Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The NO, absorption experiments were analysed on the basis of the following model :
(a) in the gas phase, NO, and NsO, are in continuous chemical equilibrium with each other
and they are transported from the bulk to the gas-liquid interface by molecular diffusion ;
R&sum&-On a dtudie la vitesse de l’absorption de NOs-N204 d’un melange avec l’azote dans
l’eau. Pour ce but on a utiliti une colonne B paroi mouillde, dans laquelle l’eau et le gaz confluent
en ecoulement laminaire. Les conditions hydra- et aerodynamiques ont et& v&ifldes dparement.
Les mesures sur l’absorption de NO, ont dte analydes selon le mecanisme suivant :
(a) dans le gaz les espbces NO, et NsO, sont transferees vers la paroi par diffusion moleculaire,
toujours mutuellement en Lquilibre chimique ;
Die Versuche zur NOa-Absorption wurden mit Hilfe folgender Modellvorstellung analysiert :
(a) in der Gasphase werden NO, und NsO, aus dem Sttimungskem zur Grenzfliiche durch
molekulare Diffusion transportiert und befinden sich stiindig im chemischen Gleichgewicht
miteinander ;
(c) die Diffusion von NsO, in Wasser ist von einer schnellen Reaktion erster Ordnung
zwischen NsO, und Wasser begleitet. Die Versuchsergebnisse stimmten ziemlich gut mit dem
vorgeschlagenen Absorptionsmechanismus fiberem. Aus ihnen wurden Daten zur fltissigkeits-
seitigen Kinetik des Absorptionsprozesses erhalten.
61
W. A. DEKKER, E. SN~ECKand H. KMMEES
THE absorption rate of nitrogen dioxide-nitrogen that the absorption rate was controlled by the
tetroxide gas mixtures from nitrogen into water chemical reaction between N,O, and water in
plays an important role in the industrial produc- the liquid phase. These authors did not find an
tion of nitric acid and the removal of NO, from indication of gas phase reaction.
gaseous mixtures*. PETERS et al. [5] stated that the reaction
The essential chemical reactions which accom- between N,O, and H,O in the gas phase close
pany this absorption are: to the interfase was rate controlling.
WENDEL and PIGFORD [6] recently stated the
j’ 2N0, (N,O,) + Hz0 z= HNO, + HNO, controlling mechanism in the absorption to be the
’ J 4HN0, ZJ 2NO + 2N0, (NsOJ + 2HsO homogeneous liquid phase reaction of dissolved
N,O, with water. However, their data indicate
The resulting overall reaction is represented by that the gas phase resistance also plays an
the following equation : important role in the absorption rate.
3N0, (3/2 NsOJ + H,O zz= 2HN0, + NO Because of the apparent complexity of the
problem we have especially aimed at carrying
The absorption of NO, in water is carried out out the absorption experiments in an apparatus
in absorption towers which can be operated in which the flow conditions of both the gas and
under various conditions. As a consequence, the liquid phase were well determined, so that a
various designs of absorption towers are possible. quantitative interpretation of the experimental
An optimum design can only be realized, however, results might be possible. In this respect, a
if the chemical and physical mechanisms of the favourable case would be the situation, in which
absorption are thoroughly understood. gas and liquid, both in laminar flow, are brought
During the last forty years several investigators into contact with each other for a specified period
have studied this process but so far their views of time T on their way through the absorption
’ \, on this subject are rather conflicting’as appears
p- unit. If, moreover, there is no velocity gradient
from a literature survey [l]. A summary of the perpendicular to the interface in either phase,
most important conclusions from the studies by it is then possible to apply a rather simple form
other investigators is given below. of the theory of diffusion to the transfer of NO,
CHAMBERSand SHERWOOD[2] interpreted their from the gas to the liquid. A wetted wall column
results on the basis of the “ two film theory ” seemed best suited to obtain the situation
and found the. gas film to be rate controlling. described above, because it has three attractive
However, the absorption rate was lower than features :
was expected from similar absorption experiments
(1) a sharp boundary between the gas and
with other gases. According to these authors,
the liquid phase,
this was due to the formation of mist in the gas
(2) a well-defined absorption area, and
phase. In addition, they found NO to be present
(3) well-known hydrodynamic conditions of
in the gas phase when a NaOH solution was
the falling liquid film.
used as the absorbing liquid ; this indicated that
a chemical reaction between NO, and H,O In addition, special measures were taken in
took place in the gas phase. order to insure :
DENBIGH and PRINCE [3] and CAUDLE and (4) cocurrent laminar flow of both gas and
liquid,
*In the gas phase NO, is in continuous equilibrium (5) a flat velocity profile of the gas in the
with N20, according to the equation: 2NO,zN,O,.
wetted tube,
This equilibrium, which is dependent on temperature and
pressure, is reached very rapidly. In this paper NO, will
(6) equal values of the surface velocity of the
be referred to as the mixture of NO, and N204, unless liquid film and the velocity of the gas,
stated otherwise. (7) equal temperatures of gas and liquid.
32
The rate of absorption of NO, in water
+LIQUID OUT
x +8,+0.2 (10e3m)
Whereas the height of the wetted wall column be t a k e n in order to maintain the t e m p e r a t u r e
(13.6cm) was fixed b y the b o u n d a r y layer and the pressure of the gas at constant known
entrance effect, the inside diameter of the absorp- values because of the sensitivity of the dimeriza-
tion column was chosen such t h a t a reasonably tion equilibrium constant of the reaction
accurate interpretation of gas absorption results 2N0~ ~ N~01.
from gas analysis d a t a alone would be possible. During a run liquid samples were t a k e n for
W i t h a diameter of 3-6 cm the percentage of analysis of H N 0 3 and H N 0 ~ in the outgoing
N H 3 absorbed b y water could be expected to lie liquid. In this way, a material balance could
between 20 and 35, depending on the contact be set up around the absorber, expressed in
time between gas and liquid. equivalent moles of N0~. Also in these experi-
ments the electrical conductivity of the outgoing
2.2 Additional equipment liquid was recorded.
CO2 absorption F o r the measurements of the
absorption rate of CO s into the water film the
3. DIscussioN OF THF. EXPERIMENTAL
pure CO 2 gas was saturated with water v a p o u r
RESULTS
at the t e m p e r a t u r e of the absorption experiments
and was then led through the absorber. A very 8.1 The CO~ absorption experiments
small a m o u n t of detergent had been added to the The experimental absorption rates of pure
water in order to prevent surface rippling. The CO 2 gas into the laminar falling water film were
COs absorption rate was found from the decrease compared with the rates predicted from the
of the CO 2 volume at constant pressure which " penetration " theory for physical absorption.
was measured b y means of the " soap bubble " According to this theory (see e.g. [7] and [8]),
m e t h o d [7]. the a m o u n t of gas absorbed b y the liquid with
N H 3 absorption--The absorption experiments initial zero gas concentration will be, per unit
of N H 3 into water from nitrogen were carried surface area and after a contact time ~:
out at 25°C. The gas flows of N H 3 and N 2 were
measured separately b y means of calibrated rota-
meters and then mixed and fed to the absorber. d ~ v8 ~\ v8 /
The incoming and outgoing gas streams I n a plot of m (r) vs. %/[(h -- Ah)/v~] this rela-
could be sampled for N H 3 analysis. The N H 3 tion would give a straight line through the origin
content of the outgoing liquid was determined with a slope of 2Cw ~¢/(D/~r). I n Fig. 3 such a
b y chemical analysis of a n u m b e r of samples a line has been drawn for 2Cw%/(D/~).=
during a run. Thus a N H 3 mass balance could 8.04 × 1 0 - S k g / m 2 sec V', which was found b y
be set up around the absorber for every experi- NIJSING [7] for absorption of CO2 at 20°C and a
ment. CO~ pressure of 760 m m Itg. The experimental
Also the electrical conductivity of the outgoing points obtained in this investigation under the
liquid was recorded in order to verify the steady same conditions have also been indicated in
operation during an experimental run. Fig. 8, and it is seen t h a t the agreement with
NO 2 absorption A differential photometer was N~JsINa'S results is very good.
built for the accurate m e a s u r e m e n t of the NO~ Also in these experiments it proved necessary
concentration in the gas mixtures. I t s operation to reduce the total film height h b y the a m o u n t
was based on the selective light absorption of NO~. Ah which is the height of the reflection wave
The value of the light absorption coefficient k~ formed above the liquid level of the collecting
for 2 - ~ 5461 A was determined to be 1.22 cm -1 reservoir (1-2 cm in these experiments). I n this
a r m -1 b y chemical calibration [1]. With this p a r t of the film practically no absorption occurs
p h o t o m e t e r the NO2 concentration of b o t h inlet as has been shown in previous work [7, 8].
and outlet gas could be accurately measured at F r o m the CO 2 absorption measurements it
frequent intervals. Special precautions had to appears t h a t the hydrodynamic conditions of the
64
The rate of absorption of NO,, in water
falling liquid film agree well with the theoretical Figure 4 shows a graphical representation of
model. equation (2) for f = 0 and f = O-07. When the
6
experimental results on the NH8 absorption had
to be plotted in this graph, a diaculty arose as
to the correct value of the active film height
and the contact time 7. Since the mass transfer
is mainly determined by diffusion in the gas
phase, it seems unlikely that the area of the
reflection wave just above the liquid level would
be entirely inactive as was the case with absorp-
tion of pure CO, into water. Therefore, the
experimental values were calculated on the basis
-
1. I
80
3
3.2 Tk NH, absorption experiment.8
The flow conditions of the gas were separately 0.
65
W. A. Dxxmza, E. 3NOECKsnd I-I. KRABSER~
per cent) and operating temperatures (25-35°C). (c) the absorption rates are considerably lower
The main results have been collected in Table 1 ; than would be the case if only the diffusion in
these lead to the following general conclusions : the gas phase were controlling ;
(d) the absorption rate, calculated from the
(a) the absorption rate (Q,),, expressed in
photometric analysis, is always 36-60 per cent
equivalent moles of NO,, is proportional to the
higher than that obtained from the chemical
average partial pressure of N, 0, in the bulk of
analysis of the liquid [( @,,,),I ;
the gas (see Fig. 5) ;
(e) a change of the operating temperature from
(b) if the inlet concentration of the gas is kept
25°C to 35°C has only a small effect on the absorp-
constant the absorption rate only slightly depends
tion rate ;
on the contact time ;
(f) mist was observed in the gas outlet when
the eN0, concentration exceeded about 9 per cent.
From this it can be concluded that N, 0,
rather than NO, plays an important role in the
absorption process. The deficit in the material
balance, as mentioned under (d), can be explained
by the occurrence of a reaction between NO,
and/or N,O, and water in the gas phase in the
0 04 0.8 1.2 16 2.0 2.4 2.8 32
neighbourhood of wet surfaces. It was estimated
b N,$., lo-*atm. that at least 93 per cent of this reaction occurred
FIG.5. NO, absorptionrste 8s a function of the average in the equipment (tubing and drying column)
N,O, partial pressurein the gas. between the gas outlet of the absorber and the
66
The rate of absorption of NO, in water
photometer, and at the very most 7 per cent in of DNO and DN 0 * was obtained by assuming a
the absorber itself. Therefore the photometric steady &ate diff&ion of NO, and N,O, molecules
analysis of the outgoing gas could not be used for through a stagnant gas film of N, (cp. ROBERTS
calculations and the experimental absorption ww
rates were computed from the chemical analysis The following differential equation was then
of the outgoing liquid. set up for the diffusion of “ eN0, ” from the
The effect, described under (c) suggests that cylindrical gas space to the wetted wall :
the liquid phase also presents a resistance to NO,
transport. The small sensitivity towards the
contact time mentioned under (b) might indicate
-that this diffusional resistance is accompanied by
a rapid reaction between NO, and/or N,O, and
water.
where p = r/F, E = R - 8, and 4 = Dz/(RF)Sd
(a) Below the entrance of the wetted wall tower At the gas-liquid interface (p = 1) the third
NO, and N,O,-in continuous equilibrium with boundary condition has to account for the above
each other-diffuse from the bulk of the gas to hypothesis concerning the N,O, dissolution and
the gas-liquid interface ; reaction. The penetration of N,O, molecules in
(b) N,O, is the only species which dissolves in the liquid film accompanied by the rapid pseudo
the liquid ; first order reaction
(c) the diffusion of N,O, into the liquid is N,O, + H,O -“I, HNO, + HNO,
accompanied by a rapid pseudo-first-order reac- results in the following equation for the absorption
tion between N,O, and water. rate at the interface :
A number of NO, and/or N,O, molecules will
(@s,“), = 2 (@n”)NsO, = 2% @’ 4) (7)
probably also react with evaporated Ha0
molecules near the gas-liquid interface. How- As was shown by DANCKWERTS[ll] equation (7)
ever, it could be assumed that the influence of the is a good approximation as long as k’ z/v, > 4
gas phase reaction on the NO, absorption rate which is the case for the greater part of the
was sufficiently small to be neglected. Moreover, absorbing film in our experiments?.
complications arising from the liberation of NO At the interface the rate of transport of eN0,
were assumed to be negligible for the conditions in the gas phase is given by :
of these experiments because of the slow decom-
position rate of HNOr (G,“), = - De (L~/iw),,~=. (8)
Because in particular the physical solubility
of N,O, in water and the rate constant of the *oNoa and %so, were taken to be 140 and 0.98 x 1O-s
ms/sec respectively at 25°C and 760 mm Hg [2].
reaction mentioned under (c) were not known
the following calculations were made. tStrictly speaking, DANCKWERTS’ derivation is valid
for a constant value of the interfacial concentration in
The diffusion of the NO, - N,O, mixture in
the liquid C,. In the present experiments C, decreases
the gas phase was regarded as the diffusion of somewhat with increasing z but detailed calculations
one fictitious component “ eNO,.” A derivation have shown here that equation (7) still is applicable with
of the diffusivity of this component as function good accuracy.
67
W. A. lhmc~~, E. SNOECK and I-I.KILAMERS
The combination of equations (7) and (8) gives and the equilibrium between cN,o, and c :
the third boundary condition :
‘N,O, =
2 WrJ &o~
___ = - --Qy’4) l/2 c - J&/f4 [2/(1 + f3c/&) - 1-j =f(c) (11)
3P
for p = 1 and 4 > 0 (9)
Substitution of (10) and (11) into (9) finally
The relation between c, (the eN0, concentration
in the gas at the interface) and C, (the saturation
concentration of N,O, in the liquid, which is in
gives :
[
3Wd
1 =
>P
1f(C)
p=1
_-.-
Q CO
(12)
equilibrium with the gas) follows from Henry’s
where Q is a dimensionless parameter defined as :
law :
‘%I= H (cN,O,)ur RgT (10) Q = D,/2R= HRgT d(k’ 0,) (13)
!
1.000 O-903 O-885 O-873 0.862 0.926 0.904 0.892
1.125 0.895 0.876 O-863 0.851 0.920 O-896 0.883
1.250 O-887 0.867 0.853 0,841 0.913 0.888 0.874
1.375 0.879 0.858 0.844 0.832 0.907 0.880 0.366
I.500 0.872 0.850 0.835 O-823 omo 0.873 0.858
1.625 0.865 O-842 O-827 0.814 0.894 0.866 O-850
I-
0.375 0.970 0.961 0.955 6.949 0.980 0.970 0+64
0.500 0.962 0.951 0.944 0.936 0.974 0.962 0.954
0.625 0.954 0.942 0.933 0.924 0.968 0.954 o-Q45
o-750 o-947 0.933 0.923 o-913 0,963 0.947 o-937
0.875 0.940 0.924 0.914 0.903 0.957 0.940 0.929
1.000 0.932 0.916 om5 O-893 O-952 o-934 0922
1.125 0.926 0.908 0.896 0.884 o-947 0.927 0.914
l-250 0.920 OWO 0.888 O-875 o-943 O-921 0907
1.375 o-914 O-893 0.880 0.866 0.938 o-915 o*QOO
1.500 O-908 0.886 0.872 O-858 o-933 0.909 0.893
1.625 0.902 0.879 0.865 0.850 0.929 0.903 0.887
68
The r8te of absorption of NO, in water
Since the equilibrium relationship between the example of such a comparison for one concentra-
eN0, concentration in the gas and the N,O, tion series.
concentration in the liquid is non-linear, an an- Then for every run the corresponding value of
alytical solution of equation (4) with the bound-
ary conditions (5), (6) and (12) was nearly im-
possible. Solutions to the differential equation
were obtained by numerical computation (Table 2)
for two values of the parameter Q, which were
chosen by previous trials.
In order to compare the theoretically computed
values of C/c0 with the experimental results, the
value of +, = De ~/(li!“)s had to be determined for
each run. The contact time T was calculated as
h/v, and the end effect of the falling film was
not taken into account for lack of arguments for
the application of a proper correction. lo%
The experimental results were plotted as FIG. 6. Comparison between the eN0, depletion of the
E/C,, vs. 4, and compared to the theoretical lines gas with computed results for Q = 0.01 and 0.02 for one
for Q = 0.01 and Q = O-02. Figure 6 gives an concentration series (runs 18, 14, 15, 16, 18 snd IQ).
103co lo* $7
Run @mole/m*) -
1 25 1.23 15.8
2 25 ,, 15.8
4 25 ,, 10.7 1.03.10-3 -28
5 25 9, 8.4
6 25 ,, 8.4
7 25 2.34 15.1
9 25 ,, 10.2
27
O*99.10-5
11 25 ,, 8.0
12 25 ." 8.0 I
20 25 6.25 9.6
a5
21 25 ,, 9.6
69
W. A. DE~KEIL, E. SNOECK and H. KMMERS
Q was found by linear interpolation between Table 4. F&d results 012 the lipuid kinetics of
Q = 0.01 and 0.02. The results of this interpola- N,04 absmptim
tion are shown in Table 8. The Q-values have
1
been subdivided into groups, each group represent- T H l/(k’ Dal HZ/k’
* For the diffusivity D, of N,O, in water at 25’C a of the NO, absorption and so to obtain more
value of 140 x 10-sm2/sec was used [12]. accurate values of H Z/(k’ 4). As a consequence,
H 2/ck’4)
Temperature 1O-3 kmole m
.-
AdOTS (“Cl m3atm set )
70
!I’berate of absorption of NO, in water
the NO, absorption experiments have been d+ = diameter of the cylindrical 5hu surface m
continued with an absorber where a low pressure D = coefficient of molecular diffusion ma se&
f = fraction
NO, - NeO, mixture is exposed to a laminar
h = height of the 5hn m
water jet. Preliminary results of this investigation
Ah = height of the end effect m
have been included in Table 5. H = Henry coefficient kmole m-3 atm-1
In this paper we shall not deal with the calcula- k,, = light absorption coefficient c.n-l atm-l
tion of the individual values of H and k’. As has Kc = equilibrium constant of the reaction
been shown by WENDEL and PIGFORD [6] this 2NOz = N,O, kmole m-3
m (7) = quantity of gas absorbed per unit area after a
can be done by combining H dk’ values with the
contact time 7 kg m-*
kinetic studies in connexion with the decomposi- p = partial pressure atm
tion of HNO, in aqueous solutions, which were Q = dimensionlessparameter, defined in equation (13)
carried out by ABEL and SCHMID [la]. The r = cylindrical co-ordinate m
authors think that the treatment by WENDEL R = radius of the wetted wall tower (dry) m
Rx = radius of the cylindrical 5hu = R - St m
and PIGFORD can be improved by using more
Rs = gas constant (8.316 x 103) J kmole-l “C-l
recent data. This would be worthwhile after T = temperature “C “K
more accurate values of H dk’ have been obtained u = velocity m se&
from new experiments. us = surface velocity of the liquid 5lm m se&
z = co-ordinate in the direction of gas and liquid
Ac~ourledgements-The authors gratefully acknowledge Row m
stimulating discussions with Dr. G. SCHMIDT (MEKOG, $ = thickness of the liquid film m
Ijmuiden), Professor D. W. VAN KREVELEN and P. J. h = wave length A
HOFTIJZER(Central Laboratory State Mines, Geleen), and p = dimensionless radius r/R”
S. P. S. ANDREW (I.C.I. Billingham). In particular the 7 = contact time ( = h/u,) SW
authors thank MEKOG for their advice regarding the
rred.= contact time with correction for the end effect
experimental set-up and for providing the NO, gas. set
(= (h - Ah)&)
The two first authors are indebted to the “ Delfts Hoge- 4 = dimensionless group = Dz/( R*)s U,
schoolfonds ” through which they obtained a fellowship @m“ = absorption rate per unit area kg m-z set-1
from the Dow Chemical Company. @,,, = absorption rate kg set-l
NOTATION Subscripts
c = concentration of component to be absorbed in e = eN0, i.e. cc = c = cNOl + 2 c&o,
the gas phase mole m-3 or kg m-3 f = 5lm
C = concentration of gas in the liquid kg m-z g=gas
d = internal diameter of the wetted wall tower (dry) 1 = liquid
m me)
= wall or gas - liquid interface
REFERENCES
r51 PETERSM. S., Ross C. P. and KIJZ~NS. J. E. Amer. Inst. Chem. Engrs. 5.1955 1 105.
131 WENDEL M. M. and PIGFORDR. L. Amer. Inst. Chem. En@. J. 1958 4 249.
171 NIJSINGR. A. T. O., HENIJRIKSZR. H. and K~AMERS H. Chem. Engng. Sci. 1959 10 33.
191 CARSLAWH. S. and JAEGERJ. C. Conduction of Heal in Solids p. 199. Oxford University Press. 1959.
[I31 WILKE C. R. and CHANG PIN Amer. Inst. Chem. En@. J. 1955 1 264.
PI ABEL E. and SC~MID H. Handbuch der Katalyse Bd. 2 S. 3 1940.
71