HENRI FAYOL ET « L’INDUSTRIALISATION » DE L’ÉTAT

Luc Rojas

L'Harmattan | « Revue Française d'Histoire des Idées Politiques »

2017/1 N° 45 | pages 165 à 186

ISSN 1266-7862
ISBN 9782343121147
DOI 10.3917/rfhip1.045.0165
Article disponible en ligne à l'adresse :
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
https://www.cairn.info/revue-francaise-d-histoire-des-idees-
politiques-2017-1-page-165.htm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Distribution électronique Cairn.info pour L'Harmattan.

© L'Harmattan. Tous droits réservés pour tous pays.

La reproduction ou représentation de cet article, notamment par photocopie, n'est autorisée que dans les
limites des conditions générales d'utilisation du site ou, le cas échéant, des conditions générales de la
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

licence souscrite par votre établissement. Toute autre reproduction ou représentation, en tout ou partie,
sous quelque forme et de quelque manière que ce soit, est interdite sauf accord préalable et écrit de
l'éditeur, en dehors des cas prévus par la législation en vigueur en France. Il est précisé que son stockage
dans une base de données est également interdit.

Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)

 VARIÉTÉS

+HQUL)D\RO
HW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

SDU/XF5RMDV 

(QFHGpEXWGHඑඑංHVLqFOHODUpIRUPHGHO¶eWDWHWGHVVHUYLFHV
SXEOLFVDSSDUDvWFRPPHXQHSUpRFFXSDWLRQPDMHXUHGHVpOLWHVHWj
XQGHJUpPRLQGUHGHO¶RSLQLRQSXEOLTXH&HWWHYRORQWpGHPRGHUQL
VHUO¶DFWLRQSXEOLTXHQ¶HVWFHSHQGDQWSDVXQHQRXYHDXWp/HFOLPDW
LQGXVWULHOV¶LQVWDXUDQWHQ)UDQFHDXGpEXWGXඑඑHVLqFOHHWIDYRUL
VDQWO¶LQWURGXFWLRQHWOHGpYHORSSHPHQWGXWD\ORULVPHHVWSURSLFHj
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

O¶DPpULFDQLVDWLRQGHODVRFLpWp,OIDXWQpDQPRLQVDWWHQGUHODJXHUUH
GHSRXUTXHOHVKRPPHVSROLWLTXHVV¶HPSDUHQWGXVXMHWHW
SRXVVHQWOHVLQGXVWULHOVjWUDYHUVGHVGLVFRXUVGHVFLUFXODLUHVHW
GHVUpXQLRQVjWD\ORULVHUO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQGXWUDYDLO$LQVL$OEHUW
7KRPDVeWLHQQH&OHPHQWHO*HRUJHV&OHPHQFHDXHWOHVLQJpQLHXUV
FRQVHLOVTXLOHVHQWRXUHQWIRQWGXWD\ORULVPHXQWKqPHSROLWLTXHHW
FRQGLWLRQQHQWO¶DYHQLUGXSD\VjODSURSDJDWLRQGHFHWWHGRFWULQH
¬OD¿QGXSUHPLHUFRQÀLWPRQGLDOFHPRXYHPHQWG¶RSLQLRQVH
FRQFHQWUHVXUOHFRPPDQGHPHQWGHO¶eWDW$QGUp7DUGLHXQ¶KpVLWH
SDVjGLUHTXHLa France est un corps sans têteDORUVTXH/pRQ

/XF5RMDVHVWSURIHVVHXUjO¶XQLYHUVLWpGH/\RQ8QLYHUVLWpGH6DLQWeWLHQQH
805&156(96,67+0(

3)ULGHQVRQ©8QWRXUQDQWWD\ORULHQGDQVODVRFLpWpIUDQoDLVHª
Annales Économies Sociétés CivilisationsHDQQpHQƒS
$QGUp7DUGLHXLa réforme de l’État3DULV)ODPPDULRQS

 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

%OXPGpFODUHLOQRXVIDXWXQFKHI࣠$XUHJDUGGHFHWWHWD\ORULVDWLRQ
GHVHVSULWVOHVLQJpQLHXUVYpULWDEOHVVFLHQWL¿TXHVGHO¶LQGXVWULH
VRQWGRQFDSSHOpVjMRXHUXQU{OHPDMHXU,OVHGpYHORSSHDLQVL
GXUDQWO¶HQWUHGHX[JXHUUHVGHQRPEUHX[FRXUDQWVVHSURSRVDQWGH
SDVVHUGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQVFLHQWL¿TXHGHO¶XVLQHjFHOOHGHODVRFLpWp
GDQVVRQHQVHPEOH&HVPRXYHPHQWVSU{QHQWGHVGHX[F{WpVGH
O¶$WODQWLTXHOHUqJQHGHVH[SHUWVOHVLQJpQLHXUVVHXOVFDSDEOHVGH
VHUYLUO¶LQWpUrWFRPPXQJUkFHjOHXUUDWLRQDOLWpHWOHXUHI¿FDFLWp
(Q)UDQFH+HQUL)D\ROLQJpQLHXUFLYLOGHVPLQHV
SDUWLFLSHGqVjFHVPRXYHPHQWVHWSURSRVHGHPHWWUHVRQ
H[SHUWLVHDXVHUYLFHGHO¶eWDW,OGpEXWHVRQSDUFRXUVGHYLHHQ
j&RQVWDQWLQRSOHDORUVTXHVRQSqUHWUDYDLOOHHQ2ULHQWSRXUOH
FRPSWHG¶XQpWDEOLVVHPHQWPpWDOOXUJLTXHIUDQoDLV,OUHQWUHUDSLGH
PHQWHQ)UDQFHRLODFKqYHHQVHVpWXGHVHQVRUWDQWGLSO{Pp
GHO¶eFROHGHVPLQHVGH6DLQWeWLHQQH6DFDUULqUHG¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLO
FRPPHQFHGRQFHQDXVHLQGHV+RXLOOqUHVGH&RPPHQWU\
'qVLODFFqGHDXSRVWHGHGLUHFWHXUGHODPLQHTXLHVWHOOH
PrPHXQHFRPSRVDQWHGHODVRFLpWpGH&RPPHQWU\)RXUFKDPEDXOW
HW'HFD]HYLOOHO¶XQHGHVSOXVLPSRUWDQWHVHQWUHSULVHVPLQLqUHHW
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

PpWDOOXUJLTXHGH)UDQFH,OSUHQGHQPDLQODGHVWLQpHGHFHJURXSH
ORUVTX¶LOHVWQRPPpHQGLUHFWHXUJpQpUDOSRVWHTX¶LORFFXSH
MXVTX¶jVDGpPLVVLRQHQ¬FHWWHpSRTXHHWMXVTX¶jVHVGHUQLqUHV
KHXUHVHQLOQHGHPHXUHSDVVDQVDFWLYLWpFDULOIRQGHDYHF
VHVGLVFLSOHVHQOH&HQWUHG¶pWXGHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYHVTXLVH
UpXQLWFKDTXHVHPDLQHUXHGH9DXJLUDUGj3DULV&¶HVWGXUDQWFHWWH
GHUQLqUHSpULRGHGHVRQH[LVWHQFHHWjODVXLWHGHODSXEOLFDWLRQGH


/pRQ%OXP©/HWWUHVVXUODUpIRUPHJRXYHUQHPHQWDOHªRevue de Paris
QRYHPEUHGpFHPEUHS

.RQVWDQWLQRV&KDW]LV©7UDYDLOªLQ0LFKqOH5LRW6DUFH\7KRPDV%RXFKHWHW
$QWRLQH3LFRQGLUDictionnaire des utopies3DULV/DURXVVHS
 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

VRQ°XYUHPDMHXUHAdministration industrielle et généraleTX¶LO

FRQFHQWUHVDUpÀH[LRQVXUODUpIRUPHGHO¶eWDW
/HVpWXGHVG¶+HQUL)D\ROVXUOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWHWOHVG\VIRQF
WLRQQHPHQWVGHO¶eWDWHWGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFVIRQWVXLWHjVHVpFULWV
VXUO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQGHVHQWUHSULVHVFRQVWLWXDQWHQO¶HVSDFHG¶XQH
GpFHQQLHXQHDERQGDQWHOLWWpUDWXUH$LQVLHQWUHHW)D\RO
VLJQHGHQRPEUHX[DUWLFOHVjSURSRVGHFHTX¶LOQRPPH©O¶LQGXVWULD
OLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDWO¶LQWURGXFWLRQGDQVO¶eWDWHWVRQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
GHVSURFpGpVIDYRULVDQWOHVXFFqVGHVHQWUHSULVHVLQGXVWULHOOHV,OHVW
pJDOHPHQWLQYLWpjGHQRPEUHXVHVUHSULVHVFRPPHFRQIpUHQFLHUD¿Q
G¶H[SRVHUVHVYXHVDXVHLQGHVRFLpWpVVDYDQWHVFRPPHOH&HUFOH
FRPPHUFLDOHWLQGXVWULHOGH)UDQFH5DSLGHPHQWLODSSDUDvWFRPPH
XQH[SHUWHQRUJDQLVDWLRQHWEpQp¿FLHG¶XQHODUJHDXGLHQFH$LQVL
HQLOSDUWLFLSHjODFRPPLVVLRQGLULJpHSDU$QGUp&LWURsQ
FKDUJpHSDUOHPLQLVWUHGHV)LQDQFHVG¶pWXGLHUOHVTXHVWLRQVFRQFHU
QDQWO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQHWOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVPRQRSROHVGHVWDEDFV
HWGHVDOOXPHWWHV/¶H[SHUWLVHTX¶LOSURSRVHHVWWUqVRULJLQDOHFDU
LOQ¶HVWQLXQKDXWIRQFWLRQQDLUHQLXQKRPPHSROLWLTXHPDLVXQ
LQJpQLHXUFLYLOKDELWXpjSHQVHUOHVSUREOqPHVG¶RUJDQLVDWLRQHQ
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

WHUPHVGHUHQGHPHQW'RQDOG5HLGUHPDUTXHG¶DLOOHXUVHQTXH
)D\ROGpSODFHVRQDSSUpFLDWLRQFULWLTXHGHVHQWUHSULVHVSULYpHVDX[
VHUYLFHVSXEOLFV,ODQDO\VHGRQFOHVDIIDLUHVSXEOLTXHVjWUDYHUVXQH
JULOOHGHOHFWXUHTX¶LODIRUJpHWRXWDXORQJGHVDFDUULqUHLQGXVWULHOOH
/¶KLVWRULRJUDSKLHVHGpYHORSSDQWDXWRXUGHFHSHUVRQQDJHHWGH
VDSHQVpHHVWVXUWRXWOHIDLWGHVFKHUFKHXUVHQVFLHQFHVGHJHVWLRQ
-HDQ/RXLV3HDXFHOOHFRQWULEXHJUDQGHPHQWjFHPRXYHPHQWSDUOH


+)D\RO©$GPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXVWULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHªBulletin de la société de
l’industrie minéraleS

+)D\RO©/¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQGHO¶eWDWªCompte-rendu de la Société de l’In-
dustrie Minérale'LVWULFW3DULVLHQ

&RQIpUHQFHSURQRQFpHOHMHXGLMDQYLHUVXU©/DUpIRUPHDGPLQLVWUDWLYH
GHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFVª

'RQDOG5HLG©)D\ROH[FqVG¶KRQQHXURXH[FqVG¶LQGLJQLWpªRevue française
de gestionVHSWRFWS
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

ELDLVGHVHVQRPEUHX[DUWLFOHVHWGHO¶RXYUDJHFROOHFWLITX¶LOGLULJH
Henri Fayol, Inventeur des outils de gestion7VXQHR6DVDNLTXDQW
jOXLQRXVRIIUHXQHELRJUDSKLHVXU+HQUL)D\RO(QODUHYXH
Entreprises et histoireFRQVDFUHXQQXPpURVSpFLDOj)D\ROGDQV
OHTXHOJHVWLRQQDLUHVHWKLVWRULHQVSURSRVHQWGHVDQDO\VHVQHXYHV/D
FRQWULEXWLRQG¶<YHV&RKHQUHYLHQWQRWDPPHQWVXUODSODFHGHO¶DXWR
ULWpGXFKHIGDQVODWKpRULHID\ROLHQQHHWjFHWWHRFFDVLRQO¶KLVWRULHQ
DWWLUHQRWUHDWWHQWLRQVXUOHVWUDYDX[GH'RQDOG5HLGSHUPHWWDQW
DLQVLG¶REVHUYHU+HQUL)D\RODXWUDYDLO1pDQPRLQVSHXG¶KLVWR
ULHQVSUpVHQWHQWXQHDQDO\VHGHVpFULWVGHO¶LQJpQLHXUSRUWDQWVXU
©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW6HXO$ODLQ&KDWULRWGDQVOHQXPpUR
VSpFLDOG¶Entrepriseset histoire FRQVDFUpj)D\ROVHSHQFKHVXU
FHWWHWKpPDWLTXHPDLVHQIRFDOLVDQWVRQDWWHQWLRQVXUO¶pFKROLPLWp
GHVWKpRULHVID\ROLHQQHV
6LFHVpFULWVQRXVRIIUHQWGHSUpFLHXVHVLQIRUPDWLRQVHWG¶LQ
WpUHVVDQWVSRLQWVGHYXHLOVQHQRXVSHUPHWWHQWSDVG¶DSSUpFLHU
OHGLDJQRVWLFGH)D\ROTXLVHSRVHHQH[SHUWGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQ
1RWUHDPELWLRQDXFRXUVGHVTXHOTXHVOLJQHVVXLYDQWHVHVWGRQF
GHPHWWUHHQOXPLqUHOHGLDJQRVWLFGHO¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOVXUO¶eWDWHW
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

VRQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQHQVRXOLJQDQWQRWDPPHQWFHTX¶LODSSHOOHOHV
PDODGLHVpWDWLVWHV1RXVHVVD\HURQVpJDOHPHQWGHFRPSUHQGUHOHV
UHPqGHVTX¶LOSURSRVHDXUHJDUGGHVRQH[SpULHQFHSURIHVVLRQQHOOH

-HDQ/RXLV3HDXFHOOHHenri Fayol, Inventeur des outils de gestion3DULV



(FRQRPLFD

7VXQHR6DVDNLLe pionnier du management contemporain : Henri Fayol, sa
vie, son management stratégique et sa théorie du management5RQpR7RN\R


Entreprises et histoire+HQUL)D\ROQƒGpFHPEUH

'5HLG©*HQqVHGXID\ROLVPHªSociologie du travailQƒS
Id©)D\ROH[FqVG¶KRQQHXURXH[FqVG¶LQGLJQLWpªRevue française de gestion,
VHSWRFWSIdThe Miners of Decazeville: A Genealogy of
Desindustrialisation&DPEULGJH0DVV+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

$&KDWULRW©)D\ROOHVID\ROLHQVHWO¶LPSRVVLEOHUpIRUPHGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
GXUDQWO¶HQWUHGHX[JXHUUHVªEntreprises et histoireQƒS
 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

FRQVWLWXDQWOHIRQGHPHQWGHVDUpÀH[LRQ1RXVGpEXWHURQVQRWUH
SURSRVHQFRQVLGpUDQWODFRPSDUDLVRQTX¶HIIHFWXH)D\ROHQWUHO¶HQ
WUHSULVHHWO¶(WDW3XLVQRXVQRXVSHQFKHURQVVXFFHVVLYHPHQWVXUOHV
JUDQGHV©PDODGLHVpWDWLVWHVªOHFORLVRQQHPHQWO¶HQFRPEUHPHQW
HWHQ¿QO¶LQVWDELOLWp

/¶eWDWXQHRUJDQLVDWLRQFRPPHXQHDXWUH"

¬SUHPLqUHYXHO¶eWDWHVWjPLOOHOLHXHVGHVDXWUHVRUJDQLVDWLRQV
,ODSSDUDvWHQHIIHWpWUDQJHGHFRPSDUHUFHWWHVWUXFWXUHjWRXWH
DXWUH1pDQPRLQV+HQUL)D\ROQ¶KpVLWHSDVjFRQIURQWHUO¶eWDWDX[
DXWUHVFRUSVVRFLDX[HWjHQGpJDJHUGHVORLVTX¶LOFRQVLGqUHFRPPH
LPPXDEOHVjO¶LPDJHGHVORLVUpJLVVDQWOHVSKpQRPqQHVPpFDQLTXHV

Une conception mécaniste des corps sociaux

/HSRVWXODWGHWUDYDLOODFUR\DQFHGHYULRQVQRXVpFULUHGH)D\RO
UpVLGHGDQVVDYLVLRQPpFDQLVWHGXFRUSVVRFLDO%LHQDYDQWODSXEOL
FDWLRQG¶Administration industrielle et généraleLOQ¶HVWSDVUDUHTXH
O¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOFRPSDUHOHVRUJDQLVDWLRQVLQGXVWULHOOHVDXFRUSV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

KXPDLQ/DFRQFHSWLRQGXIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXFRUSVKXPDLQPLVH
HQDYDQWSDU)D\ROQ¶HVWSDVVDQVUDSSHOHUFHOOHGHOD0HWWULHHWGH
VRQFpOqEUHRXYUDJHL’Homme-machine/¶DQDORJLHHPSOR\pHSDU
OHWHFKQLFLHQGH&RPPHQWU\QRXVOLYUHGRQFODYLVLRQGHGHX[FRUSV
UpJLVSDUGHVORLVPpFDQLTXHV$XVHLQGHVRQGLVFRXUVGXMXLQ
DXFRQJUqVLQWHUQDWLRQDOGHVPLQHVHWGHODPpWDOOXUJLHLODVVL
PLOHOHU{OHG¶XQVHUYLFHDGPLQLVWUDWLIjFHOXLGXV\VWqPHQHUYHX[
©&RPPHOHVHUYLFHDGPLQLVWUDWLIG¶XQHVRFLpWpLQGXVWULHOOHOH
V\VWqPHQHUYHX[GHO¶KRPPHQ¶HVWSDVYLVLEOHjO¶REVHUYDWHXU
VXSHU¿FLHOVHVDFWHVQHWRPEHQWSDVGLUHFWHPHQWVRXVOHVVHQVHW
FHSHQGDQWOHVPXVFOHVELHQTX¶LOVSRVVqGHQWXQHpQHUJLHSURSUH
FHVVHQWGHVHFRQWUDFWHUVLOHV\VWqPHQHUYHX[FHVVHG¶DJLU6DQV
VRQ DFWLRQ OH FRUSV KXPDLQ GHYLHQW XQH PDVVH LQHUWH WRXW

-XOLHQ2IIUD\GHOD0HWWULH, L’Homme-machine/H\GH,PSULPHULH(OLH/X]DF


¿OV
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

RUJDQHGpSHLQWUDSLGHPHQW'DQVWRXVOHVRUJDQHVHWGDQVWRXWHV
OHVSDUWLHVGHFKDTXHRUJDQHOHV\VWqPHQHUYHX[HVWSUpVHQWHW
DFWLI3DUGHVFHOOXOHVHWGHV¿EUHVLOUHFXHLOOHGHVVHQVDWLRQVHW
OHVWUDQVPHWG¶DERUGjGHVFHQWUHVQHUYHX[LQIpULHXUVFHQWUHV
UpÀH[HVSXLVGHOjV¶LO\DOLHXDXFHUYHDX'HFHVFHQWUHVRX
GXFHUYHDXSDUWHQVXLWHO¶RUGUHTXLSDUXQFKHPLQLQYHUVHDUULYH
DXPXVFOHTXLGRLWH[pFXWHUOHPRXYHPHQWª
)D\ROPDQLIHVWHXQUDWLRQDOLVPHVFLHQWL¿TXHjWRXWHpSUHXYH
Q¶KpVLWDQWSDVjDI¿UPHUTX¶jO¶LPDJHGHVVFLHQFHVPpFDQLTXHVOHV
SKpQRPqQHVVRFLDX[VRQWVRXPLVjGHVORLVQDWXUHOOHVLQGpSHQ
GDQWHVGHODYRORQWpGHVKRPPHV/DGRFWULQHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHTX¶LO
SXEOLHHQDGRQFSRXUDPELWLRQGHSURSRVHUGHV©ORLVIRQGD
PHQWDOHVªGHVWLQpHVjDPpOLRUHUOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVPDFKLQHV
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHVUpJLVVDQWOHVFRUSVVRFLDX[/¶LQJpQLHXUGHVKRXLO
OqUHVVHIpOLFLWHGHVDGpPDUFKHTX¶LOSODFHGDQVODOLJQpHGHOD
PpWKRGHH[SpULPHQWDOHGH&ODXGH%HUQDUGGHODPpWKRGHSRVLWLYH
G¶$XJXVWH&RPWHHWGHVSULQFLSHVGH5HQp'HVFDUWHV'qV
)D\ROSRXVVHVDUpÀH[LRQDXGHOjGXVLPSOHFDGUHGHO¶HQWUHSULVH
(QHIIHWOHVREVHUYDWLRQVTX¶LODHIIHFWXpHVGDQVWRXWHVOHVEUDQFKHV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

GHO¶DFWLYLWpKXPDLQHSURXYHQWVHORQOXLTXHOHVXFFqVGHFHUWDLQV
FRUSVVRFLDX[HVWOHIUXLWGHTXHOTXHVORLVGpFRXODQWGHODQDWXUH
KXPDLQH,OQ¶KpVLWHSDVjFRPSDUHUOHFKHIGHODSOXVKXPEOHGHV
IDPLOOHVDX[FRQGXFWHXUVG¶DUPpHHWDX[FKHIVG¶eWDW7RXVVXLYHQW
OHVPrPHVUqJOHVTXLDSSDUDLVVHQWFRPPHGHVQpFHVVLWpV6LFHV
UqJOHVQ¶RQWULHQGHP\VWpULHXVHVOHUpVXOWDWGpSHQGEHDXFRXSVHORQ
)D\ROGHODPDQLqUHGHV¶HQVHUYLU$LQVLTXHOTXHVDQQpHVDSUqV


+)D\RO©&RPPXQLFDWLRQRUDOHG¶+HQUL)D\ROORUVGHODVpDQFHVROHQQHOOHGH
FO{WXUHMXLQªBulletin de la société de l’industrie minérale

&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)'5
QRWHVPDQXVFULWHVFDUQHWGHQRWHV+RPPHVSULQFLSHV
+)D\ROGLU©$GPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXVWULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHO¶pYHLOGHO¶HVSULW


SXEOLFªBulletin de la société de l’industrie minérale

&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)'5


QRWHVPDQXVFULWHVFDUQHWGHQRWHV+RPPHVSULQFLSHVMXLOOHW


 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

DYRLUIRUPXOpFHFRQVWDWLOQ¶KpVLWHSDVjFRPSDUHUOHVVHUYLFHV
SXEOLFVjXQFRUSVVRFLDOG\VIRQFWLRQQDQWFDUVDWrWHOHPLQLVWqUH
HVWPDOFRQVWLWXpH6¶LOUHSURFKHQRWDPPHQWjO¶eWDWXQPDQTXH
G¶XQLWpHWGHFRRUGLQDWLRQGDQVODFRQGXLWHGHVDIIDLUHVSXEOLTXHVLO
QHPpFRQQDvWSDVOHVGLI¿FXOWpVGHFHWDFWHXU&¶HVWSRXUTXRL)D\RO
UDSSURFKHODVLWXDWLRQGHO¶eWDWQRQSDVGHODSHWLWHHQWUHSULVHRX
GHODIDPLOOHPDLVGHODJUDQGHHQWUHSULVH

L’État, une société anonyme

0DOJUpFHWWHFRQFHSWLRQPpFDQLVWHGHVFRUSVVRFLDX[)D\RO
QHIDLWSDVG¶DPDOJDPHHQWUHOHVRUJDQLVDWLRQV6¶LOGLIIpUHQFLH
FHVVWUXFWXUHVLOQHSUHQGSDVSRXUUXSWXUHOHXUDSSDUWHQDQFHDX
PRQGHGHO¶HQWUHSULVHRXDXVHUYLFHSXEOLF)D\ROHIIHFWXHHQHIIHW
XQHGLVWLQFWLRQSUHQDQWHQFRPSWHODWDLOOHGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQHWOD
FRPSOH[LWpGHVDIIDLUHVJpUpHV,OQ¶KpVLWHG¶DLOOHXUVSDVjGLUHHQ

© 8Q IDLW LQWpUHVVDQW HVW TXH PDOJUp O¶LQILQLH GLYHUVLWp GHV
HQWUHSULVHV WRXV OHV FRUSV VRFLDX[ GH PrPH LPSRUWDQFH
QXPpULTXHRQWHQWUHHX[XQHJUDQGHUHVVHPEODQFHH[WpULHXUH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

TXLV¶H[SOLTXHSDUO¶LGHQWLWpGHVIRQFWLRQVGDQVOHVHQWUHSULVHV
GHPrPHHVSqFHRXSDUO¶H[LVWHQFHG¶XQHPDMRULWpGHIRQFWLRQV
VHPEODEOHVGDQVOHVHQWUHSULVHVG¶HVSqFHGLIIpUHQWHª
&¶HVWSRXUTXRLjVHV\HX[O¶eWDWQHSHXWrWUHFRPSDUpjXQH
SHWLWHHQWUHSULVHPDLVjXQHVRFLpWpDQRQ\PH,OHVWLPHTX¶DXVHLQ
GHVSHWLWHVVWUXFWXUHVRQDWWDFKHXQHLPSRUWDQFHH[DJpUpHDX[
TXHVWLRQVGHSHUVRQQHDORUVTX¶DXVHLQG¶XQHJUDQGHHQWUHSULVH
G¶XQVHUYLFHSXEOLFRXG¶XQeWDWPRGHUQHOHYROXPHO¶pWHQGXHHW
ODFRPSOH[LWpGHVDIIDLUHVLPSRVHQWG¶DXWUHVSUDWLTXHV$XUHJDUG


+)D\RO©/DUpIRUPHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFV&RQIpUHQFHGH
0+HQUL)D\ROªCommerce et industrieQƒMDQYLHUS

+)D\RO©&RQIpUHQFHVIDLWHVOHVHWPDLVXUO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXV
WULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHªeFROHVXSpULHXUHGHJXHUUHS
/0GX&URX]HW©8QHQWUHWLHQDYHF0+HQUL)D\RO/HVGpYHORSSHPHQWV


DFWXHOVGHODGRFWULQHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHªLa chronique socialeMDQYLHU

 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

GHVRQH[SpULHQFHSURIHVVLRQQHOOH+HQUL)D\ROVHSUpVHQWHFRPPH
XQH[SHUWFDSDEOHGHWUDQVIpUHUOHVSUDWLTXHVGHO¶LQGXVWULHjO¶eWDW
(QVFLHQWL¿TXHGHO¶LQGXVWULHLOFRQFHSWXDOLVHOHMXLQDX
FRXUVG¶XQHUpXQLRQGX&HQWUHG¶pWXGHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYHVOHIRQFWLRQ
QHPHQWGHODJUDQGHHQWUHSULVHHWGHO¶eWDW&HVGHX[RUJDQLVDWLRQV
VRQWVFKpPDWLVpHVVRXVODIRUPHGHGHX[S\UDPLGHVXQLHVSDUOHXUV
VRPPHWV/DS\UDPLGHVXSpULHXUHFRPSUHQGSRXUO¶eWDWOHVpOHF
WHXUVOH3DUOHPHQWHWOHSUpVLGHQWGHOD5pSXEOLTXHDORUVTXHSRXU
ODVRFLpWpDQRQ\PHLOHVWTXHVWLRQGXFRQVHLOG¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQHW
GHO¶DVVHPEOpHJpQpUDOH/DS\UDPLGHLQIpULHXUHUHSUpVHQWHSRXU
O¶eWDWOHVPLQLVWUHVHWOHVIRQFWLRQQDLUHVHWSRXUODJUDQGHHQWUH
SULVHOHFRUSVVRFLDOG¶H[pFXWLRQ/HSRLQWGHUHQFRQWUHHQWUHOHV
GHX[VRPPHWVRFFXSHXQHSODFHVLQJXOLqUHGDQVO¶HVSULWGH)D\RO,O
V¶DJLWHQHIIHWGXSRLQWFRQYHUJHQWGHOD¿JXUHWRXWHVOHVDFWLRQV
GHODS\UDPLGHVXSpULHXUHYRQWHQGLUHFWLRQGHFHSRLQWDORUVTXH
WRXVOHVRUGUHVGHVWLQpVjODS\UDPLGHLQIpULHXUHSDUWHQWGHFHSRLQW
&HOXLFLV\PEROLVHODGLUHFWLRQJpQpUDOHGHODVRFLpWpDQRQ\PHRX
OHSUpVLGHQWGX&RQVHLOORUVTX¶LOHVWTXHVWLRQGHODFKRVHSXEOLTXH
¬O¶LPDJHGHODGpPDUFKHLQWHOOHFWXHOOHTXLO¶DJXLGpWRXWDXORQJ
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

GHVDFDUULqUH+HQUL)D\ROV¶DSSXLHVXUO¶H[SpULHQFHDFFXPXOpHDX
¿OGHVDQQpHV$LQVLLOQRXVUDSSHOOHHQTXHVHVUpÀH[LRQVVXU
O¶RUJDQLVDWLRQGHVFRUSVVRFLDX[UHVWHQWOHIUXLWGHVRQREVHUYDWLRQ
©3HQGDQWTXHM¶REVHUYDLVGHSUqVO¶LQGXVWULHPLQLqUHHWPpWDOOXU
JLTXHPRQDWWHQWLRQVHSRUWDLWDXVVLVXUGHVHQWUHSULVHVGHWRXWHV
VRUWHVDLQVLTXHVXUODIDPLOOHHWVXUO¶eWDW3HXjSHXMHUHFRQ
QDLVVDLVTXHFHUWDLQVSULQFLSHVDGPLQLVWUDWLIVVRQWDSSOLFDEOHV
jWRXWHVOHVHQWUHSULVHVTXHOVTXHVRLHQWOHXUQDWXUHOHXUEXWHW
OHXUVSURSRUWLRQVª
/HVSULQFLSHVTX¶LOGpJDJHDXFRXUVGHVHVREVHUYDWLRQVHWGHVHV
H[SpULPHQWDWLRQVYDOHQWjVHV\HX[DXVVLELHQSRXUO¶LQGXVWULHTXH


&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)ELV'5
FDUQHWVFLHQWLDMXLQ
+)D\ROGLU©$GPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXVWULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHO¶pYHLOGHO¶HVSULW


SXEOLFªBulletin de la société de l’industrie minérale

 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

SRXUO¶eWDW6LOHVSULQFLSHVVRQWKRUVGHGLVFXVVLRQLOQ¶HQHVWSDV
GHPrPHSRXUOHVSURFpGpVHWOHVPR\HQVG¶H[pFXWLRQ&HWWHPLVH
HQ°XYUHHVWGRQFSRXU)D\ROÀXFWXDQWHFDUHOOHGpSHQGGHVSURSRU
WLRQVHWGHODQDWXUHGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQGXPLOLHXGHVKRPPHVGHV
FLUFRQVWDQFHV«&¶HVWHQUpDOLWpGDQVO¶pODERUDWLRQGHFHVSURFpGpV
TXHV¶H[SULPHODVLQJXODULWpGHVRUJDQLVDWLRQVHWF¶HVWjFHWLQVWDQW
TX¶LOIDXWUDSSURFKHUO¶eWDWGHODJUDQGHHQWUHSULVH6HORQ)D\ROOD
FRQIHFWLRQGHFHVSURFpGpVGRLWrWUHLQVSLUpHSDUO¶H[SpULHQFHLO
IDXWHQWRXWHVFLUFRQVWDQFHVVHUpIpUHUDX[SUpFpGHQWVVHPEODEOHV
&¶HVWSRXUTXRLO¶LQGXVWULHGRLWVHUYLUGHPRGqOHjO¶eWDWFDUHOOHD
VXDFFXPXOHUDX¿OGHVRQH[LVWHQFHGHQRPEUHXVHVH[SpULHQFHV
/¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOPHWHQDYDQWOHVSURFpGpVFRXURQQpVSDUO¶H[Sp
ULHQFHHWVDQVVXUSULVHLOpQXPqUHOHVRXWLOVTX¶LODIRUJpVDXFRXUV
GHVDFDUULqUHLQGXVWULHOOHSURJUDPPHG¶DFWLRQFRQIpUHQFHGHV
FKHIVGHVHUYLFHWDEOHDXG¶RUJDQLVDWLRQSDVVHUHOOHHWFKURQRPp
WUDJH6HXOFHGHUQLHUSRLQWHVWHPSUXQWpj7D\ORU
/¶LQGXVWULHHVWDXVVLDX[\HX[GH)D\ROXQPRGqOHFDUjO¶LQ
YHUVHGHO¶eWDWHOOHQHPpFRQQDvWSDVOHV©ORLVQDWXUHOOHVªUpJLV
VDQWO¶DFWLYLWpGHVFRUSVVRFLDX[/HVHQWUHSULVHVGRLYHQWHQHIIHW
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

YDLQFUHRXPRXULUUpXVVLURXIDLUHIDLOOLWH/HPpULWHHWOHUpVXOWDW
VRQWDLQVLFHQWUDX[GDQVO¶HQWUHSULVHSULYpHFRQWUDLUHPHQWjO¶eWDW
TXLHVWVHORQ)D\ROLUUHVSRQVDEOH¬O¶RFFDVLRQGHO¶HQTXrWHVXUOHV
377TX¶LOPqQHDXGpEXWGHVDQQpHVO¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOGpYH
ORSSHO¶LGpHGHO¶LUUHVSRQVDELOLWp¿QDQFLqUHHWPRUDOHGXVHUYLFH
SXEOLFHWGHO¶eWDW/¶LUUHVSRQVDELOLWpUqJQHUDLWGRQFDXVHLQGHV
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQVFDUVHORQ)D\ROOHVVDQFWLRQVVRQWDEVHQWHVHQFDV
GHPDXYDLVUpVXOWDWVHWFHFLjWRXVOHVpFKHORQVGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQ
$LQVLLOFRQVLGqUHOHU{OHGHVLQVSHFWHXUVGHV377FRPPHSDUIDL
WHPHQWLQHI¿FDFHFDUPDOJUpOHVLUUpJXODULWpVFRQVWDWpHVFHODQH
GRQQHOLHXjDXFXQHVDQFWLRQ/HPLQLVWUHQ¶pFKDSSHSDVjOD

+)D\RO©/¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQGHO¶eWDWªCompte-rendu de la Société de l’In-



dustrie MinéraleDUWFLW
+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTT3DULV'XQRGS

 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

FULWLTXH(QHIIHWORUVTX¶XQHTXHVWLRQSHXWHQJDJHUODUHVSRQVD
ELOLWpGXPLQLVWUHRQODVRXPHWjXQHFRPPLVVLRQHWOHPLQLVWUH
GLVSDUDvWGHUULqUHFHWWHFRPPLVVLRQ1pDQPRLQVOHJULHIOHSOXV
LPSRUWDQWFRQFHUQHODUHVSRQVDELOLWp¿QDQFLqUH/HVSHUWHVGHV377
Q¶DWWHLJQHQWSDVOHPLQLVWUHFDUF¶HVWOHFRQWULEXDEOHTXLHQGRVVH
FHVSHUWHV)D\ROUHYLHQWVXUFHWWHLGpHORUVGHVDSDUWLFLSDWLRQj
ODFRPPLVVLRQ&LWURsQHQHWDMRXWHTX¶XQHPDXYDLVHJHVWLRQ
SXEOLTXHHVWV\QRQ\PHG¶DXJPHQWDWLRQGHVFKDUJHVSRXUOHFRQWUL
EXDEOH/DUHVSRQVDELOLWp¿QDQFLqUHSqVHGRQFVXUXQWLHUVUHQGDQW
DLQVLODIDLOOLWHLPSRVVLEOH&HSHQGDQWSRXUOXLOHVVDQFWLRQV
SpFXQLDLUHVQHUqJOHQWULHQ,OLQVLVWHVXUO¶DPRXUGXWUDYDLOELHQ
IDLWHWGXGHYRLUDFFRPSOLDXWUHPHQWGLWODUHVSRQVDELOLWpPRUDOH
GHVDJHQWVGHO¶eWDW,OV¶DJLWGRQFG¶XQHFULWLTXHjSHLQHYRLOpHGH
ODPRUDOHGHVDJHQWVGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFVHWQRWDPPHQWGHVFKHIV
HWGHOHXUDXWRULWp

'pVHQFRPEUHUHWGpFORLVRQQHUO¶eWDW

6LODVRFLpWpDQRQ\PHUHVWHXQPRGqOHSHUWLQHQWLOHVWFHSHQ
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

GDQWLUUpDOLVWHGHWUDQVSRVHULPPpGLDWHPHQWOHVSULQFLSHVG¶XQH
HQWUHSULVHDX[DIIDLUHVSXEOLTXHV,OIDXWHQHIIHWVHORQO¶LQJpQLHXU
FLYLOWHQLUFRPSWHGHVLQÀXHQFHVVSpFLDOHVDJLVVDQWVXUO¶RUJDQLVD
WLRQHWOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQV&¶HVWSRXUTXRLLO
FRQYLHQWGHOXWWHUFRQWUHOHV©PDODGLHVpWDWLVWHVªDYDQWG¶DSSOLTXHU
OHVSURFpGpVQpVGHO¶H[SpULHQFHLQGXVWULHOOH

Ibid.S


Ibid., S



+)D\RO©1RWHGH0)D\ROªRapport présenté par M. André Citroën au nom
de la commission chargée d’étudier les questions concernant l’organisation et
le fonctionnement des monopoles des tabacs et des allumettes3DULV,PSULPHULH
QDWLRQDOHS
+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit

 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

Alléger « l’entreprise gouvernementale »

/HGpVHQFRPEUHPHQWGHO¶eWDWFRQVWLWXHSRXU)D\ROXQHSULRULWp
,OHVWHQHIIHWLQFRQFHYDEOHGHGLULJHUOHVDIIDLUHVSXEOLTXHVDYHF
HI¿FLHQFHDORUVTXHO¶eWDWYRLWGHSXLVOD3UHPLqUH*XHUUHPRQGLDOH
VRQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQSUROLIpUHU$LQVLO¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOSRVHODTXHV
WLRQGXELHQIRQGpGHODJHVWLRQpWDWLTXHGHFHUWDLQVVHFWHXUVLQGXV
WULHOV3OXVJpQpUDOHPHQWLOSHQVHTXHO¶eWDWHVWGDQVODVLWXDWLRQ
G¶XQFKHIVHODLVVDQWDEVRUEHUSDUOHVGpWDLOV,OHVWQRWDPPHQW
WUqVVHQVLEOHjO¶DXJPHQWDWLRQGXQRPEUHGHGpFLVLRQQDLUHVDXVHLQ
GHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ$LQVLORUVGHVRQHQTXrWHVXUOHV377)D\RO
Q¶KpVLWHSDVjIXVWLJHUXQHGLUHFWLRQVHORQOXLWURSQRPEUHXVH
/HGpVHQFRPEUHPHQWGHO¶eWDWHVWGRQFDYDQWWRXWV\QRQ\PHGH
UpGXFWLRQGXSHUVRQQHOGHGLUHFWLRQ
)D\ROSUpFRQLVHO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGHFHWWHORJLTXHjODSUHPLqUHGLUHF
WLRQJpQpUDOHGH)UDQFHOHJRXYHUQHPHQW'qVLOSUpWHQGTXH
OHQRPEUHGHPLQLVWUHVHVWWURSLPSRUWDQWHWTXHFHODQXLWDXWUDYDLO
GXSUpVLGHQWGX&RQVHLO¬O¶LPDJHGHVVRFLpWpVDQRQ\PHVO¶DQFLHQ
GLUHFWHXUGH&RPPHQWU\)RXUFKDPEDXOWHW'HFD]HYLOOHSUpWHQGTXH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

OHJRXYHUQHPHQWGHYUDLWrWUHFRPSRVpGHVL[PHPEUHVPD[LPXP
+HQUL)D\ROIRQGHVRQMXJHPHQWVXUVRQH[SpULHQFHSHUVRQQHOOH
FDULOSUpVHQWHOHVSUREOqPHVTXHVXVFLWHOHWURSJUDQGQRPEUHGH
PLQLVWUHVDXUHJDUGGHODSRVLWLRQGXSUpVLGHQWGX&RQVHLO&HOOHFL
HVWGDQVVRQHVSULWVHPEODEOHDXSRVWHGHGLUHFWHXUJpQpUDOG¶XQH
VRFLpWpDQRQ\PHIRQFWLRQTXLHVWODVLHQQHMXVTX¶HQ8QFKHI
Q¶DGRQFVHORQ)D\ROTX¶XQSHWLWQRPEUHGHVXERUGRQQpVGLUHFWV
GHX[WURLVRXTXDWUHSDUIRLVFLQTRXVL[

)%ODQFSDLQ©/HVFDKLHUVLQpGLWVG¶+HQUL)D\ROªRevue management-France


QƒMXLQSS
+HQUL)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit


+)D\RO©/¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQGHO¶eWDWªCompte-rendu de la Société de l’In-



dustrie MinéraleDUWFLW

+)D\RO©/DUpIRUPHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFV&RQIpUHQFHGH
0+HQUL)D\ROªCommerce et industrieQƒMDQYLHUS
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

8QHWHOOHORLDVHORQO¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOSOXVLHXUVUDLVRQVG¶rWUH
7RXWG¶DERUGOHFKHIGRLWVDYRLUFHTX¶LOSHXWDWWHQGUHGHVHVFROODER
UDWHXUVTXHOOHFRQ¿DQFHSHXWLOOHXUDFFRUGHU"&HWWHFRQQDLVVDQFH
HVWGLI¿FLOHjDFTXpULUHOOHH[LJHGXWHPSVHWGRQFXQHFHUWDLQH
VWDELOLWpGXSHUVRQQHOHWHOOHQ¶HVWSRVVLEOHTX¶DYHFXQSHWLWQRPEUH
GHVXERUGRQQpVGLUHFWV'HSOXVDXVHLQG¶XQFRUSVVRFLDOGHJUDQGH
DPSOHXUOHGLUHFWHXUJpQpUDOVHFRQVDFUHjODFRQGXLWHGHVVHUYLFHV
SDUOHELDLVG¶HQWUHWLHQVSDUWLFXOLHUVRXGHUpXQLRQVDYHFOHVFKHIVGH
VHUYLFH6¶LOQ¶\DSDVSOXVGHFLQTRXVL[FKHIVGHVHUYLFHOHGLUHF
WHXUJpQpUDOSHXWFRQVDFUHUjFKDFXQG¶HX[jPLQXWHVSDUMRXU
VLFHQRPEUHHVWSOXVLPSRUWDQWOHVHQWUHWLHQVVHUpGXLVHQWGDQJH
UHXVHPHQW/¶RUJDQLVDWLRQFRXUWDORUVXQULVTXHFRQVLGpUDEOHOHV
VHUYLFHVGHYLHQQHQWpWDQFKHVHWIRQFWLRQQHQWLQGpSHQGDPPHQWOHV
XQVGHVDXWUHV(Q¿QOHWURSJUDQGQRPEUHGHPLQLVWUHVHPSrFKH
OHSUpVLGHQWGX&RQVHLOG¶LQWHUYHQLUHI¿FDFHPHQWGDQVODFRQGXLWH
GHVGLYHUVPLQLVWqUHV'HIDLWFKDTXHPLQLVWUHGHYLHQWSHXjSHX
LQGpSHQGDQWGDQVVRQGpSDUWHPHQWHWOHGLULJHWURSVRXYHQWVDQV
WHQLUFRPSWHGHODUpSHUFXVVLRQGHVHVDFWHVVXUODPDUFKHJpQpUDOH
GXJRXYHUQHPHQW)D\ROIDLWGRQFGHODSUROLIpUDWLRQGXSHUVRQ
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

QHOGHGLUHFWLRQXQYLFHGXTXHOGpFRXOHQWGHQRPEUHXVHVPDODGLHV
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHV,OSUpFRQLVHG¶DLOOHXUVD¿Q©G¶LQGXVWULDOLVHUª
O¶eWDWHQSURIRQGHXUGHGpVHQFRPEUHUOHVPLQLVWqUHVHWQ¶KpVLWH
SDVHQjpFULUH
©&RPPHQWVHIDLWLOTXHGHWHOVDEXVSHUVLVWHQWHWDLOOHQWPrPH
HQ JUDQGLVVDQW DYHF GHV PLQLVWUHV pFODLUpV HW GHV IRQFWLRQ
QDLUHVJpQpUDOHPHQWKRQQrWHVLQWHOOLJHQWVFRQQDLVVDQWELHQOD
WHFKQLTXHGHOHXUIRQFWLRQHWSOHLQVGHERQQHYRORQWp&¶HVWTX¶LO
QHVXI¿WSDVG¶RUGRQQHUHWGHGpVLUHUXQHUpIRUPHSRXUTX¶HOOH
V¶DFFRPSOLVVH/HVGpIDXWVTX¶RQYHXWH[WLUSHUOHVPDODGLHVTX¶RQ
YHXWJXpULURQWJpQpUDOHPHQWGHVFDXVHVSURIRQGHV/HVPHPEUHV
G¶XQFRUSVVRFLDOQHIRQFWLRQQHQWSDVELHQTXDQGODWrWHHVWPDO
FRQVWLWXpH2UODWrWHLFLF¶HVWOHPLQLVWqUHª


Ibid.
Ibid.

 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

8QHIRLVHQFRUH)D\ROVRXOLJQHOHQRPEUHWURSLPSRUWDQWGH
VXERUGRQQpVGLUHFWVTXLWUDYDLOOHQWDYHFXQPLQLVWUHHWSOXVJpQp
UDOHPHQWOHQRPEUHH[FHVVLIGHIRQFWLRQQDLUHV°XYUDQWGDQVOHV
PLQLVWqUHV,OGpQRQFHODGLOXWLRQGHVUHVSRQVDELOLWpVHWQRWDPPHQW
ODPXOWLSOLFDWLRQGHVFRPPLVVLRQVFRQVXOWDWLYHVFHQVpHVpFODLUHUOH
PLQLVWUHGDQVVHVFKRL[2UFHOOHVFLQ¶RQWVRXYHQWDXFXQHFRPSp
WHQFHHWDXFXQHSUpSDUDWLRQGHVTXHVWLRQVDERUGpHV$XGHOjGH
FHWWHLPSUpSDUDWLRQFHODGpWRXUQHO¶pWDWPDMRUGXPLQLVWUHGHVD
UHVSRQVDELOLWpHQQHVLJQDQWSDVOHVUDSSRUWVVXUOHVTXHOVVHIRQGHQW
OHVFKRL[PLQLVWpULHOV&HWWHRUJDQLVDWLRQUHPHWDXVVLHQFDXVH
UpJXOLqUHPHQWOHVOLHQVGHVXERUGLQDWLRQVTXLGHYUDLHQWVHORQ)D\RO
UpJXOHUOHVUHODWLRQVHQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWHVFRPSRVDQWHVGHO¶eWDW

+LpUDUFKLVHUHWÀXLGL¿HUOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHO¶eWDW
7RXWDXORQJGHVDUpÀH[LRQVXU©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW
+HQUL)D\ROUHPHWHQFDXVHOHVOLHQVKLpUDUFKLTXHVXQLVVDQWOHV
GLIIpUHQWVPHPEUHVGX&RQVHLOGHVPLQLVWUHV,OIXVWLJHQRWDPPHQW
O¶DEVHQFHG¶XQLWpGHGLUHFWLRQ
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

©'DQVXQUpJLPHUpSXEOLFDLQOH&RQVHLOGHV0LQLVWUHVVHXO
SHXW rWUH QRQ SDV WRXW OH JRXYHUQHPHQW PDLV VD SOXV KDXWH
H[SUHVVLRQ«2UQRWUH&RQVHLOGHV0LQLVWUHVQHFRQVWLWXHSDV
XQFRUSVYRLOjOHIDLW2QDSDUIRLVFRPSDUpOHVHQWUHWLHQVGH
QRV PLQLVWUHV JUDYHPHQW DVVHPEOpV DX FRQVHLO DXWRXU G¶XQH
WDEOHRYDOHDX[HQWUHWLHQVHQWUHPHPEUHVG¶XQFHUFOH,UUHVSHFW
HWYpULWp(WYUDLPHQWFRPPHQWOHVGLVFXVVLRQV\VHUDLHQWHOOHV
V\VWpPDWLTXHVHWFRRUGRQQpHV"3RLQWG¶RUGUHGXMRXUSRLQWGH
SURFqVSRLQWG¶DUFKLYHVHWOHVGpFLVLRQVSULVHVVRQWDEDQGRQQpHV
j OD PpPRLUH GH FKDTXH PLQLVWUH j O¶KHXUH GX GpMHXQHU /H
3UpVLGHQWGX&RQVHLOHVWVXUWRXWXQSHUVRQQDJHRUDWRLUHULHQ


+)D\RO©&RQIpUHQFHVIDLWHVOHVHWPDLVXUO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXV
WULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHªDUWFLW
$OEHUW6FKDW]L’entreprise gouvernementale et son administration3DULV


*UDVVHWSSUpIDFHG¶+HQUL)D\RO
+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit

 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

Q¶HVWRUJDQLVpDXWRXUGHOXLSRXUTX¶LOVRLWXQFKHIG¶H[SORLWDWLRQ
XQKRPPHG¶DFWLRQjODIDoRQGXGLUHFWHXUGHTXHOTX¶LPPHQVH
DIIDLUHLQGXVWULHOOHª
&HWWHDEVHQFHGHOLHQVGHVXERUGLQDWLRQHQWUHOHSUpVLGHQWGX
&RQVHLOHWOHVPLQLVWUHVV¶H[SULPHjWUDYHUVO¶LQGpSHQGDQFHDGPLQLV
WUDWLYHGHVVHFRQGV&HX[FLVRQWHQHIIHWHQWLqUHPHQWOLEUHVGDQV
ODJHVWLRQGHOHXUGpSDUWHPHQWHWVHVRXFLHQWSHXGHODFRRUGLQDWLRQ
GHVDFWLRQVHQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWHVFRPSRVDQWHVGXJRXYHUQHPHQW
'DQVGHWHOOHVFRQGLWLRQVLOQ¶HVWSDVSRVVLEOHSRXUOHSUpVLGHQWGX
&RQVHLOGHMRXHUVRQU{OHGHFKHIHWG¶LPSRVHUXQHOLJQHGLUHFWULFH
jO¶HQVHPEOHGHODSROLWLTXHJRXYHUQHPHQWDOH/¶LGpHGHO¶XQLWpGH
GLUHFWLRQFKqUHj)D\ROVHPEOHWRWDOHPHQWDEVHQWHGHVSUDWLTXHV
PLQLVWpULHOOHV&HODOHGpVROHDORUVTX¶LOSU{QHO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGHV
PpWKRGHVGHO¶LQGXVWULHjODJHVWLRQGHVDIIDLUHVSXEOLTXHVHWTX¶LO
VHSHQFKHVXUVHVH[SpULHQFHVSDVVpHV,OQ¶KpVLWHG¶DLOOHXUVSDV
HQPDLDXFRXUVG¶XQHFRQIpUHQFHjO¶eFROHVXSpULHXUHGH
JXHUUHjUDSSHOHUOHVSURFpGpVTX¶LOPLWHQ°XYUHFRPPHLQJpQLHXU
GLYLVLRQQDLUHGHVPLQHVGH&RPPHQWU\HQD¿QGHFUpHUXQH
XQLWpGHGLUHFWLRQ/HVFRQIpUHQFHVKHEGRPDGDLUHVOHSURJUDPPH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

G¶DFWLRQHWOHVUDSSRUWVVRQWGRQFSRXUO¶DQFLHQLQJpQLHXUGHVSURFp
GpVSRXYDQWFUpHUXQHXQLWpGDQVOHFRPPDQGHPHQWGHO¶eWDW
)D\ROYHXWLFLQRUPHUOHVUHODWLRQVKLpUDUFKLTXHVHQWUHOHVGLIIp
UHQWVKRPPHVFRPSRVDQWOHJRXYHUQHPHQW,OV¶DJLWG¶XQHORJLTXH
TX¶LOPHWHQ°XYUHGHSXLVHWVDSULVHGHIRQFWLRQFRPPH
GLUHFWHXUJpQpUDOGHODVRFLpWpGH&RPPHQWU\)RXUFKDPEDXOWHW
'HFD]HYLOOH

+)D\RO©/DUpIRUPHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFV&RQIpUHQFHGH


0+HQUL)D\ROªCommerce et industrieQƒMDQYLHUS

Ibid.

+)D\RO©&RQIpUHQFHVIDLWHVOHVHWPDLVXUO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXV
WULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHªDUWFLWS
&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)UDSSRUW


VXUO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQGXVHUYLFHWHFKQLTXHGHVKRXLOOqUHVGH&RPPHQWU\HW0RQWYLFT

 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

$XGHOj GH SUDWLTXHV DGPLQLVWUDWLYHV F¶HVW O¶HQVHPEOH GHV

ORJLTXHV GH O¶$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ IUDQoDLVH TX¶LO GpVDSSURXYH  ,O
HVWLPHQRWDPPHQWTXHOHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFVGRLYHQWFRPSRVHUDYHF
GHQRPEUHXVHVHQWUDYHV8QHIRLVHQFRUHLOHQYLVDJHOHSUREOqPHHQ
SUHQDQWOHSRLQWGHYXHGHVGLULJHDQWV(QHIIHWjO¶RFFDVLRQGHVRQ
HQTXrWHVXUOHV377LOUHFHQVHOHVGLI¿FXOWpVDX[TXHOOHVGRLWIDLUH
IDFHOHPLQLVWUHHQFKDUJHGHFHWWHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ6HORQ)D\ROOH
PLQLVWUHQHMRXLWSDVG¶XQHOLEHUWpG¶DFWLRQVXI¿VDQWH,OHVWHQWUDYp
GDQVVRQDFWLRQSDUOHVORLVHWOHVGpFUHWVSDUOH©IDWUDVªGHVUqJOH
PHQWVPLQLVWpULHOVDQWpULHXUVHWSRVVqGHXQSRXYRLUGHUHFUXWHPHQW
OLPLWp,OHIIHFWXHXQFRQVWDWVLPLODLUHORUVGHVDSDUWLFLSDWLRQj
ODFRPPLVVLRQ&LWURsQHWWLUHODFRQFOXVLRQTXHODUpJOHPHQWDWLRQ
H[FHVVLYHFRQVWLWXHXQKDQGLFDS,OQRWHG¶DLOOHXUVTXHO¶LQGXVWULH
GHVWDEDFVHWGHVDOOXPHWWHVHVWXQHEUDQFKHGHO¶HQWUHSULVHJRXYHU
QHPHQWDOHHWTX¶HOOHHVWpWRXIIpHVRXVODUpJOHPHQWDWLRQJpQpUDOH
IDLWHSRXUXQHQVHPEOHSOXVYDVWH$XPDXYDLVIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHV
VHUYLFHVSXEOLFV)D\RODVVRFLHpJDOHPHQWOHVPpIDLWVGHODSDSHUDV
VHULHHWGHVOHQWHXUVEXUHDXFUDWLTXHV6LFHFRQVWDWVHPEOHSDUWDJp
SDUOHVGLULJHDQWVFRPPHOHVGLULJpVLOV¶pWRQQHXQHIRLVHQFRUH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

TXHO¶RQQHIDVVHSDVDSSHOjO¶H[SpULHQFHGHO¶LQGXVWULH
$ORUVTX¶LOFRQVLGqUHOHVIRQFWLRQQDLUHVFRPPHGHVDJHQWVWUqV
FRPSpWHQWV)D\ROUHPHWHQFDXVHOHELHQIRQGpGHODJHVWLRQGH
FHVSHUVRQQHOV,OHVWLPHHQHIIHWTXHO¶DYDQFHPHQWGHVDJHQWVj
O¶DQFLHQQHWpHWQRQDXPpULWHGpFRXUDJHWRXWHLQLWLDWLYH&HODSHXW
DXVVLHQJHQGUHUVHORQOXLO¶LQWHUFKDQJHDELOLWpGXSHUVRQQHO$LQVL
FHWDYDQFHPHQWSHXWDERXWLUjODQRPLQDWLRQG¶XQDJHQWGDQVXQ

$&KDWULRW©)D\ROOHVID\ROLHQVHWO¶LPSRVVLEOHUpIRUPHGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ


GXUDQWO¶HQWUHGHX[JXHUUHVªEntreprises et histoireQƒS

+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
+)D\RO©1RWHGH0)D\ROªRapport présenté par M. André Citroën, op.


cit.S

+)D\RO©/DUpIRUPHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFV&RQIpUHQFHGH
0+HQUL)D\ROªCommerce et industrieQƒMDQYLHUS
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

VHUYLFHVDQVSUHQGUHHQFRPSWHVHVFRPSpWHQFHV8QWHFKQLFLHQ
SHXWGRQFGXMRXUDXOHQGHPDLQRFFXSHUXQSRVWHGHFRPSWDEOH
JpQpUDQWDORUVGHVGLI¿FXOWpVHWGHVOHQWHXUVGDQVOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQW
GXVHUYLFH
(QWUHHW)D\ROUHPDUTXHORUVGHVHVHQWUHWLHQVDYHF
SOXVLHXUVGLUHFWHXUVGHPDQXIDFWXUHGHWDEDFTXHODUHODWLRQHQWUH
ODGLUHFWLRQG¶XQHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQHWOHVV\QGLFDWVHVWVRXUFHGH
G\VIRQFWLRQQHPHQWFDUHOOHVDSHO¶DXWRULWpGXFKHI(QHIIHWOHV
FKHIVGDQVOHVHQWUHSULVHVG¶eWDWQ¶RQWSDVOHVPR\HQVGHVHIDLUH
REpLUORUVTXHOHVV\QGLFDWVV¶RSSRVHQWDX[UpIRUPHVFDUO¶DXWRULWp
PLQLVWpULHOOHVHSURQRQFHHQFDVGHFRQÀLWSRXUOHVV\QGLFDWV
$LQVLOHVFKHIVVHORQ)D\ROQ¶RVHQWSOXVFRPPDQGHU'HQRXYHDX[
SRXYRLUVSHXYHQWrWUHGRQQpVDXGLUHFWHXUJpQpUDOOHVRUWGHO¶DG
PLQLVWUDWLRQFRQWLQXHGDQVGHWHOOHVFLUFRQVWDQFHVjGpSHQGUHGX
SRXYRLUSROLWLTXH

/XWWHUFRQWUHO¶LQVWDELOLWp

'qVVHVSUHPLqUHVSULVHVGHSRVLWLRQV)D\ROFRQGLWLRQQHODUpXV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

VLWHGHO¶DGDSWDWLRQGHVSUDWLTXHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYHVQpHVGHO¶H[Sp
ULHQFHLQGXVWULHOOHjXQHVWDELOLWpGDQVODJRXYHUQDQFHGHODFKRVH
SXEOLTXH¬VHV\HX[FHWWHFRQGLWLRQHVWHVVHQWLHOOHD¿QGHIDLUHGH
O¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQXQHRUJDQLVDWLRQHI¿FLHQWH

Séparer politique et administration

/DJHVWLRQGHODFKRVHSXEOLTXHQHGHYUDLWSDVVHORQ)D\RO
rWUHOHIDLWGHVKRPPHVSROLWLTXHV,OGpVLJQHHQHIIHWODSROLWLTXH

+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit



&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)ELV


FDKLHUVFRQVDFUpVjO¶pWXGHVXUO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQHWOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXPRQRSROH
GHVWDEDFV

+)D\RO©1RWHGH0)D\ROªRapport présenté par M. André Citroën , op.
cit.S
 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

FRPPHOHIDFWHXUPDMHXUSURYRTXDQWO¶LQVWDELOLWpGHVRUJDQLVDWLRQV
¬O¶RFFDVLRQGHVHQTXrWHVPHQpHVVXUOHV377HWOHPRQRSROHGHV
WDEDFVLOPHWHQH[HUJXHOHWHPSVWUqVOLPLWpTXHFRQVDFUHQWOHV
PLQLVWUHVjFHVLQGXVWULHVG¶eWDW&HVGHUQLHUVVRQWGRQFDFFDSDUpV
SDUG¶DXWUHVDIIDLUHVWRXWHVDXVVLLPSRUWDQWHVHWQHSHXYHQWV¶RFFX
SHUVpULHXVHPHQWGHFHVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQV'HSOXVODSRVLWLRQGHFHV
SHUVRQQDJHVSROLWLTXHVHVWVRXYHQWWUqVLQVWDEOH,OVQHUHVWHQWHQ
UpDOLWpTXHSHXGHWHPSVjODWrWHG¶XQPLQLVWqUH)D\ROLPSXWHFHOD
DXIDLWTXHOHVKRPPHVSROLWLTXHVVRQWLVVXVGXVXIIUDJHXQLYHUVHO
/HVpOHFWLRQVVRQWGRQFSRXUOXLVRXUFHG¶LQVWDELOLWpFDUHOOHVSHXYHQW
SURYRTXHUXQFKDQJHPHQWUDGLFDOjODWrWHGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
$LQVLO¶LQJpQLHXUFLYLOSU{QHODVpSDUDWLRQGXSROLWLTXHHWGHO¶DG
PLQLVWUDWLRQ/HVKRPPHVHQFKDUJHGHODJRXYHUQDQFHSXEOLTXHQH
SHXYHQWrWUHVHORQOXLOHIUXLWG¶XQHpOHFWLRQPDLVG¶XQORQJSDUFRXUV
DGPLQLVWUDWLI$¿QGHVRXWHQLUVDGpPRQVWUDWLRQLOQ¶KpVLWHSDVj
SHUVRQQL¿HUVRQUDLVRQQHPHQWjWUDYHUVGHVKRPPHVG¶eWDWIUDQoDLV
SUHVWLJLHX[WHOV&ROEHUWHW5LFKHOLHX
©&ROEHUWHW5LFKHOLHXQ¶pWDLHQWQLRUDWHXUVSRSXODLUHVQLIUXLWV
G¶pOHFWLRQVLOVDYDLHQWDSSULVjJRXYHUQHUHQVHUYDQWGDQVOHVUDQJV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

VHFRQGDLUHVGHODKLpUDUFKLHJRXYHUQHPHQWDOHSXLVHQH[HUoDQW
ORQJWHPSVOHPpWLHUGH0LQLVWUHLOVDYDLHQWDSSULVjJRXYHUQHUHQ
JRXYHUQDQW,OVQ¶DYDLHQWSDVjDVVLVWHUDX[VpDQFHVG¶XQHFKDPEUHHW
G¶XQ6pQDWjFRPSDUDvWUHGHYDQWOHVFRPPLVVLRQVSDUOHPHQWDLUHV
jUpSRQGUHjWRXWHVOHVGHPDQGHVGHGpSXWpVRXVpQDWHXUVQ¶D\DQW
SDVGHU{OHSDUOHPHQWDLUHjMRXHULOVDYDLHQWOHWHPSVGHV¶RFFXSHUGH
OHXUVGHYRLUVDGPLQLVWUDWLIV/HVUHODWLRQVGHQRV0LQLVWUHVDYHFOH
3DUOHPHQWFRQVWLWXHQWGpMjXQHORXUGHFKDUJHODJHVWLRQG¶XQJUDQG
VHUYLFHSXEOLFHQHVWXQHDXWUHQRQPRLQVORXUGH&HVGHX[FKDUJHV
UpXQLHVGpSDVVHQWGHEHDXFRXSOHVIRUFHVGµXQVHXOKRPPHª


+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
+)D\RO©1RWHGH0)D\ROªRapport présenté par M. André Citroën, op.


cit.S

+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
$OEHUW6FKDW]L’entreprise gouvernementale et son administration3DULV


*UDVVHWSSUpIDFHG¶+HQUL)D\RO
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

$XGHOjGHO¶DOOqJHPHQWGHODFKDUJHGHWUDYDLO)D\ROPDQL
IHVWHXQHORJLTXHWUqVSURFKHGHODSHQVpHGH*XVWDYH/H%RQ$X
UHJDUGGHVDUFKLYHVFRQVHUYpHVDX&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOH
GH6FLHQFHSR3DULVQRXVVDYRQVTX¶LODOXHWDQQRWpDERQGDPPHQW
Psychologie des foulesHWHQUHWLUHFHUWDLQHVLGpHVTXDQWjODUHODWLRQ
TXHSHXYHQWHQWUHWHQLUOHVSDUOHPHQWDLUHVHWOHVpOHFWHXUV,OQRWH
G¶DLOOHXUVTXHOHVSDUOHPHQWDLUHVLQWHUYLHQQHQWDEXVLYHPHQWDXSUqV
GXPLQLVWUHHQFKDUJHGHV377D¿QGHIRUPXOHUGHVGHPDQGHV
SHUVRQQHOOHV/HFKHIGHV377TXLVRQJHjVHVLQWpUrWVSROLWLTXHV
QHSHXWTXHUpSRQGUHIDYRUDEOHPHQWjFHVGHPDQGHV,OHQYDGH
PrPHSRXUOHVPDQXIDFWXUHVGHWDEDFVHWG¶DOOXPHWWHVTXLVXELVVHQW
UpJXOLqUHPHQWOHVLQWHUYHQWLRQVGHVSDUOHPHQWDLUHV
)D\ROLPSXWHGRQFDX[pOHFWLRQVO¶LQVWDELOLWpGHO¶eWDW&HWWH
UHPLVHHQFDXVHGHODVRXYHUDLQHWpGXSHXSOHSHXWQRXVODLVVHU
SHQVHUTXHO¶LQJpQLHXUH[SULPHGHVLGpHVDQWLGpPRFUDWLTXHV2U
LOQ¶HQHVWULHQ(QHIIHWLOQ¶HVWSDVTXHVWLRQSRXUOXLGHFRQWHVWHU
ODOpJLWLPLWpGpPRFUDWLTXHGXUpJLPHPDLVGHSURSRVHUXQIRQF
WLRQQHPHQWUHQIRUoDQWODVWDELOLWpGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ8QHIRLV
HQFRUHLODGRVVHVRQUDLVRQQHPHQWjVRQH[SpULHQFHLQGXVWULHOOH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

¬WUDYHUVO¶H[HPSOHGHV377LOSURSRVHGHPHWWUHHQSODFHXQFKHI
TXLQ¶HVWSDVOLpDXSROLWLTXHHWFKDUJpGHJpUHUFHWWHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
3DUDOOqOHPHQWHWD¿QGHVHFRQIRUPHUjODOpJLWLPLWpGpPRFUDWLTXH
GXUpJLPH)D\ROVRXKDLWHGpVRUPDLVTXHOHPLQLVWUHVRLWFKDUJp
GXFRQWU{OHGHO¶DFWLYLWpGXUHVSRQVDEOHGHV377HWTX¶LOLPSXOVH
XQHRULHQWDWLRQjFHWWHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ'DQVFHIRQFWLRQQHPHQW
O¶eWDWH[HUFHGRQFVDVRXYHUDLQHWpSDUOHELDLVGXFRQWU{OH,OIDXWLFL
UDSSURFKHUFHV\VWqPHGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQH[LVWDQWHGDQVOHVJUDQGHV


*XVWDYH/H%RQPsychologie des foules3DULV3UHVVHVXQLYHUVLWDLUHVGH
)UDQFHS
+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit


+)D\RO©1RWHGH0)D\ROªRapport présenté par M. André Citroën, op.



cit.S

+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

HQWUHSULVHVHWQRWDPPHQWO¶DUWLFXODWLRQHQWUHODGLUHFWLRQJpQpUDOH
HWOHFRQVHLOG¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQUHSUpVHQWDQWO¶DVVHPEOpHJpQpUDOHGHV
DFWLRQQDLUHV(QHIIHWOHFRQVHLOG¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQQ¶DSRXUXQLTXH
REMHFWLITXHGHFRQWU{OHUO¶DFWLYLWpGHODGLUHFWLRQHWGHSURSRVHU
XQHXQLWpGHYXH'HSOXV)D\ROHVWGHSXLVOHGpEXWGHVDFDUULqUH
G¶LQJpQLHXUKDELWXpjFHPRGHGHIRQFWLRQQHPHQW(QWDQWTX¶LQ
JpQLHXUFLYLOH[SORLWDQWXQHFRQFHVVLRQKRXLOOqUHLOHVWHQUHODWLRQ
UpJXOLqUHDYHFOHVLQJpQLHXUVG¶eWDWFKDUJpVGXFRQWU{OHGHVH[SORL
WDWLRQVFHX[FLV¶DVVXUHQWTXHOHVWUDYDX[HQFRXUVUHVSHFWHQWO¶LQ
WpUrWJpQpUDO6LODVpSDUDWLRQHQWUHSROLWLTXHHWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQHVW
HVVHQWLHOOHDX[\HX[GH)D\ROSRXUDVVXUHUODVWDELOLWpGHO¶eWDW
FHOOHFLQHSHXWrWUHYpULWDEOHPHQWHIIHFWLYHTX¶HQUHVWDXUDQWO¶DX
WRULWpGHVFKHIV

5HVWDXUHUO¶DXWRULWpGHVFKHIV
'DQVO¶HVSULWG¶+HQUL)D\ROODUpXVVLWHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHG¶XQH
RUJDQLVDWLRQHVWV\QRQ\PHFHUWHVGHO¶XWLOLVDWLRQGHSURFpGpVLVVXV
GHO¶LQGXVWULHPDLVpJDOHPHQWGHODUHVWDXUDWLRQGHO¶DXWRULWpGHV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

FKHIV,OLQVLVWHjGHQRPEUHXVHVUHSULVHVVXUOHVHIIHWVQpJDWLIV
TXHSHXWSURGXLUHXQPDQTXHG¶DXWRULWp$LQVLORUVGHVHVHQWUHWLHQV
HQDYHFOHVGLUHFWHXUVGHVPDQXIDFWXUHVGHWDEDFVGH3DQWLQ
HWGH5HXLOO\LOFRQVWDWHQRWDPPHQWTXHOHPDQTXHG¶DXWRULWpDOWqUH
OHUDSSRUWKLpUDUFKLTXHHQWUHOHVGLIIpUHQWHVFRPSRVDQWHVGHFHWWH
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ)D\ROQ¶LQFULPLQHSDVOHVGLUHFWHXUVPDLVLOMXJH
OHXUU{OHGLI¿FLOHPHQWWHQDEOHDXUHJDUGG¶XQHVLWXDWLRQLQVWDEOHTXH
FUpHODJRXYHUQDQFHPLQLVWpULHOOH
$LQVL)D\ROQHFRQoRLWSDVODVpSDUDWLRQGXSROLWLTXHHWGHO¶DG
PLQLVWUDWLIVDQVXQHUHVWDXUDWLRQGHO¶DXWRULWp&HOOHFLSDVVHSRXU


/0GX&URX]HW©8QHQWUHWLHQDYHF0+HQUL)D\RO/HVGpYHORSSHPHQWV
DFWXHOVGHODGRFWULQHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHªLa chronique socialeMDQYLHU
&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)ELV


FDKLHUVFRQVDFUpVjO¶pWXGHVXUO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQHWOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGXPRQRSROH
GHVWDEDFV
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

OXLSDUO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGXUqJOHPHQWHWGHVVDQFWLRQV&HSHQGDQWLO
QRWHTX¶HQPDWLqUHGHUpSUHVVLRQO¶DXWRULWpGRLWrWUHJUDGXpH,O
VRXOLJQHQRWDPPHQWTXHO¶DSSUpFLDWLRQGHODIDXWHQHSHXWrWUHOHIDLW
GXVXSpULHXUGLUHFWGXVXERUGRQQpD\DQWFRPPLVO¶HUUHXUFDUGDQV
FHFDVODVDQFWLRQHVWWUqVVRXYHQWVpYqUH$ORUVTXHOHVXSpULHXU
KLpUDUFKLTXHQ¶pWDQWSDVLPSOLTXpGDQVODJHVWLRQGLUHFWHGHO¶HUUHXU
DSSUpFLHH[DFWHPHQWOHIDLWHWQHSURQRQFHTX¶XQHSHLQHOpJqUH/D
UpSUHVVLRQHVWDLQVLVHORQ)D\ROSOXVHI¿FDFHFDUPLHX[SURSRUWLRQ
QpHjODJUDYLWpGHODIDXWH,OV¶DSSXLHLFLVDQVFRQWHVWHVXUOHV
PHVXUHVTX¶LOPHWHQSODFHHQDX[PLQHVGH'HFD]HYLOOHD¿Q
GHOLPLWHUOHVWHQVLRQVHQWUHOHVRXYULHUVHWOHSHUVRQQHOHQFDGUDQW
1pDQPRLQVO¶DSSOLFDWLRQGXUqJOHPHQWQHFRQVWLWXHSDVSRXU
)D\ROOHSULQFLSDOIDFWHXUSHUPHWWDQWGHUHVWDXUHUO¶DXWRULWpGHV
FKHIV&¶HVWODFRPSpWHQFHSURIHVVLRQQHOOHTXLRFFXSHGDQVVRQ
HVSULWFHWWHSODFHFHQWUDOH&HOOHFLV¶DFTXLHUWSDUODFRQWLQXLWpGHV
YXHVHWGHVDFWLRQV,OHVWLPHDLQVLTX¶XQFKHIjO¶LPDJHG¶XQGLUHF
WHXUJpQpUDOG¶XQHVRFLpWpDQRQ\PHQHSHXWrWUHHI¿FDFHTX¶DSUqV
GHQRPEUHXVHVDQQpHVG¶H[SpULHQFH)D\ROQ¶KpVLWHSDVjpFULUHTX¶LO
IDXWGL[DQVjXQFKHISRXUSUHQGUHODPHVXUHGXSRVWHHWPHWWUH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

HQ°XYUHGHVDFWLRQVSHUWLQHQWHV/¶H[SpULHQFHMRXHGRQFXQU{OH
SULPRUGLDOGDQVODUHVWDXUDWLRQGHO¶DXWRULWp2QFRPSUHQGDLQVL
PLHX[SRXUTXRLO¶LQVWDELOLWpPLQLVWpULHOOHHVWXQHGRQQpHWUqVQpJD
WLYHGDQVO¶HVSULWG¶+HQUL)D\RO/DFRPSpWHQFHUHVWHO¶pOpPHQW
PDMHXUGHO¶DXWRULWpPDLVLOQHPHWSDVHQDYDQWXQHFRQFHSWLRQ
RPQLSRWHQWHGXFKHI6LFHGHUQLHUGLVSRVHGHJUDQGHVFRPSpWHQFHV
SURIHVVLRQQHOOHVGDQVOHGRPDLQHG¶DFWLYLWpGHO¶RUJDQLVDWLRQFHOD

&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)'5


QRWHVPDQXVFULWHVPDLQWLHQGHODGLVFLSOLQHUpSUHVVLRQMDQYLHU

'RQDOG5HLGLes mineurs de Decazeville. Historique de la désindustrialisa-
tion'HFD]HYLOOH$63,%'S

+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
$OEHUW6FKDW]L’entreprise gouvernementale et son administration3DULV


*UDVVHWSSUpIDFHG¶+HQUL)D\RO
 +HQUL)D\ROHW©O¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQªGHO¶eWDW

FRQVWLWXHXQHLQGpQLDEOHSOXVYDOXH&HSHQGDQWFHWWHLQFRPSp
WHQFHSURIHVVLRQQHOOHSHXWDXVVLrWUHVXSSOppHSDUO¶pWDWPDMRU
8QHIRLVHQFRUHLOV¶DSSXLHVXUVDSURSUHH[SpULHQFHHWMXVWL¿HFHWWH
SHQVpHSDUODVLWXDWLRQTX¶LOYLWHQORUVTX¶LODUULYHjODWrWHGH
ODVRFLpWpPLQLqUHHWPpWDOOXUJLTXHGH&RPPHQWU\)RXUFKDPEDXOW
HW'HFD]HYLOOH$ORUVTX¶LOQ¶DH[HUFpGHSXLVVDVRUWLHGHO¶eFROHGH
PLQHVGH6DLQWeWLHQQHTX¶DXVHLQGHKRXLOOqUHVLOGRLWGpVRUPDLV
JpUHUGHVHQWUHSULVHVPpWDOOXUJLTXHVUHPHWWDQWDLQVLHQFDXVHVD
FRPSpWHQFHSURIHVVLRQQHOOH
©-HQ¶HQVHQWDLVSDVPRLQVWUqVYLYHPHQWPDODFXQHPpWDOOXUJLTXH
-HPHKkWDLVGHODFRPEOHUGDQVODPHVXUHVWULFWHPHQWQpFHVVDLUH
j PHV IRQFWLRQV HQ IDLVDQW G¶DERUG XQ VpMRXU GH VL[ PRLV
GDQVOHVXVLQHVSXLVG¶DVVH]IUpTXHQWHVYLVLWHV-¶DYDLVpFDUWp
LPPpGLDWHPHQWWRXWHSUpWHQWLRQjpJDOHUHQFDSDFLWpWHFKQLTXH
O¶XQTXHOFRQTXHGHVVSpFLDOLVWHVWUqVQRPEUHX[HWWUqVGLYHUV
TXL FRQVWLWXDLHQW OH SHUVRQQHO GH QRV XVLQHV 0DLV M¶DYDLV OD
UHVSRQVDELOLWp GX UHFUXWHPHQW GH FH SHUVRQQHO &H IXW O¶XQH
GHVJUDQGHVGLI¿FXOWpVTXHM¶HXVjVXUPRQWHUOHVKRPPHVGH
YDOHXUQHV¶HQJDJHQWSDVYRORQWLHUVDXVHUYLFHG¶XQHHQWUHSULVH
HQVRXIIUDQFHGRQWO¶DYHQLUQ¶HVWSDVDVVXUp/¶XQHsicGHPHV
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

SUHPLHUVVRLQVIXWGHPHFRQVWLWXHUXQpWDWPDMRUVHFUpWDLUH
WHFKQLTXHHWVSpFLDOLVWHVFRQVHLOVª
(Q¿QOHVSUDWLTXHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYHVFRQVWLWXHQWSRXU)D\ROGHV
RXWLOVFDSDEOHVGHUHVWDXUHUO¶DXWRULWp$LQVLODSUpYR\DQFHHWO¶RUJD
QLVDWLRQSHUPHWWHQWGHFUpGLELOLVHUOHVFKHIVGDQVO¶HVSULWGHVVXERU
GRQQpV&HWWHFDSDFLWpDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDVHORQOXLSOXVG¶LQÀXHQFH
VXUOHIRQFWLRQQHPHQWGHVVHUYLFHVSXEOLFVTXHOHUpJLPHFRQVWLWX
WLRQQHO¬O¶LPDJHGHVHVDXWUHVSURSRVLWLRQVFHFRQVWDWVHGUHVVH
DXUHJDUGGHVRQH[SpULHQFHLQGXVWULHOOHHWQRWDPPHQWVDSULVHGH
IRQFWLRQFRPPHGLUHFWHXUGHVPLQHVGH&RPPHQWU\HQ/RUV


+)D\ROL’incapacité industrielle de l’État : les PTTop. cit
&HQWUHG¶KLVWRLUHGXඑඑHVLqFOHGH6FLHQFHSR3DULV)RQGV)D\RO+)ELV'5


REVHUYDWLRQVHWH[SpULHQFHVSHUVRQQHOOHV

+)D\RO©/¶LQGXVWULDOLVDWLRQGHO¶eWDWªCompte-rendu de la Société de l’In-
dustrie MinéraleDUWFLW
 5)+,3Qı9$5,e7e6

GHVRQDUULYpHjODWrWHGHFHWWHHQWUHSULVHLOLQVWDXUHQRWDPPHQW
GHVFRQIpUHQFHVKHEGRPDGDLUHVD¿QGHFRRUGRQQHUHWG¶RUJDQLVHU
OHVGLIIpUHQWHVEUDQFKHVDLQVLTX¶XQSURJUDPPHG¶DFWLRQFRQVWL
WXpjSDUWLUGHSUpYLVLRQVDQQXHOOHVHWGpFHQQDOHV&HODSHUPHW
DXFKDUERQQDJHG¶DQWLFLSHUOHVFKDQJHPHQWVjYHQLUHWDFFURvWOD
FRPSpWHQFHGXGLUHFWHXUDX[\HX[GHVVXERUGRQQpV

&RQFOXVLRQ

'DQVVRQH[KRUWDWLRQj©LQGXVWULDOLVHUªO¶eWDW)D\ROWHQWHG¶pWD
EOLUTXHOHVWGDQVODVRFLpWpIUDQoDLVHGHFHGpEXWGHඑඑHVLqFOHOH
PRGHGHJRXYHUQHPHQWOHSOXVHI¿FDFHFRPSWHWHQXG¶XQFHUWDLQ
QRPEUHGHFRQWUDLQWHVVRFLRORJLTXHVHWLQVWLWXWLRQQHOOHV$LQVLLO
FRQVLGqUHTXHODTXHVWLRQSULPRUGLDOHGHODUpIRUPHGHO¶eWDWQ¶HVW
SDVFHOOHGHO¶LQWHUYHQWLRQQLVPHpFRQRPLTXHPDLVFHOOHGHO¶HI¿
FDFLWpGXV\VWqPHDGPLQLVWUDWLIIUDQoDLV
/D3UHPLqUH*XHUUHPRQGLDOHDPLVHQOXPLqUHOHJRQÀHPHQW
GHVDFWLYLWpVpWDWLTXHVSURYRTXDQWXQHGRXEOHQpFHVVLWpG¶DERUG
GHUDWLRQDOLVHUOHXUH[HUFLFHSRXUHQDVVXUHUO¶HI¿FDFLWpHQVXLWHGH
© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

© L'Harmattan | Téléchargé le 16/04/2022 sur www.cairn.info (IP: 154.124.57.9)

VXSSULPHUWRXWHVOHVDFWLYLWpVTXHQHMXVWL¿HDXFXQEHVRLQUpHO/D
JXHUUHPRQWUHGRQFTXHOHSRXYRLUV¶H[HUFHPDOHQSDUWLHSDUFH
TX¶LOV¶H[HUFHHQWURSGHGRPDLQHV)D\ROV¶pYHUWXHGRQFjLGHQWL¿HU
OHV©PDODGLHVpWDWLVWHVªTXLURQJHQWO¶eWDW,OHQGpFqOHSOXVLHXUV
GRQWWURLVPDMHXUHVO¶HQFRPEUHPHQWOHFORLVRQQHPHQWHWO¶LQVWDEL
OLWp/HV©WUDLWHPHQWVªSURSRVpVVRQWWRXVOHIUXLWGHVHVREVHUYD
WLRQVSHUVRQQHOOHVHWGHVRQH[SpULHQFHLQGXVWULHOOH1pDQPRLQVLO
QHSU{QHSDVXQERXOHYHUVHPHQWFRQVWLWXWLRQQHOPDLVXQHUpIRUPH
GHVSUDWLTXHVHWGHVPpWKRGHVGHWUDYDLO3RXUFHODLOSURSRVHXQH
WHFKQLTXHGHFRPPDQGHPHQWDLQVLTX¶XQHVRFLRORJLHGHO¶DFWLRQ
(QGp¿QLWLYHLOVRXKDLWHVXEVWLWXHUODORJLTXHGHO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
SDUODORJLTXHGHO¶LQGXVWULH


+)D\RO©&RQIpUHQFHVIDLWHVOHVHWPDLVXUO¶DGPLQLVWUDWLRQLQGXV
WULHOOHHWJpQpUDOHªDUWFLW