Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 11

#$%&'()*'+,(,-* &.

-/*012345632
789:;<=>?/*@8ABA><*!CCD3

,+E(-F*G%H&-,*

Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu


upravljanja granicom

!"#$%"&
!"#"$%$&'()*&$(+,-."$/+*.'(0-$)-(1*+-$(+,-.)'$2+-)"3'$)'$&-45"$-/6*7%#)%$
)'/+*/%6)*6#$1-$)'/*,'7&)'$8-#'2*+"&'9$:'()*6#-.)*;$1-$#-8-.$/+"6#%/$0+*&$
67%,0')"8-$8*&"$/+*.*('$-8#".)*6#"$)-$(+,-.)*&$2+-)"3"$)"&'$(*6#-#-);$8-*$<#*$
)"$)&"=*.-$#'=)"58-$*/+'47&')*6#$)"&'$1-(*.*7&-.-&%>-9$?-8*$0"$6'$/*.'>-7-$
%5")8*."#*6#$2+-)"5)"=$67%,0";$%1$/*6#*&'>'$/*#')3"&-7'$"$+'6%+6';$/*#+'0)*$&'$
/+*.*("#"$-)-7"1%$+"1"8-9
?-(-$6'$+-6/+-.7&-$*$6"2%+)*6#"$2+-)"3-;$/*&-4$-)-7"1'$+"1"8-$6.'$6'$5'<>'$
8*+"6#"$%$#'+4")*7*2"&"$@%+*/68'$%)"&'9$A)-5-&$-)-7"1'$+"1"8-$&-6)*$&'$('B)"+-)$
%$C3=')2')68*4$8-#-7*2%$@%+*/68'$%)"&'$"$C3=')2')68*4$8*('86%$*$2+-)"-
3-4-9$C$*01"+*4$)-$%64&'+')*6#$D'/%07"8'$E+.-#68'$/+'4-$@%+*/68*&$%)"&"$"$
C3=')2')%;$4*,'$6'$*5'8".-#"$(-$>'$6'$#-&$#'+4")$.+7*$0+1*$%(*4->"#"$"$8*($)-69
?+*1$/+."$("*$57-)8-$5"#-#'7&$(*0".-$*6)*.)'$")F*+4-3"&'$*$-)-7"1"$+"1"8-$"$
)&')"4$.+6#-4-;$(*8$6'$%$(+%2*4$("&'7%$+-1+-G%&'$/+*.'(0-$*/'+-#".)'$-)-7"1'$
+"1"8-$%$*8."+%$2+-)"5)'$8*)#+*7'$"$1-<#"#'$(+,-.)'$2+-)"3'9
'()*+,$- ./)$+/0 -)-7"1-$ +"1"8-;$ /+"8%/7&-)&'$ /*(-#-8-;$ 2+-)"5)-$ 8*)#+*7-;$
1-<#"#-$(+,-.)'$2+-)"3'9

UVOD

+<IJ9*KI*KBAL?J>=B>?*M89:?8A>9*M8?B?J9@9*-($=*3*A>A;9NI*89N9LA3*789:<=89O=P*IL?;9L?*I*
B?Q><9*Q=;9:?*M8=@=R9*AI@?:?S9;*9KM8=J*>AK*M89:?8A>9*K:?*M8?B=K@9*KB?<=B8K>I*A>A;9NI*
89N9LA3*78B?*:?8A:?*M8?B<=89@9*K9@IAO9<I*9KM8=J*B?N9;A*T*AI@?:?S9;=*L?<9*J?;AN=*9N*KIM8?@>?U*
K:<=8AP*NA@9:*M8?B<=8ABA:?*K9@IAO9<I*9NA*B?N9;AP*IN9:A:?*I*?SN98*LBA;9@=@I*AI@?:?S9;A*
L?<9*B?N9:?*@=*S8N9>I*J8IU9V*AI@?:?S9;A*I*>=M?K8=J>?<*S;9N9>93*&*L?>AW>9O9P*@=:=;<=:*

*
:83*KO3*,;=>L?*G8XILAP*B?J9@=;<*?JK<=LA*I*FJ<=;I*NA*U8A>9OI*7&*K9KAWL?Y:?K;ABAWL=3

!""
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

$%&'()(*(+,*,-./(+%./.0,1+$%&23(*343(5&+5&647*&89+8.64%*&6+$%(93(2,*3,+.+4$4:9,5&+8(+
u radnju pretjecanja.
Pojam analize rizika+ 3(+ 4+ $&)%4;3(+ 8.64%*&89.+ 4'()(*+ ./+ $&)%4;3,+ (0&*&5.3(<+ =+
(0&*&5.3.+8(+,*,-./,+%./.0,+)(>*.%,+0,&+$%&23(*,+894$*3,+%./.0,+&)+*($-,7,*3,+/,+%&?4+.+
48-46(+$%4@(*(+)%46&3+/(5-3.1+$&8(?.2(+&*&3+4+>*,*2.380.5+$%&?-(5.5,<A+=+9&5+85.8-41+
,*,-./,+4+$%,'.-4+$%()89,'-3,+9,?-.2(+8,+89,9.89.;0.5+$&0,/,9(-3.5,1+,+%./.0+8(+$&'(/43(+8+
46&'&%.5,+&+&8.64%,*34+.-.+4+*(0.5+8-4;,3('.5,+8+5&647*&:74+64?.90,+.*'(89.2.3(<
B,),+8(+%,).+&+8.64%*&89.+6%,*.2,1+&8*&'*&+$&)%4;3(+&$7(+6%,*.;*(+89%,9(6.3(+3(+
)3(-&9'&%*&+4$%,'-3,*3(+6%,*.2&5+0&3(+8(+8,89&3.+&)+6%,*.;*(+0&*9%&-(+.+/,:9.9(+)%@,'*(+
6%,*.2(+49(5(-3(*.5+*,+,*,-./.+%./.0,<2+C%&3+&8&?,+.+'&/.-,+0&3(+$%(-,/(+)%@,'*4+6%,*.24+
*,3;(:7(+3(+'%-&+'.8&0+4+&)*&84+*,+%,8$&-&@.'(+$&9(*2.3,-(+4+$%&2(84+6%,*.;*(+0&*9%&-(1+
,+$&)%4;3(+./5(D4+6%,*.;*.E+$%.3(-,/,+8'&3&5+)4@.*&51+6(&6%,F80.5+0,%,09(%.89.0,5,+
.+&89,-.5+%(-(',*9*.5+&?.-3(@3.5,+9,0&D(%+$%()89,'-3,+'(-.0.+./,/&'+/,+,$8&-49*4+/,:9.94<+
=$&9%(?,+,*,-./(+%./.0,+(-.5.*.%,+$&9%(?4+/,+$&0%.',*3(5+8',0&6+5(9%,+)%@,'*(+6%,*.2(+
.-.+/,+6%,)*3&5+/.)&',+.+)%46.E+$%($%(0,+)4@+6%,*.2(<+G*,+$&5,@(+4+85,*3.',*34+>*,*H
2.380.E+9%&:0&',+4/+.89&)&?*&+&)%@,',*3(+'.8&0&6+894$*3,+$%&'()?(+*,)/&%,+6%,*.2(<+=+
9&5+ 85.8-4+ ,*,-./,+ %./.0,+ $%()89,'-3,+ 8$(2.>;,*+ *,;.*+ %,),+ 6%,*.;*(+ $&-.2.3(+ 0&3.5+ 8(+
4*,$%(D43(+*,)/&%+)%@,'*(+6%,*.2(+),',*3(5+$&4/),*.E+.*F&%5,2.3,+&+89,*34+*,+6%,*.2.<+
G*,+8(+$%&'&).+0,0&+?.+8(+$&).6-,+0',-.9(9,+%,),+*,+%,/.*.+5(*,)@5(*9,+I8%()89',1+&?40,1+
&?3(09.1+&$%(5,J+.+&$(%,9.'*&3+%,/.*.+I5(9&)(1+.*).0,9&%.1+$%&>-.J<
K&89&3(+9%.+%,/.*(+4$%,'-3,*3,+6%,*.2&5+I9,09.;0,1+&$(%,9.'*,+.+89%,9(:0,J+$,+$%(5,+
9&5(+.+9%.+$%.$,),347(+'%89(+,*,-./(+%./.0,L
!"#$%&'()&%#%*%+(,%#-(,(&%+&?4E',7,+4$&9%(?4+%(-(',*9*.E+.*F&%5,2.3,+/,+$%&>-.%,H
*3(+4+%(,-*&5+'%(5(*4<+M,0'&+$%&>-.%,*3(+8(+$%&'&).+0,0&+?.+8(+-,0:(+$%($&/*,-(+
&8&?(+0&3(+?.+9%(?,-&+$&)'%6*49.+)(9,-3*.3&3+6%,*.;*&3+0&*9%&-.<
2. Operativna analiza rizika+$%()89,'-3,+,*,-.9.;0(+I0',*9.9,9.'*(+.+0',-.9,9.'*(J+
5(9&)(+(',-4,2.3(+&$(%,9.'*&6+&0%4@(*3,1+$%()5(9,+,09.'*&89.+.+%(/4-9,9,+'-,H
89.9&6+%,),+%,).+)&?.',*3,+9&;*&6+$%.0,/,+89,*3,+8.64%*&89.+0,0&+?.+8(+&$9.5,-*&+
/*,-&+.80&%.89.9.+%,8$&-&@.',+8%()89',<
3. Strateka analiza rizika+ 3(+ 0&5?.*,2.3,+ 89%,9(:0(+ $%&23(*(+ 46%&@(*&89.+ .+
&$(%,9.'*(+,*,-./(+%./.0,+0&3,+8-4@.+5(*,)@5(*94+*,+*,3'.:&3+%,/.*.+),+%,/'.3(+
$%&9453(%(1+./53(*(+4+*,;.*4+%,),+$,+;,0+.+4+$%,'*.5+$%&$.8.5,<
N'(+9%.+'%89(+,*,-./(+%./.0,+$&)3()*,0&+84+/*,;,3*(+4+8489,'4+4$%,'-3,*3,+6%,*.2&51+
5(D49.51+4+&'&5+9(0894+89,'-3,+8(+*,6-,8,0+*,+!"#$%&'()*+%)%,'-*+$'-'.%<+=+'%(5(*.5,+
0,),+0,)%&'80,+$&$4*3(*&89+6%,*.;*.E+8-4@?.+.+*3.E&',+9(E*.;0,+&$%(5-3(*&89+*.3(+&$H
9.5,-*,1+9%(?,+/*,9.+$%,'.-*&+4853(%.9.+%,8$&-&@.'(+$&9(*2.3,-(<+=$%,'&+*,5+&$(%,9.'*,+
,*,-./,+%./.0,+),3(+853(%*.2(+/,+9,3+$%&2(8<

A+
O4%$EP1+O<1+Q.6*(*1+N<+IR).9&%J1+S&*65,*+C48.*(88+R*6-.8E+Q.29.&*,%P1+T,%-&U1+V)).8&*+W(8-(P+
S&*65,*1+!XXX<
2
Y&4*2.-+&F+9E(+R4%&$(,*+=*.&*1+/0+123#)4#)+5%&%,!4*#+Z+/6&#$)%,+7!$8#$9+2!)&$!,:+;#<!(%,+%)8+
$#%8<'99'!)=+;#2!<<#)8%&'!)9+%)8+7#9&+"$%2&'2#91+C%4[(--(81+Y&4*2.-+&F+9E(+R4%&$(,*+=*.&*1+!XX!<+
>>>?2!)9','*<?#*$!"%?#*@*#8!29@2<9A8%&%@,'7$%'$'#@+BCD@2%&%,!4*#EFG/H?"8I+H+!\<+A<+!XX#<

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

!"#$%&'($)*+,*-#$./+0+'+

$%&'()&*+()(,&*-./0*10*()+&2(3&4(*!"#$%&5*-60107%.5*,3&+4&'%.5*8.'9:.;(<%60*('(*:.;(<%605*
.3(1%.*.*;(%&-(=(*8.6&30*,.6&*10*&%&'()(+&>*?3604*)&*8+(8+0-9*.@60,4(3%0*(*130.@9A3&4%0*
&%&'()0* +()(,&* 19* 8.9);&%(* (* 3+0-0%1,(* .;+020%(* 8.;&=(>* B+(-60+(=05* .1%.3%(* 8.;&=(*
8.4+0@%(*)&*&%&'()9*8+.@'0-&4(,0*,+(69-7&+0%6&*19C
1 @+.6*03(;0%4(+&%(A*1'97&603&*,+(69-7&+0%6&
1 3+0-0%1,(*+&18.+0;*1'97&603&*,+(69-7&+0%6&*D*1&45*;&%*9*460;%95*-6010=
1 -601%(*+&18.+0;*1'97&603&*,+(69-7&+0%6&*D*%&*:+&%(7%.-*8+(60'&)9*('(*()3&%*%60:&5*
,.6(*:+&%(7%(*8+(60'&)5*3+14&*:+&%(=05*:+&%(=&*1*,.6.-*;+/&3.-
1 )&4070%0*.1.@0*9*,+(69-7&+0%69*D*@+.65*%&=(.%&'%.14
1 )&4070%(*8.-&:&7(*D*@+.65*%&=(.%&'%.14*40*9'.:&*9*.-.:9E&3&%69*,+(69-7&+0%6&*
F3.)&75*.+:&%()&4.+5*8+(,+(3&40'6*(4;>G
1 %&7(%*8.7(%60%6&*,+(69-7&+0%6&
1 8'&E0%(*()%.1*)&*.-.:9E&3&%60*,+(69-7&+0%6&
1 =(60%&*,+(69-7&+0%0*+.@0*%&*H=+%.-H*4+/(<49>
?)*14&4(14(7,0*8.;&4,05*&%&'()&*+()(,&*@(*10*4+0@&'&*8.10@(=0*91-60+(4(*%&*1&;+/&65*
.;%.1%.*.80+&4(3%0*(%I.+-&=(60*8.894C
1 1&)%&%6&*()*;.1&;&<%6(A*&,4(3%.14(*:+&%(7%0*8.'(=(60*,.60*19*;.30'0*;.*+&)@(6&%6&*
-+0/&*,+(69-7&+&
1 %.30*.80+&4(3%0*-04.;0*(*9)+.=(*,.6(*19*(;0%4(J=(+&%(
1 %.30*+940*,+04&%6&*,+(69-7&+&
1 9'.:0*8.60;(%(A*.1.@&*9*,+(-(%&'%(-*-+0/&-&
1 98.4+0@&*,+(3.43.+0%(A*;.,9-0%&4&>
B+(,98'60%(*14&4(14(7,(*8.;&=(*(*.80+&4(3%0*(%I.+-&=(60*,.6(*19*8+(,98'60%(*%&*40+0%9*
-.+&69*@(4(*98.489%60%(*1*(%I.+-&=(6&-&*()*;+9:(A*()3.+&>*B+(60*130:&*10*-(1'(*%&*;+9:0*
1'9/@0*,.60*10*@&30*8+0;-04%.-*8+.@'0-&4(,.-*F.@&360<4&6%0*1'9/@05*=&+(%&*(*;+>G*9,'69K
7969E(*%6(A.30*1'9/@0%(,0*,.6(*+&;0*()3&%*)0-'60*F7&1%(=(*)&*30)95*;60'&4%(=(*9*;(8'.-&41,.K
,.%)9'&+%(-*8+0;14&3%(<43(-&G>*L%I.+-&=(60*4&,.20+*4+0@&*8+(,98'6&4(*.;*14+&%(A*1'9/@(*(*
.+:&%()&=(6&*F14+&%(*7&1%(=(*)&*30)95*-029%&+.;%0*.+:&%()&=(60*D*L%40+8.'5*M9+.8.'5*NMOLG>

2"#3%+,&4,+#'.,0%.)+

N=A0%:0%1,(*,.;0,1*.*:+&%(=&-&*8+0;3(2&*P##QK4%9*,.%4+.'9*.1.@&*,.60*8+0'&)0*:+&%(=9>*
B+0-&*4.-05*.1.@0*,.60*(-&69*3&'6&%0*894%0*(18+&30*-.E(*E0*)&,.%(4.*8+(60E(*;+/&3%9*
:+&%(=9*;.,*E0*.1.@&-&*,.60*8.,9<&69*8+(60E(*;+/&3%9*:+&%(=9*@0)*%&30;0%(A*;.,9-0%&4&5*
9'&)&,*('(*()'&)&,*()*;+/&30*@(4(*)&8+(6070%>
R0294(-5* %0* -.:9* 130* %0)&,.%(40* +&;%60* @(4(* .4,+(30%0* ,+.)* .1%.3%9* :+&%(7%9*
,.%4+.'9>*S&,.5*8+(-60+(=05*,+(69-7&+0%60*+.@0*7(6(*60*8+.-04*.:+&%(70%T)&@+&%60%*F;+.:&5*
.+9/605*0,18'.)(3*(*;+>G*('(*'69;(*,.6(*%0*-.:9*'0:&'%.*8+(60E(*:+&%(=9>*B+.360+&*13(A*-6014&*
%&*.1.@%.-*3.)('9*:;60*10*18.-0%94&*+.@&*-./0*1&,+(4(*('(*=(60'(*1&;+/&6*4.3&+%.:*8+.14.+&*
40+04%(A*3.)('&*60*)&A4603&%*8.1&.*(*9)(-&*89%.*3+0-0%&5*&*;&*@(*10*8+.360+&*.@&3('&*@0)*
+&14&3'6&%6&*3.)('&*('(*8+0-60<4&%6&*40+04&*8.4+0@%(*19*+019+1(*,.6(*7014.*%(19*;.1498%(*F81(*
)&*;040,=(69*;+.:0*(*0,18'.)(3&5*+0%;:0%*9+02&6(5*OU2*1.%;05*;040,4.+(*.4,9=&6&*1+=&*(*;+>G>

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

!"#"$%&'()*+,&$-.&,*+,&$/0,1.02&

$%&'()*+,*-.*-/0,12'*3,4,&'/%/'*51,2'62%*4)7'&'8%*+,*.*-.1,+28'*-,*-7.9:%2'&'(,*
&,1'2%*';01<%*/%(%78'/'*41%57%+*=>*-0'?*0);'7,*3)8%*@%*.*8%+2)(*01%(%2-3)(*4%1')+.*
41'8%@'*41%3)*51,2'62)5*41'8%7,;,*A41'(8%1'&%*!BB*0);'7,CD*E3)*41'/)(*41)&'8%2'()*+,*-%*
.*=>*0);'7,F*2,7,;'*31'8.(6,1%2,*1):,G)-):%H*08%1)8,/2)-/*+,*2%*41%57%+,()*/%(%78'/)*
/1,9%2)*0);'7)*8%*="H#>H*,*08%1)8,/2)-/*;,/8%&,28,*2'/'*8%+2)5*'7'*8%+2)5*0);'7,*8%*0%@,*)+*
"B>D*I,37%H*08%1)8,/2)-/*+,*41)2,J%()*+0,*'*0'<%*0);'7,*8%*(,28,*)+*#B>H*,*08%1)8,/2)-/*
+,*41)2,J%()*-0,*0);'7,*8%*5)/)0)*8%+2,3,*2.7'D*K,3)J%1*-%*()9%*';0.@'*;,378.6,3*+,*
@%H*,3)*0);'7,*41%57%+,0,()*2,-.(&%H*08%1)8,/2)-/*41)7,-3,*LB>*31'8.(6,1%2%*1):%*:'/'*
""HM>D*N8%+2)*/1%:,*2,57,-'/'*+,*8%*41,3-,*4)3,;,7,*3,3)*-.*4)7'&'8-3'*-7.9:%2'&'*-37)2'*
41)&'8%2'/'*+,H*,3)*8%*)/31'0%2)*8%+2)*'7'*2'8%+2)*0);'7)H*41):7%(,/'3%*2%(,*'7'*8%*2%;2,/2,D

Broj otkrivenih vozila Vjerojatnost otkrivanja


0 od 10 59,1%
1 od 10 32,7%
2 od 10 7,2%
3 od 10 0,8%
4 od 10 0,056%
5 od 10 0,002%
6 od 10 0,00005%
7 od 10 6 x 10-7 %
8 od 10 3,6 x 10-9 %
9 od 10 8,5 x 10-12 %
10 od 10 2,2 x 10-14 %
!"#$%&"'()'*+,-.+"/0.1/'2-.0"$"13"'4.5%$"'3.+,'2-,4.5%'3-%+678"-,06'-.#69$+6:,
;<=>??@'AB'3.0/"7%0"&%+,@'AB'3.0/-.$,C

N3)7'3)*9%7'()*41)&'8%2'/'*/,(2.*:1)83.*/)*@%()*.6'2'/'*2,*-78%+%@'*2,6'2O*,3)*8%*
;,/%6%2*8%+,2*-7.6,8*31'8.(6,1%28,H*,*3)2/1)7'1,2)*8%*=>*)+*.3.42)*!BB*0);'7,H*-*41%/P
4)-/,03)(*+,*8%*=>*0);'7,*3)2/,('2'1,2)H*/,+,*-%*()9%*)6%3'0,/'*+,*8%*/,(2,*:1)83,*#"*
0);'7,D*I,37%H*.3.4,2*:1)8*0);'7,*3)8'(,*-%*31'8.(6,1'*8%*!BD*Q*):;'1)(*2,*/)*+,*-()*.*
)0)(*-7.6,8.*-,('*)+1%+'7'*-/.4,28*3)2/,('2'1,2)-/'*)+*=>H*('*;2,()*+,*8%*#B*-7.6,8%0,*
31'8.(6,1%28,H*,*2%*!B*3,3)*8%*41)&'8%28%2)D*R1)&8%28'0,28%*/,(2%*:1)83%*2%*+,8%*%5;,3/2%*
4)+,/3%H*,7'*.3,;.8%*+,*-%*-/0,12)*-/,28%*:'/2)*1,;7'3.8%*)+*)2)5*41%/4)-/,078%2)5*S*T41)P
:7%(,/'3%*2%(,*'7'*8%*2%;2,/2,TD

F*
U0,8*4)-/)/,3*31'8.(6,1%28,*8%*%3-/1%(,2*41'(8%1*'*)+,:1,2*8%*3,3)*:'*-%*4)3,;,7)*+,*8%*.*%3-/1%(2'(*
-7.6,8%0'(,*08%1)8,/2)-/*)/31'0,28,*017)*2'-3,D*N*-/0,12)-/'*)6%3'0,2'*4)-/)/,3*8%*4.2)*2'9'D

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

!"!"#$%&'()(#*+()%,)(#-.)/+.&(

#$%&'(%&)*&+,-.),+%&/&01*(2%-3%4&0%5.$+.)/6&3$7/4,83$&9%3(1%.$&+%:,.$&3,)*&/8,3;
9%+,($<&=$9&,&+*.,9,&$35$>4$3&51$3,83*&0%.,?,)*&3*@*&+%-,(,&:$-%+%.)$+$)/@*4&1*:/.($(/<
#$9%&A,&7*&0%7(,5.$&+*@$&%(91,+$89$&-)*.$(3%7(6&$&(,4*&,&A%.),&%-3%7&/&,79%1,7(,+%7(,&
1$-3*&73$5*&(*&A%.),&01*+*3(,+3,&/8,3$96&0%(1*A3%&)*&01%+%-,(,&01%B.,1$3)*<&!"#$%&"'()*+
74$(1$4%& %-$A,1& +%:,.$& :$& 01*5.*-& 7/9.$-3%& ,3C%14$?,)$4$& -%A,+*3,2& 3$& (*4*.)/& 5*;
3*1$.,:,1$3)$&,&0%+*:,+$3)$&%-1*D*3,2&%A,.)*>)$&:$7*A3,2&7./8$)*+$&,.*5$.3,2&$9(,+3%7(,<
E3$.,(,89*&7./>A*&(1*A$.*&A,&01,01*4,(,&1,:,83*&01%B.*&9%),4&@*&7*&+%-,(,&51$3,83$&0%.,?,;
)$<&F3-,9$(%1,&1,:,9$G&A,&4%5.,&A,(,&:*4.)$&0%-1,)*(.$6&1/($&0/(%+$3)$6&7$-1>$)&01(.)$5*H(*1*($&,(-<
#$%&01,4)*1&@*4%6&,&/&%+%4&7./8$)/6&9%1,7(,(,&0$1$4*(1*&,:&01*(2%-3%5&0%5.$+.)$&
I!JJ& +%:,.$6& KL& 9%3($4,3,1$3%7(,6& KL& (*4*.),(*& 51$3,83*& 9%3(1%.*M<& N*4*.)*4& 01,01*;
4.)*3%5&1,:,83%5&01%B.$&1*?,4%&-$&!J&+%:,.$&%-5%+$1$&-%7($+.)*3,4&,3-,9$(%1,4$&1,:,9$<&
O$1$+3%6&3,(,&)*-3,&$3$.,(,89,&0%-$?,&3,7/&7$+1'*3,&0$&3,7/&7+$&+%:,.$&9%),4$&7*&91,)/48$1,&
%A/2+$@*3$&,:1$D*3,4&1,:,83,4&01%B.%4<&P&%+%4&,4$5,3$13%4&7./8$)/&%A/2+$@*3%&)*&
QJL&91,)/48$1*3)$<&R$9.*6&7*-$4&+%:,.$&01*+%:*&91,)/48$1*3/&1%A/H.)/-*<&S-&!J&01,)*&
70%4*3/(,2&+%:,.$&9$0$?,(*(,&0%.,?,)*&-%0/'($3)/&01*5.*-$+$3)*&TJ&+%:,.$<
R*B3,1$3,&01%B.&+%:,.$&3*&(1*A$&U+*:$(,&1/9*U&0%.,?,)79%4&7./>A*3,9/&3$&51$3,8;
3%4&01,)*.$:/<&V$73%&)*&-$&+%:,.$&9%)$&%-5%+$1$)/&01%B./&(1*A$&01,%1,(*(3%&01*5.*-$+$(,6&
4*D/(,4&3*&(1*A$&01*5.*-$+$(,&,79.)/8,+%&($9+$&+%:,.$&+*@&,&-$.)*&(1*A$&(*4*.),(%)&9%3(1%.,&
0%-+15$+$(,&,&0%)*-,3$&+%:,.$&,:+$3&-*B3,1$3%5&01%B.$<&O$&($)&3$8,3&A,(&@*&%A/2+$@*3,&
91,)/48$1,&9%),&7*&3$.$:*&,:+$3&01%B.$6&$&($9%D*1&7*&%7,5/1$+$4%&%-&*+*3(/$.3,2&01%4)*3$&
3$8,3$&0%8,3)*3)$&91,)/48$1*3)$&,&*+*3(/$.3,2&01%4)*3$&01%B.$<&P01$+%&:A%5&(%5$&@*4%&
U7$4%U&QJL&7+%),2&9$0$?,(*($&0%7+*(,(,&+%:,.,4$&9%)$&%-5%+$1$)/&01%B./6&%-3%73%6&/&
%+%4&01,4)*1/6&01*5.*-$(&@*&7*&Q&01%B.,1$3,2&+%:,.$<

Broj otkrivenih vozila Vjerojatnost otkrivanja


0 od 7 2,21%
1 od 7 15,5%
2 od 7 34,86%
3 od 7 32,28%
4 od 7 12,91%
5 od 7 2,11%
6 od 7 0,11%
7 od 7 0,0012%
,'-%&.'/01/2)*"#)'3(#43/5"#('%'46'/7#8&%'/6#)*/5"*7#8&/6"&)9+:'"*(9/"#-9;%)9<*
=>?0@A/BCD/6#(3'+&('.&)*A/BCD/6#(3"#%*E

W%-&,3-,9$(%1,4$&1,:,9$&1$:/4,)*+$4%&,3C%14$?,)*&9%)*&3$4&/9$:/)/&3$&4%5/@*&0%7(%)$3)*&0%(*3?,)$.;
G&

3%5&1,:,9$<&S3,&3*&4%1$)/&A,(,&/&0%(0/3%7(,&(%83,6&$.,&3),2%+$&A1%)3%7(&/&9%391*(3,4&7./8$)*+,4$&)*&01%;
0%1?,%3$.3$&7$&7(/03)*4&1,:,9$<&W1,4)*1,?*6&/(+1D*3,&1,:,83,&01%B.&8,3*&7.)*-*@,&,3-,9$(%1,&1,:,9$X&(*1*(3%&
+%:,.%&(/179,2&1*5,7($179,2&%:3$9$6&01,)*+%:3,9&UInter;(1$370%1(U6&+%:,&3$&1*.$?,),&E39$1$;W1$56&(1$3:,(,1$&
91%:&Y,Z6&01*+%:,&(*97(,.<&W%)$+$&+%:,.$&9%)*&7*&/9.$0$&7$4%&/&-+$&,3-,9$(%1$&1,:,9$&01*-7($+.)$&:$&51$3,8;
3/&0%.,?,)/&3,>,&7(/0$3)&1,:,9$&3*5%&'(%&A,&(%&A,.%&+%:,.%&9%)*&7*&/9.$0$&/&0*(&,3-,9$(%1$&1,:,9$<

!"!
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

$%&'()&'*+',&-+'./01+)/'2')%34/5/'!6'.1+7&1%)8&*)'0%'9+'*+':7&8%9/'1+08&'.&;/4&'/4/'
./(+'.&;/4%'1+'/;8%0'"<=>'?&'1+';8%@%1%8'8%:7+0%A'2'&08&*2'8%':7+)B&08/':7/,1+7'C01+'1+'
.1+7&1%)8&*)'0%'9+,&'&)A7/)/'1+08&'/4/'8/)/'1+08&'.&;/4&'3/4%':7+A&'"D=>'E+)A&'3/',&C%&'
;%A412@/)/'0%'1+'A7/,/8%4'/'0%41+':7&F)%3/4%8'1+7'9+'.74&'.1+7&1%)8&'/'0%41+'./(+'&0'GD='
*42@%1+.%'A7/12,@%7+81%'&*)%)/'8+0+)+A)/7%8&>'H+I2)/,6':&*)&)%A'&)A7/.%@A+'01+4%)8&*)/'
1+';%:7%.&'.74&'./*&A';%'&.2'.7*)2'A7/,/8%48+'%A)/.8&*)/'C01+'*.%A/'8+2*:1+4/':&A2(%1'A7/J
12,@%7+81%',&-+'*A2:&'A&()%)/'A7/12,@%7%>'E%/,+6')7+3%'2;+)/'2'&3;/7'0%'*+'7%0/'&'C23/)A2'
0&3/)/'A&1%'3/':7&/;%(4%'/;'A%;8+8&C'01+4%6'C23/)A2'.7+,+8%')/1+A&,'A%;8+8&C':&*)2:A%6'
C23/)A2':7/,%81%')/1+A&,'/;07-%.%81%'A%;8+')+',&C298&*)/';%:41+8+'.&;/4%'A&1/,'1+'7&3%'
A7/12,@%7+8%>'K%A4+6'2'*42@%12'&)A7/.%81%'C23/)%A'8%0/4%;/':&)+85/1%482'0&3/)'()&'2'A&,J
3/8%5/1/'*6'7+5/,&6'#D=J)8&,'&)A7/.%@A&,'01+4%)8&(92'A7/12,@%7+81+'@/8/'8+:7&F)%3/48/,>
L07-%.%81+,' &.%A.&C' *)2:81%' 7/;/A%' ;%' A7/12,@%7+6' /;' ,1+*+5%' 2' ,1+*+5' 7%*)+'
.1+7&1%)8&*)'&)A7/.%81%'*.%A&C':&1+0/8&C'A7/12,@%7%>'MA&'&07+I+8%'&*&3%'1+08&,',1+J
*+@8&'A7/12,@%7/'7&32N&*&3+':7+A&'07-%.8+'C7%8/5+6'.1+7&1%)8&*)'0%'9+'3/)/'&)A7/.+8%':7./'
,1+*+5'1+'#D=>'O+9'*41+0+9/',1+*+5'(%8*+'0%'9+'3/)/'&)A7/.+8%'3/)'9+'/;8%0'GD=6'%'A7&;'
(+*)',1+*+5/'.1+7&1%)8&*)'&)A7/.%81%')+'/*)+'&*&3+'3/)'9+'"D=>
P%*8&'1+'0%'9+'&.%1'*)2:%81'7/;/A%'&0'2B/9+81%'&0.7%)/)/'*.%A&C'&0'A7/12,@%7+81%'
:7+A&'C7%8/@8&C':7/1+4%;%'8%'A&1+,'*+'7+0&.8&':7&.&0/'%8%4/;%'7/;/A%'/'0+F8/7%12'7/;/@8/'
:7&F4/>'?7+3%'7+9/'0%'1+'#D='&)A7/.%@A+'01+4%)8&*)/'./*&A/':&*)&)%A'A&1/'9+'2':7%A*/'3/)/'
)+(A&'&*).%7/)/6',+I2)/,6'-+41+8/'7+;24)%)'9+'*+':&*)/9/'/'*'G=J)8&,'&)A7/.+8&*)/>

3. ZATITA ZELENE GRANICE

$%0%'C&.&7/,&'&'%8%4/;/'7/;/A%'2'&A./72';%()/)+'07-%.8+'C7%8/5+')%0%':7.&':&,/*4/,&'8%'
C+&C7%Q*A%'&3/41+-1%')+7+8%6',+I2)/,6'8+')7+3%';%3&7%./)/'0+,&C7%Q*A+'/'072C+'7+4+.%8)8+'
&07+08/5+'C7%8/@8&C':&072@1%>'$7/12,@%7+81+':7+A&';+4+8+'C7%8/5+'1+'0/7+A)8&':&.+;%8&'
*'/4+C%48/,':7+4%*A&,'07-%.8+'C7%8/5+>'E%':&1+0/8/,'0/1+4&./,%'C7%8/5+'/4+C%48/':7+4%;%A'
1+'1+08&*)%.8&'2@/8/)/6'%')/,+'1+'/'.1+7&1%)8&*)'0%'9+'*+'0&C&0/)/'R'.+9%>'E%'072C/,'0/1+4&J
./,%':7+4%-+81+'C7%8/5+'1+'A&,:4/5/7%8/1+':%'9+'/':&A2(%1/'/4+C%48/B':7+4%;%A%'3/)/'71+I/>
S7./' A&7%A' 2' 2*:&*)%.41%812' A.%4/)+)8&C' *2*)%.%' ;%()/)+' 07-%.8+' C7%8/5+' 3/)' 9+'
:&01+4%'C7%8/5+'8%':7+):&*)%.41+8+';&8+'7/;/A%':%'9+,&'C7%8/@8&':&072@1+':&0/1+4/)/'8%'
*41+0+9+'A%)+C&7/1+T
! "#$%&'()*+,-.#/*%,0,.1'R':7+4%;%A'C7%8/5+'8/1+',&C29'3+;')+B8/@A/B':&,%C%4%6'
&08&*8&'81+;/8':7+4%;%A'3+;':&,%C%4%'1+':&.+;%8'*'.+4/A/,')+(A&9%,%'U023&A+'
7/1+A+6'1+;+7%6'8+:7&B&08&',&@.%78&':&072@1+6'C2*)%'8+:7&B&08%'(2,%6',/8/7%8&'
:&072@1+6'4/)/5+'/'*4>V
! "#$%&'()*-%)$+()/*%,0,.1'R':7+4%;%A'1+',&C29+'2@/8/)/'3+;':&,%C%4%6'%4/'1+'5/1+4/'
:7&5+*'02C&)7%1%8'/4/'1+':7+&@/)'U:4/)A+'7/1+A+'A&1+'*+',&C2':7+C%;/)/6'(2,&./)&'
:&072@1+'20%41+8&'&0':7&,+)8/B':7%.%5%6'&).&7+8&'7%.8/@%7*A&':&072@1+'A&1+'
*+'4%A&'8%0;/7+'/'07>V
! "#$%&'()*2,-#.#/*%,0,.1'R'/4+C%48&':7+4%-+81+'C7%8/5+'1+',&C29+'&3%./)/'37;&'/'
:7/A7/.+8&'U:7&B&08&'(2,&./)&':&072@1+'C01+'*+':7&,+)8/5+':7&)+-2'8+:&*7+08&'
2;'07-%.82'C7%8/52'/'*4>V>

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

$%&'(')'*+%,'-./01'*2'*3.(045*6%*1'(%)*/%)-*%+.*1'*3.(/571'*56*(/4%&)5*-/%)085*
)%2'91').:*3%*2'*25+9%().*,.;'*(.(%1'*+%,'-./01%*3.(/571%*&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%<
=91'('>0* +./%+:* )%+.)* -'.-/%?2+'* 0* (';.-/%?2+'* %)%906':* 5,&/@0&%)1'* 1'* A/.1%* 0*
3/%&%8%*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%*-/%)08'<*C/%)085*,/'A%:*25+9%().*3.(1'90*)%*.3B.()'*/%1.)':*
)%(60/%,0*.(/'@')0*&/';')2+0*3'/0.(*3/';%*291'('>';*/%23./'(5D
! 3.(/571'*)02+.-*/060+%*E*FG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*2/'()1'-*/060+%*E*HFG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*IJG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*FJG*&/';')%<
$%+.)*.(/'@').-*&/';')%*5)5,%/*3.(/571%*&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%*('K)0/%,*>'*2'*/0L
607)%*,.7+%*-(1'*2'*(.-%@%15*09'-%9)0*3/'9%280<*M+.90+.*0;%;.*+%;'/5*6%*()'&).N).>).*
2)0;%)1':*,%(%*>';.*)15*3.2,%&0,0*(%*)%(60/'*('K)0/%)5*/0607)5*,.7+5<*$%+.)*3.2,%&91%)1%*
+%;'/'*(/4%&)%*-/%)08%*)%(60/%,*>'*2'*3/';%*291'('>';*/%23./'(5D
! 3.(/571'*)02+.-*/060+%*E*HFG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*2/'()1'-*/060+%*E*IFG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*FJG*&/';')%
! 3.(/571'*&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*HJJG*&/';')%*O+%;'/%P<
MA/6.*)%+.)*3.2,%&91%)1%*+%;'/'*A/.1*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%*)%*/0607).1*,.7+0*>'*2'*
(/%2,07).*2;%)10,0*,'*>'*2'*(/4%&)%*-/%)08%*3.1%7%).*3.7',0*3/'9%60,0*)%*(/5-0;*(01'9.&0;%<*
$%+.)*)'+.-*&/';')%*(.A0,*>';.*2,%A09%)*/%23./'(*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%*3/'+.*)%(60/%).-*
(01'9%*(/4%&)'*-/%)08'*,'*>'*2'*)%*291'('>0*)%70)*;.>0*3/.801')0,0*5+53%)*A/.1*O5+9157515>0*
0*,%;)5*A/.1+5P*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%<*M6;0;.*6%*3/0;1'/*(%*1'*A/.1*2957%1'&%*09'-%9)0B*
3/'9%6%+%*A0.*291'('>0D
! 3.(/571'*)02+.-*/060+%*E*H*2957%1
! 3.(/571'*2/'()1'-*/060+%*E*#*2957%1%
! 3.(/571'*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*HF*2957%1'&%
! 3.(/571'*&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%*E*!*2957%1%<
Q%+9':*)%*)%(60/%).;*3.(/5715*'&0('),0/%).*1'*!!*2957%1%*09'-%9).-*3/'9%2+%*(/4%&L
)'*-/%)08'<*R%;)%*A/.1+%*2'*)'*;.4'*'-6%+,).*5,&/(0,0:*%90*,';'91';*2,%,02,07+0B*;',.(%*
;.4';.*06/%75)%,0*.7'+0&%)0*A/.1*+.10*3/'(2,%&91%*)%1&1'/.1%,)015*3/.81')5*2,&%/).-*2,%)1%<
S+.*6)%;.*(%*1'*3.(/571'*)02+.-*/060+%*A09.*3.+/0&%).*HFG*&/';')%*0*5*,.*&/01';'*
1'*'&0('),0/%)*1'(%)*2957%1*09'-%9).-*3/'9%2+%*,%(%*;.4';.*3/',3.2,%&0,0*(%*2'*5*.2,%90B*
TFG*&/';')%*(.-.(09.*1.U*FLV*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%<*W.*,.;*;.('95:*)%*3.(/5715*2/'()1'-*
/060+%*2'*56*(&%*'&0('),0/%)%*2957%1%*(.-.(09.*1.U*XLT*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%*)%*3.(/5715*
&02.+.-*/060+%*56*HF*'&0('),0/%)0B*2957%1'&%:*(.-.(09.*2'*1.U*HF*2957%1'&%:*(.+*)%*3.(/5715*
&/9.*&02.+.-*/060+%*)01'*A09.*,%;)'*A/.1+'*,'*1'*5+53)0*A/.1*09'-%9)0B*3/'9%6%+%*1'()%+*
A/.15*'&0('),0/%)0B*2957%1'&%*O!P<*M*.&.;*3/0;1'/5*&0(910&.*1'*(%*2'*56*!!*'&0('),0/%)%*
2957%1%*&1'/.1%,).*(.-.(09.*1.U*HXLH"*2957%1'&%*+.10*)025*A090*'&0('),0/%)0<*Q%+9'*,%;)%*
A/.1+%*2'*+/'>'*5*/%23.)5*.(*#I:VG*(.*#V:IG<
Y9'-%9)0*3/'9%280*+.10*59%6'*5*+%,'-./015*,%;)'*A/.1+'*;.-5*2'*,%+.@'/*(.*.(/'@')'*
;1'/'*%)%9060/%,0<*W.2,.10*801'90*)06*0)(0+%,./%*+.10*5+%6515*)%*3.70)1')0*09'-%9)0*3/'9%6%+*
(/4%&)'*-/%)08':*%*(01'9'*2'D

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

!"#$%#&%'()($($%$&'()*+,$-*.,$/'01(20$3'4(+56$)'(5,76$*&,856&,$6$85,.0)6$,1,$90-*.$
2091.,:$ '(29(-56&*$ +*305*$ ;,1.0$ <1*/*=,$ ,$ 81>?$ 6$ ',.0-(9($ ,$ /*&*7,9($ -*.,$ 80$
/'*&046$ 364$ 3'4(+50$ )'(5,70:$ ,9/'*+,2,'(5,$ 9*8&,@,$ /'0-*$ -(5(1($ ,1,$ /*&*-(:$
/*9(-56&($;*31.,-(+($4,7($,1,$3'6)($/'0/'0-($-*.,9$86$2(/',.0=05,$/6&*+,$-*.,$
8,.0-6$3'4(+56$)'(5,76$,$3'>
2. na izvedene$%$010-&'*5,=-0$5(/'(+0$2($30&0-7,.6$-'0&(5.(:$/',/'091.05($/.0A=(5($
/*31*)($<-(-*$;,$*8&(1,$+,31.,+,$&'()*+,?$5($/'0&/*8&(+1.05,9$9.08&,9($,10)(15,B$
/'01(2(-(:$'(2+6=05($8&'65($!"#$%&$/'0-*$/'0&/*8&(+1.050$8&(20$-'0&(5.($,10)(1C
5,B$9,)'(5(&($-*.($/*&02(5.09$,2+1(=,$;(&0',.6$,2$8-',+05*)$8&*15*)$8(&($<*8&(.0$
2(;,1.0405*$+',.090$/*&02(5.($8&'650?$,$3'>
D,&(5.0$ ,$ ,2+*E05.0$ ,53,-(&*'($ -*.,$ 6-(26.6$ 5($ /'01(2(-$ 3'4(+50$ )'(5,70$ *+,8,$ *$
8/*8*;5*8&,$,$,5*+(&,+5*8&,$)'(5,=5,B$/*1,7(.(7(>$F'0;($+*3,&,$;',)6$3($80$=,&(.6$8(9*$*5,$
&'()*+,$-*.,$503+*.;05*$6-(26.6$5($3.01*+(5.($=*+.0-(:$($50$4,+*&,5.0>$D0A@,9$*;,1(405.09$
-',&,=5,B$9.08&($9*40$80$862,&,$+'09058-,$'(29(-$6$-*.09$.0$,10)(15,$/'01(2(-$/*=,5.05>
G'(5,=5($/*1,7,.($9*'($-*58&(5&5*$(5(1,2,'(&,$8+*.6$3.01(&5*8&$,$;,&,$8/'095($/',1(C
)*3,&,$80$5*+,9$8,&6(7,.(9(>$H*&057,.(15,$6-6/5,$;'*.$,10)(15,B$/'01(2(-($9*'($80$/'*7.0C
5.,+(&,$*3$*/B*35*)$'(.*5($3*$*/B*35*)$'(.*5(:$($&(95($;'*.-($50$89,.0$80$2(509(',+(&,>

*"!"#+%,'-'%#./0%1$(#2/%$-3(#4#4$4'/%,$567'-#'(/-'6/-5%

H*50-(3$2(A&,&6$3'4(+50$)'(5,70$5,.0$0-*5*9,=5*$*;(+1.(&,$5($8(9*.$)'(5,=5*.$7'&,$
/($80$*3(;,'0$3'6)(=,.,$&(-&,=-,$/',8&6/>$I/B*35.0$)'(5,=50$/*1,7,.0$/*+1(=0$80$*3$3'4(+50$
)'(5,70$/'09($656&'(A5.*8&,$&0',&*',.($5($9.08&($5($-*.,9($80$8.03,5.6.6$/6&*+,$-*.,$+*30$
*3$)'(5,70>$J(,90:$8$*;2,'*9$5($&*$3($.0$-'0&(5.0$,2+(5$6'0E05,B$/6&*+($/*50-(3$+'1*$
5(/*'5*$,$*362,9($/65*$+'0905(:$,10)(15,$9,)'(5&,$,$-',.69=(',$@0$5(-*5$/'01(8-($3'4(+50$
)'(5,70$/',.0$,1,$-(85,.0$/*&'(4,&,$/6&*+0$-*.,9($80$9*)6$1(-A0$-'0&(&,$,1,$5($-*.,9($,B$=0-($
*8*;($8$+*2,1*9$-*.($@0$,9$/*9*@,$6$3(1.5.09$-'0&(5.6$/'09($656&'(A5.*8&,>
I+($&(-&,-($.0$2(8,)6'5*$0-*5*9,=5(:$90E6&,9:$&'0;($6&+'3,&,$-*1,-*$.0$6=,5-*+,&(>$
I/B*35.($)'(5,=50$/*1,7,.0$8&(7,*5,'(5($5($-',4(5.6$/6&*+($-*.,$3*1(20$,2$89.0'($3'4(+50$
)'(5,70$*;(+1.(&$@0$-*5&'*16$+*2,1($86-1(35*$8+*.*.$/'*7.05,>$K(-*$.0$/'*8&*'$62$3'4(+56$
)'(5,76$5($-*.09$80$9*40$/',9.05.,+(&,$*+($&(-&,-($81(;*$5(801.05$,$/'*90&$+*2,1($.0$+'1*$
81(;:$/*1,7,.8-,$8164;05,7,$86$8-1*5,$-*5&'*1,'(&,$8(9*$.03(5$3,*$+*2,1($%$*5(.$-*.,$/',/(3($
*8*;(9($-*.0$5,86$,2$&*)$/*3'6=.(>
L$.035*9$/*.035*8&(+1.05*9$/',9.0'6$*/B*35.($)'(5,=50$/*1,7,.0$;,&$@0$5($&(-+*9$
-',4(5.6$A08&$8(&,$350+5*$,1,$!#M$6-6/5*)$+'0905(>$N07,9*$3($@0$*3$/0&$+*2,1($-*.($
/'*E6$6$5(+0305,B$A08&$8(&,$-*5&'*1,'(5*$;,&,$8(9*$.035*>$O(-10:$9*40$80$/'0&/*8&(+,&,$3($
@0$&,.0-*9$3(5($&,9$-',4(5.09$/'*@,$!P$+*2,1(:$($8(9*$.035*:$*35*85*$#M$*3$6-6/5*)$
;'*.($@0$;,&,$-*5&'*1,'(5*>$Q-*:$(5(1*)5*$/'0&B*35,9$/',9.0',9($-*.,$86$80$*35*8,1,$5($
)'(5,=56$ -*5&'*16:$ /'0&/*8&(+,9*$ 3($ .0$ /*8&*&(-$ 816=(.0+($ -',.69=('05.($ &(-*E0'$ #M:$
&(3($,9(9*$#M$-*5&'*10$5($#M$816=(.0+($-',.69=('05.(>$L$/'*8.0-6$@0$80$&,.0-*9$.035*)$
3(5($3*)*3,&,$.03(5$816=(.$-',.69=('05.(:$(1,$5(.+.0'*.(&5,.0$50@0$;,&,$*&-',+05>$O6)*'*=5*$
)103(.6@,:$.03(5$816=(.$-',.69=('05.($;,&$@0$*&-',+05$8+(-,B$!P$3(5(:$3*-$@0$R"$816=(.0+($
*8&(&,$50*&-',+05*>$F(-(+$*35*8$.0$50/',B+(&1.,+$,$9*409*$)($89(&'(&,$/'*;109*9>

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

$%&'()*+*&,)+'-.-+/&0)/)1+2+3%41-5)+6%-704.(8-0&9.-+.4:&+/4+9)+6%&0&/-+%-3&%&;14+
3%41-<14+ :&1.%&(4+ .)+ /4+ 904:&+ 0&;-(&+ :&8)+ 14-=)+ '2/)+ :&1.%&(-%41&>+ ?4/4+ -*4*&+ !@A+
:&1.%&()+14+@A+:%-82*<4%)184+-+94*-*+.-*)+B)+2+6%&98):2+904:-+<).0%.-+/41+'-.-+&.:%-0)1+
8)/41+9(2<48+:%-82*<4%)184>+C+/4(8)+B)+D@A+:%-82*<4%)184+&9.4.-+1)&.:%-0)1&E+*)=2.-*E+
2;-*482B-+2+&';-%+.%&F:&0)+9+:&8-*4+9)+92&<40482+:%-82*<4%-+:&/+904:&3+9(2<484+:4/4+92+
&.:%-0)1-E+&04+%2.4+B)+;4+:%-82*<4%)+6&9.4.-+1)6%-704.(8-04>
G&/+&04:0)+.4:.-:)+6%&0)/')+3%41-<1)+:&1.%&()+*&,)+9)+6&840-.-+1)0&(8:&9.+6&9.2H
64184+3%41-<1)+&67&/18)+6%)*4+&9&'4*4+:&8)+904:&/1)01&+:&1.%&(-%482+.)+-7+9)+6%&62F.4+
');+ :&1.%&()>+ I)=2.-*E+ .%)'4+ 2;-*4.-+ 2+ &';-%+ :4:&+ 9)+ 148<)FB)+ ;'&3+ 9(4'&3+ -*&01&3+
9.4184+ &9&')+ :&8)+ ,-0)+ 2+ 9(4'&+ 149)(8)1&*+ 6&/%2<82+ 2;+ 3%41-52+ &/(2<282+ 14+ '40(8)18)+
:%-82*<4%)18)*E+6&9)'-5)+4:&+2.0%/)+/4+*&32+1):&1.%&(-%41&+6%&(4;-.-+:&1.%&(1)+.&<:)+
3%41-<1)+6&(-5-8)>

!"#$%&'()*+,)#$-+.()/)#0/0'+1)#-+1+20

J968)F14+414(-;4+%-;-:4+B)+;4+6&9(8)/-52+-*4.-+-+6&0)B412+&.:%-04<:2+/8)(4.1&9.+2+6&/%2<82+
414(-;-%41)+:%-*-14(1)+6&840)>+I)=2.-*E+:%-82*<4%)18)+:4&+6%)/*).+%496%40)+2+&0&*+
.):9.2+1)B)+1)9.4.-+9+6&%49.&*+:04(-.).)+3%41-<1)+:&1.%&()+-+;4F.-.)+/%,401)+3%41-5)>+K%1&+
.%,-F.)+B)+14+9*418)1+6%-(8)0+:%-82*<4%)1)+%&')+%)43-%4.-+6&%49.&*+5-8)14E+F.&+B)+/8)(&04.-+
:4&+6&.-548+:%-82*<4%-*4+/4+149.40)+:%-*-14(12+/8)(4.1&9.>+L491&+8)+/4+:%-82*<4%-+1)B)+
149.40-.-+:&%-9.-.-+/&.4/4F18)+*).&/)+8)%+-*+;'&3+29*8)%)1&9.-+3%41-<1)+:&1.%&()+14+18-7E+
&/1&9+%-;-:4+-+/&'-0)1)+:&%-9.-+1)+-/)+2+6%-(&3>+M1&+F.&+9)+*&,)+&<):-04.-+8)+6%&*8)14+
14<-14+-()34(1&3+/8)(&04184+.)+:&%-F.)18)+*).&/4+:&8)+1-92+6&;14.)+3%41-<1&8+6&(-5-8-+-(-+
:&8-*4+1-8)+6&90)B)14+6&.%)'14+6&;&%1&9.>+C1/-:4.&%+.4:0)+6%&*8)1)+8)+64/+&.:%-04<:)+
/8)(4.1&9.-+3%41-<1)+6&(-5-8)+2;+-9.&/&'1-+6&0%4.4:+5-8)1)+:%-82*<4%)1)+%&')+14+.%,-F.2+14+
%4;-12+:&84+8)+'-(4+6%-8)+6%-*8)1)+414(-;)+%-;-:4+-+29*8)%)1&3+/8)(&04184+3%41-<1)+6&(-5-8)>
?(-:&01&+9)+.&+*&,)+6%-:4;4.-+14+9(8)/)B-+14<-1N+9-0-+:%23&0-+6%)/9.40(8482+/04+14H
<-14+6&<-18)184+OIM?P+-9.)+:%-*-14(1)+4:.-01&9.->+Q)(-<-14+:%234+6%-:4;28)+9.04%1-+'%&8+
9(2<48)04+:%-82*<4%)184+O&.:%-0)1-+9(2<48)0-+R+.4*14+'%&8:4P>+J+&0&*+9(2<482+6%0-+14<-1+
6&<-18)184+OIM?+SP+8)+:%-82*<4%)18)+%&')+68)F-5)+/&:+8)+/%23-+14<-1+6&<-18)184+OIM?+
!P+:%-82*<4%)18)+%&')+2+0&;-(2>+Q&;-(4+:&8-*4+9)+:%-82*<4%-+%&'4+92+14:&1+6%&0)/)1)+
414(-;)+%-;-:4+0)(-:-*+/-8)(&*+6&/0%312.4+.)*)(8-.&8+3%41-<1&8+:&1.%&(-+/&:+9)+68)F45-*4+
:&8-+:%-82*<4%)+%&'2+1)+6&90)B28)+6%)0-F)+6&;&%1&9.-+O6%-*8)%-5)+/1)01-+*-3%41.-+:&8-+
92+6&;14.-+6&(-5-89:-*+9(2,')1-5-*4+14+3%41-<1&*+6%-8)(4;2P>

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-%+&%.%"#/,&0#/#$%&.%&1023+,.4&.%5#.%&125#.+,.+%&$0#+435%0,.+%

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

$%&'()*+,-.'+/)0%1'+2(2,1%+3-)&+(-%*%1451%6+4(7%.1)87%+&'+,)0&'014()+-48,)-'9'1+
2+)3&'+(47'/)-%&':+;'927%*<+8+)3=%-)*+14+7)+04+&'+7'*'5&%7)*+()17-)5)*+)326.4>'1+84*)+
0-2/%+14?%1+,)?%1&'1&4<+7%&'()*+/)0%1'+>'+8'+=14?4&1)+8*41&%7%+0)(+>'+,-.%+14?%1+,)?%1&'1&4<+
()&'*+8'+1'+,)8.'>2&'+,-'.%@'+,)=)-1)87%<+7%&'()*+/)0%1'+,)8747%+=14?4&1)+=4872,5&'1%&%:
A4)+@7)+&'+.%05&%.)+B+(-%&2*?4-'1&'+&'+0%14*%?14+,)&4.4:+C)?%1%7'5&%+8'+,-%54/)94.4&2+
)()51)87%*4+74()+04+,-)1454='+1).'+14?%1'+(-%&2*?4-'1&4+()&%+>'+%*+,).'>47%+,-%6)0'+
%D%5%+2*41&%7%+-%=%(+)0+)7(-%.41&4:+C)5%E%&4<+8+0-2/'+87-41'<+7-'34+&'014()+0%14*%?1)+,-)F
.)0%7%+4145%='+-%=%(4+(4()+3%+872,41&+=4,-&'?%.41&4+(-%&2*?4-'1&4+,)-4874)+%5%+)874)+14+
,-%6.475&%.)&+-4=%1%:

!"#$%&'()*%&

G+HE6'1/'18()*+()0'(82+)+/-41%E4*4I+J?5:+K:L+0'M1%-41)+&'+04+8'+/-41%?14+()17-)54+1'+
8487)&%+84*)+)0+,-).&'-'+)8)34+14+/-41%?1%*+,-%&'54=%*4+7'+=4@7%7'+%=*'92+7%6+/-41%?1%6+
,-%&'54=4<+.'>+%+)0+4145%='+-%=%(4+=4+21274-1&2+8%/2-1)87+%+,-)E&'1'+,-%&'71&%+()&'+3%+*)/5'+
2/-)=%7%+8%/2-1)87+.41&8(%6+/-41%E4:+C-'*4+7)*'<+82874.+%17'/-%-41)/+2,-4.5&41&4+/-41%E)*+
*)N'*)+,)0%&'5%7%+14+,-%(2,5&41&'+,)0474(4<+4145%=2+-%=%(4+%+,-).'032+140=)-4+0-N4.1'+
/-41%E':
O145%=4+-%=%(4+*)-4+3%7%+,)02,-74+82874.)*+=4+,-%(2,5&41&'+,)0474(4+()&%+82+%=.)-+
%1P)-*4E%&4+)+1'=4()1%7%*+4(7%.1)87%*4+2+,)0-2?&2+1405'N1)87%+/-41%?1'+,)5%E%&':+Q)(+8'+
14+14&1%N)&+-4=%1%+4145%=4+-%=%(4+()-%87%+(4()+3%+8'+()1E'17-%-45%+14,)-%+14+)1'+,-'()/-4F
1%?1'+4(7%.1)87%+=4+()&'+8'+,-'7,)874.5&4+04+,-'0874.5&4&2+,-%&'71&2+/-41%?1)&+8%/2-1)87%<+
14+),'-47%.1)&+-4=%1%+()-%87'+8'+84=141&4+,-%(2,5&'14+14+7'*'5&2+,)0474(4+)+'.%0'17%-41%*+
852?4&'.%*4+,-'()/-41%?1)/+(-%*%145%7'74+(4()+3%+8'+),7%*451)+=145)+%8()-%87%7%+8-'087.4+
,).&'-'14+=4+=4@7%72+/-41%E':+O145%=4+-%=%(4+()-%87%+74()9'-+*'140N*'172+14+14&.%@)&+
-4=%1%+04<+82(5401)+.-87%+%+-4=*&'-2+8%/2-1)81'+,-%&'71&'<+-4=.%&'+,-)72*&'-'<+%=*&'1'+2+
14?%12+-404+%<+,)+,)7-'3%<+2+,-4.1%*+,-),%8%*4:
C)&4*+%+*&'87)+4145%='+-%=%(4+&481)+&'+0'M1%-41)+2+82874.2+2,-4.5&41&4+8E6'1/'1F
8()*+/-41%E)*<+@7)+=14?%+04+>'+74(4.+*)0'5+-404+3%7%+2+,)7,21)87%+%*,5'*'17%-41+%+()0+
148+2548()*+R',235%('+S-.478('+2+8E6'1/'18(%+,-)87)-:+G,-4.)+=47)+&'+2+).)*+?541(2+
14/5484(+874.5&'1+14+),'-47%.12+4145%=2+-%=%(4+&'-+>'+&'014(4+,-%*&'14+),'-47%.1'+4145%='+
-%=%(4+)*)/2>%7%+3)5&2+874104-0%=4E%&2+140=)-4+0-N4.1'+/-41%E'+?%*'+>'+8'+214,-%&'0%7%+%+
64-*)1%=%-47%+,-%(4=+8741&4+8E6'1/'18('+/-41%E'+(4)+E&'5%1':

I+
T2-),'41+ C4-5%4*'17+ 410+ 76'+ U)21E%5+ )P+ 76'+ T2-),'41+ G1%)1<+ !"##$%&'() !"*+) "%) ',+) -$.+/
0"1+-%&%0) ',+) #"1+#+%') "2) 3+-/"%/) 45-"//) 6"-*+-/) 785,+%0+%) 9"-*+-/) !"*+:;) <+0$.4'&"%) 7=!:) >")
?@ABACC@:+V-2W'55'8<+T2-),'41+C4-5%4*'17+410+76'+U)21E%5+)P+76'+T2-),'41+G1%)1<+!XXY:+,''3DBB+$-E.+FG
+$-"34G+$BH+FI-&8+-1B)H+FI-&8+-1G*"J$-&KLMDHDACC@DNC?DCCCNDCCOAD=>DPQR+F+Z":+[:+!XX":

!"#
Alenko Vruka: Operativna analiza rizika u sustavu upravljanja granicom
Polic. sigur. (Zagreb), godina 18. (2009), broj 3, str. 288-298

LITERATURA
$%& '()*+,+-& .%& /!0012%& !"#$%#"&' (%)*' +,"&-)%)%& '34& 567(8,& )9:,(*9;%& <,+,=9>& <,+,=9&
5,+:(,&?6(&3,)6@(9:*@&56+:(6;&6?&'(),A&B6(@,8%
!%& 567+@*;& 6?& :C,& D7(6E,9+& F+*6+%& /!00!2%& ./' 0#12,32,' 4"$"&5362& G& .7$28,"&' 958:28)'
#5,$85&;' (2<5="&' ",:' 82":<%))%5,>' (2#5<<2,:"$%5,)' ",:' 92)$' ?8"#$%#2)@' H(7I,;;,8>&
567+@*;&6?&:C,&D7(6E,9+&F+*6+%'AAA@#5,)%&%6<@2685?"@26B62:5#)B#<)C:"$"B&%98"%8%2B
DEFB#"$"&5362GHI.J@?:K&J&!1%&$%&!00"%
K%&D7(6E,9+&L9(;*9),+:&9+A&:C,&567+@*;&6?&:C,&D7(6E,9+&F+*6+%&/!0012%&45<<6,%$-'45:2'
5,'$12'86&2)'35=28,%,3'$12'<5=2<2,$'5K'?28)5,)'"#85))'958:28)'L0#12,32,'M58:28)'45:2N@'
M,N7;9:*6+&/D52&O6&P1!Q!001%&H(7I,;;,8>&D7(6E,9+&L9(;*9),+:&9+A&:C,&567+@*;&6?&:C,&
D7(6E,9+&F+*6+%&1$$?>BB268O&27@2685?"@26BP27/8%028=B P27/8%028=@:5Q68%RST>P>HIIU>V
IW>IIIV>IIXH>.J>DEF&J&$"%&K%&!00"%
R%&.6S+*T-&.%&/!0012%&D85:6#$%5,'5K'(%)*'+,"&-)%)%&'34&567(8,&)9:,(*9;%&<,+,=9>&<,+,=9&
5,+:(,&?6(&3,)6@(9:*@&56+:(6;&6?&'(),A&B6(@,8%
P%&.6S+*T-&.%&/!0012%&(%)*'+,"&-)%)'"$'./'.7$28,"&'M58:28)%&'34&567(8,&)9:,(*9;%&<,+,=9>&
<,+,=9&5,+:(,&?6(&3,)6@(9:*@&56+:(6;&6?&'(),A&B6(@,8%
1%&.6S+*T-&.%&/!0012%&!12'Y2",%,3'5K'(%)*'+,"&-)%)'%,'M58:28'02#68%$-%&'34&567(8,&)9J
:,(*9;%&<,+,=9>&<,+,=9&5,+:(,&?6(&3,)6@(9:*@&56+:(6;&6?&'(),A&B6(@,8%
U%&.7(ECV-&.%-&3*N+,+-&W%&/DA*:6(2&/!0002%&P5,3<",'M6)%,2))'.,3&%)1'E%#$%5,"8-%&X9(;6Y>&
'AA*86+&Z,8;,V&46+N)9+%
#%&W9=6;9*+,+-&[%&/!00U2%&45<?8212,)%=2'(%)*'+,"&-)%)'Y5:2&'K58'$12'M58:28'Z6"8:)%&D8E66>&
H6(A,(&9+A&5698:&<79(A&'@9A,)V%

W7))9(V
!"#$%&'()*+%,
Operational Risk Analysis in the Border Management System
O6&@67+:(V&C98&*)E(,N+9\;,&\6(A,(&8,@7(*:V&\,@978,&:C,(,&9(,&+6:&87?]@*,+:&8,@7(*:V&6?]@,(8&9+A&
+6:&,+67NC&)6A,(+&,^7*E),+:&:6&\;6@T&9;;&:C(,9:8%&_6&A,E;6V&,I*8:*+N&(,867(@,8&:6&\,8:&,??,@:&9&
(*8T&9+9;V8*8&C98&:6&\,&E,(?6(),A%
M*8T&9+9;V8*8&*8&9+&*)E6(:9+:&@6+@,E:&Y*:C*+&:C,&D7(6E,9+&F+*6+&/DF2%&_C,&*)E6(:9+@,&6?&(*8T&
9+9;V8*8& *8& @;,9(;V& A,]+,A& *+& :C,& DF& W@C,+N,+& 59:9;6N7,& 9+A& :C,& W@C,+N,+& H6(A,(& 56A,%& '8
5(69:*9&C98&A,@*A,A&:6&`6*+&:C,&DF-&9+A&:C,(,\V&:C,&W@C,+N,+&'N(,,),+:-&(*8T&9+9;V8*8&Y*;;&\,@6),&
9&?9)*;*9(&@6+@,E:&:6&:C,&5(69:*9+&\6(A,(&8,@7(*:V&?6(@,8%
_C,&](8:&E9(:&6?&:C,&9(:*@;,&*8&9+&*+:(6A7@:*6+&:6&:C,&@6+@,E:&6?&(*8T&9+9;V8*8-&9+A&:C,&8,@6+A&E9(:&
A*8@788,8&:C,&E,(?6()9+@,&6?&6E,(9:*6+9;&(*8T&9+9;V8*8&?6(&\6(A,(&@6+:(6;&9+A&8:9:,&\6(A,(&E(6:,@:*6+%
Key words:&(*8T&9+9;V8*8-&A9:9&@6;;,@:*6+-&\6(A,(&@6+:(6;-&8:9:,&\6(A,(&E(6:,@:*6+-&\6(A,(&8,@7(*:V%

!"#

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi