRB @ELPB q &I >
AFQȑ e OLVBW SLRP NRB 0>ÕI ÄQ>FQ P>RSÄq
'>F AFQȑ e)B 0>ÕI IBǀIB OLF 0>ÕIq
&I > AFQȑ e,RF q
'>F AFQȑ e*>FP ?FBK PÔOƮq
!FBR A>R@RKB J>KFÇOB &I BPQ JÅJB >IIÄ SBOP I2OFJ 1ERJJFJ
BQ PBPQ BKNRFP IÀ ?>P "Q JÅJB IBP Ä@I>FOP AB IRJFÇOB PRO I2OFJ
1ERJJFJ KLKQ M>P SLRIR IRF ALKKBO RKB OÄMLKPB "Q NRBPQ
@B NRFI > C>FQ &I > O>JMÄ BPQ >IIÄ A>KP RKB @>SBOKB LÖ FI V
>S>FQ RKB J>DF@FBKKB RKB AFPBRPB AB ?LKKB >SBKQROB "Q @BQQB
J>DF@FBKKBƿ &I PÄQ>FQ AÄDRFPÄ BK C>KQ>PPFK BQ FI BPQ >IIÄ IÀ ?>P
FI > AFQȑ e§SLNRB MLRO JLF IBPMOFQ AB 0>JRBI IB MOLMEÇQB q
"Q BIIB > AFQǀBIIB > AFQȑ eLK BE ?FBK QR P>FP @B NRB 0>ÕI >
AFQ q "IIB M>OI>FQ À 0>ÕI J>FP BIIB KB IB P>S>FQ M>P "IIB > AFQȑ
e0>ÕI > AFQ NRB QLRP @BRU NRF ÄSLNRBKQ IBP JLOQP ALFSBKQ ÅQOB JFP
À JLOQ q
&I > AFQȑ e'B QB MOLQÄDBO>F AB 0>ÕI J>FP ÄSLNRB MLRO JLF
IBPMOFQ AB 0>JRBI q
ILOP I> J>DF@FBKKB PBPQ JFPB À C>FOB PBP FK@>KQ>QFLKP BQ À RK
JLJBKQ ALKKÄ NR>KA BIIB > SR >MM>O>ÉQOB 0>JRBI PLK BPMOFQ NRF
SBK>FQ PB J>QÄOF>IFPBO ABS>KQ BRU BIIB > AFQȑ e'B SLFP ABP AFBRU
NRF JLKQBKQ AB I> QBOOB q
¦> @BPQ RK ABP OÄ@LKCLOQP /BD>OABW IB ?O>SB 0>JRBI NRF
PB QBK>FQ IÀ BI> C>FP>FQ ABRU >KP NRFI ÄQ>FQ JLOQ J>FP FI PB
QBK>FQ IÀ +LK PBRIBJBKQƿ &I PB QBK>FQ IÀ SÅQR AB PLK J>KQB>R
AB MOLMEÇQB +LK PBRIBJBKQ FI ÄQ>FQ QLRGLROP SFS>KQ J>FP FI ÄQ>FQ
QLRGLROP MOLMEÇQB IIÄIRF>Ʈ
"IIB > AFQȑ e1R J>P QOLJMÄB q R MOLȓƿ
"Q 0>ÕI > AFQȑ e0>JRBI GB KB P>FP M>P @B NRFI C>RQ C>FOB
ABJ>FK GB ALFP >IIBO >R @LJ?>Q BQ I"PMOFQ J> NRFQQÄ q &I >
AFQȑ e'B KB MBRU JÅJB M>P OB@BSLFO AR 0BFDKBRO RK PLKDB "Q
I2OFJ 1ERJJFJ KB SBRQ M>P JB M>OIBO 'B PRFP A>KP RKB QOÇP
J>RS>FPB M>PPB q
&I > AFQȑ e-RFPNRB QR BP ABSBKR RK BKKBJF AB !FBR q FI > AFQ
eMLRONRLF J>P QR C>FQ PLOQFO AB JLK OBMLPq 3LVBW BPQ @B NRB
0>JRBI > AFQ &I > AFQȑ e-LRONRLF J>P QR C>FQ PLOQFO AB JLK OBMLP
MRFPNRB QR BP ABSBKR RK BKKBJF AB !FBRq "Q IÀ FI IRF > AFQ @B NRFI
BK ÄQ>FQ &I > AFQƿ *>FP FI >II>FQ QLRQ AB JÅJB IRF >KKLK@BO I>
->OLIB AR 0BFDKBRO "Q NR>KA FI I> C>FQƿ *>FKQBK>KQ PLRSBKBW
SLRP @BI> C>FP>FQ ABRU >KP NRFI ÄQ>FQ JLOQ 3LVBW *>FP FI >
AFQȑ e'B S>FP Q>KKLK@BO I> ->OLIB q &I IRF > >KKLK@Ä I> ->OLIB
AR 0BFDKBRO &I > AFQȑ e!BJ>FK QR S>P QLJ?BO >R @LJ?>Q BQ
'LK>QE>K QLK CFIP S> QLJ?BO >SB@ QLF "Qq FI > AFQ eÀ @BQQB EBROB
ABJ>FK PLFO SLRP PBOBW >SB@ JLF q 0FI ÄQ>FQ MBOAR >ILOP 0>JRBI
IB MOLMEÇQB IÄQ>FQ >RPPF BPQ Ã> IB CLKA>JBKQ>IFPJB SLRP SLVBW
>ILOP @B NRBPQ IB MOÄQBKAR CLKA>JBKQ>IFPJB 3LVBW SLVBW &I >
AFQȑ e3LRP PBOBW >SB@ JLF ABJ>FK PLFO À @BQQB EBROB q 3LVBW
ILOP PF 0>ÕI ÄQ>FQ MBOAR 0>JRBI IÄQ>FQ >RPPF MRFPNRFIP ÄQ>FBKQ
QLRP IBP ABRU >R JÅJB BKAOLFQ
+LK KLKƮ )BP CLKA>JBKQ>IFPQBP SLRPƿIBP MOÄQBKARP
CLKA>JBKQ>IFPQBP @LJJB I> MOÄQBKARB ÄDIFPB AR EOFPQ BQ IBP
MOÄQBKARP EOÄQFBKP IB MOÄQBKAR EOFPQF>KFPJB RGLROAERF AR
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
C>FQ NRB SLRP ÅQBP JÄOF@>FK SLRP ÅQBP @BKPÄ ÅQOB EOÄQFBK ǀ AR
C>FQ NRB SLRP ÅQBPǀNRB SLRP ÅQBP JÄOF@>FK 3LVBW ¦> @BPQǀ
@BPQ AR MOÄQBKAR EOFPQF>KFPJB *>FP RK SO>F EOÄQFBK @BPQ RK
ELJJB KÄ AB KLRSB>R AB I"PMOFQ BQ RKB CBJJB KÄB AB KLRSB>R
AB I"PMOFQ ¦> @BPQ SO>FJBKQƿ )BP >RQOBP FIP FJFQBKQ J>FP IBP
SO>FP EOÄQFBKP PLKQ >MMBIÄP M>O !FBR
2HK UNTR OK@ÌS DWOKHPTDQ K@ CHEEÇQDMBD DMSQD KDROQHS DS KÁLD
LK BE ?FBK Ã> @BPQ RKB NRBPQFLK AFCCF@FIB *>FP A>?LOA
SLRP ÅQBP RK ÅQOB QOFK QLRQ @LJJB -ÇOB #FIP BQ 0>FKQ "PMOFQ -ÇOB
#FIP BQ 0>FKQ "PMOFQ PLKQ QOLFP QFQOBP PB O>MMLOQ>KQ À RKB PBRIB
-BOPLKKB @BPQ ÀȓAFOB 'ÄPRP EOFPQ "Q SLRP ÅQBP ¾JB @LOMP
BQ BPMOFQ *>FP FI C>RQ @BP QOLFP ÄIÄJBKQP MLRO @LKPQFQRBO SLQOB
MBOPLKKB 0FI KV > NRRK PBRI AB @BP ÄIÄJBKQP SLRP KÅQBP M>P
SLRP &I C>RQ IBP QOLFP ÄIÄJBKQP MLRO @LKPQFQRBO SLQOB MBOPLKKB
LJJB GB I>F AFQ I>RQOB GLROȑ e B@F @BPQ J> J>FK @B@F @BPQ
JLK ALFDQ @B@F @BPQ JLK KBW @B@F @BPQ JBP VBRU J>FP LNH
@BPQ NRFq ,NH @BIRF À NRF >MM>OQFBKQ QLRQ Ã> @BPQ NRF BPQ @B
NRF BPQ À IFKQÄOFBRO AB JLF @BPQ Ã> I>ǀIFKQBIIFDBK@B
0F @BP VBRU PF @BP J>FKP PF @B @LOMP PB QOLRS>FQ F@F
BU>@QBJBKQ QBI NRFI BPQ >RGLROAERF GBǀGB MLROO>FP NR>KA JÅJB
JLK @LOMP MLROO>FQ ÅQOB F@F J>FP LNH @B NRB GB PRFP MLROO>FQ ÅQOB
M>OQF B NRB @BIRF NRB GB PRFP À IFKQÄOFBRO AB JLF PBO>FQ M>OQF
BPQǀ@BPQ @BQQB M>OQFB IÀǀM>OQFB IÀ NRF BPQ IBPMOFQ )¾JB @BPQ
I> K>QROB AB @BQ BPMOFQ AB PLOQB NRB ILOPNRB IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ
SFBKQ PRO SLRP &I KB C>FQ OFBKƿ 3LRPƿ &I @E>KDB LR @LKSBOQFQ
SLQOB BPMOFQ BK RKB ¾JB AFCCÄOBKQB "Q @BQQB ¾JB @BPQ RKB K>QROB
AFCCÄOBKQB PRO @BQ BPMOFQ !LK@ I¾JB BPQ I> K>QROB AB SLQOB BPMOFQ
R AÄM>OQ SLRP ÄQFBW JBPNRFK J>RS>FP FI V >S>FQ AB I> E>FKB
AB I> JÄ@E>K@BQÄ BQ RK BPMOFQ AB AFPMRQB J>FKQBK>KQ SLRP ÅQBP
>CCB@QRBRU ALRU DBKQFI BQǀBQƿ 3LRP SLVBW I> AFCCÄOBK@B BPQ
SLQOB K>QROB ,K MLROO>FQ >MMBIBO JLF G>MMBIIB Ã> @LJJB Ã>
BPQ SLQOB ¾JB NRF > ÄQÄ @E>KDÄB )> SFBFIIB ¾JB BPQ JLOQB BQ
I> KLRSBIIB ¾JB NRF BPQ I> KLRSBIIB K>QROB SLRP I>SBW OBÃRB M>O
RKB K>FPP>K@B 3LVBW
3LQOB @BOSB>R KBPQ M>P SLQOB FKQBIIFDBK@B @BPQ IBPMOFQ NRF
BPQ BK SLRP NRF BPQ SLQOB FKQBIIFDBK@B 3LVBW 3LQOB @BOSB>R BPQ RK
>J>P AB J>QFÇOB BQ AB @BIIRIBP BQ QLRQ FI K> M>P AFKQBIIFDBK@B
MOLMOB 0FI BK >S>FQ RKB >ILOP Q>KQ NRFI PB QOLRSBO>FQ IÀ NRB
SLRP PLVBW JLOQ LR SFS>KQ FI CLK@QFLKKBO>FQ NR>KA JÅJB 3LVBW
*>FP @B KBPQ M>Pǀ@B KBPQ M>P SLQOB @BOSB>R @BPQ SLQOB BPMOFQ
À IFKQÄOFBRO AB SLRP "Q SLQOB ¾JB @BPQ I> K>QROB AB @BQ BPMOFQ
BPQ I¾JB AB IBPMOFQ NRF @LKQOÎIB IBPMOFQ NRF @LKQOÎIB IB @LOMP
3LVBW 3LFIÀ @BPQ Ã>
LK FI C>RQ NRB GB JB AÄMÅ@EB M>O@B NRB KLRP MOBKLKP AR
OBQ>OA LK GB MBKPB NRB Ã> GBPMÇOB NRB Ã> OÄMLKA À I> NRBPQFLK
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
%QÊQD !Q@MG@L RHK UNTR OK@ÌS DWOKHPTDQ RHK UNTR OK@ÌS
OQÇBHRDQ RH KDR EDLLDR CDUQ@HDMS SÇLNHFMDQ NT O@QKDQ DM
K@MFTDR C@MR K@RRDLAKÇD
"E ?FBK GB @OLFP NRB PF RKB CBJJB BPQ MOÄAF@>QBRO A>KP
I>PPBJ?IÄB ÅQOB MOÄAF@>QBRO Ã> FI KB IRF BPQ M>P MBOJFP AB IÅQOB
->O @LKQOB PF BIIB > IB ALK ABP I>KDRBP BQ NRBIIB M>OIB A>KP
I>PPBJ?IÄB IÀ LÖ FI V >ǀFI V > ABP MOLMEÇQBP BQǀBQ LÖ IBP ALKP
PLKQ OÄRKFP Ã> GB @OLFP NRBIIB > IB AOLFQ AB IB C>FOB "K BCCBQ
A>KP I> F?IB KLRP SLVLKP NRFI V >S>FQ ABP MOLMEÄQBPPBP @LJJB
*FOV>J BQ A>RQOBP BQ BIIBP KÄQ>FBKQ M>P BIIBP K>S>FBKQ >R@RKB
GROFAF@QFLK 0F GB MBRU >OOFSBO À J> JFKF MOÄAF@>QFLK F@F GBǀ
GFK@IRO>F Ã> 3LVBW
*>FP IBP CBJJBP PF BIIBP LKQ ABP ALKPƿ LK GB @OLFP NRB
I> J>KFÇOB @LOOB@QB NR>KA KLRP KLRP OÄRKFOLKP ?FBKQÎQ NR>KA
KLQOB ÄDIFPB PBO> RK MBR JFBRU ÄQ>?IFBƿ "QǀBQ PLFQ AFQ BK
M>PP>KQ FI V > RK KLRSB>R DOLRMB RK KLRSB>R RKB >RQOB ÄDIFPB
NRF S> PRKFO BQƿƿPB GLFKAOB À @BQQB ÄDIFPB AÇP NRB KLRP
>ROLKP AB I> MI>@B MLRO BRU F@F BQ QLRQ 2KB >RQOB ÄDIFPB S>
SBKFO PRKFO À @BQQB ÄDIFPB @B KB PBO> M>P RKB LOD>KFP>QFLK BIIB S>
PFJMIBJBKQ SBKFO À IÄDIFPB BK Q>KQ NRB @LOMP AB @OLV>KQP A>KP
RK DOLRMB "QǀBQ BRU @BPQ RK DOLRMB AB DBKP NRF LKQ ABP ALKP
"Q >ILOP NR>KA LK PB OÄRKFO> FI C>RAO> NRB @BP MBOPLKKBP
NRF LKQ ABP ALKP PB OÄRKFPPBKQ BKQOB BIIBP À @BOQ>FKP JLJBKQP
MLRO SLFO @B NRB I"PMOFQ IBRO AFO> "Q BKPRFQB @BI> MLROO> ÅQOB
ALKKÄ ABMRFP IBPQO>AB "Q IBP DBKPƿ BPQ MLRO IÄAFCF@>QFLK
AB IÄDIFPB
ILOP PF LK M>OIB BK I>KDRBP BQ NRB SLRP P>SBW MBOPLKKB
KFKQBOMOÇQB @BI>ƿ "Q IÀ NR>KA LK BPQ BK MIBFKB OÄRKFLK M>OCLFP
FI V > RK DO>KA J>KNRB AB OBPMB@Q SLRP P>SBW @BPQ @B NRLK
@LKPQ>QB M>OCLFP &I JBPQ >OOFSÄ AÅQOB BK QO>FK AB C>FOB RK
>MMBI À I>RQBI A>KP JLK >PPBJ?IÄB BQ NRB NRBINRRK PB IÇSB
BQ FKQBOOLJMB I>MMBI À I>RQBI BK M>OI>KQ BK I>KDRBP "E ?FBK
SLRP SLVBW ǀ LO FI PB MBRQ NRB @BQQB MBOPLKKB >FQ ?BI BQ ?FBK
M>OIÄ BK I>KDRBP FI PB MBRQ NRB @BI> >FQ ÄQÄ IB 0>FKQ "PMOFQ J>FP
SLRP SLVBW P>KP NRB @BQQB MBOPLKKB >FQ OBÃR IBKPBFDKBJBKQ MLRO
P>SLFO @B NRFI C>RQ C>FOB P>SLFO OBQBKFO @BI>
&I JBPQ >OOFSÄ AÅQOB >PPFP IÀ PRO IBPQO>AB À Ä@LRQBO MOÅ@EBO
RK MOÄAF@>QBRO BQ BK IB SLV>KQ >OOFSBO À RK MLFKQƿ ,E G>S>FP
QBIIBJBKQ BKSFB AB JB IBSBO MLRO >IIBO IRF ALKKBO RK @LRM AB
J>FK NRB GB KB P>S>FP MIRP NRLF C>FOB "Q SLRP >SBW C>FQ M>OBFI
QLRP KLRP C>FPLKP M>OBFI *>FP NRBPQ @B NRB @BPQ ¦> @BPQ RK
J>KNRB AB OBPMB@Q /BPQBW ?FBK >PPFP /BPMB@QBW JLK COÇOB
'>F Ä@LRQÄǀG>F Ä@LRQÄ #OÇOB +BSFIIB MOÅ@EBO BQ FI J> Ä@LRQÄ
MOÅ@EBO >ILOP NRLK P>KP ALRQB NRLKƿ #OÇOB ' 1 F@F BQ QLRP
IBP >RQOBP LR BQ QLRP IBP >RQOBP NR>KA LK PÄ@LRQB JRQRBIIBJBKQ
MOÅ@EBO LK PB AFQȑ e,E COÇOB GB @OLFP NRB GB S>FP JB IBSBO MLRO
>IIBO IRF ALKKBO RK @LRM AB J>FK q 3LVBW ,K PBKQ SO>FJBKQ
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
G>J>FP +LK SLRP KB ABSBW M>P OBMOBKAOB RKB CBJJB NRF > ÄQÄ
J>OFÄB À NRBINRRK A>RQOB
*>FKQBK>KQȑ e-LROO>FP GB OBQLROKBO SBOP BIIB NRF > ÄQÄ
J>OFÄB >S>KQ LR ALFP GBǀLR ALFP GB ÅQOB IF?OBq 3LRP ÅQBP IF?OBƮ
/BPQBW IF?OBƮ ,RF FI KB C>RQ M>P OBQLROKBO +LK JLKPFBROƮ "IIB
PBPQ J>OFÄB >SB@ NRBINRRK A>RQOB QBKBW SLRP ILFK ABIIB BPQ
SO>FƮ +Bƿ B NRF > ÄQÄ PLRFIIÄƿƿ 3LRP @LJMOBKBW 0F KLRP
>SFLKP RK MBR MIRP AB QBJMP G>FJBO>FP >MMOLCLKAFO Ã> *>FP
MLRO @B NRF BPQ AB SLQOB NRBPQFLK JLK COÇOB NRF NRB SLRP PLVBW
+LK JLKPFBROƮ +B OBQLROKBW >?PLIRJBKQ M>P SBOP @BQQB CBJJB
MLRO I> OBMOBKAOB >ILOP NRBIIB PBPQ J>OFÄB ABRU LR QOLFP CLFP
>MOÇP PÅQOB J>OFÄB >SB@ SLRP BPQ J>I
&I KV > M>P ILKDQBJMP G>F J>OFÄ RK @LRMIB NRF >S>FQ AÄGÀ ÄQÄ
J>OFÄ FIP >S>FBKQ AFSLO@Ä BQ ÄQ>FBKQ M>OQFP BQ RK @LRMIB ¾DÄ "E
?FBK @ÄQ>FBKQ #OÇOB BQ 0RO -R@HBQQ SLFIÀ NRF @ÄQ>FQ BK C>FQ &IP
K>OOFS>FBKQ M>P À PBKQBKAOB FIP LKQ BR RKB MBQFQB MOFPB AB ?B@
FIP LKQ AFSLO@Ä "IIB > SÄ@R PBRIB BQ BPQ OBPQÄB CFAÇIB SO>FJBKQ
BQ IRF FI > C>FQ M>OBFI R ?LRQ ARK @BOQ>FK QBJMP FIP LKQ SR NRB
@ÄQ>FQ OFAF@RIB AB IBRO M>OQ FIP PLKQ OBSBKRP BQ FIP AÄPFO>FBKQ ÅQOB
J>OFÄP '>F AFQȑ eFBK PÔOƮq 3LVBW e BPQ BK LOAOB @BPQ @B NRB
SLRP ABSOFBW ÅQOB q ILOP FIPƿ "K C>FQ MBKA>KQ QLRQ @B QBJMP
FIP ÄQ>FBKQ QLRGLROP J>OFÄP &IP K>S>FBKQ G>J>FP ÄQÄ AFSLO@ÄP LK
IBRO > PFJMIBJBKQ ALKKÄ IBP M>MFBOP MLRO NRFIP MRFPPBKQ SFSOB
BKPBJ?IB @LJJB J>OF BQ CBJJB @BPQ QLRQ M>O@B NRB AÇP IB
AÄM>OQ FIP ÄQ>FBKQ J>OFÄP
0TD RHFMHEHDMS KDR SQNHR KDSSQDR RTQ KD BQTBHEHW B@SGNKHPTD
3LVLKP 0TD RHFMHEHDMS KDR SQNHR KDSSQDR RTQ KD BQTBHEHW
B@SGNKHPTD
"E ?FBK GB MBKPB NRB QLRP IBP @OR@FCFU PLKQ M>OBFIP PF GB
KBƿ 'B CBO>FP JFBRU AB SÄOFCFBO *>FP FI V > & /ȓ+ & @B NRF
PFDKFCFB e'ÄPRP AB +>W>OBQE /LF ABP 'RFCPq 3LVBW 0FI P>DFQ AB
Ã> GB KB P>S>FP M>P NRFI V >S>FQ NRBINRB @ELPB AB PMÄ@F>I À M>OQ
Ã> LR NRBINRB @ELPB A>RQOB *>FP @BP IBQQOBP PFDKFCFBKQ e'ÄPRP
AB +>W>OBQE /LF ABP 'RFCPq & / + & @BPQ @B NRFI V > PRO IB
@OR@FCFU FBK
2DQ@HS BD L@K CDLOKNXDQ KDR CÌLDR ONTQ @KHLDMSDQ KD ENMCR
CD BNMRSQTBSHNM CD KÇFKHRD
LK BE ?FBK SLF@FǀSLF@F RK MLFKQ AÄIF@>Q MLRO IÄDIFPB BK @B
JLJBKQ +LK @B NRF BPQ @LOOB@Q @BPQ NRB IBP AÉJBP >FIIBKQ >R
JFKFPQOB BPQ SO>FƮ !>KP I> F?IB FIP >S>FBKQ RKB ?LÉQB NRFIP
MI>Ã>FBKQ MOÇP AB I> MLOQB ǀ A>KP IK@FBK 1BPQ>JBKQ ǀ ILOP AB I>
@LKPQOR@QFLK BQQB ?LÉQB ÄQ>FQ RK CLKAP NRB IBP DBKP >IFJBKQ>FBKQ
MLRO IBP OÄM>O>QFLKPƿ 3LRP >SBW PLRSBKQ IR Ã> A>KP IK@FBK
1BPQ>JBKQ &IP BKQOBQBK>FBKQ IBP ?¾QFJBKQP BQ QLRQ Ã> 1LRQBP IBP
OÄM>O>QFLKP BCCB@QRÄBP PRO IB ?¾QFJBKQ ÄQ>FBKQ @LRSBOQBP M>O @B
CLKAP *>FP IB AFUFÇJB AB @BI> >II>FQ IB AFUFÇJB ABP AÉJBPƿ
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
'B S>FP SLRP IB AFOB @EBO >JFȑ I> JBFIIBROB J>KFÇOB AB QOLRSBO
I> SLILKQÄ AB !FBR A>KP @BOQ>FKBP >CC>FOBP FJMLOQ>KQBP @BPQ M>O
I> MOFÇOB 3LVBW
*>FKQBK>KQ I>FPPBW JLFƿ 3LF@F RKB JBOSBFIIBRPB
MBQFQB @ELPB F@F 0F SLRPǀPFǀPF SLRP >SBW RKB >CC>FOB QOÇP
FJMLOQ>KQBƿ LK SLF@F @LJJBKQ JLF GB JV MOBKAP 'B
MOÄPBKQB Ã> >R 0BFDKBRO "Q @BPQ @B NRF > QLRGLROP C>FQ J> CLO@Bȑ
GB J>QQBKAP >R 0BFDKBRO MLRO SLFO @B NR&I AFO> "Q GB OBPQB
KBRQOB À @B PRGBQ GB KB MBK@EB KF ARK @ÎQÄ KF AB I>RQOB BQ GB AFPȑ
e*>FKQBK>KQ -ÇOB ÄIBPQB @BI>ǀ@BI> MBRQƿq
LK ?FBK PÔO A>KP JLK @>P I> MIRM>OQ AR QBJMP PF @BPQ QOÇP
FJMLOQ>KQ G>QQBKAP A>SLFO RKB SFPFLK *>FP >SB@ ?FBK ABP DBKP
!FBR KB QO>FQB M>P M>O ABP SFPFLKP ->O @LKPÄNRBKQ GB KB SLRP
@LKPBFIIBO>FP M>P AB C>FOB Ã> 3LVBW ->O@B NRB @BPQ PBRIBJBKQ
@BOQ>FKBP MBOPLKKBP NRF LKQ ABP SFPFLKP BQ IBP >RQOBP CLKQ >RQOB
@ELPB 3LRP SLRP C>FQBP >RQOB @ELPB NRB JLF GB KB MLROO>FP M>P
C>FOB MBRQ ÅQOB ǀ A>KP SLQOB J>KFÇOB AB PBOSFO IB 0BFDKBRO ǀ BQ
JLF GB C>FP NRBINRB @ELPB NRB SLRP SLRP KB MLROOFBW M>P C>FOB
3LVBW !FBR QO>FQB >SB@ KLRP AB AFCCÄOBKQBP J>KFÇOBP
!LK@ JLF PF GÄQ>FP À SLQOB MI>@B BQ NRB GB K>S>FP M>P AB
SFPFLKP AR 0BFDKBRO GB J>QQBKAO>FP PFJMIBJBKQ >R 0BFDKBRO
BK AFP>KQȑ e0BFDKBRO J>FKQBK>KQ JLKQOB JLF NRBIIB AÄ@FPFLK
MOBKAOB q "Q IÀ SLRP SLRP PBKQBW @LKARFQ À >DFO ARKB @BOQ>FKB
J>KFÇOB >QQBKABW BK@LOB RK MBR BQ >QQBKABW BK@LOB RK MBR MIRP
ILKDQBJMP BQ SLVBW A>KP NRBIIB AFOB@QFLK AB NRBI @ÎQÄ SLRP
MBK@EBW A>KP NRBIIB AFOB@QFLK I"PMOFQƿ !FQBPȑ e*>FKQBK>KQ
-ÇOB 1R P>FP NRB A>KP JLK @RO Ã> K> M>P AFJMLOQ>K@B J>FP
GBǀGB SLRAO>FP P>SLFO @B NRB 1LF 1R SBRU C>FOB À @B PRGBQ q
BPQ @LJJB Ã> NRB GB C>FP M>OCLFP MLRO IBP OÄRKFLKP 'B JB
PBKP S>DRBJBKQ @LKARFQ À >IIBO A>KP @BQQB AFOB@QFLK @F LR A>KP
@BQQB AFOB@QFLK IÀ BQ @BPQ @BQQB AFOB@QFLK IÀ NRB GB MOBKAP 3LFIÀ
I> J>KFÇOB AB C>FOB M>O@B NRB IÀ @BPQ C>FQ M>O I> MOFÇOB SLRP C>FQBP
AB SLQOB JFBRU
"Q GB @OLFP @B@F JBP >JFP @LJJB MLRO @B NRF ÄQ>FQ >OOFSÄ
À ->RI >RQOBCLFP A>KP IBǀA>KP IB +LRSB>R 1BPQ>JBKQ &I ÄQ>FQ
MOBPPÄ ABP ABRU @ÎQÄP KB P>@E>KQ A>KP NRBIIB AFOB@QFLK >IIBO
&I PBPQ BKD>DÄ PRO I> J>RS>FPB OLRQB BQ FI > OBÃR RK >MMBI
J>@ÄALKFBK !B JÅJB GB @OLFP NRB PF SLRP MOBKBW RKB AÄ@FPFLK
MLRO !FBR BQ NRB SLRP C>FQBP AB SLQOB JFBRU GB @OLFP NRB !FBR
SLRP @LOOFDBO> BQ NRB SLRP KB SBFIIBO> À @B NRB SLRP KB C>PPFBW
M>P C>RPPB OLRQB 'B @OLFP NRB @BPQ @B NRB !FBR CBO>
3LVLKP RK MBR %QÊQD !Q@MG@L PT@QQHUDQ@ SȇHK @TW FDMR
PTH RNMSRNMS BNMRHCÇQÇR BNLLD KDR UHDQFDR DMCNQLHDR
KNQRPTHKR RDQNMS ITFÇR @T ITFDLDMS
"E ?FBK I> SFBODB BKALOJFB PBO> P>RSÄB ?FBK PÔO "IIB PBO>
P>RSÄB >R GRDBJBKQ "IIB KB PBO> G>J>FP I§MLRPB J>FP BIIB C>FQ
M>OQFB ARK DOLRMB AB DBKP P>RSÄP NRF M>PPBOLKQ BK GRDBJBKQ NRF
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
BK >SLFO QLRQ MIBFK *>FP PLRSBKBW SLRPȑ e BIRF NRF BPQ BK SLRP
BPQ MIRP DO>KA NRB @BIRF NRF BPQ A>KP IB JLKAB q
0TDRS BD PTD )ÇRTR UNTK@HS CHQD C@MR ,@SSGHDT DS
0TD QDOQÇRDMSDMS KDR CNTYD O@MHDQR DS KDR RDOS O@MHDQR
0TDRSHNM ONTQ CHL@MBGD L@SHM
3LVLKP RK MBRǀSLVLKP RK MBRȑ *>QQEFBR 'B KB PRFP M>P
SO>FJBKQ PÔO IÀ 2K FKPQ>KQ NRB GB IB QOLRSBȑ *>QQEFBR BQ
BQ +LRP V SLFIÀ
«SDR UNTRDžR@MR HMSDKKHFDMBD DS MD UNTR Q@OODKDY
UNTR OKTR KDR BHMP O@HMR LR IBP BHMP LHKKD GNLLDR DS
BNLAHDM CD O@MHDQR UNTR @UDY DLONQSÇR
-H KDR RDOS O@HMR LR IBP PT@SQD LHKKD GNLLDR DS
BNLAHDM CD BNQADHKKDR UNTR @UDY DLONQSÇDR
*>FKQBK>KQ L?PBOSBW -OBKLKP GRPQB RK MBR MIRP E>RQ
"Q )ÇRTR KDTQ CHSȇ &@QCDY UNTR @UDB RNHM CT KDU@HM CDR
OG@QHRHDMR DS CDR R@CCTBÇDMR
+DR CHRBHOKDR Q@HRNMM@HDMS DM DTW LÈLDR DS CHR@HDMSȇ
"PQ @B O@QBD PTD MNTR M@UNMR O@R OQHR CD O@HMR
'ÄPRPƿ *>FKQBK>KQ L?PBOSBWƮ ƿ)ÇRTR K@X@MS
BNMMTDž &I > @>MQÄ IBROP MBKPÄBP SLRP SLVBW ƿCHSȇ
/NTQPTNH Q@HRNMMDY UNTR DM UNTR LÈLDR FDMR CD ODT CD
ENH RTQ BD PTD UNTR M@UDY O@R OQHR CD O@HMR
«SDR UNTRDžR@MR HMSDKKHFDMBD DS MD UNTR Q@OODKDY
UNTR OKTR KDR BHMP O@HMR BQ IBP BHMP LHKKD GNLLDR LR
BNLAHDM CD O@MHDQR UNTR @UDY DLONQSÇR
"UMOFJÄ BK A>RQOBP QBOJBPȑ e0F SLRP >SBW SR !FBR MLROSLFO
BQ >@@LJMIFO RK JFO>@IB >ILOP KB MBRQ &I M>P AB KLRSB>R
>@@LJMIFO RK JFO>@IBq 3LVBW 3LRP SLVBW PFƿ "UMOFJÄ BK
A>RQOBP QBOJBPȑ 0&I SLRP > P>RSÄ ARKB SFB AB MÄ@EÄ KB MBRQ
&I M>P DRÄOFO SLQOB @LOMP +B SLRP O>MMBIBW SLRP M>P NRB NR>KA
SLRP ÄQFBW MÄ@EBRO &I > ÄIBSÄ SLQOB ¾JB A>KP I> CLF MLRO NRB
SLRP @OLVFBW !B JÅJB KB MBRQ &I M>P AB KLRSB>R C>FOB NRBINRB
@ELPB AB DO>KA MLRO SLRP +B MBRQ &IǀKB MBRQ &I M>P >@@LJMIFO
@B JFO>@IB LR C>FOB KFJMLOQB NRLF MLRO SLRP )BP @FKN M>KFBOP
&I > AFQȑ e/>MMBIBW SLRP q
LJJBƿ .R>KA FIP LKQ QO>SBOPÄ I> JBO /LRDB !FBR >
LRSBOQ IB M>PP>DB BQ > C>FQ BK PLOQB NRB I> JBO /LRDB PLRSOB FIP
LKQ QO>SBOPÄ BQ BK OBPPLOQ>KQ AB I>RQOB @ÎQÄ AÇP NRFI K> MIRP
BR AB>R FIP PB PLKQ JFP À JROJROBO ->P SO>F !ÇP NRFIP PB PLKQ
OBQOLRSÄP P>KP M>FK FIP PB PLKQ JFP À @OFBOȑ e+LRP K>SLKP M>P
AB M>FK q 3LVBW &I > AFQȑ e+>SBW SLRP M>P PLKDÄ >R JFO>@IB
IÀ ?>P À I> JBO /LRDB +>SBW SLRP M>P QO>SBOPÄƿq )LOPNRFIP
ÄQ>FBKQǀÄQ>FBKQ QLRP A>KP IB MÄQOFK MOÇP AB I> JBO /LRDBȑ e,E q
NRFIP LKQ AFQ eFI >RO>FQ JFBRU S>IR JLROFO 3LFIÀ IBP §DVMQFBKP
FIP PLKQ PRO KLP Q>ILKP J>FKQBK>KQ 3LF@F NRBPQ @B NRB KLRP
>IILKP C>FOBq
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
&I > AFQȑ e.RF > CO>MMÄ I> QBOOB AB MI>FBP IÀ ?>P .RF > C>FQ
BK PLOQB NRB IB PLIBFI @LKQFKRB À ?OFIIBO A>KP $LPBKq 3LVBW
+LRP ABSLKP KLRP O>MMBIBO @BP @ELPBP O>MMBIBW SLRP NRB !FBR
BPQ !FBRƮ IIÄIRF>Ʈ "K QLRQB @FO@LKPQ>K@B &I BPQ QLRGLROP !FBR &I
MBRQ SO>FJBKQ QLRQ C>FOB
2HK UNTR OK@ÌS ONTQQHDY UNTR DWOKHPTDQ gKD "NQOR CD
"GQHRSs C@MR ( "NQHMSGHDMR DS gKªONTRD CD "GQHRSs
C@MR ONB@KXORD $RS BD PTD K@ MNTUDKKD )ÇQTR@KDL
DRS ROHQHSTDKKD HBH C@MRROHQHSTDKKD HBH C@MR K ONB@KXORD
"DK@BDK@ DRS BD KD CHRBDQMDLDMS ROHQHSTDK CD BD PTDRS
KªFKHRD
+LKƮ LK SLVLKP RK MBR PF GB MOBKAP @BIRF @F BK MOBJFBO
& LOFKQEFBKP BK SFQBPPB & LOFKQEFBKP @E>MFQOB ?FBK BQ
SBOPBQ
"Q UNTR ÈSDR KD BNQOR CD "GQHRS DS UNTR ÈSDR RDR
LDLAQDR BG@BTM ONTQ R@ O@QS
"KPRFQB NRBI ÄQ>FQ IB M>PP>DB PRFS>KQ ML@>IVMPB ǀ
ML@>IVMPB >R @E>MFQOB BQ IB SBOPBQ FBK KLRP V SLFIÀ
/THR TM CDR RDOS @MFDROTHR TM CDR RDOS @MFDR PTH
SDM@HDMS KDR RDOS BNTODR QDLOKHDR CDR RDOS CDQMHDQR
EKÇ@TW UHMS DS HK L@CQDRR@ K@ O@QNKD DM CHR@MSȇ 5HDMR BQ
ID SD LNMSQDQ@H I>ǀI>ǀID SD LNMSQDQ@H KÇONTRD K@ EDLLD
CD K FMD@T
,RF IB LOMP AB EOFPQ 3LRP SLVBW IB @LOMP AB EOFPQ > ÄQÄ
OLJMR MLRO KLP MÄ@EÄP BQ KLRP >SLKP QLRP ÄQÄ ?>MQFPÄP A>KP
RK PBRI "PMOFQ MLRO CLOJBO @B LOMP IÀ BQ KLRP BK ABSBKLKP
JBJ?OBP "Q ALÖ BPQ @B NRBǀALÖ BPQ @B NRB IBǀIB @LOMPƿ !LÖ
BPQ @B NRB J> CBJJB PVJ?LIFNRBJBKQ M>OI>KQƿ !LÖ BPQ @B
NRªSB BPQ SBKRB !R @LOMP AA>J "IIB > ÄQÄ MOFPB AB PLK @ÎQÄ
ªSB > ÄQÄ MOFPB AR @ÎQÄ AA>J )B EOFPQƿ "Q BIIB C>FP>FQ M>OQFB
AB PLK @LOMP &I > AFQȑ e"IIB BPQ @E>FO AB J> @E>FO BQ LP AB JBP LP
"Q GB I>MMBIIBO>F CBJJB q 3LVBW
LK BQ IB LOMP AB EOFPQ > ÄQÄ MOFP AR @LOMP AB 'ÄPRP @>O
KLRP PLJJBP BPMOFQ @E>FO BQ LP AB )RF 3LVBW "K BCCBQ KLRP
PLJJBP A>KP 0LK LOMP M>O RKB K>FPP>K@B "Q M>O@B NRB @B
@LOMP @F )RF >MM>OQFBKQ ?FBK NRFI PLFQ KÄ A>KP IB MÄ@EÄ &I I>
O>@EBQÄ !FBR IB OBPPRP@FQBO> >RU ABOKFBOP GLROP BQ GB SFSO>F A>KP
@BIRF IÀ MLRO I§QBOKFQÄ 3LVBW BPQ Ã> FBK
*>FKQBK>KQ SLVLKP RK MBR I> ABOKFÇOB NRBPQFLK F@F @ÄQ>FQȑ
e"PQ @B NRB I> KLRSBIIB 'ÄORP>IBJ BPQ PMFOFQRBIIBq +LK KLK I>
KLRSBIIB 'ÄORP>IBJ 'B>K I> SRB ABP@BKAOB AR FBI A>RMOÇP AB
!FBR @B KBPQ M>P IB AFP@BOKBJBKQ AB @B NRBPQ I§DIFPB >@QRBIIB
3LVBW BPQǀ@BPQ RKB I>ǀI> KLRSBIIB 'ÄORP>IBJ 'B>K I> SRB
ABP@BKAOB AR FBI MOÄM>OÄB @LJJB RKB ǀ ML@>IVMPB SLRP
SLVBW ǀ MOÄM>OÄB @LJJB RKB §MLRPB NRF PBPQ M>OÄB MLRO
0LK §MLRU
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
NRB I> @LILJ?B )BP ABRU PÄQ>FBKQ MBO@EÄP PRO IB JÅJB MBO@ELFO
J>FP NR>KA FI > I¾@EÄ @B SFBRU @LO?B>R BE ?FBK IBƿ 'FJ>DFKB
NRB QLRQBP IBP B>RU PBKQ>FBKQ J>RS>FP À @>RPB ABP JFIIFLKP AB
@LOMP ERJ>FKP DLKCIÄP BQ BK AÄ@LJMLPFQFLK NRFI V >S>FQ PRO IB>R
BQ ABP @EBS>RU BQ ABP >KFJ>RU NRF ÄQ>FBKQ QLRP JLOQP )B JLKAB
BKQFBO >S>FQ ÄQÄ AÄQORFQ &I V >S>FQ IÀ @BP SFBFIIBP @E>OLDKBP NRF
CILQQ>FBKQ À I> PROC>@B AB IB>R BQ QLRQ Ã> "Q +LÄ > I¾@EÄ I>
@LILJ?B M>O@B NRFI MBKP>FQ >SLFO SR IB PLIBFI ?OFIIBO RK MBR "Q
FI SLRI>FQ P>SLFO PF IB KFSB>R ABP B>RU >S>FQ ?>FPPÄ LR KLK >ILOP
FI > I¾@EÄ IBǀIBǀIB @LO?B>R "Q IB @LO?B>R BPQ >IIÄ PB MLPBO PRO RK
@>A>SOBȑ e,E CLOJFA>?IB @BPQ ?LKƮq 3LRP SLVBW FI J>KDB>FQ
RK @>A>SOB -LRONRLF ÄQ>FQ P> K>QROB &I ÄQ>FQ RK @LO?B>R -BR
FJMLOQB @LJ?FBK AB QBJMP FI ÄQ>FQ OBPQÄ >SB@ I> @LILJ?B @LJ?FBK
AB CLFP FI >S>FQ BKQBKAR +LÄ MOÅ@EBO @LJ?FBK AB QBJMP FI ÄQ>FQ
OBPQÄ >SB@ @BQ LFPB>R MRO FI ÄQ>FQ RK @LO?B>R >R AÄM>OQ !ÇP NRFI
> BR IL@@>PFLK AB PB JLKQOBO PLRP PLK SO>F GLRO FI I> C>FQ
*>FP M>O @LKQOB NR>KA FI > I¾@EÄ I> @LILJ?B ILOPNRBIIB PBPQ
BKSLIÄB CFLR BIIB K> M>P MR PRMMLOQBO Ã> "IIB K> MR >IIBO KRIIB
M>OQ BIIB K> MR QOLRSBO >R@RK IFBR MLRO MLPBO I> MI>KQB AB PBP
MFBAP >ILOP BIIB BPQ OBSBKRB A>KP I>O@EB "Q @BPQ @LJJB Ã>
&I MBRQ >OOFSBO NRLK SLRP I¾@EB MBKA>KQ RK MBQFQ JLJBKQ
MLRO SLFO @B NRB SLRP >IIBW C>FOB J>FP @B NRB SLRP CBOBW QLRGLROP
PF SLRP >SBW RKB K>QROB AB @LILJ?B SLRP KB MLROOBW M>P J>KDBO
I> KLROOFQROB AB @LO?B>R BPQ QLRQ "IIB KB MBRQ M>P ÅQOB AFDÄOÄB
@BPQ QLRQ
,Ö FOFBW SLRP NRB CBOFBW SLRP !FQBP JLF @B NRB SLRP CBOFBW
PF SLRP KÄQFBWǀPF SLRP KÄQFBW M>P RK EOÄQFBKƮ !FQBP JLF @B NRB
GB CBO>FP @B J>QFK PF GB KÄQ>FP M>P RK EOÄQFBKƮ .RB MLROO>FP GB
C>FOB @B J>QFK >ILOP NRB J> JÇOB BPQ >IFQÄB IÀ ?>P À IEÎMFQ>I
A>KP @BQ ÄQ>Q IÀ NRBIIB BPQ FK@LKP@FBKQB BQ >IFQÄB >RO>FP GB IB
@RO À JB QBKFO F@F À I> @E>FOB MLRO MOÅ@EBO BQ >DFO @LJJB Ã>
BK ALKK>KQ IFJMOBPPFLK NRB GB KBK C>FP M>P DO>KA @>P BPQ
M>O@B NRB GB P>FP NRB J> JÇOB BPQ P>RSÄB 3LVBW 'B P>FP NRBIIB BPQ
P>RSÄB 'B P>FP BK .RF G>F @OR GB PRFP MBOPR>AÄ NR&I > I> MRFPP>K@B
AB D>OABO JLK AÄMÎQ GRPNRÀ @B GLRO IÀ
.RBPQ @B NRB J>J>K CBO>FQ J>FKQBK>KQ "E ?FBK MBRQ ÅQOB
NRBIIB >RO>FQ BR AB ?LKKBP FKQBKQFLKP QLRQB P> SFBȑ e2K GLRO GB
PBO>F EOÄQFBKKB q *>FP @LJJBKQ MLROO>FQ BIIB IÅQOB J>FKQBK>KQ
NRBIIB BPQ >IFQÄB @LJJB Ã> FK@LKP@FBKQB LJJBKQ MLROO>FQ BIIB
ABSBKFO EOÄQFBKKB J>FKQBK>KQ .RB CBO>FBKQ PBP BKC>KQP
)>RQOB GLRO NR>KA KLRP I>SLKP BKSLVÄB BJJBKÄB IÀ ?>P
MLRO NRLK IRF ALKKB AR DIR@LPB IÀ ?>Pƿ BPQ QLRQ @B NRBIIB
> A>KP IB @LOMP AR DIR@LPB "IIB KB MBRQ M>P >S>IBO BIIB BPQ
M>O>IVPÄB "IIB > AFQȑ e&I V > RKB @ELPB NRB GB SBRU NRB QR P>@EBP
FIIVq BIIB > M>OIÄ AB JLF BQ AB !LILOÇP KLRP ÄQFLKP IÀ AB PBP
BKC>KQP BQ QLRQ BQ AB NRBINRBP RKP AB JBP COÇOBP NRF ?LFSBKQ
'>F AFQȑ e"E ?FBK FIP QLKQ ?OFPÄ IB @RO q
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
&I > AFQ BIIB > AFQȑ e*>FP FIIV QLRQ Ã> @BPQ I> SFB ARKB JÇOB
I> OLRB NRF QLROKB q "IIB > AFQȑ e*>FP GB PRFP P>RSÄB q "Q BIIB > AFQȑ
e'B PRFP MOÅQB À M>OQFO q
'>F AFQȑ e*>J>K QR >RO>FP MR KLRP I>FPPBO RKB J>FPLK NRF
PÄQBKAB AB 'BCCBOPLKSFIIB À 2QF@> RK M>I>FP QR >RO>FP MR KLRP
I>FPPBO AFU JFIIFLKP AB ALII>OP NRF K>RO>FBKQ ÄQÄ NRRK PRGBQ
AB AFPMRQBP BQ AB NRBOBIIBP >MOÇP QLK AÄM>OQ @BPQ QLRQ @B NRF
BK PBO>FQ OÄPRIQÄ J>FP J>J>K QR KLRP I>FPPBP IB MIRP DO>KA
QOÄPLO NRB NRBINRRK MRFPPB I>FPPBOȑ I>ǀI>PPRO>K@B NRB KLRP QB
OBSBOOLKP A>KP @B ->VP >R ABIÀ AR CIBRSB q BPQ SO>F 3LVBW
3LRP ÅQBP P>RSÄP BQ GB PRFP PF @LKQBKQ AB P>SLFO NRB EOFPQ
P>RSB KLPƿ *>FP FI PB MBRQ NRB KLRP OÄQOLDO>AFLKP FI PB MBRQ
NRB KLRP >DFPPFLKP J>I QLRP KLRP >SLKP KLP E>RQP BQ KLP ?>P
J>FP A>KP SLQOB ¾JB AÇP NRB SLRP C>FQBP NRBINRB @ELPB BE ?FBK
FI V > BK SLRP NRBINRB @ELPB NRF PB AÄQO>NRB SLRP IB P>SBW ILOP
À IFKPQ>KQ @BPQ IB JLJBKQ AB P>RQBO PRO IB @ÎQÄ BPQ IB JLJBKQ
AB P>RQBO PRO IB @ÎQÄ §ILFDKBW SLRP AB Ã>
LK AFPLKP NRB SLRP >IIFBW NRBINRB M>OQ >RGLROAERF BQǀBQ
NRB NRBINRRK P>S>K@B SBOP SLRP BK AFP>KQȑ e%Ä LK JB AFQ NRB
QR BP IRK ABP BU>IQÄP IÀ ?>P q
&JJÄAF>QBJBKQ 0>Q>K AFQȑ e/BJBQP IB À P> MI>@BƮq 3LVBW
e2K BU>IQÄ Ã> GB KB P>FP M>P GB PRFP RK EOÄQFBKƮq 3LVBW
"Q QLRGLROP BK MOÄPBK@B AR J>I OÄMLKABW >R J>I M>O IB ?FBK
"Q PLRSBKBW SLRP J>FKQBK>KQ >QQ>@EBW SLRP À @B@F PLRSBKBW
SLRPȓBKȑ NR>KA SLRP OÄMLKABW >R J>I M>O IB ?FBK IB J>I KB MBRQ
M>P QBKFO BK MOÄPBK@B AR ?FBK &I KB IB MBRQ M>P
LK GB PRFP JFPPFLKK>FOB BQ G>F ÄQÄ A>KP IB JLKAB BKQFBO G>F
ÄQÄ @LKCOLKQÄ >R J>I PLRP QLRQBP PBP CLOJBP À QLRQBP PLOQBP AB
PMFOFQBP AFPJBP BQ À QLRQBP IBP CLOJBP AB @RIQB ABP AÄJLKP BQ LE
À QLRQ @B NRLK MBRQ FJ>DFKBO IÀ LÖ FI V > AB QLRQ BQ G>F QLRGLROP
@LKPQ>QÄ NRB IB ?FBK QOFLJMEB QLRGLROP AR J>I
§@LRQBW MBR JFJMLOQB À NRBI MLFKQ I> KRFQ BPQ PLJ?OB "IIB
MLROO>FQ ÅQOB PLJ?OB À RK MLFKQ QBI NRB SLRP MLROOFBW I> M>IMBO
3LRP MLROOFBW IBSBO IBP J>FKP @LJJB @B@F BQ KB SLFO >?PLIRJBKQ
>R@RKB LJ?OB )B JLFKAOB O>F AB IRJFÇOB S> JLKQOBO @B NRB
@>@EB @BQQB L?P@ROFQÄ BOQ>FKBJBKQ @BPQ @B NRB C>FQ I> SFB BK
MOÄPBK@B AB I> JLOQ BPQ @B NRB C>FQ IB ?FBK BK MOÄPBK@B AR J>I
BPQ @B NRB C>FQ I> CLF BK MOÄPBK@B AR ALRQB BIIB IB AFPMBOPB
LJJBKQ I> KRFQ MBRQ BIIB OBPQBO IÀ NR>KA IB PLIBFI C>FQ ?OFIIBO
À QO>SBOP BIIB PBP ?ÄKÄAF@QFLKP ,Ö S> I> KRFQ "IIB KBUFPQB MIRP
.RBPQ FI >OOFSÄ À I> KRFQ ,Ö BPQ IL?P@ROFQÄ NRFI V >S>FQ A>KP @B
1>?BOK>@IB FI V > BKSFOLK ALRWB EBROBP ,Ö BPQ IL?P@ROFQÄ NRF
ÄQ>FQ CFDÄB F@F À IFKQÄOFBRO AB @BP JROP "IIB KBUFPQB MIRP "IIB >
AFPM>OR -LRONRLF )> IRJFÇOB BPQ BKQOÄB "Q NR>KA I> IRJFÇOB BPQ
BKQOÄB IL?P@ROFQÄ > ÄQÄ CLO@ÄB AB M>OQFO ,RF JLKPFBROƮ
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
-OBKBW IBP @OÄ>QROBP NRF PB MOLJÇKBKQ I> KRFQ IBP ?I>QQBP BQ IBP
P@>O>?ÄBP IBP ?BPQFLIBP BQ QLRQ Ã> .RB IB PLIBFI PB IÇSB LR NRRKB
IRJFÇOB PB JBQQB À Ä@I>FOBOȑ OBD>OABW IBP CFIBO SBOP IL?P@ROFQÄ
)§S>KDFIB BPQ @LJJB Ã> .R>KA FI PB JBQ À Ä@I>FOBO NR>OOFSB QȓFI
À @BRU NRF SBRIBKQ SLRP QO>FQBO ABU>IQÄ .R>OOFSB QȓFI >RU DBKP
NRF PB JLNRBKQ AB SLRP .R>KA I> )RJFÇOB PB JBQ À Ä@I>FOBO FIP
PB MOÄ@FMFQBKQ SBOP IL?P@ROFQÄ À QLRQB SFQBPPB M>O@B NRFIPǀNRFIP
PLKQ IBP BKC>KQP AB I> KRFQ *>FP IBP BKC>KQP AR GLRO J>O@EBKQ
A>KP I> )RJFÇOB
ILOP @BPQ KLRP NRF PLJJBP IBP BKC>KQP AB I> )RJFÇOB M>O I>
DO¾@B AB !FBR !LK@ RKB CLFP NRB I> )RJFÇOB PBPQ JFPB À Ä@I>FOBO
KLRP OBKALKP DO¾@BP À !FBR BQ KLRP J>O@ELKP IBP VBRU LRSBOQP
BK OBD>OA>KQ ABP @ELPBP NRLK KB MBRQ M>P SLFO >SB@ IFI K>QROBI
"K BCCBQ I> CLF BPQ RKB CBOJB >PPRO>K@B ABP @ELPBP NRLK BPMÇOB
RKB AÄJLKPQO>QFLK AB @BIIBP NRLK KB SLFQ M>P JBKƮ '>FJB Ã>
'B K>F M>P IB QBJMP AB C>FOB J> JFKF MOÄAF@>QFLK A>MMLOQBO
@B NRB G>S>FP IFKQBKQFLK AB MOÅ@EBO M>O@B NRB IÀ KLRP >IILKP
ABSLFO MOFBO MLRO IBP J>I>ABP
LJ?FBK >FJBKQ IB 0BFDKBRO JBKƮ *>FKQBK>KQ >MOÇP @BP
NRBPQFLKP NRB KLRP >SLKP BRBP BQ @BOQ>FKBP ÄQ>FBKQ QO>K@E>KQBP
BQ QLRQ BQ MBRQ ÅQOB NRBK V OÄMLKA>KQ MBRQ ÅQOB NRB GB KB I>F
JÅJB M>P C>FQ @LJJB G>RO>FP AÔ M>O@B NRB GB K>F M>P BR IB
QBJMP AB @EBO@EBO IBP M>PP>DBP AB I§@OFQROB 'B IBP >RO>FP Ä@OFQP
PRO I> CBRFIIB PF G>S>FP BR IB QBJMP 'BPMÇOB NRB QLRQ IB JLKAB
BPQ P>QFPC>FQ 0FKLK BE ?FBK OBQLROKBW I>ȓJLF M>O Ä@OFQ !LKKBW
JLF IB QBJMP AB IÄQRAFBO PF SLRP QOLRSBW NRB GB KV >F M>P OÄMLKAR
@LJMIÇQBJBKQ
*BO@F AÅQOB OBPQÄP "Q J>FKQBK>KQ KLRP >IILKP CLOJBO I>
IFDKB AB MOFÇOB A>KP RK FKPQ>KQ *>FP >S>KQ AB IB C>FOB @E>KDBLKP
I>QJLPMEÇOB J>FKQBK>KQ >MOÇP >SLFO ALKKÄ ABP OÄMLKPBP IRKB
OÄMLKA>KQ À @B@F BQ À NRBINRRK NRF @OLFQ @LJJB @B@F LR @LJJB
@BI> 3LRP SLVBW NR>KA LK OÄMLKA >RU NRBPQFLKP M>OCLFP @BPQ
RK MBR QO>K@E>KQ ALK@ >ALOLKP PFJMIBJBKQ IB 0BFDKBRO BQ
@E>KQLKPȑ
'B )>FJB GB )>FJB
->O@B NR&I J> >FJÄ IB MOBJFBO
"Q > >@NRFP JLK P>IRQ
0RO IB ?LFP AR >IS>FOB
*>FKQBK>KQ GB SLRAO>FP NRB SLRP PBOOFBW I> J>FK AB
NRBINRRK MOÇP AB SLRP MBKA>KQ NRB KLRP @E>KQLKP AB KLRSB>R
'B )>FJB GB )>FJB
->O@B NR&I J> >FJÄ IB MOBJFBO
"Q > >@NRFP JLK P>IRQ
0RO IB ?LFP AR >IS>FOB
*>FKQBK>KQ IBSLKP PFJMIBJBKQ IBP J>FKP SBOP )RF @LJJB
@B@F
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
0F SLRP P>SFBWȑ GB PRFP SBKR À I> @E>FOB FI V > BKSFOLK ABRU
EBROBP BQ GB MBKP>FP MOBPNRB KB M>P MLRSLFO >OOFSBO À I> JLFQFÄ
AB I> OÄRKFLK 'ÄQ>FP PF C>QFDRÄ PF ÄMRFPÄ BQ G>S>FP IFJMOBPPFLK
AB @LRSBO RKB DOFMMB J>FP J>FKQBK>KQ GB JB PBKP ?FBK M>O@B
NRB G>F AFQȑ e BPQ JLK ABSLFO BKSBOP !FBR 'B @OLFP À !FBR q "Q
G>F AÔ @LJ?>QQOB Ã> *> CBJJB IÀ MLROO>FQ SLRP AFOB I> JÅJB
@ELPBȑ NR>KA G>F BPP>VÄ AB SBKFO F@F @B J>QFK GÄQ>FP BKOLRÄ BQ
QLRQ '>F AFQȑ e LJJBKQ S>FP GB V >OOFSBOq *>FP ELKKÅQBJBKQ
J>FKQBK>KQ GB JB PBKP JBOSBFIIBRPBJBKQ ?FBK "Q GBǀGB @OLFP NRB
GB MLROO>FP MOBKAOB JLK PRGBQ BQ JB JBQQOB À MOÅ@EBO BQǀBQ
SO>FJBKQ GB JB PBKP ?FBK
*>FP @BPQ NRB SLRP SLVBW FI C>RQ OBD>OABO >RU @ELPBP NRLK
KB SLFQ M>P >SB@ IBP VBRU ,K IBP SLFQ >SB@ IB @RO ,K V @OLFQ BQ LK
QÄJLFDKB AB @BP @ELPBP NRLK KB SLFQ M>P J>FP NRLK @OLFQ ->O@B
NRB I> CLF @BPQ Ã> e"Q I> CLF BPQ RKB CBOJB >PPRO>K@B ABP @ELPBP
NRLK BPMÇOB RKB AÄJLKPQO>QFLK AB @BIIBP NRLK KB SLFQ M>P q
B J>QFK GL?PBOS>FP RK GBRKB EOÄQFBK >PPFP F@F ABS>KQ JLF
"Q GB PRFP >R @LRO>KQ ARKB AÄ@FPFLK NRB @BQQB MBOPLKKB > MOFPB
"Q G>MMOÄ@FB SO>FJBKQ Ã> 'B KB AFO>F M>P NRF @BPQ J>FP GBǀ
G>MMOÄ@FB RKBǀRKB AÄ@FPFLK NR> MOFPB @B EOÄQFBK MBR FJMLOQB
NRFI P>DFPPB JÅJB ARK >PPL@FÄ ARK >JF ARK MÇOB LR ARKB
JÇOB LR AB NRF NRB @B PLFQ FI AÄPFOB >OABJJBKQ OBPQBO CFAÇIB À
EOFPQ 3LVBW
BPQ @LJJB Ã> NRLK D>DKB RK ?FBK >FJÄ @BPQ BK ÄQ>KQ
CFAÇIB BPQ BK ÄQ>KQ CFAÇIB NRLK D>DKB PBP ?FBK >FJÄP
*>FKQBKBW SLQOB @LKSF@QFLK 0LVBW PÔO NRB SLRP ÅQBP BK OÇDIB >SB@
!FBR BQ BKPRFQB KB ?LRDBW MIRP AB IÀ 1BKBW SLRPȓBK PQOF@QBJBKQ
À Ã> /FBK KB MLROO> G>J>FP SLRP C>FOB ?OLK@EBO PF SLRP SLRP BK
QBKBW PQOF@QBJBKQ À Ã>
*>FKQBK>KQ KLRP >IILKP QLRP C>FOB ABP BOOBROP 0LRSBKBW
SLRPȓBK "Q NR>KA SLRP SLRP @LKPFAÄOBW IBP RKP IBP >RQOBP KB
OBD>OABW M>P IBOOBRO AB I>RQOB 3LRP SLVBW KB C>FQBP M>P Ã>
M>O@B NRB PLRSBKBW SLRP SLRP >RPPF SLRP C>FQBP ABP BOOBROP
*>FP OBD>OABW À EOFPQ NRF DRFAB @BQQB MBOPLKKB "Q PF BIIB
> ?BPLFK A>FAB >ILOP MOFBW MLRO BIIB BPQǀ@BPQ @LJJB Ã>
NRB KLRP J>O@ELKP A>KP IE>OJLKFB SLRP SLVBW BK MOF>KQ "Q
PLRSBKBW SLRP NR>KA SLRP MOFBW MLRO NRBINRRK A>RQOB NRF >
ABP BKKRFP !FBR SLRP ELKLOBO> BQ SLRP DRÄOFO> SLRP NR>KA
SLRP MOFBW MLRO NRBINRRK A>RQOB BPQ SO>F BPQ I> ?>PB AR
EOFPQF>KFPJBȑ PBKQO>FABO P>PPFPQBO JRQRBIIBJBKQ ÅQOB DBKQFIP
IBP RKP >SB@ IBP >RQOBP PB @LJMOBKAOB JRQRBIIBJBKQ ILOP PF
SLRP SLVBW IBOOBRO AB SLQOB MOL@E>FK PF SLRP SLVBW NRB ABP DBKP
LKQ C>FQ C>RPPB OLRQB KB C>FQBP M>P C>RPPB OLRQB >SB@ BRU J>FP
MOFBW PFJMIBJBKQ MLRO BRU LKQFKRBW PFJMIBJBKQ À MOFBO BQ
!FBR @LJMOBKAO> &I OB@QFCFBO> QLRQ
*>FKQBK>KQ GBPMÇOB PF @BPQ I> SLILKQÄ AR 0BFDKBRO ǀ GB @OLFP
NRB FIIV > RK PVPQÇJB FI BKSLFB RKB @>OQB À QLRQ IB JLKAB "Q PF
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
J>J>K S> JFBRU @BQQB PBJ>FKB MLRO >RQ>KQ NRB KLRP P>@EFLKP
IÀ KLRP KB PLJJBP M>P PÔOP J>FP PF J>J>K S> JFBRU @BQQB
PBJ>FKB BQ QLRQ AFJ>K@EB MOL@E>FK GBǀGB SLRAO>FP >MMLOQBO
RKǀRK *BPP>DB ÄS>KDÄIFNRB 0F Ã> KB AÄO>KDB M>P KLQOBǀKLQOB
MOÄ@FBRU M>PQBRO F@F "Q KLRP BPMÄOLKP NRB SLRP OBSFBKAOBW PF
SLRP IB MLRSBW 0F SLRP MLRSBW SBKFO KLRP PBOLKP @LKQBKQP NRB
SLRP PLVBW M>OJF KLRP
)>FJBW SLRP AB QLRQ SLQOB @RO 8)>PPBJ?IÄB AFQȑ
eJBK qȑǀȑ+ ! § : +BPQ &I M>P JBOSBFIIBRU .RB MLROOFLKP KLRP
C>FOB P>KP )RF *>FKQBK>KQ NRB MLROOFBW SLRP C>FOB -LROOFBW
SLRP JFKAFNRBO NRBINRB @ELPB NRF PLFQ MIRP DILOFBRU 0F SLRP
MLRSBW JB JLKQOBO NRBINRB @ELPB NRF PLFQ MIRP DILOFBRU NRB Ã>
>ILOP GBǀGBǀGB SBKAO>F QLRQ @B NRB G>F BQ GB AÄPFOBO>F >OABJJBKQ
I> @ELPB NRB SLRP J>ROBW JLKQOÄB NRF PBO>FQ MIRP DILOFBRPB NRB
B@F ,RF JLKPFBRO B@F BPQ I> @ELPB I> MIRP DILOFBRPB NRB GB
@LKK>FPPBȑ AB P>SLFO >SB@ >PPRO>K@B NRB KLRP PLJJBP P>RSÄP
AB P>SLFO NRB IB !FBR JÅJB NRF > C>FQ IBP @FBRU BQ I> QBOOB > ?FBK
SLRIR 0>?>FPPBO ABP@BKAOB E>?FQBO M>OJF KLRP BQ KLRP MLOQBO
>PPFPQ>K@B
*>FKQBK>KQ SLF@F @LJJBKQ KLRP P>SLKP PF KLRP PLJJBP A>KP
IB SO>F LR M>P SLRP SLVBWȑ @BPQ NRB I> @ELPB JÅJB NR&I > C>FQB
>R @LJJBK@BJBKQ >SB@ IBP EOÄQFBKP AB @BQQB ÄMLNRB IÀ ǀ I>
JÅJB ÄDIFPB IB JÅJB CLK@QFLKKBJBKQ I> J>KFÇOB ALKQ IB 0>FKQ
"PMOFQ > >DF BQ I> J>KFÇOB ALKQ IB AF>?IB IBP > @LJ?>QQRP BQ I>
J>KFÇOB ALKQ FIP PB PLKQ QBKRP AB?LRQ ǀ @BPQ I> JÅJB @ELPB NRF
PB MOLARFQ F@F JÅJB >SB@ IBP JÅJBP PFDKBP IBP JÅJBP MOLAFDBP
IB JÅJB !FBR I> MOBRSB FKC>FIIF?IB NRB @BPQ )RF
!FQBP JLF A>MOÇP @B NRB AÄ@I>OB I> P@FBK@B AFQBP JLF
AB J>KFÇOB P@FBKQFCFNRB @LJJBKQ NRBINRRK MLROO>FQ MOÄAFOB
NRBINRB @ELPB NRF >OOFSBO>FQ A>KP IBP >KKÄBP LR A>KP IBP QBJMP
À SBKFO ǀ >S>KQ NRB I> @ELPB >OOFSB *LKQOBW JLF I> MRFPP>K@B
LÖ NRBIIB PLFQ NRF MLROO>FQ @LKK>ÉQOB @BI> A>S>K@B >S>KQ NRB
I> @ELPB >OOFSB !FQBP JLF NRBIIB FKQBIIFDBK@B ERJ>FKB MLROO>FQ
PLKABO NRLF NRB @B PLFQ JLKQOBW JLF M>O NRBI JLVBK LK
MLROO>FQ SLFO NRBINRB @ELPB BQ MOÄAFOB NRBINRB @ELPB NRF >OOFSB
BU>@QBJBKQ QBIǀQBI NRBI 3LVBW &I KV BK > >R@RK
!LK@ &I BPQ !FBR 3LRP SLVBW &I BPQ !FBR "Q M>O@B NR&I BPQ
!FBR M>O 0> DO¾@B &I SFBKQ E>?FQBO M>OJF KLRP BQ BU>@QBJBKQ
@LJJB &I I>S>FQ C>FQ À @BQQB ÄMLNRB IÀ >SB@ @BP ELJJBP NRF
LKQ MOÄAFQ @BP @ELPBP BQ @E>@RKB ABIIBP BPQ >OOFSÄB BU>@QBJBKQ
@LJJB BIIB >S>FQ ÄQÄ MOÄAFQB *>FKQBK>KQ @B JÅJB !FBR BPQ >SB@
KLRP MOÄAFP>KQ BQ C>FP>KQ BU>@QBJBKQ IBP JÅJBP @ELPBP NRB @B
NR&I >S>FQ C>FQ À @BQQB ÄMLNRB IÀ "E ?FBK KLRP ABSOFLKP ÅQOB
QBIIBJBKQ EBROBRU >R MLFKQ AB P>RQBO MLRO >FKPF AFOB AB KR>DB
BK KR>DB @LJJB Ã> AB J>O@EBO A>KP IBPM>@B MOBPNRB M>O@B
NRB KLRP P>SLKP
,+!2 & 1" ,/!/" "1 !, 1/& + " !" )§$)& 0"
+LRP P>SLKP NRB KLRP PLJJBP M>PPÄP AB I> JLOQ À I> 3FB
+LRP P>SLKP NRB KLRP >SLKP IB P>IRQ +LRP P>SLKP NRB KLRP
PLJJBP EOÄQFBKP "Q KLRP P>SLKP NRB KLRP FOLKP >R FBI M>O@B
NRB !FBR > C>FQ I> MOLJBPPB BQ &I BPQ F@F @LKQFKR>KQ À >S>K@BO >SB@
KLRP BQ AB J>KFÇOB NRB KLRP MRFPPFLKP )B SLFO
+LRP )B SLVLKP LJJBKQ BPQ @B NRB GB )B SLFP .R>KA GB
SLRP SLFP 3LRP )B SLVBW BK JLF GB )B SLFP BK SLRP 3LRP SLVBW
GB SLFP @B NR&I C>FQ MLRO SLRP 1BKBW F@F GB )B SLFP F@F JB OÄSÄIBO
I> ->OLIB 3LRP AFQBPȑ e LJJBKQ MLRSBW SLRP )B SLFO BK JLFq
"E ?FBK OBD>OABW &I BPQ F@F BK QO>FK AB JB OÄSÄIBO I> ->OLIB
'B )> SLFP IÀ ?>Pȑ &I SLRP )> ALKKB BQ SLRP )> D>OABW 3LVBW
"KPRFQB SLRP OBD>OABW BK >OOFÇOB BQ SLRP AFQBPȑ e LJJBKQ > QȓFI
@LJJBKQ BPQ @B NRB Ã> > MR >OOFSBOq "KPRFQB SLRP OBSBKBW BQ
SLRP @LKPQ>QBW NRB @BPQ ?FBK SO>F SLRP SLVBW !LK@ SLRP )B
SLVBW BK JLF GB )B SLFP BK SLRP
"Q KLRP )B SLVLKP A>KP IB IBSBO AR PLIBFI +LRP )B SLVLKP
A>KP IB @LR@EBO AR PLIBFI +LRP )B SLVLKP A>KP IBP CIBROP +LRP )B
SLVLKP A>KPƿ +LRP )B SLVLKP M>OQLRQ M>O@B NRB KLRP PLJJBP
M>PPÄP ABP ÄIÄJBKQP FKCÄOFBROP AB I> @LKAFQFLK QBOOBPQOB À @BQ
ÄIÄJBKQ ÄIBSÄ AB I> DILFOB AB !FBR NRF KLRP MBOJBQ AB SLFO
0> ?B>RQÄ
&I V > NRBINRBP GLROP NR>KA GÄQ>FP BK SLV>DB IÀ ?>P ÀǀÀ
PRO I> OLRQB AB II>PH> NR>KA G>II>FP C>FOB RKB M>OQFB AB @E>PPB
GÄQ>FP IÀ À JB MLPBO ABP NRBPQFLKPȑ e-LRONRLF -LRONRLFq
/BD>OABW @LJJBǀ@LJJB !FBR BPQ OÄBI -LROQ>KQ FI V > ABP
J>I>ABP M>OQLRQ J>FP !FBR NRF P>S>FQ
LK ABJ>FK GB PRFP @BKPÄ M>OQFO #OÇOB /LV IÀ ?>P >R CLKA BQ
KLRP QLRP KLRP PLJJBP @BKPÄP M>OQFO ABJ>FK MLRO IB LILO>AL
MLRO KLQOBƿQLRP IBP >RQLJKBP KLRP >IILKP IÀ ?>P À I> @E>PPB
LÖ KLRPƿGB PRFP OBKQOÄ ABP OÄRKFLKP MLRO V >IIBO *>FP GB KB MBRU
M>P V >IIBO À @>RPB AB J>J>K AB IÄQ>Q AB J>J>K
*>FKQBK>KQ OBD>OABW I> ?LKQÄ AR 0>FKQ "PMOFQ &I P>S>FQ Ã>
ABMRFP QOÇP ILKDQBJMP ILOP >R IFBR AB JB I>FPPBO V >IIBO
SLFIÀ NR&I J> ALKKÄ RKB SFPFLK BQ J> BKSLVÄ IÀ ?>P &I J>
ALKKÄ RK DBKOB AB M>OQFB AB @E>PPB NRB GB K>RO>FP M>P MR >SLFO
A>KP IB LILO>AL SLRP SLVBW M>O@B NRFI KV > M>P A>KFJ>RU
@LJJB Ã> A>KP IB LILO>AL 3LFIÀ NR&I J> ALKKÄ Ã> M>O
SFPFLK &I J> MBOJFP A>SLFO Ã> P>@E>KQ NR&I >II>FQ ABSLFO JB
MOFSBO AB @B SLV>DB IÀ A>KP IB LILO>AL 3LRP M>OIBW AB ?LKQÄ
BQ AB JFPÄOF@LOABƮ "E ?FBK >ILOP MLRONRLF ILOP FI V > QOÇP
ILKDQBJMP &I P>S>FQ NRB J> JÇOB >II>FQ PLRCCOFO &I P>S>FQ NRB J>
JÇOB >II>FQ ÅQOB À IEÎMFQ>I 0&I IB MBOJBQ >ILOP &I IB C>FQ A>KP RK
?LK ?RQ NRB JLF GFDKLOB *>FP GB P>FP NRB QLRQ Ã> e@LK@LROQ >R
?FBK AB @BRU NRF >FJBKQ IB 0BFDKBROq
0F AB QBJMP À >RQOB KLRP MOBKFLKP IB QBJMP AB KLRP >OOÅQBO
ÄDIFPB MLRO SLFO KLQOB !FBRƮ OOÅQBW SLRP AÄQ>@EBW SLRP AB
SLP @LKQO>OFÄQÄP BQ OBPQBW QO>KNRFIIBP NRBINRBP JFKRQBP A>KP I>
.2"01&,+0 "1 /§-,+0"0
'3&/$)