Jeep ®

Compass
MA N U A L D O P R O P RI E T Á RI O
  
1?2?J^9: $ "J2>a?3" @"2 5$2 $:E"Kb>3" 4# c$$@N
12$@?2?#": $:5$ &?94?K @?2? Kb$ @$2#>5>2 ?@2$E>?2 ?: Z4?K>3?3$: 3$:5$ X$WE4K"] Z4$ D"> @$9:?3" @?2? ? 45>K>Y?;<"
Z4"5>3>?9? $ @?2? 45>K>Y?;\$: $:@$EWD>E?:] @$2#>5>93"] ?::>#] @$2E42:": $ 45>K>Y?;\$: $# a$2?K 9<" ?3?@5?3": ?":
52?3>E>"9?>: X$WE4K":N - ?K>9b?#$95" $ ? 3>2>a>J>K>3?3$ :<" 3>D$2$95$: 3? #?>"2 @?25$ 3": "452": X$WE4K":] $# $:52?3?
9"2#?K "4 $# @$2E42:": D"2? 3$ $:52?3?d @"25?95"] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K >9X$:5>2 5"3" " 5$#@" 9$E$::‘2>" @?2? E"9b$E$2 ?
3>9e#>E? 3" X$WE4K"N
12"::$a4>93" 9? K$>542? 3$:5$ &?94?K] $9E"952?2‘ >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:$Kb": $ ?X>:": >#@"25?95$: @?2? " 4:" 3"
X$WE4K"] Z4$ " ?_43?2<" ? ?@2"X$>5?2 ?: Z4?K>3?3$: 5^E9>E?: 3" :$4 c$$@N f 2$E"#$93‘X$K K[AK" E"# ?5$9;<" ?95$: 3$
:$ @2$@?2?2 @?2? ? @2>#$>2? X$Y 9? E"934;<"] 3$ #"3" ? D?#>K>?2>Y?2A:$ E"# ": E"#?93": $# @?25>E4K?2] E"# ":
2$K?5>X": ?": D2$>":] g 3>2$;<" $ ?" Ee#J>"d ?" #$:#" 5$#@"] @"3$2‘ E"#$;?2 ? E"#@2$$93$2 " E"#@"25?#$95" 3"
X$WE4K" 9?: X‘2>?: :4@$2DWE>$: 3? $:52?3?N
!" >95$2>"2 3$:5$ 3"E4#$95" $9E"952?2‘ E?2?E5$2W:5>E?:] @?25>E4K?2>3?3$: $ >9D"2#?;\$: $::$9E>?>: @?2? " E4>3?3"]
? #?945$9;<" ?" K"9a" 3" 5$#@"] ? :$a42?9;? 3$ E"934;<" $ 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :$4 c$$@N ’@h: 5[AK" E"9:4K5?3"]
?E"9:$Kb?#": ? E"9:$2X?2 " @2$:$95$ &?94?K 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? D?E>K>5?2 ? :4? E"9:4K5? $ @?2? Z4$ $:5$_? ?
J"23" 3" #$:#" $# E?:" 3$ X$93?N
!" )>X2" 3$ S?2?95>?] D"29$E>3" 9" i>5 3$ J"23" 3" X$WE4K"] $9E"952?2‘ ?>93? ? 3$:E2>;<" 3": ,$2X>;": 3$
’::>:5[9E>? Z4$ ? c$$@ "D$2$E$ ?": :$4: 8K>$95$:] " 8$25>D>E?3" 3$ S?2?95>? $ " 3$5?Kb$ 3": 5$2#": $ 3?: E"93>;\$:
@?2? ? #?945$9;<" 3? #$:#?N C$E"#$93?A:$ 5?#J^# ? K$>542? 3" &?94?K B‘:>E" 3$ ,$a42?9;? 9" .2e9:>5"] Z4$
52?5? 3$ 5$#?: >#@"25?95$: E"#" ?: 9"2#?: 3$ E>2E4K?;<"] ?: >9D2?;\$: $ @$9?K>3?3$: @2$X>:5?: 9" 8h3>a" 3$ .2e9:>5"
B2?:>K$>2"] 3>2$;<" 3$D$9:>X? $ 9";\$: 3$ @2>#$>2": :"E"22": $# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$] ?K^# 3$ E"9E$>5":] 3$D>9>;\$: $
:>9?K>Y?;<" J‘:>E? 3$ 52e9:>5"N - &?94?K B‘:>E" 3$ ,$a42?9;? 9" .2e9:>5" $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K 9" :>5$ jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2
Ak 12"@2>$5‘2>": Ak &?94?K 3$ ,$a42?9;? 9" .2e9:>5"N
+:5?#": E$25": Z4$ $:5?: @4JK>E?;\$: >2<" D?Y[AK" $952?2 $# :>95"9>? E"# " :$4 9"X" X$WE4K" $ ?@2$E>?2 ": :$2X>;":
5^E9>E": 3? c$$@ Z4$ $:5<" 3>:@"9WX$>: @?2? :4? ?::>:5[9E>?N
B"? K$>542?] $95<"] $ J"? X>?a$#O
!
"
  !

  "

    #

   !  " $

!! %

!!   ! &

" !  "#! ’

"!  ! "    (

! $ )

 !!%$ *J
 
)+=.(C’ -BC=S’.UC=’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N ’A7 !
(.=)=Q’/0- *- &’!(’) N N N N N N N N N N N N N ’AL
’*V+C.l!8=’, + !-.’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N ’AH
,m&B-)-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N ’AH
&-*=P=8’/n+,o’).+C’/n+, *-
V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N ’AH

#
#
   
 
!%!"  "&
% 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " D2$>" 3$ $:5?A
"  '() ?J?:5$E$2 " X$WE4K"
?@$9?: E"# S?:"K>9? 5>@" 8 :$#
Eb4#J" "4 $5?9"K $5WK>E" b>32?5?3"
E"#J4:5WX$K $# Z4?KZ4$2 @2"@"2;<"N
’ ?3>;<" 3$ "452" 5>@" 3$ a?:"K>9?
9" 5?9Z4$] 9<" b"#"K"a?3? @?2? 4:"
?45"#"5>X"] @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9": >2A
2$X$2:WX$>: ?" X$WE4K"N
!#!
 *+,-' .-  , &
 % /'(0] E?:" X"E[ "@5$
@"2 ?J?:5$E$2 " :$4 X$WE4K" $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ E"# $5?9"K] ^ 2$E"#$93?3"
" ?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#@K$5" 3" 5?9Z4$
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# a?:"K>9? q9" #WA
9>#" 4# 5?9Z4$r ? E?3? 7GNGGG i#
@?2? 2$34Y>2 @2"X‘X$>: E"95?#>9?9A
5$: @2"E$3$95$: 3" $5?9"KN
=:5" ^ >#@"25?95$ @?2? #?95$2 "
J"# D49E>"9?#$95" $ 3$:$#@$9b"
3" #"5"2 $] @2>9E>@?K#$95$] $X>5?2
3>D>E4K3?3$: 9" :>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 3"
#"5"2N
"   ') C$?J?:5$E$2 " 5?9A
Z4$ 3" X$WE4K" 45>K>Y?93" :"#$95$
 ' 12 - ,   , -' 
 (3    .- 12  ,
  , -'  4  ' , 3 
*   5 '67  ' * &
5  8 9 ,  34 ,67  *+&
,-':

!49E? 45>K>Y?2 J>"3>$:$K @42"
q7GGsr "4 ?3>E>"9?2 #?>: J>"3>$:$K
?" 5?9Z4$] $pE$3$93" ": X?K"2$: @2$A
X>:5": 9? )$a>:K?;<" P$3$2?K X>a$95$
g ^@"E? 3? D?J2>E?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N -
4:" 3$ "452": @2"345": "4 #>:542?:
@"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 >22$X$2:>X$K#$95$ "
#"5"2 $] $# E"9:$Z4[9E>?] ?94K?2 ?
a?2?95>? @$K": 3?9": E?4:?3":N
1?2? #?>"2$: 3$5?Kb$: :"J2$ 45>K>A
Y?;<" 3" E"#J4:5WX$K E"22$5"] X$2 $:A
@$E>D>E?;\$: $# t)"9a? >9?5>X>3?3$
3" X$WE4K"t $ t’J?:5$E>#$95":tN
!
!!  "
E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" $:5$_? ?E>"9?3"
$ Z4$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" $:5$_?
9? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r "4
 q1"95" #"25"r] @>:?2 9" @$3?K 3"
D2$>"d $# :$a4>3?] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @?25>3?N
!!" %
"!! !"
*42?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95"] " E"9A
X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E" ?5>9a$ 5$#@$2?542?:
$K$X?3?:N 1"2 >::"] 9<" $:5?E>"9?2 "
X$WE4K" $# E>#? 3$ D"Kb?: :$E?: "4
"452" #?5$2>?K >9DK?#‘X$K% @$2>a" 3$
>9E[93>"N
   " !"%&

- X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
:>:5$#? Z4$ @$2#>5$ 4# 3>?a9h:5>E"
E"95W94" 3": E"#@"9$95$: 2$K?E>"A
9?3": E"# ?: $#>::\$: @?2? a?2?95>2
#$!
4# #$Kb"2 2$:@$>5" @$K" #$>" ?#J>A
$95$N
; !" $ ?K542? 3" :"K" $ @"2 4# E$952" 3$
!< a2?X>3?3$ #?>: ?K5" 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ?
,$] ?@h: ? E"#@2? 3" X$WE4K"] 3$A
:$_?2 >9:5?K?2 ?E$::h2>": Z4$ 9$E$::>A
5$# 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" $K^52>E? qE"# "
2>:E" 3$ 3$:E?22$a?2 a2?34?K#$95$ ?
J?5$2>?r] 3>2>_?A:$ g   ! = &
,  > Z4$ ?X?K>?2‘ ? ?J:"2;<" $K^A
52>E? 5"5?K $ X$2>D>E?2‘ :$ " :>:5$#? 3"
X$WE4K" $:5‘ $# E"93>;\$: 3$ :4:5$9A
5?2 ? E?2a? 9$E$::‘2>?N
"! !&
"!!
(#? E"22$5? #?945$9;<" @$2#>5$
E"9:$2X?2 >9?K5$2?3": 9" 5$#@" ":
2$93>#$95": 3" X$WE4K" $ ?: E?2?E5$A
2W:5>E?: 3$ :$a42?9;?] 2$:@$>5?93" "
#$>" ?#J>$95$ $ #?95$93" J?>p": ":
E4:5": 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"N
!#! % ! &
!"
- 2>:E" 3$ E?@"5?#$95" @?2? ":
X$WE4K": D"2? 3$ $:52?3? ^ :>a9>D>E?A
#$"
5>X?#$95$ #?>: $K$X?3" Z4$ ? Z4?KA
Z4$2 "452" 5>@" 3$ X$WE4K"N +:5$ X$WA
E4K" ^ E?2?E5$2>Y?3" @"2 4#? #?>"2
#4>5": "452": X$WE4K": @?2? " 52?9:A
@"25$ 3$ @?::?a$>2":] E?2?E5$2W:5>E?:
Z4$ @$2#>5$# 3$:$#@$9b": #$Kb"A
2$: 94#? ?#@K? a?#? 3$ ?@K>E?;\$:
3$ D"2? 3$ $:52?3?N
!" $95?95"] ?3"5?93" 4# $:5>K" 3$
E"934;<" @$2>a":"] ^ @"::WX$K @$23$2
" E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K"N
*$X>3" ?" E$952" 3$ a2?X>3?3$
#?>: ?K5"] " X$WE4K" $:5‘ #?>: :4_$>5"
3" Z4$ "452": ? E?@"5?2 E?:" :?>? 3"
E"952"K$ 3" #"5"2>:5?N
1"25?95"] $952?2 E"# E?45$K? $#
E42X?: D$Eb?3?: $ $X>5?2 #?9"J2?:
J24:E?: "4 "452?: E"93>;\$: 3$
E"934;<" 9<" :$a42?: Z4$ @"3$2>?#
@2"X"E?2 ? @$23? 3$ E"952"K$ 3"
X$WE4K"N ’ >9"J:$2Xe9E>? 3?: @2$:A
E2>;\$: @"3$2>? @2"X"E?2 >9E>3$95$:]
E?@"5?#$95" 3" X$WE4K" $ K$:\$: a2?A
X$: "4 #"25?>:N ’54?2 E"# E?45$K?N
’ 9<" 45>K>Y?;<" 3": E>95": 3$ :$A
a42?9;? ^ ? E?4:? @2>9E>@?K 3$ K$:\$:
a2?X$: "4 #"25?>:N +# E?:" 3$ E?@"A
5?#$95"] 4# @?::?a$>2" :$# E>95" 3$
:$a42?9;? ?@$25?3" 5$# #4>5" #?>:
@2"J?J>K>3?3$: 3$ :"D2$2 K$:\$: #"2A
5?>: 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ? 4# @?::?a$>2"
Z4$ " 4:$ E"22$5?#$95$N (:$ :$#@2$
": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?N
   
 
!?  !!
,$#@2$ Z4$ D"2$# D"29$E>3?: >93>A
E?;\$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 2$K?5>X?: ?" X$WA
E4K" q$:Z4$23?o3>2$>5? "4 D2$95$o52‘:r]
$:5?: 3$X$# :$2 $95$93>3?: E"#" 2$A
K?5>X?: g @$2E$@;<" 3$ 4# "E4@?95$
:$95?3" 9" K4a?2 3" #"5"2>:5?N 8?A
:": @?25>E4K?2$:] Z4$ :$_?# 4#? $pA
E$;<" ? $:5? >93>E?;<"] :$2<" "@"2A
549?#$95$ ?::>9?K?3": 9" 5$p5"N
’: D>a42?: >93>E?3?: ?" K"9a" 3"
&?94?K 5[# 4#? D49;<" >93>E?5>X?%
>:5" @"3$ :>a9>D>E?2 Z4$ ?Ka49: 3$A
5?Kb$: 2$@2$:$95?3": 9? >#?a$# 9<"
E"22$:@"93?# ?" Z4$ @"3$2‘ $9E"9A
52?2 9" :$4 X$WE4K"N
 1?2? >3$95>D>E?2 " E?@W54K" $# Z4$
$:5<" E"95>3?: ?: >9D"2#?;\$: @2$A
5$93>3?:] @"3$ E"9:4K5?2 " W93>E$ ?KA
D?J^5>E" :>54?3" 9" D>9?K 3" @2$:$95$
&?94?K 3$ (:" $ &?945$9;<"N
    @$EWD>E?: 9<" :<" >3$95>D>E?3?: E"#"

)$93" $:5$ &?94?K 3$ (:" $ &?A
945$9;<" $9E"952?2‘ 4#? :^2>$ 3$
’*V+C.l!8=’, 3$:5>9?3?: ? $X>5?2
@2"E$3>#$95": Z4$ @"3$2>?# 3?9>D>A
E?2 " :$4 X$WE4K"N
’K^# 3>::"] $:5<" @2$:$95$: !-A
.’, ? :$a4>2 ?5$95?#$95$ @?2? $X>5?2
4#? 45>K>Y?;<" >9?3$Z4?3? 3": E"#A
@"9$95$: 3" X$WE4K"] Z4$ @"3$2>?#
E?4:?2 ?E>3$95$:N
1"2 $:5$ #"5>X"] 2$:@$>5?2 2>a"2"A
:?#$95$ 5"3?: ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$: 3$
’*V+C.l!8=’ $ !-.’, #$9E>"9?A
3?: ?" K"9a" 3" 5$p5"N
 1?2? :$a42?9;? 3?: @$::"?:N
 1?2? >95$a2>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
 1?2? @2"5$;<" 3" #$>" ?#J>$95$

!$:5$ &?94?K 3$ (:" $ &?945$9A
;<" $:5<" 3$:E2>5?: 5"3?: ?: X$2:\$:
3" c$$@ 8"#@?::N 8"95$u3": "@A
E>"9?>:] $Z4>@?#$95": 3$3>E?3": ?
&$2E?3": $:@$EWD>E": "4 X$2:\$: $:A
5?>: 9" 5$p5"% ^ 9$E$::‘2>" E"9:>3$2?2
?@$9?: ?: >9D"2#?;\$: 2$K?5>X?: ?"
$Z4>@?#$95"] #"5"2>Y?;<" $ X$2:<"
3" X$WE4K" 3$ :4? @2"@2>$3?3$N +X$9A
54?>: E"95$u3": >952"34Y>3": 342?95$
? X>3? @2"345>X? 3" #"3$K"] #?: >9A
3$@$93$95$: 3" @$3>3" $p@2$::" 3$
E"95$u3": "@E>"9?>: 9" #"#$95" 3?
?Z4>:>;<"] :$2<" >3$95>D>E?3": E"# ?
>93>E?;<" q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN

-: 3?3": E"95>3": 9$:5? @4JK>E?A
;<" 3$X$# :$2 $95$93>3": E"#" 3$:A
5>9?3": ? E"934Y>AK" E"22$5?#$95$ 9?
45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N ’ ,.+))’!A
.=, $:5‘ $#@$9b?3? 94# @2"E$::" 3$
?@$2D$>;"?#$95" E"95W94" 3": X$WE4A
K": @2"34Y>3":] 2$:$2X?93"A:$] ?::>#]
" 3>2$>5" 3$ $D$54?2 #"3>D>E?;\$: 9"
#"3$K" 3$:E2>5" @"2 #"5>X": 3$ 9?A
542$Y? 5^E9>E? $o"4 E"#$2E>?KN 1?2?
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] 3>2>a>2A:$ g C$3$
!
3$ ’::>:5[9E>? c$$@N
!
+# ?Ka49: E"#@"9$95$: 3" X$WA
E4K" $:5<" @2$:$95$: $5>Z4$5?: E"K"2>A
3?:] E4_? :>#J"K"a>? >93>E? @2$E?4A
;\$: >#@"25?95$: ? "J:$2X?2 9? 45>K>A
Y?;<" 3" @2h@2>" E"#@"9$95$N
1"2 J?>p" 3" E?@v 3" #"5"2 $p>:5$
?>93? 4#? $5>Z4$5? 2$E?@>54K?5>X? 3":
:W#J"K":N
 " 
# $#
 !
w4?KZ4$2 #"3>D>E?;<" "4 ?K5$2?A
;<" 3" X$WE4K" @"3$ E"#@2"#$5$2
a2?X$#$95$ ? :$a42?9;? $ @2"X"E?2
?E>3$95$:] E"# 2>:E": ?5^ #$:#"
#"25?>: @?2? ": "E4@?95$:N
#$%
!< " ! 

,$] ?@h: ? ?Z4>:>;<" 3" X$WE4K"]
3$:$_?2 >9:5?K?2 ? J"23" ?E$::h2>":
Z4$ 9$E$::>5$# 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" $K^A
52>E? @$2#?9$95$ q?45"22‘3>"] ?95>A
D425" @"2 :?5^K>5$] $5ENr "4 Z4$ ?D$5$#
" J?K?9;" $K^52>E"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g 
 ! = ,  > ] Z4$ X$2>D>E?2‘
:$ " :>:5$#? $K^52>E" 3" X$WE4K" 5$#
E?@?E>3?3$ @?2? :4@"25?2 ? E?2a? :"A
K>E>5?3?] "4 :$ ^ 9$E$::‘2>" >95$a2‘AK"
E"# 4#? J?5$2>? 3$ #?>"2 E?@?E>A
3?3$N

12$D>2? :$#@2$ ’E$::h2>": S$94WA
9": c$$@N .?95" " X$WE4K" E"#"
:$4: $Z4>@?#$95": E"9:"#$# $9$2A
a>? 3? J?5$2>? #$:#" 3$:K>a?3":% ^
" 3$9"#>9?3" xE"9:4#" $# :5?93yA
JyzN 8"#" ? J?5$2>? @"::4> 4# K>#>5$
#‘p>#" 3$ E"9:4#" @?2? a?2?95>2 ?
@?25>3? 3" #"5"2] 3$X$A:$ 3>#$9:>"A
9?2 " E"9:4#" 3": $Z4>@?#$95": 3$
?E"23" E"# $::? #?2a$#N
#$&
!#!
1?2? ?::$a42?2 ? Z4?K>3?3$ $ " @$2A
D$>5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"] 2$A
E"#$93?#": >9:5?K?2 :"#$95$ ?E$:A
:h2>": a$94W9": c$$@] g 3>:@":>;<" 9?
  ! = ,  > N
’ >9:5?K?;<" 3$ 2‘3>":] ?K?2#$:]
2?:52$?3"2$: "4 Z4?KZ4$2 "452" ?E$:A
:h2>" $K$52v9>E" 9<" a$94W9" @"3$2‘
"E?:>"9?2 E"9:4#" $pE$::>X" 3$
E?2a? 3? J?5$2>?] @"3$93" @2"X"E?2
" 9<" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K" $ ?
@$23? 3? a?2?95>?N

12$:5?2 ?5$9;<" 9? #"95?a$# 3$
2"3?: $ E?K"5?: 3$ 2"3? 9<" a$94W9?:%
@"3$# 2$34Y>2 ? X$95>K?;<" 3": D2$>":
$ @"25?95" ? :4? $D>E>[9E>? $# E"9A
3>;\$: 3$ D2$9?a$9: J24:E?:] E"9:A
5?95$: "4 2$@$5>3?:] E"#" $# K"9a?:
3$:E>3?:N 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 5?#J^# 3$
Z4$ 9?3? q@"2 $pN 5?@$5$:r @"::? >9A
5$2D$2>2 9" E42:" 3": @$3?>:N
!!   
$@A
-: 3>:@":>5>X": $K^52>A
E":o$K$52v9>E": >9:5?K?3": ?@h: ?
?Z4>:>;<" 3" X$WE4K" $ 9" e#J>5"
3" :$2X>;" @h:AX$93? 3$X$# 5$2 ?
#?2E? N
’ ,.+))’!.=, ?45"2>Y? ? #"9A
5?a$# 3$ 3>:@":>5>X": 2$E$@5"2$:A
52?9:#>::"2$: 3$:3$ Z4$ ?: >9:5?K?A
;\$: :$_?# 3$X>3?#$95$ $D$54?3?:
94# E$952" $:@$E>?K>Y?3"] 2$:@$>A
5?93" ?: >93>E?;\$: 3" D?J2>E?95$N

’ #"95?a$# 3$ 3>:@":>5>X": Z4$
E"#@"25$# #"3>D>E?;\$: 3?: E?2?EA
5$2W:5>E?: 3" X$WE4K" @"3$ 3$5$2#>9?2
>9D2?;\$: 3$ 52e9:>5" $ ? $X$954?K ?94A
K?;<" 3? a?2?95>? 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ?":
3?9": E?4:?3": @$K? 2$D$2>3? #"3>D>A
E?;<"] 3>2$5? "4 >93>2$5?#$95$N
’ ,.+))’!.=, 3$EK>9? Z4?KZ4$2
2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @"2 3?9": 2$:4KA
5?95$: 3? >9:5?K?;<" 3$ ?E$::h2>":
9<" D"29$E>3": "4 2$E"#$93?3":
@$K? ,.+))’!.=, $ >9:5?K?3": 9?
?4:[9E>? 3$ E"9D"2#>3?3$ E"# ?: $Z4>@?# " X$WE4K"] E"#@2"#$5$93"
>93>E?;\$: D"29$E>3?:N ? :$a42?9;? 3" #$:#"N
,$] 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K" $o"4 !
!"    @2hp>#" 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?]
! $:5>X$2$# @2$:$95$: 3>:@":>5>X":
E"#" E$K4K?2$:] E"#@45?3"2$:
-: ?@?2$Kb": 2?3>"52?9:#>::"2$: @"25‘5$>:] :#?25@b"9$: "4 5?JK$5:]
q8B] 2?3>"?#?3"2$: $ :>#>K?2$:r 9<" @"3$ X$2>D>E?2A:$ 4#? 2$34;<" 3$
@"3$# :$2 45>K>Y?3": 9" >95$2>"2 3" 3$:$#@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? 1?::>X$
X$WE4K"] ? 9<" :$2 Z4$ :$ 45>K>Y$ +952yo{$yK$:: +952yA!AS"N
4#? ?95$9? :$@?2?3? #"95?3?
$p5$29?#$95$N
’ $D>E>[9E>? 3$ 52?9:#>::<" $ 3$
2$E$@;<" 3$:5$: ?@?2$Kb": @"3$ D>E?2
@2$_43>E?3? @$K" $D$>5" 3$ JK>93?a$#
3? E?22"E$2>? 3" X$WE4K"N !" Z4$
E"9E$29$ ?" 4:" 3": E$K4K?2$: qS,&]
S1C,] (&.,] ).+r E"# b"#"K"a?A
;<" "D>E>?K] 3$X$# :$2 2>a"2":?#$95$
2$:@$>5?3?: ?: >9:524;\$: D"29$E>3?:
@$K" D?J2>E?95$ 3" E$K4K?2N


- 4:" 3$::$: 3>:@":>5>X": 9" >9A
5$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K" q:$# ?95$9? $pA
5$29?r @"3$ E?4:?2 3?9": g :?u3$ 3":
@?::?a$>2": $ D49E>"9?#$95": >22$A
a4K?2$: 9": :>:5$#?: $K$52v9>E": Z4$

#$’
#
!   %" 
V=,.’, *- V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N BA7

"

(
(
   !
! 1
!

"

7 8"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2 I 19$4:oC"3?:

L P?2h>: 3>?95$>2": 6 +:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"2$: $p5$29":
H 1?2?AJ2>:? F 1"25?:

($!
! B
!!

7 )4Y$: 52?:$>2?: H 1"25?A#?K?:

L )>#@?3"2oK?X?3"2 3" X>32" 52?:$>2"

($"
! C
!  "

"

7 8"#?93": 3?: K4Y$: $p5$29?: I V"K?95$

L *>D4:"2$: 3$ ?2 6 w4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
H ’K?X?9E? $:Z4$23? :"J " X"K?95$ qE"#?93": F ’K?X?9E? 3$ E"#?93": 3":
3$ D?2"K ?K5"oJ?>p" $ K4Y$: >93>E?3"2?: 3$ 3>2$A K>#@?3"2$:oK?X?3"2$: 3": X>32":
;<"r | 1"25?AK4X?:

($%
! D


7 8"#?93": 3": X>32": $K^52>E": I 8"#?93": EK>#?5>Y?;<"

L B?9E": 6 1?>9$K 3$ J"5\$: 3$ E"#?93"
H ’K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" F ,>:5$#? (E"99$E5

($&
 &    ! 8’1} *- &-.-C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AII
1-C.’A&’)’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AI6
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7
+w(=1’&+!.-, =!.+C!-, N N N N N N N N N N N 8A67
8T’V+, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7
C’8{ *+ .+.-  ,+ +w(=1’*- N N N N N N N N 8A66
8-&(.’*-C *+ =S!=/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AF
1C-.+/0- *- ’&B=+!.+ N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6F
,=,.+&’ *+ 1’C.=*’ C+&-.’ q,$
$Z4>@?3"r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A| ’1)=8’.=V- 8’C. q:$ $Z4>@?3"r N N N N N N N N N 8A6M

,=,.+&’ +)+.C}!=8- *+ 1C-.+/0- *- #

V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A~
,=,.+&’ *+ 1C-.+/0- ’!.=P(C.- N N N N N N N 8AM
1-C.’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A77
B’!8-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7F
’1-=’A8’B+/’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7M
*=C+/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8ALG
+,1+)T-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AL7
)(Q+, +¡.+C!’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8ALH
)(Q+, =!.+C!’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AL~
)=&1’*-C+, + )’V’*-C+, *-,
V=*C-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8ALM
8)=&’.=Q’/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AHH
V=*C-, +)f.C=8-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AIG
.+.- ,-)’C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AIL

)
)
 
8"#$;? ?Z4> " E"9b$E>#$95" 3$
:$4 9"X" X$WE4K"N
- #?94?K $p@K>E? 3$ D"2#? :>#@K$:
$ 3>2$5? E"#" ^ D$>5" $ E"#" D49E>"9?
1"2 >::"] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K E"9:4K5‘A
K" $:5?93" E"9D"25?X$K#$95$ :$95?3"
? J"23"] 3$ #"3" ? @$2#>5>2 X$2>D>E?2
>#$3>?5?#$95$ ?: @?25$: 3$:E2>5?: 9"
#?94?KN
&
! A!
!#!
=#@?E5": X>"K$95": @"3$# 3?9>D>A
E?2 ": E"#@"9$95$: $K$52v9>E": E"9A
5>3": 9? Eb?X$N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#! !#!
’: Eb?X$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# E"952"K$ 1?2? ?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# E?2A
2$#"5" @"::4$# $# :$4 >95$2>"2 4#? 2$a?3"2 :$# D>"] ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
J?5$2>? Z4$] :$ >9a$2>3?] @"3$ E?4:?2 !0- 3$X$ :$2 @":>E>"9?3? :"J2$ "
D$2>#$95": >95$29": a2?X$: $# 4# @$A #$:#"] "4 ? 4#? 3>:5e9E>? >9D$2>"2 ?
2W"3" 3$ 34?: b"2?:] @"3$93" K$X?2 g 76E# 3" E?22$a?3"2 :$# D>"N
#"25$N +# E?:" 3$ >9a$:5<" ?E>3$9A
- @":>E>"9?#$95" 3? Eb?X$ $K$A
#
5?K 3? #$:#?] @2"E42?2 ?5$93>#$95"
#^3>E" >#$3>?5?#$95$N 52v9>E? $# 4#? 3>:5e9E>? >9D$2>"2 ?
76 E# 3" E?22$a?3"2 :$# D>" "4 :"A
&?95$2 ? J?5$2>? q9"X? "4 4:?3?r J2$ " #$:#" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 " E"9A
D"2? 3" ?KE?9E$ 3$ E2>?9;?:N 52"K$ 2$#"5" 3? #$:#? $ >#@$3$ Z4$
" :>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 3" X$WE4K" 2$E"A
!": E?:": $# Z4$ 9<" D"2 @"::WA
9b$;? ? Eb?X$] 9<" :$93" @"::WX$K
X$K D>p?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ? J?5$2>? 9"
3?2 ? @?25>3? 9" X$WE4K"N
>95$2>"2 3? Eb?X$] @?::?2 ? 45>K>Y?2 ?
Eb?X$ 2$:$2X? 3" X$WE4K" $ 3>2>a>2A:$
g  !  , ' > ?::># Z4$    EF'   &&
@"::WX$KN ,$#@2$ Z4$ D"2 9$E$::‘A
2>? ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 3?
Eb?X$] D>9?K>Y?3? :4? 45>K>Y?;<"] @"A
:>E>"9?2 " #$:#" $# :4? :$3$ 9"
E"2@" 3? Eb?X$ @?2? $X>5?2 " ?E$::"
g J?5$2>? 3? #$:#?N
)$!
7N ’54?2 9" J"5<" 3$ K>J$2?;<" 3?
Eb?X$
LN +p52?>2 ? Eb?X$ #$Ee9>E?

)$"
G*  5 67 & - 6H , 
’ :$a4>2] $:5<" 2$:4#>3?: ?: @2>9E>@?>: D49;\$: Z4$ @"3$# :$2 ?5>X?3?: 45>K>Y?93" ? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<"N

!4 -     
G*  *       *     
 & '

8b?X$ $K$52v9>E? 12$::<" 9" J"5<" 12$::<" 9" J"5<" 12$::<" 34@K? 9" J"5<"
)?#@$_": 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"
L K?#@$_": 7 K?#@$_" L K?#@$_":
q@?2? Eb?X$ E"# E"952"K$ 2$#"5"r
#

)$%
!!" ! ! 
! !" !  !&"!! 3$>p?3? 3$952" 3" X$WE4K"N
12$::<" J2$X$ 9" J"5<" % 3$:A
52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:] 3? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?:] ?E$93>#$95" 5$#@"2>A
Y?3" 3? K4Y >95$29? $ :>9?K>Y?;<" K4A
#>9":? 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"N
f @"::WX$K @2$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 " J"A
5<" 3$ 3$:52?X?#$95" 9" E"952"K$ 2$A
#"5" 4#? u9>E? X$Y @?2? 3$:52?X?2 ?
@"25? 3>?95$>2? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5?
"4 34?: X$Y$: 9" $:@?;" 3$ 6 :$a49A
3": @?2? 3$:JK"Z4$?2 5"3?: ?: @"25?:
$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
f] 9" $95?95"] @"::WX$K #43?2 ? 3$A
D>9>;<" ?54?K 3$ #"3" Z4$ " :>:5$#?
3$:52?X$ ?@$9?: ? @"25? 3" E"9345"2
"4 5"3?: ?: @"25?: g @2>#$>2? @2$::<"
3" J"5<" 9" E"952"K$ 2$#"5"N 1?2?
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" x*>:@K?yz 9" E?@W54K" x8"9b$A
E>#$95" 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":z
$ ?: >93>E?;\$: D"29$E>3?: 9" :4@K$A
#$95" 3" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5N
)$&

- D49E>"9?#$95" 3" E"952"K$
2$#"5" 3$@$93$ 3$ X‘2>": D?5"2$:]
E"#" ? $X$954?K >95$2D$2[9E>? 3$
"93?: $K$52"#?a9^5>E?: $#>5>3?: @"2
D"95$: $p5$29?:d " $:5?3" 3$ E?2a? 3?
J?5$2>? $ ? @2$:$9;? 3$ "J_$5": #$5‘A
K>E": @2hp>#": 3? Eb?X$ 3" X$WE4K"N
!" $95?95"] ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ? ?J$2A
542? #?94?K 3" X$WE4K" 45>K>Y?93" "
$9E?>p$ #$5‘K>E" 3? Eb?X$] >952"34A
Y>93" " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 9? D$Eb?342?
3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2N
!!" ! !  !
!" !  !&"!! Eb?X$: $K$52v9>E?: 3$X>3?#$95$ E"A
12$::<" J2$X$ 9" J"5<" % 52?X?A
#$95" 3?: @"25?:] 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
#?K?: E"# 3$:K>a?#$95" 3? K4Y >9A
5$29? $ :>9?K>Y?;<" K4#>9":? 3": >9A
3>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"N
1?2? X$WE4K": $Z4>@?3": E"# Eb?A
X$: $K$52v9>E?:] :$ 4#? "4 #?>: @"2A
5?: $:5>X$2$# ?J$25?:] " 52?X?#$95"
^ $D$54?3"] 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 D"2#?N +9A
52$5?95"] ?: @"25?: :$2<" 3$:52?X?3?:
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ E?:" ? Eb?X$ :$_?

=9:$2>2 $ a>2?2 ? Eb?X$ 9? D$Eb?342?
3? @"25? 3" #"5"2>:5? 52?X? $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ $::? @"25?N
!  ! !&
!
G* ' I ,
1?2? a?2?95>2 ? >a9>;<" 3" #"5"2 $
" E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"]
^ 9$E$::‘2>" 45>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$
3>D>E?3?: @?2? " :>:5$#? $K$52v9>E"
3" X$WE4K"N
,$ 4#? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 5>X$2 :>3"
E"3>D>E?3? @?2? 4# X$WE4K"] 9<"
@"3$ :$2 45>K>Y?3" $# 9$9b4# "452"N
!#!
8?3? Eb?X$ D"29$E>3? @"::4> 4#
Eh3>a" @2h@2>"] 3>D$2$95$ 3$ 5"3":
": "452":] Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 @2$X>?#$95$
#$#"2>Y?3" @$K? E$952?K $K$52v9>E?
3" :>:5$#?N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
 ! ! ! 
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" @$3>2 4#?
9"X? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?] 3>2>a>2A:$ g
  ! = ,  > K$X?93"
E"9:>a" 4# 3"E4#$95" 3$ >3$95>D>A
E?;<" @$::"?K $ " 3"E4#$95" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
% ! %!! !
! A!
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ? J?5$2>?] @2"E$3$2
3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 +p52?>2 " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" @2$:$95$
9" >95$2>"2 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
 ’54?93" E"# ?5$9;<"] >952"34A
Y>2 ? @"95? 3" E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 9?
:$3$ 1 3? Eb?X$] 3$ #"3" ? :$A
@?2?2 ?: 34?: @?25$: Z4$ ? E"#A
@\$# q$# ?K5$29?5>X? ?" E"2@"
#$5‘K>E"] ^ @"::WX$K >952"34Y>2 ?
@?25$ @K?9? 3? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93?
?@2"@2>?3?rN
 C$#"X$2 ? J?5$2>? B
 =9:$2>2 4#? 9"X? J?5$2>?] E"#
?5$9;<" @?2? 2$:@$>5?2 ?: @"K?A
2>3?3$:N
C$#"95?2 ?: 34?: @?25$: 3? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E?] E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$
D>E?# E"22$5?#$95$ JK"Z4$?3?:N
 C$E"K"E?2 " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 9"
>95$2>"2 3? Eb?X$N
#

’ "@$2?;<" 3$ :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?A
5$2>? 3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3? E"# E4>3?3"]
3$ #"3" ? 9<" 3?9>D>E?2 ? Eb?X$ $K$A
52v9>E?N

1?2? 3?2 ? @?25>3? 9" X$WE4K" E"#
? J?5$2>? 3? Eb?X$ 3$:E?22$a?3?]
?@">?2 ? $p52$#>3?3$ ?22$3"93?3? 3?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? qK?3" "@":5" ?" 3"
E"2@" #$5‘K>E"r 9" J"5<" 3" 3>:@":>A
5>X" 3$ @?25>3? $ @2$::>"9?2 " @2h@2>"
J"5<" ?52?X^: 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
)$’
 
 
! A! &   
EF'   &&
1?2? ?5>X?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
^ 9$E$::‘2>" Z4$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
$:5$_? @2$:$95$ 9" >95$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘A
E4K"N
- E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" ?5>X?A:$
5?#J^# :$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? :$ $9A
E"952?2 9" >95$2>"2 3" @"25?A#?K?: "4
9? E"J$2542? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
- E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @"3$ ?:A
:4#>2 ": :$a4>95$: $:5?3":%
  @ % #"5"2 3$:K>a?3"]
JK"Z4$>" 3? 3>2$;<"N ’Ka49:
3>:@":>5>X": $K^52>E": q@"2 $pN]
D$Eb?#$95" E$952?K>Y?3" 3?:
)$*
@"25?:] ?K?2#$] $5ENr $:5<"]
E"9543"] 3>:@"9WX$>:N
  % @":>;<" 3$ #?2Eb?N ."A
3": ": 3>:@":>5>X": $K^52>E": $:A
5<" 3>:@"9WX$>:N f @"::WX$K @?:A
:?2 @?2? $:5$ $:5?3" @2$::>"9?93"
4#? X$Y " J"5<" 3" E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<"] :$# @2$::>"9?2 " @$A
3?K 3" D2$>"N
 ! % @?25>3? 3" #"5"2N

8"# " #"5"2 K>a?3"] ^ @"::WX$K
?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K" K$X?93" E"9A
:>a" ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?] ?::># " #"A
5"2 E"95>94?2‘ K>a?3"N - X$WE4K" ?:A
:>9?K?2‘ ? ?4:[9E>? 3? Eb?X$ 9" b?A
J>5‘E4K" 3$@">: 3$ D$Eb?3? ? @"25?N
1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$ ?
@?25>3? 3" #"5"2 X$2 E?@W54K" t1?25>3?
$ "@$2?;<"t
!#!
’95$: 3$ :?>2 3" X$WE4K"] ?E>"A
9?2 "  " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"N !?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"#
Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"] 3$:K"E?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" @?2? ? @":>;<"
q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r $ @2$::>"9?2 " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? 3$:K"E‘AK"
@?2?  N
w4?93" :?>2 3" X$WE4K"] JK"Z4$?2
:$#@2$ 5"3?: ?: @"25?: @2$::>"9?93"
" 2$:@$E5>X" J"5<" qE"9:4K5?2 ? "@;<"
t1?::>X$ +952yt 9" @?2‘a2?D" t1"25?:trN
!#!
1?2? ?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# :>:A
5$#? {$yK$:: +95$2A!AS"] 9<" 3$>p?2
? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 9" >95$2>"2 "4 @2hA
p>#" 3" X$WE4K" "4 94# K"E?K ?E$:A
:WX$K g: E2>?9;?:N !<" 3$>p?2 " X$WA
E4K" E"# " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ >a9>;<" 9?
@":>;<" N
 (#? E2>?9;? @"3$2>? ?E>"9?2 ": K$A
X?95?3"2$: 3": X>32": $K^52>E":] "4A
52": E"#?93": "4 E"K"E?2 " X$WE4K"
$# #"X>#$95"N
  '
   ( 
)*+,-
+:5$ :>:5$#? @$2#>5$ 3?2 ? @?25>3?
9" #"5"2 @$K" K?3" 3$ D"2? 3"
X$WE4K"] ?52?X^: 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?]
@2"@"2E>"9?93" E"9X$9>[9E>? $
#?95$93" ? :4? :$a42?9;?N -  ,>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 2$#"5? 9<"
?KE?9E$ #‘p>#" ^ 3$ ?@2"p>#?3?A
#$95$ 7GG #N

B?22$>2?: DW:>E?: $952$ " X$WE4K" $
? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? @"3$# "J:524>2 ?
E"#49>E?;<" $ 2$34Y>2 " ?KE?9E$ 3"
:>:5$#?N
" J! ! !! &
"!
  5-  ,  6H &
*       .-  *+&
,-' ,   ' K     &
   )
 8e#J>" $# q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN
 1"25?:] E?@v 3" #"5"2 $ 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?: D$Eb?3":N
 )4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? 3$:K>a?3?:N
 1$3?K 3$ D2$>" 9<" ?E>"9?3"N
 B?5$2>? E"# 4# 9WX$K ?E$>5‘X$K
3$ E?2a?N
3$:?5>X?3" $# $X$95" ?95$2>"2N
 =93>E?3"2 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K?2#$
X$>E4K?2 @>:E?93" q?K?2#$
?5>X?3"rN
 8"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 @ N
 8"#J4:5WX$K 9" 9WX$K #W9>#" 2$A
Z4$2>3"N
!#!
c?#?>: 3[ >9WE>" g @?25>3? 2$#"5?
$# 4#? a?2?a$# D$Eb?3? "4 Z4?KA
Z4$2 ?#J>$95$ E"9D>9?3" "4 @"4E"
X$95>K?3"N -: a?:$: 3$ $:E?@$ E"9A
5[# &"9hp>3" 3$ 8?2J"9" q8-r] Z4$
^ >9"3"2" $ >9E"K"2N - &"9hp>3" 3$ #
8?2J"9" ^ X$9$9":" $] :$ >9?K?3"]
@"3$ E?4:?2 a2?X$: E"9:$Z4[9E>?:]
?5^ #$:#" ? #"25$N
&?95$9b? ?: Eb?X$: D"2? 3" ?KA
E?9E$ 3?: E2>?9;?:N ’ "@$2?;<" 3"
,>:5$#? 3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5?] X>32":]
52?X?: 3?: @"25?: "4 "452": E"#?9A
3": @"3$ "E?:>"9?2 a2?X$: ?E>3$95$:N

8?:" " X$WE4K" D?Kb$ $# $p$E45?2
? @?25>3? "4 :?>? @2$#?542?#$95$
3" #"3" 3$ @?25>3? 2$#"5?] ?
#$9:?a$# E"22$:@"93$95$ ?" >#@$A
3>#$95" $9E"952?3" :$2‘ $p>J>3? 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N
)$+
 ’ #$9:?a$# @$2#?9$E$2‘ :$93"
$p>J>3? ?5^ Z4$ ? >a9>;<" :$_? E"K"A
E?3? 9? @":>;<" @ N
         
12$::>"9?2 34?: X$Y$: 2?@>3?#$95$
" J"5<" 3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5? 9?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N ’: @"25?: 3" X$WA
E4K" :<" 52?X?3?: $ ?: K4Y$: 3$ $:5?A
E>"9?#$95" @>:E?#N !? :$Z4[9E>?]
? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 :$2‘ $D$54?3? $
" X$WE4K" @$2#?9$E$2‘ 9" &"3" 3$
1?25>3? C$#"5? @"2 4# E>EK" 3$ 76
#>945":N

,$ 3$5$E5?3? Z4?KZ4$2 D?Kb? 9" #"A
5"2 "4 J?>p" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] "
#"5"2 :$2‘ 3$:K>a?3" ?@h: 7G :$a49A
3":N
’: K4Y$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" :$2<"
K>a?3?: $ ?::># :$2<" #?95>3?: 34A
2?95$ 5"3" " @$2W"3" $# Z4$ " X$WA
E4K" $:5>X$2 9" &"3" 3$ 1?25>3? C$A
#"5?N
)$,
1"2 4#? Z4$:5<" 3$ :$a42?9;?]
": X>32": $K^52>E": $ 5$5" :"K?2 $K^A
52>E" q:$ $Z4>@?3"r D>E?# 3$:?J>K>5?A
3": Z4?93" " X$WE4K" $:5‘ 9" &"3"
3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5?N
’ @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 @"3$2‘ :$2 $D$A
54?3? 2$#"5?#$95$ @"2 34?: X$Y$:
E"9:$E45>X?:N +952$5?95"] 4# E>EK"
3? >a9>;<" 3$X$2‘ :$2 $p$E45?3"
q@2$::>"9?93" 34?: X$Y$: " J"5<"
,.’C.o,.-1r @?2? Z4$ :$_? @"::WX$K
2$?K>Y?2 ? @?25>3? 4#? 5$2E$>2? X$YN
        
  5  *+,-'
12$::>"9?2 34?: X$Y$: 2?@>3?#$95$
" J"5<" 3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5? 9?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? "4 ?a4?23?2 " E>EK"
3$ 76 #>945": E"# " #"5"2 $# D49A
E>"9?#$95"N

1?2? $X>5?2 3$:K>a?#$95": 9<" >9A
5$9E>"9?>:] " :>:5$#? :$2‘ 3$:?J>K>A
5?3" E"# 4#? @2$::<" :>#@K$: 3" J"A
5<" 3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5? 9? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? $# ?5^ 3">: :$a493": ?@h:
?E4:?2 " 2$E$J>#$95" 3$ 4#? 5$95?A
5>X? X‘K>3? 3$ 1?25>3? C$#"5?N
         
 5  *+,-'
*42?95$ " E>EK" 3$ 76 #>945":] $9A
52$ 9" X$WE4K" @"25?93" 4#? Eb?X$
X‘K>3? $ @2$::>"9$ " J"5<" 3" E"#4A
5?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"N - #"3" 3$ @?25>3?
2$#"5? :$2‘ $9E$22?3" $ " X$WE4K" $:A
5?2‘ @2"95" @?2? :$2 E"934Y>3" 9"2A
#?K#$95$N
 .
  '
  !
L EL M
- :>:5$#? ,$952y {$y >#@$3$ ?
45>K>Y?;<" 9<" ?45"2>Y?3? 3" X$WE4K"]
3$:?5>X?93" ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2N
- :>:5$#? 9<" 9$E$::>5? 3$ b?J>A
K>5?;<"o?5>X?;<"% " D49E>"9?#$95" ^
?45"#‘5>E"] >93$@$93$95$#$95$ 3"
D?5" 3?: @"25?: 3" X$WE4K" $:5?2$#
JK"Z4$?3?: "4 3$:JK"Z4$?3?:N
 8"K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>A
;<" 9? @":>;<"  ] " :>:5$#? ,$9A
52y {$y >3$95>D>E? " Eh3>a" 52?9:#>A
5>3" @$K? Eb?X$N ,$ " Eh3>a" D"2 2$E"A
9b$E>3" E"#" X‘K>3"] " :>:5$#? ,$9A
52y {$y ?45"2>Y? ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2N
V"K5?93" ? E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  @ ] "
:>:5$#? ,$952y {$y 3$:?5>X? ? E$952?K
Z4$ E"952"K? " #"5"2] >#@$3>93"]
?::>#] ? @?25>3? 3" #$:#"N
1?2? ": @2"E$3>#$95": 3$ @?25>3?
3" #"5"2 E"22$5":] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" x1?25>3? 3" #"5"2z 9" E?@W54K"
t1?25>3? $ -@$2?;<"tN
!!  &
!"
,$] 342?95$ ? @?25>3?] " Eh3>a"
3? Eb?X$ 9<" 5>X$2 :>3" 2$E"9b$A
E>3" E"22$5?#$95$] 9" Z4?32" 3$
>9:524#$95": ^ X>:4?K>Y?3" " WE"9$
qE"9:4K5?2 ? :$;<" x)4Y$: 3$
?3X$25[9E>?: $ #$9:?a$9:z 9"
E?@W54K" t8"9b$E$93" " :$4 @?>9$K
3$ >9:524#$95":trN +:5? E"93>;<"
>#@K>E? 9? @?2?3? 3" #"5"2 ?@h: L
:$a493":N !$:5$ E?:"] ?@2"p>#?2 ?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r 3"
J"5<" ,.’C.o,.-1 $ @2$::>"9‘AK"
@?2? 4#? 9"X? 5$95?5>X? 3$ @?25>3?]
"4 E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  @ $ 9"X?#$95$
$#  d :$ " JK"Z4$>" @$2:>:5>2]
X"K5?2 ? 5$95?2 E"# ?: "452? Eb?X$:
D"29$E>3?:N ,$ ?>93? 9<" D"2 @"::WX$K
K>a?2 " #"5"2] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > N
,$ " WE"9$ D"2 X>:4?K>Y?3" 34A
2?95$ ? #?2Eb?] :>a9>D>E? Z4$ " :>:A
5$#? $:5‘ $D$54?93" 4# ?45"3>?aA
9h:5>E" q3$X>3"] @"2 $p$#@K"] ? 4#?
Z4$3? 3$ 5$9:<"rN ,$ ? X>:4?K>Y?;<"
@$2:>:5>2] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! &
= ,  > N

!<" X>"K?2 " :>:5$#? ,$952y {$y
N +X$954?>: #"3>D>E?;\$:o?K5$2?;\$:
@"3$# @2"X"E?2 ? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3?
D49;<" 3$ @2"5$;<"N
- :>:5$#? ,$952y {$y 9<" ^ E"#@?A
5WX$K E"# ?Ka49: :>:5$#?: 3$ >a9>;<"
g 3>:5e9E>? 3>:@"9WX$>: 9" #$2E?3"N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$:5$: 3>:@":>5>X": @"3$
@2"X"E?2 @2"JK$#?: 3$ @?25>3? $ ?
3$:?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<" 3$ @2"5$;<"N
."3?: ?: Eb?X$: D"29$E>3?: E"# "
X$WE4K" D"2?# @2"a2?#?3?: $# D49A
;<" 3" :>:5$#? $K$52v9>E" @2$:$95$
9" @2h@2>" X$WE4K"N
8?3? Eb?X$ @"::4> 4# Eh3>a" @2hA
@2>" Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 #$#"2>Y?3" @$K?
E$952?K 3" :>:5$#?N 1?2? ? #$#"2>A #
Y?;<" 3$ 9"X?: Eb?X$:] 3>2>a>2A:$ g
C$3$ 3$ ’::>:5[9E>? c$$@N
  '
   "
!!" / .- 0
- ?K?2#$ ^ @2$X>:5" $# ?3>;<" ?
5"3?: ?: D49;\$: 3" 5$K$E"#?93" _‘
?95$2>"2#$95$ 3$:E2>5?:N
  !!"
- ?K?2#$ >95$2X^# 9": :$a4>95$:
E?:":%
 ’J$2542? 9<" ?45"2>Y?3? 3$ 4#?
"4 #?>: @"25?:] 3" E?@v 3" #"A
)$-
 5"2 "4 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
q@2"5$;<" @$2>#$52?KrN
 ’E>"9?#$95" 3" E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" q45>K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? Eb?X$
9<" 2$E"9b$E>3? @?2? ? @":>;<"
rN
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3" ?K?2#$ @2"X"E?
" ?E>"9?#$95" 3? :>2$9$ $ 3": >93>A
E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"N

’ D49;<" 3$ JK"Z4$>" 3" #"5"2 ^
a?2?95>3? @$K" :>:5$#? ,$952y {$y¢]
Z4$ :$ ?5>X? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$] $pA
52?>93" ? Eb?X$ 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ >aA
9>;<" "4] 9?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"#
:>:5$#? {$yK$:: +95$2A!AS"] :?>93"
3" X$WE4K" K$X?93" E"9:>a" ? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? $ $D$54?93" " JK"Z4$>" 3?:
@"25?:N

- ?K?2#$ ^ ?3$Z4?3" 3$ "2>a$# g:
9"2#?: 3": 3>D$2$95$: @?W:$:N
)$!.
$p5$29" 3? @"25?N 1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?A

;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 ? "@;<" x1?::>X$ +9A
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?K?2#$ ?45"#"5>X" ^
52yz 9" @?2‘a2?D" x1"25?:zN
4# :>:5$#? E"#@K$#$95?2 3$ :$a4A
8"# $pE$;<" 3$ ?Ka49: #$2E?A
2?9;? 3$:$9X"KX>3" @?2? 3>D>E4K5?2 ?
3":] ?: :$5?: $D$54?# 4#? :>9?K>Y?A
"E"22[9E>? 3$ D425" 3" X$WE4K"] J$#
;<" K4#>9":? :>#@K$:] 4#? :>9?K>Y?A
E"#" ? ?;<" "4 ?5" 3$ X?93?K>:#"
3$ 5$2E$>2":N ;<" ?Eu:5>E? $ ?5>X? " 52?X?#$95" 3?:
@"25?:N
8"# " ?K?2#$ K>a?3"] 9" Z4?32"

3$ >9:524#$95": E"#$;? ? @>:E?2 ?
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?K?2#$ $K$52v9>E" 9<" K4YA$:@>? !
#"9>5"2? ? Z4$J2? 3$ X>32": $ ? #"A
X>#$95?;<" 3$ 4#? $X$954?K >9X?:<"
9" >95$2>"2 3" X$>E4K"N
!!  !!"
- ?K?2#$ :"#$95$ :$2‘ ?5>X?3"
E"# @"25?: $ E?@v D$Eb?3": $ " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" 
"4 $p52?W3?N
1?2? ?5>X?2] @":>E>"9$ ? Eb?X$ $#
3>2$;<" ?" X$WE4K"] 3$@">: @2$::>"9$ ’ ?5>X?;<" 3" ?K?2#$ ^ @2$E$3>3?
$ :"K5$ " J"5<" N 1?2? X$2:\$: @"2 4#? D?:$ 3$ ?45"3>?a9h:5>E"N
E"# Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?] ? ?5>X?;<" 3" !" E?:" $# Z4$ :$_? 3$5$E5?3?
?K?2#$ @"3$ 5?#J^# :$2 $D$54?3? 4#? ?9"#?K>?] ^ $#>5>3" 4#? :>9?K>A
?52?X^: 3? @2$::<" 3" J"5<" tJK"A Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?N
Z4$>" 3$ @"25?:t :>54?3" 9" @4p?3"2
 ,$ D"2 $#>5>3? 4#? :$a493? :>A
9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E? ?@h: ? ?5>X?;<"
3" ?K?2#$] 3$:?5>X‘AK" @2$::>"9?93"
" J"5<" ] X$2>D>E?2 " D$Eb?#$95"
E"22$5" 3?: @"25?:] 3" E?@v 3" #"A
5"2 $ 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:d $#
:$a4>3?] 2$?5>X?2 " :>:5$#? @2$::>"A
9?93" " J"5<" N ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?" 4K52?@?::?2 ?
,$ " ?K?2#$ $#>5>2 4# :>9?K :"9"2"
#$:#" E"# ?: @"25?:] E?@v $ 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?: E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?A
3":] :>a9>D>E? Z4$ D"> 3$5$E5?3? 4#?
?9"#?K>? 9" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:A
5$#?% 9$:5$ E?:"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > :
!!  !!"
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 9? Eb?X$N
,<" $D$54?3?: ?: :$a4>95$: ?;\$:
qE"# $pE$;<" 3$ ?Ka49: #$2E?3":r%
 *">: J2$X$: ?E$93>#$95": 3": >9A
3>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"N
 *">: J2$X$: :>9?>: ?Eu:5>E":
q"93$ @2$:$95$:r
 *$:52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:N
1?2? X$2:\$: E"# Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?]
? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" ?K?2#$ @"3$ 5?#A
'
J^# :$2 $D$54?3? @$K" @2"@2>$5‘2>" 3? !!"@!!"
Eb?X$ :$a42?93" 94# 3": @4p?3"2$: !J! ! !
3>?95$>2":N 1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:]  
E"9:4K5?2 ? "@;<" x1?::>X$ +952yz 9"
,$ 5"3?: ?: @"25?: $:5>X$2$# E"22$A
@?2‘a2?D" x1"25?:zN
5?#$95$ D$Eb?3?:] D>E?2<" 52?X?3?:
 X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ LG #
i#ob qD49;<" t’45"EK":$trN
’E>"9?93" ? ?J$2542? E$952?K>Y?3?
?52?X^: 3" E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 3? Eb?X$] 12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 9" @?>9$K
" ?K?2#$ 9<" :$ 3$:K>a?N 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2 "4
3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" @?2? $D$54?2
" 52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:] 5?#@? 3"
N  !!" @"25?A#?K?: $ 5?#@? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
1?2? $pEK4>2 5"5?K#$95$ " ?K?2#$ 8"# ?: @"25?: 52?X?3?:] @2$::>"9?2
q@"2 $p$#@K"% $# E?:" 3$ >9?5>X>A
" J"5<" @?2? $D$54?2 " 3$:52?X?A
3?3$ @2"K"9a?3? 3" X$WE4K"r $D$54?2
#$95" 3?: @"25?:] 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
" D$Eb?#$95" 3$ D"2#? #?94?K] 45>A
#?K?: $ 5?#@? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
K>Y?93" ? Eb?X$ 9? D$Eb?342?N

w4?93" :$ 3$:E?22$a?2$# ?:
@>Kb?: 3? Eb?X$ E"# 5$K$E"#?93"]
@?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " ?K?2#$] @":>E>"9?2
? Eb?X$ qK?3" "@":5" 3? Eb?X$ 3$
$#$2a[9E>?r 3" X$WE4K" @2hp>#" ?"
J"5<" 3$ >a9>;<" ,.’C.o,.-1N
)$!!
 *  @ *    -'
- 52?X?#$95" >93>X>34?K 3?: @"2A
5?: @"3$ 5?#J^# :$2 $D$54?3" ?54A
?93" 9" J"5<" 3$ 52?X?#$95" :"J2$
? #?;?9$5? 3$ ?J$2542? 3?: @"25?:N
1?2? 3$:52?X?2 ?: @"25?: D2"95?>:]
@4p?2 ? #?;?9$5? 3$ ?J$2542? 3?:
@"25?: ?5^ " @2>#$>2" J?5$95$ "4 ?54?2
9" J"5<" 3$ 52?X?#$95" :"J2$ ? #?A
;?9$5?N 1?2? 3$:52?X?2 ?: @"25?: 52?A
:$>2?:] ?54?2 9" J"5<" 3$ 52?X?#$95"
:"J2$ ? #?;?9$5? 3? @"25? $# Z4$:A
5<"N
!!"@!!"
! !  N
 *      ' (&
 ) E"# @"25?: D$Eb?3?:] @2$::>"9?2
" J"5<" 9? Eb?X$N

=9:$2>2 $ a>2?2 ? Eb?X$ 9? D$Eb?342?
3? @"25? 3" #"5"2>:5? 52?X? $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ $::? @"25?N
- 52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?: @"3$
?>93? :$2 ?5>X?3" E"# 5"3?: ?: @"25?:
)$!"
D$Eb?3?: $ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
?J$25?N (#? X$Y @2$::>"9?3" " J"A
5<" 9? Eb?X$] $:5?2‘ @2$3>:@":5"
" 52?X?#$95" 3$ 5"3?: ?: @"25?:]
>9EK4>93" ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
?J$25?N w4?93" ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
#?K?: D"2 D$Eb?3?] :$2‘ JK"Z4$?3? $
_‘ 9<" :$ @"3$2‘ ?J2>2 @$K" $p5$2>"2N
!#!
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 5$# E"9:>a" ?
Eb?X$ 9" #"#$95" 3" D$Eb?#$95"
3? @"25? "4 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:]
3$ #"3" ? $X>5?2 D$Eb?2 ? @2h@2>?
Eb?X$ 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"N
(#? X$Y D$Eb?3? 9" >95$2>"2] ?
Eb?X$ :h @"3$ :$2 2$E4@$2?3? E"#
? 45>K>Y?;<" 3? :$a493? Eb?X$ D"29$A
E>3?N
 *      ' (&
  ) @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 9?
Eb?X$ "4 >9:$2>2 $ a>2?2 " E"2@" #$A
5‘K>E" q@2$:$95$ 9" >95$2>"2 3? Eb?X$r
9? D$Eb?342? 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3"
#"5"2>:5?N
EL &&  !
L
!#!
- D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 2$A
E"9b$E>#$95" 3$@$93$ 3$ X‘2>": D?A
5"2$: E"#"] @"2 $p$#@K"] ? $X$954?K
>95$2D$2[9E>? 3$ "93?: $K$52"#?a9^5>A
E?: $#>5>3?: @"2 D"95$: $p5$29?: q@"2
$pN E$K4K?2$:r] " $:5?3" 3$ E?2a? 3?
J?5$2>? 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? $ ? @2$A
:$9;? 3$ "J_$5": #$5‘K>E": 9? @2"p>A
#>3?3$ 3? @2h@2>? Eb?X$ "4 3" X$WA
E4K"N
!$:5$: E?:":] ^] E"9543"] @"::WX$K
$D$54?2 " 3$:JK"Z4$>" 3?: @"25?: 45>A
K>Y?93" " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" @2$:$95$ 9"
>95$2>"2 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
- :>:5$#? 1?::>X$ +952y ^ E?@?Y 3$
>3$95>D>E?2 ? @2$:$9;? 3$ 4#? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? 9? @2"p>#>3?3$ 3?: @"25?:
$ 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
- :>:5$#? @$2#>5$ 52?X?2o3$:52?X?2
?: @"25?: q"4 ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:r
:$# 5$2 Z4$ @2$::>"9?2 9$9b4# J"5<"
9? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
,$ " :>:5$#? >3$95>D>E?2 E"#" X‘A
K>3? ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 3$5$E5?3? 9"
$p5$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"] J?:5? E"K"E?2 ?
#<" $# 4# 3": @4p?3"2$: 3?: @"2A
5?: 3>?95$>2?: @?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " ?K?2#$
$ 3$:52?X?2 " #$E?9>:#" 3$ ?J$2542?
3?: @"25?: $ 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
-93$ ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ $:5>X$2 @2$A
:$95$] E"K"E?93" ? #<" 9" @4p?A
3"2 3? @"25? 3" E"9345"2] ^ @"::WX$K
3$:52?X?2 ?@$9?: ? @"25? 3" K?3" 3"
#"5"2>:5? "4 5"3?: ?: @"25?: $# D49A
;<" 3? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$D>9>3? ?54?93"
9" #$94 "4 9" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£
q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
:4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
?5>X?2‘ 5?#J^# " ?K?2#$ q:$ $Z4>A

@?3"rN
,$ $:5>X$2 4:?93" K4X?: "4 :$ 5>X$2
Eb"X>3" $ " @4p?3"2 3? @"25? $:5>X$2
#"Kb?3"] ^ @"::WX$K Z4$ ? :$9:>J>K>A
3?3$ 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3" 1?::>X$ +952y D>A
Z4$ 2$34Y>3? $] E"9:$Z4$95$#$95$]
" 5$#@" 3$ 2$?;<" 3? D49;<" :$_?
#?>: K"9a"N
#
8"K"E?93" ? #<" 9" @4p?3"2 3?
@"25? 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"] 5"3?: ?:
@"25?: $ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: :$ !0- E"K"E?2 ? #<" :"J2$ " @4p?A
3$:52?X?#N 3"2 3? @"25? @?2? @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
3$ 52?X?#$95"N .?K ?;<" @"3$ 3$:A
 *      52?X?2 ?E>3$95?K#$95$ ?: @"25?:N
1?2? $D$54?2 " 52?X?#$95" 3?: @"2A
5?:] @2"E$3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 5$# E"9:>a"
? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? $ Z4$ :$ $9A
E"952? @2hp>#" 3" @4p?3"2 3?
@"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? "4 3"
@?::?a$>2"N
 12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" t.2?X?#$95"
3?: @"25?:t :>54?3" 9" @4p?3"2]
3$:5$ #"3"] :$2<" 52?X?3?: 5"3?: 
?: @"25?: $ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A *$@">: 3$ 5$2 @2$::>"9?3" " J"5<"
#?K?:N - 52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?: 3$ t52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:t] ^ 9$E$:A
)$!%
:‘2>" ?a4?23?2 L :$a493": ?95$: 3$
@"3$2 9"X?#$95$ 3$:52?X?2 ?: @"25?:
?52?X^: 3" @4p?3"2N ’54?93" 9" @4A
p?3"2 3? @"25? 9" $:@?;" 3$ L :$A
a493": ^] ?::>#] @"::WX$K X$2>D>E?2 :$
" X$WE4K" $:5‘ E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?3"]
:$# Z4$ ?: @"25?: :$_?# 9"X?#$95$
3$:52?X?3?:N
’: @"25?: $ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
3" X$WE4K" @"3$# :$2] 3$ Z4?KZ4$2
D"2#?] 52?X?3?: @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"
9? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? "4 9" @?>9$K
>95$29" 3? @"25? 3" X$WE4K"N
!4 -     5= ,    
 '   
,$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 9<" D49E>"A
9?2] @"2 $p$#@K"] $# E?:" 3$ J?5$A
2>? 3$:E?22$a?3? 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
"4 3" @2h@2>" X$WE4K"] ^] 9" $95?95"]
@"::WX$K 45>K>Y?2 " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 3$
$#$2a[9E>? @2$:$95$ 9" >95$2>"2 3?
Eb?X$ @?2? ?E>"9?2 " 3$:52?X?#$95"
3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5?N
1?2? $p52?>2 " E"2@" #$5‘K>E"] @2"A
E$3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" $# t)>J$2?;<"
3? Eb?X$ 3$ $#$2a[9E>?t 9? :$;<"
)$!&
t8b?X$:t 3$:5$ #$:#" E?@W54K"N =9A
:$2>2] $# :$a4>3?] " E"2@" #$5‘K>E"
3? Eb?X$ 9? D$Eb?342? 3? @"25? 3"
K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? $ a>2‘AK" @?2? 3$:A
52?X?2 ? @"25?N

- E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 3? Eb?X$ 9<"
5$# 4# :$95>3" 3$ >9:$2;<" "J2>a?5hA
2>"d @"3$] ?::>#] :$2 >952"34Y>3" >9A
3>D$2$95$#$95$ 9" >95$2>"2 3? D$Eb?A
342?N

’ D># 3$ $X>5?2 3$>p?2 >9X"K495?2>?A
#$95$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 9" >95$2>"2
3" X$WE4K"] ? D49;<" 1?::>X$ +952y
$:5‘ $Z4>@?3? E"# 4#? D49;<" ?45"A
#‘5>E? 3$ 3$:52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:
Z4$ D49E>"9? :$ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >aA
9>;<" $:5>X$2 9? @":>;<"  N

,$ 4#? 3?: @"25?: 3" X$WE4K" $:5>A
X$2 ?J$25? $ D"2 @2$::>"9?3" " J"5<"
tJK"Z4$>" 3?: @"25?:t :>54?3" 9": @4A
p?3"2$: 3?: @"25?: 3>?95$>2?:] "4 "
J"5<" 9? #"K342? >95$29? 3" @?>A
9$K 3? @"25?] 4#? X$Y D$Eb?3?: 5"3?:
?: @"25?: ?J$25?:] " X$WE4K" $D$54? 4#
E"952"K$ >95$29" $ $p5$29" @?2? X$2>A
D>E?2 ? $X$954?K @2$:$9;? 3$ Eb?X$:
$K$52v9>E?: b?J>K>5?3?:N
,$] 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"] D"2 3$A
5$E5?3? 4#? 3?: Eb?X$: $K$52v9>E?: $
9$9b4#? "452? D"2 3$5$E5?3? 9" :$4
$p5$2>"2] ? D49;<" 1?::>X$ +952y 3$:A
52?X? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 5"3?: ?: @"2A
5?:] $#>5$ 52[: :>9?K>Y?;\$: ?Eu:5>E?:
$ ?E>"9? ": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"N
,$] @$K" E"952‘2>"] 9" >95$2>"2
3" b?J>5‘E4K"] :$ $9E"952?2$#
4#? "4 #?>: Eb?X$: $K$52v9>E?:]
@2$::>"9?93"A:$ " J"5<" ] " D49A
E>"9?#$95" 3?: Eb?X$: 9" >95$2>"2
3" b?J>5‘E4K" :$2‘ 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$
3$:?5>X?3"N
1?2? 2$?5>X?2 " :$4 E"22$5" D49E>"A
9?#$95"] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" N

’: @"25?: :h :$2<" 3$:52?X?3?:
Z4?93" 5>X$2$# :>3" D$Eb?3?: @2$:A
:>"9?93" " J"5<" t.2?X?#$95" 3?:
@"25?:t K"E?K>Y?3" 9": @4p?3"2$:
3?: @"25?: 3>?95$>2?:] "4 " J"5<"
9? #"K342? >95$29? 3" @?>9$K 3?
@"25?] Z4?93" 4#? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
X‘K>3? D"2 2$E"9b$E>3? 9" >95$2>"2 3"
X$WE4K" $] 9" $p5$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"]
9<" D"2 3$5$E5?3? 9$9b4#? "452?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
1"2 :4? X$Y] " X$WE4K" 9<" 3$:JK"A
Z4$?2‘ ?: @"25?: ?" X$2>D>E?2A:$ 4#?
3?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
 ’: @"25?: 5>X$2$# :>3" D$Eb?3?:
#?94?K#$95$ 45>K>Y?93" ": @4A
p?3"2$: 3$ 52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:
q"4 " E"2@" #$5‘K>E" 3? Eb?X$]
?@$9?: @?2? ? @"25? 3" #"5"2>:5?rN
 .>X$2 :>3" 3$5$E5?3? 9" $p5$2>"2
4#? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 9?: @2"p>A
#>3?3$: 3" X$WE4K"N
,$ ? D49;<" 1?::>X$ +952y D"2 3$:?A
5>X?3? ?54?93" 9" &$94 3" 3>:@K?y
"4 9" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£] ?: @2"5$A
;\$: @?2? $X>5?2 3$>p?2 >9X"K495?2>?A
#$95$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 9" >95$2>"2
3" X$WE4K" 3$:?5>X?#A:$ q@?2? #?>:
>9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95"
$:@$EWD>E"rN
!,   & '
’" ?@2"p>#?2A:$ 3? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?: E"# 4#? Eb?X$ $K$A
52v9>E? X‘K>3?] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
3$ ?J$2542? :>54?3" 9? @2h@2>?
#?;?9$5? 3? 5?#@? @?2? 3$:52?X?2 "
@"25?A#?K?: $] :$ $Z4>@?3? ? D49;<"]
?J2>AK? $K$52"9>E?#$95$ $# 4# :h
#"X>#$95"N

,$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? D"2 $:Z4$E>3?
9" >95$2>"2 3" @"25?A#?K?:] " 52?X?A
#$95" 3? 5?#@? 9<" :$2‘ $D$54?3"] ?
9<" :$2 Z4$ $:5$_? @2$:$95$ 9" $p5$A
2>"2 4#? "452? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 2$E"A
9b$E>3? 9? @2"p>#>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"N
8"# " X$WE4K" JK"Z4$?3"] ?" :$
$D$54?2 " 3$:52?X?#$95" ?@$9?: 3?
5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:] $ 9" @":5$2>"2
D$Eb?#$95" D"2 3$5$E5?3? 4#? Eb?X$
9" :$4 >95$2>"2] 5"3?: ?: @"25?: :$2<"
3$:52?X?3?: $ ?: K4Y$: @>:E?2<" 34?:
X$Y$:N #

’95$: 3$ E"K"E?2 " X$WE4K" $# #"A
X>#$95"] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " @"25?A
#?K?: $:5$_? E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?3"N
 *        &
'
1?2? $D$54?2 " 52?X?#$95" 3" @"25?A
#?K?:] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 9?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? "4 9" @?>9$K >95$29"
3$ 4#? @"25? 3>?95$>2?] "4 ?>93?
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" :>54?3" g 3>2$>5?
9? @?25$ >95$29? 3" @4p?3"2 $p5$29"
E"# ?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" q:$ $Z4>A
@?3"rN +::? ?;<" 5?#J^# >2‘ JK"A
Z4$?2 5"3?: ?: @"25?: 3" X$WE4K"N
)$!’
! *67@ *67    
- :>:5$#? 1?::>X$ +952y @"3$ :$2
?5>X?3"o3$:?5>X?3" ?52?X^: 3" &$94
3" 3>:@K?y "4 3" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£
q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
:4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
   !!
!! !! ?" #?95$2 ?: E":5?: J$# ?@">?3?:
!#!
(5>K>Y?2 :$#@2$ $:5$ 3>:@":>5>X"
Z4?93" 52?9:@"25?2 E2>?9;?:N
*$@">: 3$ 5$2 ?E>"9?3" " 3>:@":>A
5>X" $# ?#J?: ?: @"25?: 52?:$>2?:] X$A
2>D>E?2 ? :4? $D$5>X? ?5>X?;<" ?54?93"
9" @4p?3"2 >95$29" 3$ ?J$2542? 3?:
@"25?:N
)"E?K>Y?3": @2hp>#": ?": 52>9E":
3?: @"25?: 52?:$>2?:] >#@$3$# :4?
?J$2542? @$K" >95$2>"2N
- 3>:@":>5>X" :h @"3$ :$2 ?E$::?3"
$ ?5>X?3" E"# ?: @"25?: ?J$25?:N 1?2?
)$!*
>::"] 45>K>Y?2 4#? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93?  
?@2"@2>?3? $ a>2‘AK"%
!  %!
-: J?9E": 3>?95$>2": @"3$# :$2
2$a4K?3": 3$ #"3" ? a?2?95>2 " #‘A
p>#" E"9D"25" 3": "E4@?95$:N
’ 2$a4K?a$# 3" J?9E" 3" E"9345"2
3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3? "J:$2X?93"A:$ Z4$]
E"952? " $9E":5"] ": @4K:": 3$X$#
@"3$2 ?5>9a>2 ? @?25$ :4@$2>"2 3" ?2"
 ’5^ ? @":>;<" % 3>:@":>5>X" 3" X"K?95$N
?5>X" q@"25? JK"Z4$?3?rd ’K^# 3>::"] 3$X$ :$2 @"::WX$K @>:?2
 ’5^ ? @":>;<" % 3>:@":>5>X" 9" @$3?K 3" D2$>" ?5^ " :$4 D># 3$
3$:K>a?3" q? @"25? @"3$ :$2 ?J$25? E42:"N
@$K" >95$2>"2rN
- :>:5$#? @$2#?9$E$
?5>X" #$:#" ?" $D$54?2 "
3$:52?X?#$95" $K^52>E" 3?: !#!
@"25?:N
w4?KZ4$2 2$a4K?a$# 3$X$ :$2 $D$A
54?3? :"#$95$ E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# :$a42?9;?N

!#!
-: 2$X$:5>#$95": 5[p5$>: 3": J?9A
E": $:5<" 3>#$9:>"9?3": @?2? 2$:>:5>2
342?95$ #4>5" 5$#@" ?" 3$:a?:5$ 2$A
:4K5?95$ 3? 45>K>Y?;<" 9"2#?K 3" X$WA
E4K"N
!" $95?95"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" $X>5?2
D2>E;\$: $pE$::>X?: $o"4 @2"K"9a?A
3?: E"# ?E$::h2>": 3$ X$:54‘2>"] 5?>:
E"#" D>X$K?: #$5‘K>E?:] ?@K>E?;\$:]
D>p?3"2$: $# X$KE2" $ :$#$Kb?95$:]
4#? X$Y Z4$ ": #$:#":] ?54?93"
3$ #"3" K"E?K>Y?3" $ E"# 4#? $K$A
X?3? @2$::<" 9": D>":] @"3$# @2"X"A
E?2 ? 24@542? 3": #$:#":] E"# E"9A
:$Z4$95$: 3?9": 9" 2$X$:5>#$95"N
5-'5     ' 5 - '
)$X?95?2 ? ?K?X?9E? $ $#@422?2 "
J?9E" @?2? ? D2$95$ "4 @?2? 52‘:N
*$:K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? @?2? E>#? "4
@?2? J?>p" ?5^ ? "J5$2 ? ?K542? 3$:$A
_?3?N
#
!#!
(#? X$Y ?E>"9?3? ? ?K?X?9E?
5-'5  ,' 67   &
3$ 2$a4K?a$#] X$2>D>E?2 :$#@2$ :$
,
" J?9E" $:5‘ JK"Z4$?3" 9?: a4>?:]
5$95?93" 3$:K"E‘AK" @?2? ? D2$95$ $ ’54?2 9? ?K?X?9E? ] ?E"#@?A
@?2? 52‘:N 9b?93" " $9E":5" E"# " #"X>#$95"
3" 52"9E" q#?95$2 ? ?K?X?9E? ?E>"A
’ ?4:[9E>? 3$:5$ JK"Z4$>" @"3$2‘ 9?3? ?5^ ?5>9a>2 ? @":>;<" 3$:$_?3? $
@2"X"E?2 " 3$:K"E?#$95" >9$:@$2?3" 3$@">: :"K5‘AK?rN
3" J?9E" $ E?4:?2 ? @$23? 3$ E"9A
52"K$ 3" X$WE4K"N
5-'5  '- 

+D$54?2 ? 2$a4K?a$#] $:5?93" :$9A
5?3" 9" J?9E" $# Z4$:5<" qK?3" 3"
#"5"2>:5? "4 K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"rN
)$!+
%!  "! @
!! " !"
$! / .- 0
’Ka4#?: X$2:\$: @"3$# $:5?2 $Z4>A
@?3?: E"# 2$a4K?a$# $K^52>E? @?2? "
J?9E" 3" #"5"2>:5? $o"4 J?9E" 3"
@?::?a$>2"N -: >95$224@5"2$: $K^52>E":
@?2? ": J?9E": 3>?95$>2": q2$a4K?a$#
@?2? " ?::$95" $ @?2? " $9E":5"r $:5<"
K"E?K>Y?3": 9": K?3": $p5$29": 3":
J?9E":] @2hp>#": ?" ?::"?Kb"N (:$A
": @?2? $D$54?2 ": ?_4:5$:N
!#!
!<" E"K"E?2 "J_$5": @"2 J?>p" 3"
J?9E" E"# 2$a4K?a$# $K^52>E? @?2?
9<" 3>D>E4K5?2 " :$4 #"X>#$95" $ E?4A
:?2 3?9": ?": :>:5$#?: 3$ 2$a4K?a$#N
’K^# 3>::"] "J_$5": 3$>p?3": 3$A
J?>p" 3" J?9E" @"3$# K>#>5?2 " #"A
X>#$95" 3" #$:#"N
5-'5     ' 5 - '
+#@422?2 " >95$224@5"2 @?2? ? D2$95$
"4 @?2? 52‘: @?2? 3$:K"E?2 " J?9E"
9? 3>2$;<" E"22$:@"93$95$N - J?9E"
#"X$2‘ 9? 3>2$;<" 3" >95$224@5"2N
)>J$2$ " >95$224@5"2 Z4?93" ? @":>;<"
3$:$_?3? D"2 ?KE?9;?3?N
5-'5  '-  5-'5  ,' 67   &
14p?2 "4 $#@422?2 " >95$224@5"2 ,
@?2? #"3>D>E?2 ? ?K542? 3" ?::$95" 3" +#@422?2 " >95$224@5"2 @?2? ? D2$95$
J?9E"N - J?9E" :$ #"X$2‘ 9? 3>2$A "4 @?2? 52‘: @?2? >9EK>9?2 " $9E":5"
;<" 3" >95$224@5"2N )>J$2$ " >95$224@A 9? 3>2$;<" E"22$:@"93$95$N - $9A
5"2 Z4?93" ? @":>;<" 3$:$_?3? D"2 ?KA E":5" 3" J?9E" :$ #"X$2‘ 9? 3>2$A
E?9;?3?N ;<" 3" >95$224@5"2N )>J$2$ " >95$224@A
5"2 Z4?93" ? @":>;<" 3$:$_?3? D"2 ?KA
5-'5  ,' 67    E?9;?3?N
14p?2 "4 $#@422?2 ? @?25$ D2"95?K
3" >95$224@5"2 @?2? #"3>D>E?2 " e9A
a4K" 3$ >9EK>9?;<" 3? ?K#"D?3? 3"
?::$95"N - J?9E" :$ #"X$2‘ 9? 3>2$A
;<" 3" >95$224@5"2N

’52?X^: 3$:5$: J"5\$: ^ @"::WX$K 2$A

a4K?2 ? ?K542?] ? @":>;<" 9" :$95>3"
K"9a>543>9?K $ ? >9EK>9?;<" 3" $9A
E":5"N
)$!,
5-'5 ' 4 '9 , & 
.- 
’54?2 9" >95$224@5"2% @?2? D2$95$ "4
@?2? 52‘: @?2? ?4#$95?2 "4 3>#>94>2
" :4@"25$ 3? Y"9? K"#J?2d @?2? E>#?
"4 @?2? J?>p" @?2? :4J>2 "4 3$:E$2 ?
@":>;<" 3" :4@"25$ K"#J?2N
%! !  
% ! /O2@D20
1?2? "J5$2 ? $p@?9:<" 3? ‘2$? 3$
E?2a? 3" X$WE4K"] E?3? @?25$ 3"
J?9E" 52?:$>2" @"3$ :$2 5"5?K#$95$
2$EK>9?3?N =::" @$2#>5$ ? $p5$9:<"
3" $:@?;" @?2? 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E?2a?
$9Z4?95" #?95^# ?Ka4# $:@?;"
@?2? "E4@?95$: 9" J?9E" 52?:$>2"]
E"9D"2#$ ? E"9D>a42?;<" 3$:$_?3?N
%!"  %! !&

1?2? 2$J?5$2 " J?9E" 52?:$>2"] J?:5?
@4p?2 ?: ?K?X?9E?: 9?: K?5$2?>: :4@$A
2>"2$: 3" J?9E" $] $# :$a4>3?] 3"A
J2?2 ": $9E":5": E"#@K$5?#$95$ @?2?
D2$95$N
1?2? 2$5"29?2 g E"9D>a42?;<" "2>a>A
9?K] K$X?95?2 ": $9E":5": ?5^ 52?X‘A
K":N
' 
%! !
1?2? ?4#$95?2 ? :$a42?9;? 3":
@?::?a$>2":] ": ?@">?AE?J$;?: :<" 2$A
a4K‘X$>: $# ?K542?N
!#!
)$#J2$A:$ Z4$ ": ?@">?AE?J$;?:
3$X$# :$2 2$a4K?3": $pEK4:>X?#$95$
E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3" $ 3$ #?9$>2?
Z4$ ? 94E?] $ 9<" " @$:E";"] :$
?@">$ 9$K$:N
,"#$95$ 9$:5? @":>;<" @"3$#
#
@2"5$a[AK" $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:\$:N
1?2? 2$a4K?2 ? ?K542?] K$X?95?2 "
?@">?AE?J$;? ?5^ "4X>2 " 2$:@$E5>X"
24W3" 3$ JK"Z4$>"N
1?2? ?J?>p‘AK":] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
3$ ?_4:5$N
)$!-
! !&!%! !  67
5-'5 
1?2? ": K4a?2$: 52?:$>2": $:5<" @2$A
X>:5": ?@">": 3$ E?J$;? 2$a4K‘X$>:
$# 3">: 9WX$>: 3$ ?K542?N
7N B"5<" 3$ K>J$2?;<"
LN B"5<" 3$ ?_4:5$
C$a4K?a$# @?2? E>#?% $K$X?2 "
?@">" 3$ E?J$;? ?5^ "4X>2 " 2$:@$EA
5>X" 24W3" 3$ JK"Z4$>"N
C$a4K?a$# @?2? J?>p"% @2$::>"9?2
" J"5<" 3$ ?_4:5$ $ ?J?>p?2 " ?@">"
3$ E?J$;?N
)$".
1?2? 2$#"X$2 ": ?@">?AE?J$;?:]
@2"E$3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
 )$X?95?2 ": ?@">?AE?J$;?: ?5^ g
?K542? #‘p>#?
 C$J?5$2 ": $9E":5": 3" J?9E"]
?E>"9?93" ?: ?K?X?9E?: K?5$2?>:
 12$::>"9?2 ": J"5\$:] 3$ ?_4:5$ $
3$ K>J$2?;<"] ?" K?3" 3": 3">:
:4@"25$:
 1"2 D>#] 2$#"X$2 ":
?@">?AE?J$;?: @4p?93"A": ?5^
2$5>2?2 ?: b?:5$: 3?: :$3$: 9":
$9E":5": 3": J?9E":N

-: ?@">?AE?J$;?: 52?:$>2":] 4#?
X$Y 2$#"X>3":] 3$X$# :$#@2$ :$2
2$@":>E>"9?3": E"22$5?#$95$ ?95$:
3$ @2"E$3$2 g 9"2#?K 45>K>Y?;<" 3"
X$WE4K"N C$>952"34Y>2 ?: b?:5$: 3"
?@">?AE?J$;?: 9?: 2$:@$E5>X?: :$3$:]
#?95$93" @2$::>"9?3": ": J"5\$: 3$
?_4:5$ $ 3$ K>J$2?;<"N +# :$a4>3?]
2$@":>E>"9?2 ": ?@">?AE?J$;?:
E"9D"2#$ ?: 9$E$::>3?3$:N
 
!"  !
!#!
’: 2$a4K?a$9: ?@$9?: 3$X$# :$2 2$A
?K>Y?3?: E"# " X$WE4K" $:5?E>"9?3"
$ " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3"N
,"#$95$ ?::># @"3$2‘ :$2 a?2?9A
5>3? ? :$a42?9;?N
!#!
f 5$2#>9?95$#$95$ @2">J>3? Z4?KA
Z4$2 >95$2X$9;<" $# @h:AX$93?] E"#
E"9:$Z4$95$: 3?9": 9? 3>2$;<" "4
9? E"K49? 3$ 3>2$;<" q@"2 $pN #"9A
5?a$# 3$ :>:5$#? ?95>D425"rN
’: >95$2X$9;\$: @"3$# E?4:?2]
?K^# 3? 3>#>94>;<" 3" 3$:$#@$9b"
3" :>:5$#? $ @$23? 3? a?2?95>?]
a2?X$: @2"JK$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;?N
 - X"K?95$ @"3$ :$2 2$a4K?3" $#
?K542? $ $# @2"D493>3?3$%
*$:K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? >93>E?3? @?2?
J?>p" q$# 3>2$;<" ?" ?::"?Kb"rN
+D$54?2 ? 2$a4K?a$# 3" X"K?95$N
C$5"29?2 ? ?K?X?9E? g @":>;<" "2>A
a>9?K @?2? 52?X?2 " X"K?95$ 9"X?A
#$95$N
 '&
   
*$:K"E?93" ? ?K?X?9E? "J5^#A:$%
 1":>;<" 9"2#?K
 1":>;<" ?95>"D4:E?#$95"
- $:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29" ^
$Z4>@?3" E"# 4# 3>:@":>5>X" E"952?
?E>3$95$: Z4$ " 3$:@2$93$ $# E?:"
3$ Eb"Z4$N
   A&
"
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $p>:5$ 4# $:A
@$Kb" $K$52"E2v#>E"] E?@?Y 3$ #"3>A
D>E?2 ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ? E?@?E>3?3$
2$DK$5"2? @?2? $X>5?2 " "D4:E?#$95"
3" E"9345"2
- $:@$Kb" $K$52"E2v#>E" @"::4>
4#? 5$EK? @ @?2? ? ?5>X?A
;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<" $K$52"E2vA
#>E? ?95>"D4:E?#$95"N
   N&

5-'5 '9 ,
’ 2$a4K?a$# ^ @"::WX$K :"#$95$
E"# ? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 N
)$"!

 ’A 1":>;<" 9$452?
 BA ,$K$;<" 3" $:@$Kb" $:Z4$23"
 8A 8"952"K$ 3? @":>;<" 3": $:@$A
Kb":N
 *A ,$K$;<" 3" $:@$Kb" 3>2$>5"
 +A C$E"Kb>#$95" $K^52>E" 3": 2$A
52"X>:"2$: q:$ $Z4>@?3"r

.$2#>9?3? ? 2$a4K?a$#] a>2?2 " J"A
5<" 3$ :$K$;<" 3" $:@$Kb" @?2? ? @"A
:>;<" 9$452? @?2? $X>5?2 3$:K"E?#$9A
5": ?E>3$95?>:N
)$""
!#!
w4?KZ4$2 2$a4K?a$# 3$X$ :$2 $D$A
54?3? :"#$95$ E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# :$a42?9;?N
!#!
’: K$95$: 3": $:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"A
2$: :<" @?2?JhK>E?: $ ?4#$95?# "
E?#@" 3$ X>:<"N
!" $95?95"] 3>#>94$# " 5?#?9b"
3? >#?a$#] 3?93" ? >#@2$::<" 3$
Z4$ " "J_$5" 2$DK$5>3" $:5‘ #?>: 3>:A
5?95$ 3" Z4$ ? 2$?K>3?3$N
,'G    -'
1?2? 2$E"Kb$2 ": $:@$Kb":]
$#@422‘AK": 3? @":>;<" "2>a>9?K 9"
:$95>3" 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
,$ ? :?K>[9E>? 3" $:@$Kb" E2>?2 3>A
D>E4K3?3$: 94#? @?::?a$# $:52$>5?]
3"J2$A" 3? @":>;<" ?J$25? @?2? ?
@":>;<" 2$E"Kb>3?] 2$5"29?93" g @2>A
#$>2? ?::># Z4$ @"::WX$K] :$#@2$ 9?
3>2$;<" >93>E?3? @$K?: :$5?:N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
,'G   '9 , / .- &
0
1?2? 2$E"Kb$2 ": $:@$Kb":] a>2?2 "
J"5<" :$K$5"2 @?2? ? @":>;<" 3$ 2$E"A
Kb>#$95" $K^52>E"N 1":>E>"9?2 " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" 
@?2? E"K"E?2 ": $:@$Kb": 9? @":>;<"
3$ #?2Eb?N

*42?95$ ? #?2Eb?] ": $:@$Kb": 3$A
X$# :$2 #?95>3": :$#@2$ ?J$25":]
949E? 3$X$# $:5?2 3"J2?3":N
,'G   - P ,  &
 *   / .- 0
+:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K] @?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2A
:\$:] " 2$E"Kb>#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3":
2$52"X>:"2$: $p5$29":N
1":>E>"9?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  @?2? E"K"E?2 ": $:A
@$Kb": 9? @":>;<" 3$ #?2Eb?N
+:5? D49;<" @$2#>5$ #?>"2$: $:@?A
;": $952$ ": X$WE4K": $# $:5?E>"9?A
#$95": $ @2"5$a$ ": 2$52"X>:"2$: E"9A
52? ?E>3$95$:N
!;" $  
  N / .- &
0
12$::>"9?93"A:$ " J"5<" 9"
EK>#?5>Y?3"2] ?5>X?A:$ " 3$:$#A
J?;?#$95"o3$:E"9a$K?#$95" 3":
$:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"2$: $p5$29":N
   ! "&
! / .- 0
8?3? @?2?A:"K b‘ 4# $:@$Kb" 3$
E"25$:>? >K4#>9?3"N 1?2? 4:?2 " $:@$A
Kb"] a>2?2 " @?2?A:"K @?2? J?>p" $ K$A
X?95?2 ? E"J$2542?N ’: K4Y$: :$ ?E$9A
3$# ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ $ :<" 3$:K>a?A
3?: ?" E"J2>2 9"X?#$95$ " $:@$Kb"N
7N 8"J$2542? 3" $:@$Kb" 3$ E"25$A
:>?N
/ 
"!  J
- E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$:] K"E?K>Y?3"
9" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95":] E"#?93? " D49E>"9?#$95"
3": D?2h>:] 3?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<"] 3?:
K4Y$: 3$ 2"3?a$# 3>429?] 3": D?2h>:
J?>p": $ 3?: K4Y$: 3$ 9$JK>9? 3>?9A #
5$>2?: $ 52?:$>2?:N
’ >K4#>9?;<" $p5$29? 3" X$WE4K"
5$# :4?: @2>9E>@?>: D49;\$: $p$E45?A
3?: Z4?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
$:5‘ 9? @":>;<"  $ K4Y$: 3$ $:5?A
E>"9?#$95" Z4?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" $:5‘ 9? @":>;<"  @N
)$"%
  6H  , -
’ 5?J$K? ? :$a4>2 >93>E? ? E"93>;<" 3?: K4Y$: A  q?E$:"r o  q?@?a?3"r A 3$ ?E"23" E"# ? @":>;<" 3? ?K?X?9E?
3" E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$:N

- ,      '-K /,  , -  5 67  0

 67  -K   67 -K   67
 -  '-K -K ::: -K  ',  ' 4 (
, -       

-! -! -! -! -PP

-PP -! -! -! -!

’(.- A &-*-
-! -PP -PP -PP -PP
*=’
’(.- A &-*-
-PP -! -! -! -!
!-=.+

!#!
8"# " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $# ,.-1o-PP $ " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: 9? @":>;<" ] ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" E"95>94?2<"
?E$:?:N ’" ?J2>2 ? @"25? 3>?95$>2? $:Z4$23?] 4# ?X>:" :"9"2" :$2‘ ?5>X?3"] >93>E?93" Z4$ ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" $:5<"
?E$:?:N
1?2? ?@?a‘AK?:] @":>E>"9?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: $# ’(.- "4 $# N

)$"&
!" ! !
"!  ;!  &
"   !"
 %?  "!
8"# ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" "4 ": D?A
2h>: ?E$:":] a>2?2 " :$K$5"2 @?2? E>#?
@?2? ?4#$95?2 ? >95$9:>3?3$ 3? >K4A
#>9?;<" 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
$ 3": a2?D>:#": 3": J"5\$: 3$ E"A
#?93" "4 @?2? J?>p" @?2? 3>#>94WA
K?N
!< %!N
S>2?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: @?2? ?
@":>;<" @?2? ?E$93$2 ?: K4Y$: 3$
@":>;<"] ?: K4Y$: 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95": $ 5?#J^# ": D?2h>: J?>p":N
J  !" !
/:::      0
!#!
’: K4Y$: 3>429?: 9<" :4J:5>54$#
": D?2h>: J?>p": 342?95$ ? E>2E4K?;<"
9"5429? "4 $# 5u9$>:N
- 4:" 3?: K4Y$: 3>429?: ^ 2$a4A
K?#$95?3" @$K" Eh3>a" 3$ 52e9:>5"N
-J:$2X?2 ?: @2$:E2>;\$:N
8"# " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9?
@":>;<"  $ " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$:
9? @":>;<" !] ?: K4Y$: 3$ 3$
2"3?a$# 3>429? $:5?2<" ?5>X?3?: :$
? >K4#>9?;<" ?#J>$95$ $:5>X$2 ?E>#?
3" K>#>5$ 3$D>9>3" @$K" E"9345"2N
+# E?:" 3$ ?E>"9?#$95" 3": >93>A
E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"] ?: K4Y$: 3$ 2"A
3?a$# 3>429? ?@?a?#A:$ ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$N
J  %!
- >95$224@5"2 3?: K4Y$: 3$ 9$JK>9?
$:5‘ >95$a2?3" 9" E"#45?3"2 3$ K4A
Y$:N
8"# ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" "4 ": D?A
2h>: J?>p": ?E$:":] @2$::>"9?2 " J"A
5<" @?2? K>a?2o3$:K>a?2 ?: K4Y$: 3$
9$JK>9?N
#
J  %! !!
- >95$224@5"2 3? K4Y 3$ 9$JK>9?
52?:$>2? $:5‘ >95$a2?3" 9" E"#45?3"2
3$ K4Y$:N
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2?
K>a?2o3$:K>a?2 ? K4YN
’ K4Y 3$ 9$JK>9? 52?:$>2? ?E$93$A
:$ ?@$9?: E"# D?2h>: J?>p": "4 K4Y$:
3$ 9$JK>9? K>a?3?:N ’ K4Y ?@?a?A
:$ @2$::>"9?93" 9"X?#$95$ 9" J"5<"
"4 ?@?a?93" ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<"N
)$"’
" J!  !&
"  !< 2>" #43?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: 3?
+:5? D49;<" ?52?:? " 3$:K>a?#$95"
3": D?2h>:N ’ 5$#@"2>Y?;<" @"3$
:$2 2$a4K?3? ?54?93" 9" #$94 3"
3>:@K?y "4 9" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£]
:$93" E"9D>a42‘X$K $# G] HG] FG "4
MG :$a493": q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:]
E"9:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
 H .-  , 3- 67 -
   ,  -,-'
&?95$2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: 9?
@":>;<" ! $] $# :$a4>3?] 3$:K>A
a?2 " X$WE4K"N -: D?2h>: @$2#?9$E$A
2<" ?E$:": @$K" 5$#@" E"9D>a42?3"
@2$X>?#$95$N
J  !!"
"   !
’E$93$#A:$ ?" @":>E>"9?2 " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: 9? @":>;<" :$A
a4>3" 3" :$4 3$:K>a?#$95" "4] ?@h:
3$:K>a?2 " X$WE4K"] 52?9:>5?2 @?2? @"A
:>;<" N ’::>#] 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95": ?E$93$A:$ ? K4YA$:@>? :W#A
J"K" N
)$"*
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 ? D49;<"] ^ 9$E$::‘A
@":>;<" @?2? Z4?KZ4$2 "452? @"A
:>;<"N
!< !
1?2? K>a?2 ": D?2h>: ?K5":] $#@422?2
? ?K?X?9E? q$# 3>2$;<" ?" @?>9$K 3"
X$WE4K"rN - E"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: 3$X$
:$2 a>2?3" @?2? ? @":>;<" ! "4
N 5>X? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 9": E?:" $#
’ @":>;<" >9:5‘X$K ?5>X?A:$
@4p?93" ? ?K?X?9E? $# 3>2$;<" ?"
X"K?95$N
8"# " D?2"K ?K5" K>a?3"] 9" Z4?A
32" 3$ >9:524#$95": ?E$93$A:$ ? K4YA
$:@>? N K4Y$: a>2?3" @?2? ? @":>;<" !
- D?2"K ?K5" 3$:K>a?A:$ X"K5?93" ?
E"K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 9? @":>;<" E$952?K
$:5‘X$KN
’ K4YA$:@>? ?@?a?A:$ 9" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95":N
 Q  ' - P , / .- &
0
’ D># 3$ 9<" "D4:E?2 "452": E"9A
345"2$: 9? $:52?3? " D?2"K :$ 3$:?A
Z4$ E24Y?2 E"# "452": X$WE4K": "4
E?:" $:5$_? ?52‘: 3$ "452" X$WE4K" 9"
#$:#" :$95>3" 3$ #?2Eb?N
+:5? D49;<" ?5>X?A:$ ?54?93" 9"
&$94 3" 3>:@K?y "4 9" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5 $ E"# " E"#45?3"2 3$
q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
:4@K$#$95" (E"99$E5£r N
!" @2>#$>2" ?E>"9?#$95" 3" D?A
2"K ?K5" q$#@422?93" ? ?K?X?9E? $:A
Z4$23?r] ?5>X?A:$ ? D49;<" q?E$93$A:$
? K4YA$:@>? 3$ E"2 X$23$ 9" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95": rN
 ,$ ": D?2h>: ?K5": $:5>X$2$# ?E$:":]
?E$93$A:$ 5?#J^# ? K4YA$:@>? 3$ E"2
?Y4K 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 ? D49;<" ?45"#‘A
5>E?] a>2?2 " ?2" 3" E"#45?3"2 3$ K4A
Y$: @?2? ? @":>;<" "4 3$:?J>K>A
5?2 ? D49;<" 9" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£
q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
:4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"r N

’.+!/⁄-
’ D49E>"9?K>3?3$ @"3$ :$2 K>#>5?3?
"4 " :>:5$#? @"3$ 9<" D49E>"9?2 :$
" :$9:"2 $:5>X$2 "J:524W3"N
- :>:5$#? @"3$ 5$2 :4? "@$2?;<"
K>#>5?3? "4 9<" D49E>"9?2 $# E"9A
3>;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: E"#" Eb4X? D"25$]
a2?9>Y" $ 9$X"$>2" $:@$::"N P"25$:
E"952?:5$: 3$ K4Y @"3$# >9DK4$9E>?2
? E?@?E>3?3$ 3$ 2$E"9b$E>#$95" 3"
:$9:"2N
’ ‘2$? ?" 2$3"2 3" :$9:"2 9<"
3$X$ :$2 E"J$25? E"# ?3$:>X": "4
Z4?KZ4$2 "452" "J_$5"N
!<" ?34K5$2?2 "4 $p$E45?2 Z4?KA
Z4$2 "@$2?;<" 9? ‘2$? 3" @?2?AJ2>:?
?" 2$3"2 3" :$9:"2N
)>#@?2 E"2@": $:52?9b":] E"#" $pA
E2$#$95": 3$ @‘::?2":] >9:$5":] 9$X$
"4 a$K" 9" @?2?AJ2>:?N (:$ 3$5$2a$9A
5$: $:@$EWD>E": $ @?9": K>#@": @?2?
$X>5?2 ?22?9b?2 " @?2?AJ2>:?N
!   
! :$K$E>"9?3" >2‘ :$ ?5>X?2 342?95$ 6
8"K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? $:Z4$23? 9?
@":>;<" $:5‘X$K%
 1?2? E>#?% ?5>X?;<" 3" >93>E?3"2
3$ 3>2$;<" 3>2$>5"N
 1?2? J?>p"% ?5>X?;<" 3" >93>E?3"2
3$ 3>2$;<" $:Z4$23"N
!" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":
>K4#>9?A:$ E"# >95$2#>5[9E>? ?
K4YA$:@>? "4 N
-: >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"
3$:?5>X?#A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?"
2$@"2 " X$WE4K" 9? @":>;<" 3$
#?2Eb? 2$5>KW9$? "4 E?:" " E"9345"2
2$5"29$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3? $:Z4$23? g
@":>;<" E$952?K $:5‘X$KN
- 67   G 5 / - 6 
3 (0
,$#@2$ Z4$ :$ @2$5$93? ?::>9?K?2
4#? #43?9;? 3$ D?>p?] E"K"E?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? $:Z4$23? 9? @":>;<" >9:5‘X$K
@"2 #$9": 3$ #$>" :$a493"N #
- >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" 3" K?3"
K?#@$_": @?2? 3$@">: :$ 3$:K>a?2 ?4A
5"#?5>E?#$95$N
!!"  !<
  67  3 ( '- 
(#? E"22$5? "2>$95?;<" 3": D?2h>:
^ 4# D?5"2 3$5$2#>9?95$ @?2? " E"9A
D"25" $ ? :$a42?9;?] 9<" :h 3" E"9A
345"2] #?: 5?#J^# 3": "452": #"5"A
2>:5?: 3? $:52?3?N ’3$#?>:] $:5? J"?
@2‘5>E? 2$:@$>5? ?: 9"2#?: 3" 8h3>a"
3$ .2e9:>5" B2?:>K$>2"N
1?2? a?2?95>2 ? :> #$:#" $ ?": "4A
52": ?: #$Kb"2$: E"93>;\$: 3$ X>:>J>A
K>3?3$ ?" X>?_?2 E"# ": D?2h>: ?E$:":]
)$"+
" X$WE4K" 3$X$ 5$2 4#? "2>$95?;<"
E"22$5? 3": D?2h>:N
*>2>a>2A:$ 2$a4K?2#$95$ g  
! = ,  > @?2? " E"952"K$ $ ?
$X$954?K 2$a4K?a$#N
- X$WE4K" ^ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$a4K?a$# $K^52>E? 3":
D?2h>:] u5>K Z4?93" :$ ?K5$2? " @$:" "4
? 3>:@":>;<" 3$ E?2a?: 9" X$WE4K"N
    67  3 Q 
P49E>"9? ?@$9?: E"# " E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
1?2? $D$54?2 ? 2$a4K?a$#] a>2?2 "
:$K$5"2 % 1?2? " E"952"K$ $ ? $X$954?K 2$a4A
 1":>;<" Go7% 4#? "4 34?: @$::"?:
9": J?9E": 3>?95$>2":N
 1":>;<" L% 5"3": ":
J?9E": "E4@?3": ¥ E?2a?
49>D"2#$#$95$ 3>:52>J4W3? 9"
@"25?A#?K?:N - @$:" 5"5?K
3$ "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K" $
E?2a? 9<" 3$X$ 4K52?@?::?2 ?
E?@?E>3?3$ #‘p>#? 3$ E?2a? 3"
X$WE4K"N
)$",
 1":>;<" H% #"5"2>:5? ¥ E?2a? 49>A
D"2#$#$95$ 3>:52>J4W3? 9" @"25?A
#?K?:N - @$:" 5"5?K 3" #"5"2>:5?
3" X$WE4K" $ E?2a? 9<" 3$X$ 4KA
52?@?::?2 ? E?@?E>3?3$ #‘p>#?
3$ E?2a? 3" X$WE4K"N

8"952"K?2 ? @":>;<" 3$ ?K>9b?A
#$95" 3": D?2h>: :$#@2$ Z4$ #43?2
" @$:" 3? E?2a? 52?9:@"25?3?N
!  !< 
%!
K?a$#] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = &
,  > :
  
> ! J !
!!
- E"9_495" 3? K4Y >95$29? 3>?9A
5$>2? @"::4> H :>54?;\$: 3>:5>95?:] 3$
?E"23" E"# ? @":>;<" 3" >95$224@5"2%
1":>;\$: 3" >95$224@5"2 E$952?K%
  67 ,  ') ?: K4Y$: >95$29?:
?E$93$# $ ?@?a?# E"# ? ?J$2A
542? $ D$Eb?#$95" 3?: @"25?:
  67 ) ?: K4Y$: >95$29?:
@$2#?9$E$# :$#@2$ 3$:K>a?3?:N
  67 ) ?: K4Y$: >95$29?: @$2A
#?9$E$# :$#@2$ ?E$:?:N
’: K4Y$: ?E$93$#o?@?a?#A:$ 3$
#?9$>2? @2"a2$::>X?N
-: >95$224@5"2$: K?5$2?>: ?E$93$#
$ ?@?a?# ?: K4Y$: 3$ K$>542?N

’95$: 3$ :?>2 3" X$WE4K"]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ?: Ke#@?3?: 3"
E"9_495" >95$29" $:5$_?# ?@?a?3?:d
3$:5$ #"3"] $X>5?A:$ ? 3$:E?2a?
3? J?5$2>?] 3$@">: 3$ D$Eb?3?: ?:
@"25?:N *$ Z4?KZ4$2 D"2#?] :$ :$
$:Z4$E$2 3$ 4#? Ke#@?3? ?E$:?]
?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ 76 #>945": ?@h:
" #"5"2 5$2 :>3" 3$:K>a?3"] $K?
?@?a?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$N
  K67  '-K  
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] E"# ? >K4#>A
9?;<" >95$29? 9? @":>;<" 9$452?] $#
$:@$E>?K $# K4a?2$: @"4E" >K4#>9?A
3":] ?E$93$A:$ ? Ke#@?3? 3? K4Y >9A
5$29? Z4?93" ^ 3$:52?X?3? 4#? 3?:
@"25?: @?2? @2"@"2E>"9?2 #?>: ?a>K>A
3?3$ 9? $952?3? 9" X$WE4K"N
!" ! !
"!  ;!  &
"   !" !#!
 %?  "!
8"# ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" "4 ": D?A
2h>: ?E$:":] a>2?2 " :$K$5"2 @?2? E>#?
@?2? ?4#$95?2 ? >95$9:>3?3$ 3? >K4A
#>9?;<" 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
$ 3": a2?D>:#": 3": J"5\$: 3$ E"A
#?93" "4 @?2? J?>p" @?2? 3>#>94WA
K?N
J"22?Eb? 3?: @?Kb$5?: 3": K>#@?3"A
2$:N
’ ?K?X?9E? 3>2$>5? :"J " X"K?95$
2$u9$ 5"3": ": E"#?93": @?2? ? K>#A
@$Y? 3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ 3" X>32" 52?:$>2"N
" !  !! 
!!&%! #
 '  
- ,    
   

" !  !!  !#!
!!&%!   !
!<" 45>K>Y?2 " K>#@?3"2 @?2? " 2$5>A
2?2 9$X$ "4 a$K" ?E4#4K?3": 9" @?2?A
J2>:?N !$:5?: E"93>;\$:] :$ " K>#@?A
3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? D"2 :4J#$5>3" ? 4#
$:D"2;" $pE$::>X"] ?5>X?A:$ ? @2"5$A
!<" 3$X$ :$2 ?@K>E?3" 9" @?2?A
;<" 3" #"5"2] Z4$ >9>J$ " :$4 D49E>A
J2>:? o X>32" 52?:$>2" 9$9b4# 5>@" 3$
"9?#$95" 342?95$ ?Ka49: :$a493":N
@2"345" b>32"22$@$K$95$ "4 b>32"DhA
J>E"] >9EK4>93" E2>:5?K>Y?;<"N ,$ ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 9<" D"2 @":5$A
2>"2#$95$ 2$:5?J$K$E>3?] #$:#" ?@h:
’ ?@K>E?;<" 3$:5$: @2"345": 2$A
4#? 9"X? @?25>3? 3" X$WE4K"] E"95?A
34Y ? $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:5$#? 3$ K>#A
5?2 ?   ! = ,  > N
@?3"2$:] @"3$93" E?4:?2 52$@>3?;<"]
24W3" $ #‘ X>:>J>K>3?3$] J$# E"#"
"E?:>"9?2 4# 3$:a?:5$ @2$#?542" 3?
)$"-

!#!
f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 9<" ?E>"9?2 " K>#A
@?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? E"# ?: @?Kb$5?:
K$X?95?3?:N
+:5? ?5>543$ @2$:$2X? ": K>#@?3"A
2$:N
P49E>"9? :"#$95$ E"# " E"#45?A
3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
- ?2" $p5$29" 3? ?K?X?9E? @"3$
?::4#>2 ?: :$a4>95$: @":>;\$:%
7N % K>#@?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?
3$:K>a?3"
LN % D49E>"9?#$95" >95$2#>5$95$
q$# >95$2X?K": 3$ 7G :$a493":rN
)$%.
HN % D49E>"9?#$95" >95$2#>5$95$
qJ?:$?3" 9? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K"rN
IN R) D49E>"9?#$95" E"95W94"
K$95"N
6N ) D49E>"9?#$95"
E"95W94" 2‘@>3"N
*$:K"E?93" ? ?K?X?9E? @?2? E>#?
q@":>;<" >9:5‘X$Kr] ?5>X?A:$ ? D49;<"
% " D49E>"9?#$95" $:5‘ K>#>A
5?3" ?" 5$#@" $# Z4$ :$ #?95^#
#?94?K#$95$ ? ?K?X?9E? 9$:5? @":>A
;<"N ’ :"K5?2 ? ?K?X?9E?] $:5? X"K5?
g :4? @":>;<" @?2?93" ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ " K>#@?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N +:5?
D49;<" ^ u5>K @?2? 2$#"X$2] @"2 $p$#A
@K"] @$Z4$9?: ?E4#4K?;\$: 3$ :4A
_$>2? 3" @?2?AJ2>:?] "4 " "2X?Kb" #?A
5>9?KN

’5$9;<"% $:5? D49;<" 9<" ?5>X? "
K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N 1?2? $:a4>Eb?2
" KWZ4>3" 3" K?X?3"2 9" @?2?AJ2>:?] ^
9$E$::‘2>" 4:?2 ? D49;<" 3$ K?X?a$#N
- 67  '*5 ' 5 
14p?2 ? ?K?X?9E? @?2? " X"K?95$
q@":>;<" >9:5‘X$Kr @?2? ?E>"9?2 " K?A
X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N
’" #?95$2 ? ?K?X?9E? @4p?3?]
?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$] E"# 4#
u9>E" #"X>#$95"] " _?5" 3" K?X?3"2
3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ " @2h@2>" K>#@?3"2N
- D49E>"9?#$95" 3" K>#@?3"2 3"
@?2?AJ2>:? E"95>94? ?@h: 3$:K>a?A
#$95" 3? ?K?X?9E? $ $p$E45? 52[:
@?::?3?: D>9?>:N
*     'G  ' &
   &4  /3- 67 S &
* ,    S0
’ D49;<" t:$2X>E$ @":>5>"9t @$2A
#>5$ ?" #"5"2>:5? $D$54?2 ? :4J:5>A
54>;<" 3?: @?Kb$5?: 3" K>#@?3"2 3"
@?2?AJ2>:? #?>: D?E>K#$95$] @$2#>A
5>93" ?>93? @2"5$a[AK?: $# E?:" 3$
a$K"N
! *67  3- 67) @?2? ?5>X?2 ^
9$E$::‘2>" 3$:?5>X?2 " K>#@?3"2 3"
@?2?AJ2>:? q?2" ! 9? @":>;<" r ?95$:
3$ E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  N

’ D49;<" :h @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3? 9"
$:@?;" 3$ L #>945": ? @?25>2 3? @?:A
:?a$# 3" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2?
? @":>;<"  N
1?2? @"3$2 ?5>X?2 ? D49;<"] E"K"E?2
? ?K?X?9E? X>2?3? @?2? E>#? q@":>;<"
>9:5‘X$Kr 342?95$ @$K" #$9": #$>"
:$a493"N
1?2? E?3? ?5>X?;<" X‘K>3? 3? D49A
;<"] ?: @?Kb$5?: 3$:K"E?#A:$ @?2?
?::>9?K?2 ? E"22$5? ?Z4>:>;<" 3" E"A
#?93"N
- E"#?93" @"3$ :$2 2$@$5>3" ?5^
4# #‘p>#" 3$ 52[: X$Y$:N ’ Z4?25?
2$@$5>;<" 3" E"#?93" 3$:?5>X? ? D49A
;<"N
,$] ?@h: 5$2 45>K>Y?3" ? D49;<"] X"KA
5?2 ? E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  E"# ?: @?Kb$5?: $#
4#? @":>;<" 3>D$2$95$ 3? 3$ 2$@"4:" @?2?AJ2>:? $# D49;<" 3? ‘a4? @2$A
q9? J?:$ 3" @?2?AJ2>:?r] $:5?: :h :$A :$95$ 9" X>32"N
2<" E"K"E?3?: 3$ 9"X" 9? @":>;<" 3$
- :$9:"2 5$# 4# E?#@" 3$ 2$A
2$@"4:" ? :$a4>2 ? 4# E"#?93" $D$A
a4K?a$# Z4$ X?2>? @2"a2$::>X?#$95$
54?3" ?52?X^: 3? ?K?X?9E? q3$:K"E?A
3$ K>#@?3"2 @?2?3" q9$9b4#? @?:A
#$95" 3? ?K?X?9E? @?2? E>#?] @?2?
:?3?r Z4?93" " X>32" $:5‘ :$E"] @?2?
4#? @":>;<" >9:5‘X$Kr "4 ?" 4K52?@?:A
K>#@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:? 9? Lƒ X$K"E>A
:?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 6 i#obN
3?3$ E"95W94? qD49E>"9?#$95" E"9A
5W94" 2‘@>3"r E"# Eb4X? >95$9:?N #

!<" 3$X$ :$2 ?@K>E?3" 9$9b4# 4 ' 67   *67   
5>@" 3$ @2"345" b>32"22$@$K$95$ "4
b>32"DhJ>E"] >9EK4>93" E2>:5?K>Y?;<"
3$ X>32":N ’ ?@K>E?;<" 3$:5$: @2"A
!#!
345": 2$34Y ? $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:5$#?
!<" ?5>X?2 " :$9:"2 3$ Eb4X? 34A
3$ K>#@?3"2$:] E?4:?93" 52$@>3?;<"]
2?95$ ? K?X?a$# 3" X$WE4K" $# 4#
24W3" $ #‘ X>:>J>K>3?3$] J$# E"#"
3$:a?:5$ @2$#?542" 3? J"22?Eb? 3?: :>:5$#? 3$ K?X?a$# ?45"#‘5>E?N
@?Kb$5?:N 1"3$2>? E?4:?2 ?X?2>?: 9" :$9:"2N
  ! / .- 0
+:5‘ K"E?K>Y?3" ?52‘: 3" $:@$Kb" 2$A
52"X>:"2 >95$29"] $# E"95?5" E"# " !#!
@?2?AJ2>:? $ $:5‘ $# E"93>;\$: 3$ 3$A ,$ D"2 X$2>D>E?3? ? @2$:$9;? 3$ a$K"
5$E5?2 ? @2$:$9;? 3? Eb4X? $] E"9:$A "4 J?22" 9" @?2?AJ2>:?] E$25>D>E?2A:$
Z4$95$#$95$] ?E>"9?2 ? K>#@$Y? 3" 3" 3$:K>a?#$95" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"N
)$%!
 +:5? @2‘5>E? @2$:$2X? ": K>#@?3"A
2$:N
’54?93" 9" &$94 3" 3>:@K?y "4 9"
:>:5$#? (E"99$E5£] ^ @"::WX$K b?A
J>K>5?2o3$:?J>K>5?2 " :$9:"2 3$ Eb4X?N
q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
:4@K$#$95" (E"99$E5£r
(#? X$Y b?J>K>5?3"] " D49E>"9?A
#$95" 3" #"3" ?45"#‘5>E" 3" K>#A
@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:? $:5?2‘ ?5>X" a>A
2?93" " ?2" $p5$29" 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$
@":>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 7 "4 LN
P$>5" >::"] ^ ?::>9?K?3? 4#? @?:A
:?3? 3" K>#@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:? >93>A
E?93" Z4$ " #"3" ?45"#‘5>E" $:5‘
?5>X"N

&?95$2 K>#@" " X>32" 9? 2$a><" 3"
:$9:"2N
)$%"
+*'    4 '     
,G-*
’: @":>;\$: 7 $ L E"22$:@"9A
3$# 5?#J^# ?" 7 $ L 9WX$K 3$
:$9:>J>K>3?3$ 3" :$9:"2 3$ Eb4X?
qZ4?93" $:5$ ^ ?5>X?3" ?52?X^: 3"
&$94 3" 3>:@K?y "4 9" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5£rN
,$ ? X?2>?;<" 3? :$9:>J>K>3?3$] 34A
2?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :$9:"2] D"2
3$ 4# 9WX$K #$9"2 @?2? 4# 9WX$K
#?>"2 3$ :$9:>J>K>3?3$] ^ ?::>9?K?3?
4#? t@?::?3?t 3" K>#@?3"2N +::?
@?::?3? ^ 5?#J^# $p$E45?3? E"# "
@?2?AJ2>:? :$E"N
 *67
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " :$9:"2] ?54?2 9"
&$94 3" 3>:@K?y q"4 9" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5£rN 1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " D49E>A
"9?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3" K>#@?3"2
3$ @?2?AJ2>:?] @":>E>"9?2 " E"#45?A
3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $#  @ "4
a>2?2 " ?2" $p5$29" 3? ?K?X?9E? @?2?
? @":>;<" N a4>95$ qE"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @":>A
,$ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" D"2 3$>A
p?3" 9? @":>;<"  @ $ " ?2"
$p5$29" 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$>p?3" 9? @":>A
;<" 7 "4 L ] 9? @?25>3? :$a4>95$
qE"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 r " D49E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E"
3" K>#@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:? Eb4X? :h
:$2‘ 2$:5?J$K$E>3" Z4?93" " X$WE4K"
?5>9a>2 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ :4@$2>"2 ?
6{#ob] 9$:5$ E?:" 9<" ^ X$2>D>E?3?
4#? @?::?3? 3" K>#@?3"2 3$ @?2?A
J2>:? @?2? ?::>9?K?2 :4? ?5>X?;<"N
’5^ Z4$ ? E"93>;<" 3$:E2>5? ?E>#?
:$_? ?5>9a>3? 9<" :$2‘ $D$54?3" E>EK"
3$ K>#@$Y?] #$:#" 9? @2$:$9;? 3$
Eb4X?N
=::" $X>5? ?5>X?;\$: >9X"K495‘2>?:
3" :$9:"2 3$ Eb4X? $# D?:$ 3$ ?E>"A
9?#$95" 3" #"5"2 q@"2 $pN 342?95$ ?
K?X?a$# 3" @?2?AJ2>:?] JK"Z4$>" 3?:
@?Kb$5?: 9" X>32" 3$X>3" ?" a$K"rN

*$:K"E?93"A:$ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >aA
9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  @ E"#
" ?2" " ?2" $p5$29" 3? ?K?X?9E? 9?
@":>;<" 7 "4 L ] 9? @?25>3? :$A
;<" r " 2$:5?J$K$E>#$95" " D49A
E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3" K>#@?3"2
3$ @?2?AJ2>:?] @"3$ :$2 D$>5" a>2?93"
" ?2" $p5$29" 3? @":>;<" 7 @?2?    "!
] $ $# :$a4>3? X"K5?93" @?2? ? 1  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<"
"!J! !"
@":>;<" 7 N C$?K>Y?93" $:5$ @2"E$A &’¡ ’o8N 12$::>"9?2 @?2? #43?2 ?
3>#$95"] " D49E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘A %H   ' 3  ' E"9D>a42?;<" 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2N 12$:A
5>E" $:5?2‘ ?5>X" >93$@$93$95$#$95$ :>"9?93" 9"X?#$95$] ? "@$2?;<" 3"
3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"N !$:5$ EK>#?5>Y?3"2 $952?2‘ $# #"3" #?A
E?:"] X$2>D>E?A:$ 4#? @?::?3? 3" K>#A 94?KN
@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:?] >93$@$93$95$A
B  B"5<" ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3"
#$95$ 3?: E"93>;\$: 3" X>32"] @?2?
E"#@2$::"2 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2N 12$::>A #
?::>9?K?2 ? ?D$5>X? ?5>X?;<" 3? D49E>A
"9?2 @?2? #43?2 ? E"9D>a42?;<" 3"
"9?K>3?3$ 3" :$9:"2 3$ Eb4X?N
EK>#?5>Y?3"2N 12$::>"9?93" 9"X?A
#$95$] ? "@$2?;<" 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2
 $952?2‘ $# #"3" #?94?KN
+# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :$9:"2 " K>#A C  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<"
%H  '  , , & 
@?3"2 3$ @?2?AJ2>:? ?>93? D49E>"9?2‘ 3? 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3$ ?2N
.- 
3$ D"2#? #?94?KN ’ ?X?2>? 3" :$9:"2
D  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<"
@"3$ :$2 ?::>9?K?3? 9" 3>:@K?y $# ?KA
’(.- qD49E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E"rN
a4#?: X$2:\$:N
T  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<"
3? D49;<" 3$ 3$:E"9a$K?A
#$95"o3$:$#J?;?#$95" 3": X>32":
3>?95$>2":N ’5>X?93" $:5? D49;<"] ?
!#! X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?3"2 ?4#$95?2‘
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" K>#@?2 " @?2?A $ " EK>#?5>Y?3"2 $952?2‘ $# #"3"
J2>:?] X$2>D>E?2 :$#@2$ :$ " 3>:@":>A #?94?KN
5>X" $:5‘ 3$:K>a?3"N
O  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<"
+X>5$ 2>:E":N 3? D49;<" 3$ 3$:E"9a$K?A

)$%%
#$95"o3$:$#J?;?#$95" 3": X>32":
52?:$>2":N
U  B"5<" 3$ ?4#$95" 3? 5$#@$A
2?542? 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"N
V  B"5<" 3$ 2$34;<" 3? 5$#@$A
2?542? 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"N
W  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<"
,R!8 q?K>9b?#$95" 3?: 5$#@$2?542?:
3$D>9>3?:r 3" #"5"2>:5?o @?::?a$>2"N
12  C$a4K?3"2 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
X$95>K?3"2N
11  B"5\$: 3$ :$K$;<" $ 3>:52>A
J4>;<" 3" ?2N
1B  B"5<" 3$ ?5>X?A
;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2N
1C  B"5<" 3$ 2$34;<" 3? 5$#@$A
2?542? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2N
1D  B"5<" 3$ ?4#$95" 3? 5$#A
@$2?542? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2N
- EK>#?5>Y?3"2 ?45"#‘5>E" *4?KA
Y"9$ 2$a4K? ?: 5$#@$2?542?: 3" ?2 9"
b?J>5‘E4K" $# 34?: Y"9?:% K?3" 3"
E"9345"2 $ K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"N
)$%&
- :>:5$#? #?95^# E"9:5?95$ "
E"9D"25" 3" b?J>5‘E4K" $ E"#@$9:?
?: $X$954?>: X?2>?;\$: 3?: E"93>A
;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: $p5$29?:N

1?2? 4#? a$:5<" >3$?K 3" E"9D"25"]
? 5$#@$2?542? 3$ 2$D$2[9E>? ^ LL8
q|LPrN
-: @?2e#$52": $ ?: D49;\$: E"9A
52"K?3?: ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ :<"%
 .$#@$2?542? 3" ?2 9": 3>D4:"2$:
K?3" #"5"2>:5?o@?::?a$>2"N
 *>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 9": 3>D4:"2$:
K?3" #"5"2>:5?o@?::?a$>2"N
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?3"2 qX?2>?A
;<" E"95W94? 3" DK4p" 3$ ?2rN
 ’5>X?;<" 3" E"#@2$::"2 q@?2? "
2$:D2>?#$95"o3$:4#>3>D>E?;<" 3"
?2rN
 C$E>2E4K?;<" 3" ?2N
."3?: $:5?: D49;\$: :<" #"3>D>E‘A
X$>: #?94?K#$95$] >95$2X>93" 9" :>:A
5$#? $ :$K$E>"9?93" 4#? "4 X‘2>?:
D49;\$: @?2? #"3>D>E?2 ": :$4: @?2eA
#$52":N
’: :$K$;\$: #?94?>: 5[# :$#@2$
@2>"2>3?3$ :"J2$ " ?45"#?5>:#" $ :<"
#$#"2>Y?3?: ?5^ Z4$ " 4:4‘2>" @2$:A
:>"9$ " J"5<" ! ] $pE$5" 9": E?A
:": $# Z4$ " :>:5$#? >95$2X$9b? @"2
#"5>X": 3$ :$a42?9;? $:@$EWD>E":N
’: :$a4>95$: "@$2?;\$: 9<" 3$:?5>A
X?# ? D49;<" ’(.-%
 ’5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3? 2$E>2E4A
K?;<"N
 ’5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3"
E"#@2$::"2N
 ’5>X?;<" 3? D49;<" ,R!8N
 ’5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3" X>32"
52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"N
’ :$K$;<" #?94?K 3$ 4#? D49;<"
9<" @2$_43>E? " E"952"K$ 3?: "452?:
$# ?45"#‘5>E"N ’ Z4?95>3?3$ 3$
?2 >952"34Y>3? 9" b?J>5‘E4K" ^ >93$A
@$93$95$ 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"]
:$93" 2$a4K?3? @$K" X$95>K?3"2 E"9A
52"K?3" $K$52"9>E?#$95$N
 ’ 5$#@$2?542? 3" ?2 >952"34Y>3" ^
:$#@2$ E"952"K?3? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$]
$# D49;<" 3?: 5$#@$2?542?: :$K$E>"A
9?3?: 9" 3>:@K?y q$pE$5" Z4?93" "
:>:5$#? $:5‘ 3$:K>a?3" "4 $# ?Ka4A
#?: E"93>;\$: Z4?93" " E"#@2$::"2
$:5‘ 3$:?5>X?3"rN
- :>:5$#? @$2#>5$ :$K$E>"9?2 "4
#"3>D>E?2 #?94?K#$95$%
 .$#@$2?542?: 3" ?2 @?2? " K?3"
3" E"9345"2 $ @?::?a$>2"
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?3"2 qX?2>?A
;<" E"95W94?r
 *>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 @?2? 3>D$2$95$:
@":>;\$: q@?2? D49;<" ’(.-rN
 ’5>X?;<" 3" E"#@2$::"2N
 P49;<" 3$:E"9a$K?#$95" $ 3$A
:$#J?;?#$95" 3": X>32":N
 C$E>2E4K?;<" 3" ?2N
 V>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"N
 *$:?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#?N
"'   3- ,     
,'  K
- :>:5$#? @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3" 3$ D"2A
#?: X‘2>?:] E"9543"] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" ’(.- $ $95<" 3$A
D>9>2 ?: 5$#@$2?542?: 3$:$_?3?:N
*$:5$ #"3"] " :>:5$#? E"#$;?2‘
? D49E>"9?2 3$ #"3" E"#@K$5?#$95$
?45"#‘5>E" 2$a4K?93" 5$#@$2?542?]
Z4?95>3?3$ $ 3>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 >9A
52"34Y>3" 9" b?J>5‘E4K" $ a$2>93" ?
D49;<" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" $ ? ?5>X?;<"
3" E"#@2$::"2 3" E"93>E>"9?3"2N
*42?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘A
5>E"] ^ @"::WX$K X?2>?2 ?: 5$#@$2?A
542?: :$K$E>"9?3?:] ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 "
X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"] ?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" ,R!8] ?5>X?2 $ 3$:?5>X?2 " E"#A
@2$::"2 $ ? 2$E>2E4K?;<"] ?54?93" ?
Z4?KZ4$2 #"#$95" 9": 2$:@$E5>X":
J"5\$: $ #?9"@K?:% " :>:5$#? #"3>A
D>E?2‘ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?: 3$D>9>;\$:
@?2? :$ ?3?@5?2 ?": 9"X": @$3>3":N
*$:5$ #"3"] " EK>#?5>Y?3"2 E"95>A
94?2‘ ? E"#?93?2 ?45"#?5>E?#$95$
5"3?: ?: D49;\$: $pE$5" ?: Z4$
@"3$# :$2 #43?3?: #?94?K#$95$N
’ X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?3"2 ^ u9>E?
@?2? 5"3? ? Y"9? 3" b?J>5‘E4K"N
5-'5    -   
12$::>"9?2 ": J"5\$: 1D "4 1C @?2?
2$a4K?2 ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" ?2 9? Y"9?
3>?95$>2? $:Z4$23? $ ": J"5\$: U "4
V @?2? 2$a4K?2 ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" ?2 9?
Y"9? 3>?95$>2? 3>2$>5? 3" b?J>5‘E4K"N #
’: 5$#@$2?542?: :$K$E>"9?3?: :<" X>A
:4?K>Y?3?: 9" 3>:@K?yN
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" ,R!8 @?2? ?K>A
9b?2 ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" ?2 $952$ ?:
34?: Y"9?:N
1?2? X"K5?2 g a$:5<" :$@?2?3? 3?:
5$#@$2?542?: 3" ?2 9?: 34?: Y"9?:]
@2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" ,R!8
"4 ?K5$2?2 ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" K?3" 3"
@?::?a$>2"N
'67    4- 67  
12$::>"9?93" ": J"5\$: 11 ^ @":A
:WX$K 3$D>9>2 #?94?K#$95$ 4#? 3?:
3>:52>J4>;\$: @"::WX$>: 3" ?2%
 ,?W3? 3$ ?2 3": 3>D4:"2$: E$9A
52?>: $ K?5$2?>:N
)$%’
 ,?W3? 3$ ?2 3": 3>D4:"2$: D2"9A
5?>: E$952?>: $ K?5$2?>: $ 3": 3>D4A
:"2$: 3? 2$a><" 3": @^: 3>?95$>A
2":N
 ,?W3? 3$ ?2 3": 3>D4:"2$: 3?
2$a><" 3": @^: 3>?95$>2":N
 ,?W3? 3$ ?2 3": 3>D4:"2$: 3?
2$a><" 3": @^: 3>?95$>2":] @?2?A
J2>:?: $ X>32": K?5$2?>:N
!? #"3?K>3?3$ ’(.-] " EK>#?5>A
Y?3"2 E"#?93? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?
3>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 $ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
X$95>K?3"2 q": )+*: 9" J"5<" 3$ :$K$A
;<" D>E?2<" ?@?a?3":rN ’ 3>:52>J4>;<"
3" ?2] Z4?93" :$K$E>"9?3? #?94?KA
#$95$] ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? ?52?X^: 3? K>a?A
;<" 3": )+*: 9" J"5<" 3$ :$K$;<"N
1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"952"K$ ?45"A
#‘5>E" 3? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 ?@h:
4#? :$K$;<" #?94?K] @2$::>"9?2 "
J"5<" ’(.-N
)$%*
5-'5  *',   *  &
'
S>2?2 ? #?9"@K? 12 "4 @2$::>"9?2
": J"5\$: X>254?>: E"22$:@"93$95$:
9? 5$K? 3" (E"99$E5£ @?2? ?4#$9A
5?2o3>#>94>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?A
3"2 q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4KA
5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN ’ ?5>X?A
;<" ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K? >K4#>9?;<" 3":
)+*: :>54?3": 9? 2$a><" 3? #?9"@K?N
 V$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? 3" X$95>K?A
3"2 § 5"3": ": )+*: ?E$:":N
 V$K"E>3?3$ #W9>#? 3" X$95>K?3"2
§ 4# )+* ?E$:"N

1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"952"K$ ?45"A
#‘5>E" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?3"2
?@h: 4#? 2$a4K?a$# #?94?K] @2$::>A
"9?2 " J"5<" ! N
%7 !
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" ! q)+*
9" J"5<" ?E$:"r] " EK>#?5>Y?3"2 ?94K?
5"3?: ?: 2$a4K?a$9: #?94?>: ?95$2>"A
2$: $ 2$a4K? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$%
 ’ Z4?95>3?3$ $ ? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3"
?2 >952"34Y>3" 9" b?J>5‘E4K"N
 - E"#@2$::"2 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2N
 ’ 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3" ?2N
+:5? E"93>;<" ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K"
?E$93>#$95" 3" )+* 9" J"5<" !
N
=95$2X>93" #?94?K#$95$ 9? 3>:52>A
J4>;<" 3$ ?2 "4 9? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
X$95>K?3"2] ?@?a?A:$ " )+* @?2? ?::>A
9?K?2 Z4$ " EK>#?5>Y?3"2 _‘ 9<" E"9A
52"K? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 5"3?: ?: D49A
;\$:N

,$ " :>:5$#? 9<" E"9:$a4>2 a?2?9A
5>2 " ?KE?9E$o#?945$9;<" 3? 5$#@$A
2?542? @$3>3? 9?: X‘2>?: Y"9?: 3" b?A
J>5‘E4K"] ? 5$#@$2?542? 3$D>9>3? K?#A
@$_? 342?95$ ?Ka49: :$a493":N
1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"952"K$ ?45"A
#‘5>E" 3" :>:5$#? 3$@">: 3$ 4#? "4
#?>: :$K$;\$: #?94?>:] @2$::>"9?2 "
J"5<" ! N
%7 L
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" L q)+* 9"
J"5<" ?E$:"r @?2? ?K>9b?2 ? 5$#@$2?A
542? 3" ?2 K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" g 3"
K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5?N
+:5? D49;<" D?E>K>5? ? 2$a4K?a$# 3?
5$#@$2?542? 9? @2$:$9;? ?@$9?: 3"
#"5"2>:5?N
1?2? X"K5?2 g a$:5<" :$@?2?3? 3?:
5$#@$2?542?: $ 3? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2]
?K5$2?2 ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" K?3" 3" @?:A
:?a$>2"N
, ,-'67  
12$::>"9$ " J"5<" ] K"E?K>Y?3"
9" @?>9$K D2"95?K] @?2? ?K5$2?2 "
:>:5$#? $952$ " #"3" 3$ 2$E>2A
E4K?;<" >95$29? $ " #"3" 3$ ?2
$p5$29" q" >93>E?3"2 3" #"3" 3$
2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29? $ " >93>E?3"2
3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" :$2<" ?E>"9?3":
Z4?93" " J"5<" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" D"2
@2$::>"9?3"rN
- ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" @"3$2‘ :$2 3$A
:?5>X?3" #?94?K#$95$ :$# Z4$ "
#"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" :$K$E>"9?3"
:$_? ?K5$2?3"N
- #"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29?
@"3$ :$2 4:?3" Z4?93" E"93>;\$:
$p5$29?: E"#" D4#?;?] "3"2$:] @"A
$>2? "4 ?K5? 4#>3?3$ $:5>X$2$# @2$A
:$95$: 9" ?#J>$95$] @"2^# " 4:"
E"95W94" 3" #"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<"
>95$29? @"3$ 5"29?2 " ?2 @2$:$95$
9" >95$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K" 3" X$WA
E4K" ?J?D?3"] "E?:>"9?93" " $#J?A
;?#$95" 3": X>32":N - 4:" @2"K"9A
a?3" 3" #"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" >9A
5$29? 9<" ^ 2$E"#$93?3"N
+# EK>#? D2>"] " 4:" 3" #"3" 3$
2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29? @"3$ E?4:?2 "
$#J?;?#$95" $pE$::>X" 3": X>32":
3" X$WE4K"N
- #"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29?
@"3$ 9<" $:5?2 3>:@"9WX$K] E?:" :$A
_?# >3$95>D>E?3?: E"93>;\$: Z4$ @":A
:?# E2>?2 $#J?;?#$95" 9? D?E$ >9A
5$29? 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N

’ $:52?5^a>? 3$ 2$E>2E4K?A
;<"o2$9"X?;<" 3" ?2 D49E>"9? 3$
#"3" ?45"#‘5>E" :$93" E"952"K?3"
@"2 ?Ka"2>5#": Z4$ @$2#>5$# 4#?
#$Kb"2 $p@$2>[9E>? @?2? ": "E4@?9A
5$: 3" X$WE4K"N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] " #"3" 3$
2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29? 5?#J^# @"3$2‘
:$2 ?E>"9?3" @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"
a2‘D>E" @2$:$95$ 9? 5$K? 3? E$952?K
(E"99$E5N
- #"3" 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" >95$29? #
5?#J^# 9<" @"3$2‘ :$2 ?E>"9?3"
@$K" J"5<" a2‘D>E"] E?:" :$_?#
>3$95>D>E?3?: E"93>;\$: Z4$ @"::?#
E2>?2 $#J?;?#$95" 9? D?E$ >95$29?
3" @?2?AJ2>:?N
   ,'  K
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" !@ @?2? K>A
a?2o3$:K>a?2 " E"#@2$::"2 q? ?5>X?;<"
^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K" ?E$93>#$95" 3"
)+* 9" @2h@2>" J"5<"rN ’ 3$:?5>X?A
;<" 3" E"#@2$::"2 @$2#?9$E$ #$A
#"2>Y?3? #$:#" 3$@">: 3$ 3$:K>a?2
" #"5"2N
1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"952"K$ ?45"A
#‘5>E" 3? ?5>X?;<" 3" E"#@2$::"2]
@2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" !@
"4 " J"5<" ! N 8"# " E"#@2$:A
:"2 3$:K>a?3"] ^ @"::WX$K 2$>9>E>?2 #?A
)$%+
94?K#$95$ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$95>K?A
3"2N
w4?93" " E"#@2$::"2 ^ ?5>X?3" $
" #"5"2 $:5‘ K>a?3"] ? X$95>K?;<" #?A
94?K 9<" @"3$ J?>p?2 3? X$K"E>3?3$
#W9>#? q?@$9?: 4# )+* ?E$:"rN

8"# " E"#@2$::"2 3$:K>a?3"] 9<"
^ @"::WX$K >952"34Y>2 9" b?J>5‘E4K" ?2
E"# 5$#@$2?542? >9D$2>"2 g 5$#@$2?A
542? $p5$2>"2N ’K^# 3>::"] $# E"9A
3>;\$: ?#J>$95?>: $:@$EWD>E?:] ": X>A
32": @"3$# D>E?2 $#J?;?3": 2?@>3?A
#$95$ @"2Z4$ " ?2 9<" @"3$ :$2 3$A
:4#>3>D>E?3"N
 46   - , 5'&
   *      
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" "!N @?2?
?5>X?2 q)+* 9" J"5<" ?E$:"r " 3$:$#A
J?;?#$95" "4 3$:E"9a$K?#$95" 3"
@?2?AJ2>:? $ 3": X>32": K?5$2?>:N
)$%,
 46   - , 5'&
   *      9 ,
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" ! @?2?
?5>X?2 q)+* 9" J"5<" ?E$:"r " 3$:$#A
J?;?#$95" "4 3$:E"9a$K?#$95" 3"
X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"N
’ D49;<" 3$:?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ ?@h: E$2E? 3$ 7G #>945": "4
Z4?93" 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2 $ 9<" :$
2$?5>X? 9? @?25>3? :$a4>95$N 12$::>"A
9?93" $:5$ J"5<" 9"X?#$95$] 6 #>A
945": :$2<" ?3>E>"9?3": ?" 3$:$#A
J?;?#$95" "4 3$:E"9a$K?#$95" 3"
X>32" 52?:$>2"N

!<" ?@K>E?2 ?3$:>X": 9": D>K?#$9A
5": $K^52>E": 9? @?25$ >95$29? 3"
X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"] @?2? $X>5?2
3?9>D>E‘AK"] @2$_43>E?93" " :$4
D49E>"9?#$95"N
1?2? ? ?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<" 3$ 3$A
:$#J?;?#$95" "4 3$:E"9a$K?#$95"
3" X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"] " #"5"2
3$X$ $:5?2 K>a?3"N
 *67  ,'  K
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<"  N
8"# " EK>#?5>Y?3"2 3$:?5>X?3"%
 ’ 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3" ?2 ^ ?5>X?3?]
>:"K?93" ?::># " b?J>5‘E4K" 3"
$p5$2>"2N
 - E"#@2$::"2 ^ 3$:?5>X?3"N
 - X$95>K?3"2 ^ 3$:K>a?3"N
 f @"::WX$K ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " X>32"
52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"N

’ E$952?K 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2 #$#"A
2>Y? ?: 5$#@$2?542?: 3$D>9>3?: ?9A
5$: 3? 3$:?5>X?;<" $ 2$:5?J$K$E$A?:
Z4?93" :$ @2$::>"9? 4# J"5<" Z4?KA
Z4$2 3" :>:5$#?N
 *67  ,'  K
1?2? X"K5?2 ? K>a?2 " EK>#?5>Y?3"2
$# E"93>;\$: ?45"#‘5>E?:] @2$::>"A
9?2 " J"5<" ! N
 ' K67  ,'  K   !  !%& a$>2"r @?2? 3$:$#J?;?2 X>32": K?5$A
 2?>:N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" E"9:5?95$ 3"
?2AE"93>E>"9?3" @"3$ 2$:4K5?2] -: 3>D4:"2$: @"3$# :$2 "2>$95?3": % A *>D4:"2$: 3$ ?2 K?5$2?>: 2$a4K‘A
E"# " 5$#@"] 9? D"2#?;<" 3$ ?a>93" 9": 2$K?5>X": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ X$>: $ "2>$95‘X$>:%
#?4 Eb$>2" 3$X>3" ?" ?Eu#4K" #"3" ? "2>$95‘AK": @?2? ? @":>;<"
3$ @"$>2? $ 4#>3?3$ 9" :>:5$#? 3$:$_?3?N  ’54?2 9" 3>:@":>5>X"  @?2? "2>$9A
3$ ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"] D?E>K>5?93" ? 5?2 " 3>D4:"2 9? 3>2$;<" 3$:$_?3?N
@2"K>D$2?;<" 3$ D49a": $ J?E5^2>?:N  3-    '    S>2?2 " :$K$5"2  @?2? 2$a4K?2 "
1?2? #>9>#>Y?2 " @2"JK$#? 3$ #?4 DK4p" 3$ ?2N #
Eb$>2"] ^ 2$E"#$93?3"] :$#?9?KA
#$95$] 3$:K>a?2 " ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"  3-    ,   
$ K>a?2 " ?Z4$E$3"2] 9" #‘p>#"]
E$2E? 3$ 6 ? 7G #>945": ?95$: 3$
$:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"] @?2? Z4$ ?
4#>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? :$_? $K>#>9?3?N
- D>K52" 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"] $p>:A
5$95$ 9" :>:5$#?] 3$X$ :$2 :4J:5>54W3"
E"# #?>"2 D2$Z4[9E>? :$ " X$WE4K"
52?9:>5?2 E"9:5?95$#$95$ $# $:52?3?:
3$ #4>5? @"$>2? "4 D>E?2 $:5?E>"9?3"
3$J?>p" 3$ ‘2X"2$:N
! A *>D4:"2$: 3$ ?2 E$952?>: 2$a4K‘A
8"9:4K5?2 " t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<" X$>: $ "2>$95‘X$>:%
@2"a2?#?3?t @?2? E"9b$E$2 ": >95$2A
X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" E"22$5":N  ’54?2 9" 3>:@":>5>X" % @?2? "2>$9A
5?2 " 3>D4:"2 9? 3>2$E<" 3$:$_?3?
! *>D4:"2$: 3$ ?2 K?5$2?>: D>p":
qK?3" 3" E"9345"2 $ K?3" 3" @?::?A  S>2?2 " :$K$5"2  @?2? 2$a4K?2 "
DK4p" 3" ?2N

)$%-
  ' A @":>;<" ?J$25?
 2 A @":>;<" D$Eb?3?
 A *>D4:"2 3$ ?2 :4@$2>"2 D>p" @?2?
3$:$#J?;?2 " @?2?AJ2>:?N
 3-      
! A *>D4:"2$: 3$ ?2 52?:$>2": 2$a4A
K‘X$>: $ "2>$95‘X$>:%
  0 
!! $ 
 P49E>"9?# E"# " E"#45?3"2 3$
!#!
- 4:" >#@2h@2>" 3": K$X?95?3"2$:
$K^52>E": 3": X>32": @"3$ :$2 @$2>A
a":"N
’95$: $ 342?95$ " ?E>"9?#$95"]
X$2>D>E?2 :$#@2$ :$ ": @?::?a$>2":
9<" $:5<" $p@":5": ?" 2>:E" 3$ K$:\$:
@2"X"E?3?: 5?95" 3>2$5? "4 >93>2$5?A
#$95$ @$K": X>32": $# #"X>#$95"]
E"#" @"2 "J_$5": @$::"?>: ?22?:5?3":
"4 _"a?3": @$K": #$:#":N
!49E? 3$>p$ E2>?9;?: :"Y>9b?: 9"
X$WE4K"N
>a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  $ 342?95$
E$2E? 3$ 7 #>945" ?@h: ? @?::?a$#
@?2? ? @":>;<"  @ q"4 5?#A
J^# ?@h: ? 2$5>2?3? 3? Eb?X$ #$EeA
9>E?] @?2? X$WE4K": $Z4>@?3": E"#
Eb?X$ #$Ee9>E? E"# 5$K$E"#?93"rN
’J2>93" 4#? 3?: @"25?: 3>?95$>2?:]
$:5$ D49E>"9?#$95" ^ 3$:?5>X?3"N
          
'   
-: J"5\$: $:5<" @":>E>"9?3": 9?
#"K342? 3" @?>9$K 3? @"25?N ’ @?25>2
3" @?>9$K 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"A
2>:5? ^ @"::WX$K E"#?93?2%

 ’54?2 9" 3>:@":>5>X" % @?2? "2>$9A

5?2 " 3>D4:"2 9? 3>2$E<" 3$:$_?3?
!#!
 S>2?2 " :$K$5"2  @?2? 2$a4K?2 "
DK4p" 3" ?2N ’" :?>2 3" X$WE4K"] 2$5>2$ :$#@2$
? Eb?X$ 3? >a9>;<" @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$
": K$X?95?3"2$: $K^52>E": 3": X>32":]
?E>"9?3": >9?3X$25>3?#$95$] E"9:5>A
54?# @$2>a" @?2? Z4$# @$2#?9$E$ ?
J"23"N

)$&.

 ’J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3": X>32":
3>?95$>2":N P49E>"9?#$95"
tE"95W94" ?45"#‘5>E"t $# D?:$
3$ ?J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3" X>32"
$ :>:5$#? 3$ ?95>$:#?a?#$95"
?5>X"N
 ’J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3": X>32":
52?:$>2":N P49E>"9?#$95" tE"95WA
94" ?45"#‘5>E"t $# D?:$ 3$ ?J$2A
542? 3" X>32" $ :>:5$#? ?95>$:#?A
a?#$95" ?5>X"N
 ’5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3":
E"#?93": 3": K$X?95?3"2$: 3$
X>32": 3?: @"25?: 52?:$>2?:N
’J$2542? 3": X>32":%
12$::>"9?2 ": J"5\$: @?2? ?J2>2 "
X>32" 3$:$_?3"N
12$::>"9?93" J2$X$#$95$ Z4?KA
Z4$2 J"5<" 3$ ?J$2542?] Z4$2 9?: @"2A
5?: 3>?95$>2?: "4 9?: @"25?: 52?:$>2?:]
"J5^#A:$ " E42:" tE"# >95$224@;\$:t
3" X>32"] $9Z4?95" Z4$ $p$2E$93"
4#? @2$::<" @2"K"9a?3? ?5>X?A:$ "
?E>"9?#$95" tE"95W94" ?45"#‘5>E"tN
- X>32" @?2? 9? @":>;<" @2$5$9A
3>3? @2$::>"9?93" 9"X?#$95$ " 2$:A
@$E5>X" J"5<"N
P$Eb?#$95" 3": X>32":%
)$X?95?2 ": J"5\$: @?2? D$Eb?2 "
X>32" 3$:$_?3"N
’ D?:$ 3$ D$Eb?#$95" 3" X>32"
"E"22$ :$a493" ?: #$:#?: Kha>E?:
3$:E2>5?: @?2? ? D?:$ 3$ ?J$2542?N
1?2? ": X>32": 3?: @"25?: 52?:$>2?:
$:5‘ @2$X>:5" ?@$9?: " D$Eb?#$95"
tE"# >95$224@;\$:tN
#
8"#?93": 3? @"25? 3>?95$>2? 3"
K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"o@"25?: 52?:$>2?:%
!? #"K342? 3" @?>9$K 3? @"25?
3>?95$>2? 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" $:5<"
@2$:$95$: ": J"5\$: @?2? " E"#?93"
3" 2$:@$E5>X" X>32"N
    *  5-  6   &
5    *      &
@  
!" X$WE4K" $:5‘ ?5>X? ? D49;<" 3$
?95>$:#?a?#$95" 9? D?:$ 3$ :4J>3?
3": X>32": 3>?95$>2":o52?:$>2":N
+:5$ :>:5$#? 3$ :$a42?9;? ^ E?@?Y
3$ 2$E"9b$E$2 ? $X$954?K @2$:$9;?
3$ 4# "J:5‘E4K" 342?95$ " #"X>A
#$95" 3$ D$Eb?#$95" 3" X>32"N ’:A
:>#] " :>:5$#? >95$22"#@$ " E42:" 3$
)$&!
D$Eb?#$95" $] E"9D"2#$ ? @":>;<"
3" X>32"] >9X$25$ " :$4 #"X>#$95"N
+:5$ 3>:@":>5>X" ^] @"25?95"] u5>K
5?#J^# $# E?:" 3$ $X$954?K ?E>"9?A
#$95" >9X"K495‘2>" 3": K$X?95?3"2$:
3$ X>32": @"2 @?25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: @2$A
:$95$: 9" X$WE4K"N
’ D49;<" ?95>$:#?a?#$95" $:5‘
?5>X? 342?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95"
#?94?K "4 ?45"#‘5>E" 3" X>32"N
’@h: ? >95$2X$9;<" 3" :>:5$#? ?95>A
$:#?a?#$95" ^ >95$22"#@>3" 3$ >#$A
3>?5" " E42:" 3" X>32"N +# :$a4>3?]
" E42:" 3" X>32" ^ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$
>9X$25>3" $ " #$:#" X"K5? ? 3$:E$2
E$2E? 3$ 6 E# 2$K?5>X?#$95$ g @":>A
;<" 3$ @2>#$>2? @?2?3?N *42?95$ $:5$
5$#@" 9<" ^ @"::WX$K ?E>"9?2 " X>32"N

,$ ? @2"5$;<" ?95>$:#?a?#$95"
D"2 ?E>"9?3? H X$Y$: E"9:$E45>X?:
9" $:@?;" 3$ 7 #>945" "4 $:5>X$2 $#
?X?2>?] ^ >9>J>3" " D49E>"9?#$95"
?45"#‘5>E" 3" X>32" $# :4J>3?]
@$2#>5>93"A" :"#$95$ @"2 2$::?K5":]
E"# K>J$2?;\$: :4E$::>X?: 3" J"5<"
)$&"
@?2? ? #?9"J2? :$a4>95$N 1?2?  
@"3$2 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"22$5" D49E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? ^ 9$E$::‘2>"  ! $ / .- &
$D$54?2 4#? #"X>#$95?;<" @?2? 0
J?>p" 3" X>32" $9X"KX>3"N
 , ' K67      *  
'9 , !#!
’" :?>2 3" X$WE4K"] 2$#"X$2 :$#@2$
’ :$a4>2 g 3$:?5>X?;<" 3? ?K>#$9A
? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<" 3$ :$4 >95$2>"2N
5?;<" $K^52>E?] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" >9>E>?K>A
Y?2 9"X?#$95$ " D49E>"9?#$95" ?4A +:5? @2‘5>E? ?_43? ? $X>5?2 Z4$
5"#‘5>E" 3": K$X?95?3"2$: 3$ X>32":N " 5$5" :"K?2] ?E>"9?3" >9?3X$25>3?A
#$95$] E"9:5>54? 4# @$2>a" @?2?
- @2"E$3>#$95" 3$ >9>E>?K>Y?;<"
Z4$# @$2#?9$E$ 3$952" 3" X$WE4K"N
3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3" E"# ?: @"25?: D$A
Eb?3?: $ $# E?3? @"25?%
 ’E>"9?2 " E"#?93" 3" X>32" ?5^
:$4 D$Eb?#$95" E"#@K$5"N 1$2A !#!
#?9$E$2 ?E>"9?93" " E"#?93" - 4:" >#@2h@2>" 3" 5$5" :"K?2 @"3$
@?2? D$Eb?#$95" @"2 #?>: L :$A :$2 @$2>a":"N
a493":N
’95$: $ 342?95$ ? :4? #"X>#$9A
 12$::>"9?2 " E"#?93" 3" X>32"
5?;<"] E$25>D>E?2A:$ Z4$ ": @?::?a$>A
D>2#$#$95$ ?5^ :4? ?J$2542? E"#A
2": 9<" $:5$_?# $p@":5": ?" 2>:E" 3$
@K$5?N 1$2#?9$E$2 ?E>"9?93" E"A
K$:\$: @2"X"E?3?: @$K" #"X>#$95"
#?93" @?2? ?J$2542? @"2 #?>: L
3$ ?J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3" 5$5" :"K?2
:$a493":N
"4 @$K" ?22?:5?#$95" 3$ "J_$5": Z4$
@"::?# E"K>3>2 E"# ": #$:#":N

!#!
- 5$5" :"K?2 3$X$ :$2 D$Eb?3" #?A
94?K#$95$ :$#@2$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" D"2
52?9E?3"N
- 5$5" :"K?2 9<" @"::4> :>:5$#?
3$ D$Eb?#$95" E$952?K>Y?3"] E"#"
"E"22$ E"# ": X>32": 3?: @"25?:] $
9<" :$2‘ D$Eb?3" 9" 52?X?#$95" 3?:
@"25?: @$K?: Eb?X$:N
- 5$5" :"K?2 $K^52>E" ^ E"#@":5"
@"2 3">: @?>9^>: 3$ X>32"] 3": Z4?>: "
3>?95$>2" ^ #hX$K $ " 52?:$>2" ^ D>p"]
$ $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# E"25>9? 3$ @2"A
5$;<" E"952? " :"K 3$ #"X>#$95?;<"
$K^52>E?N
- D49E>"9?#$95" 3" 5$5" $ 3? E"2A
5>9? :h :$ X$2>D>E? E"# " E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" N
!%!
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" B " @?>9$K 3$
X>32" 3>?95$>2" :$2‘ ?J$25" E"#@K$5?A
#$95$N
!#!
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ J?a?a$>2" 52?9:A
X$2:?K] 9<" ?J2>2 " 5$5" :"K?2N
!<" ?J2>2 " 5$5" 9? @2$:$9;? 3$
9$X$ "4 a$K"] @">: " #$:#" @"3$2‘
:$2 3?9>D>E?3"N
’ #"X>#$95?;<" ?45"#‘5>E? @"3$
:$2 >95$22"#@>3? $# Z4?KZ4$2 @":>A
;<"] @2$::>"9?93" 9"X?#$95$ " J"A
5<" B N
!"
’ @?25>2 3? @":>;<" 3$ ?J$2542? 5"A
5?K] @4p?2 " J"5<" B $ " @?>9$K 3>?9A
5$>2" :$2‘ D$Eb?3" E"#@K$5?#$95$N
’ #"X>#$95?;<" ?45"#‘5>E? @"3$
:$2 >95$22"#@>3? $# Z4?KZ4$2 @":>A
;<"] @4p?93" 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" B N
#
""! ! !
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 1 $ ? E"25>9? :$
#"X>#$95?2‘ ?5^ " @2>#$>2" $:5‘a>"
3$ ?J$2542?N ’" :$a493" 5"Z4$ 9"
J"5<" 1 ] ? E"25>9? :$ #"X>#$95?2‘
@?2? ? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"] ?5^ ?
@":>;<" 3$ ?J$2542? 5"5?KN
8"# ? E"25>9? E"#@K$5?#$95$
?J$25?] @4p?2 " J"5<" 1 $ ? E"25>9? :$
#"X>#$95?2‘ @?2? " @2>#$>2" $:5‘a>"
3$ D$Eb?#$95"N 14p?93" 9"X?#$95$
" J"5<" 1 ] ? E"25>9? :$ #"X>#$95?2‘
@?2? ? @?25$ 3>?95$>2? 3" X$WE4K"] ?5^
? @":>;<" 3$ D$Eb?#$95" 5"5?KN
1?2? >95$22"#@$2 " #"X>#$95" 3?
E"25>9? 342?95$ ?: D?:$: 3$ ?J$2542? $
D$Eb?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E"] ?54?2 9"X?A
#$95$ 9" J"5<" 1 N
)$&%
 SS & !%! 
 
1?2? E"K"E?2 " 5$5" 9? @":>;<"
t:@">K$2t] @2$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 " J"5<"
CN
*42?95$ ? #"X>#$95?;<" @?2?
?5>9a>2 ? ?J$2542? 3$ ?J$2542? 3"
:@">K$2] 4#? @":5$2>"2 @2$::<" 9"
J"5<" C >95$22"#@$ " #"X>#$95" 3"
5$5" :"K?2N
  !"!!&
"
- 5$5" :"K?2 $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
:>:5$#? 3$ :$a42?9;? ?95>$:#?a?A
#$95" E?@?Y 3$ 2$E"9b$E$2 ? $X$9A
54?K @2$:$9;? 3$ 4# "J:5‘E4K" 34A
2?95$ " #"X>#$95" 3$ D$Eb?#$95" 3"
X>32"d Z4?93" :$ X$2>D>E? $:5$ $X$95"]
" :>:5$#? >95$22"#@$ $ >9X$25$
>#$3>?5?#$95$ " E42:" 3" X>32"N

’@h: 52[: 5$95?5>X?: 3$ D$Eb?#$95"
3" 5$5" :"K?2 >95$22"#@>3?: @$K" :>:A
5$#? 3$ :$a42?9;?] " 3>:@":>5>X" ?9A
5>$:#?a?#$95" :$2‘ 3$:?J>K>5?3" $]
)$&&
?@h: ?::$a42?2 ? >9$p>:5[9E>? 3$ "J:A
5‘E4K":] " 5$5" :"K?2 3$X$2‘ :$2 D$A
Eb?3" @4p?93" " J"5<" B ?5^ " D>#
3" E42:" 3" @?>9$KN
'.  
!%!
!#!
(#? E"K"E?;<" >9E"22$5? 3? X?2$5?
@"3$ @2"X"E?2 ? Z4$3? X>"K$95? 3"
E?@vN
8$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3" E"22$5" 52?X?A
#$95" 3? X?2$5? 9" 3>:@":>5>X"N
!#!
."3? ? #?9"J2? 3$ K$X?95?#$95"
3? X?2$5? 3$X$ :$2 D$>5? ?52?X^: 3"
>:"K?3"2 5^2#>E"] 3$:5?E?3" 9? @":>A
;<" ! 3? >#?a$# :$a4>95$N
+:5$_? :$#@2$ ?5$95" g: 2$E"#$9A
3?;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
)$X?95?2 " E?@v 45>K>Y?93" ?#J?:
?: #<":N
’95$: 3$ @2"E$3$2 ?" K$X?95?A
#$95"] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ": J2?;":
3": K>#@?3"2$: 3" @?2?AJ2>:? 9<"
$:5$_?# K$X?95?3": $ $# D49E>"9?A
#$95" $ 3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" $:5$_?
@?2?3" $ " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
?E>"9?3"N
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 14p?2 ? ?K?X?9E? >95$29? 3$ K>J$A
2?;<" 3" E?@v] K"E?K>Y?3? :"J "
@?>9$KN

 ’E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? :"J " E?@v]
@4p?93"A? @?2? " K?3" $:Z4$23"
qK?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"r $ K$X?95‘AK"N
!"
!#!
1"2 #"5>X": 3$ :$a42?9;?] " E?@v
3$X$ #?95$2A:$ J$# D$Eb?3" 342?95$
? #?2Eb?N 1"25?95"] X$2>D>E?2 :$#A
@2$ " D$Eb?#$95" E"22$5" 3" E?@v]
E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5$_? J$# 52?A
X?3"N
,$] 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] @$2E$J$2
Z4$ 9<" $:5‘ @$2D$>5?#$95$ 52?X?3"]
@?2?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ $ D$Eb?2 " E?@v
3$ #"3" E"22$5"N
!#!
+p$E45?2 ?: "@$2?;\$: ?@$9?: E"#
" X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
+:5$_? :$#@2$ ?5$95" g: 2$E"#$9A
3?;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 B?>p?2 " E?@v ? E$2E? 3$ HG E$9A
5W#$52": 3" X<" 3" #"5"2d $#
:$a4>3?] 3$>p‘AK" E?>2 $ E$25>D>E?2A
:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5$_? E"#@K$5?#$95$
D$Eb?3" $ 9<" ?@$9?: $9a?5?3"
9? @":>;<" 3$ :$a42?9;?N 8?:"
$:5$_? ?@$9?: $9a?5?3"] 9<" $p$2A
E$2 @2$::<" 9" E?@v] #?: X"K5?2 ?
K$X?95‘AK" $ 2$@$5>2 ? #?9"J2?N
#

V$2>D>E?2 :$#@2$ " D$Eb?#$95" E"2A
2$5" 3" E?@v] @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ :$ ?J2?
$# #"X>#$95"N
'
%;
(:$ " E"952"K$ 2$#"5" "4 " J"5<"
>95$29" 3$ 52?X?#$95" 3? @"25? 9"
@?>9$K 3? @"25? @?2? 52?9E?2 ? 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?:N ’: 52?X?: #?94?>:
3?: @"25?: 9<" 52?9E?# ? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?:N
- JK"Z4$>" 3" @"25?A#?K?: ^ $K^A
52>E" $ :h D49E>"9? E"# " X$WE4K"
@?2?3"] "4 :$_?] " E"#?93" 3$ JK"A
)$&’
Z4$?2o3$:JK"Z4$?2 ^ 3$:?5>X?3" E"#
" X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"N
- @"25?A#?K?: @"3$ :$2 ?J$25" 3?:
:$a4>95$: #?9$>2?:%
 ’E>"9?93" " J"5<" 3$ ?J$2A
542? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 9? Eb?X$ $K$A
52v9>E?N
 1?2? X$WE4K": E"# " "@E>"9?K
tT?93: D2$$t] @?::?93" " @^ :"J "
@?2?AEb"Z4$ 52?:$>2" qX$2 @2"E$A
3>#$95" 9$::$ E?@>54K" 9? :$;<"
t1"25?A#?K?: E"# ?J$2542? b?93:
D2$$ q#<": K>X2$:rtN
 ’E>"9?93" " J"5<" 9" E"9_495"
3>?95$>2" 3$ K4Y$: >95$29?:N
 ’E>"9?93" " J"5<" $p5$29" 9?
5?#@? 52?:$>2?] ?E>#? 3? @K?E?N
 ’E>"9?93" " J"5<" K"E?K>Y?3" 9?
K?5$2?K $:Z4$23?] 3$952" 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N
 *$:52?X?93" ? 52?X? 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>? E"# 4#? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93?]
@$K" K?3" 3$ 3$952" 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N
)$&*
!%! !4 -      ( 
w4?93" 3$:52?X?3"] ^ @"::WX$K
?J2>2 " @"25?A#?K?: @$K" $p5$2>"2 3"
!#! X$WE4K"] ?54?93" 9" @4p?3"2 E"#
?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" @":>E>"9?3"
84>3?3" ?" ?J2>2 ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N
9? @?25$ >9D$2>"2 3? 5?#@? ?5^ "4X>2
" $:5?K>3" 3$ $D$5>X" 3$:JK"Z4$>" "4
-J_$5": E"K"E?3": 9" @"25?A#?K?: @2$::>"9?93" 2?@>3?#$95$ 34?: X$A
@"3$# :$2 3?9>D>E?3": ?" ?J2>2 ? Y$: " J"5<" 9? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?N
5?#@?N
!#!
!<" 52?9:@"25?2 @$::"?: 9" @"25?A
#?K?:N
- $:@?;" 3" @"25?A#?K?: ^ 3$:A
5>9?3" $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?" 52?9:@"25$
!4 -        /
3$ E?2a?:N ’ D># 3$ $X>5?2 K$:\$:
.- 0
a2?X$:] @$::"?: 3$X$# :$#@2$ :$2
52?9:@"25?3?: 9": ?::$95": $ 4:?93" 12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 3$ ?J$2542? 3?
" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?N 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 9" @?>9$K 3$
5$5"] @2hp>#" g: K4Y$: 3$ E"25$:>?N
!"
,$a42?2 9" @4p?3"2 ! $ J?>p?2
? @"25?] @2$::>"9?93" _495" 3? D$A
Eb?342? ?5^ :$95>2 " D$Eb?#$95" 3?
#$:#?N

’95$: 3$ X"K5?2 ? D$Eb?2 " @"25?A
#?K?:] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 5$# ?
Eb?X$ $# :4? @"::$] @"2Z4$ " @"25?A
#?K?: :$2‘ JK"Z4$?3" ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$N
!&"!! " !!&
" $ / .- 0
!4 -   3,G   '9 , 
 & '
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" 9? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r] 9" >95$A
2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K" q@2hp>#" g: K4A
Y$: 3$ 5$5"r] 9" >95$2>"2 3" @"25?A
#?K?: q@?>9$K >95$29" K?3" $:Z4$23"r]
"4 ?E>"9?93" " @4p?3"2 $K^52>E" $pA
5$29" qZ4?93" 3$:52?X?3"r] ? 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?:%
 ’J2>2‘ Z4?93" 5"5?K#$95$
D$Eb?3?N
 P$Eb?2‘ Z4?93" 5"5?K#$95$
?J$25?N
 =9X$25$2‘ " :$95>3"] Z4?93" $#
#"X>#$95"N
’@h: #uK5>@K?: "J:524;\$: 9"
#$:#" E>EK"] ? 5?#@? 3" E"#A
@?25>#$95" 3$ J?a?a$9: >2‘ @?2?2
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ $ 3$X$ :$2 ?J$25?
"4 D$Eb?3? #?94?K#$95$N
T‘ 5?#J^# :$9:"2$: D>p?3": 9?
K?5$2?K 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2?N (#? K$X$
@2$::<" $# Z4?KZ4$2 K4a?2 ?" K"9a"
3$::?: D?>p?: D?2‘ E"# Z4$ ? 5?#@? 3"
E"#@?25>#$95" 3$ J?a?a$9: 2$5"29$
g @":>;<" ?J$25?N

- J"5<" :>54?3" 9? @?25$ >95$29?
3" @4p?3"2 5$# ? D49;<" 3$ 52?X?2
5"3?: ?: @"25?: 3" X$WE4K"N
#

’ 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 5$2‘ :$4
:$95>3" 3$ ?J$2542? "4 D$Eb?#$95"
>9X$25>3" E?:" $9E"952$ ?Ka4#? 2$:>:A
5[9E>? ?" #"X>#$95" $#@2$$93>3"N
8?:" #uK5>@K?: "J:524;\$: :$_?# $9A
E"952?3?: 9" #$:#" E>EK"] " #"X>A
#$95" :$2‘ >95$22"#@>3"N
1"25?95"] 3$X$A:$ :$#@2$ 3$>p?2 "
E?#>9b" 3? 5?#@? K>X2$] 3>:@$9:?93"
Z4?KZ4$2 ?4pWK>" #?94?K ?" @2"E$3>A
#$95" ?45"#‘5>E"N

,$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: D"2 3$>A
p?3? ?J$25? @"2 4# K"9a" 5$#@"] "
:>:5$#? 3$ D$Eb?#$95" $K^52>E" @"3$
)$&+
:$ 3$:?5>X?2] :$93" 9$E$::‘2>" E"9A
EK4>2 " @2"E$3>#$95" #?94?K#$95$
@?2? 2$>9>E>?2 ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$N

,$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: D"2 3$>A
p?3? ?J$25? @"2 4# K"9a" 5$#@"] "
:>:5$#? 3$ D$Eb?#$95" $K^52>E" @"3$
:$ 3$:?5>X?2] :$93" 9$E$::‘2>" E"9A
EK4>2 " @2"E$3>#$95" #?94?K#$95$
@?2? 2$>9>E>?2 ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$N
!#!
*42?95$ ? "@$2?;<" $K^52>E? 3?
5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:] @$::"?: "4
"J_$5": @2hp>#": @"3$# :"D2$2
D$2>#$95": $ 3?9":N
’95$: 3$ ?5>X?2 ? D49;<"]
E$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$ Z4$ " E?#>9b"
3? 5?#@? $:5‘ K>X2$] "J:$2X?93"
" @":>E>"9?#$95" 3$ E?2a?: $
#?95$93"A:$ ?5$95" g @2$:$9;? 3$
@$::"?: 9?: @2"p>#>3?3$:N
)$&,
 & ' , 4 -   
X  3 Y / 7&' * 0 & 
.- 
1?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $:5‘ 3>:@"9WA
X$K 4# :>:5$#? 3$ ?J$2542? 3" @"25?A
#?K?: 3" 5>@" b?93: D2$$] 45>K>Y?93"
" #"X>#$95" 3": @^: $# 4#? 2$A
a><" 3$K>#>5?3? @"2 J?>p" 3" @?2?A
Eb"Z4$ 52?:$>2" 3" X$WE4K" $ @2hp>#"
3? @K?E?N
1?2? ?J2>2 "4 D$Eb?2 ? 5?#@? 52?A
:$>2? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 4:?93" $::$ 2$A
E42:"] 4:$ 4# #"X>#$95" 3$ Eb45$
E"# ": @^: @?2? 3$952" q3$J?>p" 3"
X$WE4K"r $ @?2? D"2? ?J?>p" 3? @K?E?
52?:$>2?N ’ Y"9? 3$ ?5>X?;<" ^ 3$
E$2E? 3$ 6G E# 3$ K?3" ? K?3"N !<"
#"X? " @^ @?2? " K?3" "4 $# #"X>A
#$95": 3$ X?22$342? "4 ": :$9:"2$:
@"3$# 9<" 3$5$E5?2 " #"X>#$95"N

’ Y"9? 3$ ?5>X?;<" ^ ? #$:#?
@?2? X$WE4K": E"# "4 :$# 2$J"Z4$
$Z4>@?3"N
w4?93" 4# #"X>#$95" 3": @^:
@?2? ?J$2542? 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
#?K?: X‘K>3" D"2 E"9EK4W3"] :$2‘ $#>A
5>3" 4# :"#] ?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
@>:E?2<" $ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
?J2>2‘ ?@h: ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ 4# :$A
a493" "4 D$Eb?2‘ ?@h: ?@2"p>#?3?A
#$95$ 52[: :$a493":N
’ ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3$:5$ 2$A
E42:" @"3$ :$2 E"9D>a42?3? 9" (E"9A
9$E5N


’J2>2 "4 D$Eb?2 " @"25?A#?K?: E"#
$::$ 2$E42:" 2$Z4$2 Z4$ ? Eb?X$ $K$A
52v9>E? 1?::>X$ +952y X‘K>3? $:5$_? K"A
E?K>Y?3? 3$952" 3$ 7]6 # 3? #?;?A
9$5? 3? 5?#@?N ,$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
9<" $:5>X$2 ? #$9": 7]6 #] " @"25?A
#?K?: 9<" 2$:@"93$2‘ ? 9$9b4# #"A
X>#$95" 3": @^:N +::?: E"9D>a42?;\$:
@"3$# :$2 b?J>K>5?3?: "4 3$:?J>K>5?A
3?: ?52?X^: 3$ (E"99$E5N
+:5$ 2$E42:" 3$ ?J$2542? 3? 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?: 3$X$ :$2 3$:K>a?3"
342?95$ " K$X?95?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"
@?2? 52"E? 3$ @9$4:] K?X?a$# #?94?K
$ :$2X>;": 3$ #?945$9;<"N
+:5$ 2$E42:" @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3" @"2
Z4?KZ4$2 "J_$5" #$5‘K>E" D?Y$93"
4# #"X>#$95" :$#$Kb?95$ @?2?
3$952" $ @?2? D"2? :"J ? @K?E?
52?:$>2?] @"2 3$J?>p" 3" X$WE4K"N
- 3>:@":>5>X" :h D49E>"9?2‘ :$ ?
52?9:#>::<" $:5>X$2 9? @":>;<" 1
q1?2irN
,$ ?Ka" "J:524>2 ? $K$X?;<" 3?
5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: $9Z4?95"
$K? $:5>X$2 ?J2>93" "4 D$Eb?93"] "
:>:5$#? >2‘ 2$X$25$2 " #"X>#$95" ?4A
5"#?5>E?#$95$] 3$:3$ Z4$ $9E"952$
2$:>:5[9E>? :4D>E>$95$N
!#!
+p>:5$# :$9:"2$: K"E?K>Y?3": ?" *>2>a>2 E"# ? 5?#@? 52?:$>2? ?J$25?
K?3" 3? ?J$2542? 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2?N @"3$ @$2#>5>2 Z4$ a?:$: 3$ $:E?@?A
(# K$X$ 5"Z4$ $# Z4?KZ4$2 K4a?2 #$95" X$9$9":": $952$# $# :$4 X$WA
?" K"9a" 3$::?: D?>p?: D?2‘ E"# E4K"N
Z4$ ? 5?#@? 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3$
J?a?a$9: 2$5"29$ g @":>;<" ?J$25?N &?95$9b? ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
:$#@2$ D$Eb?3? Z4?93" $:5>X$2 "@$A
#
,$ ? 5?#@? 52?:$>2? $K^52>E? $9E"9A 2?93" " X$WE4K"N
52?2 X‘2>?: "J:524;\$: 9" #$:#" E>A
EK"] " :>:5$#? >2‘ @?2?2 ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$N ,$ >::" "E"22$2] ? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?: 3$X$2‘ :$2 "@$2?3? #?A
94?K#$95$N !#!
*42?95$ ? "@$2?;<" $K^52>E?]
’ 5?#@? 52?:$>2? $K^52>E? :$2‘ K>J$A
@"3$# "E"22$2 3?9": g E?2a? "4
2?3?] #?: 9<" :$2‘ ?J$25?] $# 5$#@$A
D$2>#$95": g: @$::"?: @2hp>#?:N
2?542?: ?J?>p" 3$ LI 8N 8$25>D>Z4$A
8$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$ Z4$ " E?#>9b" 3$
:$ 3$ 2$#"X$2 Z4?KZ4$2 ?Eu#4K" 3$
3$:K"E?#$95" 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2?
9$X$ "4 a$K" 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2? ?95$:
$:5$_? K>X2$ ?95$: 3$ ?5>X‘AK?N
3$ ?J2>AK?N
,$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: D"2 3$>A 8$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?: $:5$_? D$Eb?3? $ 52?X?3?
p?3? ?J$25? @"2 4# K"9a" @$2W"3"
q?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ 4#? b"2?r] @"3$ ?95$: 3$ @?25>2N
:$2 9$E$::‘2>" D$Eb‘AK? #?94?K#$95$
@?2? 2$3$D>9>2 ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 3" -: ?#"25$E$3"2$: ? a‘: :4:5$95?#
:>:5$#?N ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 9? @":>;<"
?J$25?N !" $95?95"] E"#" ? @2$::<"
)$&-
3" a‘: E?> E"# ? 5$#@$2?542?] @"3$
:$2 9$E$::‘2>" 4# ?4pWK>" ?": :4@"2A
5$: ?" ?J2>2 ? 5?#@? $# 5$#@" D2>"N

1$2#>5? Z4$ " :>:5$#? ?J2? ? 5?#@?
3" @"25?A#?K?: ?5^ " D>9?KN +#@422?2
"4 @4p?2 #?94?K#$95$ ? 5?#@? 52?A
:$>2? @"3$ ?5>X?2 " 2$E42:" 3$ 3$5$EA
;<" 3$ "J:5‘E4K" 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2?
$ >95$22"#@$2 ? "@$2?;<" "4 >9X$25$2
:4? 3>2$;<"N
!!!   
!!
'   , 5
- :>:5$#? 3" @K?9" 3$ E?2a? @":A
:4> 4#? E?@?E>3?3$ #‘p>#? 3$ 7~G
iaN !<" E?22$a?2 "J_$5": E"# @$:"
:4@$2>"2 ?" 3>#$9:>"9?3"N
 67   7   &
'
12"E$3$2 3$ ?E"23" E"# ": @?::":
? :$a4>2%
)$’.
7N C$EK>9?2 " J?9E" 52?:$>2"d
LN 14p?2 " 5?#@<"d
HN +#@422?2 " 5?#@<" @?2?
2$#"X[AK" 3" @>9" 3$ :4@"25$d
IN S>2?2 " 5?#@<" $ 2$#"X[AK" 3"
X$WE4K"N
! ' 67  , '   & '
!#!
’95$: 3$ 2$J?5$2 " $9E":5"] 2$#"A
X$2 Z4?KZ4$2 "J_$5" @2$:$95$ 9" ?:A
:$95" 3" J?9E"N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
’ ?#@K>?;<" 3" K?3" 3>2$>5" 3"
@"25?A#?K?: @$2#>5$ 52?9:@"25?2
3">: @?::?a$>2": 9? @?25$ $:Z4$23?
3" J?9E" 52?:$>2" $9Z4?95" ?
?#@K>?;<" 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" @$2#>5$
52?9:@"25?2 4# @?::?a$>2"N
12"E$3$2 :$a4>93" ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3? :$;<" tB?9E":t 9" E?@W54K"
t8"9b$E$93" " :$4 X$WE4K"tN
 (67   K     , 5
!" >95$2>"2 3" @"25?A#?K?: $:5<"
K"E?K>Y?3": a?9Eb": @?2? ? ?9E"2?A
a$# 3$ E?J": $ D>p?;<" 3?: E?2A
a?:] a?2?95>93" #?>"2 $:5?J>K>3?3$
?": X"K4#$: 52?9:@"25?3":N
   
*">: E$:5": @?2? ?2#?Y$9?#$95"
3$ @$Z4$9": "J_$5": $:5<" >9:5?K?3":
9?: K?5$2?>: 52?:$>2?: 3" X<" 3$ E?2a?N

+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] 3$X>3" ?"
:>:5$#? 3$ :"# >9:5?K?3"] b‘ ?@$9?:
4# E$:5" 9" X<" 3$ E?2a?N
 - @"25?AK4X?: $:5‘ K"E?K>Y?3" 9" !!&
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":] K?3" 3" @?:A
-: @?2?A:h>: $9E"952?#A:$ ?" K?3"
:?a$>2"N ’54?2 9" @4p?3"2 D2"95?K
3" $:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29"N 1"3$#
@?2? ?J2>2 " E"#@?25>#$95"N
:$2 "2>$95?3?: @?2? ? D2$95$ $ @?2? ":
K?3":N
1?2? "2>$95?2 9" :$95>3" K?5$2?K]
2$5>2‘AK? 3" a?9Eb" 3" K?3" 3" $:@$A
Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29" $ a>2‘AK" @?2? ?
_?9$K? K?5$2?KN #
1 '  !? @?25$ 3$ 52‘: 3" @?2?A:"K $p>:A
  5$# $:@$Kb": 3$ E"25$:>? >K4#>9?A
3":] Z4$ @$2#>5$# ? :4? 45>K>Y?;<"
!J!
#$:#" $# E"93>;\$: 3$ D2?E? K4#>A
-: $Z4>@?#$95": $:5<" 3>:52>J4WA 9":>3?3$N
3": 9" b?J>5‘E4K" 3" X$WE4K" E"9A
 1?2? ?E$::?2 " $:@$Kb"] K$X?95?2 ?
D"2#$ ? :$a4>2N
E"J$2542? 1 N
!<" >9:$2>2 9" @"25?AK4X?: "J_$5":
3$ 3>#$9:\$: 5?>: Z4$ 9<" @$2#>5?#
!&!
" D$Eb?#$95" E"#@K$5"N ’K^# 3>::"]
342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$
Z4$ " @"25?AK4X?: $:5‘ @$2D$>5?#$95$
D$Eb?3"N
!#!
!<" X>?_?2 E"# ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
K4X?: ?J$25?N
+# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$] @"3$ D$2>2 ":
"E4@?95$: 3": K4a?2$: 3>?95$>2":N

)$’!
"!!          *  
  3  ' +:5‘ :>54?3? 9? @?25$ $:Z4$23? 3$9A - X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#?
52" 3" @"25?A#?K?:N 1"3$ D49E>"9?2 5"#?3? >9X$2:"2? 3$ 776 X"K5: "4 LLG
+:5‘ :>54?3? 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?KN
?@$9?: E"# " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" X"K5: $ 76G j?55: q:$ $Z4>@?3"r ! ] K"A
P49E>"9? ?@$9?: E"# " E"#45?3"2
9? @":>;<"  "4 E"9:5?95$#$95$ E?K>Y?3? 9? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" E"9:"K$
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  :$ 2"54A
?K>#$95?3? @$K? J?5$2>?N 8"9:4K5$ ? E$952?K @?2? E"9X$25$2 ? E"22$95$ *8
K?3? E"# 4# :W#J"K" 3$ Eb?X$N ."A
  ! = ,  > @?2? #?>"A $# E"22$95$ ’8N +:5? 5"#?3? @"3$
#?3?: 2"54K?3?: E"# 4# :W#J"K" 3$
2$: 3$5?Kb$:N ?K>#$95?2 5$K$D"9$: E$K4K?2$:] $K$52vA
J?5$2>?] @"2 $:5?2$# E"9$E5?3?: 3>2$A
9>E": $ "452": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ J?>p?
5?#$95$ g J?5$2>? 3" X$WE4K"] D49E>"A
@"5[9E>? Z4$ 2$Z4$2$# @"5[9E>? 3$
9?# " 5$#@" 5"3"N
?5^ 76G ¤?55:N


."3": ": ?E$::h2>": E"9$E5?3": g:
5"#?3?: E"# :W#J"K" 3$ xJ?5$2>?z
3$X$# :$2 2$#"X>3": "4 3$:K>a?3":
Z4?93" " X$WE4K" 9<" $:5>X$2 $#
4:" @?2? @2"5$a$2 ? J?5$2>? E"952?
3$:E?2a?N

!<" >952"34Y>2 9?: 5"#?3?: ?@?2$A
Kb": E"# @"5[9E>? :4@$2>"2 ? 76G ¤N
’K^# 3>::"] 9<" 3?9>D>E?2 ? 5"#?3?
4:?93" ?@?2$Kb": >9?3$Z4?3":N
1?2? K>a?2 ? 5"#?3? 3" >9X$2:"2
3$ $9$2a>?] J?:5? E"9$E5?2 " 3>:@":>A
5>X"N ’ 5"#?3? 3$:K>a? ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ Z4?93" " 3>:@":>5>X" ^ 3$:E"A
9$E5?3"N
- >9X$2:"2 3$ $9$2a>? ^ @2"_$5?3"
E"# @2"5$;<" E"952? :"J2$E?2a? $#A

)$’"
J45>3?N ,$ ? EK?::>D>E?;<" 3$ $9$2a>?
3$ 76G ¤?55: D"2 $pE$3>3?] " >9X$2A
:"2 3$ $9$2a>? :$2‘ 3$:K>a?3" ?45"A
#?5>E?#$95$N ’::># Z4$ " 3>:@":>A
5>X" $K^52>E" D"2 2$#"X>3" 3? 5"#?3?]
" >9X$2:"2 3$X$ 2$>9>E>?2 ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$N 1?2? $X>5?2 :"J2$E?22$a?2
" E>2E4>5"] X$2>D>Z4$ ?: EK?::>D>E?;\$:
3$ $9$2a>? $# 3>:@":>5>X": $K^52>E":
?95$: 3$ 4:?2 " >9X$2:"2N
!#!
!<" >9:>2? 9$9b4# "J_$5" 9": 2$A
E$@5‘E4K": $ 9<" 5"Z4$ E"# ?: #<":
#"Kb?3?:N P$Eb$ ? 5?#@? Z4?93"
9<" $:5>X$2 $# 4:"N
,$ $:5? 5"#?3? D"2 #?94:$?3? >9A
E"22$5?#$95$] @"3$ E?4:?2 Eb"Z4$
$K^52>E" $ D$2>#$95": a2?X$:N
!   %! !  !&%> 
%!  ! 
+:5‘ K"E?K>Y?3" $952$ ": J?9E": 3>A
!! / .- 0
?95$>2":N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] @"2 J?>p"
- ?@">" 3$ J2?;": ^ 2$a4K‘X$K 9"
3" ?::$95" 3" J?9E" 3" @?::?a$>2"
:$95>3" K"9a>543>9?K @?2? @2"@"2E>"A
$9E"952?A:$ 4# X<" @"25?A"J_$5":N
9?2 " #‘p>#" 3$ E"9D"25"N
14p?2 $ 2$J?5$2 ? ?K#"D?3?]
?E"#@?9b?93"A? E"# ? #<"] @?2?
#
?E$::?2 " X<" @"25?A"J_$5": N
!! R !!
! ! ! / .- &
0
1?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $:5‘ 3>:@"A
9WX$K 4# E?22$a?3"2 :$# D>" ! @?2?
?@?2$Kb": E$K4K?2$:] K"E?K>Y?3" 9"
E"9:"K$ E$952?K 3" X$WE4K"N
!" >95$2>"2 3" ?@">" 3$ J2?;" $:5‘
@2$:$95$ 4# X<" @"25?A"J_$5":N 1?2?
5$2 ?E$::"] ?54?2 9" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$
52?X?#$95" $ K$X?95?2 " ?@">" 3$
J2?;"N
)$’%
 ,$4 5$K$D"9$ E$K4K?2 3$X$ :$2 @2"_$A
5?3" @?2? E?22$a?#$95" :$# D>"N ,$ "
5$K$D"9$ 9<" $:5>X$2 $Z4>@?3" E"# ?
D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 3$ E?22$a?#$95" :$#
D>"] 4#? E?@? 3$ 2$@":>;<" "4 4#?
@K?E? 52?:$>2? $:@$E>?K>Y?3? @"3$ :$2
?3Z4>2>3? $# :4? "@$2?3"2? 3$ E$K4A
K?2N 8"9:4K5$ " #?94?K 3" @2"@2>$A
5‘2>" 3" :$4 5$K$D"9$ @?2? "J5$2 #?>:
>9D"2#?;\$:N
’ J?:$ 3$ E?22$a?#$95" :$# D>" ^
$Z4>@?3? E"# 4# 5?@$5$ ?95>3$22?A
@?95$] 4#? J?:$ ?_4:5‘X$K @?2? :$a4A
2?2 " :$4 5$K$D"9$ E$K4K?2 $ 4# >93>A
E?3"2 )+*N
-   , 
 ,$# K4Y% ? J?:$ 3$ E?22$a?#$95"
$:5‘ "E>":? "4 @2"E42?93" 4#
3>:@":>5>X"N
 )4Y ?Y4K% " 3>:@":>5>X" D"> 3$5$EA
5?3" $ $:5‘ E?22$a?93"N
 )4Y X$2#$Kb?o@>:E?93"% $22" >9A
5$29" "4 "J_$5" $:52?9b" 3$5$EA
5?3"N
)$’&

’ J?:$ 3$ E?22$a?#$95" :$# D>"
9<" D49E>"9?2‘ :$ ?Ka4#? 3?: Z4?A
52" @"25?: $:5>X$2 ?J$25?] #$:#" :$
" #"5"2 $:5>X$2 D49E>"9?93"N ’J2>2
? 5?#@? 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3$ J?A
a?a$9: 9<" >95$2D$2$ 9? "@$2?;<" 3?
J?:$ 3$ E?22$a?#$95"N
- 4:" 3$ 4#? E?@? 3$ 5$K$D"9$
@"3$ >95$2D$2>2 9" E?22$a?#$95" :$#
D>"N

- 5$#@" 3$ E?2a? 3$@$93$2‘ 3"
5>@" 3$ ?@?2$Kb" 45>K>Y?3" $ 3?: D49A
;\$: ?5>X?: 342?95$ " 5$#@" 3$ E?2a?N
!#!
1?2? ?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# E?2A
2$a?3"2 :$# D>"] ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
!0- 3$X$ :$2 @":>E>"9?3? :"J2$ "
#$:#"] "4 ? 4#? 3>:5e9E>? >9D$2>"2 ?
76E# 3" E?22$a?3"2 :$# D>"N
- @":>E>"9?#$95" 3? Eb?X$ $K$A
52v9>E? $# 4#? 3>:5e9E>? >9D$2>"2 ?
76 E# 3" E?22$a?3"2 :$# D>" "4 :"A
J2$ " #$:#" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 " E"9A
52"K$ 2$#"5" 3? #$:#? $ >#@$3$ Z4$
" :>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 3" X$WE4K" 2$E"A
9b$;? ? Eb?X$] 9<" :$93" @"::WX$K
3?2 ? @?25>3? 9" X$WE4K"N
!#!
- E?22$a?3"2 j>2$K$:: 4:? ? 5$E9"A
K"a>? 3$ >934;<" @?2? D?Y$2 " E?22$A
a?#$95" 3$ 3>:@":>5>X": E"#@?5WX$>:
E"# $::? 5$E9"K"a>?N
f ?J:"K45?#$95$ @2">J>3" ?K"E?2
Z4?>:Z4$2 #?5$2>?>: #$5‘K>E": :"J2$
? ‘2$? 3$ E?22$a?#$95"N

1?2? #?>"2 $D>E>[9E>? 3$ E?22$a?A
#$95" ^ 2$E"#$93?3" #?95$2 " 3>:A
@":>5>X" 9" E$952" 3? ‘2$? 3$ E?22$A
a?#$95"N 8?:"] 342?95$ ? 3>2$;<"] "
3>:@":>5>X" :?>? 3? ‘2$? 3$ E?22$a?A
#$95"] " E?22$a?3"2 @"3$ >95$22"#A g @"25? (,B .>@" 8] 4#? #$9:?a$#
@$2 " @2"E$::" 3$ E?2a?N ?@?2$E$2‘ $ @$2#>5>2‘ Z4$ X"E[ :$K$A
E>"9$ " 3>:@":>5>X" ? :$2 4:?3"N
! %
’: 5"#?3?: (,B $:5<" K"E?K>Y?3?:
9" E"9:"K$ E$952?KN +:5$ 2$E42:" @$2A
#>5$ Z4$ 4# 3>:@":>5>X" $p5$29" :$_?
E"9$E5?3" 9?: @"25?: (,B "4 ’(¡N
#
8"9$E5?2 4# 3>:@":>5>X"
:#?25@b"9$ ? 4#? @"25? (,B ?5>X?2‘ 2   3
": 2$E42:": ’932">3 ’45"£ "4 ’@@K$  1 '
8?21K?y¢] :$ $Z4>@?3"N 1?2? "J5$2
7N 1"25? (,B 5>@" 8 +# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] " X$WE4K" @":A
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5$ x’9A
32">3 ’45" £z "4 x’@@K$ 8?21K?y¢z LN 1"25? (,B 5>@" ’ :4> J?22?: K"9a>543>9?>: Z4$ @"3$#
9" #?94?K 3? E$952?K #4K5>#W3>?N :$2 45>K>Y?3?:] E"# " ?E2^:E>#" 3$
1?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $:5‘ 3>:@"A ?E$::h2>": $:@$EWD>E":] @?2? " 52?9:A
9WX$K 4#? :$a493? @"25? (,B K"E?A @"25$ 3$ ?5^ F~ ia 3$ E?2a?N
 K>Y?3? 9? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" E"9:"K$
1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] 3>2>a>2A:$ g
*">: 3>:@":>5>X": @"3$# :$2 E"A E$952?K] 45>K>Y?3? @?2? E?22$a?2 4#
  ! = ,  > :
9$E5?3": ?" #$:#" 5$#@" $ ?#J?: 3>:@":>5>X" $p5$29"N
?: @"25?: D"29$E$2<" 2$E42:": 3$ E?2A
2$a?#$95"N ’@$9?: 4#? @"25? @"3$
52?9:D$2>2 3?3": @?2? " :>:5$#? @"2
X$YN

1"2 $p$#@K"] :$ 4# 3>:@":>5>X" $:A

5>X$2 E"9$E5?3" g @"25? (,B .>@" ’
$ "452" 3>:@":>5>X" $:5>X$2 E"9$E5?3"

)$’’
' 
  
"! J! 9b$>2"] $5ENr% @$2>a" 3$ >9E[93>"N
 H '(
-: :>:5$#?: 45>K>Y?3": @?2? 2$34Y>2
?: $#>::\$: 3": #"5"2$: PK$p :<"%
E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"] :"93? K?#J3? $
:>:5$#? ?95>$X?@"2?;<"N
 H  '
-: :>:5$#?: 45>K>Y?3": @?2? 2$34Y>2
?: $#>::\$: 3": #"5"2$: *>$:$K] :<"%
E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E" "p>3?95$ q*-8r]
:>:5$#? 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3": a?:$:
3$ $:E?@$ q+SCr] D>K52" 3$ @?25WE4K?:
q*1Pr $ E?5?K>:?3"2 :$K$5>X" @?2? hp>A
3": 3$ !>52"a[9>" ?5>X" E"# ’2K? HL
q,8CrN
!#!
!" :$4 D49E>"9?#$95"] " E"9X$2A
:"2 E?5?KW5>E" $ D>K52" 3$ @?25WE4K?:
q*1Pr ?5>9a$# $K$X?3?: 5$#@$2?54A
2?:N
)$’*
1"25?95"] 9<" $:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"
:"J2$ #?5$2>?K >9DK?#‘X$K q@"2 $pN
2$KX?] D"Kb?: :$E?:] ?a4Kb?: 3$ @>A
!#!
’K5$2?;\$: D$>5?: 9" X$WE4K" E"# "
"J_$5>X" 3$ ?4#$95?2 " :$4 3$:$#A
@$9b"] 5?>: E"#" 2$5>2?3? 3" E?5?K>A
:?3"2 $o"4 #"3>D>E?;\$: 9" :>:5$#?
3$ >9_$;<" $K$52v9>E?] ?K^# 3$ E"9A
52>J4W2$# @?2? ?4#$95?2 3$:9$E$::?A
2>?#$95$ ? @"K4>;<" ?5#":D^2>E?] @"A
3$# 2$:4K5?2 9" E?9E$K?#$95" 3? a?A
2?95>? 3": E"#@"9$95$: $9X"KX>3":N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN

.2?D$a?2 E"# " :>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?A
#$95" #"3>D>E?3" "4 3?9>D>E?3"]
?K^# 3$ ?4#$95?2 E"9:>3$2?X$KA
#$95$ " 9WX$K 3$ 24>3" 3" X$WE4K"
q@"K4>;<" :"9"2?r] E"9:5>54> 4#?
>9D2?;<" ?" 8h3>a" !?E>"9?K 3$
.2e9:>5"N
  !!   / &
'   ,-'  ' 0
- *>$:$K 1?25>E4K?5$ P>K5$2 ^ 4# D>KA
52" #$Ee9>E"] >952"34Y>3" 9" :>:5$#?
3$ 3$:E?2a?] Z4$ E?@542? D>:>E?#$95$
?: @?25WE4K?: 3$ E?2J"9" @2$:$95$:
9": a?:$: 3$ 3$:E?2a? 3" #"5"2 *>$A
:$KN
’ ?3";<" 3" D>K52" 3$ @?25WE4K?:
5"29?A:$ 9$E$::‘2>? @?2? $K>#>9?2
Z4?:$ 5"5?K#$95$ ?: $#>::\$: 3$ @?2A
5WE4K?: 3$ E?2J"9" $# :>95"9>? E"#
?: ?54?>:oD4542?: 9"2#?: K$a>:K?5>X?:N
*42?95$ " 4:" 9"2#?K 3" X$WE4K"] ?
49>3?3$ E$952?K 3$ E"952"K$ 3" #"5"2
a2?X? 4#? :^2>$ 3$ 3?3": >9$2$95$:
?" 4:" q@$2W"3" 3$ 4:"] 5>@" 3$ @$2A
E42:"] 5$#@$2?542?: ?5>9a>3?:] $5ENr $
3$5$2#>9? ? Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ @?25WE4K?:
?E4#4K?3?: 9" D>K52"N
8"#" " D>K52" E"9:>:5$ 94# :>:5$#?
3$ ?E4#4K?;<"] 3$X$ :$2 2$a$9$2?3"
qK>#@"r @$2>"3>E?#$95$ Z4$>#?93"
?: @?25WE4K?: 3$ E?2J"9"N
 w4?93" :?542?3"] " :>:5$#? ?E>A
"9? 4#? K4YA$:@>? $ $p>J$ 4#? #$9A
:?a$# 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":] >9A
3>E?93" ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ $K>#>9?2
@?25WE4K?: @"K4$95$: 2$5>3?: 9" D>K52"N
f 9$E$::‘2>" #?95$2 " X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95" ?5^ " 5^2#>9" 3? 2$a$9$A
2?;<"N w4?93" ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a?]
^ $p>J>3? 9" @?>9$K 4#? #$9:?a$#
>93>E?93" " 5^2#>9" 3" @2"E$::" 3$
2$a$9$2?;<"N
+pE$@E>"9?K#$95$] E?:" 9<" :$_?
@"::WX$K #?95$2 " X$WE4K" $# #"X>A
#$95"] ? K>#@$Y? 3" D>K52" 3$ @?25WA
E4K?: *1P @"3$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? E"#
" X$WE4K" $# #?2Eb? K$95? ?5^ Z4$
? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a4$ $ ? #$9:?a$#
>93>E?93" " 5^2#>9" 3" @2"E$::" 3$
2$a$9$2?;<" ?@?2$;? 9" @?>9$K 3$
>9:524#$95":N

’.+!/0-% ?" 2$?K>Y?2 " @2"E$A
3>#$95" E"# " X$WE4K" $# #?2Eb?
K$95?] 949E? $:5?E>"9?2 $# K"E?>: D$A
Eb?3": "4 :"J2$ #?5$2>?K >9DK?#‘A
X$K] $# 2?Y<" 3" ?Z4$E>#$95" $K$A
X?3" 3" E?5?K>:?3"2] 3$E"22$95$ 3"
D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K 3" #"5"2N ’ X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3? #$9:?a$# 3$3>E?3?
?K5? 5$#@$2?542? ?5>9a>3? @$K" E?5?K>A 9" 3>:@K?y] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" t)4A
:?3"2 @"3$2‘ a$2?2 2>:E" 3$ >9E[93>"] Y$: 3$ ?3X$25[9E>?: $ #$9:?a$9:t 9"
Z4?93" $# E"95?5" E"# #?5$2>?K >9A E?@W54K" t8"9b$E$93" :$4 @?>9$K 3$
DK?#‘X$K q@"2 $pN 2$KX?] D"Kb?: :$E?:] >9:524#$95":tN
?a4Kb?: 3$ @>9b$>2"] $5ENrN V>3$ x12"A
’ ?4:[9E>? 3? 2$?K>Y?;<" 3" E>EK"
5$;<" 3" ?#J>$95$z 9" E?@W54K" x8"A
3$ K>#@$Y? 3" D>K52" 3$ @?25WE4K?: *1P
9b$E$93" :$4 X$WE4K"z $ x,>:5$#?
3$ D"2#? ?3$Z4?3?] _495?#$95$ E"#
#
3$ $:E?@?#$95"z 9" E?@W54K" x&?A
? 9<" "J:$2Xe9E>? 3": ?X>:": >93>E?A
945$9;<" $ E4>3?3": E"# " :$4 X$WA
5>X": 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": 3"
E4K"zN
X$WE4K"] @"3$2‘ ?E$K$2?2 " @2"E$::"
3$ 3$a2?3?;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2N ’
- @2"E$3>#$95" 3$ 2$a$9$2?;<" K4YA$:@>? 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 ?E$93$2‘
^ E"952"K?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ @$K? E?:" " :>:5$#? E"9:5?5$ Z4$ " hK$" D">
E$952?K 3$ E"952"K$ 3" #"5"2 $# D49A 3$a2?3?3" >93>E?93" ? 9$E$::>3?3$
;<" 3" $:5?3" 3$ ?E4#4K?;<" 3" D>KA 3? 52"E?N !$:5$ E?:"] @2"E42$ >#$A
52" $ 3?: E"93>;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" 3>?5?#$95$ 4#? 3?: E"9E$::>"9‘2>?:
X$WE4K"N 3?   ! = ,  > @?2? ?
*42?95$ ? 2$a$9$2?;<"] ^ @"::WX$K X$2>D>E?;<" $ :4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" 3"
Z4$ :$ X$2>D>Z4$# ": D$9v#$9": :$A #"5"2N
a4>95$:% ?4#$95" K>#>5?3" 3" 2$a>#$
3$ #?2Eb? K$95?] ?5>X?;<" 3" $K$A
52"X$95>K?3"2] ?4#$95" K>#>5?3" 3":
a?:$:] $K$X?3?: 5$#@$2?542?: 9? 3$:A
E?2a?N
+:5?: :>54?;\$: 9<" 3$X$# :$2 >9A
5$2@2$5?3?: E"#" ?9"#?K>?: $ 9<"
?D$5?# " D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K 3"
X$WE4K" 9$# " ?#J>$95$N +# E?:" 3$
)$’+
 ! "?  & ? " " 
+:5$ X$WE4K" $:5‘ $# E"9D"2#>3?3$ E"# ?: C$:"K4;\$: 8-!’&’ q8"9:$Kb" !?E>"9?K 3" &$>" ’#J>$95$r X>a$95$:
9? 3?5? 3$ :4? @2"34;<"N
-: W93>E$: 3$ D4#?;? $# ?E$K$2?;<" K>X2$ $:5<" $p@2$::": $# #A7 qE"$D>E>$95$ 3$ ?J:"2;<" 3$ K4Yr E"9D"2#$
$9:?>": 2$?K>Y?3": E"# E"#J4:5WX$K 3$ 2$D$2[9E>?] $:@$E>D>E?3" 9?: C$:"K4;\$: X>a$95$: 3" 8-!’&’N
+:5$ W93>E$ ^ 4#? 2$D$2[9E>? @?2? X$2>D>E?;<" Z4?95" ?" $:5?3" 3$ #?945$9;<" 3" X$WE4K"N

  ,   ,   ,' 67 ' * 

  B:2  '

~6G 2@# q?2AE"93>E>"9?3" 3$:K>a?3"r

C"5?;<" &?2Eb? )$95?
MLG 2@# q?2AE"93>E>"9?3" K>a?3"r
C"5?;<" 3$ 8"25$ 6GGG 2@#
A7
m93>E$ 3$ "@?E>3?3$ $# ?E$K$2?;<" K>X2$ q# r q?K5>543$ ?E>#? 3$ H6G #r G]IG
A7
m93>E$ 3$ "@?E>3?3$ $# ?E$K$2?;<" K>X2$ q# r q?K5>543$ ?J?>p" 3$ H6G #r G]IG

)$’,
'   
(4 )*+,-
! !   1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$
8’C. ^ 4# ?@K>E?5>X" Z4$ @$2#>5$
?" E"9345"2 3" X$WE4K" $D$54?2 " @?A
a?#$95" 3$ @2"345": $ :$2X>;": "D$A
2$E>3": @"2 $#@2$:?: @?2E$>2?: 3$
#?9$>2? @2‘5>E? $ >9"X?3"2?N - ?@K>A
E?5>X" 8’C. @"3$ :$2 45>K>Y?3" ?52?A
X^: 3$ :#?25@b"9$] E"# :>:5$#? "@$A
2?E>"9?K ’932">3 "4 >-, $] Z4?93"
E"#@?5WX$K] 5?#J^# ?52?X^: 3? E$9A
52?K #4K5>#W3>? 3" X$WE4K" 9? Z4?K ?:
D49;\$: ’932">3 ’45" $ ’@@K$ 8?2A
1K?y $:5>X$2$# 3>:@"9WX$>:N
+952$ ": :$2X>;": 3>:@"9>J>K>Y?3":
@$K" ?@K>E?5>X" 8’C. $:5‘ " @?a?A
#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" Z4$ @"3$ :$2 45>A
K>Y?3" $# $:5?E>"9?#$95": $ @$3‘A
a>":N 1?2? Z4$ $:5$ :$2X>;" @"::? :$2
45>K>Y?3"] $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K 9" @?2?A
J2>:? 3$ ?Ka49: X$WE4K": " ?3$:>X"]
>93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
X?;<"] ?a4?23?2 9" #W9>#" F b"2?:
@?2? ? @2>#$>2? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;"N
" ?@K>E?5>X" 8’C.] E"9D>2#?2 ?
- X$WE4K" ^ E"#$2E>?K>Y?3" E"#
E"#@?5>J>K>3?3$ E"# ? E$952?K
$:5$ :$2X>;" 3$:?J>K>5?3" $ E?:" :$_?
#4K5>#W3>? 3" :$4 X$WE4K" $
3$ >95$2$::$ 3" @2"@2>$5‘2>" ?5>X‘AK"]
?5>X?;<"o:4J:5>54>;<" 3" ?3$A
@2"E$3$2 E"9D"2#$ >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
:>X"o45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$
@?a?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3$ $:5?A
#
 B?>p?2 " ?@K>E?5>X" X!YN E>"9?#$95":o@$3‘a>":] ?E$::?2 "
 C$?K>Y?2 " 2$a>:52" 9" ?@K>E?5>X"N :>5$ jjjNE?25N?@@NJ2 "4 ? 8$952?K
 8?3?:52?2 4# E?25<" 3$ E2^3>5" 3$ ’_43?] 3>:@"9WX$K 9" @2h@2>"
@?2? @?a?#$95"N ?@K>E?5>X"N
 !? ?J? x+:5?E>"9?#$95" $ 1$3‘A
a>"z] :$a4>2 " @?::" ? @?::" @?2?
D?Y$2 ? E"952?5?;<" 3$ 4# 3":
@K?9": 3>:@"9WX$>:N

-: E4:5": 2$D$2$95$: g #$9:?K>3?3$
$ 2$E?2a? 3$ E2^3>5": @?2? 45>K>Y?A
;<" 3": :$2X>;": :<" 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>A
3?3$ 3" @2"@2>$5‘2>" 3" X$WE4K"] J$#
E"#" $X$954?>: E4:5": @?2? :4J:5>54>A
;<" 3" ?3$:>X"N +# 2"3"X>?: K"E?K>A
Y?3?: D"2? 3" $:5?3" 3$ ,1] ?@h: ?5>A
)$’-
)
 &    ' 
  
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *A7
1’=!+) *+ =!,.C(&+!.-, N N N N N N N N N N N N *AL
*=,1)’R N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *A7H
8-&1(.’*-C *+ B-C*- N N N N N N N N N N N *ALG
)(Q+, *+ ’*V+C.l!8=’, +
&+!,’S+!, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *AL7
,=,.+&’ *+ *=’S!U,.=8- *+ B-C*- N N N N *AIL $

/
/
 
+:5? :$;<" 3" #?94?K D"29$E$AKb$
5"3?: ?: >9D"2#?;\$: u5$>: @?2? E"A
9b$E$2] >95$2@2$5?2 $ 45>K>Y?2 E"22$5?A
#$95$ " @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N

/$!
'    
" 
’ 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ $ ? @":>;<" 3": >9:524#$95": $ 3": :>9?K>Y?3"2$: @"3$# X?2>?2 $# D49;<" 3": >5$9: "@E>"9?>:
?3Z4>2>3":o3>:@"9WX$>:N

7A *>D4:"2$: D>p": 3$ ?2 K?5$2?>: LA *>D4:"2$: K?5$2?>: "2>$95‘X$>: HA V"K?95$ IA 8$952?K (E"99$E5 6A 1"25?AK4X?: FA
*>D4:"2$: E$952?>: "2>$95‘X$>: |A 8"9_495" 3$ E"#?93": 3" @?>9$K ~A 8"#?93": 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" MA ’K?X?9E?
3>2$>5? qE"#?93" 3$ K>#@$Y?oK?X?a$# 3": X>32":r 7GA ’K?X?9E? $:Z4$23? 3$ E"#?93" 3$ D?2"K ?K5"oJ?>p" $ K4Y$: 3$
3>2$;<"r 77A B"5\$: 3$ E"#?93"N

/$"
;!  " &  H '(
;-  -' 3- ,  '

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N

/$%
 ;-  -' 3- ,  ' , 3 5- P*'

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N
/$&
 ;-   5 '

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N

/$’
;!  " &  H  '
;-  -' 3- ,  '

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N

/$*
 ;-  -' 3- ,  ' , 3 5- P*'

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N

/$+
 ;-   5 '

7N 8"95?Aa>2":d LN *>:@K?yd HN V$K"EW#$52"d IN =93>E?3"2 3" 9WX$K 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kd 6N =93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N

/$,
"  %
1:  &5 
=93>E?] $# 2"5?;\$: @"2 #>945"
q2@# p 7GGGr] ? X$K"E>3?3$ ?9a4K?2
3" #"5"2N - @"95$>2" :"J2$ ? #?2E?
?#?2$K? q@?2? X$2:\$: PK$p] F]6 ? ~
2@# 9" #":52?3"2 $ @?2? X$2:\$: *>A
$:$K I]6 ? F 2@#r $ @?2? " Z4?32" 3>A
a>5?K] >93>E?;<" :"J2$ 9u#$2": F $ |]
>93>E? 4# 2$a>#$ 3$ 2"5?;\$: #4>5"
$K$X?3"] Z4$ @"3$ E?4:?2 3?9": ?"
#"5"2 $] @"25?95"] 3$X$ :$2 $X>5?3"N
!#!
- :>:5$#? 3$ E"952"K$ 3? >9_$A
;<" $K$52v9>E? >95$22"#@$ " DK4p" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K Z4?93" " #"5"2 $:5>X$2
E"# $pE$::" 3$ 2"5?;\$:N
+:5? >95$224@;<" ?E?22$5? $# E"9A
:$Z4$95$ @$23? 3$ @"5[9E>? 3" @2hA
@2>" #"5"2N

 2"5?;\$: @"2 #>945"N
B:   'F
+p>J$ #$9:?a$9: 3$ ?E"23" E"# ?:
E"93>;\$: ?@2"@2>?3?: $ ?: $:E"Kb?:
3" E"9345"2N
C: ',+  
)"E?K>Y?3" 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524A
#$95":] 5$# ? D49;<" 3$ >93>E?2 ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 3$:K"E?#$95" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
D:   ,  +*'  , 4-&
+*'
- >93>E?3"2 3>a>5?K 9" 3>:@K?y >9A
3>E? ? Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K
@2$:$95$ 9" 5?9Z4$N
- 52>e9a4K" @2$:$95$ 9" K?3" 3>A
2$>5" 3" :W#J"K" >93>E? " K?3" 3"
X$WE4K" 9" Z4?K $:5‘ @2$:$95$ " J"E?K
@?2? " ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ E"#J4:5WA
X$KN
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] _495?A
#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#?
#$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y $ 4#? :>9?K>A
Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?] Z4?93" " X"K4#$ 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K Eb$a? g 2$:$2X?N

+# E?:" 3$ ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA
$:@>? $ >93>E?;<" 9?: 34?: J?22?: >9A
D$2>"2$: 3? $:E?K? 3" >93>E?3"2] $D$A
54?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K
" #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$ @"::WX$KN
!#!
!<" X>?_?2 E"# " 5?9Z4$ Z4?:$ $
X?Y>"N
’: $X$954?>: D?K5?: 3$ ?K>#$95?;<"
@"3$# 3?9>D>E?2 " E?5?K>:?3"2N

+X$954?K X?2>?;<" #"#$95e9$? 9?
>9D"2#?;<" ?@2$:$95?3? @$K" >93>A
E?3"2 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 9<" E?2?E5$A
2>Y? 4#? ?9"#?K>? $# :$4 D49E>"A
9?#$95"] 4#? X$Y Z4$ 5?K X?2>?;<"
@"3$ $:5?2 2$K?E>"9?3? ? D?5"2$: $pA
5$29":] 5?>: E"#"% @":>;<" 3" X$WE4K"
$# ?EK>X$: "4 3$EK>X$:d X?2>?;\$: 3$
5$22$9"] $5EN +:5? @$2E$@;<" @"3$
:$2 #?>: $X>3$95$ K"a" ?@h: " 2$?A
J?:5$E>#$95" 3" X$WE4K"] $952$5?95"]
/$-
^ >#@"25?95$ 2$::?K5?2 Z4$ " :>:5$#?
@"::4> #"9>5"2?#$95" 3$::?: X?2>?A
;\$: $ ?54? a2?3?5>X?#$95$] @2"@"2A
E>"9?93" ? E"22$;<" 3?: >9D"2#?;\$:
?@2$:$95?3?: 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$9A
5":N
T:   ,    -  
'+.-    3,    
’ K4YA$:@>? "4] $# D49;<" 3?: X$2A
:\$:] " >93>E?3"2 3>a>5?K 9" 3>:@K?y]
>93>E? ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" KWZ4>3" 3$
?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N
!? 45>K>Y?;<" 9"2#?K 3" X$WE4K"] ?
$:E?K? 3>a>5?K @"3$ @":>E>"9?2A:$ 9?:
3>X$2:?: @":>;\$: 3$952" 9" $:@?;"
3$ >93>E?;<" $# 2$K?;<" g: E"93>A
;\$: 3$ 4:" 3" X$WE4K"N

!?: X$2:\$: E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49A
E>"9?K] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$]
_495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$
4#? #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y $ 4#? :>A
9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?] @?2? ?::>9?K?2 "
?4#$95" $pE$::>X" 3? 5$#@$2?542?
/$!.
3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"A
5"2N
!?: X$2:\$: E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49A
E>"9?K 2$E"9D>a42‘X$K] " :W#J"K"
9" 3>:@K?y D>E? X$2#$Kb" @?2? ?::>9?A
K?2 " ?4#$95" $pE$::>X" 3? 5$#@$2?A
542? 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3"
#"5"2N
!": E?:": ?E>#? 3$:E2>5":] @?2?2 "
#"5"2 $ 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = &
,  > N
%?  "!  P49;<" 3$:?J>K>5?3?% )+* ?E$:"N
%H  ,     '
P49E>"9?# :"#$95$ E"# " E"#4A
5?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" 
1?2? ?Ka4#?: D49;\$:] Z4?93"
4#? D49;<" ^ K>a?3?] ?E$93$A:$ ?
K4YA$:@>? E"22$:@"93$95$ :>54?3?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N 1?2?
3$:K>a?2] J?:5? @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
9"X?#$95$N
-: J"5\$: $:5<" K"E?K>Y?3": 9" @?>A
9$K E$952?K] ?J?>p" 3? E$952?K #4K5>A
#W3>?N
’Ka49: J"5\$: @"::4$# 4# )+*
Z4$ >93>E? ? ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3?
D49;<"%
 P49;<" b?J>K>5?3?% )+* ?@?a?3"N

-: J"5\$: @"3$# ?@2$:$95?2 D49A
;\$: $ @":>;\$: 3>D$2$95$:] 3$@$9A
3$93" 3? X$2:<" $ 3? E"9D>a42?;<"
3": "@E>"9?>: ?3Z4>2>3":N
!&  Z
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:A
5$#? ,5?25',5"@ #?94?K#$95$N ’ 3$A
:?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ ^ >9A
3>E?3? @"2 4#? #$9:?a$# $p>J>3?
9" 3>:@K?y $o"4 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95": q3$@$93$93" 3? X$2:<"rN
w4?93" " :>:5$#? ^ 3$:?5>X?3"] "
)+* K"E?K>Y?3" :"J " J"5<" ^ K>a?3"N
%&     /',  , 4 ' F
  '0
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:A
5$#? +,8N
- :>:5$#? +,8 #$Kb"2? " E"952"K$
3>2$E>"9?K $ $:5?J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
:"J 3>X$2:?: E"93>;\$: 3$ E"934A
;<"N8"22>a$ " :"J2$$:5$2;" $ " :4J$:A
5$2;" 3" X$WE4K"] 2$@?25>93" ? D2$9?A
a$# 9?: 2"3?: ?@2"@2>?3?:N
&     *   3  
 3 (  5 /    &
-  R 5 F & R0
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:A
5$#?N
- :>:5$#? $#>5$ 4# ?K$25? E?:" "
X$WE4K" :$_? 3>2$E>"9?3" @?2? ": K>A
#>5$: 3? D?>p? 3$ #?9$>2? 9<" >95$9A
E>"9?KN

’ D49;<" ^ :$#@2$ ?5>X?3?N ’
K4Y >93>E?3"2? 9" J"5<" D>E?2‘ ?E$:?
Z4?93" ? D49;<" $:5>X$2 3$:?5>X?3?N
& -K    5= , 
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ?: K4Y$:
3$ $#$2a[9E>? 3" X$WE4K"N
8"# ?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? K>A
a?3?:] "J5^#A:$ ? >95$2#>5[9E>? 3?:
K4Y$:A$:@>?
&     [  &   
,    
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:A
5$#? 1?2i:$9:$N
’ >93>E?;<" 3$ ?5>X?A
;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" ^ :$#@2$ ?E"#A
@?9b?3? 3? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#?
#$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? X>:4?K>Y?3? 9"
3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

’ D49;<" ^ :$#@2$ ?5>X?3?N ’
K4Y >93>E?3"2? 9" J"5<" D>E?2‘ ?E$:?
Z4?93" ? D49;<" $:5>X$2 3$:?5>X?3?N
&       , *  [
 
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:A
5$#? 1?2i:$9:$ ?E5>X$ @?2i ?::>:5N
1?2? ?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?] @2$::>"9$
? 5$EK? E"22$:@"93$95$N" 3>:@K?y 3" $
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $p>J>2‘ ?:
>9:524;\$: 9$E$::‘2>?: @?2? ? 2$?K>Y?A
;<" 3? #?9"J2?N
& ! 45  '  5 
1?2? ? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2J?a:]
?54?2 9" &$94 3" 3>:@K?y qE"9:4KA
5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" x*>:@K?yz 9" E?@W54K"
x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95":zrN
/$!!
%H  ,    , '
,  ' &  .- 
P49E>"9?# :"#$95$ E"# " E"#4A
5?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" 
1?2? ?Ka4#?: D49;\$:] Z4?93"
4#? D49;<" ^ K>a?3?] ?E$93$A:$ ?
K4YA$:@>? E"22$:@"93$95$ :>54?3?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N 1?2?
3$:K>a?2] J?:5? @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
9"X?#$95$N
-: J"5\$: $:5<" K"E?K>Y?3": 9"
E"9:"K$ E$952?K] 9? @?25$ @":5$2>"2 3?
#"K342? 3" Ee#J>"N
’Ka49: J"5\$: @"::4$# 4# )+*
Z4$ >93>E? ? ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3?
D49;<"%
/$!"
 P49;<" 3$:?J>K>5?3?% )+* ?E$:"N
 P49;<" b?J>K>5?3?% )+* ?@?a?3"N

-: J"5\$: @"3$# ?@2$:$95?2 D49A
;\$: $ @":>;\$: 3>D$2$95$:] 3$@$9A
3$93" 3? X$2:<" $ 3? E"9D>a42?;<"
3": "@E>"9?>: ?3Z4>2>3":N
& !- '
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" ’45" b"K3N
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2? K>a?2 ? D49A
;<" ’45" T"K3N ’ K4YA$:@>? :$ ?E$93$
9" 3>:@K?yN w4?93" ? D49;<" ’45"
T"K3 $:5‘ ?5>X? ?95$: 3? >a9>;<" :$2
3$:K>a?3?] $K? E"95>94?2‘ ?5>X? ?@h:
K>a?2 ? >a9>;<" 9"X?#$95$N
&   
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" ,@"25N
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" ,1-C.] ?
D49;<" ^ ?5>X?3? $ "J5^#A:$ 4# @2"A
a2?#? 3$ E"934;<" $:@"25>X?] E?2?EA
5$2>Y?3? @"2 4#? 2$:@":5? #?>: 2‘A
@>3? 3$ ?E$K$2?;<" $ 4# #?>"2 $:A
D"2;" 9" X"K?95$] @?2? 3?2 4#? :$9A
:?;<" 3$ E"934;<" ?3$Z4?3?N
& DR \
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" I¤* )"jN
I¤* )-¤ $9D?5>Y? ": 3$:$#@$A
9b": t"DDA2"?3t 3" X$WE4K" $# 5"3?:
?: #"3?K>3?3$: 3$ E"934;<"N
>&  '' ,  ,  '
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" T>KK 3$:E$95 E"952"KN
- :>:5$#? #?95^# " X$WE4K" ? 4#?
X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ 342?95$ 4#?
3$:E>3?] ?54?93" 3$ D"2#? ?45v9"#?
$ 3>D$2$9E>?3? 9": D2$>":N
E& DR ,[
B"5<" @?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49A
;<" I¤* )"EiN
*$:?5>X? ? D49;<" 3$ 3$:?5>X?;<"
3" $>p" 3$ 52?9:#>::<"] a?2?95>93"
? >#$3>?5? 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3" 5"2Z4$
?" ?E"@K?#$95" 52?:$>2"N +:5? D49;<"
^ :$K$E>"9‘X$K 9? #"3?K>3?3$ !
$ ?45"#‘5>E? 9?: "452?: #"3?K>3?3$:  !L "!
3$ E"934;<"N

 '5
, 67
- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K "4 #4KA
5>D49E>"9?K 2$E"9D>a42‘X$K] E?@?Y 3$ )"E?K>Y?;<" 3" 3>:@K?y 3$ 7Gt $
"D$2$E$2 >9D"2#?;\$: u5$>: ?" E"934A :$4: J"5\$: 3$ E"#?93"N
)"E?K>Y?;<" 3" 3>:@K?y 3$ H]6 $
5"2 342?95$ ? E"934;<" 3" X$WE4K"N :$4: J"5\$: 3$ E"#?93"N
!" 3>:@K?y @"3$# :$2 X>:4?K>Y?A $
8"# ? Eb?X$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
3?:] $952$ "452?:] ?: :$a4>95$: >9D"2A
 q$ ? Eb?X$ $p52?W3?] @?2? X$2A
#?;\$:%
:\$: E"# Eb?X$ #$Ee9>E?r] E"# ?
?J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3$ 4#? @"25?] T"2?] S$?2 ,b>D5 =93>E?5"2 q>93>E?A
" 3>:@K?y ?5>X?A:$ #":52?93" 342?95$ ;\$: 3? #43?9;? 3$ X$K"E>3?3$r q:$
?Ka49: :$a493": ? b"2? $ ": Z4>KvA $Z4>@?3"r] $9a?5$ 3? #43?9;?] 5$#A
#$52": 5"5?>: @$2E"22>3":N @$2?542? $p5$2>"2] >93>E?;\$: 3? Ju:A
:"K? q"93$ @2$:$95$r] 3?5?] X$K"E>A
!" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": 3>a>5?K]
3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"] #$9:?a$9: 3$ ?3A
E"# ? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
X$25[9E>?] Z4>K"#$52?a$# 5"5?K @$2A
,5"@] E"# ? ?J$2542? $ D$Eb?#$95"
)"E?K>Y?;<" 3" 3>:@K?y 3$ | $ :$4: E"22>3? $ WE"9$: 3$ $X$954?>: :>9?K>A
3?: @"25?: ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? :"#$95$ ?
J"5\$: 3$ E"#?93"N Y?;\$: 3$ ?X?2>?N
Z4>K"#$52?a$# 5"5?K @$2E"22>3?N

/$!%
%?  "!
+:5<" K"E?K>Y?3": 9" K?3" $:Z4$23"
3" X"K?95$N
 % @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 3$ 2$E"A
1$2#>5$# :$K$E>"9?2 $ >95$2?a>2
E"# ?: "@;\$: 3" t&$94 @2>9E>@?Kt
3" 3>:@K?y qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D"
t&$94 @2>9E>@?KtrN
 o % @2$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 ":
J"5\$: @?2? 5$2 ?E$::" ?" &$94
@2>9E>@?K $ @?2? @$2E"22$2 @?2?
E>#? "4 @?2? J?>p" ?: X‘2>?: "@A
;\$: 3" &$94 $ 3": :4J#$94:N
 o % @2$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 ":
J"5\$: @?2? 5$2 ?E$::" g: 5$K?: 3$
>9D"2#?;\$: "4 ?": :4J#$94: 3$
4#? "@;<" 3" &$94 @2>9E>@?KN
/$!&
 E) @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2? 5$2
?E$::"o:$K$E>"9?2 ?: 5$K?: 3$
>9D"2#?;\$: "4 ": :4J#$94:
3$ 4#? "@;<" 3" &$94
@2>9E>@?KN &?95$2 " J"5<"
@2$::>"9?3" 342?95$ 7 :$a493"
@?2? 2$3$D>9>2 ?: D49;\$:
X>:4?K>Y?3?:o:$K$E>"9?3?:N
9b$E>#$95" 3$ X"Y @?2? >9>E>?2
2‘3>"] #W3>?] 9?X$a?;<"] >9>E>?2
"4 ?5$93$2 4#? Eb?#?3? 5$K$DvA
9>E? $ $9X>?2 "4 2$E$J$2 4# 5$p5"N
-: E"#?93": 3$ X"Y J‘:>E": @"A
3$# :$2 3?3": ? Z4?KZ4$2 #"A
#$95" 342?95$ " 4:" 3" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5N ’@$25$ " J"5<" $]
?@h: " J>@$] 3>a? 4# E"#?93"N
-: @2>9E>@?>: E"#?93": :<"%
 x8?9E$K?2z @?2? >95$22"#@$2
4#? :$::<" 3$ X"Y ?54?KN
 x’_43?z @?2? "4X>2 4#? K>:5?
3$ E"#?93": 3$ X"Y :4a$2>A
3":N
 xC$@$5>2z @?2? "4X>2
": @2"#@5: 3" :>:5$#?
9"X?#$95$N
 % @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2? D>9?A
K>Y?2 4#? Eb?#?3? 3$ 5$K$D"9$N
 % @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2?
?E$::?2 ?: @‘a>9?: 3" #$94N
!,  -4  -) 3$@">: 3$
5$2 :$K$E>"9?3" ? "@;<" 3$ &$94
3$:$_?3?] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2?
5$2 ?E$::" ?": X‘2>": :4J#$94:N
+  " - , ') @2$::>"A
9?2 " J"5<" N
"  !
- &$94 @2>9E>@?K ^ E"#@":5" @"2
4#? :^2>$ 3$ "@;\$: E4_? :$K$;<"]
2$?K>Y‘X$K ?52?X^: 3": J"5\$: 3$ E"A
#?93"] @$2#>5$ " ?E$::" ? 3>X$2:?:
"@;\$: 3$ $:E"Kb? $ 3$D>9>;<" >93>A
E?3?: ? :$a4>2N

’ #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3?:
"@;\$: 3" &$94 q>93>E?;\$: #?>u:A
E4K?: "4 #>9u:E4K?:r X?2>? $# D49A
;<" 3" 5>@" 3$ 3>:@K?yN
 ',+   V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
 KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"A
1?2? ?Ka4#?: $952?3?: $:5‘ @2$X>:5" +:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ X>:4?A
5"2N
4# :4J#$94N K>Y?2 9" 3>:@K?y ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K"N  .$#@$2?542? 3" Ee#J>" q:$ $Z4>A
@?3"r
(#? X$Y X>:4?K>Y?3? ? X$K"E>3?3$
 V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3? 5$#@$2?542?
9" 3>:@K?y] @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<" E
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ :>:5$#? (E"9A 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" q:$
^ @"::WX$K 3$D>9>2 ? 49>3?3$ 3$ #$A
9$E5£] ?Ka4#?: "@;\$: 3" &$94 $Z4>@?3"rN
3>3? qti#obt "4 t&1Ttr @?2? X>:4?K>A
:<" X>:4?K>Y?3?: $ a$2>3?: 9" 3>:@K?y Y?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$N  .$#@$2?542? 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2
3$:5$ uK5>#" $ 9<" 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?A V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3? 5$#@$2?542? 3"
32" 3$ >9:524#$95": qE"9:4K5$ ?: >9A  3 *+,-' / 3 6H 4   hK$" 3" #"5"2N
3>E?;\$: 9" :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN   *+,-'0  .$9:<" 3? J?5$2>? $
+:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ X>:4A V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" X?K"2 3$ 5$9:<"
 ?  " ?K>Y?2 9" 3>:@K?y ?: >9D"2#?;\$: 2$K?A q$:5?3" 3$ E?2a?r 3? J?5$2>?N
- &$94 ^ E"9:5>54W3" @$K?: :$A 5>X?: ?" t$:5?3"t 3" X$WE4K" qE"9:4KA  +E"9"#N 8"#JN
a4>95$: "@;\$:% 5?2 >93>E?;\$: ?J?>p"rN V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3": 3?3": 3$ $E"A
9"#>? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
 V+)-8m&+.C-  12$::<" 3": @9$4:  ,$2X>;" q#?945$9;<"
 =!P- V+m8()- V>:4?K>Y?;<" 3?: >9D"2#?;\$: @2"a2?#?3?r
2$K?5>X?: ?" :>:5$#? .1&, +:5? "@;<" $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K :"A
 .C=1
q:$ $Z4>@?3"r q@?2? #?>: #$95$ @?2? ": X$WE4K": E"# Z4?A
 “(*=- >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 " 32" 3$ >9:524#$95": #4K5>D49E>"A
 -PP C-’* E?@W54K" t,$a42?9;?trN 9?K $ #4K5>D49E>"9?K 2$E"9D>a42‘A
 ’V=,-,  .$#@$2?542? 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$A X$KN 1?2? ": X$WE4K": $Z4>@?3":
 8-!PN *=,1)’R D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 E"# Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": 3>a>A
5?K] $:5‘ >9D"2#?;<" :$2‘ $p>J>3?
 8-!P=SN V+m8()-
?52?X^: 3$ #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?
9" @2h@2>" Z4?32"N
/$!’
 V>:4?K>Y?;<" $# i# q"4 #>r $
3>?: 2$:5?95$: @?2? >9:@$;<" 3$
#?945$9;<"N
 !WX$K 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3"
@?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q:"A
#$95$ @?2? ?: X$2:\$: 3>$:$KrN V>A
:4?K>Y?;<" 3" 9WX$K 3$ ’C)’ HL]
@2$:$95$ 9" 2$:$2X?5h2>"N

- t1K?9" 3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?A
#?3?t @2$X[ ? #?945$9;<" 3" X$WA
E4K" $# >95$2X?K": @2$$:5?J$K$E>3":
qE"9:4K5?2 " E?@W54K" t&?945$9;<" $
E4>3?3": E"# " :$4 X$WE4K"trN
’ #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y 3$
xC$X>:<"z ^ E"#@K$#$95?2 gZ4$K?:
E"95>3?: 9$::$ #?94?K 9" E?@W54K"
x&’!(.+!/0- + 8(=*’*-,
8-& ,+( V+m8()-z $ 9" x&’A
!(’) *+ S’C’!.=’ + &’!(.+!A
/’-zN f +,,+!8=’) ? X$2>D>E?;<"
3$:5$ E?@W54K" $ 3" &?94?K 3$ S?A
2?95>? $ &?945$9;<" @?2? ? E"22$5?
#?945$9;<" $ a?2?95>? 3" X$WE4K"N
w4?93" ? #?945$9;<" @2"a2?A
#?3? qt2$X>:<"tr $:5‘ @$25" 3" @2?Y"
@2$X>:5"] 3$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2
/$!*
3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  ]
9" 3>:@K?y ?@?2$E$ ? >93>E?;<"
tC$X>:<"t :$a4>3? 3" 9u#$2" 3$
Z4>Kv#$52":o#>Kb?: $ 3>?: Z4$ D?K5?#
@?2? ? #?945$9;<" 3" X$WE4K"N 8"9A
5?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > Z4$
2$?K>Y?2‘] ?K^# 3?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ #?A
945$9;<" @2$X>:5?: 9" t1K?9" 3$ #?A
945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3?t " Y$2?#$95"
3? 2$D$2>3? X>:4?K>Y?;<" q2$:$5rN
 * !  /! = ,   , -&
 0 / .- 0
+:5$ #$94 >9D"2#? ?: E"9D>a42?A
;\$: X>a$95$: 3" 824>:$ 8"952"K
’3?@5?5>X"N ’: >9D"2#?;\$: ?@2$A
:$95?3?: 3$@$93$# 3" $:5?3" 3"
:>:5$#?N
 / !@ %0
+:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ X>:4?A
K>Y?2 ?: >9D"2#?;\$: 2$K?5>X?: ?" t.2>@
E"#@45$2t q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:]
E"9:4K5?2 ?: >93>E?;\$: 9" @?2‘a2?D"
t.2>@ E"#@45$2t 9$:5$ E?@W54K"rN
’: >9D"2#?;\$: X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9"
3>:@K?y] @?2? " .2>@ ’ $ @?2? " .2>@
B] :<"%
 *>:5e9E>? qi# "4 #>Kb?:rN
 8"9:4#" #^3>" q#@a] "4
Ko7GGi# "4 i#oKrN
 .$#@" 3$ X>?a$#
qb"2?:o#>945":o :$a493":rN
-  / -' K67  3 6H
P- 0
+:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ X>:4A
?K>Y?2] 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95":] ?: >9D"2#?;\$: @2$:$95$:
9" 3>:@K?y 3" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5£N
’: >9D"2#?;\$: X>:4?K>Y?3?: :<"%
 tC‘3>" q’& "4 P&rt% X>:4?K>Y?;<"
3" 9"#$ 3? $:5?;<" 3$ 2‘3>" q:$
3>:@"9WX$Kr] D2$Z4[9E>? $ WE"9$
a2‘D>E"
 t&1Ht% X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" 5W54K" "4
3" 9u#$2" 3? D?>p? $# 2$@2"34A
;<"N
 t(,Bt% X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" 5W54K" "4
3" 9u#$2" 3? D?>p? $# 2$@2"34A
;<"N
 t>1"3t% X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" 5W54K" 3?
D?>p? q:$ 3>:@"9WX$KrN
 V$2 5$K$D"9$%
!" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524A
#$95": @"3$# ?>93? X>:4?K>Y?2A:$ ?:
>9D"2#?;\$: 2$K?5>X?: g #"3?K>3?3$
.$K$D"9$ q?@$9?: :$ 5>X$2 :>3" ?5>X?3?
? D49;<" tV$2 5$K$D"9$t] X$2 "@;<" 3$
&$94 t*$DN V$WE4K"trN
’: >9D"2#?;\$: X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9"
3>:@K?y 3>Y$# 2$:@$>5" ?" $:5?3" 3$
E"9$p<" 3" E$K4K?2 q5$K$D"9$ K>a?3"
"4 3$:K>a?3"r] ?: Eb?#?3?: 5$K$Dv9>A
E?: ?5>X?:o2$E$J>3?:o$# $:@$2? $ ?
a$:5<" 3?: 34@K?: Eb?#?3?: q@2>A
#$>2? 2$E$J>3? :$a493? $# $:@$2?]
$5ENrN
33  / .- 0
+:5$ #$94 >9D"2#? ?: E"9D>a42?A
;\$: @?2? ? E"934;<" -DD C"?3N
!*  /" 5    K0
+:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ X>A
:4?K>Y?2 9" 3>:@K?y ?: #$9:?a$9: 3$
>9D"2#?;<"o?X?2>? #$#"2>Y?3?: @$K"
X$WE4K"N
A V$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# 3>:@K?y
#4K5>D49;\$: 2$E"9D>a42‘X$K
!$:5?: X$2:\$:] ? E"2 3$ D493" 3"
3>:@K?y X?2>? $# D49;<" 3? @2>"2>A
3?3$ 3$ ?X?2>? X>:4?K>Y?3?%
 &$9:?a$9: 3$ ?X?2>? E"# @2>"2>A
3?3$ J?>p?% 3>:@K?y 3$ E"2 ?#?A
2$K?N
 &$9:?a$9: 3$ ?X?2>? E"# @2>"2>A
3?3$ ?K5?% 3>:@K?y 3$ E"2 X$2#$A
Kb?N
3: +,-' /" 3 ,67  3 &
6H  *+,-'0
+:5? "@;<" 3$ &$94 @$2#>5$ #"A
3>D>E?2 ?: 3$D>9>;\$: 2$K?5>X?: ?%
 t*>:@K?yt
 t(9>3?3$t
 tT"2? ' *?5?t
 t,$a42?9;?t
 t,$a42No’::>:5Nt
 t)4Y$:t
 t1"25?: $ 52?X?:t

1?2? 5"3?: ?: "452?: @"::WX$>: 2$a4A
K?a$9:] E"9:4K5?2 ?: >93>E?;\$: 9" :4A
@K$#$95" (E"99$E5£ qE"9:4K5?2 >9:A
524;\$: 9" :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
A V$2:\$: E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49A
;\$: 2$E"9D>a42‘X$K
!$:5?: X$2:\$: $:5<" @2$:$95$: 49>A
E?#$95$ ?: "@;\$: 3$ #$94 t*>:A
@K?yt q^ @"::WX$K :$K$E>"9?2 ?@$9?: ?:
"@;\$: tV$2 5$K$D"9$t $ tV$2 9?X$a?A
;<"tr] t,$a42?9;?t $ t,$a42No ’::>:5Nt
q^ @"::WX$K :$K$E>"9?2 ?@$9?: ? "@A
;<" tV"K4#$ 3": ?X>:":trN $
."3?: ?: "452?: "@;\$: :<" X>:4?K>A
Y?3?: $ a$2>3?: 9" 3>:@K?y 3" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5£N
A *>:@K?y
,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" x*>:@K?yz ^
@"::WX$K 5$2 ?E$:" g: :$a4>95$: 3$D>9>A
;\$:%
 t=3>"#?t% @$2#>5$ :$K$E>"9?2 "
>3>"#? $# Z4$ X>:4?K>Y?2‘ ?: >9A
D"2#?;\$:o?3X$25[9E>?:N
 tV$2 5$K$D"9$t @$2#>5$ X>:4?K>Y?2]
9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524A
#$95":] ?: >9D"2#?;\$: 2$K?5>X?:
g #"3?K>3?3$ .$K$D"9$ X>:4?K>Y?A
/$!+
 3?: 9" 3>:@K?y 3" :>:5$#? (E"9A
9$E5£N
 tV$2 9?X$a?;<"t% @$2#>5$ X>:4?A
K>Y?2] 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$
>9:524#$95":] ?: >9D"2#?;\$: 2$A
K?5>X?: g #"3?K>3?3$ !?X$a?;<"N
A t(9>3?3$t
,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" t(9>3?3$t
^ @"::WX$K :$K$E>"9?2 ? 49>3?3$ 3$
#$3>3? ? 45>K>Y?2 @?2? ? X>:4?K>Y?;<"
3?: X‘2>?: a2?93$Y?:N
’: "@;\$: @"::WX$>: :<"%
 t*>:5e9E>?t
 t12$::<"t
 t.$#@$2?542?t
 t8"9:4#" >9:5?95e9$"t
A tT"2? ' *?5?t
,$K$E>"9?93" " #$94 tT"2? '
*?5?t ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ? 2$a4K?a$#
3" 2$Kha>"N
’: "@;\$: @"::WX$>: :<"%
/$!,
 t’E$25?2 b"2?t% 2$a4K?a$# 3?: b"A
2?: $ #>945":N
 tP"2#?5"t% 2$a4K?a$# 3" D"2#?5"
3? b"2? t7Lbt q7L b"2?:r "4 tLIbt
qLI b"2?:rN
 tC$a4K? 3?5?t% 2$a4K?a$# 3" 3>?]
#[: $ ?9"N
A t,$a42?9;?t
,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" t,$a42?9;?t
^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ?: :$a4>95$: 2$a4A
K?a$9:%
 t1?::$9a$2 ’=CB’St% ?5>X?;<" $
3$:?5>X?;<" 3" ?>2J?a 3" K?3" 3"
@?::?a$>2"N 67  &
5   *) ?E$93>#$95"] E"#
K4Y D>p?] 3" )+*  K"E?K>A
Y?3" 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
67  5   &
*) ?E$93>#$95"] E"# K4Y D>p?]
3" )+*  K"E?K>Y?3" 9"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": q:$ $Z4>A
@?3"rN
 tB$$@ X$K"E>3?3$t% 3$D>9>;<" 3"
K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
qi#ob "4 #@br] 4K52?@?::?3" "
Z4?K " E"9345"2 ^ ?X>:?3" ?52?A
X^: 3$ 4# :>9?K :"9"2" $ X>:4?K
qX>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$#
$ 4# :W#J"K" 9" 3>:@K?yrN
 tT>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5t% ?5>X?;<" $ 3$:?A
5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? T>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5
qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" x,>:5$#?
T,’z 9" E?@W54K" x,$a42?9;?zrN
A t,$a42N' ’::>:5N 3$ 3>2$;<"t
,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" t,$a42N' ’:A
:>:5N 3$ 3>2$;<"t ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ?:
:$a4>95$: 2$a4K?a$9:%
 t1?2i,$9:$t% :$K$;<" 3" 5>@"
3$ :>9?K>Y?;<" D"29$E>3? @$K"
:>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$N
 tV"KN 1?2i,N 52?:Nt% :$K$;<" 3"
X"K4#$ 3?: :>9?K>Y?;\$: ?Eu:5>A
E?: D"29$E>3?: @$K" :>:5$#? 1?2iA
,$9:$N
 tV"KN 1?2i,$9:$t% :$K$;<" 3"
X"K4#$ 3?: :>9?K>Y?;\$: ?Eu:5>A
E?: D"29$E>3?: @$K" :>:5$#? 1?2iA
,$9:$N
 tV"KN 1?2i,N 3>?95Nt% :$K$;<" 3"
X"K4#$ 3?: :>9?K>Y?;\$: ?Eu:5>A
E?: D"29$E>3?: @$K" :>:5$#? 1?2iA
,$9:$N
 t,>3$ *>:5 ¤?29t q:$ $Z4>@?3"r%
:$K$;<" 3" 5>@" 3$ :>9?K>Y?;<"
D"29$E>3? @$K" :>:5$#? 3$ ?X>:"
3$ 3>:5e9E>? K?5$2?KN
 t,$9:"2 Eb4X?t% b?J>K>5?;<" $ 3$A
:?J>K>5?;<" 3" ?E>"9?#$95" ?45"A
#‘5>E" 3" K>#@?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?
$# E?:" 3$ Eb4X?N
 )?9$,$9:$ D"2E$ q:$ $Z4>@?3"r%
:$K$;<" 3? D"2;? ? :$2 ?@K>E?3?
?" X"K?95$ @?2? E"K"E?2 " E?22"
9? X>? ?52?X^: 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 3>2$A
;<" $K^52>E?] $# E?:" 3$ D49E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? )?9$,$9:$
 tV"K4#$ ?X>:":tN
 t&?945N D2$>":t q:$ $Z4>@?3"r%
?5>X?;<" 3" @2"E$3>#$95" @?2?
$D$54?2 ? #?945$9;<" 3" :>:5$#?
3$ D2$9?a$#N
 t’45" 1?2i B2?i$t q:$ $Z4>@?3"r%
?5>X?;<" $ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E"N
A t)4Y$:t
,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" t)4Y$:t ^
@"::WX$K $D$54?2 ?: :$a4>95$: 2$a4K?A
a$9:%
 t)4Y ?#J>$95$ >95$29?t% :$K$;<" ,$K$E>"9?93" ? "@;<" t1"25?: $
3? >95$9:>3?3$ 3? >K4#>9?;<" 3? 52?X?:t ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ?: :$a4>95$:
K4Y ?#J>$95$ >95$29?N 2$a4K?a$9:%
 t’E$93>#$95" 5$#@"2‘2>" 3": D?A
2h>:t% 3$D>9>;<" 3" ?52?:" 3$ ?@?A  tP$Eb?#$95" 3?: @"25?: ?45"#Nt%
a?#$95" 3": D?2h>: ?@h: ? 3$:?5>A ?5>X?;<" $ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" D$Eb?A
X?;<" 3" #"5"2N #$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3?: @"25?: E"#
 tP?2h>: ?" ’J2>2t% ?5>X?;<" 3? >9A " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"N
5$2#>5[9E>? 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$  t*$:52?X?2 @"25?: ?45"#N
3>2$;<" $# D?:$ 3$ ?J$2542? 3?: ?" :?>2t% @$2#>5$ 3$:52?X?2
@"25?:N ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?: @"25?: ?"
 t,$9:"2 E2$@4:E4K?2t% 2$a4K?a$# :?>2 3" X$WE4K"N
$
3? :$9:>J>K>3?3$ 3$ ?E$93>#$95"  t1>:E?2 K4Y$: ?" 52?9E?2t% ?5>X?A
3": D?2h>:N ;<" 3? >95$2#>5[9E>? 3": >93>E?A
 t+:E42$E$2 ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ D?A 3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" $# D?:$ 3$ D$A
2h>: ?K5":t% ?5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" Eb?#$95" 3?: @"25?:N
3": D?2h>: ?K5": ?45"#‘5>E": q:$  tB4Y>9?2 ?" 52?9E?2t% @$2#>5$ $:A
$Z4>@?3"rN E"Kb$2 :$ ? J4Y>9? 3$X$2‘ 5"E?2
 t)4Y$: 3>429?:t% ?5>X?A 4#? X$Y] 34?: X$Y$: "4 3$:?J>K>A
;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3?: K4Y$: 5?2 " 5"Z4$ 3? J4Y>9? ?" 52?X?2 ?:
3>429?:N @"25?:N
 t)4Y$: 3$ E42X?t% ?5>X?;<" $ 3$A  tB4Y>9?2 E"# @?25>3? 2$#"5?t%
:?5>X?;<" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ E42X? q:$ ?5>X?;<" $ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" 5"Z4$
$Z4>@?3"rN 3? J4Y>9? 9? @?25>3? 2$#"5? 3"
X$WE4K"N
A t1"25?: $ 52?X?:t  t7 5"Z4$ 3? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? 3$:52?X?t q@?2?
X$2:\$:o#$2E?3":] "93$
@2$X>:5"r% @$2#>5$ $:E"Kb$2
/$!-
 :$ @2$5$93$ ?J2>2 ?: @"25?:
"4 ?@$9?: ? 3" K?3" 3"
E"9345"2 Z4?93" @2$::>"9?2 "
2$:@$E5>X" J"5<" 9? Eb?X$ E"#
5$K$E"#?93"N
' 

, 67
- E"#@45?3"2 3$ J"23"] "4 t52>@
E"#@45$2t] @$2#>5$ X>:4?K>Y?2] E"#
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 ] ?: #$3>3?: 2$K?5>X?: ?" $:5?3"
3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N
+:5? D49;<" E?2?E5$2>Y?A:$ @"2 34?:
#$#h2>?: :$@?2?3?:] 3$9"#>9?3?:
t.2>@ ’t $ t.2>@ Bt] 9?: Z4?>: :<" 2$A
a>:52?3": ": 3?3": 3?: t#>::\$: E"#A
@K$5?:t 3" X$WE4K" qX>?a$9:r] 3$ #"3"
>93$@$93$95$ 49: 3": "452":N
’#J?: ?: #$#h2>?: @"3$# :$2 2$>A
9>E>?3?:% 2$:$5 A >9WE>" 3$ 4#? 9"X?
#>::<"N
- x.2>@ ’z $ " t.2>@ Bt @$2#>5$# ?
X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3?: :$a4>95$: #$3>3?:%
/$".
 *>:5e9E>? @$2E"22>3?
 8"9:4#" #^3>"
 .$#@" 3$ X>?a$# q342?;<" 3?
E"934;<"r
1?2? $D$54?2 ? 2$>9>E>?K>Y?;<" 3?:
#$3>3?:] @2$::>"9?2 $ #?95$2 @2$::>A
"9?3" " J"5<" E 9": E"#?93": 9"
X"K?95$N

-: X?K"2$: t’45"9"#>?t $ t8"9A
:4#" >9:5?95e9$"t 9<" @"3$# :$2 Y$A
2?3":N
  K * -' K
  ] ,   , ) >93>E? ?
3>:5e9E>? @$2E"22>3? 3$:3$ " >9WA
E>" 3? 9"X? #>::<"N
  -  9 ) 2$@2$:$95? ?
#^3>? 3": E"9:4#": 3$:3$ " >9WA
E>" 3? 9"X? X>?a$#N
    * 5 ) 5$#@" 3$E"2A
2>3" 3$:3$ " >9WE>" 3? 9"X? #>:A
:<"N
%7 SES
 12$::<" J2$X$ 3" J"5<"% X>:4?K>A
Y?;<" 3?: X‘2>?: #$3>3?:N
 12$::<" K"9a? 3" J"5<"% Y$2?A
#$95" q2$:$5r 3?: #$3>3?: $ >9WA
E>" 3$ 4#? 9"X? #>::<"N
* 7
=9>E>? ? @?25>2 3" #"#$95" $# Z4$
D"> $D$54?3? 4# Y$2?#$95" q2$:$5r%
 x&?94?Kz ?52?X^: 3? @2$::<" 3"
J"5<" E N
 x’45"#‘5>E"z Z4?93" ? t3>:5e9A
E>? @$2E"22>3?t ?5>9a$ " X?K"2 3$
MMMMM]M i# qE$2E? 3$ FL7IG #>A
Kb?:r "4 Z4?93" " t5$#@" 3$ X>A
?a$#t ?5>9a$ " X?K"2 3$ MMMN6M
qMMM b"2?: $ 6M #>945":rN
 *$@">: 3$ E?3? 3$:K>a?#$95" $
E"9:$Z4$95$ 9"X? K>a?;<" 3? J?A
5$2>?N
       
- ?E$93>#$95" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ ?3X$25[9E>? qK4Y$:A$:@>?r $:5‘ ?::"E>?3" ? #$9:?a$9: $o"4 ?X>:": ?Eu:5>E":] E"9D"2#$
E"9D>a42?;\$: $:@$EWD>E?:N +::$: :>9?>: :<" :>95^5>E": $ 3$ ?X>:" $ 9<" 3$X$# :$2 E"9:>3$2?3": E"#@K$5": "4 E"#"
?K5$29?5>X?: g: >9D"2#?;\$: 3$:5$ &?94?K 3$ (:" $ &?945$9;<"] Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 K>3" :$#@2$ E"# #4>5? ?5$9;<"N
+# E?:" 3$ :>9?K>Y?;<" 3$ ?X?2>?] :$#@2$ E"9:4K5$ " E"95$u3" >93>E?3" 9" @2$:$95$ E?@W54K"N


’: :>9?K>Y?;\$: 3$ ?X?2>? Z4$ ?@?2$E$# 9" 3>:@K?y :<" :4J3>X>3>3?: $# 34?: E?5$a"2>?:% ?9"#?K>?: a2?X$: $
?9"#?K>?: #$9": a2?X$:N ’: ?9"#?K>?: a2?X$: a$2?# 4# E>EK" 3$ #$9:?a$9: 2$@$5>3" @"2 4# 5$#@" @2"K"9a?3"]
$9Z4?95" " 5$#@" 3" E>EK" 3$ #$9:?a$9: @?2? ?: #$9": a2?X$: ^ #?>: E425"N ’: K4Y$:A$:@>? @$2#?9$E$# ?E$:?:
$
$9Z4?95" 9<" D"2$# $K>#>9?3?: ?: E?4:?: 3?: ?X?2>?: E"22$:@"93$95$:N


’: K4Y$:A$:@>? :<" X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9" 3>:@K?y $o"4 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] 3$@$93$93" 3? X$2:<" ?3Z4>2>3?N
’Ka4#?: K4Y$:A$:@>? @"3$# 9<" $:5?2 @2$:$95$: @?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:N

-K&   , * 'G
-K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

;    @   !&

!" $ !!
1":>E>"9?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 
] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N

/$"!
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

+.-   3   -3 ,   C$:5?J$K$;? " 9WX$K 3" K>Z4>3" 3": D2$>": $] $# :$a4>3?]
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" " 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3": D2$>": X$2>D>Z4$ :$ ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a?N
9" 3$@h:>5" 3$:E$ ?J?>p" 3" 9WX$K #W9>#"] 3$X>3" ? 4#? ,$ ? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:?] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   !&
@"::WX$K @$23? 3$ KWZ4>3" @$K" E>2E4>5"N  = ,  > N
*$:$9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" $ X$2>D>E?2 :$
    ,     '9 , ,  
? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a?N
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ E"# " D2$>" $K^52>E" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:?] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   !&
#$95" ?E>"9?3"N
 = ,  > N
!!! !  !!
S>2?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  ]
? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:?] @"3$ 9<" :$ X$2>D>E?2 " *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
$D$>5" 3? 3>2$;<" ?::>:5>3? $ " $:D"2;" 9" X"K?95$ @"3$2‘
?4#$95?2 :$9:>X$K#$95$] $#J"2? :$ #?95$9b? ? @"::>J>K>A
3?3$ 3$ X>2?2 " X$WE4K"N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] " 3>:@K?y X>:4?K>Y? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$A
EWD>E?N

/$""
-K&   .-  5 3 ,
!!! !%!
S>2?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  ]
? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N - ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? E"# K4Y D>p? >93>E?
4#? ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?>2J?aN
- 3>:@K?y #":52? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
  !!  !!
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ 3$ #"3" D>p" E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"
$ " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" E"9345"2 ?D>X$K?3"N
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ 3$ D"2#? >95$2#>5$95$] _495?#$95$
E"# 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E? Z4?93"] E"# " X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95"] " E>95" 3" E"9345"2 9<" $:5‘ E"22$5?#$95$
?D>X$K?3"N
 .- 3K

,$ ? K4YA$:@>? 9<" :$ ?E$93$2 ?" 3$:K"E?2 "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  "4 @$2#?9$E$2
?E$:" 342?95$ ? #?2Eb? q_495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9:?a$#
X>:4?K>Y?3? @$K" 3>:@K?yr] ^ @"::WX$K Z4$ $p>:5? 4#?
?9"#?K>? 9": :>:5$#?: 3$ D2$>":d 9$::$ E?:"] ": ?>2J?a:
"4 ": @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2$: @"3$# 9<" :$ ?5>X?2 $# E?:" 3$
?E>3$95$ "4] 94# 9u#$2" 3$ E?:": #?>: K>#>5?3"] ?5>X?2A:$
3$ #"3" $22?3"N ’95$: 3$ @2"::$a4>2] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > @?2? " >#$3>?5" E"952"K$ 3" :>:5$#?N
’ ?X?2>? 3? K4YA$:@>? ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K" ?E$93>#$95"
$
3" WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N !$::$
E?:"] ? K4YA$:@>? @"3$ 9<" ?::>9?K?2 $X$954?>: ?9"#?K>?:
9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?>2J?aN ’95$: 3$ @2"::$a4>2] 3>2>a>2A:$ g 
 ! = ,  > @?2? " >#$3>?5" E"952"K$ 3" :>:5$#?N
1?2? ? 3$:?5>X?;<" @$2#?9$95$ 3" :>9?K :"9"2" 3" :>:5$#?
,NBNCN q,$?5 B$K5 C$#>93$2r] 3>2>_?A:$ g   ! = , 
> N
f @"::WX$K 2$?5>X?2 " :>:5$#? ?52?X^: 3" &$94 3$ 8"9D>a4A
2?;<"N
/$"%
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,
N! " !!  ;  !&
"  "
*$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" ]
? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N
’ K4YA$:@>? q"4] $# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] " WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yr
?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" " #"5"2 $:5>X$2 E"# 5$#@$2?542? $pE$:A
:>X?N - 3>:@K?y #":52? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
/$"&
 .- 3K
 ,   ,G  ') @?2?2 " X$WE4K"] 3$:K>a?2 "
#"5"2 $ E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$A
D$E>#$95" 9" >95$2>"2 3" 3$@h:>5" 9<" $:5$_? ?J?>p" 3"
9WX$K 3$ 2$D$2[9E>? &=!N ,$ D"2 $::$ " E?:"] ?a4?23?2 "
?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2d $# :$a4>3?] ?J2>2 K$95?#$95$ $
E"# E4>3?3" " 5?#@<"] 2$@"2 " KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"]
E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5$ $:5$_? E"#@2$$93>3" $952$ ?:
2$D$2[9E>?: &=! $ &’¡ $p>:5$95$: 9" @2h@2>" 3$@h:>5"N
’K^# 3>::"] X$2>D>E?2 X>:4?K#$95$ ? @2$:$9;? 3$ $X$954A
?>: @$23?: 3$ KWZ4>3"N ,$] 9" ?22?9Z4$ :$a4>95$] ? K4YA$:@>?
q"4 " WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yr :$ ?E$93$2 9"X?#$95$] E"95?5?2 ?
  ! = ,  > N
 ,  - ' K67 *   *+,-') ?J2?93?2 $] E?:"
? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$;? ?E$:?] @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N P>E?2 @?2?3"
342?95$ L "4 H #>945":] #?95$93" " #"5"2 D49E>"9?93" $
K>a$>2?#$95$ ?E$K$2?3"] @?2? D?X"2$E$2 4#? E>2E4K?;<" #?>:
?5>X? 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"d $# :$a4>3?] 3$:K>a?2 "
#"5"2N V$2>D>E?2 " 9WX$K E"22$5" 3" KWZ4>3"] E"#" 3$:E2>5"
?95$2>"2#$95$N

+# E?:" 3$ @$2E42:": #4>5" 3>DWE$>:] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K
#?95$2 " #"5"2 K>a?3" $ K>a$>2?#$95$ ?E$K$2?3" @"2 ?Ka49:
#>945": ?95$: 3$ " 3$:K>a?2N
-K&   ,   ' ] 4  .-    -  
-K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!!!    !!" $

*$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49: 
:$a493":N
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ ?X?2>? $ $# E?:" 3$ D2$9?a$9: X>"K$95?:]
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ^ 3$5$E5?3? 4#? ?X?2>? 9" @"3$ "E"22$2 " 52?X?#$95" 3?: 2"3?: 52?:$>2?:] E"#
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N E"9:$Z4$95$ @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ 3$22?@?a$9:N
- 3>:@K?y #":52? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
!!!  "! !%
*$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 

$
] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N
12"E$3$2 E"# @243[9E>? $ 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g 
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" " :>:5$#? ’B, :$ $9E"952?  ! = ,  > N
>9$D>E>$95$N !$::$ E?:"] " :>:5$#? 3$ D2$>": #?95^# >9?K5$A
2?3? ? @2h@2>? $D>E‘E>?] #?: :$# ?: @"5$9E>?K>3?3$: "D$2$A
E>3?: @$K" :>:5$#? ’B,N
- 3>:@K?y #":52? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
!!!  "!  " !<" @2"::$a4>2 " ?93?#$95" E"# 4# "4 #?>: @9$4: X?A
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ^ 3$5$E5?3? 4#? ?X?2>? 9" Y>":] 3?3" Z4$ ? E"934;<" 3" X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 E"#@2"A
:>:5$#? .1&,N 8?:" "E"22? 4# #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" 3" #$5>3?N 1?2?2 " X$WE4K" $X>5?93" D2$9?a$9: $ #43?9;?: 3$
:$9:"2] ? K4YA$:@>? @>:E?2‘ @"2 4# 5$#@" $ K"a" ?@h: @$2A 3>2$;<" J24:E?:N *>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! &
#?9$E$2‘ ?E$:?N = ,  > N

/$"’
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

7  - -3 ,  

’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9:?a$# X>:4A
?K>Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y] @?2? ?::>9?K?2 Z4$ ? @2$::<" 3" @9$4 ^
>9D$2>"2 ?" X?K"2 2$E"#$93?3" $o"4 Z4$ :$ $:5‘ X$2>D>E?93" +# Z4?KZ4$2 E"93>;<" 9? Z4?K 9" 3>:@K?y :$_? X>:4?K>A
4#? K$95? @$23? 3$ @2$::<"N !$::$: E?:":] @"3$# 9<" $:A Y?3? ? #$9:?a$# tV$2 #?94?Kt] E"9:4K5?2 -BC=S’.-C=A
5?2 a?2?95>3?: ? #$Kb"2 342?;<" 3" @9$4 $ 4# E"9:4#" 3$ ’&+!.+ " @?2‘a2?D" tC"3?:t 3" E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":t]
E"#J4:5WX$K >3$?KN 2$:@$>5?93" 2>a"2":?#$95$ ?: >93>E?;\$: 9$K$ E"95>3?:N
8?:" 3">: "4 #?>: @9$4: $:5$_?# 94#? 3?: E"93>;\$: :4A
@2?E>5?3?:] " 3>:@K?y #":52?2‘] $# :4E$::<"] ?: >93>E?;\$:
2$K?5>X?: ? E?3? @9$4N
"! 
*$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 
] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?::># Z4$ "
#"5"2 :$ K>a?2N
  * 67     
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K? >95$2#>5[9E>?
3? K4YA$:@>?% ? :>9?K>Y?;<" 3? >95$2X$9;<" >93>E? Z4$ "
X$WE4K" $:5‘ $# E"93>;\$: E2W5>E?: 3$ $:5?J>K>3?3$ $ ?3$A
2[9E>?N
!*      
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? 9<" :$ ?@?a?2] "4 :$ @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:? E"#
" #"5"2 K>a?3"] :>a9>D>E? Z4$ D"> 3$5$E5?3? 4#? ?X?2>? 9"
:>:5$#? +,8N !$:5$: E?:":] 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ 8   ! = &
!*       ''   !  ,  > N
- ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? $# :>#4K5e9$" E"# ? X>:4?A
K>Y?;<" 9" 3>:@K?y 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 3$3>E?3?] >93>E? ?
?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? T>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5N

/$"*
-K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!! !! @ !  "! 

!! !
*$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 
] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?::># Z4$ "
#"5"2 :$ K>a?2N
- ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? ?::>9?K? Z4$ ?Ka49: :>:5$#?:
3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>X": D"2?# @?2E>?K "4 5"5?K#$95$ 3$:?5>X?A
3":N 1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$ ": :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;?]
E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" t8?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>X?t
9" E?@W54K" t,$a42?9;?tN
C$?5>X?93" ": :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>X?] ? K4YA$:@>?
?@?a?A:$N
!!!  "! %@> $

+# E"93>;\$: 9"2#?>:] 3$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
@?2? ? @":>;<"  ] ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ,$] 3$:K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"
3$:K>a?2A:$ ?::># Z4$ " #"5"2 D49E>"9?2N  ] ? K4YA$:@>? 9<" :$ ?E$93$2 "4 :$] 342?95$
? #?2Eb?] :$ ?E$93$2 E"# K4Y D>p? "4 >95$2#>5$95$ q$#
- D49E>"9?#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? @"3$ :$2 X$2>D>E?3" ?52?X^: ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] _495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?yr]
3$ 3>:@":>5>X": ?3$Z4?3": @$K": ?a$95$: 3$ E"952"K$ 3" 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > N
52‘D$a"N C$:@$>5$ ?: 9"2#?: X>a$95$: 9" @?W: "93$ E>2E4K?N
!*       ^67
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:? "4 :$ :$ ?E$93$2 342?95$
? #?2Eb?] :>a9>D>E? Z4$ " :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 9<" D49E>"9? !$:5?: E"93>;\$:] ^ @"::WX$K E"95>94?2 ? E"934Y>2] $X>A
E"22$5?#$95$N ’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$:? E"# K4Y D>p? ?::>9?K? 4# 5?93"] 9" $95?95"] $:D"2;": :$X$2": 3" #"5"2 "4 X$K"E>A
#?4 D49E>"9?#$95" 9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K>#$95?;<"o>a9>;<" Z4$ 3?3$: $K$X?3?:N ’ 45>K>Y?;<" @2"K"9a?3? 3" X$WE4K" E"# ?
@"3$ @2"X"E?2 $K$X?3?: $#>::\$: 9" $:E?@?#$95"] @$23? K4YA$:@>? ?E$:? 3$ D"2#? D>p? @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9":N
3$ 3$:$#@$9b"] #‘ 3>2>a>J>K>3?3$ $ E"9:4#": $K$X?3":N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] " 3>:@K?y X>:4?K>Y? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$A *>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ ? 4# E"9E$::>"9‘2>" 3?  
EWD>E?N ! = ,  > N
’ K4YA$:@>? ?@?a?A:$ :$ ? ?9"#?K>? 3$:?@?2$E$2] #?: "
:>:5$#? #$#"2>Y? ? :>9?K>Y?;<"N

/$"+
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!!!  "!  >  ! &

 ; !!    /!!
CB0 /* H  '0
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# ? K4YA$:@>? ] 9"
E?:" 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$A
;<" 3$ ’C)’ HL E"# 4# @2"345" Z4$ @"::4? E?2?E5$2W:5>A
E?: 3>D$2$95$: 3?: $:@$E>D>E?3?:] "4 $95<"] :$_? 3$5$E5?3?
?Ka4#? ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#?N 8?:" ? ?X?2>? 9<" :$_? :"K4E>A
"9?3?] " :>:5$#? ,8C @"3$2‘ D?Y$2 E"# Z4$ ? @?25>3? 3" *>2>a>2A:$ " >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > N
#"5"2 D>Z4$ >93>:@"9WX$KN

’95$: 3? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 D>E?2 >93>:@"9WX$K] :$2<"
$p>J>3?: 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] #$9:?a$9: 3$ ?K$25?
Z4$ >93>E?# ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ X$2>D>E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"
3$ ’C)’ HL @?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q,8Cr $ ? ?45"9"#>?
2$:5?95$ 3" X$WE4K" ?5^ Z4$ ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 D>Z4$
>93>:@"9WX$KN
C$?J?:5$E$2 " 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ ’C)’ HL @?2? 2$34;<" 3$
@"K4$95$:] E"9D"2#$ >93>E?3" 9" E?@W54K" x1?25>3? $ -@$A
2?;<"z] :$;<" x12"E$3>#$95" 3$ ’J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ ?a$95$
2$345"2 KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q’2K? HLrz] ?5^
Z4$ :$ ?5>9_? " 9WX$K #‘p>#" 3" #$:#"N ’@h: D>9?K>Y?2 "
%!N   !  ; !! 2$?J?:5$E>#$95"] 2$?K>Y?2 " E>EK" 3? Eb?X$ @"2 52[: X$Y$:]
   /!! CB0 /* H  '0 :$# ?E>"9?2 " @$3?K 3$ D2$>"] @?2? Z4$ " :W#J"K" :$ ?@?A
a4$N 8?3? E>EK" 3$ Eb?X$ E"9:>:5$ $# @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
- ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" $# E"9_495" E"# ? K4YA$:@>? 3$ @?25>3? @?2? E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $# 
] >93>E? Z4$ " 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3" $] $# :$a4>3?] @2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" 3$ @?25>3?
’C)’ HL @?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q,8Cr $:5‘ X?Y>"N @?2? E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $#  @N

8?:" " :W#J"K" 9<" :$ ?@?a?2 ^ :>9?K Z4$ $p>:5$ ?Ka4#?
?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ’C)’ HL q,8CrN *>2>a>2A:$ "
#?>: J2$X$ @"::WX$K g   ! = ,  > N

/$",
-K&   .-  5 3 ,
!!!  "! %@>
   ,' 
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?E$93$2 3$ D"2#? >95$2#>5$95$] :>a9>D>E?
Z4$ " E?5?K>:?3"2 @"3$ $:5?2 3?9>D>E?3"N
!  "%@!"! "!!
’ K4YA$:@>? q"4 " WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yr ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" 9"
5?9Z4$ 2$:5?# E$2E? 3$ | ? M K>52": 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
’" #$:#" 5$#@" Z4$ ? ?45"9"#>? >9D$2>"2 ? E$2E? 3$ 6G
i#] $# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] 9" 3>:@K?y ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#?
#$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
J  %! !!
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ ?" K>a?2 ? K4Y 3$ 9$JK>9? 52?:$>2?N
  !!  "!
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ^ 3$5$E5?3" ? D?3>a? 3" #"A
5"2>:5?N
*$@">: Z4$ ? #$9:?a$# @"@A4@ ^ ?@?a?3?] $K? ^ ?2#?Y$A
9?3? ?5^ Z4$ ? E"93>;<" 9<" :$_? #?>: X$23?3$>2?
 .- 3K
,"K5?2 " @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2] E"K"E?93" " #"5"2 ? J?>p":
2$a>#$: 3$ 2"5?;\$:] ?5^ ? K4YA$:@>? @?2?2 3$ @>:E?2N
12"::$a4>2 ? #?2Eb? E"# 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ #"3$2?3?] @2"A
E42?93" $X>5?2 E"93>;\$: 3$ E"934;<" Z4$ @"::?# @2"X"A
E?2 #?>: >95$2#>5[9E>?: $ 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g 
 ! = ,  > :
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? q"4 " WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yr E"#$;?2 ? @>:E?2
342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N
$
’ 3$5$E;<" 3$ :"9"K[9E>? 3" #"5"2>:5? ?_43? ? $X>5?2 ?E>A
3$95$: E?4:?3": @"2 D?3>a?] ?E"9:$Kb?93" ": #"5"2>:5?: ?
D?Y$2$# 4#? @?4:? 9" 5$#@"N ’::># Z4$ " &"5"2>:5? :"A
9"K$95" D"2 3$5$E5?3"] 4#? _?9$K? @"@A4@ :$2‘ $p>J>3? E"9A
5>94?#$95$ ?5^ Z4$ " #"5"2>:5? @2$::>"9$ " J"5<" -{ @?2?
K>#@?2N
/$"-
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!;"  "%
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ^ D$>5? 4#? 5$95?5>X? 3$ @?2A
5>3? E"# ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" E"#J4:5WX$K ?J?>p" 3$ E$2E?
3$ 7F 8] >93>E?93" Z4$ " :>:5$#? 9<" E"9EK4>4 " ?Z4$E>A
#$95" $ ?@?a?93"A:$ Z4?93" " E"#J4:5WX$K 5>X$2 ?5>9a>3"
? 5$#@$2?542? >3$?KN
f @"::WX$K 3?2 @?25>3? 9" #"5"2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?::># Z4$ ?
K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a?2N

+# E"93>;\$: 3$ 5$#@$2?542? ?#J>$95$ #"3$2?3? "4
$K$X?3?] " ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? @"3$ ?E$93$2A:$
2?@>3?#$95$] E"# 342?;<" Z4?:$ >#@$2E$@5WX$KN
!!!  !;"  "%
’ >95$2#>5[9E>? 3? K4YA$:@>? q$# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$: _495?A !$:5$ E?:"] 3>2>_?A:$ " #?>: 3$@2$::? @"::WX$K g  
#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?yr] ! = ,  > N
>93>E? 4#? ?9"#?K>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$ @2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3"
E"#J4:5WX$KN

-K&   , *   .-    -  

-K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

J    !< %!N

’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ ?5>X?93" ?: K4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" "4 ":
D?2h>: J?>p":N
  K67  ' 5    3 Q 
+:5? D49;<" @$2#>5$ #?95$2 ?: K4Y$: ?E$:?: 342?95$ 4#
@$2W"3" 3$ HG] FG "4 MG :$a493": ?@h: 5$2 E"K"E?3" "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N

/$%.
 -K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!< ! !"

q:$ $Z4>@?3"r
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ ?5>X?93" ": D?2h>: ?K5": ?45"#‘5>E":N

!<  %!
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" :$ K>a?# ": D?2h>: 3$ 9$A
JK>9?N

!   ;

’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ E"#?93" 3":
>93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" q:$5?:r ^ 3$:K"E?3? @?2? J?>p" "4]
_495?#$95$ E"# " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" 3>2$>5"] Z4?93" :$ $
?E>"9? " J"5<" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N
!   
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ E"#?93" 3":
>93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" q:$5?:r ^ 3$:K"E?3? @?2? E>#? "4]
_495?#$95$ E"# " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" $:Z4$23"] Z4?93"
:$ ?E>"9? " J"5<" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N

-K&   , K-'  .-    -  

-K&   .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!< !
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ ?5>X?93" ": D?2h>: ?K5":N

/$%!
+ 4'  , * 'G * -' K    'F
+ 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

  <  " 

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ E"# K4Y D>p?] _495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9A
:?a$# X>:4?K>Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y] Z4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5?2
4#? @2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$ 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2N 
,$ " :W#J"K" :$ ?E$93$2 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] 3$:K>a?2
 >#$3>?5?#$95$ " #"5"2 $ 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
!<" 45>K>Y?2 " X$WE4K" ?5^ Z4$ ? ?X?2>? 5$9b? :>3" > N
$K>#>9?3?N - ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" 9<" >93>E? ?
Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ hK$" @2$:$95$ 9" #"5"2% " E"952"K$ 3" 9WX$K
3$X$ :$2 :$#@2$ $D$54?3" #?94?K#$95$N
!!! !%!
- ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" >93>E? 4#? ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#?
*>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
3$ ?>2J?aN
- 3>:@K?y #":52? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N

!!!  !!
- ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" E"# " #"5"2 K>a?3" >93>E? *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
4#? ?X?2>? 9" ?K5$29?3"2N

!" ! ! " 

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" 4#? "4 #?>: @"25?: 9<" :$ P$Eb?2 E"22$5?#$95$ 5"3?: ?: @"25?:N
$9E"952?# E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?3?:N 8"# ?: @"25?: ?J$25?: $
" X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"] ^ $#>5>3" 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"N

!" "   ! A  "

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" " E?@v 3" #"5"2 9<" $:5‘
E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?3"N 8"# " E?@v 3" #"5"2 ?J$25" $ P$Eb?2 E"22$5?#$95$ " E?@v 3" #"5"2N
" X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"] ^ $#>5>3? 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<"
?Eu:5>E?N

/$%"
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!" "  ! !" !  !&

"!! / .- 0
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: 9<"
$:5‘ E"22$5?#$95$ D$Eb?3?N 8"# ? 5?#@? ?J$25? $ " X$WE4K"
$# #"X>#$95"] ^ $#>5>3? 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?N
!!!  _"% !"
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9:?a$# X>:4A
?K>Y?3? @$K" 3>:@K?y $ 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?] Z4?93" ^
3$5$E5?3? 4#? ?X?2>? 9" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"
" !! N!  <  "
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ $# E?:" 3$ :"J2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3"
hK$" 3" #"5"2N
P$Eb?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
*>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > N

’ E"934;<" E"# " :W#J"K" ?E$:" @"3$ @2"X"E?2 a2?X$:
3?9": 9" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"] @2"X"E?93" ? :4? 24@542?N
’K^# 3>::"] @2"X"E?2 " :"J2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3" hK$"% "
:$4 $X$954?K E"95?5" E"# " #"5"2 Z4$95$ "4 E"# ":
E"#@"9$95$: 3" $:E?@$ ? ?K5? 5$#@$2?542? @"3$ @2"X"E?2
>9E[93>":N
$

,$ " :W#J"K" :$ ?E$93$2 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] @?2?2
>#$3>?5?#$95$ " X$WE4K" $ 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2N

+ 4'  ,   ' ] 4 * -' K    'F

+ 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!!!  "! L EL @ !!  !&

"%!"
!*        F EF N
*>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#? -
:W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#? ,$952y
{$yN

/$%%
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

  *    4  
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ ?" E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  ] _495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#?
#$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?] @?2? ?::>9?K?2 Z4$ "E"22$4 4#? @":A
:WX$K 5$95?5>X? 3$ ?22"#J?#$95" 9? @2$:$9;? 3$ ?K?2#$N
  "!    "%& 1?2? " @2"E$3>#$95" 3$ 2$?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ E"25$
 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] E"9:4K5?2 ? :$;<" x,>:5$#? 3$ E"25$ 3$
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ q_495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$Kz 9" E?@W54K" t+# E?:" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?tN ,$
4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?r $# E?:" 3$ >95$2X$9;<" 3" :>:A 9<" D"2 @"::WX$K 2$:5?J$K$E$2 ? ?K>#$95?;<" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K]
5$#? 3$ E"25$ 3" E"#J4:5WX$KN 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N

 !   ! !!

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ q_495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$
4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?r Z4?93" ? 5$#@$2?542? $p5$2>"2 ^
>a4?K "4 >9D$2>"2 ? H«8 qH|PrN

+# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :$9:"2 3$ 5$#@$2?542? $p5$29?] ":
9u#$2": Z4$ >93>E?# " :$4 X?K"2 :<" :4J:5>54W3": @"2 52?;":N

/$%&
+ 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

<  " !! / .- 0

 H  ') " :W#J"K" ^ X>:4?K>Y?3" 9" 3>:@K?y] $# ?KA
a4#?: X$2:\$: _495?#$95$ E"# 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
- :W#J"K" @$2#?9$E$ X>:4?K>Y?3" @"2 E>EK": 3$ H #>945":
E"# >95$2X?K": 3$ :W#J"K" ?@?a?3" 3$ 6 :$a493": ?5^ Z4$
" hK$" :$_? :4J:5>54W3"N

’@h: ? @2>#$>2? :>9?K>Y?;<"] ? E?3? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2]
" :W#J"K" E"95>94?2‘ ? ?E$93$2A:$ 9" #"3" >93>E?3"
?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5^ " hK$" :$2 :4J:5>54W3"N +# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:
" 3>:@K?y X>:4?K>Y? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
- ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" 9<" 3$X$ :$2 E"9:>3$2?3"
4# 3$D$>5" 3" X$WE4K"] #?: ?::>9?K? Z4$ ? 45>K>Y?;<"
9"2#?K 3" X$WE4K" K$X"4 g 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ :4J:5>54>2 "
hK$"N ’ 3$a2?3?;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 ^ ?E$K$2?3? @"2 4#?
45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K" $# @$2E42:": J2$X$:] >#@$3>93" Z4$
" #"5"2 ?5>9_? ? 5$#@$2?542? 3$ 2$a>#$N
*>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N

’ @?25>2 3" #"#$95" $# Z4$ :$ ?E$93$ " :W#J"K"] " hK$"
3$a2?3?3" 3" #"5"2 3$X$ :$2 :4J:5>54W3" K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K
$ 949E? ?K^# 3$ 6GG i# ?@h: " @2>#$>2" ?E$93>#$95" 3"
:W#J"K"N !<" 2$:@$>5?2 ?: >9D"2#?;\$: ?E>#? >93>E?3?: @"3$
E?4:?2 3?9": a2?X$: 9" #"5"2 $ ? ?94K?;<" 3? a?2?95>?N
- ?E$93>#$95" 3$:5$ :W#J"K" 9<" $:5‘ 2$K?E>"9?3" E"# ?
Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ hK$" @2$:$95$ 9" #"5"2d @"25?95"] $# E?:" 3$
?E$93>#$95" >95$2#>5$95$ 3? #$:#?] 9<" ^ ?J:"K45?#$95$
9$E$::‘2>" ?E2$:E$95?2 #?>: hK$" ?" #"5"2N
$

,$ " :W#J"K" @>:E?2 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] 3>2>a>2A:$ g 
 ! = ,  > N

!!!      < "

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ E"# K4Y D>p?] _495?#$95$ E"# ? #$9A
:?a$# X>:4?K>Y?3? @$K" 3>:@K?y] $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :$9A
:"2 3$ @2$::<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2N

!!!    !

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ q_495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?r $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 3" :$9:"2 3$
Eb4X?N

!!!    !

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ q_495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?r $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 3" :$9:"2
E2$@4:E4K?2N

/$%’
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K


’ @2$:$9;? 3$ ‘a4? 9" E>2E4>5" 3$ ?K>#$95?;<"
@"3$ @2"X"E?2 a2?X$: 3?9": 9" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" $
!  !     /* H >22$a4K?2>3?3$: 9" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" #"5"2N 8?:" "
 '0 :W#J"K" :$_? X>:4?K>Y?3" 9" 3>:@K?y q_495?#$95$ E"# ?
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ E"# K4Y D>p? 342?95$ ? #?2Eb? q_49A X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?r] 3>2>a>2A:$ ?::>#
5?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?yr Z4$ @"::WX$K g   ! = ,  > @?2? ? "@$2?;<"
@?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? @2$:$9;? 3$ ‘a4? 9" >95$2>"2 3" D>K52" 3$ 3$ :?9a2>?N ,$#@2$ Z4$ ? #$:#? :>9?K>Y?;<" :$ X$2>D>E?2
3>$:$KN >#$3>?5?#$95$ ? :$a4>2 ? 4# ?J?:5$E>#$95"] ^ @"::WX$K Z4$
5$9b? :>3" >952"34Y>3? ‘a4? 9" 5?9Z4$% 9$::$ E?:"] 3$:K>a?2
>#$3>?5?#$95$ " #"5"2 $ E"95?5?2 ?   ! = , 
> N
!!! ! J N!
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 4#? ?X?2>? 9?: :$a4>9A
5$: K4Y$:%
 )4Y$: 3>429?: q*C)r
 )4Y$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
 =93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 3" 2$J"Z4$ q:$ @2$:$95$r ’ ?X?2>? @"3$ 3$X$2A:$ ? 4#? Ke#@?3? Z4$>#?3? "4 ?"
2$:@$E5>X" D4:WX$K 3$ @2"5$;<" Z4$>#?3" "4 g >95$224@;<"
 )4Y$: 3" 2$J"Z4$ q:$ @2$:$95$r
3? K>a?;<" $K^52>E?N 12"E$3$2 g :4J:5>54>;<" 3? Ke#@?3? "4
 )4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" 3" 2$:@$E5>X" D4:WX$KN 8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > N
 =93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"
 )4Y 3$ 9$JK>9?
 )4Y 3$ #?2Eb? ? 2^
 )4Y$: 3$ D2$>"
 )4Y$: 3$ @K?E?

/$%*
+ 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

" J!   /3 '    +,-'0  ,-  /   * &

H  ' ,  0
1":>E>"9?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 
] " :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$] #?: 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$ ?@h: ?Ka49:
:$a493":N - :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ 3$ #"3" D>p" @?2? ?::>9?A
K?2 Z4$ " :>:5$#? *1P @2$E>:? 3$ $K>#>9?2 ?: :4J:5e9E>?: 
@"K4$95$: 2$5>3?: q@?25WE4K?:r ?52?X^: 3" @2"E$::" 3$ 2$a$A ’ X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ #?2Eb? 3$X$ :$2 :$#@2$ ?3$Z4?3? g
9$2?;<"N :>54?;<" 3" 52e9:>5" $ g: E"93>;\$: ?5#":D^2>E?:] :$#@2$
- :W#J"K" 9<" :$ ?E$93$ :$#@2$ Z4$ " *1P :$ $9E"9A 2$:@$>5?93" K$>: X>a$95$:N f @"::WX$K 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2 #$:#"
52? $# 2$a$9$2?;<"] #?: :"#$95$ Z4?93" ?: E"93>;\$: 3$ E"# ? K4YA$:@>? ?E$:?d @"2^#] >95$224@;\$: 2$@$5>3?: 3"
E"934;<" $p>a>2$# ? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?" E"9345"2N 1?2? D?Y$2 @2"E$::" 3$ 2$a$9$2?;<" @"3$# E?4:?2 4#? 3$a2?3?;<"
E"# Z4$ " :W#J"K" :$ ?@?a4$] #?95$2 " X$WE4K" $# #"X>A @2$E"E$ 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2N 1"2 $::$ #"5>X"] ^ :$#@2$
#$95" ?5^ ? 2$a$9$2?;<" 5$2#>9?2N ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K ?a4?23?2 Z4$ " :W#J"K" :$ ?@?a4$ ?95$: 3$
3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2] :$a4>93" ?: >93>E?;\$: ?E>#? >93>E?3?:N
$
’ 342?;<" 3" @2"E$::" ^ 3$ 76 #>945":] $# #^3>?N ’:
E"93>;\$: >3$?>: @?2? 5$2#>9?2 " @2"E$::" :<" ?5>9a>3?: !<" ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K E"9EK4>2 ? 2$a$9$2?;<" 3" *1P E"# "
#?95$93" " X$WE4K" $# #?2Eb? ? FG i#ob E"# 2$a>#$ 3" X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
#"5"2 :4@$2>"2 ? LGGG 2@#N
- ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" 9<" 3$X$ :$2 E"9:>3$2?3" 4#?
?9"#?K>? $] @"2 >::"] 9<" ^ 9$E$::‘2>" K$X‘AK" g "D>E>9?N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] _495?#$95$ E"# " ?E$93>#$95" 3"
:W#J"K"] " 3>:@K?y X>:4?K>Y? ? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
!!!  "! EL &&  q:$ $Z4>A
@?3"r
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
4#? #$9:?a$#] $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? {$yK$::
+95$2A!AS"N

!!!  "!    "%

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# ? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ *>2>a>2A:$] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] g   ! = ,  > N
4#? #$9:?a$#] $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$ E"25$ 3"
E"#J4:5WX$KN

/$%+
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

!!!    "

*>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > @?2?
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 3" 3>:@":>5>X" $K>#>9?2 ? ?X?2>?N
,@$$3 )>#>5$2N

!!!  !< ! !" / .- &

0 *>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > @?2?
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? ?X?2>? 3": D?2h>: ?KA $K>#>9?2 ? ?X?2>?N
5": ?45"#‘5>E":N

" !! N!  <  _"% !&

"
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ $# E?:" 3$ :"J2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3" ’a4?23?2] E"# " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3" "4 9" #W9>#"] ? 3$:?5>A
Ee#J>"] ?@h: 4#? 45>K>Y?;<" @?25>E4K?2#$95$ $p>a$95$N X?;<" 3" :W#J"K"N
!$::$ E?:"] ^ $D$54?3? 4#? K>#>5?;<" 3" 3$:$#@$9b" 3"
#"5"2N

!!!  !  %; / .- 0

*>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > @?2?
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? ?X?2>? 3" a?9Eb" 3$ $K>#>9?2 ? ?X?2>?N
2$J"Z4$N

*>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > @?2?

!!!  "!  
$K>#>9?2 ? ?X?2>?N

/$%,
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

C$?J?:5$E$2 " 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ ’2K? HL] E"9D"2#$ >93>E?3"

%!N   !  ; !!
   /!! CB0 /* H  '0
’ K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$] _495?#$95$ E"# #$9:?a$# $:@$A
EWD>E? 3$ ?K$25?] >93>E?93" Z4$ " 9WX$K 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ’C)’ HL $:5‘ J?>p" $ ^ 9$E$::‘2>"
2$?J?:5$E$2 " #$:#"N

’: #$9:?a$9: 3$ ?K$25? @?::?# ? :$2 $p>J>3?: Z4?93" "
X$WE4K" @"::4> 4#? ?45"9"#>? >a4?K "4 >9D$2>"2 ? LNIGG i#
$ X?2>?# 3$ ?E"23" E"# " 9WX$K 3$ ’C)’ HL @2$:$95$ 9"
2$:$2X?5h2>"N ’: #$9:?a$9: @"3$# >93>E?2 ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$
2$?J?:5$E>#$95" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" "4 ? ?45"9"#>? 2$:5?95$ 3"
X$WE4K" ?5^ Z4$ ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 D>Z4$ >93>:@"9WX$KN
9" E?@W54K" x1?25>3? $ -@$2?;<"z] :$;<" x12"E$3>#$95" 3$
’J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34;<" 3$
@"K4$95$: q’2K? HLrzN

!": E?:": $# Z4$ ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 9<" $:5$_?
3>:@"9WX$K] 3$X>3" ?" J?>p" 9WX$K ’2K? HL] 2$?J?:5$E$2 "
#$:#" $ ?a4?23?2 Z4$ ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a4$ qE$2E? 3$
3">: #>945":r $ 3?2 ? @?25>3? 9" #"5"2 9"2#?K#$95$N

- ,     '-K&  7 *  ,   
-    '  `  ` 7 9 ,P   5 & 8 $
  ! = ,  > N

+ 4'  , 4  , * -' K    'F

+ 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

! " ! !!!

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ Z4?93" ^ 4K52?@?::?3" " K>#>5$ 3$
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3" q@"2 $pN 7LG i#obr ?52?X^: 3" &$94 3"
3>:@K?yN
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWA
D>E? $ ^ $#>5>3? 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?N

1?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:o#$2E?3":] ?E$93$A:$ 5?#J^# 4#
"452" :W#J"K" 3$ E"2 X$2#$Kb?N

/$%-
 + 4'  .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K

   / .- 0

+ 4' , , '-K 3 () ?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? T>KK
*$:E$95 8"952"KN
+ 4' , , '-K   ) 3$:?5>X?;<" 3"
:>:5$#? T>KK *$:E$95 8"952"KN

  A

- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ $# E?:" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3" 824>:$
8"952"K $K$52v9>E"N

  "
- :W#J"K" ?E$93$A:$ $# E?:" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3" ,@$$3
)>#>5$2N

" 5  * -' K    'F

" 5 
 .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K
  'F
!!! ! ! ! q:$ $Z4>@?3"r
*>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g   ! = ,  > @?2?
,+CV I¤* ’ #$9:?a$# ?E$93$A:$ @?2? ?::>9?K?2 ? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#? $K>#>9?2 ? ?X?2>?N
3$ 52?;<" >95$a2?KN
"! %&  " q:$ $Z4>@?3"r
%'.-    

B)=!*A,1-. !" 3>:@K?y ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? $# )>J$2?2 " @?2?AEb"Z4$ 3$ $X$954?>: "J:5‘E4K":] K>#@?93"A"
&-!=.-C=!S E?:" 3$ JK"Z4$>" 3" :$9:"2 3" :>:5$#? BK>93A:@"5 &"9>A 3$ >#@42$Y?:N
5"2>9aN !$::$ E?:"] ": )+*: K"E?K>Y?3": 9": $:@$Kb": 2$52"A
X>:"2$: $p5$29": $:5<" ?E$:": E"# K4Y D>p?N
f 5?#J^# $#>5>3" 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"N

/$&.
 " 5 
 .-  5 3 ,  .- 3K
  'F
   7    +*'
’ E?4:? 3$ #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" @"3$ 3$X$2A:$ g 5$9:<"
>9:4D>E>$95$ 3? J?5$2>? "4 ? $X$954?>: ?X?2>?: 9" :>:5$#? ’ E?4:? 3$ #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" @"3$ 3$X$2A:$ g 5$9:<"
B)=!*A,1-. $K^52>E"N 8"95?5?2] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] ?   ! = ,  >9:4D>E>$95$ 3? J?5$2>? "4 ? $X$954?>: ?X?2>?: 9" :>:5$#?
&-!=.-C=!S > @?2? ? X$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? $K^52>E"N !" 3>:@K?y ^ $K^52>E"N 8"95?5?2] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] ?   ! = , 
X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? $# E?:" 3$ JK"Z4$>" > @?2? ? X$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? $K^52>E"N
3" :$9:"2 3" :>:5$#? BK>93A:@"5 &"9>5"2>9aN !$::$ E?:"] ":
)+*: K"E?K>Y?3": 9": $:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"2$: $p5$29": $:5<"
?E$:": E"# K4Y D>p?N
"! !E
%'.-     
’ #$9:?a$# ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y $# E?:" 3$ JK"Z4$>"
)>J$2?2 " @?2?AEb"Z4$ 3$ $X$954?>: "J:5‘E4K":] K>#@?93"A"
3$ >#@42$Y?:N
$
3": :$9:"2$: 3" :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$N
1’C{,+!,+ f 5?#J^# $#>5>3" 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"N

   7    +*' ’ E?4:? 3$ #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" @"3$ 3$X$2A:$ g 5$9:<"

!" 3>:@K?y ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? $#
E?:" 3$ 9<" 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$N
"! !"!! /0
&+!,’S+!, w4?93" ? #?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3? qt2$X>:<"tr $:5‘ @$25" 3"
tC$X>:<"t @2?Y" @2$X>:5"] @":>E>"9?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2?
q&’!(.+!/0- ? @":>;<"  ] 9" 3>:@K?y ?@?2$E$ ? >93>E?;<" tC$X>:<"t
1C-SC’&’*’r :$a4>3? 3" 9u#$2" 3$ Z4>Kv#$52": "4 3>?: q"93$ @2$X>:5"r
Z4$ D?K5?# @?2? ? #?945$9;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
>9:4D>E>$95$ 3? J?5$2>? "4 ? $X$954?>: ?X?2>?: 9" :>:5$#?
$K^52>E"N 8"95?5?2] K"a" Z4$ @"::WX$K] ?   ! = , 
> @?2? ? X$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? $K^52>E"N
8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > Z4$ @2"E$3$2‘] @?2?
?K^# 3?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ #?945$9;<" @2$X>:5?: 9" t1K?9" 3$
#?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3?t " Y$2?#$95" 3? 2$D$2>3? X>:4?K>A
Y?;<" q2$:$5rN

/$&!
    
    

"! %
- ,>:5$#? 3$ *>?a9h:5>E" 3$
B"23" q        r
$D$54? 4# 3>?a9h:5>E" E"95W94" 3":
E"#@"9$95$: 2$K?E>"9?3": E"# ?:
$#>::\$: a?:":?: @2"34Y>3?: @$K"
X$WE4K"N ’K^# 3>::"] >93>E? @"2 #$>"
3" ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] ?E"#@?A
9b?3? 3$ #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y
q?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:r] ? E"93>;<" 3$
D?Kb? 3$ E"#@"9$95$: 3" :>:5$#? 3$
E"952"K$ 3" #"5"2N
- :>:5$#? -B* 5$# E"#" "J_$5>A
X":%
 #?95$2 :"J E"952"K$ ? $D>E>[9E>?
3" :>:5$#?]
 :>9?K>Y?2 4# ?4#$95" 3$ $#>:A
:\$: 3$X>3" ? 4# D49E>"9?#$95"
>22$a4K?2 3" X$WE4K"] $
/$&"
 :>9?K>Y?2 ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ :4J:A
5>54>2 ": E"#@"9$95$: 3$5$2>"2?A
3":N
- :>:5$#? 3>:@\$ 5?#J^# 3$ 4#
E"9$E5"2 Z4$ @$2#>5$ ? K$>542? 3":
Eh3>a": 3$ $22": #$#"2>Y?3": 9?
E$952?K $K$52v9>E?] $# E"9_495" E"#
4#? :^2>$ 3$ @?2e#$52": $:@$EWD>E":
3$ 3>?a9h:5>E" $ D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
#"5"2N .?K X$2>D>E?;<" ^ @"::WX$K @?2?
": ?a$95$: $9E?22$a?3": 3$ D>:E?K>Y?A
;<" 3$ 52e9:>5"] #$3>?95$ ? >95$2D?E$
3" :>:5$#? E"# >9:524#$95": ?3$A
Z4?3":N
J& !  !!! 
"!  !< 
%@  "
+# E"93>;\$: 9"2#?>:] @":>E>"A
9?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ?
@":>;<"  ] ? K4YA$:@>? q?#?A
2$K" e#J?2r :$ ?E$93$] #?: Z4?93"
" #"5"2 D49E>"9?2 3$X$ ?@?a?2A:$N ,$
? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$ ?E$:?] "4 :$
?E$93$2 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] ^ >93>E?A
;<" 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" >#@$2D$>5" 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ E"952"K$ 3" #"5"2N
- ?E$93>#$95" D>p" 3? K4YA$:@>?
>93>E? #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" 9" :>:A
5$#? 3$ ?K>#$95?;<"o>a9>;<"] Z4$
@"3$2‘ @2"X"E?2 ?4#$95" 3$ $#>:A
:\$: 3" $:E?@$] @"::WX$K @$23? 3$ 3$A
:$#@$9b"] #‘ 3>2>a>J>K>3?3$ $ E"9A
:4#": $K$X?3":N +# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:
" 3>:@K?y $p>J$ #$9:?a$# $:@$EWA
D>E?N
!$::?: E"93>;\$:] ^ @"::WX$K E"9A
5>94?2 ? 3>2>a>2] :$#@2$ $X>5?93" $:A
D"2;": 3" #"5"2 $ ?K5?: X$K"E>3?3$:N
- 4:" @2"K"9a?3" 3" X$WE4K" E"#
? K4YA$:@>? ?E$:? @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?A
9":N !$::$ E?:"] @2"E42$ ?  
! = ,  > N
w4?93" " #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" 3$A
:?@?2$E$] ?@?a?A:$ ? K4YA$:@>?] #?: "
:>:5$#? #$#"2>Y? ? :>9?K>Y?;<"N ,$ ?
K4YA$:@>? :$ ?E$93$ 3$ #"3" >95$2#>A
5$95$ ^ >93>E?;<" 3$ @"::WX$K 3?9" 9"
E?5?K>:?3"2N !" E?:" 3$ ?E$93>#$95"
>95$2#>5$95$] :"K5?2 " @$3?K 3" ?E$A
K$2?3"2] 2$34Y>93" ? X$K"E>3?3$] ?5^
Z4$ ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a4$N 12"::>a?
? #?2Eb? $# X$K"E>3?3$ 2$34Y>3? $
@2"E42$ ?   ! = ,  > N
 !#!
,$] ?" :$ E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" ] ? K4YA$:@>?
9<" :$ ?E$93$2] "4 :$ ?E$93$2
3$ #"3" D>p"o>95$2#>5$95$ 342?95$ ?
#?2Eb?] E"95?5?2 " Z4?95" ?95$: ?
  ! = ,  >
’ D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 3? K4YA$:@>?
@"3$ :$2 X$2>D>E?3? @$K": ?a$95$: 3$
D>:E?K>Y?;<" 3" 52e9:>5" "4 $# $X$9A
$
54?>: @2"a2?#?: "D>E>?>: 3$ >9:@$;<"
3$ X$WE4K":N C$:@$>5$ ?: 9"2#?: X>A
a$95$:N

/$&%
/
  
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A7
8’C’8.+Cm,.=8’, *+ ,+S(C’!/’ ’.=V’ N N N N +A7
8=!.-, *+ ,+S(C’!/’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N +ALF
’)+C.’ *+ !0- ’P=V+)’&+!.- *-, 8=!.-,
*+ ,+S(C’!/’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AHG
1CfA.+!,=-!’*-C+, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AHL
,+S(C’!/’ 1’C’ 8C=’!/’, N N N N N N N N N N +AHH
,=,.+&’, *+ ,+S(C’!/’
,(1)+&+!.’C+, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AIL

0
0
 
- E?@W54K" ? :$a4>2 ^ #4>5" >#@"2A
5?95$% ?Z4> :<" 3$:E2>5": ": :>:5$#?:
3$ :$a42?9;? D"29$E>3": E"# " X$WA
E4K" $ D"29$E>3?: ?: >93>E?;\$: 9$A
E$::‘2>?: :"J2$ E"#" 45>K>Y‘AK": E"2A
2$5?#$95$N
!  
  
 
 
*$@$93$93" 3?: E"9D>a42?;\$:
3>:@"9WX$>:] 9" X$WE4K" $:5<" @2$A
:$95$: ": :$a4>95$: 3>:@":>5>X": 3$
:$a42?9;? ?5>X?%
 .8 q.2?E5>"9 8"952"Kr
 1B’ q1?9>E B2?i$ ’::>:5r
 T,’ qT>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5r
 *,. q*y9?#>E ,5$$2>9a ."2Z4$r
 +C& q+K$E52"9>E C"KK &>5>a?5>"9r
 .,8 q.2?>K$2 ,j?y 8"952"Kr
 T*8 qT>KK *$:E$95 8"952"Kr
 ’B, q’95>AK"Ei B2?i>9a ,y:5$#r
 +,8 q+K$E52"9>E ,5?J>K>5y 8"952"Kr
 B,& qBK>93 ,@"5 &"9>5"2>9ar
 P8¤ qP"2j?23 8"KK>:>"9
¤?29>9ar
 .,C q.2?DD>E ,>a9 C$E"a9>5>"9r
 .1&, q.>2$ 12$::42$ &"9>5"2>9a
,y:5$#r
1?2? " D49E>"9?#$95" 3": :>:5$A
#?:] E"9:4K5?2 ?: @‘a>9?: :$a4>95$:N
"!  / ,    '0
- :>:5$#? 3$ E"952"K$ 3$ 52?;<"
>95$2X^# ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ $# E?:"
3$ @?5>9?;<"] 3$ @$23? 3$ ?3$2[9E>?
$# @>:" #"Kb?3" q?Z4?@K?9?a$#r]
?E$K$2?;<" $# @>:": $:E"22$a?3>":]
E"# 9$X$ "4 a$K"] $5EN 3$ 4#? "4
#?>: 2"3?: #"52>Y$:N
+# D49;<" 3?: E"93>;\$: 3$ @?5>A
9?;<"] :<" ?5>X?3?: 34?: Kha>E?: 3$
E"952"K$ 3>D$2$95$:%
 ,$ ? @?5>9?;<" $9X"KX$ #?>: 3$
4#? 2"3? #"52>Y] " :>:5$#? ’,C
>95$2X^# 2$34Y>93" ? @"5[9E>?
52?9:#>5>3? @$K" #"5"2N
 ,$ ? @?5>9?;<" $9X"KX$ ?@$9?:
4#? 3?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$:]
?5>X?A:$ ? D49;<" B)* qB2?i$
)>#>5$3 *>DD$2$95>?Kr 52?X?93"
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ? 2"3?
Z4$ @?5>9? q^ :>#4K?3"
" E"#@"25?#$95" 3$ 4#
3>D$2$9E>?K ?45"JK"E?95$rN =:5"
@2"X"E?2‘ 4# ?4#$95" 3$
52?9:D$2[9E>? 3$ 5"2Z4$ #"5"2 9?
2"3? Z4$ 9<" $:5‘ @?5>9?93"N
+::? D49;<" @$2#?9$E$ ?5>X?
#$:#" D"2$# :$K$E>"9?3?:
#"3?K>3?3$: t,>:5$#?: %
@?2E>?K#$95$ 3$:?5>X?3":t $
t,>:5$#?: 3$:?5>X?3":t qE"9:4K5?2
?: @‘a>9?: :$a4>95$:rN
  * 67    
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?A
K?3? @$K? >95$2#>5[9E>? 3? K4YA$:@>?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] @?2?
>9D"2#?2 " E"9345"2 Z4$ " X$WE4K"
$:5‘ $# E"93>;\$: E2W5>E?: 3$ $:5?J>A
K>3?3$ $ ?3$2[9E>?N
0$!
 !#!
1?2? #?>"2 $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:5$#?
3$ E"952"K$ 3$ 52?;<" ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K
Z4$ ": @9$4: $:5$_?# $# J"# $:5?3"
3$ E"9:$2X?;<"N
P?;? ? >9:@$;<" @$2>h3>E? 3" @9$4
@?2? X$2>D>E?2 " 3$:a?:5$ $ " @2?Y" 3$
X?K>3?3$ @?2? a?2?95>2 ? :$a42?9;? $
? $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:5$#?N
!#!
1?2? " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
:>:5$#? .8] ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K Z4$ ":
@9$4: :$_?# 3? #$:#? #?2E? $ 3"
#$:#" 5>@" $# 5"3?: ?: 2"3?:N
’K^# 3>::"] 3$X$# 5$2 @2>9E>@?KA
#$95$ " 5>@" $ 3>#$9:\$: @2$:E2>5?: $
$:5?2 $# @$2D$>5?: E"93>;\$: 3$ E"9A
:$2X?;<" $ E"# ? @2$::<" 3": @9$4:
3$ ?E"23" E"# " @2$X>:5" 9" #?94?KN
0$"
!#!
’ @2$:$9;? 3" :>:5$#? .8 9<" 3$X$
>934Y>2 " E"9345"2 ? E"22$2 2>:E":N
- 5>@" 3$ E"934;<" 3$X$ :$2 :$#A
@2$ ?3$Z4?3" g: E"93>;\$: 3" @>:"
3? $:52?3?] g X>:>J>K>3?3$ $ ?" 52e9A
:>5"N ’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K? :$a4A
2?9;? 9? $:52?3? ^ :$#@2$ 3" E"934A
5"2N
!#!
- :>:5$#? .8 9<" ^ E?@?Y 3$ E"9A
52?2>?2 ?: K$>: 9?542?>: 3? PW:>E? $ 9<"
^ E?@?Y 3$ ?4#$95?2 ? ?3$2[9E>? 3$A
@$93$95$ 3?: E"93>;\$: 3? $:52?3?N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# @243[9E>? $
?5$9;<"N
!#!
- :>:5$#? .8 9<" ^ E?@?Y 3$ $X>A
5?2 ?E>3$95$:] >9EK4>93" ": 3$X>3": ?
$pE$::>X? X$K"E>3?3$ $# E42X?] E"9A
34;<" $# :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ J?>p? ?3$A
2[9E>? "4 ?Z4?@K?9?a$#N
*>2>_? E"# 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ $ @24A
3[9E>?N
!#!
’ E?@?E>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? .8 949E?
3$X$ :$2 5$:5?3? 3$ D"2#? >22$:@"9:‘A
X$K $ @$2>a":?N
+X>5$ E"#@2"#$5$2 ? @2h@2>? :$a4A
2?9;? $ ? 3$ 5$2E$>2":N
"! %! /  , % [ ! 0
- :>:5$#? 1B’ D"> E"9E$J>3" @?2?
"5>#>Y?2 ? E?@?E>3?3$ 3$ D2$9?a$#
3" X$WE4K" 342?95$ 4#? D2$9?a$# 3$
$#$2a[9E>?N
 - :>:5$#? 2$E"9b$E$ ? D2$9?a$#
3$ $#$2a[9E>? #"9>5"2?93" ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ $ ? D"2;? E"# Z4$ ^ @2$::>"A
9?3" " @$3?K 3" D2$>" $] E"9:$Z4$9A
5$#$95$] ?@K>E? ? @2$::<" >3$?K ?":
D2$>":N =::" @"3$ ?_43?2 ? 2$34Y>2 ":
$:@?;": 3$ D2$9?a$# % " :>:5$#? 1B’
E"#@K$5?] @"25?95"] " :>:5$#? ’B,N
’ ?::>:5[9E>? #‘p>#? 3" :>:5$#?
1B’ ^ "J5>3? ?" @2$::>"9?2 #4>5" 2?A
@>3?#$95$ " @$3?K 3" D2$>"N ’K^#
3>::"] @?2? "J5$2 ? #‘p>#? D49E>A
"9?K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#?] ^ 9$E$::‘2>"
@2$::>"9?2 E"95>94?#$95$ " @$3?K 3"
D2$>" 342?95$ ? D2$9?a$#] $X>5?93"
@>:?2 >95$2#>5$95$#$95$N
!<" 2$34Y>2 ? @2$::<" 9" @$3?K 3"
D2$>" ?5^ ? D2$9?a$# 3$>p?2 3$ :$2
9$E$::‘2>?N
- :>:5$#? 1B’ 3$:?5>X?A:$ Z4?93"
:$ :"K5? " @$3?K 3" D2$>"N
!#!
’ @2$:$9;? 3" :>:5$#? 1B’ 9<"
3$X$ >934Y>2 " E"9345"2 ? E"22$2 2>:A
E":N - 5>@" 3$ E"934;<" 3$X$ :$2
:$#@2$ ?3$Z4?3" g: E"93>;\$: 3"
@>:" 3? $:52?3?] g X>:>J>K>3?3$ $ ?"
52e9:>5"N ’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K? :$A !#!
a42?9;? 9? $:52?3? ^ :$#@2$ 3" E"9A
- :>:5$#? 1B’ 9<" @"3$ $X>5?2 ?E>A
345"2N
3$95$:] >9EK4>93" ": 3$X>3": ? $pE$:A
84#@2? :$#@2$ ?: 2$a2?: 3$ 52e9A :>X? X$K"E>3?3$ $# E42X?] E"934;<"
:>5"] 2$:@$>5?93" ?: X$K"E>3?3$: #‘A $# :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ J?>p? ?3$2[9E>? "4
p>#?: @$2#>5>3?: $# E?3? X>?] 2$34A ?Z4?@K?9>9aN
Y>93" ? X$K"E>3?3$ Z4?93" ?: E"93>A
*>2>_? E"# ?5$9;<" $ @243[9E>?N
;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: D"2?# 3$:D?X"2‘X$>:
E"#" Eb4X? $ K4#>9":>3?3$ 2$34A
Y>3? $ #?95$9b? 3>:5e9E>? 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? 3": "452": X$WE4K":N
!#!
’ E?@?E>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? 1B’ %
949E? 3$X$ :$2 5$:5?3? 3$ D"2#?
!#! >22$:@"9:‘X$K $ @$2>a":?N
- :>:5$#? 1B’ 9<" @"3$ E"952?A !<" E"#@2"#$5? :4? @2h@2>? :$A
2>?2 ?: K$>: 9?542?>: 3? PW:>E? $ 9<" a42?9;?] 3": "452": "E4@?95$: @2$A
@"3$ ?4#$95?2 ? ?3$2[9E>? 3$@$9A :$95$: ? J"23" 3" X$WE4K" $ 3$ 5"3":
3$95$ 3?: E"93>;\$: 3? $:52?3?N ": "452": 45>K>Y?3"2$: 3? $:52?3?N
&?95$9b?A:$ ?5$95" $ :$_? @24A
3$95$ ?" 3>2>a>2N
0$%
"! ! / ''   ! 0
f @?25$ >95$a2?95$ 3" :>:5$#? +,8
$ D?E>K>5? " ?22?9Z4$ 9?: :4J>3?:]
?5>X?93"A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 9": E?A
:": :$a4>95$:%
 !?: :4J>3?:% X$WE4K" $:5?E>"9?3"
$# $:52?3? E"# >9EK>9?;<" :4A
@$2>"2 ? 6s] #"5"2 K>a?3"] D2$>"
@2$::>"9?3" $ Ee#J>" $# @"95"
#"25" "4 4#? #?2Eb? 3>D$2$95$
3? #?2Eb? ? 2^ $9a?5?3?N
 !?: 3$:E>3?:% X$WE4K" $:5?E>"A
9?3" $# $:52?3? E"# >9EK>9?;<"
:4@$2>"2 ? 6s] #"5"2 K>a?3"] D2$>"
@2$::>"9?3" $ #?2Eb? ? 2^ $9a?A
5?3?N
!? D?:$ 3$ @?25>3?] ? E$952?K 3"
:>:5$#? +,8 #?95^# ? @2$::<" 3$
D2$9?a$# 9?: 2"3?: ?5^ ?" ?KE?9E$ 3"
5"2Z4$ 3" #"5"2 9$E$::‘2>" g @?25>3?
"4] $# 5"3" " E?:"] @"2 4# 5$#@"
#‘p>#" 3$ L :$a493":] @$2#>5>93"
3$:K"E?2 D?E>K#$95$ " @^ 3>2$>5" 3"
@$3?K 3" D2$>" @?2? " ?E$K$2?3"2N
1?::?3": ": L :$a493":] #$:#"
Z4$ 9<" 5$9b? :>3" $D$54?3" ? @?2A
0$&
5>3?] " :>:5$#? 3$:?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$] K>J$25?93" a2?34?K#$95$ ?
@2$::<" 3$ D2$9?a$#N
*42?95$ $:5? D?:$ 3$ K?2a?3? ^ @":A
:WX$K "4X>2 4# 24W3" 5W@>E" 3$ 3$:$9A
a?5$ #$Ee9>E" 3": D2$>":] Z4$ >93>E?
" #"X>#$95" >#>9$95$ 3" X$WE4K"N
 *67    
- :>:5$#? T>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5 @"3$ :$2
3$:?5>X?3" ?54?93" 9" &$94 3" 3>:A
@K?y qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" x*>:@K?yz
9" E?@W54K" x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 @?>A
9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":zrN
!#!
- :>:5$#? T,’ 9<" ^ 4# D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N
!<" ?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K" :$# 5$2
?E>"9?3" " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"]
3$:K>a?3" " #"5"2 $ @":>E>"9?3" "
Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<" A 1’C{ q$:5?E>A
"9?#$95"r] $:5?E>"9?93" " X$WE4K"
$# E"93>;\$: 3$ :$a42?9;? q@?2?
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" tP2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"t 9"
E?@W54K" t1?25>3? $ "@$2?;<"trN
!#!
1"3$# $p>:5>2 :>54?;\$: $# @$Z4$A
9?: >9EK>9?;\$: q>9D$2>"2$: ? ~sr] $#
E"93>;\$: 3$ X$WE4K" E?22$a?3"] $#
Z4$ " :>:5$#? T>KK ,5?25 ’::>:5 @"3$
9<" :$ ?5>X?2] @2"X"E?93" 4# K>a$>2"
2$E4"] $ ?4#$95?93" " 2>:E" 3$ 4#?
E"K>:<" E"# 4# "452" X$WE4K" "4 "JA
_$5"N
!<" E"K"Z4$ $# @$2>a" :4? :$a4A
2?9;? $ ? 3$ "452?: @$::"?:N
"!  /F  ,  5
 .-0
’ D49;<" *,. ?@2"X$>5? ? >95$a2?A
;<" 3" :>:5$#? +,8 E"# ? 3>2$;<"
?::>:5>3? $K^52>E? @?2? ?4#$95?2 " 9WA
X$K 3$ :$a42?9;? 3$ 5"3" " X$WE4K"N
+# :>54?;\$: E2W5>E?: qD2$9?a$# $#
@>:": E"# ?3$2[9E>? 3>D$2$9E>?3?r] "
:>:5$#? +,8] ?52?X^: 3? D49;<" *,.]
E"#?93? g 3>2$;<" ? ?54?;<" 3$ 4#
?4#$95" ?3>E>"9?K 3$ 5"2Z4$ 9" X"A
K?95$ 3$:5>9?3" ? :4a$2>2 ?" E"9345"2
? #?9"J2? #?>: E"22$5?N
’ ?;<" E""23$9?3? 3": D2$>": $
3? 3>2$;<" ?4#$95? ? :$9:?;<" 3$
:$a42?9;? $ 3$ E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
- *,. E"9:5>54> ?4pWK>" g E"934A
;<" $ 9<" :4J:5>54> " E"9345"2 9? 2$:A
@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3? E"934;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K? :$a42?9;?
9? $:52?3? @$25$9E$ :$#@2$ ?" E"9A
345"2N
"! " /',  , '' "  &
5  0
- :>:5$#? #"9>5"2? ? 5$93[9E>?
@?2? ? $K$X?;<" 3?: 2"3?: 3" :"K"
E?:" " E"9345"2 $D$54$ #?9"J2?: $pA
52$#?:] 5?>: E"#" $X>5?2 :4J>5?#$95$
4# "J:5‘E4K"] :"J2$543" $# E"93>A
;\$: 3$ $:52?3? 9<" >3$?>:N
,$ D"2$# X$2>D>E?3?: $::?: E"93>A
;\$:] " :>:5$#?] ?" >95$2X>2 9": D2$>":
$ 9? @"5[9E>? 3" #"5"2] K>#>5? ? @":A
:>J>K>3?3$ 3$ ?: 2"3?: :$ K$X?95?2$#
3" :"K"N !" $95?95"] 9<" ^ @"::WA
X$K $X>5?2 ? 5$93[9E>? @?2? " E?@"5?A
#$95" 3" X$WE4K" :$ " D$9v#$9" :$
3$X$2 ? E?4:?: E"#" ? E"934;<" $#
$K$X?3?: >9EK>9?;\$: K?5$2?>:] " Eb"A
Z4$ E"952? "J_$5": "4 "452": X$WE4A
K":N
!#!
- 3$:$#@$9b" 3$ 4# X$WE4K"
$Z4>@?3" E"# +C& 949E? 3$X$ :$2
@":5" g @2"X? 3$ #"3" >22$:@"9:‘X$K
$ @$2>a":"N
!<" E"K"Z4$ $# @$2>a" :4? :$a4A
2?9;? $ 3$ "452?: @$::"?:N
"!  /  ' \F  &
 '0
- :>:5$#? 45>K>Y? 4#? :^2>$ 3$ :$9A
:"2$: K"E?K>Y?3": 9" X$WE4K" @?2?
>3$95>D>E?2 4#? $pE$::>X? a4>9?3? 3"
2$J"Z4$ $ 5"#?2 ?: @2$E?4;\$: 9$A
E$::‘2>?: @?2? @?2‘AK"N
1?2? E"952?J?K?9;?2 " $D$>5" 3?
a4>9?3? 3" 2$J"Z4$] " :>:5$#? @"3$
2$34Y>2 ? @"5[9E>? 3" #"5"2 $ >95$2A
X>2 9?: 2"3?: $# Z4$:5<"N - :>:5$#?
.,8 ?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 4#?
X$Y 3$5$E5?3? ? a4>9?3? $pE$::>X? 3"
2$J"Z4$N
%
  * 67    
w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"] 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": E"#$;? ?
@>:E?2 ? K4YA$:@>? ] ? @"5[9E>?
3" #"5"2 ^ 2$34Y>3? $ @"3$ :$95>2
4#? D2$9?a$# $# E?3? 2"3?] ? :$a4>2
g 5$95?5>X? 3$ @?2?2 ? 3$22?@?3? 3"
2$J"Z4$N - :>:5$#? :h $:5‘ ?5>X" E"#
" +,8 K>a?3"N
*$:?5>X?93" " :>:5$#? +,8 q@2$::>A
"9?93" " J"5<" :>54?3" 9" E"9:"K$
0$’
E$952?Kr] ^ 5?#J^# 3$:?5>X?3" " :>:A
5$#? .,8N
!#!
+# E?:" 3$ 2$J"Z4$:] 2$E"#$93?A
:$ :$#@2$ " #‘p>#" E4>3?3" 342?95$
? E"934;<"N
!49E? 4K52?@?::?2 ?: E?2a?: #‘A
p>#?: @$2#>5>3?: qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" t1$:":t 9" E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^EA
9>E":trN
!#!
- :>:5$#? .,8 9<" ^ E?@?Y 3$ 3$A
5$2 4#? a4>9?3? 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 2$J"A
Z4$N
,$ " :>:5$#? :$ ?5>X?2 342?95$ ?
E"934;<"] 2$34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$] @?A
2?2 " X$WE4K" 94# K"E?K :$a42" $ E"A
K"E?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ? E?2a? @?2? >#A
@$3>2 ? a4>9?3? 3" 2$J"Z4$N
0$*
"!  / '' ,   & 4 ' 67    
 '0 / .- 0
1?2? b?J>K>5?2 " :>:5$#?] @2$::>"9?2
f @?25$ >95$a2?95$ 3" :>:5$#? +,8 $ " J"5<"  9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K 3"
5$# E"#" "J_$5>X" #?95$2 " X$WE4K" X$WE4K"N
? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ 342?95$
4#? 3$:E>3?] ?54?93" 3$ D"2#? ?45vA
9"#? $ 3>D$2$9E>?3? 9": D2$>":N
*$::$ #"3"] ^ a?2?95>3? ? $:5?A
J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" $ ? Z4>K"#$52?A
a$# $# @K$9? :$a42?9;? :"J2$543"
$# E"93>;\$: 3$ J?>p? ?3$2[9E>? $
>9EK>9?;\$: $K$X?3?:N
- :>:5$#? @"3$ $9E"952?2A:$ $#
52[: #"3?K>3?3$: 3>D$2$95$:%
 ' 5 % " :>:5$#? $:5‘ 3$:?5>A - :>:5$#? b?J>K>5?A:$ :$ D"2$# :?A
X?3"N 5>:D$>5?: ?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
  5) " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X?3"
 ,$ " J"5<" 9? #"3?K>3?3$ I¤*
$ @2"95" @?2? >95$2X>2 Z4?93" ?:
)-¤ $:5>X$2 ?E>"9?3"N
E"93>;\$: 3$ ?5>X?;<" $:5>X$2$#
:?5>:D$>5?:N  ’ X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" D"2 >9D$A
2>"2 ? L6 i#obN
 ! *) " :>:5$#? E"952"K? ?5>X?A
#$95$ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"N  - D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^A
52>E" q+1Br $:5>X$2 3$:$9a?5?3"N
 ’ @"25? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2 $:5>A
X$2 D$Eb?3?N
! *67    
(#? X$Y b?J>K>5?3"] " :>:5$#?
T*8 ?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ :$ "
X$WE4K" D"2 E"934Y>3" 94#? 3$:E>3?
E"# >9EK>9?;<" :4D>E>$95$#$95$ ?K5?]
:4@$2>"2 ? ~sN
’ ?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?K?3?
@$K" ?E$93>#$95"] E"# K4Y D>p?] 3"
WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yN
’ X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3? @?2? " :>:A
5$#? T*8 @"3$ :$2 2$a4K?3? ?52?X^:
3" @$3?K 3" D2$>" $ 3" ?E$K$2?3"2 q9"
>95$2X?K" 3$ 7 i#ob ? L6 i#obrN (#?
X$Y ?5>9a>3? ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$:$_?3?]
:"K5?93" ?#J": ": @$3?>:] " :>:5$#?
T*8 #?95$2‘ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3?N
*$::$ #"3"] " E"9345"2 @"3$ 2$a4A
K?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"] 2$A
5"#?2 " E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K"N
8"# ? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" $#
@"95" #"25"] ? 2$a4K?a$# 3? X$K"E>A
3?3$ ?52?X^: 3" @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2
9<" $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$KN
- E"9345"2 @"3$ ?94K?2 ? Z4?KZ4$2
#"#$95" ? >95$2X$9;<" 3" :>:5$#?
T*8 @2$::>"9?93" ? D493" " @$3?K
3" ?E$K$2?3"2 "4 3" D2$>"N
 *67    
- :>:5$#? T*8 ^ 3$:?5>X?3"] #?:
@$2#?9$E$ 3>:@"9WX$K] :$ D"2 X$2>D>A
E?3? 4#? 3?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
 ’ X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 4K52?@?:A
:?2 ": L6 i#ob #?: @$2#?9$E$2
>9D$2>"2 ? IG i#obN
 - X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 94#? 3$:E>3?
E"# >9EK>9?;<" 9<" :4D>E>$95$]
>9D$2>"2 ? ~s] "4 $:5>X$2 $# 4#
5$22$9" @K?9" "4 94#? $:52?3?
$# :4J>3?
 ’ ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘A
5>E" $:5>X$2 9? @":>;<" 1 q+:5?E>"A
9?#$95"rN
4 ' 67    
 12$::<" 3" J"5<" qD>a42? ?95$2>"2rN
 ’5>X?;<" 3$ 4#? #"3?K>3?3$ 3>A
D$2$95$ 3$ I¤* )-¤N
 ’J$2542? 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3"
E"9345"2N
 ,4@$2?;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ IG
i#ob q:?W3? >#$3>?5? 3? D49;<"
T*8rN
’ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?A
K?3? @$K" ?E$93>#$95"] E"# K4Y >9A
5$2#>5$95$] 3" WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?yN
!#!
(#? 45>K>Y?;<" @2"K"9a?3? 3"
:>:5$#? @"3$ K$X?2 ?" :4@$2?Z4$E>A
#$95" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$#N
+# E?:" 3$ :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3":
D2$>":] " :>:5$#? T*8] :$ ?5>X"] :$2‘
a2?34?K#$95$ 3$:?5>X?3" ?@h: "@"2A
549? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?" E"9345"2 q?@?a?A
:$ " )+* 9" J"5<"rd :h :$2‘ @"::WA
%
X$K 2$?5>X‘AK" Z4?93" ? 5$#@$2?542?
3": D2$>": 5>X$2 3$:E>3" " :4D>E>$95$N
’ 3>:5e9E>? @$2E"22WX$K 3$@$93$ 3?
5$#@$2?542? 3": D2$>": $] ?::>#] 3?
>9EK>9?;<"] 3? E?2a? $ 3? X$K"E>3?3$
3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
- 3$:$#@$9b" 3$ 4# X$WE4K"
$Z4>@?3" E"# T*8 949E? 3$X$ :$2
0$+
E"K"E?3" g @2"X? 3$ #"3" >9E?45" $
@$2>a":"N
!<" E"K"Z4$ $# @$2>a" :4? :$a4A
2?9;? $ 3$ "452?: @$::"?:N
"! !% /!  &',[ % [ 5
F 0
.2?5?A:$ 3$ 4# :>:5$#?] @?25$ >95$A
a2?95$ 3" :>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$#] Z4$
$X>5?] E"# Z4?>:Z4$2 E"93>;\$: 3"
@>:" 3? $:52?3? $ 3$ >95$9:>3?3$ 3?
?;<" 3$ D2$9?a$#] " JK"Z4$>" $ ?
E"9:$Z4$95$ @?5>9?;<" 3$ 4#? "4
#?>: 2"3?:] a?2?95>93"] 3$:5$ #"3"]
" E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K" #$:#" 9?: D2$A
9?a$9: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? $ "5>#>Y?93"
": $:@?;": 3$ D2$9?a$#N
- :>:5$#? >95$2X^# 9? D2$9?a$#]
Z4?93" ?: 2"3?: $:5<" @2hp>#?: 3"
JK"Z4$>"] 5>@>E?#$95$ $# E"93>;\$:
3$ D2$9?a$9: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? "4 $#
E"93>;\$: 3$ J?>p? ?3$2[9E>?] "93$
": JK"Z4$>": @"3$# :$2 #?>: D2$A
Z4$95$:N
- :>:5$#? ?4#$95? 5?#J^# ? E"9A
52"K?J>K>3?3$ $ $:5?J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K" :$ ? D2$9?a$# :$ X$2>D>E?2 94#?
0$,
:4@$2DWE>$ E"# ?3$2[9E>? 3>D$2$9E>A
?3? $952$ ?: 2"3?: 3" K?3" 3>2$>5" $
3" K?3" $:Z4$23" "4 9?: E42X?:N
8"#@K$5? " :>:5$#?] " :>:5$#?
+B* q+K$E52"9>E B2?i>9a D"2E$
*>:52>J45>"9r] Z4$ @$2#>5$ 2$@?25>2
? ?;<" 3$ D2$9?a$# $952$ ?: 2"3?:
3>?95$>2?: $ 52?:$>2?:N
  * 67    
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3" ’B, ^ 3$5$E5‘A
X$K ?52?X^: 3$ 4#? K>a$>2? @4K:?;<"
3" @$3?K 3" D2$>"] ?E"#@?9b?3? 3$
24W3"% $:5$ ^ 4# E"#@"25?#$95" @$2A
D$>5?#$95$ 9"2#?K 3" :>:5$#? $# D?:$
3$ >95$2X$9;<"N
!#!
w4?93" " ’B, >95$2X>$2] $ :$ :$95>2
?: @4K:?;\$: 3" @$3?K 3" D2$>"] 9<"
?K>X>?2 ? @2$::<"] #?: #?95$2 " @$3?K
5"5?K#$95$ @2$::>"9?3" :$# 2$E$>"N
*$::? D"2#?] "J5^#A:$ 4# $:@?;"
3$ D2$9?a$# >3$?K $ E"#@?5WX$K E"#
?: E"93>;\$: 3" @>:" 3? $:52?3?N
!#!
1?2? 5$2 ? #‘p>#? $D>E>[9E>? 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$# ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 4#
@$2W"3" 3$ ?::$95?#$95" 3$ ?@2"p>A
#?3?#$95$ 6GG i#N
*42?95$ $::$ @$2W"3" ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘A
X$K 9<" $D$54?2 D2$9?a$9: #4>5" J24:A
E?:] 2$@$5>3?: $ @2"K"9a?3?:N
!#!
,$ " ’B, >95$2X>$2] ^ :>9?K Z4$ :$
$:5‘ ?5>9a>93" " K>#>5$ 3$ ?3$2[9E>?
$952$ ": @9$4: $ " @>:" 3? $:52?3?N
f 9$E$::‘2>" 2$34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$
@?2? ?3?@5?2 ? #?2Eb? g ?3$2[9E>?
3>:@"9WX$KN
!#!
- :>:5$#? ’B, 9<" @"3$ E"952?A
2>?2 ?: K$>: 9?542?>: 3? PW:>E? $ 9<"
@"3$ ?4#$95?2 ? ?3$2[9E>? 3$@$9A
3$95$ 3?: E"93>;\$: 3? $:52?3?N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# @243[9E>? $
?5$9;<"N
!#!
- :>:5$#? ’B, 9<" @"3$ $X>5?2 ?E>A
3$95$:] >9EK4>93" ": 3$X>3": ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ $pE$::>X? $# E42X?] E"934A
;<" $# :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ J?>p? ?3$2[9A
E>? "4 ?Z4?@K?9?a$#N
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K? :$a42?9;?
9? $:52?3? @$25$9E$ :$#@2$ ?" E"9A
345"2N
!#!
’: E?@?E>3?3$: 3" :>:5$#? ’B,
949E? 3$X$# :$2 5$:5?3?: 3$ D"2#?
>22$:@"9:‘X$K $ @$2>a":?N
!<" E"K"Z4$ $# @$2>a" :4? :$a4A
2?9;? $ 3$ "452?: @$::"?:N
!#!
1?2? " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
:>:5$#? ’B,] ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K Z4$ ":
@9$4: :$_?# 3? #$:#? #?2E? $ 3"
#$:#" 5>@" $# 5"3?: ?: 2"3?:N
’K^# 3>::"] ": @9$4: 3$X$# 5$2
@2>9E>@?K#$95$ " 5>@"] ?: 3>#$9:\$:]
$:5?2 E?K>J2?3": E"9D"2#$ 2$E"#$9A
3?3" 9$:5$ #?94?K $ $# @$2D$>5?:
E"93>;\$: 3$ E"9:$2X?;<"N
!%!  "! 
+# D49;<" 3?: X$2:\$:] $p>:5$# ?5^
H #"3": 3$ E"9D>a42?;<" 3" :>:5$#?
+,8 @2$:$95$: 9" X$WE4K"%
 ,>:5$#? b?J>K>5?3"
 ,>:5$#? @?2E>?K#$95$
3$:?J>K>5?3"
 ,>:5$#? 3$:?J>K>5?3"
   G4 ' 
+:5$ ^ " #"3" 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"
9"2#?K 342?95$ ? E"934;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
- :>:5$#? $:5?2‘ 9? #"3?K>3?3$
t,>:5$#? b?J>K>5?3"t ? E?3? @?25>3?
3" #"5"2N +:5$ #"3" 3$X$ :$2 45>K>A
Y?3" 9? #?>"2 @?25$ 3?: :>54?;\$: 3$
E"934;<"N

f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K :$K$E>"9?2 ?: #"A
3?K>3?3$: t,>:5$#? @?2E>?K#$95$ 3$A
:?J>K>5?3":t "4 t,>:5$#?: 3$:?J>K>5?A %
3":t ?@$9?: @"2 #"5>X": 3$ E"934A
;<" $:@$EWD>E":N
    , '   4 ' 
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" % 9"
@?>9$K E$952?K 342?95$ #$9": 3$ 6
:$a493":] 342?95$ ? #?2Eb? 3" X$WA
E4K"] ^ @"::WX$K K>#>5?2 ? >95$2X$9;<"
3": :>:5$#?: .8 $ +,8] " Z4$ @$2#>5$
Z4$ ?: 2"3$# a>2$# #?>: 3" Z4$ "
Z4$ ^ @$2#>5>3" 9"2#?K#$95$N +:5$
#"3" @"3$ :$2 u5>K Z4?93" " X$WE4K"
$:5>X$2 ?5"K?3"N
0$-

’ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" #"3" ^ ?::>9?A
K?3? @$K" ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": q$#
?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] _495?#$95$ E"# ?
X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 9"
3>:@K?yrN
1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " #"3" t,>:5$#?
b?J>K>5?3"t 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"] @2$:A
:>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" N 3" 3$:$#@$9b" 9?: #"3?K>3?3$:
- #"3" t,>:5$#? b?J>K>5?3"t :$2‘
2$?5>X?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ? E?3?
@?25>3? 3" #"5"2N
0$!.
   4 ' 
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" 342?95$
#?>: 3$ 6 :$a493":] :$2‘ E"#@K$5?A
#$95$ 3$:K>a?3" " :>:5$#? +,8] ?K^#
3": :>:5$#?: .8] .,8 $ +C&d " :>:A
5$#? .8 :$2‘ K>#>5?3" ?@$9?: g ?;<"
3$ D2$9?a$# $# E?3? 2"3? #"52>YN
’ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" #"3" ^ ?::>9?A
K?3" @$K" ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": q$#
?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] _495?#$95$ E"# ?
X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 9"
3>:@K?yrN

’" 4K52?@?::?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$
E$2E? 3$ F6 i#ob] ": :>:5$#?: :$
E"#@"25?# E"#" 3$:E2>5" @?2?
" #"3" t,>:5$#? @?2E>?K#$95$
3$:?J>K>5?3"tN
1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " #"3"t,>:5$#?
b?J>K>5?3"t] @2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ "
J"5<" N
- #"3" t,>:5$#? b?J>K>5?3"t :$2‘
2$?5>X?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ? E?3?
@?25>3? 3" #"5"2N
 H .-  ,     *
',&  a
!?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# 3>:@"A
:>5>X" ,$K$EA.$22?>9£] ? ?5>X?;<" 3$
?Ka4#?: #"3?K>3?3$: 3$ E"934;<"
@2$X[ ? 3$:?5>X?;<" @?2E>?K "4 5"5?K
3$ ?Ka49: :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>A
X":] ? D># 3$ "5>#>Y?2 " 3$:$#@$9b"
9? #"3?K>3?3$ $:@$EWD>E?N
8"# 3$:?5>X?;<" @?2E>?K "4 5"5?K
3": :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>X": 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] ?E$93$A:$ ?
K4YA$:@>? N
!?: #"3?K>3?3$: t,’!*t $
t&(*t] ": :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>A
X": :<" @?2E>?K#$95$ 3$:?J>K>5?3": $
@2$@?2?3": @?2? a?2?95>2 " #‘p>#"
3$ D49E>"9?#$95" $:@$EWD>E?:N +#
5"3" " E?:"] ^ @"::WX$K 2$?5>X‘AK":
E"#@K$5?#$95$ ? Z4?KZ4$2 #"A
#$95" @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<" 9"
E"9:"K$ E$952?K E?:" :$ @2$5$93?
@2>X>K$a>?2 ? :$a42?9;? 2$K?5>X?#$95$
?": 3$:$#@$9b": t"DDA2"?3tN


!?: #"3?K>3?3$: I¤* )-¤] ":
:>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;? ?5>X": :<" @?2A
E>?K#$95$ 3$:?J>K>5?3":] ? D># 3$ a?A
2?95>2 " #‘p>#" 3$:$#@$9b" $# "DDA
2"?3 $ 9<" :$2‘ @"::WX$K 2$?5>X‘AK":N
!#!
w4?93" ? #"3?K>3?3$ t,>:5$#?:
@?2E>?K#$95$ 3$:?J>K>5?3":t ^ :$K$E>A
"9?3?] ? >95$2X$9;<" 3? D49;<" .8
K>#>5?A:$ ?@$9?: g ?;<" 3$ D2$9?a$#
$# E?3? 2"3? #"52>Y $ ? K4YA$:@>?
?E$93$A:$ 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$9A
5":N
!? #"3?K>3?3$ t,>:5$#?: @?2E>?KA
#$95$ 3$:?J>K>5?3":t] " X?K"2 3$ 5"2A
Z4$ 3" #"5"2 Z4$ @"3$ $p>a>2 " :>:A
5$#? +,8 9<" :$2‘ a?2?95>3" $] ?:A
:>#] ? $:5?J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" :$2‘
2$34Y>3?N
!#!
8"# ? #"3?K>3?3$ t,>:5$#?:
@?2E>?K#$95$ 3$:?J>K>5?3":t :$K$E>"A
9?3?] " :>:5$#? .,8 q.2?>K$2 ,j?y
8"952"Kr ^ 3$:?J>K>5?3"N
*>2>_? E"# ?5$9;<" $ @243[9E>?N
!#!
- $:5>K" 3$ E"934;<" 3$X$ :$2 :$#A
@2$ ?3$Z4?3" g: E"93>;\$: 3" @>:"
3? $:52?3?] g X>:>J>K>3?3$ $ ?" 52e9A
:>5"N
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K? :$a42?9;?
9? $:52?3? @$25$9E$ :$#@2$ ?" E"9A
345"2N
!#!
w4?93" ? #"3?K>3?3$ t,>:5$#?:
3$:?J>K>5?3":t ^ :$K$E>"9?3?] $#
E?:" 3$ #?9"J2?: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] "
:>:5$#? +,8 9<" $:5?2‘ 3>:@"9WX$KN
’ #"3?K>3?3$ t,>:5$#?: 3$:?J>K>A
5?3":t :h 3$X$ :$2 E"9:>3$2?3? @?2?
4#? 45>K>Y?;<" D"2? 3$ $:52?3?N
"! %" /%'    " &
50 / .- 0
- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# :>:5$#? 3$ #"9>5"2?#$95" 3$
@"95": E$a": qB,&r] Z4$] ?52?X^: 3$
:$9:"2$: >9:5?K?3":] 3$5$E5? X$WE4K":
qE?22":] E?#>9b\$:] #"5"E>EK$5?:]
$5Er Z4$ $952?# 9?: Y"9?: 3$ @"95": %
E$a": ?52‘:] g D2$95$ "4 @$K?: K?5$2?>:
3" E"9345"2N
’@h: ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2] ?: K4Y$:
3$ ?3X$25[9E>? 3" :>:5$#? B,& 3$A
X$# :$ ?E$93$2 @"2 ?Ka49: >9:5?95$:
0$!!
9": 3">: 2$52"X>:"2$:] E"9D>2#?93"
Z4$ " :>:5$#? $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K $ "@$A
2?95$N
- :>:5$#? B,& "@$2? Z4?93" "
X$WE4K" $:5‘ $# Z4?KZ4$2 #?2Eb?] >9A
EK4>93" ? 2^] $ $952? $# #"3"  
 Z4?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" ^
@":>E>"9?3? $# N
’: Y"9?: E"J$25?: @$K" :>:5$#? E"A
J2$# ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ ? K?2a42? 3$
4#? D?>p? 3$ 52‘D$a" 3$ E?3? K?3" 3"
X$WE4K" qH]~ #rN ’ E"J$2542? K"9a>A
543>9?K E"#$;? 9" 2$52"X>:"2 $p5$29"
$ :$ $:5$93$ @"2 ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$
H #$52": ?K^# 3" @?2?AEb"Z4$: 52?A
:$>2"N - :>:5$#? #"9>5"2? ?: Y"9?:
3$:E2>5?: E"# " X$WE4K" $# X$K"E>A
3?3$: ? @?25>2 3$ 7G i#ob $ ?K$25? "
E"9345"2 :"J2$ "452": X$WE4K": 9$:A
:?: ‘2$?:N

’: ‘2$?: E"J$25?: @$K" :>:5$#? B,&
9<" :$ ?K5$2?# :$ " :$4 X$WE4K" $:5>A
X$2 2$J"E?93" Z4?KZ4$2 5>@" 3$ ?52$A
K?3"N 1"25?95"] :$#@2$ X$2>D>Z4$ X>A
:4?K#$95$ ?: D?>p?: ?3_?E$95$: ?95$:
3$ 3?2 >9WE>" ? Z4?KZ4$2 #?9"J2?
E"# " X$WE4K" 9$::?: E"93>;\$:N
8?:" ? $p5$9:<" K?5$2?K 3" X$WE4K"
:$_? :4@$2?3? @$K" ?52$K?3"] ? K4Y
3$ ?3X$25[9E>? 3" :>:5$#? B,& :$
#?95$2‘ ?E$:? 342?95$ 5"3" " 5$#@"
3$ 3>2$;<"N
!<" ^ @"::WX$K 3$:?5>X?2 " #"9>A
5"2?#$95" 3$ @"95" E$a" qB,&r] $9A
Z4?95" " ,>:5$#? 3$ ?X>:" 3$ ?D?:A
5?#$95" 3$ D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$# q)?9$
*$@?2542$ ¤?29>9a ,y:5$# A )*¤,r
$:5>X$2 b?J>K>5?3"N
!'     
- :>:5$#? B,& $p>J$ 4# ?K$25?
X>:4?K 9" 2$52"X>:"2 E"22$:@"93$95$
?" K?3" @$K" Z4?K :$ ?@2"p>#? "
X$WE4K" 3$5$E5?3" $ 4# ?K$25? :"9"2"
Z4$ 5?#J^# $#43$E$ " ‘43>" 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ :"#] E?:" $:5$_? K>a?3"N
- :>:5$#? #"9>5"2? ? Y"9? 3$ 3$A
5$E;<" 3$ 52[: 3>D$2$95$: @"95": 3$
$952?3? qK?5$2?K] 52?:$>2? $ D2$95$r $9A
Z4?95" " X$WE4K" ^ E"934Y>3" @?2?
?X?K>?2 ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ ?K$25?:] Z4$
:$2<" $#>5>3": 342?95$ $::$: 5>@": 3$
$952?3? $# E?3? Y"9?N

!<" JK"Z4$?2 ? ‘2$? "93$ ": :$9A


- :>:5$#? B,& 9<" ?K$25? " E"9A
345"2 :"J2$ X$WE4K": :$ ?@2"p>#?93"
$# ?K5?: X$K"E>3?3$: "4 D"2? 3?: Y"A
9?: 3$ 3$5$E;<"N
0$!"
:"2$: $:5<" >9:5?K?3": E"# "J_$5":
E"#" ?3$:>X": 3$ @?2?AEb"Z4$]
2?Ei: 3$ J>E>EK$5? "4 ?D>9:N ’ ‘2$?
52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K" 3$X$ $:5?2 :$#@2$
K>X2$ 3$ K?#?] 9$X$] a$K" $ Z4?KZ4$2
:4_$>2? @?2? Z4$ " :>:5$#? B,&
D49E>"9$ ?3$Z4?3?#$95$N
+,-'   (   ' '& '  5  E$2E? 3$ L6 i#ob] ? K4YA$:@>? 9<" :$
 ?E$93$N
’" 4K52?@?::?2 K$95?#$95$ "452"
X$WE4K" qE"# 3>D$2$9;? 3$ X$K"E>A
3?3$ >9D$2>"2 ? E$2E? 3$ 76 i#obr $ 4^ 3 (
$:5$ @$2#?9$E$2 9" @"95" E$a" 34A
2?95$ E$2E? 3$ 7]6 :$a493":] ? K4YA
$:@>? 9" $:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 $p5$29"
3" K?3" E"22$:@"93$95$ :$ ?E$93$N

+,-'   (     P
- :>:5$#? 9<" ?::>9?K? ? @2$:$9;?
3$ "J_$5": D>p": q@"2 $pN @K?E?:]
@":5$:] #42":] J?22?9E": 9" ?E":5?A %
#$95"] $5ENrN !" $95?95"] $# ?Ka4A
#?: "E?:>\$:] " :>:5$#? @"3$ ?5>X?2A
:$ 9? @2$:$9;? 3$::$: "J_$5":N +::$
E"#@"25?#$95" ^ 9"2#?K $ 9<" >9A
3>E? 4#? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#?N
- :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? X$WE4K": Z4$ :$
?@2"p>#?# 3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WA
E4K" 3$ ?#J": ": K?3": $ $952?# 9?
‘2$? 3$ 3$5$E;<" 52?:$>2? E"# 4#?
3>D$2$9;? 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ 2$K?5>X? ?"
@2h@2>" X$WE4K" >9D$2>"2 ? 6G i#obN
,$ ? 3>D$2$9;? $952$ ? X$K"E>3?3$
3": 3">: X$WE4K": D"2 :4@$2>"2 ?

0$!%
 P35      
- :>:5$#? 9<" ?X>:? " #"5"2>:5? 3?
@2$:$9;? 3$ X$WE4K": Z4$ X>?_?# 9"
:$95>3" E"952‘2>" ?" 3" @2h@2>" X$WA
E4K"] 9?: D?>p?: 3$ 2"3?a$# ?3_?E$9A
5$:N
!#!
- :>:5$#? 3$ #"9>5"2?#$95" 3$
@"95": E$a": qB,&r ^ ?@$9?: 4# :4A
@"25$ @?2? ?4p>K>?2 ? 3$5$E;<" 3$ "JA
_$5": 9?: Y"9?: 3$ @"95": E$a":N -
:>:5$#? 9<" D"> 3$:$9X"KX>3" @?2? 3$A
5$E5?2 @$3$:52$:] E>EK>:5?: "4 ?9>#?>:N
&$:#" " :$4 X$WE4K" :$93" $Z4>A
@?3" E"# " :>:5$#? B,&] #?95$9b?A
:$ :$#@2$ ?5$95" ?": 2$52"X>:"2$:]
"Kb$ @?2? ": K?3": $ 4:$ ": >93>E?A
0$!&
3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" ?95$: 3$ 52"E?: 3$
D?>p?:N
*$>p?2 3$ :$a4>2 $::?: ?;\$: @"3$
K$X?2 ? D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ ?5^ ?
#"25$ 3": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K" $o"4
3$ 5$2E$>2":N
    /   G &
,  0
+:5$ :>:5$#? ?_43? " #"5"2>:5? 9?:
#?9"J2?: $# #?2Eb? ? 2^ $# E?:"
3$ X>:>J>K>3?3$ 2$34Y>3?N
- :>:5$#? C81 E"952"K? ?: ‘2$?: 3$
3$5$E;<" 52?:$>2?: $# ?#J": ": K?A
3": 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? 3$5$E5?2 ": "JA
_$5": Z4$ :$ 3$:K"E?# @?2? ": K?3":
3" X$WE4K" ? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ #W9>#?
3$ ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ 6 i#ob $ ": "JA
_$5": Z4$ :$ 3$:K"E?# ? 4#? X$K"E>A
3?3$ #‘p>#? 3$ E$2E? 3$ HG i#ob]
E"#" "E"22$ a$2?K#$95$ 9": $:5?E>"A
9?#$95":N
’ ?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?K?3?
?" E"9345"2 ?52?X^: 3$ 4# >93>E?;<"
X>:4?K $ ?Eu:5>E?] E"# 2$34;<" 3"
X"K4#$ 3" 2‘3>" Z4?93" K>a?3"N

,$ ": :$9:"2$: $:5>X$2$# E"J$25":
@"2 "J:5‘E4K": "4 @"2 X$WE4K":] "
:>:5$#? 9<" ?X>:?2‘ " E"9345"2N
!#!
- C81 9<" ^ 4# :>:5$#? 3$ ?_43?
g #?2Eb? ? 2^N ,4? 3$:5>9?;<" ^ :$2
4:?3" @?2? ?4p>K>?2 " E"9345"2 ? 3$A
5$E5?2 4# X$WE4K" X>93" $# :4? 3>A
2$;<" $ 9<" D"> 3$:$9X"KX>3" @?2?
3$5$E5?2 @$3$:52$:] E>EK>:5?: "4 ?9>A
#?>:N ,$#@2$ X$2>D>Z4$ ? 52?:$>2? 3"
X$WE4K" @"2 E"#@K$5"] "Kb$ ?52‘: 3$
X"E[ $ E$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$ Z4$ 9<" b?_?
@$3$:52$:] ?9>#?>:] "452": X$WE4K":]
"J:524;\$: $ "J_$5": 9": @"95": E$A
a": ?95$: 3$ 3?2 2^N
*$>p?2 3$ :$a4>2 $::?: ?;\$: @"3$
K$X?2 ? D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ ?5^ ?
#"25$ 3": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K" $o"4
3$ 5$2E$>2":N
"'   3- ,    
!?: E"9D>a42?;\$: 3" :>:5$#?] ^
@"::WX$K :$K$E>"9?2 ": #"3": 3$
?K$25? $952$ ?: "@;\$: 3$ ?@$9?:
K4Y$: 3$ ?K$25? X>:4?K] K4Y$: $ ?X>:":
:"9"2": E"#J>9?3": $ 5"3": ":
?K$25?: 3$:K>a?3":N
!   '  * - 
w4?93" $:5? #"3?K>3?3$ $:5‘
?5>X?] " :>:5$#? B,& $9X>? 4#?
:>9?K>Y?;<" X>:4?K @?2? " $:@$Kb" 2$A
52"X>:"2 K?5$2?K ?D$5?3" @$K? @2$:$9;?
3" "J_$5" 3$5$E5?3"N
!" $95?95"] 342?95$ " D49E>"9?A
#$95" 9? #"3?K>3?3$ C81] " :>:A
5$#? @2"34Y ?K?2#$: X>:4?>: $ ?Eu:A
5>E": Z4?93" ^ 3$5$E5?3? ? @2$:$9;?
3$ 4# "J_$5" 9?: @2"p>#>3?3$:N
w4?93" ^ $#>5>3? ? :>9?K>Y?;<"
?Eu:5>E?] " X"K4#$ 3" (E"99$E5£ ^
2$34Y>3"N
!'  * -   ,b ,
w4?93" $:5? #"3?K>3?3$ $:5‘
?5>X?] " :>:5$#? B,& $9X>? 4#?
:>9?K>Y?;<" X>:4?K @?2? " $:@$Kb" 2$A
52"X>:"2 K?5$2?K ?D$5?3" @$K? @2$:$9;?
3" "J_$5" 3$5$E5?3"N
w4?93" "E"22$ ? ?5>X?;<" 3" >93>A
E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" 9" K?3" E"22$:@"9A
3$95$ gZ4$K$ "93$ D"> 3$5$E5?3" 4#
"J:5‘E4K"] ^ 5?#J^# $#>5>3? 4#? :>A
9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?N
*42?95$ ? $#>::<" 3? :>9?K>Y?;<"
?Eu:5>E?] " X"K4#$ 3" (E"99$E5£ ^
@":5$2>"2#$95$ 2$34Y>3"N
!'   *
w4?93" " :>:5$#? ^ 3$:?5>X?3"
q#"3?K>3?3$ t’X>:" 3$ e9a4K" E$a"t
$# t-PPtr] ": :>:5$#?: B,& "4 C81
9<" $#>5>2<" 9$# :>9?K>Y?;\$: ?Eu:A
5>E?: 9$# X>:4?>:N
- :>:5$#? B,& #$#"2>Y?2‘ ? #"A
3?K>3?3$ 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" $# 45>A
K>Y?;<" 9" #"#$95" 3? 3$:?5>X?;<"
3" #"5"2N ’ E?3? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2]
? #"3?K>3?3$ ?95$2>"2#$95$ #$#"A %
2>Y?3? :$2‘ :$K$E>"9?3? $ 45>K>Y?3?N
"! R / \  ''  
R 50 / .- 0
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?K$25? 3$ E"K>:<" D2"9A
5?K qP8¤r E?KE4K? ? @2"J?J>K>3?3$
3$ 4#? E"K>:<" ?52?X^: 3" #"9>5"A
2?#$95" 3? 3>:5e9E>? 3" X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95" ? "J:5‘E4K": $] 3$ ?E"23"
E"# ? :>54?;<" $ :4?: E"9D>a42?;\$:]
a$2? ?X>:": :"9"2": $ X>:4?>: "2>$9A
5?93" ? >95$2X$9;<" 3" E"9345"2 $
@"3$ ?54?2 9" :>:5$#? 3$ D2$>": @?2?
0$!’
3?2 5$#@" :4D>E>$95$ ?" E"9345"2 3$
2$?a>2 $ #>5>a?2 ? @"5$9E>?K E"K>:<"N
8?:" " :>:5$#? 9<" 3$5$E5$ 2$?;<"
3" E"9345"2 $# 2$K?;<" ?": ?K$25?:
@2"a2$::>X":] ": D2$>": :$2<" ?5>X?3":
@?2? ?_43?2 ? 2$34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$
3" X$WE4K" $ #>5>a?2 4#? @"5$9E>?K
E"K>:<" D2"95?KN 8?:" " E"9345"2 2$?_?
?": ?K$25?: >9>E>?93" 4#? D2$9?a$#]
:$ " :>:5$#? 3$5$2#>9?2 Z4$ $p>:5$
? >95$9;<" 3$ $X>5?2 ? E"K>:<" #?:
? D"2;? ?@K>E?3? 9": D2$>": 9<" ^
:4D>E>$95$] 4#? D"2;? ?3>E>"9?K :$2‘
@2"X>3$9E>?3?] @2"X>3$9E>?93" 4#?
D2$9?a$# ?3>E>"9?KN
,$ 4#? :>54?;<" 3$ ?K$25? 3$ E"A
K>:<" D2"95?K E"#$;?2 ? 4#? X$K"E>A
3?3$ ?J?>p" 3$ E$2E? 3$ FL i#ob] "
:>:5$#? @"3$ $p$E45?2 ? #‘p>#? D2$A
9?a$# @"::WX$K @?2? #>5>a?2 ? E"K>:<"
$# @"5$9E>?KN 8?:" " X$WE4K" X$9b? ?
:$2 @?2?3" E"#@K$5?#$95$] " :>:5$#?
#?95$2‘ " X$WE4K" @?2?3" @"2 3">:
:$a493": $ $95<" K>J$2?2‘ ": D2$>":N
0$!*

!<" 5$:5?2 " :>:5$#? P8¤N 1?2?
$X>5?2 " 4:" 3$:2$a2?3"] ?@h: Z4?52"
$X$95": 3$ D2$9?a$# ?5>X? ? D49E>"A
9?K>3?3$ :$2‘ 3$:?5>X?3? ?5^ " @2hA
p>#" E>EK" 3$ Eb?X$N

w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$2#>9? Z4$
- :>:5$#? P8¤ ^ 3$:5>9?3" ?" 4:"
9<" $p>:5$ #?>: ? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 4#?
42J?9"N 1?2? " 4:" 3" X$WE4K" $#
E"K>:<" E"# " X$WE4K" g D2$95$] ?
@$2E42:": "DDA2"?3] " :>:5$#? 3$X$
#$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y :$2‘ 3$:?5>A
:$2 3$:?5>X?3" @?2? @2$X$9>2 ?K$25?:
X?3?N
3$:9$E$::‘2>":N


’ X$K"E>3?3$ #W9>#? @?2? ?5>X?A
;<" 3" :>:5$#? P8¤ ^ 3$ L i#obN w4?93" " P8¤ qP"2j?23 8"KK>:>"9
¤?29>9ar ^ 3$:?5>X?3"] " 1+B q1$A
3$:52>?9 +#$2a$9Ey B2?i>9ar ^ 3$:?A
 5>X?3" _495?#$95$ $ :"#$95$ @"3$2‘
- :>:5$#? P8¤ @"3$ 3$5$E5?2 3$ :$2 ?5>X?3" 9"X?#$95$] :$ " P8¤ D"2
D"2#? $Z4>X"E?3? $ @2"X$2 ?X>:" :"A ?5>X?3" @2>#$>2"N
9"2"] J$# E"#" D2$9?a$# 3>?95$ 3$
"J_$5": $:5?E>"9‘2>":] E"#" a2?3$:]
#42$5?: $ @K?E?:] $ 9<" ?@$9?: X$WA
E4K":N .?>: E"93>;\$: :<" @2$X>:5?: $
D?Y$# @?25$ 3" D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2A
#?K 3" :>:5$#?N
  5    5= ,  ,  
  / % &     &
5 ,F % [ 50
- :>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$# ?45"#‘5>E?
3$ $#$2a[9E>? @?2? #>5>a?2 E"K>:\$:
E"# 4:4‘2>": 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 52e9:>5"
^ 4#? 5$E9"K"a>? 3$ :$a42?9;? Z4$
D"29$E$ D2$9?a$# ?45"#‘5>E? @?2? "
X$WE4K"] Z4?93" ": @$3$:52$: $:5<"
$# :4? 52?_$5h2>? $ " E"9345"2 9<"
5"#"4 #$3>3?: :4D>E>$95$: @?2? $X>A
5?2 4#? E"K>:<" >#>9$95$N
- :>:5$#? 45>K>Y? >9D"2#?;\$: 3$
:$9:"2$: 3$ 2?3?2 $ Ee#$2?: 9? @?25$
3>?95$>2? 3" X$WE4K" @?2? ?@K>E?2 ?4A
5"#?5>E?#$95$ "4 E"#@K$#$95?2 ":
D2$>": $# :>54?;\$: $# Z4$ ^ 3$5$EA
5?3" 4# 4:4‘2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 52e9A
:>5" q@$3$:52$:] E>EK>:5?:] $5ENr $# @$A
2>a" >#>9$95$ 3$ :$2 ?52"@$K?3" @$K"
X$WE4K"N
-: E$9‘2>": E"#49: 3$ ?54?;<" 3"
:>:5$#?] "E"22$# Z4?93" ": 4:4‘2>":
3" :>:5$#? 3$ 52e9:>5" $ " X$WE4K"
$:5<" 9?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
 - X$WE4K" $:5‘ :$a4>93" $#
D2$95$ $ 4# @$3$:52$ ?52?X$::? ?
X>?N
 - X$WE4K" X?> X>2?2 g 3>2$>5? $ 4#
@$3$:52$ ?52?X$::? ? X>?N

’ 5$E9"K"a>? 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 3$5$EA
;<" 3$ @$3$:52$: 52?J?Kb? :"#$95$
3$952" 3": K>#>5$: 3" :>:5$#?N -
#?>"2 E"9D"25" "D$2$E>3" @$K" 3$5$EA
5"2 3$ @$3$:52$: 9<" 3$X$ 949E? E"A
K"E?2 ? :$a42?9;? $# 2>:E"] :$93" ?
2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @"2 D2$?2 $# 5$#@"
b‘J>K ^ :$#@2$ 3" E"9345"2N - 3$5$EA
5"2 3$ @$3$:52$: 9<" @"3$ $X>5?2 :"A
Y>9b" ?E>3$95$: $ D$2>#$95": a2?X$:N

- P8¤ @"3$ 2$?a>2 ? X$WE4K": $#
:>54?;\$: 3$ #"X>#$95" K$95" "4 @?A
2?3"N 1"2 $p$#@K"] " P8¤ @"3$
?54?2 $# :>54?;\$: $# Z4$ " X$WE4K"
%
:$a4>3" :?>2 3? :4? D?>p? @?2? #43?9A
;?: 3$ 3>2$;<" "4 $952?3?: $# $:5?A
E>"9?#$95" $ Z4$ ?>93? :$ $9E"952$
9" E?#@" 3$ X>:"2 3" :$9:"2N +:5$_?
:$#@2$ ?5$95" $ @2"95" @?2? 5"#?2 "
E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K"] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
0$!+


- $:5?3" @2$3$D>9>3" 3" :>:5$#?
1+B ^ :$#@2$ -! ?@h: E?3? E>EK" 3?
Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<"N
!'   3  5  -67 
3  
- :>:5$#? P8¤ $p>J$ 4# ?K$25?
X>:4?K 9" 3>:@K?y $ 4# ?K$25? :"9"2"
Z4$ 5?#J^# $#43$E$ " ‘43>" 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ :"#] E?:" $:5$_? K>a?3"N
!?: E"9D>a42?;\$: 3" :>:5$#?
P8¤] 9" #$94 3" :>:5$#? (E"9A
9$E5] ^ @"::WX$K :$K$E>"9?2 ": #"3":
3$ ?54?;<" $952$ ?: "@;\$:%
 t“43>" ¥ P2$>"t  @$2#>5>3":
?K$25?: $ D2$9?a$# 3$ #?9$>2?
0$!,
?45v9"#? "4 E"#" :4@"25$ ?3>A
E>"9?K E?:" ? ?54?;<" 3" E"934A
5"2 9": D2$>": 9<" :$ #":52$ :4A
D>E>$95$ $# $X$95": 3$ @"5$9E>?K
E"K>:<" D2"95?KN
 ’@$9?: ?K$25?:  #?95^# ": ?K$2A
5?:] #?: >#@$3$ Z4$ " :>:5$#?
?54$ 9? D2$9?a$# 3" X$WE4K"
 *$:K>a?3"  :$# ?K$25?: "4 Z4?KA
Z4$2 ?54?;<" 9? D2$9?a$# 3" X$WA
E4K"N
!#!
- :>:5$#? P8¤ 9<" :$ 3$:5>9?
? $X>5?2 4#? E"K>:<" :"Y>9b"] 5?#A
@"4E" ^ E?@?Y 3$ 3$5$E5?2 5"3": ":
5>@": 3$ @"5$9E>?>: E"K>:\$:N - E"9A
345"2 ^ >95$>2?#$95$ 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2
$X>5?2 4#? E"K>:<" #?95$93" " E"9A
52"K$ 3" X$WE4K" X>? D2$>": $ 3>2$;<"N
!<" ?5$95?2 @?2? >::" @"3$ K$X?2 ?
D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ ?5^ ? #"25$ 3":
"E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"N
.?#J^# ^ @"::WX$K 3$D>9>2 ? :$9A
:>J>K>3?3$ 3": ?K$25?: $# 2$K?;<" g
3>:5e9E>? 3" X$WE4K" @?2? ": "J:5‘E4A
K": 3$5$E5?3":] E"9D"2#$ 3$5?Kb?3"
? :$a4>2N
!'      4 '    
   67    
’: E"9D>a42?;\$: 3$ "@$2?;<" $ ?
:$9:>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? P8¤ @"3$#
:$2 ?K5$2?3?: ?52?X^: 3" #$94 3" :>:A
5$#? (E"99$E5 q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?A
;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWA
D>E"rN
1"2 @?32<"] " X$WE4K" :?> 3$ D‘J2>E?
E"# ? E"9D>a42?;<" 3$ :$9:>J>K>3?3$
3" P8¤ E"#" t&^3>?t] J$# E"#"
" #"3" 3$ ?54?;<" E"#" t“43>" ¥
P2$>"tN =::" @$2#>5$ Z4$ " :>:5$#?
?K$25$ " E"9345"2 :"J2$ 4#? @"::WX$K
E"K>:<" E"# " X$WE4K" g D2$95$ ?52?X^:
3$ ?K$25?: :"9"2": $ X>:4?>: $ ?@K>Z4$
D2$9?a$# ?45v9"#?N
’K5$2?93"A:$ " $:5?3" @?2? t)"9a$t
@$2#>5$ Z4$ " :>:5$#? ?K$25$ " E"934A
5"2 :"J2$ 4#? @"::WX$K E"K>:<" E"#
" X$WE4K" g D2$95$ ?52?X^: 3$ ?K$25?:
:"9"2": $ X>:4?>: Z4?93" $:5$ $:5‘ ?
4#? 3>:5e9E>? #?>"2 3" Z4$ 9? E"9A
D>a42?;<" t&^3>?tN =::" @2"@"2E>"9?
" #‘p>#" 3$ 5$#@" 3$ 2$?;<" @?2?
$X>5?2 4#? @"::WX$K E"K>:<"N
’K5$2?93"A:$ " $:5?3" @?2? t1$25"t
@$2#>5$ Z4$ " :>:5$#? ?K$25$ " E"934A
5"2 :"J2$ 4#? @"::WX$K E"K>:<" E"#
" X$WE4K" g D2$95$ ?52?X^: 3$ ?K$25?:
:"9"2": $ X>:4?>: Z4?93" $:5$ $:5‘ ?
4#? 3>:5e9E>? #4>5" #?>: @2hp>#?N
=::" @2"@"2E>"9? #$9": 5$#@" 3$ 2$A
?;<" 3" Z4$ ?: E"9D>a42?;\$: t&^A
3>?t $ t)"9a$t] " Z4$ @$2#>5$ 4#? $pA
@$2>[9E>? 3$ 3>2$;<" #?>: 3>9e#>E?N

- $:5?3" @2$3$D>9>3" 3" :>:5$#? ^
:$#@2$ -! ?@h: E?3? E>EK" 3? Eb?X$
3$ >a9>;<"N
- :>:5$#? 9<" 2$5^# ? uK5>#? E"9A
D>a42?;<" :$K$E>"9?3? @$K" E"9345"2
?@h: " X$WE4K" :$2 3$:K>a?3"N - :>:A
5$#? :$#@2$ X"K5?2‘ g E"9D>a42?;<"
@?32<" qt1+B -9t $ ?K$25?: t“43>" ¥
P2$>"tr Z4?93" " X$WE4K" D"2 9"X?A
#$95$ K>a?3"N

- :>:5$#? P8¤ @"3$ 2$?a>2 3$
D"2#? $Z4>X"E?3? ? "J_$5": >22$K$A
X?95$:] E"#" "J_$5": :4:@$9:": $#
?K542? $K$X?3?] 2$DK$5"2$: 9? X>?] "JA
_$5": D"2? 3" E?#>9b" 3" X$WE4K"]
"J_$5": $:5‘5>E": 3>:5?95$:] 52‘D$a" 9"
K?3" "@":5" 3? X>? "4 X$WE4K": g
D2$95$ Z4$ $:5$_?# g #$:#? X$K"E>A
3?3$ "4 #?>: 2‘@>3":N

- :>:5$#? P8¤] _495" E"# " ’88]
@"3$ :$2 3$:?J>K>5?3" #":52?93" ?KA
a4#?: 3?: :$a4>95$: 5$K?:%
!'   -67 ' 
8?:" " 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95": @?::$ ? $p>J>2 4#? #$9:?A
a$# >93>E?93" D49E>"9?K>3?3$ K>#>A
5?3?] " X$WE4K" ?>93? @"3$ :$2 E"9A
34Y>3" 9"2#?K#$95$N ’@$:?2 3>::"] ?
D2$9?a$# ?5>X? @"3$ 9<" $:5?2 E"#A
@K$5?#$95$ 3>:@"9WX$KN (#? X$Y Z4$
? E"93>;<" 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2 K>#>5?2 ?
?54?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 9<" $:5>X$2 #?>:
@2$:$95$] :$4 $:5?3" 3$ @K$9" 3$A
:$#@$9b" :$2‘ 2$5"#?3"N 12"E42?2 ?
  ! = ,  > :$ ? #$9A
:?a$# @$2:>:5>2N
!'   * 
8?:" " :>:5$#? :$ 3$:K>a4$ $ 3>:A
@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": @?::$
? $p>J>2 4#? #$9:?a$# 3$ >93>:@"A
9>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? P8¤] >::" >9A
3>E? Z4$ b‘ 4#? D?Kb? >95$29? 9" :>:A
5$#?N +#J"2? " X$WE4K" ?>93? @"::?
:$2 E"934Y>3" 9"2#?K#$95$] ^ 2$E"A
#$93‘X$K E"9:4K5?2 ?   ! &
= ,  > @?2? Eb$E?2 " :>:5$#?N
%
"! ! / 33 ,  5 ! 0 &
! = ,    , G,   
',   ]   / .- 0
- ,>:5$#? 3$ 2$E"9b$E>#$95" 3$
@K?E?: 3$ 52e9:>5" A .,’ q.2?DD>E ,>a9
’::>:5r 4:? 4#? Ee#$2? #"95?3?
9" @?2?AJ2>:?] J$# E"#" 3?3":
3" #?@? Z4?93" " X$WE4K" $:5‘
$Z4>@?3" E"# 9?X$a?;<" q:"#$95$
X$WE4K": $Z4>@?3": E"# (E"99$E5
C7 7GN7 T>abr] @?2? 3$5$E5?2 :>9?>:
3$ 52e9:>5" 2$E"9b$EWX$>:] E"#"%
0$!-
 )>#>5$: 3$ X$K"E>3?3$

- :>:5$#? .,’ $p>J>2‘ ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$ " :>9?K 3$ $:52?3? 3$5$EA
5?3" 9? 49>3?3$ 3$ #$3>3? q#@b "4
i#obr :$K$E>"9?3? 9?: E"9D>a42?;\$:
3" (E"99$E5 "4 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?A
32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N
,$ 9$9b4# :>9?K 3$ K>#>5$ 3$ X$A
K"E>3?3$ D"2 3$5$E5?3"] " :>:5$#? 2$A
X$25$2‘ @?2? ": :>9?>: 3$ K>#>5$ 3$ X$A
K"E>3?3$ Z4$ $:5<" ?2#?Y$9?3": 9"
:>:5$#? 3$ 9?X$a?;<"N
- :>:5$#? X$2>D>E? :$#@2$ ": :>9?>:
3$ 52e9:>5" Z4$ >93>E?# ": :>9?>: 3$
K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ ?54?>:N - :>:A
5$#? ^ E?@?Y 3$ 2$E"9b$E$2 $ $p>J>2
?5^ 3">: :>9?>: 3$ 52e9:>5" 3>D$2$95$:
9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$9A
5":N
0$".
! *67   *67
- :>:5$#? .,’ @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3"
"4 3$:?5>X?3" 3$952" 3" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5 ?52?X^: 3" #$94 x,$a4A
2?9;?o’::>:5[9E>? ?" &"5"2>:5?zN
- :>:5$#? ’.=V’*- ^ :>9?K>Y?3"
@"2 :>9?>: 3$ 52e9:>5" #":52?3": 9"
3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

&$:#" :$ " :>:5$#? $:5>X$2 *+,’A
.=V’*-] " :>9?K 3$ K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"A
E>3?3$ :$2‘ $p>J>3" Z4?93" " #"5"A
2>:5? " :$K$E>"9?2 9? 5$K? tT-&+tN
"   = ,       
 ]  
- .,’ 5$# 52[: #"3": 3$ "@$2?;<"
:$K$E>"9‘X$>: Z4$ $:5<" 3>:@"9WX$>:
?52?X^: 3" :>:5$#? (E"99$E5N
  -'
w4?93" ? "@;<" tV>:4?Kt D"2 :$K$A
E>"9?3"] " :>:5$#? ?K$25?2‘ " #"A
5"2>:5? Z4?93" ? X$K"E>3?3$ ?54?K
3" X$WE4K" $pE$3$2 " K>#>5$ 3$
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$5$E5?3" 3? $:52?3?]
#":52?93" 4# a2‘D>E" 9" X>:"2 3"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
  -' c   
w4?93" ? "@;<" tV>:4?K ¥ :"A
9"2?t D"2 :$K$E>"9?3"] " :>:5$#?
?K$25?2‘ " #"5"2>:5? Z4$ $K$ $:5‘
$pE$3$93" " K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
E"# 4#? >93>E?;<" X>:4?K 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
$ :"?93" 4# ?K$25? :"9"2"N -
?K$25? :"9"2" 342?2‘ 7G :$a49A
3": $ " ?K$25? X>:4?K @$2#?9$A
E$2‘ ?5>X" $9Z4?95" " X$WE4K" $:A
5>X$2 $pE$3$93" " K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"A
E>3?3$N

,$#@2$ Z4$ 4# ?K$25? :"9"2" ^
:"K>E>5?3" @$K" :>:5$#? .,’] " 2‘3>"
5?#J^# ^ :>K$9E>?3"N
 ! ' 5
w4?93" " :>:5$#? .,’ ^
3$:K>a?3"] " :>:5$#? 9<"
#":52?2‘ 9$9b4# :>9?K
3$ 52e9:>5" q? #$9": Z4$
:$K$E>"9?3" 9? 5$K? xT-&+z]
Z4$ #":52?2‘ ": :>9?>: 3$ K>#>5$
 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ 3$5$E5?3":r] $
9$9b4# ?K$25? :$2‘ $#>5>3" @?2?
" #"5"2>:5?N
  ,6H    'F
-: :>9?>: 3$ 52e9:>5" 3$5$E5?3":
q:"#$95$ @K?E?: 3$ X$K"E>3?3$:r :<"
#":52?3": 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$
>9:524#$95":] 3$@$93$93" 3?: >9D"2A
#?;\$: 3>:@"9WX$>:N
w4?93" 4# K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
3$5$E5?3" 2$E$95$#$95$ ^ #?>"2 3"
Z4$ " K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ ?54?K] ?
5$K? :$2‘ ?54?K>Y?3? _495" E"# 4#?
:$5? x@?2? E>#?zN
w4?93" 4# K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
3$5$E5?3" 2$E$95$#$95$ ^ >9D$2>"2 ?"
K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ ?54?K] ? 5$K? :$2‘
?54?K>Y?3? _495" E"# 4#? :$5? x@?2?
J?>p"zN

’: :$5?: @?2? E>#? "4 @?2? J?>p"
:$2<" $p>J>3?: @"2 ?5^ E>9E" :$a49A
3":N
   *',  (, 
w4?93" ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
$pE$3$ " K>#>5$ $# 6 i#ob] " :>9?K
3$ K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ 9" 3>:@K?y
3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": :$2‘ X>:4A
?K>Y?3" 4# E"95"29" X$2#$Kb" @?2?
?K$25?2 " #"5"2>:5?N

’.+!/0-
’ D49E>"9?K>3?3$ @"3$ :$2 K>#>5?3?
"4 " :>:5$#? @"3$ 9<" D49E>"9?2 :$
" :$9:"2 $:5>X$2 "J:524W3"N
- :>:5$#? @"3$ 5$2 :4? "@$2?;<"
K>#>5?3? "4 9<" D49E>"9?2 $# E"9A
3>;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: E"#" Eb4X? D"25$]
a2?9>Y" $ 9$X"$>2" $:@$::"N P"25$:
E"952?:5$: 3$ K4Y @"3$# >9DK4$9E>?2
? E?@?E>3?3$ 3$ 2$E"9b$E>#$95" 3"
:$9:"2N
’ ‘2$? ?" 2$3"2 3" :$9:"2 9<"
3$X$ :$2 E"J$25? E"# ?3$:>X": "4
Z4?KZ4$2 "452" "J_$5"N
!<" ?34K5$2$ "4 $p$E45$ Z4?>:Z4$2
"@$2?;\$: 9? ‘2$? @?2?AJ2>:? ?" 2$3"2
3" :$9:"2N
)>#@$ E"2@": $:52?9b":] E"#" $pA
E2$#$95": 3$ @‘::?2":] >9:$5":] 9$X$
"4 a$K" 9" @?2?AJ2>:?N (:$ 3$5$2a$9A
5$: $:@$EWD>E": $ @?9": K>#@": @?2?
$X>5?2 ?22?9b?2 " @?2?AJ2>:?N
 " /  -  "  5
F 0
!#!
’ @2$:$9;? 3" :>:5$#? .1&, 9<"
>:$95? " E"9345"2 3$ 2$a4K?2#$95$
X$2>D>E?2 ? @2$::<" 3": @9$4:] >9EK4A %
:>X$ " :"J2$::?K$95$ $ 2$?K>Y?2 ? E"2A
2$5? #?945$9;<" 3": #$:#":N
- :>:5$#? 9<" ?E4:? 4#? $X$954?K
?X?2>? 3$ 4# @9$4N
!#!
’ @2$::<" 3": @9$4: 3$X$ :$2 X$2>A
D>E?3? E"# @9$4: D2>":d :$] @"2 Z4?KA
Z4$2 #"5>X"] :$ X$2>D>E?2 ? @2$::<"
E"# ": @9$4: Z4$95$:] 9<" 2$34Y>2 ?
0$"!
@2$::<" #$:#" Z4$ :$_? :4@$2>"2 ?"
X?K"2 @2$X>:5"N
C$@$5>2 " E"952"K$ E"# ": @9$4:
D2>":N
!#!
8?:" :$_?# #"95?3?: 4#? "4 #?>:
2"3?: :$# :$9:"2 q@"2 $pN $# E?:" 3$
>9:5?K?;<" 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$r] "
:>:5$#? 3$>p?2‘ 3$ $:5?2 3>:@"9WX$KN
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$: :$2‘ $p>J>3?
4#? #$9:?a$# 3$ ?X>:" ?5^ :$2$#
#"95?3?: 9"X?#$95$ ?: 2"3?: E"#
:$9:"2$:N
!#!
- :>:5$#? .1&, 9<" ^ E?@?Y 3$
?::>9?K?2 @$23?: >#@2$X>:5?: 3? @2$:A
:<" 3": @9$4: q@"2 $pN $# E?:" 3$
D42": $# 4# @9$4rN
0$""
!$::$ E?:"] @?2?2 " X$WE4K" D2$A
?93" E"# E?45$K? $ :$# $D$54?2 #?A
9"J2?: J24:E?:N
!#!
’ @2$::<" 3": @9$4: @"3$ X?2>?2
$# D49;<" 3? 5$#@$2?542? $p5$29?N
- :>:5$#? @"3$ >93>E?2 5$#@"2?2>A
?#$95$ 4#? @2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$N
!$::$ E?:"] E"952"K?2 ? @2$::<"
3": @9$4: ? D2>" $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"]
2$:5?J$K$E[AK? E"9D"2#$ 2$E"#$9A
3?3" 9$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
’: "@$2?;\$: 3$ #"95?A
a$#o3$:#"95?a$# 3": @9$4:
$o"4 2"3?: 2$Z4$2$# @2$E?4;\$:
@?25>E4K?2$:N 1?2? $X>5?2 3?9>D>E?2 "4
#"95?2 >9E"22$5?#$95$ ": :$9:"2$:]
? :4J:5>54>;<" 3": @9$4: $o"4 2"3?:
:h 3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3? @"2 @$::"?K
$:@$E>?K>Y?3"N 8"95?5?2 ?  
! = ,  > :
8?K>J2?2 ": @9$4: E"9D"2#$ 2$E"A
#$93?3" 9$:5$ #?94?KN
- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# :>:5$#? 3$ #"9>5"2?;<" 3?
@2$::<" 3": @9$4: .1&, q.>2$ 12$:A
:42$ &"9>5"2>9a ,y:5$#r] E?@?Y 3$
?::>9?K?2 ?" E"9345"2 4#? $X$954?K
@2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$ 3": @9$4: E"#
J?:$ 9? @2$::<" ? D2>" >93>E?3? 9"
E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":tN
- :>:5$#? ^ E"9:5>54W3" @"2 4#
:$9:"2 52?9:#>::"2 3$ 2?3>"D2$Z4[9A
E>? #"95?3" $# E?3? 2"3? q9? 2"3?
9" >95$2>"2 3" @9$4r] E?@?Y 3$ $9X>?2
g E$952?K 3$ E"952"K$ ?: >9D"2#?;\$:
2$K?5>X?: g @2$::<" 3$ E?3? @9$4
’ X>:4?K>Y?;<" 9" 3>:@K?y qX$2:\$:
E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K $ X$2:\$:
E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K 2$E"9D>A
a42‘X$Kr "E"22$ 3? :$a4>95$ #?9$>2?%

’ @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95" X?2>?
E"# J?:$ 9? 5$#@$2?542? 3$
E$2E? 3$ G]G| J?2 q7 @:>r ? E?3?
F]68 q7LPrN =:5" :>a9>D>E? Z4$ g
3>#>94>;<" 3? 5$#@$2?542? $p5$29?
E"22$:@"93$ ? 4#? 3>#>94>;<" 3?
@2$::<" 3": @9$4:N C$a4K?2 :$#@2$ ?
@2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95" 3": @9$4: ?
D2>"N +:5? uK5>#? ^ 3$D>9>3? E"#" ?
@2$::<" 3": @9$4: ?@h: @$K" #$9":
H b"2?: 3$ >9?5>X>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" "4
4#? Z4>K"#$52?a$# >9D$2>"2 ? 7]F
i# ?@h: 4# >95$2X?K" 3$ H b"2?:N
’ @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95" ? D2>"
9<" 3$X$ :$2 :4@$2>"2 g #‘p>#? >9A
3>E?3? 9? @?25$ @":5$2>"2 3" @9$4%
@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9:4K5?2 "
@?2‘a2?D" tC"3?:t 9" E?@W54K" t*?A
3": 5^E9>E":tN
’ @2$::<" 3": @9$4: ?4#$95? 34A
2?95$ ? E"934;<" 3" X$WE4K"N f 4#?
E"93>;<" 9"2#?K $ 9<" 2$Z4$2 Z4?KA
Z4$2 2$a4K?a$# 3? @2$::<"N
- :>:5$#? .1&, ?::>9?K? ?" E"9A
345"2 ? $X$954?K @2$:$9;? 3$ 4#?
E"93>;<" 3$ @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95"
>9:4D>E>$95$ :$ $:5? 3$:E$2 ?J?>p" 3"
K>#>5$ 3$ ?3X$25[9E>? @"2 Z4?KZ4$2
#"5>X"] >9EK4>93" ": $D$>5": 3? J?>p?
5$#@$2?542? $ ? 9"2#?K @$23? 3$
@2$::<" 3" @9$4N
- :>:5$#? .1&, @?2?2‘ 3$ ?::>9?A
K?2 ? E"93>;<" 3$ @2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$
Z4?93" $:5? D"2 9"X?#$95$ >a4?K "4
:4@$2>"2 g 3$ $9Eb>#$95" ? D2>" @2$:A
E2>5?N ,$ D"2 ?::>9?K?3? 4#? @2$::<"
>9:4D>E>$95$ 3": @9$4: qK4YA$:@>?
?E$:? 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":r]
?4#$95?2] ?::>#] ? @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>A
#$95" ?5^ ?5>9a>2 " X?K"2 ? D2>" @2$:A
E2>5"N
- :>:5$#? ?54?K>Y?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ $ ? K4YA$:@>? ?@?a?A:$ ?:A
:># Z4$ " :>:5$#? 2$E$J$ ?: @2$::\$:
3$ $9Eb>#$95" ?54?K>Y?3?:N 1"3$
:$2 9$E$::‘2>" E"934Y>2 " X$WE4K"
@"2 ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ LG #>945": ?
4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ :4@$2>"2 ?
E$2E? 3$ L6 i#ob ?5^ Z4$ " :>:5$#?
.1&, @"::? 2$E$J$2 $:5?: >9D"2#?A
;\$:N
( '   ,  '
=#?a>9?93" Z4$ ? @2$::<" 3$ $9A %
Eb>#$95" ? D2>" q?::>#] E"# " X$WE4K"
@?2?3" b‘ @$K" #$9": H b"2?:r @2$:A
E2>5? :$_? >a4?K ? L]H J?2 qHH @:>r] :$
? 5$#@$2?542? ?#J>$95$ D"2 3$ LG8
qF~Pr $ ? @2$::<" 3": @9$4: 3$5$EA
5?3? D"2 3$ 7]M6 J?2 qL~ @:>r] 4#? 3$:A
E>3? 3? 5$#@$2?542? @?2? A|8 qLGPr
@2"X"E? 4#? 3>#>94>;<" 3? @2$::<"
3": @9$4:] $# E$2E? 3$ 7]F6 J?2 qLI
@:>rN +:5? @2$::<" ^ :4D>E>$95$#$95$
J?>p?] ?5>X?93" ? K4YA$:@>? N
- ?Z4$E>#$95" 3": @9$4: 3$X>3"
g E"934;<" 3" X$WE4K" @"3$ @2"A
0$"%
X"E?2 4# ?4#$95" 3? @2$::<" 3":
@9$4: ?5^ E$2E? 3$ 7]M6 J?2 qL~ @:>r]
#?: ? K4YA$:@>? @$2#?9$E$2‘] 3$
Z4?KZ4$2 D"2#?] ?E$:?N !$::? :>54?A
;<"] ? K4YA$:@>? :h :$ ?@?a?2‘ 3$@">:
3": @9$4: $:5?2$# Eb$>": ?" X?K"2
3$ @2$::<" ? D2>" @2$:E2>5" @?2? " X$WA
E4K"N

- :>:5$#? .1&, D"> E"9E$J>3"
@?2? ?: 2"3?: $ ": @9$4: "2>a>9?>:N
’: @2$::\$: @2$:E2>5?: $ ": E"9:$A
Z4$95$: K>#>5$: 3$ ?K?2#$ 3$D>9>3":
E"# " :>:5$#? .1&, D"2?# $:5?A
J$K$E>3": E"# J?:$ 9? 3>#$9:<"
3": @9$4: #"95?3": 9" X$WE4K"N ’
45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @9$4: :"J2$::?K$95$:
3$ 3>#$9:<"] 5>@" $o"4 3$:$9b" 3>A
D$2$95$: 3": "2>a>9?>: @"3$ :$2 E?4:?
3$ D49E>"9?#$95" ?9v#?K" 3"
:>:5$#? "4 3$ 3?9": 9": :$9:"2$:N
’: 2"3?: #"95?3?: $# @h:AX$93?
@"3$# @2"X"E?2 3?9": 9": :$9:"2$:N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ X$3?95$: @?2? @9$4:
$# @h:AX$93? @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9":
9" :$9:"2 3" :>:5$#? 3$ E"952"K" 3?
@2$::<" 3": @9$4: q.1&,rN ’ :$a4>2 g
45>K>Y?;<" 3$ X$3?95$ @?2? @9$4: $#
0$"&
@h:AX$93?] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 3>2>a>2A:$
g   ! = ,  > @?2?
#?93?2 $D$54?2 " E"952"K$ 3": :$9:"A
2$:N ’@h: " E"952"K$ "4 ? 2$a4K?a$#
3? @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95"] 2$#"95?2
:$#@2$ " 5?#@<" 3? X‘KX4K? @?2?
$X>5?2 ? >9D>K52?;<" 3$ b4#>3?3$ $ :4A
_$>2? Z4$ @"3$2>?# 3?9>D>E?2 " :$9:"2
3$ E"952"K$ 3? @2$::<" 3": @9$4:N
 ' K67  7 -3 ,  
 -
,$ D"2 3$5$E5?3" 4# X?K"2 3$ @2$:A
:<" >9:4D>E>$95$ $# 4# "4 X‘2>":
@9$4:] ?E$93$A:$ ? K4YA$:@>? 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $ 9" 3>:@K?y
:<" X>:4?K>Y?3?: ?: #$9:?a$9: $:@$A
EWD>E?:N - :>:5$#? $X>3$9E>? ?>93?
3$ D"2#? a2‘D>E? ? @":>;<" 3" @9$4
"4 3": @9$4: E?2?E5$2>Y?3": @"2 4#?
@2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$N f 5?#J^# $#>A
5>3" 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"N
!$::$ E?:"] @?2?2 " X$WE4K"] X$A
2>D>E?2 ? @2$::<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95" 3$
E?3? @9$4 $ $9Eb[AK": ?" X?K"2 E"2A
2$5" 3$ @2$::<" ? D2>" >93>E?3" @$K?
#$9:?a$# X>:4?K>Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y "4
9" #$94 3$3>E?3" ?" :>:5$#? .1&,N
" 5  * 3 ,67  "
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#?]
?K^# 3$ $#>5>2 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"] ?
K4YA$:@>? @>:E? 342?95$ |6 :$a49A
3": $ 3$@">: @$2#?9$E$ ?E$:? E"#
K4Y D>p?N N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] ^ X>:4?K>Y?3?
? #$9:?a$# t&?945$9;<" ,>:5$#?t
3$952" 3" #$94 t=9D" V$WE4K"t 9" 3>:A
@K?y $ 52?;": q r :<" $p>J>3": 9" K4A
a?2 3" X?K"2 3? @2$::<"] ?::>9?K?93"
3$::? D"2#? ? >#@"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ 3$A
5$E5?2 " :$9:"2N !" #$94 t&$9:?a$9:
’2#?Y$9?3?:t ? #$9:?a$# t&?94A
5$9;<" ,>:5N12$::N@9$4:t ^ $p>J>3?N
8"K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>A
;<" $#  $ 9"X?#$95$ $#  ]
? :$Z4[9E>? 3$ :>9?K>Y?;<" 2$@$5$A:$
"93$ ? ?X?2>? ?>93? $:5>X$2 @2$:$95$N
’ K4YA$:@>? ?@?a?A:$ $ ? #$9:?A
a$# 9" 3>:@K?y ^ 3$:?5>X?3? Z4?93"
? E"93>;<" 3$ ?X?2>? 3$:?@?2$E$ $]
$# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $# X$Y 3$ 52?A
;":] ^ 9"X?#$95$ X>:4?K>Y?3" " X?K"2
3$ @2$::<"N
1"3$2>? X$2>D>E?2A:$ 4#? ?9"#?K>?
3" :>:5$#? 9": :$a4>95$: E?:":%
 *>:5u2J>": ? 2?3>"D2$Z4[9E>? @?2A
5>E4K?2#$95$ >95$9:": @"3$# >9>A
J>2 " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
:>:5$#? .1&,N +:5? E"93>;<" :$2‘
:>9?K>Y?3? @"2 4#? #$9:?a$#
$:@$EWD>E? 9" 3>:@K?yN ’ :>9?K>A
Y?;<" 3$:?@?2$E$2‘ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ ?::># Z4$ ?: >95$2D$2[9A
E>?: 3? 2?3>"D2$Z4[9E>? 3$>p?2$#
3$ >95$2D$2>2 E"# " :>:5$#?N
 ’@K>E?;<"] $# ?D5$2#?2i$5] 3$
@$KWE4K?: E"K"2>3?: $# X>32": Z4$
>95$2D$2$# E"# ?: "93?: 3$ 2‘3>"
$#>5>3?: @$K" :>:5$#? .1&,N
 (5>K>Y?;<" 3$ E"9_495":
2"3?o@9$4 :$# :$9:"2$: @?2?
:>:5$#? .1&,N
 ’ 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 9<" 3>:@\$
3$ :$9:"2 3$ E"952"K$ 3? @2$::<"
3" @9$4N 1"25?95"] ? @2$::<"
3" @9$4 9<" ^ E"952"K?3? @$K"
:>:5$#?N

- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ E"# "4 :$#
:$9:"2 .1&, "2>a>9?K @?2? #$3>2 ?
@2$::<" 3": @9$4:N
’ 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ @"3$ 9<" $:A
5?2 $Z4>@?3? E"# 4# :$9:"2 .1&,N
(#? X$Y #"95?3?] 342?95$ ? #?2A
Eb?] ?E$93$A:$ ? K4YA$:@>? q>95$2A
#>5$95$ 342?95$ E$2E? 3$ |6 :$a49A
3": $ 3$@">: ?E$:? E"# K4Y D>p?r] ?
#$9:?a$# t&?945$9;<" ,>:5$#?t ^
#":52?3? 9" 3>:@K?y $ 52?;": q r :<"
$p>J>3": 9" K4a?2 3" X?K"2 3? @2$::<"
$# 5"3?: ?: 2"3?:N !" #$94 t&$9A
:?a$9: ’2#?Y$9?3?:t ? #$9:?a$#
t&?945$9;<" ,>:5N12$::N@9$4:t ^ $p>A
J>3?N +::? E"93>;<" E"95>94? ?5^ Z4$
:$_? #"95?3? 9" X$WE4K" 4#? 2"3?
$Z4>@?3? E"# :$9:"2 .1&, "2>a>9?KN
C"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 3$ 3>#$9:\$:
9"2#?>: q:$# :$9:"2 .1&,r% 4#? X$Y
#"95?3?] 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] ?E$93$A
:$ ? K4YA$:@>? q>95$2#>5$95$ 34A
2?95$ E$2E? 3$ |6 :$a493": $ 3$@">:
?E$:? E"# K4Y D>p?r] ? #$9:?a$# &?A
945$9;<" ,>:5$#?t ^ #":52?3? 9" 3>:A
@K?y $ 52?;": q r :<" $p>J>3": 9"
K4a?2 3" X?K"2 3? @2$::<" $# 5"3?:
?: 2"3?:N !" #$94 t&$9:?a$9: ’2A
#?Y$9?3?:t ? #$9:?a$# t&?945$9A
;<" ,>:5N12$::N@9$4:t ^ $p>J>3?N +::?
E"93>;<" E"95>94? ?5^ Z4$ :$_? #"9A
5?3? 9" X$WE4K" 4#? 2"3? $Z4>@?3?
E"# :$9:"2 .1&, "2>a>9?KN ’::>#] "
:>:5$#? ^ 2$:5?J$K$E>3"] E"# ? K4YA
$:@>? :$ ?@?a?93"] ? #$9:?a$#
3$ @2$::<" 9<" 3>:@"9WX$K 3$>p?93"
:$ :$2 #":52?3? $ " X?K"2 3? @2$::<"
3? 2"3? X"K5?93" ? :$2 $p>J>3"
C"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 3$ 3>#$9:\$:
9"2#?>: qE"# :$9:"2 .1&,r% 4#?
X$Y #"95?3?] @"3$ :$2 9$E$::‘2>"
E"934Y>2 " X$WE4K" @"2 ?@2"p>#?A
3?#$95$ LG #>945": ? 4#? X$K"E>A
3?3$ E"9:5?95$ :4@$2>"2 ? E$2E? 3$
L6 i#ob] @?2? Z4$ ?::># ? K4YA$:@>?
?@?a4$A:$] ? #$9:?a$# 3$ @2$:A
:<" 9<" 3>:@"9WX$K 3$>p$ 3$ :$2 #":A %
52?3? $ " X?K"2 3? @2$::<" 3? 2"3?
X"K5$ ? :$2 $p>J>3"N

+# 5"3": ": E?:": ?E>#? >93>E?A
3":] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K X$2>D>E?2 ? @2$:A
:<" 3$ $9Eb>#$95" 3" @9$4 :"J2$:A
:?K$95$ ?95$: 3$ E"#$;?2 ? E"934Y>2
" X$WE4K"N
0$"’


+# E?:" 3$ :4J:5>54>;<" 3": @9$4:]
?" E"934Y>2 " X$WE4K" 342?95$ J2$X$:
@$2W"3":] @"3$ :$2 9$E$::‘2>" 4#
@"4E" 3$ 5$#@" ?95$: Z4$ " :>:5$#?
:$_? 2$:5?J$K$E>3"N
 *67      " 5?K >#@"25e9E>? Z4$ ": :>:5$#?: 3$
- :>:5$#? .1&, @"3$ :$2 3$:?5>A
X?3" :4J:5>54>93" ?: 2"3?: $Z4>@?3?:
E"# :$9:"2$: .1&, @"2 "452?: Z4$
9<" ?: @"::4?#N +# :$a4>3?] E"934A
Y>2 @"2 ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ LG #>945":
? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ :4@$2>"2
? E$2E? 3$ L6 i#obN
- :>:5$#? .1&, $#>5>2‘ 4# :>9?K
:"9"2"] ? K4YA$:@>? D>E?2‘ >95$2#>A
5$95$ 342?95$ E$2E? 3$ |6 :$a493":
$] $# :$a4>3?] @$2#?9$E$2‘ ?E$:?
E"# K4Y D>p? $ 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?A
32" 3$ >9:524#$95": :$2‘ X>:4?K>Y?3?
? #$9:?a$# tV$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#?
.1&,t $ 52?;": q r 9" K4a?2 3": X?A
K"2$: 3$ @2$::<"N
’ @?25>2 3" E>EK" 3$ @?25>3? :$A
a4>95$] " :>:5$#? .1&, 9<" $#>5>2‘
Z4?KZ4$2 :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E? $ 9"
0$"*
3>:@K?y 9<" :$2‘ #?>: X>:4?K>Y?3? ?
#$9:?a$# tV$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#?
.1&,t] #?: ": 52?;": q r @$2#?9$A
E$2<" X>:4?K>Y?3": 9" K4a?2 3" X?K"2
3? @2$::<"N
   
 
."3": ": K4a?2$: 9": J?9E": 3"
X$WE4K" $:5<" $Z4>@?3": E"# E>95":
3$ :$a42?9;? E"# 52[: @"95": 3$
D>p?;<"] E"# 2$:@$E5>X" $92"K?3"2N
- #$E?9>:#" 3" $92"K?3"2 >95$2A
X^# JK"Z4$?93" " E>95" $# E?:" 3$
D2$9?a$# J24:E? "4 3$ D"25$ 3$:?E$A
K$2?;<" 3$X>3" ? 4# Eb"Z4$N +:5?
E?2?E5$2W:5>E? @$2#>5$] $# E"93>;\$:
9"2#?>:] " K>X2$ 3$:K>Y?#$95" 3? E"2A
2$>? 9" E>95"] 3$ #"3" ? ?3?@5?2A:$
@$2D$>5?#$95$ ?" E"2@" 3" "E4@?95$N
- E"9345"2 3$X$ 2$:@$>5?2 q$ D?Y$2
2$:@$>5?2 ? 5"3": ": @?::?a$>2":r ?:
3>:@":>;\$: K$a>:K?5>X?: K"E?>: 2$K?5>A
X?: g "J2>a?;<" $ D"2#?: 3$ 45>K>Y?A
;<" 3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?N
’@$25?2 :$#@2$ ": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? ?95$: 3$ >9>E>?2 ? X>?a$#N

12$:5?2 ? #‘p>#? ?5$9;<" g: >9A
D"2#?;\$: D"29$E>3?: 9?: @‘a>9?: :$A
a4>95$:N *$ D?5"] ^ 3$ D493?#$9A
@2"5$;<" :$_?# 45>K>Y?3": 3" #"3"
E"22$5" @?2? a?2?95>2 ? #‘p>#? :$a4A
2?9;? @"::WX$K ?" E"9345"2 $ ?": @?:A
:?a$>2":N

1?2? ?E$::" ? 3$:E2>;<" :"J2$ ? 2$A
a4K?a$# 3": ?@">": 3$ E?J$;?] E"9A
:4K5?2 x’@">?AE?J$;?:z 9" E?@W54K"
x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 X$WE4K"zN
J!   
!!
8"K"E?2 " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? #?9A
5$93" " 52"9E" $2$5" $ ?@">?3" E"9A
52? " $9E":5"N
1?2? ?@$25?2 ": E>95":] :$a42?2 9?
K>9a4$5? 3$ $9a?5$ $ >952"34Y>AK? 9?
:$3$ 3? D>X$K? ?5^ "4X>2 4# $:5?K>3"
3$ JK"Z4$>"N
,$] 342?95$ ? $p52?;<" 3" E>95"]
$:5$ :$ JK"Z4$?2] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 3$>p‘A
K" $92"K?2 4# @"4E" $ @4p‘AK" 9"X?A
#$95$ $X>5?93" #?9"J2?: J24:E?:N
1?2? 3$:?@$25?2 " E>95"] @2$::>"9?2
" J"5<" $ ?E"#@?9b?2 " E>95" 34A
2?95$ :$4 2$E"Kb>#$95" 3$ #"3" ?
$X>5?2 Z4$ D>Z4$ 5"2E>3"N
!#!
!<" 3$:?D>X$K?2 " E>95" 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?N
+# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$] ? 9<" 45>K>Y?A
;<" 3" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? @"3$ E?4A
:?2 D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ ?5^ ? #"25$

3": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"N
’" X"K5?2 ? E"K"E?2 " J?9E" @":5$A
2>"2 3? @":>;<" 2$J?5>3? 9? 3$ 45>K>Y?A
;<" 9"2#?K] @2$:5?2 ?5$9;<" g 2$@"A
:>;<" E"22$5? 3" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?]
!#! 3$ #"3" ? a?2?95>2 4#? >#$3>?5? 3>:A
,$ "E"22$2 E"K>:<"] ": @?::?a$>2": @"9>J>K>3?3$N
3": J?9E": 52?:$>2": Z4$ 9<" $:5>X$A
2$# 4:?93" ": E>95":] ?K^# 3$ $:5?A
2$# >9D2>9a>93" ?: K$>: 3$ 52e9:>5" :$A
2<" $p@":5": ? 4# a2?93$ 2>:E"N
’ 9<" 45>K>Y?;<" 3": E>95": 52?:$>A
2": E"9:5>54> $# 4# @$2>a" 5?#J^#
%
@?2? ": "E4@?95$: 3": J?9E": 3>?9A
5$>2": 3" X$WE4K"N
8"# " X$WE4K" $:5?E>"9?3" $# $:A
52?3?: E"# D"25$ >9EK>9?;<"] " $92"A
K?3"2 @"3$ JK"Z4$?2] " Z4$ ^ 9"2#?KN
’K^# 3>::"] " #$E?9>:#" 3" $92"K?A
3"2 JK"Z4$>? " E>95" ? E?3? $p52?;<"
2‘@>3? "4 $# E?:" 3$ D2$9?a$9: J24:A
E?:] Eb"Z4$: "4 E42X?: ? X$K"E>3?3$
$K$X?3?N
0$"+
!" " !!  @":>;<" #?>: $2$5? @"::WX$K $ " E>95"
  !! !&

!#!
’ 2$a4K?a$# $# ?K542? 3": E>95":
3$ :$a42?9;? 3$X$ :$2 D$>5? E"# "
X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# :$a42?9;?N
1?2? $D$54?2 ? 2$a4K?a$# $# ?K542?]
3$ E>#? @?2? J?>p"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>"
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 3$ 3$:52?X?#$95"
$ D?Y$2 3$:K>Y?2 " @2h@2>" @49b" @?2?
J?>p"N
1?2? 3$:K"E?2 " @49b" @?2? E>#?]
J?:5? $#@422‘AK" ?5^ ? @":>;<" 3$:$A
_?3?] :$# @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"N
0$",
C$a4K?2 :$#@2$ ? ?K542? 3": E>9A
5": 3$ :$a42?9;?] ?3?@5?93"A": ?":
": @?::?a$>2":] 2$34Y E"9:>3$2?X$KA
#$95$ " 2>:E" 3$ K$:\$: $# E?:" 3$
Eb"Z4$N
’ 2$a4K?a$# E"22$5? "J5^#A:$
Z4?93" " E>95" @?::? @2hp>#" g
#$5?3$ 3? 3>:5e9E>? $952$ ? $p52$#>A
3?3$ 3" "#J2" $ " @$:E";"N
! !! ! J!
   !!
!#!
1?2? a?2?95>2 ? #‘p>#? @2"5$A
;<" ?": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"]
2$E"#$93?A:$ #?95$2 " $9E":5" 9?
J$# ?3$2$95$ ?" 5h2?p $ g J?E>?N
1?2? a?2?95>2 " E"22$5" D49E>"9?A
#$95" 3" E>95"] 9<" 45>K>Y?2 " J?9E"
$pE$::>X?#$95$ 2$EK>9?3" 342?95$ ":
@$2E42:": 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
8$25>D>E?2A:$ Z4$ 5"3": ": "E4@?95$:
3" X$WE4K" $:5$_?# 45>K>Y?93" " E>95"
3$ :$a42?9;?N V>?_?2 :$# 45>K>Y?2 ":
E>95": ?4#$95? " 2>:E" 3$ K$:\$: a2?A
X$:] "4 3$ #"25$] $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<"N
!#!
,$ " E>95" 5>X$2 :>3" :4J#$5>3"
? 4#? D"25$ :"K>E>5?;<" E"#"] @"2
$p$#@K"] ?@h: 4# ?E>3$95$] "
#$:#" 3$X$ :$2 :4J:5>54W3" E"#A
@K$5?#$95$ _495" E"# ?: D>p?;\$:]
": @?2?D4:": $ " @2h@2>" :>:5$#?
@2^A5$9:>"9?3"2N
P?Y$2 ? :4J:5>54>;<" #$:#" :$ "
E>95" 9<" 5>X$2 ?@2$:$95?93" 3?9":
X>:WX$>:] @">: $:5$: $Z4>@?#$95": @"A
3$# 5$2 @$23>3" :4?: @2"@2>$3?3$:
3$ 2$:>:5[9E>?N
 C$:@$>5?2 q$ D?Y$2 "J:$2X?2 ?": "E4A
@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"r 5"3?: ?: 3>:@":>A
;\$: K$a>:K?5>X?: K"E?>: 2$D$2$95$: g
"J2>a?;<" $ g: #"3?K>3?3$: 3$ 45>K>A
Y?;<" 3": E>95":N ’@$25?2 :$#@2$ ":
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? ?95$: 3$ >9>E>?2
? X>?a$#N
- 4:" 3": E>95": ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 5?#A
J^# @?2? ?: #4Kb$2$: a2‘X>3?:% @?2?
$K?: $ @?2? " J$J[ " 2>:E" 3$ K$:\$:]
$# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<"] ^ #$9"2 :$ 5>X$A
2$# ": E>95": E"K"E?3":N
’: a2‘X>3?: 3$X$# @":>E>"9?2 ?
@?25$ >9D$2>"2 3" E>95" #4>5" $#
J?>p"] 3$ #"3" Z4$ @?::$ :"J2$ ?
J?E>? $ :"J ? J?22>a?N ‹ #$3>3? Z4$
? a2?X>3$Y @2"::$a4$] ? E"9345"2?
3$X$ 2$a4K?2 " J?9E" $ " X"K?95$
3$ #"3" ? 5$2 " @K$9" E"952"K$
3" X$WE4K" q": @$3?>: $ " X"K?95$
3$X$# :$2 3$ D‘E>K ?E$::>J>K>3?3$rN
."3?X>?] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" #?95$2 ?
#‘p>#? 3>:5e9E>? @"::WX$K $952$ "
X$952$ $ " X"K?95$N
’ E"22$>? 3" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?
9<" 3$X$ $:5?2 5"2E>3?N ’ @?25$ :4@$A
2>"2 3$X$ @?::?2 9" "#J2" $ ?52?X$:A
:?2 3>?a"9?K#$95$ " 5h2?pN ’ @?25$
>9D$2>"2 3$X$ ?3$2>2 g J?E>? $ 9<" ?"
?J3v#$9 3" "E4@?95$N !<" 45>K>Y?2
3>:@":>5>X": q#"K?:] D$Eb":] $5ENr Z4$
>#@$;?# " E"95?5" 3": E>95": 3$ :$A
a42?9;? E"# " E"2@" 3": "E4@?95$:N
8?3? E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3$X$ :$2
45>K>Y?3" :h @"2 4#? @$::"?% 9<"
52?9:@"25?2 E2>?9;?: ?" E"K" 3": @?:A
:?a$>2": 45>K>Y?93" ": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? @?2? ? @2"5$;<" 3$ ?#J":N *$
#"3" a$2?K] 9<" ?@$25?2 9$9b4# "JA
_$5" g @$::"?N
"!   
!!
1?2? ? E"22$5? #?945$9;<" 3": E>9A
5": 3$ :$a42?9;?] "J:$2X?2 ?5$95?A
#$95$ ": :$a4>95$: ?X>:":%
 (5>K>Y?2 :$#@2$ ": E>95": J$# $:A
5>E?3":] 9<" 5"2E>3":d E$25>D>Z4$A
:$ Z4$ $:5$: 3$:K>Y$# K>X2$#$95$
:$# >#@$3>#$95":N
 V$2>D>E?2 " D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" :$a4>95$
#"3"% $9a?5?2 " E>95" $ @4p‘AK"
E"# D"2;?N
 ’@h: 4# ?E>3$95$ 3$ 4#? E$25? %
a2?X>3?3$] :4J:5>54>2 " E>95"
3$ :$a42?9;? 4:?3"] #$:#"
Z4$ ?@?2$95$#$95$ 9<" $:5$_?
3?9>D>E?3"N ,4J:5>54>2 5?#J^# "
E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? $# E?:" 3$
?5>X?;<" 3": @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2$:N
 1?2? K>#@?2 ": E>95": 3$
:$a42?9;? 9<" 45>K>Y?2
3$5$2a$95$: ?a2$::>X":]
J2?9Z4$?3"2$: "4 E"2?95$:
$ Z4?KZ4$2 "452? :4J:5e9E>?
Z4W#>E? Z4$ @"::? $9D2?Z4$E$2
?: D>J2?: 3" E>95"N )?X‘AK": g
#<" E"# ‘a4? $ :?J<" 9$452"]
0$"-
 $9p?a4‘AK": $ 3$>p‘AK": :$E?2 g
:"#J2?N
 +X>5$ Z4$ ": $92"K?3"2$: :$_?#
#"Kb?3":% " :$4 E"22$5" D49E>A
"9?#$95" ^ a?2?95>3" :h :$ 9<"
:"D2$2$# >9D>K52?;\$: 3$ ‘a4?N
 ,4J:5>54>2 " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?
Z4?93" $:5>X$2$# @2$:$95$: :>A
9?>: 3$ 3$:a?:5$ "4 E"25$:N
  
"  
   
 
"! % / %'   0
- :>:5$#? ,BC ?K$25? ": @?::?a$>A
2": 3": K4a?2$: 3>?95$>2": 3" 9<" ?D>A
X$K?#$95" 3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?
?52?X^: 3$ :>9?K>Y?;\$: X>:4?>: q?E$9A
3>#$95" 3$ K4YA$:@>? 9" Z4?32" 3$
>9:524#$95": $ 3$ WE"9$: 9" 3>:@K?yr
$ ?Eu:5>E?: qE"9:4K5?2 ": @?2‘a2?D":
:$a4>95$:rN
0$%.
" !" ! J&
 !    &
!!  ! !&
 3":N
w4?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
^ @":>E>"9?3" @?2? @":>;<" ] ?
K4YA$:@>? ?E$93$A:$ 342?95$ ?KA
a49: :$a493":] Z4?KZ4$2 Z4$ :$_? "
$:5?3" 3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? 3>?9A
5$>2":N
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] :$ " E>95"
3$ :$a42?9;? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2 D"2
3$:?D>X$K?3" "4 " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?
3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" $:5>X$2 3$:?D>A
X$K?3" qE"# " @?::?a$>2" :$95?3"r] ?
K4Y @$2#?9$E$ ?E$:? E"# K4Y D>p?N
’::># Z4$ :$ 4K52?@?::? " K>#>5$
3": ~ i#ob 342?95$ ?Ka49: :$a493":
qX?2>‘X$>: $# D49;<" 3?: E"93>;\$:
3" X$WE4K"r] E"# ": E>95": 3$ :$A
a42?9;? 3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2 "4 3"
K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" qE"# " @?::?a$>2"
:$95?3"r 3$:?D>X$K?3"] ?5>X?A:$ 4#?
:>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E? $# :>#4K5e9$"
E"# ? >95$2#>5[9E>? 3? K4YA$:@>?
342?95$ E$2E? 3$ 7GL :$a493":N
(#? X$Y ?5>X?3"] $:5$ E>EK" 3$ :>A
9?K>Y?;\$: @$2#?9$E$ ?5>X" @"2 5"3?
? :4? 342?;<" q>93$@$93$95$#$95$
3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"r "4 ?5^ Z4$
": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? :$_?# ?@$25?A
w4?93" ^ ?E"@K?3? ? #?2Eb? ?
2^] 342?95$ " E>EK" 3$ ?X>:":] " :>9?K
:"9"2" ^ 3$:?5>X?3" $ ? K4YA$:@>?
?E$93$A:$ E"# K4Y D>p?N - E>EK" 3$
:>9?K>Y?;\$: :$2‘ 2$?5>X?3" ?::># Z4$
? X$K"E>3?3$ 4K52?@?::? 9"X?#$95$
": ~ i#obN

!?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# 3>:A
@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K] $# E?:" 3$ E>95"
3$ :$a42?9;? 3$:?D>X$K?3"] ?E$93$A
:$ " WE"9$ N
" !"  
   !!
 ! ! /
.- 0
-: WE"9$: :<" X>:4?K>Y?3": 9" 3>:A
@K?y qD>a42?: :$a4>95$: A X$2:\$: E"#
3>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K "4 X$2:\$:
E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K 2$E"9D>A
a42‘X$Kr @?::?3": ?Ka49: :$a493":
3$@">: 3" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" :$2
E"K"E?3" 9? @":>;<" $] ?@h:
E$2E? 3$ HG :$a493":] ?@?a?#A:$N
’ :$a4>2 ?" D$Eb?#$95" 3$ 4#?
@"25?] "4 ? :$a4>2 ? 4#? #43?9;? 3$
$:5?3" 3$ E"K"E?;<" 3": E>95":] ":
WE"9$: ?E$93$#A:$ 9"X?#$95$ 34A
2?95$ E$2E? 3$ HG :$a493": @?2? 3$A
@">: :$ ?@?a?2$#N

!?: :>54?;\$: ?E>#?] _495?#$95$
E"# " ?E$93>#$95" 3" 2$:@$E5>X"
WE"9$ 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95":] :$2‘ ?5>X?3" 5?#J^# 4#
:>9?K :"9"2"N
-: WE"9$: X>:4?K>Y?3": 9" 3>:@K?y
>93>E?#%
!) E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" K4a?2
52?:$>2" $:Z4$23"N
%) E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" K4a?2 52?A
:$>2" E$952?KN
) E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" K4a?2
52?:$>2" 3>2$>5"N

!?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# 3>:A
@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K] 9": E?:": $#
Z4$ " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? $:5>X$2 3$A
:?D>X$K?3"] ?E$93$A:$ " WE"9$ N 5$# >9WE>" $ 5$2#>9? 3$ #"3" >93$A
-: WE"9$: :<" X>:4?K>Y?3": $# D49A
;<" 3": 2$:@$E5>X": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? 3": K4a?2$: 52?:$>2": $ @$2#?A
9$E$# ?E$:": 342?95$ E$2E? 3$ HG
:$a493": 3$:3$ ? uK5>#? #43?9;? 3$
$:5?3" 3" E>95"%
 ,$ " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?
$:5>X$2 ?D>X$K?3"] " WE"9$
E"22$:@"93$95$ :$2‘ 3$ E"2 X$23$
 ,$ " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? $:5>X$2
3$:?D>X$K?3"] " WE"9$ E"22$:@"9A
3$95$ :$2‘ 3$ E"2 X$2#$Kb?N
,$ 4# E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 52?:$>2"
D"2 3$:?D>X$K?3"] _495?#$95$ E"# "
?E$93>#$95" 3" 2$:@$E5>X" WE"9$ 9"
3>:@K?y] :$2‘ ?5>X?3" 5?#J^# 4# :>A
9?K :"9"2"N
’K^# 3>::"] ": WE"9$: X"K5?# ?
?E$93$2A:$ 342?95$ E$2E? 3$ HG :$A
a493": :$#@2$ Z4$ 4#? 3?: @"25?:
52?:$>2?: ^ D$Eb?3?N
8?:" :$_?# 3$:?D>X$K?3": X‘2>":
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?] ? :>9?K>Y?;<" X>A
:4?K q3$ E"2 X$2#$Kb" >95$2#>5$95$r
@$93$95$ @?2? E?3? K4YA$:@>?N
- WE"9$ D>E?2‘ X$23$ Z4?93" D"2
%
?D>X$K?3" " 2$:@$E5>X" E>95" 3$ :$a4A
2?9;?N
*$E"22>3": E$2E? 3$ HG :$a493":
3$:3$ ? uK5>#? :>9?K>Y?;<"] ": WE"9$:
2$K?5>X": ?": K4a?2$: 52?:$>2": :$ ?@?A
a?#] >93$@$93$95$#$95$ 3" $:5?3"
3" E>95" qWE"9$ X$2#$Kb" "4 X$23$rN

!" Z4$ 3>Y 2$:@$>5" ?": J?9E":
52?:$>2":] ": WE"9$:] $p>J>3": 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] >9A
0$%!
3>E?# ?@$9?: :$ ": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? $:5<" 3$:?D>X$K?3": qWE"9$ X$2A
#$Kb"r "4 ?D>X$K?3": qWE"9$ X$23$r]
#?: 9<" >93>E? ? @2$:$9;? 3$ 4#
$X$954?K @?::?a$>2"N

’: K4Y$:A$:@>?oWE"9$: @$2#?9$A
E$# ?@?a?3": :$] E"K"E?93" "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
] 5"3": ": E>95": q3>?95$>2": $
52?:$>2":r $:5>X$2$# ?D>X$K?3":N

1?2? ": K4a?2$: 52?:$>2":] ": WE"A
9$: ?5>X?#A:$ ?Ka49: :$a493": ?@h:
? E"K"E?;<" 3" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>A
;<" 9? @":>;<" ] >93$@$93$95$A
#$95$ 3" $:5?3" 3": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? q#$:#" Z4$ ": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? $:5$_?# 5"3": ?D>X$K?3":rN

."3?: ?: K4Y$:A$:@>?oWE"9$: :$
?E$93$# Z4?93" @$K" #$9": 4#
E>95" @?::? 3$ ?D>X$K?3" @?2?
3$:?D>X$K?3" "4 X>E$AX$2:?N
0$%"
'0 - @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2 9<" 9$E$::>5?
3$ Z4?KZ4$2 #?945$9;<" "4 K4J2>D>A
   E?;<"% Z4?KZ4$2 >95$2X$9;<" 3$ #"A
3>D>E?;<" 3?: :4?: E"93>;\$: "2>a>A

9?>: >9X?K>3? ? :4? $D>E>[9E>?N
- X$WE4K" ^ 3"5?3" 3$ @2^A
,$] 3$X>3" ? $X$95": 9?542?>: $pA
5$9:>"9?3"2$: @?2? ": E>95": 3$ :$A
E$@E>"9?>: q@"2 $pN% >9493?;\$:] #?A
a42?9;? 3>?95$>2": Z4$] $# E?:" 3$
2^: Eb$>?:] $5ENr] " 3>:@":>5>X" 5>X$2
Eb"Z4$ D2"95?K X>"K$95"] 2$E"Kb$# ?KA
:>3" ?5>9a>3" @"2 ‘a4? $o"4 K?#?] ^
a49: E$95W#$52": ? E"22$>? 3": E>95":]
9$E$::‘2>" 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! &
a?2?95>93" ?::># ? @$2D$>5? ?3$2[9E>?
= ,  > @?2? @2"E$3$2 g :4? :4J:A
3": E>95": ?" E"2@" 3": "E4@?95$:]
5>54>;<"N
?95$: 3$ >9>E>?2 ? ?;<" 3$ 2$5$9;<"N
’ ?5>X?;<" $D$5>X? 3": @2^A
5$9:>"9?3"2$: ^ 2$E"9b$E>3? @$K" 
2$E4" 3? E"22$>? 3" E>95" $# 3>2$;<" 1?2? 5$2 ? #‘p>#? @2"5$;<" @$K?
?" $92"K?3"2N ?;<" 3" @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2] 45>K>Y?2 "
E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? #?95$93"A" J$#
’K^# 3>::"] " X$WE4K" @"::4>
?3$2$95$ ?" 52"9E" $ g J?E>?N
4# :$a493" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @2^A
5$9:>"9?#$95" q>9:5?K?3" 9? ‘2$? 3"
D2>:"r $ ? :4? ?5>X?;<" ^ 2$E"9b$EWX$K
@$K" $9E425?#$95" 3" E?J" #$5‘K>E"N
*42?95$ ? >95$2X$9;<" 3" @2^A !#!
5$9:>"9?3"2 @"3$A:$ X$2>D>E?2 4#? - @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2 ^ 45>K>Y‘X$K :"A
K>a$>2? $#>::<" 3$ D4#?;? Z4$ 9<" ^ #$95$ 4#? X$YN
9"E>X? $ 9<" >93>E? 4# @2>9EW@>" 3$ ’@h: ? :4? 45>K>Y?;<"] 3>2>_?A :$ g
>9E[93>"N   ! = ,  > @?2? ? :4J:A
5>54>;<" E"#@K$5? 3": 3>:@":>5>X":]
>9EK4>93" ": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?N
!#!
+# b>@h5$:$ ?Ka4#? 3$X$A:$ 3$:A
#"95?2 "4 >95$2X>2 9": E"#@"9$95$:
3" 3>:@":>5>X" @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2N
w4?KZ4$2 2$@?2?;<" 3$X$ :$2 D$>5?
@"2 @$::"?K Z4?K>D>E?3" $ ?45"2>Y?3"N
12"E42$ :$#@2$ ?   ! = &
,  >
!#!
=95$2X$9;\$: Z4$ >#@K>E?# >#@?EA
5":] X>J2?;\$: "4 ?Z4$E>#$95": K"E?A
K>Y?3": q:4@$2>"2$: ? 7GG8r @"2 4#?
342?;<" #‘p>#? 3$ F b"2?: 9? ‘2$?
@2hp>#? ?" @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2 @"3$#
@2"X"E?2 3?9": "4 ?5>X?;\$:N
*>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
> :$#@2$ Z4$ :$ 5>X$2 3$ >95$2X>2
9$::$: E"#@"9$95$:N
"!  !! V$2>D>Z4$ :$#@2$ ? K$a>:K?;<" $#
X>a"2 9" @?W: $ :4?: 3$5$2#>9?;\$:N
1?2? ?4#$95?2 ? @2"5$;<" $# E?:"
3$ ?E>3$95$] ": $92"K?3"2$: 3":
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? 3>?95$>2": $:5<"
$Z4>@?3":] 9" :$4 >95$2>"2] E"#
4# 3>:@":>5>X" Z4$ @$2#>5$ 3":?2
?3$Z4?3?#$95$ ? D"2;? Z4$ ?54? 9"
5h2?p $ 9": "#J2": 342?95$ ? ?;<"
3$ 2$5$9;<" 3": E>95": $# E?:" 3$
E"K>:<" D2"95?KN
  '
  
%
!   !! "
!!
*$ ?E"23" E"# ? 2$a4K?#$95?;<"
3" 8"9:$Kb" !?E>"9?K 3$ .2e9:>5" !#!
q8"952?9r] X>a$95$ g ^@"E? 3$ D?J2>E?A ! ) 949E? 45>K>A
;<" 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? 52?9:>5?2 $# X$WA Y?2 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K
E4K": ?45"#"5"2$:] ?: E2>?9;?: E"# X"K5?3": E"952? " :$95>3" 3$ #?2Eb?
>3?3$ >9D$2>"2 ? 3$Y ?9": Z4$ 9<" 5$A 9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" E"# " ?>2J?a 3"
9b?# ?5>9a>3" 7]I6 # 3$ ?K542? 3$A K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" b?J>K>5?3"N
X$# :$2 52?9:@"25?3?: 9": J?9E": 52?A
:$>2": 4:?93" >93>X>34?K#$95$ E>95" ’ ?5>X?;<" 3" ?>2J?a $# E?:" 3$
3$ :$a42?9;? "4 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9A E"K>:<" @"3$ "E?:>"9?2 K$:\$: a2?X$:
;<" $Z4>X?K$95$N "4 #"25?>: g E2>?9;? 52?9:@"25?3?N
0$%%


,"#$95$ " J?9E" 52?:$>2" 3$X$2‘
:$2 4:?3" @?2? " 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>A
?9;?:] @"2 :$ 52?5?2 3? @":>;<" #?>:
@2"5$a>3?N

- 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: 9" J?9E"
3>?95$>2" :h ^ @$2#>5>3" $# E?:":
@2$X>:5": E"9D"2#$ K$a>:K?;<" $# X>A
a"2N !$::$: E?:":] 3$X$2<" :$2 "J:$2A
X?3?: ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?A
;<" $ #"95?a$# @?2? E?3? a24@" 3$
3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K] E"9A
D"2#$ 3$5?Kb?3" 9? 5?J$K? 3$ #"95?A
a$# 9" E?@W54K" :$a4>95$% t’3$Z4?A
;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?9A
5>KtN
!" B2?:>K ?: $pE$;\$: :<"%
 V$WE4K" 3"5?3" $pEK4:>X?#$95$
3$ J?9E": 3>?95$>2":N
 w4?95>3?3$ 3$ E2>?9;?: ? :$2$#
52?9:@"25?3?: $pE$3$2 " 9u#$2"
3$ ?::$95": 3": J?9E": 52?:$>2":N
!$::$ E?:"] ? E2>?9;? 3$ #?>"2
$:5?542? 3$X$2‘ :$2 52?9:@"25?3?
0$%&
9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" E"# " :>:5$#?
3$ 2$5$9;<" ?@2"@2>?3" @?2? :$4
@$:" $ ?K542?N

V$2>D>Z4$ :$#@2$ ? K$a>:K?;<" $#
X>a"2 9" @?W: $ :4?: 3$5$2#>9?;\$:N
1?2? ? #$Kb"2 @2"5$;<" $# E?:"
3$ E"K>:<"] 5"3": ": "E4@?95$: 3$A
X$# X>?_?2 :$95?3": $ @2"5$a>3": @$A
K": :>:5$#?: 3$ 2$5$9;<" ?3$Z4?3":
qE>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?] 3>:@":>5>X": 3$
2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K] $5ENrN

8?3? :>:5$#? 3$ 2$5$9;<" ^
@2"_$5?3" $pEK4:>X?#$95$ @?2? ?
:$a42?9;? 3$ 4#? E2>?9;?d 949E?
52?9:@"25?2 34?: "4 #?>: E2>?9;?:
9" #$:#" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<"
>9D?95>K ?" #$:#" 5$#@"N

!<" @$2#>5>2 Z4$ ": E>95": 3$ :$A
a42?9;? :$ ?@">$# 9" @$:E";" 3?
E2>?9;?N

!49E? 52?9:@"25?2 E2>?9;?: 9" E"K"
$ 949E? 45>K>Y?2 " #$:#" E>95" @?2?
@2"5$;<" 3$ #?>: 3$ 4# "E4@?95$ ?"
#$:#" 5$#@"N

!<" @$2#>5>2 Z4$ ? E2>?9;? 45>K>Y$ "
E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3>?a"9?K 3$J?>p"
3": J2?;": "4 @"2 52‘: 3?: E":5?:N

*42?95$ 5"3": ": @$2E42:": 3$ 45>A
K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"] a?2?95>2 Z4$ ? E2>A
?9;? @$2#?9$;? E"# ": E>95": ?3$A
Z4?3?#$95$ ?D>X$K?3":N

8"9D>2? :$ " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$
2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K ^ E"#@?5WX$K E"#
:$4 X$WE4K" $ X$2>D>Z4$ 9? 5?J$K? 3$
#"95?a$# ?: @":>;\$: @"::WX$>:
@?2? >9:5?K?;<"N ,>a? E"22$5?#$95$
?: >9D"2#?;\$: 3$ >9:5?K?;<"
E"95>3?: 9" #?94?K 3$ #"95?a$#
3>:@"9>J>K>Y?3" @$K" D"29$E$3"2 3"

3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN
!<" #"X>#$95$ ": J?9E": 3" X$WA
E4K" E"# ? E2>?9;? ?K"_?3? $# :$4
 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN C$?A
’E"9:$Kb?A:$ X$2>D>E?2 9?   K>Y$ 5"3": ": ?_4:5$: ?95$: 3$ E"K"E?2
! = ,  > ? 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ ? E2>?9;? 9" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<"
3$ 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K >9D?95>KN
3? )>9b? c$$@ ’E$::h2>":] $:@$E>D>A
E?#$95$ 3$:$9X"KX>3": @?2? 4:" 9":

X$WE4K": c$$@N
+# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$] :4J:5>54>2 "
3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K @"2
 4# 9"X"N
!<" ?D>p$ "4 :"J2$@"9b? 9$9b4#
#?5$2>?K 9": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" %
>9D?95>KN .?K @2‘5>E? @"3$ E"#@2"#$A
5$2 " D49E>"9?#$95" ?3$Z4?3" 3":
#$:#": $ "D$2$E$2 2>:E": g E2>?9;?N


&$:#" Z4?93" $:5<" 3$:"E4@?A
3":] ": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9A
D?95>K 3$X$# $:5?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ?D>A
p?3": @?2? $X>5?2 :$4 3$:K"E?#$95"
9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"N ,$ @2$D$A
2>2] 2$#"X?A": 3" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"
Z4?93" 9<" $:5>X$2$# $# 4:"N

0$%’
!;!      !


!<" 45>K>Y$ 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K Z4$ 9<" @"::?# :$2 E"22$5?#$95$ >9:5?K?3": $# :$4 X$WE4K"N +:5$: 3$X$#
$:5?2 3$X>3?#$95$ D>p?3": @$K": E>95": "4 @$K" :>:5$#? =,-P=¡o."@ .$5b$2 $ 9<" 3$X$# @"::4>2 >95$2D$2[9E>? E"#
3$#?>: @?25$: >95$29?: 3" X$WE4K"N V$2>D>Z4$ :$#@2$ " #?94?K 3" $Z4>@?#$95" @?2? $D$54?2 ? #"95?a$# E"22$5?#$95$N

4'  - ' K67

     @   
!;! !! ! !!


 -  1) 44= , 3  - , * +*' ’5^ 7 ?9" 3$ >3?3$ "4 E"# @$:" ?5^ 7H {a q›r

 -  B) , G
 -  C)    '*67
 -  D) ,   5-  6  *+,-'
,4@$2>"2 ? 7 ?9" $ >9D$2>"2 "4 >a4?K ? I ?9": 3$ >3?3$] "4 E"# @$:" $952$ M $ 7~ {a q›r
,4@$2>"2 ? I ?9": $ >9D$2>"2 "4 >a4?K ? | ?9": $ :$>: #$:$:d "4 E2>?9;?: E"# ?5^ 7]I6 # 3$ ?K542?
$ @$:" $952$ 76 ? HF {a q›r
,4@$2>"2 ? | ?9": $ :$>: #$:$: $ >9D$2>"2 "4 >a4?K ? 7G ?9":d "4 E2>?9;?: E"# ?K542? :4@$2>"2 ?
7]I6 #N

q›r 8"9D"2#$ K>#>5$ #‘p>#" 3$D>9>3" @$K" D?J2>E?95$ 3" 3>:@":>5>X"N

0$%*
4'   5
% ,     % ,    & Bd 3 '  % ,    & Bd 3 ' 
5  % ,    & Cd 3 ' 
/ 5 0 /  ,  '0 /  '  0

S24@" 7 ( q›r (7 (7 (P
7 7
S24@" L ( q››r ( ( (P

S24@" H ( q››r (7 (7 (P
 e  '67 , +*' ,    - *   /- ' K   ,   5-  60:
 e  '67 , +*' ,      67 - *   *          ,G  *+,-':
Ne  4    5   :
7 § - J?9E" 3" @?::?a$>2" K"E?K>Y?3" ? D2$95$ 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K 3$X$2‘ :$2 ?_4:5?3" 9? @":>;<" #?>: ? D2$95$ @"::WX$K @?2?
$X>5?2 " E"95?5" 3? E2>?9;? $ "4 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K E"# " J?9E"N
q›r § &"X$2 " ?::$95" 3" @?::?a$>2" D2"95?K 9? @":>;<" #?>: 2$E4?3? @"::WX$KN =9:5?K?;<" @$2#>5>3? :"#$95$ E"# ?>2J?a 3$:?5>X?3"N
q››r § &"X$2 " ?::$95" 3" @?::?a$>2" D2"95?K @?2? ? @":>;<" >#$3>?5?#$95$ ? D2$95$ 3? E"K49? "93$ " E>95" ^ D>p?3"] a?2?95>93" Z4$ " E>95"
$:5$_? 5$9:>"9?3" ?@h: ? >9:5?K?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN ’ >9EK>9?;<" 3" ?::$95" 3$X$ :$2 2$a4K?3? @?2? 2$#"X$2 Z4?>:Z4$2
D"Ka?: 342?95$ ? >9:5?K?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"N %


1?2? E"22$5? >9:5?K?;<"] @":>E>"9$ " ?@">?AE?J$;? 9? @":>;<" #?>: ?K5? "4 2$#"X?A" @?2? $X>5?2 >95$2D$2[9E>? $952$
$K$ $ " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN 1?2? ?E$::" ? 3$:E2>;<" :"J2$ ? 2$a4K?a$# 3": ?@">?AE?J$;?:] E"9:4K5?2
x’@">?AE?J$;?:z 9" E?@W54K" x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 X$WE4K"zN


+# E?:" 3$ 2$#";<" 3" ?@">?AE?J$;?:] $:5$ 3$X$ :$2 2$E"K"E?3" :$#@2$ Z4$ " ?::$95" 9<" $:5>X$2 E"# ? E?3$>2>9b?
>9:5?K?3?N 8"9D>2? :$#@2$ ?: >9:524;\$: 3$ #"95?a$# 3" #?94?K 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN 8"9D>2? :$#@2$
?: >9:524;\$: 3$ #"95?a$# 3" #?94?K 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN

0$%+

’@h: >9:5?K?3" 4# 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K 9? :$a493? D>K$>2?] 5"3? #"X>#$95?;<" $ 2$a4K?a$# 3": ?::$95":
3$X$# :$2 $X>5?3?: $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"] 2$?K>Y?3?: X$2>D>E?93" :$ " 3>:@":>5>X" @$2#?9$E$ $# #"95?a$# E"22$5?] :$#
D"Ka?: "4 >95$2D$2[9E>?: E"# "452?: @?25$: 3" X$WE4K"N

!#!
SC’V+ 1+C=S-%
!49E? 45>K>Y?2 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K X"K5?3": E"952? " :$95>3" 3$ #?2Eb? 9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" E"# ?>2J?a
3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"N

0$%,
! !!  " "!
   !!
!!$  N  

-: J?9E": 52?:$>2": K?5$2?>: 3" X$WA
E4K" $:5<" $Z4>@?3": E"# D>p?;\$:
=,-P=¡N
+:5?: D>p?;\$: @$2#>5$# Z4$ X"E[
#"95$ :>:5$#?: 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K
=,-P=¡] :$# 4:?2 ": E>95": 3$ :$A
a42?9;? 3" X$WE4K"] #?:] ?_4:5?93"
" ?::$95" 3$ E2>?9;? 3>2$5?#$95$ g:
52[: e9E"2?: 3>:@"9WX$>: 9" X$WE4K"N
f @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ? #"95?a$# 3$
3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K E"#
5$E9"K"a>?: =,-P=¡ $ ": E"9X$9E>"A
9?>: q45>K>Y?93" E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?r
$# 3>D$2$95$: ?::$95": 3" #$:#" X$WA
E4K"] 3$:3$ Z4$ 2$:@$>5?3?: ?: >9A
3>E?;\$: 3?: 5?J$K?: 3$ #"95?a$#N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: >9:524;\$: E"95>3?:
9" #?94?K 3$ >9:5?K?;<" 3" 3>:@":>A
5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN
1?2? >9:5?K?2 4# 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$A
5$9;<" >9D?95>K =,-P=¡] ^ 9$E$::‘2>"
D>p‘AK" g: 34?: e9E"2?: #$5‘K>E?: !
K"E?K>Y?3?: g D2$95$ 3" J?9E" 52?A
:$>2"] 9" @"95" 3$ $9E"952" 3" ?:A
:$95" E"# " $9E":5"N
+# :$a4>3?] @2$93$2 ? E"22$>?
:4@$2>"2   q3>:@"9WX$K $#
E"9_495" E"# ? E?3$>2>9b?r $# 4#?
3?: e9E"2?: % K"E?K>Y?3?: 9? @?25$
>9D$2>"2 52?:$>2? 3" ?::$95"] @?2?
4#? ?3$Z4?3? ?9E"2?a$#N
’ 5W54K" 3$ 3$#"9:52?;<"] ? D>a42?
:$a4>95$ ^ 4# $p$#@K" 3$ E?3$>2>9b?
3$ E2>?9;? =,-P=¡ a24@" 49>X$2:?K 7N
!<" 45>K>Y$ " #$:#" a?9Eb" 3$
?9E"2?a$# =,-P=¡ @?2? >9:5?K?2 #?>:
3$ 4# 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K
?" #$:#" 5$#@"N
%

’ D>a42? ?95$2>"2 ^ ?@$9?: >93>E?A
5>X? @?2? ? #"95?a$#N ’ #"95?a$#
3$X$ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? 3$ ?E"23" E"# ?:
>9:524;\$: E"95>3?: 9" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$
2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K $ :$4 #?94?K 3$ >9:A
5?K?;<"N - $9E?>p$ E"22$5" 3" 3>:@"A
:>5>X" =,-P=¡ ^ $X>3$9E>?3" @"2 4#
EK>Z4$N
-: "452": a24@": :<" E"J$25": @"2
?::$95": =,-P=¡ $:@$EWD>E":] $ :"A
0$%-
#$95$ @"3$# :$2 4:?3": :$ $:@$E>A
D>E?#$95$ 5$:5?3": @?2? $:5$ X$WE4K"
qE$25>D>Z4$A:$ 9" #?94?K 3" 3>:@":>A
5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K :$ " #$:#"
^ >93>E?3" @?2? $:5$ X$WE4K"rN

0$&.
!;!  !  !! " !! !!  !! N
5  % ,     % ,    % ,   
5        *
    ' / 5 0 /  ,  '0 /  '  0

S24@" G qfi 7G iar + =,-oC7 ¡ ¡ =)

+ =,-oC7 ¡ ¡ =)

S24@" G ¥ qfi 7H iar * =,-oCL ¡ ¡ =)

8 =,-oCH ¡ ¡ =) q›r

* =,-oCL ¡ ¡ =)

8 =,-oCH ¡ ¡ =) q›r

S24@" 7 qM ? 7~ iar B =,-oPL ¡ ¡ =(P

B7 =,-oPL¡ ¡ ¡ =(P

’ =,-oPH ¡ ¡ =(P
%
¡ § 12">J>3? ? #"95?a$# 3$ 3>:@":>5>X" E"# =,-P=¡ 9$::$ ?::$95"N
=) § =9:5?K?;<" E"#@?5WX$K E"# 3>:@":>5>X": =,-P=¡ 3$ E?5$a"2>? :$#>49>X$2:?K] b"#"K"a?3": $:@$E>D>E?#$95$ @?2? $:5$ X$WE4K"N !$E$::‘2>"
E"9:4K5?2 ? K>:5? 3$ X$WE4K": ?@2"X?3": 9" #?94?K 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K @?2? E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ 4:" 9$:5$ X$WE4K"N
=)q›r § &"95?a$# @"::WX$K #$3>?95$ 2$a4K?a$# 3" J?9E" ?95$2>"2N
=(P § =9:5?K?;<" E"#@?5WX$K E"# 3>:@":>5>X": =,-P=¡ E?5$a"2>? 49>X$2:?K E"# #"95?a$# "2>$95?3? @?2? ? D2$95$ 3" X$WE4K" b"#"K"a?3": @?2?
$:5$ a24@" 3$ @$:"N

8"9:4K5$ :$#@2$ ? K$a>:K?;<" X>a$95$ 9" @?W: 2$K?5>X? ?" 4:" 3$ 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ 2$5$9;<" >9D?95>KN

0$&!
    q,>3$ J?ar 3" #"5"2>:5? $ 3" @?:A
:?a$>2"N
  '  ’>2J?a: K?5$2?>: @?2? ? @2"5$;<"
  3? E?J$;? 3": "E4@?95$: 3": K4A
a?2$: 3>?95$>2": $ 3": "E4@?9A
!%! 5$: 3": K4a?2$: 52?:$>2": K?5$2?>:
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3"] E"9D"2#$ q¤>93"j J?a:rN
? X$2:<"] E"#%
’ @":>;<" 3": ?>2J?a: $:5‘ ?::>A
9?K?3?] 9" X$WE4K"] E"# ? >93>E?A
;<" t’=CB’St :>54?3? 9" E$952" 3"
X"K?95$] 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":]
9" 2$X$:5>#$95" K?5$2?K "4 94#? $5>A
Z4$5? @2hp>#" 3" @"95" 3$ ?J$2542?
3" ?>2J?aN
7N ’>2J?a: D2"95?>: @?2? " #"5"A
!#!
2>:5?N
1?2? 9<" ?K5$2?2 ? :$9:>J>K>3?3$
LN ’>2J?a: D2"95?>: @?2? " @?::?A
3" :>:5$#? ?>2J?a] $X>5$ ? >9:5?K?;<"
a$>2"N
9" X$WE4K"] 3$ ?95$@?2":] @2"5$;\$:
HN ’>2J?a 3$ _"$Kb": @?2? " #"5"A D2"95?>: $o"4 K?5$2?>:] ?E$::h2>": 9<"
2>:5?N a$94W9": "4 9<" b"#"K"a?3": "4
#$:#" E"#@"9$95$: 9<" @2$E"9>Y?A
!'9       +* ` , & 3": @$K? D‘J2>E?N
3   * 7)
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
 ’>2J?a: K?5$2?>: 3>?95$>2": @?2? ?
;\$: 3$::$ #?94?KN
@2"5$;<" 3? J?E>?] 5h2?p $ E":5?:
0$&"
!%! !
-: ?>2J?a: D2"95?>: q#"5"2>:5?
$ @?::?a$>2"r $ " ?>2J?a @?2? ":
_"$Kb": 3" E"9345"2 q:$ $Z4>@?3"r
@2"5$a$# ": "E4@?95$: 3": K4a?2$:
3>?95$>2": 9?: E"K>:\$: D2"95?>: 3$
a2?X>3?3$ #^3>?A?K5?] ?52?X^: 3?
>95$2@":>;<" 3? J"K:? Z4$ :$ >9DK?
$952$ " "E4@?95$ $ " X"K?95$ "4 "
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
’ 9<" ?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2J?a: 9": "4A
52": 5>@": 3$ Eb"Z4$ qK?5$2?K] @":5$A
2>"2] E?@"5?#$95"] $5ENr 9<" ^ @"2A
5?95" :>9v9>#" 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" >2A
2$a4K?2 3" :>:5$#?N
-: ?>2J?a: D2"95?>: q#"5"2>:5? $
@?::?a$>2"r 9<" :<" :4J:5>54WX$>:] #?:
E"#@K$#$95?2$: ?" 4:" 3": E>95": 3$
:$a42?9;?] Z4$ ^ "J2>a?5h2>"] E"#"
@2$:E2>5" @$K? K$a>:K?;<" X>a$95$N
+# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<"] 4#? @$::"?
Z4$ 9<" 45>K>Y$ ": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? ^ @2"_$5?3? @?2? ? D2$95$ $ @"3$
J?5$2 9? J"K:? ?>93? $# D?:$ 3$ ?J$2A
542?N !$::? :>54?;<"] ? @2"5$;<" "D$A
2$E>3? @$K? J"K:? D>E? @2$_43>E?3?N
 -: ?>2J?a: D2"95?>: @"3$# 9<"
?5>X?2A:$ 9": :$a4>95$: E?:":%
 8b"Z4$: D2"95?>: E"952? "J_$5":
#4>5" 3$D"2#‘X$>:] Z4$ 9<" ?D$A
5?# ? :4@$2DWE>$ D2"95?K 3" X$WA
E4K" q@"2 $pN] >#@?E5" 3" @?2?A
K?#?: E"952? #42$5?: "4 J?22?:
3$ :$a42?9;? 3? X>?r
 +9E?>p$ 3" X$WE4K" :"J "452":
X$WE4K": "4 J?22$>2?: 3$ @2"5$;<"
q@"2 $p$#@K" :"J E?#>9b\$: "4
J?22?: K?5$2?>: 3? X>?rN
’ 9<" ?5>X?;<" 9?: E"93>;\$:
?E>#? 3$:E2>5?: 3$X$A:$ ?" D?5" 3$
": ?>2J?a: @"3$2$# 9<" "D$2$E$2
Z4?KZ4$2 @2"5$;<" ?3>E>"9?K 2$K?5>A
X?#$95$ ?": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? $]
@"2 >::"] ? 2$:@$E5>X? ?5>X?;<" :$2>?
>9"@"2549?N
’ 9<" ?5>X?;<"] 9$:5$: E?:":] 9<"
>93>E? 4#? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#?N
! 45 3  ' '  
f E"9:5>54W3" @"2 4#? J"K:? 3$
$9Eb>#$95" >9:5?95e9$" E"95>3? 94#
X<" $:@$EWD>E" K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E$952"
3" X"K?95$N
! 45 3  ' ' 5 
f E"9:5>54W3" @"2 4#? J"K:? E"#
$9Eb>#$95" >9:5?95e9$" E"95>3?
94# ?3$Z4?3" E"#@?25>#$95"
:>54?3" 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":]
E"# 4# #?>"2 X"K4#$ $# 2$K?;<" g
3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2N
! 45   ^'G /[  450 
'    / .- 0
- ?>2J?a @?2? _"$Kb": ^ E"9:5>54W3"
@"2 4#? J"K:? 3$ $9Eb>#$95" >9:5?9A
5e9$" E"95>3? $# 4# X<" $:@$EWD>E"
:>54?3" :"J ? E"J$2542? 3? E"K49? >9A
D$2>"2 g ?K542? 3": _"$Kb": 3" #"5"A
2>:5?N - {9$$ J?a D"29$E$ 4#? @2"5$A
;<" ?3>E>"9?K ?" #"5"2>:5? $# E?:"
3$ >#@?E5" D2"95?K X>"K$95"N
! 45 3  '  '  &
5   , G   ,  6
- 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: 9" J?9E"
3>?95$>2" ^ @2">J>3"] :?KX" $pE$;\$:
>93>E?3?: ?95$2>"2#$95$ 9$:5$ E?@WA
54K"N +# 5?>: E?:": $pE$@E>"9?>:] ?:
E?3$>2>9b?: Z4$ :$ #"95?# 9" :$9A
5>3" E"952‘2>" ?" 3$ #?2Eb? 9<" 3$A
X$# ! :$2 #"95?3?: 9" J?9E"
3>?95$>2" E"# ?>2J?a 3" K?3" 3" @?:A
:?a$>2" ?5>X"] 4#? X$Y Z4$ ? ?5>X?;<"
3" ?>2J?a] $# E?:" 3$ Eb"Z4$] @"A
3$2>? @2"34Y>2 K$:\$: #"25?>: 9? E2>A
?9;? 52?9:@"25?3?N
%
!#!
’Ka4#?: X$2:\$: 5[# ?>2J?a D2"9A
5?K 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" ,+&1C+
’.=V-N
!$::$: E?:":] ^ @2">J>3" " 52?9:A
@"25$ 3? E2>?9;? 9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2"N
,$a4>2 "  ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$:
@2$:$95$: 9? $5>Z4$5? :>54?3? 9" @?2?A
:"K 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"N
0$&%
 *67   45 ' 
5 )  45 3  '   45
' '    67  4, ` 
Q (   , / .- 0
- 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: 9" J?9E"
3>?95$>2" ^ @2">J>3"] :?KX" $pE$;\$:
>93>E?3?: ?95$2>"2#$95$ 9$:5$ E?@WA
54K"N +# 5?>: E?:": $pE$@E>"9?>:]
E?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" 52?9:@"25?2 4#?
E2>?9;? 94#? E?3$>2>9b? X>2?3? 9"
:$95>3" "@":5" ?" :$95>3" 3$ #?2Eb?
9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 3$A
:?5>X?2 " ?>2J?a D2"95?K 3" K?3" 3"
@?::?a$>2" $ " ?>2J?a K?5$2?K 3>?95$>2"
q,>3$ J?arN
1?2? ? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2J?a:]
?54?2 9" &$94 3" 3>:@K?y qE"9:4KA
5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" x*>:@K?yz 9" E?@W54K"
x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95":zrN
!? #"K342?] :>54?3? 9" @?>9$K
3$ >9:524#$95":] $:5<" @2$:$95$: ":
)+*:  $  N
8"K"E?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>A
;<" 9? @":>;<"  ] ": 3">: )+*:
?E$93$#A:$ 342?95$ ?Ka49: :$a49A
3":N 8?:" >::" 9<" ?E"95$;?] 3>2>a>2A
:$ g   ! = ,  > N *4A
0$&&
2?95$ ": @2>#$>2": :$a493":] " ?E$9A
3>#$95" 3": )+*: 9<" >93>E? " 2$?K
$:5?3" 3? @2"5$;<" 3" @?::?a$>2"]
#?: 5$# ?@$9?: " "J_$5>X" 3$ X$2>D>A
E?2 " :$4 E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95"N ’
:$a4>2 ?" 5$:5$] E"# ? 342?;<" 3$ ?KA
a49: :$a493":] ": )+*: >93>E?2<" "
$:5?3" 3? @2"5$;<" 3" ?>2J?a 3" @?:A
:?a$>2"N
67  5   *) "
)+*  ?E$93$A:$ E"# K4Y D>p?N
67  5   &
*) " )+*  ?E$93$A:$ E"#
K4Y D>p?N
-: )+*: @"3$# ?E$93$2A:$ E"#
>95$9:>3?3$: 3>D$2$95$:] E"9D"2#$ ?:
E"93>;\$: 3" X$WE4K"N ’ >95$9:>3?3$
@"3$ X?2>?2 342?95$ " #$:#" E>EK"
3$ Eb?X$N
!%! !! / .- 0
1?2? ?4#$95?2 ? @2"5$;<" 3": "E4A
@?95$:] $# E?:" 3$ Eb"Z4$ K?5$2?K]
" X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# ?>2J?a:
K?5$2?>: 3>?95$>2": q,>3$ J?ar $ ?>2J?a:
3$ E"25>9? q¤>93"j J?arN
  45
,<" E"9:5>54W3": @"2 3">: 5>@": 3$
J"K:?: 9": $9E":5": 3": J?9E": 3>?9A
5$>2": Z4$ @2"5$a$# ? ‘2$? 3? J?E>?]
3" 5h2?p $ 3?: E":5?: 3": "E4@?95$:
$# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<" K?5$2?K 3$ a2?X>A
3?3$ #^3>?A?K5?N
,<" ?::>9?K?3": @$K? $5>Z4$5? t’=CA
B’St E":542?3? 9" K?3" $p5$2>"2 3":
J?9E": 3>?95$>2":N
R \ 45
f E"9:5>54W3" @"2 4#? J"K:? x3$
E"25>9?z ?K"_?3? @"2 52‘: 3": 2$X$:5>A
#$95": K?5$2?>: 3" 5$5" $ E"J$25? @"2
?E?J?#$95": ?3$Z4?3":N
.[# " "J_$5>X" 3$ @2"5$a$2 ? E?A
J$;? 3": "E4@?95$: 3>?95$>2": $ 52?A
:$>2": $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<" K?5$2?K] a2?A
;?: g :4? ?#@K? :4@$2DWE>$ 3$ 3$:$9A
X"KX>#$95"N
+# E?:" 3$ Eb"Z4$: K?5$2?>: 3$
J?>p? a2?X>3?3$] ? ?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2A
J?a: K?5$2?>: 9<" ^ 9$E$::‘2>?N
’ #$Kb"2 @2"5$;<" @"2 @?25$ 3"
:>:5$#? $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<" K?5$2?K
"J5^#A:$ #?95$93" 4#? E"22$5? @"A
:>;<" 9" J?9E" @$2#>5>93"] 3$::$
#"3"] 4# E"22$5" 3$:3"J2?#$95" 3"
¤>93"j J?aN
!#!
!<" ?@K>E?2 ?3$:>X": "4 "452": "JA
_$5": 9" X"K?95$] 9" @?>9$K 9? ‘2$?
3" ?>2J?a 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"] 9"
2$X$:5>#$95" K?5$2?K 3" K?3" 3" 5$5"
$ 9": J?9E":N
!<" E"K"E?2 "J_$5": 9" @?>9$K 9"
K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" q@"2 $p$#@K"] E$A
K4K?2$:r 4#? X$Y Z4$ @"3$2>?# >95$2A
D$2>2 E"# ? E"22$5? ?J$2542? 3" ?>2J?a
3" @?::?a$>2" $] @"2 "452" K?3"] E?4A
:?2 K$:\$: a2?X$: ?": "E4@?95$: 3"
X$WE4K"N
!#!
8"934Y>2 #?95$93" :$#@2$ ?:
#<": 9" X"K?95$] 3$ #"3" Z4$]
$# E?:" 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3" ?>2J?a]
$:5$ @"::? $9Eb$2A:$ :$# $9E"952?2
"J:5‘E4K":N
!<" E"934Y>2 E"# " E"2@" 3$J24A
;?3" @?2? ? D2$95$ #?: #?95$2 " $9A
E":5" 94#? @":>;<" $2$5?] ?@">?93"
J$# ?: E":5?:N
!#!
- 52?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: 9" J?9E"
3>?95$>2" ^ @2">J>3"] :?KX" $pE$;\$:
>93>E?3?: ?95$2>"2#$95$ 9$:5$ E?@WA
54K"N +# 5?>: E?:": $pE$@E>"9?>:] 9?
@2$:$9;? 3$ ?>2J?a 3" K?3" 3" @?::?A
a$>2" ?5>X?3"] !0- >9:5?K?2 E?3$>2>A
9b? >9D?95>K X>2?3? 9" :$95>3" "@":5"
?" :$95>3" 3$ #?2Eb? 9" J?9E" 3>A
?95$>2"N +# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<"] ? ?5>A
X?;<" 3" ?>2J?a @"3$ @2"34Y>2 K$A
:\$: #"25?>: 9? E2>?9;? 52?9:@"25?3?]
>93$@$93$95$#$95$ 3? a2?X>3?3$ 3?
E"K>:<"N
1"25?95"] 3$:?5>X?2 :$#@2$ " ?>2A
J?a 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" Z4?93"
9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" 3" @?::?a$>2" :$
>9:5?K? 4#? E?3$>2>9b? @?2? E2>?9;?:
#"95?3? 9" :$95>3" "@":5" ?" :$9A
5>3" 3$ #?2Eb?N ’K^# 3>::"] " J?9E"
3>?95$>2" 3" @?::?a$>2" 3$X$ :$2 2$A
a4K?3" @?2? ? @":>;<" #?>: 2$E4?3?]
@?2? $X>5?2 @"::WX$>: E"95?5": 3? E?A
3$>2>9b? @?2? E2>?9;?: E"# " @?>9$KN
C$?5>X?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ " ?>2J?a 3"
@?::?a$>2" ?::># Z4$ :$ 5>X$2 3$:>9:A
5?K?3" ? @2h@2>? E?3$>2>9b?N
!#!
1?2? ? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2J?a:] 45>A
K>Y$ " &$94 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$9A
%
5": q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
8"9:4K5?2 " E?@W54K" x8"9b$E$93"
" :$4 @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":z 9"
@?2‘a2?D" x-@;\$: 3" #$94zN
!#!
!<" @2$93$2 "J_$5": 2Wa>3": ?":
E?J>3$: $ g: ?K;?: 3$ :4:5$95?;<"N
+::$: "J_$5": @"3$# >95$2D$2>2 E"#
? E"22$5? ?J$2542? 3": j>93"j J?a:
0$&’
$] @"2 "452" K?3"] E?4:?2 K$:\$: a2?A
X$: ?": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
!<" ?@">?2 ? E?J$;?] ": J2?;": "4
": E"5"X$K": 9? @"25?] 9?: _?9$K?: $
9? ‘2$? 3" j>93"j J?aN
+::?: @2$E?4;\$: 5[# " "J_$5>X"
$X>5?2 @"::WX$>: K$:\$: 342?95$ ? D?:$
3$ $9Eb>#$95"N
!#!
!<" E"K"E?2 949E? ? E?J$;?] ":
J2?;": $ ": E"5"X$K": D"2? 3?: _?9$A
K?:N
+X>5$ ?E>3$95$:N
!#!
,$ ? K4YA$:@>? 9<" :$ ?E$93$2
@":>E>"9?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>A
0$&*
;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" ] "4 D>E?2 2": E"# 2$X$:5>#$95":] E"J$2542?: "4
?E$:? 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] ^ @"::WX$K E?@? @?2? J?9E":N
Z4$ $:5$_? @2$:$95$ 4#? ?9"#?K>?
9": :>:5$#?: 3$ 2$5$9;<"N +:5$: @"3$# @2$_43>E?2 " D49E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N
!$::$ E?:"] ": @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2$:
"4 ": ?>2J?a: @"3$# 9<" :$ ?5>X?2 $#
E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$ "4] $# 4# 9u#$2"
3$ E?:": #?>: K>#>5?3"] ?5>X?2A:$ 3$
!#!
#"3" $22?3"N ’95$: 3$ @2"::$a4>2]
E"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > !<" X>?_?2 E"# "J_$5": ?" E"K"]
@?2? " >#$3>?5" E"952"K$ 3" :>:5$#?N $# D2$95$ ?" 5h2?p 9$# E"# E?Eb>#A
J": "4 K‘@>: 9? J"E?] $5EN
+# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<" E"# >95$2X$9A
;<" 3" ?>2J?a] @"3$2<" E?4:?2 3?9":
!#! a2?X$:N
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $# E?:" 3$
?X?2>? 3" )+*  q:>54?3" 9?
#"K342? @2$:$95$ 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:A
!#!
524#$95":r] ?E$93$A:$ ? K4YA$:@>?
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N ,$ " X$WE4K" 5>X$2 :>3" "J_$5" 3$
2"4J" "4 5$95?5>X? 3$ 2"4J"] :$ 5>X$2
’5$9;<" g: :>9?K>Y?;\$:N
:"D2>3" ?5": 3$ X?93?K>:#"] >9493?A
;\$: "4 ?K?a?#$95":] #?93?2 X$2>D>A
E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ ?>2J?a:N
+::$ @2"E$3>#$95" 3$X$ :$2 2$?K>A
!#!
Y?3" 9?   ! = ,  > N
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ ,>3$ J?a:] 9<" E"A
J2>2 " $9E":5" 3": J?9E": 3>?95$>A

!#!
8"# " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9?
@":>;<" ] #$:#" E"# " #"5"2
3$:K>a?3"] ": ?>2J?a: @"3$# :$2 ?5>A
X?3": 5?#J^# E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"]
E?:" $:5$ :"D2? Eb"Z4$ 3$ "452" X$WA
E4K" $# #"X>#$95"N ’::>#] #$:#"
E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] :$ $:5>X$2 @2$A
:$95$ ?Ka4#? $pE$;<" @2$X>:5? 9? )$>
Z4$ _4:5>D>Z4$ ? >9:5?K?;<" 3? E?3$>A
2>9b? 9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2"] ?: E?3$>A
2>9b?: 3$ E2>?9;?: Z4$ :$ #"95?#
9" :$95>3" "@":5" ?" :$95>3" 3? #?2A
Eb? ! 3$X$# :$2 >9:5?K?3?: 9"
J?9E" 3>?95$>2" 3" @?::?a$>2" 9? @2$A
:$9;? 3$ ?>2J?a 3" @?::?a$>2" ?5>X"N
1"25?95"] 3$:?5>X?2 :$#@2$ " ?>2A
J?a 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" Z4?93"
9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" 3" @?::?a$>2" :$
>9:5?K? 4#? E?3$>2>9b? @?2? E2>?9;?:
#"95?3? 9" :$95>3" "@":5" ?" :$9A
5>3" 3$ #?2Eb?N ’K^# 3>::"] " J?9E"
3>?95$>2" 3" @?::?a$>2" 3$X$ :$2 2$A
a4K?3" @?2? ? @":>;<" #?>: 2$E4?3?]
@?2? $X>5?2 @"::WX$>: E"95?5": 3? E?A
3$>2>9b? @?2? E2>?9;?: E"# " @?>A
9$KN C$?5>X?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ " ?>2A
J?a 3" @?::?a$>2" ?::># Z4$ 5>X$2 3$A
:>9:5?K?3" ? @2h@2>? E?3$>2>9b?N 1"2
D>#] 2$E"23?2A:$ Z4$] :$ " E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" :$ $9E"952?2 9? @":>;<"
 ] 9$9b4# 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ :$a4A
2?9;? q?>2J?a: "4 @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2$:r
^ ?5>X?3" $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:<"d ? D?K5?
3$ ?5>X?;<" 3$ 5?>: 3>:@":>5>X":] 9$:A
5$: E?:":] 9<" @"3$ :$2 E"9:>3$2?3?
E"#" :>9?K 3$ ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#?N
!#!
’ ?X?2>? 3? K4YA$:@>? ^ >93>E?3?
E"# " ?E$93>#$95"] 9" 3>:@K?y 3"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":] 3$ 4# WE"9$
3$ ?X?2>? 3" ?>2J?a $ @$K? X>:4?K>A
Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
!<" :<" 3$:?5>X?3?: ?: E?2a?: @>2"A
5^E9>E?:N
’95$: 3$ @2"::$a4>2] E"95?5?2 ?
  ! = ,  > @?2? "
>#$3>?5" E"952"K$ 3" :>:5$#?N
!#!
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3" ?>2J?a $:5‘
@2$X>:5? @?2? 5>@": 3$ E"K>:\$:
3$ a2?X>3?3$ :4@$2>"2 g 3": @2^A
5$9:>"9?3"2$:N
+# E"K>:\$: E"#@2$$93>3?: 9" >9A
5$2X?K" $952$ ": 3">: K>#>5$: 3$ ?5>X?A
;<"] ^ 9"2#?K Z4$ :"#$95$ ": @2^A
5$9:>"9?3"2$: $952$# $# D49E>"9?A
#$95"N
%
!#!
- ?>2J?a 9<" :4J:5>54> ": E>95":
3$ :$a42?9;?] #?: ?4#$95? ? :4?
$D>E‘E>?N
*?3" Z4$ ": ?>2J?a: D2"95?>: 9<"
>95$2X[# $# E?:" 3$ E"K>:\$: D2"95?>:
? J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$] E"K>:\$: K?5$2?>:]
E"K>:\$: 52?:$>2?: "4 E?@"5?#$95":]
": "E4@?95$: $:5<" @2"5$a>3":] ?K^#
3": $X$954?>: ?>2J?a: K?5$2?>:] @$K":
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? Z4$] @"25?95"]
3$X$# $:5?2 :$#@2$ ?@$25?3":N
0$&+

!<" K?X?2 ": J?9E": E"# ‘a4? "4
X?@"2 :"J @2$::<" qg #<" "4 9?: $:A
5?;\$: 3$ K?X?a$# ?45"#‘5>E?: @?2?
J?9E":rN

’ ?5>X?;<" 3": ?>2J?a: D2"95?>: $o"4
K?5$2?>: ^ @"::WX$K :$ " X$WE4K" D"2
:4J#$5>3" ? D"25$: E"K>:\$: 2$K?E>"A
9?3?: g ‘2$? >9D$2>"2 3? E?22"E$2>?
q$pN E"K>:\$: X>"K$95?: E"952? a2?A
3$:] @?::$>":] Z4$3?: 3" X$WE4K" $#
a2?93$: J42?E": "4 3$@2$::\$: 3$ $:A
52?3?] $5ENrN

’ $952?3? $# D49E>"9?#$95" 3":
?>2J?a: K>J$25? 4#? @$Z4$9? Z4?95>A
3?3$ 3$ @h:% $:5$: 9<" :<" 9"E>X": $
9<" >93>E?# 4# @2>9EW@>" 3$ >9E[9A
3>"N !" $95?95"] " @h @"3$2‘ >22>5?2
? @$K$ $ ": "Kb":% 9$:5$ E?:"] K?X?2
E"# :?J<" 9$452" $ ‘a4?N
0$&,

."3?: ?: >95$2X$9;\$: 3$ E"952"K$]
2$@?2?;<" $ :4J:5>54>;<" >9$2$95$:
?": ?>2J?a: 3$X$# :$2 $D$54?3?: 9?
  ! = ,  > :

+# E?:" 3$ :4E?5$?#$95" 3" X$WA
E4K"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
> @?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ ?>2A
J?a:N

’ ?5>X?;<" 3$ @2^A5$9:>"9?3"2$: $
?>2J?a: ^ 3$E>3>3? 3$ #"3" 3>D$2$9A
E>?3"] E"# J?:$ 9" 5>@" 3$ E"K>:<"N
’ 9<" ?5>X?;<" 3$ 4# "4 #?>: ?>2A
J?a: 9<" >93>E? 4# #?4 D49E>"9?A
#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N
'   ' C+’B’,.+8+!*- - V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N PA|6
S’!8T- *+ C+B-w(+ N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA~H
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA7
*=8’, *+ *=C+/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA~6
1’C.=*’ *- &-.-C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA7
C+8-&+!*’/n+, 1’C’ *+,)=S’C -
&-.-C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI
PC+=- *+ +,.’8=-!’&+!.- N N N N N N N N N N N PA6
.C’!,&=,,0- ’(.-&“.=8’ N N N N N N N N N N PA7G
.C’/0- =!.+SC’) N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA7F
,=,.+&’ *+ 8-!.C-)+ *+ .C’/0- 1-C +=¡-
q.C’8.=-! 8-!.C-)¥r N N N N N N N N N N N N N PALG
*=C+/0- ’,,=,.=*’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PALH
&-*- *+ 8-!*(/0- ,1-C. N N N N N N N N N PALI
,=,.+&’ ,.’C.',.-1 q,+ +w(=1’*-r N N N N N PALI
)=&=.’*-C *+ V+)-8=*’*+ N N N N N N N N N N PALM &
8-!.C-)+ *+ V+)-8=*’*+ N N N N N N N N N N PAH7
,=,.+&’ *+ ’V=,- *+ ’P’,.’&+!.- *’
P’=¡’ *+ C-*’S+& q,+ +w(=1’*-r N N N N N N PAIL
&-!=.-C *+ ,-!-)l!8=’ -( *=,.C’/0-
*- &-.-C=,.’ q*2>X>9a *2"j:9$:: ?93
*>:52?E5>"9r q,$ $Z4>@?3"r N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI|
’,,=,.+!.+ *+ +,.’8=-!’&+!.- N N N N N N N PAI~
8⁄&+C’ *+ Cf N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA|H

1
1
 
+952$#": 9" tE"2?;<"t 3" X$WE4K"%
X$_?#": E"#" 45>K>Y‘AK" 3? #$Kb"2
D"2#? $# 5"3?: ?: :4?: @"5$9E>?K>3?A
3$:N !$:5$ E?@W54K" $:5<" 3$:E2>5":
@2"E$3>#$95": 3$ E"#" E"934Y>AK"
$# :$a42?9;? $# Z4?KZ4$2 :>54?;<"N
'   

" !
’95$: 3$ K>a?2 " X$WE4K"] 2$a4K?2 "
J?9E"] ": $:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"2$: >95$2A
9": $ $p5$29": $ ?@$25?2 E"22$5?#$95$
" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;?N
1?2? ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2] 949E?
@2$::>"9?2 " @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2N
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>"] 9" 3>:@K?y @"A
3$# X>:4?K>Y?2A:$ #$9:?a$9: Z4$ >9A
3>E?# " @2"E$3>#$95" @?2? $D$54?2 ?
@?25>3?N
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
:>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? Z4$ D?Y ? a$:5<"
?45"#‘5>E? 3" #"5"2 3$ @?25>3?] 9<"
:$93" 9$E$::‘2>" #?95$2 ? Eb?X$ a>A
2?3? 9? @":>;<" !@! "4 " J"A
5<" !@ @2$::>"9?3" 5"3" "
5$#@" ?5^ Z4$ " #"5"2 3[ ? @?25>3?N
!#!
- #"5"2 E"9:"#$ "p>a[9>" $ K>J$2?
a‘: E?2Jv9>E"] #"9hp>3" 3$ E?2J"9"
$ "452": a?:$: 5hp>E":N
f @$2>a":" 3$>p?2 " #"5"2 D49E>"A
9?93" $# K"E?K D$Eb?3"N
!#!
+9Z4?95" " #"5"2 9<" $:5>X$2 K>A
a?3"] " :$2X"D2$>" 9<" $:5‘ ?5>X"N
*>?95$ 3>::"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" $p$2E$2
4# $:D"2;" 9" @$3?K 3$ D2$>" #4>5"
#?>"2 3" Z4$ " b?J>54?KN
!#!
1?2? ": X$WE4K": E?5?K>:?3": 3$X$
:$2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ $X>5?3" ? @?25>3?
E"# $#@422<"] 2$J"Z4$ "4 ?@2"X$>A
5?93" ?: 3$:E>3?:N
+::?: #?9"J2?: @"3$# E?4:?2 "
?DK4p" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K 9" E"9X$2:"2
E?5?KW5>E" $ 3?9>D>E‘AK" >22$#$3>?X$KA
#$95$N
!#!
’Ka49: E4>3?3": :<" 9$E$::‘2>":
&
9" @2>#$>2" @$2W"3" 3$ X>?a$#N
!": @2>#$>2": 7FGG i#] 9<" $p>A
a>2 " #‘p>#" 3$:$#@$9b" 3" X$WA
E4K" q@"2 $pN] ?E$K$2?;\$: $pE$::>X?:]
3>:5e9E>?: 3$#?:>?3?#$95$ @2"K"9A
a?3?: 9": 2$a>#$: #‘p>#":] D2$9?A
a$9: $pE$::>X?#$95$ J24:E?:] $5ENrN
1$!

!#!
8"# " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3"] 9<" 3$>p?2
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
"!N
+:5? ?5>543$ $X>5? " E"9:4#" >93$A
:$_‘X$K 3$ $9$2a>? 3? J?5$2>?N
" !! ? " E"9345"2 @"3$ 3?2 ? @?25>3?N
N
’@h: a>2?2 ? Eb?X$ @?2? ? @":>A
;<" !@! "4 @2$::>"9?2 " J"A
5<" !@ ] " :>:5$#? >2‘ ?5>A
X?2 " #"5"2 3$ @?25>3? @$K" 5$#@"
9$E$::‘2>" ?" D49E>"9?#$95" 3" #"A
5"2N +# E?:" 3$ 9<" D49E>"9?#$95"
3" #"5"2] " :>:5$#? >2‘ >95$22"#@$2
? 5$95?5>X? 3$ @?25>3? ?@h: 4# 5$#@"
#‘p>#" 3$ 7G :$a493":] "E?:><" $#
Z4$ @"3$2‘ :$2 $D$54?3? 4#? 9"X?
5$95?5>X? 3$ K>a?2 " #"5"2N

w4?93" ? 5$#@$2?542? $:5>X$2
?J?>p" 3$ E$2E? 3$ 7F 8 $ " :>:5$#?
1$"
?J?:5$E>3" E"# $5?9"K] "4 4#?
#>:542? $5?9"K ¥ a?:"K>9?] " :>:5$#?
3$ ?Z4$E>#$95" 3" E"#J4:5WX$K :$2‘
?5>X?3" E"# ? ?J$2542? 3? @"25? 3"
#"5"2>:5?N ,$ 4#? 5$95?5>X? 3$ @?2A
5>3? D"2 D$>5? ?95$: Z4$ " @2"E$::" 5$2A
#>9$] ? K4YA$:@>? :$ ?E$93$2‘ $
@$2#?9$E$2‘ ?E$:? ?5^ Z4$ " :>:5$#?
$:5$_? @2"95"N ’::># Z4$ " E"#J4:A
5WX$K ?5>9a>2 ? 5$#@$2?542? >3$?K] ?
K4YA$:@>? :$ ?@?a?2‘] >93>E?93" Z4$
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 +9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
$K^52>E" $ @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E?
3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"A
9?#$95"r "4  q1"95" #"25"rN
 1>:?2 9" @$3?K 3$ D2$>"] :$# @>:?2
9" ?E$K$2?3"2N
 S>2?2 ? Eb?X$ 9" E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" ?5^ ? @":>;<"
!@! "4 @2$::>"9?2 "
J"5<" !@ N
 ,$ " #"5"2 9<" K>a?2] X"K5?2
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2?
? @":>;<"  a>2?93" ?
Eb?X$ "4 @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"
!@ $ ?a4?23?2 7G 76
:$a493": ?95$: 3$ 2$@$5>2 ?
#?9"J2? 3$ @?25>3?N
" !! ?

!#!
- ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? 3$
#"3" >95$2#>5$95$ ?@h: ? @?25>3? "4
342?95$ 4#? E"934;<" @2"K"9a?3?
?::>9?K? 4#? ?9"#?K>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$
@2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3?: X$K?:N
,$ " #"5"2 K>a?2] ^ @"::WX$K 45>K>Y?2
2$a4K?2#$95$ " X$WE4K"] #?: ^ @2$A
E>:" 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$ g 
 ! = ,  > :
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 +9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
$K^52>E" $ @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E?
3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"A
9?#$95"r "4  q1"95" #"25"rN
 1>:?2 9" @$3?K 3$ D2$>"] :$# @>:?2
9" ?E$K$2?3"2N
 S>2?2 ? Eb?X$ 9" E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" ?5^ ? @":>;<" ! "4
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" !@ N
 ,$ " #"5"2 9<" K>a?2] X"K5?2
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2?
? @":>;<"  a>2?93" ?
Eb?X$ "4 @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"
!@ $ ?a4?23?2 7G 76
:$a493": ?95$: 3$ 2$@$5>2 ?
#?9"J2? 3$ @?25>3?N

,$] E"# " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9?
@":>;<"  ] " :W#J"K" 9" 3>:A
@K?y @$2#?9$E$2 ?E$:" _495?#$95$
E"# ? K4YA$:@>? ] X"K5?2 ? E"K"E?2
" E"#45?3"2 9? @":>;<"  @ $
3$@">: 9"X?#$95$ $#  N ,$ ? K4YA
$:@>? q"4 " :W#J"K" 9" 3>:@K?yr @$2A
#?9$E$2 ?E$:?] X"K5?2 ? 5$95?2 E"# ?:
"452?: Eb?X$: D"29$E>3?:N ,$] #$:#"
?::>#] 9<" D"2 @"::WX$K K>a?2 " #"5"2]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N
!! ! < !!
!!
w4?93" " X$WE4K" 9<" D"2 K>a?3"
"4 E"934Y>3" 342?95$ @$K" #$9": HG
3>?:] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 5$2 ": :$a4>95$:
E4>3?3":N
1?2? K>a?2 " #"5"2] @2"E$3$2 3"
:$a4>95$ #"3"%
 8"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<" !@! N
 ,$ " #"5"2 9<" K>a?2 3$952" 3$
7G :$a493":] X"K5?2 ? E"K"E?2 "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 ] ?a4?23?2 6 :$a493": $
3$>p?2 ?22$D$E$2 " #"5"2 3$ @?2A
5>3?d $# :$a4>3?] 2$@$5>2 " @2"E$A
3>#$95" 3$ @?25>3?N
 ,$ " #"5"2 9<" K>a?2 ?@h: ~ 5$9A
5?5>X?:] 3$>p?2 ?22$D$E$2 " #"5"2
3$ @?25>3? 342?95$ @$K" #$9": 7G
:$a493": $] $# :$a4>3?] 2$@$5>2 "
@2"E$3>#$95"N

(#? @?25>3? ?@h: >9?5>X>3?3$ @2"A
K"9a?3? 3" X$WE4K" @?25>E4K?2#$95$
3>DWE>K] @"3$ 5?#J^# :$2 @2"X"E?3?
@$K" @?2E>?K 3$:E?22$a?#$95" 3? J?A
5$2>?N !$::$ E?:"] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" t1?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>?t 9" E?A
@W54K" t+# E?:" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?tN
!!  !!  "
!* 
!<" 5$95?2 ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 3$>A
p?93" E"#J4:5WX$K "4 "452" KWZ4>3"
>9DK?#‘X$K 9" >95$2>"2 3? 5"#?3? 3$
?2 3" E"2@" 3$ J"2J"K$5?% $:5? "@$2?A
;<" @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9": 9" #"5"2 $
$# $X$954?>: @$::"?: Z4$ :$ $9E"9A
52$# 9?: @2"p>#>3?3$:N
!<" 5$95?2 ? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2 2$J"A
E?93" "4 $#@422?93" " X$WE4K"N +:A &
5?: #?9"J2?: @2"X"E?2>?# ? $952?3?
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K 9" E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KWA
5>E" Z4$] 9? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2] :$ >9A
DK?#?2>?] @2"X"E?93" " :"J2$?Z4$E>A
#$95" $ 3?9": 9" @2h@2>" E"9X$2:"2N
+# E?:" 3$ J?5$2>? 3$:E?22$a?3?] ^
@"::WX$K $D$54?2 4#? @?25>3? 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>? K>a?93"A?] ?52?X^: 3$ E?J":
?3$Z4?3":] ? 4#? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2 "4
g J?5$2>? 3$ "452" X$WE4K"N ."3?X>?]
1$%
$:5? #?9"J2? @"3$ :$2 @$2>a":? :$
$D$54?3? 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5"N 8"9:4KA
5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" t1?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>?t 9" E?@W54K" t+# E?:" 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>?tN
     , 4  
,G* ' I , /EF'   &&
0 , 5
’ D?K5? 3$ 2$:@":5? 3" 3>:@":>5>X"
3$ @?25>3? ?" @2$::>"9?2 " 2$:@$E5>X"
J"5<" @"3$ :>a9>D>E?2 Z4$ ? J?5$2>? 3?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? $:5$_? 3$:E?22$a?3?N
’::>#] " :>:5$#? 9<" >2‘ 3$5$E5?2 ?
@2$:$9;? 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? ? J"23"
3" X$WE4K" $ X>:4?K>Y?2‘ 9" 3>:@K?y
4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?N
!$:5$ E?:"] ?@">?2 ? $p52$#>3?3$
?22$3"93?3? 3? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?
qK?3" "@":5" 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ?" Z4?K :$
$9E"952? " E"2@" #$5‘K>E"r 9" J"5<"
3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @?25>3? $ @2$::>"A
9?2 " @2h@2>" J"5<" ?52?X^: 3? Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E?N *$::$ #"3" ?E>"9?A:$ "
3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @?25>3? 3" #"5"2N
1$&
!;"  "
 ! < ! !!
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 8"K"E?2 K$95?#$95$ " X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95"] D?Y$93" " #"5"2 2"A
3?2 $# 2$a>#$ #^3>"] :$# :"K>E>A
5?2 ?E$K$2?;\$: J24:E?:
 +X>5?2 @2"E42?2] 3$:3$ ": @2>#$>A
2": Z4>Kv#$52":] " #‘p>#" 3$ 3$A
:$#@$9b"N f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K ?a4?2A
3?2 Z4$ " >93>E?3"2 3? 5$#@$2?A
542? 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"
3" #"5"2 E"#$E$ ? :4J>2N
!"  ? 1?2? 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2] @2"E$3$2 3"
% :$a4>95$ #"3"%
’95$: 3$ 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2] #?95[A
K" $# #?2Eb? K$95? 342?95$ ?Ka49:
#>945": 3$ #"3" ? @$2#>5>2 4#? K4A
J2>D>E?;<" ?3$Z4?3? 3" 542J"E"#A
@2$::"2N +:5$ @2"E$3>#$95" ^ @?2A
5>E4K?2#$95$ ?E"9:$Kb?3" ?@h: 4#?
E"934;<" $p>a$95$N
’@h: " D49E>"9?#$95" E"# @K$9?
E?2a? "4] $# 5"3" " E?:"] E"# D"25$:
:"K>E>5?;\$: 3$ @"5[9E>?] #?95$2 "
#"5"2 $# #?2Eb? K$95? 3$ H ? 6
#>945": ?95$: 3$ 3$:K>a‘AK"N
+:5$ @$2W"3" 3$ 5$#@" @$2#>5$ ?"
hK$" K4J2>D>E?95$ $ ?" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$A
D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 $K>#>9?2 " E?K"2
$pE$::>X" 3? Ee#?2? 3$ E"#J4:5<"]
2"K?#$95":] E"#@"9$95$: >95$29": $
542J"E"#@2$::"2N
 #
'    

"
 +:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" 94#? @":>A
;<" Z4$ 9<" E"9:5>54? @$2>a" @?2?
" 52e9:>5"N
 1":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"
$# q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r N
 ’E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N
 8"# " #"5"2 $# #?2Eb? K$95?]
E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  N
!* 
8"# " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3"] 9<" 3$>p?2
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
N
G* ' I , /EF'   &&
0
8"# X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" :4@$A
2>"2 ? ~ i#ob ^] $# 5"3" " E?:"] @":A
:WX$K 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2] #$:#" E"#
? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 94#? @":>A
;<" 3>D$2$95$ 3$ q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN
!$:5$ E?:"] @?2? 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2]
^ 9$E$::‘2>" @2$::>"9?2 @2"K"9a?3?A
#$95$ " J"5<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @?2A
5>3? "4 @2$::>"9‘AK" H X$Y$: E"9:$A
E45>X?#$95$ 9" $:@?;" 3$ @"4E": :$A
a493":N !$:5$ E?:"] " #"5"2 3$:K>A
a?2‘ $ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" :$2‘
@":>E>"9?3" $#  N
8"# " :>:5$#? {$yK$:: +95$2A!A
S"] ^ @"::WX$K ?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K"
E"# " #"5"2 K>a?3"] K$X?93" E"9:>a"
? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E?] :$# Z4$ " #"A
5"2 :$ 3$:K>a4$N - X$WE4K" ?::>9?K?2‘ "     
? @2$:$9;? 3? Eb?X$ ? J"23" 3" X$WA
E4K" ?@$9?: $# E?:" 3$ D$Eb?#$95"  
3?: @"25?:N   !!"
*$:K>a?93" " X$WE4K" q@?::?a$# 3? $
@":>;<"  @?2?  r] ? ?K>#$9A - X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
5?;<" 3": ?E$::h2>": ^ #?95>3? 34A D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] Z4$
2?95$ E$2E? 3$ H #>945":N a?2?95$ 4# 3$:$#@$9b" >3$?KN
’J2>93" ? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" E"9A - D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
345"2 E"# " Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
$:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4# >95$224@5"2]
?E$:"] :$2‘ $#>5>3" 4# J2$X$ :>9?K K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K] 4#
?Eu:5>E"] @?2? K$#J2?2 ?" E"9345"2 #"5"2 E"# @>9;? @?2? E?3? 2"3?
Z4$ 3$:K>a4$ " X$WE4K"N !" 3>:@K?y 52?:$>2? $ 4# #h34K" 3$ E"952"K$
:$2‘ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# $:A $K$52v9>E"N
@$EWD>E?N
w4?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
$:5‘ 9? @":>;<"  ] " D49E>"9?A
#$95" 3": K$X?95?3"2$: 3": X>32": &
$K^52>E": @$2#?9$E$ ?5>X" 342?95$
E$2E? 3$ H #>945":N ’ ?J$2542? 3$
4#? 3?: @"25?: 3>?95$>2?: ?94K? $:5?
D49;<"N
*$@">: 3$ 4# @$2E42:" 3$:a?:A
5?95$] ?95$: 3$ 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2] 3$>A
p?2 " #"5"2 $# #?2Eb? K$95? @?2?
@$2#>5>2 Z4$ J?>p$ ? 5$#@$2?542? 9"
>95$2>"2 3" X<" 3" #"5"2N
1$’


’95$: 3$ ?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K"] $9A
a?5?2 :$#@2$ " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $K^52>E"N

1?2? $:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"] 3$:K>a?2
" #"5"2] ?E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"] $ 3$>p?2 ?: 2"3?: X>2?3?: $#
3>2$;<" ?" #$>"AD>" qa4>?:r 3" @?:A
:$>"N ,$ " X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $:5?E>"9?3"
$# 4#? 3$:E>3? W9a2$#$] ?E"9:$Kb?A
:$ 5?#J^# ? 52?X?2 ?: 2"3?: E"# 4#
E?K;"] E49b?: "4 @$32?: @":>E>"9?A
3?: g D2$95$ 3?: 2"3?: q$# E?:" 3$
D"25$ >9EK>9?;<"rN .?#J^# @":>E>"A
9?2 :$#@2$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9?
@":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN

+# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9? J?5$2>? 3"
X$WE4K"] @?2? 3$:JK"Z4$?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] ^ 9$E$::‘A
2>" $D$54?2 ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$2>?N
- D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
@"3$ :$2 $9a?5?3" 3$ 34?: D"2#?:%
1$*
 &?94?K#$95$] @4p?93" " >95$2A
24@5"2 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?KN
 ’45"#?5>E?#$95$ 9?: E"93>;\$:
3$ t  t "4 3$ t    !(!8’ 3$>p?2 ?: E2>?9;?: 9" >9A
B2?i$tN
!,      -'  3   
,    
!#!
*42?95$ ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $# $:52?3?: E"# >9EK>9?;<"] ^
>#@2$:E>93WX$K $9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:A
5?E>"9?#$95"] ? @2>#$>2? #?2Eb? :$
$:5>X$2 $# :4J>3?] ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ $#
3$:E>3? q9? @2$:$9;? 3$ Ee#J>" ?4A
5"#‘5>E"] @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? $#
t tr $ X>2?2 ?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?:N
,$ " X$WE4K" D"2 $:5?E>"9?3" $#
>9EK>9?;\$: ?E$954?3?:] JK"Z4$?2 ?:
2"3?: E"# 4# E?K;"N
!#!
5$2>"2 3" X$WE4K" :$# X>a>Ke9E>?] 9$#
?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K" E"# ?: @"2A
5?: 3$:52?X?3?: 94# K"E?K D?E>K#$95$
?E$::WX$K g: E2>?9;?:N
8$25>D>E?2A:$ ?>93? 3$ Z4$ ?: E2>?9A
;?: 9<" ?E>"9$# >9?3X$25>3?#$95$ "
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] "
@$3?K 3" D2$>" "4 ? ?K?X?9E? 3? Ee#A
J>" ?45"#‘5>E"N
!#!
- D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
3$X$ :$2 :$#@2$ $9a?5?3" Z4?93" :$
?J?93"9? " X$WE4K"N
’54$ :$#@2$ E"# :$a42?9;?N
1?2? $9a?5?2 #?94?K#$95$ " D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" E"# "
X$WE4K" @?2?3"] @4p$ J2$X$#$95$ "
>95$224@5"2 K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$
E$952?KN
 *42?95$ " $9a?5$ 3" D2$>" 3$ $:5?A
E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] @"3$ @$2E$J$2A
:$ 4# K>a$>2" 24W3" @2"X$9>$95$ 3?
@?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
,$ $9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" E"# " @$3?K 3" D2$>" @2$::>A
"9?3"] @"3$ @$2E$J$2A:$ 4# K>a$>2"
#"X>#$95" 3" @$3?KN

+# E?:" 3$ ?E$93>#$95" 3?
K4YA$:@>? 3$ ?X?2>? 9" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>A
"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] ?Ka4#?: 3$ :4?:
D49E>"9?K>3?3$: :$2<" 3$:?5>X?3?:N
!$:5$ E?:"] " E"9345"2 ^ 2$:@"9A
:‘X$K @$K" ?E>"9?#$95" 3" D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K" $#
E"93>;\$: 3$ E"#@K$5? :$a42?9;?N
,$] $# E>2E49:5e9E>?: $pE$@E>"A
9?>:] D"2 9$E$::‘2>" :"K>E>5?2 ? >95$2A
X$9;<" 3" D2$>" E"# " X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95"] #?95$2 " >95$224@5"2 9"
E"9:"K$ E$952?K @4p?3" 342?95$ 5"3"
" 5$#@" $# Z4$ :$ @2$5$93$ ? >95$2A
X$9;<" 3" @2h@2>" D2$>"N
’ K4YA$:@>? @"3$ :$ ?E$93$2 :$
" :>:5$#? b>32‘4K>E" $:5>X$2 #"#$9A
5?9$?#$95$ >93>:@"9WX$K $ ? D2$9?A
a$# :"K>E>5?2 ?::>:5[9E>? 3": #"5"2$:
$K^52>E":N
’K^# 3>::"] ?E$93$#A:$ ?45"#?A
5>E?#$95$ ?: K4Y$: 3$ D2$>"] E"#"
?E"95$E$2>? @?2? 4#? D2$9?a$# 9"2A
#?K $D$54?3? ?52?X^: 3? @2$::<" 3"
@$3?K 3" D2$>"N
1?2? >95$22"#@$2 ? :"K>E>5?;<" 3$
D2$9?a$# E"# " X$WE4K" $# #"X>A
#$95"] :"K5?2 " >95$224@5"2 9" E"9A
:"K$ E$952?KN
,$] ?52?X^: 3$:5$ @2"E$3>#$95"] "
X$WE4K" D"2 D2$?3" ?5^ ?5>9a>2 4#? X$A
K"E>3?3$ >9D$2>"2 ? ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$
H i#ob $ " >95$224@5"2 D"2 #?95>3" @4A
p?3"] :$2‘ $9a?5?3" 3$D>9>5>X?#$95$
" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N

’ E"934;<" 3" X$WE4K" E"# "
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" $9A
a?5?3"] "4 ? 45>K>Y?;<" 2$@$5>3? 3"
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" @?2?
t?#?E>?2t " X$WE4K"] @"3$2>?# @2"A
X"E?2 a2?X$: 3?9": 9" :>:5$#? 3$ D2$A
9?a$#N
 5  -'  3    &
,     '9 ,
1?2? 3$:$9a?5?2 #?94?K#$95$ "
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"] ? Eb?X$ 3$
>a9>;<" 3$X$ $:5?2 9? @":>;<" 
N ’K^# 3>::"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" @>:?2 9"
@$3?K 3" D2$>"] $ 3$@">: @2$::>"9?2
J2$X$#$95$ " >95$224@5"2 9" E"9:"K$
E$952?KN
*42?95$ " 3$:$9a?5$] @"3$ :$2 @$2A
E$J>3" 4# K$X$ 24W3" @2"X$9>$95$ 3?
@?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"] J$# E"#"
4# K>a$>2" #"X>#$95" 3" @$3?K 3"
D2$>"N

&
!49E? 45>K>Y?2 ? @":>;<" q+:5?E>A
"9?#$95"r $# :4J:5>54>;<" 3" D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N w4?93"
$:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"] $9a?5?2 :$#@2$
" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
@?2? $X>5?2 K$:\$: "4 3?9": @2"X"E?A
3": @$K" #"X>#$95" >9E"952"K?3" 3"
X$WE4K"N
1$+
"!!  !&
"    !&
!" $
w4?93" " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
$:5>X$2 $9a?5?3" $ ?@K>E?3" g: 2"3?:
$# Z4?KZ4$2 4#? 3?: :$a4>95$: #"A
3?K>3?3$:] ?E$93$A:$ " )+* 9" >95$2A
24@5"2 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K _495?#$95$
E"# ? K4YA$:@>? 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95":N
!,     P ,
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" @"3$ :$2 $9A
a?5?3" @4p?93" 4#? u9>E? X$Y " >9A
5$224@5"2 K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$ E$9A
52?KN 1"2 "452" K?3"] @?2? 3$:$9a?5‘A
K"] ?E>"9$ " >95$224@5"2 #?95$93" "
@$3?K 3" D2$>" @2$::>"9?3"N
!,      ] ,
8"# " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"] "
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" ^ ?5>A
X?3" @4p?93" E"95>94?#$95$ " >9A
5$224@5"2 342?95$ ? E"934;<"N ’: K4A
Y$: 3$ D2$>" :$ ?E$93$2<" ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$N 1?2? 3$:$9a?5?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"] J?:5? :"K5?2 " >95$2A
1$,
24@5"2N 8?:" " X$WE4K" 5$9b? :4? X$A
K"E>3?3$ 2$34Y>3? ? @"95" 3$ @?2?2
E"#@K$5?#$95$] ? @?25>2 3$ ?@2"p>A
#?3?#$95$ 6 i#ob " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>A
"9?#$95" E"95>94?2‘ $9a?5?3"N
 * !\F ' /  
* H@  ,`   * 0
- D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
:$2‘ 3$:?5>X?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ :$
" E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" K?3" 3" #"A
5"2>:5? $:5>X$2 ?@$25?3" $] ?@h: @?2A
5>3? 9? >a9>;<" $ ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"
E"K"E?3? $#  "4  ] D"2 D$>5? 4#?
5$95?5>X? 3$ :?>2 E"# " X$WE4K"N
!-  [ % [
- D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"
@"3$ :$2 @2"a2?#?3" @?2? :$2 $9a?A
5?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ :$] E"# ? X$A
K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" >9D$2>"2 ? H i#ob]
? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" D"2 3$:K"E?3?
@?2? ? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN
+:5? #"3?K>3?3$ ^ b?J>K>5?3? "4 3$A
:?J>K>5?3? 9" #$94 3$ E"9D>a42?;\$:
3" (E"99$E5 q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:]
E"9:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
8?3? $9a?5$ ?45"#‘5>E" 3" D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" @"3$ :$2 ?94K?3"
@2$::>"9?93" " >95$224@5"2 9" E"9A
:"K$ E$952?K $] ?" #$:#" 5$#@"] 3$:A
K"E?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" ?45"A
#‘5>E" @?2? ? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?A
#$95"rN
3'
f 4#? D49;<" 3$ :$a42?9;? Z4$
$9a?5? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" E?:" " X$WA
E4K" :$ $9E"952$ 94#? E"93>;<" 9<"
:$a42? E"# ? >a9>;<" K>a?3?N - D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" :$2‘ $9a?5?3" :$
5"3?: ?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$: D"2$#
$9E"952?3?:%
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" >9D$2>"2 ?
H i#ob
 !$9b4#? 5$95?5>X? 3$ @2$::<" 3"
@$3?K 3" D2$>" "4 3" @$3?K 3"
?E$K$2?3"2 3$5$E5?3?
 8>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" #"5"2>:5?
3$:?D>>X$K?3"
 1"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? ?J$25?
 ’K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" D"2? 3? @"A
:>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r
 ’ D49;<" ,?D$T"K3 @"3$ :$2 5$#A
@"2?2>?#$95$ $pEK4W3? @2$::>"9?93"
" >95$224@5"2 K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$
E$952?K $] ?" #$:#" 5$#@"] @>:?93"
9" @$3?K 3" D2$>" $ #?95$93" ? @"25?
3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? ?J$25?N
(#? X$Y #?94?K#$95$ $pEK4W3?] ?
D49;<" :$2‘ 2$?5>X?3? Z4?93" ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?5>9a>2 ": LG i#ob
"4 Z4?93" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
D"2 3$:K"E?3? 9? @":>;<"  @
$] $# :$a4>3?] @?2?  N
! 
- ’45" T"K3 ^ 4# D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>A
"9?#$95" Z4$ >#@$3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K"
:$ 3$:K"Z4$ ?E>3$95?K#$95$ Z4?93"
$:5‘ @?2?3" "4 9" #"#$95" 3$ ?2A
2?9E?2N
’::># Z4$ " X$WE4K" @?2? 3$ :$
#"X$2 ?@h: ? D2$9?a$#] " :>:5$#?
#?95^# ? @2$::<" ?@K>E?3? 9": D2$>":
@$K" @$3?KN - ’45" T"K3 ?54? 3>2$5?A
#$95$ 9": D2$>": 3" @$3?K] 9<" :$93"
9$E$::‘2>"] @?2? $::$ E?:"] ?54?2 9"
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
w4?93" " E"9345"2 @2$::>"9?2 " T"K3 $:5‘ ?5>X? ?95$: 3? >a9>;<" :$2
?E$K$2?3"2] " ’45" T"K3 K>J$2? ": 3$:K>a?3?] $K? E"95>94?2‘ ?5>X? ?@h:
D2$>": $ " X$WE4K" $:5?2‘ K>X2$ @?2? :$ K>a?2 ? >a9>;<" 9"X?#$95$N
#"X>#$95?2N
’ 2$5$9;<" 3" X$WE4K" 5?#J^# :$2‘
$9E$22?3? :$ ?: E"93>;\$: @?2? :$4
D49E>"9?#$95" 9<" $:5>X$2$# :?5>:A
D$>5?:N
 ,$ ? @"25? 3" E"9345"2 $:5‘ D$A
Eb?3?N
 ,$ " E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" #"A
5"2>:5? $:5‘ ?D>X$K?3"N
 ,$ " X$WE4K" $:5‘ @?2?3"
' 5  3- 67 !- '
 ,$ D"> 3?3? ? @?25>3? 9" #"5"2N
 ,$ " Ee#J>" 9<" $:5>X$2 @":>E>"A 12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" E"22$:@"93$95$
9?3" $# N @?2? 3$:K>a?2 ? D49;<" $ ? K4YA$:@>?
 ,$ ? #?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" :$ ?@?a?2‘N &
?45"#‘5>E" 3" 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ - D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K$52vA
1?2i ’::>:5 ,y:5$# 9<" $:5‘ ?5>A 9>E" ^ K>a?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ @?2?
X?3?N #?95$2 " X$WE4K" @?2?3"N
 5  3- 67 !- '

12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" >93>E?3" ! & ,$ Z4?93" D"2 3$:K>a?3? ? D49;<"
 9" E"9_495" 3$ J"5\$: 9" ’45" T"K3] " @$3?K 3" D2$>" D"2 ?E>"A
E"9:"K$ E$952?K @?2? K>a?2 ? D49;<" 9?3"] " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K$A
’45" T"K3N ’ K4YA$:@>? :$ ?E$93$ 52v9>E" 9<" :$ K>a?2‘N
9" 3>:@K?yN w4?93" ? D49;<" ’45"
1$-


’ 5$E9"K"a>? 3" :>:5$#? ’45" T"K3
52?J?Kb? :"#$95$ 3$952" 3": K>#>5$:
3" :>:5$#?N - #?>"2 E"9D"25" "D$A
2$E>3" @$K" ,>:5$#? ’45" T"K3 9<"
3$X$ E"K"E?2 ? :$a42?9;? $# 2>:E"N
+:5$_? ?5$95" ?" ?E$93>#$95" 3? K4YA
$:@>? @?2? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ’45"
T"K3N - ’45" T"K3 9<" #?95^# :4?:
D49;\$: $# 5"3?: ?: E"93>;\$: 3$
D2$9?a$#N
   
% 

- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" E"#?9A
3?3" $K$52"9>E?#$95$] 9" Z4?K ?
#43?9;? 3$ #?2Eb?: ?E"95$E$
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ $# D49;<" 3$ @?A
2e#$52": >9:5?95e9$": 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"
3" X$WE4K" qX$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"]
>9EK>9?;<" 3? $:52?3? $ @":>;<" 3"
@$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2rN
’ @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3? :$K$;<" #?94?K
3?: #?2Eb?: 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ $:5‘] $#
1$!.
5"3" " E?:"] 3>:@"9WX$K 3$X>3" g @"A
:>;<" t#"3?K>3?3$ :$Z4$9E>?Kt @?2?
? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"N
 !L
- 3>:@K?y qX$2:\$: E"# 3>:@K?y
#4K5>D49;\$:r "4 qX$2:\$: E"#
3>:@K?y #4K5>D49;\$: 2$E"9D>a42‘X$Kr
@"3$ X>:4?K>Y?2%
 !? #"3?K>3?3$ ?45"#‘5>E?% ? @"A
:>;<" :$K$E>"9?3? q1] C] !] *rN
 !? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<" &?A
94?K q:$Z4$9E>?Kr% " $9a?5$ 3?
#43?9;? q:4@$2>"2 "4 >9D$2>"2r]
$D$54?3" #?94?K#$95$] ?52?X^:
3? >93>E?;<" 94#^2>E?N
!!!!  _"%
’ ?K?X?9E? @"3$ ?::4#>2 ?: :$A
a4>95$: @":>;\$:%
 1 § +:5?E>"9?#$95"N
 C § &?2Eb? ? 2^N
 ! § 1"95" #"25"N
 * § *2>X$ q#?2Eb? @?2? ? D2$95$
?45"#‘5>E?rN
 ’45",5>Ei% ¥ @?::?a$# @?2? ? #4A
3?9;? :4@$2>"2 9? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$
E"934;<" #?94?K q:$Z4$9E>?Krd
@?::?a$# @?2? ? #43?9;? >9D$A
2>"2 9? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<"
:$Z4$9E>?KN
- $:Z4$#? @?2? " $9a?5$ 3?: #?2A
Eb?: $:5‘ >93>E?3" 9? #"K342? K"E?K>A
Y?3? ?" K?3" 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"N
’ #?2Eb? $9a?5?3? ^ X>:4?K>Y?3?
9" 3>:@K?y q:"#$95$ Z4?93" $:5‘ 9?
#"3?K>3?3$ :$Z4$9E>?KrN
1?2? :$K$E>"9?2 4#? #?2Eb?] @2$:A
:>"9?2 " J"5<" 3? ?K?X?9E? :$K$5"2?
3$ #?2Eb?: $ 3$:K"E‘AK? @?2? ? D2$95$
"4 @?2? 52‘:N
 !" E?:" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" Ee#J>"
9? #"3?K>3?3$ t:$Z4$9E>?Kt] ?5>X?3?
3$:K"E?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$  q*2>X$r
@?2? ? $:Z4$23?] :<" ?KE?9;‘X$>: ?:
@":>;\$: @?2? ¥ "4 @?2? N +:5?:
@":>;\$: :<" >9:5‘X$>:N
1?2? :?>2 3? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?A
#$95"r] "4 @?2? @?::?2 3? @":>;<"
 q1"95" #"25"r @?2? ? @":>;<" 
q*2>X$r "4  q&?2Eb? ? 2^r Z4?93"
" X$WE4K" ^ @?2?3" "4 :$ 3$:K"E? g
J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" @>:?2
5?#J^# 9" @$3?K 3" D2$>" qE"9:4K5?2
? "@;<" t,>:5$#? 3$ >9>J>;<" 3" $9A
a?5$ 3$ #?2Eb?: :$# " @$3?K 3" D2$>"
?E>"9?3"t 9$:5$ E?@W54K"rN

!0- ?E$K$2?2 342?95$ ? @?::?a$#
3? @":>;<" q"4  r @?2? "452?
@":>;<"N

*$@">: 3$ :$K$E>"9?2 4#? #?2Eb?]
?a4?23?2 ?Ka49: :$a493": ?95$: 3$
?E$K$2?2N +:5? @2$E?4;<" ^ @?25>E4K?2A
#$95$ >#@"25?95$ E"# " #"5"2 D2>"N

!<" 3>2>a>2 " X$WE4K" E"# ? #<"
?@">?3? 9? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"] >::"
@"3$ K$X?2 ?%
A &43?9;? >9X"K495‘2>? 3$ #?2Eb?
@$K" E"9345"2 @?2? ? @":>;<" !$452?K
q!r
A - Ee#J>" @"3$ $95$93$2 #"#$9A
5?9$?#$95$ Z4$ $:5‘ $# 4#? @":>;<"
>95$2#$3>‘2>? q9$9b4#? #?2Eb? $9A
a?5?3?r] @"3$93" $952?2] ?::>#] $#
#"3" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N V$2 >9D"2#?A
;\$: $# tP49;<" 3$ $#$2a[9E>? 3"
Ee#J>"t 9$::$ E?@W54K"N
8?:" "E"22? ? 5$95?5>X? 3$ #4A
3?9;? 3$ #?2Eb? 3$  @?2?  "4
 E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3" :$# @2$:A
:>"9?2 " @$3?K 3$ D2$>"] ? ?K?X?9E?
3$ Ee#J>" @"3$2‘ 52?X?2 $ >#@$3>2 ?
#43?9;? 3$ @":>;<"N - 3>:@K?y 3?
?K?X?9E? 3" E"#?93" 3$ Ee#J>" $
3$ >93>E?;<" 3$ #?2Eb? 3" @?>9$K D>A
E?2‘ @>:E?93" $ :$2‘ >9D"2#?3" 9"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": ? #$9:?a$#%
X"-      -  
 ,G ^Y:
8?:" :$_? 2$@$5>3? ? 5$95?5>X? 3$
#43?9;? 3$ #?2Eb? Z4?93" " 3>:A
@K?y 3" Ee#J>" $:5>X$2 @>:E?93"] ?
?K?X?9E? >2‘ @$2#>5>2 ? @?::?a$# @?2?
$X>5?2 @"::WX$>: 3?9": ?" :>:5$#? $
": 3>:@K?y: E"95>94?2<" @>:E?93"N ,$
>:5" "E"22$2] #43$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$
#?2Eb? @?2? ? @":>;<" 1 @?2? 2$5"2A
9?2 ?" D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K 3" :>:A
5$#?N

!<" ^ 2$E"#$93?3? ? @?::?a$#
3$ #?2Eb? 3$ ! @?2? * "4 3$ !
@?2? C E"# " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"N
!$:5?: E"93>;\$: ?@?2$E$2‘ ? #$9:?A
a$# 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": x&
',  -  '*   - &
  z "4 X',  -  '&
*   -   YN
%%!  "!! 
"!!  !
’K^# 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"] K"A
E?K>Y?3? 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K] ?Ka4#?:
X$2:\$: 3>:@\$# 5?#J^# 3$ ?K?X?9A
E?: 3" 5>@" tJ"2J"K$5?t] K"E?K>Y?3?:
?52‘: 3" X"K?95$] Z4$ >2<" D49E>"9?2
1$!!
$# X$K"E>3?3$ :4@$2>"2 ? M i#ob]
@2$::>"9?93"A?: E"952? " X"K?95$ 9?
@?25$ E$952?K 3?: #$:#?:N
+:5?93" " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"]
?E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 5>@" tJ"2J"K$5?t
3>2$>5? @?2? >9:$2>2 4#? #?2Eb? :4A
@$2>"2 "4 ? ?K?X?9E? $:Z4$23? @?2?
>9:$2>2 4#? #?2Eb? >9D$2>"2N
? ! !!!!
,     / 0
!#!
!49E? 45>K>Y?2 ? @":>;<"
q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r $# :4J:5>54>;<" 3"
D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N
w4?93" :$ $:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"]
?E>"9?2 :$#@2$ " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $K^52>E" @?2? $X>5?2 #"X>#$9A
5": ?E>3$95?>: 3" X$WE4K"N
1$!"
!#!
,$ ? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r
9<" $:5>X$2 $9a?5?3?] " X$WE4K" @"3$
3$:K"E?2A:$ $ @2"X"E?2 K$:\$: 9?:
@$::"?:N
’95$: 3$ :?>2 3" X$WE4K"] E$25>D>E?2A
:$ 3$ Z4$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"
$:5‘ 9? @":>;<" $ Z4$ " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $:5$_? ?E>"9?3"N
+:5? @":>;<" >95$a2? " D2$>" 3$ $:5?A
E>"9?#$95"] JK"Z4$?93" " Ee#J>"N
8"# ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9$:5? @"A
:>;<"] ^ @"::WX$K K>a?2 " #"5"2N

!49E? 5$95?2 :$K$E>"9?2 ? @":>;<"
E"# " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"N ’9A
5$: 3$ ?J?93"9?2 " X$WE4K"] E"K"E?2
:$#@2$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9$:5?
@":>;<"] ?E>"9?93" 5?#J^# " D2$>"
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
’" $:5?E>"9?2 94# 5$22$9" @K?9"]
E"K"E?2 @2>#$>2" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#A
J>" 9? @":>;<" $] $# :$a4>3?] ?E>A
"9?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
’" $:5?E>"9?2 $# :4J>3?] ?95$: 3$
E"K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @"A
:>;<" ] ?E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"d E?:" E"952‘2>"] @"3$ :$2 3>DWA
E>K 3$:K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" ?
@?25>2 3? @":>;<" N
1?2? X$2>D>E?2 " $D$5>X" $9a?5$ 3?
@":>;<" %
 *$:K"E?2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ @?2? ?
D2$95$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"] ?5^
?" D># 3$ E42:"N
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 9" 3>:@K?y
?@?2$;? ? K$52? N
8"# " @$3?K 3" D2$>" :"K5"]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? ?K?X?9E? 3$
Ee#J>" 9<" :$ 3$:K"Z4$ 3? @":>;<"
N
" ,G  9 /0
,$K$E>"9?2 $:5? @":>;<" ?@$9?:
E"# " X$WE4K" E"#@K$5?#$95$
@?2?3"N

!#!
+9a?5?2 ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ ?@$9?: E"#
" X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " #"5"2 $# #?2Eb?
K$95? $ " ?E$K$2?3"2 5"5?K#$95$ :"K5"N
+:5? ?;<" @"3$2‘ @2$:$2X?2 ? E?>p?
3$ Ee#J>"
    /0
!#!
!<" @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ #?2A
Eb?: $#  q1"95" #"25"r] 9$# 3$:A
K>a?2 " #"5"2 @?2? @$2E"22$2 4#? $:A
52?3? $# 3$:E>3?N
+:5$ 5>@" 3$ E"934;<" ^ @$2>a":" $
2$34Y ? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ >95$2X$9;<"
$# E?:" 3$ 2$@$95>9?: X?2>?;\$: 3"
DK4p" 3" 52‘D$a" "4 3? :4@$2DWE>$ 3?
$:52?3?N 8"22$A:$ " 2>:E" 3$ @$23$2
" E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K" $ @2"X"E?2
?E>3$95$:N
8"22$:@"93$ g @":>;<" 3$ @"95"
#"25" 3$ 4# Ee#J>" #?94?KN 8"#
? ?K?X?9E? 9? @":>;<"  ^ @"::WX$K
K>a?2 " #"5"2N
+9a?5?2 ? @":>;<"  $# E?:" 3$
@?2?3?: @2"K"9a?3?: E"# " #"5"2
K>a?3"N ’E>"9?2 5?#J^# " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N
 * /0 & " ,G    3  
- P ,
(5>K>Y?2 $:5? @":>;<" $# E"93>;\$:
3$ #?2Eb? 9"2#?>:N
’ @?::?a$# 3? @":>;<"  @?2?
? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r "4 
q&?2Eb? ? 2^r :h 3$X$ "E"22$2 3$@">:
3$ :"K5?2 " @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2] E"#
" X$WE4K" @?2?3" $ E"# " @$3?K 3"
D2$>" @2$::>"9?3"N
+:5? @":>;<" ?::$a42? " $9a?5$ ?4A
5"#‘5>E" 3?: 2$K?;\$: #?>: ?3$Z4?A
3?: g: $p>a[9E>?: 3$ #?2Eb? $ ? #‘A
p>#? $E"9"#>? $# 5$2#": 3$ E"9A
:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
!$:5? @":>;<"] " Ee#J>" $D$54? ?4A
5"#?5>E?#$95$ ?: #43?9;?: 3$ #?2A
Eb?:] :$K$E>"9?93" ? 2$K?;<" #?>:
?3$Z4?3? $952$ ?: 3>:@"9WX$>: @?2?
? #?2Eb? g D2$95$] a?2?95>93"] ?:A
:>#] E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ E"934;<" >3$A
?>: $# 5"3?: ?: #?>: EK‘::>E?: E"93>A
;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
!- ,[  "'   -&
 6  -' /.- , '0
+# E?:" 3$ D2$Z4$95$: #43?9;?:
3$ #?2Eb? q@"2 $pN Z4?93" :$ E"934Y
" X$WE4K" $# E"93>;\$: 3$ E?2a?
@$:?3?] $# $:52?3?: $# >9EK>9?;<"]
E"# D"25$ X$95" E"952‘2>" "4 342?95$
" 2$J"Z4$ 3$ ?52$K?3": @$:?3":r] ^
?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 45>K>Y?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$
’45":5>Ei q#43?9;? :$Z4$9E>?Kr @?2?
:$K$E>"9?2 $ #?95$2 4#? 2$K?;<" D>p?
#?>: J?>p?N
!$:5?: E"93>;\$:] ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$
4#? #43?9;? #?>: J?>p? #$Kb"2? " &
3$:$#@$9b" 3" X$WE4K" $ @2"K"9a? ?
342?;<" 3" Ee#J>"] K>#>5?93" ?: #4A
3?9;?: 3$ #?2Eb?: $ $X>5?93" D$9vA
#$9": 3$ :"J2$?Z4$E>#$95"N
f @"::WX$K @?::?2 3? @":>;<" 
q32>X$r @?2? ? #"3?K>3?3$ :$Z4$9A
E>?K] Z4?KZ4$2 Z4$ :$_? ? X$K"E>3?3$
3" X$WE4K"N
! *67
1$!%
 8"# ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @"A
:>;<"  q*2>X$r] @?2? ?5>X?2 ? #"3?A
K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<" :$Z4$9E>?K] 3$:A
K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? @?2? ? $:Z4$23? q>9A
3>E?;<" $ ¥ 9? #"K342?r "4 ?E>"9?2
4#? 3?: J"2J"K$5?: ?52‘: 3" X"K?95$
q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN !" 3>:@K?y :$2‘ X>:4?A
K>Y?3? ? #?2Eb? $9a?5?3?N
’: 52"E?: 3$ #?2Eb?: @?::?# ? :$2
D$>5?: 9" 3$:K"E?#$95" 3? ?K?X?9E?
3$ Ee#J>" @?2? ? D2$95$ q r $ @?2? 52‘:
q¥r "4 9" ?E>"9?#$95" 3?: J"2J"K$A
5?: 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" q r $ 3>2$>5" q¥r
?52‘: 3" X"K?95$N
 *67
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$
E"934;<" :$Z4$9E>?K] X"K5?2 ? E"K"A
E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<"
 q*2>X$r q#"3?K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<"
t?45"#‘5>E?tr "4] ?K^# 3>::"] 5?#A
J^# @2$::>"9?2 ? J"2J"K$5? 3>2$>5? q¥r
?5^ Z4$ ? >93>E?;<"  X"K5$ ? ?@?A
2$E$2 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95":N
!* 
 +# :4@$2DWE>$: $:E"22$a?3>?:]
9<" $D$54?2 2$34;\$: 3$
1$!&
#?2Eb?:% ?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$:
@"3$# @$23$2 ?3$2[9E>?] E"#
E"9:$Z4$95$ 2>:E" 3$ @?5>9?a$#
3" X$WE4K"] Z4$ @"3$ @2"X"E?2
?E>3$95$: "4 K$:\$: 9?: @$::"?:N
 1?2? :$K$E>"9?2 ? #43?9;? E"2A
2$5? @?2? ? #‘p>#? 3$:?E$K$2?A
;<" qD2$>" 3" #"5"2r] J?:5? #?95$2
@2$::>"9?3? ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ #?2A
Eb?: @?2? ? D2$95$ q r "4 ? J"2J"A
K$5? $:Z4$23? q r% " Ee#J>" @?::?
@?2? 4#? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ D49E>"A
9?#$95" $# Z4$ ? 3$:?E$K$2?;<"
3" X$WE4K" @"3$ :$2 $D$54?3? E"#
D?E>K>3?3$N
 - X$WE4K" #?95$2‘ ? 2$K?;<" :$K$A
E>"9?3? @$K" E"9345"2 ?5^ Z4$ ?:
E"93>;\$: 3$ :$a42?9;? " @$2#>A
5?#N =:5" :>a9>D>E?] @"2 $p$#@K"]
Z4$ " :>:5$#? @2"E42?2‘ $X>5?2
? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" #"5"2] 2$52"E$A
3$93" 3$ D"2#? ?45v9"#?] E?:"
" 2$a>#$ 3" #"5"2 :$_? 3$#?:>A
?3" J?>p"N
  "#! 
_"% / .- 0
’ D49;<" 3" Ee#J>" ^ E"9:5?9A
5$#$95$ #"9>5"2?3? @?2? 3$5$E5?2
$X$954?>: ?9"#?K>?:N ,$ 3$5$E5?2
4#? E"93>;<" Z4$ @"3$2>? @2"X"E?2
3?9": Ee#J>"] ?5>X?A:$ ? D49;<" 3$
t$#$2a[9E>? 3" Ee#J>"tN
!$:5? E"93>;<"] " Ee#J>" @$2#?A
9$E$ 9? Iƒ #?2Eb?] >93$@$93$95$A
#$95$ 3? #?2Eb? :$K$E>"9?3? @":>A
;\$:% q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r]  q&?2Eb?
? 2^r $  q1"95" #"25"r E"95>94?# ?
D49E>"9?2N
!" 3>:@K?y @"3$ :$2 X>:4?K>Y?3" "
:W#J"K" N
+# E?:" 3$ $X$954?K t$#$2a[9E>?
3" Ee#J>"t] 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?#$95$
g   ! = ,  > N
’X?2>? 5$#@"2‘2>?
+# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 5$#@"2‘2>?] ^
@"::WX$K 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"22$5" D49A
E>"9?#$95" 3" Ee#J>" $# 5"3?: ?:
#?2Eb?: @?2? ? D2$95$ @2"E$3$93" 3"
:$a4>95$ #"3"%
 1?2?2 " X$WE4K"N
 *$:K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"
@?2? q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN
 8"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<"  N
 ’a4?23?2 E$2E? 3$ 7G :$a493":
3$@">: 3$ K>a?2 " #"5"2N
 ,$K$E>"9?2 ? #?2Eb? @2$5$93>3?%
:$ 9<" 3$5$E5?2 #?>: " @2"JK$#?]
" Ee#J>" X"K5? ? D49E>"9?2 E"2A
2$5?#$95$N

+# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 5$#@"2‘2>?] ^
?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 3>2>a>2A:$ " #?>: 2?@>3?A
#$95$ @"::WX$K g   ! = , 
> N
%;    &
  !!"
 H .-  ,   
EF'   &&) $:5? D49;<" 2$A
Z4$2 " @":>E>"9?#$95" 3? ?K?X?9E?
3$ #?2Eb?: $# q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rd
$# :$a4>3?] E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
"!  %  &
!  "!! "  ! Eb?: $952$ ?: @":>;\$: q+:5?E>A
  !!
+:5$ :>:5$#? >#@$3$ " 3$:K"E?A
#$95" 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$ #?2Eb?: 3?
@":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r :$ 5>X$2
@>:?3" 9" @$3?K 3" D2$>"N
1?2? E"K"E?2 ?" Ee#J>" 94#? @":>A
;<" 3>D$2$95$ 3$ q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r]
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 3$X$ $:5?2
9? @":>;<" ! q#"5"2 K>a?3" "4
3$:K>a?3"r $ " @$3?K 3" D2$>" 3$X$ $:A
5?2 @2$::>"9?3"N
! !
’ >9"J:$2Xe9E>? 3?: >9:524;\$: D"2A
9$E>3?: ? :$a4>2 @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?A
9": 9? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"%
 ,$K$E>"9?2 ? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"A
9?#$95"r ?@$9?: E"# " X$WE4K"
E"#@K$5?#$95$ @?2?3"N
 ,$K$E>"9?2 ? @":>;<"  q&?2Eb? ?
2^r] "4 @?::?2 3$  @?2? 4#? "452?
@":>;<" ?@$9?: E"# " X$WE4K"
E"#@K$5?#$95$ @?2?3" $ " #"5"2
$# #?2Eb? K$95?N
 !<" $D$54?2 #43?9;?: 3$ #?2A
"9?#$95"r]  q&?2Eb? ? 2^r] 
q1"95" #"25"r "4  q*2>X$r E"#
" #"5"2 K>a?3" 94# 2$a>#$ :4@$A
2>"2 g #?2Eb? K$95?N
 ’95$: 3$ $9a?5?2 Z4?KZ4$2 #?2A
Eb?] @>:?2 D493" 9" @$3?K 3"
D2$>"N

&?95$2 @2$::>"9?3" " @$3?K 3"
D2$>" $9Z4?95" :$ 3$:K"E? ? ?K?X?9E?
3?: #43?9;?: @?2? 4#? @":>;<" 3>D$A
2$95$ 3? @":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r
$ ’45",5>EiN
 ’ #"X>#$95?;<" >9$:@$2?3? 3" &
X$WE4K" @"3$ @2"X"E?2 K$:\$: 9":
"E4@?95$: "4 9?Z4$K$: Z4$ :$
@"3$# $9E"952?2 9?: @2"p>#>3?A
3$: >#$3>?5?:N !<" ?J?93"9?2
" X$WE4K" E"# " #"5"2 K>a?3"%
?95$: 3$ :?>2 3" b?J>5‘E4K"] ?E>A
"9?2 :$#@2$ " D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?#$95" $K^52>E"] 3$:K"E?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3?: #?2Eb?: @?2? ? @"A
:>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r] 3$:K>A
1$!’
 a?2 " #"5"2N 8"# " E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  ] "
Ee#J>" ^ JK"Z4$?3" 9? @":>;<"
q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r] @?2? >#@$3>2
$X$954?>: #"X>#$95": ?E>3$95?>:
3" X$WE4K"N
 w4?93" 3$:E$2 3" X$WE4K"] 2$5>A
2?2 :$#@2$ ? Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? 3"
X$WE4K" $ D$Eb?2 5"3?: ?: @"25?:N
!49E? 3$>p?2 $X$954?>: E2>?9;?:
:$# X>a>Ke9E>? 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WA
E4K"N
 !<" 3$>p?2 " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ @?2A
5>3? ?5>X?3"N (#? E2>?9;? @"3$
?E>"9?2 ": K$X?95?3"2$: 3$ X>A
32": $K^52>E":] "452": E"#?93":
"4 3?2 @?25>3? >9?3X$25>3?#$95$
" #"5"2N
 f @$2>a":" E"K"E?2 " Ee#J>"
94#? @":>;<" 3>D$2$95$ 3$
q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r "4  q1"95"
#"25"r 94# 2$a>#$ 3" #"5"2
:4@$2>"2 g #?2Eb? K$95?N ,$
9<" @>:?2 D493" 9" @$3?K 3"
D2$>"] " X$WE4K" @"3$ ?E$K$2?2
2?@>3?#$95$N +9a?5?2 ? #43?9;?
?@$9?: E"# " #"5"2 9" 2$a>#$
3$ #?2Eb? K$95?] @>:?93" D493"
9" @$3?K 3" D2$>"N
1$!*
 ,$ ? 5$#@$2?542? 3" Ee#J>" 4KA
52?@?::?2 ": K>#>5$: 3$ D49E>"9?A
#$95" 9"2#?>:] ? E$952?K 3" Ee#A
J>" @"3$ #"3>D>E?2 ? :$Z4[9E>?
3$ $9a?5$ 3?: #?2Eb?: $ 2$34Y>2
" 5"2Z4$ #"52>YN
 +# E?:" 3$ :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3?
E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"] 9" 3>:@K?y ^
X>:4?K>Y?3" " :W#J"K" N !$:5$
E?:"] ? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" @"3$
D49E>"9?2 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5" ?5^
Z4$ ?22$D$;?N
 *42?95$ ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"
$ 5$#@$2?542? $p5$29? $p52$#?A
#$95$ J?>p?] " D49E>"9?#$95" 3?
E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" @"3$ :"D2$2 X?A
2>?;\$: E"# J?:$ 9? 5$#@$2?542?
3" #"5"2 $ 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"]
J$# E"#" $# D49;<" 3? X$K"E>A
3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"N
 ’ ?5>X?;<" 3? $#J2$?a$# 3"
E"9X$2:"2 3$ 5"2Z4$ $ 3? ~ƒ
"4 Mƒ #?2Eb? ^ >9>J>3? ?5^
Z4$ " hK$" 3" Ee#J>" $:5$_?
E"22$5?#$95$ ?Z4$E>3"N - $:52?3? >22$a4K?2$:N
E"#@K$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
Ee#J>" :$2‘ ?5>X?3" ?::># Z4$ ?
5$#@$2?542? 3" hK$" ?5>9a>2 "
X?K"2 @2$$:5?J$K$E>3"N
 
> !  DR  >
!  DR R
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4#
:>:5$#? E?@?Y 3$ 52?9:D$2>2 @?2?
" $>p" 52?:$>2" 3$ #"3" E"#@K$A
5?#$95$ ?45"#‘5>E" 5"3? ? 52?;<"
9$E$::‘2>? @?2? :$ 3$:@2$93$2 D?E>KA
#$95$ 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 :>54?;<" a?2?9A
5>93"] ?" #$:#" 5$#@"] $E"9"#>?
$# 5$2#": 3$ $#>::\$: $ E"9:4#":N
’ 52?9:#>::<" ^ E"9:5>54W3? @"2 4#
3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 52?9:D$2[9E>? 3$ @"5[9A
E>? 1.( q1"j$2 .2?9:D$2 (9>5r E?@?Y
3$ 3$:K>a?2 5"3" " $>p" 52?:$>2" >#$A
3>?5?#$95$ ?" E"#?93" 3" Ee#J>"
Z4?93" ?: E"93>;\$: " @$2#>5>2$#
q@"2 $pN $# E?:" 3$ #?2Eb? $# ?4A
5"$:52?3?r $ @"2 4# ?E"@K?#$95" 52?A
:$>2" E?@?Y 3$ #"34K?2 2?@>3?#$95$
? Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ 5"2Z4$ 9$E$::‘2>"
@?2? 3$:@2$93$2 " X$WE4K" "4 #$Kb"A
2?2 ? :4? 3>2>a>J>K>3?3$ $# @>:": 3$
! ! :$#@$9b": t"DDA2"?3t 3" X$WE4K"
’ 52?;<" 9?: Z4?52" 2"3?: #"52>Y$: $# 5"3?: ?: #"3?K>3?3$: 3$ E"9A
qI¤*r ^ E"#@K$5?#$95$ ?45"#‘5>E? 34;<"N
9? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<" 9"2#?KN


!<" ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ? #43?9;?
3$ #"3?K>3?3$ Z4?93" " X$WE4K" 4KA
52?@?::?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 7LG i#obN
 I¤*
! *67   67 5 '
-: J"5\$: @?2? ? ?5>X?;<" 3? 52?A
;<" >95$a2?K] :$ 3>:@"9WX$>:] $:5<" K"A
E?K>Y?3": 9" E"9_495" 3$ J"5\$: $
9" J"5<" ,$K$EA.$22?>9£ @":>E>"9?A
3": 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K] @$2#>5>93"
:$K$E>"9?2%
 I¤* )-8{ qJ"5<" r% 3$:?5>X?
? D49;<" 3$ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" $>p"
3$ 52?9:#>::<"] a?2?95>93" ? >#$A
3>?5? 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3" 5"2Z4$
?" ?E"@K?#$95" 52?:$>2"N +:5?
D49;<" ^ :$K$E>"9‘X$K 9? #"3?K>A
3?3$ ! $ ?45"#‘5>E? 9?: "4A
52?: #"3?K>3?3$: 3$ E"934;<"N
 I¤* )-¤ qJ"5<" % $ :$K$5"2
)-¤ qX$2:\$:
.2?>Kb?jir qJ"5<" % $ :$K$5"2
,$K$EA.$22?>9£r $9D?5>Y? ":
3$:$#@$9b": t"DDA2"?3t 3"
X$WE4K" $# 5"3?: ?: #"3?K>3?3$: ’ D49;<" I¤* )-8{ @"3$
3$ E"934;<"N :$2 ?5>X?3? #$3>?95$ @2$::<" 3"
2$:@$E5>X" J"5<" $ ? #43?9;? 3"
5>@" 3$ 5$22$9" @"3$ :$2 ?K5$2?3?] &
#$3>?95$ ?E>"9?#$95" 3" :$K$5"2
 ] K"E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K
q:$ $Z4>@?3"r 9?: @":>;\$: !
@?2? R@!@" "4 E
qX$2:\$: .2?>Kb?jir $ " I¤* )-¤
9<" 5>X$2 :>3" ?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5>X?3"N
’ ?5>X?;<" 3$ 4#? D49;<" q@"2
$pN I¤* )-¤r 3$:?5>X? ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ ? "452?N
,$K$EA.$22?>9£r $9D?5>Y? ": 3$A
1$!+


+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] ? @2$::<" 3"
J"5<" DR R ?5>X? ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$ 5?#J^# ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$
I¤* )-8{N (#? @":5$2>"2 @2$::<"
3" J"5<" DR R 3$>p?2‘ ?5>X? ?
D49E>"9?K>3?3$ I¤* )-8{N 1"2 "4A
52" K?3"] ? 4#? @":5$2>"2 @2$::<" 3"
J"5<" DR E ] :$2<" 3$:?5>X?A
3?: ?#J?: ?: D49E>"9?K>3?3$:N

’ D49;<" I¤* )-¤ :h ^ ?E"9:$A
Kb‘X$K @?2? @>:": 3$ $:52?3? >22$a4K?A
2$: $ $:E"22$a?3>?:N
1$!,
!#!
- E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3? D49A
;<" I¤* 3$@$93$ 3": @9$4:% 3$X$#
:$2 5"3": 3?: #$:#?: 3>#$9:\$:] 3"
#$:#" 5>@" $ 3? #$:#? E>2E49D$2[9A
E>?N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @9$4: E"# 3>#$9A
:\$: 3>D$2$95$: 5$# $D$>5": 9$a?5>X":
9" E"#@"25?#$95" 3>9e#>E" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
!#!
!<" E"934Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$: :4@$A
2>"2$: g: @$2#>5>3?: @$K?: E"93>;\$:
3? $:52?3?N
*>2>_? :$#@2$ E"# :$a42?9;?N
!!@!! !
"!! DR R
! *67  '  DR R
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] E"#45?3"2
3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  "4 E"#
" #"5"2 K>a?3"] 3$:K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E?
3$ Ee#J>" @?2? ? @":>;<"  q*2>X$r]
 q&?2Eb? ? 2^r "4  q1"95" #"25"r
$ @2$::>"9?2 4#? X$Y " J"5<" DR
R:
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] E"# ? #"3?A
K>3?3$ $9a?5?3?] 9" 3>:@K?y ^ X>:4?A
K>Y?3? ? #$9:?a$# tI¤* )-¤tN -
)+* K"E?K>Y?3" 9" 3>:@":>5>X" ,$K$EA
.$22?>9£ @"3$2>? D>E?2 >95$2#>5$95$
?5^ ?" D>9?K 3" $9a?5$N
 *67  '  DR
R
’ 3$:?5>X?;<" @"3$ "E"22$2 ? Z4?KA
Z4$2 X$K"E>3?3$ E"#@2$$93>3? $952$
G $ 7LG i#obN
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] 9" 3>:@K?y
? #$9:?a$# tI¤* )-¤t ?@?a?A:$
4#? X$Y E"9EK4W3? ? 3$:?5>X?;<"N
!$:5$ E?:" " )+* 9" J"5<" DR
R $:5‘ ?@?a?3"N


,$ ?: E"93>;\$: @?2? $9a?5?2 ? D49A
;<" I¤* )-¤ 9<" D"2$# :?5>:D$>5?:]
9" 3>:@K?y ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? 4#? #$9:?A
a$# $:@$EWD>E? >93>E?93" ?: >9:524A
;\$: @?2? ? E"9EK4:<" 3? >952"34;<"
:"K>E>5?3?N
&!
- 3>:@":>5>X" ,$K$EA.$22?>9£ E"#A
J>9? ?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3": :>:5$#?:
3$ E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K" E"# ? @"::>A
J>K>3?3$ 3$ >95$2X$9;<" 3" E"9345"2]
3$ #"3" ? D"29$E$2 " #$Kb"2 3$:$#A
@$9b" $# Z4?KZ4$2 5>@" 3$ 5$22$9"N
 ! "!! 

."E?2 " :$K$5"2 @?2? E>#? "4 @?2?
J?>p" @?2? :$K$E>"9?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$
3$:$_?3?N
- ?E>"9?#$95" 3" :$K$5"2] :$ ?
D49E>"9?K>3?3$ I¤* )-¤ 9<" 5>A
X$2 :>3" ?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5>X?3?] ?5>A
X?2‘ ?45"#?5>E?#?95$ ? D49E>"9?K>A
3?3$ I¤* )-8{N

!<" ^ @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ? #43?9;?
3$ #"3?K>3?3$ Z4?93" " X$WE4K" 4KA
52?@?::?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 7LG i#obN
 ! /!- P ,0 % ? #"3?A
K>3?3$ 3$ 52?;<" 9?: Z4?52" 2"A
3?: #"52>Y$: E"# D49E>"9?#$95"
E"95W94" $ E"#@K$5?#$95$ ?45"A
#‘5>E" @"3$ :$2 45>K>Y?3? @?2? ?
E"934;<" $# 2"3"X>?: ?:D?K5?3?:
$ $:52?3?: 3$ 5$22?N +:5? #"3?K>A
3?3$ $Z4>K>J2? ? 52?;<" @?2? a?A
2?95>2 #?9"J2?J>K>3?3$ $ ?E$K$A
2?;<" #$Kb"2?3?: 2$K?5>X?#$95$
? 4# X$WE4K" E"# 52?;<" E"#
34?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$:N +:5? #"3?A
K>3?3$ 2$34Y ?>93? " E"9:4#" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K] 4#? X$Y Z4$ @$2A
#>5$ 3$:K>a?2] "93$ ?: E"93>;\$:
" @$2#>5>2$#] " $>p" 3$ 52?9:#>:A
:<"N 1?2? 5$22$9": ?E>3$95?3": "4
?K5? @$2D"2#?9E$] 2$E"#$93?A:$
" 4:" 3?: 3$#?>: #"3?K>3?3$:]
E"9D"2#$ :4?: @?25>E4K?2>3?3$:N
 R /*0 % $:5? #"3?K>A
3?3$ @$2#>5$ 5$2 #?>"2 $:5?J>K>A
3?3$ $# E"93>;\$: 3$ 5$#@" ?3A
X$2:?:N (5>K>Y?2 @?2? ? E"934;<"
$# 52$Eb": D"2? 3$ $:52?3? :4@$2A
DWE>$: E"# J?>p? ?3$2[9E>? E"#"]
@"2 $p$#@K"] @>:": 3? $:52?3? E"A
J$25": 3$ 9$X$N !? #"3?K>3?3$
,!-¤] E"9D"2#$ ?: E"93>;\$:
3$ D49E>"9?#$95" $ @?2? X$2:\$:
E"# Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"] $:5? uKA
5>#? @"3$2>? $9a?5?2 ? Lƒ #?2Eb?
q$# X$Y 3? 7ƒr 342?95$ ? @?25>3?]
? D># 3$ 2$34Y>2 ?" #W9>#" ? 3$:A
K>Y?#$95" 3?: 2"3?:N
 !@" /  @' 0 % #"A
3?K>3?3$ 3$ E"934;<" D"2? 3$ $:A
52?3? @?2? ? 45>K>Y?;<" $# :4@$2A
DWE>$: E"# J?>p? ?3$2[9E>?] E"#"
@>:": ?2$9":":] K?#? "4 E"J$25":
E"# 2$KX? #"Kb?3?N ’ 52?9:#>:A
:<" ^ 3$D>9>3? @?2? "D$2$E$2 ? #‘A
p>#? 52?;<"N &
 E) $:5? #"3?K>3?3$
$:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K ?@$9?: E"#
D49E>"9?K>3?3$ I¤* )-¤ ?5>X?N
- 3>:@":>5>X" 3$D>9$ " X$WE4K"
@?2? #?p>#>Y?2 ? :4? 52?;<" $
@$2#>5>2 ? #?>: ?K5? E?@?E>3?3$
@?2? X>2?2 $# :4@$2DWE>$:
D"2? 3$ $:52?3? E"# $K$X?3?
?3$2[9E>?N +:5? #"3?K>3?3$
a?2?95$ " #‘p>#" 3$:$#@$9b"
1$!-
 t"DDA2"?3tN +:5? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$X$
:$2 45>K>Y?3? @?2? $9D2$95?2
"J:5‘E4K": :4@$2‘X$>: ? J?>p?
X$K"E>3?3$ E"#"] @"2 $p$#@K"]
?EK>X$: 3$ a2?93$: 3>#$9:\$:]
:4KE": @2"D493":] $5EN
!? @?25>3? 3" #"5"2] ^ ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$ :$K$E>"9?3? ? #"3?K>3?3$
’(.- q)+* ?E$:" ?" K?3" 3? #$9A
:?a$# ’(.-rN
S>2?93" " #?9W@4K" ! ] " )+*
?" K?3" 3? #$9:?a$# ’(.- @$2#?A
9$E$ ?E$:"N 1"2 "452" K?3"] ": "452":
)+*: ?E$93$#A:$ :$Z4$9E>?K#$95$]
$# D49;<" 3": 2$::?K5": E"#49>E?A
3": ?" @2h@2>" #?9W@4K" >93>E?93"]
?::>#] ?" E"9345"2 Z4?K ? 9"X? #"A
3?K>3?3$ @$3>3?N
(#? X$Y ?5>9a>3? ? #"3?K>3?3$
@2$5$93>3? q)+* ?" K?3" 3? 2$:@$EA
5>X? #$9:?a$# ?E$:"r] J?:5? #?95$2
" #?9W@4K" $# @":>;<" ?5^ Z4$ "
:>:5$#? ,$K$EA.$22?>9£ :$ ?5>X$ @?2?
$D$54?2 " $9a?5$ 3? #"3?K>3?3$ :$K$A
E>"9?3?N
+9Z4?95" " :>:5$#? 3$D>9$ " X$WA
E4K" :$a493" ? #"3?K>3?3$ @$3>3?]
1$".
" )+* 2$K?5>X" g @2h@2>? #"3?K>3?3$
E"#$;? ? K?#@$_?2 q@"2 4# 5$#@"
#W9>#" 3$ #$>" :$a493" ?5^ 4#
5$#@" #‘p>#" 3$ E$2E? 3$ 6 :$a49A
3":rN
w4?93" " )+* :$ ?E$93$ E"# K4Y
D>p? $] ?" #$:#" 5$#@"] :$ ?@?a? "
3? #"3?K>3?3$ ’(.-] :>a9>D>E? Z4$
? 9"X? #"3?K>3?3$ :$K$E>"9?3? D">
E"22$5?#$95$ ?5>X?3?N
8?:" 9<" :$_? @"::WX$K $D$54?2 ?
?5>X?;<" 3? #"3?K>3?3$ @$3>3? 3$9A
52" 3$ 6 :$a493":] " )+* 2$K?5>X" g
@2h@2>? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$>p?2‘ 3$ K?#A
@$_?2] $9Z4?95" " )+* 2$K?5>X" g #"A
3?K>3?3$ ?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5>X? q#"3?A
K>3?3$ ’(.-r E"95>94?2‘ ?E$:"] E"#
K4Y D>p?N
.43" >:5" :$2‘ >a4?K#$95$ X‘K>3"
@?2? Z4?KZ4$2 @?::?a$# @":5$2>"2 $9A
52$ 3>D$2$95$: #"3?K>3?3$: 3" 3>:@"A
:>5>X" ,$K$EA.$22?>9£N
   
  
'  / (
   6-
’Ka4#?: X$2:\$: @"3$# $:5?2
$Z4>@?3?: E"# 4# :>:5$#? 3$9"#>A
9?3" .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ q+K$52"9>E
)"Ei$2rN .2?5?A:$ 3$ 4# :>:5$#? 3$
JK"Z4$>" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" #$Ee9>E"
3? 52?9:#>::<" E"9b$E>3" E"#"
3>D$2$9E>?K] " Z4?K :$ E"9:5>54> $#
4# 2$E42:" ?3>E>"9?K 9?: :>54?;\$:
3$ $#$2a[9E>? $# Z4$ "E"22$ ?
@$23? 3$ ?52>5"o?3$2[9E>? 3$ 4#?
3?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$: q2$:@"9:‘X$>:
@$K? 52?;<" 3" X$WE4K"rN
- 3>D$2$9E>?K ?45"#"5>X" ^ 4# :>:A
5$#? Z4$ ?4p>K>? " X$WE4K" 9?: E42A
X?:] $D$54?93" 4#? $Z4?K>Y?;<" 3$
X$K"E>3?3$: $952$ ?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$:N
,$ " :>:5$#? 9<" $p>:5>::$] " E"952"K$
3>2$E>"9?K 3$ 4# X$WE4K" :$2>? #4>5"
3>DWE>K _‘ Z4$ ? 2"3? :>54?3? 3" K?3"
$p5$29" 3? E42X? ?@2$:$95?2>? ? 5$9A
3[9E>? ? ?22?:5?2 ? 2"3? >95$29?] 3$A
X>3" ?" @$2E42:" 9?542?K#$95$ #?>"2
Z4$ ? @2>#$>2? @2$E>:? @$2E"22$2N
 - :>:5$#? 3$ JK"Z4$>" .2?E5>"9
E"952"K¥ ?94K? 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$ ?
D49;<" 3" 3>D$2$9E>?K] #?95$93" "
5"2Z4$ qD"2;? 52?9:#>5>3? @$K" #"5"2r
>a4?K $# ?#J?: ?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?:N
=::" @$2#>5$ Z4$ ? 2"3? E"# #?>"2
E"93>;<" 3$ ?3$2[9E>? ?" :"K"] 9?A
Z4$K$ #"#$95"] @"::? #"X>#$95?2 "
X$WE4K"N

SC’V+ 1+C=S-% " :>:5$#? .2?EA
5>"9 E"952"K¥ _?#?>: 3$X$ :$2 ?E>"A
9?3" $# K"E?>: E"# ?3$2[9E>? @K$9?
E"#" X>?: ?:D?K5?3?:] 3$ E"9E2$5" "4
X>?: 9<" @?X>#$95?3?: Z4$ "D$2$;?#
J"?: E"93>;\$: 3$ ?3$2[9E>? ?" :"K"N
,$ " :>:5$#? D"2 >93$X>3?#$95$ ?E>A
"9?3" 9?: E"93>;\$: ?95$2>"2#$95$
E>5?3?:] ?: 2"3?: #"52>Y$: 3$:K>Y?2<"
3?9>D>E?93" ": $K$#$95": 3? 52?9:A
#>::<"N !$::? :>54?;<"] " X$WE4K"
?@2$:$95?2‘ 4#? 5$93[9E>? ? :$a4>2
2$5"] E"# @"::WX$K @$23? 3" E"9A
52"K$ 3>2$E>"9?K $ E"9:$Z4$95$ 2>:E"
3$ ?E>3$95$N 8"#" #$3>3? 3$ :$a4A
2?9;?] " X$WE4K" 5$# 4# 3>:@":>5>X"
?45"#‘5>E" Z4$ 3$:?5>X? " :>:5$#?
.2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ Z4?93" ? X$K"E>A
3?3$ ?5>9a$ LG i#ob q3$5$E5?3? @"2
#$>" 3$ 4# :$9:"2 >9:5?K?3" 9" X$WA
E4K"rN
- 4:" 3" :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥
^ D493?#$95?K Z4?93" 4#? 3?: 2"3?:
@$23$ ? ?3$2[9E>? 9" @>:" @"2 "93$
:$ 52?D$a?] :$ :42a>2$# 9" E?#>9b"
"J:5‘E4K": E"#" $:52?3?: E"# J?22"]
?2$>?] @$32?:] a2?#? #"Kb?3? $ "4A
52?: E"93>;\$: Z4$ "D$2$;?# @"4E"
?52>5"N
’95$: 3$ 4:?2 " :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9
E"952"K¥] @"2^#] ^ @2$E>:" ?X?K>?2 ?:
E"93>;\$: 3" K"E?K @?2? :$ E$25>D>E?2
3$ Z4$ $::? ?;<" ^ 2$?K#$95$ 9$E$:A
:‘2>?N f 2$E"#$93‘X$K] @2$X$95>X?A
#$95$] @?2?2 " X$WE4K" $ ?E>"9?2 "
:>:5$#? @"4E": #$52": ?95$: 3$ 52?9:A
@"2 "J:5‘E4K": Z4$ 2$@2$:$95$# 2>:E"
3$ @$23? 3$ ?3$2[9E>? 3?: 2"3?:N

- :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ 9<"
$:5‘ 3$:5>9?3" ? 2$E"9b$E$2 " 5>@" 3$
@>:" @"2 "93$ " X$WE4K" 52?9:>5?N -
_4Ka?#$95" 3? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ ?E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? ^ :$#@2$ 3" #"A
5"2>:5?] ?::># E"#" ? "J:$2X?;<" 3?:
2$E"#$93?;\$: 3$ :$a42?9;? 3$:E2>A
5?: 9" @2$:$95$ #?94?KN

1?2? Z4$ "E"22? " D49E>"9?#$95"
:?5>:D?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"9A
52"K¥ ^ $::$9E>?K Z4$ b?_? E"93>;\$:
3$ ?3$2[9E>? $#] @$K" #$9":] 4#?
3?: 2"3?: 3$ 52?;<"N
- 4:" 3" .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ ^ #4>5"
>#@"25?95$ 5?#J^# $# ?EK>X$: "4
3$EK>X$: K$X$: E"# @"4E? ?3$2[9E>?]
9": Z4?>: " a>2" $# D?K:" 3$ 4#?
2"3? @"3$ D?Y$2 E"# Z4$ " X$WE4K"
@$2E? ? 52?_$5h2>?N
&

- 4:" 3" :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"9A
52"K¥ ^ 3$:?E"9:$Kb?3" $# ?EK>X$:
D"25$:] @">: b?X$2‘ 4#? 5$93[9E>? 3$
? #?>"2 @?25$ 3" @$:" 3" X$WE4K" :$2
52?9:D$2>3" @?2? " $>p" 52?:$>2"N +::?
52?9:D$2[9E>? @"3$ "E?:>"9?2 ? D?K5?
3$ ?3$2[9E>? 9" $>p" 3>?95$>2" q"93$
"E"22$ ? 52?;<"r] E"# ? @$23? 3$
1$"!
52?_$5h2>? 3" X$WE4K" $ E"9:$Z4$95$
2>:E" 3$ ?E>3$95$:N

’ 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? .2?EA
5>"9 E"952"K¥ 9<" ?4#$95? ? E?@?E>A
3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 3$ :4J>2 "4 ?22?9E?2
$# ?EK>X$: $pE$::>X?#$95$ W9a2$#$:
q9<" 2$E"#$93?3":r] #$:#" Z4?93"
? X>? $# Z4$:5<" ?@2$:$95?2 E"93>A
;\$: 3$ ?3$2[9E>?N
1?2? ?E>"9?2 " :>:5$#? q" X$WE4K"
3$X$2‘ "J2>a?5"2>?#$95$ $:5?2
@?2?3"r 3$X$A:$ @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
E"22$:@"93$95$ @2$:$95$ 9" E"9A
_495" 3$ J"5\$: 3$ E"#?93":N +:5$
?E>"9?#$95" >2‘ "E"22$2 :"#$95$
E"# " @$3?K 3$ D2$>" @2$::>"9?3"N
!#!
’@h: 5$2 ?E>"9?3" " :>:5$#?] 9<"
?22?9E?2 " X$WE4K" J24:E?#$95$N -
X$WE4K" 3$X$ :$2 ?E$K$2?3" a2?34?KA
#$95$ ?E"#@?9b?93" E"# E4>3?3"
1$""
? :4? #"X>#$95?;<" ?" K"9a" 3" @$2A
E42:"N
+X>5?2 #?9"J2?: J24:E?: 9? 3>2$A
;<" $ @2$:5?2 ?5$9;<" g @2$:$9;? 3$
@$32?: "4 "452": "J:5‘E4K": Z4$ @"A
3$2>?# @2"X"E?2 3?9": 9": E"#@"A
9$95$: #$Ee9>E":N
,"J2$543" Z4?93" " :>:5$#? .2?EA
5>"9 E"952"K¥ $:5>X$2 ?E>"9?3"] :$A
a42?2 " X"K?95$ D>2#$#$95$ ?@$9?:
@$K? :4? @?25$ $p5$29?] 4#? X$Y Z4$]
3$@$93$93" 3? @":>;<" 3?: 2"3?:
9" #"#$95" 3" ?E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:A
5$#?] @"3$ "E"22$2 4#? #"X>#$95?A
;<" ?J24@5? 3$:5$N - $X$954?K $9A
342$E>#$95" 3? 3>2$;<"] $9Z4?95"
" .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ $:5>X$2 K>a?3"] ^
4#? E"9:$Z4[9E>? 9?542?K 3" ?E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N

’ #"X>#$95?;<" 3" X$WE4K" E"#
" :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ ?E>"9?3"
@"3$2‘ @2"X"E?2 ? 3$:?E"#"3?;<"
3$ @$32?: "4 "452": "J_$5": ?22$#$:A
:?3": @$K? D"2;? 3$ 52?;<" 3?: 2"3?:]
@"3$93" ?5>9a>2 5$2E$>2":N

=#$3>?5?#$95$ ?@h: ? 45>K>Y?;<"
3" :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥] $:5$
3$X$ :$2 3$:K>a?3"N
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?] @2$::>"9?2
9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" E"22$:@"93$95$N
*$ Z4?KZ4$2 #?9$>2?] " :>:5$#? >2‘ :$
3$:?5>X?2 ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ Z4?93" ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ :$a42?9;? 3$ LG i#ob
D"2 :4@$2?3?N
- :>:5$#? E"95? E"# ?: :$a4>95$:
:>9?K>Y?;\$: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"%
!" #"#$95" 3" ?E>"9?#$95"%
 =93>E?;<" :"9"2?% 7 J>@ K"9a"N
 =93>E?;<" X>:4?K% ? K4YA$:@>? E"2A
2$:@"93$95$ ?E$93$A:$ 3$ #?A
9$>2? >95$2#>5$95$ $ ?::># @$2#?A
9$E$ $9Z4?95" " :>:5$#? $:5>X$2
?E>"9?3"N
 &$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95": 342?95$ 6 :$a49A
3":N
w4?93" " X$WE4K" ?KE?9;? ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ 3$ 76 i#ob] @?2? ?K$25?2 Z4$
? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ :$a42?9;? @?2? 3$A
:?5>X?;<" ?45"#‘5>E? 3" :>:5$#? qLG
i#obr $:5‘ @2hp>#?%
!" #"#$95" 3? 3$:?5>X?;<" qX"A
K495‘2>? "4 ?45"#‘5>E?r 3" :>:5$#?%
 =93>E?;<" :"9"2?% 7 J>@ E425"N
 =93>E?;<" X>:4?K% ? K4YA$:@>? E"2A
2$:@"93$95$ :$ ?@?a? 9" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95":N
 &$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y 342?95$ 6
:$a493":N
,$ "E"22$2 4#? ?X?2>? 3" :>:5$#?%
 =93>E?;<" X>:4?K% ? K4YA$:@>? E"2A
2$:@"93$95$ @$2#?9$E$ ?E$:?N
 &$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y 3$ ?X?2>?
3" :>:5$#?N

,$ "E"22$2 4#? 5$95?5>X? 3$ ?E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? E"# " X$WE4K"
$# #"X>#$95"] "4 :$# @>:?2 " @$3?K
3$ D2$>"] " :>:5$#? 9<" ^ ?E>"9?3" $
? K4YA$:@>? E"22$:@"93$95$ 9" Z4?A
32" 3$ >9:524#$95": :$ ?E$93$ @"2 ?KA
a49: :$a493":] >93>E?93" Z4$ " E"A
#?93" 3$ ?E>"9?#$95" D"> 2$E$J>3"]
@"2^# ?: E"93>;\$: 3$ ?E>"9?#$95"
9<" D"2?# ?5$93>3?:N
- :>:5$#? .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥
3$:5>9?A:$ ? ?4p>K>?2 " #"5"2>:5? 9?:
#?9"J2?: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? $# Z4$ "
:>:5$#? @"3$2>? $X>5?2 "4 2$#"X$2 "
X$WE4K" 3$ 4# ?5"K?#$95"N ’ :4?
@2$:$9;? 9<" 3$X$ >934Y>2 " 4:4‘2>"
? 52?9:@"2 "J:5‘E4K": :$X$2": "4 ?
2$?K>Y?2 52>Kb?: 2?3>E?>: @?2? ?: Z4?>:
" X$WE4K" 9<" $:5‘ @2$@?2?3" qX$2
2$E"#$93?;\$: $:@$EWD>E?: 9" E?@WA
54K" B  (:" E"22$5" 3" X$WE4K"rN
!#!
SC’V+ 1+C=S-%
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" " K$X?95?#$95"
3$ 4#? 3?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?:] #"5>A
X?3" @"2 4#? "@$2?;<" 3$ #?945$9A
;<" 3" X$WE4K"] " :>:5$#? 949E? 3$X$
:$2 ?E>"9?3"N

’: X$2:\$: .2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ 9<"
5[# 52?;<" 9?: Z4?52" 2"3?:N .2?5?A:$
3$ 4# :>:5$#? ?4p>K>?2 @?2? #$Kb"2?2
? 52?;<" 3" X$WE4K"] ? Z4?K :$#@2$
"E"22$ :"#$95$ 9" $>p" 3>?95$>2"N
   
 
 $!
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? $K^52>E? 3?
3>2$;<" 3‘ ?" E"9345"2 J"?: 2$:@":A
5?: 3" X$WE4K" $ D?E>K>5? ? #?9"J2?J>A
K>3?3$ $# $:@?;": K>#>5?3":N - 9WX$K
3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ^ X?2>‘X$K @?2? "D$2$E$2
#$9"2$: $:D"2;": $# #?9"J2?: 3$ &
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $ D>2#$Y? ?" 3>2>a>2N

8?:" " :>:5$#? :"D2? ?Ka4#? >95$2A
24@;<" 3? ?::>:5[9E>? @"2 D?Kb? 3$
Z4?KZ4$2 9?542$Y?] ?>93? :$2‘ @"::WA
X$K "@$2?2 ? 3>2$;<" #?94?K#$95$N
!" $95?95"] " $:D"2;" $p>a>3" @?2?
1$"%
#?9"J2?: 3$X$2‘ ?4#$95?2 :4J:5?9A
E>?K#$95$N
,$ ?: E"93>;\$: 3$ D?Kb? @$2:>:5>A
2$#] 3>2>_?A:$ g   ! = , 
> N
   
 '
   / .- 0
! *67   *67
1?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? D49;<"]
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" $:@$EWD>E"  
% :>54?3" 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?KN
1$"&

-: J"5\$: @"3$# ?@2$:$95?2 D49A
;\$: $ @":>;\$: 3>D$2$95$:] 3$@$9A
3$93" 3? X$2:<" $ 3? E"9D>a42?;<"
3": "@E>"9?>: ?3Z4>2>3":N
’ ?5>X?;<" 3? D49;<" ^ >93>E?3?
@$K? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3? K4YA$:@>?
,1-C. 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" ,1-C.] ?
D49;<" ^ ?5>X?3? $ "J5^#A:$ 4# @2"A
a2?#? 3$ E"934;<" $:@"25>X? E?2?EA
5$2>Y?3? @"2 4#? 2$:@":5? #?>: 2‘A
@>3? 3$ ?E$K$2?;<" $ 4# $:D"2;" 9"
X"K?95$] Z4$ @2"@"2E>"9?# ?" E"9A
345"2 4#? 3>2>a>J>K>3?3$ #?>: @2?Y$A
2":?N
’ D49;<" ,1-C. @2"@"2E>"9? 4#?
2$:@":5? #?>: 2‘@>3? 3$ ?E$K$2?;<"]
4#? ?K5$2?;<" 9" 5$#@" 3$ #43?9A
;?: 3" E?#J>" @?2? 4# 2$a>#$ #?>:
$:@"25>X" $ 4# K>a$>2" ?4#$95" 9" $:A
D"2;" 9? 3>2$;<"] @?2? 3?2 4#? :$9A
:?;<" 3$ E"934;<" ?3$Z4?3?N +::$
@2"a2?#? 3$ E"934;<" $ u5>K $# 4#?
$:52?3? :>94":? "93$ ? @2$E>:<" 3?
3>2$;<" $ #?>: 3$:$_?3?N
12$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<" @?2?
3$:?5>X?2 ? D49;<" $ 2$a2$::?2 ?" @2"A
a2?#? 3$ E"934;<" 9"2#?KN

+# D?:$ 3$ ?E$K$2?;<"] 45>K>Y?93"
? D49;<" ,1-C.] ^ @"::WX$K :$95>2 X>A
J2?;\$: 9? 3>2$;<"] Z4$ :<" E?2?E5$A
2W:5>E?: 3$ 4# @2"a2?#? $:@"25>X"N

7 ' ( 
1 '-
  "!
- :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ 3$:K>a? ?45"A
#?5>E?#$95$ " #"5"2 :$#@2$ Z4$ "
X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 @?2?3" q?5$93$93" g:
E"93>;\$: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:A
5$#?r $ 2$>9>E>? Z4?93" " E"9345"2
2$5>2? ? @2$::<" :"J2$ " @$3?K 3$ D2$>"N
+:5$ @2"E$3>#$95" ?4#$95? ? $D>A
E>[9E>? 3" X$WE4K" ?52?X^: 3? 2$34A
;<" 9" E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 2$A
34Y ?: $#>::\$: 3$ a?:$: 9"E>X": $ ?
@"K4>;<" :"9"2?N
!!  !! 
"!
1?2? ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 " :>:5$#? #?A
94?K#$95$] @2$::>"9$ " J"5<" K"A
E?K>Y?3" 9" E"9:"K$ E$952?K "4 9"
@?>9$K] E"9D"2#$ ? X$2:<"N
’ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" :>:5$#?
,5?25',5"@ ^ >93>E?3? @"2 4#?
#$9:?a$# $p>J>3? 9" 3>:@K?y $o"4
9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": q3$@$9A
3$93" 3? X$2:<"rN w4?93" " :>:5$#?
^ 3$:?5>X?3"] " )+* K"E?K>Y?3"
:"J " J"5<" ^ K>a?3"N
!"
] 4  - P ,
" !- /' 5   -&
 P ,0
+# X$WE4K": 3$ 52?9:#>::<" ?45"A
#‘5>E?] :$ " :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ $:5‘
?5>X?3" $ " X$WE4K" ^ @?2?3" q@?2?2
@"2 4# 5$#@" :4D>E>$95$ @?2? " :>:A
5$#? ?54?2r " #"5"2 ^ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ 3$:K>a?3" 9?: :$a4>95$: E"9A
3>;\$:%
 ’K?X?9E? 3$ X$K"E>3?3$: 9? @"A
:>;<" N
 1$3?K 3" D2$>" @2$::>"9?3"N

- 3$:K>a?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3"
#"5"2 ^ b?J>K>5?3" ?@$9?: 3$@">: 3$
:4@$2?2 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ E$2E?
3$ 6 i#ob] @?2? $X>5?2 2$@$5>3":
3$:K>a?#$95": 3" #"5"2 Z4?93"
E"934Y>2 ? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ J?>p?N
" !-  /     -&
P ,0
+# E?:" 3$ 52?9:#>::<" ?45"#‘A
5>E?] " #"5"2 ^ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 2$A
K>a?3" Z4?93" " E"9345"2 $D$54? 4#
3": :$a4>95$: @2"E$3>#$95":%
 w4?93" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ X$K"E>3?A
3$: ^ #"X>#$95?3? "4 Z4?93" "
@$3?K 3$ D2$>" ^ K>J$2?3"N 8"#
? D49;<" x,5?25',5"@z b?J>K>5?3?]
K>J$2?2 " @$3?K 3" D2$>" @?2? @$2A
#>5>2 ? 2$@?25>3? 3" #"5"2] 3$:3$
Z4$ " Ee#J>" $:5$_? 9? @":>;<"
3$ *2>X$ /0N &
,$ " Ee#J>" $9E"952?A:$ D"2? 3?
@":>;<" 3$ *2>X$ q*r " X$WE4K" X?>
@?25>2 ?45"#?5>E?#$95$N
1$"’
  6H .- 4    
 /!- 0
1"2 Z4$:5<" 3$ E"9D"25"] 3$ 2$34A
;<" 3$ $#>::\$: $ 3$ :$a42?9;?] "
#"5"2 9<" ^ 3$:K>a?3" :"J ?: :$a4>9A
5$: E"93>;\$:%
 =9EK>9?;<" :4@$2>"2 ?" X?K"2 @2$A
$:5?J$K$E>3" @?2? a?2?95>2 ? :$a4A
2?9;? 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:A
5$#?N
 - #"5"2 ?>93? $:5‘ D2>"N
 - 9WX$K 3$ E?2a? 3? J?5$2>?
?J?>p" 3" K>#>5$ @2$$:5?J$K$E>3"N
 ’ @"25? 3" E"9345"2 9<" $:5‘
D$Eb?3?N
 - E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" #"5"A
2>:5? 9<" $:5‘ ?D>X$K?3"N
 ’ #?2Eb? ? 2^ D"> ?E>"9?3? q@"2
$p$#@K"] @?2? ?: #?9"J2?: 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"rN
 -E"22$4 2$?J?:5$E>#$95"
2$E$95$N +:5? E"93>;<" ^
5$#@"2‘2>? qX$2 ?3X$25[9E>?:
9" 5h@>E" x,>:5$#? DK$pz 9$:5$
E?@W54K"rN
 - E?@v $:5‘ ?J$25" "4 3$:52?A
X?3"N
1$"*
 - 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K
$:5‘ 9? 2$:$2X?N
 ’ K4YA$:@>? 3" :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@
$:5‘ ?E$:?N

’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"
@"3$ >9>J>2 " ?45":5"@ 3$ ?E"23" E"#
? "@;<" $:E"Kb>3? @$K" 4:4‘2>"] E"9A
D"2#$ 3$:E2>5" 9" E?@W54K" t8K>#?5>A
Y?;<"tN
  6H        &
 /!- 0
1"2 Z4$:5<" 3$ E"9D"25"] 3$ 2$A
34;<" 3$ $#>::\$: $ 3$ :$a42?9;?]
" #"5"2 @"3$ 2$>9>E>?2 ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ :$# Z4?KZ4$2 >95$2X$9;<" 3"
E"9345"2] :$ "E"22$2$# ?: :$a4>95$:
E"93>;\$:%
 !WX$K 3$ E?2a? 3? J?5$2>? ?J?>p"
3" K>#>5$ @2$$:5?J$K$E>3"N
 -E"22$4 ? 3$@2$::<" 3" :>:5$#?
3$ D2$>"] 3$X>3" ?" ?E>"9?#$95"
3" @$3?K 3$ D2$>" 2$@$5>3?: X$Y$:N
 V$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"] @"2
$p$#@K"] 9": E?:": 3$ $:5?2
52?D$a?93" $# 3$:E>3?:N
 - #"5"2 D"> 3$:K>a?3" ?52?X^: 3"
:>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ @"2 ?@2"p>#?A
3?#$95$ 52[: #>945":N
!#!
1?2? " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
:>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@] " 9WX$K 3$ E?2a?
3? J?5$2>? 3$X$ $:5?2 ?E>#? 3" K>#>5$
@2$$:5?J$K$E>3"N
V$2>D>E?2 ? E?2a? 3? J?5$2>? 9": @$A
2W"3": >93>E?3": 9" 1K?9" 3$ #?94A
5$9;<" @2"a2?#?3?N
*42?95$ " ’45":5"@] ? K4YA$:@>?
9? E"2 X$23$ D>E?2‘ ?E$:? 9" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95":] E"#" >93>E?;<" 3$
Z4$ " #"5"2 D"> 3$:K>a?3" @$K" :>:A
5$#? ,5?25',5"@N
1"2 #"5>X" 3$ :$a42?9;?] "
,5?25',5"@ @"3$2‘ :$2 3$:?J>K>5?3"N
,$2‘ X>:4?K>Y?3? 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524A
#$95":] E"9D"2#$ ? X$2:<"] ? #$9:?A
a$# 3$ >93>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#?N
" 
!!
*42?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
,5?25',5"@] $# E"93>;<" 3$ ’45":A
5"@ q#"5"2 3$:K>a?3"r] ?" ?J2>2 ?
@"25? $ 2$5>2?2 " @^ 3" D2$>"] "4 ?J2>2
? @"25? $ 3$:?D>X$K?2 " E>95" 3$ :$a4A
2?9;?] " :>:5$#? >2‘ ?E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"] :"K>E>5?93"
? >95$2X$9;<" 3" 4:4‘2>" @?2? 2$@?2A
5>3? 3" #"5"2 ?52?X^: 3$ 4#? #$9A
:?a$# 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

f @"::WX$K #?95$2 " #"5"2 $# D49A
E>"9?#$95"] 3$:?J>K>5?93" " :>:5$#?
,5?25',5"@N
!#!
*42?95$ " D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:A
5$#? ,5"@',5?25] " E"9345"2 3$X$ $:A
5?2 :$#@2$ ?5$95" ?" ?E>"9?#$95" 3"
@$3?K 3$ D2$>"N
*$X>3" ? 3>X$2:?: E"93>;\$:] "
#"5"2 @"3$2‘ :$2 2$K>a?3" $ " X$WE4K"
@"3$2‘ $952?2 $# #"X>#$95" E?:" "
D2$>" 9<" $:5$_? E"#@K$5?#$95$ @2$:A
:>"9?3"N
!!  &
!"
+# E?:" 3$ #?4 D49E>"9?#$95"]
" :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ ^ 3$:K>a?3"N -
E"9345"2 ^ >9D"2#?3" 3? ?9"#?K>?
@$K? :>9?K>Y?;<" 3? K4YA$:@>?] _495?A
#$95$ E"# 4#? #$9:?a$# X>:4?K>A
Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y q?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:rN
!$:5$ E?:"] 3>2>a>2A:$ ?   !&
 = ,  > :
!* = , 
 3- ,        
 Z  P 3 , ^- ,
, ^ ' ,Q 
7 5 -+  > :
&
!!  
+# E?:": 3$ >9?5>X>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
$:5$_? ?5$95" g E?2a? 3? J?5$2>?N
+D$54?2 " :$a4>95$ @2"E$3>#$95"%
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" 3$:E"9$E5?2 "
E?J" #?::? qAr 3? J?5$2>?] " #$:#"
3$X$ :$2 D$>5" ?52?X^: 3" D?K:" @"K"
9$a?5>X" !] E"#" ? :$a4>2%
1$"+

 12$::>"9$ " J"5<" % 3" $9a?5$
2‘@>3" @?2? :"K5‘AK" 3" D?K:" @"K"N
 C$#"X? " $9a?5$ 2‘@>3"  3"
D?K:" @"K" 9$a?5>X" N
1$",
 1?2? 2$E"K"E?2 " E?J"] $#@422?2
9" :$95>3" E"952‘2>" ?5^ "4X>2 "
EK>Ei 3? 52?X?] E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3"
52?X?#$95"N
- :$9:"2 =B, ! 9<" @"3$ 949E?
:$2 3$:E"9$E5?3" 3" @"K"] $pE$5"
9" E?:" 3$ :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$A
2>?N

’95$: 3$ E"95>94?2 E"# " @2"E$A
3>#$95"] ?a4?23$ @$K" #$9": 7 #>A
945" @?2? @":>E>"9?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N

’ J?5$2>? @?2? X$WE4K": E"# :>:A
5$#? ,5?25',5"@ @"::4> E?2?E5$2W:5>A
E?: Z4$ :<" $:@$EWD>E?: @?2? $:5? X$2A
:<" $ X>:?# a?2?95>2 " @$2D$>5" D49E>A
"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N 1?2? :4J:5>54>A
;<" 3? J?5$2>?] 3>2>_?A:$ >#@2$:E>93>A
X$K#$95$ g   ! = ,  > :
!!  "#!
+# E?:" 3$ @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
E"# J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2] 9<" E"9$E5?2 "
E?J" 9$a?5>X" qAr 3? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2
?" 5$2#>9?K 9$a?5>X"  3? J?5$2>? 3"
X$WE4K"N 8"9$E5?2 ? 4# @"95" 3$
#?::? #"5"2oEe#J>" q:>a? " @2"E$3>A
#$95" 3$ x1?25>3? E"# J?5$2>? ?4p>A
K>?2zrN


’95$: 3$ ?J2>2 " E?@v] ^ @2$E>:"
?::$a42?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" $:5$_?
3$:K>a?3" $ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"
9? @":>;<" -PPN f ?E"9:$Kb?3" 2$5>A
2?2 ? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<" 3$ 3$952" 3"
X$WE4K" Z4?93" " #$:#" $:5>X$2 @?A
2?3" $ E"# "452?: @$::"?: @2$:$95$:
9" >95$2>"2N
*42?95$ " 2$?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K] ?::$a42?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ "
X$WE4K" $:5$_? 3$:K>a?3" E"# " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<" -PPN
!<" 2$#"X$2 " :$9:"2 =B, q,$9:"2
>95$K>a$95$ 3? J?5$2>?r 3" @"K" 9$a?A
5>X" 3? J?5$2>? !] @">: " :>:5$#? ,5?25
' ,5"@ @"3$2‘ D>E?2 >9"@$2?95$N

’@h: :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$2>? " :>:A
5$#? ,5?25',5"@ @"3$ D>E?2 5$#@"2?A
2>?#$95$ >93>:@"9WX$KN
    
 
 
f 4# 3>:@":>5>X" Z4$ @$2#>5$ K>#>A
5?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ? X?K"2$:
@2"a2?#‘X$>: @$K" #"5"2>:5?N
f @"::WX$K @2"a2?#?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$
#‘p>#? E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3" "4
E"# " X$WE4K" $# #"X>#$95"N ’
X$K"E>3?3$ #W9>#? @2"a2?#‘X$K ^ 3$
HG i#obN
w4?93" " 3>:@":>5>X" $:5‘ ?5>X"] ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 3$@$93$ 3?
@2$::<" 3" @$3?K ?E$K$2?3"2] ?5^ :$2
?5>9a>3? ? X$K"E>3?3$ K>#>5$ @2"a2?A
#?3? qE"9:4K5?2 ? "@;<" t12"a2?#?A
;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ K>#>5$trN
!!   
1?2? ?5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X"] @2$::>"9?2
" J"5<" 9" X"K?95$N
’ ?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" ^ ?::>9?A
K?3? @$K? X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" :W#J"K"
9" 3>:@K?y q3$ E"2 J2?9E? 9?: X$2:\$:
E"# 3>:@K?y #4K5>D49;\$: 2$E"9D>a4A
2‘X$Kr] _495?#$95$ E"# 4#? #$9:?A
a$# $:@$EWD>E?] $ @$K" uK5>#" X?K"2
3$ X$K"E>3?3$ #$#"2>Y?3?N
,$ " 824>:$ 8"952"K $K$52v9>E" 5>A
X$2 :>3" ?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5>X?3"] ^ 9$A
E$::‘2>" @2$::>"9?2 34?: X$Y$: " J"A
5<" N ’ @2>#$>2? @2$::<" 3$:K>a? ?
D49;<" ?95$2>"2#$95$ ?5>X?3?] ? :$A
a493? @2$::<" ?5>X? " ,@$$3 )>#>5$2N
&
!"! ! &
! "
’ X$K"E>3?3$ K>#>5$ @"3$ :$2 @2"A
a2?#?3? :$# 9$E$::?2>?#$95$ ?5>X?2
" 3>:@":>5>X"N
1?2? #$#"2>Y?2 4# X?K"2 3$ X$A
K"E>3?3$ #?>: ?K5" 3" Z4$ " X>:4?A
K>Y?3"] @2$::>"9?2 J2$X$#$95$ " J"A
5<" ,+. ¥N ’ E?3? @2$::<" 3" J"5<"
1$"-
E"22$:@"93$ 4# ?4#$95" 3? X$K"E>A
3?3$ 3$ E$2E? 3$ 7 i#ob $9Z4?95"
Z4$] #?95$93" " J"5<" @2$::>"9?3"]
"J5^#A:$ 4# ?4#$95" 3$ 6 i#obN
1?2? #$#"2>Y?2 4# X?K"2 #?>:
J?>p" 3" Z4$ " X>:4?K>Y?3"] @2$:A
:>"9?2 " J"5<" ,+. N ’ E?3?
@2$::<" 3" J"5<" E"22$:@"93$ 4#?
3>#>94>;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ E$2E?
3$ 7 i#ob $9Z4?95" Z4$] #?95$93"
" J"5<" @2$::>"9?3"] "J5^#A:$ 4#?
3>#>94>;<" 3$ 6 i#obN
!!@!! 
 
’5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"% @2$::>"9?2
": J"5\$: ,+. ¥ "4 ,+. N ’ ?5>X?A
;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K?
X>:4?K>Y?;<" 3" :W#J"K" 9" 3>:A
@K?y q3$ E"2 X$23$ 9?: X$2:\$: E"#
3>:@K?y #4K5>D49;\$: 2$E"9D>a42‘X$KrN
*$:?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"% @2$::>A
"9?2 " J"5<" !N ’ 3$:?5>X?;<"
3" 3>:@":>5>X" ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K? X>A
:4?K>Y?;<" 3" :W#J"K" 9" 3>:@K?y
q3$ E"2 J2?9E?rN
1$%.
C$?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"% @2$::>"A
9?2 " J"5<" N
! !!" ! &
! !"!!
12$::>"9?93" " @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?A
3"2 5"5?K#$95$ ?5^ " tD493"t qD># 3$
E42:"r] ^ @"::WX$K 4K52?@?::?2 ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ @2"a2?#?3? #$:#" Z4?93"
" 3>:@":>5>X" $:5‘ ?5>X" q@"2 $pN $#
E?:" 3$ 4K52?@?::?a$#rN
- 3>:@":>5>X" ^ 3$:?5>X?3" ?5^ 2$A
34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ ?J?>p" 3" K>#>5$
3$D>9>3"] $95<" :$ 2$?5>X? ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$N
"#! ! !
!"!!
’ X$K"E>3?3$ @2"a2?#?3? E"#$;?
? K?#@$_?2 9": :$a4>95$: E?:":%
 w4?93" :$ 5>X$2 @2$::>"9?3" "
@$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?3"2 $ ? X$K"E>A
3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 5>X$2 4K52?@?:A
:?3" ? X$K"E>3?3$ @2"a2?#?3?N
 ’5>X?93" " :>:5$#? ?@h: 5$2 3$D>A
9>3" 4# K>#>5$ >9D$2>"2 g $D$5>X?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"N
 w4?93" " 3>:@":>5>X" 9<" D"2 E?A
@?Y 3$ 2$34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
X$WE4K" 3$X>3" g >9EK>9?;<" 3?
$:52?3?N
 +# E?:" 3$ ?E$K$2?;<" J24:E?N
!!   
1?2? 3$:?5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X"] @2$:A
:>"9?2 " J"5<" N

’ ?5>X?;<" 3" 824>:$ 8"952"K $K$A
52v9>E" "4 3? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ T*8
q       r @2"X"E?2‘ ?
3$:?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"N
 *67 - P ,     &
 *
- 3>:@":>5>X" 3$:?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?A
5>E?#$95$ $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :>:A
5$#?N !$:5$ E?:"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g 
 ! = ,  > N
   
 
 !! !  &
! / .- 0
- 8"952"K$ ’3?@5?5>X" 3$ V$K"A
E>3?3$ q’3?@5>X$ 824>:$ 8"952"K 
’88r ^ 4# :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>?
g E"934;<"] 3$ E"952"K$ $K$52v9>E"]
Z4$ @$2#>5$ #?95$2 " X$WE4K" ? 4#?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$:$_?3?] :$# ? 9$E$::>A
3?3$ 3$ @>:?2 9" @$3?K 3" ?E$K$2?A
3"2] $ Z4$ ?3?@5? :4? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$
?E"23" E"# " X$WE4K" $9E"952?3" g
D2$95$] 2$34Y>93" ? X$K"E>3?3$ $ 2$A
5"#?93" ? @2$$:5?J$K$E>3? E?:" 9<"
b?_? 9$9b4# "J:5‘E4K" 9" E?#>9b"N
8"9543"] 9<" ^ 4# :>:5$#? 3$ :$A
a42?9;? $ 9<" D"> 3$:$9X"KX>3" @?2?
@2$X$9>2 E"K>:\$:N
+:5$ :>:5$#? @"3$ :$2 45>K>Y?3" ?
4#? X$K"E>3?3$ :4@$2>"2 ? HG i#ob]
$# K"9a": 52$Eb": 3$ $:52?3? 2$5":]
:$E": $ E"# @"4E?: X?2>?;\$: 3$
X$K"E>3?3$ q@"2 $p$#@K" @$2E42:":
$# ?45"$:52?3?:rN
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 9<" ^
X?95?_":? $# $:52?3?: $p52?42J?9?:
E"# #4>5" 52e9:>5"N !<" ^ 2$E"#$9A
3?3" 45>K>Y?2 " 3>:@":>5>X" 9? E>3?3$N

,$ 9<" D"2 3$5$E5?3" 4# X$WE4K" g
D2$95$] " ’88 #?95$2‘ 4#? X$K"E>A
3?3$ D>p? 3$D>9>3? @$K" E"9345"2N
,$ D"2 3$5$E5?3" 4# X$WE4K" g
D2$95$] " ’88 ?@K>E?2‘ D2$9?a$# "4
?E$K$2?;<" K>#>5?3?: q:$# $pE$3$2 ?
X$K"E>3?3$ "2>a>9?K#$95$ 3$D>9>3?r
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ @?2? #?95$2 ?
3>:5e9E>? @2$3$D>9>3?] #?95$93"
4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"#@?5WX$K E"# ?
3" X$WE4K" ?3>?95$N
- 8"952"K$ 3$ V$K"E>3?3$ @"::4>
3">: #"3": 3$ E"952"K$%
 &"3" 8"952"K$ ’3?@5?5>X" 3$ V$A
K"E>3?3$ @?2? #?95$2 4#? 3>:5e9A
E>? ?@2"@2>?3? $952$ X$WE4K":N
 &"3" V$K"E>3?3$ P>p? @?2? 2"3?2
? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ @2$A
3$5$2#>9?3?N 1?2? >9D"2#?;\$:
?3>E>"9?>:] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D"
t&"3" V$K"E>3?3$ P>p?t 9$:5? :$A
;<"N
f :$#@2$ @"::WX$K ?K5$29?2 $952$ ":
#"3": ?52?X^: 3": J"5\$: 3" :>:5$#?
9" X"K?95$N -: 3">: #"3": 3$ E"9A
52"K$ D49E>"9?# 3$ #?9$>2?: 3>D$2$9A
5$:N ,$#@2$ E"9D>2#$ Z4?K #"3" $:5‘
:$K$E>"9?3"N

- ’88 ^ 4# :>:5$#? 3$ E"9X$9>A
[9E>?N +K$ 9<" ?54? E"#" :4J:5>545"
?" $9X"KX>#$95" ?5>X" Z4$ ? E"934A
;<" 3$ 4# X$WE4K" $p>a$N f :$#@2$
2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2 $:5?2
?5$95" g X>?] ?" 52‘D$a" $ g: E"93>A
;\$: EK>#‘5>E?:] J$# E"#" g X$K"E>A
3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" $ ? 3>:5e9E>? @?2? ":
3$#?>:N ’E>#? 3$ 543"] ^ 3$K$ ? 2$:A
@"9:?J>K>3?3$ :"J2$ ? D2$9?a$#] @?2? &
?::$a42?2 ? "@$2?;<" :$a42? 3" X$WA
E4K" :"J 5"3? $ Z4?KZ4$2 E"93>;<"N ’
E"#@K$5? ?5$9;<" 3" E"9345"2 ^ $p>A
a>3? @$2#?9$95$#$95$ @?2? ? #?94A
5$9;<" 3" E"952"K$ :"J2$ " X$WE4K"N
’ 9<" "J:$2X?;<" 3$::?: E"93>;\$:
@"3$ K$X?2 ? ?E>3$95$: E"# D$2>#$9A
5": a2?X$: $ ?5^ ? #"25$N
- :>:5$#? ’88%
1$%!
 !<" 2$?a$ ? @$3$:52$:] X$WE4K":
52?D$a?93" 9" :$95>3" "@":5" 3?
X>?N
 1"3$ 9<" K$X?2 ?: E"93>;\$: 3?
X>?] 3" 52‘D$a" $ 3" 5$#@" $#
E"9:>3$2?;<"] $ ?>93? @"3$ 5$2
:4? ?54?;<" K>#>5?3? 3>?95$ 3$
E"93>;\$: ?3X$2:?: X>:>J>K>3?3$ g
3>:5e9E>?N
 !$# :$#@2$ 2$E"9b$E$ @K$9?A
#$95$ E"93>;\$: 3$ E"934;<"
E"#@K$p?:] " Z4$ @"3$ 2$:4K5?2
$# ?X>:": >9E"22$5": "4 9<" $#>A
5>3":N
- :>:5$#? ’88 3$X$ :$2 3$:K>a?3"%
 w4?93" :"J 9$JK>9?] Eb4X? D"25$]
9$X$] a2?9>Y"] 52‘D$a" >95$9:" $
:>54?;\$: E"#@K$p?: 3$ E"934A
;<" q@"2 $p$#@K"] $# Y"9?: 3$
"J2?: $# 2"3"X>?:rN
 ’" $952?2 $# D?>p?: @?2? E"9X$2A
:\$: "4 $# ?K;?: 3$ ?E$::"d ?"
E"934Y>2 $# $:52?3?: :>94":?:]
E"J$25?: @"2 a$K" "4 9$X$] $:E"2A
2$a?3>?: "4 Z4$ E"# ?EK>X$: "4
3$EK>X$: #4>5" W9a2$#$:N
1$%"
 ’" 2$J"E?2 ?52$K?3": $# X>?: $#
52$Eb": 3$ :4J>3?: "4 3$:E>3?:
W9a2$#$:N
 w4?93" Z4?>:Z4$2
E>2E49:5e9E>?: >#@$3>2$# 4#?
E"934;<" :$a42? ? X$K"E>3?3$
E"9:5?95$N
-: J"5\$: @?2? " E"#?93" 3" E"9A
52"K$ $K$52v9>E" 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ $:5<"
K"E?K>Y?3": 9" K?3" 3>2$>5" 3" X"A 7N 8’!8  8?9E$K?2
K?95$N
LN -9o-DD
1?2? ?::$a42?2 4# D49E>"9?#$95" HN ,+.¥  ’4#$95?2 X$K"E>3?3$
E"22$5"] " E"952"K$ $K$52v9>E" 3$ X$A IN C+,  C$5"#?2
K"E>3?3$ D"> E"9E$J>3" 3$ #"3" ?
6N ,+.A  *>#>94>2 X$K"E>3?3$
3$:K>a?2A:$ $# E?:" 3$ ?E>"9?#$95"
:>#4K5e9$" 3$ X‘2>?: D49;\$:N !$:5$ FN )>#>5?3"2 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
E?:"] ^ @"::WX$K 2$?5>X?2 " :>:5$#? |N *$D>9>2 3>:5e9E>?  ?4#$95?2
@2$::>"9?93" " J"5<" $ 2$3$D>A ~N ’88 -9o-DD
9>93" ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$:$_?3? 3" X$WA
E4K"N

w4?KZ4$2 #"3>D>E?;<" 9" Eb?::>]
9? :4:@$9:<" "4 9" 5?#?9b" 3":
@9$4: 3" X$WE4K" ?D$5?2‘ " 3$:$#@$A
9b" 3": :>:5$#?: ’88 $ P8¤ q’K$25?
3$ 8"K>:<" P2"95?KrN
!!   
!#!
’" 45>K>Y?2 " E"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>A
3?3$] "J:$2X?2 ?Ka49: E4>3?3":
#4>5" >#@"25?95$: E"# 2$K?;<" ?"
Ee#J>"N
!<" @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ #?2A
Eb?: $# @"95" #"25"N
!#!
- 824>:$ 8"952"K @"3$ :$2 @$2>a":"
"93$ " :>:5$#? 9<" D"2 E?@?Y 3$
#?95$2 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$N
+# ?Ka4#?: E"93>;\$:] ? X$K"E>A
3?3$ @"3$ :$2 $pE$::>X?] E"# " 2>:E"
3$ @$23$2 " E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K" $ @2"A
X"E?2 ?E>3$95$:N !<" 4:?2 " 3>:@":>A
5>X" $# E"93>;\$: 3$ 52e9:>5" >95$9:"
"4 $# $:52?3?: >22$a4K?2$: :>94":?:]
E"9a$K?3?:] E"# 9$X$ "4 K?#?N
!#!
+# E?:" 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 3$D$>54A
":" "4 ?X?2>? 3" 3>:@":>5>X"] 3>2>a>2A
:$ g   ! = ,  > :
*>2>_? :$#@2$ $# :$a42?9;?N
1?2? ?5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X"] @2$::>"9?2
" J"5<" N
- :>:5$#? :h @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3" :$ ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 ?E>#?
3$ G i#obN
’ X$K"E>3?3$ #W9>#? ? :$2 3$D>9>3?
9" ’88 ^ HG i#obN
w4?93" " :>:5$#? ^ ?5>X?3" $ $:5‘
@2"95" @?2? :$2 4:?3"] " 3>:@K?y 3"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $p>J$ ? #$9A
:?a$# t’88 12"95"tN
w4?93" " :>:5$#? ^ 3$:?5>X?3"]
" 3>:@K?y $p>J$ ? #$9:?a$# t’88
*$:K>a?3"tN

f @$2>a":" 3$>p?2 " 3>:@":>5>X" K>A
a?3" Z4?93" 9<" $:5‘ :$93" 45>K>A
Y?3"N *$ D?5"] $p>:5$ " 2>:E" 3$ ?5>X‘A
K" >9X"K495?2>?#$95$ $ @$23$2 " E"9A
52"K$ 3" X$WE4K" 3$X>3" ? 4# $pE$::"
3$ X$K"E>3?3$ >#@2$X>:5"N
- :>:5$#? ’88 9<" @"3$ :$2 ?5>A
X?3" :"J ?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
 .2?9:#>::<" $# I¤* )-¤N
 1$3?K 3$ D2$>" ?E>"9?3"N
 P2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
?E>"9?3"N
 ’K?X?9E? 3$ 52?9:#>::<" $# ]
 "4 N
&
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 9" #"A
#$95" ?E>#? 3? D?>p? 3$ X$K"E>A
3?3$ :$K$E>"9?3?N
 P2$>": :4@$2?Z4$E>3":N
 1"25? 3" #"5"2>:5? ?J$25?N
 8>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" #"5"2>:5?
9<" ?D>X$K?3"N
1$%%


- 3>:@":>5>X" 9<" ^ E"#@?5WX$K
E"# ?: D49E>"9?K>3?3$: I¤* )-¤
$ T*8N ,$ $:5?: D"2$# ?5>X?3?: $9A
Z4?95" $:5>X$2 45>K>Y?93" " E"952"K$
3$ X$K"E>3?3$] " 3>:@":>5>X" :$2‘ 3$A
:?5>X?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$N *42?95$
? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$::?: D49;\$:] " 824>:$
8"952"K $K$52v9>E" 9<" $:5?2‘] $#
5"3" E?:"] 3>:@"9WX$KN
 ! !
>!!
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 ’5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X" qE"9:4K5?2 ?:
>93>E?;\$: ?95$2>"2#$95$ 3$:E2>A
5?:rN
 w4?93" " X$WE4K" 5>X$2 ?5>9a>3"
? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$:$_?3?] @2$::>"A
9?2 " J"5<"  c q"4  r $
:"K5‘AK" @?2? ?5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X"%
?" :"K5?2 " ?E$K$2?3"2] " X$WE4K"
@2"::$a4>2‘ g X$K"E>3?3$ :$K$E>"A
9?3?N
1$%&
’" $9D2$95?2 52$Eb": $# 3$:E>3? $
E"# " 3>:@":>5>X" ?5>X?3"] ^ @"::WA
X$K Z4$ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?4A
#$95$ K>a$>2?#$95$ $# 2$K?;<" g :$A
K$E>"9?3?N

’95$: 3$ @2$::>"9?2 ": J"5\$: 
c q"4  r] " X$WE4K" 3$X$ X>?_?2
? X$K"E>3?3$ E"9:5?95$ $# 5$22$9"
9>X$K?3"N
!! ! !

’ @2$::<" 3" J"5<"  c q"4 
r @$2#>5$ 3>#>94>2 "4 ?4#$95?2 ?
X$K"E>3?3$ $# 7 i#ob 3$D>9>3? ?52?A
X^: 3" &$94 3" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32"
3$ >9:524#$95":N
!-    *', 
(#? X$Y ?5>X?3" " 824>:$ 8"952"K
$K$52v9>E"] ^ @"::WX$K ?4#$95?2 ? X$A
K"E>3?3$ @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"  c
N 3? X$K"E>3?3$ $# K$X$: :4J>3?: ^
&?95$93" " J"5<" @2$::>"9?3"] ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3? E"95>94?2‘ ? ?4A
#$95?2 ?5^ :"K5?2 " J"5<"] 3$@">: :$2‘
#$#"2>Y?3? ? 9"X? X$K"E>3?3$N
1"2 "452" K?3"] ? E?3? @2$::<" 3"
J"5<"  c "J5^#A:$ " ?4#$95" 3$
7 i#ob 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3?N
 ' K67      *   &
 G
!?: X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# Ee#A
J>" ?45"#‘5>E"] $# E?:" 3$ @$2E42:"
$# #"95?9b?:] " 3>:@":>5>X" @"3$ 2$A
34Y>2 ?45"9"#?#$95$ ? X$K"E>3?3$
$9a?5?3? @?2? #?95$2 ? X$K"E>3?3$
3$D>9>3?N
+# $:52?3?: E"# D"25$ >9EK>9?;<"]
? 3>#>94>;<" "4 " ?4#$95" 3$ X$K"A
E>3?3$ @"3$ :$2 9"5‘X$K $ ^] @"25?95"]
@2$D$2WX$K 3$:?5>X?2 " 3>:@":>5>X"N

- 3>:@":>5>X" #?95^# #$#"2>A
Y?3? ? X$K"E>3?3$ #$:#" $# :4J>3?
$ $# 3$:E>3?N (#? K>a$>2? X?2>?;<"
@$2D$>5?#$95$ 9"2#?KN
 - 67  *', 
8"# " 3>:@":>5>X" ?5>X?3"] @?2?
3>#>94>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$] @2$::>"9?2 "
J"5<"  N
&?95$93" " J"5<" @2$::>"9?3"] ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3? E"95>94?2‘ ? 3>A
#>94>2 ?5^ :"K5?2 " J"5<"] 3$@">: :$2‘
#$#"2>Y?3? ? 9"X? X$K"E>3?3$N
1"2 "452" K?3"] ? E?3? @2$::<" 3"
J"5<"  & "J5^#A:$ ? 2$34;<" 3$
7 i#ob 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3?N
"! !
,$ b"4X$2 9? #$#h2>? 3"
:>:5$#? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3?
?95$2>"2#$95$] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
 $ :"K5‘AK" @?2? X"K5?2 ?" X?K"2
#$#"2>Y?3"N
!#!
C$5"#?2 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ Z4$ :$_?
#4>5" ?K5? "4 #4>5" J?>p? @?2? ?:
E"93>;\$: ?@2$:$95?3?: @"3$ D?Y$2
E"# Z4$ " X$WE4K" ?E$K$2$ "4 3$A
:?E$K$2$ ?J24@5?#$95$] E"#@2"#$A
5$93" ? :$a42?9;? 3? "@$2?;<" $ @"A
3$93" K$X?2 ? a2?X$: ?E>3$95$:N
(:?2 ? D49;<" 3$ 2$5"#?3? 3$ X$A
K"E>3?3$ ?@$9?: :$ ?: E"93>;\$: 3$
52‘D$a" $ 3? X>? @$2#>5>2$#N
 ! _!  *>:5e9E>? #?>: K"9a?
 f 
’ 3>:5e9E>? 3$ ?E"#@?9b?#$95"
$:@$E>D>E?3? @?2? " ’88 @"3$ :$2
3$D>9>3? X?2>?93" " ?_4:5$ $952$ Z4?A
52" J?22?: q#?>: K"9a$r] 52[: J?22?:
qK"9a$r] 34?: J?22?: q#^3>?r $ 4#?
J?22? qE425?rN (:?93" $:5? E"9D>a4A
2?;<" $ ": X?K"2$: 3? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
&
X$WE4K"] " ’88 E?KE4K? $ 3$5$2#>9?
? 3>:5e9E>? @?2? " X$WE4K" g D2$95$N *>:5e9E>? K"9a?
8"9D>a42?93" $:5? "@;<" 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":%
1$%’
 *>:5e9E>? #^3>?
*>:5e9E>? E425?
1?2? 3>#>94>2 ? 3>:5e9E>? $:5?J$A
K$E>3?] @2$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 " J"5<"
t*>:5e9E>? 3$D>93?  3>#>94>2tN ’
E?3? X$Y Z4$ " J"5<" ^ @2$::>"9?3"]
? 3>:5e9E>? 3$D>9>3? 3>#>94> $# 4#?
J?22? q#?>: K"9a?rN (#? X$Y Z4$ ?
3>:5e9E>? #?>: K"9a? ^ ?KE?9;?3?] :$
" J"5<" D"2 @2$::>"9?3" 9"X?#$95$]
? 3>:5e9E>? X"K5?2‘ g #?>: K"9a? 3>:A
@"9WX$KN
- X$WE4K" #?95$2‘ ? X$K"E>3?3$ :$
9<" b"4X$2 "452" X$WE4K" g D2$95$N ,$
4# X$WE4K" 52?D$a?93" $# #$9"2 X$A
K"E>3?3$ ^ 3$5$E5?3" 9? #$:#? D?>p?]
:$2‘ $p>J>3" " WE"9$ 3$ X$WE4K" 3$A
5$E5?3" 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:A
524#$95": $ " :>:5$#? ?_4:5?2‘ ? X$K"A
1$%*
E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$
@?2? #?95$2 ? 3>:5e9E>? 3$D>9>3?] >9A
3$@$93$95$#$95$ 3" X?K"2 3? X$K"A
E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3? 9" ’88N

- :>:5$#? ’88 3$:?E$K$2? " X$WA
E4K" ?5^ @?2‘AK" Z4?93" " X$WE4K"
Z4$ $:5‘ :$93" :$a4>3" @?2? E"#@K$A
5?#$95$N ’@h: 3">: :$a493":] E"# "
X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " E"9345"2 @"3$ 2$?A
5>X?2 " :>:5$#? @2$::>"9?93" " J"5<"
 "4 @>:?93" 9" ?E$K$2?3"2] E"9A
:>3$2?93" ? uK5>#? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$D>A
9>3?N
- X$WE4K" #?95$2‘ ? 3>:5e9E>? 3$A
D>9>3? ?5^ Z4$%
 - X$WE4K" g D2$95$ ?E$K$2$ ?5^
4#? X$K"E>3?3$ ?E>#? 3? X$K"A
E>3?3$ 3$D>9>3?
 - X$WE4K" g D2$95$ :?>? 3? :4?
D?>p? "4 3" ?KE?9E$ 3" :$9:"2
 ’ 3>:5e9E>? 3$D>9>3? :$_? ?K5$2?3?
 - :>:5$#? :$ 3$:?5>X$
’ D2$9?a$# #‘p>#? ?@K>E?3? @$K"
’88 ^ K>#>5?3?N !" $95?95"] " E"9A
345"2 :$#@2$ @"3$ ?E>"9?2 ": D2$>":
@"2 E"95? @2h@2>?] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"N

’: K4Y$: 3$ D2$>" :$#@2$ :$ ?E$9A
3$# Z4?93" " :>:5$#? ’88 @2"X>A
3$9E>? Z4?KZ4$2 D2$9?a$#N
(# ?X>:" 3$ @2"p>#>3?3$ ?K$25? "
E"9345"2 :$ " ’88 @2$X[ Z4$ " :$4
9WX$K #‘p>#" 3$ D2$9?a$# 9<" ^ :4A
D>E>$95$ @?2? #?95$2 ? 3>:5e9E>? 3$A
D>9>3?N 8?:" >::" "E"22?] 4# ?K$25?
X>:4?K 3$ D2$9?a$# >2‘ @>:E?2 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": $ 4#
?K$25? :"9"2" :$2‘ $#>5>3" $9Z4?95"
" ’88 E"95>94? ?@K>E?2 :$4 9WX$K #‘A
p>#" 3$ D2$9?a$#N


- :>:5$#? 3$ ?K$25? 3$ E"K>:<" D2"9A
5?K qP8¤r ?54? $# E"9_495" E"# "
E"952"K$ ?3?@5?5>X" 3$ X$K"E>3?3$N ’
5$K? 3$ ?K$25? 3$ D2$9?a$# 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": ^ 4#
?K$25? @?2? Z4$ " E"9345"2 5"#$ ?:
#$3>3?: 9$E$::‘2>?: $ 9<" :>a9>D>E?
9$E$::?2>?#$95$ Z4$ " :>:5$#? P8¤
$:5‘ ?E>"9?93" ": D2$>": 3$ #?9$>2?
?45v9"#?N 8"9:4K5$ ? :$;<" t,>:5$#?
P8¤t 9" E?@W54K" t,$a42?9;?t @?2?
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:N
!-(+'   -'  5
w4?93" $# E"934;<" E"# " ’88
?5>X" $ :$a4>93" 4# X$WE4K"] @"3$
:$2 @2"X>3$9E>?3? 4#? ?E$K$2?;<"
?3>E>"9?K @?2? Z4$] ?4#$95?93"A:$
? X$K"E>3?3$ @2$3$D>9>3? 9" :>:5$#?]
:$_? D$>5? ? 4K52?@?::?a$#N
- ?4pWK>" :$2‘ @2"#"X>3" ? @?25>2
3? ?5>X?;<" 3" >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<"
q:$5?r @?2? ? $:Z4$23? q$# K"E?>: E"#
52‘D$a" @$K? 3>2$>5?r "4 3>2$>5? q$# K"A
E?>: E"# 52‘D$a" @$K? $:Z4$23?r $ :$2‘
#?95>3" ?@$9?: 342?95$ ? 4K52?@?:A
:?a$# @$K" K?3" $:Z4$23" "4 3>2$>5"]
2$:@$E5>X?#$95$] E"# " :>:5$#? 2$A
5"29?93" g X$K"E>3?3$ "2>a>9?K#$95$
$:5?J$K$E>3? ?" D>9?K 3? #?9"J2?N

w4?93" " X$WE4K" D>Y$2 ? 52?9:>A
;<" 3$ 4# K"E?K E"# 52‘D$a" @$K?
$:Z4$23? @?2? 4# K"E?K E"# 52‘D$a"
@$K? 3>2$>5? "4 X>E$AX$2:?] " :>:5$#?
’88 3$5$E5?2‘ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ "
:$95>3" 3" 52‘D$a"N
!'    - 67
!'   ' K   
- :>:5$#? @"3$ $p>J>2 4# ?K$25?
X>:4?K 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:A
524#$95": $ $#>5>2 4# ?X>:" :"9"2"
Eb?#?93" ? ?5$9;<" @?2? ? >93>:@"A
9>J>K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? $ "2>$95?93" ?
K>#@$Y? 3" :$9:"2 D2"95?K 3" X$WE4K"%
 +# E"93>;\$: 3$ X>:>J>K>3?3$ @2$A
E‘2>?:] E"#" :"J 9$X$ "4 Eb4X?
D"25$
 w4?93" " :$9:"2 D"2 "J:524W3"
@"2 K?#?] :4_$>2?] a$K" "4 ?D>9:
 w4?93" " X$WE4K" :$ $9E"952?2
$# ‘2$?: 3$ ?K5": W93>E$: 3$ 2$A
&
DK$p<" 3? K4Y] E"#" $# K"E?>:
E"# @K?E?: $ J?22$>2?: 2$DK$5>X?:
"4 $# 2$a>\$: E"J$25?: @"2 a$K"
"4 9$X$ q" :>:5$#? >2‘ :$ 2$E4@$A
2?2 Z4?93" " X$WE4K" 3$>p?2 $::?:
‘2$?:r

+# 2?2?: "E?:>\$:] Z4?93"
9$9b4# X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 :$93" 3$5$EA
1$%+
5?3" $# :$4 E?#>9b"] $:5$ ?K$25?
@"3$ ?@?2$E$2 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$N
,$ ?: E"93>;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: 9<" D"A
2$# 4# D?5"2] " :$9:"2 3$X$2‘ :$2 $p?A
#>9?3"] @"3$93" 3$#?93?2 K>#@$Y?
"4 ? 2$#";<" 3$ 4#? "J:524;<"N -
:$9:"2 $:5‘ E$952?K>Y?3" g D2$95$ 3"
X$WE4K"] K"a" ?J?>p" 3? a2?3$ >9D$A
2>"2N
1?2? #?95$2 " :>:5$#? ’88 "@$A
2?93" E"22$5?#$95$] ^ >#@"25?95$ 9"A
5?2 " :$a4>95$%
 &?95$2 :$#@2$ K>#@" " E"X$2 $#
D2$95$ ?" :$9:"2] K"E?K>Y?3" 9"
E$952" 3" @?2?AEb"Z4$ 3>?95$>2"
?J?>p" 3? a2?3$ >9D$2>"2] 45>K>A
Y?93" 4# @?9" #?E>"N
 !<" >9:5?K?2 9$9b4# 5>@" 3$
?E$::h2>" @2hp>#" ?" :$9:"2]
>9EK4>93" #?5$2>?K 52?9:@?2$95$
 !<" D?Y$2 Z4?KZ4$2 ?K5$2?;<" 9":
E"#@"9$95$: "2>a>9?>: @2hp>#":
?" :$9:"2N
 ,$ ? D2$95$ 3" X$WE4K" D"2 3?9>D>A
E?3? @"2 Z4?KZ4$2 ?E>3$95$] @2"A
E42?2 ?   ! = ,  > N
1$%,
w4?93" ?: E"93>;\$: Z4$ 3$:?A
5>X?2?# " :>:5$#? ’88 9<" $:5>X$A
2$# #?>: @2$:$95$:] " :>:5$#? X"K5?2‘
?" $:5?3" 3$ 3$:K>a?3" $ 2$5"#?2‘ "
D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K Z4?93" 2$?5>A
X?3"N

,$ " ?K$25? 3$ K>#@$Y? 3" :$9:"2
"E"22$2 D2$Z4$95$#$95$] :$# Z4?KA
Z4$2 "J:524;<" X>:WX$K 3" :$9:"2] @2"A
E42?2 ?   ! = ,  > N
!'   ' K   &4 
- :>:5$#? @"3$ $p>J>2 4#? #$9A
:?a$# 3$ ?K$25? :"J2$ ? K>#>5?;<"
3$ :4? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ $ "2>$95?93"
? K>#@$Y? 3" @?2?AJ2>:? 3" X$WE4K"
9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$9A
5": $ $#>5>2 4# ?X>:" :"9"2" Z4?93"
?: E"93>;\$: K>#>5?2$# :$4 3$:$#A
@$9b" 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$N
=::" "E"22$ E"# #?>"2 D2$Z4[9E>?
$# #"#$95": :"J E"93>;\$: 3$ X>A
:>J>K>3?3$ @2$E‘2>?:] E"#" :"J 9$X$]
9$JK>9? "4 Eb4X? D"25$N
- :>:5$#? 5?#J^# @"3$ D>E?2 K>A
#>5?3" Z4?93" " @?2?AJ2>:? D"2 "J:A
524W3" @"2 K?#?] :4_$>2? "4 a$K" $
Z4?93" b"4X$2 9^X"? @"2 3$952" 3"
X>32"N !$::$: E?:":] " 3>:@K?y 3" @?>A
9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": ?@2$:$95?2‘ 4#?
#$9:?a$# 3$ ?K$25? :"J2$ ? K>#>5?A
;<" 3? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ $ "2>$95?93"
? K>#@$Y? 3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ " :>:5$#?
5$2‘ :$4 3$:$#@$9b" 2$34Y>3"N
,$ ?: E"93>;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: 9<" D"A
2$# 4# D?5"2] " @?2?AJ2>:? $ ? EeA
#$2? ?52‘: 3" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29" 3$A
X$2<" :$2 $p?#>9?3":N .?KX$Y :$_?
9$E$::‘2>" K>#@?2 $::$: $Z4>@?#$9A
5": "4 2$#"X$2 ?Ka4#? "J:524;<"N
’ #$9:?a$# 3$ ?K$25? 3$ K>#>5?A
;<" 3? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ @"3$ :$2 $p>A
J>3? $# ?Ka49: #"#$95": $9Z4?95"
" X$WE4K" ^ E"934Y>3" :"J E"93>A
;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: ?3X$2:?:N - :>:5$#?
’88 :$ 2$E4@$2?2‘ ?::># Z4$ " X$WA
E4K" 3$>p?2 ? ‘2$? :"J 5?>: E"93>A
;\$:N +# 2?2?: "E?:>\$:] Z4?93" ?
Ee#$2? 9<" $:5‘ 2?:52$?93" 9$9b4#
5>@" 3$ X$WE4K" "4 "J_$5" $# :$4 E?A
#>9b"] ? $p>J>;<" 3$::? #$9:?a$#
@"3$ "E"22$2 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$N
 w4?93" ?: E"93>;\$: Z4$ K>#>A
5?2?# " D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?
’88 9<" $:5>X$2$# #?>: @2$:$95$:]
" :>:5$#? X"K5?2‘ ?" $:5?3" 3$ 3$:A
K>a?3" $ 2$5"#?2‘ " D49E>"9?#$95"
9"2#?K Z4?93" 2$?5>X?3"N

,$ " ?K$25? 3$ K>#@$Y? 3" @?2?A
J2>:? "E"22$2 D2$Z4$95$#$95$] :$#
Z4?KZ4$2 "J:524;<" X>:WX$K 3" @?2?A
J2>:? "4 3? Ee#$2? >95$29?] @2"E42?2
?   ! = ,  > N
!'     67    
,$ " :>:5$#? :$ 3$:K>a?2 $ @?::?2 ?
$p>J>2 4# ?K$25? X>:4?K 9" 3>:@K?y 3"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": "2>$95?93" ?
2$@?2?;<" 3" ’88oP8¤] @"3$ b?X$2
4#? D?Kb? >95$29? 9" :>:5$#? "4 4#
#?4 D49E>"9?#$95" Z4$ K>#>5? ? D49A
E>"9?K>3?3$ 3" ’88N
+#J"2? " X$WE4K" E"95>94$ $#
E"93>;\$: 9"2#?>:] " :>:5$#? $:5?2‘
5$#@"2?2>?#$95$ >93>:@"9WX$KN
8?:" >::" "E"22?] ^ 2$E"#$93‘X$K
5$95?2 ?5>X‘AK" #?>: 5?23$] @2$D$A
2$9E>?K#$95$ ?@h: " X$WE4K" :$2
3$:K>a?3" $ K>a?3" 9"X?#$95$N ,$ "
@2"JK$#? @$2:>:5>2] @2"E42?2 ? 
 ! = ,  > N
,-6H  , -67 , !
4.-   '
*42?95$ ? E"934;<" E"# 2$J"Z4$
3$ ?52$K?3":] 9<" ^ ?E"9:$Kb?3" "
4:" 3" ’88N
+,-' ',  3 (
- ’88 @"3$ 9<" 3$5$E5?2 "452"
X$WE4K" g D2$95$ 3$:K"E?3" 3? K>9b?
3$ :$4 @$2E42:"] ?>93? Z4$ 9?
#$:#? D?>p?] ?::># E"#" X$WE4K":
3$:K"E?93"A:$ K?5$2?K#$95$] E"#"
"E"22$ 9? 49><" 3$ 34?: D?>p?: 3?
@>:5?N 1"3$ 9<" b?X$2] 9$::$: E?:":]
3>:5e9E>? :4D>E>$95$ @?2? " X$WE4K" g
D2$95$N - X$WE4K" 3$:K"E?3" @"3$
:$ #"X$2 9? K>9b? 3$ :$4 @$2E42:"]
" Z4$ @"3$ K$X?2 " :>:5$#? ? D2$?2
"4 ?E$K$2?2 " X$WE4K" 3$ #?9$>2?
>9$:@$2?3?N
- *  , * H
1"2 Z4$:5\$: 3$ $:5?J>K>3?3$] " :>:A
5$#? @"3$ 2$34Y>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ $
?E$K$2?;<" 3" X$WE4K" $# E42X?: $
&
E"9X$2:\$: :$# Z4?KZ4$2 X$WE4K" 3$A
5$E5?3" g D2$95$N (#? X$Y D"2? 3?
E42X?] " :>:5$#? 2$5"#?2‘ ? X$K"E>A
3?3$ "2>a>9?K#$95$ $:5?J$K$E>3?N =:5"
^ @?25$ 3" D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K 3"
’88N

- 3$:$#@$9b" 3" ’88 @"3$ :$2
K>#>5?3" $# E42X?: D$Eb?3?:N
1$%-

 +* ` ,' * - ,' *
- ’88 @"3$ 9<" 3$5$E5?2 4# X$WA
E4K" 9? :4? D?>p? Z4?93" ? X>? ?@2$A
:$95?2 3$:9WX$>: X$25>E?>:] E"#" $#
2"3"X>?: E"# 52$Eb": #"95?9b":":N
*$@$93$93" 3? X$K"E>3?3$] 3? E?2a?
3" X$WE4K"] 3?: E"93>;\$: 3" 52‘D$a"
$ 3? >9EK>9?;<" 3" 5$22$9"] " 3$:$#A
@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? @"3$ :$2 K>#>5?3"N
"- 6  3 (
1$&.
- ’88 @"3$ 9<" 3$5$E5?2 4# X$WA
E4K" ?5^ Z4$ $K$ $:5$_? E"#@K$5?A
#$95$ 9? :4? D?>p?N !" #"#$95"
>K4:52?3" ?E>#?] " ’88 ?>93? 9<"
3$5$E5"4 " X$WE4K" 2$?K>Y?93" ? #4A
3?9;? 3$ D?>p? $ @"3$ 9<" 3$5$E5‘AK"
?5^ Z4$ :$_? 5?23$ @?2? Z4$ " ’88
5"#$ Z4?KZ4$2 #$3>3?N 1"3$ 9<"
b?X$2 3>:5e9E>? :4D>E>$95$ @?2? " X$WA
E4K" 52"E?93" 3$ D?>p?:N +:5$_? :$#A
@2$ ?5$95" $ @2"95" @?2? ?E>"9?2 ":
D2$>":] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
+,-'   
V$WE4K": $:52$>5":] E"#" #"5"E>A
EK$5?:] 52?D$a?93" @2hp>#": ?": K>#>A
5$: 3? D?>p?] "4 :$ 3$:K"E?93" K?5$A
2?K#$95$ 9$::?: 2$a>\$:] 9<" :<" 3$A
5$E5?3": ?5^ Z4$ $:5$_?# E"#@K$5?A
#$95$ 3$952" 3? D?>p?N 1"3$ 9<" b?A
X$2 3>:5e9E>? :4D>E>$95$ ?5^ " X$WE4K"
? D2$95$ @?2? $::$: X$WE4K":N
- ’88 9<" 2$?a$ ? X$WE4K": @?A
2?3":] ? 9<" :$2 Z4$ " #$:#" :$_?
3$5$E5?3" ?>93? $# #"X>#$95"N 1"2
$p$#@K"] " ’88 9<" 5"#?2‘ Z4?KA
Z4$2 #$3>3? $# :>54?;\$: $# Z4$
" X$WE4K" :$a4>3" :?>2 3$ :4? D?>p?
$ " X$WE4K" g D2$95$ $:5>X$2 9$K? @?A
2?3" "4 @2$:5$: ? @?2?2N +:5$_? :$#A
@2$ ?5$95" $ @2"95" @?2? ?E>"9?2 ":
D2$>":] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
!!   
- E"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ ^ 3$:?5>A
X?3"] :$# Z4$ ? X$K"E>3?3$ #$#"A
2>Y?3? :$ ?@?a4$] :"J ?: :$a4>95$:
E"93>;\$:%
 - @$3?K 3" D2$>" ^ @2$::>"9?3"
 - J"5<" ! ^ @2$::>"9?3"
 - :>:5$#? 3": D2$>": ’B, $952?
$# ?;<"
 ’ ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" ^ #"X>3?
@?2? Z4?KZ4$2 @":>;<" 3>D$2$95$
3? 
 - :>:5$#? +,8 ^ ?5>X?3"
 - D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" ^ ?E>A
"9?3"
 - E>95" 3$ :$a42?9;? 3" E"9A
345"2 ^ 3$:?D>X$K?3" $# J?>p?:
X$K"E>3?3$:
 ’ @"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? ^
?J$25? $# J?>p?: X$K"E>3?3$:
 - :>:5$#? .,8 $952? $# ?;<"
 - E"9345"2 3$:K>a? 5"5?K#$95$ "
:>:5$#? +,8
- :>:5$#? ^ ?5>X?3" $ ? X$K"E>3?3$
#$#"2>Y?3? ^ ?@?a?3? 9": :$a4>95$:
E?:":%
 12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" 9" X"A
K?95$
 12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" 9" X"A
K?95$
 - E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" ^ E"K"A
E?3" 9? @":>;<"  @ 
 - #"3" 3$ 52?;<" I¤* )-¤ ^ !$:5$ #"3" 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ D>p?] "
:>:5$#? 9<" 2$?a>2‘ ? "452": X$WE4K":
:$K$E>"9?3"
g :4? D2$95$N *? #$:#? D"2#?] 9$A
9b4# ?K$25? "4 ?;<" 2$K?E>"9?3? g
" ! N! @2"p>#>3?3$ 3$ 4# X$WE4K" g D2$95$
$952?2‘ $# ?;<"] #$:#" $# 3>:A
+# ?3>;<" ?" E"952"K$ ?3?@5?5>X"
5e9E>?: #4>5" E425?:N +:5$_? :$#@2$
3$ X$K"E>3?3$] 4# #"3" 3$ E"952"K$
3$ X$K"E>3?3$ D>p? $:5‘ 3>:@"9WX$K
?5$95" ?" #"3" 3$ E"952"K$ 3$ X$K"A
E>3?3$ :$K$E>"9?3"N
E"# " X$WE4K" $# X$K"E>3?3$: ?E>#?
3$ HG i#obN
12"E$3$2 E"9D"2#$ ?: "2>$95?;\$:
+:5$ #"3" "@$2? 3$ #?9$>2? :$#$A @?2? " ’88 Z4?95" ?": ?_4:5$: $
Kb?95$ ?" E"952"K$ ?3?@5?5>X"] :$# ?K5$2?;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$N
Z4?KZ4$2 4:" 3?: D49E>"9?K>3?3$: 3$
3$5$E;<" 3$ X$WE4K": g D2$95$] 3$
?K$25?: $ ?4pWK>" 3$ D2$9?a$# $ 3$
?_4:5$: ?45"#‘5>E": 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ $ &
3$ 3>:5e9E>?N
1?2? #43?2 " #"3" 3$ E"952"K$
3$ X$K"E>3?3$] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
@?2? 3$:K>a?2 ": :>:5$#?: ?5>X": $]
$# :$a4>3?] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
@?2? ?5>X?2 " E"952"K$ $K$52v9>E" 3$
X$K"E>3?3$ D>p?N
1$&!
    
 "  
 " /  
 (  1 
'-
  67    
- :>:5$#? 4:? 4#? Ee#$2? "2>$9A
5?3? @?2? ? D2$95$ 9" :$95>3" 3$ #?2A
Eb? @?2?] ? X$K"E>3?3$: 3$ FG ? 7~G
i#ob] 3$5$E5?2 #?2E?;\$: 3$ D?>p?:
3$ 2"3?a$# $ #"9>5"2?2 ? @":>;<"
3" X$WE4K" $# 2$K?;<" ? $K?:N
- :>:5$#? $#>5$ 4# ?K$25? E?:" "
X$WE4K" :$_? 3>2$E>"9?3" @?2? ": K>A
#>5$: 3? D?>p? 3$ #?9$>2? 9<" >95$9A
E>"9?KN -: ?K$25?: @"3$# :$2 X>:4?K
"4 5‘5>K q@?2? Z4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$A
5$E5? ?: 34?: D?>p?:rN

1?2? D49E>"9?#$95" E"22$5" 3" :>:A
5$#?] X$2>D>E?2 ? E"#@?5>J>K>3?3$ 3"
3>:@":>5>X" E"# ? X>? 3$ 52‘D$a" ? :$2
45>K>Y?3?N
1$&"
w4?93" ?@$9?: 4#? #?2E?;<" 3$
D?>p? ^ 3$5$E5?3? $# 4# 3": K?3": 3"
X$WE4K"] :"#$95$ " ?K$25? X>:4?K 9"
3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": ^
$#>5>3" @?2? " E"9345"2 $# E?:" 3$
#43?9;? 3$ D?>p? 9<" >95$9E>"9?KN

w4?93" ?: E"93>;\$: 3$ "@$2?A
;<" D"2$# ?5$93>3?:] " :>:5$#? D?2‘ " (#? #$9:?a$# 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>A
#"9>5"2?#$95" 3?: #<": 3" E"934A 9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": >93>E?2‘ Z4$ "
5"2 $ $#>5>2‘ 4# ?K$25? :"9"2" :$ $K?: :>:5$#? D"> ?5>X?3"%
9<" $:5>X$2$# @":>E>"9?3?: 9" X"A
K?95$N - :>:5$#? E?9E$K?2‘ :4? ?54?A
;<" E?:" " E"9345"2 9<" 2$5"29$ E"#
:4?: #<": ?" X"K?95$N
! *67   *67    
 *   3    3 ( 
5 /    -  R 5
F & R0
- $:5?3" 3" :>:5$#? ^ :$#@2$ ?5>A
X?3" ?@h: E?3? E>EK" 3? Eb?X$ 3$ >aA
9>;<"N
1?2? ?5>X?2 "4 3$:?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?]
J?:5? @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"  E"22$:A
@"93$95$%
"!"  !!
 "!  ! 
!!!"  !N! 
!"
- :>:5$#? >93>E?2‘ ?: E"93>;\$:
?54?>: 3?: D?>p?: 3$ 2"3?a$# 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
  'F  C:T '5  
.- 
w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"% ?:
K>9b?: :$ ?@2$:$95?# 9? E"2 E>9Y?
Z4?93" ?#J?: ?: D?>p?: K>#W52"D$: 3?
D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$# 9<" @43$2?# :$2
3$5$E5?3?: $ " >93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$:$95?
$# J2?9E" :hK>3"N
+ ' .-      3 (
 .-  ,
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"]
" >93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$:$95? 9?
E"2 J2?9E" :hK>3" Z4?93"
?@$9?: ? D?>p? 3? $:Z4$23?
D"> 3$5$E5?3? $ " :>:5$#? $:5‘
@2"95" @?2? D"29$E$2 ?K$25?:
X>:4?>: 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$
>9:524#$95": :$ 4#? :?W3? 3$
D?>p? 9<" >95$9E>"9?K "E"22$2N
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$ ?
D?>p? :$ ?@2"p>#? $ :$ $:5‘ $#
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?]
? K>9b? $:@$::? 3? $:Z4$23? @$2A
#?9$E$ $# J2?9E" :hK>3" $ "
>93>E?3"2 #43? 3$ J2?9E" :hK>3"
@?2? ?#?2$K" >95$2#>5$95$N

- :>:5$#? "@$2? E"# " E"#@"2A
5?#$95" :>#>K?2 @?2? 4#? :?W3? @$K?
D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5? Z4?93" ?@$9?: ? #?2A
E?;<" 3$ D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5? D"2 3$5$EA
5?3?N
+ ' .-    4 
3 ( ,
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"] ?:
K>9b?: 3?: D?>p?: #43?# 3$ E>9Y?
@?2? J2?9E" @?2? >93>E?2 Z4$ ?#A
J?: ?: #?2E?;\$: 3$ D?>p?: D"2?#
3$5$E5?3?:N - >93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$A
:$95? 9? E"2 X$23$ :hK>3" Z4?93"
?#J?: ?: D?>p?: D"2?# 3$5$E5?3?:
$ " :>:5$#? $:5‘ t?2#?3"t @?2?
D"29$E$2 ?K$25?: X>:4?>: 9" 3>:A &
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":
$ 4# ?K$25? 5‘5>K 9" X"K?95$ :$
4#? :?W3? 3$ D?>p? 9<" >95$9E>"A
9?K "E"22$2N
1$&%
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?]
?: K>9b?: $:@$::? $ $:52$>5? 3? $:A
Z4$23? @?::?# ? :$ ?@2$:$95?2
$# J2?9E" :hK>3" $ " >93>E?3"2
#43? 3$ X$23$ :hK>3" @?2? ?#?A
2$K" :hK>3"N !$:5$ #"#$95" 4#
5"2Z4$ ^ ?@K>E?3" ?" X"K?95$ 9"
:$95>3" "@":5" 3" K>#>5$ 3? D?>p?N
 1"2 $p$#@K"% ,$ ?@2"p>#?93"A
:$ 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3? D?>p? "
X"K?95$ X>2?2‘ @?2? ? 3>2$>5?N
1$&&
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$ ?
D?>p? :$ ?@2"p>#? $ :$ $:5‘ $#
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?] ?
K>9b? $:@$::? 3? $:Z4$23? @>:E?
3$ J2?9E" @?2? E>9Y?] ? K>9b? $:A
52$>5? 3? $:Z4$23? @$2#?9$E$ $#
J2?9E" :hK>3" $ " >93>E?3"2 #43?
3$ ?#?2$K" :hK>3" @?2? ?#?2$K"
>95$2#>5$95$N !$:5$ #"#$95" 4#
5"2Z4$ ^ ?@K>E?3" ?" X"K?95$ 9"
:$95>3" "@":5" 3" K>#>5$ 3? D?>p?N
 1"2 $p$#@K"% ,$ ?@2"p>#?93"A
:$ 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3? D?>p? "
X"K?95$ X>2?2‘ @?2? ? 3>2$>5?N

- :>:5$#? "@$2? E"# " E"#@"2A
5?#$95" :>#>K?2 @?2? 4#? :?W3? @$K?
D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5?N
  'F  U:2 - 12:2 '5
  .- 
w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"% ?:
K>9b?: :$ ?@2$:$95?# 9? E"2 E>9Y?
Z4?93" ?#J?: ?: D?>p?: K>#W52"D$: 3?
D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$# 9<" @43$2?# :$2
3$5$E5?3?: $ " >93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$:$95?
$# J2?9E" :hK>3"N

+ ' .-      3 (
 .-  ,
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"] "
>93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$:$95? 9? E"2
J2?9E" :hK>3" Z4?93" ?@$9?: ?
#?2E?;<" 3$ D?>p? 3? $:Z4$23?
D"> 3$5$E5?3? $ " :>:5$#? $:5‘
@2"95" @?2? D"29$E$2 ?K$25?:
X>:4?>: 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$
>9:524#$95": :$ 4#? :?W3? 3$
D?>p? 9<" >95$9E>"9?K "E"22$2N
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$ ?
D?>p? :$ ?@2"p>#? $ :$ $:5‘ $#
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?] ?
K>9b? $:@$::? 3? $:Z4$23? @>:E?
$# ?#?2$K"] ? K>9b? $:52$>5? @$2A
#?9$E$ $# ?#?2$K" :hK>3" $ "
>93>E?3"2 #43? 3$ J2?9E" :hK>3"
@?2? ?#?2$K" >95$2#>5$95$N

- :>:5$#? "@$2? E"# " E"#@"2A
5?#$95" :>#>K?2 @?2? 4#? :?W3? @$K?
D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5? Z4?93" ?@$9?: ? #?2A
E?;<" 3$ D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5? D"2 3$5$EA
5?3?N
+ ' .-    4 
3 ( ,
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X"] ?:
K>9b?: 3?: D?>p?: #43?# 3$ E>9Y?
@?2? J2?9E" @?2? >93>E?2 Z4$ ?#A
J?: ?: #?2E?;\$: 3$ D?>p?: D"2?#
3$5$E5?3?:N - >93>E?3"2 :$ ?@2$A
:$95? 9? E"2 X$23$ :hK>3" Z4?93"
?#J?: ?: D?>p?: D"2?# 3$5$E5?3?:
$ " :>:5$#? $:5‘ t?2#?3"t @?2?
D"29$E$2 ?K$25?: X>:4?>: 9" 3>:A
@K?y 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":
$ 4# ?K$25? 5‘5>K 9" X"K?95$ :$
4#? :?W3? 3$ D?>p? 9<" >95$9E>"A
9?K "E"22$2N
 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?]
?: K>9b?: $:@$::? $ $:52$>5? 3? $:A
Z4$23? @?::?# ? :$ ?@2$:$95?2
$# ?#?2$K" :hK>3" $ " >93>E?3"2
#43? 3$ X$23$ :hK>3" @?2? ?#?A
2$K" :hK>3"N !$:5$ #"#$95" 4# &
5"2Z4$ ^ ?@K>E?3" ?" X"K?95$ 9"
:$95>3" "@":5" 3" K>#>5$ 3? D?>p?N
 1"2 $p$#@K"% ,$ ?@2"p>#?93"A
:$ 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3? D?>p? "
X"K?95$ X>2?2‘ @?2? ? 3>2$>5?N
1$&’

 w4?93" " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5? Z4$ ?
D?>p? :$ ?@2"p>#? $ :$ $:5‘ $#
4#? :>54?;<" 3$ :?W3? 3$ D?>p?] ?
K>9b? $:@$::? 3? $:Z4$23? @>:E?
$# ?#?2$K"] ? K>9b? $:52$>5? 3?
$:Z4$23? @$2#?9$E$ $# ?#?2$K"
:hK>3" $ " >93>E?3"2 #43? 3$
?#?2$K" :hK>3" @?2? ?#?2$K" >9A
5$2#>5$95$N !$:5$ #"#$95" 4#
5"2Z4$ ^ ?@K>E?3" ?" X"K?95$ 9"
:$95>3" "@":5" 3" K>#>5$ 3? D?>p?N
 1"2 $p$#@K"% ,$ ?@2"p>#?93"A
:$ 3" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3? D?>p? "
X"K?95$ X>2?2‘ @?2? ? 3>2$>5?N
1$&*

- :>:5$#? "@$2? E"# " E"#@"2A
5?#$95" :>#>K?2 @?2? 4#? :?W3? @$K?
D?>p? 3? 3>2$>5?N
!'        
- :>:5$#? @"::4> E"9D>a42?;\$:
@?2? ?_4:5?2 ? >95$9:>3?3$ 3" 5"2Z4$
3" ?K$25? 5‘5>K] ? :$9:>J>K>3?3$ 3?
Y"9? 3$ ?5>X?;<" 3": ?K$25?: $ ?
D"2;? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? :$2 ?@K>E?3?
?" X"K?95$] @?2? Z4$ $:5$: "E"22?#
#?>: E$3" "4 #?>: 5?23$N .?>: E"9D>A
a42?;\$: @"3$# :$2 D$>5?: ?52?X^: 3"
#$94 3" E"#@45?3"2 3$ J"23" 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

- 4:" 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"
?95$: 3?: #?9"J2?: 3$ #43?9;? 3$
D?>p? :4@2>#$ ": ?K$25?: E"22$:@"9A
3$95$:N

- :>:5$#? 9<" ?@K>E? 9$9b4# 5"2A
Z4$ 9" X"K?95$ Z4?93" Z4?KZ4$2 :>:A
5$#? 3$ :$a42?9;? $952? $# ?54?;<"
q’B,] .8] +,8] P8¤] $5ENrN

w4?93" " :>:5$#? )?9$ ,$9:$ D"2
b?J>K>5?3"] " :>:5$#? 3$ #"9>5"2?A
#$95" 3$ @"95" E$a" qB,&r 5?#J^#
:$2‘ b?J>K>5?3" ?45"#?5>E?#$95$N
   
     
  
  (8 9
:4 44  ,
4 ;  - ( 
)*+,-
- #"9>5"2 3$ :"9"K[9E>? "4 3>:52?A
;<" 3" #"5"2>:5? $#>5$ ?K$25?: @?2? "
E"9345"2 Z4?93" >3$95>D>E? Z4$ " $K$
$:5‘ ?@2$:$95?93" :>9?>: 3$ @$23? 3$
E"9E$952?;<"] :"9"K[9E>? "4 #$:#"
3"2#>93" ?" X"K?95$N
- :>:5$#? >3$95>D>E? ": @2>#$>2":
:>9?>: 3$ :"9"K[9E>? "4 3>:52?;<" $
$#>5$ ": ?K$25?: @?2? Z4$ " #"5"2>:5?
D>Z4$ E>$95$ 3$::? :>54?;<" 3$ 2>:E"N
! *67   *67

- :>:5$#? ^ @2$3$D>9>3" E"#" -!
? E?3? E>EK" 3? Eb?X$ 3$ >a9>;<"N
- :>:5$#? @"3$ :$2 ?5>X?3" $ 3$:?A
5>X?3" ?52?X^: 3" (E"99$E5] :$K$E>"A
9?93" " :$a4>95$ 9? "23$#%
7N ’::>:5[9E>? ?" &"5"2>:5?
LN *$5$E;<" 3$ #"5"2>:5?
:"9"K$95"

- :>:5$#? 9<" $p>#$ " E"9345"2 3?
2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3$ E"934Y>2 " X$WA
E4K"N ,$ :$95>2 :"9"K[9E>? "4 E?9:?;"
?" 3>2>a>2] @?2$ E"# :$a42?9;? @?2?
D?Y$2 4#? @?4:?] :$# $:@$2?2 @$K":
?X>:": 3" :>:5$#?N ,h X"K5$ @?2? ?
$:52?3? Z4?93" $:5>X$2 $# E"93>;\$:
DW:>E?: $ #$95?>: ?3$Z4?3?: @?2? $X>A
5?2 E"K"E?2 ? :> #$:#" $ ? "452": #"A
5"2>:5?: $# @$2>a"N

- :>:5$#? #"9>5"2? ?Ka49: @?2eA
#$52": 3$ E"#@"25?#$95" 3" E"9A
345"2] ?X?K>?93" E?:" :$ ?K5$2$# 3$
D"2#? >9$:@$2?3? "4 xD"2? 3" @?A
32<"zN - :>:5$#? (5>K>Y? 3?3": 3"
#"5"2>:5? $ 3" X$WE4K" @?2? E?KE4K?2
Z4?93" " #"5"2>:5? $:5‘ :$ :$95>93"
:"9"K$95"N ,$ " :>:5$#? 3$5$E5?2 Z4$
" #"5"2>:5? $:5‘ :"9"K$95"] 4# :>9?K
:"9"2" :$2‘ "4X>3" $ :$2‘ $p>J>3" 9"
3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N
,$ " E"9345"2 ?E$>5?2 ? :4a$:5<" D"2A
9$E>3? @$K" :>:5$#?] @2$::>"9?93" "
J"5<" -{ 9? ?K?X?9E? #4K5>D49;\$:]
? #$9:?a$# 3$:?@?2$E$2‘ 3" X>:"2N
8?:" " #"5"2>:5? 9<" 2$E"9b$;?
" ?X>:" D"29$E>3" @$K" :>:5$#?] ?
#$9:?a$# @$2#?9$E$2‘ 9? 5$K? @"2
7 #>945"N

!" E?:" 3$ D?Kb? 3" :>:5$#?] ? K4YA
$:@>? $:@$EWD>E? ?@?2$E$2‘ 9" Z4?32" &
3$ >9:524#$95": _495" E"# 4#? #$9A
:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? 9" 3>:@K?yN
,$ " ’B, $:5>X$2 ?5>X?3"] x’B,
’.=V’*-t :$2‘ $p>J>3" 9" K4a?2 3"
:W#J"K" 3" :>:5$#? $ @$2#?9$E$2‘
?5>X" ?5^ Z4$ " ’B, :$_? 3$:?5>X?3"N
1$&+
- ,    
- :>:5$#? #"9>5"2? ?Ka49: @?2eA
#$52": 3$ E"#@"25?#$95" 3" E"9A
345"2] ?X?K>?93" E?:" :$ ?K5$2$# 3$
D"2#? >9$:@$2?3? "4 xD"2? 3" @?A
32<"zN

’ 5$E9"K"a>? 3" #"9>5"2 3$ :"9"A
K[9E>? "4 3>:52?;<" 3" #"5"2>:5? D49A
E>"9? :"#$95$ 3$952" 3": K>#>5$: 3"
:>:5$#?N - #?>"2 E"9D"25" @2"@"2E>A
"9?3" @$K" :>:5$#? 9<" 3$X$ #"5>X?2
? 4#? E"934;<" @$2>a":?N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: :$a4>95$: @2$:E2>A
;\$:%
 +# E"934;\$: #?>: K"9a?:] D?Y$2
@?2?3?: 2$a4K?2$: $ #?>: K"9a?:
@?2? 3$:E?9:"N
 ’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3$ E"934Y>2
E"# :$a42?9;? ^ :$#@2$ 3" E"9A
345"2N
 - #"9>5"2 3$ :"9"K[9E>? "4 3>:A
52?;<" 3" #"5"2>:5? 9<" 2$E"A
1$&,
9b$E$ " E?9:?;" 3" E"9345"2 $#
5"3?: ?: E>2E49:5e9E>?:N
 ’5$95?2 @?2? ?: >93>E?;\$: 3" 3>:A
@K?y $ :$a4>2 :$#@2$ ?: >9:524;\$:
@2$:E2>5?: 9" #?94?KN
     
   
"! !E / .- 0
- X$WE4K" @"3$ $:5?2 $Z4>@?3"
E"# 4# :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? 3$ $:A
5?E>"9?#$95" Z4$] E"9D"2#$ ? X$2A
:<"] "D$2$E$ :>9?K>Y?;\$: X>:4?>: $ :"A
9"2?: 3$ ?E"23" E"# ? @2"p>#>3?3$
3$ "J:5‘E4K": ?@$9?: 9? 52?:$>2? "4
9? 52?:$>2? $ 9? 3>?95$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
- :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ ^ ?5>X?3"
Z4?93" ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ 3" X$WE4K"
^ $9a?5?3? q$# X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?:
E"# :$9:"2$: 9? 3>?95$>2?] " :>:5$#?
5?#J^# :$ ?5>X?2‘ E"# " Ee#J>"
9? @":>;<"  ] E"# D49E>"9?#$95"
$Z4>X?K$95$ @?2? "J:5‘E4K": g D2$95$
3" X$WE4K"rN
- :>:5$#? E"95>94?2‘ ?5>X" ?5^ Z4$
? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 4K52?@?::$ 77
i#obN w4?93" >::" "E"22$] " :>:5$#?
^ 3$:?5>X?3" $ 4# ?X>:" ^ $p>J>3"
9" 3>:@K?y] >93>E?93" Z4$ " X$WE4K"
$:5‘ #4>5" 2‘@>3"N - :>:5$#? X"K5?2‘
?" $:5?3" ?5>X" Z4?93" ? X$K"E>3?3$
3$E?>2 @?2? 4# X?K"2 3$ ?@2"p>#?3?A
#$95$ M i#obN
!#!
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K" $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $ @"2 "452?: #?9"J2?:] @"A
5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?:] ^ :$#@2$ 3"
E"9345"2N
’" $D$54?2 $:5?: #?9"J2?:]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ :$#@2$ 3$ Z4$ 9<" $:A
5<" @2$:$95$: @$::"?: q$:@$E>?K#$95$
E2>?9;?:r 9$# ?9>#?>: ?" K"9a" 3?
52?_$5h2>? Z4$ :$ @2$5$93$ @$2E"22$2N
-: :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
E"9:5>54$# 4#? ?_43? @?2? " E"934A
5"2] $#J"2? $:5$ 949E? 3$X? 2$34Y>2
? :4? ?5$9;<" 342?95$ #?9"J2?:
@"5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?:] #$:#" :$
$p$E45?3?: ? J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$N

!#!
1?2? @$2#>5>2 " D49E>"9?#$95" E"2A
2$5" 3" :>:5$#?] ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K Z4$
": :$9:"2$: $:5$_?# :$#@2$ K>#@": 3$
K?#?] :4_$>2?] 9$X$ "4 a$K"N *42?95$
? K>#@$Y? 3": :$9:"2$:] 5$2 " #‘p>#"
E4>3?3" @?2? 9<" ": 2>:E?2 "4 3?9>A
D>E?2d $X>5?2 ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @?9": :$A
E":] ‘:@$2": "4 342":N -: :$9:"2$:
3$X$# :$2 K?X?3": E"# ‘a4?] $X$9A
54?K#$95$ E"# ? ?3>;<" 3$ :b?#@""
@?2? E?22"N
!?: :>54?;\$: 3$ K?X?a$# Z4$ 45>A
K>Y?# $Z4>@?#$95": E"# _?5" 3$ X?A
@"2 "4 3$ ?K5? @2$::<"] K?X?2 2?@>3?A
#$95$ ": :$9:"2$: #?95$93" " J>E"
@?2? ?K^# 3": 7G E# 3$ 3>:5e9E>?N
!#!
f 3$ $p52$#? >#@"25e9E>? X$2>D>E?2
? E"22$5? D>p?;<" 3? @K?E? 3>?95$>2?
3" X$WE4K" 3$ #?9$>2? ? a?2?95>2 Z4$
? #$:#? $:5$_? J$# ?E"@K?3?] @K?9?
$ D>p?3? E"# ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ Z4?52"
@?2?D4:":N
1K?E?: >9:5?K?3?: 3$ #?9$>2? >9E"2A
2$5?] $#@$9?3?: "4 3?9>D>E?3?:] @"A
3$# D?Y$2 E"# Z4$ " :>:5$#? 3$ ?:A
:>:5[9E>? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" q,>:5$#?
1?2i:$9:$r a$2$ ?X>:": 3$ "J:5‘E4K":
3$ D"2#? >9E"22$5? "4 $22v9$?N
!#!
1?2? $X$954?>: >95$2X$9;\$: 9":
:$9:"2$: K"E?K>Y?3": 9" @?2?A
Eb"Z4$] 3>2>a>2A:$ $pEK4:>X?#$95$ g
  ! = ,  > N
=95$2X$9;\$: 9" @?2?AEb"Z4$ $D$A
54?3?: 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5" @"3$#] 3$
D?5"] E"#@2"#$5$2 " D49E>"9?#$95"
3": :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
 ' K67 ,b ,
+9a?5?93" ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ $ 9"
E?:" 3$ @2$:$9;? 3$ 4# "J:5‘E4K"
52?:$>2"] ^ ?5>X?3? 4#? :>9?K>Y?;<"
?Eu:5>E? Z4$ X?2>? E"# ? 3>:5e9E>?
3" "J:5‘E4K" ?" @?2?AEb"Z4$N
P2$Z4[9E>? 3? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:A
5>E?%
 ’4#$95? E"# ? 3>#>94>;<" 3?
3>:5e9E>? $952$ X$WE4K" $ "J:5‘A
E4K"N
 ."29?A:$ E"95W94" Z4?93" ? 3>:A
5e9E>? Z4$ :$@?2? " X$WE4K" 3"
"J:5‘E4K" ^ >9D$2>"2 ? E$2E? 3$
HG E# $ @?2? >#$3>?5?#$95$ :$ ?
3>:5e9E>? 3" "J:5‘E4K" ?4#$95?2N
 1$2#?9$E$ E"9:5?95$ :$ ? 3>:5e9A
E>? $952$ X$WE4K" $ " "J:5‘E4K"
@$2#?9$E$2 >9?K5$2?3?N ,$ $:5?
:>54?;<" :$ X$2>D>E?2 @?2? ": :$9A
:"2$: K?5$2?>:] " :>9?K ^ >95$22"#A
@>3" ?@h: ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ H :$A
a493": @?2? $X>5?2] @"2 $p$#@K"]
:>9?K>Y?;\$: $# E?:" 3$ #?9"J2?
&
_495" ? @?2$3$: "4 #42":N
w4?93" " :>:5$#? $#>5$ 4#? :>A
9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E?] " X"K4#$ 3" :>:A
5$#? (E"99$E5] :$ ?E>"9?3"] ^ ?45"A
#?5>E?#$95$ 2$34Y>3" @$K" :>:5$#?
1?2i,$9:$N
1$&-
 ' K67    'F +# a$2?K] " X$WE4K" $:5‘ #?>: @2hA    ,       
p>#" 3" "J:5‘E4K" Z4?93" 9" 3>:A
’: :>9?K>Y?;\$: 2$K?5>X?: ?" :>:A
@K?y ^ X>:4?K>Y?3" 4# u9>E" ?2E" >9A
5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ :<" X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9"
5$2#>5$95$ $ ? :>9?K>Y?;<" ?Eu:5>E? :$
3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":
5"29?2 E"95W94?N
?@$9?: :$ ? 2$:@$E5>X? D49;<" 5>X$2
:>3" :$K$E>"9?3? 9" #$94 3" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5N   

- :>:5$#? ?::>9?K? ? @2$:$9;? 3$ -: :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"] 3$

4# "J:5‘E4K" X>:4?K>Y?93" 4# u9>E"
?2E" 94#? 3?: ‘2$?: @"::WX$>:] E"#
J?:$ 9? 3>:5e9E>? 3" "J_$5" $ 9? @"A
:>;<" $# 2$K?;<" ?" X$WE4K"N ,$ "
"J:5‘E4K" D"2 3$5$E5?3" $# 4#? ‘2$?
E$952?K 9? 52?:$>2? "4 9? 3>?95$>2?
q:$ $Z4>@?3"r 3" X$WE4K"] 9" 3>:@K?y
:$2‘ X>:4?K>Y?3"] E"# ? ?@2"p>#?;<"
3" "J:5‘E4K"] 4# ?2E" :hK>3" :$ #"A
X$93" $# 3>2$;<" ?" X$WE4K" g #$A
3>3? $# Z4$ " X$WE4K" :$ ?@2"p>#?
3" "J:5‘E4K"N
,$ " "J:5‘E4K" D"2 3$5$E5?3" $#
‘2$?: K?5$2?>: $:Z4$23? $o"4 3>2$>5?]
9? 3>?95$>2? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r "4 9? 52?A
:$>2?] 9" 3>:@K?y :$2‘] @"2 :4? X$Y]
X>:4?K>Y?3" 4# ?2E" >95$2#>5$95$ 9?
Y"9? E"22$:@"93$95$ :$ #"X$93" $#
3>2$;<" ?" X$WE4K" g #$3>3? $# Z4$
" X$WE4K" :$ ?@2"p>#?N
?E"23" E"# ? X$2:<"] $:5<" :>54?3":
9" @?2?AEb"Z4$ 52?:$>2" "4 $# ?#A ,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" u9>E"o?2E" :hK>3"
J": ": @?2?AEb"Z4$:N +K$: 5[# ? D49A
;<" 3$ 3$5$E5?2 ? @2$:$9;? 3$ $X$9A
54?>: "J:5‘E4K": Z4$ :$ $9E"952$#
@2hp>#" 3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? "4 3>?9A
5$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
-: :$9:"2$: ?X>:?# " E"9345"2
3? @2$:$9;? 3$ "J:5‘E4K":] ?52?X^:
3$ 4# :>9?K :"9"2" >95$2#>5$95$ $]
Z4?93" @2$:$95$:] 5?#J^# E"# :>A
9?K>Y?;\$: X>:4?>: 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?A ,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" K$95"o?2E" :hK>3"
32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

1$’.
 ,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" K$95"o?2E" :hK>3"    ,         
   
&?9"J2?: E"# ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ $9A
a2$9?3?%

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" K$95"o?2E" :hK>3"

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" 2‘@>3"o?2E" >95$2#>A

5$95$

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" u9>E"o?2E" :hK>3"

&
,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" 2‘@>3"o?2E" >95$2#>A
5$95$

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" E"95W94"o?2E" >95$2A

#>5$95$
,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" K$95"o?2E" :hK>3"

1$’!
 ,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" 2‘@>3"o?2E" >95$2#>A
5$95$

,$# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"o?2E" >95$2#>A ,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" E"95W94"o?2E" >95$2A

5$95$ #>5$95$

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" E"95W94"o?2E" >95$2A  ] ,   ,67

#>5$95$
,$ ": :$9:"2$: 3$5$E5?# 3>X$2:":
"J:5‘E4K":] ^ K$X?3" $# E"9:>3$2?A
&?9"J2?: E"# " Ee#J>" 9? @":>A ;<" ?@$9?: ?Z4$K$ Z4$ :$ $9E"952?
;<"  % #?>: @2hp>#" 3" X$WE4K"N

,>9?K ?Eu:5>E" 2‘@>3"o?2E" >95$2#>A

5$95$

,$# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"o?2E" :hK>3"

1$’"
 ' K6H  !'    

!' 

*>:5e9E>? &?>"2 Z4$ LGG &$9"2 Z4$ HG

LGG 76G E# 76G 7LG E# 7LG 7GG E# 7GG F6 E# F6 HG E#
52?:$>2? E# E#
’2E": 
!$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$
$:Z4$23?
’2E": 
!$9b4# F« :hK>3" 6« :hK>3" I« :hK>3" H« >95$2#>5$95$ L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$
E$952"
’2E": 
!$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$
3>2$>5?
’K$25? :"9"2" ?4#$95? g #$3>3? Z4$ ": "J_$5": :$ ?@2"p>#?# 3" X$WE4K"N w4?93" "
’K$25? :"9"2" !$9b4# 8"95W94"
"J_$5" $:5‘ ? #$9": 3$ HG E#] " ?K$25? :$2‘ 4# 5"# E"95W94"N
V"K4#$ 3"
2‘3>" 2$34Y>3"
!<" !<" !<" !<" !<" !<" !<"
Z4?93" b‘
?K$25? :"9"2"

 ' K6H  !'      &

!' 

*>:5e9E>? D2"95?K &?>"2 Z4$ 7LG E# 7LG 7GG E# 7GG F6 E# F6 HG E# &$9"2 Z4$ HG E#

’2E":  $:Z4$23? !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$

’2E":  E$952" !$9b4# I« :hK>3" H« >95$2#>5$95$ L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$

’2E":  3>2$>5? !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# L« >95$2#>5$95$ 7« >95$2#>5$95$

1$’%
 !' 

’K$25? :"9"2"
?4#$95? g #$3>3?
’K$25? :"9"2" !$9b4# !$9b4# !$9b4# Z4$ ": "J_$5": :$ 8"95W94"
?@2"p>#?# 3"
X$WE4K"N
V"K4#$ 3" 2‘3>"
2$34Y>3" Z4?93" b‘ !<" !<" !<" !<" !<"
?K$25? :"9"2"

1$’&
!!@!!
1?2? ?5>X?2 $ 3$:?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?]
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" >93>E?3"  9?
>#?a$# ? :$a4>2N
’ @?::?a$# 3$ $:5?3" 3" :>:5$#?]
3$ ?5>X?3" @?2? 3$:?5>X?3" $ X>E$A
X$2:?] ^] 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 D"2#?] :$#A
@2$ ?E"#@?9b?3? 3? X>:4?K>Y?;<"
3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? X>:4?A
K>Y?3? 9" 3>:@K?y 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95":N
w4?93" " :>:5$#? $:5‘ ?5>X?3"] "
)+* :>54?3" 9" J"5<" $:5‘ ?@?a?3"N
’" E"952‘2>"] :$ " :>:5$#? $:5>X$2
3$:?5>X?3"] " )+* $:5‘ ?E$:" E"# K4Y
D>p?N - )+* ?E$93$A:$] 5?#J^# $#
E?:" 3$ ?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ N
12$::>"9?93" " J"5<" E"# " :>:A
5$#? $# ?X?2>?] " )+* K?#@$_? 34A
2?95$ E$2E? 3$ 6 :$a493":] 3$@">:
@$2#?9$E$ ?E$:" E"# K4Y D>p?N
’" @":>E>"9?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >aA
9>;<" $#  ] " :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$
#?95^# 9? #$#h2>? " uK5>#" $:A
5?3" q?5>X?3" "4 3$:?5>X?3"r @2$:$95$
Z4?93" "E"22$ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" #"5"2N

*$@">: 3$ 5[AK" 3$:?5>X?3"] "
:>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ @$2#?9$E$ 9$:5?
E"93>;<" ?5^ g @":5$2>"2 2$?5>X?;<"]
#$:#" $# E?:" 3$ @?::?a$# 3"
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 3$  @?2?
 @ $ 3$@">: 9"X?#$95$ @?2?
 N
8?:" $:5$_? E"22$5?#$95$ ?5>X?3"]
:>:5$#? ?5>X?A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$
Z4?93" :$ $9a?5? ? #?2Eb? ? 2^N
’" E"952‘2>"] " :>:5$#? 3$:?5>X?A:$
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ 3$:K"E?93" ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ #?2Eb?: @?2? 4#? @":>;<"
3>D$2$95$ 3? #?2Eb? ? 2^N
!J!  !"!!
+X$954?>: ?9"#?K>?: 3": :$9:"2$:
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" :<" ?::>9?K?3?:]
342?95$ " $9a?5$ 3? #?2Eb? ? 2^] @$K"
?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#J"K" 9" Z4?A
32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $ @$K? 2$:@$EA
5>X? #$9:?a$# X>:4?K>Y?3? 9" 3>:A
@K?y qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" x)4Y$:A
$:@>?: $ #$9:?a$9:z 9" E?@W54K" t8"A
9b$E$93" " @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":tr]
?::># E"#" @"2 4# :>9?K ?Eu:5>E"N
!" " %&
;

*42?95$ ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?#$95"] @2$:5?2 :$#@2$ ? #‘p>#? &
?5$9;<" ?": "J:5‘E4K": Z4$ :$ @":A
:?# $9E"952?2 @"2 E>#? "4 @"2 J?>p"
3" :$9:"2N -: "J_$5": E"K"E?3": ?
E425? 3>:5e9E>?] $# ?Ka4#?: E>2E49:A
5e9E>?: 9<" :<" 3$5$E5?3": @$K" :>:A
5$#? $ @"25?95" @"3$# 3?9>D>E?2 "
X$WE4K" "4 :$2 3?9>D>E?3":N
1$’’
 +p>:5$# ?Ka4#?: E"93>;\$: Z4$
@"3$# >9DK4$9E>?2 9" 3$:$#@$9b"
3" :>:5$#? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"%
 (#? :$9:>J>K>3?3$ 2$34Y>3? 3"
:$9:"2 $ 3>#>94>;<" 3" 3$:$#A
@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?4pWK>" ?"
$:5?E>"9?#$95" @"3$A:$ 3$X$2 g
@2$:$9;? 9? :4@$2DWE>$ 3" :$9:"2
3$ a$K"] 9$X$ "4 K?#?N
 - :$9:"2 3$5$E5? 4# "J_$5" 9<"
$p>:5$95$ qt>95$2D$2[9E>? 3$ $E"tr
@2"X"E?3" @"2 >95$2D$2[9E>?: 3$
E?2‘E5$2 #$Ee9>E"] @"2 $p$#@K"%
K?X?a$# 3" X$WE4K"] Eb4X? qE"9A
3>;\$: $p52$#?: 3$ X$95"r] a2?A
9>Y"N
 ’: :>9?K>Y?;\$: $9X>?3?:
@$K" :$9:"2 @"3$# :$2
>a4?K#$95$ ?K5$2?3?: @$K?
@2$:$9;? 9?: @2"p>#>3?3$: 3$
:>:5$#?: 3$ 4K52?::"9: q@"2
$pN D2$>": @9$4#‘5>E": 3$
X$WE4K": @$:?3": "4 #?25$K":
@9$4#‘5>E":rN
 - 3$:$#@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?4A
pWK>" ?" $:5?E>"9?#$95" @"3$ :$2
>a4?K#$95$ >9DK4$9E>?3" @$K? @"A
:>;<" 3": :$9:"2$:] @"2 $p$#A
1$’*
@K"] X?2>?93" ": ?K>9b?#$95":
q3$X>3" ?" 3$:a?:5$ 3": ?#"2A
5$E$3"2$:] :4:@$9:\$:r "4 :4J:A
5>54>;<" 3": @9$4:] $pE$::" 3$
E?2a? "4 #"3>D>E?;\$: E"# " "JA
_$5>X" 3$ 2$J?>p?2 " X$WE4K"
 - a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ 9? ?4:[9A
E>? 3$ 2$J"Z4$ @"3$2>? >95$2D$A
2>2 E"# " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95"
3": :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
’ >9:5?K?;<" 3" a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"A
Z4$ D>p" >#@$3$ ? @"::>J>K>3?3$
3$ 4# D49E>"9?#$95" E"22$5" 3":
:$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N !"
E?:" 3$ X$WE4K": $Z4>@?3": E"#
a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ $p52?WX$K] :$_?
"2>a>9?K "4 >9:5?K?3" ?@h: ? ?Z4>A
:>;<" 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? $X>5?2 4#
D49E>"9?#$95" >9E"22$5" 3": :$9A
:"2$:] ^ 2$E"#$93‘X$K 3$:$9a?5‘A
K" 3? 52?X$::? :$#@2$ Z4$ 9<" D"2
9$E$::‘2>" @?2? 2$J"E?2 4# ?52$A
K?3"N
 ’ @2$:$9;? 3$ ?3$:>X": 9": :$9A
:"2$:N 12$:5?2 ?5$9;<" @?2? 9<"
:"J2$@"2 Z4?KZ4$2 ?3$:>X" 9":
@2h@2>": :$9:"2$:N
"!  !!  _&
! !! / .- 0
!#!
1?2? Z4$ " :>:5$#? D49E>"9$ E"2A
2$5?#$95$] ": :$9:"2$: 3$X$# $:5?2
K>#@": $ :$# X$:5Wa>" 3$ K?#?] :4A
_$>2?] 9$X$ "4 a$K"N .$9b? E4>3?3"
@?2? 9<" 2>:E?2 "4 3?9>D>E?2 ": :$9A
:"2$: ?" K>#@‘AK":N +X>5$ 4:?2 @?9":
:$E":] ‘:@$2": "4 342":N
-: :$9:"2$: 3$X$# :$2 K?X?3":
E"# ‘a4? K>#@? $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"]
E"# :b?#@"" @?2? E?22":N !": :$2A
X>;": 3$ K?X?a$# Z4$ 45>K>Y?# X?@"2
"4 _?5": 3$ ?K5? @2$::<"] K>#@$ ": :$9A
:"2$: 2?@>3?#$95$] #?95$93" " J>E"
? @$K" #$9": 7G E# 3": :$9:"2$:N
!#!
w4?KZ4$2 2$@>9542? "4 2$5"Z4$: 9?
@>9542? 9? ‘2$? 3": :$9:"2$: 3" @?2?A
Eb"Z4$: 3$X$# :$2 2$?K>Y?3?: :"A
#$95$ 9?   ! = ,  > N
 ’ ?@K>E?;<" >9E"22$5? 3? @>9542?
@"3$ ?D$5?2 ? "@$2?;<" 3": :$9:"2$:
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N
’ D49;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K$25? 3$
3>:5e9E>? K?5$2?K ^ 3$5$E5?2 ? @2$:$9;?
3$ "J:5‘E4K": @2hp>#": g: K?5$2?>:
3" X$WE4K" ?52?X^: 3$ :$9:"2$: 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" K"E?K>Y?3": 9" @?2?A
Eb"Z4$ 3>?95$>2" $ 52?:$>2"N
- :>:5$#? ?X>:? " #"5"2>:5? E"#
4# :>9?K :"9"2" $] Z4?93" $Z4>@?3"]
E"# >93>E?;\$: X>:4?>: 9? 5$K? 3"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
!!@!!
- :>:5$#? E"9:$a4$ D49E>"9?2 :"A
#$95$ 3$@">: 3$ @$2E"22$2 4#? E425?
3>:5e9E>? $ :$ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K" $:5>X$2 $952$ G $ 77 i#obN
- :>:5$#? @"3$ :$2 ?5>A
X?3"o3$:?5>X?3" ?52?X^: 3"
2$:@$E5>X" #$94 9" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5 q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:]
E"9:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
"!? " !
’Ka4#?: E"93>;\$: @"3$# >9DK4A
$9E>?2 " 3$:$#@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
?K$25? 3$ 3>:5e9E>? K?5$2?K%
 (#? 2$34;<" 9? :$9:>J>K>3?3$
3" :$9:"2 $ 4#? E"9:$Z4$95$
3>#>94>;<" 9" 3$:$#@$9b" 3"
:>:5$#? ?::>:5$95$ 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" @"3$# ?E"95$E$2 @$K? @2$A
:$9;? 3$% a$K"] 9$X$] K?#? "4
E?#?3? $:@$::? 3$ 5>95? 9? :4A
@$2DWE>$ 3" :$9:"2N
 - :$9:"2 @"3$ 3$5$E5?2 4# "J:5‘A
E4K" >9$p>:5$95$ qt>95$2D$2[9E>? 3$
$E"tr] 3$X>3" ? >95$2D$2[9E>?: #$A
Ee9>E?:] E"#" 342?95$ K?X?a$#
3" X$WE4K"] 9" E?:" 3$ Eb4X?]
qX$95" D"25$r $ a2?9>Y"] @"2 $p$#A
@K"N
 -: :>9?>: $9X>?3": @$K" :$9:"2
5?#J^# @"3$# :$2 ?K5$2?3": @$K?
@2$:$9;? 3$ :>:5$#?: 4K52?::v9>A
E": qE"#" :>:5$#?: 3$ D2$>" @9$4A
#‘5>E" 3$ E?#>9b\$: "4 D42?3$>A &
2?: @9$4#‘5>E?:] @"2 $p$#@K"r
@2hp>#": ?" X$WE4K"N
 - 3$:$#@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? ?::>:A
5$95$ 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 5?#J^#
@"3$ :$2 >9DK4$9E>?3" @$K? @":>A
;<" 3": :$9:"2$:] ?Ka4#? ?K5$A
2?;<" 9? E"9D>a42?;<" 3" 52?_$5"
qE?4:?3? @$K" 3$:a?:5$ 3": ?#"2A
5$E$3"2$:] :4:@$9:<"r] 52"E? 3$
1$’+
 @9$4:] :"J2$E?22$a? 3" X$WE4K"
"4 "@$2?;\$: 3$ ?_4:5$ Z4$ 2$A
J?>p?# " X$WE4K"N
 ’ @2$:$9;? 3$ 4# a?9Eb" 3$ 2$A
J"Z4$ :$# " 2$:@$E5>X" 2$J"Z4$
5?#J^# @"3$ >95$2D$2>2 9" E"22$5"
D49E>"9?#$95" 3": :$9:"2$: 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N ’95$: 3$ 45>K>Y?2
" :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$] 2$E"#$93?A
:$ 2$#"X$2 3" X$WE4K" " E"9_495"
3? $:D$2? 3" a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"A
Z4$ $ ": 2$:@$E5>X": ?E$::h2>":
Z4?93" $:5$ uK5>#" 9<" ^ 45>A
K>Y?3" @?2? "@$2?;\$: 3$ 2$J"A
Z4$N - 3$:E4#@2>#$95" 3$::?
2$E"#$93?;<" @"3$ K$X?2 ? D$A
2>#$95": @$::"?>: "4 3?9": ?"
X$WE4K" "4 "J:5‘E4K":] 4#? X$Y
Z4$] Z4?93" " :>9?K :"9"2" E"9A
5W94" D"2 $#>5>3"] ? $:D$2? 3" a?9A
Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ $:5?2‘ #?>: @2hA
p>#? 3" "J:5‘E4K" Z4$ " @?2?A
Eb"Z4$ 52?:$>2"N ,$ Z4>:$2 3$>p?2
" a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ :$# " 2$A
J"Z4$] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K @2"E42?2
?   ! = ,  > @?2?
?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ ?54?K>Y?;<" 3"
:>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$] _‘ Z4$ ": :$9A
:"2$: E$952?>: @"3$# 3$5$E5?2 "
1$’,
a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ E"#" :$93"
4# "J:5‘E4K"N
 ’ @2$:$9;? 3$ $5>Z4$5?: 9": :$9A
:"2$: @"3$ @2$_43>E?2 " E"22$5"
D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N 1"2A
5?95"] 9<" E"K"Z4$ ?3$:>X": 9":
:$9:"2$:N
"! !E !
!E ! / .- 0
!#!
- $:5?E>"9?#$95" $ "452?: #?A
9"J2?: @"5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?: :<"
:$#@2$ 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" #"A
5"2>:5?N ’" $p$E45?2 $::?: "@$2?;\$:]
E$25>D>Z4$A:$ :$#@2$ Z4$ 9<" b‘ "4A
52?: @$::"?: q$:@$E>?K#$95$ E2>?9;?:r
"4 ?9>#?>: 9" K"E?K "93$ X"E[ Z4$2
$:5?E>"9?2N
-: :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" ?4A
p>K>?# " #"5"2>:5?] #?: $:5$ _?#?>:
3$X$ 3$:X>?2 :4? ?5$9;<" 342?95$
#?9"J2?: @"5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?:]
#$:#" ?: 2$?K>Y?3?: $# J?>p? X$K"A
E>3?3$N
!#!
.?95" ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a? 3$ $:A
5?E>"9?#$95" Z4?95" ?: 2$:@$E5>X?:
#?9"J2?: @?2? $:5?E>"9?2 3$X$# :$A
a4>2 ?: K$>: 3$ 52e9:>5" X>a$95$:N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$:
3$::$ #?94?KN
!#!
8?:" Z4$>2? @?2?2 " X"K?95$ E"# ?:
#<": 342?95$ 4#? #?9"J2?] ^ ?E"9A
:$Kb‘X$K @$a‘AK" D>2#$#$95$ @$K" ?2"
$p5$29"N
!<" 5$95$ #?95$2 ?: #<": 9" ?2"
>95$29" "4 :$a42?2 ": 2?>":N
!#!
- D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?
J?:$>?A:$ $# X‘2>": E"#@"9$95$:%
:$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 3>?9A
5$>2": $ 52?:$>2":] :$9:"2$: K?5$2?>:]
:>:5$#? 3$ 3>2$;<"] 2"3?:] :>:5$#?
3$ D2$>": $ @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":N
- #?4 D49E>"9?#$95" 3$ 4# 3$:A
5$: E"#@"9$95$: @"3$ ?D$5?2 " D49E>A
"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N
!#!
=95$2X$9;\$: 9? ‘2$? 3": :$9:"2$:
9" @?2?AEb"Z4$ 3$X$# :$2 2$?K>Y?3?:
:"#$95$ 9? C$3$ 3$ ’::>:5[9E>? c$$@N
’ ?@K>E?;<" >9E"22$5? 3? @>9542?
@"3$ ?D$5?2 " D49E>"9?#$95" 3": :$9A
:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"N
- :>:5$#? ?_43? " #"5"2>:5? ? ?X?A
K>?2 4#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 3$
?E"23" E"# ? K?2a42? 3" X$WE4K" $
a$2$9E>? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ " #"X>A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ 342?95$ ? #?9"J2?N
- :>:5$#? 45>K>Y? ": :$9:"2$: 3>?9A
5$>2":] 52?:$>2": $ K?5$2?>: 3" X$WE4K"
@?2? ?X?K>?2] E?KE4K?2 $ #"9>5"2?2 ?:
3>:5e9E>?: 3": "452": X$WE4K": $ 3$A
#?>: "J:5‘E4K": @2hp>#":N
!!@!!
1?2? ?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?] @2$::>"9$ ?
5$EK?  % " X>:"2 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:A
524#$95": $p>J>2‘ ?: >9:524;\$: 9$A
E$::‘2>?: @?2? ? 2$?K>Y?;<" 3? #?9"A
J2?N
’: K4Y$: 3$ )+* 5?#J^# :$ ?E$9A
3$# 9" E?:" 3$ 4#? D?Kb? 9" :>:5$#?
1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5N ,$ ? 5$A
EK? ^ @2$::>"9?3? 342?95$ 4#? ?X?2>?
9" :>:5$#?] " )+* @>:E? @"2 E$2E? 3$
6 :$a493": $ 3$@">: ^ 3$:?5>X?3?N
- :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 :$2‘ 3$:?5>X?3" ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ Z4?93" Z4?KZ4$2 4#? 3?: :$A
a4>95$: E"93>;\$: D"2 $9E"952?3?%
 &?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
E"#@K$5?d
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?E>#? 3$
HG i#ob 342?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#?
X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"d
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?E>#? 3$
| i#ob 342?95$ ? ?54?;<" 3" :>:A
5$#? 9? 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $952?3?
9? X?a?d
 V"K?95$ 5"E?3" 342?95$ ? ?54?A
;<" 3" :>:5$#? 9? 3>2$;<" @?2? ?
$952?3? 9? X?a?d
 B"5<" 3" 1?2i,$9:$
D2"95?Ko52?:$>2" @2$::>"9?3"d
 1"25? 3" #"5"2>:5? ?J$25?d
 .?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: ?J$25?d
 =95$2X$9;<" 3": :>:5$#?:
+,8o’B,d &
 - :>:5$#? @$2#>5>2‘ 4# #‘p>#"
3$ :$>: 52"E?: $952$ ?: @":>;\$: 
$  9? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"N ,$
? #?9"J2? 9<" @43$2 :$2 E"#A
@K$5?3? E"# $::?: :$>: 52"E?:] "
:>:5$#? E?9E$K?2‘ :4? ?54?;<" $ "
3>:@K?y 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":
>9:524>2‘ " E"9345"2 ? E"#@K$5?2
? #?9"J2? #?94?K#$95$N
1$’-
 - :>:5$#? ’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5
$952?2‘ $# "@$2?;<" $ J4:E?2‘ 4#?
X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" ?@$9?:
Z4?93" 5"3?: ?: :$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:
D"2$# $9E"952?3?%
 ’K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<"
d
 8"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
d
 B"5<" 3" 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 ?5>X?3"d
 1"25? 3" #"5"2>:5? D$Eb?3?d
 .?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: D$Eb?3?d
 V$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?J?>p" 3$
L6 i#obN

*42?95$ ? J4:E?] ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3"
X$WE4K" 9<" 3$X$ 4K52?@?::?2 ": HG
i#obd Z4?93" ?5>9a>2 ": L6 i#ob] "
#"5"2>:5? 2$E$J$ 4# ?X>:" @?2? 3>#>A
94>2 ? X$K"E>3?3$d E?:" ? X$K"E>3?3$
4K52?@?::$ ": HG i#ob] " :>:5$#? :$2‘
3$:?5>X?3" q9$:5$ E?:"] $K$ @"3$ :$2
2$>9>E>?3" @2$::>"9?93" ? 5$EK? rN
1$*.
!"  "!
*42?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"] " :>:5$#? 4:?
": :$9:"2$: K?5$2?>:] Z4$ :<" ?5>X?A
3": ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ Z4?93" " #"A
5"2 $:5‘ $# D49E>"9?#$95" $ ? 4#?
X$K"E>3?3$ >9D$2>"2 ? HG i#obN
*42?95$ ? #?9"J2?] $ 3>?95$ 3?
3$5$E;<" 3$ "J:5‘E4K":] " E"934A
5"2 5?#J^# 2$E$J$ >9D"2#?;\$: "D$A
2$E>3?: @$K": :$9:"2$: 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" qF 3>?95$>2": $ I 52?:$>2":r Z4$
D"29$E$# >9D"2#?;\$: $p52?: :"J2$ ?
3>:5e9E>? ? :$2 #?95>3? 3": "J:5‘E4A
K": g D2$95$ $ ?52‘: 3" X$WE4K"N
,$ ? D49;<" ’E5>X$ 1?2i,$9:$ D"2
?5>X?3? 3$@">: 3$ 5$2 :>3" 3$:?5>X?3?]
": :$9:"2$: :<" ?5>X?3": #?>: 4#?
X$Y $ @$2#?9$E$# 9$:5? E"93>;<"
:"#$95$ 342?95$ " #"X>#$95" 3"
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N
  !!&
" !!   &
!
1?2? $:5?E>"9?2 9? 3>2$;<" @?2?K$K?
?" X$WE4K"] ?5$9;<" ?": :$a4>95$:
@"95":%
- :>:5$#? ^ ?5>X?3" @2$::>"9?93"
? 5$EK? % 3$@">: 3$ :$K$E>"9?3"]
" #"3" 3$ J4:E? D>E? ?5>X" 9" :>:A
5$#?N 8"9:>3$2?93" Z4$ " :>:5$#?
2$E"9b$E$ ?: X?a?: 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" #$:#" Z4?93" $:5? D49;<"
9<" D"> :$K$E>"9?3?] $K? @"3$ :$2
?5>X?3? >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?@h: " X$WA
E4K" 5$2 @?::?3" @2hp>#" ? 4#? X?a?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" ?@2"@2>?3? @?2?
$K$N - :>:5$#? $95<"] ?52?X^: 3? 5$K?
9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":] >9D"2#?2‘
?" #"5"2>:5? Z4?>: ": @2"E$3>#$95":
@?2? ? 2$?K>Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #?9"J2?
E"22$5?N
,'G     ,    
*42?95$ ? J4:E? $ ?5^ Z4$ ? #?2A
Eb? ? 2^ :$_? $9a2$9?3?] @"3$A:$ :$A
K$E>"9?2 " 5>@" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
3$:$_?3"N (#? #$9:?a$# >93>E?93"
? :$K$;<" 3" 5>@" 3$ X?a? ? :$2 J4:A
E?3? ?@?2$E$2‘ 9" 3>:@K?y 3" @?>9$K
3$ >9:524#$95":] ?: 5$EK?: 3$ 9?X$A
a?;<" 9" X"K?95$ 3$X$# :$2 4:?3?:
@?2? 52"E?2 " 5>@" 3$ J4:E? $ ? 5$EK?
-{ @2$::>"9?3? @?2? E"9D>2#?2 ? :$A
K$;<" $952$%
 t1?2?K$K"t% " X$WE4K" @2"E42?2‘
4#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" @?A
2?K$K? ?" :$95>3" 3? E"934;<"N
 t1$2@$93>E4K?2t% " X$WE4K" @2"E4A
2?2‘ 4#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
@$2@$93>E4K?2 ?" :$95>3" 3? E"9A
34;<"N
,      ''
,$K$E>"9?3" " #"3" @?2?K$K"] "
:>:5$#? D?Y] ?52?X^: 3": :$9:"2$:
K?5$2?>:] 4#? J4:E? E"95W94? @"2
4#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" Z4$
:$_? ?3$Z4?3? @?2? ?: 3>#$9:\$: 3"
X$WE4K"N
%-,  !, *  [ 

*42?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"] 4:$ " >93>E?3"2 3$
3>2$;<" q:$5?r @?2? :$K$E>"9?2 " K?3"
3" X$WE4K" @?2? " Z4?K ? #?9"J2?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 3$X$2‘ :$2 D$>5?N
- 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5 ?45"A
#?5>E?#$95$ J4:E?2‘ 4#? X?a? @$K"
K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"] E?:" " >93>E?3"2
3$ 3>2$;<" 9<" :$_? ?5>X?3"N

- E"9345"2 3$X$ ?::$a42?2 Z4$ ?
X?a? :$ #?95$9b? K>X2$ $ 3$:"J:A
524W3? q3$ @$3$:52$:] J>E>EK$5?:] $5ENr
@?2? ? #?9"J2?N

- E"9345"2 ^ 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2
E$25>D>E?2A:$ Z4$ ? X?a? :$K$E>"9?3?
^ E"#@?5WX$K E"# ? #?9"J2? ? :$2
2$?K>Y?3? $ $:5‘ E"#@K$5?#$95$ K>A
X2$] >9EK4:>X$ 3$ J42?E":] :?K>[9E>?:
$ @2"54J$2e9E>?: 3$ "J_$5":oX$WE4K":
@2hp>#": qE"#" ‘2X"2$:] $:E?3?:]
E?;?#J?:] 5?#@?: 3$ @"25?A#?K?:]
52?:$>2?: 3$ E?#>9b\$:] v9>J4:] $5ENrN

*42?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"] " E"9345"2 3$X$
#?95$2 " X$WE4K" 5<" @?2?K$K" "4 @$2A
@$93>E4K?2 q3$@$93$93" 3" 5>@" 3$
#?9"J2?r ?": "452": X$WE4K": Z4?95"
@"::WX$KN

’@$9?: ? uK5>#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>A
"9?#$95" 3$5$E5?3? :$2‘ >93>E?3?
q$p$#@K"% :$ @?::?93" @"2 3>X$2:?:
X?a?: 3>:@"9WX$>: $# 4# $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"] " :>:5$#? >93>E?2‘ ?@$9?: ?
uK5>#? 3$5$E5?3? @?2? ? #?9"J2?rN
w4?93" 4#? X?a? 3>:@"9WX$K ^ $9A &
E"952?3?] :$ " X$WE4K" 9<" $:5>X$2 $#
@":>;<"] " E"9345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ?
:$a4>2 $# D2$95$ E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?
@":>E>"9‘AK" @?2? 4#? :$Z4[9E>? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" @?2?K$K"N
1$*!
 5  ,     5  3  
8"# " X$WE4K" $# @":>;<"] " E"9A
345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? >95$22"#@$2
:$4 #"X>#$95" $ 2$5>2?2 ?: #<": 3"
X"K?95$N
5  ,        
 7  *' 
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3" $ :$# ?:
#<": 9" X"K?95$] " E"9345"2 :$2‘
"2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$
Ee#J>" $# N
1$*"
5  ,     ,   
,] 4   
w4?93" " E"9345"2 E"K"E? ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
@"3$ >9:524WAK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N
 3 ,      5-  
, ,'-7  *    *' 
- :>:5$#? $95<" >9:524>2‘ " E"934A
5"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3" X$WE4K"
$ #"X[AK" @?2? 52‘:N
 3 ,      * 
*+,-'    P

f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
" 4:" 3" D2$>" $ 3" ?E$K$2?3"2 34A
2?95$ ? #?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
:$#>?45"#‘5>E?N

w4?93" " :>:5$#? "2>$95? " E"9A
345"2 ? 2$5>2?2 :4?: #<": 3" X"K?95$]
" E"9345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"A
2$: 3" X$WE4K" $ E"#$;?2 ? #"X[AK"
@?2? 52‘: K$95?#$95$N

- :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 @$2#>5>2‘ 4# #‘p>#" 3$ :$>:
52"E?: $952$ ?: @":>;\$:  $  3"
Ee#J>"N ,$ ? #?9"J2? 9<" @43$2
E"9EK4W3? E"# $::?: :$>: 52"E?:] "
:>:5$#? :$2‘ 3$:?5>X?3" $ " 3>:@K?y
3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": "2>$95?2‘ "
E"9345"2 ? E"95>94?2 #?94?K#$95$N

- :>:5$#? E?9E$K?2‘ ? #?9"J2? :$
" X$WE4K" $pE$3$2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ |
i#ob 342?95$ ? ?::>:5[9E>? ?5>X? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N - :>:5$#? ?K$25?2‘
" E"9345"2 g X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 6 i#ob]
"2>$95?93"A" ? 2$34Y>2N - E"9345"2
:$2‘ 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2 E"#@K$5?2 ? #?A
9"J2? :$ " :>:5$#? D"2 3$:?5>X?3"N

,$ " :>:5$#? D"2 3$:?5>X?3" 342?95$
? #?9"J2? @"2 Z4?KZ4$2 2?Y<"] "
E"9345"2 3$X$ 5"#?2 " E"952"K$ 3"
X$WE4K"N
w4?93" " X$WE4K" ?5>9a$ " D># 3"
:$4 #"X>#$95" @?2? 52‘:] " :>:5$#?
"2>$95?2‘ " E"9345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ":
?22$3"2$: $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N
 3 ,      !  3 ,       ,  
 ,] 4   
 w4?93" " E"9345"2 @":>E>"9? ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
@"3$ "2>$95‘AK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
4:?2 " D2$>" $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N - E"9A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N
345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3"
X$WE4K" $ $:5?2 @2$@?2?3" @?2? @?2‘A
K" Z4?93" D"2 "2>$95?3" "4 Z4?93"
:4? >95$2X$9;<" D"2 9$E$::‘2>?N
&
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " E"934A
5"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# N
 3 ,      5-  
, ,'-7  *    *' 
- :>:5$#? $95<" "2>$95?2‘ " E"9A
345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: $ #"X$2
" X$WE4K" g D2$95$N
1$*%
 345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3"
X$WE4K" $ $:5?2 @2$@?2?3" @?2? @?2‘A
K" Z4?93" D"2 "2>$95?3" "4 Z4?93"
:4? >95$2X$9;<" D"2 9$E$::‘2>?N

8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " E"934A

5"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# N
 3 ,      *   3 ,      5-  
*+,-'   3   , ,'-7  *    *' 
w4?93" " X$WE4K" ?5>9a>2 " D># 3" - :>:5$#? $95<" "2>$95?2‘ " E"9A
:$4 #"X>#$95" g D2$95$] " :>:5$#? 345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: $ #"X$2
"2>$95?2‘ " E"9345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": " X$WE4K" @?2? 52‘:N
?22$3"2$: $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N

 3 ,       ,  
 ,] 4   
w4?93" " E"9345"2 @":>E>"9? ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
@"3$ "2>$95‘AK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N  3 ,      * 
 3 ,      ! *+,-'    P
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ ?a"2? 9? X?a?
 @?2?K$K? ?" :$95>3" 3$ E"934;<"N
w4?93" ? #?9"J2? $:5>X$2 E"#@K$5?]
f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
" E"9345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? X$2>D>E?2
4:?2 " D2$>" $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N - E"9A
1$*&
? @":>;<" 3" X$WE4K" $:5?E>"9?3"N ,$
" E"9345"2 $:5>X$2 :?5>:D$>5"] 3$X$ @"A
:>E>"9?2 " Ee#J>" $# N (#? #$9:?A
a$# E"9D>2#?93" Z4$ " :>:5$#? E"9A
EK4>4 ? #?9"J2? $ "2>$95?93" " E"9A
345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ? @":>;<" 3" X$WE4K"
:$2‘ $p>J>3? @"2 ?Ka49: >9:5?95$:N
,$ 9$E$::‘2>"] 5$2#>9?2 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?2 #?94?K#$95$N
!, *  [  , ,'-+  *&
3 .-   67  *+,-'
,        ,-'
,$K$E>"9?3" " #"3" @$2@$93>E4A
K?2] " :>:5$#? D?Y] ?52?X^: 3": :$9A
:"2$: K?5$2?>:] 4#? J4:E? E"95W94?
@"2 4#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" Z4$
:$_? ?3$Z4?3? @?2? ?: 3>#$9:\$: 3"
X$WE4K"N
%-,  !, *  [ 

*42?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"] 4:$ " >93>E?3"2 3$
3>2$;<" q:$5?r @?2? :$K$E>"9?2 " K?3"
3" X$WE4K" @?2? " Z4?K ? #?9"J2?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" 3$X$2‘ :$2 D$>5?N
- 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5 ?45"A
#?5>E?#$95$ J4:E?2‘ 4#? X?a? @$K"
K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2"] E?:" " >93>E?3"2
3$ 3>2$;<" 9<" :$_? ?5>X?3"N

- E"9345"2 3$X$ ?::$a42?2 Z4$ ?
X?a? :$ #?95$9b? K>X2$ $ 3$:"J:A
524W3? q3$ @$3$:52$:] J>E>EK$5?:] $5ENr
@?2? ? #?9"J2?N

- E"9345"2 ^ 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2
E$25>D>E?2A:$ Z4$ ? X?a? :$K$E>"9?3?
^ E"#@?5WX$K E"# ? #?9"J2? ? :$2
2$?K>Y?3? $ $:5‘ E"#@K$5?#$95$ K>A
X2$] >9EK4:>X$ 3$ J42?E":] :?K>[9E>?:
$ @2"54J$2e9E>?: 3$ "J_$5":oX$WE4K":
@2hp>#": qE"#" ‘2X"2$:] $:E?3?:]
E?;?#J?:] 5?#@?: 3$ @"25?A#?K?:]
52?:$>2?: 3$ E?#>9b\$:] v9>J4:] $5ENrN

*42?95$ ? J4:E? @"2 4#? X?a?
3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"] " E"9345"2 3$X$
#?95$2 " X$WE4K" 5<" @?2?K$K" "4 @$2A
@$93>E4K?2 q3$@$93$93" 3" 5>@" 3$
#?9"J2?r ?": "452": X$WE4K": Z4?95" &
@"::WX$KN

’@$9?: ? uK5>#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>A
"9?#$95" 3$5$E5?3? :$2‘ >93>E?3?
q$p$#@K"% :$ @?::?93" @"2 3>X$2:?:
X?a?: 3>:@"9WX$>: $# 4# $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"] " :>:5$#? >93>E?2‘ ?@$9?: ?
uK5>#? 3$5$E5?3? @?2? ? #?9"J2?rN
1$*’
 w4?93" 4#? X?a? 3>:@"9WX$K ^ $9A
E"952?3?] :$ " X$WE4K" 9<" $:5>X$2 $#
@":>;<"] " E"9345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ?
:$a4>2 $# D2$95$ E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?
@":>E>"9‘AK" @?2? 4#? :$Z4[9E>? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" @?2?K$K"N
5  ,     5  3  
8"# " X$WE4K" $# @":>;<"] " E"9A
345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? >95$22"#@$2
:$4 #"X>#$95" $ 2$5>2?2 ?: #<": 3"
X"K?95$N
1$**
5  ,        
 7  *' 
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3" $ :$# ?:
#<": 9" X"K?95$] " E"9345"2 :$2‘
"2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$
Ee#J>" $# N
 3 ,      5-  
, ,'-7  *    *' 
- :>:5$#? $95<" >9:524>2‘ " E"934A
5"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3" X$WE4K"
$ #"X[AK" @?2? 52‘:N
5  ,     ,   
,] 4   
w4?93" " E"9345"2 E"K"E? ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
@"3$ >9:524WAK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N
 3 ,      * 
*+,-'    P

f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
" 4:" 3" D2$>" $ 3" ?E$K$2?3"2 34A
2?95$ ? #?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
:$#>?45"#‘5>E?N

w4?93" " :>:5$#? "2>$95? " E"9A
345"2 ? 2$5>2?2 :4?: #<": 3" X"K?95$]
" E"9345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"A
2$: 3" X$WE4K" $ E"#$;?2 ? #"X[AK"
@?2? 52‘: K$95?#$95$N

- :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 @$2#>5>2‘ 4# #‘p>#" 3$ :$>:
52"E?: $952$ ?: @":>;\$:  $  3"
Ee#J>"N ,$ ? #?9"J2? 9<" @43$2
E"9EK4W3? E"# $::?: :$>: 52"E?:] "
:>:5$#? :$2‘ 3$:?5>X?3" $ " 3>:@K?y
3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": "2>$95?2‘ "
E"9345"2 ? E"95>94?2 #?94?K#$95$N

- :>:5$#? E?9E$K?2‘ ? #?9"J2? :$
" X$WE4K" $pE$3$2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ |
i#ob 342?95$ ? ?::>:5[9E>? ?5>X? 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N - :>:5$#? ?K$25?2‘
" E"9345"2 g X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ 6 i#ob]
"2>$95?93"A" ? 2$34Y>2N - E"9345"2
:$2‘ 2$:@"9:‘X$K @"2 E"#@K$5?2 ? #?A
9"J2? :$ " :>:5$#? D"2 3$:?5>X?3"N

,$ " :>:5$#? D"2 3$:?5>X?3" 342?95$
? #?9"J2? @"2 Z4?KZ4$2 2?Y<"] "
E"9345"2 3$X$ 5"#?2 " E"952"K$ 3"
X$WE4K"N
w4?93" " X$WE4K" ?5>9a$ " D># 3"
:$4 #"X>#$95" @?2? 52‘:] " :>:5$#?
"2>$95?2‘ " E"9345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ":
?22$3"2$: $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N
 3 ,      !

f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
4:?2 " D2$>" $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N - E"9A
345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3"
X$WE4K" $ $:5?2 @2$@?2?3" @?2? @?2‘A
K" Z4?93" D"2 "2>$95?3" "4 Z4?93"
:4? >95$2X$9;<" D"2 9$E$::‘2>?N
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " E"934A
5"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# N
 3 ,       ,  
 ,] 4   
&
w4?93" " E"9345"2 @":>E>"9? ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
@"3$ "2>$95‘AK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N
1$*+
  3 ,      5-  
, ,'-7  *    *' 
- :>:5$#? $95<" "2>$95?2‘ " E"9A
345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: $ #"X$2
" X$WE4K" g D2$95$N
 3 ,      * 
*+,-'   3  
w4?93" " X$WE4K" ?5>9a>2 " D># 3"
:$4 #"X>#$95" g D2$95$] " :>:5$#?
"2>$95?2‘ " E"9345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ":
?22$3"2$: $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N
1$*,
 3 ,      !  3 ,       ,  
 ,] 4   
 w4?93" " E"9345"2 @":>E>"9? ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# ] " :>:5$#?
f 3$ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2
@"3$ "2>$95‘AK" ? ?a4?23?2 " #"X>A
4:?2 " D2$>" $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N - E"9A
#$95" 3" X"K?95$ :$2 E"9EK4W3"N
345"2 3$X$ X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: 3"
X$WE4K" $ $:5?2 @2$@?2?3" @?2? @?2‘A
K" Z4?93" D"2 "2>$95?3" "4 Z4?93"
:4? >95$2X$9;<" D"2 9$E$::‘2>?N
8"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"] " E"934A
5"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? @":>E>"9?2 ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" $# N
 3 ,      5-  
, ,'-7  *    *' 
- :>:5$#? $95<" "2>$95?2‘ " E"9A
345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ": ?22$3"2$: $ #"X$2
" X$WE4K" @?2? 52‘:N

 3 ,      * 
*+,-'    P
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ ?a"2? 9? X?a?
@?2?K$K? ?" :$95>3" 3$ E"934;<"N
w4?93" ? #?9"J2? $:5>X$2 E"#@K$5?]
" E"9345"2 :$2‘ "2>$95?3" ? X$2>D>E?2
? @":>;<" 3" X$WE4K" $:5?E>"9?3"N ,$
" E"9345"2 $:5>X$2 :?5>:D$>5"] 3$X$ @"A
:>E>"9?2 " Ee#J>" $# N (#? #$9:?A
a$# E"9D>2#?93" Z4$ " :>:5$#? E"9A
EK4>4 ? #?9"J2? $ "2>$95?93" " E"9A
345"2 ? X$2>D>E?2 ? @":>;<" 3" X$WE4K"
:$2‘ $p>J>3? @"2 ?Ka49: >9:5?95$:N
,$ 9$E$::‘2>"] 5$2#>9?2 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?2 #?94?K#$95$N
!, *  [  , ,'-+  *&
3 .-   67  *+,-'
!#!
- E"9345"2 3$X$ :$2 E?45$K":"
342?95$ ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" @?2?K$K" "4 @$2@$93>E4K?2]
#$:#" 45>K>Y?93" " :>:5$#? 1?2iA
,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5N ,$#@2$
X$2>D>Z4$ E4>3?3":?#$95$ ?: ‘2$?:
?52‘: $ g D2$95$ 3" X$WE4K" $
E$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3? ?4:[9E>? 3$ @$3$:A
52$:] ?9>#?>:] "452": X$WE4K":] "J:A
524;\$: $ @"95": E$a": ?95$: 3$ #"A
X$2 " X$WE4K" @?2? D2$95$ $ @?2? 52‘:N
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3? 3>2$;<" ^
:$#@2$ E"9D>?3? ?" E"9345"2] Z4$
3$X$ #?95$2 :$#@2$ ? ?5$9;<" ?":
?22$3"2$:N !<" D?Y[AK" @"3$ K$X?2
? ?E>3$95$: E"# D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $
?5^ #"25$N

- :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 ^ ?@$9?: 4# ?::>:5$95$ 3$ $:A
5?E>"9?#$95" $ 9<" $:5‘ ?@5" ? 2$A
E"9b$E$2 5"3": ": "J:5‘E4K":] >9A
EK4>93" @$Z4$9?: "J:524;\$:N 1?A
2?K$K$@W@$3": @"3$# :$2 3$5$E5?3":
?@$9?: 5$#@"2?2>?#$95$ "4 :$Z4$2
:$2$# 3$5$E5?3":N -J:5‘E4K": K"E?K>A
Y?3": ?E>#? "4 ?J?>p" 3": :$9:"2$:
9<" :$2<" 3$5$E5?3": Z4?93" #4>5"
@2hp>#":N
- X$WE4K" 3$X$ :$2 E"934Y>3" K$9A
5?#$95$ Z4?93" " :>:5$#? 1?2i,$9:$
’E5>X$ 1?2i ’::>:5 $:5>X$2 $# 4:" @?2?
Z4$ :$_? @"::WX$K @?2‘AK" $# 5$#@"
Z4?93" 4# "J:5‘E4K" D"2 3$5$E5?3"N
f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K Z4$ " E"9345"2 :$#A
@2$ "Kb$ @?2? 52‘: Z4?93" $:5>X$2
4:?93" " :>:5$#?N
!! ! !!  !!&
"
&

+:5? D49;<" 9<" @"3$ :$2 4:?3?
@?2? :?>2 3$ X?a?: @$2@$93>E4K?2$:]
?@$9?: 3$ X?a?: @?2?K$K?:N
1$*-
 ! *67  3- 67
1?2? ?5>X?2 ? D49;<"] @2$::>"9?2 ?
5$EK? N ’@h: ? :$K$;<"] " :>:5$#?
:$ ?5>X? $ >9D"2#? ?" E"9345"2 ?:
?;\$: Z4$ 3$X$# :$2 5"#?3?: @?2?
Z4$ ? #?9"J2? :$_? 3$:$#@$9b?3?
E"22$5?#$95$N
’54?2 9" >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2?  3 ,         3 ,      * 
:$K$E>"9?2 " K?3" @?2? " Z4?K " X$WA    7  *'  *+,-'    P
E4K" 3$X$2‘ :?>2] ?5>X?93" ? :$5? @?2?
? 3>2$>5? "4 @?2? ? $:Z4$23?N
!? #?9"J2?] " :>:5$#? "2>$95? ?
#43?9;? @?2? ? #?2Eb? ? 2^ $ ? :$K$A
;<" 3" K?3" 3$ :?W3? @$K" >93>E?3"2
3$ 3>2$;<"N )?2a?2 " X"K?95$ $ 4:$
?@$9?: ": @$3?>: $9Z4?95" " :>:5$#?
#?9$_? " X"K?95$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$
@?2? :?>2 3? X?a?N ’ #?9"J2? :$2‘ >9A
5$22"#@>3? E?:" " E"9345"2 #?95$A  3 ,      5-    3 ,      !
9b? ?;<"] X"K495‘2>? "4 9<"] :"J2$ " , ,'-7  *    *' 
X"K?95$ q5"E?93" "4 :$a42?93" @?2?
>#@$3>2 :$4 #"X>#$95"rN

1$+.
  3 ,       ,    3 ,      5-  
 ,] 4    , ,'-7  *    *' 

 3 ,      !

 3 ,      5-    3 ,      * 

, ,'-7  *    *'  *+,-'    P
’ #?9"J2? :$#>?45"#‘5>E? 5$2A
#>9? Z4?93" ? #$9:?a$# 3$ #?9"A
J2? E"9EK4W3? ?@?2$E$2 9" X>:"2N ’"
D>9?K 3? #?9"J2?] " :>:5$#? 3$X"KX$
" E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K" ?" E"9345"2N &
 3 ,       ,  
 ,] 4    "!? " !
 ,$ ": :$9:"2$: :"D2$2$# ?Ka4#
 3 ,      *  >#@?E5" Z4$ ?K5$2? :4?: @":>;\$:]
*+,-'   3   ? "@$2?;<" 2$?K>Y?3? @$K" :>:A
5$#? @"3$2‘ @>"2?2 E"9:>3$2?X$KA
#$95$N
 - :>:5$#? ?5>9a$ 4# 3$:$#@$A
9b" :4@$2>"2 3$@">: Z4$ " X$WA

1$+!
 E4K" @$2E"22$ E$2E? 3$ 6G i#
q:>:5$#? 3$ t?45"E?K>J2?;<"trN
 ,$ ": :$9:"2$: $:5>X$2$#
:4_":] E"J$25": @"2 9$X$]
a$K"] K?#? "4 5>X$2$# :>3"
2$@>95?3": $# E"#@?2?;<" E"#
:4?: E"93>;\$: "2>a>9?>:] ?
"@$2?;<" 3" :>:5$#? @"3$ @>"2?2
32?:5>E?#$95$N f $p52$#?#$95$
>#@"25?95$ Z4$ ": :$9:"2$:
:$_?# #?95>3": :$#@2$ K>#@":
@?2? Z4$ " :>:5$#? D49E>"9$
?3$Z4?3?#$95$N *42?95$ ?
K>#@$Y? D>Z4$ ?5$95" @?2? 9<"
2>:E‘AK": "4 3?9>D>E‘AK":d $X>5$
4:?2 @?9": :$E": "4 ‘:@$2":N -:
:$9:"2$: 3$X$# :$2 K?X?3": E"#
‘a4? K>#@? $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"]
E"# :b?#@"" @?2? E?22":N
!": :$2X>;": 3$ K?X?a$# Z4$
45>K>Y?# _?5": 3$ X?@"2 "4 3$
?K5? @2$::<"] K>#@$ ": :$9:"2$:
2?@>3?#$95$] #?95$93" ": _?5":
3$ X?@"2oJ>E": 3$ ?K5? @2$::<" ?
@$K" #$9": 7G E# 3": :$9:"2$:N
 ’ @2"p>#>3?3$ E"# D"95$: 4K52?:A
:v9>E?: qD2$>": @9$4#‘5>E": 3$
E?#>9b\$: "4 D42?3$>2?: @9$4A
#‘5>E?:] @"2 $p$#@K"r @"3$ >9DK4A
1$+"
$9E>?2 9$a?5>X?#$95$ " 3$:$#@$A
9b" 3" :$9:"2N
 -: :$9:"2$: @"3$# 3$5$E5?2 4#
"J:5‘E4K" >9$p>:5$95$ q24W3" 3$
$E"r 3$X>3" ? 24W3": #$Ee9>E":]
E"#" 342?95$ ? K?X?a$# 3" X$WA
E4K"] 9" E?:" 3$ Eb4X?] X$95"
D"25$ $ a2?9>Y"] @"2 $p$#@K"N
 -: :$9:"2$: @"3$# 9<" 3$5$E5?2
"J_$5": 3$ 4# 3$5$2#>9?3" D"2A
#?5" $:@$EWD>E" "4 3$ 3$5$2#>9?A
3": #?5$2>?>: q@"K": #4>5" D>9":]
X>a?: 3$ 2$J"Z4$:] @?>9^>:] 2$3$:]
J4Eb?:] "J:5‘E4K": @?2? 3$K>#>A
5?2 $:5?E>"9?#$95"] @?X>#$95":]
K?5?: 3$ K>p"] X$WE4K": ? #"5"2]
$5ENrN 12$:5$ :$#@2$ #4>5? ?5$9A
;<" :$ " X$WE4K" $ :4? 52?_$5h2>?
:<" 2$?K#$95$ E"#@?5WX$>: E"# ?
X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" >3$95>D>A
E?3? @$K" :>:5$#?N
 - 4:" 3$ q4# "4 #?>:r @9$4:
"4 2"3?: 3$ 5?#?9b": 3>D$2$9A
5$: 3?Z4$K$: D"29$E>3": E"# "
X$WE4K" @"3$# ?D$5?2 " D49E>"9?A
#$95" 3" :>:5$#?N
 ,$ b"4X$2 ?Ka4# 2$J"Z4$ qE"# "
$9a?5$ 3$X>3?#$95$ ?E"@K?3"r] "
:>:5$#? :$ 3$:?5>X?2‘ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$N
 !" #"3" tJ4:E? $# ?93?#$95"t]
" :>:5$#? @"3$ >3$95>D>E?2 4# K"A
E?K $Z4>X"E?3" @?2? $D$54?2 ? #?A
9"J2? q4# $952"9E?#$95"] E?K;?A
3?:] @"95": 3$ @?::?a$# 9? 2"5?]
$5ENrN
 ,$ 4#? #?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $:5‘ :$93" 2$?K>Y?3? $952$
3">: X$WE4K": _‘ $:5?E>"9?3": $#
3$:?K>9b?#$95"] " :>:5$#? @"3$
$:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" 3$ D"2#? 3$A
:?K>9b?3? 9? X?a?N
 !" E?:" 3$ #?9"J2?: @?2? $:5?A
E>"9?2 $# $:52?3?: $# 3$EK>X$]
" 3$:$#@$9b" 3" :>:5$#? @"3$
@>"2?2] @"3$93" ?5^ 3$:?5>X?2A:$N
 ,$ 4#? #?9"J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $:5‘ :$93" 2$?K>Y?3? $952$
3">: X$WE4K": _‘ $:5?E>"9?3": 9?:
D?>p?: 3": 3">: K?3":] @"3$ :$2
Z4$ " :>:5$#? K$X$ " X$WE4K" :"A
J2$ ? D?>p?N
 1"3$ :$2 >#@"::WX$K 2$?K>Y?2 ?Ka4A
#?: #?9"J2?: $# E42X?: #4>5"
D$Eb?3?:N
 12$:5$ #4>5? ?5$9;<" @?2? a?A
2?95>2 Z4$ ?: E"93>;\$: E"95>A
94$# D?X"2‘X$>: 342?95$ ? #?9"A
J2? 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" q"J:$2X$
@"2 $p$#@K"] :$ b‘ @$::"?: $o"4
?9>#?>: 9? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95"] X$WE4K": $# #"X>#$95"]
$5ENr $ >95$2X$9b? >#$3>?5?#$95$]
:$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
 *42?95$ ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?#$95"] @2$:5$ ?5$9;<" ?": E?2A
2": Z4$ :$ ?@2"p>#?# @$K? 3>2$A
;<" "@":5?N C$:@$>5$ :$#@2$ ?:
K$>: 3$ 52e9:>5"N

!<" :$ a?2?95$ ? E"22$5? "@$2?;<"
3" :>:5$#? :$ " X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $Z4>A
@?3" E"# E"22$95$: ?95>3$22?@?95$:
"4 E"# $:5$@$ 5$#@"2‘2>"N

’ D49;<" >9D"2#? ?" #"5"2>:5? ?@$A
9?: :"J2$ ? uK5>#? X?a? 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" @"::WX$K q@?2?K$K? "4 @$2@$9A
3>E4K?2r 3$5$E5?3? @$K": :$9:"2$: 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"N

’Ka4#?: #$9:?a$9: $p>J>3?: :<"
?E"#@?9b?3?: 3$ :>9?>: :"9"2":N
<  0
_"!  $ !ER !
%!E  / .- 0
’ Ee#$2? 3$ 2^ $:5‘ :>54?3? 9?
5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
!#!
’ 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ @$K" $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" $ @"2 "452?: #?9"J2?:] @"A
5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?:] ^ :$#@2$ 3"
#"5"2>:5?N ’" $D$54?2 $:5?: #?9"J2?:]
" E"9345"2 3$X$ E$25>D>E?2A:$ :$#@2$
3$ Z4$ 9" $:@?;" 3$ #?9"J2? 9<"
$:5$_?# @2$:$95$: @$::"?: q$:@$E>?KA
#$95$ E2>?9;?:r 9$# ?9>#?>:N
’ Ee#$2? E"9:5>54> 4#? ?_43? @?2?
" E"9345"2] $#J"2? $:5$ 949E? 3$X?
2$34Y>2 ? :4? ?5$9;<" 342?95$ ?:
#?9"J2?: @"5$9E>?K#$95$ @$2>a":?:]
#$:#" :$ $p$E45?3?: ? J?>p? X$K"A
E>3?3$N ’K^# 3>::"] @2"::$a4>2 :$#A
@2$ ? 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ #"3$2?3?] 3$
#"3" ? @"3$2 D2$?2 ? Z4?KZ4$2 #"A
#$95" 9" E?:" 3$ @2$:$9;? 3$ 4#
"J:5‘E4K"N
!#!
1?2? " D49E>"9?#$95" E"22$5"] ^
>93>:@$9:‘X$K Z4$ ? Ee#$2? $:5$_?
:$#@2$ K>#@? 3$ K?#?] :4_$>2?] 9$X$
"4 a$K"N *42?95$ ? K>#@$Y? 3? EeA
#$2?] @2$:5?2 ? #‘p>#? ?5$9;<" @?2?
9<" 2>:E‘AK? 9$# 3?9>D>E‘AK?d $X>5?2
? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @?9": :$E":] ‘:@$2":
"4 342":N (5>K>Y?2 @?9": 3$ 9yK"9 "4 &
?Ka"3<" :$# D>?@":N
’ Ee#$2? 3$X$ :$2 K?X?3? E"#
‘a4? K>#@? $] $X$954?K#$95$] 4:?2
:b?#@"" @?2? ?45"#hX$KN !?: $:A
5?;\$: 3$ K?X?a$# Z4$ 45>K>Y?# #‘A
Z4>9?: E"# _?5" 3$ X?@"2 "4 3$ ?K5?
@2$::<"] K>#@?2 2?@>3?#$95$ ? EeA
#$2? #?95$93" " J>E" ? #?>: 3$ 7G
E# 3$ 3>:5e9E>?N ’K^# 3>::"] 9<" E"A
K"E?2 ?3$:>X": 9? Ee#$2?N
1$+%
! *67@ *67  ,]  
,$#@2$ Z4$ :$ ?E>"9? ? #?2Eb?
? 2^] 9" 2‘3>" ^ X>:4?K>Y?3? ? ‘2$?
E>2E493?95$ g 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
’: >#?a$9: :<" X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9? 5$K?
_495?#$95$ E"# 4#? #$9:?a$# 3$
?3X$25[9E>?N
!?: E"9D>a42?;\$: 3" :>:5$#?] ^
@"::WX$K ?5>X?2o3$:?5>X?2 ? $p>J>;<"
3?: >#?a$9: 3? Ee#$2? 342?95$ 7G
:$a493": ?@h: " 3$:$9a?5$ 3? #?2A
Eb? ? 2^N *42?95$ $::$: 7G :$a493":]
5?#J^# ^ @"::WX$K >9>J>2 ? $p>J>;<"
?52?X^: 3$ 4# J"5<" a2‘D>E" 9? 5$K?
3" :>:5$#? 3$ ‘43>"N
!?: :>54?;\$: ?J?>p" " 2‘3>" 3$:?A
5>X?2‘ ? $p>J>;<" 3?: >#?a$9: 3? EeA
#$2?%
 8?:" " X$WE4K" 4K52?@?::$ ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ 3$ 7H i#obN
 8?:" ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ #?2Eb?: $:A
5$_? 9? @":>;<" N
 8?:" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $:A
5$_? 9? @":>;<"  @ N
1$+&

’: >#?a$9: X>:4?K>Y?3?: 9? 5$K? @"A
3$# D>E?2 K>a$>2?#$95$ 3$D"2#?3?:N
!J!?  "!
  !L
 -' K6H    'F
’54?93" 9?: 3$D>9>;\$: 3" :>:5$#?
(E"99$E5£ ^ @"::WX$K ?5>X?2 ? X>:4A
?K>Y?;<" $# K>9b?: a4>? 9" 3>:@K?yN
,$ ?5>X?3?] ? a2?3$ ^ @":>E>"9?3? 9?
>#?a$# @?2? $X>3$9E>?2 ? K?2a42? 3"
X$WE4K" $ " @$2E42:" $# #?2Eb? ?
2^ @2$X>:5" E"# J?:$ 9? @":>;<" 3"
X"K?95$ q@?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:] E"9A
:4K5?2 " :4@K$#$95" $:@$EWD>E"rN
(#? K>9b? E$952?K 52?E$_?3? :"J2$A
@":5? >93>E? " E$952" 3" X$WE4K" @?2?
D?E>K>5?2 ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"9?A
#$95" "4 " ?K>9b?#$95" E"# " a?9A
Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$N ’: 3>D$2$95$: 2$A
a>\$: E"K"2>3?: >93>E?# ? 3>:5e9E>?
3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
V$_? ? :$a4>2 ?: 3>:5e9E>?: ?@2"p>A
#?3?: @?2? E?3? 2$a><"N
 5 7  'G % G HG E#
3$ 3>:5e9E>? 3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3"
X$WE4K"
 5 7 !  ' % HG E# L #
3$ 3>:5e9E>? 3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3"
X$WE4K"
 5 7   % L # "4 #?>:
3$ 3>:5e9E>? 3? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3"
X$WE4K"
" 5     'F
,$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: $:5>X$2
K$X?95?3?] ? Ee#$2? 9<" >3$95>D>E?2‘
Z4?KZ4$2 "J:5‘E4K" 9? @?25$ 52?:$>2?
3" X$WE4K"N !" 3>:@K?y :$2‘ X>:4?K>A
Y?3? 4#? #$9:?a$# 3$ ?X>:" $:@$A
EWD>E?N
!$:5$ E?:"] J?>p?2 ? 5?#@? 3"
@"25?A#?K?: @2$::>"9?93" $# E"22$:A
@"93[9E>? E"# ? D$Eb?342? ?5^ "4A
X>2 " $:5?K>3" 3? #$:#?N

+# ?Ka4#?: E>2E49:5e9E>?:] E"#"]
@"2 $p$#@K"] @2$:$9;? 3$ a$K"] 9$X$
"4 K?#? 9? :4@$2DWE>$ 3? Ee#$2?] ?
:$9:>J>K>3?3$ 3? Ee#$2? @"3$ D>E?2
2$34Y>3?N

,$] ? :$a4>2 ? >95$2X$9;\$: 3$ 2$A
@?2?;<"] :$ 5"29?2 9$E$::‘2>" X"KA
5?2 ? @>95?2 ? @"25? 3" @"25?A#?K?:]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 5>95? 9<" $952$
$# E"95?5" E"# ? Ee#$2?N

*42?95$ ?: #?9"J2?: 3$ $:5?E>"A
9?#$95"] @2$:5?2 :$#@2$ ? #‘p>#?
?5$9;<" ?": "J:5‘E4K": Z4$ :$ @":A
:?# $9E"952?2 @"2 E>#? "4 @"2 J?>p"
3" E?#@" 3$ ?;<" 3? Ee#$2?N
   
!
" "4 J?>p? 9" 5?9Z4$N !$::$ E?:"]
1?2? a?2?95>2 ? @$2D"2#?9E$ 3" X$WA
E4K"] ? ?3$Z4?;<" $ E?K>J2?;<" 3"
#"5"2 $ 3$#?>: E"#@"9$95$: :<" J?A
:$?3?: 9?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: K"E?>:] "
Z4$ >9EK4> ": E"#J4:5WX$>: 3>:@"9>J>A
K>Y?3": $ E"#$2E>?K>Y?3": 9" B2?:>KN
8?:" " X$WE4K" :$_? :4J#$5>3" g
45>K>Y?;<" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# E?2?EA
5$2W:5>E?: 3>X$2:?: 3?Z4$K?: @2$X>:5?:
@?2? " #$2E?3" J2?:>K$>2"] ?K>?3" ?"
D?5" 3$ :$2 45>K>Y?3" $# ?K5>543$: $K$A
X?3?:] #4>5" ?E>#? 3" @?32<" J2?A
:>K$>2"] " #$:#" @"3$2‘ ?@2$:$95?2
D49E>"9?#$95" >22$a4K?2 $ ?5^ #$:#"
"E"22$2 3?9": $# :$4: E"#@"9$95$:N
’95$: 3$ $D$54?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95"]
^ >#@"25?95$ E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3" 5>@" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K E"22$5"N
’K^# 3>::"] 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2 ?95$:
3$ $D$54?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95"N
,$ " #"5"2 ?@2$:$95?2 D49E>"9?A
#$95" >22$a4K?2 "4 " X$WE4K" :"D2$2
:"K?X?9E": 342?95$ ? #?2Eb?] ?
E?4:? @"3$2‘ :$2 ? @2$:$9;? 3$ E"#A
J4:5WX$K 3$ Z4?K>3?3$ >9:4D>E>$95$
E"934Y>2 " X$WE4K" g E"9E$::>"9‘2>?
3?  !  , ' > #?>: @2hA
p>#?] E"# X$K"E>3?3$ #"3$2?3? $
:$# $p>a>2 #4>5" 3" #"5"2N ,$ $:5$:
>9E"9X$9>$95$: "E"22$2$# K"a" ?@h:
4# 2$?J?:5$E>#$95" $# 4# @":5" 3$
a?:"K>9?] 3$:K>a?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ "
#"5"2 $ @2"E42?2 ?  !  , '
> "4 4#? "D>E>9? $:@$E>?K>Y?3?]
? D># 3$ $X>5?2 3?9": #?>"2$: ?"
#"5"2 $ "452": :>:5$#?: 3" X$WE4K"N
-: 3>:@":>5>X": ?95>@"K4$95$: $p>A
a$# " 4:" $pEK4:>X" 3$ a?:"K>9? :$#
Eb4#J"N
*$ ?E"23" E"# 2$a4K?#$95?;<"
X>a$95$ $:5?J$K$E>3? @$K? ’!1
q’a[9E>? !?E>"9?K 3$ 1$52hK$"r ?
a?:"K>9? 9"2#?K#$95$ 3>:@"9WX$K 9"
#$2E?3" J2?:>K$>2" 9<" 3$X$ E"95$2
Eb4#J" $# @2"@"2;\$: Z4$ @"::?#
E?4:?2 3?9": ?" E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"
3": ?45"#hX$>:N
&
!#!
!49E? >952"34Y>2] 9$# #$:#"
$# E?:": 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] ? #WA
9>#? Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ a?:"K>9? E"#
Eb4#J" 9" 5?9Z4$N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
1$+’

!#!
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3? "2>a$# 3" E"#J4:A
5WX$K $ 45>K>Y?2 :"#$95$ E"#J4:5WX$K
E"# Z4?K>3?3$ E$25>D>E?3?] ?3Z4>2>3"
$# @":5": 3? C$3$ 3$ *>:52>J4>3"2$:
Z4$ 3>:@\$# 3$ @2"a2?#?: 3$ E$25>A
D>E?;<" 3$ Z4?K>3?3$ 52?9:@?2$95$:N
(5>K>Y?2 E"#J4:5WX$K E"# $:@$E>D>A
E?;<" >9?3$Z4?3? "4 3$ J?>p? Z4?A
K>3?3$ @"3$2‘ ?D$5?2 " 3$:$#@$9b"
3" X$WE4K"] ?K^# 3$ E?4:?2 3?9": >2A
2$X$2:WX$>: ?" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" $
"452": @"::WX$>: 3?9": ?" #"5"2] 9<"
E"J$25": @$K? a?2?95>?N
!#!
!<" ?3>E>"9?2 "452" 5>@" 3$ a?:"A
K>9? 9" 5?9Z4$ q$pN% a?:"K>9? 3$ ?X>A
?;<"r] 9<" b"#"K"a?3? @?2? 4:" ?4A
5"#"5>X"N
-452": 5>@": 3$ a?:"K>9? @"3$#
@2"X"E?2 3?9": >22$X$2:WX$>: 9" E"9A
X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"N
1$+*
!#!
 *+,-' .-  , &
 % /'(0] E?:" X"E[ "@5$
@"2 ?J?:5$E$2 " :$4 X$WE4K" $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ E"# $5?9"K] ^ 2$E"#$93?3"
" ?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#@K$5" 3" 5?9Z4$
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# a?:"K>9? q9" #WA
9>#" 4# 5?9Z4$r ? E?3? 7GNGGG i#
@?2? 2$34Y>2 @2"X‘X$>: E"95?#>9?9A
5$: @2"E$3$95$: 3" $5?9"KN
=:5" ^ >#@"25?95$ @?2? #?95$2 "
J"# D49E>"9?#$95" $ 3$:$#@$9b"
3" #"5"2 $] @2>9E>@?K#$95$] $X>5?2
3>D>E4K3?3$: 9" :>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 3"
#"5"2N
!#!
!<" 45>K>Y?2 E"#J4:5WX$K E"# W9A
3>E$ 3$ "E5?9?: #4>5" J?>p"N
- 4:" 3$::$ 5>@" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K
@"3$2‘ @2"X"E?2 E"#J4:5<" 3$:E"9A
52"K?3? $ ?E?22$5?2 3?9": a2?X$: ?"
#"5"2N ’ a?2?95>? 9<" E"J2>2‘ $::$
5>@" 3$ 3?9":N
!#!
(5>K>Y?2 :"#$95$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"#
$:@$E>D>E?;<" $:5?J$K$E>3? @$K? ’!1
q’a[9E>? !?E>"9?K 3" 1$52hK$"r] b"A
#"K"a?3": @?2? 4:" ?45"#"5>X"N
+X$954?>: 3?9": 9": E"#@"9$95$:
3": :>:5$#?: 3$ $#>::\$:] ?K>#$95?A
;<" $ "452": 3?9": 9" @2h@2>" #"A
5"2 E?4:?3": @$K" 4:" 3$ E"#J4:A
5WX$K D"2? 3?: $:@$E>D>E?;\$:] E"#A
J4:5WX$K E"95?#>9?3"] ?34K5$2?3" "4
E"# @2$:$9;? 3$ Eb4#J" "4 ?3>5>A
X": #$5‘K>E": g J?:$ 3$ #?9a?9[:
9<" :$2<" E"J$25": @$K? a?2?95>?N
!#!
!<" ?3>E>"9?2 ?3>5>X": 2$E"#$9A
3?3": @?2? "452": 5>@": 3$ E"#J4:5WA
X$K ?" 5?9Z4$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K 3" X$WA
E4K"] @">: b‘ 2>:E" 3$ 3?9": a2?X$:
?" E?5?K>:?3"2] >9_$5"2$:] :$9:"2$: $
?" @2h@2>" #"5"2N
’ a?2?95>? 3" X$WE4K" 9<" E"J2>2‘
$::$: 3?9":N
!#!
!<" E"K"E?2 9? $p52$#>3?3$ 3"
J"E?K 9$9b4# "J_$5"o5?#@<" 9<"
@2$X>:5" 9" X$WE4K"N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ "J_$5":o5?#@\$:
9<" E"9D"2#$: @"3$# @2"X"E?2 ?4A
#$95": 3$ @2$::<" 9" >95$2>"2 3" 2$A
:$2X?5h2>"] E2>?93" E"93>;\$: 3$ @$A
2>a"N
!#!
!<" :$ ?@2"p>#?2 3" J"E?K 3" 5?9A
Z4$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# Dh:D"2": "4
E>a?22": ?E$:":] @">: b‘ @$2>a" 3$ >9A
E[93>"N
+X>5?2 5?#J^# ?@2"p>#?2 3$#?>:
" 2":5" 3" J"E?K] @?2? 9<" >9?K?2
X?@"2$: 9"E>X":N
!#!
!<" 45>K>Y?2 " E$K4K?2o:#?25@b"9$
@2hp>#" 3? J"#J? 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"
3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
+:5? ?5>543$ @"3$ @2"X"E?2 >9E[9A
3>"N
!#!
- E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E" >9$D>E>$95$
@2"X"E? $#>::\$: 9"E>X?: 9" $:E?A
@?#$95"N
’K^# 3>::"] @"3$2‘ @"K4>2 " #$>"
?#J>$95$N
!#!
- X$WE4K" 3$X$2‘ @$2#?9$E$2 3$:A
K>a?3" $9Z4?95" $:5>X$2 :$93" ?J?:A
5$E>3"N
+::$ @2"E$3>#$95" X>:? ? a?2?95>2
" D49E>"9?#$95" E"22$5" 3" :>:5$#?
$ $X>5?2 $22": 3$ >93>E?;<" 3" >9:524A
#$95" 9" @?>9$KN

*42?95$ ? E"934;<"] " ?E$93>A
#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? @"3$ >93>E?2
?X?2>? 9" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"o-B*
"4 9" E?5?K>:?3"2] E"# ?4#$95" 9"
E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 2$34;<" &
3? @"5[9E>? 3" #"5"2 $ ?4#$95" 3"
9WX$K 3$ $#>::\$:N 1?2? :?J$2 " Z4$
D?Y$2 9$::$: E?:":] K$2 t)4Y$: 3$ ?3A
X$25[9E>? $ #$9:?a$9:t] 9" E?@W54K"
t8"9b$E$93" :$4 @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95":tN

,$ " X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $# 52e9:>5"
@"2 "452": @?W:$:] E$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$
1$++
Z4$ " ?J?:5$E>#$95" :$_? D$>5" :"A
#$95$ E"# a?:"K>9? Z4$ 9<" E"95$A
9b? Eb4#J" $# :4? E"#@":>;<"N
"! N /, 4-+*'  '
@- 5' 0
- :>:5$#? P)+¡ D"> @2"_$5?3" @?2?
@2"@"2E>"9?2 5"5?K DK$p>J>K>3?3$ 9?
?K>#$95?;<" 3" #"5"2 3" X$WE4K"]
@$2#>5>93" ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ $5?9"K "4
3$ a?:"K>9? >93>:5>95?#$95$N - E"#A
J4:5WX$K @"3$ :$2 ?3>E>"9?3" 9" 2$A
:$2X?5h2>" 9? @2"@"2;<" Z4$ " 4:4‘A
2>" _4Ka?2 E"9X$9>$95$ @?2? " 4:"N
8?J$2‘ ?" 4:4‘2>" ? ?9‘K>:$ :"J2$
Z4?K @2"@"2;<" 3": 3">: E"#J4:5WA
X$>: ^ #?>: E"9X$9>$95$ @?2? " :$4
5>@" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"] E"9:>3$2?93" ?:
3>X$2:?: X?2>‘X$>: q@2$;" 3" E"#J4:A
5WX$K] E"9:4#"] 3$:$#@$9b"] $5ENrN
’ E$952?K $K$52v9>E? 3$ E"952"K$ 3$
>9_$;<" $:5‘ @2$@?2?3? @?2? xa$2$9A
E>?2z ? >95$2?;<" $952$ ": 3">: 5>@": 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K q$5?9"K "4 a?:"K>9?r @":A
:>J>K>5?93" 4# D49E>"9?#$95" :$#A
@2$ 2$a4K?2 $# 5"3?: ?: :>54?;\$: 3$
45>K>Y?;<"N
1$+,
!" 4:" 9"2#?K " :>:5$#? PK$p 9<"
2$Z4$2 E4>3?3": "4 @2"E$3>#$95":
$:@$E>?>:] $pE$54?93" ? "J:$2X?;<"
3?: ?3X$25[9E>?: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" @2$A
:$95$: 9$:5$ E?@W54K" $ ": @"95": 3$
#?945$9;<" $:@$EWD>E":N
!#!
!<" 45>K>Y?2 E"#J4:5WX$>: 3>D$2$9A
5$: 3": $:@$E>D>E?3":N
- :>:5$#? :"#$95$ $:5‘ @2$@?2?3"
@?2? D49E>"9?2 E"# $5?9"K $ a?:"K>9?
?45"#"5>X":N
!#!
 *+,-' .-  , &
 % /'(0] E?:" X"E[ "@5$
@"2 ?J?:5$E$2 " :$4 X$WE4K" $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ E"# $5?9"K] ^ 2$E"#$93?3"
" ?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#@K$5" 3" 5?9Z4$
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# a?:"K>9? q9" #WA
9>#" 4# 5?9Z4$r ? E?3? 7GNGGG i#
@?2? 2$34Y>2 @2"X‘X$>: E"95?#>9?9A
5$: @2"E$3$95$: 3" $5?9"KN
=:5" ^ >#@"25?95$ @?2? #?95$2 "
J"# D49E>"9?#$95" $ 3$:$#@$9b"
3" #"5"2 $] @2>9E>@?K#$95$] $X>5?2
3>D>E4K3?3$: 9" :>:5$#? 3$ @?25>3? 3"
#"5"2N
!#!
!<" ?3?@5?2 " X$WE4K" @?2? D49E>"A
9?#$95" E"# S!V qS‘: 9?542?K X$>A
E4K?2rN
’: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3" :>:5$#? P)+¡
9<" @"::>J>K>5?# ? E"9X$2:<"N

-: #"5"2$: DK$p @"3$# ?@2$:$95?2
9WX$>: 3$ 24W3": 3>D$2$95$:] 3$@$9A
3$93" 3" E"#J4:5WX$K 45>K>Y?3" q$5?A
9"K "4 a?:"K>9?r J$# E"#" @$2E$9A
54?K 3$ #>:542?N +:5$ E"#@"25?#$95"
^ 9"2#?K $ 9<" ?D$5? " 3$:$#@$9b"
3" #"5"2N


’@h: 4# ?J?:5$E>#$95"] " :>:5$#?
PK$p 9$E$::>5? 3$ 4# @$Z4$9" 5$#@"
3$ ?3?@5?;<" q?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ 7G
#>945":r E"# " X$WE4K" D49E>"9?93"]
@?2? 2$E"9b$E$2 " E"#J4:5WX$K Z4$
$:5‘ 9" 5?9Z4$ q$5?9"K "4 a?:"K>9?rN
+:5? 2$E"#$93?;<" ^ >#@"25?95$]
:"J2$543"] Z4?93" 5$9b? "E"22>3"
? 52"E? 3" E"#J4:5WX$K Z4$ $:5?X?
:$93" 45>K>Y?3" q$pN% $5?9"K $# X$Y
3$ a?:"K>9?rN - X$WE4K" 3$X$ E4#@2>2
4# @$2E42:" #W9>#" q@$K" 5$#@" ?9A
5$2>"2#$95$ $:@$E>D>E?3"r @?2? Z4$ "
:>:5$#? ?::>#>K$ " 9"X" E"#J4:5WX$KN
+:5$ @2"E$3>#$95" >2‘ #>9>#>Y?2
$X$954?>: @2"JK$#?: 9? @2hp>#? @?2A
5>3? 3" X$WE4K"] @2>9E>@?K#$95$ :$ "
#"5"2 $:5>X$2 D2>"N
"  "9?#$95" ?9"2#?K 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K>A
- ,      4 (   -&

!#!
(5>K>Y?2 :"#$95$ " Q'  ' &
, 3 , /120 3? K>9b? ?45"#"A
5>X?N - 4:" 3$ "452": @2"345": "4
#>:542?: @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 3$ #"3" >2A
2$#$3>‘X$K " #"5"2 E"# ? E"9:$A
Z4$95$ @$23? 3? a?2?95>? @$K": 3?A
9": E?4:?3":N
+# E?:" 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" ?E>3$9A
5?K E"# "452": 5>@": 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K]
9<" K>a4$ " #"5"2 $ @2"E$3? ?" $:A
X?Y>?#$95" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"N ,$] @$K"
E"952‘2>"] " #"5"2 5>X$2 D49E>"9?3"
#$:#" Z4$ @"2 4# @$2W"3" J2$XW:A
:>#"] ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K $:X?Y>?2] ?K^#
3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 5"3"
" E>2E4>5" 3$ ?K>#$95?;<"N
8"# 5$#@$2?542?: J?>p?:] " a2?4
3$ DK4>3$Y 3" hK$" 3>$:$K @"3$ 5"29?2A
:$ >9:4D>E>$95$ 3$X>3" g D"2#?;<" 3$
@?2?D>9?:] E"# " E"9:$Z4$95$ D49E>A
#$95?;<" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
+# E?:" 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#
hK$" 3>$:$K 9<" ?3$Z4?3" g 5$#@$A
2?542? 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"] ^ 2$E"#$93‘X$K
#>:542?2 " hK$" 3>$:$K E"# 4# ?3>A
5>X" $:@$E>?K] >952"34Y>93" 9" 2$:$2A
X?5h2>" @2>#$>2" " ?95>E"9a$K?95$ $]
$# :$a4>3?] " hK$" 3>$:$KN
!" E?:" 3$ 45>K>Y?A
;<"o$:5?E>"9?#$95" @2"K"9a?3"
3" X$WE4K" $# 2$a>\$: #"95?9b"A
:?:oD2>?:] ^ 2$E"#$93‘X$K $D$54?2 "
?J?:5$E>#$95" E"# " hK$" 3>$:$K
3>:@"9WX$K 9" K"E?KN ’K^# 3>::"]
9$:5$: E?:":] :4a$2$A:$ #?95$2
9" >95$2>"2 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 4#?
Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K :4@$2>"2 &
? 6Gs 3? E?@?E>3?3$ u5>KN
!%!"
1?2? a?2?95>2 " 2$?J?:5$E>#$95"
E"#@K$5" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"] $D$54?2
34?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"
?@h: " @2>#$>2" $:5?K>3" 3? @>:5"K?
3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"N
1$+-


8"9:4K5?2 ? K$a>:K?;<" X>a$95$N
+X>5?2 @":5$2>"2$: "@$2?;\$: 3$
?J?:5$E>#$95" Z4$ @"::?# @2"X"E?2
?9"#?K>?: 9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K>#$95?A
;<"N
"  !%!&
"  "%
- t8?@K$:: P4$Kt ^ 4# 3>:@":>A
5>X" :>54?3" 9" J"E?K 3" 3$@h:>5" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$Kd $:5$ ?J2$A:$ $ X"K5? ?
D$Eb?2A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?Z4?93"
3? >952"34;<"o$p52?;<" 3? @>:5"K? 3$
?J?:5$E>#$95"N
’ 5?#@? 3" E"#J4:5WX$K
3$:JK"Z4$>?A:$ Z4?93" " D$Eb?A
#$95" E$952?K>Y?3" 3?: @"25?: ^
3$:K>a?3" $ JK"Z4$>?A:$ ?45"#?A
5>E?#$95$ K>a?93" " D$Eb?#$95"
E$952?K>Y?3"N
1$,.
!4 -     J"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" ? :$2 45>A
1?2? $D$54?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95"] @2"A K>Y?3" 9" #"#$95" $# Z4$ D"2
2$?J?:5$E$2 " X$WE4K"N
E$3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
 ’J2>2 ? 5?#@?] ?54?93" 9" @"95"
>93>E?3" @$K? :$5?N
 =9:$2>2 ? @>:5"K? 9" J"E?K 3$ ?J?:A
5$E>#$95" % A X$2:\$: *>$:$K $ 
X$2:\$: PK$p $ @2"E$3$2 ?" ?J?:A
5$E>#$95"N
1?2? ?: X$2:\$: 3>$:$K] ? 2$D$2[9A
E>? ! >93>E? " J"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$A
 .$2#>9?3" " ?J?:5$E>#$95"] ?9A
E>#$95" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ ’C)’ 5$: 3$ 2$#"X$2 ? @>:5"K?] ?a4?2A
HLN !": E?:" $# Z4$ "452" 5>@" 3?2 @$K" #$9": 7G :$a493": @?2?
3$ DK4>3"] 3>D$2$95$ 3" ’C)’ HL] @$2#>5>2 Z4$ " E"#J4:5WX$K DK4?
D"2 >952"34Y>3" 9" J"E?K 3$ ?J?:A 9" >95$2>"2 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"N
5$E>#$95" !] 3>2>a>2A:$ " >#$3>A
?5?#$95$ g   ! = , 
> N +:5$_? :$#@2$ ?5$95" ?"
 +# :$a4>3?] 2$5>2?2 ? @>:5"K? 3$
?J?:5$E>#$95" 3" J"E?K $ D$Eb?2
? 5?#@?N
"  !%!&
"  ! 
; !!  
 /!! CB0 /?
0
1?2? $D$54?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$
’2K? HL] @2"E$3$2 E"9D"2#$ >93>E?3"
? :$a4>2%
 +:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" $# 4#? :4A
@$2DWE>$ @K?9? $ 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2N
 ’J2>2 ? 5?#@? 3" J"E?K 3$ ?J?:A
5$E>#$95" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
 *$:?@$25?2 $ 2$#"X$2 ? 5?#@? 3"
J"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ ’2K?
HL !] E"2 ?Y4KN
 =9:$2>2 " J>E" 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"
9" J"E?KN
 12"E$3$2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95"N
 ’E"#@?9b?2 " 9WX$K 3" 2$:$2X?A
5h2>" @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ " #$:#"
52?9:J"23$N
 C$#"X$2 " J>E" 3$
?J?:5$E>#$95" 3" J"E?KN
 C$E"K"E?2 $ ?@$25?2 ? 5?#@? 3"
J"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ ’2K?
HL ’] E"2 ?Y4KN
 12$::>"9?2 $ :"K5?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$
" J"5<" 3$ @?25>3? 3" X$WE4K" 3$
D"2#? Z4$ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >aA
9>;<" D>Z4$ $# x+9a>9$z q9<" ^
9$E$::‘2>" K>a?2 " #"5"2 3" X$WA
E4K"rN
 ’a4?23?2 Z4$ ? K4YA$:@>? :$
?@?a4$N
 *?2 ? @?25>3? 9" #"5"2 3" X$WA
E4K"N

+X>5?2 4K52?@?::?2 " 9WX$K #‘p>#"
3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"
3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34A
;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q,8CrN
C$:@$>5$ :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$:
3$:5$ #?94?KN

!": E?:": $# Z4$ " ?J?:5$E>#$95"
:$_? 2$?K>Y?3" 3$X>3" ?" 2$:$2X?5h2>"
3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" ’C)’ HL $:A
5?2 X?Y>"] :$2‘ 9$E$::‘2>" " 2$?J?:5$A
E>#$95" #W9>#" 3$ :$>: K>52": q2$E"A
#$93?3" " ?J?:5$E>#$95" 5"5?K @?2?
#?>"2 ?45"9"#>?r $ ?a4?23?2 E$2E?
3$ 3">: #>945": ?5^ Z4$ ? K4YA$:@>?
:$ ?@?a4$ @?2? 3?2 @?25>3? 9" #"A
5"2N

’ E?@?E>3?3$ 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ’C)’ HL ^ 3$
7H K>52":N
!": E?:": $# Z4$ 2$?K>Y?2 " ?J?:A
5$E>#$95" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#?
3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3"
&
q’C)’ HLr] $9X?:?3"] 5"#?2 ?: :$A
a4>95$: @2$E?4;\$:%
 V$2>D>E?2 " @2?Y" 3$ X?K>3?3$ 3"
@2"345"N
 )$2 ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$: @2$:$95$:
9? $5>Z4$5? 3? $#J?K?a$# ?95$:
3$ >9>E>?2 " ?J?:5$E>#$95"N
 ’E"#@?9b?2 " 9WX$K 3" 2$:$2X?A
5h2>" @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ " #$:#"
52?9:J"23$N
1$,!

!#!
+X>5?2 4K52?@?::?2 " 9WX$K #‘p>#"
3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"
3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34A
;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q,8CrN
C$:@$>5$ :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$:
3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
+# E?:" 3$ 3$22?#?#$95" 3$
’C)’ HL $# ?Ka4# E"#@"9$95$
3" X$WE4K"] K?X?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?
2$a><" E"# ‘a4? E"22$95$N
(5>K>Y?2 #?5$2>?K ?J:"2X$95$ @?2?
2$E"Kb$2 " KWZ4>3" Z4$ 5$9b? E?W3"
9" :"K"N
!#!
8?:" " ’C)’ HL 5$9b? :>3" ?3>E>A
"9?3" $22"9$?#$95$ 9" 2$:$2X?5h2>"
1$,"
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > N
f >#@"25?95$ $:5?2 ?5$95" ?" ?J?:A
5$E$2 " 2$:$2X?5h2>"N
!#!
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWA
Z4>3" Z4$ @"::4? E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3>A
D$2$95$: 3?: $:@$E>D>E?3?: $o"4 3$A
a2?3?3"] @"3$ "E?:>"9?2 " ?E$93>A
#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>? 9" Z4?32" 3$
>9:524#$95"N
8"9:4K5?2 " E?@W54K" x8"9b$E$93"
" :$4 @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":z] :$A
;<" z)4Y$: 3$ ’3X$25[9E>?: $ &$9A
:?a$9:zN
!#!
!<" ?3>E>"9?2 ?3>5>X": $o"4 "452":
KWZ4>3": ?" ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3"
@?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q’C)’
HLrN
-452": KWZ4>3": 9<" $:@$E>D>E?3":
?3>E>"9?3": ?" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$
’C)’ HL @"3$# 3?9>D>E?2 " :>:5$#?N
!#!
+# E?:" 3$ 3?9": ?" :>:5$#? 3$
>9_$;<" 3$ ’C)’ HL @?2? 2$34;<" 3$
@"K4$95$: q,8Cr] 3$X>3" ? 45>K>Y?;<"
3$ @2"345": 9<" $:@$E>D>E?3": ? a?A
2?95>? :$2‘ ?94K?3?N
C$:@$>5$ :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$:
3$::$ #?94?KN
!#!
- 9WX$K 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ ’2K? HL]
X>:4?K>Y?3" ?52?X^: 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:A
524#$95" 3" X$WE4K" q#$94 t=9D" V$WA
E4K"tr 9<" ^ ?54?K>Y?3" :$ " X$WE4K"
$:5>X$2 $:5?E>"9?3" $# :4@$2DWE>$: >9A
EK>9?3?:N
+:5?E>"9$ $# K"E?K @K?9" @?2? Z4$
@"::? "E"22$2 ? ?54?K>Y?;<" 3" :>:A
5$#?N

!#!
!": E?:": $# Z4$ " 9WX$K ’C)’
HL $:5>X$2 J?>p"] " E"9345"2 :$2‘ >9A
D"2#?3" ?52?X^: 3" ?E$93>#$95" 3?
K4YA$:@>? ] _495?#$95$ E"# #$9A
:?a$# $:@$EWD>E? 3$ ?K$25?N 8"9:4K5?2
" E?@W54K" x8"9b$E$93" " :$4 @?>A
9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":z] :$;<" z)4Y$:
3$ ’3X$25[9E>?: $ &$9:?a$9:zN
- E"9:4#" 3" ?a$95$ 2$345"2
KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$:
q’C)’ HLr @"3$2‘ X?2>?2 3$ ?E"23"
E"# ?: E"93>;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3"
X$WE4K"N
!#!
,$ " ’C)’ HL @2$:$95$ 9" 2$:$2A
X?5h2>" :4@$2?Z4$E$2 ? #?>: 3$ 6G«
8 @"2 4# @$2W"3" @2"K"9a?3" 3$
5$#@" q3$X>3" ? >22?3>?;<" :"K?2 3>A
2$5?] @"2 $p$#@K"r] " #$:#" @"3$2‘
:$ 3$E"#@"2] @2"34Y>93" X?@"2$:
3$ ?#"9W?E" " Z4?K @"::4> 4# "3"2
D"25$N
+X>5?2 >9?K?2 $:5$: X?@"2$: ?" ?J2>2
? 5?#@? 3" J"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"N
!#!
- ’C)’ HL ^ E"9:>3$2?3" 4# @2"A
345" $:5‘X$K $ E"# K"9a? 342?;<"] :$
?2#?Y$9?3" $# 5$#@$2?542?: >9D$2>A
"2$: ? HL« 8N
,$a4>2 :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$:
@2$:$95$: 9? $5>Z4$5? 3? $#J?K?a$#
3" @2"345"N
 &  
1
%;  !!
!#!
- :>:5$#? ’B, E"# Z4$ " X$WE4K"
$:5‘ $Z4>@?3" 9<" E"952"K? " :>:5$#?
3$ D2$9?a$# 3" 2$J"Z4$N
’::>#] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 5$2 4# E4>A
3?3" $:@$E>?K $# :4@$2DWE>$: $:E"2A
2$a?3>?:N
!#!
!49E? #"3>D>E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ D2$A
9?a$# 3" X$WE4K" @?2? " E"#?93"
3" D2$>" 3" 2$J"Z4$N
- :>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$# 3" 2$J"A
Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ >93$A
@$93$95$ 3" :>:5$#? b>32‘4K>E" 3"
X$WE4K"N
&
!#!
’ ,.+))’!.=, 9<" :$ 2$:@"9:?J>A
K>Y? @$K? a?2?95>? 3$ @$;?: $ ?E$::hA
2>": 9<" a$94W9": >9:5?K?3": 9" X$WA
E4K"N
’ >9:5?K?;<" >9?3$Z4?3? 3$ @$;?:
$ ?E$::h2>": @"3$ ?E?22$5?2 3?9": g
E?22"E$2>?] 9<" :$93" @?::WX$>: 3$
E"J$2542? 3$ a?2?95>?N
1$,%


1?2? " 2$J"Z4$ 3$ ?52$K?3":] " X$WA
E4K" 3$X$ 5$2 4# a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$
b"#"K"a?3" $ 4# :>:5$#? $K^52>E"
?3$Z4?3"N ’ >9:5?K?;<" 3$X$ :$2 $D$A
54?3? @"2 @$::"?K $:@$E>?K>Y?3"N

1?2? ? >9:5?K?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$
2$J"Z4$] E"9:4K5?2 :$#@2$ ? K$a>:K?A
;<" X>a$95$N

&"95?2 $X$954?K#$95$ $:@$Kb":
2$52"X>:"2$: $:@$EWD>E": $o"4 :4@K$A
#$95?2$: 2$:@$>5?93" ? K$a>:K?;<"
X>a$95$N

C$E"23?2 Z4$ " 2$J"Z4$ 3$ 4#
?52$K?3" 2$34Y ? @"::>J>K>3?3$ #‘A
p>#? 3$ 4# X$WE4K" @?2? :4@$2?2 ?EK>A
X$:] ?4#$95? ": $:@?;": 3$ D2$9?a$9:
$ ": 5$#@": @?2? 4#? 4K52?@?::?a$#
:$#@2$ $# 2$K?;<" ?" @$:" 5"5?K 3"
#$:#"N
1$,&

!": @$2E42:": $# 3$:E>3?] $9a?5$
4#? #?2Eb? J?>p?] $# X$Y 3$ 4:?2
E"9:5?95$#$95$ " D2$>"N

- @$:" Z4$ " 2$J"Z4$ $p$2E$ 9"
a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ 3" X$WE4K"] 2$A
34Y $# >a4?>: X?K"2$: ? E?@?E>3?3$
3$ E?2a? 3" @2h@2>" X$WE4K"N 1"2 4#?
Z4$:5<" 3$ :$a42?9;? $ @?2? 9<" 4KA
52?@?::?2 " @$:" #‘p>#" 2$J"E‘X$K]
^ 9$E$::‘2>" 5$2 $# E"95? " @$:" 3"
2$J"Z4$ $# @K$9? E?2a?] >9EK4>93"
": ?E$::h2>": $ ?: J?a?a$9: @$::"?>:N

C$:@$>5?2 ": K>#>5$: 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
@?2? ": X$WE4K": E"# ?52$K?3":N +#
5"3" " E?:"] ? X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#?
9<" 3$X$ 4K52?@?::?2 ": 7GG i#obN

(# $X$954?K D2$>" $K^52>E" "4 "452"
q@"2 $pN a4>9Eb" $K^52>E"] $5ENr 3$X$
:$2 ?K>#$95?3" 3>2$5?#$95$ @$K? J?A
5$2>? ?52?X^: 3$ 4# E?J" E"# :$;<"
9<" >9D$2>"2 ? L]6 ##L N

’K^# 3?: 3$2>X?;\$: $K^52>E?: ^ ?3A
#>5>3" K>a?2 ?" :>:5$#? $K^52>E" 3"
X$WE4K" :h " E?J" @?2? ? ?K>#$95?A
;<" 3$ 4# $X$954?K D2$>" $K^52>E" $ "
E?J" @?2? 4#? Ke#@?3? 3$ >K4#>9?A
;<" >95$29? 3" ?52$K?3" E"# @"5[9E>?
9<" :4@$2>"2 ? 76 ¤N 1?2? ?: E"9$A
p\$: 45>K>Y?2 ? E$952?K @2^A>9:5?K?3?
E"# E?J" 3? J?5$2>? E"# :$;<" 9<"
>9D$2>"2 ? L]6 ## L N

=9:5?K?;\$: $K^52>E?: >22$a4K?2$:
$o"4 ?E$::h2>": E"# @"5[9E>?
:4@$2>"2 ?" $:@$E>D>E?3" @"3$#
"E?:>"9?2 E425"AE>2E4>5": $ >9E[93>"N

’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ E?2a?: ?4p>K>?2$:
3>D$2$95$: 3?: K4Y$: $p5$29?: q@"2 $pN
D2$>" $K^52>E"] a4>9Eb" $K^52>E"] $5ENr
3$X$ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? E"# " #"5"2 K>A
a?3"N
   3 (67   5   H
4.-   &
D(B D(D
- 2$J"Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 >9:5?K?3" 45>A 'G\[ !#!
K>Y?93" ? @2$3>:@":>;<" "2>a>9?K 9" * F~H F|7 F|7 1?2? >9:5?K?;<" @":5$2>"2 3" 3>:@"A
X$WE4K" @?2? 2$E$J$2 " 3>:@":>5>X"N :>5>X" 3$ :4@"25$ $ a4>9Eb"] @2"E42$
+ 7GG| MM6 MMG
!? >K4:52?;<" $:5<" ": @"95": 3$ D>A :$#@2$ ?   ! = ,  > :
P IMI IMI IMI
p?;<" Z4$ 3$X$# :$2 :$#@2$ 2$:@$>A C$:@$>5$ ": 3?3": E"9:5?95$: 9?:
5?3": 9? >9:5?K?;<" @":5$2>"2 3" 3>:A S ILI ILI ILI
>9:524;\$: 3$ #"95?a$#o>9:5?K?;<"
@":>5>X" 3$ 2$J"Z4$N T IM6 IM6 IM6 3" D?J2>E?95$ 3" :4@"25$ $ a4>9Eb"N
c 6H6 6H6 6H6 +# E?:" 3$ >9:5?K?;<" >9E"22$5? 3"
3>:@":>5>X"] b‘ 2>:E" 3$ ?E>3$95$N
{ 6F| 6F| 6F|

 ' K67  5- ,G

    
- E"9_495" 3$ :4@"25$ $ a4>9Eb" 
@"3$ :$2 >9:5?K?3" 9" X$WE4K" ? E2>A -: X$WE4K": D"2? 3$ $:52?3? :<"
5^2>" 3" @2"@2>$5‘2>"N ,$ D"2 9$E$:A E?2?E5$2>Y?3": @"2 4#? #?>"2 ?K542? &
:‘2>? ? :4? 45>K>Y?;<"] b‘ 4# K"E?K ?" :"K" $ @"2 4#? X>? @2"@"2E>"9?KA
_! / 0 ?@2"@2>?3" 9? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WA #$95$ 2$34Y>3?] @?2? 5"29‘AK": ?3$A
 H E4K"] 45>K>Y?93" ? #$:#? @2$3>:@":>A Z4?3": g: #?>: X?2>?3?: E"93>;\$:
 ;<" @?2? " 2$J"Z4$] @?2? 2$E$J$2 " Z4$ 3>:5>9a4$# ? E"934;<" D"2? 3$
 &
D(B D(D 3>:@":>5>X"N 1?2? 4#? 3$X>3? >9:5?K?A $:52?3?N
'G\[
;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ :4@"25$ $ a4>9A
’ 676 6GH 6GH ’: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ @2"_$5" D?Y$#
Eb" ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 3$:#"95?2 $ #"95?2
E"# Z4$ " :$4 E$952" 3$ a2?X>3?3$
B 6~6 6|H 6|H @$;?: 3" X$WE4K"] 3$::? D"2#?] ^ 9$A
:$_? #?>: ?K5" 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ?" 3":
8 FG~ 6MF 6MF
E$::‘2>" E"9b$E>#$95" 5^E9>E" $ D$2A
X$WE4K": 52?3>E>"9?>:N (#? 3?: X?9A
2?#$95?: $:@$E>?>:N
5?a$9: "D$2$E>3?: @$K? #?>"2 ?K542?
1$,’
?" :"K" ^ ? #$Kb"2 X>:>J>K>3?3$ 3? $:A
52?3?N
"!  "% :4@$2>"2 ?: I :$#?9?:% :$ ? @2$::<"
’ :$a4>2 :<" >93>E?3?: ?Ka4#?:
:4a$:5\$: u5$>: Z4$ @$2#>5$# "J5$2
4#? $E"9"#>? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K $ 4#?
E"95$9;<" 3?: $#>::\$: 9"E>X?:N
" - 67  *+,-'
’: E"93>;\$: 3$ #?945$9;<" 3"
X$WE4K" 2$@2$:$95?# 4# D?5"2 #4>5"
>#@"25?95$] Z4$ >9E>3$ 3>2$5?#$95$
:"J2$ " E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] ?
52?9Z4>K>3?3$ 3$ #?2Eb? $ ? @2h@2>?
X>3? u5>K 3" X$WE4K"N 1"2 $::$ #"5>X"]
^ "@"2549" E4>3?2 3? #?945$9;<" D?A
Y$93" E"# Z4$ " X$WE4K" @?::$ @$K?:
2$X>:\$: $ "@$2?;\$: 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2$X>:5?: 9" t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3?tN
1$,*
-
8"952"K?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$ ? @2$:A
:<" 3": @9$4: E"# 4# >95$2X?K" 9<"
$:5>X$2 #4>5" J?>p?] ": E"9:4#": ?4A
#$95?#] @"2Z4$ ? 2$:>:5[9E>? ?" 2"A
K?#$95" ^ #?>"2N
 5 b 
!<" X>?_?2 E"# " @"25?A#?K?: :"A
J2$E?22$a?3"N - @$:" 3" X$WE4K" $
" :$4 ?K>9b?#$95" >9DK4$9E>?# D"25$A
#$95$ ": E"9:4#": $ ? $:5?J>K>3?3$N
 &455 @  &.- 
C$5>2?2 " J?a?a$>2" "4 " @"25?A
$:Z4>: 3" 5$5" 3$@">: 3$ 45>K>Y?3":N
+:5$: ?E$::h2>": 3>#>94$# ? @$9$52?A
;<" ?$2"3>9e#>E? 3" X$WE4K"] 5$93"
4#? >9DK4[9E>? 9$a?5>X? 9": E"9:4A
#":N +# E?:" 3$ 52?9:@"25$ 3$ "JA
_$5": $:@$E>?K#$95$ X"K4#":":] 45>K>A
Y?2 3$ @2$D$2[9E>? 4# 2$J"Z4$N
    * '9 ,
(5>K>Y?2 ": 3>:@":>5>X": $K^52>E":
?@$9?: 342?95$ " 5$#@" 9$E$::‘2>"N
- X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"] ": D?2h>:
:4@K$#$95?2$:] ": K>#@?3"2$: 3":
X>32": $ ? X$95">9b? 3" :>:5$#?
3$ ?Z4$E>#$95"] ?J:"2X$# 4#?
9"5‘X$K Z4?95>3?3$ 3$ E"22$95$]
@2"X"E?93" @"2 E"9:$a4>95$ 4# ?4A
#$95" 3" E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K
q?5^ ¥L6s $# E>2E4K?;<" 42J?9?rN
'  K
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2 @2"A
X"E? 4# ?4#$95" 3": E"9:4#":%
Z4?93" ? 5$#@$2?542? $p5$29? " @$2A
#>5>2] 45>K>Y?2 3$ @2$D$2[9E>? ? :>#A
@K$: X$95>K?;<"N
!,Q    ] ,
- 4:" 3$ ?E$::h2>": ?$2"3>9e#>A
E":] 9<" E$25>D>E?3": @?2? 5?K D>#]
@"3$ @2$_43>E?2 ? ?$2"3>9e#>E? $ ":
E"9:4#":N
  
  * 67
!<" 3$>p?2 ?Z4$E$2 " #"5"2 E"#
" X$WE4K" @?2?3" 9$# $# #?2Eb?
K$95?] 9$# $# 2$a>#$ $K$X?3"% 9$:A
5?: E"93>;\$:] " #"5"2 ?Z4$E$ #4>5"
#?>: K$95?#$95$] ?4#$95?93" ":
E"9:4#": $ ?: $#>::\$:N f ?E"9:$A
Kb‘X$K @?25>2 K"a" $ K$95?#$95$] $X>A
5?93" 2$a>#$: $K$X?3":] 3$:5$ #"3"]
" #"5"2 ?Z4$E$2‘ #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$N
" 4  b 
+X>5?2 ?E$K$2?2 Z4?93" $:5>X$2 @?A
2?3" 9": :$#‘D"2": "4 ?95$: 3$ 3$:A
K>a?2 " #"5"2N +:5? uK5>#? #?9"J2?]
E"#" 5?#J^# ? t34@K? $#J2$?a$#t]
:<" >9u5$>: $ @2"X"E?# ?4#$95" 3":
E"9:4#": $ 3? @"K4>;<"N
 ,   ,G
.<" K"a" ?: E"93>;\$: 3" 52e9:>5"
" @$2#>5?#] 45>K>Y?2 ?: #?2Eb?: #?>:
?K5?:N - 4:" 3$ #?2Eb?: J?>p?: @?2?
"J5$2 4#? J"? 2$:@":5? 3" #"5"2
@2"X"E? ?4#$95" >9$X>5‘X$K 3" E"9A
:4#"N *? #$:#? D"2#?] ? >9:>:5[9E>?
$# #?95$2 #?2Eb?: ?K5?: $# 52$Eb":
3$ J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$] ?K^# 3$ ?4#$9A
5?2 " E"9:4#" $ ? $#>::<" 3$ @"K4A
$95$:] ?E$K$2? " 3$:a?:5$ 3" #"5"2N
',  P(  #$95$ " E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] ?:
- E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K ?4A
#$95? @2"@"2E>"9?K#$95$ $# 2$K?A
;<" g X$K"E>3?3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" 3$A
:$9X"KX$d E"#" $p$#@K"] @"3$A:$
3>Y$2 Z4$ @?::?93" 3$ MG ? 7LG
i#ob] " >9E2$#$95" 3$ E"9:4#" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K ^ 3$ ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$
HGsN
.$95?2 #?95$2 4#? X$K"E>3?3$ 49>A
D"2#$] 3$952" 3" @"::WX$K] $X>5?93"
D2$?3?: $ 2$5"#?3?: 3$:9$E$::‘2>?:]
Z4$ E"9:"#$# E"#J4:5WX$K $ ?4A
#$95?#] :>#4K5?9$?#$95$] ? $#>:A
:<" 3$ @"K4$95$:N ’E"9:$Kb?A:$ ?
?3"5?2 4# #"3" 3$ 3>2>a>2 @243$95$]
52?5?93" 3$ ?95$E>@?2 ?: #?9"J2?:
@?2? $X>5?2 @$2>a" >#>9$95$ $ 3$ 2$:A
@$>5?2 ? 3>:5e9E>? 3$ :$a42?9;? $# 2$A
K?;<" ?": X$WE4K": Z4$ 52?D$a?# K"a"
? D2$95$N
!,' 67
’E$K$2?2 3$ D"2#? X>"K$95?] >934A
Y>93" " #"5"2 ? D49E>"9?2 $# 2"A
5?;\$: $K$X?3?:] @$9?K>Y? 9"5?X$KA
$#>::\$: 3$ @"K4$95$: $ ? @2h@2>? 34A
2?J>K>3?3$ 3" #$:#"d E"9X^# ?E$K$A
2?2 a2?34?K#$95$ $ 9<" 4K52?@?::?2 "
2$a>#$ 3$ 5"2Z4$ #‘p>#" 3" #"5"2N
  6H  - ' K67
.2?_$5": #4>5" E425": $ @?25>3?: D2$A
Z4$95$: E"# " #"5"2 D2>" 9<" @$2#>A
5$# Z4$ " #"5"2 ?5>9_? ? 5$#@$2?542?
>3$?K 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"] ?K^# 3$ :>aA
9>D>E?2 4# >9E2$#$95" 3$ E"9:4#"
$ 3$ $#>::<" 3$ :4J:5e9E>?: 9"E>X?:
3? "23$# 3$ 76 ? HGsN &
 -67   ]    ,  67 
*    
- E"9:4#" $K$X?3" 3$ E"#J4:A
5WX$K $:5‘ K>a?3" 3>2$5?#$95$ ? :>54A
?;\$: 3$ 52e9:>5" >95$9:"] :"J2$543"
9?: a2?93$: E>3?3$:] "93$ :$ 52?D$a?
342?95$ ? #?>"2 @?25$ 3" 5$#@" 45>A
K>Y?93" #?2Eb?: J?>p?: $ ?: @?2?3?:
$# :$#‘D"2": :<" #4>5" D2$Z4$95$:N
1$,+
 .?#J^# ": @$2E42:": :>94":":]
E"#" $:52?3?: 3$ #"95?9b?] "4
52$Eb": $# #?4 $:5?3" 3$ E"9:$2X?A
;<"] >9DK4$9E>?# 9$a?5>X?#$95$ "
E"9:4#"N
  -  - 6H   ]  :
*42?95$ ?: @?2?3?: @2"K"9a?3?:]
#"5>X?3?: @"2 52e9:>5" >95$22"#@>3"]
" #$Kb"2 ? D?Y$2 ^ 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2N
!   !! $:@?;": D$Eb?3":N

f $p52$#?#$95$ @$2>a":" 3$>p?2
E2>?9;?: 9" >95$2>"2 3" X$WE4K" $:5?E>A
"9?3" Z4?93" ? 5$#@$2?542? $p5$2>"2
D"2 #4>5" $K$X?3?N - E?K"2 9" >95$2>"2
3" b?J>5‘E4K" @"3$ 5$2 E"9:$Z4[9A
E>?: a2?X$: "4 #$:#" #"25?>:N

!49E? X>?_?2 9" X<" 3$ E?2a? >9A
5$29"N +# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$] $X$954A
?>: @$::"?: Z4$ :$ $9E"952$# 9" >9A
5$2>"2 3" @"25?A#?K?: $:5?2>?# #?>:
1$,,
$p@":5?: ?" 2>:E" 3$ K$:\$: a2?X$: "4
#$:#" #"25?>:N

8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 5"3": ": "E4A
@?95$: 3" X$WE4K" 4:$# E"22$5?#$95$
": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? $ Z4$ $X$954A
?>: E2>?9;?: $:5<" E"22$5?#$95$ @":>A
E>"9?3?: 9?: 2$:@$E5>X?: E?3$>2>9b?:N
!   !"!
’ >95$2X$9;<" 3": ?>2J?a: @"3$
:$2 @$2>a":? @?2? 4# ?9>#?K Z4$ :$
$9E"952$ 9" J?9E" 3>?95$>2"N ’::>#]
^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K E"K"E?2 ": ?9>#?>: 9"
J?9E" 52?:$>2"] 9" >95$2>"2 3$ a?>"K?:
?3$Z4?3?: 2$5>3?: @$K": E>95": 3$
:$a42?9;? 3" X$WE4K"N
’K^# 3>::"] K$#J2$A:$ ?>93? Z4$]
$# E?:" 3$ D2$9?a$# J24:E? "4 3$
?E>3$95$] 4# ?9>#?K 9<" ?3$Z4?3?A
#$95$ 2$5>3" @"3$2>? :$2 @2"_$5?3"
@?2? " >95$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K"] E"# "
2>:E" 3$ :$ D$2>2 $ D$2>2 ": "E4@?95$:
3" X$WE4K"N
!  !!
’: $#>::\$: 3? 3$:E?2a? :<" #4>5"
@$2>a":?: $ @"3$# :$2 K$5?>:N *$
D?5"] E"95[# #"9hp>3" 3$ E?2J"9"]
4# a‘: >9E"K"2 $ >9"3"2" Z4$] :$
>9?K?3"] @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3$:#?>": $
$9X$9$9?#$95":N
1?2? $X>5?2 >9?K?2 " #"9hp>3" 3$
E?2J"9"] :$a4>2 ?: >93>E?;\$: ?J?>p"%
 !<" #?95$2 " #"5"2 K>a?3" $#
 ,$] @"2 Z4?KZ4$2 #"5>X" q@"2 $pN
52?9:@"25$ 3$ E?2a?: X"K4#":?:r]
D"2 9$E$::‘2>" E"934Y>2 E"# ?
5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: ?J$25?] D$A
Eb?2 5"3": ": X>32": $ ?5>X?2 ?
X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? 3" X$95>K?A
3"2 3" EK>#?5>Y?3"2N !0- ?5>X?2
? #"3?K>3?3$ 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3$
?2N
 8?:" :$_? >93>:@$9:‘X$K @$2#?A
9$E$2 ? J"23" 3" X$WE4K" @?2?3"
E"# " #"5"2 K>a?3"] 2$a4K?2 " :>:A
5$#? 3$ X$95>K?;<"o?Z4$E>#$95"
$ ?E>"9?2 " X$95>K?3"2 3$ #"3"
? >952"34Y>2 ?2 $p5$29" 9" b?J>5‘A
 E4K"N ’5>X?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#?
3" X$95>K?3"2N
(#? #?945$9;<" ?3$Z4?3? 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ 3$:E?2a? E"9:5>54> ? #$A
Kb"2 @2"5$;<" E"952? >9D>K52?;\$: 3$
#"9hp>3" 3$ E?2J"9" 9" b?J>5‘E4K"N
,$ D"2 3$5$E5?3" 4# 24W3" ?9hA
#?K" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 3$:E?2a?] ? @2$A
:$9;? 3$ a?:$: 3$ 3$:E?2a? 9" >9A
5$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K"] "4 :$ ? E?22"A
E$2>? "4 ? @?25$ 52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"
$:5>X$2$# 3?9>D>E?3?:] #?93?2 X$2>A
D>E?2 5"3" " :>:5$#? 3$ 3$:E?2a? $
?: 2$a>\$: 3? E?22"E$2>? ?3_?E$95$:
@?2? >3$95>D>E?2 $X$954?>: E"#@"9$9A
5$: @?25>3":] 3?9>D>E?3":] 3$5$2>"2?A
3": "4 Z4$ 5$9b?# :"D2>3" 3$:K"E?A
#$95": 2$K?5>X": g @":>;<" 3$ #"9A
5?a$# E"22$5?N 1?2? $:5?: "@$2?;\$:]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > :
,"K3?: ?J$25?: "4 E"9$p\$: 3$:?A
@$25?3?: @"3$# @$2#>5>2 >9D>K52?;\$:
3$ a?:$: 3$ 3$:E?2a? 9" >95$2>"2 3"
b?J>5‘E4K"N
V$2>D>E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ 3$:E?2a?
:$#@2$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" D"2 $K$X?3"
@?2? "@$2?;\$: 3$ K4J2>D>E?;<" "4
3$ :4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$"N ,4J:5>54>2 ":
E"#@"9$95$: E"9D"2#$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
1?2? $:5?: "@$2?;\$:] 3>2>a>2A:$ g
  ! = ,  > N
? !! ! 
!  !!
 ' K67   67 5 ' /DR
R0
*42?95$ ? E"934;<" D"2? 3$ $:A
52?3?] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" I¤* )-¤]
:$ $Z4>@?3"] 9" 3>:@":>5>X" ,$K$EA
.$22?>9£ @?2? "J5$2 4#? #?>"2 52?A
;<" $ 4# #?>"2 E"952"K$ $# 5$2A
2$9": $:E"22$a?3>": "4 >9?E$::WX$>:]
$# 3$:E>3? "4 $# :4J>3? $# >9EK>A
9?;\$: $ @?2? ?4#$95?2 ? 52?;<" ?
J?>p?: X$K"E>3?3$:N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$:5? #"3?K>3?3$
3$X$ $:5?2 K>#>5?3? ? :>54?;\$:
$p52$#?:] E"#" 9$X$] K?#?] ?2$>?]
>:5" ^] Z4?93" ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 3>:@"2
3$ 4#? #?>"2 @"5[9E>? 3$ 2$J"Z4$
? J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$N
 *   ,Q 5  P  '5&

’@$:?2 3? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K"
?52?X$::?2 E42:": 3$ ‘a4? $ 3$5$2A
#>9?3?: ‘2$?: E"# ?K?a?#$95" 9<"
#4>5" @2"D493?: ^ $p52$#?#$95$ >#A
@"25?95$ 2$:@$>5?2 ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$:
3$:5$ #?94?K] ?::># E"#" " J"#
:$9:" $# 2$K?;<" g :>54?;<" X>X$9E>A
?3?N
f 9$E$::‘2>" 2$:@$>5?2 ?: 2$E"#$9A
3?;\$: $ ?: E"93>;\$: 3? X>?] @?2?
$X>5?2 3?9": #?5$2>?>: $] @2>9E>@?KA
#$95$] a?2?95>2 ? :$a42?9;? 3": "E4A
@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"N
)$>? ?5$95?#$95$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
&
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?K @?2? $p$E4;<"
3$::$ 5>@" 3$ #?9"J2?N
-@5?93" " E"9345"2 @"2 52?D$a?2
@"2 4# K"E?K ?K?a?3" "4 ?52?X$::?2
4# Eh22$a"] >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?@h: ?
52?X$::>?] :$2‘ 9$E$::‘2>? ? X$2>D>E?A
;<" 3$ 5"3": ": 9WX$>: 3": KWZ4>3":
3": 2$:$2X?5h2>": 3" X<" #"5"2N
(5>K>Y?2 " X$WE4K" @?2? ?52?X$::?2
‘2$?: ?K?a?3?: "4 Eh22$a": @"3$ @2"A
1$,-
X"E?2 3?9": 9<" E"J$25": @$K? a?2?9A
5>?N

’95$: 3$ D?Y$2 ? 52?X$::>? "J:$2X$
?5$95?#$95$ ? D"2;? 3? E"22$95$Y? $ ?
@2"D493>3?3$ 3? ‘a4?N .2?D$a?2 E"#
" X$WE4K" @"2 K"E?>: ?K?a?3": "4 Eh2A
2$a": ^ ?K5?#$95$ ?22>:E?3"] >9EK4A
:>X$ @?2? ? :?u3$ DW:>E? 3": "E4@?9A
5$:] ?K^# 3$ @"3$2 E?4:?2 :^2>": 3?A
9": ?" X$WE4K"N
8"22$95$Y?: #4>5" D"25$:] ?>93?
Z4$ @"4E" @2"D493?:] @"3$# ?22?:A
5?2 " X$WE4K" D?Y$93"A" @$23$2 52?;<"
$ K$X?93"A" @?2? K"E?>: E"# #?>"2
@2"D493>3?3$] D?E>K>5?93" ? ?J:"2;<"
3? ‘a4? @$K" #"5"2 3" X$WE4K"N
*$ D"2#? ?Ka4#? " #"5"2 @"3$
?3#>5>2 ‘a4? :"J @$9? 3$ E?K;" b>A
32‘4K>E" $ E"9:$Z4$95$ 52?X?#$95"
$ Z4$J2? 3$ E"#@"9$95$: >95$29":]
E?4:?93" @?2?3? >#$3>?5?N .?K :>54?A
;<" 9<" ^ E"J$25? @$K? a?2?95>?N
-J:$2X$ ?5$95?#$95$ ?: 2$E"#$9A
3?;\$: 3$:E2>5?: ? :$a4>2] J$# E"#"
?9?K>:$ ?5$95?#$95$ ?: E"93>;\$: 3?
1$-.
X>?] ?95$: 3$ ?52?X$::?2 Eh22$a": "4
‘2$?: ?K?a?3?:%
 ’ @2"D493>3?3$ % #‘p>#? 3$
‘a4? @?2? 52?9:@"2 52$Eb": ?K?A
a?3": ^ 3$ ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ I~
E# q? 2$D$2[9E>? 3$ ?K542? 3" :"K"
@"3$ X?2>?2 3$ ?E"23" E"# ? X$2A
:<" 3" X$WE4K"rN +# E?:" 3$ ‘a4?
E"22$95$ $X>5$ @2"D493>3?3$: :4A
@$2>"2$: ? LL E#N -J:$2X$ Z4$
Z4?95" #?>: E?22$a?3"] #$9"2
:$2‘ ? ?K542? 3$ :"K" 3" X$WE4K"N ’
E?2a? #‘p>#? 2$E"#$93?3? @?2?
52?X$::>? 3$ 52$Eb": ?K?a?3": $
Eh22$a": ^ 3$ LIG ia] Z4$ $Z4>A
X?K$ ? ?@2"p>#?3?#$95$ ? :"#?A
5h2>? 3": @$:": 3" #"5"2>:5?] 4#
q7r @?::?a$>2" $ #?>: |G ia 3$
J?a?a$9:N
 *$D>9? 4#? 2$D$2[9E>? 9"
@?2?AEb"Z4$ $ 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?:
@?2? Z4$ 342?95$ ? @?::?a$#
@"::? E"9D$2>2 ? @2"D493>3?3$ 3?
‘a4?N 1"2 #$3>3? 3$ :$a42?9;?]
2$E"#$93?A:$ Z4$ ? ?K542?
#‘p>#? 3? ‘a4? 9" #"#$95"
3? 52?X$::>? 9<" E4J2? ": D?2h>:
3$ 9$JK>9? ] >9:5?K?3": 9"
@?2?AEb"Z4$ 3>?95$>2" 3"
X$WE4K"N

’ ?K542? 3" :"K" X?2>? E"9D"2#$ ?
X$2:<" 3" X$WE4K"] @"3$93" ?K5$2?2 ?
>93>E?;<" :4a$2>3? 9? >K4:52?;<" ?9A
5$2>"2N 8$25>D>Z4$A:$ :"J2$ " @"95" 3$
2$D$2[9E>? 3$ ?K542? 3" :"K" E"9D"2#$
? X$2:<" 3$ :$4 X$WE4K"N
 ’5$95$A:$ g :>54?;<" X>X$9E>?3?
$] $:@$E>?K#$95$] g: E"93>;\$:
3? X>?N
 ’5$95$A:$ @?2? ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3?
E"22$95$Y?] @">: #$:#" :$93"
$# J?>p? @2"D493>3?3$ ? ‘a4?
@"3$2‘ :4J>2 @$K" @?2?AEb"Z4$
?5^ 4#? ?K542? :4@$2>"2 ?" K>#>5$
 #‘p>#"] @"::>J>K>5?93" ? ?J:"2A
;<" 3$ ‘a4? @$K" #"5"2 3" X$WA
E4K"N
 ’ X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? ?" 52?D$a?2
@"2 Eh22$a":] ‘2$?: ?K?a?3?: "4
$9Eb$95$: 3$X$ :$2 3$ ~ i#obN
 (5>K>Y?2 ? 7 #?2Eb?N +# Ee#J>":
?45"#‘5>E": :$K$E>"9?2 " #"3"
#?94?K @?2? ?E>"9?2 ? 7ƒ #?2Eb?N
 !<" #43?2 3$ #?2Eb? 342?95$
? @?::?a$# @"2 Eh22$a":] ‘2$?:
?K?a?3?: "4 $9Eb$95$:N
 !<" ?E$K$2?2 3$#?:>?3?#$95$ "
X$WE4K"N (#? #?>"2 ?E$K$2?;<"
@"3$2‘ "E?:>"9?2 @$23? 3$ 52?A
;<"] ?4#$95" 3?: X$K"E>3?3$ $
2"5?;<"N ’ #?>"2 2"5?;<" 3" #"A
5"2] @"2 :4? X$Y] ?4#$95? ? :4EA
;<" 3$ ?2 $ ? @2"J?J>K>3?3$ 3$
>9a$:5<" 3$ ‘a4?] ?E?22$5?93" :^A
2>": 3?9": ?" #"5"2 3" X$WE4K"]
": Z4?>: 9<" :$2<" E"J$25": @$K?
a?2?95>?N
 1?2? X$WE4K": IpI] :$K$E>"9?2
? #"3?K>3?3$ ?3$Z4?3? I¤*
)-¤ 342?95$ ? @?::?a$# @"2
Eh22$a":] ‘2$?: ?K?a?3?: "4
$9Eb$95$:N
 ’95$: 3$ D?Y$2 ? @?::?a$# @$K?
‘2$? ?K?a?3?] Eh22$a" "4 $9Eb$9A
5$: X$2>D>Z4$ @2$X>?#$95$ " E?#>A
9b" ? :$2 @$2E"22>3"] @">: >22$A
a4K?2>3?3$: 9" @>:" @"3$2<" ?4A
#$95?2 ? @2"D493>3?3$ >9$:@$2?A
3?#$95$N V$2>D>Z4$ 5?#J^# :$
$p>:5$# "J:5‘E4K": >9:52?9:@"9WA
X$>: :4J#$2:":] E"#" 52"9E": 3$
‘2X"2$ $ @$32?:N !<" :$93" @":A
:WX$K ?X?K>?2 ?: 2$?>: E"93>;\$:
3? X>?] 2$E"#$93?A:$ 9<" D?Y$2 ?
:4? 52?X$::>?] :"J @$9? 3? "E"2A
2[9E>? 3$ 3?9": 9" #"5"2] ?::>#
E"#" 2>:E" g :?u3$ $ :$a42?9;?
3": "E4@?95$: 3" X$WE4K"N
 ’ D"2#?;<" 3$ "93?: @"3$ ?4A
#$95?2 ? @2"D493>3?3$ ?K^# 3":
I~ E# @?2? ‘a4? @?2?3?: $ LL E#
@?2? E"22$95$Y?:N ’a4?23$ ? ‘a4?
$:5?J>K>Y?2 @?2? D?Y$2 ? @?::?a$#N
 *42?95$ ? 52?X$::>?] $# 9$9b4#?
b>@h5$:$ ? ‘a4? @"3$2‘ @?::?2 @$A
K?: ?J$2542?: 3?: a2?3$: :4@$2>"2
$ E$952?K ! 3" @?2?AEb"Z4$ 3>A
?95$>2" qV$2 >#?a$# 9? @‘a>9?
?95$2>"2rN

+# E?:" 3$ $9Eb$95$: E"# 2‘@>3? $
>#@2$X>:5? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ ?4#$95"
3$ @2"D493>3?3$ 3? ‘a4? $ D"2#?;<"
3$ E"22$95$Y?] @?2? a?2?95>2 ? :$a4A
2?9;? DW:>E? 3": "E4@?95$: ^ 2$E"A
#$93?3" 9<" D?Y$2 ? 52?X$::>? 3" K"A
E?KN !$::?: :>54?;\$: E"934Y? " X$WA
E4K" @?2? 4# K"E?K :$a42" $ ?a4?23$
? 3>#>94>;<" 3" 9WX$K 3$ ‘a4? @?2?
>9>E>?2 ? 52?X$::>?N
 -67 , *@' @  
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ 4#? $:@$::? E?A
#?3? 3$ 9$X$] K?#? "4 ?2$>?] :$ :$
$:5>X$2 52?9:@"25?93" 4#? E?2a? "4
:$ @2$5$93$2 5$2 #$Kb"2 E"952"K$ 3"
X$WE4K" ? J?>p?: X$K"E>3?3$:] $9a?A &
5?2 4#? #?2Eb? J?>p? $] :$ 9$E$:A
:‘2>"] :$K$E>"9?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$ 3"
:>:5$#? I¤* ?3$Z4?3? ?" 5$22$9"
$# Z4$:5<" ?54?93" 9" 3>:@":>5>X"
,$K$EA.$22?>9£N
1?2? #?95$2 ? 3>2$;<" 3" X$WE4K"]
9<" 2$34Y>2 ? #?2Eb? #?>: 3" Z4$ "
9$E$::‘2>"N
1$-!
 -67  -4 
!#!
,$ " #"5"2 3$:K>a?2] " X$WE4K" X>2?2
"4 9<" :$ E"9:$a4>2 ?X?9;?2 $# #?2A
Eb? 2$5>KW9$? 9? @?25$ ?K5? 3? #"95?A
9b? "4 3$ 4#? $:52?3? $# >9EK>9?A
;<"] 949E? 5$95?2 $D$54?2 4#? >9X$2A
:<" 3$ #?2Eb?N
+:5? "@$2?;<" @2"X"E?2>? " E?@"A
5?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N C$E4?2 9" 52$A
Eb" $# >9EK>9?;<" @2"E$3$93" E"#
" #‘p>#" E4>3?3"] E"K"E?93" ? ?K?A
X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<" 3$ #?2A
Eb? ? 2^N !<" @$2E"22$2 4#? >9EK>A
9?;<" $# 3$:E>3? E"# " Ee#J>" $#
@"95" #"25" $ ?@$9?: E"# " 4:" 3"
D2$>"N
’95$: 3$ $9D2$95?2 4#? :4J>3?] X$A
2>D>E?2 ?: E"93>;\$: 3" 5"@" $o"4
3" "452" K?3"N ’95$: 3$ $9D2$9A
5?2 4#? :4J>3? E"# D"25$ >9EK>9?;<"]
E"K"E?2 ?: #43?9;?: 94#? #?2Eb?
#?>: J?>p? $ :$K$E>"9?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$
I¤* )-¤N
1$-"
+# :4J>3?: @?25>E4K?2#$95$ ?E$9A
54?3?:] $9a?5?2 ? 7ƒ #?2Eb? $ :$K$E>A
"9?2 ? #"3?K>3?3$ I¤* )-¤N

,$ " X$WE4K" 3$:K>a?2] "4 @$23$2
D"2;? #"52>Y 94#? E"K>9? ?E$954?3?]
$9a?5?2 " #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$ @"::WA
X$K ? #?2Eb? ? 2^] @2"E42?93" 2$5"A
#?2 t#"52>E>3?3$o ?3$2[9E>?t g: 2"A
3?:] $X>5?93" 5?95" Z4?95" @"::WX$K
>95$2X$9;\$: J24:E?: 9": D2$>": $ 9"
X"K?95$ $ #?95$93" 4#? 52?_$5h2>?
?3$Z4?3?N C$E4?2 K$95?#$95$ $#
3$:E>3?] #?95$93" :"J E"952"K$ ?
X$K"E>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" ?@$9?: E"# ?
?;<" 3" D2$>" 3" #"5"2N ,$] @?2? #?9A
5$2 " E"952"K$ 3" X$WE4K"] D"2 9$E$:A
:‘2>" 2$E"22$2 ?": D2$>":] ?@K>E?2 4#?
@2$::<" a2?34?K $ $X>5?2 JK"Z4$?2 "4
D?Y$2 @?5>9?2 ?: 2"3?:N !49E? @2"E$A
3$2 9? 3>?a"9?K $# 52$Eb": $# :4A
J>3? "4 $# 3$:E>3?] 52?D$a4$ :$#A
@2$ $# 3>2$;<" 2$5>KW9$?N ,$ ?: 2"3?:
@$23$2$# ?3$2[9E>? $9Z4?95" $:5>X$2
:$ ?@2"p>#?93" 3" 5"@" 3$ 4#? :4A
J>3?] 3$:?E$K$2?2 $ #?95$2 ? #?2Eb?
E"9:5?95$ X>2?93" K$95?#$95$ ?: 2"A
3?: 3>?95$>2?: @?2? ? $:Z4$23? $ @?2?
? 3>2$>5?N +:5? #?9"J2? D?X"2$E$ ?
?3$2[9E>? $ ?::$a42? ? 52?;<" 9$E$:A
:‘2>? @?2? E"#@K$5?2 ? :4J>3?N
 -67  , 
8"K"E?2 4#? #?2Eb? J?>p? $ "
:>:5$#? I¤* 9? #"3?K>3?3$ I¤*
)-¤ "4 :$K$E>"9?2 " :>:5$#? T*8N
*$>p?2 Z4$ " X$WE4K" 3$:;? K$95?A
#$95$ ?" K"9a" 3? >9EK>9?;<" $ Z4$
?: Z4?52" 2"3?: :>95?# ? ?;<" 3$ D2$A
9?a$# 3" #"5"2N *$:5$ #"3"] :$2‘
@"::WX$K #?95$2 :"J E"952"K$ ? X$K"A
E>3?3$ $ ? 3>2$;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
w4?93" :$ @$2E"22$# 3$:E>3?: $#
#"95?9b?:] ? ?;<" 2$@$5>3? 9": D2$>":
@"3$ @2"X"E?2 " :$4 :"J2$?Z4$E>A
#$95" ?5^ E"#@2"#$5$2 5"5?K#$95$ ?
$D>E‘E>? 3? ?;<" 3$ D2$9?a$#N +X>5?2]
:$ @"::WX$K] D2$9?a$9: J24:E?: "4 2$A
@$5>3?: 2$34Y>93" ?: X$K"E>3?3$:N
! Q  , -67   ,G 3 
  
-: @$2E42:": D"2? 3$ $:52?3? :4A
_$>5?# " X$WE4K" ? :"K>E>5?;\$: :4@$A
2>"2$: gZ4$K?: ? Z4$ $:5?2>? :4_$>5"
$# $:52?3?: 9"2#?>:N *$@">: 3$ $D$A
54?2 4# @$2E42:" D"2? 3$ $:52?3?]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" 9<" :"A
D2$4 3?9":N +# @?25>E4K?2] X$2>D>E?2 "
:$a4>95$%
!#!
’ @2$:$9;? 3$ #?5$2>?K ?J2?:>X"
9": D2$>": @"3$ @2"X"E?2 4# 3$:a?:5$
$pE$::>X" "4 E"#@2"#$5$2 " :$4 E"2A
2$5" D49E>"9?#$95"N
,$ " X$WE4K" 5>X$2 :>3" E"934Y>3"
$# ?#J>$95$: @?25>E4K?2#$95$ @"$>A
2$95":] #?93?2 X$2>D>E?2 ": D2$>": $
K>#@‘AK":] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"N
 =9:@$E>"9?2 E4>3?3":?#$95$ ?
@?25$ 3? E?22"E$2>? 3" X$WE4K"N
V$2>D>E?2 ": @9$4:] ? $:524542?
3? E?22"E$2>?] ? 3>2$;<"] ?:
:4:@$9:\$: $ " :>:5$#? 3$
3$:E?2a? @?2? 3$5$E5?2 $X$954?>:
3?9":N
 =9:@$E>"9?2 " 2?3>?3"2 @?2?
>3$95>D>E?2 $X$954?>: 2$:W34": 3$
K?#? $o"4 3$52>5":% :$ @2$:$95$:]
2$#"X[AK":N
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ": $K$#$95":
3$ D>p?;<" q@?2?D4:":] E?X>Kb?:r
3": E"#@"9$95$: 3? 52?9:#>::<"]
3? 3>2$;<"] 3?: :4:@$9:\$: $ 3"
Eb?::>: 9<" $:5<" 3$:?@$25?3":%
:$ $:5>X$2$#] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > :
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ 9<"
@$2#?9$;?# $92":E?3?: @K?95?:
"4 ?2J4:5":% 3$ D?5"] @"3$2>?#
>9E$93>?2A:$ "4 @2"X"E?2
$X$954?>: 3?9": 9?: 54J4K?;\$:]
9?: a4?29>;\$: $ 9" $>p" 3$
52?9:#>::<"N
 ’@h: 4#? 45>K>Y?;<" @2"K"9a?3?
$# 5$22$9": K?#?E$95":] ?2$9"A
:":] E"# E42:": 3$ ‘a4? "4 :>A
#>K?2$:] X$2>D>E?2 $ K>#@?2 " #?>:
2?@>3?#$95$ @"::WX$K " 2?3>?3"2] &
? X$95">9b?] ": 3>:E": $ ?: @?:5>A
Kb?: 3": D2$>":] ?: E"93>;\$: 3":
@9$4:N
 ,$] ?@h: ? 45>K>Y?;<" $# 5$22$9":
K?#?E$95":] K"3":": "4 :>#>K?2$:]
:$ :$95>2$# X>J2?;\$:] E$25>D>Z4$A
:$ 3$ Z4$ 9?: 2"3?: 9<" D>E?#
@2$:": E"2@": $:52?9b": Z4$ @"A
3$2>?# E"#@2"#$5$2 " :$4 $Z4>A
KWJ2>"N
1$-%
1
      
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA7
)(Q+, *+ ’*V+C.l!8=’ *+ 1+C=S- N N N N N N N SA7
,(B,.=.(=/0- *+ )⁄&1’*’, N N N N N N N N N N SAF
P(,mV+=, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA7I
.C-8’ *+ 1!+(, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SALI
1’C.=*’ *- &-.-C 8-& B’.+C=’
’(¡=)=’C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAHL
,=,.+&’ *+ 8-C.+ *+ 8-&B(,.mV+) N N N N N SAH6
,+ - &-.-C ,(1+C’w(+8+C N N N N N N N N N N SAH|
’)’V’!8’ *- 8⁄&B=- ’(.-&“.=8- N N N N SAH|
)=B+C’!*- (& V+m8()- 1C+,- N N N N N N N N SAH~
C+B-8’!*- - V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N SAHM
+¡.=!.-C *+ =!8l!*=-, N N N N N N N N N N N N SAIH

2
2
 
(# @9$4 D42?3" "4 4#? Ke#@?3?
Z4$>#?3?fl
1"3$ ?E"95$E$2 Z4$ ?Ka49: >9E"9A
X$9>$95$: @$2542J$# ? 9"::? X>?a$#N
’: @‘a>9?: 3$3>E?3?: g $#$2a[9A
E>? @"3$# :$2 3$ ?_43? @?2? $9D2$95?2
52?9Z4>K?#$95$ ?: :>54?;\$: E2W5>E?:N
+# :>54?;\$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] ^
?E"9:$Kb‘X$K K>a?2 @?2? " 9u#$2"
>93>E?3" 9" )>X2" 3$ S?2?95>?N
f 5?#J^# @"::WX$K K>a?2 @?2? " 9uA
#$2" 49>X$2:?K] 9?E>"9?K "4 >95$29?A
E>"9?K @?2? @2"E42?2 ? C$3$ 3$ ’::>:A
5[9E>? #?>: @2hp>#?N
  
    ' 
!"!!   !"!! 
!#!
1?2? ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] $:5‘ 3>:@"A
9WX$K ? D49;<" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23"
Z4$ D"29$E$ :4@"25$ $# E?:": 3$ ?E>A
3$95$ $o"4 $#$2a[9E>? q?X?2>? 3" X$WA
E4K"r] $ 5?#J^# 3>:@"9>J>K>Y? >9D"2A
#?;\$: :"J2$ " $:5?3" 3" X$WE4K"]
:4? K"E?K>Y?;<"] $952$ "452?:N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3? D49;<" 3$ ?::>:5[9A
E>? ? J"23" ^ 2$?K>Y?3? ?52?X^: 3":
J"5\$: >93>E?3": @$K?: :$5?:] :$93"
J"5<" 3? $:Z4$23? x,-,z $ " 3? 3>A
2$>5? x’,,=,.z] K"E?K>Y?3": 9" $:@$A
Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29" 3" X$WE4K"N
 * 6    5= ,  /0
’ ?5>X?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>? @"3$2‘ :$2 D$>5? 3$ D"2#?%
 ’45"#‘5>E? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r] $#
E?:" 3$ >#@?E5" :>a9>D>E?5>X"
2$a>:52?3" @$K" :>:5$#?N
 &?94?K] ?52?X^: 3? @2$::<" @2"A
K"9a?3? 3" J"5<" x,-,z ] K"E?A
K>Y?3" 9" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$29" 3"
X$WE4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ ?E>"9?A
#$95" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>? #?A
94?K#$95$] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" x,-,z
@"2 E$2E? 3$ L :$a493":] " )+* E"2A
2$:@"93$95$ ?" J"5<" x,-,z D>E?2‘
X$23$] >93>E?93" Z4$ ? Eb?#?3? $:5‘
:$93" $D$54?3? $ :$ ?@?a?2‘ ?::>#
Z4$ ? #$:#? D"2 D>9?K>Y?3?N

,$ " J"5<" x,-,z D"2 ?E>"9?3" 3$
#?9$>2? $Z4>X"E?3?] 3$952" 3$ 4#
@$2W"3" 3$ 7G :$a493":] @2$::>"9?2
9"X?#$95$ " #$:#" @?2? ?94K?2 ?
Eb?#?3?N
’ E"#49>E?;<" E"# ? E$952?K
3$ ?5$93>#$95" :$2‘ 2$?K>Y?3? ’
45>K>Y?93"A:$ " :>:5$#? 3$ ‘43>" 3"
X$WE4K" q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
8?:" 9<" :$_? @"::WX$K 2$?K>Y?2 ?
Eb?#?3? 3$ X"Y "4 ? #$:#? D"2 >9A
5$22"#@>3? 3$X>3" ? D?K5? 3$ E"J$2A
542? 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 5$K$D"9>?] " :>:A
5$#? 5$95?2‘ $952?2 $# E"95?5" E"#
2$!
? E$952?K 3$ ?5$93>#$95" @"2 4# @$A
2W"3" 3$ 6 #>945":N
!": E?:": $# Z4$ b"4X$2 9$E$::>A
3?3$ 3? E$952?K 3$ ?5$93>#$95" $:A
5?J$K$E$2 E"95?5" E"# " X$WE4K"] "
:>:5$#? 2$E$J$2‘ 4#? Eb?#?3? Z4$
:$2‘ ?E$>5? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$N
’" $D$54?2 ? Eb?#?3?] :$2<" 52?9:A
#>5>3": ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ g E$952?K
3$ ?5$93>#$95"] ": :$a4>95$: 3?3":
3" X$WE4K" 3$ ?E"23" E"# @2^X>? ?4A
5"2>Y?;<" 3" EK>$95$N
 C$a>:52" Z4$ " EK>$95$ 45>K>Y"4 "
:$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N
 &?2E? 3" X$WE4K"N
 ’: uK5>#?: E""23$9?3?: 3$ S1,
E"9b$E>3?: 3" X$WE4K"N
!" E?:" 3$ " :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9A
E>? ? J"23" ?@2$:$95?2 4#? ?X?2>?]
2$D$2$95$ ?" :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
q,-,r] " )+* E"22$:@"93$95$ ?" J"A
5<" x,-,z D>E?2‘ X$2#$Kb"N *>2>a>2A:$
?::># Z4$ @"::WX$K ?   ! &
= ,  > N
2$"

=a9"2?2 ? :>9?K>Y?;<" 3$ ?X?2>?
$#>5>3? @$K" :>:5$#?] @"3$ >#@":A
:>J>K>5?2 ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$
$#$2a[9E>? q,-,r Z4?93" 9$E$::‘A
2>"N

!" E?:" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;"
3$ $#$2a[9E>? q,-,r] ? Eb?#?3? :$2‘
$9E?#>9b?3? ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ @?2?
4#? E$952?K 3$ ?5$93>#$95" @2>X?3?N

+# E?:" 3$ @$2>a" ?": "E4@?95$:
3" X$WE4K" q>9E[93>"] @":>;<" @$2>A
a":? 3" X$WE4K" 9? X>?] $952$ "452":r]
9<" ?a4?23?2 " E"95?5" E"# ? E$9A
52?K 3$ ?5$93>#$95"N ,$ $:5>X$2 $#
E"93>;\$:] :?>2 3" X$WE4K" $ E"K"E?2A
:$ $# K"E?K :$a42"N

’ >9:5?K?;<" 3$ ?E$::h2>": 9<" b"A
#"K"a?3": @$K? ,.+))’!.=, @"3$
E?4:?2 >95$2D$2[9E>? 9" :>:5$#?] >#A
@$3>93" " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
#$:#"N
!#!
&$:#" Z4$ " :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>? q,-,r $:5$_? D49E>"9?93"
E"22$5?#$95$] D?5"2$: D"2? 3"
E"952"K$ 3? ,.+))’!.=,] E"#"
3?9": :"D2>3": @$K" X$WE4K" 342?95$
" >9E>3$95$] 2$3$ 3$ 5$K$D"9>? 3?
"@$2?3"2? @?2E$>2? E"9a$:5>"9?3?
"4 9<" 3>:@"9WX$K] E"93>;\$: #$5$A
"2"Kha>E?: ?3X$2:?] K"E?K>Y?;<" 3"
X$WE4K" $#o"4 @2hp>#" ? $:524542?:
Z4$ @"::?# E?4:?2 >95$2D$2[9E>?]
$952$ "452":] @"3$# >95$2D$2>2 "4
>95$22"#@$2 ?: Eb?#?3?:N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
!#!
1?2? Z4$ " :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
q,-,r :$_? 3>:@"9>J>K>Y?3" ^ 9$E$::‘A
2>" Z4$ :$_? D$>5? ? >9:E2>;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"oEK>$95$N
1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$
" @2"E$3>#$95" @?2? b?J>K>5?;<"
3" :$2X>;"] @$2W"3" 3$ 3>:@"9>A
J>K>3?3$] E"J$2542? $ $X$954?>:
E4:5": 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"] ?E$::?2 " :>5$
jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N
 * 6  ! = ,  /!0
’ ?5>X?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9A
E>? @"3$2‘ :$2 D$>5? 3$ D"2#?%
 ’45"#‘5>E? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r] $#
E?:" 3$ ?X?2>?: Z4$ >#@$;?# "
X$WE4K" 3$ :$ K"E"#"X$2N
 &?94?K] ?52?X^: 3? @2$::<" 3"
J"5<" x’,,=,.z] K"E?K>Y?3" 9" 2$A
52"X>:"2 >95$29" 3" X$WE4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ ?E>"A
9?#$95" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>?]
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" x’,,=,.z] " )+*
E"22$:@"93$95$ ?" J"5<" x’,,=,.z D>A
E?2‘ X$23$] >93>E?93" Z4$ ? Eb?#?3?
$:5‘ :$93" $D$54?3? $ :$ ?@?a?2‘ ?:A
:># Z4$ ? #$:#? D"2 D>9?K>Y?3?N
’" :$ @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" x’,,=,.z]
:$2<" $p>J>3": 3">: J"5\$: a2‘D>E": 9?
5$K? 3? E$952?K #4K5>#W3>? 3" X$WE4K"%
 ,$2X>;": (E"99$E5 ?"
@2$::>"9‘AK"] " 4:4‘2>" @"3$2‘
:"K>E>5?2 >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$ "
X$WE4K"] E"952?5?2 "4 E?9E$K?2 ":
:$2X>;": 3>:@"9WX$>:N
 ’::>:5[9E>? +#$2a$9E>?K
?" @2$::>"9‘AK"] " 4:4‘2>"
@"3$2‘ :"K>E>5?2 ": :$2X>;": 3$
?::>:5[9E>? LI b"2?:] 3>:@"9WX$>:
9" #?94?K 3" 12>X>K$a$ ,$2X>E$N

f 9$E$::‘2>" @2$::>"9?2 4# 3": J"A
5\$: a2‘D>E":] $p>J>3": 9? 5$K? 3? E$9A
52?K #4K5>#W3>? 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? 3?2
@2"::$a4>#$95" g 2$?K>Y?;<" 3? Eb?A
#?3?N

,$ " J"5<" x’,,=,.z D"2 ?E>"9?3"
3$ #?9$>2? $Z4>X"E?3?] @2$::>"9?2
9"X?#$95$ " #$:#" @?2? ?94K?2 ?
Eb?#?3?N
’ E"#49>E?;<" E"# ? E$952?K
3$ ?5$93>#$95" :$2‘ 2$?K>Y?3?
45>K>Y?93"A:$ " :>:5$#? 3$ ‘43>" 3"
X$WE4K" q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
8?:" 9<" :$_? @"::WX$K 2$?K>Y?2 ?
Eb?#?3? 3$ X"Y "4 ? #$:#? D"2 >9A
5$22"#@>3? 3$X>3" ? D?K5? 3$ E"J$2A
542? 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 5$K$D"9>?] " :>:A
5$#? >2‘ 2$?K>Y?2 4#? 9"X? Eb?#?3?
@?2? $952?2 $# E"95?5" E"# ? E$952?K
3$ ?5$93>#$95"N
’" $D$54?2 ? Eb?#?3? :$2<" 52?9:A
#>5>3": ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ g E$952?K
3$ ?5$93>#$95"] ": :$a4>95$: 3?3":
3" X$WE4K" 3$ ?E"23" E"# @2^X>? ?4A
5"2>Y?;<" 3" EK>$95$N
 C$a>:52" Z4$ " EK>$95$ 45>K>Y"4 "
:$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>?N
 &?2E? 3" X$WE4K"N
 ’: uK5>#?: E""23$9?3?: 3$ S1, ’
E"9b$E>3?: 3" X$WE4K"N
 - 5>@" 3$ ?X?2>? ?@2$:$95?3? @$K"
X$WE4K" Z4$ ?5>X"4 ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ " :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? q:$
$Z4>@?3"rN
2$%
 !" E?:" 3$ " :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:A
5[9E>? ? J"23" ?@2$:$95?2 4#? ?X?A
2>?] 2$D$2$95$ ?" :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9A
E>? q’,,=,.r] " )+* E"22$:@"93$95$
?" J"5<" x’,,=,.z D>E?2‘ X$2#$Kb"N
*>2>a>2A:$ ?::># Z4$ @"::WX$K ? 
 ! = ,  > N

=a9"2?2 ? :>9?K>Y?;<" 3$ ?X?2>?
$#>5>3? @$K" :>:5$#?] @"3$ >#@"::>A
J>K>5?2 ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:A
5[9E>? q’,,=,.r Z4?93" 9$E$::‘2>"N

+# E?:" 3$ @$2>a" ?": "E4@?95$:
3" X$WE4K" q>9E[93>"] @":>;<" @$2>A
a":? 3" X$WE4K" 9? X>?] $952$ "452":r]
9<" ?a4?23?2 " E"95?5" E"# ? E$9A
52?K 3$ ?5$93>#$95"N ,$ $:5>X$2 $#
E"93>;\$:] :?>2 3" X$WE4K" $ E"K"E?2A
:$ $# K"E?K :$a42"N

’ >9:5?K?;<" 3$ ?E$::h2>": 9<" b"A
#"K"a?3": @$K? ,.+))’!.=, @"3$
E?4:?2 >95$2D$2[9E>? 9" :>:5$#?] >#A
2$&
@$3>93" " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
#$:#"N

8?:" 4#? Eb?#?3? 3" :>:5$#? 3$
$#$2a[9E>? q,-,r $:5$_? $# ?93?A
#$95" $ :$_? :"K>E>5?3? 4#? 9"X?
Eb?#?3? ?52?X^: 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:A
5[9E>? q’,,=,.r] $:5? 9"X? Eb?#?3?
9<" :$2‘ 2$?K>Y?3?N
!#!
&$:#" Z4$ " :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9A
E>? q’,,=,.r $:5$_? D49E>"9?93" E"2A
2$5?#$95$] D?5"2$: D"2? 3" E"952"K$
3? ,.+))’!.=,] E"#" 3?9": :"D2>A
3": @$K" X$WE4K"] 2$3$ 3$ 5$K$D"9>?
3? "@$2?3"2? @?2E$>2? E"9a$:5>"9?3?
"4 9<" 3>:@"9WX$K] E"93>;\$: #$5$A
"2"Kha>E?: ?3X$2:?:] K"E?K>Y?;<" 3"
X$WE4K" $#o"4 @2hp>#" ? $:524542?:
Z4$ @"::?# E?4:?2 >95$2D$2[9E>?] $9A
52$ "452":] @"3$# >95$2D$2>2 "4 >95$2A
2"#@$2 ?: Eb?#?3?:N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
!#!
1?2? Z4$ " :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>?
q’,,=,.r :$_? 3>:@"9>J>K>Y?3" ^ 9$A
E$::‘2>" Z4$ :$_? D$>5? ? >9:E2>;<" 3"
X$WE4K"oEK>$95$N
1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$
" @2"E$3>#$95" @?2? b?J>K>5?;<" 3$
@?E"5$: 3$ :$2X>;":] @$2W"3" 3$ 3>:A
@"9>J>K>3?3$] E"J$2542? $ $X$954?>:
E4:5": 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" ?E$::?2 " :>5$
jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N

-: :$2X>;": 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23"
:<" 3>:@"9>J>K>Y?3": @?2? 45>K>Y?;<"
?45"#?5>E?#$95$ ?" @":>E>"9?2 " E"A
#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 3" X$WE4K" 9? @"A
:>;<" N

!#!
8?:" ? ?::>9?542? 3" :$2X>;" 3$
$#$2a[9E>? q,-,r "4 3" :$2X>;" 3$
?::>:5[9E>? q’,,=,.r] $p@>2$] ": #$:A
#": 9<" $:5?2<" #?>: 3>:@"9WX$>:N
1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2#?;\$: ?E$::?2
" :>5$ jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23"]
:$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>? q,-,r $ :$2A
X>;" 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? q’,,=,.r] 45>K>Y?
4#? J?5$2>? >93$@$93$95$ Z4$ @$2A
#>5$ ? 3>:@"9>J>K>3?3$ 3$ ?Ka49: :$2A
X>;":] #$:#" Z4$ ? J?5$2>? @2>9E>@?K
3" X$WE4K" $:5$_? 3$:E"9$E5?3?N

- :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23"
@"::4> 4#? J?5$2>? 3$ J?Ei4@] ? Z4?K
@$2#>5$ Z4$ " :>:5$#? @$2#?9$;? $#
D49E>"9?#$95" @"2 4# @$2W"3" K>#>A
5?3" 3$ 5$#@" 9": E?:": $# Z4$ ?
J?5$2>? @2>9E>@?K 3" X$WE4K" D"2 3$:A
E"9$E5?3?N ’ J?5$2>? 3$ J?Ei4@ 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23" @"::4>
4#? X>3? u5>K 3$ 6 ?9": ?@2"p>#?3?A
#$95$N 8?:" "E"22? ?Ka4#? D?Kb? 2$A
K?E>"9?3? ?" :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ?
J"23"] " E"9345"2 :$2‘ ?K$25?3" ?52?A
X^: 3? $p>J>;<" 3$ #$9:?a$# $:@$A
EWD>E? 9? E$952?K #4K5>#W3>? 3" X$WA
E4K" $ " #$:#" 3$X$2‘ 3>2>a>2A:$ ?
  !  ,  > Nz
’ ,.+))’!.=, E"K$5?] 52?5? $
45>K>Y? ": 3?3": @$::"?>: 3" EK>$95$ $
3" X$WE4K" $# E"9D"2#>3?3$ E"# ":
2$Z4>:>5": K$a?>:N 1?2? #?>: >9D"2A
#?;\$: :"J2$ " 52?5?#$95" $ :$4:
3>2$>5": $# 2$K?;<" ? $:5$: 3?3":]
?E$::$ ? 1"KW5>E? 3$ 12>X?E>3?3$ 3?
,.+))’!.=,] 3>:@"9WX$K 9" :>5$
jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N
"  ',' K67 / .- &
0:
’ K"E?K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K" $:5?2‘
:$#@2$ ?5>X?] :$_? @?2? ? 45>K>Y?;<"
3" :$2X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>? q,-,r "4
@?2? ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" :$2X>;" 3$ ?::>:A
5[9E>? q’,,=,.rN
- WE"9$ ] @2$:$95$ 9? @?25$ :4A
@$2>"2 3? E$952?K (E"99$E5] >93>E?
Z4$ ? D49;<" a$"K"E?K>Y?;<" $:5‘
?5>X? $ @"3$ :$2 3$:?J>K>5?3? ?52?X^:
3? @2h@2>? E$952?KN

w4?93" ? D49;<" a$"K"E?K>Y?;<"
^ 3$:?J>K>5?3?] ?52?X^: 3? E$952?K
(E"99$E5] ? K"E?K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"
E"95>94? ? :$2 2$a>:52?3? ?@$9?: @?2?
45>K>Y?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 9?X$a?;<"]
:$a42?9;?] :$a42" $ ?::>:5[9E>? ?
E"934;<"] Z4?93" 3>:@"9WX$>: $o"4
E"952?5?3":N
!-' K67    
’ ?54?K>Y?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:A
5[9E>? ? J"23" $ 3? E$952?K (E"99$E5]
@"3$# :$2 2$?K>Y?3": 3$ #?9$>2? 2$A
#"5?] ? D># 3$ E"K"E?2 ? 3>:@":>;<"
3" EK>$95$ X$2:\$: 3$ :"D5j?2$ #?>:
2$E$95$: Z4$ >9EK4?# 9"X?: D49E>"A ’
9?K>3?3$: "4 #$Kb"2>?: 3?: D49E>"A
9?K>3?3$: _‘ 3>:@"9WX$>:N
+:5?: ?54?K>Y?;\$: 3$ :"D5j?2$ 3$A
X$# :$2 2$?K>Y?3?: E"9D"2#$ "2>$9A
5?3" @$K? ,.+))’!.=,N
2$’


’ ?54?K>Y?;<" 3$ :"D5j?2$ 3$ #?A
9$>2? 2$#"5? 3? E$952?K (E"99$E5 :"A
#$95$ @"3$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? :$ " X$WA
E4K" $:5>X$2 5?#J^# $Z4>@?3" E"#
" :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>? ? J"23"N

’Ka4#?: 3?: ?54?K>Y?;<" 3$
:"D5j?2$ :$2<" 2$?K>Y?3?: ?45"#?5>A
E?#$95$] "452?:] @"2 :4? X$Y] :$2<"
E"#49>E?3?: ?" EK>$95$ ?52?X^: 3$
#$9:?a$# $:@$EWD>E?] $p>J>3? 9?
5$K? 3? E$952?K (E"99$E5] 9? Z4?K
^ @"::WX$K E"9D>2#?2 "4 ?3>?2 5?K
?54?K>Y?;<"N 1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2A
#?;\$: :"J2$ " @2"E$3>#$95" 3$
?54?K>Y?;<" 3$ :"D5j?2$ 3$ #?9$>2?
2$#"5?] 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?::>:5[9E>?
? J"23" $ 3? E$952?K (E"99$E5]
?E$::?2 " :>5$ jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N
 *67   * 6    &
5= ,   ! = , 
8?:" " EK>$95$ X$93? " :$4 X$WE4K"
? 5$2E$>2":] "4 3$:$_$ 3$:?5>X?2 " :$2A
X>;" 3$ $#$2a[9E>? q,-,r $ " :$2X>;"
2$*
3$ ?::>:5[9E>? q’,,=,.r] " #$:#" 3$A
X$2‘ 3>2>a>2A:$ ?   ! = , 
> N 1?2? #?>"2$: >9D"2#?;\$: ?E$:A
:?2 " :>5$ jjjN_$$@NE"#NJ2N
J  "#!
  
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" @?2? K>a?2o
3$:K>a?2 ?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N
8"# ?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? K>A
a?3?:] "J5^#A:$ ? >95$2#>5[9E>? 3?:
K4Y$:A$:@>? N

- 4:" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? ^
2$a4K?#$95?3" @$K" Eh3>a" 3? 52e9A
:>5" 3" @?W: "93$ :$ E>2E4K?% "J:$2X?2
?: @2$:E2>;\$:N
  5    5= , 
’: K4Y$: 52?:$>2?: $#>5$# 4# :>9?K
K4#>9":" @?2? ": #"5"2>:5?: Z4$ $:A
5<" ?52‘: 3" X$WE4K"] @?2? >93>E?2 Z4$
D"> ?@K>E?3" 4#? D"2;? $K$X?3? 3$
D2$9?a$# 9" X$WE4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ D2$9?a$# 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>?] ?E$93$#A:$ ?45"#?5>E?#$95$ $
:>#4K5?9$?#$95$ ?: K4Y$: 3$ D2$>" $
": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" q:$5?:r $ 9"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": ?E$93$#A:$
?: K4Y$:A$:@>? N
’: K4Y$: 3$:K>a?#A:$ ?45"#?5>E?A
#$95$ 9" #"#$95" $# Z4$ ? D2$9?A
a$# 9<" 5$# #?>: E?2‘5$2 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>?N
    
<'
"
 ’95$: 3$ :4J:5>54>2 4#? Ke#@?3?
X$2>D>Z4$ Z4$ ": 2$:@$E5>X": E"9A
5?5": 9<" $:5$_?# "p>3?3":N
 ,4J:5>54>2 ?: Ke#@?3?: Z4$>#?A
3?: @"2 "452?: 3" #$:#" 5>@" $
@"5[9E>?N
 *$@">: 3$ :4J:5>54>2 4#? Ke#A
@?3? 3": D?2h>:] X$2>D>E?2 :$#@2$
? :4? E"22$5? "2>$95?;<"N
 w4?93" 4#? Ke#@?3? 9<"
D49E>"9?] ?95$: 3$ :4J:5>54WAK?]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " D4:WX$K
 E"22$:@"93$95$ $:5‘ W95$a2"%
@?2? ? K"E?K>Y?;<" 3": D4:WX$>:]
E"9:4K5?2 tP4:WX$>:z 9$:5$
E?@W54K"N
!#!
&"3>D>E?;\$: "4 2$@?2?;\$: 3" :>:A
5$#? $K^52>E" 2$?K>Y?3?: D"2? 3? 
!  , '   ] 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5"
$ :$# 5$2 $# E"9:>3$2?;<" ?: E?2?EA
5$2W:5>E?: 5^E9>E?: 3" :>:5$#? @"3$#
E?4:?2 ?9"#?K>?: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"
$ @$2>a" 3$ Z4$>#?342?:N
C>:E" 3$ >9E[93>"N
!#!
’: Ke#@?3?: b?Kha$9?: E"95[# a‘:
:"J @2$::<"N
+# E?:" 3$ 24@542?] ^ @"::WX$K ?
@2"_$;<" 3$ D2?a#$95": 3$ X>32"N
2?: @"3$ $#J?;?2 $ D"2#?2 E"93$9A
:?;<" 9" >95$2>"2 3?: K$95$:N .2?5?A
!#! :$ 3$ 4# D$9v#$9" 9?542?K 3$X>3" g
3>D$2$9;? 3$ 5$#@$2?542? $ 4#>3?3$
’: Ke#@?3?: b?Kha$9?: 3$X$# :$2
$952$ " >95$2>"2 $ " $p5$2>"2 3? K$95$
#?94:$?3?: 5"E?93" $pEK4:>X?#$95$
Z4$] 9" $95?95"] 9<" >93>E? 4#?
9? @?25$ #$5‘K>E?N ,$ " J4KJ" 52?9:A
?9"#?K>? $ 9<" E"#@2"#$5$ " 9"2A
@?2$95$ $952?2 $# E"95?5" E"# ": 3$A
#?K D49E>"9?#$95" 3": 3>:@":>5>X":
3":] >:5" 2$34Y ? >95$9:>3?3$ 3? K4Y
3$ >K4#>9?;<"N ’ E"93$9:?;<" 3$:?A
$#>5>3? $ @"3$ 5?#J^# @2$_43>E?2 ?
@?2$E$ ?Ka49: #>945": ?@h: " ?E$9A
342?;<" 3? Ke#@?3?N
3>#$95" 3": D?2h>:] ? @?25>2 3" E$952"
3" 2$DK$5"2] $:5$93$93"A:$ @2"a2$::>A
+# E?:" 3$ E"95?5" ?E>3$95?K] $:A
X?#$95$ @?2? ?: J"23?:N
D2$a?2 ? Ke#@?3? E"# 4# @?9" E"#
‘KE""K $ 3$>p?2 :$E?2N

+D$54?2 ? "@$2?;<" 3$ :4J:5>54>;<"
3? Ke#@?3? ?@$9?: E"# " #"5"2
!#! 3$:K>a?3"N 8$25>D>E?2A:$ ?>93? 3$ Z4$
’95$: 3$ @2"E$3$2 g :4J:5>54>;<" " @2h@2>" #"5"2 $:5‘ D2>"] @?2? $X>5?2
3?: Ke#@?3?:] ?a4?23?2 @?2? Z4$ :$ " @$2>a" 3$ Z4$>#?342?:N
$:D2>$#N ’
1+C=S- *+ w(+=&’*(C’,O

w4?93" " EK>#? ^ D2>" "4 u#>3" "4
?@h: Eb4X? D"25$ "4 K?X?a$#] ? :4A
@$2DWE>$ 3": D?2h>: "4 3?: K4Y$: 52?:$>A
2$+
   ']     *+,-'

]   , 3 ,67

)4Y$: 3$ 2"3?a$# 3>429? q*NCN)r )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

P?2h>: J?>p":o?K5": )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

=93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 3>?95$>2": ¤RL7¤

)4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" 3>?95$>2?: )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

P?2h>: 3$ 9$JK>9? )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

=93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" K?5$2?>: 9" $:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 $p5$29" )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

)4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" 52?:$>2?: )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

)4Y$: 3$ D2$>" ¤L7¤ ))

.$2E$>2? K4Y 3$ D2$>" qJ2?i$ K>ab5r )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

)4Y 3$ #?2Eb? ? 2^ ¤L7¤ ))

=93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 52?:$>2": ¤R7F¤ ))

)4Y 3$ 9$JK>9? 52?:$>2? ¤L7¤ ))

)4Y$: 3$ @K?E? )+* q8"95?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > r

)4Y$: 3$ E"25$:>? 3$ 5$5" 3>?95$>2?: ¤6¤

)4Y$: 3": $:@$Kb": 3$ E"25$:>? q@?2?A:h>:r .6 L]H¤

)4Y 3$ E"25$:>? 3$ 5$5" 52?:$>2? ¤6¤

)4Y 3" @"25?A#?K?: ¤6¤

)4Y 3" @"25?AK4X?: ¤6¤

2$,
%  "! _"&
!! N!
 -  Q ,    
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" @?2? E?3? E"9A
_495"%
 Q  '@4 (
-: D?2h>: ?K5":oJ?>p": :<" 3$ )+*N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] E"95?5?2 ? 
 ! = ,  > N
-K  5  -  /:::0 
 ,    67    )
’: K4Y$: 3$ 2"3?a$# 3>429?
q*NCN)Nr :<" 3$ )+*N 1?2? ? :4J:5>54>A
;<"] E"95?5?2 ?   ! = , 
> N
1?2? ": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 3>A
?95$>2":] ?54?2 E"#" ? :$a4>2%
 V>2?2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ ?: 2"3?:N
 (5>K>Y?93" ? Eb?X$ ?3$Z4?3?]
3$:?@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:": $
2$#"X$2 ? 5?#@?N
 C$#"X$2 ": E"9$E5"2$: $K^52>E":N
 12$::>"9?2 ?: ?J?: 3$ 52?X?#$95"  -  Q ,   
:4@$2>"2 $ >9D$2>"2 q@?2? ?: K4Y$:
8"95^# ?: Ke#@?3?: 3?: :$a4>95$:
3$ 2"3?a$# 3>429?r "4 a>2?2 9"
K4Y$:%
:$95>3" ?95>Ab"2‘2>" q@?2? ": >93>A
E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"rN
7N )?95$29?: 52?:$>2?:
 =9:$2>2 ? 9"X? Ke#@?3?] @2$::>"A
LN )4Y$: 3$ D2$>"
9?93" ?5^ "4X>2 4# EK>Z4$ qK4Y$:
3$ 2"3?a$# 3>429?r "4 a>2?93" HN =93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<"
9" :$95>3" b"2‘2>" qK4Y$: 3$ @"A
:>;<"r] ?::$a42?93"A:$ 3" E"22$5" 1?2? 2$5>2?2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$3$2
52?X?#$95"N 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 V"K5?2 ? K>a?2 ": E"9$E5"2$: $K^A
52>E":N
 V"K5?2 ? #"95?2 ? 5?#@? 3$
?E$::"N
 Q   4' 
-: D?2h>: 3$ 9$JK>9? :<" 3$ )+*N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] E"95?5?2 ? 
 ! = ,  > N
’
 ’J2>2 ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
  ,    67 '    (5>K>Y?93" 4#? Eb?X$ ?3$Z4?3?]
-: >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" K?5$2?>: 2$#"X$2 ?: 52?X?: 1 N
:<" 3$ )+*N 1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] E"9A  C$#"X$2 " E"9$E5"2 $K^52>E" @2$:A
5?5?2 ?   ! = ,  > N :>"9?93" " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 3$:52?A
X?#$95"N
2$-
 C$#"X$2 " a24@" h5>E" 52?:$>2"]
3$:K>Y?93"A" @?2? D"2? E"#" >9A
3>E?3" 9? D>a42? :$a4>95$N
 C$#"X$2 ": J4KJ": 3?: Ke#@?3?:
? :$2$# :4J:5>54W3?: a>2?93"A":
9" :$95>3" ?95>Ab"2‘2>"N
7N S24@" h5>E" 52?:$>2"
LN 1>9" $:D^2>E" 3$ $9E?>p$
2$!.
7N )e#@?3? 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>A -K   ,G  9
2$;<"
LN )e#@?3? 3?: K4Y$: 3$ D2$>"
HN 8"9$E5"2 $K^52>E"
IN 1>9" $:D^2>E" 3$ $9E?>p$
1?2? E"K"E?2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 =9:$2>2 ? 9"X? Ke#@?3?]
E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5‘
E"22$5?#$95$ 52?X?3?N 12"E$3$2 E"9D"2#$ ": :$a4>95$:
 C$@":>E>"9?2 " a24@" h5>E" 52?A @?::": @?2? 2$#"X$2 ?: Ke#@?3?:%
:$>2" 9" X$WE4K"N
 V"K5?2 ? K>a?2 " E"9$E5"2 $K^52>E"N  ’J2>2 ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
 C$>9:5?K?2 " a24@" h5>E" 52?:$>2"]  (5>K>Y?93" 4#? Eb?X$ ?3$Z4?3?]
"J:$2X?93" " ?K>9b?#$95" 3$ 5"A 2$#"X$2 ?: 5?#@?: 3$ ?E$::" 1
3": ": @>9": $:D^2>E": 3$ $9E?>p$N ?" a24@" h5>E" 52?:$>2" $ ?: 5?#A
@?: 3$ ?E$::" g: Ke#@?3?: 3?
 =9:5?K?2 ?: 52?X?: 3$ ?@$25"N
@"25? 52?:$>2?N
 1"2 D>#] D$Eb?2 ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
 (5>K>Y?93" 4#? Eb?X$ ?3$Z4?3?]
#?K?:N
2$#"X$2 ?: 52?X?: 3$ ?@$25"N
 C$#"X$2 " E"9$E5"2 $K^52>E" @2$:A
:>"9?93" " 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 3$:52?A
X?#$95"N
 *$:K>Y?2 " a24@" 3? K4Y 3$ #?2A
Eb? ? 2^ @?2? 2$#"X[AK"N
 *$:?@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:": $ 2$#"A  =9:$2>2 ? 9"X? Ke#@?3?] %  "! _"&
X$2 ? Ke#@?3?N E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5‘ !! !
E"22$5?#$95$ 52?X?3?N
-K  ,      
 V"K5?2 ? #"95?2 E"22$5?#$95$ "
a24@" 3? K4Y 3$ #?2Eb? ? 2^] 1?2? 2$#"X$2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
?@$25?93" ": @?2?D4:":N 3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 C$@":>E>"9?2 " a24@" 3? K4Y 3$
#?2Eb? ? 2^ 9" X$WE4K"N
 P>p?2 ?: 52?X?: 3$ ?@$25" $ 2$K>a?2
" E"9$E5"2 $K^52>E"N
 C$>9:5?K?2 ": @?>9^>: $ 5?#@?: 3$
7N .2?X?: 3$ ?@$25" ?E$::"] ?::$a42?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$
$:5<" 52?X?3": E"22$5?#$95$N
 1"2 D>#] D$Eb$ ? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N
 (5>K>Y?93" 4#? D$22?#$95? ?3$A
 ,  '-K  3   /4 [ ' 5G0 Z4?3?] 2$#"X$2 " E"9_495" 3$
K4Y$: 3$ E"25$:>? 3>?95$>2?:N
- J2?i$ K>ab5 @"::4> >K4#>9?;<" ?
)+*N 1?2? ? :4? :4J:5>54>;<"] 3>2>a>2A  ,"K5?2 ?: 52?X?: $ ? :$3$ 3?: K4Y$:
:$ g   ! = ,  > N E"9D"2#$ >93>E?3" @$K?: :$5?:N
 C$#"X$2 ?: Ke#@?3?: @4p?93"A ’
-K  ', ?: 3$ :4?: :$3$:N
7N 1?2?D4:":
LN 8"9$E5"2 $K^52>E" ’ K4Y 3$ @K?E? @"::4> >K4#>9?;<" ?
HN )e#@?3? 3? K4Y 3$ #?2Eb? ? 2^ )+*N 1?2? ? :4? :4J:5>54>;<"] 3>2>a>2A
:$ g   ! = ,  > N
1?2? >9:5?K?2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$3$2
E"#" ? :$a4>2%

2$!!
 Y$: 3$ E"25$:>?] ?::$a42?93"A:$
3$ Z4$ D>Z4$# E"22$5?#$95$ 52?A
X?3":N

-K   'G  ,     &

'
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ? Ke#@?3?] @2"E$3$2
3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
-K   &'-*
 )$X?95?2 ? E"J$2542? 3" $:@$Kb" 1
$ $p52?>2 ? E"J$2542? 3? Ke#@?3? 1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ? Ke#@?3?] @2"E$3$2
BN E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
 ,4J:5>54>2 ? Ke#@?3?] K>J$2?93" ?
?95>a? 3": E"95?5": K?5$2?>: $ $#  ’J2>2 " @"25?AK4X?:N
:$a4>3? E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ ?  =9:$2>2 ": 3$3": 9" >95$2>"2 3?
9"X? $:5$_? E"22$5?#$95$ JK"Z4$A :$3$ >K4:52?3? 9? DD>a42? :$a4>95$]
?3? $952$ ": #$:#":N 2$5>2?2 ? Ke#@?3? $ :4J:5>54WAK?N
7N .2?X?:  C$>9:5?K?2 ? E"J$2542? 3? Ke#A  =9:$2>2 ? 9"X? Ke#@?3?]
LN ,$3$ 3?: Ke#@?3?: @?3?N E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5‘
 1"2 D>#] J?>p?2 ? E"J$2542? 3" E"22$5?#$95$ 52?X?3?N
1?2? >9:5?K?2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$3$2 $:@$Kb"N
E"#" ? :$a4>2%

 =9:$2>2 ?: 9"X?: Ke#@?3?:]

E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ D>E?2?#
E"22$5?#$95$ 52?X?3?:N
 &"95?2 9"X?#$95$ ? :$3$ 3?:
Ke#@?3?: $ " E"9_495" 3?: K4A

2$!"
-K     
 V$2:\$: :$# 5$5" :"K?2%
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 ’54?2 9" a24@" h5>E" $ ?J2>2 ? ?J?
BN
 ,4J:5>54>2 ? Ke#@?3? 1 N
 C$>9:5?K?2 " E"9_495"N
 V$2:\$: E"# 5$5" :"K?2%
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 B?>p?2 ? ?K;? 3$ :$a42?9;?] ?54A
?93" 9" :$95>3" >93>E?3" @$K?
:$5?] $ 2$#"X$2 ? 5?#@?N
 ,4J:5>54>2 ? Ke#@?3?
3$:@2$93$93"A? 3": E"95?5":
K?5$2?>:N
 =9:$2>2 ? 9"X? Ke#@?3?]
E$25>D>E?93"A:$ 3$ Z4$ $:5‘
E"22$5?#$95$ JK"Z4$?3? $952$ ":
@2h@2>": E"95?5":N
 &"95?2 " E"9_495" 9? :4? @":>A
;<" E"22$5?N
-K   & '
1?2? :4J:5>54>2 ?: Ke#@?3?:] @2"E$A
3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 ’J2>2 " @"25?A#?K?: $p52?>2 ? J?:$
3? Ke#@?3? ?54?93" 9" @"95"
>93>E?3" @$K? :$5?N
 *$:?E"@K?2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ ?
J?:$ 3? Ke#@?3? 3$ :4? :$3$N
 S>2?2 ? J?:$ 3? Ke#@?3? @?2?
:4J:5>54WAK?N
 1"2 D>#] 2$#"95?2 " E"9_495"N
’
2$!%
 C=,8- *+ =!8l!*=-N

!#!
!<" :4J:5>54>2 $# E?:" ?Ka4# 4#
!#! D4:WX$K @"2 "452" 3$ E?@?E>3?3$ 3>D$A
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" $D$54?2 4#? K?X?A 2$95$ 3" $:@$E>D>E?3"N
a$# 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2] 5$2
1+C=S- *+ =!8l!*=-N
E4>3?3" @?2? 9<" >9:>:5>2 3>2$5?#$95$
E"# 4# _?5" 3$ ‘a4? 9? E$952?K 3":
D4:WX$>: $ 9": #"5"2$: 3": K>#@?3"A
2$: 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N
!#!
+X>5$ 3?9": ?": E"#@"9$95$:N
!" E?:" 3$ >95$2X$9;<" 3$ 4# D4A
:WX$K a$2?K 3$ @2"5$;<" q&’¡=AP(,+]
&+S’AP(,+] &=*=AP(,+r] E"95?5?2 ?
  ! = ,  > N
!#!
1$::"?K $:@$E>?K>Y?3" E"22>a>2‘ "
!" E?:" 3$ " D4:WX$K >95$22"#@$2A
" ! :$ 9"X?#$95$] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
>9E"9X$9>$95$N

!! ! = ,  > N

C=,8- *+ =!8l!*=-N
!#!
!#! ’95$: 3$ :4J:5>54>2 4# D4:WX$K]
!49E? :4J:5>54>2 4# D4:WX$K ?X?2>A E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ :$ E"K"E"4 "
?3" @"2 D>": #$5‘K>E": "4 "452" #?A E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $#  ] :$
5$2>?K 3$ 2$E4@$2?;<"N 2$5>2"4 ? Eb?X$] :$ #$Ee9>E?] $ Z4$

2$!&
:$ 3$:K>a"4 $o"4 3$:$9a?5"4 5"3":
": ?E$::h2>":N
+X>5$ 3?9": g: >9:5?K?;\$: $K^52>E?:N
! !  2$:>:5[9E>? q9<" D"2;?2 @?2? ?K^#
-: D4:WX$>: $:5<" ?a24@?3": $#
Z4?52" E$952?>: K"E?K>Y?3?: 9" E"#A
@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2] @"2 J?>p" 3"
Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $ 9" >95$2>"2
3" @"25?A#?K?:N
! !& 
" !"  "
’ E$952?K $:5‘ :>54?3? 9" K?3" $:A
Z4$23" 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2
 67     ,  ' 
3-+* 
 ’54?2 9" @?2?D4:" 1 ] 45>K>Y?93" ?  ’K>X>?2 " @?2?D4:"N
2$:@$E5>X? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93? ?@2"A  - D$Eb?#$95" $D$5>X" ^ ?::>9?A
@2>?3?N K?3" @$K? D>p?;<"] 9? 2$:@$E5>X?
 S>2?2 K$95?#$95$ " @?2?D4:" 9" :$3$] 3$ 5"3? ? E?J$;? 3" @?2?A
:$95>3" ?95>Ab"2‘2>" ?5^ $9E"952?2 D4:"N
3" K>#>5$rN
 ’K>X>?2 K$95?#$95$ " @?2?D4:"N
 ’ ?J$2542? $D$5>X? ^ ?::>9?K?3?
@$K? :?W3? 3$ 5"3? ? E?J$;? 3"
@?2?D4:" 3? 2$:@$E5>X? :$3$N
 C$#"X$2 ? 5?#@? B ] D?Y$93"A
? 3$:K>Y?2 E"#@K$5?#$95$ @?2?
E>#?] E"#" >93>E?3" 9? D>a42?N
 1?2? #"5"2 7NH] ?54?2 9?: 52?X?:
>93>E?3?: @$K?: :$5?: @?2? 2$5>2?2 1?2? 5$2 ?E$::" ?": D4:WX$>:] ?54?2
? 5?#@? 3? E?>p? 3$ D4:WX$>:N 9?: @2$:>Kb?: >93>E?3?: @$K?: :$5?: $
2$5>2?2 ? 5?#@?N
" 5     ,  ' 
3-+*    '  &3-+*   4 
 P>p?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ? 5?#@? B g ’
(#? E$952?K @"25?AD4:WX$>: $:5‘ :>A
E?>p?] D?Y$93"A? 3$:K>Y?2 E"#A 54?3? 9? J?5$2>?N 1?2? 5$2 ?E$::" ?":
@K$5?#$95$ 3$ E>#? @?2? J?>p"N D4:WX$>:] ?54?2 9?: @2$:>Kb?: 1 $ 2$5>A
 S>2?2 K$95?#$95$ " @?2?D4:" 9" 2?2 ? 5?#@? B N
:$95>3" b"2‘2>" ?5^ $9E"952?2 2$A
:>:5[9E>? q9<" D"2;?2 @?2? ?K^#
3" K>#>5$r] 45>K>Y?93" ? 2$:@$E5>X?
Eb?X$ 3$ D$93? ?@2"@2>?3?N
2$!’
 1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3$:5$: D4:WX$>:]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N

2$!*
-+*   ,  '  ,     
&
 /!0     J!


PG7 |G &h34K" 3" J"3y E"#@45$2

PGL |G &h34K" 3" J"3y E"#@45$2] E?>p? 3$ D4:WX$>: 3" @"25?A#?K?:

PGH LG ’K>#$95?;<" 3?: E?2a?: E"952"K?3?: @$K" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<"

PGH HG V,( $ ’=,=! qEe#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"r

PGI IG &h34K" 3": :>:5$#?: 3$ E"952"K$ 3$ D2$9?a$#

PG6  

PGF IG C$K^ 3" #"5"2 3$ @?25>3?

PG|  
’K>#$95?;<" @?2? E$952?K 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" $ :$K$5"2 3$ #?2Eb?:] E"952"K$ 3? 3>2$;<" qX$2:\$: :$#
PG~ HG
,5?25',5"@r
’K>#$95?;<" @?2? E$952?K 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" $ :$K$5"2 3$ #?2Eb?:] E"952"K$ 3? 3>2$;<" qX$2:\$: E"#
PG~ IG
,5?25',5"@r
PGM |]6 ’K>#$95?;<" @?2? E$952?K 3$ >9_$;<"] E"#?93" 1¤& 3" $K$52"X$95>K?3"2

P7G LG ’K>#$95?;<" 3? J4Y>9?

P77 LG ’K>#$95?;<" 3$ E?2a?: :$E493‘2>?: qX$2:\$: E"# #"5"2 LNG c.*r ’

P77 L6 ’K>#$95?;<" 3$ E?2a?: :$E493‘2>?: qX$2:\$: E"# #"5"2 LNG PK$pr

P7I |]6 ’K>#$95?;<" 3" ?Z4$E$3"2 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 2$E>2E4K?;<" 3$ a?:$: tJK"j Jyt

P76 IG ’K>#$95?;<" 3? J"#J? 3": :>:5$#?: 3$ E"952"K$ 3$ D2$9?a$#

P7F 7G ’K>#$95?;<" 3? E$952?K 3$ >9_$;<" $ 3? E$952?K 3$ Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"

P7| 7G ’K>#$95?;<" @?2? E?2a?: :$E493‘2>?: 3" #"5"2

2$!+
 &
 /!0     J!

’K>#$95?;<" @?2? ? 5"#?3? 3$ $9$2a>? 52?:$>2? 7LV q?K>#$95?;<" E"# >a9>;<" -!  @?2? ?K>#$95?2 ? 5"#?3?
P7~ LG
3>2$5?#$95$ 3? J?5$2>?] #"X$2 " D4:WX$K 3? @":>;<" P7~ @?2? ? PHGr
P7M |]6 ’K>#$95?;<" 3" E"#@2$::"2 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"

PLG LG ’K>#$95?;<" 3? 5"#?3? 3$ $9$2a>? D2"95?K

PL7 76 ’K>#$95?;<" 3? J"#J? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K

LG qPK$pr o 76
PLL ’K>#$95?;<" @?2? E$952?K 3$ >9_$;<"
q*>$:$Kr
PLH HG ’K>#$95?;<" @?2? " >9X$2:"2 7L| V "4 LHG V
’K>#$95?;<" @$2#?9$95$ 3? 5"#?3? 3$ $9$2a>? 52?:$>2? 7LV q@":>;<" 3$:"E4@?3?  @?2? ?K>#$95?2 ? 5"#?3?
PHG 
3>2$5?#$95$ 3? J?5$2>?] #"X$2 " D4:WX$K 3? @":>;<" P7~ @?2? ? PHGr
PH7 IG ,>:5$#? (2$>?

PH6 6G V$95>K?3"2 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2

PHM LG +8&

PI| |]6 V$95>K?3"2 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 1¤&

PI~ LG ,$9:"2$: ?K>#$95?;<" 42$>?

PIM LG ,$9:"2$: ?K>#$95?;<" ,8C&

P6L 76 8"952"K$ 3? 3>2$;<"

P~7 FG ’K>#$95?;<" X$K? 3$ ?Z4$E>#$95" q*>$:$Kr

P~L IG ’K>#$95?;<" ?Z4$E$3"2 3" D>K52" 3>$:$K

P~H IG ’K>#$95?;<" X$95>K?3"2 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"

P~I HG ’K>#$95?;<" 52?9:#>::<" I¡I

P~| 6 ’K>#$95?;<" :$K$5"2 3$ Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"

2$!,
&
 /!0     J!


P~~  

P~M HG ’K>#$95?;<" 3$:$#J?;?3"2 3" X>32" 52?:$>2"

PMG 6 ,$9:"2 =B, q$:5?3" 3$ E?2a? 3? J?5$2>?r

P7H6 |G &"34K$ J"3y 8"#@45$2 $ (9>3?3$ 3$ 3>:52>J4>;<" 52?:$>2?

P7HM L6 ¤8’8

P¡¡ LG ’K>#$95?;<" 2‘3>" qX$2:\$: E"# ,5?25',5"@r

2$!-
! !& 
!  "
’ E$952?K $:5‘ :>54?3? 9" K?3" $:A
Z4$23" 3? E"K49? 3$ 3>2$;<" $ ": D4A
:WX$>: :<" K>X2$#$95$ ?E$::WX$>: @$K?
@?25$ >9D$2>"2 3" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$9A
5":N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3$:5$: D4:WX$>:]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N

2$".
-+*   ,  '   '   -  

  /!0     J!

PH7 |N6 ,>:5$#? ?>2J?a

PHH LG V>32" $K^52>E" 3>?95$>2" qK?3" @?::?a$>2"r

PHI LG V>32" $K^52>E" 3>?95$>2" qK?3" #"5"2>:5?r

V>32" $K^52>E" 3>?95$>2" qK?3" #"5"2>:5?r] *)8 $ ,S¤] C‘3>"] (,B] .B&] 8,,] (9>3?3$ 3$ 8"952"K$ 3$
PHF LG
.$5" :"K?2] TV’8
PH| 7G w4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":d :>:5$#? IpI
1"25?: 52?X?#$95"o3$:52?X?#$95" 3?: @"25?:] K>J$2?;<" 3? 5?#@? 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] 3$:52?X?#$95" 3?
PH~ LG
5?#@? 52?:$>2?
PIL |N6 ’B,] 3>2$;<" $K^52>E?

PIH LG B"#J? 3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ 3" X>32" 52?:$>2"

PI| LG )$X?95?3"2 $K^52>E" 3" X>32" 52?:$>2" $:Z4$23"

PI~ LG )$X?95?3"2 $K^52>E" 3" X>32" 52?:$>2" 3>2$>5"

PIM |N6 ,S¤] V,(] ’,B&] =8,] @"95" E$a" 2$52"X>:"2 qJK>93 :@"5] 1’&

P6G |N6 ,>:5$#? ?>2J?a

’
8"#?93": 3$ K4Y$: $p5$29?:] ?Z4$E$3"2 3$ D>K52" 3$ hK$" 3>$:$K] >95$224@5"2 3$ K4Y 3$ D2$>"] Ee#$2?
P67 |N6 D2"95?K] E"#?93" 3$ E"952"K$ 3$ 52?;<" q#?2Eb? ? 2^r] :$9:"2 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3$ ?2 3" @?::?a$>2"]
$:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2 >95$K>a$95$] 9>X$K?#$95" 3" D?2"K] TV’8
=18] #h34K" 3$ >a9>;<"] CPT&] >95$224@5"2 3? K4Y 3$ D2$>"] #h34K" 3$ K>J$2?;<" 3$ #<": K>X2$:] +1B,]
P6H |N6
:$9:"2 3$ Eb4X?
B?9E" 3" #"5"2>:5?] 5"#?3? 3" E?22$a?3"2 (,B] #h34K" 3$ E?22$a?#$95" :$# D>"] +B)] ?K>#$95?;<"
PMI 76
3" :"@2?3"2 3" #"5"2] 5"#?3? 52?:$>2?] ?E$93$3"2

2$"!
! !& 
!&"!!
1?2? 5$2 ?E$::" ?": D4:WX$>:] 2$#"A
X$2 ? 5?#@? 9" K?3" $:Z4$23" 3"
@"25?A#?K?:N


V$WE4K": $Z4>@?3": E"# ?J$2542?
$K^52>E? 3? 5?#@? 52?:$>2? ?@2$:$95?#
4# D4:WX$K PG7 3$ HG ’#@–2$: E"#
:$3$ 9" :4@"25$ 3? E$952?K 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N

2$""
-+*   ,  '   & '

  /!0    & J!

P7 HG =9X$2:"2 3$ D2$Z4[9E>?

PL L6 ,>:5$#? 3$ ‘43>" T=P=

PH LG ’K>#$95?;<" 3" 5$5" :"K?2

PI  

P6 HG ’K>#$95?;<" 3" #"5"2 3$ #"X>#$95?;<" 3" J?9E" 3" #"5"2>:5?

PF |]6 ’K>#$95?;<" 3" #"5"2 3$ ?_4:5$ K"#J?2 3" J?9E" 3" #"5"2>:5?

P|  

P~  

2$"%
  ' 
 !! !! %&

!#!
,$ 3$>p?3": 9" b?J>5‘E4K"] ? 2"3?
E"# " @9$4 D42?3" $ " #?E?E" E"9:A
5>54> 4# :^2>" @$2>a" @?2? ? :$a42?9;?
3": "E4@?95$: $# E?:" 3$ ?E>3$95$:
"4 3$ D2$9?a$9: J24:E?:N
1"2 $::$ #"5>X"] X"K5?2 ? E"K"E?2 "
#?E?E" $ ?: 3$#?>: D$22?#$95?: 2$:A
@$E5>X" ?K"_?#$95" 9" @"25?A#?K?:]
?::># E"#" " @9$4 D42?3"N
!#!
f $p52$#?#$95$ ?22>:E?3" 5$95?2
:4J:5>54>2 4#? 2"3? 9" K?3" 3" X$WA
E4K" @2hp>#" 3? D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$#N
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" $:5‘
:4D>E>$95$#$95$ K"9a$ 3? X>?] @?2?
$X>5?2 :$2 ?5>9a>3"N
2$"&
!#!
’::>9?K?2 ? @2$:$9;? 3" X$WE4K" @?A
2?3" :$a493" ?: 3>:@":>;\$: X>a$9A
5$:% K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] 52>e9a4K"
3$ :>9?K>Y?;<"] $5EN
’: @$::"?: ? J"23" 3$X$# :?>2 3"
X$WE4K"] $:@$2?93" Z4$ :$ $D$54$ ?
:4J:5>54>;<" $ ?D?:5?93"A:$ 3" @$2>a"
3" 52‘D$a"N - X$WE4K" 3$X$ $:5?2
3$:E?22$a?3"N
!#!
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ :$ 3$:5>9? $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?"
4:" 5$#@"2‘2>"N
&?93?2 2$@?2?2 $ 2$#"95?2 ? 2"3?
:4J:5>54W3? " #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$ @":A
:WX$KN
!#!
!49E? >9:5?K?2 4# @9$4 52?3>E>"A
9?K 94#? 2"3? 3$:5>9?3? g 45>K>Y?;<"
E"#" 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N !<" ^ @$2A
#>5>3" 45>K>Y?2 :>#4K5?9$?#$95$ 34?:
"4 #?>: 2"3?: :"J2$::?K$95$:N
C$:@$>5?2 :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
1?2? :"K5?2 $ ?@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:":
3?: 2"3?:] 45>K>Y?2 ?@$9?: ? Eb?X$ 3$
2"3? D"29$E>3? _495" ?" X$WE4K"N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
!#!
!49E? 45>K>Y$ @?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3?
Z4$ 9<" :$_?# $:@$E>D>E?3": @?2?
$:5$ X$WE4K"N
 1?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3? >9E"22$5": "4
?@$25?3": >9?3$Z4?3?#$95$ @"3$2<"
D?Y$2 ? 2"3? :"K5?2A:$N
!#!
!<" K4J2>D>E?2 ?: 2":E?: 3": @?2?A
D4:": ?95$: 3$ #"95?2 ": @9$4:] @">:
$:5$: @"3$2<" :"K5?2A:$ $:@"95?9$?A
#$95$ 342?95$ ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"O
+# 9$9b4#? E>2E49:5e9E>? ": @?A
2?D4:": 3$X$# :$2 K4J2>D>E?3":N 1?2?A
D4:": E"# >#@42$Y?: 3$X$# :$2 K>#A
@":N +# E?:" 3$ E"22":<" "4 2":Z4$A
?#$95" 3>DWE>K] ": @?2?D4:": 3$X$#
:$2 :4J:5>54W3":N
!#!
8"# ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ #"9A
5?3?] " X$WE4K" 5$# :4?: E?2?E5$2W:5>A
E?: 3$ E"934;<" ?K5$2?3?:N
+X>5?2 ?E$K$2?;\$: $ D2$9?a$9: X>A
"K$95?:] #43?9;?: 3$ 3>2$;<" J24:A
E?: $ E42X?: $# ?K5? X$K"E>3?3$N ’
342?J>K>3?3$ #^3>? 3" @9$4 :"J2$:A
:?K$95$ ^ 3$ HNGGG i#N .2?9:E"22>3?
$::? Z4>K"#$52?a$#] " @9$4 3$X$ :$2
:4J:5>54W3" @$K" "2>a>9?K "4 @"2 "452"
:"J2$::?K$95$ E"# ?: #$:#?: E?2?EA
5$2W:5>E?: 3" Z4$ a4?29$E$ " X$WE4K"N
!#!
’ 2"3? D"29$E>3? ^ $:@$EWD>E? @?2?
" X$WE4K"% 9<" 45>K>Y‘AK? $# 4# X$WA
E4K" 3$ #"3$K" 3>D$2$95$ 9$# 45>A
K>Y?2 2"3?: :"J2$::?K$95$: 3$ "452":
#"3$K": 9" X$WE4K"N ’ 2"3? :"J2$:A
:?K$95$ :h 3$X$ :$2 45>K>Y?3? $# E?:"
3$ $#$2a[9E>?N ’ :4? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$X$
:$2 2$34Y>3? ?" #W9>#" >93>:@$9:‘A
X$K $ ? X$K"E>3?3$ 9<" 3$X$ 4K52?@?:A
:?2 ? X$K"E>3?3$ 3$ ~G i#ob "4 7LG
i#ob] >93>E?3? 9? @2h@2>? 2"3? E"9A
D"2#$ " #"3$K"oX$2:<"N
!? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ $9E"952?A:$
?@K>E?3" 4# ?3$:>X" ?K?2?9_?3" E"#
": @2>9E>@?>: ?X>:": ?E$2E? 3? 45>K>Y?A
;<" 3? @2h@2>? 2"3? $ 3?: 2$:@$E5>X?:
K>#>5?;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"N - ?3$:>X"
9<" 3$X$ 3$ D"2#? ?Ka4#? :$2 2$#"A
X>3" 9$# E"J$25"N !? 2"3? :"J2$::?A
K$95$ 949E? :$ 3$X$ ?@K>E?2 9$9b4#?
E?K"5? 3$ 2"3?N
!#!
- #?E?E" ^ 4#? D$22?#$95? $:A
543?3? $ E"9E$J>3? ?@$9?: @?2? ?
:4J:5>54>;<" 3$ 4#? 2"3?] $# E?:"
3$ D42" "4 3?9": 9" 2$:@$E5>X" @9$4]
9" X$WE4K" $# Z4$ ^ D"29$E>3" "4 $#
X$WE4K": 3" #$:#" #"3$K"N !49E?
3$X$ :$2 45>K>Y?3" 3$ "452?: D"2#?:
E"#"] @"2 $p$#@K"] @?2? K$X?95?2
X$WE4K": 3$ "452": #"3$K": "4 "JA
_$5": 3>D$2$95$:N +# 9$9b4# E?:"
45>K>Y‘AK" @?2? "@$2?;\$: 3$ #?94A
5$9;<" "4 2$@?2?;<" @"2 J?>p" 3"
X$WE4K"N !49E? :$ @":>E>"9?2 @"2 ’
J?>p" 3" X$WE4K" $K$X?3"N
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" "@$2?2 @"2
J?>p" 3" X$WE4K"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g  
! = ,  > N - @":>E>"9?#$95"
>9E"22$5" 3" #?E?E" @"3$ @2"X"A
E?2 ? Z4$3? 3" X$WE4K" K$X?95?3"%
45>K>Y‘AK" ?@$9?: 9?: @":>;\$: >93>A
2$"’
E?3?:N !<" 45>K>Y?2 " #?E?E" @?2?
E?@?E>3?3$: :4@$2>"2$: g >93>E?3? 9?
$5>Z4$5? 9$K$ ?@K>E?3?N
!#!
(#? #"95?a$# >9E"22$5? 3? E?A
K"5? 3? 2"3? q:$ $Z4>@?3"r] @"3$ @2"A
X"E?2 ? 2$:@$E5>X? :$@?2?;<" Z4?93"
" X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $# #?2Eb?N f ?J:"A
K45?#$95$ @2">J>3" #?94:$?2 ? X‘KA
X4K? 3$ $9Eb>#$95"N !<" >952"34Y>2
D$22?#$95?: 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 $:@^E>$ $9A
52$ ? 2"3? $ " @9$4N
V$2>D>E?2 2$a4K?2#$95$ ? @2$::<"
3": @9$4: $ 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$]
2$:@$>5?93" ": X?K"2$: >93>E?3": 9"
E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":tN
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 1?2?2 " X$WE4K" $# 4#? @":>;<"
$# Z4$ 9<" 2$@2$:$95$ 4# @$2>a"
@?2? " 52e9:>5" $ @$2#>5? :4J:5>54>2
? 2"3? ?54?93" E"# :$a42?9;?]
" #?>: K"9a$ @"::WX$K 3? J"23?
3? @>:5? 3? $:52?3?N - 5$22$9"
2$"*
3$X$ $:5?2] :$ @"::WX$K] @K?9" $ 3>2$>5? ?" :4J:5>54>2 ? 2"3? 3>?95$>2?
:4D>E>$95$#$95$ E"#@?E5"N $:Z4$23?rN
 )>a?2 ?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
$ ?E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$ ’ 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ $:5‘ :>54?3?
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N 3$J?>p" 3" 5?@$5$ 3$ 2$X$:5>#$95"
 8"K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" 9? 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
@":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"rN 1?2? 5$2 ?E$::" g 2"3? :"J2$::?A
 *$:K>a?2 " #"5"2 ?95$: 3$ 3$:E$2 K$95$] @2"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
3" X$WE4K"N - #"5"2 3$X$2‘ :$2
#?95>3" 3$:K>a?3" 342?95$ 5"3? ?  *$@">: 3$ ?J2>2 " @"25?A#?K?:]
"@$2?;<"N :$a42?2 9" @4p?3"2 $ K$X?95?2 "
@K?9" 3$ E?2a? :$a42?93"A" E"#
4#? #<"N

 14p?2 ? K>9a4$5? $ K$X?95?2 " 5?A
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" @?2?2 " X$WA @$5$ 3$ 2$X$:5>#$95"N
E4K" @?2? ? 52"E? 3$ @9$4 " X$WE4K"
?" K"9a" 3$ 4#? $:52?3? >9EK>9?3?]
$:@$E>?K#$95$ :$ #4>5" ?E$954?3?]
"4 $# 4# 5$22$9" >9:5‘X$K] E?K;?2 ?:
2"3?: 3" X$WE4K" @?2? $X>5?2 " #"X>A
#$95"N
1?2? >::"] @2"X>3$9E>?2 $ @":>E>"A
9?2 4# E?K;" ?52‘: 3? 2"3? 3>?#$52?KA
#$95$ "@":5? g Z4$ :$2‘ :4J:5>54W3?]
$X>5?93" ?::># #"X>#$95?;<" >93$A
:$_?3? 3" X$WE4K" $9Z4?95" ^ K$X?9A  C$5>2?2 ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 3$
5?3" q@N $pN% E?K;?2 ? 2"3? 52?:$>2? :4? :$3$ 3$:?@$25?93" " 3>:@":>A
5>X" 3$ D>p?;<"N

 C$5>2?2 ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ $ ?:
D$22?#$95?: 3" >95$2>"2 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N

1?2? #?>: >9D"2#?;\$: $ ?3X$25[9A
E>?: :"J2$ " 4:" E"22$5" 3" E"9_495"
2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?K$95$] X$2 xC"3?:
$ 19$4:z 9" E?@W54K" x&?945$9;<" $
E4>3?3": E"# " :$4 X$WE4K"zN
!"! B) " #?E?E"N
’: D$22?#$95?: $:5<" K"E?K>Y?3? g
3>2$>5? $ 3$J?>p" 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?A
K$95$ 9" @"25?A#?K?:N
1) ? Eb?X$ 3$ 2"3?] @?2? 3$:#"9A
5?a$#o?@$25" 3": @?2?D4:": 3? 2"3?
$ @?2? " ?E>"9?#$95" 3" #?E?E"N
C) " D49>K ?3?@5?3"2 @?2? " 2$?J?:A
5$E>#$95" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N
D) ? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93? q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
T) " @>9" 3$ ?K>9b?#$95" 3?: 2"A
3?:N
 3 6H    4  
,,
 - #?E?E" 9<" 9$E$::>5? 3$ Z4?KA
Z4$2 2$a4K?a$#N
 - #?E?E" 9<" @"3$ :$2 2$@?A
2?3"% $# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>?] 3$X$ :$2
:4J:5>54W3" @"2 "452" "2>a>9?KN
 !$9b4#? D$22?#$95? ?K^# 3?
Eb?X$ 3$ 2"3? D"29$E>3? 3$X$ :$2
#"95?3? 9" #?E?E"N
"  ! 

8"# " X$WE4K" $ ?: @$::"?: $# :$A
a42?9;? E"9D"2#$ "2>$95?3" @2$X>?A
#$95$] @2"E$3$2 3$ ?E"23" E"# ?:
>93>E?;\$: ? :$a4>2%

’
,$ D"2 "J2>a?3" ? D?Y$2 ? 52"E? 3$
@9$4 9" >95$2>"2 3? D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$#
"4 $# :4?: @2"p>#>3?3$:] @2$:5?2
? #‘p>#? ?5$9;<" ?": X$WE4K": $#
52e9:>5"N
2$"+
 C$5>2?2 5"3?: ?: @$::"?: 3$ 3$9A 2"3?2 ": @?2?D4:": 4#? X"K5? 9" :$95>3" b"2‘2>" ?5^ >9:$2>2 D>2#$A
52" 3" X$WE4K" @?2? Z4$ @"::? :$95>3" ?95>Ab"2‘2>"N #$95$ " :4@"25$ 3" #?E?E" 9?
K$X?95‘AK"N Y"9? 3$ $K$X?;<" 3? K"9a?2>9?]
 ’X>:?2 g: @$::"?: @2hp>#?: Z4$ 5$93" " E4>3?3" 3$ #?95$2 ?K>A
 9b?3" " @2h@2>" :4@"25$ E"# "
" X$WE4K" $:5‘ @2$:5$: ? :$2 K$A
X?95?3"] ?K$25?93" :$2 9$E$::‘2>" 12$:5?2 @?25>E4K?2 ?5$9;<" g Eb?X$ $95?Kb$ >93>E?3" @$K" :W#J"K"
Z4$ :$ ?D?:5$# 3?: :4?: @2"p>#>A @?2? 3$:#"95?a$# 3": @?2?D4:": 3? 9" 2$X$:5>#$95" @"2 J?>p" 3?
3?3$: $] :"J2$543"] Z4$ 5$9b?# 2"3? 342?95$ :4? 45>K>Y?;<"] @">: $K? @"25?N
" E4>3?3" 3$ 9<" 5"E?2 " X$WA @"3$ 5$2 $p52$#>3?3$: @"95>?a43?:N
E4K" ?5^ Z4$ :$_? ?J?>p?3" 9"X?A
#$95$N  1":>E>"9?2 " #?E?E" :"J " X$WA
 !<" K$X?95?2 " X$WE4K" ?K^# 3? E4K"] _495" g 2"3? ? :$ :4J:5>A
?K542? 9$E$::‘2>? @?2? ? 2$5>2?3? 54>2N ’ E?J$;? 3" #?E?E" 3$X$
3? 2"3?N $:5?2 @":>E>"9?3? @$2@$93>E4K?2
g J?:$ $ 52?X?3" 9$::? @":>;<"N
 8?K;?2 ?: 2"3?: @?2? $X>5?2 " 3$:A
1?2? 52?X‘AK"] $#@422?2 ? E?J$;?
K"E?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N
@?2? ? 3>2$>5?] ?5^ " $9E?>p$ 3"
 ,$ " X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $Z4>@?3" @>9" $# :4? :$3$
E"# 2"3?: 3$ K>a?] $# Z4$ "
E"J2$AE4J" E"J2$ ": @?2?D4:":]
45>K>Y?2 E"# #4>5? ?5$9;<"
? Eb?X$ @?2? 3$:@2$93$2 "
E"J2$AE4J" ?95$: 3$ K$X?95?2 "
X$WE4K"N
 ’95$: 3$ K$X?95?2 " X$WE4K"] ?K>A
X>?2] :$# 2$#"X$2] ": @?2?D4:":
9? 2"3? E"# " @9$4 X?Y>" 45>K>A
Y?93" ? Eb?X$ N +9Z4?95" ? 2"3?
?>93? $:5‘ ?@">?3? 9" :"K"] J?:5?  =9:$2>2 ? Eb?X$ 3$ 2"3? 9" b$A
p‘a"9" 3" #?E?E" $ a>2‘AK? 9"
2$",

- K$X?95?#$95" 3" X$WE4K" ?K^#
3" 9$E$::‘2>" @"3$ 5"29‘AK" #$9":
$:5‘X$K% @"3$ 3$:K>Y?2 3" #?E?E"
$ D$2>2 ?: @$::"?: @2hp>#?:N !<"
K$X?95?2 " X$WE4K" ?K^# 3? ?K542?
9$E$::‘2>? @?2? ? 2$5>2?3? 3? 2"3?N

(5>K>Y$ :"#$95$ ": @?2?D4:": 3$
2"3? $:@$E>D>E?3?: @?2? " :$4 X$WA
E4K"N 1?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3? >9E"22$5?: "4
?@$25?3?: >9?3$Z4?3?#$95$ @"3$2<"
D?Y$2 ? 2"3? :"K5?2A:$N

 )$X?95?2 " X$WE4K" " :4D>E>$95$ 

@?2? @$2#>5>2 ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3?
2"3?N
 C$#"X$2 ": @?2?D4:": $ ? 2"3?
q$# X$2:\$: $Z4>@?3?: E"# 5?#A
@<" 3? 2"3?] 2$5>2‘AK" 3$@">: 3$
5$2 ?K>X>?3" ": @?2?D4:": Z4$ "
D>p?# $] @"2 D>#] 3$:?@$25?2 " uKA
5>#" @?2?D4:" $ $p52?>2 ? 2"3?rN
 C$#"X$2 " @>9" 3$ ?K>9b?#$95"
D"29$E>3" $# E"9_495" E"# "
#?E?E" $ >9:$2>AK" 9" E4J" 3?
2"3? @?2? ?4p>K>?2 9" $9E?>p$ 3?
2"3?N
 &"95?2 ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N
 12"E$3$2 E"# " ?@$25" 3": @?2?A
D4:": ?@$9?: ?5^ D>E?2$# D>2#$:]
:$# ?@$25‘AK": 5"5?K#$95$N
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 2"3? 9"2#?K
$:5‘] 9?: :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ E"95?5" E"#
" E4J"] K>#@? $ :$# >#@42$Y?: Z4$
@"3$# E?4:?2 " ?D2"4p?#$95" 3":
@?2?D4:": 3$ D>p?;<"N
 ’E>"9?2 " #?E?E" $ ?J?>p?2 E"#A
@K$5?#$95$ " X$WE4K"N
 ’@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:":] @?::?93"
?K5$29?3?#$95$ 3$ 4# @?2?D4:"
@?2? " "@":5"] :$a493" ? "23$#
94#^2>E? >K4:52?3? 9? D>a42? :$A
a4>95$N +# E?:" 3$ 3uX>3?: :"J2$
" 5"2Z4$ 3$ ?@$25" 3": @?2?D4:":]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
> N

1?2? $X>5?2 K$:\$: $# @$::"?:] "
?@$25" D>9?K 3": @?2?D4:": :h 3$X$
:$2 $D$54?3" Z4?93" " X$WE4K" 5>X$2
?: 2"3?: 9" :"K"] @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ "
@2h@2>" X$WE4K" E?>? 3" #?E?E"N

!49E? 4:$ D"2;? $p52? E"# ": @^:
9$# 4:$ 4#? $p5$9:<" 9? Eb?X$ 3$
’
2"3?N =:5" @"3$2‘ E?4:?2 ?@$25" $pA
E$::>X" 3": @?2?D4:":N

1?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3? E"22"W3": $ 3$
2":Z4$?#$95" 3>DWE>K 3$X$# :$2 :4J:A
5>54W3": ?95$: 3? X$2>D>E?;<" 3" 5"2A

2$"-
Z4$ 3$ ?@$25" $ ": D42": 2":Z4$‘X$>:
3" E4J" 3? 2"3? 3$X$# :$2 K>#@":N

+952$ $# E"95?5" E"# ?  !&
  , ' > " #?>: 2‘@>3" @"::WX$K
@?2? X$2>D>E?2 " ?@$25" E"22$5" 3": @?A
2?D4:": 3$ D>p?;<" 3?: 2"3?:] 4:?93"
4#? Eb?X$ 3$ 5"2Z4$ E?K>J2?3? ?3$A
Z4?3?#$95$N
!#!
1?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3? ?@$25?3": 3$ #?A
9$>2? >9E"22$5? @"3$# :$ :"K5?2 34A
2?95$ ? E"934;<" $ E?4:?2 ?E>3$95$:]
D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ @$23? 3$ E"952"K$
3" X$WE4K"N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
 C$@":>E>"9?2 " #?E?E"] ?: D$22?A
#$95?: $ " @9$4 X?Y>" 9" >95$A
2>"2 3" @"25?A#?K?:] E$25>D>E?93"A
:$ 3" :$4 E"22$5" 52?X?#$95"N
2$%.

’: 2"3?: E"# @9$4 49>3>2$E>"9?K
:<" 2$E"9b$EWX$>: @"2 :$5?: 9" DK?9E"
3" @9$4] Z4$ >93>E?# " :$95>3" 3$
2"K?#$95" @2$X>:5"] Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 ?JA
:"K45?#$95$ 2$:@$>5?3"N ,h ?::># ":
@9$4: #?95[# ?: :4?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?:
$# 5$2#": 3$ ?3$2[9E>?] 24W3"] 2$A
:>:5[9E>? ?" 3$:a?:5$ $ 32$9?a$# $#
@>:" #"Kb?3"N

,$] ?@h: 4# D42"] D"2 9$E$::‘A
2>" #"95?2 4#? 2"3? 3$::$ 5>@" 9"
:$95>3" >9X$2:" ?" @2$X>:5"] ^ 2$E"A
#$93‘X$K E"95>94?2 ? E"934Y>2 E"#
#4>5" E4>3?3"] 4#? X$Y Z4$] 9$:A
5?: E"93>;\$:] " 2$93>#$95" 3" @9$4
^ K>#>5?3"N +:5? @2$E?4;<" 3$X$ :$2
K$X?3? $# E"9:>3$2?;<" :"J2$543"
E"# @>:" 3? $:52?3? #"Kb?3"N

1?2? @"3$2 3$:D245?2 3? #$Kb"2
D"2#? 3?: X?95?a$9: 3" @>:" 3? $:A
52?3? 49>3>2$E>"9?K] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K
X"K5?2 ? E"K"E?2 " #?>: 3$@2$::?
@"::WX$K 5"3?: ?: 2"3?: 9" :$95>3" 3$
#?2Eb? @2$X>:5"N

8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 2"3? :"J2$:A
:?K$95$ $:5‘ #"95?3? E"# ? X‘KX4K?
X>2?3? @?2? D"2?N ’ 2"3? @"3$ D>A
E?2 3?9>D>E?3? :$ #"95?3? >9E"22$5?A
#$95$N

,$ " X$WE4K" $:5>X$2 $Z4>@?3" E"#
E"J2$AE4J" "4 E?K"5?] 9<" 5$95?2
#"95‘AK": 9? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N
"!" ! !  &
J! "!
,$a4>93" " @2"E$3>#$95" ?95$2>"2A
#$95$ 3$:E2>5"] K$X?95?2 " X$WE4K" $
3$:#"95?2 ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N +#
:$a4>3?] X"K5?2 ? #"95?2 ? 2"3? 3$
45>K>Y?;<" 9"2#?K @2"E$3$93" E"#"
3$:E2>5" ? :$a4>2N
 H ,   6
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 2"3? 9"2A
#?K $:5‘] 9?: :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ E"9A
5?5" E"# " E4J"] K>#@? $ :$# >#A
@42$Y?: Z4$ @"3$#] $# :$a4>3?]
E?4:?2 " ?D2"4p?#$95" 3": @?2?A
D4:": 3$ D>p?;<"N
 &"95?2 ? 2"3? 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 9"2A
#?K $ $92":E?2 4# @?2?D4:" $#
4# 3": "2>DWE>": 2":E?3":] :$#
?@$25‘AK"N
 &"95?2 ? E?K"5? 3? 2"3?] D?Y$93"
E">9E>3>2 " D42" E"# ? #$>?AK4?
$ E"# " @?2?D4:" _‘ $92":E?3"d
$# :$a4>3?] >9:$2>2 ": I @?2?D4:":
2$:5?95$:N
 ’J?>p?2 " X$WE4K" $ 2$5>2?2 " #?A
E?E"N
 ’52?X^: 3? 45>K>Y?;<" 3? Eb?X$
D"29$E>3?] ?@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:":
:$a4>93" ? "23$# ?95$2>"2#$95$
>K4:52?3?N
 H ,   ' 5 '*
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? 2"3? 9"2A
#?K $:5‘] 9?: :4@$2DWE>$: 3$ E"9A
5?5" E"# " E4J"] K>#@? $ :$#
>#@42$Y?: Z4$ @"3$# E?4:?2 "
?D2"4p?#$95" 3": @?2?D4:": 3$
D>p?;<"N
 =952"34Y>2 ? 2"3? 9" E4J" $ ?@$2A
5?2 ": @?2?D4:": E"# ? Eb?X$ D"2A
9$E>3?N
 ’J?>p?2 " X$WE4K" $ 2$5>2?2 " #?A
E?E"N
 ’52?X^: 3? 45>K>Y?;<" 3? Eb?X$
D"29$E>3?] ?@$25?2 ": @?2?D4:":
:$a4>93" ? #$:#? "23$# ?95$A
2>"2#$95$ >K4:52?3?N
 V"K5?2 ? >9:$2>2 " 5?#@<" 3? 2"3?N
! Q    67
 8"K"E?2 " #?E?E" $ ?: "452?:
D$22?#$95?: 9": :$4: 2$:@$E5>X":
K"E?>: 3$952" 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
 8"K"E?2 ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 9"
X<" 3" @"25?A#?K?:N
 C$@":>E>"9?2 E"22$5?#$95$ " 5?A
@$5$ 3$ 2$X$:5>#$95" 3" @"25?A
#?K?:N

+952$ $# E"95?5" E"# ?  !&
  , ' > " #?>: 2‘@>3" @"::WX$K
@?2? X$2>D>E?2 " ?@$25" E"22$5" 3": @?A
2?D4:": 3$ D>p?;<" 3?: 2"3?:] 4:?93"
4#? Eb?X$ 3$ 5"2Z4$ E?K>J2?3? ?3$A
Z4?3?#$95$N
!#!
1?2?D4:": 3$ 2"3? ?@$25?3": 3$ #?A
9$>2? >9E"22$5? @"3$# :$ :"K5?2 34A
2?95$ ? E"934;<" $ E?4:?2 ?E>3$95$:]
D$2>#$95": a2?X$: $ @$23? 3$ E"952"K$
3" X$WE4K"N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
’
!#!
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ :$ 3$:5>9? $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?"
4:" 5$#@"2‘2>"] $# E?:" 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>?N
2$%!
 ’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$X$ :$2 2$34Y>3? ?"
#W9>#" >93>:@$9:‘X$KN
!#!
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ :$ 3$:5>9? $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?"
4:" 5$#@"2‘2>"N
&?93?2 2$@?2?2 $ 2$#"95?2 ? 2"3?
:4J:5>54W3? " #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$ @":A
:WX$KN
'   
   
/  
!!  "#!
+# E?:" 3$ J?5$2>? 3$:E?22$a?3?] ^
@"::WX$K $D$54?2 4#? @?25>3? 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>? 45>K>Y?93" E?J": $ ? J?5$2>?
3$ 4# "452" X$WE4K" "4 :$2X>93"A:$
3$ 4#? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2N +# 5"3": ":
E?:":] ? J?5$2>? 45>K>Y?3? 3$X$ 5$2 E?A
@?E>3?3$ >a4?K "4 @"4E" :4@$2>"2 $#
2$K?;<" g 3$:E?22$a?3?N
2$%"
’ @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>? @"3$ :$2
@$2>a":? :$ $D$54?3? 3$ #"3" >9E"2A
2$5"% :$a4>2 E"# ?5$9;<" ": @2"E$3>A
#$95": 3$:E2>5": ? :$a4>2N
!#!
+X>5?2 ?J:"K45?#$95$ ? 45>K>Y?;<"
3$ 4# E?22$a?3"2 3$ J?5$2>?: 2‘@>3"
@?2? ? @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N
-: :>:5$#?: $K$52v9>E": $ ?: E$9A
52?>: 3$ >a9>;<" $ ?K>#$95?;<" 3" #"A
5"2 @"3$2>?# D>E?2 3?9>D>E?3":N

!<" 45>K>Y?2 4#? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2
"4 Z4?KZ4$2 "452? D"95$ 3$ ?K>#$95?A
;<" $p5$29? E"# 4#? 5$9:<" :4@$2>"2
? 7L V% @"3$2>?# 3?9>D>E?2A:$ ? J?5$A
2>?] " #"5"2 3$ @?25>3?] " ?K5$29?3"2
"4 " :>:5$#? $K^52>E" 3" X$WE4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>?
E"# J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2] 949E? K>a?2 "
E?J" 9$a?5>X" q r 3? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2
?" @"K" 9$a?5>X" 3? J?5$2>? 3" X$WA
E4K"] #?: :># ? 4# @"95" 3$ #?::?
#"5"2oE?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"N
7N 1"K" @":>5>X"
LN 1"K" 9$a?5>X"
!#!
’95$: 3$ ?J2>2 " E?@v 3" #"5"2]
3$:K>a?2 " X$WE4K"] E$25>D>E?93" 3$
Z4$ " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" $:5$_? 9?
@":>;<"  N C$:@$>5?2 " >93>E?3"
9? @K?E? ?@K>E?3? :"J " E?@v 3" #"A
5"2N w4?93" :$ $9E"952?2$# "452?:
@$::"?: 9" X$WE4K"] ?E"9:$Kb?A:$ $pA
52?>2 :$#@2$ ? Eb?X$N - X$WE4K" 3$X$
:$2 ?J?93"9?3" :$#@2$ 3$@">: 3$ 5$2
? @"::$ 3? Eb?X$ "4 3$ ? 5$2 E"K"A
E?3" " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @"A
:>;<"  N
*42?95$ ?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ ?J?:5$A
E>#$95" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] E$25>D>E?2A
:$ 3$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" $:5$_? 3$:K>a?3"
qE"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 rN
!! " %!! !N&
!
’ J?5$2>? 3" X$WE4K" $:5‘ K"E?K>A
Y?3? 9" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2]
?52‘: 3" a24@" h@5>E" $:Z4$23"N
!#!
!<" :$ ?@2"p>#?2 3? X$95">9b?
3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" 2?3>?3"2] @">:
" $K$52"X$95>K?3"2 @"3$ E"#$;?2 ?
D49E>"9?2 $ E?4:?2 K$:\$:N
C$:@$>5$ :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$:
3$::$ #?94?KN
!#!
C$5>2?2 Z4?KZ4$2 "J_$5" #$5‘K>E"
q@"2 $pN ?9^>:] 2$Kha>":] @4K:$>2?:r]
E?@?Y 3$ @2"X"E?2 4# E"95?5" $K^A
52>E" ?E>3$95?KN
1$2>a" 3$ a2?X$: K$:\$:O
!#!
’: J?5$2>?: E"95[# ‘E>3" Z4$ @"3$
Z4$>#?2 ? @$K$ "4 ": "Kb":N ’: J?5$A
2>?: a$2?# b>32"a[9>"] D?E>K#$95$ >9A
DK?#‘X$K $ $p@K":>X"N
’::>#] 9<" ?@2"p>#?2 Eb?#?: "4
3>:@":>5>X": Z4$ @"::?# @2"X"E?2
D?W:E?:N
12"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 ’E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95"] 3$:K"E?2 ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" @?2? ?
@":>;<" q+:5?E>"9?#$95"r
$] $# :$a4>3?] E"K"E?2 "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9?
@":>;<"  @ N
 *$:K>a?2 5"3": ": "452": ?E$::hA
2>": $K^52>E": @2$:$95$: 9" X$WA
E4K"N
 ,$ 45>K>Y?2 ? J?5$2>? 3$ "452" X$WA
E4K"] $:5?E>"9?2 $:5$ uK5>#" ?" ?KA
E?9E$ 3": E?J": 45>K>Y?3": @?2?
? K>a?;<"] ?E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$ $:5?A
E>"9?#$95" $ E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$
? >a9>;<" $:5‘ 3$:K>a?3?N

!<" K>a?2 3>2$5?#$95$ ": 5$2#>9?>:
9$a?5>X": 3?: 34?: J?5$2>?:O ,$ ? J?A
5$2>? ?4p>K>?2 $:5>X$2 >9:5?K?3? $# "4A
52" X$WE4K"] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ $952$
$:5$ uK5>#" $ " X$WE4K" E"# ? J?5$2>?
3$:E?22$a?3? 9<" $p>:5$# @?25$: #$A
5‘K>E?: ?E>3$95?K#$95$ $# E"95?5"]
_‘ Z4$ @"3$ E2>?2A:$ 4#? K>a?;<" g ’
#?::? E"# " 2>:E" 3$ @2"X"E?2 a2?A
X$: K$:\$: 9?: @$::"?: $X$954?K#$95$
@2$:$95$: 9?: @2"p>#>3?3$:N
2$%%


,$ $D$54?3" 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5"] "
@2"E$3>#$95" 3$:E2>5" ? :$a4>2 @"3$
@2"X"E?2 a2?X$: K$:\$: ? @$::"?: "4
3?9>D>E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ 2$E?2a? 3$ 4#
"4 3$ ?#J": ": X$WE4K":N ,$a4>2 E2>A
5$2>":?#$95$ ?: >93>E?;\$: D"29$E>A
3?: ? :$a4>2N
 567  ,4
1?2? $D$54?2 ? @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>?] @2"E$3$2 E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$A
a4>2%
 )>a?2 4#? $p52$#>3?3$ 3" E?J"
45>K>Y?3" @?2? " @":>5>X" q¥r ?"
5$2#>9?K @":>5>X" q¥r 3" X$WE4K"
E"# ? J?5$2>? 3$:E?22$a?3?N
 )>a?2 4#? $p52$#>3?3$ 3" E?J"
45>K>Y?3" @?2? " @":>5>X" q¥r ?"
5$2#>9?K @":>5>X" q¥r 3" X$WE4K"
E"# ? J?5$2>? ?4p>K>?2N
 )>a?2 4#? $p52$#>3?3$ 3" E?J"
45>K>Y?3" @?2? " 9$a?5>X" q r ?"
5$2#>9?K 9$a?5>X" q r 3? J?5$2>?
?4p>K>?2N
 )>a?2 ? $p52$#>3?3$ "@":5? 3"
E?J" 45>K>Y?3" @?2? " 9$a?5>X" q r
2$%&
? 4#? #?::? 3" #"5"2 q4#?
@?25$ $# #$5?K 3" #"5"2 "4 3?
E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" E"# ? J?5$2>?
3$:E?22$a?3?r K"9a$ 3? J?5$2>? $
3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ E"#A
J4:5WX$KN
 )>a?2 " #"5"2 3" X$WE4K" E"# J?A
5$2>? ?4p>K>?2] 3$>p?93"A" D49E>A
"9?2 ?Ka49: #>945": $# #?2Eb?
K$95?N +# :$a4>3?] K>a?2 " #"5"2
3" X$WE4K" E"# ? J?5$2>? 3$:E?2A
2$a?3?N
!#!
!<" K>a?2 " E?J" ?" 5$2#>9?K 9$A
a?5>X" q r 3? J?5$2>? 3$:E?22$a?3?N ’
D?W:E? 2$:4K5?95$ @"3$2>? E?4:?2 ? $pA
@K":<" 3? J?5$2>? $ @2"X"E?2 K$:\$:
a2?X$:N
(5>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$ " @"95" 3$
#?::? $:@$EWD>E"d 9<" 45>K>Y?2 Z4?KA
Z4$2 "452? @?25$ #$5‘K>E? $p@":5?N
   ,4
(#? X$Y K>a?3" " #"5"2] 2$5>2?2
": E?J":] :$a4>93" ? "23$# >9X$2:?
2$K?5>X?#$95$ g ?E>#? 3$:E2>5?N
,$] 3$@">: 3$ ?Ka4#?: 5$95?5>X?:]
" #"5"2 9<" K>a?2] 9<" >9:>:5>2 >945>KA
#$95$] #?: E"95?5?2 ?   ! &
= ,  > N
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" 2$E"22$2 D2$A
Z4$95$#$95$ g @?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9A
E>?] #?93?2 X$2>D>E?2 ? J?5$2>? $ " :>:A
5$#? 3$ 2$E?2a? 3" X$WE4K" 9? 
 ! = ,  > N
!! " "!%! 
$!
+X>5?2 ?J:"K45?#$95$ ? @?25>3? @"2
$#@422<"] @"2 2$J"Z4$ "4 45>K>Y?93"
?: 3$:E>3?:N

+X$954?>: ?E$::h2>": q@"2 $pN E$K4A
K?2$:] $5ENr K>a?3": g: 5"#?3?: 3$ E"2A
2$95$ 3" X$WE4K" ?J:"2X$# E"22$95$
#$:#" Z4$ 9<" :$_?# 45>K>Y?3":N ,$
3$>p?3": K>a?3": #4>5" 5$#@" E"# "
#"5"2 3$:K>a?3"] @"3$# 3$:E?22$a?2
? J?5$2>?] E"# E"9:$Z4$95$ 2$34;<"
3? 342?;<" 3$:5? uK5>#? $o"4 >#@":A
:>J>K>3?3$ 3$ K>a?2 " #"5"2N
  
  !
!! 
=95$2X^# $# E?:" 3$ Eb"Z4$ @2"A
X"E?93"%
 ’ >95$224@;<" 3? ?K>#$95?;<" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K E"# E"9:$Z4$95$
3$:?5>X?;<" 3" #"5"2N
 - 3$:52?X?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3?:
@"25?:N
 - ?E$93>#$95" 3?: K4Y$: >95$2A
9?:N
 ’ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3? X$95>K?;<" 3"
EK>#?5>Y?3"2N
 ’E$93>#$95" 3?: K4Y$: 3$ $#$2A
a[9E>? q@?2? 3$:?5>X?2 ?: K4Y$:]
@2$::>"9?2 " J"5<" :>54?3" 9" @?>A
9$K 3$ >9:524#$95":rN
+# ?Ka4#?: X$2:\$:] ? >95$2X$9;<" 1?2? 2$:5?J$K$E$2 " E"22$5" D49E>A
3" :>:5$#? ^ ?::>9?K?3? @$K? X>:4?K>A "9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"] $D$54?2 " :$A
Y?;<" 3$ 4#? #$9:?a$# 9? 5$K?N *" a4>95$ @2"E$3>#$95" q$:5$ @2"E$3>A
#$:#" #"3"] 4#? #$9:?a$# $:A #$95" 3$X$ :$2 >9>E>?3" $ E"9EK4W3"
@$EWD>E? 9" 3>:@K?y ?X>:? " E"9345"2 $# #$9": 3$ 7 #>945"r%
E?:" ? D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 3" :>:5$#? D>A
Z4$ E"#@2"#$5>3?N
=9:@$E>"9?2 E4>3?3":?#$95$ " X$WA
E4K" @?2? :$ E$25>D>E?2 3$ Z4$ 9<"
$p>:5?# D4a?: 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K] @"2
$p$#@K" 9" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"A
5"2] :"J " X$WE4K" "4 9? @2"p>#>3?3$
3? ‘2$? 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"N *$@">: 3?
E"K>:<"] 3$:K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >aA
9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  @?2? 9<"
3$:E?22$a?2 ? J?5$2>?N
’
!#!
*$@">: 3" >#@?E5"] E?:" :$ :>95?
Eb$>2" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K "4 :$ X$2>D>A
Z4$# X?Y?#$95": 9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K>A
#$95?;<"] 9<" 2$?5>X?2 " :>:5$#?N
C>:E" 3$ >9E[93>"O
2$%’
 ,     4',  ,  3- ,      *+,-'

!6H   *'*  -' K67

8"# ? ?K?X?9E? 3": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 9? @":>;<" 9$452?]

E"K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
*$:K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  =93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5? >95$2#>5$95$
=93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $:Z4$23? >95$2#>5$95$d >93>E?3"2 3$
’5>X?2 " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5?
3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5? ?E$:" D>p"
=93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5? >95$2#>5$95$d >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<"
’5>X?2 " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $:Z4$23?
@?2? ? $:Z4$23? ?E$:" D>p"
=93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $:Z4$23? >95$2#>5$95$d >93>E?3"2 3$
’5>X?2 " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5?
3>2$;<" @?2? ? 3>2$>5? ?E$:" D>p"
’5>X?2 " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $:Z4$23? ’#J": ": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" @$2#?9$E$# ?E$:": D>p":

*$:?5>X?2 " >93>E?3"2 3$ 3>2$;<" @?2? ? $:Z4$23? ’#J": ": >93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" ?@?a?#A:$

*$:K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<" 

*$:K"E?2 " E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" @?2? ? @":>;<"  - :>:5$#? D"> 2$>9>E>?3" $ " #"5"2 @"3$ :$2 2$?5>X?3"

2$%*
    
'1
" 3>?3"2 @"3$ @2"X"E?2 Z4$>#?342?:
’" @$2E"22$2 52$Eb": E"#" ": 3$:A
E2>5": ? :$a4>2] $ 9? @2$:$9;? 3$ E"9A
3>;\$: EK>#‘5>E?: $pE$@E>"9?>: Z4$
@"::?# @2"X"E?2 " ?@?2$E>#$95" 3$
D$9v#$9": 3$ :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3"
#"5"2] ?3"5?2 ?: :$a4>95$: ?J"23?A
a$9:%
  -67   ) K>#>5?2 ?
X$K"E>3?3$N
  -67  *  - 4  /,
 ]  0) E"# " X$WE4K" @?2?3"]
E"K"E?2 " Ee#J>" $# @"95"
#"25" $ #?95$2 " #"5"2 9"
2$a>#$ #W9>#"N

(# :>:5$#? 3$ 2$D2>a$2?;<" :4@$A
2?Z4$E>3" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 " X$WE4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95"] $9A
E":5?2 $ @?2?2 " X$WE4K"N P?Y$2 D49E>A
"9?2 " #"5"2 $# #?2Eb? K$95? E"# "
?2AE"93>E>"9?3" 3$:?5>X?3" ?5^ Z4$
? 5$#@$2?542? J?>p$N ,$ ? 5$#@$2?A
542? 9<" J?>p?2] 3>2>a>2A:$ ?::># Z4$

@"::WX$K g C$3$ 3$ ’::>:5[9E>? c$$@ N
’ :?W3? 3$ KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>A
’ :$a4>2] $:5<" >93>E?3?: ?Ka4#?: #$95" 3" #"5"2 "4 3$ X?@"2 3" 2?A
:>54?;\$: ?3>E>"9?>: Z4$ D?X"2$E$# "
?@?2$E>#$95" 3$ :>54?;\$: $pE$@E>"A a2?X$:N ,$ 9"5?2 X?@"2 @2"X$9>$95$
9?>: 3$ :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2% 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2] "4 :$
"4X>2 " 24W3"] 9<" ?J2>2 " E?@v ?5^
Z4$ " 2?3>?3"2 5$9b? 5>3" 5$#@" :4D>A
 ,$ " ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" $:5>X$2 K>A
E>$95$ @?2? ?22$D$E$2N !49E? 5$95?2 5>A
a?3"] 3$:K>a‘AK"N - :>:5$#? 3$
2?2 " 5?#@<" E"# " 2?3>?3"2 Z4$95$N
?2AE"93>E>"9?3" E"952>J4> @?2? "
:4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N
 
 C$a4K?2 " ?Z4$E>#$95" 3" b?A
J>5‘E4K" @?2? " #‘p>#"] "2>$9A  < 
5?93" ? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3" ?2 @?2? % 
" @>:" "4 @?2? " $p5$2>"2 3" X$WA
E4K"] E?:" ?: E"93>;\$: EK>#‘A !!"  "#&
5>E?: $p5$29?: @$2#>5?# #?95$2 !
": X>32": K?5$2?>: ?J$25":d $# :$A +# E?:" 3$ ?X?2>?] @?2? 3$:K"E?2 ?
a4>3?] ?5>X?2 " X$95>K?3"2 3" :>:A
5$#? 3$ EK>#?5>Y?;<" g X$K"E>A
?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>" 3? @":>;<" q+:A ’
5?E>"9?#$95"rN @2"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$
3?3$ #‘p>#?N *$::$ #"3"] " #"3"%
?Z4$E$3"2 ?54?2‘ E"#" 4# 2?3>A
?3"2 :4@K$#$95?2] E"952>J4>93"
 *$:K>a?2 " #"5"2N
@?2? 3>::>@?2 " E?K"2 3" :>:5$#?
3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N  ’E>"9?2 " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E"N
2$%+
 ’54?93" E"# E4>3?3" 9" @"95"
>93>E?3" @$K? :$5?] 2$#"X$2]
K$X?95?93"A? @?2? E>#?] ?
#"K342? qE"# ? E">D?r 3?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>"N
 8"K"E?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9?
@":>;<"  q@"95" #"25"rN
 V"K5?2 ? #"95?2 E"22$5?#$95$ ?
#"K342? $ ? E">D? 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$
Ee#J>"N
 *?2 ? @?25>3? 9" #"5"2 E"# ?
?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" 9? @":>;<"
 12$::>"9?2 ? D493" " @$3?K 3"  q@"95" #"25"rN
D2$>" $ #?95[AK" @2$::>"9?3"N
 =9:$2>2 @$2@$93>E4K?2#$95$ 4#?
@$Z4$9? Eb?X$ 3$ D$93? ?@2"A
   
@2>?3?] "4 D$22?#$95? :>#>K?2] 9" ! ' 
D42" g 3>2$>5? 9? @?25$ @":5$2>"2
,$ " X$WE4K" ?5"K?2 $# 4# 5$22$9"
3" E"9_495" $] $# :$a4>3?] @2$:A
?2$9":"] 3$ K?#? "4 9$X$] @2"E$3$2
:>"9?2 $ :$a42?2 ? ?K?X?9E? 3$
3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
3$:52?X?#$95"N
 S>2?2 " X"K?95$ :4E$::>X?#$95$
@?2? ? 3>2$>5? $ @?2? ? $:Z4$23?]
E"# " >954>5" 3$ K>J$2?2 ? ‘2$? 9"
$95"29" 3?: 2"3?:N
 12$::>"9?2 $ :$a42?2 " J"5<" 3?
?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>"N
 8"#45?2 :4E$::>X?#$95$ $952$ ?:
@":>;\$:  $  $] 342?95$ $:5$
@2"E$::"] @2$::>"9?2 K$X$#$95$ "
?E$K$2?3"2N

.2"E?: $952$ ?: @":>;\$:  $  @"A
3$# :$2 D$>5?: E"# ?: 2"3?: $# X$A
K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? 3$ ~ i#obN ,$#@2$
Z4$ ? 52?9:#>::<" ^ #?95>3? 9? @"A
:>;<"  q@"95" #"25"r @"2 #?>: 3$ L
:$a493":] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" @2$::>"9?2 "
@$3?K 3$ D2$>" @?2? :$K$E>"9?2 ?: @"A
:>;\$:  "4  N

(:?2 " #W9>#" @"::WX$K 3$ @2$:A
:<" 9" ?E$K$2?3"2 >2‘ #?95$2 " #"A
X>#$95" 3$ J?K?9;" 3$952" 3$ 4#?
?54?;<" $D>E>$95$] :$# Z4$ ?: 2"3?:
a>2$# $# D?K:" "4 ?: 2"5?;\$: 3" #"A
5"2 :$ $K$X$# $pE$::>X?#$95$N

2$%,

,$ 9$E$::‘2>"] @2$::>"9?2 " J"5<"
t+,8 -DDt @?2? 3$:?J>K>5?2 @?2E>?KA
#$95$ " :>:5$#? +,8 ?95$: 3$ 3?2 >9WA
E>" g "@$2?;<"N ’@h: K>J$2?2 " X$WA
E4K"] @2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$ " J"5<"
@?2? b?J>K>5?2 " :>:5$#? qE"9:4K5?2 ?
:$;<" t8?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ :$a42?9;?
?5>X?t 9" E?@W54K" t,$a42?9;?t @?2?
#?>: >9D"2#?;\$:rN
  
!
!?  "#!
!" @2$:$95$ 5h@>E" :<" 3$:E2>5":
": @2"E$3>#$95": @?2? " 2$J"Z4$ 3"
X$WE4K" $# :>54?;\$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N

1?2? $D$54?2 " 2$J"Z4$] ^ 9$E$::‘A
2>? 4#? J?22? 3$ 2$J"Z4$ 2Wa>3? 3$
#"3" ? $X>5?2 3?9>D>E?2 " X$WE4K"N

(5>K>Y?2 ?@$9?: J?22? 3$ 2$J"Z4$
2Wa>3?N 8"9$E5?2 ? J?22? 3$ 2$J"Z4$
?" X$WE4K" ?52?X^: 3" a?9Eb" 3$ 2$A
J"Z4$] 9<" ?": @?2?AEb"Z4$:N

C$:@$>5?2 ? K$a>:K?;<" 3$ 52e9:>5"
X>a$95$ @?2? @2"E$3>#$95": 3$ 2$J"A
Z4$N

w4?93" :$ D>p? " X$WE4K" 9? @K?5?A
D"2#? 3$ 4# E?#>9b<" 3$ 2$J"Z4$]
9<" 45>K>Y?2 ": E"#@"9$95$: 3?: :4:A
@$9:\$: 3>?95$>2? "4 52?:$>2? E"#"
@"95": 3$ D>p?;<"N (# 2$J"Z4$ $D$A
54?3" 3$ #"3" >#@2h@2>" @"3$ @2"A
’
X"E?2 3?9": 9" X$WE4K"N
2$%-
4.-  *+,-' & ,  6H 5  

! !! /R0 ! ! /DR0

  %; ! !!   _"% !" _"% !"

C$J"Z4$ $# 4#? :4@$2DWE>$
!+!T(&’ !0- 1+C&=.=*- !0- 1+C&=.=*-
@K?9?

+K$X?;<" 3?: 2"3?: "4 2$J"Z4$ .C’,+=C-, !0- 1+C&=.=*- !0- 1+C&=.=*-
9" X$WE4K" *=’!.+=C-, -{ !0- 1+C&=.=*-
V$WE4K" $# 4#? @K?5?D"2#? 3$
.-*-, &+)T-C &f.-*- &+)T-C &f.-*-
X$WE4K" 3$ :"E"22"

2$&.
? " ! !&
! /R0
 H , ,] 4  - P ,
f 2$E"#$93‘X$K 2$J"E?2 " X$WE4K"
E"# ?: Z4?52" 2"3?: +)+V’*’, 3"
:"K" 9? @K?5?D"2#? 3$ 4# X$WE4K" 3$
:"E"22"N
8?:" 9<" $:5$_? 3>:@"9WX$K 4# X$WA
E4K" 3$ :"E"22" E"# @K?5?D"2#?] "
X$WE4K" 3$X$ :$2 2$J"E?3" E"# ?:
2"3?: 3>?95$>2?: +)+V’*’, 3" :"K"
q45>K>Y?93" 4# X$WE4K" "4 4#? D$22?A
#$95? ?3$Z4?3? Z4$ @$2#>5? ? $K$A
X?;<" 3?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?:rN
? " ! &
! /DR0  _"% !&
"
f 2$E"#$93‘X$K 2$J"E?2 " X$WE4K"
E"# ?: Z4?52" 2"3?: +)+V’*’, 3"
:"K"N
f] ?::>#] @"::WX$K 2$J"E?2 " X$WA
E4K" $# 4#? @K?5?D"2#? 3$ 4# X$WA
E4K" 3$ :"E"22"] #?: 9<" E"# 4#?
$p52$#>3?3$ $K$X?3? $ ? "452? $# 4#
E?22" 3$ 2$J"Z4$N

+X>5?2 ? $K$X?;<" ?@$9?: 3?: 2"3?:
3>?95$>2?: q"4 52?:$>2?:rN ’ $K$X?;<"
?@$9?: 3?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?: q"4 52?A
:$>2?:r 342?95$ " 2$J"Z4$ @"3$ @2"A
X"E?2 3?9": 9? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"N

,$ " X$WE4K" D"2 2$J"E?3" :$# 2$:A
@$>5?2 ": 2$Z4>:>5": ?E>#? >93>E?3":]
@"3$# "E"22$2 3?9": a2?X$: 9? E?>p?
3$ Ee#J>"N -: 3?9": @2"X"E?3": @"2
4# 2$J"Z4$ $D$54?3" 3$ #"3" >#A
@2h@2>" 9<" $:5<" E"J$25": @$K? a?A
2?95>?N
%;  
!  !  %; &
 ; !
!#!
12$::>"9?2 " J"5<" 3$ @?25>3?] :$#
@>:?2 9" D2$>"] @?2? E"K"E?2 " E"#4A
5?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
+# :$a4>3?] @2$::>"9?2 9"X?#$95$
" J"5<" 3$ @?25>3? @?2? E"K"E?2 "
E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"
 ] :$# ?J2>2 ? @"25? 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
*42?95$ " 2$J"Z4$] K$#J2?2A:$
Z4$] 9<" 5$93" ? ?_43? 3" :$2X"D2$>"
$ 3? 3>2$;<" ?::>:5>3? $K$52"#$EeA
9>E?] @?2? D2$?2 " X$WE4K" :$2‘ 9$E$:A
:‘2>" $p$2E$2 #?>: D"2;? 9" @$3?K
3$ D2$>" $ @?2? X>2?2 " X"K?95$ :$2‘
9$E$::‘2>? 4#? ?;<" #?>: $9^2a>E?N
!<" 45>K>Y?2 E?J": DK$pWX$>: @?2? $D$A
54?2 " 2$J"Z4$ $ $X>5?2 ": $:5>E\$:N
*42?95$ ?: "@$2?;\$: 3$ 2$J"Z4$]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ? D>p?;<" 3" ?E"A
@K?#$95" 9" X$WE4K" 9<" 3?9>D>Z4$
’
": E"#@"9$95$: $# E"95?5"N
’" 2$J"E?2 " X$WE4K"] ^ "J2>a?5h2>"
2$:@$>5?2 ?: 9"2#?: $:@$EWD>E?: 3$
E>2E4K?;<" 2"3"X>‘2>?] 2$K?5>X?: 5?95"
?" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ Z4?95" ?"
E"#@"25?#$95" $# $:52?3?N ’95$: 3$
?@$25?2 " a?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$] K>#@?2
E4>3?3":?#$95$ ? :$3$ 2":E?3?N
2$&!
 !#!
-: a?9Eb": 3$ 2$J"Z4$ q:$ $Z4>A
@?3"r 3$X$# :$2 45>K>Y?3": :"#$95$
$# :>54?;\$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] @?2? D>A
p?2 ? E>95? $ @?2? 3$:K"E?#$95" 3"
X$WE4K" @?2? ? @2?9Eb? 3$ 2$J"Z4$N
!<" 45>K>Y?2 ": a?9Eb": 3$ 2$J"Z4$
:$ ?: 2"3?: $:5>X$2$# 52?X?3?: "4
@?2? >;?2 " X$WE4K"] @">: >::" @"3$2‘
3?9>D>E‘AK"N
!#!
C$:@$>5?2 ? K$a>:K?;<" 3$ 52e9:>5"
X>a$95$ @?2? ?: :>54?;\$: 3$ 2$J"Z4$N
’" 2$J"E?2 " X$WE4K"] 9<" 3?2 52?9A
E": $ "4 ?22?9Z4$: Z4$ @"::?# 3?9>A
D>E?2 " X$WE4K" $ E"K"E?2 $# 2>:E" ?:
@$::"?: $9X"KX>3?: 9? "@$2?;<"N
2$&"
!#!
1?2? " 3$:?5"K?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"
D"2? 3? X>? @?X>#$95?3?] "4 :$_?] $#
E"93>;\$: 3$ J?22"] ?2$>?] @>:": $:A
E"22$a?3>":] $5EN] #$3>?95$ " ?4pWA
K>" 3$ "452" X$WE4K"] :$#@2$ 45>K>Y?2
4#? J?22? 3$ 2$J"Z4$ 2Wa>3?N ’9A
5$: 3$ >9>E>?2 ? "@$2?;<"] 3$:"J:A
524>2 ?: 2"3?: $] :$ "452": D?5"2$: >#A
@$3>2$# ? 2$5>2?3? 3" X$WE4K" @"2
:4? @2h@2>? 52?;<"] E"#"] @"2 $p$#A
@K"] @>:" $pE$::>X?#$95$ $:E"22$a?A
3>"] ?2$9":"] K?#?] $5EN] 4# X$WE4K"
?@2"@2>?3" @?2? 2$J"Z4$ 3$X$ :$2 45>A
K>Y?3"N +# :$a4>3?] 3$@$93$93" 3?
:>54?;<"] E"K"E?2 " X$WE4K" $#  "4
#?2Eb? 2^ ] ?E$K$2?93" a2?3?5>X?A
#$95$ $ :>#4K5?9$?#$95$ ?" X$WE4K"
4:?3" @?2? " 2$J"Z4$N
!$ N !! %; /
+:5? "@$2?;<"  3$X$ :$2 2$?K>A .- 0
Y?3? $# Z4?KZ4$2 E"93>;<" 3$ 2>:E" -: a?9Eb": 3$ 2$J"Z4$ $:5<" D>p?A
@?2? ": E"9345"2$: $ @$::"?: $9X"KA 3": g E?22"E$2>? 3" X$WE4K"N +:5‘ 3>:A
X>3?:N @"9WX$K 4# a?9Eb" 9? @?25$ 52?:$>2?
!N
 -J:$2X?2 E"# ?5$9;<" ? X?K>3?3$
3" $p5>95"2 q? 3?5? $9E"952?A:$ a2?A
X?3? 9" E"2@" 3" E>K>932"r $ :$ "
@"95$>2" 3" #?9v#$52" $:5‘ 3$952"
3? D?>p? 9"2#?K 3$ "@$2?;<"N

/   
  
"!?
- $p5>95"2 3$ >9E[93>": @"3$ :$2
?3Z4>2>3" 9?   ! = , 
> N
’ @?25$ 3>?95$>2? 3" J?9E" 3" #"A
5"2>:5? ! $:5‘ @2$X>:5? @?2? ? >9:5?K?A
;<" 3" :4@"25$ @?2? D>p?;<" 3" $p5>9A
5"2 3$ >9E[93>":N ’


C$E"#$93?#": K$2 ?: >9:524;\$:
>#@2$::?: 9" $Z4>@?#$95"

2$&%
2
     
   !
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TA7
,+CV=/-, ’S+!*’*-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TA7
8-&1’C.=&+!.- *- &-.-C N N N N N N N N N TA7G
C+8’CC+S’!*- ’ B’.+C=’ N N N N N N N N N N N TA7|
,+CV=/-, !’ 8-!8+,,=-!“C=’ N N N N N N N N TA7|
)+V’!.’!*- - V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N TALF
1!+(, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TALF
)-!S’ =!’.=V=*’*+ *- V+m8()- N N N N N N TAHL
8’CC-8+C=’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TAHH
=!.+C=-C *- V+m8()- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TAHF

3
3
 
(#? E"22$5? #?945$9;<" @$2#>5$
#?95$2 " 3$:$#@$9b" 3" X$WE4K" ?"
K"9a" 3" 5$#@"] 2$34Y>2 ": E4:5": 3$
D49E>"9?#$95" $ @2"5$a$2 ? $D>E>[9A
E>? 3": :>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;?N
!$:5$ E?@W54K"] $p@K>E?A:$ E"#"N
   

"! !"!!
(#? E"22$5? #?945$9;<" ^ 3$5$2A
#>9?95$ @?2? a?2?95>2 ?" X$WE4K" 4#?
K"9a? 342?;<" $# E"93>;\$: >3$?>:N
1"2 >::"] ? c$$@ 3$D>9>4 4#? :^A
2>$ 3$ E"952"K$: $ 3$ >95$2X$9;\$:
3$ #?945$9;<" $# >95$2X?K": @2$$:A
5?J$K$E>3":] E"#" 3$:E2>5" 9" 1K?9"
3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?#?3?N
’95$: 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 >9:@$;<"] ^] 9"
$95?95"] :$#@2$ 9$E$::‘2>" 5$2 $#
?5$9;<" ?: >93>E?;\$: 3$:E2>5?: 9"
1K?9" 3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?#?3?
q@"2 $pN X$2>D>E?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$
" 9WX$K 3": KWZ4>3":] ? @2$::<" 3":
@9$4:] $5ENrN
- :$2X>;" 3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?A
#?3? ^ $D$54?3" @$K?   !&
 = ,  > ] E"# ": 5$#@": @2^A
D>p?3":N ,$] 342?95$ ? 2$?K>Y?;<" 3$
E?3? >95$2X$9;<"] ?K^# 3?: "@$2?A
;\$: @2$X>:5?:] :$ ?@2$:$95?2 ? 9$E$:A
:>3?3$ 3$ "452?: :4J:5>54>;\$: "4 2$A
@?2?;\$:] ?: #$:#?: :h @"3$2<" :$2
$D$54?3?: E"# " $p@KWE>5" ?E"23" 3"
8K>$95$N (5>K>Y?93" D2$Z4$95$#$95$
" X$WE4K" @?2? " 2$J"Z4$ 3$ ?52$K?A
3":] 2$34Y>2 " >95$2X?K" $952$ 4#?
#?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3? $ ? "452?N

-: E4@"9: 3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?A
#?3? :<" @2$:E2>5": @$K? #"95?3"2?N
’ 9<" $p$E4;<" 3": #$:#": @"3$
E"#@"25?2 ? E$::?;<" 3? a?2?95>?N

f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K :>9?K>Y?2 g  
! = ,  > $X$954?>: @$Z4$9?:
?9"#?K>?: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"] :$#
$:@$2?2 @$K? $p$E4;<" 3" @2hp>#"
E4@"#N
!? <!
’ E?3? 7NGGG i# "4 ?95$: 3$ X>A
?a$9: K"9a?:] E"952"K?2 $ $X$954?KA
#$95$ 2$:5?J$K$E$2%
 - 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>A
#$95" 3" #"5"2
 - 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3": D2$>":N
 - 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3" K?X?3"2 3"
X>32" 52?:$>2" $ @?2?AJ2>:?N
 12$::<" $ E"93>;\$: 3": @9$4:N
 - D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
>K4#>9?;<" qD?2h>:] >93>E?3"2$:
3$ 3>2$;<"] $#$2a[9E>?] $5ENr
 P49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?
K>#@?3"2oK?X?3"2 3"
@?2?AJ2>:?oX>32" 52?:$>2" $
@":>E>"9?#$95"o 3$:a?:5$ 3?:
@?Kb$5?:N
 !WX$K 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" (
@?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q’2K?
HLr q:"#$95$ @?2? ?: X$2:\$: 3>$A
:$KrN

3$!
 ’ E?3? C:222 i#] X$2>D>E?2 $] :$
9$E$::‘2>"] 2$:5?J$K$E$2% " 9WX$K 3$
hK$" 3" #"5"2N
J! !  &

+# E?:" 3$ ?E$93>#$95" 3" :W#A
J"K" q?#?2$K" e#J?2r 9" 3>:@K?y
qhK$" 3" #"5"2 3$a2?3?3"r] " hK$" 3"
#"5"2 3$X$ :$2 :4J:5>54W3" >#$3>?5?A
#$95$] >93$@$93$95$ 3? Z4>K"#$52?A
a$# @$2E"22>3? $o"4 5$#@" 3$ 4:"]
:"J @$9? 3$ 3?9": :$X$2": ?" #"5"2N

’.+!/0-% ": >95$2X?K": 3$ :4J:A
5>54>;<" 3$ hK$" 3" #"5"2] :$_? @"2
5$#@" "4 Z4>K"#$52?a$#] 3$X$# :$2
2$34Y>3": g #$5?3$ 9": E?:": 3$ 45>A
K>Y?;<" :$X$2? 3" X$WE4K"] "4 :$_?]
E?:" " X$WE4K" :$_? 45>K>Y?3" @2$3"A
#>9?95$#$95$ $# 4#? "4 #?>: 3?:
:$a4>95$: E"93>;\$:%
 C$J"Z4$ 3$ ?52$K?3":] 5‘p>] $9A
52$a? 3$ @"25? $# @"25?] $5EN
3$"
 +:52?3?: @"$>2$95?:] ?2$9":?:] K?A
#?E$95?:] $5EN
 1$2E42:": J2$X$: q#$9": 3$ |A~
i#r $ 2$@$5>3": $o"4 E"# 5$#@$A
2?542?: J?>p?:N
 &"5"2 Z4$ a>2? D2$Z4$95$#$95$
$# #?2Eb? K$95? "4 K"9a": @$2A
E42:": ? J?>p? X$K"E>3?3$] >9EK>A
9?;\$: ?E$954?3?: @"2 K"9a": @$A
2W"3": $o"4 a2?93$: ?K5>543$:N
 +# E?:" 3$ K"9a? >9?5>X>3?3$ 3"
X$WE4K" q:4@$2>"2 ? HG 3>?:rN
f 9$E$::‘2>" $D$54?2 ?: :$a4>95$:
X$2>D>E?;\$: E"# #?>: D2$Z4[9E>? 3"
Z4$ ? >93>E?3? 9" 1K?9" 3$ &?94A
5$9;<" 12"a2?#?3?%
 8"952"K$ 3?: E"93>;\$: $ 3$:A
a?:5$ 3?: @?:5>Kb?: 3": D2$>": ?
3>:E" 3>?95$>2":N
 8"952"K$ 3" $:5?3" 3$ K>#@$Y?
3?: D$Eb?342?: 3" E?@v 3" #"A
5"2 $ 3? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:]
K>#@$Y? $ K4J2>D>E?;<" 3?: ?K?A
X?9E?:N
 8"952"K$ X>:4?K 3?: E"93>;\$:%
#"5"2] E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"]
52?9:#>::<"] :$a#$95":
2Wa>3": $ DK$pWX$>: 3?:
54J4K?;\$: q$:E?@$o?K>#$95?;<"
3$ E"#J4:5WX$KoD2$>":r
$K$#$95": 3$ J"22?Eb?
qD"K$:o#?9a?:oE?:Z4>Kb":] $5ENrN
 8"952"K$ 3" $:5?3" 3$ E?2a? $
9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3? J?5$2>? q$K$A
52hK>5"rN
 8"952"K$ X>:4?K 3?: E"93>;\$: 3?:
E"22$>?: 3$ E"#?93" 3": ?E$::hA
2>":N
 8"952"K$ $ $X$954?K :4J:5>54>;<"
3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ 3" D>K52" 3"
hK$"N
 8"952"K$ $ $X$954?K :4J:5>54>;<"
3" D>K52" 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"N
 8"952"K$ $ $X$954?K :4J:5>54>;<"
3" D>K52" 3" ?2N
’: 2$X>:\$: 3$X$# :$2 2$?K>Y?3?:
 .- '  5 -   ]
"4 :$_?] ? E?3? 7LNGGG i# qX$WE4K":
PK$pr "4 ? E?3? LGNGGG i# qX$WE4K":
*>$:$Kr] "4 ? E?3? 7L #$:$: qPK$p $
*>$:$Kr] *',   .- , 
 N
 ’ 5"K$2e9E>? @$2#>5>3? @?2? ?
$p$E4;<" 3?: 2$X>:\$: :$2<" 3$
7NGGG i# @?2? #$9": "4 @?2? #?>:]
E?:" "E"22? @"2 Z4>K"#$52?a$# "4
HG 3>?: @?2? #$9": "4 @?2? #?>:]
E?:" "E"22? @"2 5$#@"N
( ' /*+,-' '(0)
 1d * 7) E?:" "E"22? @"2 Z4>A
K"#$52?a$#] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3?
$952$ 77NGGG $ 7HNGGG i#N &?:
E?:" "E"22? @"2 5$#@"] 3$X$2‘ :$2
2$?K>Y?3? $952$ 77 $ 7H #$:$:N
 Bd * 7) E?:" "E"22? @"2 Z4>A
K"#$52?a$#] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3?
$952$ 77NGGG $ 7HNGGG i# ! <
? 7ƒ 2$X>:<"N &?: E?:" "E"22? @"2
5$#@"] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? $952$
77 $ 7H #$:$: ! < ? 7ƒ 2$X>:<"N
 Bd * 7% E?:" "E"22? @"2 Z4>A
K"#$52?a$#] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3?
$952$ 7MNGGG $ L7NGGG i# ! <
? 7ƒ 2$X>:<"N &?: E?:" "E"22? @"2
5$#@"] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? $952$
77 $ 7H #$:$: ! < ? 7ƒ 2$X>:<"N
! ! "!&

’@h: ? 2$?K>Y?;<" 3? uK5>#? 2$X>:<"
>93>E?3? 9" 1K?9" 3$ &?945$9;<"]
E"9:>3$2?2 ? #$:#? D2$Z4[9E>? @?2?
:4J:5>54>;<" $ X$2>D>E?;<" 3$ E?3?
>5$#N

( ' /*+,-'  '0)

 1d * 7% E?:" "E"22? @"2 Z4>A

K"#$52?a$#] 3$X$2‘ :$2 2$?K>Y?3? (
$952$ 7MNGGG $ L7NGGG i#N &?:
E?:" "E"22? @"2 5$#@"] 3$X$2‘ :$2
2$?K>Y?3? $952$ 77 $ 7H #$:$:N

3$%
" 1:C 1O % N
* H
/ggg0 ! , 1B:222 [ -  , 1B "&
1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd 1Cd 1Dd 1Td
` *',   .- ,   
/ Q  b'  * 7 ' K0
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ D>K52" 3$ hK$"
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
3" #"5"2N q›r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" D>K52" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN q›r ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" $K$#$95" 3" D>K52" 3$ ?:@>2?A
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
;<" 3$ ?2 3" #"5"2N
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" $K$#$95" 3" D>K52" 3$ ?:@>2?A
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
;<" 3$ ?2 3" #"5"2N q››r
V$2>D>E?;<" 3": 9WX$>: 3": KWZ4>3":oDK4>3": 3$
5"3": ": :>:5$#?:% D2$>":] K?X?3"2 3": X>32":]
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 q9WX$K $ E"95?#>9?A
;\$:r] $5EN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: @?:5>Kb?: 3$ D2$>" 3?: 2"3?:
3>?95$>2?: $ 52?:$>2?:N
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
-B,N% 8?:" ? $:@$::42? u5>K 3?: @?:5>Kb?: :$_?
#$9"2 3" Z4$ 6 ##] 3$X$A:$ :4J:5>54WAK?:
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" $:a4>Eb" $ @?Kb$5?: 3": X>32":
52?:$>2": $ @?2?AJ2>:?] E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?]
E"#?93": $K^52>E": 3": X>32": 3?: @"25?:] :>:A
5$#? 3$ ?J$2542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3?: @"25?:N ,>:A
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
5$#? $K^52>E"o$K$52v9>E" q2‘3>"] ?K?2#$] $5ENr
$ >K4#>9?;<" >95$29? $ $p5$29? $ :>9?K>Y?;<"N
w4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $ >93>E?3"2$:N +:A
5?3" 3? J?5$2>?N

3$&
* H
/ggg0 ! , 1B:222 [ -  , 1B "&
1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd 1Cd 1Dd 1Td
` *',   .- ,   
/ Q  b'  * 7 ' K0
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: 54J4K?;\$: 3$ $:E?@?#$95"]
3$ ?K>#$95?;<" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K $ 3": D2$>":N
8"#@"9$95$: 3$ J"22?Eb? 3? @?25$ >9D$2>"2
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
3" X$WE4K"] E">D?:] a4?29>;\$:] #?9a4$>2?: $
@9$4: q3$:a?:5$ $ @2$::<"r] :4:@$9:\$:] E?>p?
3$ 3>2$;<" $ _495? b"#"E>9^5>E?NN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" D>K52" 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"N q›r ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
)>#@$Y? $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"] K4J2>D>E?;<" 3?: E?A
9?K$5?: $ E"#@"9$95$: #hX$>: 3" 5$5" :"K?2 ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: E"22$>?: 3": h2a<": ?4p>K>?2$:
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
3" #"5"2N q›r
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"o>a9>;<" 3"
#"5"2N (5>K>Y?2 " $Z4>@?#$95" 3$ 3>?a9h:A ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
5>E"N C$:$5?2 " ?X>:" 3$ 2$X>:\$:N
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" DK4>3" 3": D2$>":N ? E?3? LI #$:$: "4 ? E?3? HFNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" q$K^A
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
52>E"rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" 9WX$K 3$ $#>::\$: 3": a?:$:
¥ ¥ ¥
3$ $:E?@?#$95"N
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? $X?@"2?5>X" 3" 5?9Z4$
¥ ¥ ¥
3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN q›r
(
,4J:5>54>;<" 3?: E"22$>?: 3": h2a<": ?4p>K>?A
2$: 3" #"5"2 q"4 ? E?3? F ?9":] " Z4$ "E"2A ¥
2$2 @2>#$>2"rN q›r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3?: X$K?: 3$ >a9>;<" 3" #"5"2N ? E?3? FGNGGG i# q>93$@$93$95$ 3" 5$#@"r

3$’
* H
/ggg0 ! , 1B:222 [ -  , 1B "&
1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd 1Cd 1Dd 1Td
` *',   .- ,   
/ Q  b'  * 7 ' K0
=9:@$E>"9?2 $] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"] :4J:5>54>2 ? X‘KA
¥
X4K? 1CVN q›r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" KWZ4>3" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$A
? E?3? 7LG #$:$: "4 ? E?3? LIGNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r
E>#$95" 3" #"5"2N q›r
UK$" 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"N P"2 )>D$ q:$# 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ :4J:5>54>;<"r
1?2? EK>$95$: Z4$ "@5$# @"2 ?J?:5$E$2 " :$4
X$WE4K" $pEK4:>X?#$95$ E"# $5?9"K] ^ 2$E"A
#$93?3" " ?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#@K$5" 3" 5?9A
Z4$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K E"# a?:"K>9? q9" #W9>#" ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
4# 5?9Z4$r ? E?3? 7GNGGG i# @?2? 2$34Y>2
@2"X‘X$>: E"95?#>9?95$: @2"E$3$95$: 3" $5?A
9"KN
/g0   .- *  -4 -+@* 3 ,    K  ,`   *+,-' - ' K        
  `   ` ' ,  -  ,  6H *   - / 4.-` P( `   5      ` ,:0 - .-  G-* ' 5
 * :
/gg0   *+,-' - ' K           `     ' , `  '    3 '    67   
 *  -4 -+    * H:
/ggg0 ! ' ] ,       (,-67  * H 9)
  C2   /     -    0 , ,    :
  1222 [ /    -    0 , ,   .- '  5 :

3$*
" B:2 & 
* H
/ggg0 ! , B2:222 [ -  , 1B "` *',   1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd
.- ,    / Q  b'  * 7 ' K0
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ D>K52" 3$ hK$" 3" #"5"2N q›r
’5$9;<"% " #"3$K"  ' ^ $Z4>@?3" E"# 4# :>:5$#? Z4$ #"A
9>5"2? ? E"93>;<" 3$ 3$a2?3?;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2] @"25?95"]
?K^# 3?: >93>E?;\$: @"2 Z4>K"#$52?a$# $ 5$#@" _‘ #$9E>"A
9?3?:] ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ 3" D>K52" 3$ hK$" 3" ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
#"5"2 3$X$2‘ :$2 $D$54?3? >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?@h: ? :>9?K>Y?;<" 3$
4#? K4YA$:@>? $:@$EWD>E? "4 4#? #$9:?a$# 9" @?>9$K 3$ >9:524A
#$95": "E"22$2N 12"E42?2 ?  !  , ' > @?2? ? :4J:5>A
54>;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ 3" D>K52" 3$ hK$"N
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" D>K52" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN q›r ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" $K$#$95" 3" D>K52" 3$ ?:@>2?;<" 3$ ?2 3" #"5"2N
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
q›r
V$2>D>E?;<" 3": 9WX$>: 3": KWZ4>3":oDK4>3": 3$ 5"3": ": :>:5$#?:%
D2$>":] K?X?3"2 3": X>32":] ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 q9WX$K $ E"95?A ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
#>9?;\$:r] $5EN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: @?:5>Kb?: 3$ D2$>" 3?: 2"3?: 3>?95$>2?: $ 52?:$>2?:N
-J:N% 8?:" ? $:@$::42? u5>K 3?: @?:5>Kb?: :$_? #$9"2 3" Z4$ 6 ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
##] 3$X$A:$ :4J:5>54WAK?:N q›r
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: 54J4K?;\$: 3$ $:E?@?#$95"] 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K $ 3": D2$>":N 8"#@"9$95$: 3$ J"22?Eb? 3? @?25$ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
>9D$2>"2 3" X$WE4K"] E">D?:] a4?29>;\$:] #?9a4$>2?: $ @9$4:N

(
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" $:a4>Eb" $ @?Kb$5?: 3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ X>32" 52?A
:$>2"] E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;?] :>:5$#? 3$ >K4#>9?;<" $ :>9?K>Y?A
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
;<"] E"#?93": $K^52>E": 3": X>32": 3?: @"25?:] :>:5$#? 3$ ?J$2A
542?oD$Eb?#$95" 3?: @"25?:N
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" D>K52" 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"N q›r ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

3$+
* H
/ggg0 ! , B2:222 [ -  , 1B "` *',   1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd
.- ,    / Q  b'  * 7 ' K0
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? $K^52>E"o$K$52v9>E" q2‘3>"] ?K?2#$] $5ENr]
J?5$2>? $ >K4#>9?;<" >95$29? $ $p5$29?N w4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
$ >93>E?3"2$:N
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ X$95>K?;<" 3" E‘25$2 3" #"5"2 tJK"j
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
JytN q›r
V$2>D>E?;<"oK>#@$Y?oK4J2>D>E?;<" 3?: E?9?K$5?: $ E"#@"9$95$:
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
#hX$>: 3" 5$5" :"K?2 q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<"o>a9>;<" 3" #"5"2N (5>K>Y?2 "
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
$Z4>@?#$95" 3$ 3>?a9h:5>E"N
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" 9WX$K 3" hK$" 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" #$Ee9>E" q:$
¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥
$Z4>@?3"rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" q$K^52>E"rN ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

V$2>D>E?;<" 3" 9WX$K 3$ $#>::\$: 3": a?:$: 3$ $:E?@?#$95"N ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

,4J:5>54>;<" 3" DK4>3" 3": D2$>": qZ4?93" 3>:@"9WX$K] 3$X$A:$
5?#J^# :4J:5>54>2 " DK4>3" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?E>"9?#$95" b>32‘4K>E" ’ E?3? LI #$:$: "4 ? E?3? FGNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r
3? $#J2$?a$#rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3?: E"22$>?: 3": h2a<": ?4p>K>?2$: 3" #"5"2N q››r ¥ ¥ ¥ ¥

,4J:5>54>;<" 3?: E"22$>?: 3": h2a<": ?4p>K>?2$: 3" #"5"2N q›r ? E?3? I~ #$:$: "4 ? E?3? FGNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" #$Ee9>E" q:$ $Z4>A
¥ ¥
@?3"rN
V$2>D>E?;<" 3? E"22$>? 3$95?3? 3" E"#?93" 3? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3"
¥ ¥ ¥
#"5"2N q››r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3? E"22$>? 3$95?3? 3" E"#?93" 3? 3>:52>J4>;<" 3"
? E?3? I~ #$:$: "4 ? E?3? ~GNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r
#"5"2N q›r
,4J:5>54>;<" 3" KWZ4>3" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 ? E?3? 7G ?9": "4 ? E?3? LIGNGGG i# q" Z4$ "E"22$2 @2>#$>2"r

3$,
* H
/ggg0 ! , B2:222 [ -  , 1B "` *',   1d Bd Cd Dd Td Od Ud Vd Wd 12d 11d 1Bd
.- ,    / Q  b'  * 7 ' K0

UK$" 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E" q:$ $Z4>@?3"rN P"2 )>D$ q:$# 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ :4J:5>54>;<"r
/g0   .- *  -4 -+@* 3 ,    K  ,`   *+,-' - ' K        
  `   ` ' ,  -  ,  6H *   - / 4.-` P( `   5      ` ,:0 - .-  G-* ' 5
 * :
/gg0  ,  - ' K67  *+,-'           `    - ' , ` 3- - ,  '  
 '     ,    Q 57 -( '   / &,  ,  @4 4 hP5-@'  0` ,      '      
, B2:222 [ - 1B  `  ,P ` 3-  -4 - 6H:
/ggg0 ! ' ] ,       (,-67  * H 9)
  C2   /     -    0 , ,    :
  1222 [ /    -    0 , ,   .- '  5 :

3$-
'    
?
" 1:C 1O % N

7 ’J?:5$E>#$95" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 $ X?2$5? 3$ I 8?>p? 3$ D4:WX$>:

#$3>;<" 3$ 9WX$K 6 )WZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2
L )WZ4>3" 3": D2$>": F )WZ4>3" 3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?oK?X?3"2 3"
H B?5$2>? X>32" 52?:$>2"

3$!.
" B:2 

7 P>K52" 3$ ?:@>2?;<" 3$ ?2 3" #"5"2 6 8?>p? 3$ D4:WX$>:

L ’J?:5$E>#$95" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 F )WZ4>3" 3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?oK?X?3"2 3"
H )WZ4>3" 3": D2$>": X>32" 52?:$>2"
I B?5$2>? | )WZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2
~ V?2$5? 3$ E"952"K$ 3" 9WX$K 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2

3$!!
!   (# 2$?J?:5$E>#$95" E"# KWZ4>3"
!#!
!49E? D4#?2 342?95$ Z4?KZ4$2 >9A
5$2X$9;<" 9" X<" 3" #"5"2N
1"3$2<" $:5?2 @2$:$95$: a?:$: $ X?A
@"2$: >9DK?#‘X$>:] E"# 2>:E" 3$ >9A
E[93>"N
!#!
8"# #"5"2 Z4$95$] ?54?2 E"#
#4>5" E4>3?3" 9" >95$2>"2 3" X<" 3"
#"5"2N
1$2>a" 3$ Z4$>#?342?:N
!#!
*42?95$ ": 2$?J?:5$E>#$95":] 5$A
9b? ?5$9;<" @?2? 9<" E"9D493>2 ":
X‘2>": 5>@": 3$ KWZ4>3":% :<" 5"3": >9A
E"#@?5WX$>: $952$ :>O
3$!"
>9?3$Z4?3" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 a2?X$A
#$95$ " X$WE4K"N
<  "
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " 9WX$K 3" hK$"
$:5‘ E"#@2$$93>3" $952$ ": 9WX$>:
&m! $ &“¡ 9? X?2$5? 3$ E"952"K$ N
,$ " 9WX$K 3$ hK$" $:5>X$2 @2hp>#"
"4 ?J?>p" 3? 2$D$2[9E>? &=!] ?3>E>A
"9?2 hK$" ?52?X^: 3" J"E?K 3$ $9Eb>A
#$95" ?5^ ?5>9a>2 ? 2$D$2[9E>? &’¡N
!#!
!" E?:" 3$ 2$@":>;<" 3" 9WX$K 3"
hK$" 3" #"5"2] ?a4?23?2 Z4$ " #"5"2
$:D2>$ ?95$: 3$ ?54?2 9" 5?#@<" 3$
?J?:5$E>#$95"] $:@$E>?K#$95$ @?2?
X$WE4K": E"# 5?#@<" 3$ ?K4#W9>" q:$
$Z4>@?3"rN
’.+!/0-% @$2>a" 3$ Z4$>#?34A
2?:O
!#!
- 9WX$K 3" hK$" 949E? 3$X$ :4@$A
2?2 ? 2$D$2[9E>? &“¡N 8?:" " 9WX$K
5$9b? :4@$2?3" ? 2$D$2[9E>? &“¡ 9?
X?2$5?] ?a4?23?2 " #"5"2 $:D2>?2 $ 2$A
5>2?2 " hK$" $# $pE$::"N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
+p52?>2 ? X?2$5? 3$ E"952"K$ 3" 9WA
X$K 3$ hK$" 3" #"5"2] K>#@‘AK? E"#
4# @?9" Z4$ 9<" :"K5$ @$K" $ >9:$2>A
K? 9"X?#$95$N +p52?WAK? 4#? :$a493?
X$Y $ E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " 9WX$K 3$
hK$" 3" #"5"2 $:5‘ E"#@2$$93>3" $9A
52$ ?: #?2E?: &=! $ &’¡ $p>:5$95$:
9? @2h@2>? X?2$5?N

- hK$" 3" #"5"2 3$a2?3?A:$ @"2
5$#@" $ @$23$ :4?: @2"@2>$3?3$: 3$
K4J2>D>E?;<"] @"25?95" 3$X$ :$2 :4J:A
5>54W3" 3$ ?E"23" E"# " @K?9" 3$
#?945$9;<"] >93$@$93$95$#$95$ 3$
E">9E>3>2 E"# ?: 2$X>:\$: @2"a2?#?A
3?:N
C$E"#$93?A:$ $p@2$::?#$95$ Z4$
? :4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" $ 3": D>K52":
:$_? D$>5? ?@$9?: 9? C$3$ 3$ ’::>:A
5[9E>? c$$@N
 -   Q'  
!#!
!<" ?E2$:E$95?2 hK$" E"# E?2?E5$A
2W:5>E?: 3>D$2$95$: 3?: 3" hK$" _‘ @2$A
:$95$ 9" #"5"2N
(5>K>Y?2 :$#@2$ @2"345": 2$E"#$9A
3?3": qX$2 E?@W54K" t*?3": .^E9>A
E":trN
!#!
- hK$" 3" #"5"2 4:?3" $ " D>K52" 3"
hK$" :4J:5>54W3" E"95[# :4J:5e9E>?:
@$2>a":?: @?2? " ?#J>$95$N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3" hK$" $ 3": 5>@" $# 2$K?;<" ?" _‘ @2$:$95$ 9"
D>K52":] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 3>2>a>2A:$ g >95$2>"2 3" 3$@h:>5"N - KWZ4>3" 9<"
  ! = ,  > @"3$ :$2 #>:542?3" E"# Z4?KZ4$2
"452" 5>@" 3$ KWZ4>3" ?95>E"9a$K?95$N
’ 5W54K" >93>E?5>X"] " E"9:4#" #‘A
+# E?:" 3$ 2$?J?:5$E>#$95" E"#
p>#" 3$ hK$" 3" #"5"2 ^ 3$ IGG
4# @2"345" 9<" ?3$Z4?3"] $X>5?2
a2?#?: ? E?3? 7GGG i#N !" @2>A
?J:"K45?#$95$ K>a?2 " #"5"2 $ 3>2>a>2A
#$>2" @$2W"3" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WA
:$ g   ! = ,  > N
E4K"] " #"5"2 $:5‘ $# D?:$ 3$ t?#?A
E>?#$95"t] #"5>X" @$K" Z4?K " E"9A
:4#" 3$ hK$" 3" #"5"2 :h @"3$ :$2
E"9:>3$2?3" $:5?J>K>Y?3" 3$@">: 3$
5$2 @$2E"22>3" ": @2>#$>2": 6NGGG ? !#!
FNGGG i#N
- :>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" $:5‘
@2$::42>Y?3"N 8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>"
:4J:5>54>2 ? 5?#@? 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" ]
;  !"
45>K>Y?2 4#? @$;? a$94W9?] E?:" E"9A
 "
52‘2>" ? $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:5$#? @"3$ D>A
,$ " 9WX$K D"2 >9:4D>E>$95$] 3$:?@$2A E?2 E"#@2"#$5>3?N
5?2 " 5?#@<" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" $ 3$:@$A
_?2 K$95?#$95$ " KWZ4>3" 3$:E2>5" 9" 8"# " #"5"2 Z4$95$] 9<" 2$5>2?2
E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":tN " 5?#@<" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"% @$2>a" 3$
Z4$>#?342?:N
(
!#!
1?2? $X$954?>: 2$?J?:5$E>#$95":
3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3"
#"5"2] 45>K>Y?2 4# KWZ4>3" 3" #$:#"
3$!%
;  !! 
!!&%!@ !! 
 !
,$ " 9WX$K D"2 >9:4D>E>$95$] K$X?95?2
" 5?#@<" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" $ ?J?:5$E$2
E"# " KWZ4>3" $:@$E>D>E?3" 9" E?@WA
54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":tN
’J?:5$E$2 E"# 9" #W9>#" G7 q4#r
K>52" @?2? " 2$a4K?2 D49E>"9?#$95" 3"
:>:5$#?N
!#!
!<" X>?_?2 E"# " 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3"
K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? X?Y>"% ? ?;<"
3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? ^ D493?A
#$95?K @?2? #$Kb"2?2 ? X>:>J>K>3?3$N
- D49E>"9?#$95" 2$@$5>3" 3" :>:A
5$#? 9? ?4:[9E>? 3$ KWZ4>3" @"3$
3?9>D>E?2 "4 3$5$2>"2?2 2?@>3?#$95$
?Ka4#?: @?25$: 3" :>:5$#?N
3$!&
!#!
’Ka49: ?3>5>X": E"#$2E>?>: 3" KWA
Z4>3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? :<" >9A
DK?#‘X$>:
- X<" 3" #"5"2 E"95^# @?25$:
Z4$95$: Z4$] $# E"95?5"] @"3$# @2"A
X"E?2 4# >9E[93>"N
  
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " DK4>3" $:5‘
9" 9WX$K #‘p>#"N
,$ " 9WX$K 3" DK4>3" 9" 2$:$2X?5h2>"
D"2 >9:4D>E>$95$] 3$:?@$25?2 " 5?#@<"
3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" $ 3$:@$_?2 K$95?#$95$
" DK4>3" 3$:E2>5" 9" E?@W54K" t*?3":
5^E9>E":tN
!#!
+X>5?2 Z4$ " DK4>3" 3": D2$>":] ?KA
5?#$95$ E"22":>X"] $952$ $# E"95?5"
E"# ?: @?25$: @>95?3?:N
8?:" >::" ?E"95$;?] K?X?2 >#$3>?A
5?#$95$ E"# ‘a4?N
!#!
- DK4>3" 3": D2$>": ^ X$9$9":" $ ?KA
5?#$95$ E"22":>X"N +# E?:" 3$ E"9A
5?5" ?E>3$95?K] K?X?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$
?: @?25$: ?D$5?3?: E"# :?J<" 9$452"
$ $9p?a4?2 E"# ‘a4? ?J493?95$N
+# E?:" 3$ >9a$:5<"] 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$A
3>?5?#$95$ ? 4# #^3>E"N
!#!
- :W#J"K" ] @2$:$95$ 9" 2$:$2A
X?5h2>"] >3$95>D>E? ": DK4>3": 3$ D2$>":
3$ 5>@" :>95^5>E"] 3>:5>9a4>93"A": 3":
3$ 5>@" #>9$2?KN
PK4>3" 3$ D2$>" 3$ 5>@" #>9$2?K
3?9>D>E? >22$#$3>?X$K#$95$ ?: _495?:
$:@$E>?>: $# J"22?Eb? 3" :>:5$#? 3$
D2$9?a$#N
%!!
!#!
- KWZ4>3" $p>:5$95$ 9? J?5$2>? ^ X$A
9$9":" $ E"22":>X"N +X>5?2 " E"95?5"
E"# ? @$K$ $ ": "Kb":N
!<" :$ ?@2"p>#$ 3? J?5$2>? E"#
Eb?#? "4 @"::WX$>: D"95$: 3$ D?W:E?:%
@$2>a" 3$ $p@K":<" $ >9E[93>"N
!#!
- D49E>"9?#$95" E"# " 9WX$K 3"
KWZ4>3" #4>5" J?>p" 3?9>D>E? >22$@?A
2?X$K#$95$ ? J?5$2>? $ @"3$ @2"X"E?2
? :4? $p@K":<"N
-J:$2X?2 :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
,$ " X$WE4K" D>E?2 @?2?3" @"2 4#
@$2W"3" @2"K"9a?3" $# E"93>;\$:
3$ D2>" >95$9:"] 2$5>2?2 ? J?5$2>? 3"
X$WE4K" $ 52?9:@"25‘AK? @?2? 4# K4a?2
?Z4$E>3"N
8"22$A:$ " 2>:E" 3$ E"9a$K?#$95"N
!#!
’" #?94:$?2 ? J?5$2>? "4 $# :4?:
@2"p>#>3?3$:] 3$X$A:$ :$#@2$ @2"5$A
a$2 ": "Kb":N
(5>K>Y?2 hE4K": ?@2"@2>?3": @?2? ?
"@$2?;<"N
!#!
’: J?5$2>?: E"95[# :4J:5e9E>?:
#4>5" @$2>a":?: @?2? " ?#J>$95$N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$2>?]
3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = ,  > N
’ J?5$2>? 9<" 9$E$::>5? 3$ ?J?:5$A
E>#$95": 3" $K$52hK>5" E"# ‘a4? 3$:A
5>K?3?N
(# E"952"K$ @$2>h3>E"] $D$54?3"
@$K?   ! = ,  > ] ^]
E"9543"] 9$E$::‘2>" @?2? X$2>D>E?2 ?
:4? $D>E>[9E>?N
-4 - 67  4 
!#!
.2"E? 3? J?5$2>? 3" X$WE4K"% ’ J?A
5$2>? 3" X$WE4K" D"> 3$:$9X"KX>3? @?2?
a?2?95>2 " #$Kb"2 3$:$#@$9b"] E"9A
D>?J>K>3?3$ $ Z4?K>3?3$ @?2? " :$4
X$WE4K"N .?#J^# D"> 3$:$9X"KX>3?
:"J #$3>3? @?2? " K"E?K 3$ :4? >9:A
5?K?;<"] a?2?95>93" 5"5?K :$a42?9;?N
!" E?:" 3$ 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ 52"E?] ^
>#@2$:E>93WX$K Z4$ ? J?5$2>? :4J:5>A
545? 5$9b? ?: #$:#?: $:@$E>D>E?;\$:
$ E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3? J?5$2>? "2>a>9?K]
5?>: E"#"% 5$9:<" 9"#>9?K qVrd E?A
@?E>3?3$ 9"#>9?K q’obrd E"22$95$ 3$
@?25>3? q’rd @"K?2>3?3$ q@":>;<" 3":
5$2#>9?>:r $ ?: 3>#$9:\$: q?K542?] K?2A (
a42? $ E"#@2>#$95"rN
+# E?:" 3$ 3uX>3?:] @2"E42$ ?
 !  , ' > N
3$!’
 +# E?:" 3$ 9$E$::>3?3$] :4J:5>54>2
? J?5$2>? @"2 "452? "2>a>9?K E"# ?:
#$:#?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?:N 1?2? ? #?A
945$9;<" 3? J?5$2>?] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" :$A
a4>2 ?: >93>E?;\$: D"29$E>3?: @$K" D?A
J2>E?95$ 3? J?5$2>?N

’@h: ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$2>? "4
3$:E"9$p<" 3" :$9:"2 3$ J?5$2>?] 2$A
?K>Y?2 " :$a4>95$ @2"E$3>#$95" @?2?
? E?K>J2?;<" 3" :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@%
1?25>2 " X$WE4K" 9"2#?K#$95$ $
3$:K>a‘AK"N 1":5$2>"2#$95$] 2$5>2?2 ?
Eb?X$ 3? >a9>;<"] D$Eb?2 ?: @"25?:]
3$:K>a?2 ?: E?2a?: $K^52>E?: $ 3$>p?2 "
X$WE4K" $# 2$@"4:" :$# ?E>"9?2 "
?K?2#$N - X$WE4K" 3$X$ @$2#?9$E$2
$# 2$@"4:" @"2 4# @$2W"3" #W9>#"
3$ I b"2?:N
 'G b    ' 5
- 67  4 
1?2? $X>5?2 3$:E?22$a?2 2?@>3?A
#$95$ ? J?5$2>? $ @?2? @2$:$2X?2 ?
D49E>"9?K>3?3$ 9" 5$#@"] :$a4>2 2>A
a"2":?#$95$ ?: :$a4>95$: >93>E?;\$:%
3$!*
 ’" $:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K"]
E$25>D>Z4$A:$ Z4$ ?: @"25?:]
E?@v] 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?:
$ @"25>9b"K?: $:5$_?# J$#
D$Eb?3":] @?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ ?:
K4Y$: >95$29?: 3" b?J>5‘E4K"
@$2#?9$;?# ?E$:?:N
 ’@?a?2 ?: K4Y$: >95$29?:% 3$ Z4?KA
Z4$2 #"3"] " X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>A
@?3" E"# 4# :>:5$#? 3$ 3$:A
K>a?#$95" ?45"#‘5>E" 3?: K4Y$:
>95$29?:N
 8"# " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3"] 9<" 3$>A
p?2 3>:@":>5>X": ?E$:": @"2 K"9a"
5$#@" q@"2 $pN ?45"22‘3>"] K4Y$:
3$ $#$2a[9E>?] $5ENrN
 ’95$: 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 >95$2X$9;<" 9"
:>:5$#? $K^52>E"] 2$5>2?2 " E?J" 3"
@"K" 9$a?5>X" 3? J?5$2>?N
,$] ?@h: ? ?Z4>:>;<" 3" X$WE4K"]
@2$5$93$ >9:5?K?2 ?E$::h2>": $K^52>E":
Z4$ 9$E$::>5?# 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" $K^A
52>E? @$2#?9$95$ q@"2 $pN ?K?2#$]
$5ENr "4 ?E$::h2>": Z4$ ?D$5$# " J?A
K?9;" $K^52>E"] E"95?5?2 ?  
! = ,  > ] E4_" @$::"?K Z4?A
K>D>E?3" ?X?K>?2‘ ? ?J:"2;<" $K^52>E?
5"5?KN
!#!
(#? #"95?a$# >9E"22$5? 3":
?E$::h2>": $K^52>E": $ $K$52v9>E":
@"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9": a2?X$: 9"
X$WE4K"N
,$] ?@h: ? ?Z4>:>;<" 3" X$WE4K"] :$
@2$5$93$2 >9:5?K?2 ?E$::h2>": q@"2 $pN
?95>D425"r] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! &
= ,  > ] Z4$ >2‘ :4a$2>2 ": 3>:@"A
:>5>X": #?>: ?3$Z4?3": $ :"J2$543"
>9D"2#?2 :"J2$ ? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ 45>A
K>Y?2 4#? J?5$2>? E"# #?>"2 E?@?E>A
3?3$N

’ J?5$2>? #?95>3? @"2 #4>5"
5$#@" $# $:5?3" 3$ E?2a? >9D$2>"2 ?
6Gs :"D2$ 3?9": @"2 :4KD?5?;<"] 2$A
34Y>93" ? E?@?E>3?3$ $ ? ?@5>3<" g
@?25>3?N ’K^# 3>::"] D>E? #?>: :4_$>5?
g @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ E"9a$K?#$95"
q@"3$ "E"22$2 ? 7G8rN +# E?:" 3$
@?2?3? @2"K"9a?3?] E"9:4K5?2 "
@?2‘a2?D" t=9?5>X>3?3$ @2"K"9a?3?
3" X$WE4K"t] 9$:5$ E?@W54K"N
  
 
" 2?95$ E$2E? 3$ LI b"2?:N (#? E?2a?

’ 3$:E2>;<" 3" @2"E$3>#$95" 3$
2$E?2a? 3? J?5$2>? $:5‘ >93>E?3? 49>A
E?#$95$ ? 5W54K" >9D"2#?5>X"N 1?2? ?
$p$E4;<" 3$:5? "@$2?;<"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g
  ! = ,  > N

’95$: 3$ @2"E$3$2 ?" E"25$ 3? ?K>A
#$95?;<" $K^52>E? 3? J?5$2>?] ?a4?2A
3?2 @$K" #$9": 4# #>945" ? @?25>2
3" @":>E>"9?#$95" 3" E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" $#  $ ? @?25>2 3" D$A
Eb?#$95" 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" E"9A
345"2N !" @":5$2>"2 2$:5?J$K$E>#$95"
3? ?K>#$95?;<" $K^52>E? 3? J?5$2>?]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" $:5$_? $#  $ Z4$ ? @"25?
3" K?3" 3" #"5"2>:5? $:5$_? D$Eb?3?N

C$E"#$93?A:$ 4#? 2$E?2a? K$95?
3$ J?>p? >95$9:>3?3$ 3$ E"22$95$] 34A
342?95$ #4>5" 5$#@" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2
? J?5$2>?N

f $::$9E>?K Z4$ ": E?J": 3" :>:A
5$#? $K^52>E" :$_?# 9"X?#$95$ K>a?A
3": E"22$5?#$95$ g J?5$2>?] "4 :$_?]
" E?J" @":>5>X" q¥r ?" 5$2#>9?K @":>A
5>X" $ " E?J" 9$a?5>X" q r ?" 5$2#>9?K
9$a?5>X"N -: 5$2#>9?>: 3? J?5$2>? $:A
5<" ?::>9?K?3": E"# ": :W#J"K": 3$
5$2#>9?K @":>5>X" q¥r $ 5$2#>9?K 9$a?A
5>X" q r $ $:5<" >93>E?3": 9? 5?#@?
3? J?5$2>?N -: 5$2#>9?>: 3": E?J":
3$X$# 5?#J^# $:5?2 K>X2$: 3$ E"22"A
:<" $ D>p?3": D>2#$#$95$ ?": 5$2#>A
9?>:N ,$ D"2 45>K>Y?3" 4# E?22$a?3"2
3$ J?5$2>?: 3$ 5>@" t2‘@>3"t E"# J?A
5$2>? #"95?3? 9" X$WE4K"] ?95$: 3$
K>a?2 " E?22$a?3"2 3$ J?5$2>?:] 3$:A
K>a?2 ?#J": ": E?J": 3? J?5$2>? 3"
X$WE4K"N !<" 45>K>Y?2 " E?22$a?3"2 3$
J?5$2>? 3$ 5>@" t2‘@>3"t @?2? D"29$E$2
? 5$9:<" 3$ ?22?9Z4$N
!!
1?2? $D$54?2 ? 2$E?2a?] @2"E$3$2
E"#" >93>E?3" ? :$a4>2%
 *$:K>a?2 " 5$2#>9?K 3" @"K" 9$A
a?5>X" 3? J?5$2>?N
 )>a?2 ?": @"K": 3? J?5$2>? ": E?A
J": 3" ?@?2$Kb" 3$ 2$E?2a?] 2$:A
@$>5?93" ?: @"K?2>3?3$:N
 )>a?2 " ?@?2$Kb" 3$ 2$E?2a?N
 .$2#>9?3? ? 2$E?2a?] 3$:K>a?2 "
?@?2$Kb" ?95$: 3$ " 3$:K>a?2 3?
J?5$2>?N
 )>a?2 " 5$2#>9?K ?" @"K" 9$a?5>X"
3? J?5$2>?N
    
  % 
"  "!&

(
!#!
’ #?945$9;<" $22?3? 3" X$WE4K"
"4 ? 9<" $p$E4;<" 3$ >95$2X$9;\$: $
3$!+
2$@?2?;\$: qZ4?93" 9$E$::‘2>?:r @"A
3$# E"#@"25?2 2$@?2?;\$: #?>: 3>:A
@$93>":?:] 3?9": $# "452": E"#@"A
9$95$: "4 4# >#@?E5" 9$a?5>X" 9"
3$:$#@$9b" 3" X$WE4K"N
&?93?2 $p?#>9?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$
$X$954?>: ?9"#?K>?: 3$ D49E>"9?A
#$95" 9?   ! = ,  > :
!#!
- X$WE4K" $:5‘ $Z4>@?3" E"# KWZ4>A
3": "5>#>Y?3": @?2? @2"5$a$2 " :$4
3$:$#@$9b"] 342?;<" $ @2"K"9a?2 ":
:$4: >95$2X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<"N !<"
45>K>Y?2 :4J:5e9E>?: Z4W#>E?: @?2? K?A
X?2 $:5$: E"#@"9$95$:] 4#? X$Y Z4$
@"3$# 3?9>D>E?2 " #"5"2] ? E?>p? 3$
Ee#J>" "4 " :>:5$#? 3$ EK>#?5>Y?A
;<"N +::$: 3?9": 9<" $:5<" E"J$25":
@$K? a?2?95>? 3" X$WE4K"N
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" $D$54?2 4#? K?A
X?a$# 3$X>3" g ?X?2>? 3$ 4# E"#A
@"9$95$] 45>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$ "
KWZ4>3" $:@$EWD>E" @?2? 5?K @2"E$3>A
#$95"N
3$!,
!#!
f ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K E"9D>?2 ? #?945$9A
;<" 3" X$WE4K" g   ! = &
,  > N 1?2? $D$54?2 @$::"?K#$95$
?: "@$2?;\$: @$2>h3>E?: $ ?: @$Z4$A
9?: >95$2X$9;\$: 3$ #?945$9;<" 9"
X$WE4K"] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 45>K>Y?2 $Z4>A
@?#$95" ?3$Z4?3"] @$;?: a$94W9?:
$ ": KWZ4>3": 9$E$::‘2>":N
!<" $D$54?2 Z4?KZ4$2 5>@" 3$ >95$2A
X$9;<" :$ 9<" :$ @"::4>2 ? $p@$2>[9A
E>? 9$E$::‘2>?N
’: @‘a>9?: :$a4>95$: E"95[# ?:
9"2#?: :"J2$ ? #?945$9;<" ,P&
 @2$X>:5? @$K" @$::"?K 5^E9>E" Z4$
@2"_$5"4 " X$WE4K"N
’K^# 3$:5?: >93>E?;\$: 3$ #?94A
5$9;<" $:@$E>D>E?3?: 9? #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3? 2$a4K?2] $:5<" @2$:$95$:
"452": E"#@"9$95$: Z4$ @"3$# 9$A
E$::>5?2 3$ >95$2X$9;\$: "4 :4J:5>54>A
;\$: 342?95$ " E>EK" 3$ X>3? 3" X$WA
E4K"N
<  "
  '  +*'  Q'  
!#!
(#? Z4?95>3?3$ $pE$::>X? "4
>9:4D>E>$95$ 3$ hK$" 9" >95$2>"2 3"
JK"E" ^ $p52$#?#$95$ @2$_43>E>?K
@?2? " #"5"2N
12$:5?2 ?5$9;<" @?2? #?95$2 4#
9WX$K ?3$Z4?3"N
1?2? a?2?95>2 4#? E"22$5? K4J2>D>A
E?;<" 3" #"5"2] ^ >93>:@$9:‘X$K Z4$
" hK$" :$_? :$#@2$ #?95>3" ?" 9WA
X$K @2$:E2>5" qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D"
t8"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2t 9$:5$ E?A
@W54K"rN
V$2>D>E?2 " 9WX$K 3" hK$" $# >95$2A
X?K": 2$a4K?2$:] @"2 $p$#@K" ? E?3?
?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$KN
’ X$2>D>E?;<" 3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3?
E$2E? 3$ 6 #>945": ?@h: 5$2 3$:K>a?3"
" #"5"2] 4#? X$Y ?5>9a>3? ? @K$9?
5$#@$2?542? 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"N -
X$WE4K" 3$X$ ?>93? :$2 $:5?E>"9?3"
" #?>: @"::WX$K :"J2$ 4#? :4@$2DWE>$
@K?9?N
P?Y$2 E"# Z4$ " 9WX$K 3" hK$"
:$ :>54$ :$#@2$ 9" >95$2>"2 3? :$;<"
3? b?:5$ 3$ E"952"K$ E"#@2$$93>3?
$952$ ": K>#>5$: 3$ #W9>#" $ #‘p>#"N
-4 - 67  Q'  
8"9:4K5?2 " t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3?t @?2? E"9b$E$2 ": >95$2A
X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" E"22$5":N
,'G     Q'  
1?2? a?2?95>2 3$:$#@$9b" h5>#" $
#‘p>#? @2"5$;<" $# Z4?KZ4$2 5>@"
3$ E"93>;<" 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"] ^
?E"9:$Kb‘X$K 45>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$
hK$": 3" #"5"2 E$25>D>E?3": ’8+’
qE"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘a2?D" tPK4>3": "2>a>A
9?>: $ K4J2>D>E?95$:t 9" E?@W54K" t*?A
3": 5^E9>E":trN
!  *    Q'  
C$E"#$93?A:$ $:52>5?#$95$ 9<"
?E2$:E$95?2 ?3>5>X": q3>D$2$95$: 3":
E"2?95$: 3$ 3$5$E;<" 3$ X?Y?#$9A
5":r ?" hK$" 3" #"5"2N
- hK$" 3" #"5"2 ^ 4# @2"345"
$:@$E>D>E?#$95$ E"9E$J>3" @?2? "
X$WE4K" $ " :$4 3$:$#@$9b" @"3$
D>E?2 3$5$2>"2?3" @$K" ?E2^:E>#" 3$
"452": ?3>5>X":N
' 67  Q'   5
   , * 3 ' 
1?2? ? $K>#>9?;<" 3" hK$" 3" #"A
5"2 $ 3": 2$:@$E5>X": D>K52":] 3>2>a>2A
:$ g: $95>3?3$: E"#@$5$95$: @?2? E"A
9b$E$2 ? 9"2#? K"E?KN

UK$" a?:5" $ D>K52": $K>#>9?3": 3$
D"2#? >9E"22$5? @"3$# @2"X"E?2 a2?A
X$: 3?9": 9" ?#J>$95$N
  <  "
-4 - 67  3 '   Q' 

- D>K52" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 3$X$
:$2 :4J:5>54W3" ? E?3? :4J:5>54>;<" 3"
hK$" 3" #"5"2N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘A
X$K 45>K>Y?2 4#? @$;? a$94W9?] $:@$A
E>D>E?#$95$ E"9E$J>3? @?2? $:5$ X$WA
E4K"N
  !
!#!
- :>:5$#? 3$ >952"34;<" 3$ ?2 qD>KA
52" 3$ ?2] 54J4K?;\$: 3$ J"22?Eb?]
$5ENr @"3$ 3$:$#@$9b?2 4#? D49A
;<" 3$ @2"5$;<" $# E?:" 3$ 2$5"29":
3$ Eb?#? 3" #"5"2N !0- C+&-A
V+C $:5$ :>:5$#? ? 9<" :$2 @?2? @"A
3$2 @2"E$3$2 ? >95$2X$9;\$: 3$ 2$@?A
2?;<" "4 3$ #?945$9;<"N
’95$: 3$ K>a?2 " #"5"2] E$25>D>E?2A:$
3$ Z4$ " :>:5$#? 9<" $:5‘ 3$:#"9A
5?3"% ? >9"J:$2Xe9E>? 3$:5? @2$E?4A
;<" @"3$ @2"X"E?2 a2?X$: K$:\$:N
-4 - 67  3 '   
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" (
45>K>Y?2 4#? @$;? a$94W9?] $:@$E>A
D>E?#$95$ E"9E$J>3? @?2? $:5$ X$WA
E4K"N
3$!-
 -: >95$2X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" 3$A
X$# :$2 "J:$2X?3": 9" x1K?9" 3$
&?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3?z 3$ ?E"23"
E"# " 5>@" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
!&! & "!&
  "!
!#!
C$E"#$93?A:$ ? 45>K>Y?;<" $pEK4A
:>X? 3$ KWZ4>3": 2$D2>a$2?95$: $ K4J2>A
D>E?95$: @?2? E"#@2$::"2 ?@2"X?3":
$ ?3$Z4?3": ?" $:@$EWD>E" :>:5$#?
3$ ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" 3" X$WE4K"N ’KA
a49: 2$D2>a$2?95$: 9<" ?@2"X?3": :<"
>9DK?#‘X$>: $ @"3$# $p@K"3>2] E"#
" 2>:E" 3$ E?4:?2 K$:\$:N
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ KWZ4>3": 2$D2>a$2?9A
5$: "4 K4J2>D>E?95$: 9<" ?@2"X?3":
@"3$] ?>93?] E"#@2"#$5$2 ? $D>E>[9A
E>? 3" :>:5$#?] 5"29?93" 9$E$::‘2>?:
2$@?2?;\$: 3>:@$93>":?:N
3$".
!#!
- :>:5$#? 3" ?2AE"93>E>"9?3"
E"95^# 2$D2>a$2?95$ ? ?K5? @2$::<"N
1?2? $X>5?2 3?9": $# @$::"?: "4
9" :>:5$#?] " $X$954?K ?E2^:E>#" 3$
2$D2>a$2?95$ "4 Z4?KZ4$2 2$@?2?;<"
Z4$ $p>_? ? 3$:?5>X?;<" 3?: 54J4K?A
;\$: 3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3" @$K?  
! = ,  > N
1?2? a?2?95>2 " #$Kb"2 3$:$#A
@$9b" @"::WX$K] " :>:5$#? 3$
?2AE"93>E>"9?3" 3$X$ :$2 E"952"K?3"
$ :4J#$5>3" ? #?945$9;<" _495" 3?
  ! = ,  > 9" >9WE>"
3" X$2<"N

!<" 45>K>Y?2 :4J:5e9E>?: Z4WA
#>E?: @?2? K?X?2 " :>:5$#? 3"
?2AE"93>E>"9?3"] 4#? X$Y Z4$ ":
E"#@"9$95$: >95$29": @"3$2>?#
D>E?2 3?9>D>E?3":N *?9": 3$::? 9?54A
2$Y? 9<" :<" E"J$25": @$K? a?2?95>?N
-4 - 67  3 '  
 &,  ,   / .- 0
8"9:4K5?2 " t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3?t @?2? E"9b$E$2 ": >95$2A
X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" E"22$5":N
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<" 3" D>K52"] 3>2>a>2A
:$ g   ! = ,  > N
  "%
1?2? ? :4J:5>54>;<"] ^ 9$E$::‘2>"
45>K>Y?2 4#? @$;? a$94W9?] $:@$E>A
D>E?#$95$ E"9E$J>3? @?2? $:5$ X$WA
E4K"N
-: >95$2X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" 3$A
X$# :$2 "J:$2X?3": 9" x1K?9" 3$
&?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3?z 3$ ?E"23"
E"# " 5>@" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N
%! ! ! "<&
 ! !!
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ?: D$Eb?342?:
$ ": @"95": 3$ ?25>E4K?;<" 3? E?2A
2"E$2>?] >9EK4>93" $K$#$95": E"#"
?: a4>?: 3": J?9E":] ?: 3"J2?3>;?:
3?: @"25?: q$ ": 2$:@$E5>X": 2"K":r]
? 5?#@? 3" @"25?A#?K?: $ " E?@v
3" #"5"2 :<" K4J2>D>E?3?: @$2>"3>E?A
#$95$ E"# a2?p? g J?:$ 3$ KW5>" @?2?
?::$a42?2 " :$4 D49E>"9?#$95" E"2A
2$5" $ :>K$9E>":" $ @?2? @2"5$a[AK?:
3? D$224a$# $ 3" 3$:a?:5$N
)>#@?2 3$X>3?#$95$ ?: @$;?: 3$
#"3" ? $K>#>9?2 Z4?KZ4$2 X$:5Wa>"
3$ @h $ :4_$>2?N ’@h: ? K4J2>D>E?;<"]
$K>#>9?2 " hK$" "4 ? a2?p? $# $pA
E$::"N 12$:5?2 @?25>E4K?2 ?5$9;<" 5?#A
J^# ?": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ D$Eb?#$95"
3" E?@v 3" #"5"2] @?2? a?2?95>2 " :$4
E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95"N *42?95$ ?:
"@$2?;\$: 9" E?@v 3" #"5"2 q$D$54?2
E"# " #"5"2 D2>"r] K$#J2?2A:$ 5?#A
J^# 3$ E"952"K?2] K>#@?2 $ K4J2>D>E?2
": 2$:@$E5>X": 3>:@":>5>X": 3$ D$Eb?A
#$95"] 3$:$9a?5$ $ 3$ :$a42?9;?N
)4J2>D>E?2 ": 5?#J"2$: 3?: D$Eb?A
342?: $p5$29?: 34?: X$Y$: @"2 ?9"N
’@K>E?2 4#? @$Z4$9? Z4?95>3?3$ 3$
K4J2>D>E?95$ 3$ ?K5? Z4?K>3?3$ 3>2$5?A
#$95$ 9" 5?#J"2 3? D$Eb?342?N
*>2>a>2A:$] :$ 9$E$::‘2>"] g  
! = ,  > N
"!  ! !"
!#!
’: $#>::\$: 3" $:E?@?#$95" :<"
#4>5" @$2>a":?: $ @"3$# :$2 K$5?>:N
*$ D?5"] E"95[# #"9hp>3" 3$ E?2A
J"9"] 4# a‘: >9E"K"2 $ >9"3"2" Z4$]
:$ >9?K?3"] @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3$:#?>":
$ $9X$9$9?#$95":N
!#!
- :>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?#$95" @"3$
?5>9a>2 $K$X?3?: 5$#@$2?542?: $ @"3$
@2"X"E?2 >9E[93>" E?:" " X$WE4K"
:$_? $:5?E>"9?3" :"J2$ #?5$2>?K >9A
DK?#‘X$KN ’::>#] $2X?] E?@>#] #?5"]
"4 D"Kb?: :$E?:] $# a$2?K] @"3$#
>9E$93>?2A:$ :$ $952?2$# $# E"95?5"
E"# " :>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?#$95" 3"
X$WE4K"N
+X>5?2 $:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" "4
45>K>Y‘AK" "93$ " :>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?A
#$95" @"::? $952?2 $# E"95?5" E"#
#?5$2>?K >9DK?#‘X$KN
!#!
-: X$WE4K": E"# #"5"2>Y?;<" DK$p]
$Z4>@?3": E"# E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"]
Z4?93" ?J?:5$E>3": E"# a?:"K>9?]
3$X$# 45>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$ a?:"A
K>9? :$# Eb4#J"N (#? a?:"K>9?
E"95$93" Eb4#J" 3?9>D>E?2>? >22$A
#$3>?X$K#$95$ " E?5?K>:?3"2 $ ?94A
K?2>? ? D49;<" 3$ 2$34;<" 3?: $#>:A
:\$: @"K4$95$:] E"#@2"#$5$93" a2?A
X$#$95$ " 3$:$#@$9b" 3" #"5"2]
3?9>D>E?93"A" 3$ #"3" >22$@?2‘X$KN
,$ " #"5"2 9<" D49E>"9?2 E"22$5?A
#$95$] @?25>E4K?2#$95$ $# E?:" 3$
>a9>;<" >22$a4K?2 "4 3$ 4#? Z4$3?
3$ 3$:$#@$9b"] 3>2>a>2A:$ >#$3>?5?A
#$95$ g   ! = ,  > N
- D49E>"9?#$95" @2"K"9a?3" $
?9v#?K" 3" #"5"2 @"3$ @2"X"E?2 " (
:"J2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3" E?5?K>:?3"2 $]
E"9:$Z4$95$#$95$] @"::WX$>: 3?9":
9" #$:#" $ 9" X$WE4K"N
3$"!
 (#? #?945$9;<" ?3$Z4?3? 3"
:>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?#$95" 3" #"5"2
E"9:5>54> ? #$Kb"2 @2"5$E<" E"952?
>9D>K52?;\$: 3$ #"9hp>3" 3$ E?2J"9"
9" b?J>5‘E4K"N
,$ D"2 3$5$E5?3" 4# 24W3" ?9v#?K"
3" $:E?@?#$95"] "4 ? @2$:$9;? 3$
D4#?;? 9" >95$2>"2 3" b?J>5‘E4K"] "4
:$ " D493" 3? E?22"E$2>? "4 ? @?25$
52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K" 5>X$2$# D>E?3" 3?A
9>D>E?3":] #?93?2 X$2>D>E?2 5"3" " :>:A
5$#? 3$ $:E?@?#$95" $ ?: ‘2$?: 3?
E?22"E$2>? ?3_?E$95$: _495" g 
 ! = ,  > @?2? >3$95>D>E?2
$X$954?>: E"#@"9$95$: @?25>3":] 3?A
9>D>E?3":] 3$5$2>"2?3": "4 Z4$ 5$A
9b?# :"D2>3" 3$:K"E?#$95": 2$K?5>A
X?#$95$ g @":>;<" 3$ #"95?a$# E"2A
2$5?N
,"K3?342?: ?J$25?: "4 K>a?;\$: 3$A
:?@$25?3?: @"3$# @$2#>5>2 >9D>K52?A
;\$: 3$ a?:$: 3$ $:E?@$ 9" >95$2>"2
3" b?J>5‘E4K"N
&?93?2 X$2>D>E?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ $:A
E?@?#$95" :$#@2$ Z4$ " X$WE4K" D"2
$K$X?3"N ,4J:5>54>2 ": E"#@"9$95$:
"93$ 9$E$::‘2>" q@?2? $:5?: "@$2?A
3$""
;\$:] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
> rN
+# E"93>;\$: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"
9"2#?>:] " E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E" 9<"
2$Z4$2 #?945$9;<"% 5"3?X>?] @?2?
?::$a42?2 " E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95"
$ $X>5?2 Z4$ D>Z4$ 3?9>D>E?3"] ^ $pA
52$#?#$95$ >#@"25?95$ Z4$ " #"5"2
D49E>"9$ @$2D$>5?#$95$N
1?2? 2$34Y>2 ?" #W9>#" " 2>:E"
3$ 3?9>D>E?2 " E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"]
@2"E$3$2 3" :$a4>95$ #"3"%
 !<" 3$:K>a?2 " #"5"2 "4 3$:K>a?2
" E"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" E"# 4#?
#?2Eb? ?E"@K?3? $ " X$WE4K" $#
#"X>#$95"N
 !<" 5$95?2 K>a?2 " #"5"2 E"#
#?9"J2?: 3$ >9^2E>?N
 !<" >9:>:5>2 9? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WA
E4K" :$ " 2$a>#$ 3$ #?2Eb? K$95?
D"2 #4>5" >22$a4K?2 "4 ?: E"9A
3>;\$: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" D"2$#
#?9>D$:5?#$95$ >22$a4K?2$:N
"!  !"
’ :?W3? 3$ KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>A
#$95" 3" #"5"2 "4 3$ X?@"2 3" 2?A
3>?3"2 @"3$ @2"X"E?2 Z4$>#?342?:
a2?X$:N
,$ 9"5?2 X?@"2 @2"X$9>$95$ 3" X<"
3" #"5"2] "4 :$ "4X>2 " :>KX"] 9<"
?J2>2 " E?@v ?5^ Z4$ " 2?3>?3"2 5$9b?
?22$D$E>3"N

!49E? 5$95?2 5>2?2 ? 5?#@? 3" 2$A
:$2X?5h2>" 3$ $p@?9:<" Z4$95$N 1+A
C=S- *+ w(+=&’*(C’,O
 3 ,67  '+.-    3, &
   
V$2>D>E?2 " 9WX$K 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$A
D$E>#$95" :$#@2$ E"# " #"5"2 D2>"N
,$] 9" >95$2>"2 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$A
E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 $p>:5>2$# >#@42$A
Y?:] $:X?Y>?2] K?X?2 $ ?J?:5$E$2 " :>:A
5$#?% ^ 9$E$::‘2>" 3>2>a>2A:$ g 
 ! = ,  > N
V$2>D>E?2 ? @?25$ 3>?95$>2? 3" E"9A
3$9:?3"2 @?2? X$2>D>E?2 ? $X$954?K
?E4#4K?;<" 3$ >9:$5":] D"Kb?: $ "4A
52": 3$52>5":N ,$ $:5>X$2 :4_?] K>#@‘AK?
@4KX$2>Y?93" 3$K>E?3?#$95$ ‘a4?N
V$2>D>E?2 ": 54J": DK$pWX$>: 3" :>:A
5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 @?2?
a?2?95>2 Z4$ ? J"22?Eb? 9<" $:5‘ 3$A
5$2>"2?3? $ Z4$ 9<" $p>:5$# D$93?:]
K?E$2?;\$:] E"25$: $ "J:524;\$: 9":
54J": 3" K?3" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ $pA
@?9:<" $ 3" K?3" 3" 2?3>?3"2N ,$
5>X$2 3uX>3?: 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ? X?Y?A
#$95": 3" :>:5$#? q@"2 $pN 9? @2$A
:$9;? 3? 9$E$::>3?3$ 3$ ?J?:5$E>A
#$95": D2$Z4$95$:r] #?93?2 X$2>D>E?2
? :4? $:5?9Z4$>3?3$ _495" g  
! = ,  > N
8"# " #"5"2 3$:K>a?3" $ g 5$#@$A
2?542? 3$ D49E>"9?#$95" 9"2#?K] X$A
2>D>E?2 ? X$3?;<" 3" 2?3>?3"2 3" :>:A
5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"N

!0- 5>2?2 ? 5?#@? 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>"
3$ $p@?9:<" :$ " KWZ4>3" $:5>X$2 ?
D$2X$2% 1+C=S- *+ w(+=&’*(C’,O

’95$: 3$ >95$2X>2 9? 3$:#"95?a$#
3? 5?#@? 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" KWZ4>3"
3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2] ?a4?23?2
Z4$ " :>:5$#? ?22$D$;?N
!4,  @, 5@'*5
, '+.-    3,   

,$ " KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3"
#"5"2 $:5>X$2 :4_"] #?93?2 $D$54?2
>95$2X$9;\$: 3$ K>#@$Y? $ K?X?a$#
_495" g   ! = ,  > N
8"9:4K5?2 " t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3?t @?2? E"9b$E$2 ": >95$2A
X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" E"22$5":N

1?2? " ?J?:5$E>#$95"] 45>K>Y?2 4#
KWZ4>3" E"# ?: #$:#?: E?2?E5$2W:A
5>E?: >93>E?3?: $#tPK4>3": "2>a>9?>:
$ K4J2>D>E?95$:t qE"9:4K5?2 " E?@W54K"
t*?3": 5^E9>E":trN

!<" 45>K>Y?2 :"#$95$ ‘a4?] KWZ4>A
3": 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 g
J?:$ 3$ ‘KE""K] >9>J>3"2$: 3$ E"22"A
:<" "4 @2"345": ?95>D$224a$# ?3>E>"A
9?>:] 4#? X$Y Z4$ @"3$# :$2 >9E"#A
@?5WX$>: E"# " KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>A
#$95" 3" #"5"2 $ @2"X"E?2 ? "J542?A
;<" 3" 2?3>?3"2N ’K^# 3>::"] ^ ?E"9A
:$Kb‘X$K ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ KWZ4>3" 3$
?22$D$E>#$95" g J?:$ 3$ #"9"$5>K$9"
aK>E"K qX$2 E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E": A
PK4>3": "2>a>9?>: $ K4J2>D>E?95$:trN
    *Q   (  7
      3,   

’ 5?#@? 3$X$ :$2 J$# D$Eb?3?
@?2? $X>5?2 X?Y?#$95" 3$ KWZ4>3" 3$
?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 $ a?2?95>2
Z4$ " KWZ4>3" 2$a2$::$ ?" 2?3>?3"2 3"
2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ $p@?9:<"N
(
V$2>D>E?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$ ? 5?#@?
$ K>#@‘AK? 3$ $X$954?>: E"2@": $:A
52?9b": 3$@":>5?3": 9? :4@$2DWE>$ $pA
5$29?N
3$"%


!49E? ?3>E>"9?2 KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$A
E>#$95" E"# " #"5"2 Z4$95$ "4 :"A
J2$?Z4$E>3"N

!<" 5$95?2 ?22$D$E$2 4# #"5"2 :"A
J2$?Z4$E>3" 3$:?@$25?93" "4 2$5>A
2?93" ? 5?#@?N - E?K"2 @2"X"E?] 3$
D?5"] 4# 9"5‘X$K ?4#$95" 3? @2$::<"
9" :>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"N

(5>K>Y?2 $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ? 5?#@?
3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ $p@?9:<" @2$X>:5?
@?2? " X$WE4K" @?2? $X>5?2 3?9": 9"
#"5"2N
' 67  '+.-    3, &
    5
’ $K>#>9?;<" 3" KWZ4>3" 3$ 2$D2>a$A
2?;<" 3" #"5"2 $:5‘ :4_$>5? ? 9"2#?:
K$a?>:% 3>2>a>2A:$ g: $95>3?3$: E"#@$A
5$95$: @?2? E"9b$E$2 ? 9"2#? K"E?KN
3$"&

1?2? $X>5?2 Z4$ " KWZ4>3" :$_? >9a$A
2>3" @"2 E2>?9;?: "4 ?9>#?>:] 9<" "
a4?23?2 $# 2$E>@>$95$: ?J$25": $ 9<"
" 3$:E?22$a?2 9" 5$22$9"N ,$ >9a$A
2>3"] E"95?5?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ 4# #^A
3>E"N +K>#>9?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ $X$9A
54?>: X$:5Wa>": 3$ KWZ4>3" 3" 5$22$9"N

w4?93" 9? @?2?3? 3" X$WE4K" ?@h:
4# J2$X$ 52?_$5"] 9"5?2A:$ ? :?W3? 3$
X?@"2 @$K" K?3" D2"95?K 3" E?@v 3"
#"5"2N .2?5?A:$ 3$ 4# D$9v#$9"
9"2#?K 3$X>3" g @2$:$9;? 3$ Eb4X?]
9$X$ "4 D"25$ 4#>3?3$ 9? :4@$2DWE>$
3" 2?3>?3"2N

8"# " #"5"2 $ " :>:5$#? D2>":] 9<"
?3>E>"9?2 KWZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95"
?K^# 3" 9WX$K #‘p>#" >93>E?3" 9"
2$:$2X?5h2>" 9" >95$2>"2 3" X<" 3"
#"5"2N
"!  !"
1?2? a?2?95>2 ? $D>E>[9E>? 3" :>:A
5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$#] X$2>D>E?2 @$2>"3>A
E?#$95$ ": E"#@"9$95$:% @?2? $:5?
"@$2?;<"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! &
= ,  > N
8"9:4K5?2 " t1K?9" 3$ #?945$9;<"
@2"a2?#?3?t @?2? E"9b$E$2 ": >95$2A
X?K": 3$ #?945$9;<" E"22$5":N

8"934Y>2 E"# " @^ ?@">?3" 9" @$A
3?K 3" D2$>" @"3$ @2$_43>E?2 ? :4? $D>A
E>[9E>?] ?4#$95?93" " 2>:E" 3$ ?E>A
3$95$:N *42?95$ ? #?2Eb?] 949E?
#?95$2 " @^ 9" @$3?K 3" D2$>" $ 9<"
:"K>E>5‘AK" >945>K#$95$ @?2? $X>5?2 "
:"J2$?Z4$E>#$95" 3": D2$>":% " 3$:A
a?:5$ $pE$::>X" 3?: @?:5>Kb?: @"3$
@2"X"E?2 3?9": 9" :>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?A
a$#N

1?2? " ?J?:5$E>#$95"] 45>K>Y?2 4#
KWZ4>3" E"# ?: #$:#?: E?2?E5$2W:5>A
E?: >93>E?3?: $# tPK4>3": "2>a>9?>:
$ K4J2>D>E?95$:t qE"9:4K5?2 " E?@W54K"
t*?3": 5^E9>E":trN

+# E?:" 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95"] 45>K>Y?2
?@$9?: DK4>3" 3$ D2$>" 9"X" "4 E"9A
5>3" $# 4# 2$E>@>$95$ @$2D$>5?#$95$
D$Eb?3"N (# DK4>3" 3$ D2$>" E"9A
5>3" $# 4# 2$E>@>$95$ ?J$25" ?J:"2X$
4#>3?3$% 5?K E"93>;<" @"3$ @2"X"A
E?2 ? $J4K>;<" >#@2$X>:5? 3" DK4>3"
342?95$ D2$9?a$9: J24:E?: $ @2"K"9A
a?3?:] @2"X"E?93" 4#? ?X?2>? >#A
@2$X>:5? 9": D2$>":] " Z4$ @"3$ :$2
E?4:? 3$ ?E>3$95$:N

&?95$2 :$#@2$ " 5?#@<" 3" 2$:$2A
X?5h2>" 3" DK4>3" 3": D2$>": q@2$:$95$
9" X<" 3" #"5"2r @$2D$>5?#$95$ D$A
Eb?3"N

(#? Z4?95>3?3$ $pE$::>X? 3$
DK4>3" 3$ D2$>" 9" >95$2>"2 3"
2$:$2X?5h2>" @"3$ @2"X"E?2 ? D4a?
@?2? ?: @?25$: Z4$95$: 3" #"5"2]
E"# " 2$:@$E5>X" 2>:E" 3$ >9E[93>"N
- DK4>3" 3$ D2$>" @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2
5?#J^# :4@$2DWE>$: @>95?3?: $ @?25$:
3$ @K‘:5>E"% ?::>#] @2$:5?2 @?25>E4K?2
?5$9;<"N
+X>5?2 " E"95?5" 3" DK4>3" 3$ D2$>"
E"# KWZ4>3": g J?:$ 3$ @$52hK$"N ’:
a4?29>;\$: 3$ X$3?;<" @"3$# D>E?2
3?9>D>E?3?:] E"# E"9:$Z4$95$ >9$D>A
E>[9E>? 3": D2$>":N
_"% !"
!#!
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ hK$" 3" Ee#J>"
3>D$2$95$ 3" @2$:E2>5" @"3$ E"#@2"A
#$5$2 ? Z4?K>3?3$ 3?: #43?9;?: 3$
#?2Eb? $o"4 @2"X"E?2 X>J2?;\$: ?9vA
#?K?: 3? @2h@2>? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"N
(5>K>Y$ :"#$95$ @2"345": @2$:E2>A
5": @?2? :$4 X$WE4K" qX$2 E?@W54K" t3?A
3": .^E9>E":tr
(5>K>Y?2 49>E?#$95$ 4# hK$" 3?
E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" E"# ?: #$:#?:
E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: >93>E?3?: $# tPK4>3":
"2>a>9?>: $ K4J2>D>E?95$:t qE"9:4K5?2 "
E?@W54K" t*?3": 5^E9>E":trN
!  *  ,  
!<" ?3>E>"9?2 Z4?KZ4$2 5>@" 3$
?3>5>X": ?" hK$" 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘A
5>E"N - hK$" @?2? " Ee#J>" ?45"#‘A
5>E" ^] 3$ D?5"] 4# @2"345" $:@$E>D>A
E?#$95$ E"9E$J>3" @?2? $:5$ X$WE4K"
$ " 3$:$#@$9b" @"3$ D>E?2 @2$_43>A
E?3" @$K" ?E2^:E>#" 3$ "452": ?3>5>A
X":N
+X>5?2 ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ X$3?95$:
@?2? E?>p?: 3$ Ee#J>"] 4#? X$Y Z4$
@"3$# E"#@2"#$5$2 ? $D>E‘E>? 3?:
a4?29>;\$: 3" Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E"N

!<" 45>K>Y?2 :4J:5e9E>?: Z4W#>E?:
@?2? K?X?2 ? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"] 4#?
X$Y Z4$ @"3$# 3?9>D>E?2 ": E"#@"A
9$95$:N (
3$"’
 .-= ,    ,  Q'
!?: E"93>;\$: 9"2#?>: 3$ D49E>"A
9?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"] 9<" ^ 9$E$::‘A
2>" :4J:5>54>2 " hK$" 3" Ee#J>"N
,$ D"2$# 9"5?3": X?Y?#$95": 3$
hK$" "4 :$ 3$5$E5?2$# ?9"#?K>?: 9"
D49E>"9?#$95" 3? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"]
#?93?2 $D$54?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ "
E"952"K$ _495" g   ! = , 
> N

8"934Y>2 " X$WE4K" E"# 4# 9WX$K
3$ hK$" >9:4D>E>$95$ @"3$ @2"X"E?2
a2?X$: 3?9": 9? E?>p? 3$ Ee#J>"N
   
!
  !
8?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>" K$X?95?2 " X$WA
E4K"] 3>2>a>2A:$ g   ! = , 
> ] Z4$ $:5‘ $Z4>@?3? E"# $K$X?A
3"2$: 3$ J2?;": "4 $K$X?3"2$: 3$ "D>A
E>9?N
3$"*
' 
"!? % ! &
!!
’95$: 3$ K"9a?: X>?a$9: $] 3$ Z4?KA
Z4$2 D"2#?] ? E?3? 34?: :$#?9?:]
?@2"p>#?3?#$95$] E"952"K?2 ? @2$:A
:<" 3": @9$4:] >9EK4>93" ? $X$954?K
2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N +D$54?2 " E"9A
52"K$ E"# ": @9$4: D2>":N
! A @2$::<" 9"2#?K% J?93? 3$ 2"A
8"# ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"] ^ 9"2A 3?a$# a?:5? 3$ #"3" 49>D"2#$N
#?K Z4$ ? @2$::<" ?4#$95$ 3$X>3"
?" ?Z4$E>#$95" 3": @9$4:d @?2? " % A @2$::<" >9:4D>E>$95$% J?93? 3$
E"22$5" X?K"2 2$K?5>X" g @2$::<" 3$ 2"3?a$# @?25>E4K?2#$95$ a?:5? 9?:
$9Eb>#$95" 3" @9$4] E"9:4K5?2 " @?A J"23?:N
2‘a2?D" xC"3?: $ @9$4:z 9" E?@W54K"  A @2$::<" $pE$::>X?% J?93? 3$ 2"A
x*?3": 5^E9>E":zN 3?a$# @?25>E4K?2#$95$ a?:5? 9" E$9A
(#? @2$::<" $22?3? @2"X"E? 4# 52"N
E"9:4#" ?9"2#?K 3": @9$4:% -: @9$4: 3$X$# :$2 :4J:5>54W3":
Z4?93" ? $:@$::42? 3? D?>p? 3$ 2"K?A
#$95" D>E?2 2$34Y>3? @?2? 7]F ##N
"!? ! 3" X$WE4K" @?2? " $:Z4$23" $ X>E$A
!#!
- E"#@"25?#$95" $# $:52?3? 3"
X$WE4K" 3$@$93$ 3? E"22$5? @2$::<"
3$ $9Eb>#$95" 3": @9$4:N
8"9:4K5$ ": X?K"2$: 3$ @2$::<" 9"
E?@W54K" t*?3": .^E9>E":tN
!#!
(#? @2$::<" 3$#?:>?3" J?>p? @2"A
X"E? " :4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3" @9$4
E"# @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ a2?X$: 3?9":
9" #$:#"N
(5>K>Y$ ": X?K"2$: 3$ @2$::<" 3$:A
E2>5": 9" E?@W54K" t*?3": .^E9>E":tN
!#!
!? @2$:$9;? 3$ @9$4: t49>3>2$E>"A
9?>:t] 9<" $D$54?2 ? 52"E? $# E24Y 3":
@9$4:] 3$:K"E?93"A": 3" K?3" 3>2$>5"
X$2:?N
!? @2$:$9;? 3$:5$ 5>@" 3$ @9$4:]
:h ^ @"::WX$K 3$:K"E?2 ?: 2"3?: 3"
$>p" 3>?95$>2" @?2? " $>p" 52?:$>2" $
X>E$AX$2:?] #?95$93"A?: 9" #$:#"
K?3" 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
!<" $D$54?2 52?5?#$95": 3$ 9"X?
@>9542? 3?: 2"3?: $# K>a? K$X$ Z4$
9$E$::>5?# 3? 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ 5$#@$2?A
542?: :4@$2>"2$: ? 76G8N
’: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: #$Ee9>E?: 3?:
2"3?: @"3$# D>E?2 E"#@2"#$5>3?:N
1?2? $X>5?2 3?9": 9": @9$4:] :$a4>2
?: :$a4>95$: @2$E?4;\$:%
 +X>5?2 D2$9?a$9: $ @?25>3?:
J24:E?:] Eb"Z4$: X>"K$95":
E"952? @?::$>":] J42?E": 3?
$:52?3? $ "J:5‘E4K": $ @$2E42:":
@2"K"9a?3": $# $:52?3?:
>22$a4K?2$:N
 8"952"K?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$ :$ ":
@9$4: ?@2$:$95?# E"25$: 9": K?A
3":] J"Kb?: "4 :$ ? D?>p? 3$ 2"K?A
#$95" $:5‘ 3$:a?:5?3? 3$ D"2#?
>22$a4K?2N
 +X>5?2 X>?_?2 E"# " X$WE4K" :"A
J2$E?22$a?3"N ,$ D42?2 4# @9$4]
@?2?2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ $ :4J:5>54WA
K"N
 ’ E?3? 7GNGGGo76NGGG Z4>Kv#$A
52":] $D$54?2 " 2"3WY>" 3": @9$4:]
#?95$93"A": 3" #$:#" K?3" 3"
X$WE4K" @?2? 9<" >9X$25$2 " :$9A
5>3" 3$ 2"5?;<" qE?:" ": @9$4:
D"2$# 3$ 5>@" t49>3>2$E>"9?KtrN ’:
2"3?: E"# @>:" 49>3>2$E>"9?K :<"
2$E"9b$EWX$>: @"2 :$5?: 9" DK?9E"
3" @9$4] Z4$ >93>E?# " :$95>3"
3$ 2"K?#$95" @2$X>:5"] Z4$ 3$X$
:$2 ?J:"K45?#$95$ 2$:@$>5?3"N ,h
?::># ": @9$4: #?95[# ?: :4?:
E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: $# 5$2#": 3$ ?3$A
2[9E>?] 24W3"] 2$:>:5[9E>? ?" 3$:A
a?:5$ $ 32$9?a$# $# @>:" #"A
Kb?3"N (
 -: @9$4: $9X$Kb$E$#] #$:#" :$
@"4E" 45>K>Y?3":N ’ @2$:$9;? 3$
2?Eb?342?: 9? J"22?Eb? 3? D?>p?
3$ 2"K?#$95" $ 9": DK?9E": 3"
3$"+
 @9$4 E"9:5>54> 4# :>9?K 3$ $9A
X$Kb$E>#$95"N +# 5"3" " E?:"]
:$ ": @9$4: 5>X$2$# :>3" #"95?A
3": b‘ #?>: 3$ F ?9":] ^ 9$E$:A
:‘2>" Z4$ :$_?# E"952"K?3": @"2
@$::"?K $:@$E>?K>Y?3"N 8"952"K?2
>a4?K#$95$ E"# $:@$E>?K E4>3?3"
? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N
 +# E?:" 3$ :4J:5>54>;<"] #"95?2
:$#@2$ @9$4: 9"X":] $X>5?93" ":
3$ @2"X$9>[9E>? 34X>3":?N
 ’" :4J:5>54>2 4# @9$4] ^ ?E"9A
:$Kb‘X$K :4J:5>54>2 5?#J^# ? X‘KA
X4K? 3$ $9Eb>#$95"N
!   9" @?2‘a2?D" t=9D"2#?;\$: a$2?>:t
1?2? " 5>@" 3$ 2"3?: $ @9$4: #"9A
5?3": 9" X$WE4K"] E"9:4K5?2 " @?2‘A
a2?D" xC"3?: $ @9$4:z 9" E?@W54K"
x*?3": 5^E9>E":zN
3$",
"!? %  &
J   3>D$2$95$] 2$K?5>X?#$95$ ?" X$WE4K"N
!#!
-: #^5"3": 3$ 2"3WY>" 3?: 2"3?:
>93>E?3": !0- 3$X$# :$2 ?3"5?3":
$# E?:" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @9$4: t49>A
3>2$E>"9?>:tO (5>K>Y?93" $:5$ 5>@" 3$
@9$4:] :h ^ @"::WX$K 3$:K"E?2 ?: 2"3?:
3" $>p" 3>?95$>2" @?2? " $>p" 52?:$>2"
$ X>E$AX$2:?] #?95$93"A?: 9" #$:#"
K?3" 3" X$WE4K"N
8"9:4K5?2 ?: @2$E?4;\$: 3$:E2>5?:
@?2? "J5$2 #?>: >9D"2#?;\$: ?
2$:@$>5"N
-: @9$4: 3>?95$>2": $ 52?:$>2": $:A
5<" :4_$>5": ? 3>D$2$95$: E?2a?: $ :"A
K>E>5?;\$: 3$X>3" ? E42X?:] #?9"J2?:
$ D2$9?a$9:N 1"2 >::"] $:5<" :4_$>5": ?
4# 3$:a?:5$ 9<" 49>D"2#$N
1?2? $X>5?2 $:5$ @2"JK$#?] ^ @":A
:WX$K $D$54?2 " 2"3WY>" 3": @9$4:
9" #"#$95" "@"2549"N 1"2 2"3WA
Y>" 3": @9$4: $95$93$A:$ " 3$:K"E?A
#$95" 3?: 2"3?: @?2? 4#? @":>;<"
8?3? 2"3? :$2‘] ?::># @":5? ? 52?J?A
Kb?2 $# 4# $>p" 3>D$2$95$ $] :$#@2$
Z4$ @"::WX$K] 9" K?3" "@":5" 3" X$WA
E4K"N
- 2"3WY>" 3": @9$4: E"952>J4> @?2?
#?95$2 >9?K5$2?3?: ?: E?@?E>3?3$: 3$
?3$2[9E>? $ 3$ 52?;<" $# $:52?3?:
#"Kb?3?: "4 E"# K?#?] ?::$a42?93"
4#? h5>#? #?9"J2?J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K"N
+# E?:" 3$ 3$:a?:5$ ?9"2#?K 3":
@9$4:] >3$95>D>E?2 ? E?4:? $ E"22>a>A
K? ?::># Z4$ @"::WX$K] 3>2>a>93"A:$ g
  ! = ,  > N

-: :$a4>95$: #^5"3": 3$ 2"3WY>"
!0- 3$X$# :$2 ?3"5?3": $# E?:" 3$
45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @9$4: t49>3>2$E>"9?>:tO
(5>K>Y?93" $:5$ 5>@" 3$ @9$4:] :h ^
@"::WX$K 3$:K"E?2 ?: 2"3?: 3" $>p"
3>?95$>2" @?2? " $>p" 52?:$>2" $ X>E$A
X$2:?] #?95$93"A?: 9" #$:#" K?3"
3" X$WE4K"N 8"9:4K5?2 ?: @2$E?4;\$:
3$:E2>5?: 9" @?2‘a2?D" t=9D"2#?;\$:
a$2?>:t @?2? "J5$2 #?>: >9D"2#?;\$:
? 2$:@$>5"N
 H ,  67    
/R0
- #^5"3" 3$ 2"3WY>" :4a$2>3" @?2?
? 52?;<" 3>?95$>2? ^ tE24Y?3" ?52‘:t]
E"#" >93>E?3" 9? D>a42? :$a4>95$N
 H ,  67 5 ' /DR0
- #^5"3" 3$ 2"3WY>" 3": @9$4:
:4a$2>3" @?2? ": X$WE4K": 3$ Z4?52"
2"3?: #"52>Y$: ^ tE24Y?3" g D2$95$t]
E"#" >93>E?3" 9? D>a42? :$a4>95$N

- E"22$5" D49E>"9?#$95" 3?:
X$2:\$: E"# Z4?52" 2"3?: #"52>Y$:
qI¤*r 3$@$93$ 3": @9$4:% 3$X$#
:$2 5"3": 3?: #$:#?: 3>#$9:\$:]
3" #$:#" 5>@" $ 3? #$:#?
E>2E49D$2[9E>?N - 4:" 3$ @9$4: 3$
3>#$9:\$: 3>D$2$95$: @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2
" X$WE4K"N f 9$E$::‘2>" :$a4>2 "
2"3WY>" 3": @9$4: @?2? "J5$2 4#
3$:a?:5$ $Z4>K>J2?3" 3$:5$:N
C$E"#$93?A:$] ?@h: " 2"3WY>"] X$A
2>D>E?2 " J?K?9E$?#$95" 3?: 2"3?: $
" ?K>9b?#$95" 3? 3>2$;<"N
%!!!" ! !
’: 2"3?: 3" X$WE4K" D"2?# @2$X>A
?#$95$ J?K?9E$?3?: @"2 "E?:><" 3?
#"95?a$#] 9" $95?95"] ? 2"3?a$#
@"3$2‘ @2"X"E?2 " :$4 3$:J?K?9E$?A
#$95"N
(# 3": :>9?>: 3$ Z4$ ? 2"3? $:5‘
3$:J?K?9E$?3? ^ Z4?93" :$ @$2E$J$
X>J2?;\$: 9? 3>2$;<"N - 3$:J?K?9E$A
?#$95" @2"X"E? 3$:a?:5$ 3? 3>2$;<"]
3? :4:@$9:<" $ 3": @9$4:N
’@h: ? #"95?a$# 3$ 4# @9$4
9"X" "4 $# E?:" 3$ D"25$ >#@?E5"
9" @9$4 ^ 9$E$::‘2>" J?K?9E$?2 ?
2$:@$E5>X? 2"3?N
!!" ! 
- X$WE4K" 3$X$ $:5?2 E"# ?: $:A
@$E>D>E?;\$: a$"#^52>E?: 3? :4:@$9A
:<" $# E"9D"2#>3?3$ E"# " D?J2>A
E?95$] @">: ?::>#] 9<" $:5?2‘ :4_$>5"
? :"D2$2 3$:$Z4>KWJ2>" 3?: D"2;?: Z4$
?54?# 9" X$WE4K" Z4?93" $# :$95>3" (
3$ #?2Eb?] $ E"9:$Z4$95$ 3$:a?:5$
@2$#?542" 3": E"#@"9$95$: 3? :4:A
@$9:<" $ 3": @9$4:N
3$"-
 +# E?:" 3$ 3$:a?:5$ ?9"2#?K 3":
@9$4:] @2"E42$ ?   ! = , 
> @?2? ?K>9b?#$95" 3? 3>2$;<"N
!#!
- ’K>9b?#$95" 3$ 3>2$;<" $ " J?A
K?9E$?#$95" 3": @9$4: 9<" :<" E"A
J$25": @$K? S?2?95>? 3" X$WE4K"N
.?#J^# 9<" :<" E"J$25": ":
$X$954?>: >9E"9X$9>$95$: 3$E"22$9A
5$: 3" D?5" 3$ " X$WE4K" 52?D$a?2 D"2?
3?: $:@$E>D>E?;\$: D"29$E>3?: @$K?
,.+))’!.=, 9" Z4$ :$ 2$D$2$ ? $::$:
>5$9:N
!@  %!
!? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 3" :$4 X$WA
E4K" $9E"952?A:$ ?@K>E?3" 4# ?3$A
:>X" ?K?2?9_?3" E"# ": @2>9E>@?>:
?X>:": ?E$2E? 3? 45>K>Y?;<" 3? @2hA
@2>? 2"3? $ 3?: 2$:@$E5>X?: K>#>5?;\$:
3$ 45>K>Y?;<"N - ?3$:>X" 9<" 3$X$ 3$
D"2#? ?Ka4#? :$2 2$#"X>3" 9$# E"A
J$25"N !? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ 949E?
3$%.
:$ 3$X$ ?@K>E?2 9$9b4#? E?K"5? 3$
2"3?N
!#!
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ :$ 3$:5>9? $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?"
4:" 5$#@"2‘2>"N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN
!#!
’ X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? @$2#>5>3?
342?95$ " 4:" 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$
^ 3$ ~G i#ob "4 7LG i#ob] >93>E?3?
9? $5>Z4$5? 3? @2h@2>? 2"3?N
*>2>a>2 E"# @243[9E>? $ 9<" 4K52?A
@?::?2] $# b>@h5$:$ ?Ka4#?] " K>#>5$
3$ X$K"E>3?3$ @$2#>5>3"N

1?2? X$WE4K": E"# E"9_495"
2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?K$95$ 3$:$9X"KA
X>3" $pEK4:>X?#$95$ @?2? " 4:"
5$#@"2‘2>"] ? X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#?
3$ 45>K>Y?;<" ^ 3$ ~G i#obN q+pN%
19$4: 2"3?95$: LL6oF6 C7| $ @9$4
:"J2$::?K$95$ 7I6o|GC7|rN !<"
4K52?@?::?2] $# b>@h5$:$ ?Ka4#?] "
K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ @$2#>5>3"N

1?2? ?: X$2:\$: E"# E"9_495"
2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?K$95$ 3$ 3>#$9A
:\$: 9"2#?>:] ? X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#?
3$ 45>K>Y?;<" ^ 3$ 7LG i#obN !<"
4K52?@?::?2] $# b>@h5$:$ ?Ka4#?] "
K>#>5$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ @$2#>5>3"N
+# E?:" 3$ 3uX>3? Z4?95" g :>54A
?;<" @2$:$95$ $# :$4 X$WE4K"] E"9A
:4K5$ ? $5>Z4$5? ?3$:>X? ?K?2?9_?3?
?@K>E?3? 9? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$] 9?
Z4?K $:5‘ $:@$E>D>E?3? ? X$K"E>3?3$
#‘p>#? @$2#>5>3? 3$ 4:"N
*>2>a>2 E"# @243[9E>?N
 !#!
’: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ E"934;<" 3"
X$WE4K"] E"# ? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$
#"95?3?] :<" ?K5$2?3?:N *$:5$ #"3"]
3$X$A:$ $X>5?2 ?E$K$2?;\$: $ D2$9?A
a$9: X>"K$95?:] #43?9;?: 3$ 3>2$A
;<" J24:E?: $ E42X?: ? a2?93$ X$K"E>A
3?3$N ’ 342?J>K>3?3$ #^3>? 3" @9$4
:"J2$::?K$95$ ^ 3$ HGGG i#N
.2?9:E"22>3? $:5? Z4>K"#$52?a$#]
" @9$4 3$X$ :$2 :4J:5>54W3" @$K" "2>A
a>9?K "4 @"2 "452" :"J2$::?K$95$ E"#
?: #$:#?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3" Z4$ $:5‘
$Z4>@?3" 9" X$WE4K"N
!#!
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ :$ 3$:5>9? $pEK4:>X?#$95$ ?"
4:" 5$#@"2‘2>"N
&?93?2 2$@?2?2 $ 2$#"95?2 ? 2"3?
:4J:5>54W3? " #?>: 2?@>3?#$95$ @":A
:WX$KN
!#!
!49E? >9:5?K?2 4# @9$4 52?3>E>"A
9?K 94#? 2"3? 3$:5>9?3? g 45>K>Y?;<"
E"#" 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$N !<" ^ @$2A
#>5>3" 45>K>Y?2 :>#4K5?9$?#$95$ 34?:
"4 #?>: 2"3?: :"J2$::?K$95$:N
C$:@$>5?2 :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
!#!
!<" K4J2>D>E?2 ?: 2":E?: 3": @?2?A
D4:": ?95$: 3$ #"95?2 ": @9$4:] @">:
$:5$: @"3$2<" :"K5?2A:$ $:@"95?9$?A
#$95$ 342?95$ ? 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"O
+# 9$9b4#? E>2E49:5e9E>? ": @?A
2?D4:": 3$X$# :$2 K4J2>D>E?3":N 1?2?A
D4:": E"# >#@42$Y?: 3$X$# :$2 K>#A
@":N +# E?:" 3$ E"22":<" "4 2":Z4$A
?#$95" 3>DWE>K] ": @?2?D4:": 3$X$#
:$2 :4J:5>54W3":N
!#!
- 9<" E4#@2>#$95" 3?: 2$:52>;\$:
3$ 4:" 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ @"3$
E?4:?2 ?E>3$95$: E"# 2>:E" 3$ a2?X$:
K$:\$: "4 #"25$N
,>a? :$#@2$ ?: @2$:E2>;\$: 3" #?A
94?KN

V$2>D>E?2 2$a4K?2#$95$ ? @2$::<"
3": @9$4: "2>a>9?K#$95$ >9:5?K?3":
$ 3" @9$4 :"J2$::?K$95$] 2$:@$>5?93"
": X?K"2$: >93>E?3": 9$:5$ #?94?K]
9" E?@W54K" x*?3": 5^E9>E":zN
1?2? " E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$:A
:?K$95$ D"29$E>3" 5"5?K#$95$ :$# ?2]
"4 $# E?:" 3$ $X$954?K $:X?Y>?A
#$95" 5"5?K] $D$54?2 " $9Eb>#$95"
3" @9$4 :"J2$::?K$95$ ?5^ ?KE?9;?2
? @2$::<" @2$:E2>5? 9$:5$ #?94?K] 9" (
E?@W54K" x*?3": 5^E9>E":zN
- E"9_495" 2"3?o@9$4 :"J2$::?A
K$95$ 3$X$ $:5?2 :$#@2$ E"93>E>"A
9?3" $# K"E?K ?3$Z4?3" 9" X$WE4K"
3$%!
$ E?K>J2?3" 9? @2$::<" >93>E?3?] @?2?
Z4$] $# E?:" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?] $:5$_?
@2"95" @?2? :$2 45>K>Y?3" 3$ D"2#? :$A
a42? $ ?3$Z4?3?N
    
  !
!? E$2E? 3$ 6 #>945":] 2$a4K?3"A"
,$ " X$WE4K" 5>X$2 3$ @$2#?9$E$2
@?2?3" 342?95$ #?>: 3$ 4# #[:]
"J:$2X?2 ?: :$a4>95$: @2$E?4;\$:%
 +:5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" $# @>:"
@K?9"] $# K"E?K E"J$25"] :$E"
$] :$ @"::WX$K] X$95>K?3" $ ?J2>2
K>a$>2?#$95$ ": X>32":N
 8?K;?2 ?: 2"3?:o@9$4: "4 @":>E>A
"9?2 ? ?K?X?9E? $# qEe#J>"
?45"#‘5>E"r @?2? $X>5?2 " 3$:K"A
E?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N
 8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " D2$>" 3$
$:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^52>E" 9<" $:5‘
$9a?5?3"N
 *$:K>a?2 " 5$2#>9?K 9$a?5>X" 3"
@"K" 3? J?5$2>? $ X$2>D>E?2 :$4 $:A
5?3" 3$ E?2a?N *42?95$ " ?2#?Y$A
3$%"
9?#$95"] $:5$ E"952"K$ 3$X$ :$2
2$@$5>3" 52>#$:52?K#$95$N
 ,$ 9<" :$ 3$:K>a?2 ? J?5$2>? 3"
:>:5$#? $K^52>E"] E"952"K?2 " :$4
$:5?3" 3$ E?2a? ? E?3? 52>95? 3>?:N
 )>#@?2 $ @2"5$a$2 ?: @?25$: @>95?A
3?: ?@K>E?93" E$2?: @2"5$5"2?:N
 )>#@?2 $ @2"5$a$2 ?: @?25$: #$A
5‘K>E?: J2>Kb?95$: E"# @2"345":
$:@$EWD>E": 3>:@"9WX$>: 9" #$2A
E?3"N
 +:@?Kb?2 @h 3$ 5?KE" 9?: @?Kb$A
5?: $# J"22?Eb? 3" K>#@?3"2 3"
@?2?AJ2>:? $ 3" K>#@?3"2 3" X>A
32" 52?:$>2" $ 3$>p‘AK?: K$X?95?A
3?: 3": X>32":
 8"J2>2 " X$WE4K" E"# 4#? E?@?
3$ 5$E>3" "4 3$ @K‘:5>E" @$2D4A
2?3"] @2$:5?93" @?25>E4K?2 ?5$9A
;<" @?2? 9<" 3?9>D>E?2 ? :4@$2DWA
E>$ @>95?3? ?22?:5?93" ? $X$954?K
@"$>2? 9$K? ?E4#4K?3?N !<" 45>A
K>Y?2 E?@?: 3$ @K‘:5>E" E"#@?E5"]
Z4$ 9<" @$2#>5$# ? $X?@"2?;<"
3? 4#>3?3$ @2$:$95$ 9? :4@$2DWA
E>$ 3" X$WE4K"N
 +9Eb$2 ": @9$4: ? 4#? @2$::<"
3$ ¥G]6 J?2 q¥|]L6 @:>r :4@$2>"2
$# 2$K?;<" g @2$:E2>5? $ E"952"K‘A
K? @$2>"3>E?#$95$N
 !<" $:X?Y>?2 " :>:5$#? 3$ 2$D2>A
a$2?;<" 3" #"5"2N
 ,$#@2$ Z4$ :$ 3$>p?2 " X$WE4K"
>9?5>X" 342?95$ 34?: "4 #?>: :$A
#?9?:] E"# " #"5"2 $# #?2A
Eb? K$95?] ^ 9$E$::‘2>" K>a?2 " :>:A
5$#? 3$ ?2AE"93>E>"9?3" 342?95$
@?2? ?2 $p5$29" $ E"# X$95">9b?
3$D>9>3? 9" #‘p>#"N +::? "@$A
2?;<" a?2?95>2‘ 4#? K4J2>D>E?;<"
?3$Z4?3? 9" :>:5$#? 2$34Y>93"]
?::>#] ?" #W9>#" ? $X$954?K>A
3?3$ 3$ 3?9": 9" E"#@2$::"2
Z4?93" " :>:5$#? D"2 9"X?#$95$
K>a?3"N

’.+!/0-% !" E?:" 3$ 4:" 3$ J>A
"3>$:$K q@"2E$95?a$# #‘p>#? E"9A
D"2#$ @2$X>:5" 9? )$a>:K?;<" P$3$2?K
X>a$95$ g ^@"E? 3? D?J2>E?;<" 3" X$WA
E4K"r ^ 9$E$::‘2>" @2"5$a$2 " X$WE4K"
$# E?:" 3$ @?2?3?: @2"K"9a?3?: qk
7 #[:rN ’95$: 3$ 4#? @?2?3? @2"K"9A
a?3? 3" X$WE4K"] 3$X$A:$ E"9:4#>2 "
E"#J4:5WX$K @2$:$95$ 9" 5?9Z4$ 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K ?5^ ?E$93$2 ? K4YA$:@>?
3$ 2$:$2X?N ’" K>a?2 9"X?#$95$ "
#"5"2 3$@">: 3$ 4# K"9a" @$2W"3"]
2$?J?:5$E$2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ E"# 3>$A
:$K 9"X"N

’95$: 3$ @2"E$3$2 ?" E"25$ 3? ?K>A
#$95?;<" $K^52>E? 3? J?5$2>?] ?a4?2A
3?2 @$K" #$9": 4# #>945" ? @?25>2
3" @":>E>"9?#$95" 3" E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" $#  $ ? @?25>2 3" D$A
Eb?#$95" 3? @"25? 3" K?3" 3" #"5"A
2>:5?N !" @":5$2>"2 2$:5?J$K$E>#$95"
3? ?K>#$95?;<" $K^52>E? 3? J?5$2>?]
E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" $:5$_? $#  $ Z4$ ? @"25?
3" K?3" 3" E"9345"2 $:5$_? D$Eb?3?N
 
 !  !
!"$
- X$WE4K" ^ 3"5?3" 3?: #$Kb"2$:
:"K4;\$: 5$E9"Kha>E?: @?2? @2"5$a$2
$D>E?Y#$95$ ? E?22"E$2>? 3? E"22"A
:<"N
+>: ?: @2>9E>@?>:%
 12"345": $ :>:5$#?: 3$ @>9542?
Z4$ E"9D$2$# ?" X$WE4K" 2$:>:A
5[9E>? g E"22":<" $ g ?J2?:<"N
 +#@2$a" 3$ Eb?@?: a?KX?9>Y?3?:
q"4 @2^A52?5?3?:r] 3"5?3?: 3$ ?K5?
2$:>:5[9E>? g E"22":<"N
 .2?5?#$95" :@2?y E"# #?5$2>?>:
@K‘:5>E":] E"# D49;<" 3$ @2"5$A
;<"] 9": @"95": #?>: $p@":5":%
>95$2>"2 3" @?2?AK?#?:] J"23?:]
$5EN
 (:" 3$ E?>p?: x?J$25?:z] @?2? $X>A
5?2 ? E"93$9:?;<" $ ? ?Eu#4K" 3$
‘a4?] Z4$ @"3$# D?X"2$E$2 ? D"2A
#?;<" 3$ D$224a$# 9" >95$2>"2N
 (5>K>Y?;<" 3$ @$KWE4K?: $:@$E>?>:
E"# D49;<" @2"5$5"2? ?95>?J2?:<"
9": @"95": #?>: $p@":5": q@"2 $pN
@?2?AK?#?: 52?:$>2"] @"25?:] $5ENrN
!!!  N 
  ! ! 
! !!
- X$WE4K" @"::4> 4#? a?2?95>?
E"952? ? @$2D42?;<"] 3$X>3" g E"22"A
:<"] 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 $K$#$95" "2>a>9?K
3? $:524542? "4 3? E?22"E$2>?N 1?2?
?: E"93>;\$: a$2?>: 3$:5? a?2?95>?]
E"9:4K5?2 " &?94?K 3$ S?2?95>?N
! ! !!
- 
!#!
-: 3$5$2a$95$: :4_?# ?: ‘a4?:N
)?X?2 " X$WE4K" :"#$95$ $# K"A
E?>: $Z4>@?3": @?2? " 2$E"Kb>#$95"
$ ? 3$@42?;<" 3": KWZ4>3": 45>K>Y?3":
@?2? ? K?X?a$#N
(
!#!
’ D># 3$ #?95$2 >95?E5?: ?: E?2?EA
5$2W:5>E?: $:5^5>E?: 3? @>9542?] ^ ?E"9A
3$%%
:$Kb‘X$K 9<" 45>K>Y?2 @2"345": ?J2?:>A
X": $o"4 $9E$2?3"2$: @?2? " $#J$K$A
Y?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?A
;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
+# E?:" 3$ ?J2?:\$: "4 D>::42?:
@2"D493?:] 2$E"#$93?A:$ Z4$ :$_?#
D$>5": 3$ >#$3>?5" ": 2$5"Z4$: 9$E$:A
:‘2>":] @?2? $X>5?2 ? D"2#?;<" 3$ D$2A
24a$#N
’ #?945$9;<" 3? @>9542? E"9:>:5$
9? K?X?a$#] E4_? @$2>"3>E>3?3$ 3$A
@$93$ 3?: E"93>;\$: $ 3" ?#J>$95$
3$ 45>K>Y?;<"N 1"2 $p$#@K"] 9?: 2$A
a>\$: 3$ a2?93$ @"K4>;<" ?5#":D^A
2>E?] ^ ?E"9:$Kb‘X$K K?X?2 " X$WE4K"
E"# #?>"2 D2$Z4[9E>?N
’Ka4#?: @?25$: 3" X$WE4K" @"3$#
$:5?2 $Z4>@?3?: E"# 5>95? "@?E? Z4$]
@?2? :$2 @2$:$2X?3? E"#" 5?K] 9$E$:A
:>5? 3$ E4>3?3": @?25>E4K?2$:% E"9:4KA
5?2 ? ?3X$25[9E>? :$a4>95$N
3$%&
!#!
!?: $:5?;\$: 3$ K?X?a$#] $X>5?2 ?
K?X?a$# 3" X$WE4K" E"# 2"K": $o"4
$:E"X?:N )?X?2 " X$WE4K" $pEK4:>A
X?#$95$ g #<" 45>K>Y?93" @2"345":
3$5$2a$95$: E"# 1T 9$452"d :$E‘A
K" E"# 4# @?9" #?E>"] 4#$3$A
E>3"N !<" 45>K>Y?2 @2"345": ?J2?:>X":
$o"4 ?J2>Kb?95?3"2$: @?2? " $#J$K$A
Y?#$95" 3" X$WE4K"N -: $pE2$#$95":
3$ @‘::?2": 3$X$# :$2 K?X?3": >#$3>A
?5?#$95$ $ E"# E4>3?3"] @">: ? :4?
?E>3$Y ^ @?25>E4K?2#$95$ ?a2$::>X?N
+X>5?2 q:$ 9<" D"2 >93>:@$9:‘X$Kr $:A
5?E>"9?2 " X$WE4K" 3$J?>p" 3$ ‘2X"A
2$:d 2$#"X$2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ ?: :4J:A
5e9E>?: 2$:>9":?: 3$ "2>a$# X$a$A
5?K @"2Z4$] 4#? X$Y :$E?:] @?2? ?
:4? 2$#";<"] @"3$ :$2 9$E$::‘2>" "
$#@2$a" 3$ @2"345": ?J2?:>X": $o"4
?J2>Kb?95?3"2$:] @?25>E4K?2#$95$ 3$A
:?E"9:$Kb?3": @"2 :$2$# @"5$9E>?>:
E?4:?: 3$ ?K5$2?;<" 3? E?2?E5$2W:5>E?
3$ "@?E>3?3$ 3? 5>95?N 1?2? ? K>#A
@$Y? 3" @?2?AJ2>:? 3>?95$>2" $ 3" X>A
32" 52?:$>2"] 45>K>Y?2 3$5$2a$95$: $:A
@$EWD>E": $ @?9": J$# K>#@": @?2?
9<" 2>:E?2 "4 ?K5$2?2 ? 52?9:@?2[9E>?
3": #$:#":N
1?2? 4#? K?X?a$# E"22$5? 3" X$WA
E4K"] :$a4>2 $:5?: >93>E?;\$:%
 ,$ D"2 K?X?2 " X$WE4K" $# 4#?
#‘Z4>9? ?45"#‘5>E?] 2$5>2?2 ? ?9A
5$9? 3" 5$5"N
 ,$ @?2? ? K?X?a$# 3" X$WE4K" D"A
2$# 45>K>Y?3": X?@"2>Y?3"2$: "4
K>#@?3"2$: 3$ ?K5? @2$::<"] #?9A
5$2 4#? 3>:5e9E>? #W9>#? 3$ IG
E# 3? E?22"E$2>? @?2? $X>5?2 3?A
9": "4 ?K5$2?;\$:N ’Eu#4K": 3$
‘a4?] ? K"9a" @2?Y"] @"3$# 3?A
9>D>E?2 " X$WE4K"N
 f @2$D$2WX$K #"Kb?2 ? E?22"E$2>?
E"# 4# _?5" 3$ ‘a4? 3$ J?>p?
@2$::<"N
 1?::?2 :"J2$ ? E?22"E$2>?] 4#?
$:@"9_? E"# 4#? K>a$>2? :"K4;<"
3$5$2a$95$] $9p?a4?93" D2$Z4$9A
5$#$95$ ? $:@"9_?N
 +9p?a4?2 J$# E"# ‘a4? $ :$Z4$
E"# _?5" 3$ ?2 "4 4# @?9" #?A
E>"N
 *42?95$ ? :$E?a$#] E4>3?2 :"J2$A
543" 3?: @?25$: #$9": X>:WX$>: q@"2
$pN X<": 3?: @"25?:] E?@v] E"95"29"
3": D?2h>:] $5ENr "93$ ? ‘a4? @"3$ @?A
2?2 E"# #?>"2 D?E>K>3?3$N !<" K?X?2
" X$WE4K" 3$@">: 3$ 4#? @?2?3? ?"
:"K "4 E"# " E?@v 3" #"5"2 Z4$95$%
@"3$ ?K5$2?2 " J2>Kb" 3? 5>95?N
’: @?25$: $p5$29?: 3$ @K‘:5>E" 3$A
X$# :$2 K>#@?: E"# " #$:#" @2"A
E$3>#$95" 2$?K>Y?3" @?2? ? K?X?a$#
9"2#?K 3" X$WE4K"N

+X>5?2 " #?>: @"::WX$K $:5?E>"9?2 "
X$WE4K" 3$J?>p" 3$ ‘2X"2$:d ?: :4J:A
5e9E>?: 2$:>9":?: E"9D$2$# 4# ?:A
@$E5" "@?E" g 5>95? $ ?4#$95?# ?
@"::>J>K>3?3$ 3$ E"22":<"N

+X$954?>: $pE2$#$95": 3$ @‘::?2":
3$X$# :$2 K?X?3": >#$3>?5?#$95$ $
E"# E4>3?3"] @">: ? :4? ?E>3$Y ^
@?25>E4K?2#$95$ ?a2$::>X?N

1?2? 9<" 3?9>D>E?2 ?: 2$:>:5[9E>?:
$K^52>E?: @2$:$95$: 9? :4@$2DWE>$ >9A
5$29? 3" X>32" 52?:$>2" 5^2#>E"] $:D2$A
a?2 3$K>E?3?#$95$ :$a4>93" " :$9A
5>3" 3?: 2$:>:5[9E>?:N
  
(5>K>Y?2 3$5$2a$95$: $:@$EWD>E": $
@?9": J$# K>#@": @?2? 9<" ": 2>:E?2
"4 ?K5$2?2 ? :4? 52?9:@?2[9E>?N
 Q     
(5>K>Y?2 4# @?9" #?E>"] 9<" :$E"]
$#J$J>3" $# ‘a4? $ :?J<" @?2? ?4A
5"#hX$>:N

!? "@$2?;<" 3$ K>#@$Y? 3": 52?9:A
@?2$95$: 3$ @K‘:5>E" 3": D?2h>:] 9<"
45>K>Y?2 :4J:5e9E>?: ?2"#‘5>E?: q@"2
$pN J$9Y>9?r "4 Z4$5"9?: q@"2 $pN
?E$5"9?rN
+# E?:" 3$ K>#@$Y? E"# 4#? #?9A
a4$>2? 3$ ‘a4?] #?95$2 " _?5" 3$ ‘a4?
? 4#? 3>:5e9E>? 3$] @$K" #$9":] LG
E# 3": D?2h>:N
7  
’ K>#@$Y? 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3"
#"5"2] 45>K>Y?93" K?X?3"2? 3$ ?K5?
@2$::<"] 9<" ^ 2$E"#$93?3?N -:
E"#@"9$95$: 3" #"5"2 @"::4$# @2"A
5$;<" E"952? ? >9D>K52?;<" 3$ ‘a4?]
@"2^# ?: @2$::\$: a$2?3?: @$K? K?X?A
3"2? @"3$# 3?9>D>E‘AK":N
!#!
,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" $D$54?2 4#? K?X?A
a$# 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3" #"5"2] 5$2
E4>3?3" @?2? 9<" >9:>:5>2 3>2$5?#$95$
E"# 4# _?5" 3$ ‘a4? 9? E$952?K 3":
D4:WX$>: $ 9": #"5"2$: 3": K>#@?3"A
2$: 3" @?2?AJ2>:?N
+X>5$ 3?9": ?": E"#@"9$95$:N
(
’ K?X?a$# 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3"
#"5"2 ^ 4# @2"E$3>#$95" Z4$ 3$X$
:$2 $X>5?3"N 1"2^#] Z4?93" >:5" :$
3$%’
5"29?2 9$E$::‘2>"] "J:$2X?2 ?: 2$E"A
#$93?;\$: ? :$a4>2%
 ’ K?X?a$# 3$X$ :$2 $D$54?3? E"#
" #"5"2 D2>" $ " E"#45?3"2 3$
>a9>;<" 9? @":>;<"  N
 !<" 45>K>Y$ :4J:5e9E>?: E‘4:5>E?:]
@2"345": ‘E>3": "4 3$2>X?3": 3$
@$52hK$"N
 +X>5$ _?5": 3†‘a4? 3>2$5?#$95$ :"A
J2$ ": E"#@"9$95$: $K$52"$K$52vA
9>E": $ :$4: Eb>E"5$:N
 12"5$_? E"# @K‘:5>E": " ?K5$29?A
3"2] ? E$952?K 3? >a9>;<"o>9_$;<"
$K$52v9>E?] ? J?5$2>?] ? J"J>9? $
? E$952?K 3" :>:5$#? ’B,N
 12"5$_? 5?#J^# E"# @K‘:5>E" "
2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" DK4>3" 3$ D2$>"]
@?2? $X>5?2 ? :4? E"95?#>9?;<"N
’@h: ? K?X?a$#] E$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$
Z4$ ?: X‘2>?: @2"5$;\$: q@"2 $pN] 5?#A
@\$: 3$ J"22?Eb? $ @2"5$;\$: X‘2>?:r]
9<" $:5<" 2$#"X>3?: "4 3?9>D>E?3?:N
’@h: ? K?X?a$#] 9<" @4KX$2>Y$ 9$A
9b4# 5>@" 3$ DK4>3" qhK$" 3>$:$K] Z4$A
2":$9$] hK$" 3$ #?#"9? $5ENr :"J2$
3$%*
" #"5"2 $ E"#@"9$95$:] :"J @$9? 3$
3?9>D>E‘AK":] E?4:?93"] >9EK4:>X$] ?
2$5$9;<" 3$ @"$>2?N
!#!
- $#@2$a" >9?3$Z4?3" 3$ _?5":
3‡‘a4? @"3$ @2"X"E?2 3?9": 9?: E"KA
#$>?: 3" 2?3>?3"2 $ 9" #"5"2 $K^A
52>E" 3" $K$52"X$95>K?3"2N
’ K>#@$Y? 3" $K$52"X$95>K?3"2 3"
2?3>?3"2 3$X$ :$2 D$>5? 2$:@$>5?93" ?:
3>:@":>;\$: $:5?J$K$E>3?: 9" 5h@>E"
?95$2>"2] tV<" 3" #"5"2tN
   !

!!
!#!
!49E? 45>K>Y?2 @2"345": >9DK?#‘A
X$>:] E"#" ^5$2 "4 J$9Y>9?] @?2? ?
K>#@$Y? 3?: @?25$: >95$2>"2$: 3" X$WA
E4K"N
’: E?2a?: $K$52":5‘5>E?: Z4$ :<" a$A
2?3?: 342?95$ ? "@$2?;<" 3$ K>#@$Y?
@"3$# @2"X"E?2 >9E[93>"N
!#!
!<" @"25?2 $#J?K?a$9: 3$ ?$2":A
:h>: 9" X$WE4K"% @$2>a" 3$ $p@K":<"N
-: ?$2"::h>: 9<" 3$X$# $:5?2 $pA
@":5": ? 4#? 5$#@$2?542? :4@$2>"2 ?
6G 8N !" >95$2>"2 3$ 4# X$WE4K" $pA
@":5" ?" :"K] ? 5$#@$2?542? @"3$ :4A
@$2?2 3$ D"2#? :>a9>D>E?5>X? $::$: X?A
K"2$:N
!#!
’ ‘2$? 3" @>:" :"J ? @$3?K$>2? 9<"
3$X$ ?@2$:$95?2 "J:5‘E4K":N
8$25>D>Z4$A:$ 3$ Z4$ $X$954?>: 5?A
@$5$: $:5$_?# :$#@2$ J$# $:5>E?3":
$ 9<" >95$2D>2?# E"# ": @$3?>:N
 V$2>D>E?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$ " $:5?3"
3$ K>#@$Y? 3": >95$2>"2$:] @"2 J?>p"
3": 5?@$5$:] Z4$ @"3$2>? @2"X"E?2 ?
"p>3?;<" 3? Eb?@?N
!   !!  &

8$25>D>E?2A:$ Z4$ 9?3? q5?@$5$:]
$5ENr >#@$;? " #"X>#$95" $ " E42:"
3": @$3?>: 3" X$WE4K"N
!#!
8$25>D>E?2A:$ 3$ Z4$ ": 5?@$5$: $:5$A
_?# :$#@2$ $:5$93>3": $ J$# @":>E>A
"9?3":N -J:$2X?2 ? K"E?K>Y?;<" E"2A
2$5? $# E?3? 49>3?3$ $ :$4 2$:@$EA
5>X" @":>E>"9?#$95"N ’Ka4#?: X$2A
:\$: 3>:@\$# 3$ @2$:>Kb?: 3$ D>p?;<"]
>93>E?3?: @$K?: :$5?: !] @?2? ?4p>K>?2
9? :4? 2$5$9;<" 9" ?::"?Kb"N
’ 3>:@":>;<" >93$X>3?] "4 " 4:" 3$
4# 5?@$5$ 9<" b"#"K"a?3"] @"3$ :$
5"29?2 4# "J:5‘E4K" ?" ?E>"9?#$95"
3": @$3?>:N (5>K>Y?2] $pEK4:>X?#$95$]
5?@$5$: "2>a>9?>: $o"4 b"#"K"a?3":
@$K? c$$@] $X>5?93" #?5$2>?>: 9<" ?4A
5"2>Y?3":N

1?2? ? :$a42?9;? 3" E"9345"2] "
5?@$5$ 3$X$ :$2 D>p?3" 9?: @2$:>Kb?:
>93>E?3?: @$K?: :$5?: !N
V$2>D>E?2 @$2>"3>E?#$95$ " $:5?3"
3$ K>#@$Y? 3": >95$2>"2$:] @"2 J?>p"
3": 5?@$5$:] Z4$ @"3$2>? @2"X"E?2 ?
"p>3?;<" 3? Eb?@?N 1?2? ? :$a42?9;?
9? E"934;<"] 45>K>Y?2 :"#$95$ 5?@$A
5$: a$94W9": c$$@N
%!  ! " 
+K>#>9?2 " @h E"# 4#? $:E"X? #?A
E>? "4 E"# 4# ?:@>2?3"2N 1?2? 4#?
#$Kb"2 K>#@$Y? 3": 2$X$:5>#$95":
$# X$K43"] ?E"9:$Kb?#": ? 4#$3$A
E$2 ? $:E"X?N +:D2$a?2 ": J?9E": E"#
4#? $:@"9_? 4#$3$E>3? $# 4#? :"A
K4;<" 3$ ‘a4? $ 3$5$2a$95$ 9$452"N
%! "  / .- &
0
+K>#>9?2 ? :4_$>2? :$E? E"# 4#?
DK?9$K? "4 4# @?9" u#>3"] :$# $p$2A
E$2 3$#?:>?3? @2$::<"N
C$5>2?2 ?: #?9Eb?: 3$ KWZ4>3": "4
3$ a"2342? E"# 4# @?9" :$E" ?JA
:"2X$95$] :$# $:D2$a?2N 1?::?2 $#
:$a4>3? 4#? DK?9$K? "4 @?9" #?E>"
4#$3$E>3" E"# ‘a4? $ :?J<" 9$4A
52"N ,$ ? #?9Eb? @$2:>:5>2] 45>K>Y?2
@2"345": $:@$EWD>E":] 5$93" $:@$E>?K
?5$9;<" g: >9:524;\$: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"N
(

!<" 4:?2 949E? ‘KE""KN 8$25>D>E?2A
:$ 3$ Z4$ ": @2"345": 45>K>Y?3": @?2?
? K>#@$Y? 9<" E"95[# ‘KE""K $ 3$2>A
3$%+
X?3":] #$:#" $# J?>p?: E"9E$952?A #$95$ 4#$3$E>3" E"# ‘a4?N f 3$:?A
;\$:N E"9:$Kb?3" " $#@2$a" 3$ K$9;": 3$
@?@$K Z4$ @"3$2>?# 3$>p?2 2$:W34":N
!    &
! ! ! " 
/ .- 0
1?2? K>#@?2 $:5$: E"#@"9$95$:
!#! 4:?2 :h ‘a4? $ :?J<" 9$452"N !49E?
45>K>Y?2 ‘KE""K "4 @2"345": g J?:$ 3$
!<" 45>K>Y?2 ‘KE""K] J$9Y>9? $ :$4:
‘KE""KN
3$2>X?3": @?2? ? K>#@$Y? 3" 52?9:A
@?2$95$ 3" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": $ ’95$: 3$ 4:?2 @2"345": $:@$EWD>A
3" @?>9$KN E": @?2? ? K>#@$Y? 3": >95$2>"2$:]
?::$a42?2A:$ Z4$ " @2"345" 9<" E"9A
C>:E" 3$ 3?9": ?": #?5$2>?>:N 5^# ‘KE""K $o"4 :4J:5e9E>?: E"# J?:$
?KE"hK>E?N
+D$54?2 ? K>#@$Y? 3": @K‘:5>E": >9A
5$29": E"# 4# @?9" 3$ #>E2"D>J2?]
:$ @"::WX$K] 4#$3$E>3" $# 4#? :"K4A
;<" 3$ ‘a4? $ 3$5$2a$95$ 9$452" 9<"
?J2?:>X"N
1?2? K>#@?2 #?9Eb?: a"2342":?:
"4 2$:>:5$95$:] 45>K>Y?2 @2"345": $:A
@$EWD>E": :$# :"KX$95$: $ $:543?3":
@?2? 9<" ?K5$2?2 " ?:@$E5" $ ? E"2 3":
E"#@"9$95$:N
1?2? 2$#"X$2 " $X$954?K @h] 45>K>A
Y?2 4# @?9" 3$ #>E2"D>J2?] $X$954?KA

3$%,
 0 
=!.C-*(/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7
*’*-, 1’C’ ’ =*+!.=P=8’/0- N N N N N N N N N =A7
&-.-C N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AH
.C’!,&=,,0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AI
PC+=-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A6
,(,1+!,n+, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A6
*=C+/0- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AF
C-*’, + 1!+(, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A|
+,1+8=P=8’/n+, *+ C-*’, + 1!+(, N N N N N N N =A~
*=&+!,n+, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A77
1+,-, + 8’CS’, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7I
’B’,.+8=&+!.-, N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A76
,=,.+&’ +)f.C=8- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7F
P)(=*-, -C=S=!’=, + )(BC=P=8’!.+, N N N N N N =A7F
V+)-8=*’*+ &“¡=&’ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7M
+&=,,n+, *+ 8- N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7M
C’*=-PC+w(l!8=’ *+ 8-!.C-)+ C+&-.-%
T-&-)-S’/n+, )+S’=, N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AL7
)

4
4
  ZFA
520V
P70
P00
0016
."3?: >9:524;\$: u5$>: @?2? @$2A
E$J$2 E"#" ^ D$>5" $ E"#" D49E>A
"9? " :$4 X$WE4K" $:5<" E"95>3?:
9$:5$ E?@W54K" $ >K4:52?3?: E"# 3?A
3": $ 5?J$K?:N 1?2? " ?@?>p"9?3"] "
5^E9>E"] #?: 5?#J^# :>#@K$:#$95$
@?2? Z4$# Z4$2 E"9b$E$2 #?>: 3$5?A ZFA5
20VP
70P00
0016

Kb?3?#$95$ " :$4 X$WE4K"N

!;! "!  !&
  !
+::$ 9u#$2" 5?#J^# :$ $9E"952?
 '  a2?X?3" 9" ?::"?Kb" 3" b?J>5‘E4K"] !? @K?Z4$5?] :>54?3? 9" E"K49? 3?
@"25? 3>?95$>2? 3" K?3" 3>2$>5"] $:5<"
  "  ?" K?3" 3" J?9E" 3>?95$>2" 3>2$>5"%
>93>E?3": ": 3?3": 2$K?5>X": ?%
i"  !
 !) X?K"2 E"22$5" 3" E"$D>E>$95$ 3"
- 9u#$2" 3" Eb?::> qV=!r
W93>E$ 3$ "@?E>3?3$ q@?2? #"5"A
$9E"952?A:$ a2?X?3" 9? @?25$ >9D$2>"2
2$: *>$:$KrN
$:Z4$23? 3" @?2?AJ2>:?%
 %) 5>@" 3$ #"5"2] Eh3>a" 3? X$2A
:<" 3? E?22"E$2>?] 9u#$2" @?2?
@$;?:] Eh3>a" 3$ E"2N

1?2? ?E$::?2] a>2?2 ? 5?#@? ] ?54A

?93" E"#" >93>E?3"N
)

4$!
4$"

 5  
 H 1:C % 1O N B:2 1O  '

8>EK" -55" *>$:$K

!u#$2" $ @":>;<" 3": E>K>932": I $# K>9b? I $# K>9b?

*>e#$52" $ E42:" 3": @>:5\$: q##r |G p ~F]6 ~H p MG]I

8>K>932?3? 5"5?K qE#·r 7NHHL]G 7M6F]G

.?p? 3$ E"#@2$::<" 7G]6%7 7F]6% 7

S?:"K>9? +5?9"K
1"5[9E>? #‘p>#? q’B!.r qEXr 7|G
7~G]G 7~6]G
1"5[9E>? #‘p>#? q’B!.r qi¤r 7HL]6 7HF]G 7L6

C$a>#$ E"22$:@"93$95$ q2@#r 6|6G 6|6G H|6G

."2Z4$ #‘p>#" q’B!.r q!#r L|G]G L|G]G H6G

."2Z4$ #‘p>#" q’B!.r qiaD#r L|]6 L|]6 H6]|

C$a>#$ E"22$:@"93$95$ q2@#r 7|6G 7|6G 7|6G

~6G 6G 2@# q’o8 3$:KNr
C$a>#$ 3$ #?2Eb? K$95? q2@#r ~6G
MGG 6G 2@# q’o8 K>aNr

-+ * ,-' 
 H +*'  -+   3   3 ,' K67  % /!0

~7]| )>#>5$3o)>#>5$3 ,
1:C - 4 1O '( !O
~7]M ,@"25o)"9a>543$ )

4$%
  H +*'  -+   3   3 ,' K67  % /!0

B:2 1O  ' ,     ,     ' ~G]7

B:2 1O  ' ,     ,    - ' ~L]7

!"!
 5  
 H !'  67

1:C - 4 1O '( =9_$;<" 5>@" #4K5>@"95"] 3>2$5?

B:2 1O  ' =9_$;<" 3>2$5? t&4K5>_$5 == ¥¥t

!#!
&"3>D>E?;\$: "4 2$@?2?;\$: 3" :>:5$#? 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" $D$54?3?: 3$ #"3" >9E"22$5" $ :$# 5$2 $# E"95? ?:
E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 5^E9>E?: 3" :>:5$#? @"3$# E?4:?2 ?9"#?K>?: 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"N
C=,8- *+ =!8l!*=-O

  
] 4  - P ,
 H  (  *',   67

!O 8"# :$>: #?2Eb?: g D2$95$ $ #?2Eb? ? 2^ *>?95$>2?

4$&
  H  (  *',   67

!W 8"# 9"X$ #?2Eb?: g D2$95$ $ #?2Eb? ? 2^ =95$a2?K

" 
 , 3 ,6H
   
 H             
,    
8"#?93" $K^52>E" E"#
1:C - 4 1O '( ’ 3>:E" X$95>K?3"] E"# ’ 3>:E" :hK>3"] E"#
?54?;<" 9?: 2"3?:
@>9;? DK454?95$ $ 4# @>9;? DK454?95$ $ 4#
@":5$2>"2$: ?52?X^: 3$
E>K>932" 3$ E"#?93" E>K>932" 3$ E"#?93"
B:2 1O  ' #"5"2 9?: @>9;?: 3$
@?2? E?3? 2"3? @?2? E?3? 2"3?
D2$>"

 ' #
 , 3 ,6H
 H       

1:C - 4 1O '( ,>:5$#? &E1b$2:"9 E"# 2"3?:

,>:5$#? &E1b$2:"9 E"# 2"3?:
>93$@$93$95$:] J2?;": ":E>K?95$: >9D$2>"2$:
>93$@$93$95$:] K>9i: 52?9:X$2:?>:oK?5$2?>: $
E"# a$"#$52>? 52>?9a4K?2 $ J?22?
B:2 1O  ' $:5?J>K>Y?3"2?
J?22? $:5?J>K>Y?3"2?

4$’
 
 , 3 ,6H
 H b    *'  *'   ]   +   ,- * / 0  

*$ @>9b<" $ E2$#?Kb$>2? E"#

1:C - 4 1O '( L]F~ 77]H
3>2$;<" ?::>:5>3? $K^52>E?
*$ @>9b<" $ E2$#?Kb$>2? E"#
B:2 1O  ' L]F~ 77]H
3>2$;<" ?::>:5>3? $K^52>E?

4$*
  '    ,  , 5 ! ! ! !
/ ,  P(   -0 +p$#@K"% U> ( 1U B  D2
C"3?: $# K>a? "4 $# ?;" $:5?#A
@?3"N WB § FHG ia WC § F6G ia U K?2a42? 3? 2"3? $# @"K$a?3?:N
19$4: 54J$K$:: 3$ E?2E?;? 2?3>?KN WD § F|G ia WT § FMG ia > @$2D>K 3? a?K$2>? q2$K$X" K?5$2?K
WO § |7G ia WU § |HG ia "93$ ?@">? " E?KE?9b?2 3" @9$4rN

 WV § |6G ia WW § ||6 ia 1U 3>e#$52" 3$ #"95?a$# $# @"A

K$a?3?: qE"22$:@"93$ ?" 3" @9$4 Z4$
8"# @9$4: 54J$K$:: 9<" 45>K>Y?2 122 § ~GG ia 121 § ~L6 ia
3$X$ :$2 #"95?3"rN
Ee#?2?: 3$ ?2N
12B § ~6G ia 12C § ~|6 ia
B D"2#? $ 9u#$2" 3": tb4#@t
q2$K$X" E>2E49D$2$9E>?K] Z4$ #?95^#
! !     ,  *',  P(  9? :$3$ " E?KE?9b?2 3" @9$4 .4J$A
+p$#@K"% B1T@OT 1O WV ; ?5^ 7FG i#ob K$:: 9? 2"3?rN
B1T  )?2a42? 9"#>9?K 3" @9$4  ?5^ 7FG i#ob  D2 E"#@$9:?;<" 3? 2"3?
$# ## q3>:5e9E>? $952$ " @K?9" 3$ ?@">"
 ?5^ 7~G i#ob 3>:E"o2"3? $ ? K>9b? #$3>?9? 3?
OT  C$K?;<" ?K542?oK?2a42? $# s 2"3?rN
 ?5^ 7MG i#ob
  .>@" 3$ E"9:524;<" q2?3>?K] 9"
E?:"r  ?5^ LGG i#ob

1O  *>e#$52" $# @"K$a?3?:  ?5^ L7G i#ob

WV  m93>E$ 3$ E?@?E>3?3$ 3$  ?5^ LIG i#ob

E?2a? R ?5^ L|G i#ob
  m93>E$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ #‘p>#? L ?5^ HGG i#ob

4$+
 ' " #
! ' ,67
 7
   1:C - 4 '(
  1:C - 4 '(
   1:C - 4 '(
 5 - 1:C - 4 '(
  B:2  '
 5 - B:2  '
  'G\[ B:2  '
4$,
   ' 

|]G p C7| +.IG q)>a?r
,"J2$::?K$95$% I]G p C7| +.L6 q’;"r
|]6 p C7M +.IG q)>a?r
,"J2$::?K$95$% I]G p C7| +.L6 q’;"r
|]6 p C7M +.IG q)>a?r
,"J2$::?K$95$% I]G p C7| +.L6 q’;"r
|]G p C7~ +.IG q)>a?r
,"J2$::?K$95$% I]G p C7| +.L6 q’;"r
|]6c p 7Mt +.IG q:^2>$r
I]Gc p 7|‡‡ +.L6 q:"J2$::?K$95$r
|]Gc p 7~‡‡ +.IG q:^2>$r
I]Gc p 7|‡‡ +.L6 q:"J2$::?K$95$r
F]6c p 7|‡‡ +.IG q:^2>$ $ :"J2$::?K$95$r
-
LL6oFG C7| 7GHT -!AC-’*
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LH6oI6 C7M M6T -!AC-’*
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LH6oI6 C7M M6T -!AC-’*
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LL6o66 C7~ M~V -!AC-’*
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LH6oI6 C7M M6T q:^2>$r
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LL6o66 C7~ M~V q:^2>$r
,"J2$::?K$95$% .7F6o~G C7| 7GI&
LL6oFG C7| MMT &¥, q:^2>$ $
:"J2$::?K$95$r
 !#!
’ 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ @"::4> E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3>D$2$95$: E"#" 3>#$9:<" "4 #?2E? 3": @9$4: 3$ 2"3?a$# $ 3$X$ :$2
45>K>Y?3? ?@$9?: $# E?:" 3$ $#$2a[9E>?N ’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$X$ :$2 2$34Y>3? ?" #W9>#" >93>:@$9:‘X$K $ ? X$K"E>3?3$
9<" 3$X$ 4K52?@?::?2 V2 [ @G - 1B2 [ @G`  ,  Q   , 3   '@* 7N 9?: X$2:\$: E"#
2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$ #$9"2 Z4$ ?: 3$ 4:" 9"2#?K] $9E"952?A:$ ?@K>E?3" 4# ?3$:>X" E"# ": @2>9E>@?>: ?X>:": :"J2$ ?
45>K>Y?;<" $ 3?: 2$:@$E5>X?: K>#>5?;\$:N
!<" 2$#"X$2 " ?3$:>X"] 9<" E"J2>AK" $ 949E? ?@K>E?2 9$9b4#? E?K"5? 3$ 2"3?N

!#!
8"# @9$4: .4J$K$:: q:$# Ee#?2?r] 9<" 4:?2 Ee#?2?: 3$ ?2N ’: 2"3?: 3$ K>a? K$X$ :<" D>p?3?: E"# @?2?D4:":
$:@$EWD>E": >9E"#@?5WX$>: E"# Z4?KZ4$2 2"3? 3$ ?;" $:5?#@?3"] $pE$5" E"# ? 3$ 2$:$2X? $:@$EWD>E?N
C$:@$>5?2 :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN

!#!
.2?9:>5?2 E"# @9$4: 3$:E?K>J2?3": $o"4 E?K>J2?3": E"# @2$::<" >9D$2>"2 g 2$E"#$93?3? @"3$ 3?9>D>E?2 ?: 2"3?: $
": @2h@2>": @9$4:] 5"29?93"A": #?>: X4K9$2‘X$>: ? J42?E": $ >#@$2D$>;\$: 9?: X>?:N
-J:$2X$ :$#@2$ ?: 2$E"#$93?;\$: 3$:5$ #?94?KN
)

4$-

(5>K>Y$ :"#$95$ @9$4: E"# E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: $ 3>#$9:\$: @2$:E2>5?: 9" #?94?KN +:5? E"93>;<" a?2?95$ 4#? E"22$5?
>93>E?;<" 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ $ 3>:5e9E>? @$2E"22>3? 9" Z4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95":N

  

8"# " @9$4 Z4$95$ " X?K"2 3? @2$::<" 3$X$ :$2 ¥G]H J?2 q¥I]H6 @:>r $# 2$K?;<" ?" X?K"2 @2$:E2>5"N V"K5?2 ?
E"952"K?2] 3$ Z4?KZ4$2 D"2#?] " X?K"2 E"22$5" E"# " @9$4 D2>"N

 , 3 ,6H
K @ 5
 7  4 '  /g0
      

   1:C - 4 '(
  1:C - 4 '(
L]I J?2 qH6 @:>r L]L J?2 qHL @:>r I]7 J?2 qFG @:>r
   1:C - 4 '(
 5 - 1:C - 4 '(

  B:2  '

L]I J?2 qH6 @:>r L]L J?2 qHL @:>r I]7 J?2 qFG @:>r
 5 - B:2  '

  'G\[ B:2  ' L]I J?2 qH6 @:>r L]L J?2 qHL @:>r L]I J?2 qH6 @:>r

q›r ’@h: 4#? 45>K>Y?;<" $# $#$2a[9E>? 3? 2"3? :"J2$::?K$95$] E?:" :$_? 9$E$::‘2>"] E?K>J2?2 ? 2"3? E"# " X?K"2
2$E"#$93?3"] E"9:4K5?93" ? 5?J$K?N

4$!.
 ,$ D"2 9$E$::‘2>" $K$X?2 " X$WE4K"] E"9:4K5?2 t)$X?95?93" " X$WE4K"t] 9" E?@W54K" t&?945$9;<" $ E4>3?3": E"# :$4
X$WE4K"tN

  #
’: 3>#$9:\$: $:5<" $p@2$::?: $# #>KW#$52": $ 2$D$2$#A:$ ?" X$WE4K" $Z4>@?3" E"# @9$4: $# 3"5?;<"N *$ ?E"23"
E"# ? 3>#$9:<" 3?: 2"3?:] ^ @"::WX$K $9E"952?2 @$Z4$9?: X?2>?;\$: ?": X?K"2$: >93>E?3":N

8"9:>3$2?2 ? ?K542? E"# " X$WE4K" :$# E?2a?N

"  / 0
 7 ! %       

   1:C - 4 '( !O IIGI M76 LFHF ~6H 7FHL 766G LGHH 76I6 7~7M

4$!!
  7 ! %       

  1:C - 4 '(

!O
IIGI M76 LFHF ~6H 7FL6 766G LGHH 76I6 7~7M
   1:C - 4 '(
!O
 5 - 1:C - 4 '(
IIGI M76 LFHF ~6H 7FL~ 766G LGHH 76I6 7~7M
!O
7FII]~
  B:2  ' IHM~ MG~ LFHF ~6I 766G LGHH 76I6 7~7M
7F6G]L›
7FII]~
 5 - B:2  ' IHM~ MG~ LFHF ~6I 766G LGHH 76I6 7~7M
7F6G]L›
7F6I]7
  'G\[ B:2  ' IHM~ MG~ LFHF ~6I 76IF LGHH 76H~ 7~7M
7F6M]M›

› 8"# 2?Ei 3$ 5$5"

! !!
 & '
 ,  , 4 ,      67
 ,  , 4 ,    4 
 '

1:C - 4 '( I|F 77~G

B:2  ' I|F 77~G

 7   'G\[ IHL 77~G

4$!"
!'-  ' *   '      (
’ ?K542? ^ #$3>3? 9? @2"p>#>3?3$ 3? #?2a$# >9D$2>"2 3" 3>D$2$9E>?K $ 3$5$2#>9? 5?#J^# ": X?K"2$: 2$K?5>X": ?":
e9a4K" 3$ $952?3?] :?W3? $ $ 2?#@?N

!'-  ' *   ' /,  *+,-' *K 0

 7 !'- 

   1:C - 4 '( !O LGM]G

  1:C - 4 '( !O
LGL]G
 1:C - 4 '( !O
 5 - 1:C - 4 '( !O LG6]G
  B:2  ' L7L]G
 5 - B:2  ' L7M]G
  'G\[ B:2  ' LL~]G

_ 5-' , , + ,

 H _ 5-'     _ 5-'  + _ 5-'   

   1:C - 4 '( !O LG]M H7]I LG]~

  1:C - 4 '( !O LG]F HG]~ LG]7

   1:C - 4 '( !O LG]F H7]I LG]~

 5 - 1:C - 4 '( !O L7]6 HG]| LG]6

  B:2  ' LM]M LM]H L7]G

 5 - B:2  '

)
HG]H HL]7 L7]F

  'G\[ B:2  ' HG]F HH]L LL]F

4$!%
 _ 5-'     % " e9a4K" 3$ $952?3? ^ 3$5$2#>9?3" @$K? K>9b? b"2>Y"95?K 3" @>:" 3? $:52?3? $ @$K? K>9b?
5?9a$95$ Z4$ @?::? $952$ ? 2"3? 3>?95$>2? $ " @"95" >9D$2>"2 #?>: :?K>$95$ 3" X$WE4K"N
w4?95" #?>"2 ^ " e9a4K"] #$9"2$: :$2<" ?: @"::>J>K>3?3$: 3$ E"K>3>2] E"# ? E?22"E$2>? "4 " Eb?::>] 342?95$ 4#?
:4J>3? ?E$954?3? "4 ?" 4K52?@?::?2 4# "J:5‘E4K"N
_ 5-'  + % " e9a4K" 3$ :?W3? ^ 3$5$2#>9?3" @$K?: #$:#?: K>9b?: 3" t⁄9a4K" 3$ $9a?5$t $ 2$D$2$A:$ g @?25$
52?:$>2? 3" X$WE4K"N
_ 5-'    % " X?K"2 3" e9a4K" 3$ 2?#@? $:5‘ 2$K?E>"9?3" E"# ? ?K542? ?" :"K" 3" X$WE4K" $ 2$@2$:$95?
? @"::>J>K>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 3$ 4K52?@?::?2 4#? K"#J?3?] #?>: "4 #$9": ?E$954?3?] :$# Z4$ " X$WE4K"] ?" 5"E?2
9? K"#J?3? E"# ?: :4?: @?25$: >9D$2>"2$: #?>: :?K>$95$: q9"2#?K#$95$ ? @?25$ >9D$2>"2 3? E?22"E$2>?r] @$2#?9$;?
?@">?3" 9" 5$22$9" E"# " Eb?::> "4 E"# ? E?22"E$2>?] " Z4$ @2"X"E?2>? ? @$23? 3$ ?3$2[9E>? 3?: 2"3?:N
w4?95" #?>"2 ^ ? ?K542? 3" :"K"] #?>"2 :$2‘ " e9a4K" 3$ 2?#@?N +# 5"3" " E?:"] K$#J2$ Z4$ Z4?95" #?>"2 ?
?K542? 3" :"K"] #$9"2 ^ ? :4? $:5?J>K>3?3$ 3$X>3" g $K$X?;<" 3" E$952" 3$ a2?X>3?3$] 2$34Y>93" E"9:$Z4$95$#$95$
" e9a4K" 3$ >9EK>9?;<" K?5$2?KN

'   
 , 3 ,6H /[50
 5 -
   1:C   1:C    1:C   B:2  5 -   'G\[
@, 5 1:C - 4
- 4 '( - 4 '( - 4 '(  ' B:2  ' B:2  '
'(
1$:" ? X?Y>" qE"# 5"3":
": KWZ4>3": $ 2$:$2X?5h2>"
76GI 76~M 76~M 76~6 7|HI 7|LG 7|FH
3$ E"#J4:5WX$K Eb$>" ?
MGsr
8?@?E>3?3$ u5>K >9EK4>93"
IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG
" E"9345"2

4$!&
  5 -
   1:C   1:C    1:C   B:2  5 -   'G\[
@, 5 1:C - 4
- 4 '( - 4 '( - 4 '(  ' B:2  ' B:2  '
'(
8?2a?: #‘p>#?: ?3#>5>3?:
q›r 7GGF 7GI7 7GI7 7GHF 77FG 776~ 77F~
 $>p" 3>?95$>2"
 $>p" 52?:$>2" ~M~ MI~ MI~ MIM M|I MFL MM6
 5"5?K 7MGI 7M~M 7M~M 7M~6 L7HI L7LG L7FH
8?2a?: #‘p>#?: 2$J"E‘A
IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG IGG
X$>:

q›r 8?2a?: ? 9<" 4K52?@?::?2N f 3? 2$:@"9:?J>K>3?3$ 3" E"9345"2 3>:@"2 ?: #$2E?3"2>?: 9" X<" 3" @"25?A#?K?: $o"4
9" @K?9" 3$ E?2a?] 2$:@$>5?93" ?: E?2a?: #‘p>#?: ?3#>5>3?:N

   
 , 3 ,6H / '  0
 *Q @   1:C - 4 ( B:2  '

.?9Z4$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K% FG FG

>9EK4>93" 4#? 2$:$2X? 3$% ~ ~

C$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" @?2? 2$34;<" 3$
!* 7H
@"K4$95$: q,8Cr ’C)’ HL q:"#$95$ X$2:\$: 3>$:$Kr
,>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2% q›r ~ F]6G

8‘25$2 3" #"5"2% I]6 H]~

8‘25$2 3" #"5"2 $ D>K52"% I]~ I]L )

4$!’
  *Q @   1:C - 4 ( B:2  '

8e#J>"% F]L F]G

8>2E4>5" 3": D2$>": b>32‘4K>E":% G]6 G]6

C$:$2X?5h2>" 3" KWZ4>3" 3": K?X?3"2$: 3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ 3" X>32" 52?:$>2" q#WA
I]~ 7]G
9>#"r%
q›r PK4>3" @?2? :>:5$#?: 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" g J?:$ 3$ #"9"$5>K$9"aK>E"K] Z4$ E"9D$2$ @2"@2>$3?3$ ?95>E"9a$K?95$ $ @?E"5$ 3$ ?3>5>X": ?95>E"22"A
:<" 3$ "2>a$# "2ae9>E? -’. q-2a?9>E ?93 ’E>3 .$E9"K"ayrN +:@$E>D>E?;<" P8’ &,NMGGHL 1?25$ B o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"%N&-1’C 8""K?95
-’. 6G q$# E?:" 3$ 3uX>3?: 2$E"#$93?A:$ E"9:4K5?2 ? :$;<" 3$ DK4>3": $ K4J2>D>E?95$: "2>a>9?>: 9$::$ E?@W54K"rN
!% 9" E?:" 3$ 4:" 3$ J>"3>$:$K q@"2E$95?a$# #‘p>#? E"9D"2#$ @2$X>:5" 9? )$a>:K?;<" P$3$2?K X>a$95$ g ^@"E? 3? D?J2>E?;<" 3"
X$WE4K"r ^ 9$E$::‘2>" @2"5$a$2 " X$WE4K" $# E?:" 3$ @?2?3?: @2"K"9a?3?: qk 7 #[:rN ’95$: 3$ 4#? @?2?3? @2"K"9a?3?] 3$X$A:$ E"9:4#>2 "
E"#J4:5WX$K @2$:$95$ 9" 5?9Z4$ 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K ?5^ ?E$93$2 ? K4YA$:@>? 3$ 2$:$2X?N ’" K>a?2 9"X?#$95$ " #"5"2 3$@">: 3$ 4# K"9a" @$2W"3"]
2$?J?:5$E$2 >#$3>?5?#$95$ E"# 3>$:$K 9"X"N

 0 
%!!
1:C - 4 1O '( B:2 1O  '

.$9:<" 3$ ?K>#$95?;<" 7L V 7L V

"       "  

- hK$" 3" #"5"2 Z4$ $Z4>@? " :$4 X$WE4K" D"> $:@$E>D>E?#$95$ 3$:$9X"KX>3" $ 5$:5?3" @?2? :?5>:D?Y$2 ": 2$Z4>:>5":
@2$X>:5": @$K" 1K?9" 3$ &?945$9;<" 12"a2?#?3?N ’ 45>K>Y?;<" E"9:5?95$ 3": K4J2>D>E?95$: >93>E?3": a?2?95$
?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3$ E"9:4#" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K $ $#>::\$:N ’ Z4?K>3?3$ 3" K4J2>D>E?95$ ^ 3$5$2#>9?95$ @?2? "
D49E>"9?#$95" $ ? 342?;<" 3" #"5"2N

4$!*
 , 3 ,6H
 , + , .-'  *  '+.-   '-4 3 ,  ,     -
 5 ,'   ' ,67
,  3- ,      *+,-'
F #?2Eb?:% K4J2>D>E?95$d +:@$EN% % ’.P ’¤A7] Z4?K>D>E?;<" MN6666G A ’V o
12"345" T"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C ,1A=V & ’.P
8?>p? 3$ Ee#J>" ?45"#‘5>E?
M #?2Eb?:% K4J2>D>E?95$d +:@$EN% QP .+A&) 77d w4?K>D>E?;<" MN6666G A ’Vo
12"345" b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C ~'M ,@$$3 ’.P
)4J2>D>E?95$: $ a2?p?: S2?p? E"# J>::4KD$5" 3$ #"K>J3[9>"] @?2? $K$X?3?: 5$#@$2?542?: 3$ 45>K>Y?;<"N c495?: b"#"E>9^5>E?: K?3" 3?
@?2? ? 52?9:#>::<" 8"9:>:5[9E>? !)S= LN w4?K>D>E?;<" MN666~GN 2"3?
S2?p? K4J2>D>E?95$ $:@$EWD>E? @?2? _495?: b"#"E>9^5>E?: E"# J?>p" E"$D>E>$95$ c495?: b"#"E>9^5>E?: K?3" 3"
3$ ?52>5"N 8"9:>:5[9E>? !)NSN=N 7]6Nw4?K>D>E?;<" MN666~GN 3>D$2$9E>?K
)4J2>D>E?95$ :>95^5>E" E"# a2?34?;<" ,’+ |6¤AMG ’1= S)6 o @2"345" *>D$2$9E>?K 52?:$>2" qC*&r $
b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C ,R! S$?2'’pK$ A |6¤MG a24@" 3$ 2$$9X>" q1.(r
&"5"2$: PK$p .42J"% K4J2>D>E?95$ 5"5?K#$95$ :>95^5>E" G¤HG ’8+’ 8L
w4?K>D>E?;<" MN666H6AS,7 o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C &’¡1C-
)4J2>D>E?95$: @?2? " ,R!.T+.=8 G¤HG q,!oSPA6r B"E?K 3$ ?J?:5$E>#$95" 3$ hK$"
#"5"2 &"5"2$: *>$:$K% K4J2>D>E?95$ 5"5?K#$95$ :>95^5>E"] ,’+ 6¤HG] w4?K>D>E?;<" 9" #"5"2
MN666H6A,7] ’8+’ 8LN o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C &?p@2" ,y95b$5>E
*>$:$K *1P 8L 6¤HG
PK4>3" :>95^5>E" @?2? :>:5$#?: 3$ D2$>": ,’+ c7|GHd ,’+ c7|GId 8(!’ !8
PK4>3" @?2? ": D2$>": M6FAG7 *-. I ’NBNd =,- IML6d P&V,, !« 77F *-. Id+B 766oM7 A ’B!. I] C$:$2X?5h2>" 3$ D2$>": b>32‘4K>E":
MN666M| o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C *-. I,
PK4>3" @?2? :>:5$#?: 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" g J?:$ 3$ #"9"$5>K$9"aK>E"K] Z4$ E"9D$2$
PK4>3" @?2? :>:5$#? 3$ @2"@2>$3?3$ ?95>E"9a$K?95$ $ @?E"5$ 3$ ?3>5>X": ?95>E"22":<" 3$ "2>a$# C$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
?22$D$E>#$95" "2ae9>E? -’. q-2a?9>E ?93 ’E>3 .$E9"K"ayrN +:@$E>D>E?;<" P8’ &,NMGGHL ?22$D$E>#$95"
1?25$ B o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"%N&-1’C 8""K?95 -’. 6G q›rN
’a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3" C$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
@?2? 2$34;<" 3$ >9_$;<" 3$ ?a$95$ 2$345"2 KWZ4>3"
,"K4;<" 3$ ‘a4? 3$:#>9$2?K>Y?3? E"# HLs 3$ 42$>?] w4?K>D>E?;<" *=! |G G|G
@"K4$95$: ’C)’ HL @?2? 2$34;<" 3$ @"K4$95$: q,8Cr
$ =,- LLLI7A7
q:"#$95$ X$2:\$:
3>$:$Kr
’C)’ HL q:"#$95$ X$2:\$:
3>$:$Kr )

4$!+
  , + , .-'  *  '+.-   '-4 3 ,  ,     -
 5 ,'   ' ,67
,  3- ,      *+,-'
)WZ4>3" 3": K?X?3"2$:
C$:$2X?5h2>" 3" :>:5$#?
3" @?2?AJ2>:? $ 3" “KE"">: $ 5$9:>"?5>X": o @2"345" b"#"K"a?3"% &-1’C 8K$?9$2 FG, q››r
K>#@?3"2oK?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:?
X>32" 52?:$>2"

q›r !<" ^ 9$E$::‘2>? ? 3>K4>;<" 3" @2"345" &-1’C 8""K?95 -’. 6GN
q››r 1?2? D?E>K>5?2 ? K>#@$Y? 3" X>32" 3" @?2?AJ2>:?] 2$E"#$93?A:$ ?3>E>"9?2 " @2"345" &-1’C 8K$?9$2 FG, ?"
KWZ4>3" 3" 2$:$2X?5h2>" 3" K>#@?3"2 3": X>32":] 9? :$a4>95$ @2"@"2;<"% 7Gs 3$ &-1’C 8K$?9$2 FG, ¥ MGs 3$ ‘a4?
@"5‘X$KNtN
+# E?:": 3$ $#$2a[9E>? "93$ 9<" $:5>X$2$# 3>:@"9WX$>: ": K4J2>D>E?95$: E"# ?: E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: $:@$E>D>E?3?:] ^
@$2#>5>3" 45>K>Y?2] @?2? $D$54?2 ": $9Eb>#$95":] @2"345": E"# ?: $:@$E>D>E?;\$: #W9>#?: ’8+’ >93>E?3?:d 9$:5$
E?:"] 9<" $:5‘ a?2?95>3" " 3$:$#@$9b" >3$?K 3" #"5"2N

!#!
’ 45>K>Y?;<" 3$ @2"345": E"# E?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3>D$2$95$: 3?: ?95$2>"2$: >93>E?3?: @"3$2‘ @2"X"E?2 3?9": ?": :>:5$#?:
3" #"5"2 $ 3" X$WE4K" Z4$ 9<" :<" ?J2?9a>3": $# a?2?95>?N
(5>K>Y$ :"#$95$ @2"345": E"# ?: $:@$E>D>E?;\$: 2$E"#$93?3?:N

4$!,
  %/ 
V$K"E>3?3$: #‘p>#?: ?KE?9;‘X$>: ?@h: " @2>#$>2" @$2W"3" 3$ 45>K>Y?;<" 3" X$WE4K"N

 , 3 ,6H
 7 ',  P(  /[ @G0

+5?9"K% LG|]G
   1:C - 4 '( !O
S?:"K>9?% LGI]6
+5?9"K% LGF]G
  1:C - 4 '( !O
S?:"K>9?% LGH]6
+5?9"K% LGF]G
   1:C - 4 '( !O
S?:"K>9?% LGH]6
+5?9"K% LGF]6
 5 - 1:C - 4 '( !O
S?:"K>9?% LGI]G
  B:2  ' 7MI]G
 5 - B:2  ' 7MI]G
  'G\[ B:2  ' 7MI]G

 #  
.$"2 3$ 8- $# #?2Eb? K$95?] #$3>3" ?95$: 3" E"9X$2:"2 E?5?KW5>E"N

 , 3 ,6H
 7  H  
)
1:C - 4 '( fi G]Ls

4$!-
  7  H  

B:2  '

4$".
   ' !  *  ',  %7 EF'   && & "
 "1  /!0
    
 &
# 
+:5$: @2"345": $:5<" b"#"K"a?3":
@$K? ’!’.+) q’a[9E>? !?E>"9?K 3$
.$K$E"#49>E?;\$:r 3$ ?E"23" E"#
P  , , V:D
": @2"E$3>#$95": 2$a4K?#$95?3":
%'    , 
@$K? C$:"K4;<" LILoLGGG] $ ?5$93$#
?": 2$Z4>:>5": 5^E9>E": ?@K>E?3":N
’ :$Z4[9E>? 94#^2>E? >#@2$::?
?E>#? 3" Eh3>a" 3$ J?22?: >3$95>D>E?
" 9u#$2" 3$ b"#"K"a?;<" 3" _495"
g ’!’.+)N
- Eh3>a" 3$ J?22?: $ ": ?Ka?2>:#":
P  , , 12:1
K"E?K>Y?3": ?J?>p" 3? >#?a$# 3?:
 4 ' K
J?22?: E"95[# 3?3": 3" D"29$E$3"2
3" $Z4>@?#$95"N


+:5$ $Z4>@?#$95" 9<" 5$# 3>2$>5"
g @2"5$;<" E"952? >95$2D$2[9E>? @2$_4A
3>E>?K $ 9<" @"3$ E?4:?2 >95$2D$2[9A
E>? $# :>:5$#?: 3$X>3?#$95$ ?45"2>A )
Y?3":N

4$"!
',   /G* , ,  '
 0

 "

R ' G 5  /R 0 & , &

5  3 

4$""
!   "0
 
 ’@">" 3$ J2?;"
’J?:5$E>#$95" 3"
X$WE4K" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
’J?:5$E>#$95": N N N N N N N N N
’J$2542? 3" E?@v 3" #"A
5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
’J$2542? 3" @"25?A#?K?: N N N
’J$2542? 3" 5$5" :"K?2 N N N N N
’B, q’95>AK"Ei B2?i>9a ,y:A
5$#r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
’E$::" ?": D4:WX$>: N N N N N N N
’3$Z4?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" 3$
2$5$9;<" >9D?95>K N N N N N N N N
’>2J?a N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
’>2J?a: D2"95?>: N N N N N N N N N
?>2J?a: K?5$2?>: N N N N N N N N N
’K?2#$ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
’K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#J>" N N N N N N
’K$25? 3$ 9<" ?D>X$K?#$95"
3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? N N N
’K>#$95?;<" N N N N N N N N N N N
’@K>E?5>X" 8?25 q:$ $Z4>A 
@?3"r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6M
’@">?AE?J$;?: N N N N N N N N N 8A7M
B?9E" 3" #"5"2>:5? E"#
2$a4K?a$# $K^52>E? N N N N N N N 8A7~
B?9E" 52?:$>2" 2$EK>9‘X$K $
3>?95$>2" N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6H J>@?25>3" N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7M
PA|6 ’Z4$E>#$95" 3" #"5"2 K"a" B?9E": N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7F
?@h: ? @?25>3? N N N N N N N N N N N PAI
N =A76 B?5$2>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TA76
’Z4$E>#$95" $K^52>E" 3":
B?5$2>?  E?@?E>3?3$ N N N N N =A7F
$:@$Kb": $p5$29": N N N N N N N 8ALH
8AII BK"Z4$>" 3$ >a9>;<" $ @":>;<"
’22$D$E>#$95" @?2? X$2:\$:
8AIF 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" N N N N N N N PA76
542J" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI
8AIH B"5\$: 3$ E"#?93" 3" E"#A
’5>X?;<" 3" ?K?2#$ N N N N N N 8A7G
@45?3"2 3$ J"23" N N N N N N N N *A7I
’5>X?;<" 3" :@$$3
N +A~ B"5\$: 3$ E"#?93": N N N N N *A7G
K>#>5$2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PALM
SA76 ’5>X?;<" $ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3"
3>:@":>5>X" ,@$$3 K>#>5$2 N N N PAHG 
+AHF ’5>X?;<" $ 3$:?5>X?;<" 3" 8e#$2? 3$ 2^ N N N N N N N N N N PA|H
+AIL ,>:5$#? 1?2i:$9:$ N N N N N N N PA66 8?@v 3" #"5"2 N N N N N N N N N 8AII
+AIL ’5>X?;<"o3$:?5>X?;<" 3? #"A 8?2?E5$2W:5>E?: 3" X<" 3$
+AII 3?K>3?3$ I¤* )"j N N N N N N PA7~ E?2a? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6G
N 8AM ’X?2>? 3" :>:5$#? 3$ 3>?aA 8?22$a?3"2 @?2?
PA7G 9h:5>E" 3$ J"23"oE"952"K$ 3" E$K4K?2$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6H
#"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *AIL 8?22"E$2>? N N N N N N N N N N N N TAHH
+AHG ’X>:": a$2?>: :"J2$ " Ee#J>" 8$952?K @"25?AD4:WX$>:
N N =AI ?45"#‘5>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N PA76 3" E"#@?25>#$95" 3"
’X>:": @?2? 45>K>Y?;<" 3": #"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA76
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? N N N N N N +AL~
5$! *
8$952?K @"25?AD4:WX$>: 3"
@?>9$K 3$ >9:524#$95": N N N N SALG
8$952?K @"25?AD4:WX$>: 3"
@"25?A#?K?: N N N N N N N N N N N N SALL
8b?#?3? ,-, $ Eb?#?3? 3$
?::>:5[9E>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA7
8b?X$ $K$52v9>E? {$yK$:: +95$2A
!AS" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7
8b?X$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7
8>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? N N N N N N +ALF
8K>#?5>Y?;<" N N N N N N N N N N N 8AHM
8K>#?5>Y?3"2
?45"#‘5>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AHH
8K>#?5>Y?3"2 ?45"#‘5>E"
*4?KY"9$ N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AHH
8"#@?25>#$95" 3"
#"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TA7G
8"#@"25?#$95" 3? K4YA$:@>?
3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? 3":
K4a?2$: 3>?95$>2": N N N N N N N N +AHG
8"#@"25?#$95" 3": WE"9$:
3": E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? 3":
K4a?2$: 52?:$>2": N N N N N N N N N +AHG
8"#@45?3"2 3$ J"23" N N N N *ALG
8"#45?3"2 3$ >a9>;<" A Eb?X$
$K$52v9>E? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AF
5$"
8"#45?3"2 3$ K4Y$: N N N N N N 8ALH 
8"9_495" 3? K4Y >95$29? 3>?9A *?3": @?2? ?
5$>2? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AL~ >3$95>D>E?;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7
8"9:$2X?;<" 3? E?22"E$A *$:?J>K>5?;<" 3" :>:5$#?
2>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TAHH +,8 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AM
8"952"K$ ?3?@5?5>X" 3$ X$K"E>A *$:?5>X?;<" 3" ?K?2#$ N N N N 8A77
3?3$ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAH7
*$:?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X"
8"952"K$ 3?: $#>::\$: @"K4A ,@$$3 )>#>5$2 N N N N N N N N N N PAHG
$95$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A6~
*$:52?X?#$95" 3$ $#$2a[9A
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ N N N N PAH7 E>? 3? ?K?X?9E? 3" Ee#J>"
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$  ?45"#‘5>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N SAH|
?K5$2?;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ N N N PAHI *>E?: 3$ 3>2$;<" N N N N N N N N PA~6
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$  *>D4:"2$: 3" ?2 9" b?J>5‘A
?5>X?;<" 3" 3>:@":>5>X" N N N N PAHH E4K" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N 8AHM
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$  *>#$9:\$: 3" X$WE4K" N N N N N =A77
3$D>9>;<" 3? 3>:5e9E>? 3"
*>2$;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8ALG]
X$WE4K" g D2$95$ N N N N N N N N N PAH6
=AF
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$  *>:@K?y N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *A7H]
3$D>9>;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$ N N N PAHI PA7G
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$  *>:@K?y #4K5>D49E>"9?K N N N N *A7H
2$5"#?2 X$K"E>3?3$ N N N N N N PAH6 *>:@":>5>X" ?95>$:#?a?A
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ #$95" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AII
3$:?5>X?;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N PAIG *4@K>E?;<" 3?: Eb?X$: N N N N N 8A6
8"952"K$ 3$ X$K"E>3?3$
D>p? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI7
 P?2h>: J?>p": N N N N N N N N N N N
+E"9"#>? 3$
E"#J4:5WX$K N N N N N N N N N N
+#$2a[9E>? 3" Ee#J>" N N N
+Z4>@?#$95": >95$29": N N N
+:@$E>D>E?;\$: 3$ 2"3?: $
@9$4: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
+:@$Kb" >95$29" $K$52"E2vA
#>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
+:@$Kb" 2$52"X>:"2
>95$29" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
+:@$Kb": N N N N N N N N N N N N N
+:@$Kb": 3$ E"25$:>? N N N N N
+:@$Kb": 2$52"X>:"2$: $p5$2A
9": N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
+:5>K" 3$ E"934;<" N N N N N N
+pEK4:<" 3" ?K?2#$ N N N N N
+p5>95"2 3$ >9E[93>": N N N N
"
P?K5? 3$ @?25>3? 3" #"5"2
P?2h>:  ?K>9b?#$95" N N
P?2h>:  5$#@"2>Y?;<" 3"
3$:K>a?#$95" N N N N N N N N
P?2h>: ?K5": N N N N N N N N N N
P?2h>: 3$ 9$JK>9?  "2>$95?A
N PA~F ;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N PA7I P$Eb?#$95" 3" E?@v N N N N N
N 8A67 P$Eb?#$95" 3"
@"25?A#?K?: N N N N N N N N N N N N
N N N =A~ P$Eb?#$95" 3" 5$5"
:"K?2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N 8AL7 P>K52" 3$ ?2 N N N N N N N N N N N N
P>K52" 3$ E"#J4:5WX$K N N N N N
N 8AL7 P>K52" 3$ @?25WE4K?: *1P N N N N
N 8AL7 P>K52" 3" hK$" 3" #"5"2 N N N N
N 8ALH PK4>3" 3": D2$>": N N N N N N N N
PK4>3": "2>a>9?>: $ K4J2>D>E?9A
N 8AL7 5$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N PA~| P2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95" $K^A
N 8A77 52>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N SAIH P2$>": N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
P49;<" tV$95>t A ?J$2542? 3"
:@">K$2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
P49;<" ’45" T"K3 N N N N N N N
N N N PAH
P49;<" ,@"25 N N N N N N N N N N N
N N 8AL|
P49E>"9?#$95"
q,5?25',5"@r N N N N N N N N N N N N
N N 8ALF
P49E>"9?#$95" 3" 1?2i:$9:$
N N 8ALF E"# ?52$K?3": N N N N N N N N N N
8AL6 P4:WX$>: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA7I
8AL~ 
8AI6 S?9Eb" 3$ 2$J"Z4$ N N N N N N PA~H
S?2?95>? 3" $p5$2>"2 3" X$WA
8AI| E4K" $ 3? @?25$ >9D$2>"2 3?
E?22"E$2>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N TAHH
8AIH S?:$: 3$ 3$:E?2a? N N N N N N N PA~~
TA7M
TALG
8A6F
=9?5>X>3?3$ 3" X$WE4K" 9"
TA7M :>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ N N N N N N N PAL|
TA7I =93>E?3"2$: 3$ 3>2$;<" 
:$5?: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AL|
N =A7F =9:524#$95": 3$ J"23" N N N N N *AM
=95$2#>5[9E>? 3? X$K"E>3?3$
N PA6 @2"a2?#?3? N N N N N N N N N N N PAHG
N N =A6 =95$2X$9;<" 3" ?K?2#$ N N N N N 8AM
=22$a4K?2>3?3$ 9" :>:5$#? ,$9A
8AII 52y {$y N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AM
N PAM =22$a4K?2>3?3$: 9"
PALI D49E>"9?#$95" 3" :>:5$#?
,5?25',5"@ N N N N N N N N N N N N PAL|
PAL6 =:"D>p $ ."@ .$5b$2  >9:5?K?A
;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AHM
PA66

5$% *
! )>#@$Y? 3$ J?9E": $#
m93>E$ 3$ "@?E>3?3$ N N N N N N 8A6~
 &?945$9;<" 3": E>95": 3$
)?X?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? N N N N N
)$>542? E"22$5? 3? 2"3? N N N N
)$>542? E"22$5? 3" @9$4 N N N N
)$X?95?3"2 $K^52>E" 3": X>A
32": N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)$X?95?93" " X$WE4K" N N N N N
)>J$2?93" 4# X$WE4K"
@2$:" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)>#>5?3"2 3$ X$K"E>3?3$ A
,@$$3 K>#>5$2 N N N N N N N N N N N
)>#>5?3"2$: 3$ E?2a? N N N N N
)>#@?3"2 3" @?2?AJ2>:? N N N N
)>#@?3"2$: $ K?X?3"2$: 3":
X>32": N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)>#@$Y? 3?: @?25$: 3$ @K‘:A
5>E" $ 2$X$:5>3?: N N N N N N N N N
)>#@$Y? 3?: @?25$: 2$X$:5>3?:
$# E"42" N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)>#@$Y? 3$ J?9E": $ @?25$:
$# 5$E>3" N N N N N N N N N N N N N
5$&
E"42" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)>#@$Y? 3" >95$2>"2 3" X$WA
E4K" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
)WZ4>3" 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" 3"
8ALM #"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N N =A| )WZ4>3" 3" K?X?3"2 3" @?2?A
N N =A| J2>:?oK?X?3"2 3" X>32" 52?A
:$>2" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
8AIG )"9a? >9?5>X>3?3$ 3" X$WA
E4K" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
TALF
)4J2>D>E?;<" 3?: @?25$: #hA
X$>: 3? E?22"E$2>? N N N N N N N
SAH~
)4Y 3$ 9$JK>9? 52?:$>2? N N N N
PALM )4Y$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? N N N N N
+AHH )4Y$: 3$ 9$JK>9? N N N N N N N N
8ALM )4Y$: 3$ @":>;<" E"# " X$WA
E4K" 3$:K>a?3" N N N N N N N N N N
8ALM )4Y$: 3$ 2"3?a$#
3>429? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
TAH~ )4Y$: $p5$29?: N N N N N N N N N N
)4Y$: >95$29?: N N N N N N N N N N
TAH~ )4Y$:A$:@>? N N N N N N N N N N N N
TAH|
TAH|
&?945$9;<" 3" :>:5$#? 3$
?2AE"93>E>"9?3" N N N N N N N N TALG
TAHF
:$a42?9;? N N N N N N N N N N N N N +ALM
TA7H
&?945$9;<" @2"a2?#?3? N N N TA7
&$9:?a$9: 3$ ?3X$25[9A
E>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *AL7
TA7I
&$94 @2>9E>@?K 3" E"#@45?A
3"2 3$ J"23" N N N N N N N N N N N *A7I
TAHL
&"3?K>3?3$ 3$ D49E>"9?#$95"
3" D2$>" 3$ $:5?E>"9?#$95"
TALG
$K^52>E" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA~
8AL6
&"9>5"2 3$ :"9"K[9E>? "4
N SAF 3>:52?;<" 3" #"5"2>:5? N N N N PAI|
8AL6 &"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AH
&"X>#$95?;<" 3? E"25>9? 3"
8ALF 5$5" :"K?2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AIH
8AL6
8ALH
!u#$2" 3" Eb?::> N N N N N N N N N =A7
8AL~
*AL7

UK$" 3" #"5"2 N N N N N TA7L] TA7~
' 19$4: A >9D"2#?;\$: :"J2$ ?
1?>9$) 3$
>9:524#$95": N N N N N N N N N *AL¶H
1?2?A:"K N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A67
1?25>3? ?@h: >9?5>X>3?3$ @2"K"9A
a?3? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAH
1?25>3? E"# J?5$2>? ?4p>A
K>?2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAHH
1?25>3? E"# #?9"J2?: 3$
>9^2E>? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAHI
1?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>? N N N N SAHL
1?25>3? 3$ $#$2a[9E>? 9"
:>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ N N N N N N N PAL~
1?25>3? 3" #"5"2  @2"E$3>A
#$95": >9>E>?>: N N N N N N N N N N PA7
1?25>3? 3" #"5"2  X$2:\$:
3>$:$K N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAL
1?25>3? 3" #"5"2  X$2:\$:
DK$p N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAL
1?25>3? 2$#"5? N N N N N N N N N N N 8A|
1?::>X$ $952y N N N N N N N N N N N 8A7L
1$:": $ E?2a?: N N N N N N N N N N N =A7I
1K?Z4$5? 2$:4#>3? 3": 3?3": 3$
>3$95>D>E?;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A7
19$4: A a$9$2?K>3?3$: N N N N N TALF
:$a42?9;? N N N N N N N N N N N N N TALF
1"25?AK4X?: N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A67
1"25?A#?K?: N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AI6
1"25?A#?K?: E"# ?E>"9?A
#$95" $K^52>E" N N N N N N N N N N 8AI|
1"25?: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A77
1"25?: (,B N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A66
1":>;\$: 3? ?K?X?9E? 3$ Ee#A
J>" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA7L
12$@?2?;<" @?2? 52"E? 3$
@9$4: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SALI
12$::<" 3": @9$4: N N N N N N N N =A7G
12^A5$9:>"9?3"2$: N N N N N N N +AHL
12"E$3>#$95" 3$ 52"E? 3$
@9$4: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAL|
12"E$3>#$95": 3$ #?945$9A
;<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TA7|
12"E$3>#$95": 3$
:$a42?9;? N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAL|
12"a2?#?;<" 3? X$K"E>3?3$
K>#>5$ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PALM
12"5$;<" E"952? ": ?a$95$:
?5#":D^2>E": N N N N N N N N N N N TAHH
1
w4?32" 3$ >9:524#$95": N N N N *AH

C?Ei 3$ 5$5" N N N N N N N N N N N 8A66
C$?J?:5$E>#$95" N N N N N N N N PA|M
C$J"E?93" " X$WE4K" $# :>54A
?;\$: 3$ $#$2a[9E>? N N N N N SAHM
C$J"Z4$ 3" X$WE4K" N N N N N N SAI7
C$E?2a? 3? J?5$2>? N N N N N N N TA7|
C$E"#$93?;\$: @?2? 3$:K>a?2 "
#"5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI
C$a4K?a$# 3" X"K?95$ N N N N 8ALG
C$a4K?a$# $# ?K542? 3":
E>95": 3$ :$a42?9;? N N N N N N +AL~
C$a4K?a$9: 3": J?9E": N N N N 8A7F
C$#"95?a$# 3? 2"3? 3$
45>K>Y?;<" 9"2#?K N N N N N N N N SAHG
C"3?: $ @9$4: N N N N N N N N N N N N =A|
C"3WY>" 3": @9$4: N N N N N N N TAL~
,$K$EA5$22?>9 N N N N N N N N N N N PA7M
,$9:"2 3$ Eb4X? N N N N N N N N 8AH7
5$’ *
,$9:"2$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PAI~
¢ 3$ #?2Eb?: :$# " @$3?K 3$
,$952y {$y N N N N N N N N N N N N 8A~
,$2X>;": ?a$93?3": N N N N N N N TA7
,>9?K>Y?;<" 3$ ?9"#?K>?: 3"
:>:5$#? 1?2i:$9:$ N N N N N N N PA66
,>9?K>Y?;<" 3$ @2$::<" >9:4D>A
E>$95$ 3": @9$4: N N N N N N N N +AL7
,>:5$#? ’B, q’95>AK"Ei B2?i>9a
,y:5$#r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A~
,>:5$#? B,& qBK>93 ,@"5 &"A
9>5"2>9ar N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A77
,>:5$#? 3$ ?22$D$E>#$95" A
#?945$9;<" N N N N N N N N N N N TALL
,>:5$#? 3$ ?X>:" 3$ ?D?:5?A
#$95" 3$ D?>p? 3$ 2"3?a$#
q)?9$ *$@?2542$ ¤?29>9a ,y:A
5$# A )*¤,r N N N N N N N N N N N PAIL
,>:5$#? 3$ E"25$ 3$ E"#J4:5WA
X$K N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAH6
,>:5$#? 3$ 3>?a9h:5>E" 3$
J"23" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N *AIL
,>:5$#? 3$ $:E?@?#$95" A
#?945$9;<" N N N N N N N N N N N TAL7
,>:5$#? 3$ D2$9?a$# A #?94A
5$9;<" $ E4>3?3": N N N N N N N TALI
5$*
,>:5$#? 3$ >9>J>;<" 3" $9a?5$
D2$>" ?E>"9?3" N N N N N N N N N N PA76
,>:5$#? 3$ :$a42?9;? :4@K$A
#$95?2 q,C,r A ’>2J?a N N N N N +AIL
,>:5$#? *,. q*y9?#>E ,5$$2>9a
."2Z4$r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AI
,>:5$#? $K^52>E" N N N N N N N N N N =A7F
,>:5$#? +C& q+K$E52"9>E C"KK"A
X$2 &>5>a?5>"9r N N N N N N N N N N N +A6
,>:5$#? P8¤ qP"2j?23 8"KK>A
:>"9 ¤?29>9ar N N N N N N N N N N +A76
,>:5$#? DK$p qE"#J4:5WX$K
$5?9"K $o"4 a?:"K>9?r N N N N N PA|~
,>:5$#? T*8 qT>KK *$:E$95
8"952"rK N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AF
,>:5$#? T,’ qT>KK ,5?25 ’:A
:>:5r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AI
,>:5$#? -B* N N N N N N N N N N *AIL
,>:5$#? 1?2i:$9:$ N N N N N N N PAI~
,>:5$#? 1?2i:$9:$ ’E5>X$ 1?2i
’::>:5 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N PA6~
,>:5$#? 1B’ q1?9>E B2?i$ ’:A
:>:5r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AL
,>:5$#? ,BC q,$?5 B$K5 C$#>9A
3$2r N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AHG
,>:5$#? ,5?25',5"@ N N N N N N N PALI
,>:5$#? .8 q.2?E5>"9 8"9A
52"Kr N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A7
,>:5$#? .1&, q.>2$ 12$::42$
&"9>5"2>9a ,y:5$#r N N N N N N +AL7
,>:5$#? .,’ A 2$E"9b$E>#$95"
3$ @K?E?: 3$ 52e9:>5" N N N N N N +A7M
,>:5$#? .,8 q.2?>K$2 ,j?y 8"9A
52"Kr N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A6
,>:5$#?: 3$ :$a42?9;?
?5>X? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +A7
,>:5$#?: @?2? @2"5$;<" 3"
#$>" ?#J>$95$ N N N N N N N N N 8A6F
,"K>E>5?;<" 3$ Eb?X$: ?3>E>"A
9?>: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 8AI
,4J:5>54>;<" 3? J?5$2>? 3?
Eb?X$ $K$52v9>E? N N N N N N N N N 8A6
,4J:5>54>;<" 3$ 4#? Ke#A
@?3? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAF
,4J:5>54>;<" 3$ 4#? Ke#@?3?
$p5$29? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAM
,4J:5>54>;<" 3$ 4#? Ke#@?3?
>95$29? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SA77
,4a$:5\$: @?2? E"934;<"
D"2? 3$ $:52?3? A V$2:\$: E"#
52?;<" >95$a2?K N N N N N N N N N N PA~M
,4@$2?Z4$E>#$95" 3" #"A 
5"2 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N SAH|
(K52?@?::?a$# 3? X$K"E>3?3$
,4:@$9:\$: N N N N N N N N N N N N N N =A6 @2"a2?#?3? N N N N N N N N N N N PAHG
(5>K>Y?;<" 3$ a4>9Eb": N N N N PA~6
 (5>K>Y?;<" 3": E>95": 3$ :$a4A
.$5" :"K?2 $K^52>E" N N N N N N N 8AIL 2?9;? N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N +ALF
."#?3? 3$ E"22$95$ N N N N N N 8A6L (5>K>Y?;<" :$X$2? 3" X$WA
.2?;<" >95$a2?K N N N N N N N N N PA7| E4K" N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N TAL
.2?;<" >95$a2?K c$$@ ’E5>X$
*2>X$ I¤* $ c$$@ ’E5>X$ 
*2>X$ I¤* )"j N N N N N N N N PA7F V<" @"25?A"J_$5": 3" J?9E"
.2?E5>"9 E"952"K¥ N N N N N N N N PALG 3" K?3" 3" @?::?a$>2" N N N N N 8A6H
.2?9:#>::<" N N N N N N N N N N N N N =AI V$2>D>E?;<" 3": 9WX$>: N N N N N TA7L
.2?9:#>::<" ?45"#‘5>E? N N N PA7G V$2>D>E?;\$: @$2>h3>E?: N N N N N TA7
.2?9:@"25$ 3$ ?9>#?>: N N N N PA~~
.2?9:@"25$ 3$ E2>?9;?: $#
:$a42?9;? N N N N N N N N N N N N N +AHH
.2?9:@"25$ 3$
@?::?a$>2": N N N N N N N N N N N N PA~~
.2?X?#$95"o3$:52?X?#$95"
3?: @"25?: @$K" $p5$2>"2 N N N N 8A7L
.2?X?#$95"o3$:52?X?#$95"
3?: @"25?: @$K" >95$2>"2 N N N N 8A77
.2>@ E"#@45$2 N N N N N N N N N N *ALG
.2"E? 3$ @9$4: N N N N N N N N N SALI

5$+ *
 Utilize os lubrificantes
Mopar Oil
e aproveite toda a tecnologia reconhecida
mundialmente que a Mopar traz para voce
Abasteça o seu veículo com os lubrificantes Mopar Oil,
desenvolvidos exclusivamente para motores Jeep,
e garanta máxima proteção.
AS MELHORES SOLUÇÕES
EM LUBRIFICANTES
Desde 1937, a Mopar é referência mundial em peças e acessórios
automotivos, conquistando o respeito e a admiração de todos
aqueles que são apaixonados por carros.

Agora, chega ao Brasil o Mopar Oil, uma linha de lubrificantes

especialmente desenvolvida para motores Jeep com muita
tecnologia e alta performance. Realize suas revisões em dia e
mantenha a garantia de seu veículo.

Jeep e Mopar são marcas registradas da FCA US LLC. O descarte inadequado de óleo lubrificante usado ou contaminado e de suas
embalagens provoca danos à população e ao meio ambiente, podendo contaminar água e solo. O óleo usado e as embalagens são recicláveis.
Entregue-os em um posto de serviço ou de coleta autorizada, conforme Resolução CONAMA nº 362/2005 e suas alterações vigentes.
 COMPASS
COPYRIGHT BY FCA FIAT CHRYSLER AUTOMÓVEIS BRASIL LTDA. - PRINTED IN BRAZIL
As informações contidas neste manual correspondem às características do veículo na data de sua publicação. A fabricante, porém, poderá alterar
DVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVGRYHtFXORHPUD]mRGHPRGLÀFDo}HVGHQDWXUH]DWpFQLFDRXFRPHUFLDOVHPSUHMXGLFDUDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVEiVLFDVHHVVHQFLDLVGR
SURGXWR(VWHPDQXDODSUHVHQWDLQIRUPDo}HVVREUHGLIHUHQWHVYHUV}HVGRDXWRPyYHO&RQÀUDDVFDUDFWHUtVWLFDVHVSHFtÀFDVGRYHtFXORTXHYRFrDG-
TXLULX(VWHPDQXDOGLVSRQLELOL]DDVLQIRUPDo}HVQHFHVViULDVSDUDJDUDQWLUDERDHVHJXUDXWLOL]DomRGRVHXYHtFXOR(YHQWXDLVG~YLGDVSRGHUmRVHU
HVFODUHFLGDVMXQWRj5HGHGH&RQFHVVLRQiULDV &KU\VOHU'RGJH-HHSRX5$0 HRXSHOD&HQWUDOGH5HODFLRQDPHQWR &KU\VOHU'RGJH-HHSRX5$0 
DWUDYpVGRVWHOHIRQHVQž &KU\VOHU RX 'RGJH RX  -HHS RX 5$0 

31(',ÇÃO,;