Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract — Porcine ear necrosis was investigated in 23 conveniently chosen farms, consisting of 14 case farms
and 9 control farms. Biopsies of lesions and oral swabs from pigs on 11 case farms were examined by histology
and bacterial culture. All farms were visited for observations and a survey on management, housing, and the pres-
ence of other clinical signs or behavioral vices. Histological examination revealed that the lesions began on the
surface and progressed to deeper layers, and that vascular damage did not appear to be the initiating cause.
Spirochetes were only rarely observed in histological examination and were not cultured from biopsies and oral
swabs. Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus hyicus were cultured from 91% and 66% of samples, respectively.
Ear biting and a humid environment were associated with ear necrosis. On some farms large numbers of pigs were
affected and lesions were sometimes extensive. The condition appears to be an infectious disease beginning on the
surface of the skin; contributing environmental and management factors are likely.
Résumé — Enquête sur la nécrose des oreilles chez les porcs. La nécrose des oreilles porcines a fait l’objet d’une
enquête dans un échantillonnage de convenance de 23 fermes, composé de 14 fermes de cas et de 9 fermes témoins.
Les biopsies de lésions et des prélèvements oraux faits chez des porcs dans 11 fermes de cas ont été examinés par
histologie et culture bactérienne. Toutes les fermes ont été visitées pour recueillir des observations et effectuer un
examen de la gestion, du logement et de la présence d’autres signes cliniques ou vices de comportement. L’examen
histologique a révélé que les lésions commençaient sur la surface et progressaient vers des couches plus profondes
et que les dommages vasculaires ne semblaient pas être la cause initiale. Des spirochètes ont été rarement observés
à l’examen histologique et n’ont pas été cultivés dans les biopsies et les prélèvements oraux. Staphylococcus aureus
et Staphylococcus hyicus ont été cultivés dans 91 % et 66 % des échantillons, respectivement. Les morsures d’oreilles
et un environnement humide étaient associés à la nécrose des oreilles. Dans certaines fermes, un grand nombre de
porcs étaient affectés et les lésions étaient parfois importantes. L’affection semble être une maladie infectieuse qui
commence à la surface de la peau; des facteurs contributifs liés à l’environnement et à la gestion sont probables.
(Traduit par Isabelle Vallières)
Can Vet J 2013;54:491–495
Introduction ears (1). Little is understood regarding the risk factors that
influence severity and prevalence of ear necrosis. In general, ear
Ear necrosis is a common problem on Canadian pig farms and
necrosis is considered to have little effect on pig performance, at
several etiologies have been proposed but not confirmed. The
least when the lesions are only mild to moderate (2). However,
clinical manifestation of ear necrosis has been described as the
the unsightly visual appearance could interfere with the sale of
appearance of open wounds, crust, and bleeding on 1 or both
affected pigs, and raise welfare concerns.
The etiology of ear necrosis is unknown. Staphylococcus hyicus
Department of Population Medicine, Ontario Veterinary and Staphylococcus aureus have been suggested as potential
College, Guelph, Ontario (Park, Friendship, Poljak, Dewey), causative agents because of the similarity of histopathological
Animal Health Laboratory, University of Guelph, Guelph, lesions and bacterial cultural results between ear necrosis and
Ontario (DeLay, Slavic). exudative epidermitis (3–5). The pathogenesis of staphylococcal
Address all correspondence to Dr. Jeonghwa Park; e-mail: skin disease involves bacterial production of exfoliative toxins
jeonghwa@uoguelph.ca (ETs) which act as “molecular scissors” to cleave the epidermis
Use of this article is limited to a single copy for personal study. of mammalian skin (6). For a long time it was thought that
Anyone interested in obtaining reprints should contact the S. aureus ETs did not affect the epidermis of pigs (7); however,
CVMA office (hbroughton@cvma-acmv.org) for additional recent findings have demonstrated the targeting of desmoglein1
copies or permission to use this material elsewhere. in pig skin by S. aureus ETB and ETD (6). Spirochetes have
been made that ear necrosis is the result of ischemic injury due performed and bacteria were identified as S. hyicus and S. aureus
to thrombosis of the small dermal capillaries in the tips of the by standard laboratory techniques including colony morphol-
ears as a result of immune-complex deposition, as occurs in ogy, hemolysis, Gram-stain, catalase reaction, and coagulase
porcine circovirus associated disease (PCVAD) (11), or due to reaction. Antimicrobial susceptibility testing with penicillin G,
mycotoxin-associated vasculopathy (10). ampicillin, ceftiofur, spectinomycin, sulphonamide, tetracycline,
Ear necrosis appears to be influenced by environmental tiamulin, and trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole was determined
and management factors. Purchased feed, fully slatted floor- by the disk diffusion method (Kirby-Bauer Procedure) defined
ing without straw, poor air quality and high humidity, and a by the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (14). For
high stocking density of newly weaned pigs have been found to the purpose of analyzing the data, isolates classed as intermedi-
increase the risk of ear necrosis (12). Dry feed, early weaning, ate susceptibility were included with the bacteria identified as
poor housing conditions, fighting, feed and dirt on the tips of resistant.
ears, and concurrent mange have also been identified as possible Culture of spirochetes was performed following the method
risk factors (4,13). described by Pringle et al (9). Ear tissues and oral samples in
The objectives of this study were to: describe clinical and FAB were incubated for 24 to 48 h at 37°C in an anaerobic
histopathological lesions of ear necrosis; determine the presence chamber. One drop of the broth culture was added to a 0.22 mm
of potential pathogens, particularly Staphylococcus species and membrane filter placed on fastidious anaerobe agar with 10%
spirochetes; and determine herd-level risk factors of ear necrosis. horse blood. Following incubation of the agar plate at 37°C for
2 to 3 days in an anaerobic chamber, the bacterial growth under
Materials and methods the filter was examined by phase contrast microscopy.
A total of 23 conveniently selected farms were used in the study
(14 case farms and 9 control farms). To be included as a control Histopathological examination
farm, the farm owner or manager had to report that the farm Following 24 h fixation in 10% neutral buffered formalin,
had no history of clinical signs of ear necrosis, and the absence skin biopsies were processed for histologic examination. Where
of ear necrosis had to be confirmed by the researchers through sufficiently large, biopsies were bisected prior to processing,
an on-farm visit. All farms were visited between May 2010 and and all biopsies were processed in total. Serial tissue sections
April 2011, and the observations were conducted by the same (4 mm) from each biopsy were stained with hematoxylin and
individual on all farms. The research was approved by the animal eosin (H&E) and Warthin-Starry silver (WS) and were examined
care committee of the University of Guelph. using light microscopy by a single pathologist (JD).
Immunohistochemistry (IHC) for Treponema spp. was per-
Investigation of potential causative organisms formed on tissue sections from those cases in which spirochetes
Sampling for bacterial culture were identified by WS stain.
Material for diagnostic purposes was collected from 11 of
the 14 case farms. On each farm, 9 pigs were selected for Investigation of risk factors at farm level
testing by choosing 3 pigs from early, mid, and late stages of All 23 farms were visited and a questionnaire was administered to
clinical disease. Early-disease stage groups consisted of pigs the producers during a face-to-face interview. Information from
with small black scabs on their ears and were from pigs in the the questionnaire included: farm demographics, weaning age, pig
youngest affected age group. Mid-disease stage groups were flow, cleaning procedures, vaccination and medication regimens,
slightly older (1 or 2 wk) and generally exhibited lesions that feeding information, and source of pigs. In addition, observa-
had progressed to open wounds, thick scabs, and some loss tion notes for each disease-stage group were completed by the
of ear tissue. Late-disease stage groups were the oldest pigs, researchers after collecting samples during the visit to the farm.
which generally showed lesions that had resolved but bleeding Information collected through on-farm observation included: the
wounds and thick scabs were still common. Three wedge- prevalence of ear necrosis for each disease stage, a description of
shaped ear tissue biopsies and an oral swab were taken from the lesions, the presence of clinical signs other than ear necrosis
each pig. One biopsy sample was placed in a sterile plastic tube and the presence or absence of behavioral vices. A description of
for culture of S. hyicus and S. aureus. Another biopsy sample the facilities, noting the stocking density, type of flooring, feeder
was placed in a tube with fastidious anaerobe broth (FAB), and waterer type, and room temperature was recorded. A subjective
(LAB 71, Lab M, Heywood, Lancashire, UK) for culture of assessment of humidity and air quality in the pen was recorded.
spirochetes. A third biopsy sample was placed in a 100 mL On control farms, groups of pigs that were comparable to the age
jar containing 50 mL of 10% formalin solution for histologic of early, mid, and late disease stages for case farms were chosen for
examination. For the histology samples, an effort was made observation.
A R T I C LE
accuracy, consistency, and missing values.
The average prevalence of ear necrosis in each stage group
was estimated as the number of pigs affected with ear necrosis
divided by total number of pigs in the pen.
Unconditional association between ear necrosis status of
farms and putative risk factors, obtained from the survey and
observation notes were evaluated using a chi-squared test or Antimicrobials
Mann-Whitney U-test, as appropriate (P , 0.05). Variables
Figure 1. Antimicrobial resistance profiles of S. hyicus and
in the survey were measured at the farm level and the vari- S. aureus from clinical cases of ear necrosis.
ables in the observation notes were measured for each of the pen — penicillin G, amp — ampicillin, cef — ceftiofur, spec — spectinomycin,
tet — tetracycline, tia — tiamulin, sul — sulphonamide, trisul — trimethoprim-
3 stage groups at farm-level. These were then offered as sepa- sulfamethoxazole. Number of S. hyicus isolates is 63; number of
rate variables in a different stage group modeling. Initially, a S. aureus isolates is 87.
total of 16 variables was obtained from the survey and each of
21 variables obtained in early, mid, and late stage groups from
the observation notes were examined. Correlation analysis was Spirochetes
performed using the Spearman’s rank correlation statistic to Attempts to culture spirochetes from ear biopsies and oral swabs
identify collinearity among variables. Independent variables were unsuccessful. In WS-stained ear biopsies, spirochetes were
associated with the dependent variable at a 20% significance identified in 5 pigs (5.2%), including 4 pigs (11.1%, 4/36) from
level (P , 0.2) in unconditional screening were considered the early stage group and 1 pig (3.7%, 1/27) from the mid-stage
primary predictors of interest and were included in the multi- group. Spirochetes in 4 of 5 WS-positive biopsies were confirmed
variable main effects model. Then the presence or absence of as Treponema spp. by IHC. Spirochetes were clustered within
lesions of ear necrosis on the farm as the dependent variable crusts or pustules, or were located at margins of ulcerated foci in
was regressed on these primary predictors using multivariable the epidermis. In the spirochete-positive group, 3 pigs were posi-
logistic regression. Manual model building, which combined tive for S. hyicus, S. aureus, and spirochetes (3.1%, 3/96); 1 pig
forward selection, was employed in building a multivariable was positive for S. aureus and spirochetes (1%, 1/96); and 1 pig
model. Model fitting was evaluated by the Pearson Goodness of was positive only for spirochetes (1%, 1/96). Farm prevalence of
fit test. spirochetes was 36.4% (4/11).
A R T I C LE
AICc: 22.61 BICd: 26.14 associated with the condition.
OR — odds ratio.
a Wald test was used to determine statistical differences.
b AUC — area under the ROC (receiver operating characteristic) curve.
Acknowledgments
c AIC — Akaike’s Information Criteria. The research was funded by Ontario Pork, the Animal Health
d BIC — Bayesian Information Criteria.
Strategic Investment Fund, Ontario Ministry of Agriculture,
Pearson X 2 goodness-of-fit test, P , 0.001.
Food and Rural Affairs, and the University of Guelph. We are
very appreciative of the farmers who participated and Bryan
the skin and cause necrosis (17) rather than being the serious Bloomfield for technical assistance. CVJ
sequela of ear necrosis. However, bloody ear lesions are likely
to attract penmates whose chewing could result in the severity
of the lesions (18). Therefore, further research on whether ear
References
1. Petersen HH, Nielsen EO, Hassing AG, Ersbll AK, Nielsen JP.
necrosis leads to biting or biting is a prerequisite for ear necrosis Prevalence of clinical signs of disease in Danish finisher pigs. Vet Rec
is warranted since the results of such a study would assist the 2008;162:377–382.
current effort towards the control of ear necrosis. 2. Busch ME, Jensen IM, Korsgaard J. The development and consequences
of ear necrosis in a weaner herd and two growing-finishing herds. Proc
High humidity was also a risk factor for ear necrosis in the Inter Pig Vet Soc Cong 2010:45.
present study which is in agreement with other reports (4,12). 3. Richardson JA, Morter RL, Rebar AH, Olander HJ. Lesions of porcine
This is consistent with bacterial etiology since high humidity necrotic ear syndrome. Vet Pathol 1984;21:152–157.
4. Mirt D. Lesions of so-called flank biting and necrotic ear syndrome in
may facilitate the buildup of staphylococci or other pathogens. pigs. Vet Rec 1999;144:92–96.
However the assessment of the air quality and whether the barn 5. van Duijkeren E, Jansen MD, Flemming SC, et al. Methicillin-resistant
was humid in this study was subjective. In addition, humid- Staphylococcus aureus in pigs with exudative epidermitis. Emerg Infect
Dis 2007;13:1408–1410.
ity in a pig barn is highly variable because it is influenced by 6. Nishifuji K, Sugai M, Amagai M. Staphylococcal exfoliative toxins:
weather, season, and even activities in the barn such as washing. “Molecular scissors” of bacteria that attack the cutaneous defense barrier
Therefore this association of high humidity and ear necrosis in mammals. J Dermatol Sci 2008;49:21–31.
7. Elias PM, Fritsch P, Mittermayer H. Staphylococcal toxic epidermal
needs to be considered with caution. Case farms reported an necrolysis: Species and tissue susceptibility and resistance. J Invest
earlier weaning age than control farms and this finding is in Dermatol 1976;66:80–89.
agreement with a previous study (13). It has been suggested 8. Harcourt RA. Porcine ulcerative spirochaetosis. Vet Rec 1973;92:
647–648.
that when pigs are weaned at an early age they are more apt to 9. Pringle M, Backhans A, Otman F, Sjölund M, Fellström C. Isolation
engage in behavioral vices such as chewing on penmates and of spirochetes of genus Treponema from pigs with ear necrosis. Vet
possibly causing mild skin damage; therefore, weaning age could Microbiol 2009;139:279–283.
10. Cameron R. Diseases of the skin. In: Straw EB, Zimmerman JJ,
be associated with ear necrosis. The small number of farms used D’Allaire S, Taylor JD, eds. Diseases of Swine. 9th ed. Ames, Iowa:
in this study makes it difficult to clearly identify management Blackwell Publishing, 2006:179–198.
and environmental risk factors and is a significant weakness of 11. Zlotowski P, Correa AMR, Barcellos DESN, Driemeier D. Presence of
PCV2 in ear lesions in the course of PCVAD in growing pigs in Brazil.
the study. Proc Inter Pig Vet Soc Cong 2008:555.
There were numerous sources of semen, replacement of gilts, 12. Busch ME, Wachmann H, Nielsen EO, Baekbo P. Risk factors for
and different breeds of sows among the farms in this study. Pigs ear necrosis and tail lesions in weaners. Proc Inter Pig Vet Soc Cong
2008:277.
with floppy ears have been suggested to be more prone to ear 13. Smith WJ, Penny RHC, eds. Behavioral problems, including vices and
biting and possibly more vulnerable to necrosis compared to cannibalism. In: Leman AD, Glock RD, Mengeling WL, Penny RHC,
pigs with upright ears (17). However no such association was Scholl E, Straw B, eds. Diseases of Swine. 5th ed. Ames, Iowa: Iowa
State University Press, 1981:671.
noted in this study. 14. Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute. Performance standards
In conclusion, this study provides evidence that ear necrosis for antimicrobial disk and dilution susceptibility tests for bacteria iso-
is possibly an infectious disease beginning with lesions on the lated from animals; approved standard-third edition. CLSI document.
2008;28:M31–A3.
outer skin surface. Spirochetes are not likely a primary cause 15. Wegener HC, Skov-Jensen EW. Exudative epidermitis. In: Straw BR,
since they were only occasionally observed during histological Zimmerman JJ, D’Allaire S, Taylor DJ, eds. Diseases of Swine. 9th ed.
examination. Staphylococcus species should be considered to be Ames, Iowa: Blackwell Pub, 2006:675–679.
16. Lang C, Volmayr T, Waxenecker F, Hofstetter U. Etiology of the ear
potential causative agents since they were commonly isolated necrosis syndrome-investigation of infectious agents. Proc Inter Pig Vet
from ear lesions and the histological description of the lesions Soc Cong 2010:43.
are similar to exudative epidermitis which is a disease caused 17. Penny RHC, Mullen PA. Ear biting in pigs. Vet Annu 1976;16:
103–110.
by Staphylococcus species. However at this stage the role of 18. Fraser D. Attraction to blood as a factor in tail-biting by pigs. Appl
Staphylococcus species is speculative. Further research is neces- Anim Behav Sci 1987;17:61–68.